The Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection$
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 TeasersRussian Reaction Blog
Open Thread 239

Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • B
Show CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
AgreeDisagreeThanksLOLTroll
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

Here’s a new Open Thread for all of you. To minimize the load, please continue to limit your Tweets or place them under a MORE tag.

For those interested, here’s my most recent article relating the current Israel/Gaza conflict to the Jewish Holocaust of the Second World War, which I argue was merely a propaganda-hoax:

American Pravda: Israel and the Holocaust Hoax
The Unz Review • January 8, 2024 • 8,200 Words

 
Hide 1083 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to Ignore...to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. Let us start off the OT with Motorsports.

    The Dakar Rally (which does not visit Dakar) is under way kicking off 2024.

    America’s season will start next weekend, the 19th, with the “Roar Before the 24”, introducing new GTD/GT3 cars for both Corvette and Ford Mustang. The full “24 Hours of Daytona” will take place on the 28th and 29th.

    PEACE 😇

     

    • Thanks: Not Raul
    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    https://youtu.be/21T5u9qtBlk?si=BkVajSDxVRHSspxC


    Asian imports becoming slower and more expensive is good for domestic European suppliers.
     
    I don't know who you're trying to fool but I guess it's people who have never shipped between Europe and China. Shipping time between Shanghai and Rotterdam maxes out at 4 weeks and routing away from Suez adds 1 week. Customs clearance is a day either way.

    Production lead time is of course determined by product but anything that takes 30 days to make in China expect to get quoted double or triple that to make in Europe. The Suez blockage mostly harms India where rerouting across the Cape of Good Hope adds a lot more cost and time relative to China.



    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F8iv4iOXwAIxpIL.jpg

    Replies: @A123

  2. [MORE]

    ਅਕਾਲ

  3. Things we should all finally agree on in this OT (or else we might as well give up and ask Ron to close the blog for good):

    – Who is winning the war, Ukraine or Russia?
    – Is Ukraine a real country or are they just confused Russians who have forgotten their true identity?
    – Why did Western Europeans meekly go along with the neocon plan to encroach Russia?
    – Who really built the nice buildings in Riga?
    – Is Sikhism the only true religion?

    • LOL: A123
    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mikel

    For the last week I have been asking every new person I meet if they know anyplace where I can wear a raccoon coat. I want the coat. It's only 300 bucks. But right now I don't know one single place where I would wear it. Not a football game. I follow the sport but sitting down in a stadium for three hours no longer works. I think I will lose the impulse to buy it before I figure out an answer.

    One time I had a desire to own a knee length leather overcoat but it passed pretty quick.

    , @Beckow
    @Mikel

    Who is winning the war, Ukraine or Russia?

    Second half: 2 -1 for Russia. If it stays Russia wins, they could also add to the score. Ukies seem unable to score, but a tie is still possible. The sponsors-referees want to end the game early so they can pretend that not much has happened. I doubt they will succeed, too much blood.

    Is Ukraine a real country or are they just confused Russians who have forgotten their true identity?

    Ukrainians are real but confused: they try to escape who they are and also forge their identity - a very hard thing to do simultaneously. Predictably, it is not working well.

    Why did Western Europeans meekly go along with the neocon plan to encroach Russia?

    Westies are meek pu.sies scared of the big bad wolf - not the one in Moscow, the one further west. Anyone with a backbone was removed over the last 20 years as an example to others. (Also, have you been to Belgium? enough said...)

    Who really built the nice buildings in Riga?

    Riga bourgeoisie.

    Is Sikhism the only true religion?

    Yes. Can they all go back to India now? and take the other Indian non-real religionists with them.

    , @Gerard1234
    @Mikel


    Who really built the nice buildings in Riga?
     
    Good that this is mentioned.

    Of course Russia is large majority responsible for building Riga. It was comprehensively proven in my post.....then LatW's sudden probably hospitalisation because of my post (too much of a coincidence LatWakjob decided to break from the blog immediately after my return from a several month absence of here) . Main "counter-argument" from LatWakjob about all the things Russia built in Riga was :

    1.Latvians are Germans
    2.All the Russians who built the city were "Germans"
    3. Soviets are Latvians

    My next target could be the Black Russian prick "Sudden Death". Writing about somewhere as Klaipeda could educate the Black Russian delinquent dickhead.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Mikel

  4. Russian describes being sent to war in a tank that didn’t shoot:

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    Here is what I confirmed by watching 20 minutes of this video.

    John Johnson is a creep.

    War is disgusting and sad.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ

  5. @John Johnson
    Russian describes being sent to war in a tank that didn't shoot:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2S3UPUkZARo

    Replies: @QCIC

    Here is what I confirmed by watching 20 minutes of this video.

    John Johnson is a creep.

    War is disgusting and sad.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @QCIC

    What they were doing was using him as bait.

    That is why they sent him in a tank with a broken autoloader.

    The Russian response to the javalin was to send in a decoy team.

    His life meant so little that they didn't want to bother wasting a working tank on him.

    Sounds like he was the only one to survive.

    What a fine country you defend.

    Replies: @Sean

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @QCIC

    War was always disgusting and sad, no? This current war is the 21st century smaller-scale East Slavic equivalent of WWI a century ago, no?

    Replies: @QCIC

  6. @Mikel
    Things we should all finally agree on in this OT (or else we might as well give up and ask Ron to close the blog for good):

    - Who is winning the war, Ukraine or Russia?
    - Is Ukraine a real country or are they just confused Russians who have forgotten their true identity?
    - Why did Western Europeans meekly go along with the neocon plan to encroach Russia?
    - Who really built the nice buildings in Riga?
    - Is Sikhism the only true religion?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    For the last week I have been asking every new person I meet if they know anyplace where I can wear a raccoon coat. I want the coat. It’s only 300 bucks. But right now I don’t know one single place where I would wear it. Not a football game. I follow the sport but sitting down in a stadium for three hours no longer works. I think I will lose the impulse to buy it before I figure out an answer.

    One time I had a desire to own a knee length leather overcoat but it passed pretty quick.

  7. @Mikel
    Things we should all finally agree on in this OT (or else we might as well give up and ask Ron to close the blog for good):

    - Who is winning the war, Ukraine or Russia?
    - Is Ukraine a real country or are they just confused Russians who have forgotten their true identity?
    - Why did Western Europeans meekly go along with the neocon plan to encroach Russia?
    - Who really built the nice buildings in Riga?
    - Is Sikhism the only true religion?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    Who is winning the war, Ukraine or Russia?

    Second half: 2 -1 for Russia. If it stays Russia wins, they could also add to the score. Ukies seem unable to score, but a tie is still possible. The sponsors-referees want to end the game early so they can pretend that not much has happened. I doubt they will succeed, too much blood.

    Is Ukraine a real country or are they just confused Russians who have forgotten their true identity?

    Ukrainians are real but confused: they try to escape who they are and also forge their identity – a very hard thing to do simultaneously. Predictably, it is not working well.

    Why did Western Europeans meekly go along with the neocon plan to encroach Russia?

    Westies are meek pu.sies scared of the big bad wolf – not the one in Moscow, the one further west. Anyone with a backbone was removed over the last 20 years as an example to others. (Also, have you been to Belgium? enough said…)

    Who really built the nice buildings in Riga?

    Riga bourgeoisie.

    Is Sikhism the only true religion?

    Yes. Can they all go back to India now? and take the other Indian non-real religionists with them.

  8. There is a month left in the year of the bunny rabbit. Coming 10 Feb 2024 is the Dragon!

    [MORE]

    Gordon White Archaeology of the Dragon.

    Gordon is an overweight homo chaos magician. His lecture is pretty great any way.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    This might sound like nitpicking, but shouldn’t it be a Chinese dragon, not a Welsh dragon?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  9. That sort eats coal. They will be terrible for the climate. Generally like mountains. Fond of watching Rugby.

  10. AnoninTN was gloating and bragging about a sewage pipe bursting in Kiev.

    And here it is in Chelyabinsk.:

    There are no subtitles so I’ll translate. She said “it is minus 30 (Celsius). Kindergarten, rivers, oceans. Shit flowing like a river, in the literal meaning of that word…and all of that flows under the kindergarten.”

    Soviet civil “engineering” at its best.

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @AP

    You must be in hog heaven...:) shit flowing like a river...But you don't have to go all the way beyond the Urals (or to Kiev), there are rivers of poop that flood in poorer neighborhoods in UK, the grand city of Napoli is literally floating on sh..tty garbage, closer to home you have Baltimore and St. Louis, you must be familiar with them, the greatest centers of "capitalist plumbing" - even the commies couldn't do worse. It is everywhere, when Seine comes over its banks it releases the unforgivable Parisian aroma of s..t... And let's not forget the whole country of India. It is a dirty world out there.

    Most of it is not frozen, so you can fully experience it...no need to travel far, unless it is only the Russkies or Ukies s..t that you crave...but you are one weird guy.

    Replies: @AP, @LondonBob

  11. @AP
    AnoninTN was gloating and bragging about a sewage pipe bursting in Kiev.

    And here it is in Chelyabinsk.:

    There are no subtitles so I'll translate. She said "it is minus 30 (Celsius). Kindergarten, rivers, oceans. Shit flowing like a river, in the literal meaning of that word...and all of that flows under the kindergarten."

    Soviet civil "engineering" at its best.



    https://twitter.com/PStyle0ne1/status/1744799171926773790?s=20

    Replies: @Beckow

    You must be in hog heaven…:) shit flowing like a river…But you don’t have to go all the way beyond the Urals (or to Kiev), there are rivers of poop that flood in poorer neighborhoods in UK, the grand city of Napoli is literally floating on sh..tty garbage, closer to home you have Baltimore and St. Louis, you must be familiar with them, the greatest centers of “capitalist plumbing” – even the commies couldn’t do worse. It is everywhere, when Seine comes over its banks it releases the unforgivable Parisian aroma of s..t… And let’s not forget the whole country of India. It is a dirty world out there.

    Most of it is not frozen, so you can fully experience it…no need to travel far, unless it is only the Russkies or Ukies s..t that you crave…but you are one weird guy.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Beckow

    I made a post in response to AnoninTN, because the incident in Chelyabinsk appeared right after his gloating. But you seem to be very much interested in this, with your wide breath of knowledge of these incidents.


    s..t that you crave…but you are one weird guy.
     
    Clear projection.

    Replies: @Beckow

    , @LondonBob
    @Beckow

    Really enjoyed Valencia, but that odour of sewage that appears every so often when walking around is unpleasant.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

  12. @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    Here is what I confirmed by watching 20 minutes of this video.

    John Johnson is a creep.

    War is disgusting and sad.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ

    What they were doing was using him as bait.

    That is why they sent him in a tank with a broken autoloader.

    The Russian response to the javalin was to send in a decoy team.

    His life meant so little that they didn’t want to bother wasting a working tank on him.

    Sounds like he was the only one to survive.

    What a fine country you defend.

    • Replies: @Sean
    @John Johnson

    You think the less valuable British soldiers of a unit in WW2 were not sent out by their colonels and such to draw fire by getting killed? That is how war works.

  13. @Beckow
    @AP

    You must be in hog heaven...:) shit flowing like a river...But you don't have to go all the way beyond the Urals (or to Kiev), there are rivers of poop that flood in poorer neighborhoods in UK, the grand city of Napoli is literally floating on sh..tty garbage, closer to home you have Baltimore and St. Louis, you must be familiar with them, the greatest centers of "capitalist plumbing" - even the commies couldn't do worse. It is everywhere, when Seine comes over its banks it releases the unforgivable Parisian aroma of s..t... And let's not forget the whole country of India. It is a dirty world out there.

    Most of it is not frozen, so you can fully experience it...no need to travel far, unless it is only the Russkies or Ukies s..t that you crave...but you are one weird guy.

    Replies: @AP, @LondonBob

    I made a post in response to AnoninTN, because the incident in Chelyabinsk appeared right after his gloating. But you seem to be very much interested in this, with your wide breath of knowledge of these incidents.

    s..t that you crave…but you are one weird guy.

    Clear projection.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @AP


    ...breath of knowledge of these incidents.
     
    I travel a lot, one sees it all - the b..shit ideological one-sided observations, like the ones you specialize in, kind of fall by the wayside... When you get the urge to spew another retarded stereotype consider the context.

    Replies: @AP

  14. They are developing a vaccine against hGC, as a form of birth control:
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_chorionic_gonadotropin

    Right now, it is not super-effective and requires boosters. But, in theory, there are ways to improve it.

    One wonders what strange effects it might have on the population, not even considering what those in power might do with it.

    • Thanks: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    Google image search had disavowed all knowledge of the grinning Bill Gates with hypodermic needle and little frightened African children the last time I tried to find it.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

  15. @Emil Nikola Richard
    There is a month left in the year of the bunny rabbit. Coming 10 Feb 2024 is the Dragon!

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/d/de/Flag_of_Wales_%281959%29.svg/1024px-Flag_of_Wales_%281959%29.svg.png


    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UuzU98S5LSA

    Gordon White Archaeology of the Dragon.

    Gordon is an overweight homo chaos magician. His lecture is pretty great any way.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    This might sound like nitpicking, but shouldn’t it be a Chinese dragon, not a Welsh dragon?

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AnonfromTN

    You may not have appreciated the archaeology of dragon video. He makes up a lot of stuff but his raw information is great. Dragons go all the way from Wales to Sumeria to India to China to Indonesia and beyond. It's a long itinerary for a mythical beast.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

  16. @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    This might sound like nitpicking, but shouldn’t it be a Chinese dragon, not a Welsh dragon?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    You may not have appreciated the archaeology of dragon video. He makes up a lot of stuff but his raw information is great. Dragons go all the way from Wales to Sumeria to India to China to Indonesia and beyond. It’s a long itinerary for a mythical beast.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    It’s a long itinerary for a mythical beast.
     
    Yet in most places “national” dragons are easily distinguishable, although in many countries of large Chinese cultural zone they look rather Chinese.
  17. @songbird
    They are developing a vaccine against hGC, as a form of birth control:
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_chorionic_gonadotropin

    Right now, it is not super-effective and requires boosters. But, in theory, there are ways to improve it.

    One wonders what strange effects it might have on the population, not even considering what those in power might do with it.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    Google image search had disavowed all knowledge of the grinning Bill Gates with hypodermic needle and little frightened African children the last time I tried to find it.

    • LOL: songbird
    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    Google image search had disavowed all knowledge of the grinning Bill Gates with hypodermic needle and little frightened African children the last time I tried to find it.
     
    Al Capone didn’t personally murder people, either.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  18. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AnonfromTN

    You may not have appreciated the archaeology of dragon video. He makes up a lot of stuff but his raw information is great. Dragons go all the way from Wales to Sumeria to India to China to Indonesia and beyond. It's a long itinerary for a mythical beast.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    It’s a long itinerary for a mythical beast.

    Yet in most places “national” dragons are easily distinguishable, although in many countries of large Chinese cultural zone they look rather Chinese.

  19. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    Google image search had disavowed all knowledge of the grinning Bill Gates with hypodermic needle and little frightened African children the last time I tried to find it.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    Google image search had disavowed all knowledge of the grinning Bill Gates with hypodermic needle and little frightened African children the last time I tried to find it.

    Al Capone didn’t personally murder people, either.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AnonfromTN

    In Dale Cargenie's book How to Win Friends and Influence People he had 8-10 pages on the example of Al Capone. Carnegie wasn't an admirer. He thought Capone was a great example of the point that nobody looks in the mirror and sees an a$$ hole.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  20. @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    Google image search had disavowed all knowledge of the grinning Bill Gates with hypodermic needle and little frightened African children the last time I tried to find it.
     
    Al Capone didn’t personally murder people, either.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    In Dale Cargenie’s book How to Win Friends and Influence People he had 8-10 pages on the example of Al Capone. Carnegie wasn’t an admirer. He thought Capone was a great example of the point that nobody looks in the mirror and sees an a$$ hole.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    nobody looks in the mirror and sees an a$$ hole.
     
    https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fbucketeer-e05bbc84-baa3-437e-9518-adb32be77984.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F3dff4903-a3c8-40e5-a294-c7457a03e4e0_1404x1020.jpeg
    No, it's those outside of the mirror that can see one clearly, like Michael Ramirez.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  21. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AnonfromTN

    In Dale Cargenie's book How to Win Friends and Influence People he had 8-10 pages on the example of Al Capone. Carnegie wasn't an admirer. He thought Capone was a great example of the point that nobody looks in the mirror and sees an a$$ hole.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    nobody looks in the mirror and sees an a$$ hole.

    No, it’s those outside of the mirror that can see one clearly, like Michael Ramirez.

    • LOL: John Johnson
    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mr. Hack

    You are a smart guy. This is a rhetorical question.

    Why do you post comments like you are a stupid faggot?

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Mr. Hack

  22. @Beckow
    @AP

    You must be in hog heaven...:) shit flowing like a river...But you don't have to go all the way beyond the Urals (or to Kiev), there are rivers of poop that flood in poorer neighborhoods in UK, the grand city of Napoli is literally floating on sh..tty garbage, closer to home you have Baltimore and St. Louis, you must be familiar with them, the greatest centers of "capitalist plumbing" - even the commies couldn't do worse. It is everywhere, when Seine comes over its banks it releases the unforgivable Parisian aroma of s..t... And let's not forget the whole country of India. It is a dirty world out there.

    Most of it is not frozen, so you can fully experience it...no need to travel far, unless it is only the Russkies or Ukies s..t that you crave...but you are one weird guy.

    Replies: @AP, @LondonBob

    Really enjoyed Valencia, but that odour of sewage that appears every so often when walking around is unpleasant.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @LondonBob


    Really enjoyed Valencia, but that odour of sewage that appears every so often when walking around is unpleasant.
     
    That must be relatively new. I was in Valencia maybe 6-8 years ago. Walked all over the city and did not notice the odor of shit anywhere. What struck me then was meager choice and poor quality of fruits and berries available, in sharp contrast to riches of fruits and berries of excellent quality I found when I was in Spain 5-6 years before that. I took it as a sign that EU “standards” are working. So, now the smell of sewage is added. Yet another sign that Europe is making great strides to its grave. A pity, it was such a good place for vacations. Good thing I visited Notre-Dame before French morons let it burn down.
  23. Gentlemen,

    I know that many of you despaired these past few months from the absence of Yahya’s world famous film reviews. So I returned to this sacred forum to provide you with my unusually interesting and perspicuous takes on the films I watched this previous year. Overall, it has been a fruitful year for me cinematically, with a total of 141 films watched. I found it difficult to narrow down my selections to just the top 10 or 20; such was the large number of high-quality films I viewed in 2023. The key to maximizing quality films watched is to quit early when a film displays Goddard-tier dullness and pretentiousness. The Leopard will not change its spots. Just cut your losses and move on.

    1. The Godfather I (1972 – Coppola – American)
    2. The Godfather II (1974 – Coppola – American)
    3. Socrates (1971 – Rossellini – Italian)
    4. The Grand Illusion (1937 – Renoir – French)
    5. Batman Begins (2005 – Nolan – American)
    6. Gone With The Wind (1939 – Fleming – American)
    7. Wild Strawberries (1957 – Bergman – Swedish)
    8. North By Northwest (1959 – Hitchcock – American)
    9. Training Day (2001 – Fuqua – American)
    10. Great Expectations (1946 – Lean – British)
    11. Jane Eyre (1943 – Stevenson – British)
    12. Burnt By The Sun (1994 – Mikhalkov – Russian)
    13. Woman In The Dunes (1964 – Teshigahara – Japanese)
    14. Europe ‘51 (1952 – Rossellini – Italian)
    15. Annie Hall (1977 – Allen – American)
    16. Belle De Jour (1967 – Bunuel – French)
    17. The Searchers (1956 – Ford – American)
    18. The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962 – Ford – American)
    19. Mulholland Drive (2001 – Lynch – American)
    20. The Gentlemen (2019 – Ritchie – British)

    Honorable Mentions
    1. The Equalizer (2014 – Fuqua – American)
    2. Kind Hearts & Coronets (1946 – Hamer – British)
    3. Winter Sleep (2014 – Ceylan – Turkish)
    4. Taxi Driver (1976 – Scorsese – American)
    5. Hamlet (1948 – Olivier – British)

    My ranking of national cinemas remains unchanged from my last post, though I realized that my high opinion of Anglo-American cinema may be biased by the ease of watching English-language movies. Especially towards the second half of the year, I couldn’t be bothered with subtitles and strange cinematographic techniques, so my viewings were heavily tilted towards Anglo-American films. But that is a fault I aim to rectify in 2024.

    I’ve already written about some of these films in my posts throughout the year; so I’ll stick to new selections here.

    [MORE]

    The Grand Illusion centers around a group of French POWs held in captivity by the Germans; the most alluring of whom is the confident, self-assured Captain de Boeldieu, a French aristocratic officer whose untroubled bearing, upright posture, neat styling, and sardonic demeanor give him a Gaulle-esque aroma I found captivating. Renoir utilizes the setting of the film to comment upon class dynamics: “When I’m with Boeldieu, I never feel completely at ease. Call it the education barrier.” “He’s a fine type.” “Agreed, and he’s very decent. Suppose you and I went broke, we’d both be turned into beggars. If it happened to him, he’d still be Monsieur De Boeldieu.” Though I later found out Renoir is of the Socialistic bent, the film does not exude class hostility, but takes on a tolerant and matter-of-fact observational style as it relates to class and warfare. The film is also refreshing in its male-orientation; there is no romantic sub-plot to please female viewers (“Sentiment has no place in war” as de Boeldieu remarks); and it was a pleasure to view depictions of Old Europe such as the scene in the Gothic Cathedral at minute 50.

    Training Day explores the necessity of harshness, cruelty and rule-breaking in the fight against hard crime; in other words it touches upon the Jungian concept of Integrating The Shadow. “To protect the sheep you gotta catch the wolf, and it takes a wolf to catch a wolf.” Washington’s character represents the Wolf, he is willing to bend the rules and inflict cruelty on suspects to expedite the process of discovering and apprehending criminals. Denzel’s character is charismatic, bombastic, psychopathic, relentless, decisive. He asserts his will over subordinates by using his position of power and establishes his dominance fairly quickly over Hawke by use of verbal adeptness and charisma. Hawkes’ character is initially naïve, rule-following, and considerate of others. Denzel takes advantage of him by deceiving him into the hands of the cartel, but Hawke survives by sheer chance of having rescued a cartel member’s cousin earlier in the day. The script is stale when read on paper, but is brought to life by Washington’s eloquence and force of personality. One the greatest performances I’ve seen on screen, and an overall worthy production by an African-American lead actor and director.

    Batman Begins is one of the few mass-market productions I found to be worthy and enjoyable, although it comes with attendant flaws such as two-dimensional characters, a predictable plotline, and a simple script. Nevertheless, it is possible for a blockbuster film to be of high artistic value despite the typical shortcomings; and one must not forget that stalwart classics such as The Godfather and North by Northwest were mass-market productions in their own time. Bruce Wayne presents an archetype of the masculine ideal; eliciting universal respect from all ranges of viewers, as his character and behavior tap into the collective unconscious. Batman’s defining features are a) his strength, both mental and physical, which enable him to inflict damage on enemies and protect friends; b) handsome appearance in the traditional masculine sense, which though superficial, is critical to his status as a high-value male (he would not elicit respect had he been ugly and obese); c) an unbending sense of justice; and d) socio-economic status as one of the wealthiest individuals in Gotham.

    Batman is also a Dionysian figure, preferring action over knowledge-seeking. We do not see him sitting on a reclining chair, submerged in a book; but cultivating himself physically through intensive training. He mostly relies on intuition rather than logical reasoning to guide his actions. This was best evidenced in his confrontation with the Joker in the Dark Knight sequel. “The training is nothing, will is everything. The will to act”, again emphasizing action over knowledge/training. Batman also develops a network of trust between himself Fox, Alfred, Rachel, and Commissioner Gordon. While Wayne is the central character in this network, he must rely on Fox for the technology, without which he cannot perform his duties.

    • Thanks: Mr. Hack, Mr. XYZ, sudden death
    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Yahya

    The despair was palpable and several times I was tempted to call out the hounds on you. In any case, welcome back! Although its been a few years since I last viewed Mulholland Dr, I remember enjoying it and see that it nearly fell off of your list?...

    Replies: @Yahya

    , @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Yahya

    Great Expectations is one I can watch again and again. The plot contrivance where the protagonist misidentifies his benefactor for twenty years of living a totally wrong life is Dickens' absolute second best after Ebeneezer Scrooge Christmas Carol. The novel is one everybody needs to read. The movie is well done and the final scene is great climax even when you know it's coming which is never done in any other movie I can think of offhand. Out of the darkness and into the light!

    In real life she tells him to get away and calls him a loser and a creep. : )

    , @Beckow
    @Yahya


    ...the key to maximizing quality films is to quit early when a film displays Goddard-tier dullness and pretentiousness. The Leopard will not change its spots...
     
    That advise should be posted in Cannes as the global culturati march in. The post-mature culture of any kind is unbearably solipsistic...the Frenchies overdo even that. Goddard was an early sign of that.

    The films...not bad, some only so-so...sure #6,8,10,12,15...but Godfather? The boomer groupies think it is compulsory to like it, why? It is a dull, tedious, over-staged melodrama, some good acting and a decent dialogue - but the story is crap, Brando is not credible, a clownish celebration of nothingness. The gangster-mafia genre is always boring - why would anyone care about losers living sh.tty lives in sh.tty places killing each other? What's the point?

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @Yahya

    What about only limited to silent films?

    Replies: @Yahya

    , @songbird
    @Yahya

    Have not read it, but thought it was interesting when he talked about the physiological changes some movies cause.

    https://www.amazon.com/You-Are-What-Watch-Everything/dp/1523515899

    It crosses my mind to wonder, if there is some kind of biomarker that can be detected during scenes of great pozzedness. Perhaps, some metabolite of estrogen.

    Replies: @QCIC

    , @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @Yahya


    I know that many of you despaired these past few months from the absence of Yahya’s world famous film reviews. So I returned to this sacred forum to provide you with my unusually interesting and perspicuous takes on the films
     
    I am a complete philistine when it comes to films.

    I only watched a single one in 2023, it stays with you long after viewing.


    https://youtu.be/VbkYaJRByX8?si=-j8Gk2EGqfJ-nUg9

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    , @Barbarossa
    @Yahya

    Thanks Yahya, I'll cherry pick a few of these for my own viewing as I have the chance. I really do appreciate your reviews.

    I'm particularly interested in giving the The Grand Illusion a try.

    One of the best films I've seen in a bit is the 1950's version of A Christmas Carol with Alistair Sims. We always watched it at Christmas time when I was a kid and it's been a couple decades since I've seen it but I would have to say that it is an excellently fleshed out Christmas Carol. It's one of those films that is just nearly perfect in every way. The whole family loved it.

    My wife and I also saw The Boy and the Heron by Miyazaki in the theater a couple weeks ago and enjoyed it quite a bit. I you like Studio Ghibli fare it was a worthy addition. It was nice to see it on the big screen for the sake of the artwork, which gets a bit of short shrift on my small screen.

    I'm glad to hear that you are pushing your boundaries. Best of luck with the workouts, I think you'll find it worthwhile!

    Replies: @AP, @Yahya

  24. @Yahya
    Gentlemen,

    I know that many of you despaired these past few months from the absence of Yahya's world famous film reviews. So I returned to this sacred forum to provide you with my unusually interesting and perspicuous takes on the films I watched this previous year. Overall, it has been a fruitful year for me cinematically, with a total of 141 films watched. I found it difficult to narrow down my selections to just the top 10 or 20; such was the large number of high-quality films I viewed in 2023. The key to maximizing quality films watched is to quit early when a film displays Goddard-tier dullness and pretentiousness. The Leopard will not change its spots. Just cut your losses and move on.

    1. The Godfather I (1972 - Coppola - American)
    2. The Godfather II (1974 - Coppola - American)
    3. Socrates (1971 - Rossellini - Italian)
    4. The Grand Illusion (1937 - Renoir - French)
    5. Batman Begins (2005 - Nolan - American)
    6. Gone With The Wind (1939 - Fleming - American)
    7. Wild Strawberries (1957 - Bergman - Swedish)
    8. North By Northwest (1959 - Hitchcock - American)
    9. Training Day (2001 - Fuqua - American)
    10. Great Expectations (1946 - Lean - British)
    11. Jane Eyre (1943 - Stevenson - British)
    12. Burnt By The Sun (1994 - Mikhalkov - Russian)
    13. Woman In The Dunes (1964 - Teshigahara - Japanese)
    14. Europe ‘51 (1952 - Rossellini - Italian)
    15. Annie Hall (1977 - Allen - American)
    16. Belle De Jour (1967 - Bunuel - French)
    17. The Searchers (1956 - Ford - American)
    18. The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962 - Ford - American)
    19. Mulholland Drive (2001 - Lynch - American)
    20. The Gentlemen (2019 - Ritchie - British)

    Honorable Mentions
    1. The Equalizer (2014 - Fuqua - American)
    2. Kind Hearts & Coronets (1946 - Hamer - British)
    3. Winter Sleep (2014 - Ceylan - Turkish)
    4. Taxi Driver (1976 - Scorsese - American)
    5. Hamlet (1948 - Olivier - British)

    My ranking of national cinemas remains unchanged from my last post, though I realized that my high opinion of Anglo-American cinema may be biased by the ease of watching English-language movies. Especially towards the second half of the year, I couldn't be bothered with subtitles and strange cinematographic techniques, so my viewings were heavily tilted towards Anglo-American films. But that is a fault I aim to rectify in 2024.

    I've already written about some of these films in my posts throughout the year; so I'll stick to new selections here.

    The Grand Illusion centers around a group of French POWs held in captivity by the Germans; the most alluring of whom is the confident, self-assured Captain de Boeldieu, a French aristocratic officer whose untroubled bearing, upright posture, neat styling, and sardonic demeanor give him a Gaulle-esque aroma I found captivating. Renoir utilizes the setting of the film to comment upon class dynamics: "When I’m with Boeldieu, I never feel completely at ease. Call it the education barrier.” “He’s a fine type.” “Agreed, and he’s very decent. Suppose you and I went broke, we’d both be turned into beggars. If it happened to him, he’d still be Monsieur De Boeldieu.” Though I later found out Renoir is of the Socialistic bent, the film does not exude class hostility, but takes on a tolerant and matter-of-fact observational style as it relates to class and warfare. The film is also refreshing in its male-orientation; there is no romantic sub-plot to please female viewers (“Sentiment has no place in war” as de Boeldieu remarks); and it was a pleasure to view depictions of Old Europe such as the scene in the Gothic Cathedral at minute 50.

    Training Day explores the necessity of harshness, cruelty and rule-breaking in the fight against hard crime; in other words it touches upon the Jungian concept of Integrating The Shadow. "To protect the sheep you gotta catch the wolf, and it takes a wolf to catch a wolf." Washington's character represents the Wolf, he is willing to bend the rules and inflict cruelty on suspects to expedite the process of discovering and apprehending criminals. Denzel’s character is charismatic, bombastic, psychopathic, relentless, decisive. He asserts his will over subordinates by using his position of power and establishes his dominance fairly quickly over Hawke by use of verbal adeptness and charisma. Hawkes' character is initially naïve, rule-following, and considerate of others. Denzel takes advantage of him by deceiving him into the hands of the cartel, but Hawke survives by sheer chance of having rescued a cartel member's cousin earlier in the day. The script is stale when read on paper, but is brought to life by Washington's eloquence and force of personality. One the greatest performances I've seen on screen, and an overall worthy production by an African-American lead actor and director.

    Batman Begins is one of the few mass-market productions I found to be worthy and enjoyable, although it comes with attendant flaws such as two-dimensional characters, a predictable plotline, and a simple script. Nevertheless, it is possible for a blockbuster film to be of high artistic value despite the typical shortcomings; and one must not forget that stalwart classics such as The Godfather and North by Northwest were mass-market productions in their own time. Bruce Wayne presents an archetype of the masculine ideal; eliciting universal respect from all ranges of viewers, as his character and behavior tap into the collective unconscious. Batman's defining features are a) his strength, both mental and physical, which enable him to inflict damage on enemies and protect friends; b) handsome appearance in the traditional masculine sense, which though superficial, is critical to his status as a high-value male (he would not elicit respect had he been ugly and obese); c) an unbending sense of justice; and d) socio-economic status as one of the wealthiest individuals in Gotham.

    Batman is also a Dionysian figure, preferring action over knowledge-seeking. We do not see him sitting on a reclining chair, submerged in a book; but cultivating himself physically through intensive training. He mostly relies on intuition rather than logical reasoning to guide his actions. This was best evidenced in his confrontation with the Joker in the Dark Knight sequel. "The training is nothing, will is everything. The will to act", again emphasizing action over knowledge/training. Batman also develops a network of trust between himself Fox, Alfred, Rachel, and Commissioner Gordon. While Wayne is the central character in this network, he must rely on Fox for the technology, without which he cannot perform his duties.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @Mr. XYZ, @songbird, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Barbarossa

    The despair was palpable and several times I was tempted to call out the hounds on you. In any case, welcome back! Although its been a few years since I last viewed Mulholland Dr, I remember enjoying it and see that it nearly fell off of your list?…

    • Replies: @Yahya
    @Mr. Hack


    Although its been a few years since I last viewed Mulholland Dr, I remember enjoying it and see that it nearly fell off of your list?…
     
    Mulholland Dr is an interesting and original film. Problem is, I’ve watched too many excellent films this year. As mentioned, I struggled mightily to winnow down this list; lots of otherwise good films like 2001: Space Odyssey, Fight Club, Charade, Pathar Panchali etc. had to be excluded from my list.

    In any case, welcome back!
     
    Thanks, but my stay here will be short-lived. I realized that passing time in an online forum with 50-60+ year olds is not ideal for someone my age. Although I’ve certainly enjoyed and benefited from interacting with many high-caliber individuals on this forum; I decided to focus more on cultivating my physical strength and social skills over the previous months, since I had neglected those in favor of intellectual activities from a young age. The aim is to attain comprehensiveness in character and balance out my overly-intellectual natural side.

    No need to despair though, Mr. Hack, because I will stop by here every once in a while. Best of luck.

    @Emil Nikola

    Great Expectations is indeed a great movie. I probably should’ve bumped it up the list a few spots. Haven’t read the novel yet.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Sher Singh, @Talha

  25. @Mr. Hack
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    nobody looks in the mirror and sees an a$$ hole.
     
    https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fbucketeer-e05bbc84-baa3-437e-9518-adb32be77984.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F3dff4903-a3c8-40e5-a294-c7457a03e4e0_1404x1020.jpeg
    No, it's those outside of the mirror that can see one clearly, like Michael Ramirez.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    You are a smart guy. This is a rhetorical question.

    Why do you post comments like you are a stupid faggot?

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    Why do you post comments like you are a stupid faggot?
     
    If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, ….

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    , @Mr. Hack
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    I'll give you a direct response to your question (even though it's a rhetorical question): I enjoy torturing nincompoops like you. :-)

  26. @Yahya
    Gentlemen,

    I know that many of you despaired these past few months from the absence of Yahya's world famous film reviews. So I returned to this sacred forum to provide you with my unusually interesting and perspicuous takes on the films I watched this previous year. Overall, it has been a fruitful year for me cinematically, with a total of 141 films watched. I found it difficult to narrow down my selections to just the top 10 or 20; such was the large number of high-quality films I viewed in 2023. The key to maximizing quality films watched is to quit early when a film displays Goddard-tier dullness and pretentiousness. The Leopard will not change its spots. Just cut your losses and move on.

    1. The Godfather I (1972 - Coppola - American)
    2. The Godfather II (1974 - Coppola - American)
    3. Socrates (1971 - Rossellini - Italian)
    4. The Grand Illusion (1937 - Renoir - French)
    5. Batman Begins (2005 - Nolan - American)
    6. Gone With The Wind (1939 - Fleming - American)
    7. Wild Strawberries (1957 - Bergman - Swedish)
    8. North By Northwest (1959 - Hitchcock - American)
    9. Training Day (2001 - Fuqua - American)
    10. Great Expectations (1946 - Lean - British)
    11. Jane Eyre (1943 - Stevenson - British)
    12. Burnt By The Sun (1994 - Mikhalkov - Russian)
    13. Woman In The Dunes (1964 - Teshigahara - Japanese)
    14. Europe ‘51 (1952 - Rossellini - Italian)
    15. Annie Hall (1977 - Allen - American)
    16. Belle De Jour (1967 - Bunuel - French)
    17. The Searchers (1956 - Ford - American)
    18. The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962 - Ford - American)
    19. Mulholland Drive (2001 - Lynch - American)
    20. The Gentlemen (2019 - Ritchie - British)

    Honorable Mentions
    1. The Equalizer (2014 - Fuqua - American)
    2. Kind Hearts & Coronets (1946 - Hamer - British)
    3. Winter Sleep (2014 - Ceylan - Turkish)
    4. Taxi Driver (1976 - Scorsese - American)
    5. Hamlet (1948 - Olivier - British)

    My ranking of national cinemas remains unchanged from my last post, though I realized that my high opinion of Anglo-American cinema may be biased by the ease of watching English-language movies. Especially towards the second half of the year, I couldn't be bothered with subtitles and strange cinematographic techniques, so my viewings were heavily tilted towards Anglo-American films. But that is a fault I aim to rectify in 2024.

    I've already written about some of these films in my posts throughout the year; so I'll stick to new selections here.

    The Grand Illusion centers around a group of French POWs held in captivity by the Germans; the most alluring of whom is the confident, self-assured Captain de Boeldieu, a French aristocratic officer whose untroubled bearing, upright posture, neat styling, and sardonic demeanor give him a Gaulle-esque aroma I found captivating. Renoir utilizes the setting of the film to comment upon class dynamics: "When I’m with Boeldieu, I never feel completely at ease. Call it the education barrier.” “He’s a fine type.” “Agreed, and he’s very decent. Suppose you and I went broke, we’d both be turned into beggars. If it happened to him, he’d still be Monsieur De Boeldieu.” Though I later found out Renoir is of the Socialistic bent, the film does not exude class hostility, but takes on a tolerant and matter-of-fact observational style as it relates to class and warfare. The film is also refreshing in its male-orientation; there is no romantic sub-plot to please female viewers (“Sentiment has no place in war” as de Boeldieu remarks); and it was a pleasure to view depictions of Old Europe such as the scene in the Gothic Cathedral at minute 50.

    Training Day explores the necessity of harshness, cruelty and rule-breaking in the fight against hard crime; in other words it touches upon the Jungian concept of Integrating The Shadow. "To protect the sheep you gotta catch the wolf, and it takes a wolf to catch a wolf." Washington's character represents the Wolf, he is willing to bend the rules and inflict cruelty on suspects to expedite the process of discovering and apprehending criminals. Denzel’s character is charismatic, bombastic, psychopathic, relentless, decisive. He asserts his will over subordinates by using his position of power and establishes his dominance fairly quickly over Hawke by use of verbal adeptness and charisma. Hawkes' character is initially naïve, rule-following, and considerate of others. Denzel takes advantage of him by deceiving him into the hands of the cartel, but Hawke survives by sheer chance of having rescued a cartel member's cousin earlier in the day. The script is stale when read on paper, but is brought to life by Washington's eloquence and force of personality. One the greatest performances I've seen on screen, and an overall worthy production by an African-American lead actor and director.

    Batman Begins is one of the few mass-market productions I found to be worthy and enjoyable, although it comes with attendant flaws such as two-dimensional characters, a predictable plotline, and a simple script. Nevertheless, it is possible for a blockbuster film to be of high artistic value despite the typical shortcomings; and one must not forget that stalwart classics such as The Godfather and North by Northwest were mass-market productions in their own time. Bruce Wayne presents an archetype of the masculine ideal; eliciting universal respect from all ranges of viewers, as his character and behavior tap into the collective unconscious. Batman's defining features are a) his strength, both mental and physical, which enable him to inflict damage on enemies and protect friends; b) handsome appearance in the traditional masculine sense, which though superficial, is critical to his status as a high-value male (he would not elicit respect had he been ugly and obese); c) an unbending sense of justice; and d) socio-economic status as one of the wealthiest individuals in Gotham.

    Batman is also a Dionysian figure, preferring action over knowledge-seeking. We do not see him sitting on a reclining chair, submerged in a book; but cultivating himself physically through intensive training. He mostly relies on intuition rather than logical reasoning to guide his actions. This was best evidenced in his confrontation with the Joker in the Dark Knight sequel. "The training is nothing, will is everything. The will to act", again emphasizing action over knowledge/training. Batman also develops a network of trust between himself Fox, Alfred, Rachel, and Commissioner Gordon. While Wayne is the central character in this network, he must rely on Fox for the technology, without which he cannot perform his duties.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @Mr. XYZ, @songbird, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Barbarossa

    Great Expectations is one I can watch again and again. The plot contrivance where the protagonist misidentifies his benefactor for twenty years of living a totally wrong life is Dickens’ absolute second best after Ebeneezer Scrooge Christmas Carol. The novel is one everybody needs to read. The movie is well done and the final scene is great climax even when you know it’s coming which is never done in any other movie I can think of offhand. Out of the darkness and into the light!

    In real life she tells him to get away and calls him a loser and a creep. : )

  27. @AP
    @Beckow

    I made a post in response to AnoninTN, because the incident in Chelyabinsk appeared right after his gloating. But you seem to be very much interested in this, with your wide breath of knowledge of these incidents.


    s..t that you crave…but you are one weird guy.
     
    Clear projection.

    Replies: @Beckow

    …breath of knowledge of these incidents.

    I travel a lot, one sees it all – the b..shit ideological one-sided observations, like the ones you specialize in, kind of fall by the wayside… When you get the urge to spew another retarded stereotype consider the context.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Beckow

    I only pointed out a river of excrement in response to AnoninTN gloating about a sewer leak in Kiev. Excrement being your specialty, you had to chime in. Though you are a connoisseur of the bovine type.

    Was he or someone else gloating about Ukraine’s power grid problems? Russian civil engineering hasn’t been doing well from that perspective either lately, and they aren’t getting bombed a lot like Ukraine has been…

  28. @Yahya
    Gentlemen,

    I know that many of you despaired these past few months from the absence of Yahya's world famous film reviews. So I returned to this sacred forum to provide you with my unusually interesting and perspicuous takes on the films I watched this previous year. Overall, it has been a fruitful year for me cinematically, with a total of 141 films watched. I found it difficult to narrow down my selections to just the top 10 or 20; such was the large number of high-quality films I viewed in 2023. The key to maximizing quality films watched is to quit early when a film displays Goddard-tier dullness and pretentiousness. The Leopard will not change its spots. Just cut your losses and move on.

    1. The Godfather I (1972 - Coppola - American)
    2. The Godfather II (1974 - Coppola - American)
    3. Socrates (1971 - Rossellini - Italian)
    4. The Grand Illusion (1937 - Renoir - French)
    5. Batman Begins (2005 - Nolan - American)
    6. Gone With The Wind (1939 - Fleming - American)
    7. Wild Strawberries (1957 - Bergman - Swedish)
    8. North By Northwest (1959 - Hitchcock - American)
    9. Training Day (2001 - Fuqua - American)
    10. Great Expectations (1946 - Lean - British)
    11. Jane Eyre (1943 - Stevenson - British)
    12. Burnt By The Sun (1994 - Mikhalkov - Russian)
    13. Woman In The Dunes (1964 - Teshigahara - Japanese)
    14. Europe ‘51 (1952 - Rossellini - Italian)
    15. Annie Hall (1977 - Allen - American)
    16. Belle De Jour (1967 - Bunuel - French)
    17. The Searchers (1956 - Ford - American)
    18. The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962 - Ford - American)
    19. Mulholland Drive (2001 - Lynch - American)
    20. The Gentlemen (2019 - Ritchie - British)

    Honorable Mentions
    1. The Equalizer (2014 - Fuqua - American)
    2. Kind Hearts & Coronets (1946 - Hamer - British)
    3. Winter Sleep (2014 - Ceylan - Turkish)
    4. Taxi Driver (1976 - Scorsese - American)
    5. Hamlet (1948 - Olivier - British)

    My ranking of national cinemas remains unchanged from my last post, though I realized that my high opinion of Anglo-American cinema may be biased by the ease of watching English-language movies. Especially towards the second half of the year, I couldn't be bothered with subtitles and strange cinematographic techniques, so my viewings were heavily tilted towards Anglo-American films. But that is a fault I aim to rectify in 2024.

    I've already written about some of these films in my posts throughout the year; so I'll stick to new selections here.

    The Grand Illusion centers around a group of French POWs held in captivity by the Germans; the most alluring of whom is the confident, self-assured Captain de Boeldieu, a French aristocratic officer whose untroubled bearing, upright posture, neat styling, and sardonic demeanor give him a Gaulle-esque aroma I found captivating. Renoir utilizes the setting of the film to comment upon class dynamics: "When I’m with Boeldieu, I never feel completely at ease. Call it the education barrier.” “He’s a fine type.” “Agreed, and he’s very decent. Suppose you and I went broke, we’d both be turned into beggars. If it happened to him, he’d still be Monsieur De Boeldieu.” Though I later found out Renoir is of the Socialistic bent, the film does not exude class hostility, but takes on a tolerant and matter-of-fact observational style as it relates to class and warfare. The film is also refreshing in its male-orientation; there is no romantic sub-plot to please female viewers (“Sentiment has no place in war” as de Boeldieu remarks); and it was a pleasure to view depictions of Old Europe such as the scene in the Gothic Cathedral at minute 50.

    Training Day explores the necessity of harshness, cruelty and rule-breaking in the fight against hard crime; in other words it touches upon the Jungian concept of Integrating The Shadow. "To protect the sheep you gotta catch the wolf, and it takes a wolf to catch a wolf." Washington's character represents the Wolf, he is willing to bend the rules and inflict cruelty on suspects to expedite the process of discovering and apprehending criminals. Denzel’s character is charismatic, bombastic, psychopathic, relentless, decisive. He asserts his will over subordinates by using his position of power and establishes his dominance fairly quickly over Hawke by use of verbal adeptness and charisma. Hawkes' character is initially naïve, rule-following, and considerate of others. Denzel takes advantage of him by deceiving him into the hands of the cartel, but Hawke survives by sheer chance of having rescued a cartel member's cousin earlier in the day. The script is stale when read on paper, but is brought to life by Washington's eloquence and force of personality. One the greatest performances I've seen on screen, and an overall worthy production by an African-American lead actor and director.

    Batman Begins is one of the few mass-market productions I found to be worthy and enjoyable, although it comes with attendant flaws such as two-dimensional characters, a predictable plotline, and a simple script. Nevertheless, it is possible for a blockbuster film to be of high artistic value despite the typical shortcomings; and one must not forget that stalwart classics such as The Godfather and North by Northwest were mass-market productions in their own time. Bruce Wayne presents an archetype of the masculine ideal; eliciting universal respect from all ranges of viewers, as his character and behavior tap into the collective unconscious. Batman's defining features are a) his strength, both mental and physical, which enable him to inflict damage on enemies and protect friends; b) handsome appearance in the traditional masculine sense, which though superficial, is critical to his status as a high-value male (he would not elicit respect had he been ugly and obese); c) an unbending sense of justice; and d) socio-economic status as one of the wealthiest individuals in Gotham.

    Batman is also a Dionysian figure, preferring action over knowledge-seeking. We do not see him sitting on a reclining chair, submerged in a book; but cultivating himself physically through intensive training. He mostly relies on intuition rather than logical reasoning to guide his actions. This was best evidenced in his confrontation with the Joker in the Dark Knight sequel. "The training is nothing, will is everything. The will to act", again emphasizing action over knowledge/training. Batman also develops a network of trust between himself Fox, Alfred, Rachel, and Commissioner Gordon. While Wayne is the central character in this network, he must rely on Fox for the technology, without which he cannot perform his duties.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @Mr. XYZ, @songbird, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Barbarossa

    …the key to maximizing quality films is to quit early when a film displays Goddard-tier dullness and pretentiousness. The Leopard will not change its spots…

    That advise should be posted in Cannes as the global culturati march in. The post-mature culture of any kind is unbearably solipsistic…the Frenchies overdo even that. Goddard was an early sign of that.

    The films…not bad, some only so-so…sure #6,8,10,12,15…but Godfather? The boomer groupies think it is compulsory to like it, why? It is a dull, tedious, over-staged melodrama, some good acting and a decent dialogue – but the story is crap, Brando is not credible, a clownish celebration of nothingness. The gangster-mafia genre is always boring – why would anyone care about losers living sh.tty lives in sh.tty places killing each other? What’s the point?

  29. @LondonBob
    @Beckow

    Really enjoyed Valencia, but that odour of sewage that appears every so often when walking around is unpleasant.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    Really enjoyed Valencia, but that odour of sewage that appears every so often when walking around is unpleasant.

    That must be relatively new. I was in Valencia maybe 6-8 years ago. Walked all over the city and did not notice the odor of shit anywhere. What struck me then was meager choice and poor quality of fruits and berries available, in sharp contrast to riches of fruits and berries of excellent quality I found when I was in Spain 5-6 years before that. I took it as a sign that EU “standards” are working. So, now the smell of sewage is added. Yet another sign that Europe is making great strides to its grave. A pity, it was such a good place for vacations. Good thing I visited Notre-Dame before French morons let it burn down.

  30. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mr. Hack

    You are a smart guy. This is a rhetorical question.

    Why do you post comments like you are a stupid faggot?

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Mr. Hack

    Why do you post comments like you are a stupid faggot?

    If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, ….

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @AnonfromTN

    Was I too hard on your godman Putler? :-)

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

  31. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mr. Hack

    You are a smart guy. This is a rhetorical question.

    Why do you post comments like you are a stupid faggot?

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Mr. Hack

    I’ll give you a direct response to your question (even though it’s a rhetorical question): I enjoy torturing nincompoops like you. 🙂

  32. @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    Why do you post comments like you are a stupid faggot?
     
    If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, ….

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    Was I too hard on your godman Putler? 🙂

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Mr. Hack


    Was I too hard on your godman Putler?
     
    Unlike some people (naming no names), I do not have gods, neither in the sky, nor here on Earth.

    Another thing: if you think that these threads affect in any way Putin personally, or Russian policies in general, think again. This is purely inconsequential exchange of hot air, anything we write is neither here nor there. Happy cud chewing!
  33. @Mr. Hack
    @AnonfromTN

    Was I too hard on your godman Putler? :-)

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    Was I too hard on your godman Putler?

    Unlike some people (naming no names), I do not have gods, neither in the sky, nor here on Earth.

    Another thing: if you think that these threads affect in any way Putin personally, or Russian policies in general, think again. This is purely inconsequential exchange of hot air, anything we write is neither here nor there. Happy cud chewing!

  34. @Mr. Hack
    @Yahya

    The despair was palpable and several times I was tempted to call out the hounds on you. In any case, welcome back! Although its been a few years since I last viewed Mulholland Dr, I remember enjoying it and see that it nearly fell off of your list?...

    Replies: @Yahya

    Although its been a few years since I last viewed Mulholland Dr, I remember enjoying it and see that it nearly fell off of your list?…

    Mulholland Dr is an interesting and original film. Problem is, I’ve watched too many excellent films this year. As mentioned, I struggled mightily to winnow down this list; lots of otherwise good films like 2001: Space Odyssey, Fight Club, Charade, Pathar Panchali etc. had to be excluded from my list.

    In any case, welcome back!

    Thanks, but my stay here will be short-lived. I realized that passing time in an online forum with 50-60+ year olds is not ideal for someone my age. Although I’ve certainly enjoyed and benefited from interacting with many high-caliber individuals on this forum; I decided to focus more on cultivating my physical strength and social skills over the previous months, since I had neglected those in favor of intellectual activities from a young age. The aim is to attain comprehensiveness in character and balance out my overly-intellectual natural side.

    No need to despair though, Mr. Hack, because I will stop by here every once in a while. Best of luck.

    @Emil Nikola

    Great Expectations is indeed a great movie. I probably should’ve bumped it up the list a few spots. Haven’t read the novel yet.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Yahya


    Haven’t read the novel yet.
     
    Your #1 choice, "The Godfather" is a good choice. The novel, written by Mario Puzo, is a masterful work of art too. The book and the film bearing its name are both very good examples of their respective art forms, but very different one from the other. Seeing that you enjoyed the films so much, I think that you'll enjoy reading the book that started it all. I don' think that the third film was nearly as bad as the critics made it out to be...but certainly the first two installments were better.

    Replies: @Gerard1234

    , @Sher Singh
    @Yahya

    Alphaprogression App
    Reverse Grip Bench

    Replies: @Yahya

    , @Talha
    @Yahya

    Salaam Bro,

    Excellent idea - always good to be well rounded. I’m taking up Muay Thai myself and inshaAllah about to start a self-defense/grappling club (in my new basement - putting down enough pads/mats for two concurrent sparring sessions) for some of the older “uncle-brothers” in the community to get them out of skinny-fat and get used to getting punched and kicked in the face. It’s an excellent and humbling experience - I would recommend some self-defense training along with the weights. Know how to use the muscle properly - a trained jiu jitsu partner at 150 can repeatedly submit a guy 80 pounds larger. But the bigger guy who is also trained will win almost every time.

    Egypt generally brings some good competition to world wrestling and martial arts, though Morocco seems to produce very solid kickboxers.

    Anyway, may Allah swt grant you tawfiq in your endeavors!

    Wa salaam.

  35. Chronicles of “democracy”.

    Former Ukrainian deputy prosecutor general Olga Kolinko (served with interruptions from 1993 to 2005) was just murdered in her apartment in Kiev. Apparently the same “unknowns” also murdered her daughter in neighboring apartment.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AnonfromTN

    Let's see what investigations in regards to this will say. But Yeah, in the East Slavic lands, unfortunately journalist and politician killings, shootings, and poisonings have not exactly been rare in the post-Soviet era. It really is a huge tragedy and shows just how much Communism and its legacy severely fucked over these countries. I'm not even sure if Central Asia has this problem on quite as large of a scale, even after adjusting for total population size.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. Hack, @Derer

    , @AP
    @AnonfromTN

    Hmm….

    You have checked about killings in Russia?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AnonfromTN

  36. @AnonfromTN
    Chronicles of “democracy”.

    Former Ukrainian deputy prosecutor general Olga Kolinko (served with interruptions from 1993 to 2005) was just murdered in her apartment in Kiev. Apparently the same “unknowns” also murdered her daughter in neighboring apartment.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    Let’s see what investigations in regards to this will say. But Yeah, in the East Slavic lands, unfortunately journalist and politician killings, shootings, and poisonings have not exactly been rare in the post-Soviet era. It really is a huge tragedy and shows just how much Communism and its legacy severely fucked over these countries. I’m not even sure if Central Asia has this problem on quite as large of a scale, even after adjusting for total population size.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Mr. XYZ

    In the USA the fighting near the top of the food chain at the intersection of government officials and criminals may be mostly blackmail. There are occasional murders though the press is very selective on the reporting.

    Just think of the coercion that is happening on a continuous basis to allow the massive influx of illegals into the US borders? This process is obviously bad for the citizens of the USA, is criminal, immoral and clearly treasonous. Yet there is only slight visible pushback. I wonder if a combination of violence, extortion and bribery against police, prosecutors and judges is central to this entire process? Same thing for the more despicable human trafficking. Ditto for the massive influx of highly addictive drugs. Presumably a lot of responsible people know the central facts of what is going on (how could they not?) but nothing happens.

    Cui bono?

    , @Mr. Hack
    @Mr. XYZ

    Professor Stooge is well aware of just how corrupt Russia really is, but still chooses to selectively use super thick blinders when discussing this topic. Why else does he choose to live in the US and not in Russia? Also, living in even podunk Tennessee on a fully tenured professor's salary beats anything that he'd be able to afford in Moscow. Yet he manages to retain this strong nostalgia for this country that he left behind decades ago.

    , @Derer
    @Mr. XYZ


    East Slavic lands, unfortunately journalist and politician killings, shootings,
     
    Only in East Slavic lands? You are badly misinformed...what about unexplained bodies disappearing and dying around H.Clinton, it perhaps started with Vince Foster.
  37. @Yahya
    Gentlemen,

    I know that many of you despaired these past few months from the absence of Yahya's world famous film reviews. So I returned to this sacred forum to provide you with my unusually interesting and perspicuous takes on the films I watched this previous year. Overall, it has been a fruitful year for me cinematically, with a total of 141 films watched. I found it difficult to narrow down my selections to just the top 10 or 20; such was the large number of high-quality films I viewed in 2023. The key to maximizing quality films watched is to quit early when a film displays Goddard-tier dullness and pretentiousness. The Leopard will not change its spots. Just cut your losses and move on.

    1. The Godfather I (1972 - Coppola - American)
    2. The Godfather II (1974 - Coppola - American)
    3. Socrates (1971 - Rossellini - Italian)
    4. The Grand Illusion (1937 - Renoir - French)
    5. Batman Begins (2005 - Nolan - American)
    6. Gone With The Wind (1939 - Fleming - American)
    7. Wild Strawberries (1957 - Bergman - Swedish)
    8. North By Northwest (1959 - Hitchcock - American)
    9. Training Day (2001 - Fuqua - American)
    10. Great Expectations (1946 - Lean - British)
    11. Jane Eyre (1943 - Stevenson - British)
    12. Burnt By The Sun (1994 - Mikhalkov - Russian)
    13. Woman In The Dunes (1964 - Teshigahara - Japanese)
    14. Europe ‘51 (1952 - Rossellini - Italian)
    15. Annie Hall (1977 - Allen - American)
    16. Belle De Jour (1967 - Bunuel - French)
    17. The Searchers (1956 - Ford - American)
    18. The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962 - Ford - American)
    19. Mulholland Drive (2001 - Lynch - American)
    20. The Gentlemen (2019 - Ritchie - British)

    Honorable Mentions
    1. The Equalizer (2014 - Fuqua - American)
    2. Kind Hearts & Coronets (1946 - Hamer - British)
    3. Winter Sleep (2014 - Ceylan - Turkish)
    4. Taxi Driver (1976 - Scorsese - American)
    5. Hamlet (1948 - Olivier - British)

    My ranking of national cinemas remains unchanged from my last post, though I realized that my high opinion of Anglo-American cinema may be biased by the ease of watching English-language movies. Especially towards the second half of the year, I couldn't be bothered with subtitles and strange cinematographic techniques, so my viewings were heavily tilted towards Anglo-American films. But that is a fault I aim to rectify in 2024.

    I've already written about some of these films in my posts throughout the year; so I'll stick to new selections here.

    The Grand Illusion centers around a group of French POWs held in captivity by the Germans; the most alluring of whom is the confident, self-assured Captain de Boeldieu, a French aristocratic officer whose untroubled bearing, upright posture, neat styling, and sardonic demeanor give him a Gaulle-esque aroma I found captivating. Renoir utilizes the setting of the film to comment upon class dynamics: "When I’m with Boeldieu, I never feel completely at ease. Call it the education barrier.” “He’s a fine type.” “Agreed, and he’s very decent. Suppose you and I went broke, we’d both be turned into beggars. If it happened to him, he’d still be Monsieur De Boeldieu.” Though I later found out Renoir is of the Socialistic bent, the film does not exude class hostility, but takes on a tolerant and matter-of-fact observational style as it relates to class and warfare. The film is also refreshing in its male-orientation; there is no romantic sub-plot to please female viewers (“Sentiment has no place in war” as de Boeldieu remarks); and it was a pleasure to view depictions of Old Europe such as the scene in the Gothic Cathedral at minute 50.

    Training Day explores the necessity of harshness, cruelty and rule-breaking in the fight against hard crime; in other words it touches upon the Jungian concept of Integrating The Shadow. "To protect the sheep you gotta catch the wolf, and it takes a wolf to catch a wolf." Washington's character represents the Wolf, he is willing to bend the rules and inflict cruelty on suspects to expedite the process of discovering and apprehending criminals. Denzel’s character is charismatic, bombastic, psychopathic, relentless, decisive. He asserts his will over subordinates by using his position of power and establishes his dominance fairly quickly over Hawke by use of verbal adeptness and charisma. Hawkes' character is initially naïve, rule-following, and considerate of others. Denzel takes advantage of him by deceiving him into the hands of the cartel, but Hawke survives by sheer chance of having rescued a cartel member's cousin earlier in the day. The script is stale when read on paper, but is brought to life by Washington's eloquence and force of personality. One the greatest performances I've seen on screen, and an overall worthy production by an African-American lead actor and director.

    Batman Begins is one of the few mass-market productions I found to be worthy and enjoyable, although it comes with attendant flaws such as two-dimensional characters, a predictable plotline, and a simple script. Nevertheless, it is possible for a blockbuster film to be of high artistic value despite the typical shortcomings; and one must not forget that stalwart classics such as The Godfather and North by Northwest were mass-market productions in their own time. Bruce Wayne presents an archetype of the masculine ideal; eliciting universal respect from all ranges of viewers, as his character and behavior tap into the collective unconscious. Batman's defining features are a) his strength, both mental and physical, which enable him to inflict damage on enemies and protect friends; b) handsome appearance in the traditional masculine sense, which though superficial, is critical to his status as a high-value male (he would not elicit respect had he been ugly and obese); c) an unbending sense of justice; and d) socio-economic status as one of the wealthiest individuals in Gotham.

    Batman is also a Dionysian figure, preferring action over knowledge-seeking. We do not see him sitting on a reclining chair, submerged in a book; but cultivating himself physically through intensive training. He mostly relies on intuition rather than logical reasoning to guide his actions. This was best evidenced in his confrontation with the Joker in the Dark Knight sequel. "The training is nothing, will is everything. The will to act", again emphasizing action over knowledge/training. Batman also develops a network of trust between himself Fox, Alfred, Rachel, and Commissioner Gordon. While Wayne is the central character in this network, he must rely on Fox for the technology, without which he cannot perform his duties.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @Mr. XYZ, @songbird, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Barbarossa

    What about only limited to silent films?

    • Replies: @Yahya
    @Mr. XYZ

    I’ve only watched one silent film last year - The Phantom Carriage.

    Beautiful imagery and a compelling concept.

    Too sentimental for my taste though.

    I gave it an 8/10.

    I plan to watch a couple of Fritz Lang films this year.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  38. @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    Here is what I confirmed by watching 20 minutes of this video.

    John Johnson is a creep.

    War is disgusting and sad.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ

    War was always disgusting and sad, no? This current war is the 21st century smaller-scale East Slavic equivalent of WWI a century ago, no?

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Mr. XYZ

    War is usually disgusting and sad, but I don't know about always. I can't compare the SMO to earlier wars.

    Compared to 1915, people on average live longer now and generally have more "creature comforts". I wonder if we value life more, less or the same as people during WW1?

  39. @Mr. XYZ
    @Yahya

    What about only limited to silent films?

    Replies: @Yahya

    I’ve only watched one silent film last year – The Phantom Carriage.

    Beautiful imagery and a compelling concept.

    Too sentimental for my taste though.

    I gave it an 8/10.

    I plan to watch a couple of Fritz Lang films this year.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Yahya

    What about the silent films that you watched before that, in the more distant past?

  40. @Beckow
    @AP


    ...breath of knowledge of these incidents.
     
    I travel a lot, one sees it all - the b..shit ideological one-sided observations, like the ones you specialize in, kind of fall by the wayside... When you get the urge to spew another retarded stereotype consider the context.

    Replies: @AP

    I only pointed out a river of excrement in response to AnoninTN gloating about a sewer leak in Kiev. Excrement being your specialty, you had to chime in. Though you are a connoisseur of the bovine type.

    Was he or someone else gloating about Ukraine’s power grid problems? Russian civil engineering hasn’t been doing well from that perspective either lately, and they aren’t getting bombed a lot like Ukraine has been…

  41. @AnonfromTN
    Chronicles of “democracy”.

    Former Ukrainian deputy prosecutor general Olga Kolinko (served with interruptions from 1993 to 2005) was just murdered in her apartment in Kiev. Apparently the same “unknowns” also murdered her daughter in neighboring apartment.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    Hmm….

    You have checked about killings in Russia?

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Yes, as I said, killings of this type are unfortunately and tragically a common trend in the East Slavic world in the years and decades after the USSR's collapse due to the Sovok mentality severely corrupting these lands even after the USSR was gone.

    AP, off-topic, but what do you think about this online book* that compares the various regions of the US and the ex-USSR?

    https://digitalcommons.spu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1001&context=works

    *It was apparently planned to be published in print form shortly before the USSR's collapse, but then plans changed and it was decided to publish this book in virtual form in or around 1998 instead:

    https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/1992/02/16/ivans-real-face/ab48e7f4-d614-44ab-ba5d-0f90e7cdca13/

    What do you think? Is this book spot-on in its comparisons?

    , @AnonfromTN
    @AP


    You have checked about killings in Russia?
     
    Hey, you are getting off script dangerously. Ukraine is a democracy (without elections, freedoms of speech and religion, etc.), whereas Russia (with presidential, parliamentary, and local elections held on schedule, freedoms of speech and religion, etc.) is a dictatorship. Comparing “free and democratic” Ukraine with it is politically incorrect.
  42. @Yahya
    @Mr. XYZ

    I’ve only watched one silent film last year - The Phantom Carriage.

    Beautiful imagery and a compelling concept.

    Too sentimental for my taste though.

    I gave it an 8/10.

    I plan to watch a couple of Fritz Lang films this year.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    What about the silent films that you watched before that, in the more distant past?

  43. Good news for a change.

    Despite the best efforts of clown and his gang, some Ukrainian men of draft age have a chance to remain alive: Germany and Poland decided not to supply Kiev regime with cannon fodder, refused to extradite draft age Ukrainian men to their unfortunate country of citizenship.

  44. @AP
    @AnonfromTN

    Hmm….

    You have checked about killings in Russia?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AnonfromTN

    Yes, as I said, killings of this type are unfortunately and tragically a common trend in the East Slavic world in the years and decades after the USSR’s collapse due to the Sovok mentality severely corrupting these lands even after the USSR was gone.

    AP, off-topic, but what do you think about this online book* that compares the various regions of the US and the ex-USSR?

    https://digitalcommons.spu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1001&context=works

    *It was apparently planned to be published in print form shortly before the USSR’s collapse, but then plans changed and it was decided to publish this book in virtual form in or around 1998 instead:

    https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/1992/02/16/ivans-real-face/ab48e7f4-d614-44ab-ba5d-0f90e7cdca13/

    What do you think? Is this book spot-on in its comparisons?

  45. @AP
    @AnonfromTN

    Hmm….

    You have checked about killings in Russia?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AnonfromTN

    You have checked about killings in Russia?

    Hey, you are getting off script dangerously. Ukraine is a democracy (without elections, freedoms of speech and religion, etc.), whereas Russia (with presidential, parliamentary, and local elections held on schedule, freedoms of speech and religion, etc.) is a dictatorship. Comparing “free and democratic” Ukraine with it is politically incorrect.

    • LOL: Mr. XYZ
  46. @Mr. XYZ
    @QCIC

    War was always disgusting and sad, no? This current war is the 21st century smaller-scale East Slavic equivalent of WWI a century ago, no?

    Replies: @QCIC

    War is usually disgusting and sad, but I don’t know about always. I can’t compare the SMO to earlier wars.

    Compared to 1915, people on average live longer now and generally have more “creature comforts”. I wonder if we value life more, less or the same as people during WW1?

  47. @Yahya
    @Mr. Hack


    Although its been a few years since I last viewed Mulholland Dr, I remember enjoying it and see that it nearly fell off of your list?…
     
    Mulholland Dr is an interesting and original film. Problem is, I’ve watched too many excellent films this year. As mentioned, I struggled mightily to winnow down this list; lots of otherwise good films like 2001: Space Odyssey, Fight Club, Charade, Pathar Panchali etc. had to be excluded from my list.

    In any case, welcome back!
     
    Thanks, but my stay here will be short-lived. I realized that passing time in an online forum with 50-60+ year olds is not ideal for someone my age. Although I’ve certainly enjoyed and benefited from interacting with many high-caliber individuals on this forum; I decided to focus more on cultivating my physical strength and social skills over the previous months, since I had neglected those in favor of intellectual activities from a young age. The aim is to attain comprehensiveness in character and balance out my overly-intellectual natural side.

    No need to despair though, Mr. Hack, because I will stop by here every once in a while. Best of luck.

    @Emil Nikola

    Great Expectations is indeed a great movie. I probably should’ve bumped it up the list a few spots. Haven’t read the novel yet.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Sher Singh, @Talha

    Haven’t read the novel yet.

    Your #1 choice, “The Godfather” is a good choice. The novel, written by Mario Puzo, is a masterful work of art too. The book and the film bearing its name are both very good examples of their respective art forms, but very different one from the other. Seeing that you enjoyed the films so much, I think that you’ll enjoy reading the book that started it all. I don’ think that the third film was nearly as bad as the critics made it out to be…but certainly the first two installments were better.

    • Replies: @Gerard1234
    @Mr. Hack


    I don’ think that the third film was nearly as bad as the critics made it out to be…but certainly the first two installments were better.
     
    First film, and the book it was made from are certainly wonderful.............the second film is not as good - he's permanantly in PMS mode ( and his entire family), absolutely zero humour in the film compared to the plentiful amount in the first film. Most importantly there is non-stop memorable moments/scenes in the first Godfather, compared to the second film.

    I have issue with the plot in the 2nd, compared to the perfect one in the 1st. The young Godfather is like they are making a film about Jesus or Moses. I suppose in the first film he is not shown as an evil person either, but in the 2nd it is way OTT. I think the story is diminished by making well-known events at the time (revolution and overthrow of Batista in Cuba, Senate or Congress Mafia inquiry) directly linked to the plot and scenes of the film, instead of a tangential connection.

    I could be getting it confused with another film, but I did not understand why the guy who was supposed to testify in US Congress about the Godfather, but didn't because he arrived with his brother from Sicily .... later kills himself in custody after a pleasant conversation with the Robert Duvall character. Also to me it appears that either his brother is a dumbass or a conspirator.....he should not be both!

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  48. @Yahya
    @Mr. Hack


    Although its been a few years since I last viewed Mulholland Dr, I remember enjoying it and see that it nearly fell off of your list?…
     
    Mulholland Dr is an interesting and original film. Problem is, I’ve watched too many excellent films this year. As mentioned, I struggled mightily to winnow down this list; lots of otherwise good films like 2001: Space Odyssey, Fight Club, Charade, Pathar Panchali etc. had to be excluded from my list.

    In any case, welcome back!
     
    Thanks, but my stay here will be short-lived. I realized that passing time in an online forum with 50-60+ year olds is not ideal for someone my age. Although I’ve certainly enjoyed and benefited from interacting with many high-caliber individuals on this forum; I decided to focus more on cultivating my physical strength and social skills over the previous months, since I had neglected those in favor of intellectual activities from a young age. The aim is to attain comprehensiveness in character and balance out my overly-intellectual natural side.

    No need to despair though, Mr. Hack, because I will stop by here every once in a while. Best of luck.

    @Emil Nikola

    Great Expectations is indeed a great movie. I probably should’ve bumped it up the list a few spots. Haven’t read the novel yet.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Sher Singh, @Talha

    Alphaprogression App
    Reverse Grip Bench

    • Replies: @Yahya
    @Sher Singh


    Alphaprogression App

     

    I'm using the "Gym Workout Planner & Trainer" app. Works well for me.

    Reverse Grip Bench
     
    Looks interesting.

    How many sets do you perform per muscle group each week?

    Replies: @Sher Singh

  49. AP, you say that the Central Powers were the good guys in WWI, but wouldn’t sending over the Bolshevik bacillus to Russia and slaughtering the Ottoman Empire’s Christians en masse (which Germany could have probably stopped or at least reduced in scope and brutality, similar to how German General Erich von Falkenhayn was successfully able to get the Ottoman Empire to cancel its planned deportations of Palestine’s Jews in 1917-1918 in real life) more than compensate for any harm that Russia did by going to war for Serbia in 1914 and thus turning a local war into a general European war? After all, WWI, while extraordinarily bloody and extremely brutal, would not have been anywhere near as much of a disaster for humanity had Russia not went Bolshevik as a result of it and had Germany not subsequently went Nazi (or at least had a non-Bolshevik Russia allied with the West to quickly destroy Nazism within Germany before it did too much damage).

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. XYZ

    The one thing that I will say, though, is that if one would have wanted to create an EU in Europe without a Second World War, having the CPs win WWI would probably be a better way of going about doing this. In real life, after the Entente/Allied victory in WWI, interwar Europe was filled with way too much distrust to make anything like the EU viable until after another World War tragically occurred.

    , @AP
    @Mr. XYZ


    AP, you say that the Central Powers were the good guys in WWI, but wouldn’t sending over the Bolshevik bacillus to Russia
     
    The sent them there to disrupt things in the enemy country but the Russians themselves succumbed to them: the Central Powers certainly didn’t impose that evil government upon the Russians.

    But they did keep the Bolsheviks out of Ukraine and Belarus.

    and slaughtering the Ottoman Empire’s Christians en masse

     

    That was evil. The Ottoman Empire was the villainous ally to Germany and Austria-Hungary. As Stalin was, to the USA/UK.

    Still, on balance, Ottoman crimes were less evil than the total horrors of World War I.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ

  50. @Mr. XYZ
    @AnonfromTN

    Let's see what investigations in regards to this will say. But Yeah, in the East Slavic lands, unfortunately journalist and politician killings, shootings, and poisonings have not exactly been rare in the post-Soviet era. It really is a huge tragedy and shows just how much Communism and its legacy severely fucked over these countries. I'm not even sure if Central Asia has this problem on quite as large of a scale, even after adjusting for total population size.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. Hack, @Derer

    In the USA the fighting near the top of the food chain at the intersection of government officials and criminals may be mostly blackmail. There are occasional murders though the press is very selective on the reporting.

    Just think of the coercion that is happening on a continuous basis to allow the massive influx of illegals into the US borders? This process is obviously bad for the citizens of the USA, is criminal, immoral and clearly treasonous. Yet there is only slight visible pushback. I wonder if a combination of violence, extortion and bribery against police, prosecutors and judges is central to this entire process? Same thing for the more despicable human trafficking. Ditto for the massive influx of highly addictive drugs. Presumably a lot of responsible people know the central facts of what is going on (how could they not?) but nothing happens.

    Cui bono?

  51. @Mr. XYZ
    AP, you say that the Central Powers were the good guys in WWI, but wouldn't sending over the Bolshevik bacillus to Russia and slaughtering the Ottoman Empire's Christians en masse (which Germany could have probably stopped or at least reduced in scope and brutality, similar to how German General Erich von Falkenhayn was successfully able to get the Ottoman Empire to cancel its planned deportations of Palestine's Jews in 1917-1918 in real life) more than compensate for any harm that Russia did by going to war for Serbia in 1914 and thus turning a local war into a general European war? After all, WWI, while extraordinarily bloody and extremely brutal, would not have been anywhere near as much of a disaster for humanity had Russia not went Bolshevik as a result of it and had Germany not subsequently went Nazi (or at least had a non-Bolshevik Russia allied with the West to quickly destroy Nazism within Germany before it did too much damage).

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    The one thing that I will say, though, is that if one would have wanted to create an EU in Europe without a Second World War, having the CPs win WWI would probably be a better way of going about doing this. In real life, after the Entente/Allied victory in WWI, interwar Europe was filled with way too much distrust to make anything like the EU viable until after another World War tragically occurred.

  52. 😆 Some headlines are better than others: (1) 😀

    GOP Field Thins as Chris Christie Drops Out Ahead of Iowa Caucuses

    Of course there is always the master: (2)

    Chris Christie Suspends Campaign To Spend More Time With Family-Sized 12-Piece Chicken Meal From KFC
    ___

    The beloved former governor and folk hero then got into his large SUV with his family-sized 12-piece chicken meal from KFC and closed the tinted windows for privacy.

    At publishing time, Christie had also been seen spending quality time with his family-sized box of Oreos from Costco.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.breitbart.com/2024-election/2024/01/10/gop-field-thins-as-chris-christie-drops-out-ahead-of-iowa-caucuses/

    (2) https://babylonbee.com/news/chris-christie-suspends-campaign-to-spend-more-time-with-family-sized-12-piece-chicken-meal-from-kfc

    • Replies: @songbird
    @A123

    I feel like Chris Christie fat jokes had a narrow window of being funny, when he was still governor and a more serious presidential contender. (I think it required executor power) But, right now, they are akin to Mike Pence jokes.

    Currently, IMO, the best Republican primary jokes involve caste antagonism between Vivek and Haley.

    Meanwhile, the best celebrity fat jokes I imagine still invoke Lizzo. But to be sure, I'm not really up on the latest pop culture, to be certain about it.

    , @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    Ansar Allah are sanctioning vessels that have nothing to do with Israel.

     

    You're technically correct, they are actually sanctioning the Zionist Entity.

    How long will Xi support Ansar Allah interrupting Zionist Entity commerce?
     

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F7-tHFvbQAAvG9M.jpg


    😇

    Replies: @A123

  53. Is alpha-gal syndrome some sort of bioweapon designed by radical vegans?

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alpha-gal_syndrome

  54. @A123
    😆 Some headlines are better than others: (1) 😀

    GOP Field Thins as Chris Christie Drops Out Ahead of Iowa Caucuses
     
    Of course there is always the master: (2)

    Chris Christie Suspends Campaign To Spend More Time With Family-Sized 12-Piece Chicken Meal From KFC
    ___

    The beloved former governor and folk hero then got into his large SUV with his family-sized 12-piece chicken meal from KFC and closed the tinted windows for privacy.

    At publishing time, Christie had also been seen spending quality time with his family-sized box of Oreos from Costco.
     
    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.breitbart.com/2024-election/2024/01/10/gop-field-thins-as-chris-christie-drops-out-ahead-of-iowa-caucuses/

    (2) https://babylonbee.com/news/chris-christie-suspends-campaign-to-spend-more-time-with-family-sized-12-piece-chicken-meal-from-kfc

    Replies: @songbird, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    I feel like Chris Christie fat jokes had a narrow window of being funny, when he was still governor and a more serious presidential contender. (I think it required executor power) But, right now, they are akin to Mike Pence jokes.

    Currently, IMO, the best Republican primary jokes involve caste antagonism between Vivek and Haley.

    Meanwhile, the best celebrity fat jokes I imagine still invoke Lizzo. But to be sure, I’m not really up on the latest pop culture, to be certain about it.

  55. @Yahya
    Gentlemen,

    I know that many of you despaired these past few months from the absence of Yahya's world famous film reviews. So I returned to this sacred forum to provide you with my unusually interesting and perspicuous takes on the films I watched this previous year. Overall, it has been a fruitful year for me cinematically, with a total of 141 films watched. I found it difficult to narrow down my selections to just the top 10 or 20; such was the large number of high-quality films I viewed in 2023. The key to maximizing quality films watched is to quit early when a film displays Goddard-tier dullness and pretentiousness. The Leopard will not change its spots. Just cut your losses and move on.

    1. The Godfather I (1972 - Coppola - American)
    2. The Godfather II (1974 - Coppola - American)
    3. Socrates (1971 - Rossellini - Italian)
    4. The Grand Illusion (1937 - Renoir - French)
    5. Batman Begins (2005 - Nolan - American)
    6. Gone With The Wind (1939 - Fleming - American)
    7. Wild Strawberries (1957 - Bergman - Swedish)
    8. North By Northwest (1959 - Hitchcock - American)
    9. Training Day (2001 - Fuqua - American)
    10. Great Expectations (1946 - Lean - British)
    11. Jane Eyre (1943 - Stevenson - British)
    12. Burnt By The Sun (1994 - Mikhalkov - Russian)
    13. Woman In The Dunes (1964 - Teshigahara - Japanese)
    14. Europe ‘51 (1952 - Rossellini - Italian)
    15. Annie Hall (1977 - Allen - American)
    16. Belle De Jour (1967 - Bunuel - French)
    17. The Searchers (1956 - Ford - American)
    18. The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962 - Ford - American)
    19. Mulholland Drive (2001 - Lynch - American)
    20. The Gentlemen (2019 - Ritchie - British)

    Honorable Mentions
    1. The Equalizer (2014 - Fuqua - American)
    2. Kind Hearts & Coronets (1946 - Hamer - British)
    3. Winter Sleep (2014 - Ceylan - Turkish)
    4. Taxi Driver (1976 - Scorsese - American)
    5. Hamlet (1948 - Olivier - British)

    My ranking of national cinemas remains unchanged from my last post, though I realized that my high opinion of Anglo-American cinema may be biased by the ease of watching English-language movies. Especially towards the second half of the year, I couldn't be bothered with subtitles and strange cinematographic techniques, so my viewings were heavily tilted towards Anglo-American films. But that is a fault I aim to rectify in 2024.

    I've already written about some of these films in my posts throughout the year; so I'll stick to new selections here.

    The Grand Illusion centers around a group of French POWs held in captivity by the Germans; the most alluring of whom is the confident, self-assured Captain de Boeldieu, a French aristocratic officer whose untroubled bearing, upright posture, neat styling, and sardonic demeanor give him a Gaulle-esque aroma I found captivating. Renoir utilizes the setting of the film to comment upon class dynamics: "When I’m with Boeldieu, I never feel completely at ease. Call it the education barrier.” “He’s a fine type.” “Agreed, and he’s very decent. Suppose you and I went broke, we’d both be turned into beggars. If it happened to him, he’d still be Monsieur De Boeldieu.” Though I later found out Renoir is of the Socialistic bent, the film does not exude class hostility, but takes on a tolerant and matter-of-fact observational style as it relates to class and warfare. The film is also refreshing in its male-orientation; there is no romantic sub-plot to please female viewers (“Sentiment has no place in war” as de Boeldieu remarks); and it was a pleasure to view depictions of Old Europe such as the scene in the Gothic Cathedral at minute 50.

    Training Day explores the necessity of harshness, cruelty and rule-breaking in the fight against hard crime; in other words it touches upon the Jungian concept of Integrating The Shadow. "To protect the sheep you gotta catch the wolf, and it takes a wolf to catch a wolf." Washington's character represents the Wolf, he is willing to bend the rules and inflict cruelty on suspects to expedite the process of discovering and apprehending criminals. Denzel’s character is charismatic, bombastic, psychopathic, relentless, decisive. He asserts his will over subordinates by using his position of power and establishes his dominance fairly quickly over Hawke by use of verbal adeptness and charisma. Hawkes' character is initially naïve, rule-following, and considerate of others. Denzel takes advantage of him by deceiving him into the hands of the cartel, but Hawke survives by sheer chance of having rescued a cartel member's cousin earlier in the day. The script is stale when read on paper, but is brought to life by Washington's eloquence and force of personality. One the greatest performances I've seen on screen, and an overall worthy production by an African-American lead actor and director.

    Batman Begins is one of the few mass-market productions I found to be worthy and enjoyable, although it comes with attendant flaws such as two-dimensional characters, a predictable plotline, and a simple script. Nevertheless, it is possible for a blockbuster film to be of high artistic value despite the typical shortcomings; and one must not forget that stalwart classics such as The Godfather and North by Northwest were mass-market productions in their own time. Bruce Wayne presents an archetype of the masculine ideal; eliciting universal respect from all ranges of viewers, as his character and behavior tap into the collective unconscious. Batman's defining features are a) his strength, both mental and physical, which enable him to inflict damage on enemies and protect friends; b) handsome appearance in the traditional masculine sense, which though superficial, is critical to his status as a high-value male (he would not elicit respect had he been ugly and obese); c) an unbending sense of justice; and d) socio-economic status as one of the wealthiest individuals in Gotham.

    Batman is also a Dionysian figure, preferring action over knowledge-seeking. We do not see him sitting on a reclining chair, submerged in a book; but cultivating himself physically through intensive training. He mostly relies on intuition rather than logical reasoning to guide his actions. This was best evidenced in his confrontation with the Joker in the Dark Knight sequel. "The training is nothing, will is everything. The will to act", again emphasizing action over knowledge/training. Batman also develops a network of trust between himself Fox, Alfred, Rachel, and Commissioner Gordon. While Wayne is the central character in this network, he must rely on Fox for the technology, without which he cannot perform his duties.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @Mr. XYZ, @songbird, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Barbarossa

    Have not read it, but thought it was interesting when he talked about the physiological changes some movies cause.

    It crosses my mind to wonder, if there is some kind of biomarker that can be detected during scenes of great pozzedness. Perhaps, some metabolite of estrogen.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @songbird

    Around the year 2016, Scott Adams had a sincere-sounding rant I can paraphrase like the following. He said that when Hillary Clinton gave nationally televised speeches, the testosterone level of the entire country went down.

    Replies: @songbird

  56. @Mikel
    Things we should all finally agree on in this OT (or else we might as well give up and ask Ron to close the blog for good):

    - Who is winning the war, Ukraine or Russia?
    - Is Ukraine a real country or are they just confused Russians who have forgotten their true identity?
    - Why did Western Europeans meekly go along with the neocon plan to encroach Russia?
    - Who really built the nice buildings in Riga?
    - Is Sikhism the only true religion?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    Who really built the nice buildings in Riga?

    Good that this is mentioned.

    Of course Russia is large majority responsible for building Riga. It was comprehensively proven in my post…..then LatW’s sudden probably hospitalisation because of my post (too much of a coincidence LatWakjob decided to break from the blog immediately after my return from a several month absence of here) . Main “counter-argument” from LatWakjob about all the things Russia built in Riga was :

    1.Latvians are Germans
    2.All the Russians who built the city were “Germans”
    3. Soviets are Latvians

    My next target could be the Black Russian prick “Sudden Death”. Writing about somewhere as Klaipeda could educate the Black Russian delinquent dickhead.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Gerard1234

    Go for it Geraldina, you're on a roll!

    , @Mikel
    @Gerard1234

    I don't have any strong opinions on the Riga architectural landscape. If all parties involved agree with you that the best parts were built by the Russians, that is something I can perfectly live with.

    However, it is just not true that LatW left because of you. She clearly left in indignation at the epithet that G_R directed at her. Even worse, then G_R proceeded to leave the blog himself, at a time when Dmitry, Bashi, Aaron and others had been absent for a while and Yahya has briefly reappeared to let us know what a waste of his time this geriatric ward had become really. The chances of any worthwhile debate taking place here have become infinitesimal.

    But I can't blame any of them really. We had long ago entered the law of diminishing returns, discussing ad nauseam the same old subjects with the same old arguments (me included). Who doesn't have better uses of their time than that?

    With that said, I think it's been quite a remarkable feat to keep this blog alive for 2 years after his author left (and actually break records of comment numbers on this website). Perhaps as important as the subjects we keep debating are the subjects the regulars of this blog never debate: transhumanism and technological singularities (AK's favorite topics) or the JQ (Unz's obsession). This clearly signals that it was never about AK or Unz. They both just happened to attract a group of disparate people with very different backgrounds and the group then took a life of its own, building very lively threads out of nothing that for one reason or another we all felt compelled to participate in. Though obviously AK and Ron deserve credit for the phenomenon.

    Alas, everything has an end and it looks like these threads are losing the vigor and interest they once had. On to the difficult task of finding other places to debate, vent and engage people of different persuasions without being censored, I guess.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @AP, @Yevardian, @German_reader, @Gerard1234

  57. Lithuanian neopagan empire is creeping into EU heartland as their state company, based in Klaipeda, won the tender and will be commercially managing all newly built LNG import facilities in Germany;)

    KN becomes commercial manager of four German LNG terminals

    International energy terminal operator SC “Klaipėdos nafta“ (SC KN Energies starting 10th January 2024) (KN or the Company) has secured the public tender for the commercial management of four German liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminals on the North Sea coast. The Company has signed the two-year contract with Deutsche Energy Terminal GmbH (DET), the German state-owned company that operates state-controlled LNG terminals.

    On behalf of the German Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Climate Action, the DET operates Germany’s first LNG terminals on the North Sea coast, the Wilhelmshaven 1 LNG Terminal and the Brunsbüttel LNG Terminal. Additionally, DET will operate two upcoming terminals: the second LNG terminal in Wilhelmshaven and the LNG terminal in Stade on the Lower Elbe River.

    https://view.news.eu.nasdaq.com/view?id=b8733daf2321ba110d9999e87f952199f&lang=en

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @sudden death

    Is the neopaganism contagious?

    https://i.natgeofe.com/n/6ca32456-d930-4014-a9cb-a741b7d16a07/02-pagan-tourism_16x9.jpg

    Probably nobody watched the dragon lecture video; what you missed is the one who sort of looked like she would be pretty hot if you had 4 drinks and asked the question about menstruating dragons is married to the guy sitting next to her who is the most elite Satanist in Britain currently. Alkistis Dimech, Peter Grey. They own the publishing company who the speaker writes for.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @songbird

    , @Gerard1234
    @sudden death

    Peremoga! What is that, paying 40% more for gas + billions in infrastructure investment.........for "security" of about 25% of the original volume of gas received from Russia ( with some of that LNG coming from Russia anyway)! You couldn't invent this level of retardation.

    Black Russian retards have effectively killed Klaipeda dead as a port , by stopping receiving and delivering cargo to and from Belarus and Russia you imbecile. It appears to me more a pitiful sympathy gesture from the Germans - like offering 404 an EU "path to membership"

    Possibly it is part of the eternal rivalry between the Black Russian and Malo-Russian brothers!.....using the appearance of the opposite - stop Malo-Russia as a transit for gas to western Europe, and seize a small percentage of that amount delivered via BlackRussia-stan.

    Replies: @sudden death

  58. @sudden death
    Lithuanian neopagan empire is creeping into EU heartland as their state company, based in Klaipeda, won the tender and will be commercially managing all newly built LNG import facilities in Germany;)

    KN becomes commercial manager of four German LNG terminals

    International energy terminal operator SC “Klaipėdos nafta“ (SC KN Energies starting 10th January 2024) (KN or the Company) has secured the public tender for the commercial management of four German liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminals on the North Sea coast. The Company has signed the two-year contract with Deutsche Energy Terminal GmbH (DET), the German state-owned company that operates state-controlled LNG terminals.

    On behalf of the German Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Climate Action, the DET operates Germany's first LNG terminals on the North Sea coast, the Wilhelmshaven 1 LNG Terminal and the Brunsbüttel LNG Terminal. Additionally, DET will operate two upcoming terminals: the second LNG terminal in Wilhelmshaven and the LNG terminal in Stade on the Lower Elbe River.
     

    https://view.news.eu.nasdaq.com/view?id=b8733daf2321ba110d9999e87f952199f&lang=en

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Gerard1234

    Is the neopaganism contagious?

    Probably nobody watched the dragon lecture video; what you missed is the one who sort of looked like she would be pretty hot if you had 4 drinks and asked the question about menstruating dragons is married to the guy sitting next to her who is the most elite Satanist in Britain currently. Alkistis Dimech, Peter Grey. They own the publishing company who the speaker writes for.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    I'd say that if at least 4 drinks per day goes along with membership go for it, what's holding up your admission? :-)

    , @songbird
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    about menstruating dragons
     
    Sounds like that would make an epic Tampax commercial.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  59. @Mr. XYZ
    @AnonfromTN

    Let's see what investigations in regards to this will say. But Yeah, in the East Slavic lands, unfortunately journalist and politician killings, shootings, and poisonings have not exactly been rare in the post-Soviet era. It really is a huge tragedy and shows just how much Communism and its legacy severely fucked over these countries. I'm not even sure if Central Asia has this problem on quite as large of a scale, even after adjusting for total population size.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. Hack, @Derer

    Professor Stooge is well aware of just how corrupt Russia really is, but still chooses to selectively use super thick blinders when discussing this topic. Why else does he choose to live in the US and not in Russia? Also, living in even podunk Tennessee on a fully tenured professor’s salary beats anything that he’d be able to afford in Moscow. Yet he manages to retain this strong nostalgia for this country that he left behind decades ago.

  60. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @sudden death

    Is the neopaganism contagious?

    https://i.natgeofe.com/n/6ca32456-d930-4014-a9cb-a741b7d16a07/02-pagan-tourism_16x9.jpg

    Probably nobody watched the dragon lecture video; what you missed is the one who sort of looked like she would be pretty hot if you had 4 drinks and asked the question about menstruating dragons is married to the guy sitting next to her who is the most elite Satanist in Britain currently. Alkistis Dimech, Peter Grey. They own the publishing company who the speaker writes for.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @songbird

    I’d say that if at least 4 drinks per day goes along with membership go for it, what’s holding up your admission? 🙂

  61. @Gerard1234
    @Mikel


    Who really built the nice buildings in Riga?
     
    Good that this is mentioned.

    Of course Russia is large majority responsible for building Riga. It was comprehensively proven in my post.....then LatW's sudden probably hospitalisation because of my post (too much of a coincidence LatWakjob decided to break from the blog immediately after my return from a several month absence of here) . Main "counter-argument" from LatWakjob about all the things Russia built in Riga was :

    1.Latvians are Germans
    2.All the Russians who built the city were "Germans"
    3. Soviets are Latvians

    My next target could be the Black Russian prick "Sudden Death". Writing about somewhere as Klaipeda could educate the Black Russian delinquent dickhead.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Mikel

    Go for it Geraldina, you’re on a roll!

  62. @Sher Singh
    @Yahya

    Alphaprogression App
    Reverse Grip Bench

    Replies: @Yahya

    Alphaprogression App

    I’m using the “Gym Workout Planner & Trainer” app. Works well for me.

    Reverse Grip Bench

    Looks interesting.

    How many sets do you perform per muscle group each week?

    • Replies: @Sher Singh
    @Yahya


    https://imgur.com/a/A9TCCaY

    Long as the app has progress recommendations it's good.
    Alpha is good cuz let's say I did 150x10 for RIR 2 on Week 1.

    Week 3 I want to sets of 6 it'll keep in the same RIR & might have me do 175x6.
    Tracking 10RM is IMO superior for bodybuilding.

    --
    Keep in mind I was doing close to 40 sets a session a few months back.
    This is just my current way to balance 6x a week with fatigue/life.

    Alpha means I can make consistent progress without guesswork.
    When it stalls, I'll add/subtract volume or w/e.
    --

    What's your favorite bicep exercises?
    Not really feeling barbell or DB curls & don't have a low pulley or incline bench.

    :/

    Replies: @Sher Singh, @Yahya

  63. About 99% sure that YouTube is trying to get revenge on me for using adblocker, by recommending videos featuring bears “with tapeworms.”

  64. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @sudden death

    Is the neopaganism contagious?

    https://i.natgeofe.com/n/6ca32456-d930-4014-a9cb-a741b7d16a07/02-pagan-tourism_16x9.jpg

    Probably nobody watched the dragon lecture video; what you missed is the one who sort of looked like she would be pretty hot if you had 4 drinks and asked the question about menstruating dragons is married to the guy sitting next to her who is the most elite Satanist in Britain currently. Alkistis Dimech, Peter Grey. They own the publishing company who the speaker writes for.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @songbird

    about menstruating dragons

    Sounds like that would make an epic Tampax commercial.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    I couldn't hear exactly what she said. The word menstruate and the word dragon were both in there. Dragons don't exist but if they did they would be reptiles. Right?

  65. @songbird
    @Yahya

    Have not read it, but thought it was interesting when he talked about the physiological changes some movies cause.

    https://www.amazon.com/You-Are-What-Watch-Everything/dp/1523515899

    It crosses my mind to wonder, if there is some kind of biomarker that can be detected during scenes of great pozzedness. Perhaps, some metabolite of estrogen.

    Replies: @QCIC

    Around the year 2016, Scott Adams had a sincere-sounding rant I can paraphrase like the following. He said that when Hillary Clinton gave nationally televised speeches, the testosterone level of the entire country went down.

    • Replies: @songbird
    @QCIC

    Supposedly, you can hook a really good mass spectrometer to a theater somehow, and you'll get these different spikes of volatile organic compounds, that seem to reoccur at different showings. Different VOCs spiking with different scenes.

    Carbon dioxide, isoprene at tense moments. Some scenes, the chemical combinations are like fingerprints, with which the scene can be identified just from the reading, without a timestamp. But they can't explain it fully.

    You need a big crowd. Doesn't work when it's poorly attended.

    And there are changes in the blood too. The blood gets ready to clot, while watching a horror movie.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Emil Nikola Richard

  66. @Mr. Hack
    @Yahya


    Haven’t read the novel yet.
     
    Your #1 choice, "The Godfather" is a good choice. The novel, written by Mario Puzo, is a masterful work of art too. The book and the film bearing its name are both very good examples of their respective art forms, but very different one from the other. Seeing that you enjoyed the films so much, I think that you'll enjoy reading the book that started it all. I don' think that the third film was nearly as bad as the critics made it out to be...but certainly the first two installments were better.

    Replies: @Gerard1234

    I don’ think that the third film was nearly as bad as the critics made it out to be…but certainly the first two installments were better.

    First film, and the book it was made from are certainly wonderful………….the second film is not as good – he’s permanantly in PMS mode ( and his entire family), absolutely zero humour in the film compared to the plentiful amount in the first film. Most importantly there is non-stop memorable moments/scenes in the first Godfather, compared to the second film.

    I have issue with the plot in the 2nd, compared to the perfect one in the 1st. The young Godfather is like they are making a film about Jesus or Moses. I suppose in the first film he is not shown as an evil person either, but in the 2nd it is way OTT. I think the story is diminished by making well-known events at the time (revolution and overthrow of Batista in Cuba, Senate or Congress Mafia inquiry) directly linked to the plot and scenes of the film, instead of a tangential connection.

    I could be getting it confused with another film, but I did not understand why the guy who was supposed to testify in US Congress about the Godfather, but didn’t because he arrived with his brother from Sicily …. later kills himself in custody after a pleasant conversation with the Robert Duvall character. Also to me it appears that either his brother is a dumbass or a conspirator…..he should not be both!

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Gerard1234

    I think that the Sicilian relative who kills himself rather than rat out the Godfather is a testament to the mafia's levels of loyalty. I remember him discussing things with DuVall in that film while in prison, harking back to Roman times and how Roman senators often bled themselves out rather than betray the emperor, or something like that. The mafia members used to take their oaths of loyalty quite seriously, not like today.

  67. @Gerard1234
    @Mr. Hack


    I don’ think that the third film was nearly as bad as the critics made it out to be…but certainly the first two installments were better.
     
    First film, and the book it was made from are certainly wonderful.............the second film is not as good - he's permanantly in PMS mode ( and his entire family), absolutely zero humour in the film compared to the plentiful amount in the first film. Most importantly there is non-stop memorable moments/scenes in the first Godfather, compared to the second film.

    I have issue with the plot in the 2nd, compared to the perfect one in the 1st. The young Godfather is like they are making a film about Jesus or Moses. I suppose in the first film he is not shown as an evil person either, but in the 2nd it is way OTT. I think the story is diminished by making well-known events at the time (revolution and overthrow of Batista in Cuba, Senate or Congress Mafia inquiry) directly linked to the plot and scenes of the film, instead of a tangential connection.

    I could be getting it confused with another film, but I did not understand why the guy who was supposed to testify in US Congress about the Godfather, but didn't because he arrived with his brother from Sicily .... later kills himself in custody after a pleasant conversation with the Robert Duvall character. Also to me it appears that either his brother is a dumbass or a conspirator.....he should not be both!

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    I think that the Sicilian relative who kills himself rather than rat out the Godfather is a testament to the mafia’s levels of loyalty. I remember him discussing things with DuVall in that film while in prison, harking back to Roman times and how Roman senators often bled themselves out rather than betray the emperor, or something like that. The mafia members used to take their oaths of loyalty quite seriously, not like today.

    • Thanks: Gerard1234
  68. @sudden death
    Lithuanian neopagan empire is creeping into EU heartland as their state company, based in Klaipeda, won the tender and will be commercially managing all newly built LNG import facilities in Germany;)

    KN becomes commercial manager of four German LNG terminals

    International energy terminal operator SC “Klaipėdos nafta“ (SC KN Energies starting 10th January 2024) (KN or the Company) has secured the public tender for the commercial management of four German liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminals on the North Sea coast. The Company has signed the two-year contract with Deutsche Energy Terminal GmbH (DET), the German state-owned company that operates state-controlled LNG terminals.

    On behalf of the German Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Climate Action, the DET operates Germany's first LNG terminals on the North Sea coast, the Wilhelmshaven 1 LNG Terminal and the Brunsbüttel LNG Terminal. Additionally, DET will operate two upcoming terminals: the second LNG terminal in Wilhelmshaven and the LNG terminal in Stade on the Lower Elbe River.
     

    https://view.news.eu.nasdaq.com/view?id=b8733daf2321ba110d9999e87f952199f&lang=en

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Gerard1234

    Peremoga! What is that, paying 40% more for gas + billions in infrastructure investment………for “security” of about 25% of the original volume of gas received from Russia ( with some of that LNG coming from Russia anyway)! You couldn’t invent this level of retardation.

    Black Russian retards have effectively killed Klaipeda dead as a port , by stopping receiving and delivering cargo to and from Belarus and Russia you imbecile. It appears to me more a pitiful sympathy gesture from the Germans – like offering 404 an EU “path to membership”

    Possibly it is part of the eternal rivalry between the Black Russian and Malo-Russian brothers!…..using the appearance of the opposite – stop Malo-Russia as a transit for gas to western Europe, and seize a small percentage of that amount delivered via BlackRussia-stan.

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @Gerard1234

    Before starting building own LNG import facility (state company "Klaipėdos nafta" was builder and operator for ten years since 2014), Lithuania was paying 550$ for 1000m3 of pipeline Gazprom natgas in 2010. Last year the average LNG spot price was hovering roughly around 350EUR, so accounting for inflation since, Lithuania is getting almost twice cheaper natgas now;)

    Regarding Germany, the average Gazprom natgas price in whole decade prior Covid was roughly around 330$ for 1000m3 IIRC. At the start of last summer there was publicised offer from US LNG industry representatives about being capable to supply longer term LNG deals for 380$ for 1000m3 for EU customers. So that was the starting negotiating point and even generously (for RF fans) assuming the price didn't change at all when big deals were made after negotiations at the end of summer (e.g. BASF long term deal for US LNG), it was also roughly nearly the same price as Gazprom supplied natgas in previous decade for Germany, when accounting for inflation since.

    All “cargo to and from Belarus and Russia” essentially equaled one thing in Klaipeda – potash fertilizers from Belarus, just in relatively large quantities, roughly fluctuating about 10-12 million tonnes a year – 25% of all yearly load in Klaipeda. There was just one single port company (154 workers overall at the peak), partially owned by “Belaruskalij”, which was doing that job of loading fertilizers on the ships. Today this company has 45 workers, so it was grand total loss of 109 jobs in all port since 2022.

  69. @songbird
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    about menstruating dragons
     
    Sounds like that would make an epic Tampax commercial.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    I couldn’t hear exactly what she said. The word menstruate and the word dragon were both in there. Dragons don’t exist but if they did they would be reptiles. Right?

    • Agree: songbird
  70. @Gerard1234
    @Mikel


    Who really built the nice buildings in Riga?
     
    Good that this is mentioned.

    Of course Russia is large majority responsible for building Riga. It was comprehensively proven in my post.....then LatW's sudden probably hospitalisation because of my post (too much of a coincidence LatWakjob decided to break from the blog immediately after my return from a several month absence of here) . Main "counter-argument" from LatWakjob about all the things Russia built in Riga was :

    1.Latvians are Germans
    2.All the Russians who built the city were "Germans"
    3. Soviets are Latvians

    My next target could be the Black Russian prick "Sudden Death". Writing about somewhere as Klaipeda could educate the Black Russian delinquent dickhead.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Mikel

    I don’t have any strong opinions on the Riga architectural landscape. If all parties involved agree with you that the best parts were built by the Russians, that is something I can perfectly live with.

    However, it is just not true that LatW left because of you. She clearly left in indignation at the epithet that G_R directed at her. Even worse, then G_R proceeded to leave the blog himself, at a time when Dmitry, Bashi, Aaron and others had been absent for a while and Yahya has briefly reappeared to let us know what a waste of his time this geriatric ward had become really. The chances of any worthwhile debate taking place here have become infinitesimal.

    But I can’t blame any of them really. We had long ago entered the law of diminishing returns, discussing ad nauseam the same old subjects with the same old arguments (me included). Who doesn’t have better uses of their time than that?

    With that said, I think it’s been quite a remarkable feat to keep this blog alive for 2 years after his author left (and actually break records of comment numbers on this website). Perhaps as important as the subjects we keep debating are the subjects the regulars of this blog never debate: transhumanism and technological singularities (AK’s favorite topics) or the JQ (Unz’s obsession). This clearly signals that it was never about AK or Unz. They both just happened to attract a group of disparate people with very different backgrounds and the group then took a life of its own, building very lively threads out of nothing that for one reason or another we all felt compelled to participate in. Though obviously AK and Ron deserve credit for the phenomenon.

    Alas, everything has an end and it looks like these threads are losing the vigor and interest they once had. On to the difficult task of finding other places to debate, vent and engage people of different persuasions without being censored, I guess.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mikel

    This is only remotely tangentially related, but in Zechariah Sitchin's Twelfth Planet he has Utu not as a Sumerian god, but as manager of the Sumerian space port. Sitchin taught himself to read Sumerian and as far as I know nobody with a real Sumerian language degree agrees with his interpretations.

    , @Beckow
    @Mikel

    Sure, we lost some of the vigor and the name-calling is worse (kind of fun, sometimes)...but don't you want to see the ending?

    It looks likely that the story will finally get resolved this year. As that approaches the tension rises and we are forced to revisit many of the axiomatic assumptions we base our arguments on. Don't miss the finale, there is a lot of potential...

    Replies: @A123, @AnonfromTN

    , @AP
    @Mikel


    On to the difficult task of finding other places to debate, vent and engage people of different persuasions without being censored
     
    If you find such a place, let us know.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Mikel

    , @Yevardian
    @Mikel

    Unfortunately, twitter seems the best of bad options for the moment.
    I much prefer the site-design here that incentivises long comments and discourages posting excessive pictures, catchphrases, "memes" and the like, but in the end that site has pure numbers so there's at least a couple of interesting users, you just have to mute a lot of people.


    transhumanism and technological singularities (AK’s favorite topics) or the JQ (Unz’s obsession).
     
    Funny you mention that, the complete lack of interest in those two topics on this forum was quite striking to me as well. Unfortunately Our Benevolent Overlord has gone completely overboard and single-minded in his obsession at this point. Interestingly, I know a few people, even including Jews, that substantially agree with the content of his 2018 articles which torpedoed his site, but aren't antisemitic at all. All nations pursue their ethnic interests and often lie in order to achieve their goals, so ultimately my reaction is "ok, so X narrative is mostly a lie, but so what?".
    In the end they're a smart and talented people in a world in which most peoples aren't.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    , @German_reader
    @Mikel

    The problem with any forum really is that familiarity breeds contempt. Over time you start to get into an antagonistic relationship with other users, maybe even into long-running "feuds", mutual grievances accumulate and in the end you don't have anything to say to each other anymore, because the fundamental differences are just too irreconcilable.
    I suppose to some extent it might just be me, but I've encountered such dynamics in every forum I ever participated in (this one here was by no means the worst btw, and I suspect without the war in Ukraine things wouldn't have gotten as ugly as they did). As for Twitter, unlike Yevardian I don't see that as an alternative. I tried it for a few weeks, and found the experience stressful and rather toxic.
    But yes, given the decline in active users, the mutual antagonisms, and the exhausting focus on Ukraine to the exclusion of everything else there doesn't seem to be much life left here anymore (also noteworthy how Hyperborean who popped up after several years of absence already seems to have left again).
    Anyway, who knows, maybe 2024 will see some sort of resolution to the war in Ukraine (or at least freeze the fighting); here's another possible sign:
    https://www.ft.com/content/e0c9a4bb-903a-48d9-b44c-f26b445499b0


    Italy’s defence minister Guido Crosetto has called for greater diplomatic efforts to end the war between Russia and Ukraine, despite Kyiv’s warnings that Moscow has no intention to do so.

    Crosetto told a parliamentary hearing on Wednesday that Italy would seek “a dual-track strategy” with military support for Kyiv to be coupled with more engagements towards a “negotiated settlement”.

    “We must be realistic and cannot ignore the military situation on the field,” Crosetto said as lawmakers approved more bilateral aid to Kyiv. “The time seems to have come for effective diplomatic action.”

     


    Yet in a sober analysis of Ukraine’s military and political strengths, Crosetto, who was previously president of Italy’s defence industry association, expressed concern about “the real Ukrainian ability to counter Russian forces . . . in a condition of persistent numerical and air inferiority”.

    “Unfortunately, Ukraine’s summer counteroffensive did not give the desired results,” he said, warning that 2024 would be a “critical year” for Ukraine’s future.

    He insisted diplomatic efforts would run in tandem with continued military aid for Ukraine — of which Italy is now preparing an eighth package, just as it has assumed the presidency of the G7.

    “We have two paths: that of aid without ‘ifs and buts’ — and that of attempting to build a diplomatic path that brings us to the end of the conflict,” he said. “The coming months will have to balance deterrence and diplomacy.”

    But Crosetto also said talks could only begin if Russia ceased its missile and drone attacks on Ukraine. “We can start talking when the bombs stop falling,” he said. “We have to convince those who are attacking to stop.”

     

    Replies: @Beckow, @Mikel, @Hyperborean

    , @Gerard1234
    @Mikel


    She clearly left in indignation at the epithet that G_R directed at her.
     
    German reader is mild-mannered, certainly compared to myself on here.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  71. @Mr. XYZ
    AP, you say that the Central Powers were the good guys in WWI, but wouldn't sending over the Bolshevik bacillus to Russia and slaughtering the Ottoman Empire's Christians en masse (which Germany could have probably stopped or at least reduced in scope and brutality, similar to how German General Erich von Falkenhayn was successfully able to get the Ottoman Empire to cancel its planned deportations of Palestine's Jews in 1917-1918 in real life) more than compensate for any harm that Russia did by going to war for Serbia in 1914 and thus turning a local war into a general European war? After all, WWI, while extraordinarily bloody and extremely brutal, would not have been anywhere near as much of a disaster for humanity had Russia not went Bolshevik as a result of it and had Germany not subsequently went Nazi (or at least had a non-Bolshevik Russia allied with the West to quickly destroy Nazism within Germany before it did too much damage).

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    AP, you say that the Central Powers were the good guys in WWI, but wouldn’t sending over the Bolshevik bacillus to Russia

    The sent them there to disrupt things in the enemy country but the Russians themselves succumbed to them: the Central Powers certainly didn’t impose that evil government upon the Russians.

    But they did keep the Bolsheviks out of Ukraine and Belarus.

    and slaughtering the Ottoman Empire’s Christians en masse

    That was evil. The Ottoman Empire was the villainous ally to Germany and Austria-Hungary. As Stalin was, to the USA/UK.

    Still, on balance, Ottoman crimes were less evil than the total horrors of World War I.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    The sent them there to disrupt things in the enemy country but the Russians themselves succumbed to them: the Central Powers certainly didn’t impose that evil government upon the Russians.

     

    To be fair, the Russians themselves didn't vote for the Bolsheviks. However, they were unable to resist the Bolsheviks as effectively as was necessary. Similar to the Afghans with the Taliban. Based on the polling that I have seen, the overwhelming majority of Afghans did not want the Taliban (please see here: https://www.unz.com/akarlin/taliban-rule-is-the-democratic-will-of-13-of-afghans/ ), but nevertheless they were also not prepared to resist the Taliban as effectively as was necessary once the US announced that it was going to withdraw from Afghanistan.

    Interestingly enough, for all of the hate that the US's regime change wars get, Russia 1919 was a golden missed opportunity for a regime change war for the US. The other Great Powers were either defeated or too bled dry by WWI even if victorious and thus large-scale military intervention in Russia for them was not a realistic option, but it was easier to do for the US had the political will in favor of this actually been there. Alas, it wasn't. But had this hypothetical regime change war actually occurred, its benefits would have very likely massively outweighed all of the harms of the US's other, later regime change wars in real life. Such an intervention would have even been beneficial for the US with hindsight since it might have subsequently prevented WWII.

    I have read that, in the summer of 1918, before their WWI defeat, the Germans seriously considered overthrowing the Bolsheviks in Russia but ultimately decided (with the Kaiser making this decision) to postpone further discussion of this move until after a German victory in WWI, which never happened.

    It's very painful for me that my own ancestors had to suffer under Bolshevism for many decades. They and the rest of the population in that part of the world deserved so much better. Their only consolation was (or should have been) that Stalin subsequently unleashed the long knives against many of his fellow Bolshevik comrades as well, thus indicating that the Bolshevik coup ultimately wasn't a good thing for the prominent original Bolsheviks themselves either. Better life in the opposition than being brutally purged and murdered by Stalin.


    But they did keep the Bolsheviks out of Ukraine and Belarus.

     

    Only until the end of the war. Once they lost the war, they couldn't even do that. Of course, Poland subsequently tried doing that but was only partly successful. IMHO, the West should have supported Poland to the hilt against the Bolsheviks in order to get as much people out of the Bolshevik clutches as possible. Though ultimately eventually Germany and the USSR might have sought to repartition Poland, as in real life in 1939.

    That was evil. The Ottoman Empire was the villainous ally to Germany and Austria-Hungary. As Stalin was, to the USA/UK.

    Still, on balance, Ottoman crimes were less evil than the total horrors of World War I.
     

    Fair enough, I suppose. Honestly, I don't think that it was worth it for either Austria-Hungary or Russia to go to war over Serbia in 1914, and Russia should have certainly let Austria-Hungary conquer Serbia (perhaps with Russia subsequently sponsoring an anti-Austro-Hungarian insurgency in Serbia) than to militarily intervene on Serbia's behalf and thus spark World War I. Ultimately, a pro-Austro-Hungarian Serbia would have only been a return to the pre-1903 situation, which was quite tolerable for Russia. In any case, had Austria-Hungary done regime change in Serbia back in 1904-1905, when Russia was busy fighting Japan, Russia would likely not have militarily intervened. Thus, had Russia desired it, it could have also avoided militarily intervening in this in 1914 as well. The Russian people ultimately ended up paying the price for this.

    It's quite interesting, because as late as 1916, the Russian people don't appear to have been defeatist, but then defeatism appears to have rapidly set in after the Tsar was ousted:

    https://books.google.com/books?id=W2iCsWC7kgAC&pg=PA131&dq=russia+verge+revolution+1914+general+strike+petrograd&hl=en&newbks=1&newbks_redir=0&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjg0pOL1NODAxWDJkQIHV9iCc0Q6AF6BAgIEAI#v=onepage&q=russia%20verge%20revolution%201914%20general%20strike%20petrograd&f=false

    As a side note, if you could either save Franz Ferdinand in 1914 or kill Vladimir Lenin before 1917, what would you choose? I would choose killing Vladimir Lenin before 1917 because ultimately as extraordinarily tragic as WWI was, it at least had a positive outcome in rearranging the map of Europe on a more ethnic/national self-determination basis (albeit imperfectly) whereas Lenin's coup produced absolutely nothing of value that could not have been produced otherwise by a better, more humane, freer Russian government. (As an ethnic Ukrainian yourself, without the Bolshevik coup in Russia, the Ukrainian people could have been reunified within a free and democratic Greater Russia right after the end of World War I. Wouldn't that have been quite an achievement, especially with a separate Ukrainian federal unit within this Greater Russia? Maybe eventually even secession and outright independence could have actually been a realistic option for Ukraine since Viktor Chernov supported it for both Ukraine and the various other minorities in Greater Russia.)

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    BTW, AP, had the CPs won WWI, would you have felt sad that Poland could not be revived with all of the ethnographically Polish territories? After all, Germany would never give up its own Polish territories without a WWI defeat (thus ensuring that any recreated independent Poland would be landlocked) and even with Austria, it's not guaranteed that Austria would have actually given up Galicia to an independent Poland, though it is possible, especially if Poland agrees to accept a Hapsburg King as the price of this.

    Of course, if a victorious Germany would have created a proto-EU after a WWI victory with both Austria-Hungary and Poland as members, then Poland being landlocked would be less of an issue since Poland would likely have access to the Vistula and to German and Austro-Hungarian ports in such a scenario.

    As a side note, I wonder if the victorious CPs could have actually succeeded in overthrowing the Bolsheviks after a WWI victory or whether they would have simply created a quagmire for themselves, especially if they would have subsequently attempted to install their own puppet regime in Russia as opposed to letting events there play out naturally. I'm unsure that Russians would be very tolerant of a German puppet regime, though maybe Russians would have been so war-weary by this point in time that they would have reluctantly accepted it. What do you think, AP?

    Ukraine of course could have been reintegrated back to Russia in the same way that Russia wanted to reintegrate the Donbass back into Ukraine before 2022--as in, with extremely heavy autonomy and with (pro-German) Ukraine having veto power over Russian national policies in Germany's favor.

    Replies: @AP, @Beckow

  72. @Mikel
    @Gerard1234

    I don't have any strong opinions on the Riga architectural landscape. If all parties involved agree with you that the best parts were built by the Russians, that is something I can perfectly live with.

    However, it is just not true that LatW left because of you. She clearly left in indignation at the epithet that G_R directed at her. Even worse, then G_R proceeded to leave the blog himself, at a time when Dmitry, Bashi, Aaron and others had been absent for a while and Yahya has briefly reappeared to let us know what a waste of his time this geriatric ward had become really. The chances of any worthwhile debate taking place here have become infinitesimal.

    But I can't blame any of them really. We had long ago entered the law of diminishing returns, discussing ad nauseam the same old subjects with the same old arguments (me included). Who doesn't have better uses of their time than that?

    With that said, I think it's been quite a remarkable feat to keep this blog alive for 2 years after his author left (and actually break records of comment numbers on this website). Perhaps as important as the subjects we keep debating are the subjects the regulars of this blog never debate: transhumanism and technological singularities (AK's favorite topics) or the JQ (Unz's obsession). This clearly signals that it was never about AK or Unz. They both just happened to attract a group of disparate people with very different backgrounds and the group then took a life of its own, building very lively threads out of nothing that for one reason or another we all felt compelled to participate in. Though obviously AK and Ron deserve credit for the phenomenon.

    Alas, everything has an end and it looks like these threads are losing the vigor and interest they once had. On to the difficult task of finding other places to debate, vent and engage people of different persuasions without being censored, I guess.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @AP, @Yevardian, @German_reader, @Gerard1234

    This is only remotely tangentially related, but in Zechariah Sitchin’s Twelfth Planet he has Utu not as a Sumerian god, but as manager of the Sumerian space port. Sitchin taught himself to read Sumerian and as far as I know nobody with a real Sumerian language degree agrees with his interpretations.

    • Thanks: Mikel
  73. News flash.

    Iran announced that in the Gulf of Oman it seized a loaded oil tanker (formerly known as Suez Rajan) that was, along with Iranian crude oil it carried, previously stolen by the US.

    It’s an illustration of the fact that highway robbery game the empire loves so much can be played by others, as well. Those who foam at the mouth advocating stealing Russian assets should take notice.

    • Replies: @A123
    @AnonfromTN


    Iran announced that in the Gulf of Oman it seized a loaded oil tanker (formerly known as Suez Rajan) that was, along with Iranian crude oil it carried, previously stolen by the US.
     
    The Iranian piracy offended many countries:

    • Greece -- owner
    • Iraq -- cargo
    • Türkiye -- destination
    • Philippines -- crew

    Regardless of the earlier event, this is a very bad play on Khamenei's part. His attack did not directly impact the U.S. Khamenei has never been politically deft, but this seems unusually incompetent. When is the last time the Ayatollah spoke in public?

    It’s an illustration of the fact that highway robbery game the empire loves so much can be played by others, as well. Those who foam at the mouth advocating stealing Russian assets should take notice.
     
    I concur. Stealing the private assets of Russian nationals is clearly inappropriate. And, unlike Khamenei's error, potential responses could be much more accurately wielded.

    The good news is that America is unlikely to make such a mistake. First, a law would have to be passed through a divided Congress. Funding Kiev aggression is not a priority. In the unlikely event a bill is signed, it would be tied up in court for years.

    Add this to the already long list of "Symbolism Over Substance". Politicians obtain some constituency credit for talking about such ideas, even though they know they will never happen.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    , @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN

    We are going back to real history: forget treaties, contracts, electronic wordy bulls--t, who cares? They are all just pieces of paper. This will be more fun.

    I would remind the pro-Nato contingent that if the power gets reshuffled to omit paper and other verbal stuff, it will be the West that will lose more. Its power will be less than the countries with material resources and actual manufacturing. Nato is the West, there is no other way to see it.

    All they had to do was sit on the advantage, pretend to follow their own rules, wait for the ennui to set in among the rivals. But the maps were so tempting...grow and expand! get this or that pretty peninsula (Crimea)...plus the ethnic querulants who yearn to get even...(looking at Mr. Hacks, AP, 'sudden death', LatW...)

    Replies: @AP

    , @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AnonfromTN

    https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/1/11/iran-navy-says-seized-oil-tanker-off-oman-state-media-2

  74. @Mikel
    @Gerard1234

    I don't have any strong opinions on the Riga architectural landscape. If all parties involved agree with you that the best parts were built by the Russians, that is something I can perfectly live with.

    However, it is just not true that LatW left because of you. She clearly left in indignation at the epithet that G_R directed at her. Even worse, then G_R proceeded to leave the blog himself, at a time when Dmitry, Bashi, Aaron and others had been absent for a while and Yahya has briefly reappeared to let us know what a waste of his time this geriatric ward had become really. The chances of any worthwhile debate taking place here have become infinitesimal.

    But I can't blame any of them really. We had long ago entered the law of diminishing returns, discussing ad nauseam the same old subjects with the same old arguments (me included). Who doesn't have better uses of their time than that?

    With that said, I think it's been quite a remarkable feat to keep this blog alive for 2 years after his author left (and actually break records of comment numbers on this website). Perhaps as important as the subjects we keep debating are the subjects the regulars of this blog never debate: transhumanism and technological singularities (AK's favorite topics) or the JQ (Unz's obsession). This clearly signals that it was never about AK or Unz. They both just happened to attract a group of disparate people with very different backgrounds and the group then took a life of its own, building very lively threads out of nothing that for one reason or another we all felt compelled to participate in. Though obviously AK and Ron deserve credit for the phenomenon.

    Alas, everything has an end and it looks like these threads are losing the vigor and interest they once had. On to the difficult task of finding other places to debate, vent and engage people of different persuasions without being censored, I guess.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @AP, @Yevardian, @German_reader, @Gerard1234

    Sure, we lost some of the vigor and the name-calling is worse (kind of fun, sometimes)…but don’t you want to see the ending?

    It looks likely that the story will finally get resolved this year. As that approaches the tension rises and we are forced to revisit many of the axiomatic assumptions we base our arguments on. Don’t miss the finale, there is a lot of potential…

    • Replies: @A123
    @Beckow

    The quiescence of Kiev aggression will open up bandwidth to talk about other things.

    For example, we have a full fledged U.S. election year to go. To be followed by 4 years of Trump's 2nd Term. Given how much the #NeverTrump zealots hate MAGA/Trump, that will generate significant content.

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇

    Replies: @Beckow, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    , @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    It looks likely that the story will finally get resolved this year.
     
    Not the story, only its Ukrainian chapter. Despite your level-headedness, you appear to share Europe-centric delusions of many Europeans.

    The story is about the order in the world. Ukraine is only a small part of it: a bit more important than Afghanistan, but less important than Iran or Israel. Ukrainian conflict, especially hysterical reaction to it of the empire and its cocksuckers, worked as a first pebble that starts the avalanche. Theoretically, that pebble could have been stopped, but nothing can stop the avalanche that it started.

    The story won’t end until the empire is cut down to size, its minions humiliated, the USD (along with Euro) stops being reserve currency, etc. There are many more chapters to go through yet. In the end Ukraine likely won’t even deserve a chapter, just a footnote. The downfall of Europe would deserve a chapter, though.

    Replies: @Beckow

  75. @AnonfromTN
    News flash.

    Iran announced that in the Gulf of Oman it seized a loaded oil tanker (formerly known as Suez Rajan) that was, along with Iranian crude oil it carried, previously stolen by the US.

    It’s an illustration of the fact that highway robbery game the empire loves so much can be played by others, as well. Those who foam at the mouth advocating stealing Russian assets should take notice.

    Replies: @A123, @Beckow, @Emil Nikola Richard

    Iran announced that in the Gulf of Oman it seized a loaded oil tanker (formerly known as Suez Rajan) that was, along with Iranian crude oil it carried, previously stolen by the US.

    The Iranian piracy offended many countries:

    • Greece — owner
    • Iraq — cargo
    • Türkiye — destination
    • Philippines — crew

    Regardless of the earlier event, this is a very bad play on Khamenei’s part. His attack did not directly impact the U.S. Khamenei has never been politically deft, but this seems unusually incompetent. When is the last time the Ayatollah spoke in public?

    It’s an illustration of the fact that highway robbery game the empire loves so much can be played by others, as well. Those who foam at the mouth advocating stealing Russian assets should take notice.

    I concur. Stealing the private assets of Russian nationals is clearly inappropriate. And, unlike Khamenei’s error, potential responses could be much more accurately wielded.

    The good news is that America is unlikely to make such a mistake. First, a law would have to be passed through a divided Congress. Funding Kiev aggression is not a priority. In the unlikely event a bill is signed, it would be tied up in court for years.

    Add this to the already long list of “Symbolism Over Substance“. Politicians obtain some constituency credit for talking about such ideas, even though they know they will never happen.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GDp0mNoWIAEaVcU.jpg

    Replies: @A123

  76. @Beckow
    @Mikel

    Sure, we lost some of the vigor and the name-calling is worse (kind of fun, sometimes)...but don't you want to see the ending?

    It looks likely that the story will finally get resolved this year. As that approaches the tension rises and we are forced to revisit many of the axiomatic assumptions we base our arguments on. Don't miss the finale, there is a lot of potential...

    Replies: @A123, @AnonfromTN

    The quiescence of Kiev aggression will open up bandwidth to talk about other things.

    For example, we have a full fledged U.S. election year to go. To be followed by 4 years of Trump’s 2nd Term. Given how much the #NeverTrump zealots hate MAGA/Trump, that will generate significant content.

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @A123

    The drama with Trump will be this year. If he gets into the office - I am skeptical - everything will change. The fat guy has walked off the stage and the Indian harridan is still shrieking...this is still the intro chapter.

    Given the stereotype about Americans, why would anyone consider for President extremely fat people, elderly dementia patient or childless (one kid doesn't count) women with some "color" at the edge of hysteria?

    It feeds the stereotype and it is really bad marketing. US built up its cultural dominance with good marketing, and now what? How about an elderly fat woman of color with dementia - is there one like that? They should bring it on and go out in a blaze of glory...

    Russia had an elderly dork with a speech impediment and vaguely Ukie name right before the collapse started in the mid-80's...that's the way to do it.

    Replies: @A123

    , @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    I guess that you do not understand the economics of supply and demand. Increasing intermediate expenses, like transportation, reduces the Zionist Entity's ability to buy.

    Given that the Red Sea is not being transited by sanctioned container vessels, “israel” is is effectively sanctioned. This is a problem Asian suppliers who are to closely aligned with the Zionist Entity, but it is particularly inconvenient for the “israeli” economy, which is highly import dependent.

    😇

  77. @John Johnson
    @QCIC

    What they were doing was using him as bait.

    That is why they sent him in a tank with a broken autoloader.

    The Russian response to the javalin was to send in a decoy team.

    His life meant so little that they didn't want to bother wasting a working tank on him.

    Sounds like he was the only one to survive.

    What a fine country you defend.

    Replies: @Sean

    You think the less valuable British soldiers of a unit in WW2 were not sent out by their colonels and such to draw fire by getting killed? That is how war works.

  78. @A123
    @Beckow

    The quiescence of Kiev aggression will open up bandwidth to talk about other things.

    For example, we have a full fledged U.S. election year to go. To be followed by 4 years of Trump's 2nd Term. Given how much the #NeverTrump zealots hate MAGA/Trump, that will generate significant content.

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇

    Replies: @Beckow, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    The drama with Trump will be this year. If he gets into the office – I am skeptical – everything will change. The fat guy has walked off the stage and the Indian harridan is still shrieking…this is still the intro chapter.

    Given the stereotype about Americans, why would anyone consider for President extremely fat people, elderly dementia patient or childless (one kid doesn’t count) women with some “color” at the edge of hysteria?

    It feeds the stereotype and it is really bad marketing. US built up its cultural dominance with good marketing, and now what? How about an elderly fat woman of color with dementia – is there one like that? They should bring it on and go out in a blaze of glory…

    Russia had an elderly dork with a speech impediment and vaguely Ukie name right before the collapse started in the mid-80’s…that’s the way to do it.

    • Replies: @A123
    @Beckow


    The drama with Trump will be this year. If he gets into the office – I am skeptical – everything will change.
     
    This goes back to the discussions I have had with Mikel. Expectations have to be reasonable. There will be "some positive change" not "everything will change".

    In his 1st term -- House, Senate, Judiciary, and deep state were all in opposition to MAGA. Trump's 2nd term should feature more MAGA support from the House and Senate, which will correspondingly yield more appropriations and better confirmations. However, it will still be short of Mikel's impossible standard, 100% of absolutely everything! Instantly!

    Trump has spent the last 4 years building up what Barbarosa refers to as Soft Power. RINO's have been primaried and driven from office, notably the reprehensible Liz Cheney. Endorsements, rallies, and fund raisers give Trump favours to call in on critical votes.

    It took decades to dig the SJW Islamophile Globalist hole America is in. It will take a comparable amount of time to recover. Trump's 2nd term is only one step on the MAGA road. Key will be finding a successor (who may not be the VP). Kari Lake perhaps?

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

  79. @AnonfromTN
    News flash.

    Iran announced that in the Gulf of Oman it seized a loaded oil tanker (formerly known as Suez Rajan) that was, along with Iranian crude oil it carried, previously stolen by the US.

    It’s an illustration of the fact that highway robbery game the empire loves so much can be played by others, as well. Those who foam at the mouth advocating stealing Russian assets should take notice.

    Replies: @A123, @Beckow, @Emil Nikola Richard

    We are going back to real history: forget treaties, contracts, electronic wordy bulls–t, who cares? They are all just pieces of paper. This will be more fun.

    I would remind the pro-Nato contingent that if the power gets reshuffled to omit paper and other verbal stuff, it will be the West that will lose more. Its power will be less than the countries with material resources and actual manufacturing. Nato is the West, there is no other way to see it.

    All they had to do was sit on the advantage, pretend to follow their own rules, wait for the ennui to set in among the rivals. But the maps were so tempting…grow and expand! get this or that pretty peninsula (Crimea)…plus the ethnic querulants who yearn to get even…(looking at Mr. Hacks, AP, ‘sudden death’, LatW…)

    • Replies: @AP
    @Beckow


    I would remind the pro-Nato contingent that if the power gets reshuffled to omit paper and other verbal stuff, it will be the West that will lose more. Its power will be less than the countries with material resources and actual manufacturing
     
    USA is the world’s top oil producer. USA + it’s semi-appendage Canada produce nearly twice as much oil as either Russia or Saudi Arabia.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_oil_production

    USA also world’s top natural gas producer:

    https://investingnews.com/top-natural-gas-producers/

    Lithium. South America, but USA exceeds China:

    https://www.nsenergybusiness.com/features/six-largest-lithium-reserves-world/

    USA is the world’s second largest manufacturer, after China. Here the picture is mixed.

    China dominates in steel production:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_steel_production

    Though the EU, Japan, and the USA each exceed Russian steel production.

    In terms of finished goods, a lot of what China manufactures (not all, of course), is cheap stuff that we in the West would not want to make because we’d rather it be very inexpensive. Like mass production of the trinkets including cheap electronics they sell in Walmart.

    Otherwise, USA is number 1 in aircraft production:

    https://www.aerotime.aero/articles/top-10-largest-aircraft-manufacturers-in-the-world

    Almost all Western, Brazil at number 9.

    China leads in automobile production but many Chinese cars are cheap and of poor quality. And the West (which includes Japan) collectively produces more automobiles than does China:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_motor_vehicle_production

    West leads in semiconductor manufacturing (a reason China won’t be given Taiwan for awhile):

    https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/semiconductor-manufacturing-by-country

    Machine tools, China number one, but collective West exceeds it:

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/264213/leading-countries-in-machine-tool-production-based-on-market-share/

    Overall, the combination of natural resources and manufacturing particular high end manufacturing favors the West, especially the USA.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Gerard1234

  80. @Beckow
    @Mikel

    Sure, we lost some of the vigor and the name-calling is worse (kind of fun, sometimes)...but don't you want to see the ending?

    It looks likely that the story will finally get resolved this year. As that approaches the tension rises and we are forced to revisit many of the axiomatic assumptions we base our arguments on. Don't miss the finale, there is a lot of potential...

    Replies: @A123, @AnonfromTN

    It looks likely that the story will finally get resolved this year.

    Not the story, only its Ukrainian chapter. Despite your level-headedness, you appear to share Europe-centric delusions of many Europeans.

    The story is about the order in the world. Ukraine is only a small part of it: a bit more important than Afghanistan, but less important than Iran or Israel. Ukrainian conflict, especially hysterical reaction to it of the empire and its cocksuckers, worked as a first pebble that starts the avalanche. Theoretically, that pebble could have been stopped, but nothing can stop the avalanche that it started.

    The story won’t end until the empire is cut down to size, its minions humiliated, the USD (along with Euro) stops being reserve currency, etc. There are many more chapters to go through yet. In the end Ukraine likely won’t even deserve a chapter, just a footnote. The downfall of Europe would deserve a chapter, though.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN


    ...The downfall of Europe would deserve a chapter
     
    I am proudly Euro-centric, made out of Europe, I won't apologize. You will not find more European geography than the remote valleys and rolling hills north of the middle Danube...it is almost comically Euro. My priority is to preserve the good life here and I will spin ideas in that direction. Whether it is delusional I leave to others. One has to have a point of view, we are not gods...

    When this started the Western Europe was in a slow, gradual decline: lack of resources, collapsing big cities, unstoppable migrants...and idiotic liberal fanatics. We were good in the east or central-east\: steadily growing, normal, living safer and more comfortable lives. The Ukie disaster has reversed it...

    The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere - in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia's propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception and even among them the sentiment is more mixed - who they really hate are the Ukies and Orthodox, but they can't voice it now.)

    It will be in the Chapter called "Causes"...the stupidity of the Nato's failed grab of Ukraine makes the wars in the Middle East and Asia much worse for the West. The elemental reality is that with China's economic might, Middle East-Russian resources, resentful nations of the South, the last thing West needed was to add Russia with its weapons, resources and geography. But they did, for Nato bases, Crimea (nice place) and exiles' lying stories...maybe a downfall, but I still hope not...I like our quiet valleys.

    Replies: @AP, @AnonfromTN

  81. @Mikel
    @Gerard1234

    I don't have any strong opinions on the Riga architectural landscape. If all parties involved agree with you that the best parts were built by the Russians, that is something I can perfectly live with.

    However, it is just not true that LatW left because of you. She clearly left in indignation at the epithet that G_R directed at her. Even worse, then G_R proceeded to leave the blog himself, at a time when Dmitry, Bashi, Aaron and others had been absent for a while and Yahya has briefly reappeared to let us know what a waste of his time this geriatric ward had become really. The chances of any worthwhile debate taking place here have become infinitesimal.

    But I can't blame any of them really. We had long ago entered the law of diminishing returns, discussing ad nauseam the same old subjects with the same old arguments (me included). Who doesn't have better uses of their time than that?

    With that said, I think it's been quite a remarkable feat to keep this blog alive for 2 years after his author left (and actually break records of comment numbers on this website). Perhaps as important as the subjects we keep debating are the subjects the regulars of this blog never debate: transhumanism and technological singularities (AK's favorite topics) or the JQ (Unz's obsession). This clearly signals that it was never about AK or Unz. They both just happened to attract a group of disparate people with very different backgrounds and the group then took a life of its own, building very lively threads out of nothing that for one reason or another we all felt compelled to participate in. Though obviously AK and Ron deserve credit for the phenomenon.

    Alas, everything has an end and it looks like these threads are losing the vigor and interest they once had. On to the difficult task of finding other places to debate, vent and engage people of different persuasions without being censored, I guess.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @AP, @Yevardian, @German_reader, @Gerard1234

    On to the difficult task of finding other places to debate, vent and engage people of different persuasions without being censored

    If you find such a place, let us know.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AP

    There is a widget on the front page where you can calculate the most commented threads for the past week, month, &c.

    Karlinstan is a prime property. Unz's post is Boardwalk. This is Park Place.

    , @Mikel
    @AP


    If you find such a place, let us know.
     
    I'm not too optimistic. The reason why I'm still here is because I've tried in the past but failed at finding any comparable place to discus stuff. Censorship is getting terrible. What a miserable way of making a living, censoring what other people want to say respectfully on a subject. How can these "moderators" of the comments sections in so many newspapers look at themselves in a mirror after making sure, day after day, that lots of people who took the time to write something were silenced, often for petty ideological reasons? I can't imagine any normal person in their childhood dreaming of becoming a censor when they grew up. But the modern internet has created an army of such losers.

    Replies: @AP, @QCIC, @Derer

  82. @AP
    @Mikel


    On to the difficult task of finding other places to debate, vent and engage people of different persuasions without being censored
     
    If you find such a place, let us know.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Mikel

    There is a widget on the front page where you can calculate the most commented threads for the past week, month, &c.

    Karlinstan is a prime property. Unz’s post is Boardwalk. This is Park Place.

  83. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ


    AP, you say that the Central Powers were the good guys in WWI, but wouldn’t sending over the Bolshevik bacillus to Russia
     
    The sent them there to disrupt things in the enemy country but the Russians themselves succumbed to them: the Central Powers certainly didn’t impose that evil government upon the Russians.

    But they did keep the Bolsheviks out of Ukraine and Belarus.

    and slaughtering the Ottoman Empire’s Christians en masse

     

    That was evil. The Ottoman Empire was the villainous ally to Germany and Austria-Hungary. As Stalin was, to the USA/UK.

    Still, on balance, Ottoman crimes were less evil than the total horrors of World War I.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ

    The sent them there to disrupt things in the enemy country but the Russians themselves succumbed to them: the Central Powers certainly didn’t impose that evil government upon the Russians.

    To be fair, the Russians themselves didn’t vote for the Bolsheviks. However, they were unable to resist the Bolsheviks as effectively as was necessary. Similar to the Afghans with the Taliban. Based on the polling that I have seen, the overwhelming majority of Afghans did not want the Taliban (please see here: https://www.unz.com/akarlin/taliban-rule-is-the-democratic-will-of-13-of-afghans/ ), but nevertheless they were also not prepared to resist the Taliban as effectively as was necessary once the US announced that it was going to withdraw from Afghanistan.

    Interestingly enough, for all of the hate that the US’s regime change wars get, Russia 1919 was a golden missed opportunity for a regime change war for the US. The other Great Powers were either defeated or too bled dry by WWI even if victorious and thus large-scale military intervention in Russia for them was not a realistic option, but it was easier to do for the US had the political will in favor of this actually been there. Alas, it wasn’t. But had this hypothetical regime change war actually occurred, its benefits would have very likely massively outweighed all of the harms of the US’s other, later regime change wars in real life. Such an intervention would have even been beneficial for the US with hindsight since it might have subsequently prevented WWII.

    I have read that, in the summer of 1918, before their WWI defeat, the Germans seriously considered overthrowing the Bolsheviks in Russia but ultimately decided (with the Kaiser making this decision) to postpone further discussion of this move until after a German victory in WWI, which never happened.

    It’s very painful for me that my own ancestors had to suffer under Bolshevism for many decades. They and the rest of the population in that part of the world deserved so much better. Their only consolation was (or should have been) that Stalin subsequently unleashed the long knives against many of his fellow Bolshevik comrades as well, thus indicating that the Bolshevik coup ultimately wasn’t a good thing for the prominent original Bolsheviks themselves either. Better life in the opposition than being brutally purged and murdered by Stalin.

    But they did keep the Bolsheviks out of Ukraine and Belarus.

    Only until the end of the war. Once they lost the war, they couldn’t even do that. Of course, Poland subsequently tried doing that but was only partly successful. IMHO, the West should have supported Poland to the hilt against the Bolsheviks in order to get as much people out of the Bolshevik clutches as possible. Though ultimately eventually Germany and the USSR might have sought to repartition Poland, as in real life in 1939.

    That was evil. The Ottoman Empire was the villainous ally to Germany and Austria-Hungary. As Stalin was, to the USA/UK.

    Still, on balance, Ottoman crimes were less evil than the total horrors of World War I.

    Fair enough, I suppose. Honestly, I don’t think that it was worth it for either Austria-Hungary or Russia to go to war over Serbia in 1914, and Russia should have certainly let Austria-Hungary conquer Serbia (perhaps with Russia subsequently sponsoring an anti-Austro-Hungarian insurgency in Serbia) than to militarily intervene on Serbia’s behalf and thus spark World War I. Ultimately, a pro-Austro-Hungarian Serbia would have only been a return to the pre-1903 situation, which was quite tolerable for Russia. In any case, had Austria-Hungary done regime change in Serbia back in 1904-1905, when Russia was busy fighting Japan, Russia would likely not have militarily intervened. Thus, had Russia desired it, it could have also avoided militarily intervening in this in 1914 as well. The Russian people ultimately ended up paying the price for this.

    It’s quite interesting, because as late as 1916, the Russian people don’t appear to have been defeatist, but then defeatism appears to have rapidly set in after the Tsar was ousted:

    https://books.google.com/books?id=W2iCsWC7kgAC&pg=PA131&dq=russia+verge+revolution+1914+general+strike+petrograd&hl=en&newbks=1&newbks_redir=0&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjg0pOL1NODAxWDJkQIHV9iCc0Q6AF6BAgIEAI#v=onepage&q=russia%20verge%20revolution%201914%20general%20strike%20petrograd&f=false

    As a side note, if you could either save Franz Ferdinand in 1914 or kill Vladimir Lenin before 1917, what would you choose? I would choose killing Vladimir Lenin before 1917 because ultimately as extraordinarily tragic as WWI was, it at least had a positive outcome in rearranging the map of Europe on a more ethnic/national self-determination basis (albeit imperfectly) whereas Lenin’s coup produced absolutely nothing of value that could not have been produced otherwise by a better, more humane, freer Russian government. (As an ethnic Ukrainian yourself, without the Bolshevik coup in Russia, the Ukrainian people could have been reunified within a free and democratic Greater Russia right after the end of World War I. Wouldn’t that have been quite an achievement, especially with a separate Ukrainian federal unit within this Greater Russia? Maybe eventually even secession and outright independence could have actually been a realistic option for Ukraine since Viktor Chernov supported it for both Ukraine and the various other minorities in Greater Russia.)

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mr. XYZ

    See Carlton Meyer. The United States did intervene in 1917 and the Bolsheviks drove them off. He says. I have no idea how substantial the intervention was or how accurate his report is but on the whole his takes are pretty good.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  84. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    The sent them there to disrupt things in the enemy country but the Russians themselves succumbed to them: the Central Powers certainly didn’t impose that evil government upon the Russians.

     

    To be fair, the Russians themselves didn't vote for the Bolsheviks. However, they were unable to resist the Bolsheviks as effectively as was necessary. Similar to the Afghans with the Taliban. Based on the polling that I have seen, the overwhelming majority of Afghans did not want the Taliban (please see here: https://www.unz.com/akarlin/taliban-rule-is-the-democratic-will-of-13-of-afghans/ ), but nevertheless they were also not prepared to resist the Taliban as effectively as was necessary once the US announced that it was going to withdraw from Afghanistan.

    Interestingly enough, for all of the hate that the US's regime change wars get, Russia 1919 was a golden missed opportunity for a regime change war for the US. The other Great Powers were either defeated or too bled dry by WWI even if victorious and thus large-scale military intervention in Russia for them was not a realistic option, but it was easier to do for the US had the political will in favor of this actually been there. Alas, it wasn't. But had this hypothetical regime change war actually occurred, its benefits would have very likely massively outweighed all of the harms of the US's other, later regime change wars in real life. Such an intervention would have even been beneficial for the US with hindsight since it might have subsequently prevented WWII.

    I have read that, in the summer of 1918, before their WWI defeat, the Germans seriously considered overthrowing the Bolsheviks in Russia but ultimately decided (with the Kaiser making this decision) to postpone further discussion of this move until after a German victory in WWI, which never happened.

    It's very painful for me that my own ancestors had to suffer under Bolshevism for many decades. They and the rest of the population in that part of the world deserved so much better. Their only consolation was (or should have been) that Stalin subsequently unleashed the long knives against many of his fellow Bolshevik comrades as well, thus indicating that the Bolshevik coup ultimately wasn't a good thing for the prominent original Bolsheviks themselves either. Better life in the opposition than being brutally purged and murdered by Stalin.


    But they did keep the Bolsheviks out of Ukraine and Belarus.

     

    Only until the end of the war. Once they lost the war, they couldn't even do that. Of course, Poland subsequently tried doing that but was only partly successful. IMHO, the West should have supported Poland to the hilt against the Bolsheviks in order to get as much people out of the Bolshevik clutches as possible. Though ultimately eventually Germany and the USSR might have sought to repartition Poland, as in real life in 1939.

    That was evil. The Ottoman Empire was the villainous ally to Germany and Austria-Hungary. As Stalin was, to the USA/UK.

    Still, on balance, Ottoman crimes were less evil than the total horrors of World War I.
     

    Fair enough, I suppose. Honestly, I don't think that it was worth it for either Austria-Hungary or Russia to go to war over Serbia in 1914, and Russia should have certainly let Austria-Hungary conquer Serbia (perhaps with Russia subsequently sponsoring an anti-Austro-Hungarian insurgency in Serbia) than to militarily intervene on Serbia's behalf and thus spark World War I. Ultimately, a pro-Austro-Hungarian Serbia would have only been a return to the pre-1903 situation, which was quite tolerable for Russia. In any case, had Austria-Hungary done regime change in Serbia back in 1904-1905, when Russia was busy fighting Japan, Russia would likely not have militarily intervened. Thus, had Russia desired it, it could have also avoided militarily intervening in this in 1914 as well. The Russian people ultimately ended up paying the price for this.

    It's quite interesting, because as late as 1916, the Russian people don't appear to have been defeatist, but then defeatism appears to have rapidly set in after the Tsar was ousted:

    https://books.google.com/books?id=W2iCsWC7kgAC&pg=PA131&dq=russia+verge+revolution+1914+general+strike+petrograd&hl=en&newbks=1&newbks_redir=0&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjg0pOL1NODAxWDJkQIHV9iCc0Q6AF6BAgIEAI#v=onepage&q=russia%20verge%20revolution%201914%20general%20strike%20petrograd&f=false

    As a side note, if you could either save Franz Ferdinand in 1914 or kill Vladimir Lenin before 1917, what would you choose? I would choose killing Vladimir Lenin before 1917 because ultimately as extraordinarily tragic as WWI was, it at least had a positive outcome in rearranging the map of Europe on a more ethnic/national self-determination basis (albeit imperfectly) whereas Lenin's coup produced absolutely nothing of value that could not have been produced otherwise by a better, more humane, freer Russian government. (As an ethnic Ukrainian yourself, without the Bolshevik coup in Russia, the Ukrainian people could have been reunified within a free and democratic Greater Russia right after the end of World War I. Wouldn't that have been quite an achievement, especially with a separate Ukrainian federal unit within this Greater Russia? Maybe eventually even secession and outright independence could have actually been a realistic option for Ukraine since Viktor Chernov supported it for both Ukraine and the various other minorities in Greater Russia.)

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    See Carlton Meyer. The United States did intervene in 1917 and the Bolsheviks drove them off. He says. I have no idea how substantial the intervention was or how accurate his report is but on the whole his takes are pretty good.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Thanks. I'll check out his work but AFAIK the US intervention during the RCW was very half-assed and nowhere near enough to overthrow the Bolsheviks. I'm thinking of a military commitment at least equivalent to Iraq 2003 in real life. As in, 100,000-200,000 US troops in Russia in total.

    https://media.cnn.com/api/v1/images/stellar/prod/111021071034-us-troops-in-iraq-chart.jpg?q=w_640,h_360,x_0,y_0,c_fill

    https://images.jacobinmag.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/07131627/us-troop-levels-in-iraq-2003-2020-630x675.png

    https://www.economist.com/content-assets/images/20230325_WOC441.png

    But honestly, looking at the strength figures for the various forces here, that might not be enough:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_Civil_War

    The US might have needed at least 500,000 or even 1,000,000 troops in Russia to realistically meaningfully affect the Russian Civil War.

  85. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mr. XYZ

    See Carlton Meyer. The United States did intervene in 1917 and the Bolsheviks drove them off. He says. I have no idea how substantial the intervention was or how accurate his report is but on the whole his takes are pretty good.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Thanks. I’ll check out his work but AFAIK the US intervention during the RCW was very half-assed and nowhere near enough to overthrow the Bolsheviks. I’m thinking of a military commitment at least equivalent to Iraq 2003 in real life. As in, 100,000-200,000 US troops in Russia in total.

    https://media.cnn.com/api/v1/images/stellar/prod/111021071034-us-troops-in-iraq-chart.jpg?q=w_640,h_360,x_0,y_0,c_fill

    But honestly, looking at the strength figures for the various forces here, that might not be enough:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_Civil_War

    The US might have needed at least 500,000 or even 1,000,000 troops in Russia to realistically meaningfully affect the Russian Civil War.

  86. @AnonfromTN
    News flash.

    Iran announced that in the Gulf of Oman it seized a loaded oil tanker (formerly known as Suez Rajan) that was, along with Iranian crude oil it carried, previously stolen by the US.

    It’s an illustration of the fact that highway robbery game the empire loves so much can be played by others, as well. Those who foam at the mouth advocating stealing Russian assets should take notice.

    Replies: @A123, @Beckow, @Emil Nikola Richard

  87. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ


    AP, you say that the Central Powers were the good guys in WWI, but wouldn’t sending over the Bolshevik bacillus to Russia
     
    The sent them there to disrupt things in the enemy country but the Russians themselves succumbed to them: the Central Powers certainly didn’t impose that evil government upon the Russians.

    But they did keep the Bolsheviks out of Ukraine and Belarus.

    and slaughtering the Ottoman Empire’s Christians en masse

     

    That was evil. The Ottoman Empire was the villainous ally to Germany and Austria-Hungary. As Stalin was, to the USA/UK.

    Still, on balance, Ottoman crimes were less evil than the total horrors of World War I.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ

    BTW, AP, had the CPs won WWI, would you have felt sad that Poland could not be revived with all of the ethnographically Polish territories? After all, Germany would never give up its own Polish territories without a WWI defeat (thus ensuring that any recreated independent Poland would be landlocked) and even with Austria, it’s not guaranteed that Austria would have actually given up Galicia to an independent Poland, though it is possible, especially if Poland agrees to accept a Hapsburg King as the price of this.

    Of course, if a victorious Germany would have created a proto-EU after a WWI victory with both Austria-Hungary and Poland as members, then Poland being landlocked would be less of an issue since Poland would likely have access to the Vistula and to German and Austro-Hungarian ports in such a scenario.

    As a side note, I wonder if the victorious CPs could have actually succeeded in overthrowing the Bolsheviks after a WWI victory or whether they would have simply created a quagmire for themselves, especially if they would have subsequently attempted to install their own puppet regime in Russia as opposed to letting events there play out naturally. I’m unsure that Russians would be very tolerant of a German puppet regime, though maybe Russians would have been so war-weary by this point in time that they would have reluctantly accepted it. What do you think, AP?

    Ukraine of course could have been reintegrated back to Russia in the same way that Russia wanted to reintegrate the Donbass back into Ukraine before 2022–as in, with extremely heavy autonomy and with (pro-German) Ukraine having veto power over Russian national policies in Germany’s favor.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Mr. XYZ


    BTW, AP, had the CPs won WWI, would you have felt sad that Poland could not be revived with all of the ethnographically Polish territories?
     
    Not really. I would have been fine with a small Poland around Warsaw carved out of Russian territories and a Ukraine with Galicia still part of Austria, with Skoropadsky on the throne. I am not a nationalist. And anyways, that would have been far better than our timeline.

    As a side note, I wonder if the victorious CPs could have actually succeeded in overthrowing the Bolsheviks after a WWI victory
     
    Who knows? An important thing is that tens of millions of Ukrainians and Belarusians would have avoided the Bolshevik nightmare, and whatever state would have existed in Russia would have been too small or weak to threaten the world. Maybe even too weak to dare attempt the mass starvation experiments on the people whom it ruled.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ

    , @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    You are fooling yourself with the CP winning WW1. Demography is destiny, if Germany won WW1 there would be no Poland and no Baltic states - they would take it all and by now the natives would be gone: assimilated or worse.

    The Euro continent dynamic with 3-4 competing powers - Anglo-France, Germany, Russia, Turkey - is unchangeable: the smaller players always eventually fall under one of the powers. EU is just an Anglo-French-Germany combo - with US managing it, the two Western groupings combined. They also grabbed everything in the vicinity (including Poland). But when they tried to go further east and grab Ukraine, Belarus, Caucasus, the remaining Euro power, Russia, blocked it - a bridge too far. As happened before.

    For different reasons the Anglo-Euro hegemon also lost Turkey. What now? They either reverse the catastrophic losses (unlikely in Ukraine or Middle East) or there will be growing internal dissent - they will go after each other since they can't expand.

    Another scenario is that Europe is transformed into a non-Europe: half American satrapies and half Third World migrants. The two go together - if you don't realize that by now, you have not been paying attention.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

  88. @AP
    @Mikel


    On to the difficult task of finding other places to debate, vent and engage people of different persuasions without being censored
     
    If you find such a place, let us know.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Mikel

    If you find such a place, let us know.

    I’m not too optimistic. The reason why I’m still here is because I’ve tried in the past but failed at finding any comparable place to discus stuff. Censorship is getting terrible. What a miserable way of making a living, censoring what other people want to say respectfully on a subject. How can these “moderators” of the comments sections in so many newspapers look at themselves in a mirror after making sure, day after day, that lots of people who took the time to write something were silenced, often for petty ideological reasons? I can’t imagine any normal person in their childhood dreaming of becoming a censor when they grew up. But the modern internet has created an army of such losers.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Mikel

    Years ago the Atlantic had a nice commenting section using Disqus. It was completely shut down. There was a nice mix of people from the Right and the Left, and a few smart ones.

    This place for its flaws remains.

    , @QCIC
    @Mikel

    There are plenty of people who will eagerly censor whatever they are told to censor. This is one unspoken reason why censorship is such a pivotal issue for a free society. Once censorship is accepted, there are a great many people who will implement the daily work since it gives them a feeling of power.

    Wars generally lead to censorship, so intentionally starting wars is one way a government can increase control over a population.

    , @Derer
    @Mikel

    Censorship is pure evil, because it is selective and always follows some hidden agenda. It is never neutral and sometime absolutely brainless.

    US government banned the Marlboro billboards, apparently because it is "poisoning our children mind". However, Hollywood creations that are advertising for two hours detail anatomy of killings, sodomizing and more, do not poison our children mind. That is "art" and therefore exempted from censorship.

    We are still awaiting litigation of proven copycat killing by poisoned mind.

  89. @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    It looks likely that the story will finally get resolved this year.
     
    Not the story, only its Ukrainian chapter. Despite your level-headedness, you appear to share Europe-centric delusions of many Europeans.

    The story is about the order in the world. Ukraine is only a small part of it: a bit more important than Afghanistan, but less important than Iran or Israel. Ukrainian conflict, especially hysterical reaction to it of the empire and its cocksuckers, worked as a first pebble that starts the avalanche. Theoretically, that pebble could have been stopped, but nothing can stop the avalanche that it started.

    The story won’t end until the empire is cut down to size, its minions humiliated, the USD (along with Euro) stops being reserve currency, etc. There are many more chapters to go through yet. In the end Ukraine likely won’t even deserve a chapter, just a footnote. The downfall of Europe would deserve a chapter, though.

    Replies: @Beckow

    …The downfall of Europe would deserve a chapter

    I am proudly Euro-centric, made out of Europe, I won’t apologize. You will not find more European geography than the remote valleys and rolling hills north of the middle Danube…it is almost comically Euro. My priority is to preserve the good life here and I will spin ideas in that direction. Whether it is delusional I leave to others. One has to have a point of view, we are not gods

    When this started the Western Europe was in a slow, gradual decline: lack of resources, collapsing big cities, unstoppable migrants…and idiotic liberal fanatics. We were good in the east or central-east\: steadily growing, normal, living safer and more comfortable lives. The Ukie disaster has reversed it…

    The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere – in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia’s propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception and even among them the sentiment is more mixed – who they really hate are the Ukies and Orthodox, but they can’t voice it now.)

    It will be in the Chapter called “Causes“…the stupidity of the Nato’s failed grab of Ukraine makes the wars in the Middle East and Asia much worse for the West. The elemental reality is that with China’s economic might, Middle East-Russian resources, resentful nations of the South, the last thing West needed was to add Russia with its weapons, resources and geography. But they did, for Nato bases, Crimea (nice place) and exiles’ lying stories…maybe a downfall, but I still hope not…I like our quiet valleys.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Beckow


    I am proudly Euro-centric, made out of Europe, I won’t apologize. You will not find more European geography than the remote valleys and rolling hills north of the middle Danube…it is almost comically Euro. My priority is to preserve the good life here
     
    These are forces that sought to destroy it, in the last 100 years:

    Nazism
    Communism
    Mass non-European emigration
    Putin (he is working on Ukraine, Baltics probably next if Ukraine falls, but he supports gangsters further West also)

    You personally support two of those.

    Your country has supported/supports three of the four.

    We were good in the east or central-east\: steadily growing, normal, living safer and more comfortable lives
     
    You were too small to be self-sufficient. You could hope to be ignored for awhile, but it wouldn't last forever.

    The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere – in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia’s propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception
     
    Poles are the largest of the Visegrad countries, with the largest economy. There are more Poles than there are Slovaks, Hungarians, and Czechs combined, with about 10 million more Poles to spare. As such, Poles cannot be considered an exception. Considering Poles an "exception" among Visegrad is about as stupid as saying "Britain, with the exception of the English."

    And Czechs don't like Russians, either. It is only the non-Slavic Hungarians and their traditional lackeys, the Slovaks, who are the exceptional ones.

    I will note that of the 4 phenomena that tried to destroy Europe that I previously described, Poland alone of the Visegrad countries opposed all 4. Czechs and Slovaks supported Commies, Hungarians and Slovaks supported Nazis and support Putin, Poland was correct every time. And has suffered for it.

    who they really hate are the Ukies and Orthodox, but they can’t voice it now
     
    You are ignorant as usual. The small group of ex-colonists have their issues but most Poles like Ukrainians, particularly those who don't speak Russian. There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

    EU is just an Anglo-French-Germany combo – with US managing it, the two Western groupings combined. They also grabbed everything in the vicinity (including Poland). But when they tried to go further east and grab Ukraine, Belarus, Caucasus, the remaining Euro power, Russia, blocked it
     
    Biden chooses to slowly grind down the Russians using Ukrainians to do so. "Blocking" is an American, not Russian decision. Russia helpfully goes along and gets itself slowly demilitarized. Ukrainians have no choice - Russian rule is worse than fighting, so they fight. If America chose to flood Ukraine with better weapons, this would be over.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. XYZ, @Derer, @A123, @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    , @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    You will not find more European geography than the remote valleys and rolling hills north of the middle Danube…it is almost comically Euro. My priority is to preserve the good life here and I will spin ideas in that direction.
     
    As a matter of fact, quite a few patches of Europe, including your neck of woods, will suffer a lot less damage. Culturally hostile migrants flooding Europe do not go to the countryside, they stay in big cities. As those big cities are infested by libtards and therefore doomed, anyway, real rural Europe will be OK. Besides, rural areas are robbed by the rich scum living in the cities, so you might even improve your fortunes when the system collapses.

    What will disappear is Europe as a source of influence on the outside world. All myths about European superiority will wither. But normal life in the countryside might continue, unless you guys start voting for libtards. Libtards everywhere, in Europe, the US, or Russia, have an anti-Midas touch: everything Midas touched turned to gold, everything libtards touch turns to shit.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  90. @Mikel
    @AP


    If you find such a place, let us know.
     
    I'm not too optimistic. The reason why I'm still here is because I've tried in the past but failed at finding any comparable place to discus stuff. Censorship is getting terrible. What a miserable way of making a living, censoring what other people want to say respectfully on a subject. How can these "moderators" of the comments sections in so many newspapers look at themselves in a mirror after making sure, day after day, that lots of people who took the time to write something were silenced, often for petty ideological reasons? I can't imagine any normal person in their childhood dreaming of becoming a censor when they grew up. But the modern internet has created an army of such losers.

    Replies: @AP, @QCIC, @Derer

    Years ago the Atlantic had a nice commenting section using Disqus. It was completely shut down. There was a nice mix of people from the Right and the Left, and a few smart ones.

    This place for its flaws remains.

  91. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    BTW, AP, had the CPs won WWI, would you have felt sad that Poland could not be revived with all of the ethnographically Polish territories? After all, Germany would never give up its own Polish territories without a WWI defeat (thus ensuring that any recreated independent Poland would be landlocked) and even with Austria, it's not guaranteed that Austria would have actually given up Galicia to an independent Poland, though it is possible, especially if Poland agrees to accept a Hapsburg King as the price of this.

    Of course, if a victorious Germany would have created a proto-EU after a WWI victory with both Austria-Hungary and Poland as members, then Poland being landlocked would be less of an issue since Poland would likely have access to the Vistula and to German and Austro-Hungarian ports in such a scenario.

    As a side note, I wonder if the victorious CPs could have actually succeeded in overthrowing the Bolsheviks after a WWI victory or whether they would have simply created a quagmire for themselves, especially if they would have subsequently attempted to install their own puppet regime in Russia as opposed to letting events there play out naturally. I'm unsure that Russians would be very tolerant of a German puppet regime, though maybe Russians would have been so war-weary by this point in time that they would have reluctantly accepted it. What do you think, AP?

    Ukraine of course could have been reintegrated back to Russia in the same way that Russia wanted to reintegrate the Donbass back into Ukraine before 2022--as in, with extremely heavy autonomy and with (pro-German) Ukraine having veto power over Russian national policies in Germany's favor.

    Replies: @AP, @Beckow

    BTW, AP, had the CPs won WWI, would you have felt sad that Poland could not be revived with all of the ethnographically Polish territories?

    Not really. I would have been fine with a small Poland around Warsaw carved out of Russian territories and a Ukraine with Galicia still part of Austria, with Skoropadsky on the throne. I am not a nationalist. And anyways, that would have been far better than our timeline.

    As a side note, I wonder if the victorious CPs could have actually succeeded in overthrowing the Bolsheviks after a WWI victory

    Who knows? An important thing is that tens of millions of Ukrainians and Belarusians would have avoided the Bolshevik nightmare, and whatever state would have existed in Russia would have been too small or weak to threaten the world. Maybe even too weak to dare attempt the mass starvation experiments on the people whom it ruled.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    Not really. I would have been fine with a small Poland around Warsaw carved out of Russian territories and a Ukraine with Galicia still part of Austria, with Skoropadsky on the throne. I am not a nationalist. And anyways, that would have been far better than our timeline.

     

    You're certainly correct about such a scenario being far better than our timeline. BTW, what odds would you place on a victorious Germany creating a proto-EU sooner or later after a WWI victory? As I have previously said, I think that Germany, Austria-Hungary, Poland, the Baltic countries, Finland, and--if it remains independent--Ukraine would be good candidates for membership in this proto-EU, along with possibly Romania and at least some of the Balkan countries and maybe even a defeated France and/or Italy.

    A scenario where an EU can be achieved with much less bloodshed and suffering is always worth fantasizing about, IMHO.

    Who knows? An important thing is that tens of millions of Ukrainians and Belarusians would have avoided the Bolshevik nightmare,
     
    Yep, absolutely. Germany won't be returning Ukraine and Belarus to Russia for so long as the Bolsheviks will remain in power in Russia. If the Germans will succeed in overthrowing the Bolsheviks and keeping them out of power in Russia, though, then Germany could try reintegrating these regions back into Russia in a Donbass-Minsk-style format so that Germany could dominate all of Russia.

    and whatever state would have existed in Russia would have been too small or weak to threaten the world. Maybe even too weak to dare attempt the mass starvation experiments on the people whom it ruled.
     
    TBH, considering that the Khmer Rouge had quite a small state but nevertheless murdered a quarter of Cambodia's population in just four years, I don't have much faith that reducing Russia's size would make the Bolsheviks much more humane towards Russians, especially if Stalin and/or someone similar to him will still eventually come to power in Russia.

    One can, of course, also look at the 1990s North Korean famine. North Korea is also a relatively small country. Much smaller than Russia itself is.
    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    BTW, a slight nitpick, but according to this map, the Germans were supposed to withdraw from Belarus as a part of the Brest-Litovsk Treaty and hand it over to the Bolsheviks:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Brest-Litovsk

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/af/Map_Treaty_Brest-Litovsk.jpg/800px-Map_Treaty_Brest-Litovsk.jpg

    Is this map actually accurate?

  92. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    BTW, AP, had the CPs won WWI, would you have felt sad that Poland could not be revived with all of the ethnographically Polish territories? After all, Germany would never give up its own Polish territories without a WWI defeat (thus ensuring that any recreated independent Poland would be landlocked) and even with Austria, it's not guaranteed that Austria would have actually given up Galicia to an independent Poland, though it is possible, especially if Poland agrees to accept a Hapsburg King as the price of this.

    Of course, if a victorious Germany would have created a proto-EU after a WWI victory with both Austria-Hungary and Poland as members, then Poland being landlocked would be less of an issue since Poland would likely have access to the Vistula and to German and Austro-Hungarian ports in such a scenario.

    As a side note, I wonder if the victorious CPs could have actually succeeded in overthrowing the Bolsheviks after a WWI victory or whether they would have simply created a quagmire for themselves, especially if they would have subsequently attempted to install their own puppet regime in Russia as opposed to letting events there play out naturally. I'm unsure that Russians would be very tolerant of a German puppet regime, though maybe Russians would have been so war-weary by this point in time that they would have reluctantly accepted it. What do you think, AP?

    Ukraine of course could have been reintegrated back to Russia in the same way that Russia wanted to reintegrate the Donbass back into Ukraine before 2022--as in, with extremely heavy autonomy and with (pro-German) Ukraine having veto power over Russian national policies in Germany's favor.

    Replies: @AP, @Beckow

    You are fooling yourself with the CP winning WW1. Demography is destiny, if Germany won WW1 there would be no Poland and no Baltic states – they would take it all and by now the natives would be gone: assimilated or worse.

    The Euro continent dynamic with 3-4 competing powers – Anglo-France, Germany, Russia, Turkey – is unchangeable: the smaller players always eventually fall under one of the powers. EU is just an Anglo-French-Germany combo – with US managing it, the two Western groupings combined. They also grabbed everything in the vicinity (including Poland). But when they tried to go further east and grab Ukraine, Belarus, Caucasus, the remaining Euro power, Russia, blocked it – a bridge too far. As happened before.

    For different reasons the Anglo-Euro hegemon also lost Turkey. What now? They either reverse the catastrophic losses (unlikely in Ukraine or Middle East) or there will be growing internal dissent – they will go after each other since they can’t expand.

    Another scenario is that Europe is transformed into a non-Europe: half American satrapies and half Third World migrants. The two go together – if you don’t realize that by now, you have not been paying attention.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Beckow

    Who in Europe actually wants the Third World migrants to be there?

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Beckow

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @Beckow

    The Germans would want Poland and the Baltics as puppets. They would not want to exterminate them after a WWI victory. The Germans weren't bashit crazy during WWI, unlike during WWII.

    There could be mass Polish and Baltic (and perhaps Ukrainian, Balkan, Italian, et cetera) migration into Germany in this scenario if a proto-EU will eventually be developed and if Germany will actually allow free immigration with these countries, though.

    As a side note, question for AP: Do you think that Russia would have still eventually experienced a revolution without WWI? I know that Petrograd experienced a huge strike wave in July 1914, but it's unclear whether this would have actually been a prelude to a new Russian revolution in WWI's absence. I also know, however, that Russian Tsar Nicholas II wasn't actually serious about the constitutional reforms that he gave the Russian people in 1905-1906 and tried to undermine the Duma and to fill it with loyalists (by I think unilaterally changing the Duma election laws) as much as he could. This could have potentially paved the way for a new large-scale Russian crisis sometime down the road.

    I'm asking because if Russia still eventually descends into revolution without WWI, then this could potentially provide Germany and Austria-Hungary with some good opportunities. They could either offer to help restore a conservative regime in Russia in exchange for Russian conservatives agreeing to end the Franco-Russian alliance and to revive the Three Emperors' League or--alternatively--if Russian conservatives will refuse to agree to these demands, then they can aggressively sponsor any separatist movements in Russia that will accept their support in order to create a buffer zone between themselves and Russia in the event of any future war(s) with Russia.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  93. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ


    BTW, AP, had the CPs won WWI, would you have felt sad that Poland could not be revived with all of the ethnographically Polish territories?
     
    Not really. I would have been fine with a small Poland around Warsaw carved out of Russian territories and a Ukraine with Galicia still part of Austria, with Skoropadsky on the throne. I am not a nationalist. And anyways, that would have been far better than our timeline.

    As a side note, I wonder if the victorious CPs could have actually succeeded in overthrowing the Bolsheviks after a WWI victory
     
    Who knows? An important thing is that tens of millions of Ukrainians and Belarusians would have avoided the Bolshevik nightmare, and whatever state would have existed in Russia would have been too small or weak to threaten the world. Maybe even too weak to dare attempt the mass starvation experiments on the people whom it ruled.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ

    Not really. I would have been fine with a small Poland around Warsaw carved out of Russian territories and a Ukraine with Galicia still part of Austria, with Skoropadsky on the throne. I am not a nationalist. And anyways, that would have been far better than our timeline.

    You’re certainly correct about such a scenario being far better than our timeline. BTW, what odds would you place on a victorious Germany creating a proto-EU sooner or later after a WWI victory? As I have previously said, I think that Germany, Austria-Hungary, Poland, the Baltic countries, Finland, and–if it remains independent–Ukraine would be good candidates for membership in this proto-EU, along with possibly Romania and at least some of the Balkan countries and maybe even a defeated France and/or Italy.

    A scenario where an EU can be achieved with much less bloodshed and suffering is always worth fantasizing about, IMHO.

    Who knows? An important thing is that tens of millions of Ukrainians and Belarusians would have avoided the Bolshevik nightmare,

    Yep, absolutely. Germany won’t be returning Ukraine and Belarus to Russia for so long as the Bolsheviks will remain in power in Russia. If the Germans will succeed in overthrowing the Bolsheviks and keeping them out of power in Russia, though, then Germany could try reintegrating these regions back into Russia in a Donbass-Minsk-style format so that Germany could dominate all of Russia.

    and whatever state would have existed in Russia would have been too small or weak to threaten the world. Maybe even too weak to dare attempt the mass starvation experiments on the people whom it ruled.

    TBH, considering that the Khmer Rouge had quite a small state but nevertheless murdered a quarter of Cambodia’s population in just four years, I don’t have much faith that reducing Russia’s size would make the Bolsheviks much more humane towards Russians, especially if Stalin and/or someone similar to him will still eventually come to power in Russia.

    One can, of course, also look at the 1990s North Korean famine. North Korea is also a relatively small country. Much smaller than Russia itself is.

  94. @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    You are fooling yourself with the CP winning WW1. Demography is destiny, if Germany won WW1 there would be no Poland and no Baltic states - they would take it all and by now the natives would be gone: assimilated or worse.

    The Euro continent dynamic with 3-4 competing powers - Anglo-France, Germany, Russia, Turkey - is unchangeable: the smaller players always eventually fall under one of the powers. EU is just an Anglo-French-Germany combo - with US managing it, the two Western groupings combined. They also grabbed everything in the vicinity (including Poland). But when they tried to go further east and grab Ukraine, Belarus, Caucasus, the remaining Euro power, Russia, blocked it - a bridge too far. As happened before.

    For different reasons the Anglo-Euro hegemon also lost Turkey. What now? They either reverse the catastrophic losses (unlikely in Ukraine or Middle East) or there will be growing internal dissent - they will go after each other since they can't expand.

    Another scenario is that Europe is transformed into a non-Europe: half American satrapies and half Third World migrants. The two go together - if you don't realize that by now, you have not been paying attention.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

    Who in Europe actually wants the Third World migrants to be there?

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @QCIC


    Who in Europe actually wants the Third World migrants to be there?
     
    Libtards have this idiotic desire. Apparently, there are lots of them in Europe. Otherwise, assuming that popular voting still works (which I am not sure about; it does not work in the US), why do you guys elect morons and scum that, among other stupid things, facilitate their migration to Europe?

    Replies: @QCIC

    , @Beckow
    @QCIC


    ...Who in Europe actually wants the Third World migrants to be there?
     
    The coalition of people in power: globo-liberals and their genderite groupies, people living of migration: human rights hustlers, lawyers, charities...businessmen who want to keep wages low (even the migrant threat helps), and tens of millions of relatives who want to bring their cousins-friends to Europe or make money by bringing them.

    It is a very powerful ruling minority and open migration is a matter of utmost importance to them - so they won't let it go, the same is true in US. The overwhelming majority that is against is unfocused and easily intimidated.

  95. @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    You are fooling yourself with the CP winning WW1. Demography is destiny, if Germany won WW1 there would be no Poland and no Baltic states - they would take it all and by now the natives would be gone: assimilated or worse.

    The Euro continent dynamic with 3-4 competing powers - Anglo-France, Germany, Russia, Turkey - is unchangeable: the smaller players always eventually fall under one of the powers. EU is just an Anglo-French-Germany combo - with US managing it, the two Western groupings combined. They also grabbed everything in the vicinity (including Poland). But when they tried to go further east and grab Ukraine, Belarus, Caucasus, the remaining Euro power, Russia, blocked it - a bridge too far. As happened before.

    For different reasons the Anglo-Euro hegemon also lost Turkey. What now? They either reverse the catastrophic losses (unlikely in Ukraine or Middle East) or there will be growing internal dissent - they will go after each other since they can't expand.

    Another scenario is that Europe is transformed into a non-Europe: half American satrapies and half Third World migrants. The two go together - if you don't realize that by now, you have not been paying attention.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

    The Germans would want Poland and the Baltics as puppets. They would not want to exterminate them after a WWI victory. The Germans weren’t bashit crazy during WWI, unlike during WWII.

    There could be mass Polish and Baltic (and perhaps Ukrainian, Balkan, Italian, et cetera) migration into Germany in this scenario if a proto-EU will eventually be developed and if Germany will actually allow free immigration with these countries, though.

    As a side note, question for AP: Do you think that Russia would have still eventually experienced a revolution without WWI? I know that Petrograd experienced a huge strike wave in July 1914, but it’s unclear whether this would have actually been a prelude to a new Russian revolution in WWI’s absence. I also know, however, that Russian Tsar Nicholas II wasn’t actually serious about the constitutional reforms that he gave the Russian people in 1905-1906 and tried to undermine the Duma and to fill it with loyalists (by I think unilaterally changing the Duma election laws) as much as he could. This could have potentially paved the way for a new large-scale Russian crisis sometime down the road.

    I’m asking because if Russia still eventually descends into revolution without WWI, then this could potentially provide Germany and Austria-Hungary with some good opportunities. They could either offer to help restore a conservative regime in Russia in exchange for Russian conservatives agreeing to end the Franco-Russian alliance and to revive the Three Emperors’ League or–alternatively–if Russian conservatives will refuse to agree to these demands, then they can aggressively sponsor any separatist movements in Russia that will accept their support in order to create a buffer zone between themselves and Russia in the event of any future war(s) with Russia.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. XYZ

    A proto-EU ethnic map formed by a hypothetical union of Germany, Poland, and Austria-Hungary:

    https://preview.redd.it/a6h77zcb4g571.png?auto=webp&s=0cc05ff1b1b2cddfcc3844857e5f696b02d9dfb4

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  96. @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN

    We are going back to real history: forget treaties, contracts, electronic wordy bulls--t, who cares? They are all just pieces of paper. This will be more fun.

    I would remind the pro-Nato contingent that if the power gets reshuffled to omit paper and other verbal stuff, it will be the West that will lose more. Its power will be less than the countries with material resources and actual manufacturing. Nato is the West, there is no other way to see it.

    All they had to do was sit on the advantage, pretend to follow their own rules, wait for the ennui to set in among the rivals. But the maps were so tempting...grow and expand! get this or that pretty peninsula (Crimea)...plus the ethnic querulants who yearn to get even...(looking at Mr. Hacks, AP, 'sudden death', LatW...)

    Replies: @AP

    I would remind the pro-Nato contingent that if the power gets reshuffled to omit paper and other verbal stuff, it will be the West that will lose more. Its power will be less than the countries with material resources and actual manufacturing

    USA is the world’s top oil producer. USA + it’s semi-appendage Canada produce nearly twice as much oil as either Russia or Saudi Arabia.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_oil_production

    USA also world’s top natural gas producer:

    https://investingnews.com/top-natural-gas-producers/

    Lithium. South America, but USA exceeds China:

    https://www.nsenergybusiness.com/features/six-largest-lithium-reserves-world/

    USA is the world’s second largest manufacturer, after China. Here the picture is mixed.

    China dominates in steel production:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_steel_production

    Though the EU, Japan, and the USA each exceed Russian steel production.

    In terms of finished goods, a lot of what China manufactures (not all, of course), is cheap stuff that we in the West would not want to make because we’d rather it be very inexpensive. Like mass production of the trinkets including cheap electronics they sell in Walmart.

    Otherwise, USA is number 1 in aircraft production:

    https://www.aerotime.aero/articles/top-10-largest-aircraft-manufacturers-in-the-world

    Almost all Western, Brazil at number 9.

    China leads in automobile production but many Chinese cars are cheap and of poor quality. And the West (which includes Japan) collectively produces more automobiles than does China:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_motor_vehicle_production

    West leads in semiconductor manufacturing (a reason China won’t be given Taiwan for awhile):

    https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/semiconductor-manufacturing-by-country

    Machine tools, China number one, but collective West exceeds it:

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/264213/leading-countries-in-machine-tool-production-based-on-market-share/

    Overall, the combination of natural resources and manufacturing particular high end manufacturing favors the West, especially the USA.

    • Thanks: sudden death
    • Replies: @Beckow
    @AP


    the combination of natural resources and manufacturing particular high end manufacturing favors the West, especially the USA.
     
    My points was: if the power gets reshuffled to omit paper and other verbal stuff, it will be the West that will lose more....do you understand the meaning of lose more?

    In absolute terms the two camps will be roughly equal, the big loser will be Europe that has minimal resources and its manufacturing is not competitive. US-Canada-Australia will do much better - there is a strong opinion in EU that is why US is willing to do this - they are cannibalizing their Euro allies.

    But the collective West will lose more - disproportionate share of the Western economy is derived from soft activities that may go away or shrink: finance, consulting, cultural products, bulls..t jobs in the meta economy (business about business)...

    The anti-West is also growing a lot faster then the West...over time it will get worse. The way to correct it would be to go back to more real economy, but the costs are high and it goes against the dominant liberal ideology. People in the West - in Europe - are not inclined to exchange their comfy subsidized lives and bs jobs for working harder.

    The security-defense boom can cover some of it for a while but it will eventually (soon) lead to lower access to consumer goods and good life. Defense is a lot of things but it doesn't increase living standards - it is an economic black hole: stuff goes in and nothing comes out...

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @A123, @AP

    , @Gerard1234
    @AP


    USA is the world’s top oil producer. USA + it’s semi-appendage Canada produce nearly twice as much oil as either Russia or Saudi Arabia.
     
    US is a net IMPORTER of oil relative to what it produces you bimbo dumbf**k, domestic consumption is of course huge, which limits US export potential. Power comes from ability to control supply and demand of the world market you idiot, not from the self-sufficiency. With situation as it is and continues developing, US will be deprived of significant power on oil and gas markets.....Europe deprived of oil and gas ( well, oil and gas and decent prices in addition to the volume issue)

    USA also world’s top natural gas producer:
     
    Again, satisfying domestic demands you idiot, that won't come close to satisfying Europe's demand and Pindostan's inability for political and feasibility reasons to build a gas pipeline network connecting them to export all through south and central America (shipping of course export much less volume). Or, thanks to over a century of American scum f**king over that region....is South and central America likely to have enough demand for gas in comparison to Europe, despite their large populations.......because of course American "help" in the region has not lifted their living standards much.


    Otherwise, USA is number 1 in aircraft production:
     
    Of course aircraft manufacture has "nothing" in connection with Titanium and Aluminium , LMAO you POS!
    If you're linking something then it is certain to be BS & totally Dishonest. Link does not list for most of them the number of aircraft produced, and Sukhoi and other Russian companies have more workers than most of those on the list you stupid retard.

    China leads in automobile production but many Chinese cars are cheap and of poor quality.
     
    Of course, you are completely clueless on the matter and only recycling something from somewhere else and have zero experience of the issue. In reality ( previous eras were far more superior in car design IMO) , there is becoming an equilibrium /near standardisation of saloon and SUV design around the world - petrol/hybrid/electric it doesn't matter - even Romanian and Chinese car manufacturers are producing vehicles that look and drive the same as western manufacturers ....and for the interior have the same electronic features on the dashboard, same anti-collision warning, cameras, seat heating gadgets etc as them also.

    Replies: @AP

  97. @Mikel
    @AP


    If you find such a place, let us know.
     
    I'm not too optimistic. The reason why I'm still here is because I've tried in the past but failed at finding any comparable place to discus stuff. Censorship is getting terrible. What a miserable way of making a living, censoring what other people want to say respectfully on a subject. How can these "moderators" of the comments sections in so many newspapers look at themselves in a mirror after making sure, day after day, that lots of people who took the time to write something were silenced, often for petty ideological reasons? I can't imagine any normal person in their childhood dreaming of becoming a censor when they grew up. But the modern internet has created an army of such losers.

    Replies: @AP, @QCIC, @Derer

    There are plenty of people who will eagerly censor whatever they are told to censor. This is one unspoken reason why censorship is such a pivotal issue for a free society. Once censorship is accepted, there are a great many people who will implement the daily work since it gives them a feeling of power.

    Wars generally lead to censorship, so intentionally starting wars is one way a government can increase control over a population.

  98. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ


    BTW, AP, had the CPs won WWI, would you have felt sad that Poland could not be revived with all of the ethnographically Polish territories?
     
    Not really. I would have been fine with a small Poland around Warsaw carved out of Russian territories and a Ukraine with Galicia still part of Austria, with Skoropadsky on the throne. I am not a nationalist. And anyways, that would have been far better than our timeline.

    As a side note, I wonder if the victorious CPs could have actually succeeded in overthrowing the Bolsheviks after a WWI victory
     
    Who knows? An important thing is that tens of millions of Ukrainians and Belarusians would have avoided the Bolshevik nightmare, and whatever state would have existed in Russia would have been too small or weak to threaten the world. Maybe even too weak to dare attempt the mass starvation experiments on the people whom it ruled.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ

    BTW, a slight nitpick, but according to this map, the Germans were supposed to withdraw from Belarus as a part of the Brest-Litovsk Treaty and hand it over to the Bolsheviks:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Brest-Litovsk

    Is this map actually accurate?

  99. @QCIC
    @Beckow

    Who in Europe actually wants the Third World migrants to be there?

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Beckow

    Who in Europe actually wants the Third World migrants to be there?

    Libtards have this idiotic desire. Apparently, there are lots of them in Europe. Otherwise, assuming that popular voting still works (which I am not sure about; it does not work in the US), why do you guys elect morons and scum that, among other stupid things, facilitate their migration to Europe?

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @AnonfromTN

    My theory is that many people in the USA have accepted this immigrant situation but do not really believe in it. Maybe they embrace it out of some combination of foolishness and insanity.

    For sure there are many who benefit from the cheap labor, but they may not realize the total benefit to them is a net negative, probably even in real time. I have a hunch that as soon as the women start having kids the cost to the system rapidly outweighs the value of the cheap labor. Since "they are not sending their best" there is no long term payoff, either.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AP

  100. @Beckow
    @A123

    The drama with Trump will be this year. If he gets into the office - I am skeptical - everything will change. The fat guy has walked off the stage and the Indian harridan is still shrieking...this is still the intro chapter.

    Given the stereotype about Americans, why would anyone consider for President extremely fat people, elderly dementia patient or childless (one kid doesn't count) women with some "color" at the edge of hysteria?

    It feeds the stereotype and it is really bad marketing. US built up its cultural dominance with good marketing, and now what? How about an elderly fat woman of color with dementia - is there one like that? They should bring it on and go out in a blaze of glory...

    Russia had an elderly dork with a speech impediment and vaguely Ukie name right before the collapse started in the mid-80's...that's the way to do it.

    Replies: @A123

    The drama with Trump will be this year. If he gets into the office – I am skeptical – everything will change.

    This goes back to the discussions I have had with Mikel. Expectations have to be reasonable. There will be “some positive change” not “everything will change”.

    In his 1st term — House, Senate, Judiciary, and deep state were all in opposition to MAGA. Trump’s 2nd term should feature more MAGA support from the House and Senate, which will correspondingly yield more appropriations and better confirmations. However, it will still be short of Mikel’s impossible standard, 100% of absolutely everything! Instantly!

    Trump has spent the last 4 years building up what Barbarosa refers to as Soft Power. RINO’s have been primaried and driven from office, notably the reprehensible Liz Cheney. Endorsements, rallies, and fund raisers give Trump favours to call in on critical votes.

    It took decades to dig the SJW Islamophile Globalist hole America is in. It will take a comparable amount of time to recover. Trump’s 2nd term is only one step on the MAGA road. Key will be finding a successor (who may not be the VP). Kari Lake perhaps?

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    You claim what Ansarullah are doing in the Red Sea is separate from the situation in Gaza, and your reasoning?

    Both Hizbullah's and Ansarullah's military campaigns are in support of Palestine.


    How long will Xi support Ansar Allah interrupting Zionist Entity commerce?
     
    Chinese proverb

    A single child’s life is worth more than all the cargo that goes through the Bab al-Mandab Strait.


    https://twitter.com/Aldanmarki/status/1746180754713846023


    😇

    Replies: @A123

  101. Sher Singh says:
    @Yahya
    @Sher Singh


    Alphaprogression App

     

    I'm using the "Gym Workout Planner & Trainer" app. Works well for me.

    Reverse Grip Bench
     
    Looks interesting.

    How many sets do you perform per muscle group each week?

    Replies: @Sher Singh

    [MORE]

    6 day Upper-Lower Full Body Hybrid – Alpha Progression ਅਕਾਲ

    Long as the app has progress recommendations it’s good.
    Alpha is good cuz let’s say I did 150×10 for RIR 2 on Week 1.

    Week 3 I want to sets of 6 it’ll keep in the same RIR & might have me do 175×6.
    Tracking 10RM is IMO superior for bodybuilding.


    Keep in mind I was doing close to 40 sets a session a few months back.
    This is just my current way to balance 6x a week with fatigue/life.

    Alpha means I can make consistent progress without guesswork.
    When it stalls, I’ll add/subtract volume or w/e.

    What’s your favorite bicep exercises?
    Not really feeling barbell or DB curls & don’t have a low pulley or incline bench.

    :/

    • Replies: @Sher Singh
    @Sher Singh

    https://imgur com/a/A9TCCaY

    Link broken, but that's my full split.
    Did it for a friend.

    Here's the guide from Mike Israetel: (under more)

    https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/781336597492662312/1187832641127456858/image.png

    https://ryanlefebvre.github.io/RP-Hypertrophy-Hub-Visualizer/#/

    Tbh, I think viewing it from a weekly angle is wrong for a few reasons.
    Based on my experience, you should aim for a X frequency & Y volume per session.

    At that point, your weekly volume will be fine.
    That 8-20 sets per week is a broad guideline encompassing both free weights & machines.

    Since I only use barbell, cable or dumbbell I tend towards lower end & just do what's comfortable.
    --
    I have ran programs where you increase by 1 set per week.
    It's brutal, but sort of works - haven't tried it since Alpha Progression (Got it Last Nov).

    What I do now is just change reps every few weeks, but do sets by feel.
    --
    When you do too much volume you tend to just rest more & your 5x week turns into 5x in 10 days.

    Replies: @Sher Singh

    , @Yahya
    @Sher Singh


    What’s your favorite bicep exercises?
     
    E-Z Bar Curls

    I used to train 5 times per week when bulking, but have since embarked on cutting phase and reduced my sessions to 4 times per week on a minimalist program a-la Jeff Nippard.

    https://youtu.be/xc4OtzAnVMI?si=lf8H_binuuLGsc2p

    Right now I’m pissed since I didn’t lose any weight over the past week despite being on a ~500 calorie deficit. Could be due to factors related to carb intake or water retention, but frustrating to see no gains in that area. Thinking of reducing my calorie deficit by another 200kcal per day, see if it will work.

    Replies: @Sher Singh

  102. @QCIC
    @songbird

    Around the year 2016, Scott Adams had a sincere-sounding rant I can paraphrase like the following. He said that when Hillary Clinton gave nationally televised speeches, the testosterone level of the entire country went down.

    Replies: @songbird

    Supposedly, you can hook a really good mass spectrometer to a theater somehow, and you’ll get these different spikes of volatile organic compounds, that seem to reoccur at different showings. Different VOCs spiking with different scenes.

    Carbon dioxide, isoprene at tense moments. Some scenes, the chemical combinations are like fingerprints, with which the scene can be identified just from the reading, without a timestamp. But they can’t explain it fully.

    You need a big crowd. Doesn’t work when it’s poorly attended.

    And there are changes in the blood too. The blood gets ready to clot, while watching a horror movie.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @songbird

    I can believe it. Your dog understands.

    , @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    https://boingboing.net/2010/10/20/jacques-vallees-stat.html

    I, Product
    Jacques Vallee
    Boingboing

    Replies: @songbird

  103. @AnonfromTN
    @QCIC


    Who in Europe actually wants the Third World migrants to be there?
     
    Libtards have this idiotic desire. Apparently, there are lots of them in Europe. Otherwise, assuming that popular voting still works (which I am not sure about; it does not work in the US), why do you guys elect morons and scum that, among other stupid things, facilitate their migration to Europe?

    Replies: @QCIC

    My theory is that many people in the USA have accepted this immigrant situation but do not really believe in it. Maybe they embrace it out of some combination of foolishness and insanity.

    For sure there are many who benefit from the cheap labor, but they may not realize the total benefit to them is a net negative, probably even in real time. I have a hunch that as soon as the women start having kids the cost to the system rapidly outweighs the value of the cheap labor. Since “they are not sending their best” there is no long term payoff, either.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @QCIC

    If there is so much money to be made why aren't the Chinese doing it?

    Replies: @QCIC

    , @AP
    @QCIC

    Most Americans support immigration:

    https://news.gallup.com/poll/508520/americans-value-immigration-concerns.aspx

    Two-thirds of Americans consider immigration a good thing for the country, while 27% consider it a bad thing. The percentage calling it a good thing is down from its peak of 77% in 2020 and is the lowest Gallup has recorded since 2014 (when it was 63%).

    While barely a quarter of Americans consider immigration a bad thing for the country, that view is far more prevalent among Republicans (43%) than Democrats (10%), with independents roughly matching the nation as a whole (28%). Still, half of Republicans consider it a good thing, as do 67% of independents and 87% of Democrats.

    That poll found few in favor of increasing immigration (7%), while the rest were split between wanting it kept the same (39%), wanting it decreased (33%) or unsure (20%).

    Replies: @Derer, @Mr. XYZ, @Emil Nikola Richard, @QCIC

  104. @songbird
    @QCIC

    Supposedly, you can hook a really good mass spectrometer to a theater somehow, and you'll get these different spikes of volatile organic compounds, that seem to reoccur at different showings. Different VOCs spiking with different scenes.

    Carbon dioxide, isoprene at tense moments. Some scenes, the chemical combinations are like fingerprints, with which the scene can be identified just from the reading, without a timestamp. But they can't explain it fully.

    You need a big crowd. Doesn't work when it's poorly attended.

    And there are changes in the blood too. The blood gets ready to clot, while watching a horror movie.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Emil Nikola Richard

    I can believe it. Your dog understands.

  105. @songbird
    @QCIC

    Supposedly, you can hook a really good mass spectrometer to a theater somehow, and you'll get these different spikes of volatile organic compounds, that seem to reoccur at different showings. Different VOCs spiking with different scenes.

    Carbon dioxide, isoprene at tense moments. Some scenes, the chemical combinations are like fingerprints, with which the scene can be identified just from the reading, without a timestamp. But they can't explain it fully.

    You need a big crowd. Doesn't work when it's poorly attended.

    And there are changes in the blood too. The blood gets ready to clot, while watching a horror movie.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Emil Nikola Richard

    • Replies: @songbird
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Only listened to the author give an interview on a podcast, but he did mention how certain breeds of dogs have a popularity spike after they star in movies.

    Maybe, they need to keep cinema alive to data-harvest gases. Would be interesting to test different demographic groups, to see if there are any HBD angles.

  106. @QCIC
    @AnonfromTN

    My theory is that many people in the USA have accepted this immigrant situation but do not really believe in it. Maybe they embrace it out of some combination of foolishness and insanity.

    For sure there are many who benefit from the cheap labor, but they may not realize the total benefit to them is a net negative, probably even in real time. I have a hunch that as soon as the women start having kids the cost to the system rapidly outweighs the value of the cheap labor. Since "they are not sending their best" there is no long term payoff, either.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AP

    If there is so much money to be made why aren’t the Chinese doing it?

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Recent photos from the border suggest the Chinese are getting in on the act! Of course those guys may be PLA...

  107. BTW, AP, do you consider Frederick the Great to be a moderately bad historical figure for taking Silesia from Austria and thus weakening Austria? In the industrial era, having Silesia would have significantly benefitted Austria due to its large amounts of industries and natural resources. And it could have formed a part of a larger economic unit together with Czechia’s industries (which were under Austrian rule back then).

    Or do you ultimately adopt the mentality that Frederick the Great’s actions helped pave the way for unifying Germany in the long-run (by significantly strengthening Prussia, which ultimately ended up unifying Germany long after Frederick’s death) and that since Germany ended up being Austria-Hungary’s benevolent protector (from 1879 with the Dual Alliance until 1918 when both the German Empire and Austria-Hungary collapsed and descended into revolution, a time period of almost 40 years), the harm that he did by taking Silesia from Austria is outweighed by the good that he did in the long-run in regards to geopolitics?

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. XYZ

    The main thing that can be said in Frederick's defense in taking Silesia is that most of Silesia (excluding Polish-majority Upper Silesia) appears to have been Protestant like the rest of Prussia back then:

    https://i.pinimg.com/originals/95/2b/7e/952b7ed9dc3d9c021c1e014b322758d5.jpg

    (The Rhineland was Catholic but generally only became a part of Prussia in 1815, which was almost three decades after Frederick's death.)

  108. @Mr. XYZ
    BTW, AP, do you consider Frederick the Great to be a moderately bad historical figure for taking Silesia from Austria and thus weakening Austria? In the industrial era, having Silesia would have significantly benefitted Austria due to its large amounts of industries and natural resources. And it could have formed a part of a larger economic unit together with Czechia's industries (which were under Austrian rule back then).

    Or do you ultimately adopt the mentality that Frederick the Great's actions helped pave the way for unifying Germany in the long-run (by significantly strengthening Prussia, which ultimately ended up unifying Germany long after Frederick's death) and that since Germany ended up being Austria-Hungary's benevolent protector (from 1879 with the Dual Alliance until 1918 when both the German Empire and Austria-Hungary collapsed and descended into revolution, a time period of almost 40 years), the harm that he did by taking Silesia from Austria is outweighed by the good that he did in the long-run in regards to geopolitics?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    The main thing that can be said in Frederick’s defense in taking Silesia is that most of Silesia (excluding Polish-majority Upper Silesia) appears to have been Protestant like the rest of Prussia back then:

    (The Rhineland was Catholic but generally only became a part of Prussia in 1815, which was almost three decades after Frederick’s death.)

  109. @Mr. XYZ
    @Beckow

    The Germans would want Poland and the Baltics as puppets. They would not want to exterminate them after a WWI victory. The Germans weren't bashit crazy during WWI, unlike during WWII.

    There could be mass Polish and Baltic (and perhaps Ukrainian, Balkan, Italian, et cetera) migration into Germany in this scenario if a proto-EU will eventually be developed and if Germany will actually allow free immigration with these countries, though.

    As a side note, question for AP: Do you think that Russia would have still eventually experienced a revolution without WWI? I know that Petrograd experienced a huge strike wave in July 1914, but it's unclear whether this would have actually been a prelude to a new Russian revolution in WWI's absence. I also know, however, that Russian Tsar Nicholas II wasn't actually serious about the constitutional reforms that he gave the Russian people in 1905-1906 and tried to undermine the Duma and to fill it with loyalists (by I think unilaterally changing the Duma election laws) as much as he could. This could have potentially paved the way for a new large-scale Russian crisis sometime down the road.

    I'm asking because if Russia still eventually descends into revolution without WWI, then this could potentially provide Germany and Austria-Hungary with some good opportunities. They could either offer to help restore a conservative regime in Russia in exchange for Russian conservatives agreeing to end the Franco-Russian alliance and to revive the Three Emperors' League or--alternatively--if Russian conservatives will refuse to agree to these demands, then they can aggressively sponsor any separatist movements in Russia that will accept their support in order to create a buffer zone between themselves and Russia in the event of any future war(s) with Russia.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    A proto-EU ethnic map formed by a hypothetical union of Germany, Poland, and Austria-Hungary:

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mr. XYZ

    I don't think it was hypothetical in 1940. : )

  110. @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. XYZ

    A proto-EU ethnic map formed by a hypothetical union of Germany, Poland, and Austria-Hungary:

    https://preview.redd.it/a6h77zcb4g571.png?auto=webp&s=0cc05ff1b1b2cddfcc3844857e5f696b02d9dfb4

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    I don’t think it was hypothetical in 1940. : )

  111. @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN


    ...The downfall of Europe would deserve a chapter
     
    I am proudly Euro-centric, made out of Europe, I won't apologize. You will not find more European geography than the remote valleys and rolling hills north of the middle Danube...it is almost comically Euro. My priority is to preserve the good life here and I will spin ideas in that direction. Whether it is delusional I leave to others. One has to have a point of view, we are not gods...

    When this started the Western Europe was in a slow, gradual decline: lack of resources, collapsing big cities, unstoppable migrants...and idiotic liberal fanatics. We were good in the east or central-east\: steadily growing, normal, living safer and more comfortable lives. The Ukie disaster has reversed it...

    The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere - in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia's propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception and even among them the sentiment is more mixed - who they really hate are the Ukies and Orthodox, but they can't voice it now.)

    It will be in the Chapter called "Causes"...the stupidity of the Nato's failed grab of Ukraine makes the wars in the Middle East and Asia much worse for the West. The elemental reality is that with China's economic might, Middle East-Russian resources, resentful nations of the South, the last thing West needed was to add Russia with its weapons, resources and geography. But they did, for Nato bases, Crimea (nice place) and exiles' lying stories...maybe a downfall, but I still hope not...I like our quiet valleys.

    Replies: @AP, @AnonfromTN

    I am proudly Euro-centric, made out of Europe, I won’t apologize. You will not find more European geography than the remote valleys and rolling hills north of the middle Danube…it is almost comically Euro. My priority is to preserve the good life here

    These are forces that sought to destroy it, in the last 100 years:

    Nazism
    Communism
    Mass non-European emigration
    Putin (he is working on Ukraine, Baltics probably next if Ukraine falls, but he supports gangsters further West also)

    You personally support two of those.

    Your country has supported/supports three of the four.

    We were good in the east or central-east\: steadily growing, normal, living safer and more comfortable lives

    You were too small to be self-sufficient. You could hope to be ignored for awhile, but it wouldn’t last forever.

    The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere – in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia’s propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception

    Poles are the largest of the Visegrad countries, with the largest economy. There are more Poles than there are Slovaks, Hungarians, and Czechs combined, with about 10 million more Poles to spare. As such, Poles cannot be considered an exception. Considering Poles an “exception” among Visegrad is about as stupid as saying “Britain, with the exception of the English.”

    And Czechs don’t like Russians, either. It is only the non-Slavic Hungarians and their traditional lackeys, the Slovaks, who are the exceptional ones.

    I will note that of the 4 phenomena that tried to destroy Europe that I previously described, Poland alone of the Visegrad countries opposed all 4. Czechs and Slovaks supported Commies, Hungarians and Slovaks supported Nazis and support Putin, Poland was correct every time. And has suffered for it.

    who they really hate are the Ukies and Orthodox, but they can’t voice it now

    You are ignorant as usual. The small group of ex-colonists have their issues but most Poles like Ukrainians, particularly those who don’t speak Russian. There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

    EU is just an Anglo-French-Germany combo – with US managing it, the two Western groupings combined. They also grabbed everything in the vicinity (including Poland). But when they tried to go further east and grab Ukraine, Belarus, Caucasus, the remaining Euro power, Russia, blocked it

    Biden chooses to slowly grind down the Russians using Ukrainians to do so. “Blocking” is an American, not Russian decision. Russia helpfully goes along and gets itself slowly demilitarized. Ukrainians have no choice – Russian rule is worse than fighting, so they fight. If America chose to flood Ukraine with better weapons, this would be over.

    • Replies: @AP
    @AP


    Mass non-European emigration
     
    migration
    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    Mass non-European emigration

     

    It's likely the working-class Muslims and Africans that have most of the bad apples, no? Indians have integrated into, say, Britain pretty well, as have Chinese. African elites have also probably integrated into Britain pretty well. (I'm just using Britain as an example here.) Even among the Muslims, the more elite types, such as Haider al-Abadi, appear to have integrated well in Britain, in his case before moving back to Iraq after Saddam Hussein's fall in 2003 due to patriotic considerations and eventually becoming Iraq's Prime Minister in the 2014-2018 time period.

    Poland was correct every time. And has suffered for it.

     

    By resisting the Nazis, Poland also increased the odds that its Ashkenazi Jewish cognitive elite would be murdered en masse. (Hungary was able to have Hitler spare its own Jews until it foolishly decided to backstab Hitler in 1944.) Maybe Polish nationalists would not be too upset by this since they weren't the ones who were doing the killing and since in any case Poland was apparently trying to get a lot of its Jews to emigrate in the interwar years (apparently in order to make it easier for gentile Poles to advance economically, et cetera, which would have been easier with less Jewish competition). But still, it was a huge loss for both Poland and for humanity in general considering just how accomplished Ashkenazi Jews have been throughout history.

    Poland ended up getting Communism shoved down its throat in 1945 anyway. Preemptively implicitly agreeing to this in 1939 (by allying with the Soviet Union along with the Anglo-French) would have changed nothing in regards to this but would have resulted in much less Polish and Soviet suffering in WWII. But of course neither the Poles nor the West could actually foresee this. They didn't anticipate France falling in 1940. Though they should have anticipated the Nazis' ability to thoroughly brutalize Poland, albeit perhaps not to the level of outright genocide, before the Anglo-French would have actually succeeded in liberating it. Berlin would need to be liberated before Poland would, after all, and there would have been a chance of the Soviet Union entering the war at the last minute, after the Anglo-French have been bled dry, in order to try grabbing as much territory for both itself and the Communist cause as it could.

    (Zionist/Israeli Jews would have been delighted had much more of Polish Jewry survived the Holocaust since those people were by and large the people who were expected to build Israel in the future prior to the Holocaust mass-murdering 90% of them.)

    Biden chooses to slowly grind down the Russians using Ukrainians to do so. “Blocking” is an American, not Russian decision. Russia helpfully goes along and gets itself slowly demilitarized. Ukrainians have no choice – Russian rule is worse than fighting, so they fight. If America chose to flood Ukraine with better weapons, this would be over.

     

    Maybe Ukraine could get those better weapons if Haley will win in 2024. With Trump, I'm more skeptical, and of course I dislike Trump in general. Biden will probably be more of the same, though who knows? There might be a chance of very, very gradual escalation with Biden. Making the Russian frog boil harder ever more slowly so that it doesn't notice.
    , @Derer
    @AP


    There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.
     
    Only illiterate. Do not forget the J yoke in Poland is as strong as in Ukraine.

    Replies: @AP

    , @A123
    @AP


    These are forces that sought to destroy [Europe], in the last 100 years:

    Nazism
    Communism
    Mass non-European emigration
    Putin
     
    The problem with your assertion is that Putin seeks to avoid being destroyed by IslamoGloboHomo Europe. Merkel constructed Zelensky as a dagger to slit Russia's throat. She missed the cut, and Ukraine is going to pay a steep price for her failure. Other European leaders like Scholz and Macron, all-in on Kiev aggression, continue to make the situation worse.

    Mass non-European migration, especially of Muslims has been disastrous. Again, Angela "Welcome Rape-ugees" Merkel is again central to this initiating this attack on Judeo-Christians. Germany funds transports bringing invaders to Europe. And, Scholz is outraged that AfD supports "re-migration".

    It extraordinarily obvious that:

    -- Muslim Colonists are the problem.
    -- Muslim Decolonization is the answer.

    How many problems would be immediately solved if European Christendom was 99%+ Muslim free? Crime would plummet. The need for public assistance would shrink. Housing would be less expensive. Wages would be higher. Almost everything would be better.

    Why must Christian European workers suffer for the balance sheets of Islamophile Frankfurt banks? It makes no sense.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    , @Beckow
    @AP


    ...There are more Poles than...
     
    Than what? Nobody cares about the Poles, they are only bloody tools for anyone who they are currently in love with. They line like lemmings and die for the others. What they think makes no difference because we don't take their hatreds seriously.

    I was not limiting it to V4: Austria, Slovenia, Croatia, Serbia - even large parts of Germany and Italy are more level-headed. The Poles can march on and invade Russia with their Anglo allies - it would work like this: Anglos talk and ship "weapons" and the Poles die. Then you write a thank you note to your masters in London-Washington...maybe even to Berlin.

    100 years misery? You bark your inane "Habsburg" nonsense. Let me remind you that it was by far the worst in terms of human rights, freedom, oppression, number of people in prison for wrong views, under the Habsburg feudal monarchy that you so stupidly celebrate. Only Nazis exceeded it in WW2.

    If you want to compare, it was the Poles who sided first with the Nazi Germany in Munich 1938, Poland was a brutal dictatorship in the 1930's...after 1945 there were 3 million Polish commies all the way till the end...in 1968 Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia the Poles were the second largest army - so you are hallucinating, but you are losing the war so we will give you some slack...:)

    Replies: @AP

    , @Gerard1234
    @AP


    I will note that of the 4 phenomena that tried to destroy Europe that I previously described, Poland alone of the Visegrad countries opposed all 4.

    Nazism
    Communism
    Mass non-European emigration
    Putin (he is working on Ukraine, Baltics probably next if Ukraine falls, but he supports gangsters further West also)
     
    LMFAO, you dumbf**k fantasist

    1. Poles were Hitlers best alllies you stupid idiot. Poles were the Japanese best allies on the planet you stupid idiot. Poland was ideologically identical to Nazi Germany - even more fascist and just as anti-semitic.

    The 1939 disagreement with the Nazi's and Poles was because Polish Nazis ( Poles) were even more imperialistic than the Nazis. They were hungry for far-more land than what even the Nazis were wanting.

    2. LOL a Poland-Czechoslovakia-France pact would have prevented WW2 immediately.

    3. Communism was not "evil" and did not try to destroy Europe you worthless scumbag. It of course cannot be compared to Nazism in attempt to destroy Europe.

    4. Poles, LMAO, took Communism up the a$$ for 50 years without attempting to resist it you POS

    5. Poland does not "resist mass non-European" migration. If it had to decide between being part of western institutions/receive FDI etc or "resisting mass non-European migration" ........then it would choose being part of western institutions and the prostitute of other countries , as it has been for half a millennium. Its a pointless statement - for the average German, Scandinavian or Brit- the Pole is of course much closer to the African in their estimation than they are to themselves.......and they have allowed millions of Poles to migrate to their countries for cheap labour. So Poles are not "resisting" but as is typical for them, being hypocrites, parasites and pussies.

    6. Difficult to underscale the level of bimbo stupidity in "Putin trying to destroy Europe", or "Poles resisting" comments. Putin has of course been looking to work with Europe ...... that Europe and Pindostan have decided to go against the worlds biggest commodities supplier, important on many different issues.....for a failed, fake, poorest-country in Europe, shithole, whore-infected white 3rd world, nuthouse country, that manufactures nothing - is something they have to live with and is indirectly getting most of them voted out of power

    Poles are the largest of the Visegrad countries, with the largest economy. There are more Poles than there are Slovaks, Hungarians, and Czechs combined, with about 10 million more Poles to spare. As such, Poles cannot be considered an exception. Considering Poles an “exception” among Visegrad is about as stupid as saying “Britain, with the exception of the English.”
     
    That piece of retardation from yourself is like comparing Bangladeshis to Japanese in world importance despite their equalish size populations. In reality Slovaks/Czechs and Hungarians each have equal , well alot MORE prominence and prestige around the world now and historically , despite there much smaller populations and size than Poland. This is of course because Poland has been a blackhole in contribution to anything in Europe for its entire existence. The scientific, cultural contribution of those 3 countries is gigantic compared to Polands non-existant one. Slovaks/Czechs and Hungarians have real economy and stable populations......not ones artificially inflated by misleading and misdirected FDI and cheap labour from ukrops.

    The rest of your nonsense is even more bimbo-drivel

    You are ignorant as usual. The small group of ex-colonists have their issues but most Poles like Ukrainians, particularly those who don’t speak Russian. There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

     

    You have never been to Poland, Russia or Ukraine and, as proven many times, can't speak a word of any of their languages. You have of course just done some more instantaneous BS there. Beckow, different to you has knowledge of this area and these people and speaks with credibility . Poles fighting there because they are illiterate anti-Russians, not because of "loving Ukrainians", history has proven these 2 sets of dickheads can't live together for 2 seconds. Russians and "Ukrainians" lived together for 300 years.

    Replies: @China Japan and Korea Bromance of Three Kingdoms, @AP

  112. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @QCIC

    If there is so much money to be made why aren't the Chinese doing it?

    Replies: @QCIC

    Recent photos from the border suggest the Chinese are getting in on the act! Of course those guys may be PLA…

  113. @AP
    @Beckow


    I am proudly Euro-centric, made out of Europe, I won’t apologize. You will not find more European geography than the remote valleys and rolling hills north of the middle Danube…it is almost comically Euro. My priority is to preserve the good life here
     
    These are forces that sought to destroy it, in the last 100 years:

    Nazism
    Communism
    Mass non-European emigration
    Putin (he is working on Ukraine, Baltics probably next if Ukraine falls, but he supports gangsters further West also)

    You personally support two of those.

    Your country has supported/supports three of the four.

    We were good in the east or central-east\: steadily growing, normal, living safer and more comfortable lives
     
    You were too small to be self-sufficient. You could hope to be ignored for awhile, but it wouldn't last forever.

    The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere – in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia’s propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception
     
    Poles are the largest of the Visegrad countries, with the largest economy. There are more Poles than there are Slovaks, Hungarians, and Czechs combined, with about 10 million more Poles to spare. As such, Poles cannot be considered an exception. Considering Poles an "exception" among Visegrad is about as stupid as saying "Britain, with the exception of the English."

    And Czechs don't like Russians, either. It is only the non-Slavic Hungarians and their traditional lackeys, the Slovaks, who are the exceptional ones.

    I will note that of the 4 phenomena that tried to destroy Europe that I previously described, Poland alone of the Visegrad countries opposed all 4. Czechs and Slovaks supported Commies, Hungarians and Slovaks supported Nazis and support Putin, Poland was correct every time. And has suffered for it.

    who they really hate are the Ukies and Orthodox, but they can’t voice it now
     
    You are ignorant as usual. The small group of ex-colonists have their issues but most Poles like Ukrainians, particularly those who don't speak Russian. There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

    EU is just an Anglo-French-Germany combo – with US managing it, the two Western groupings combined. They also grabbed everything in the vicinity (including Poland). But when they tried to go further east and grab Ukraine, Belarus, Caucasus, the remaining Euro power, Russia, blocked it
     
    Biden chooses to slowly grind down the Russians using Ukrainians to do so. "Blocking" is an American, not Russian decision. Russia helpfully goes along and gets itself slowly demilitarized. Ukrainians have no choice - Russian rule is worse than fighting, so they fight. If America chose to flood Ukraine with better weapons, this would be over.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. XYZ, @Derer, @A123, @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    Mass non-European emigration

    migration

  114. @QCIC
    @AnonfromTN

    My theory is that many people in the USA have accepted this immigrant situation but do not really believe in it. Maybe they embrace it out of some combination of foolishness and insanity.

    For sure there are many who benefit from the cheap labor, but they may not realize the total benefit to them is a net negative, probably even in real time. I have a hunch that as soon as the women start having kids the cost to the system rapidly outweighs the value of the cheap labor. Since "they are not sending their best" there is no long term payoff, either.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AP

    Most Americans support immigration:

    https://news.gallup.com/poll/508520/americans-value-immigration-concerns.aspx

    Two-thirds of Americans consider immigration a good thing for the country, while 27% consider it a bad thing. The percentage calling it a good thing is down from its peak of 77% in 2020 and is the lowest Gallup has recorded since 2014 (when it was 63%).

    While barely a quarter of Americans consider immigration a bad thing for the country, that view is far more prevalent among Republicans (43%) than Democrats (10%), with independents roughly matching the nation as a whole (28%). Still, half of Republicans consider it a good thing, as do 67% of independents and 87% of Democrats.

    That poll found few in favor of increasing immigration (7%), while the rest were split between wanting it kept the same (39%), wanting it decreased (33%) or unsure (20%).

    • Replies: @Derer
    @AP


    Most Americans support immigration:
     
    It should read most Democrats support immigration. Who built the wall and who oppose it to keep bringing other countries rejects. Those that are doing fine will not leave their homeland. The exemption is political immigration, however in most cases the prevalence of deceit is substantial.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    That poll found few in favor of increasing immigration (7%), while the rest were split between wanting it kept the same (39%), wanting it decreased (33%) or unsure (20%).

     

    The data that you reference here is from 1965:

    Gallup takes the public’s temperature on the volume of immigration by asking if immigration should be kept at its present level, increased or decreased. This was first measured in 1965, when Congress passed the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965 that reformed federal immigration policy. That poll found few in favor of increasing immigration (7%), while the rest were split between wanting it kept the same (39%), wanting it decreased (33%) or unsure (20%).

     

    From your very same link, I found this:

    Given the major increase in the number of migrants seeking to enter the U.S. at the Southern border in recent years, Americans’ desire for less immigration has ticked upward, now reaching 41%. This exceeds the 26% who now want more immigration and is the highest since 2014.

     

    The table below, titled "Americans' Preferences for Immigration", confirms this:

    41% want immigration decreased
    31% want immigration to remain at current levels
    26% want immigration increased

    That's for right now. For 1965, the figures on the very same table were indeed like you stated above:

    39% want immigration to remain at current levels
    33% want immigration decreased
    7% want immigration increased

    This shows just how massively US immigration attitudes have shifted in a pro-immigration direction since 1965, especially considering that immigration levels to the US, whether in a per capita sense or in a total sense, were much lower in 1965 than they are right now.

    Few Americans wanted increased immigration back in 1965 but many more of them want increased immigration today, though a bit less than a couple of years ago, possibly due to Biden's border rush.

    Replies: @AP

    , @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AP

    As Ron Unz will explain at tedious length, Mexican immigrants are pretty OK.

    They are way way way better than what the Europeans are getting. The race zealots around these parts do not seem to comprehend that ethnically they are Spaniards. Almost all of the Native Americans in Mexico were wiped out.

    Replies: @QCIC, @AnonfromTN

    , @QCIC
    @AP

    Thanks.

    Did the survey ask about ILLEGAL immigration by name? If not, the results are possibly very misleading.

    In a broad sense, most Americans are for legal immigration since this has been drummed into our heads as a defining characteristic of the country.

    Replies: @A123

  115. @Mikel
    @AP


    If you find such a place, let us know.
     
    I'm not too optimistic. The reason why I'm still here is because I've tried in the past but failed at finding any comparable place to discus stuff. Censorship is getting terrible. What a miserable way of making a living, censoring what other people want to say respectfully on a subject. How can these "moderators" of the comments sections in so many newspapers look at themselves in a mirror after making sure, day after day, that lots of people who took the time to write something were silenced, often for petty ideological reasons? I can't imagine any normal person in their childhood dreaming of becoming a censor when they grew up. But the modern internet has created an army of such losers.

    Replies: @AP, @QCIC, @Derer

    Censorship is pure evil, because it is selective and always follows some hidden agenda. It is never neutral and sometime absolutely brainless.

    US government banned the Marlboro billboards, apparently because it is “poisoning our children mind”. However, Hollywood creations that are advertising for two hours detail anatomy of killings, sodomizing and more, do not poison our children mind. That is “art” and therefore exempted from censorship.

    We are still awaiting litigation of proven copycat killing by poisoned mind.

  116. @AP
    @QCIC

    Most Americans support immigration:

    https://news.gallup.com/poll/508520/americans-value-immigration-concerns.aspx

    Two-thirds of Americans consider immigration a good thing for the country, while 27% consider it a bad thing. The percentage calling it a good thing is down from its peak of 77% in 2020 and is the lowest Gallup has recorded since 2014 (when it was 63%).

    While barely a quarter of Americans consider immigration a bad thing for the country, that view is far more prevalent among Republicans (43%) than Democrats (10%), with independents roughly matching the nation as a whole (28%). Still, half of Republicans consider it a good thing, as do 67% of independents and 87% of Democrats.

    That poll found few in favor of increasing immigration (7%), while the rest were split between wanting it kept the same (39%), wanting it decreased (33%) or unsure (20%).

    Replies: @Derer, @Mr. XYZ, @Emil Nikola Richard, @QCIC

    Most Americans support immigration:

    It should read most Democrats support immigration. Who built the wall and who oppose it to keep bringing other countries rejects. Those that are doing fine will not leave their homeland. The exemption is political immigration, however in most cases the prevalence of deceit is substantial.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Derer


    Those that are doing fine will not leave their homeland.
     
    That isn't obvious because the US is the cognitive hub of the world. If one aims to be a prolific scientist or inventor or researcher, one could fare better in the US than in one's home country in a whole lot of cases.

    Plus, even those who are doing well can sometimes make more money in the US, even adjusting for the higher cost of various things in the US.
    , @AP
    @Derer


    It should read most Democrats support immigration
     
    Most independents support it too. And slightly less than half of Republicans oppose it.

    So most Americans, overall, support it.

    Replies: @QCIC

  117. @AP
    @Beckow


    I am proudly Euro-centric, made out of Europe, I won’t apologize. You will not find more European geography than the remote valleys and rolling hills north of the middle Danube…it is almost comically Euro. My priority is to preserve the good life here
     
    These are forces that sought to destroy it, in the last 100 years:

    Nazism
    Communism
    Mass non-European emigration
    Putin (he is working on Ukraine, Baltics probably next if Ukraine falls, but he supports gangsters further West also)

    You personally support two of those.

    Your country has supported/supports three of the four.

    We were good in the east or central-east\: steadily growing, normal, living safer and more comfortable lives
     
    You were too small to be self-sufficient. You could hope to be ignored for awhile, but it wouldn't last forever.

    The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere – in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia’s propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception
     
    Poles are the largest of the Visegrad countries, with the largest economy. There are more Poles than there are Slovaks, Hungarians, and Czechs combined, with about 10 million more Poles to spare. As such, Poles cannot be considered an exception. Considering Poles an "exception" among Visegrad is about as stupid as saying "Britain, with the exception of the English."

    And Czechs don't like Russians, either. It is only the non-Slavic Hungarians and their traditional lackeys, the Slovaks, who are the exceptional ones.

    I will note that of the 4 phenomena that tried to destroy Europe that I previously described, Poland alone of the Visegrad countries opposed all 4. Czechs and Slovaks supported Commies, Hungarians and Slovaks supported Nazis and support Putin, Poland was correct every time. And has suffered for it.

    who they really hate are the Ukies and Orthodox, but they can’t voice it now
     
    You are ignorant as usual. The small group of ex-colonists have their issues but most Poles like Ukrainians, particularly those who don't speak Russian. There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

    EU is just an Anglo-French-Germany combo – with US managing it, the two Western groupings combined. They also grabbed everything in the vicinity (including Poland). But when they tried to go further east and grab Ukraine, Belarus, Caucasus, the remaining Euro power, Russia, blocked it
     
    Biden chooses to slowly grind down the Russians using Ukrainians to do so. "Blocking" is an American, not Russian decision. Russia helpfully goes along and gets itself slowly demilitarized. Ukrainians have no choice - Russian rule is worse than fighting, so they fight. If America chose to flood Ukraine with better weapons, this would be over.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. XYZ, @Derer, @A123, @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    Mass non-European emigration

    It’s likely the working-class Muslims and Africans that have most of the bad apples, no? Indians have integrated into, say, Britain pretty well, as have Chinese. African elites have also probably integrated into Britain pretty well. (I’m just using Britain as an example here.) Even among the Muslims, the more elite types, such as Haider al-Abadi, appear to have integrated well in Britain, in his case before moving back to Iraq after Saddam Hussein’s fall in 2003 due to patriotic considerations and eventually becoming Iraq’s Prime Minister in the 2014-2018 time period.

    Poland was correct every time. And has suffered for it.

    By resisting the Nazis, Poland also increased the odds that its Ashkenazi Jewish cognitive elite would be murdered en masse. (Hungary was able to have Hitler spare its own Jews until it foolishly decided to backstab Hitler in 1944.) Maybe Polish nationalists would not be too upset by this since they weren’t the ones who were doing the killing and since in any case Poland was apparently trying to get a lot of its Jews to emigrate in the interwar years (apparently in order to make it easier for gentile Poles to advance economically, et cetera, which would have been easier with less Jewish competition). But still, it was a huge loss for both Poland and for humanity in general considering just how accomplished Ashkenazi Jews have been throughout history.

    Poland ended up getting Communism shoved down its throat in 1945 anyway. Preemptively implicitly agreeing to this in 1939 (by allying with the Soviet Union along with the Anglo-French) would have changed nothing in regards to this but would have resulted in much less Polish and Soviet suffering in WWII. But of course neither the Poles nor the West could actually foresee this. They didn’t anticipate France falling in 1940. Though they should have anticipated the Nazis’ ability to thoroughly brutalize Poland, albeit perhaps not to the level of outright genocide, before the Anglo-French would have actually succeeded in liberating it. Berlin would need to be liberated before Poland would, after all, and there would have been a chance of the Soviet Union entering the war at the last minute, after the Anglo-French have been bled dry, in order to try grabbing as much territory for both itself and the Communist cause as it could.

    (Zionist/Israeli Jews would have been delighted had much more of Polish Jewry survived the Holocaust since those people were by and large the people who were expected to build Israel in the future prior to the Holocaust mass-murdering 90% of them.)

    Biden chooses to slowly grind down the Russians using Ukrainians to do so. “Blocking” is an American, not Russian decision. Russia helpfully goes along and gets itself slowly demilitarized. Ukrainians have no choice – Russian rule is worse than fighting, so they fight. If America chose to flood Ukraine with better weapons, this would be over.

    Maybe Ukraine could get those better weapons if Haley will win in 2024. With Trump, I’m more skeptical, and of course I dislike Trump in general. Biden will probably be more of the same, though who knows? There might be a chance of very, very gradual escalation with Biden. Making the Russian frog boil harder ever more slowly so that it doesn’t notice.

  118. @AP
    @Beckow


    I am proudly Euro-centric, made out of Europe, I won’t apologize. You will not find more European geography than the remote valleys and rolling hills north of the middle Danube…it is almost comically Euro. My priority is to preserve the good life here
     
    These are forces that sought to destroy it, in the last 100 years:

    Nazism
    Communism
    Mass non-European emigration
    Putin (he is working on Ukraine, Baltics probably next if Ukraine falls, but he supports gangsters further West also)

    You personally support two of those.

    Your country has supported/supports three of the four.

    We were good in the east or central-east\: steadily growing, normal, living safer and more comfortable lives
     
    You were too small to be self-sufficient. You could hope to be ignored for awhile, but it wouldn't last forever.

    The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere – in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia’s propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception
     
    Poles are the largest of the Visegrad countries, with the largest economy. There are more Poles than there are Slovaks, Hungarians, and Czechs combined, with about 10 million more Poles to spare. As such, Poles cannot be considered an exception. Considering Poles an "exception" among Visegrad is about as stupid as saying "Britain, with the exception of the English."

    And Czechs don't like Russians, either. It is only the non-Slavic Hungarians and their traditional lackeys, the Slovaks, who are the exceptional ones.

    I will note that of the 4 phenomena that tried to destroy Europe that I previously described, Poland alone of the Visegrad countries opposed all 4. Czechs and Slovaks supported Commies, Hungarians and Slovaks supported Nazis and support Putin, Poland was correct every time. And has suffered for it.

    who they really hate are the Ukies and Orthodox, but they can’t voice it now
     
    You are ignorant as usual. The small group of ex-colonists have their issues but most Poles like Ukrainians, particularly those who don't speak Russian. There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

    EU is just an Anglo-French-Germany combo – with US managing it, the two Western groupings combined. They also grabbed everything in the vicinity (including Poland). But when they tried to go further east and grab Ukraine, Belarus, Caucasus, the remaining Euro power, Russia, blocked it
     
    Biden chooses to slowly grind down the Russians using Ukrainians to do so. "Blocking" is an American, not Russian decision. Russia helpfully goes along and gets itself slowly demilitarized. Ukrainians have no choice - Russian rule is worse than fighting, so they fight. If America chose to flood Ukraine with better weapons, this would be over.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. XYZ, @Derer, @A123, @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

    Only illiterate. Do not forget the J yoke in Poland is as strong as in Ukraine.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Derer


    There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

    Only illiterate.

     

    This guy was no illiterate:

    https://bi.im-g.pl/im/03/ed/1b/z29283587AMP,Pogrzeb-Daniela-Sztybera-na-Powazkach--Mezczyzne--.jpg

    https://www.polskieradio.pl/395/9766/artykul/3184898,in-memory-of-a-pole-who-died-for-free-ukraine

    Daniel, after volunteering for combat in Ukraine, served in Kyiv’s elite special forces as a reconnaissance team member. He had three university degrees and extensive military training, including at Poland's elite special-forces unit GROM.

    “I regret a bit my last message to him......He sent me a poem by Herbert, a famous Polish poet. There was a certain doubt in this piece, and the author described how no one would repay him, and that he would be mocked for what he had done. After reading it, I was stressed I felt that he needs me, so I wrote to him, "Son, you were the last to doubt. Be brave, you are fighting the army of darkness and you are on the side of good". And he answered me, Finally, Dad, thank you. I think I gave him permission to sacrifice himself. I think about it and ask myself, why I didn't write to him to be careful and not to risk it".

    “I respect what he did and have respected it from the beginning. He made his choice fully aware that he was taking a risk, but he wanted a free nation, protection of Poland, Europe, and the world,” Mirosław Sztyber added.

    Do not forget the J yoke in Poland is as strong as in Ukraine.
     
    You haven't heard of the problems between Poland and Israel?

    Replies: @A123, @Mr. XYZ

  119. @AP
    @QCIC

    Most Americans support immigration:

    https://news.gallup.com/poll/508520/americans-value-immigration-concerns.aspx

    Two-thirds of Americans consider immigration a good thing for the country, while 27% consider it a bad thing. The percentage calling it a good thing is down from its peak of 77% in 2020 and is the lowest Gallup has recorded since 2014 (when it was 63%).

    While barely a quarter of Americans consider immigration a bad thing for the country, that view is far more prevalent among Republicans (43%) than Democrats (10%), with independents roughly matching the nation as a whole (28%). Still, half of Republicans consider it a good thing, as do 67% of independents and 87% of Democrats.

    That poll found few in favor of increasing immigration (7%), while the rest were split between wanting it kept the same (39%), wanting it decreased (33%) or unsure (20%).

    Replies: @Derer, @Mr. XYZ, @Emil Nikola Richard, @QCIC

    That poll found few in favor of increasing immigration (7%), while the rest were split between wanting it kept the same (39%), wanting it decreased (33%) or unsure (20%).

    The data that you reference here is from 1965:

    Gallup takes the public’s temperature on the volume of immigration by asking if immigration should be kept at its present level, increased or decreased. This was first measured in 1965, when Congress passed the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965 that reformed federal immigration policy. That poll found few in favor of increasing immigration (7%), while the rest were split between wanting it kept the same (39%), wanting it decreased (33%) or unsure (20%).

    From your very same link, I found this:

    Given the major increase in the number of migrants seeking to enter the U.S. at the Southern border in recent years, Americans’ desire for less immigration has ticked upward, now reaching 41%. This exceeds the 26% who now want more immigration and is the highest since 2014.

    The table below, titled “Americans’ Preferences for Immigration”, confirms this:

    41% want immigration decreased
    31% want immigration to remain at current levels
    26% want immigration increased

    That’s for right now. For 1965, the figures on the very same table were indeed like you stated above:

    39% want immigration to remain at current levels
    33% want immigration decreased
    7% want immigration increased

    This shows just how massively US immigration attitudes have shifted in a pro-immigration direction since 1965, especially considering that immigration levels to the US, whether in a per capita sense or in a total sense, were much lower in 1965 than they are right now.

    Few Americans wanted increased immigration back in 1965 but many more of them want increased immigration today, though a bit less than a couple of years ago, possibly due to Biden’s border rush.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    Thanks for the correction!

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  120. @Derer
    @AP


    Most Americans support immigration:
     
    It should read most Democrats support immigration. Who built the wall and who oppose it to keep bringing other countries rejects. Those that are doing fine will not leave their homeland. The exemption is political immigration, however in most cases the prevalence of deceit is substantial.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    Those that are doing fine will not leave their homeland.

    That isn’t obvious because the US is the cognitive hub of the world. If one aims to be a prolific scientist or inventor or researcher, one could fare better in the US than in one’s home country in a whole lot of cases.

    Plus, even those who are doing well can sometimes make more money in the US, even adjusting for the higher cost of various things in the US.

  121. @AP
    @Beckow


    I am proudly Euro-centric, made out of Europe, I won’t apologize. You will not find more European geography than the remote valleys and rolling hills north of the middle Danube…it is almost comically Euro. My priority is to preserve the good life here
     
    These are forces that sought to destroy it, in the last 100 years:

    Nazism
    Communism
    Mass non-European emigration
    Putin (he is working on Ukraine, Baltics probably next if Ukraine falls, but he supports gangsters further West also)

    You personally support two of those.

    Your country has supported/supports three of the four.

    We were good in the east or central-east\: steadily growing, normal, living safer and more comfortable lives
     
    You were too small to be self-sufficient. You could hope to be ignored for awhile, but it wouldn't last forever.

    The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere – in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia’s propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception
     
    Poles are the largest of the Visegrad countries, with the largest economy. There are more Poles than there are Slovaks, Hungarians, and Czechs combined, with about 10 million more Poles to spare. As such, Poles cannot be considered an exception. Considering Poles an "exception" among Visegrad is about as stupid as saying "Britain, with the exception of the English."

    And Czechs don't like Russians, either. It is only the non-Slavic Hungarians and their traditional lackeys, the Slovaks, who are the exceptional ones.

    I will note that of the 4 phenomena that tried to destroy Europe that I previously described, Poland alone of the Visegrad countries opposed all 4. Czechs and Slovaks supported Commies, Hungarians and Slovaks supported Nazis and support Putin, Poland was correct every time. And has suffered for it.

    who they really hate are the Ukies and Orthodox, but they can’t voice it now
     
    You are ignorant as usual. The small group of ex-colonists have their issues but most Poles like Ukrainians, particularly those who don't speak Russian. There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

    EU is just an Anglo-French-Germany combo – with US managing it, the two Western groupings combined. They also grabbed everything in the vicinity (including Poland). But when they tried to go further east and grab Ukraine, Belarus, Caucasus, the remaining Euro power, Russia, blocked it
     
    Biden chooses to slowly grind down the Russians using Ukrainians to do so. "Blocking" is an American, not Russian decision. Russia helpfully goes along and gets itself slowly demilitarized. Ukrainians have no choice - Russian rule is worse than fighting, so they fight. If America chose to flood Ukraine with better weapons, this would be over.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. XYZ, @Derer, @A123, @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    These are forces that sought to destroy [Europe], in the last 100 years:

    Nazism
    Communism
    Mass non-European emigration
    Putin

    The problem with your assertion is that Putin seeks to avoid being destroyed by IslamoGloboHomo Europe. Merkel constructed Zelensky as a dagger to slit Russia’s throat. She missed the cut, and Ukraine is going to pay a steep price for her failure. Other European leaders like Scholz and Macron, all-in on Kiev aggression, continue to make the situation worse.

    Mass non-European migration, especially of Muslims has been disastrous. Again, Angela “Welcome Rape-ugees” Merkel is again central to this initiating this attack on Judeo-Christians. Germany funds transports bringing invaders to Europe. And, Scholz is outraged that AfD supports “re-migration”.

    It extraordinarily obvious that:

    — Muslim Colonists are the problem.
    — Muslim Decolonization is the answer.

    How many problems would be immediately solved if European Christendom was 99%+ Muslim free? Crime would plummet. The need for public assistance would shrink. Housing would be less expensive. Wages would be higher. Almost everything would be better.

    Why must Christian European workers suffer for the balance sheets of Islamophile Frankfurt banks? It makes no sense.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    You don’t seem to understand what Ansarullah is. It’s the de facto Yemeni state, not some Iranian proxy you can hand wave into submission. And while it’s a rational political actor, it’s very similar to an uber ideological Hizbullah, circa 1980s, but with ballistic missiles.

    https://youtu.be/Ng4HYP-dDMQ?si=GgxnbHNJ1kle3die

  122. @AP
    @Beckow


    I would remind the pro-Nato contingent that if the power gets reshuffled to omit paper and other verbal stuff, it will be the West that will lose more. Its power will be less than the countries with material resources and actual manufacturing
     
    USA is the world’s top oil producer. USA + it’s semi-appendage Canada produce nearly twice as much oil as either Russia or Saudi Arabia.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_oil_production

    USA also world’s top natural gas producer:

    https://investingnews.com/top-natural-gas-producers/

    Lithium. South America, but USA exceeds China:

    https://www.nsenergybusiness.com/features/six-largest-lithium-reserves-world/

    USA is the world’s second largest manufacturer, after China. Here the picture is mixed.

    China dominates in steel production:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_steel_production

    Though the EU, Japan, and the USA each exceed Russian steel production.

    In terms of finished goods, a lot of what China manufactures (not all, of course), is cheap stuff that we in the West would not want to make because we’d rather it be very inexpensive. Like mass production of the trinkets including cheap electronics they sell in Walmart.

    Otherwise, USA is number 1 in aircraft production:

    https://www.aerotime.aero/articles/top-10-largest-aircraft-manufacturers-in-the-world

    Almost all Western, Brazil at number 9.

    China leads in automobile production but many Chinese cars are cheap and of poor quality. And the West (which includes Japan) collectively produces more automobiles than does China:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_motor_vehicle_production

    West leads in semiconductor manufacturing (a reason China won’t be given Taiwan for awhile):

    https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/semiconductor-manufacturing-by-country

    Machine tools, China number one, but collective West exceeds it:

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/264213/leading-countries-in-machine-tool-production-based-on-market-share/

    Overall, the combination of natural resources and manufacturing particular high end manufacturing favors the West, especially the USA.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    the combination of natural resources and manufacturing particular high end manufacturing favors the West, especially the USA.

    My points was: if the power gets reshuffled to omit paper and other verbal stuff, it will be the West that will lose more.…do you understand the meaning of lose more?

    In absolute terms the two camps will be roughly equal, the big loser will be Europe that has minimal resources and its manufacturing is not competitive. US-Canada-Australia will do much better – there is a strong opinion in EU that is why US is willing to do this – they are cannibalizing their Euro allies.

    But the collective West will lose more – disproportionate share of the Western economy is derived from soft activities that may go away or shrink: finance, consulting, cultural products, bulls..t jobs in the meta economy (business about business)…

    The anti-West is also growing a lot faster then the West…over time it will get worse. The way to correct it would be to go back to more real economy, but the costs are high and it goes against the dominant liberal ideology. People in the West – in Europe – are not inclined to exchange their comfy subsidized lives and bs jobs for working harder.

    The security-defense boom can cover some of it for a while but it will eventually (soon) lead to lower access to consumer goods and good life. Defense is a lot of things but it doesn’t increase living standards – it is an economic black hole: stuff goes in and nothing comes out…

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Beckow

    All true. But. We have the top most elite human capital.

    Only alcohol-addled half-Dagestanis capitalize that. : )

    , @A123
    @Beckow


    the big loser will be Europe that has minimal resources and its manufacturing is not competitive. US-Canada-Australia will do much better – there is a strong opinion in EU that is why US is willing to do this – they are cannibalizing their Euro allies.
     
    America realizes that the CCP is the biggest manufacturing foe for everyone. Thus, gradual decoupling from Asia generally, and the CCP specifically, is a minimum requirement for national security.

    America would like Europe to be a partner in this. There is no "cannibalizing". The problem is that EU bureaucracy cannot (or choses not to) keep up.

    It is no secret hat the CCP builds industry based on IP theft and dumping to damage competitors. The obvious responses are guaranteeing national industrial champions and brutally punishing IP theft. The EU is distracted by other things like keeping borders open and green/ESG/DEI indoctrination. Individual nations, burdened by EU over reach, cannot focus on core employment and industrial priorities.

    Europe needs MEGA to match MAGA. Sadly, that is much more than 12 months away. And, it may be too late for some countries.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    , @AP
    @Beckow


    In absolute terms the two camps will be roughly equal, the big loser will be Europe that has minimal resources and its manufacturing is not competitive. US-Canada-Australia will do much better
     
    I actually agree with you here. But it is Western Europe that is declining. The East does not. Poland's economy keeps improving, year after year.

    – there is a strong opinion in EU that is why US is willing to do this – they are cannibalizing their Euro allies
     
    No one forced Germany to stupidly get rid of its nuclear power. Or to stupidly become overly dependent on Russian gas (these two phenomena are linked - Russia was funding the German anti-nuclear activists, though Germans shouldn't have listened to them). Such mistakes have consequences. German manufacturers are moving many of their operations to the USA. When peace comes to Ukraine they will move a lot there, also.

    The security-defense boom can cover some of it for a while but it will eventually (soon) lead to lower access to consumer goods and good life. Defense is a lot of things but it doesn’t increase living standards – it is an economic black hole: stuff goes in and nothing comes out…
     
    You do realize that you just described most of Russia's recent economic "growth," right?

    Much more true of Russia than of the West.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @Sean

  123. @AP
    @QCIC

    Most Americans support immigration:

    https://news.gallup.com/poll/508520/americans-value-immigration-concerns.aspx

    Two-thirds of Americans consider immigration a good thing for the country, while 27% consider it a bad thing. The percentage calling it a good thing is down from its peak of 77% in 2020 and is the lowest Gallup has recorded since 2014 (when it was 63%).

    While barely a quarter of Americans consider immigration a bad thing for the country, that view is far more prevalent among Republicans (43%) than Democrats (10%), with independents roughly matching the nation as a whole (28%). Still, half of Republicans consider it a good thing, as do 67% of independents and 87% of Democrats.

    That poll found few in favor of increasing immigration (7%), while the rest were split between wanting it kept the same (39%), wanting it decreased (33%) or unsure (20%).

    Replies: @Derer, @Mr. XYZ, @Emil Nikola Richard, @QCIC

    As Ron Unz will explain at tedious length, Mexican immigrants are pretty OK.

    They are way way way better than what the Europeans are getting. The race zealots around these parts do not seem to comprehend that ethnically they are Spaniards. Almost all of the Native Americans in Mexico were wiped out.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Most of the illegals flowing into the USA do not appear to be "Spaniards", by which I assume you mean people with 50/50 Mestizo genetics. I agree these transplants are more capable than those flowing into Europe, but it may be a matter of degree. We have a lot of Africans flowing in as well. If you mean people with pure Spanish ancestry, criollos or whatever, that is a different story and represents a much smaller group. Most of those people do fine without moving north.

    I think Ron's numbers will change over time as these invaders feel less and less pressure to conform to American social norms. While I enjoy Fred Reed's writings on Mestizo people and the Maya, I think he is mistaken about the level of 'elite human capital' south of the border. These people would not be flowing north if those societies have the potential he claims.

    , @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    The race zealots around these parts do not seem to comprehend that ethnically they are Spaniards. Almost all of the Native Americans in Mexico were wiped out.
     
    Not really. In fact, the fraction of Indians and part-Indians among Mexes who come to the US is much greater than in Mexico. This is natural: people who are doing OK do not subject themselves to the dangers of border crossing. Many of Mexes doing construction work here in TN, including those who worked in my yard and changed my roof, as well as those that wash my car at the good carwash, are 50-100% Indians, judging by their looks. Usually their foreman speaks some English and communicates with you, the rest only know “Hi” and “Fuck”.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

  124. @Beckow
    @AP


    the combination of natural resources and manufacturing particular high end manufacturing favors the West, especially the USA.
     
    My points was: if the power gets reshuffled to omit paper and other verbal stuff, it will be the West that will lose more....do you understand the meaning of lose more?

    In absolute terms the two camps will be roughly equal, the big loser will be Europe that has minimal resources and its manufacturing is not competitive. US-Canada-Australia will do much better - there is a strong opinion in EU that is why US is willing to do this - they are cannibalizing their Euro allies.

    But the collective West will lose more - disproportionate share of the Western economy is derived from soft activities that may go away or shrink: finance, consulting, cultural products, bulls..t jobs in the meta economy (business about business)...

    The anti-West is also growing a lot faster then the West...over time it will get worse. The way to correct it would be to go back to more real economy, but the costs are high and it goes against the dominant liberal ideology. People in the West - in Europe - are not inclined to exchange their comfy subsidized lives and bs jobs for working harder.

    The security-defense boom can cover some of it for a while but it will eventually (soon) lead to lower access to consumer goods and good life. Defense is a lot of things but it doesn't increase living standards - it is an economic black hole: stuff goes in and nothing comes out...

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @A123, @AP

    All true. But. We have the top most elite human capital.

    Only alcohol-addled half-Dagestanis capitalize that. : )

  125. Sher Singh says:
    @Sher Singh
    @Yahya


    https://imgur.com/a/A9TCCaY

    Long as the app has progress recommendations it's good.
    Alpha is good cuz let's say I did 150x10 for RIR 2 on Week 1.

    Week 3 I want to sets of 6 it'll keep in the same RIR & might have me do 175x6.
    Tracking 10RM is IMO superior for bodybuilding.

    --
    Keep in mind I was doing close to 40 sets a session a few months back.
    This is just my current way to balance 6x a week with fatigue/life.

    Alpha means I can make consistent progress without guesswork.
    When it stalls, I'll add/subtract volume or w/e.
    --

    What's your favorite bicep exercises?
    Not really feeling barbell or DB curls & don't have a low pulley or incline bench.

    :/

    Replies: @Sher Singh, @Yahya

    https://imgur com/a/A9TCCaY

    Link broken, but that’s my full split.
    Did it for a friend.

    Here’s the guide from Mike Israetel: (under more)

    [MORE]

    https://ryanlefebvre.github.io/RP-Hypertrophy-Hub-Visualizer/#/

    Tbh, I think viewing it from a weekly angle is wrong for a few reasons.
    Based on my experience, you should aim for a X frequency & Y volume per session.

    At that point, your weekly volume will be fine.
    That 8-20 sets per week is a broad guideline encompassing both free weights & machines.

    Since I only use barbell, cable or dumbbell I tend towards lower end & just do what’s comfortable.

    I have ran programs where you increase by 1 set per week.
    It’s brutal, but sort of works – haven’t tried it since Alpha Progression (Got it Last Nov).

    What I do now is just change reps every few weeks, but do sets by feel.

    When you do too much volume you tend to just rest more & your 5x week turns into 5x in 10 days.

    • Replies: @Sher Singh
    @Sher Singh

    Eh - added 20lb to 10rm on curls last 8 weeks.
    Just being inpatient.

    Also changing bench/ohp T1 to 6-8.
    7,7, 8,8, 6, 6 over 6 weeks.

    Front Squat Rdl probably still 4-6.

    https://swoleateveryheight.blogspot.com/2014/07/the-gzcl-method-simplified_13.html?m=1

    I kind of do that but with a bodybuilding focus.

    Lifting right now actually, OHP day lol.

    Last set doing 8 instead of 4s

    ਅਕਾਲ

  126. @AP
    @QCIC

    Most Americans support immigration:

    https://news.gallup.com/poll/508520/americans-value-immigration-concerns.aspx

    Two-thirds of Americans consider immigration a good thing for the country, while 27% consider it a bad thing. The percentage calling it a good thing is down from its peak of 77% in 2020 and is the lowest Gallup has recorded since 2014 (when it was 63%).

    While barely a quarter of Americans consider immigration a bad thing for the country, that view is far more prevalent among Republicans (43%) than Democrats (10%), with independents roughly matching the nation as a whole (28%). Still, half of Republicans consider it a good thing, as do 67% of independents and 87% of Democrats.

    That poll found few in favor of increasing immigration (7%), while the rest were split between wanting it kept the same (39%), wanting it decreased (33%) or unsure (20%).

    Replies: @Derer, @Mr. XYZ, @Emil Nikola Richard, @QCIC

    Thanks.

    Did the survey ask about ILLEGAL immigration by name? If not, the results are possibly very misleading.

    In a broad sense, most Americans are for legal immigration since this has been drummed into our heads as a defining characteristic of the country.

    • Replies: @A123
    @QCIC


    Did the survey ask about ILLEGAL immigration by name? If not, the results are possibly very misleading.
     
    I had that same insight. The poll does not effectively distinguish between legal & illegal.

    Another problem is the "inch deep" phenomenon. People will say they are "for" something that sounds unobjectionable, but that superficial count is meaningless. It vanishes in methods such as Top 5 Issues. Border Security will frequently appear in the Top 5 for many voters. Keeping or increasing migration will be a tiny fraction in comparison.

    The best questions would pair the policy with inevitable outcome. "Knowing that you will be paid less, do you support migrants coming to compete for your job?" The more that people understand cause & effect, the less willing they are to be self destructive.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @AP, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

  127. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AP

    As Ron Unz will explain at tedious length, Mexican immigrants are pretty OK.

    They are way way way better than what the Europeans are getting. The race zealots around these parts do not seem to comprehend that ethnically they are Spaniards. Almost all of the Native Americans in Mexico were wiped out.

    Replies: @QCIC, @AnonfromTN

    Most of the illegals flowing into the USA do not appear to be “Spaniards”, by which I assume you mean people with 50/50 Mestizo genetics. I agree these transplants are more capable than those flowing into Europe, but it may be a matter of degree. We have a lot of Africans flowing in as well. If you mean people with pure Spanish ancestry, criollos or whatever, that is a different story and represents a much smaller group. Most of those people do fine without moving north.

    I think Ron’s numbers will change over time as these invaders feel less and less pressure to conform to American social norms. While I enjoy Fred Reed’s writings on Mestizo people and the Maya, I think he is mistaken about the level of ‘elite human capital’ south of the border. These people would not be flowing north if those societies have the potential he claims.

  128. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AP

    As Ron Unz will explain at tedious length, Mexican immigrants are pretty OK.

    They are way way way better than what the Europeans are getting. The race zealots around these parts do not seem to comprehend that ethnically they are Spaniards. Almost all of the Native Americans in Mexico were wiped out.

    Replies: @QCIC, @AnonfromTN

    The race zealots around these parts do not seem to comprehend that ethnically they are Spaniards. Almost all of the Native Americans in Mexico were wiped out.

    Not really. In fact, the fraction of Indians and part-Indians among Mexes who come to the US is much greater than in Mexico. This is natural: people who are doing OK do not subject themselves to the dangers of border crossing. Many of Mexes doing construction work here in TN, including those who worked in my yard and changed my roof, as well as those that wash my car at the good carwash, are 50-100% Indians, judging by their looks. Usually their foreman speaks some English and communicates with you, the rest only know “Hi” and “Fuck”.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AnonfromTN

    So, a lot of the Latin Americans coming over here are at least 25% European or the close family members (such as children) of someone who is if they are coming to the US together with them. That's good enough for a white ethnostate along the Israeli model. So far, Israel thankfully continues allowing people who are at least 25% Jewish and their immediate family members into Israel.

    , @AP
    @AnonfromTN


    In fact, the fraction of Indians and part-Indians among Mexes who come to the US is much greater than in Mexico.
     
    The nearly 100% European elites of Mexico rarely come to the USA, their life is great here, but the poorest Mexicans don't come either. Hiring smugglers is not too cheap. USA tends to get poor farmers and lower middle class types from Mexico, people who want to leave badly and can come up with a few thousand dollars if they sacrifice their life savings (the poorest cannot do even that). And they tend to come from regions with higher % European ancestry rather than the deep south of Mexico where people have more Indian ancestry though there has been somewhat of a shift over time.

    Mexican-American % Indian ancestry varies from about 42% in older immigrants to 52% in recent immigrants:

    https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.01.13.905141v2.full

    This isn't too different from Mexico itself, excluding the elite. The average Mexican Mestizo is 56% Indian.

    Many of Mexes doing construction work here in TN, including those who worked in my yard and changed my roof, as well as those that wash my car at the good carwash, are 50-100% Indians, judging by their looks
     
    Looks can be somewhat deceiving, because European traits are often recessive and because the Europeans they are descended from are Meds, who tend to be dark already.

    For example Eva Longoria is 70% European and only 27% Native:

    https://blogs.ancestry.com/cm/eva-longorias-surprising-dna-test/

    https://wl-brightside.cf.tsp.li/resize/728x/jpg/70b/0ec/c3839a5e8d9978486bfb1d3e8e.jpg

    Someone who is 50/50 (the typical immigrant from Mexico) would look even more Indian than she does.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ, @QCIC, @AnonfromTN

  129. @Mikel
    @Gerard1234

    I don't have any strong opinions on the Riga architectural landscape. If all parties involved agree with you that the best parts were built by the Russians, that is something I can perfectly live with.

    However, it is just not true that LatW left because of you. She clearly left in indignation at the epithet that G_R directed at her. Even worse, then G_R proceeded to leave the blog himself, at a time when Dmitry, Bashi, Aaron and others had been absent for a while and Yahya has briefly reappeared to let us know what a waste of his time this geriatric ward had become really. The chances of any worthwhile debate taking place here have become infinitesimal.

    But I can't blame any of them really. We had long ago entered the law of diminishing returns, discussing ad nauseam the same old subjects with the same old arguments (me included). Who doesn't have better uses of their time than that?

    With that said, I think it's been quite a remarkable feat to keep this blog alive for 2 years after his author left (and actually break records of comment numbers on this website). Perhaps as important as the subjects we keep debating are the subjects the regulars of this blog never debate: transhumanism and technological singularities (AK's favorite topics) or the JQ (Unz's obsession). This clearly signals that it was never about AK or Unz. They both just happened to attract a group of disparate people with very different backgrounds and the group then took a life of its own, building very lively threads out of nothing that for one reason or another we all felt compelled to participate in. Though obviously AK and Ron deserve credit for the phenomenon.

    Alas, everything has an end and it looks like these threads are losing the vigor and interest they once had. On to the difficult task of finding other places to debate, vent and engage people of different persuasions without being censored, I guess.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @AP, @Yevardian, @German_reader, @Gerard1234

    Unfortunately, twitter seems the best of bad options for the moment.
    I much prefer the site-design here that incentivises long comments and discourages posting excessive pictures, catchphrases, “memes” and the like, but in the end that site has pure numbers so there’s at least a couple of interesting users, you just have to mute a lot of people.

    transhumanism and technological singularities (AK’s favorite topics) or the JQ (Unz’s obsession).

    Funny you mention that, the complete lack of interest in those two topics on this forum was quite striking to me as well. Unfortunately Our Benevolent Overlord has gone completely overboard and single-minded in his obsession at this point. Interestingly, I know a few people, even including Jews, that substantially agree with the content of his 2018 articles which torpedoed his site, but aren’t antisemitic at all. All nations pursue their ethnic interests and often lie in order to achieve their goals, so ultimately my reaction is “ok, so X narrative is mostly a lie, but so what?”.
    In the end they’re a smart and talented people in a world in which most peoples aren’t.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Yevardian


    Funny you mention that, the complete lack of interest in those two topics on this forum was quite striking to me as well.
     
    I am very interested in these topics. Are you?

    I read the manifesto. At least half. The varieties of alt-Russian politics were way over my head and I only skimmed those parts.

    Here is what stuck out to me:

    1. Sorrow that the fellow (I forget his name--Kolmogorov?--he is the fat guy who got drugged out and jumped to his death onto a Moscow street naked) died without a cryonics contract.

    1.a. It seems that Karlin's leader lights in this internet writing business (Anglo part) are:

    Hanania, Scott Alexander, Elizier Yudkowski.

    Yudkowski is PRO cryonics. Alexander used to be pro cryonics. In Alexander's reader surveys he had a cryonics question for years. He has deleted it and not mentioned why. I presume he is now ANTI but doesn't want to rock anybody's boat.

    1.b. So what exactly is the deal here?

    1.c. Personally I consider cryonics, as it exists, a complete waste of time and energy. But there is a fundamental question which is fascinating. What is life? It appears to me nobody has a good answer to this apart from faith and dogma.

    2. The turn towards impending AI Paperclips Doom and away from Russian Nationalism seems like a cop out. That is a point worth looking at. It is convenient for AK's self-esteem that he can put forth such an argument to trivialize losing his big bet on the Special Military Operation. If I was him I would be trying to figure out a way to pretend the latter never happened.

    3. I have more but I am skeptical that you would enjoy getting me started.

    Replies: @sudden death

  130. @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    The race zealots around these parts do not seem to comprehend that ethnically they are Spaniards. Almost all of the Native Americans in Mexico were wiped out.
     
    Not really. In fact, the fraction of Indians and part-Indians among Mexes who come to the US is much greater than in Mexico. This is natural: people who are doing OK do not subject themselves to the dangers of border crossing. Many of Mexes doing construction work here in TN, including those who worked in my yard and changed my roof, as well as those that wash my car at the good carwash, are 50-100% Indians, judging by their looks. Usually their foreman speaks some English and communicates with you, the rest only know “Hi” and “Fuck”.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    So, a lot of the Latin Americans coming over here are at least 25% European or the close family members (such as children) of someone who is if they are coming to the US together with them. That’s good enough for a white ethnostate along the Israeli model. So far, Israel thankfully continues allowing people who are at least 25% Jewish and their immediate family members into Israel.

  131. @Beckow
    @AP


    the combination of natural resources and manufacturing particular high end manufacturing favors the West, especially the USA.
     
    My points was: if the power gets reshuffled to omit paper and other verbal stuff, it will be the West that will lose more....do you understand the meaning of lose more?

    In absolute terms the two camps will be roughly equal, the big loser will be Europe that has minimal resources and its manufacturing is not competitive. US-Canada-Australia will do much better - there is a strong opinion in EU that is why US is willing to do this - they are cannibalizing their Euro allies.

    But the collective West will lose more - disproportionate share of the Western economy is derived from soft activities that may go away or shrink: finance, consulting, cultural products, bulls..t jobs in the meta economy (business about business)...

    The anti-West is also growing a lot faster then the West...over time it will get worse. The way to correct it would be to go back to more real economy, but the costs are high and it goes against the dominant liberal ideology. People in the West - in Europe - are not inclined to exchange their comfy subsidized lives and bs jobs for working harder.

    The security-defense boom can cover some of it for a while but it will eventually (soon) lead to lower access to consumer goods and good life. Defense is a lot of things but it doesn't increase living standards - it is an economic black hole: stuff goes in and nothing comes out...

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @A123, @AP

    the big loser will be Europe that has minimal resources and its manufacturing is not competitive. US-Canada-Australia will do much better – there is a strong opinion in EU that is why US is willing to do this – they are cannibalizing their Euro allies.

    America realizes that the CCP is the biggest manufacturing foe for everyone. Thus, gradual decoupling from Asia generally, and the CCP specifically, is a minimum requirement for national security.

    America would like Europe to be a partner in this. There is no “cannibalizing”. The problem is that EU bureaucracy cannot (or choses not to) keep up.

    It is no secret hat the CCP builds industry based on IP theft and dumping to damage competitors. The obvious responses are guaranteeing national industrial champions and brutally punishing IP theft. The EU is distracted by other things like keeping borders open and green/ESG/DEI indoctrination. Individual nations, burdened by EU over reach, cannot focus on core employment and industrial priorities.

    Europe needs MEGA to match MAGA. Sadly, that is much more than 12 months away. And, it may be too late for some countries.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    Everyone notices that you are in a complete panic, repeatedly and frantically ducking the question in a desperate attempt to escape.
     
    PEACE 😇
    _________

    Is this list current or have you added more people to it?

    My current BLOCKED TROLLS if anyone needs a starting place:

    Alexander Turok
    Art
    Blinky Bill
    Corvinus
    Daniel Chieh
    Druid
    Dr. Doom
    FB
    HeebHunter
    Iris
    JohnPlywood
    Kratic
    Majority of One
    Mr. Hack
    Mulga Mumblebrain
    Nokangaroos
    obwandiyag
    Pat Kittle
    Rev. Spooner
    Schuetze
    Supply and Demand
    Talha

    I will never block you, promise to do the same!

    Replies: @John Johnson, @A123

  132. @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN


    ...The downfall of Europe would deserve a chapter
     
    I am proudly Euro-centric, made out of Europe, I won't apologize. You will not find more European geography than the remote valleys and rolling hills north of the middle Danube...it is almost comically Euro. My priority is to preserve the good life here and I will spin ideas in that direction. Whether it is delusional I leave to others. One has to have a point of view, we are not gods...

    When this started the Western Europe was in a slow, gradual decline: lack of resources, collapsing big cities, unstoppable migrants...and idiotic liberal fanatics. We were good in the east or central-east\: steadily growing, normal, living safer and more comfortable lives. The Ukie disaster has reversed it...

    The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere - in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia's propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception and even among them the sentiment is more mixed - who they really hate are the Ukies and Orthodox, but they can't voice it now.)

    It will be in the Chapter called "Causes"...the stupidity of the Nato's failed grab of Ukraine makes the wars in the Middle East and Asia much worse for the West. The elemental reality is that with China's economic might, Middle East-Russian resources, resentful nations of the South, the last thing West needed was to add Russia with its weapons, resources and geography. But they did, for Nato bases, Crimea (nice place) and exiles' lying stories...maybe a downfall, but I still hope not...I like our quiet valleys.

    Replies: @AP, @AnonfromTN

    You will not find more European geography than the remote valleys and rolling hills north of the middle Danube…it is almost comically Euro. My priority is to preserve the good life here and I will spin ideas in that direction.

    As a matter of fact, quite a few patches of Europe, including your neck of woods, will suffer a lot less damage. Culturally hostile migrants flooding Europe do not go to the countryside, they stay in big cities. As those big cities are infested by libtards and therefore doomed, anyway, real rural Europe will be OK. Besides, rural areas are robbed by the rich scum living in the cities, so you might even improve your fortunes when the system collapses.

    What will disappear is Europe as a source of influence on the outside world. All myths about European superiority will wither. But normal life in the countryside might continue, unless you guys start voting for libtards. Libtards everywhere, in Europe, the US, or Russia, have an anti-Midas touch: everything Midas touched turned to gold, everything libtards touch turns to shit.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AnonfromTN


    As a matter of fact, quite a few patches of Europe, including your neck of woods, will suffer a lot less damage. Culturally hostile migrants flooding Europe do not go to the countryside, they stay in big cities. As those big cities are infested by libtards and therefore doomed, anyway, real rural Europe will be OK. Besides, rural areas are robbed by the rich scum living in the cities, so you might even improve your fortunes when the system collapses.

     

    Are rural parts of Ukraine the "real Ukraine"? Seems like they would be since they are less infested with a Sovok mentality. Other than Kiev, of course. Kiev is huge and yet very non-Sovok. But Kiev and Lviv are the only gigantic cities in central and western Ukraine; the other ones are in more Sovok eastern and southern Ukraine.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  133. @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    You will not find more European geography than the remote valleys and rolling hills north of the middle Danube…it is almost comically Euro. My priority is to preserve the good life here and I will spin ideas in that direction.
     
    As a matter of fact, quite a few patches of Europe, including your neck of woods, will suffer a lot less damage. Culturally hostile migrants flooding Europe do not go to the countryside, they stay in big cities. As those big cities are infested by libtards and therefore doomed, anyway, real rural Europe will be OK. Besides, rural areas are robbed by the rich scum living in the cities, so you might even improve your fortunes when the system collapses.

    What will disappear is Europe as a source of influence on the outside world. All myths about European superiority will wither. But normal life in the countryside might continue, unless you guys start voting for libtards. Libtards everywhere, in Europe, the US, or Russia, have an anti-Midas touch: everything Midas touched turned to gold, everything libtards touch turns to shit.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    As a matter of fact, quite a few patches of Europe, including your neck of woods, will suffer a lot less damage. Culturally hostile migrants flooding Europe do not go to the countryside, they stay in big cities. As those big cities are infested by libtards and therefore doomed, anyway, real rural Europe will be OK. Besides, rural areas are robbed by the rich scum living in the cities, so you might even improve your fortunes when the system collapses.

    Are rural parts of Ukraine the “real Ukraine”? Seems like they would be since they are less infested with a Sovok mentality. Other than Kiev, of course. Kiev is huge and yet very non-Sovok. But Kiev and Lviv are the only gigantic cities in central and western Ukraine; the other ones are in more Sovok eastern and southern Ukraine.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. XYZ

    A good rule of thumb is that the less populous a place is, the more Ukrainian it is:

    https://datatowel.in.ua/langlomerator

  134. @QCIC
    @AP

    Thanks.

    Did the survey ask about ILLEGAL immigration by name? If not, the results are possibly very misleading.

    In a broad sense, most Americans are for legal immigration since this has been drummed into our heads as a defining characteristic of the country.

    Replies: @A123

    Did the survey ask about ILLEGAL immigration by name? If not, the results are possibly very misleading.

    I had that same insight. The poll does not effectively distinguish between legal & illegal.

    Another problem is the “inch deep” phenomenon. People will say they are “for” something that sounds unobjectionable, but that superficial count is meaningless. It vanishes in methods such as Top 5 Issues. Border Security will frequently appear in the Top 5 for many voters. Keeping or increasing migration will be a tiny fraction in comparison.

    The best questions would pair the policy with inevitable outcome. “Knowing that you will be paid less, do you support migrants coming to compete for your job?” The more that people understand cause & effect, the less willing they are to be self destructive.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @AP
    @A123


    The best questions would pair the policy with inevitable outcome. “Knowing that you will be paid less, do you support migrants coming to compete for your job?”
     
    How many Americans are gardeners, roofers, fruit pickers, maids, table bussers, etc. though?

    These are the ones whose wages get cut. Other Americans benefit from this stuff being a lot cheaper than it otherwise would have been. I know quite a few people who have saved a lot of money and avoided nursing home care for ages loved ones by having live-in illegals from Poland and Ukraine stay with elderly relatives.

    I’m not arguing in favor of mass immigration, but a lot of Americans do benefit from it. And those ones are the ones who also are wealthier and pay most of the taxes.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

    , @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    Former Israeli Shin Bet chief Ami Ayalon reiterates his call to release Palestinian leader Marwan Barghouti and negotiate a two-state solution.

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GD5geFwXwAAiZsN.jpg

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GD5gewTWwAAT57W.jpg


    😇

  135. @Mr. XYZ
    @AnonfromTN


    As a matter of fact, quite a few patches of Europe, including your neck of woods, will suffer a lot less damage. Culturally hostile migrants flooding Europe do not go to the countryside, they stay in big cities. As those big cities are infested by libtards and therefore doomed, anyway, real rural Europe will be OK. Besides, rural areas are robbed by the rich scum living in the cities, so you might even improve your fortunes when the system collapses.

     

    Are rural parts of Ukraine the "real Ukraine"? Seems like they would be since they are less infested with a Sovok mentality. Other than Kiev, of course. Kiev is huge and yet very non-Sovok. But Kiev and Lviv are the only gigantic cities in central and western Ukraine; the other ones are in more Sovok eastern and southern Ukraine.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    A good rule of thumb is that the less populous a place is, the more Ukrainian it is:

    https://datatowel.in.ua/langlomerator

  136. @Yevardian
    @Mikel

    Unfortunately, twitter seems the best of bad options for the moment.
    I much prefer the site-design here that incentivises long comments and discourages posting excessive pictures, catchphrases, "memes" and the like, but in the end that site has pure numbers so there's at least a couple of interesting users, you just have to mute a lot of people.


    transhumanism and technological singularities (AK’s favorite topics) or the JQ (Unz’s obsession).
     
    Funny you mention that, the complete lack of interest in those two topics on this forum was quite striking to me as well. Unfortunately Our Benevolent Overlord has gone completely overboard and single-minded in his obsession at this point. Interestingly, I know a few people, even including Jews, that substantially agree with the content of his 2018 articles which torpedoed his site, but aren't antisemitic at all. All nations pursue their ethnic interests and often lie in order to achieve their goals, so ultimately my reaction is "ok, so X narrative is mostly a lie, but so what?".
    In the end they're a smart and talented people in a world in which most peoples aren't.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    Funny you mention that, the complete lack of interest in those two topics on this forum was quite striking to me as well.

    I am very interested in these topics. Are you?

    I read the manifesto. At least half. The varieties of alt-Russian politics were way over my head and I only skimmed those parts.

    Here is what stuck out to me:

    1. Sorrow that the fellow (I forget his name–Kolmogorov?–he is the fat guy who got drugged out and jumped to his death onto a Moscow street naked) died without a cryonics contract.

    1.a. It seems that Karlin’s leader lights in this internet writing business (Anglo part) are:

    Hanania, Scott Alexander, Elizier Yudkowski.

    Yudkowski is PRO cryonics. Alexander used to be pro cryonics. In Alexander’s reader surveys he had a cryonics question for years. He has deleted it and not mentioned why. I presume he is now ANTI but doesn’t want to rock anybody’s boat.

    1.b. So what exactly is the deal here?

    1.c. Personally I consider cryonics, as it exists, a complete waste of time and energy. But there is a fundamental question which is fascinating. What is life? It appears to me nobody has a good answer to this apart from faith and dogma.

    2. The turn towards impending AI Paperclips Doom and away from Russian Nationalism seems like a cop out. That is a point worth looking at. It is convenient for AK’s self-esteem that he can put forth such an argument to trivialize losing his big bet on the Special Military Operation. If I was him I would be trying to figure out a way to pretend the latter never happened.

    3. I have more but I am skeptical that you would enjoy getting me started.

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    Kolmogorov?–he is the fat guy who got drugged out and jumped to his death onto a Moscow street naked
     
    He was called Egor Prosvirnin.

    I have more but I am skeptical that you would enjoy getting me started.
     
    You should continue on this, me previously missed the bit about gayparading countries ending all wars between them, so maybe something else entertaining will pop up too;)

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  137. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    https://boingboing.net/2010/10/20/jacques-vallees-stat.html

    I, Product
    Jacques Vallee
    Boingboing

    Replies: @songbird

    Only listened to the author give an interview on a podcast, but he did mention how certain breeds of dogs have a popularity spike after they star in movies.

    Maybe, they need to keep cinema alive to data-harvest gases. Would be interesting to test different demographic groups, to see if there are any HBD angles.

  138. I wonder whether hyper-loquacious people tend to be more paranoid. I mean like the verbal diarrhea people.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @songbird


    I wonder whether hyper-loquacious people tend to be more paranoid. I mean like the verbal diarrhea people.
     
    Do you have some commenters on this thread in mind?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird

  139. @songbird
    I wonder whether hyper-loquacious people tend to be more paranoid. I mean like the verbal diarrhea people.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    I wonder whether hyper-loquacious people tend to be more paranoid. I mean like the verbal diarrhea people.

    Do you have some commenters on this thread in mind?

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AnonfromTN

    Two types paranoia:

    1. Ubiquitous
    2. Insufficient

    , @songbird
    @AnonfromTN

    Lol. I was thinking more along the lines of speaking than typing.

    But to go off on a tangent, I've always felt there was something "off" about Philip K. Dick's writing. Not sure whether it was drugs or his unaltered mind, but I recall hearing some surprising statistic that a lot of the early Pulitzer winners were alcoholics, so I would lean towards some sort of substance-enhancement.

    Browsing the wiki article on logorrhea, I see it is linked to a number of disorders. But I was thinking of something more like the reverse: can the need to always be talking itself lead naturally to paranoia? Suppose it is hard to separate cause from effect.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AnonfromTN

  140. @AnonfromTN
    @songbird


    I wonder whether hyper-loquacious people tend to be more paranoid. I mean like the verbal diarrhea people.
     
    Do you have some commenters on this thread in mind?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird

    Two types paranoia:

    1. Ubiquitous
    2. Insufficient

  141. @Derer
    @AP


    Most Americans support immigration:
     
    It should read most Democrats support immigration. Who built the wall and who oppose it to keep bringing other countries rejects. Those that are doing fine will not leave their homeland. The exemption is political immigration, however in most cases the prevalence of deceit is substantial.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    It should read most Democrats support immigration

    Most independents support it too. And slightly less than half of Republicans oppose it.

    So most Americans, overall, support it.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @AP

    At the national level I think this is another manipulated conversation (for decades). People do not understand the impact of different fertility rates and age distributions, chain migration and the vast number of illegal immigrants. In much of the country these aspects are not yet obvious to an uncritical eye.

  142. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    That poll found few in favor of increasing immigration (7%), while the rest were split between wanting it kept the same (39%), wanting it decreased (33%) or unsure (20%).

     

    The data that you reference here is from 1965:

    Gallup takes the public’s temperature on the volume of immigration by asking if immigration should be kept at its present level, increased or decreased. This was first measured in 1965, when Congress passed the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965 that reformed federal immigration policy. That poll found few in favor of increasing immigration (7%), while the rest were split between wanting it kept the same (39%), wanting it decreased (33%) or unsure (20%).

     

    From your very same link, I found this:

    Given the major increase in the number of migrants seeking to enter the U.S. at the Southern border in recent years, Americans’ desire for less immigration has ticked upward, now reaching 41%. This exceeds the 26% who now want more immigration and is the highest since 2014.

     

    The table below, titled "Americans' Preferences for Immigration", confirms this:

    41% want immigration decreased
    31% want immigration to remain at current levels
    26% want immigration increased

    That's for right now. For 1965, the figures on the very same table were indeed like you stated above:

    39% want immigration to remain at current levels
    33% want immigration decreased
    7% want immigration increased

    This shows just how massively US immigration attitudes have shifted in a pro-immigration direction since 1965, especially considering that immigration levels to the US, whether in a per capita sense or in a total sense, were much lower in 1965 than they are right now.

    Few Americans wanted increased immigration back in 1965 but many more of them want increased immigration today, though a bit less than a couple of years ago, possibly due to Biden's border rush.

    Replies: @AP

    Thanks for the correction!

    • Thanks: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    No problem! And Yeah, Americans nowadays are much more in favor of increased immigration than they were back in 1965, in spite of the US taking in many more immigrants both in per capita terms and in total terms right now relative to 1965. In fact, this might help explain why the Democrats have become more pro-immigration over the last 20 or 30 years (bless them!). Their base simply wants a more pro-immigration policy for the US.

    FWIW, I personally support bringing culturally compatible working-class people over here but I also support accepting as many cognitive elites as we can reasonably support and accommodate. I think that it's deeply regretful that the US Congress isn't pushing to significantly increase the number of cognitive elites who will be eligible to move over here. Canada, Australia, and New Zealand are all busy scooping them up. Why shouldn't we as well? Again, I want this to be done alongside culturally compatible working-class immigration, not in place of it.

    If I was in Europe, I'd be more of an immigration nationalist since Europe gets more troublesome working-class immigrants (Muslims and Africans instead of Latin Americans) and also gets less cognitive elites relative to the US and relative to their own working-class immigrant population. (In contrast, the immigrants that the US gets outside of Latin America are mostly cognitive elites.) If AI became a bigger thing in the West, including in Europe, thus providing less strain to the social safety net there, I could imagine myself supporting greater immigration to Europe from places like India, the Philippines, Vietnam, Thailand, East Asia, et cetera, though.

  143. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    Thanks for the correction!

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    No problem! And Yeah, Americans nowadays are much more in favor of increased immigration than they were back in 1965, in spite of the US taking in many more immigrants both in per capita terms and in total terms right now relative to 1965. In fact, this might help explain why the Democrats have become more pro-immigration over the last 20 or 30 years (bless them!). Their base simply wants a more pro-immigration policy for the US.

    FWIW, I personally support bringing culturally compatible working-class people over here but I also support accepting as many cognitive elites as we can reasonably support and accommodate. I think that it’s deeply regretful that the US Congress isn’t pushing to significantly increase the number of cognitive elites who will be eligible to move over here. Canada, Australia, and New Zealand are all busy scooping them up. Why shouldn’t we as well? Again, I want this to be done alongside culturally compatible working-class immigration, not in place of it.

    If I was in Europe, I’d be more of an immigration nationalist since Europe gets more troublesome working-class immigrants (Muslims and Africans instead of Latin Americans) and also gets less cognitive elites relative to the US and relative to their own working-class immigrant population. (In contrast, the immigrants that the US gets outside of Latin America are mostly cognitive elites.) If AI became a bigger thing in the West, including in Europe, thus providing less strain to the social safety net there, I could imagine myself supporting greater immigration to Europe from places like India, the Philippines, Vietnam, Thailand, East Asia, et cetera, though.

  144. Sher Singh says:
    @Sher Singh
    @Sher Singh

    https://imgur com/a/A9TCCaY

    Link broken, but that's my full split.
    Did it for a friend.

    Here's the guide from Mike Israetel: (under more)

    https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/781336597492662312/1187832641127456858/image.png

    https://ryanlefebvre.github.io/RP-Hypertrophy-Hub-Visualizer/#/

    Tbh, I think viewing it from a weekly angle is wrong for a few reasons.
    Based on my experience, you should aim for a X frequency & Y volume per session.

    At that point, your weekly volume will be fine.
    That 8-20 sets per week is a broad guideline encompassing both free weights & machines.

    Since I only use barbell, cable or dumbbell I tend towards lower end & just do what's comfortable.
    --
    I have ran programs where you increase by 1 set per week.
    It's brutal, but sort of works - haven't tried it since Alpha Progression (Got it Last Nov).

    What I do now is just change reps every few weeks, but do sets by feel.
    --
    When you do too much volume you tend to just rest more & your 5x week turns into 5x in 10 days.

    Replies: @Sher Singh

    Eh – added 20lb to 10rm on curls last 8 weeks.
    Just being inpatient.

    Also changing bench/ohp T1 to 6-8.
    7,7, 8,8, 6, 6 over 6 weeks.

    Front Squat Rdl probably still 4-6.

    https://swoleateveryheight.blogspot.com/2014/07/the-gzcl-method-simplified_13.html?m=1

    I kind of do that but with a bodybuilding focus.

    Lifting right now actually, OHP day lol.

    Last set doing 8 instead of 4s

    ਅਕਾਲ

  145. @AnonfromTN
    @songbird


    I wonder whether hyper-loquacious people tend to be more paranoid. I mean like the verbal diarrhea people.
     
    Do you have some commenters on this thread in mind?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird

    Lol. I was thinking more along the lines of speaking than typing.

    But to go off on a tangent, I’ve always felt there was something “off” about Philip K. Dick’s writing. Not sure whether it was drugs or his unaltered mind, but I recall hearing some surprising statistic that a lot of the early Pulitzer winners were alcoholics, so I would lean towards some sort of substance-enhancement.

    Browsing the wiki article on logorrhea, I see it is linked to a number of disorders. But I was thinking of something more like the reverse: can the need to always be talking itself lead naturally to paranoia? Suppose it is hard to separate cause from effect.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    Writers have a very high proportion of alcoholism.

    Dick was a speed freak. Did you watch Through a Glass Darkly? The bugs crawling on the guy's skin in the shower is a speed thing. Speed is very destructive. Scott Alexander prescribes adderall and ritalin and he claims 2/3 of the programmers in the valley are on the stuff. And half the time when he gets a new patient, the guy wants a speed scrip.

    When Joe Biden appears lucid it probably is a temporary drug benefit.

    Through a Glass Darkly is pretty great if you haven't watched it. But the book is even better. The best line in the book was not in the movie. Protagonist's girlfriend calls him up in the middle of the day because she has a cockroach in her kitchen and she is scared. He goes over there and kills it. He tells her they are harmless. She says,


    If I had known it was harmless I would have killed it myself.
     
    The girlfriend is a psycho. All of Dick's girlfriends were psychos. In relationship therapy class they tell you that people do that because it's familiar. The subconscious always prefers the familiar, even when simple logic tells you she is a worthless and negative force.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

    , @AnonfromTN
    @songbird


    Suppose it is hard to separate cause from effect.
     
    Classical chicken and egg conundrum. Evolution solved it, although it took millions of years.
  146. On this day in Canada 108 years ago:

    ਪ੍ਰਣਾਮ ਸ਼ਹੀਦਾਂ ਨੁ

    “And I, performing the duty of a true Sikh and remembering the name of God, will proceed towards death with the same amount of pleasure as a hungry baby goes towards his mother.”

    ਅਕਾਲ

  147. @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    The race zealots around these parts do not seem to comprehend that ethnically they are Spaniards. Almost all of the Native Americans in Mexico were wiped out.
     
    Not really. In fact, the fraction of Indians and part-Indians among Mexes who come to the US is much greater than in Mexico. This is natural: people who are doing OK do not subject themselves to the dangers of border crossing. Many of Mexes doing construction work here in TN, including those who worked in my yard and changed my roof, as well as those that wash my car at the good carwash, are 50-100% Indians, judging by their looks. Usually their foreman speaks some English and communicates with you, the rest only know “Hi” and “Fuck”.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    In fact, the fraction of Indians and part-Indians among Mexes who come to the US is much greater than in Mexico.

    The nearly 100% European elites of Mexico rarely come to the USA, their life is great here, but the poorest Mexicans don’t come either. Hiring smugglers is not too cheap. USA tends to get poor farmers and lower middle class types from Mexico, people who want to leave badly and can come up with a few thousand dollars if they sacrifice their life savings (the poorest cannot do even that). And they tend to come from regions with higher % European ancestry rather than the deep south of Mexico where people have more Indian ancestry though there has been somewhat of a shift over time.

    Mexican-American % Indian ancestry varies from about 42% in older immigrants to 52% in recent immigrants:

    https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.01.13.905141v2.full

    This isn’t too different from Mexico itself, excluding the elite. The average Mexican Mestizo is 56% Indian.

    Many of Mexes doing construction work here in TN, including those who worked in my yard and changed my roof, as well as those that wash my car at the good carwash, are 50-100% Indians, judging by their looks

    Looks can be somewhat deceiving, because European traits are often recessive and because the Europeans they are descended from are Meds, who tend to be dark already.

    For example Eva Longoria is 70% European and only 27% Native:

    https://blogs.ancestry.com/cm/eva-longorias-surprising-dna-test/

    Someone who is 50/50 (the typical immigrant from Mexico) would look even more Indian than she does.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    Mexican-American % Indian ancestry varies from about 42% in older immigrants to 52% in recent immigrants:

    https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.01.13.905141v2.full

    This isn’t too different from Mexico itself, excluding the elite. The average Mexican Mestizo is 56% Indian.
     

    So, good enough for an Israeli-style white ethnostate! Israel accepts people who are 25% or more Jewish and their immediate family members, at least just so long as they don't practice any other religion. (Practicing no religion at all is fine.)
    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    BTW, AP, I was wondering: What percentage European ancestry would you give this woman?

    https://www.istockphoto.com/photo/young-couple-kissing-on-the-beach-gm186579750-27944940

    The man here should be 100% European by ancestry or extremely close to it.

    , @QCIC
    @AP

    The paper claims the US will be 29% Hispanic/Latino by 2060. I think this percentage will be reached much sooner.

    What is the median IQ south of the border for the non-Criollo fraction (since they don't immigrate)? Possibly it is mid-low 80's. So what is the IQ of illegal immigrants to the USA? What percentage have IQ below 85?

    Eva always looked more "unknown" than she did Hispanic.

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    , @AnonfromTN
    @AP

    Everything related to darker pigmentation, darker skin, black eyes, and black hair, is dominant: lighter color simply means that the gene(s) responsible for pigment production are defective. Eye and hair color is largely a Mendelian trait. It is more complex with skin color: several genes are responsible for that, so we have many different shades, from really black Cameroonians (all genes are functional) to very blond Swedes (all genes are defective).

    But the facial features are not a Mendelian trait, and they are not dominant, but determined by a complex interplay of multiple genes. That’s why there are so many facial types. E.g., central American Indians are recognizably different from North American (whatever is left of them) or Andean Quechua people.

  148. @Derer
    @AP


    There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.
     
    Only illiterate. Do not forget the J yoke in Poland is as strong as in Ukraine.

    Replies: @AP

    There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

    Only illiterate.

    This guy was no illiterate:

    https://www.polskieradio.pl/395/9766/artykul/3184898,in-memory-of-a-pole-who-died-for-free-ukraine

    Daniel, after volunteering for combat in Ukraine, served in Kyiv’s elite special forces as a reconnaissance team member. He had three university degrees and extensive military training, including at Poland’s elite special-forces unit GROM.

    “I regret a bit my last message to him……He sent me a poem by Herbert, a famous Polish poet. There was a certain doubt in this piece, and the author described how no one would repay him, and that he would be mocked for what he had done. After reading it, I was stressed I felt that he needs me, so I wrote to him, “Son, you were the last to doubt. Be brave, you are fighting the army of darkness and you are on the side of good”. And he answered me, Finally, Dad, thank you. I think I gave him permission to sacrifice himself. I think about it and ask myself, why I didn’t write to him to be careful and not to risk it”.

    “I respect what he did and have respected it from the beginning. He made his choice fully aware that he was taking a risk, but he wanted a free nation, protection of Poland, Europe, and the world,” Mirosław Sztyber added.

    Do not forget the J yoke in Poland is as strong as in Ukraine.

    You haven’t heard of the problems between Poland and Israel?

    • Replies: @A123
    @AP

    Why would Judaism have anything to do with someone volunteering to fight in Ukraine?

    What is the Jewish population in Poland? IIRC, less than 20K. Judaism has effectively no impact on Polish culture or politics.



    Do not forget the J yoke in Poland is as strong as in Ukraine.
     
    You haven’t heard of the problems between Poland and Israel?
     
    The friction between Poland and Palestinian Jews is quite limited. These days, most of it is related to the fact that Israel is officially neutral to Russia leaning.

    I find it puzzling that everyone seems to miss that the current Kiev regime hates Jews. Here is the latest offense: (1)

    [Volodymyr Zelenskyy] is undermining a 1994 agreement with the United States, and is violating the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, by digging up a Jewish cemetery in Uman, Ukraine, to build condos.

    A project that began in the summer of 2016 in the Ukrainian city of Uman, a well-known site of Jewish pilgrimage as the burial place of Rabbi Nachman of Breslov, as well as a mass grave of victims of the Haidamacks massacre, has seen human remains being dug up as early as summer of 2022, according to a report in Ukrainian media. The site sees tens of thousands of Jewish visitors from around the world on Rosh Hashana alone, and thousands more throughout the year, even during wartime.
     
    Post Judaic apostate Zelensky's track record of anti-Semitism has been clear for years.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2024/01/10/morris-ukraine-seeks-billions-from-u-s-as-it-desecrates-jewish-cemetery-to-build-condo/

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    You haven’t heard of the problems between Poland and Israel?

     

    Who do you personally support in this dispute, AP?
  149. @songbird
    @AnonfromTN

    Lol. I was thinking more along the lines of speaking than typing.

    But to go off on a tangent, I've always felt there was something "off" about Philip K. Dick's writing. Not sure whether it was drugs or his unaltered mind, but I recall hearing some surprising statistic that a lot of the early Pulitzer winners were alcoholics, so I would lean towards some sort of substance-enhancement.

    Browsing the wiki article on logorrhea, I see it is linked to a number of disorders. But I was thinking of something more like the reverse: can the need to always be talking itself lead naturally to paranoia? Suppose it is hard to separate cause from effect.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AnonfromTN

    Writers have a very high proportion of alcoholism.

    Dick was a speed freak. Did you watch Through a Glass Darkly? The bugs crawling on the guy’s skin in the shower is a speed thing. Speed is very destructive. Scott Alexander prescribes adderall and ritalin and he claims 2/3 of the programmers in the valley are on the stuff. And half the time when he gets a new patient, the guy wants a speed scrip.

    When Joe Biden appears lucid it probably is a temporary drug benefit.

    Through a Glass Darkly is pretty great if you haven’t watched it. But the book is even better. The best line in the book was not in the movie. Protagonist’s girlfriend calls him up in the middle of the day because she has a cockroach in her kitchen and she is scared. He goes over there and kills it. He tells her they are harmless. She says,

    If I had known it was harmless I would have killed it myself.

    The girlfriend is a psycho. All of Dick’s girlfriends were psychos. In relationship therapy class they tell you that people do that because it’s familiar. The subconscious always prefers the familiar, even when simple logic tells you she is a worthless and negative force.

    • Thanks: songbird
    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    The girlfriend is a psycho. All of Dick’s girlfriends were psychos. In relationship therapy class they tell you that people do that because it’s familiar. The subconscious always prefers the familiar, even when simple logic tells you she is a worthless and negative force.
     
    IMHO, her response doesn't automatically qualify her as a psycho... It is a bit solipsistic, but applied solipsism is a female trait much too often.

    And why do you so easily believe in explanatory power of Freudian concepts? i would expect more discernment from you. The psychologists-peddled ideas like "the subconscious is irresistibly drawn to the familiar" just absolve us of any responsibility and hide ugly truths like "some humans really are (sado)masochists", normalizing our suffering for us, with the exception of "trauma" ;) (or "trauma" is a new name for "real" suffering).
    Psychology is a new religion of sinners ;)

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  150. @Beckow
    @AP


    the combination of natural resources and manufacturing particular high end manufacturing favors the West, especially the USA.
     
    My points was: if the power gets reshuffled to omit paper and other verbal stuff, it will be the West that will lose more....do you understand the meaning of lose more?

    In absolute terms the two camps will be roughly equal, the big loser will be Europe that has minimal resources and its manufacturing is not competitive. US-Canada-Australia will do much better - there is a strong opinion in EU that is why US is willing to do this - they are cannibalizing their Euro allies.

    But the collective West will lose more - disproportionate share of the Western economy is derived from soft activities that may go away or shrink: finance, consulting, cultural products, bulls..t jobs in the meta economy (business about business)...

    The anti-West is also growing a lot faster then the West...over time it will get worse. The way to correct it would be to go back to more real economy, but the costs are high and it goes against the dominant liberal ideology. People in the West - in Europe - are not inclined to exchange their comfy subsidized lives and bs jobs for working harder.

    The security-defense boom can cover some of it for a while but it will eventually (soon) lead to lower access to consumer goods and good life. Defense is a lot of things but it doesn't increase living standards - it is an economic black hole: stuff goes in and nothing comes out...

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @A123, @AP

    In absolute terms the two camps will be roughly equal, the big loser will be Europe that has minimal resources and its manufacturing is not competitive. US-Canada-Australia will do much better

    I actually agree with you here. But it is Western Europe that is declining. The East does not. Poland’s economy keeps improving, year after year.

    – there is a strong opinion in EU that is why US is willing to do this – they are cannibalizing their Euro allies

    No one forced Germany to stupidly get rid of its nuclear power. Or to stupidly become overly dependent on Russian gas (these two phenomena are linked – Russia was funding the German anti-nuclear activists, though Germans shouldn’t have listened to them). Such mistakes have consequences. German manufacturers are moving many of their operations to the USA. When peace comes to Ukraine they will move a lot there, also.

    The security-defense boom can cover some of it for a while but it will eventually (soon) lead to lower access to consumer goods and good life. Defense is a lot of things but it doesn’t increase living standards – it is an economic black hole: stuff goes in and nothing comes out…

    You do realize that you just described most of Russia’s recent economic “growth,” right?

    Much more true of Russia than of the West.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    I actually agree with you here. But it is Western Europe that is declining. The East does not. Poland’s economy keeps improving, year after year.

     

    Eastern Europe often has booming economies, but it isn't producing elite science in the same quantities as Western Europe is. It's not even close:

    https://www.unz.com/akarlin/science-production/

    https://www.unz.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/map-nature-index-cities-europe-2017.png

    The US and East Asia also punch pretty well, but sadly Eastern Europe does not:

    https://www.unz.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/map-nature-index-cities-world-2017.png

    How much of this is due to brain drain, especially of the more creative and innovative people there, is hard to say.


    When peace comes to Ukraine they will move a lot there, also.
     
    If Ukraine's security will be solidly assured, then Yes, hopefully. South Korea was also in a state of frozen conflict over the last 70+ years but nevertheless managed to become an economic wonder story:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracle_on_the_Han_River

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/5f/GDP_history_Since_1950_~_2016.png

    Its total fertility rate (currently at just 0.72 children per woman per lifetime) is extremely dismal, though. Possibly worse than even Ukraine's during wartime, though hard to tell without concrete data.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    , @Beckow
    @AP

    The situation with German economy is a lot more complicated than just the "nuclear power", etc...The energy squeeze is happening everywhere and it is getting worse. Germany used eastern Europe for a lot of energy-intensive manufacturing and it is now gradually shutting down. The overall supply chain has been blown up and the consequences are just starting - in the next 2 to 5 years we will see it.

    Russia was also a very good market: high prices and they paid on time - high profit margins in Russia subsidized other business. The money Russia earned stayed in the Western banks allowing for an investment boom and lower interest rates. The one-time proposed theft is a bad idea - imagine if your bank takes your deposits, will anyone ever work with them? Russia will continue generating hundreds of billions in profits each year - that's the money that matters and it is close to exiting permanently.

    You don't understand economics or business well - even you pointing to "defense" boom in Russia is short-sighted: they are in an existential war and they have resources (forever), they can afford to do it, Europe can't - Euros also don't have any inclination to go into an existential fight. Poland is not "Europe", it is just noise in the east.

    Replies: @AP, @Another Polish Perspective

    , @Sean
    @AP


    When peace comes to Ukraine they will move a lot there, also
     
    Which is why Putin will never let peace come to Ukraine.
  151. @AP
    @AnonfromTN


    In fact, the fraction of Indians and part-Indians among Mexes who come to the US is much greater than in Mexico.
     
    The nearly 100% European elites of Mexico rarely come to the USA, their life is great here, but the poorest Mexicans don't come either. Hiring smugglers is not too cheap. USA tends to get poor farmers and lower middle class types from Mexico, people who want to leave badly and can come up with a few thousand dollars if they sacrifice their life savings (the poorest cannot do even that). And they tend to come from regions with higher % European ancestry rather than the deep south of Mexico where people have more Indian ancestry though there has been somewhat of a shift over time.

    Mexican-American % Indian ancestry varies from about 42% in older immigrants to 52% in recent immigrants:

    https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.01.13.905141v2.full

    This isn't too different from Mexico itself, excluding the elite. The average Mexican Mestizo is 56% Indian.

    Many of Mexes doing construction work here in TN, including those who worked in my yard and changed my roof, as well as those that wash my car at the good carwash, are 50-100% Indians, judging by their looks
     
    Looks can be somewhat deceiving, because European traits are often recessive and because the Europeans they are descended from are Meds, who tend to be dark already.

    For example Eva Longoria is 70% European and only 27% Native:

    https://blogs.ancestry.com/cm/eva-longorias-surprising-dna-test/

    https://wl-brightside.cf.tsp.li/resize/728x/jpg/70b/0ec/c3839a5e8d9978486bfb1d3e8e.jpg

    Someone who is 50/50 (the typical immigrant from Mexico) would look even more Indian than she does.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ, @QCIC, @AnonfromTN

    Mexican-American % Indian ancestry varies from about 42% in older immigrants to 52% in recent immigrants:

    https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.01.13.905141v2.full

    This isn’t too different from Mexico itself, excluding the elite. The average Mexican Mestizo is 56% Indian.

    So, good enough for an Israeli-style white ethnostate! Israel accepts people who are 25% or more Jewish and their immediate family members, at least just so long as they don’t practice any other religion. (Practicing no religion at all is fine.)

  152. @AP
    @Beckow


    In absolute terms the two camps will be roughly equal, the big loser will be Europe that has minimal resources and its manufacturing is not competitive. US-Canada-Australia will do much better
     
    I actually agree with you here. But it is Western Europe that is declining. The East does not. Poland's economy keeps improving, year after year.

    – there is a strong opinion in EU that is why US is willing to do this – they are cannibalizing their Euro allies
     
    No one forced Germany to stupidly get rid of its nuclear power. Or to stupidly become overly dependent on Russian gas (these two phenomena are linked - Russia was funding the German anti-nuclear activists, though Germans shouldn't have listened to them). Such mistakes have consequences. German manufacturers are moving many of their operations to the USA. When peace comes to Ukraine they will move a lot there, also.

    The security-defense boom can cover some of it for a while but it will eventually (soon) lead to lower access to consumer goods and good life. Defense is a lot of things but it doesn’t increase living standards – it is an economic black hole: stuff goes in and nothing comes out…
     
    You do realize that you just described most of Russia's recent economic "growth," right?

    Much more true of Russia than of the West.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @Sean

    I actually agree with you here. But it is Western Europe that is declining. The East does not. Poland’s economy keeps improving, year after year.

    Eastern Europe often has booming economies, but it isn’t producing elite science in the same quantities as Western Europe is. It’s not even close:

    https://www.unz.com/akarlin/science-production/

    The US and East Asia also punch pretty well, but sadly Eastern Europe does not:

    How much of this is due to brain drain, especially of the more creative and innovative people there, is hard to say.

    When peace comes to Ukraine they will move a lot there, also.

    If Ukraine’s security will be solidly assured, then Yes, hopefully. South Korea was also in a state of frozen conflict over the last 70+ years but nevertheless managed to become an economic wonder story:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracle_on_the_Han_River

    Its total fertility rate (currently at just 0.72 children per woman per lifetime) is extremely dismal, though. Possibly worse than even Ukraine’s during wartime, though hard to tell without concrete data.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. XYZ

    AP, what do you think is the cause of Eastern Europe's lack of elite science production relative to Western Europe?

    It's a similar story in regards to patents:

    https://jakubmarian.com/number-of-patent-applications-per-capita-by-region-in-europe/

    https://jakubmarian.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/nuts2-patents.jpg

    Seems like the most innovative place in the Eastern European part of the EU is Budapest. But I do suspect that there is a Communist legacy factor in holding Eastern Europe back at least a little bit. Estonia performs much, much worse than Finland does in spite of Estonians and Finns being genetically similar, after all. (Estonia might only be around 70% Estonian, but that's still a solid majority.)

    Replies: @AP

  153. AP, I have a question for you about a Russia that was expansionist but also not destroyed its 20th century demographic potential, such as if the Whites would have won the Russian Civil War and Russia would have subsequently eventually went Fascist: In such a scenario, what exactly would Russia’s most likely expansion target(s) have been? I’m inclined to say Constantinople and the Straits, which a Fascist Russia might view as being unfinished business from WWI, but what else? If the Baltics will become independent, a Fascist Russia might go for them. Maybe also for Finland, for Bessarabia, and/or for the Kresy (eastern Poland) if it can get them. Maybe for southern Sakhalin in the Far East. But all of these territories aren’t hugely important. Is there anything bigger that an expansionist Fascist Russia can go for?

    Putin’s Russia is certainly revanchist, but much of its power (excluding nukes) have been drained away due to Russia’s 20th century extreme demographic devastation (relative to what Russia’s full potential would have been). I’m wondering what a Russia with a similar expansionist mentality but with much better demographics would have done. Maybe we can look to Tsarist Russia as a guide, but where else exactly would Tsarist Russia have expanded into if it wasn’t for WWI?

  154. @AP
    @AnonfromTN


    In fact, the fraction of Indians and part-Indians among Mexes who come to the US is much greater than in Mexico.
     
    The nearly 100% European elites of Mexico rarely come to the USA, their life is great here, but the poorest Mexicans don't come either. Hiring smugglers is not too cheap. USA tends to get poor farmers and lower middle class types from Mexico, people who want to leave badly and can come up with a few thousand dollars if they sacrifice their life savings (the poorest cannot do even that). And they tend to come from regions with higher % European ancestry rather than the deep south of Mexico where people have more Indian ancestry though there has been somewhat of a shift over time.

    Mexican-American % Indian ancestry varies from about 42% in older immigrants to 52% in recent immigrants:

    https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.01.13.905141v2.full

    This isn't too different from Mexico itself, excluding the elite. The average Mexican Mestizo is 56% Indian.

    Many of Mexes doing construction work here in TN, including those who worked in my yard and changed my roof, as well as those that wash my car at the good carwash, are 50-100% Indians, judging by their looks
     
    Looks can be somewhat deceiving, because European traits are often recessive and because the Europeans they are descended from are Meds, who tend to be dark already.

    For example Eva Longoria is 70% European and only 27% Native:

    https://blogs.ancestry.com/cm/eva-longorias-surprising-dna-test/

    https://wl-brightside.cf.tsp.li/resize/728x/jpg/70b/0ec/c3839a5e8d9978486bfb1d3e8e.jpg

    Someone who is 50/50 (the typical immigrant from Mexico) would look even more Indian than she does.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ, @QCIC, @AnonfromTN

    BTW, AP, I was wondering: What percentage European ancestry would you give this woman?

    https://www.istockphoto.com/photo/young-couple-kissing-on-the-beach-gm186579750-27944940

    The man here should be 100% European by ancestry or extremely close to it.

  155. Certain self-proclaimed amateur analyst by the moniker “AP” specified what is destroying Europe. He is right about the current Europe being destroyed by the immigration of visible minorities. However this issue is only side effect of the US idiotic policies of meddling/destroying countries close to Europe that create refugees; Iraq, Libya, Syria and more. The contemporary Europe is being destroyed by the:

    i) Washington ruling gang.
    Washington is not a friend of Europe but a bellow-the-bell competitor pretending to be a friend…Serbia, Ukraine, Germany (Nord Stream 2 terrorism) etc.

    ii) Former colonizing culprits.
    Causing chicken coming home to roost…are sent to homogeneous Central and Eastern Europe.

    iii) EU bureaucrats…
    a 50000 strong Commission is essentially based on a communist dictatorial model that was defeated in Soviet Union or Yugoslavia.
    For example:
    Pythagorean theorem was written by 24 words.
    The Lord’s Prayer by 66 words
    Archimedes Principle by 67 words
    The Ten Commandments by 179 words
    The Gettysburg Address by 286 words
    The Declaration of Independence by 1300 words, but
    THE EU CABBAGE TRADE RULES by 26 911 words.

  156. @AP
    @Derer


    It should read most Democrats support immigration
     
    Most independents support it too. And slightly less than half of Republicans oppose it.

    So most Americans, overall, support it.

    Replies: @QCIC

    At the national level I think this is another manipulated conversation (for decades). People do not understand the impact of different fertility rates and age distributions, chain migration and the vast number of illegal immigrants. In much of the country these aspects are not yet obvious to an uncritical eye.

  157. @AP
    @AnonfromTN


    In fact, the fraction of Indians and part-Indians among Mexes who come to the US is much greater than in Mexico.
     
    The nearly 100% European elites of Mexico rarely come to the USA, their life is great here, but the poorest Mexicans don't come either. Hiring smugglers is not too cheap. USA tends to get poor farmers and lower middle class types from Mexico, people who want to leave badly and can come up with a few thousand dollars if they sacrifice their life savings (the poorest cannot do even that). And they tend to come from regions with higher % European ancestry rather than the deep south of Mexico where people have more Indian ancestry though there has been somewhat of a shift over time.

    Mexican-American % Indian ancestry varies from about 42% in older immigrants to 52% in recent immigrants:

    https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.01.13.905141v2.full

    This isn't too different from Mexico itself, excluding the elite. The average Mexican Mestizo is 56% Indian.

    Many of Mexes doing construction work here in TN, including those who worked in my yard and changed my roof, as well as those that wash my car at the good carwash, are 50-100% Indians, judging by their looks
     
    Looks can be somewhat deceiving, because European traits are often recessive and because the Europeans they are descended from are Meds, who tend to be dark already.

    For example Eva Longoria is 70% European and only 27% Native:

    https://blogs.ancestry.com/cm/eva-longorias-surprising-dna-test/

    https://wl-brightside.cf.tsp.li/resize/728x/jpg/70b/0ec/c3839a5e8d9978486bfb1d3e8e.jpg

    Someone who is 50/50 (the typical immigrant from Mexico) would look even more Indian than she does.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ, @QCIC, @AnonfromTN

    The paper claims the US will be 29% Hispanic/Latino by 2060. I think this percentage will be reached much sooner.

    What is the median IQ south of the border for the non-Criollo fraction (since they don’t immigrate)? Possibly it is mid-low 80’s. So what is the IQ of illegal immigrants to the USA? What percentage have IQ below 85?

    Eva always looked more “unknown” than she did Hispanic.

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @QCIC


    always looked more “unknown” than she did Hispanic.
     

    https://youtu.be/2AzpHvLWFUM?si=iTuzGgLRhvLcJsrw
  158. Simon Webb is beating the warning drums about Haley, implying Indians may take over the leadership of America too.

    [MORE]

    I understand she benefits a lot from the Christie withdrawal.

    Haven’t been paying much attention to things and mostly successfully avoiding the ads. But I did see one the other day:

    Some Democrat candidate. The gist of what he said was “I am on the ballot because I represent freedom, which is why the Orangeman was banned from the ballot.”

  159. @Sher Singh
    @Yahya


    https://imgur.com/a/A9TCCaY

    Long as the app has progress recommendations it's good.
    Alpha is good cuz let's say I did 150x10 for RIR 2 on Week 1.

    Week 3 I want to sets of 6 it'll keep in the same RIR & might have me do 175x6.
    Tracking 10RM is IMO superior for bodybuilding.

    --
    Keep in mind I was doing close to 40 sets a session a few months back.
    This is just my current way to balance 6x a week with fatigue/life.

    Alpha means I can make consistent progress without guesswork.
    When it stalls, I'll add/subtract volume or w/e.
    --

    What's your favorite bicep exercises?
    Not really feeling barbell or DB curls & don't have a low pulley or incline bench.

    :/

    Replies: @Sher Singh, @Yahya

    What’s your favorite bicep exercises?

    E-Z Bar Curls

    I used to train 5 times per week when bulking, but have since embarked on cutting phase and reduced my sessions to 4 times per week on a minimalist program a-la Jeff Nippard.

    Right now I’m pissed since I didn’t lose any weight over the past week despite being on a ~500 calorie deficit. Could be due to factors related to carb intake or water retention, but frustrating to see no gains in that area. Thinking of reducing my calorie deficit by another 200kcal per day, see if it will work.

    • Agree: Sher Singh
    • Replies: @Sher Singh
    @Yahya

    I'm trying to cut without using macro factor atm.

    I find knowing you have X calories left encourages you to fill the bowl, so to speak.

    Instead, I make sure to get enough protein & then chill.

    With running too I just try to run after every session now - even if it's a few Km.

    --
    My ohp started climbing again since we last spoke.

    Saving that video though, thanks.

    https://bretcontreras.com/how-to-fix-glute-imbalances/

    No homo this fixed a 6 year old lifting injury I had literally days ago.

    I did iso contractions on weaker side & then during morning prayers after I think Good Mornings - my hip popped back into place.

    Took 3 days & yeah.
    --
    Still wearing Talwar everyday & involved in cases wherever they try to restrict it.

    Fateh with Maharaj Blessings.

    ਅਕਾਲ

    Replies: @Barbarossa, @Yahya

  160. @AP
    @Derer


    There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

    Only illiterate.

     

    This guy was no illiterate:

    https://bi.im-g.pl/im/03/ed/1b/z29283587AMP,Pogrzeb-Daniela-Sztybera-na-Powazkach--Mezczyzne--.jpg

    https://www.polskieradio.pl/395/9766/artykul/3184898,in-memory-of-a-pole-who-died-for-free-ukraine

    Daniel, after volunteering for combat in Ukraine, served in Kyiv’s elite special forces as a reconnaissance team member. He had three university degrees and extensive military training, including at Poland's elite special-forces unit GROM.

    “I regret a bit my last message to him......He sent me a poem by Herbert, a famous Polish poet. There was a certain doubt in this piece, and the author described how no one would repay him, and that he would be mocked for what he had done. After reading it, I was stressed I felt that he needs me, so I wrote to him, "Son, you were the last to doubt. Be brave, you are fighting the army of darkness and you are on the side of good". And he answered me, Finally, Dad, thank you. I think I gave him permission to sacrifice himself. I think about it and ask myself, why I didn't write to him to be careful and not to risk it".

    “I respect what he did and have respected it from the beginning. He made his choice fully aware that he was taking a risk, but he wanted a free nation, protection of Poland, Europe, and the world,” Mirosław Sztyber added.

    Do not forget the J yoke in Poland is as strong as in Ukraine.
     
    You haven't heard of the problems between Poland and Israel?

    Replies: @A123, @Mr. XYZ

    Why would Judaism have anything to do with someone volunteering to fight in Ukraine?

    What is the Jewish population in Poland? IIRC, less than 20K. Judaism has effectively no impact on Polish culture or politics.

    Do not forget the J yoke in Poland is as strong as in Ukraine.

    You haven’t heard of the problems between Poland and Israel?

    The friction between Poland and Palestinian Jews is quite limited. These days, most of it is related to the fact that Israel is officially neutral to Russia leaning.

    I find it puzzling that everyone seems to miss that the current Kiev regime hates Jews. Here is the latest offense: (1)

    [Volodymyr Zelenskyy] is undermining a 1994 agreement with the United States, and is violating the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, by digging up a Jewish cemetery in Uman, Ukraine, to build condos.

    A project that began in the summer of 2016 in the Ukrainian city of Uman, a well-known site of Jewish pilgrimage as the burial place of Rabbi Nachman of Breslov, as well as a mass grave of victims of the Haidamacks massacre, has seen human remains being dug up as early as summer of 2022, according to a report in Ukrainian media. The site sees tens of thousands of Jewish visitors from around the world on Rosh Hashana alone, and thousands more throughout the year, even during wartime.

    Post Judaic apostate Zelensky’s track record of anti-Semitism has been clear for years.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2024/01/10/morris-ukraine-seeks-billions-from-u-s-as-it-desecrates-jewish-cemetery-to-build-condo/

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @A123

    Exclusive photographs commissioned by Breitbart of Zelensky himself leading the pack to desecrate the Jewish cemetery. He decided to wear some ancestral garb to make the photos even more genuine:

    https://nardep.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/2bf935b4e3e5092c9bd093837c95b34d.jpg

    The condo that is to be built, is to compliment the one that he already owns in Florida. Islamo-Zelensky needs to be stopped, and kremlinstoogeA123 is the one to do it! :-).

    , @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GD0EYSDXIAEpXCJ.jpg

    Whereas Israel was being asked before the war to make a relatively limited commitment to eventual establishment of a Palestinian state, it will now need to go further in demonstrating that commitment while accepting return of the Palestinian Authority.


    https://twitter.com/TuckerCarlson/status/1745914010669609065

    Replies: @A123

  161. @Yahya
    Gentlemen,

    I know that many of you despaired these past few months from the absence of Yahya's world famous film reviews. So I returned to this sacred forum to provide you with my unusually interesting and perspicuous takes on the films I watched this previous year. Overall, it has been a fruitful year for me cinematically, with a total of 141 films watched. I found it difficult to narrow down my selections to just the top 10 or 20; such was the large number of high-quality films I viewed in 2023. The key to maximizing quality films watched is to quit early when a film displays Goddard-tier dullness and pretentiousness. The Leopard will not change its spots. Just cut your losses and move on.

    1. The Godfather I (1972 - Coppola - American)
    2. The Godfather II (1974 - Coppola - American)
    3. Socrates (1971 - Rossellini - Italian)
    4. The Grand Illusion (1937 - Renoir - French)
    5. Batman Begins (2005 - Nolan - American)
    6. Gone With The Wind (1939 - Fleming - American)
    7. Wild Strawberries (1957 - Bergman - Swedish)
    8. North By Northwest (1959 - Hitchcock - American)
    9. Training Day (2001 - Fuqua - American)
    10. Great Expectations (1946 - Lean - British)
    11. Jane Eyre (1943 - Stevenson - British)
    12. Burnt By The Sun (1994 - Mikhalkov - Russian)
    13. Woman In The Dunes (1964 - Teshigahara - Japanese)
    14. Europe ‘51 (1952 - Rossellini - Italian)
    15. Annie Hall (1977 - Allen - American)
    16. Belle De Jour (1967 - Bunuel - French)
    17. The Searchers (1956 - Ford - American)
    18. The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962 - Ford - American)
    19. Mulholland Drive (2001 - Lynch - American)
    20. The Gentlemen (2019 - Ritchie - British)

    Honorable Mentions
    1. The Equalizer (2014 - Fuqua - American)
    2. Kind Hearts & Coronets (1946 - Hamer - British)
    3. Winter Sleep (2014 - Ceylan - Turkish)
    4. Taxi Driver (1976 - Scorsese - American)
    5. Hamlet (1948 - Olivier - British)

    My ranking of national cinemas remains unchanged from my last post, though I realized that my high opinion of Anglo-American cinema may be biased by the ease of watching English-language movies. Especially towards the second half of the year, I couldn't be bothered with subtitles and strange cinematographic techniques, so my viewings were heavily tilted towards Anglo-American films. But that is a fault I aim to rectify in 2024.

    I've already written about some of these films in my posts throughout the year; so I'll stick to new selections here.

    The Grand Illusion centers around a group of French POWs held in captivity by the Germans; the most alluring of whom is the confident, self-assured Captain de Boeldieu, a French aristocratic officer whose untroubled bearing, upright posture, neat styling, and sardonic demeanor give him a Gaulle-esque aroma I found captivating. Renoir utilizes the setting of the film to comment upon class dynamics: "When I’m with Boeldieu, I never feel completely at ease. Call it the education barrier.” “He’s a fine type.” “Agreed, and he’s very decent. Suppose you and I went broke, we’d both be turned into beggars. If it happened to him, he’d still be Monsieur De Boeldieu.” Though I later found out Renoir is of the Socialistic bent, the film does not exude class hostility, but takes on a tolerant and matter-of-fact observational style as it relates to class and warfare. The film is also refreshing in its male-orientation; there is no romantic sub-plot to please female viewers (“Sentiment has no place in war” as de Boeldieu remarks); and it was a pleasure to view depictions of Old Europe such as the scene in the Gothic Cathedral at minute 50.

    Training Day explores the necessity of harshness, cruelty and rule-breaking in the fight against hard crime; in other words it touches upon the Jungian concept of Integrating The Shadow. "To protect the sheep you gotta catch the wolf, and it takes a wolf to catch a wolf." Washington's character represents the Wolf, he is willing to bend the rules and inflict cruelty on suspects to expedite the process of discovering and apprehending criminals. Denzel’s character is charismatic, bombastic, psychopathic, relentless, decisive. He asserts his will over subordinates by using his position of power and establishes his dominance fairly quickly over Hawke by use of verbal adeptness and charisma. Hawkes' character is initially naïve, rule-following, and considerate of others. Denzel takes advantage of him by deceiving him into the hands of the cartel, but Hawke survives by sheer chance of having rescued a cartel member's cousin earlier in the day. The script is stale when read on paper, but is brought to life by Washington's eloquence and force of personality. One the greatest performances I've seen on screen, and an overall worthy production by an African-American lead actor and director.

    Batman Begins is one of the few mass-market productions I found to be worthy and enjoyable, although it comes with attendant flaws such as two-dimensional characters, a predictable plotline, and a simple script. Nevertheless, it is possible for a blockbuster film to be of high artistic value despite the typical shortcomings; and one must not forget that stalwart classics such as The Godfather and North by Northwest were mass-market productions in their own time. Bruce Wayne presents an archetype of the masculine ideal; eliciting universal respect from all ranges of viewers, as his character and behavior tap into the collective unconscious. Batman's defining features are a) his strength, both mental and physical, which enable him to inflict damage on enemies and protect friends; b) handsome appearance in the traditional masculine sense, which though superficial, is critical to his status as a high-value male (he would not elicit respect had he been ugly and obese); c) an unbending sense of justice; and d) socio-economic status as one of the wealthiest individuals in Gotham.

    Batman is also a Dionysian figure, preferring action over knowledge-seeking. We do not see him sitting on a reclining chair, submerged in a book; but cultivating himself physically through intensive training. He mostly relies on intuition rather than logical reasoning to guide his actions. This was best evidenced in his confrontation with the Joker in the Dark Knight sequel. "The training is nothing, will is everything. The will to act", again emphasizing action over knowledge/training. Batman also develops a network of trust between himself Fox, Alfred, Rachel, and Commissioner Gordon. While Wayne is the central character in this network, he must rely on Fox for the technology, without which he cannot perform his duties.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @Mr. XYZ, @songbird, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Barbarossa

    I know that many of you despaired these past few months from the absence of Yahya’s world famous film reviews. So I returned to this sacred forum to provide you with my unusually interesting and perspicuous takes on the films

    I am a complete philistine when it comes to films.

    I only watched a single one in 2023, it stays with you long after viewing.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    The general looks like he could still pass the fitness test to get out of basic training.

    Replies: @Coconuts

  162. @QCIC
    @AP

    The paper claims the US will be 29% Hispanic/Latino by 2060. I think this percentage will be reached much sooner.

    What is the median IQ south of the border for the non-Criollo fraction (since they don't immigrate)? Possibly it is mid-low 80's. So what is the IQ of illegal immigrants to the USA? What percentage have IQ below 85?

    Eva always looked more "unknown" than she did Hispanic.

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    always looked more “unknown” than she did Hispanic.

    [MORE]

  163. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @Yahya


    I know that many of you despaired these past few months from the absence of Yahya’s world famous film reviews. So I returned to this sacred forum to provide you with my unusually interesting and perspicuous takes on the films
     
    I am a complete philistine when it comes to films.

    I only watched a single one in 2023, it stays with you long after viewing.


    https://youtu.be/VbkYaJRByX8?si=-j8Gk2EGqfJ-nUg9

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    The general looks like he could still pass the fitness test to get out of basic training.

    • Replies: @Coconuts
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Is it supposed to be Rudolfo Graziani? Imo the real Graziani looked a bit more like a thin version of Tony Soprano than that actor. I guess the setting is Libya in the 1920s.

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

  164. @A123
    @QCIC


    Did the survey ask about ILLEGAL immigration by name? If not, the results are possibly very misleading.
     
    I had that same insight. The poll does not effectively distinguish between legal & illegal.

    Another problem is the "inch deep" phenomenon. People will say they are "for" something that sounds unobjectionable, but that superficial count is meaningless. It vanishes in methods such as Top 5 Issues. Border Security will frequently appear in the Top 5 for many voters. Keeping or increasing migration will be a tiny fraction in comparison.

    The best questions would pair the policy with inevitable outcome. "Knowing that you will be paid less, do you support migrants coming to compete for your job?" The more that people understand cause & effect, the less willing they are to be self destructive.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @AP, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    The best questions would pair the policy with inevitable outcome. “Knowing that you will be paid less, do you support migrants coming to compete for your job?”

    How many Americans are gardeners, roofers, fruit pickers, maids, table bussers, etc. though?

    These are the ones whose wages get cut. Other Americans benefit from this stuff being a lot cheaper than it otherwise would have been. I know quite a few people who have saved a lot of money and avoided nursing home care for ages loved ones by having live-in illegals from Poland and Ukraine stay with elderly relatives.

    I’m not arguing in favor of mass immigration, but a lot of Americans do benefit from it. And those ones are the ones who also are wealthier and pay most of the taxes.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @AP

    US society has changed significantly in the last 75 years in ways that are related to immigration. Some of the changes are "natural" and others are the result of intentional social engineering. Many of the costs of the social engineering are hidden by a debt-funded government and the whole process is influenced by gradually increasing prosperity.

    The illegals from the south are doing jobs that were previously done by citizens. Partially due to the rising average age of white Americans the demand for these jobs exceeds the supply of workers. On the other hand, if the jobs were priced with all the costs included (call them the externalities) then the supply and demand might work out just with local people.

    There are many different trends at work. Most are influenced by the pressure on the family and the destruction of education.

    Replies: @A123

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Worth noting that a sizable part of the mass immigration to the US, specifically the non-Latin American part, also largely consists of cognitive elites. Those people benefit the US by founding businesses, creating jobs, paying more taxes than they take out of the US budget, doing innovation and scientific research, et cetera.

  165. @A123
    @AP

    Why would Judaism have anything to do with someone volunteering to fight in Ukraine?

    What is the Jewish population in Poland? IIRC, less than 20K. Judaism has effectively no impact on Polish culture or politics.



    Do not forget the J yoke in Poland is as strong as in Ukraine.
     
    You haven’t heard of the problems between Poland and Israel?
     
    The friction between Poland and Palestinian Jews is quite limited. These days, most of it is related to the fact that Israel is officially neutral to Russia leaning.

    I find it puzzling that everyone seems to miss that the current Kiev regime hates Jews. Here is the latest offense: (1)

    [Volodymyr Zelenskyy] is undermining a 1994 agreement with the United States, and is violating the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, by digging up a Jewish cemetery in Uman, Ukraine, to build condos.

    A project that began in the summer of 2016 in the Ukrainian city of Uman, a well-known site of Jewish pilgrimage as the burial place of Rabbi Nachman of Breslov, as well as a mass grave of victims of the Haidamacks massacre, has seen human remains being dug up as early as summer of 2022, according to a report in Ukrainian media. The site sees tens of thousands of Jewish visitors from around the world on Rosh Hashana alone, and thousands more throughout the year, even during wartime.
     
    Post Judaic apostate Zelensky's track record of anti-Semitism has been clear for years.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2024/01/10/morris-ukraine-seeks-billions-from-u-s-as-it-desecrates-jewish-cemetery-to-build-condo/

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Exclusive photographs commissioned by Breitbart of Zelensky himself leading the pack to desecrate the Jewish cemetery. He decided to wear some ancestral garb to make the photos even more genuine:

    The condo that is to be built, is to compliment the one that he already owns in Florida. Islamo-Zelensky needs to be stopped, and kremlinstoogeA123 is the one to do it! :-).

  166. @AP
    @AnonfromTN


    In fact, the fraction of Indians and part-Indians among Mexes who come to the US is much greater than in Mexico.
     
    The nearly 100% European elites of Mexico rarely come to the USA, their life is great here, but the poorest Mexicans don't come either. Hiring smugglers is not too cheap. USA tends to get poor farmers and lower middle class types from Mexico, people who want to leave badly and can come up with a few thousand dollars if they sacrifice their life savings (the poorest cannot do even that). And they tend to come from regions with higher % European ancestry rather than the deep south of Mexico where people have more Indian ancestry though there has been somewhat of a shift over time.

    Mexican-American % Indian ancestry varies from about 42% in older immigrants to 52% in recent immigrants:

    https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.01.13.905141v2.full

    This isn't too different from Mexico itself, excluding the elite. The average Mexican Mestizo is 56% Indian.

    Many of Mexes doing construction work here in TN, including those who worked in my yard and changed my roof, as well as those that wash my car at the good carwash, are 50-100% Indians, judging by their looks
     
    Looks can be somewhat deceiving, because European traits are often recessive and because the Europeans they are descended from are Meds, who tend to be dark already.

    For example Eva Longoria is 70% European and only 27% Native:

    https://blogs.ancestry.com/cm/eva-longorias-surprising-dna-test/

    https://wl-brightside.cf.tsp.li/resize/728x/jpg/70b/0ec/c3839a5e8d9978486bfb1d3e8e.jpg

    Someone who is 50/50 (the typical immigrant from Mexico) would look even more Indian than she does.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ, @QCIC, @AnonfromTN

    Everything related to darker pigmentation, darker skin, black eyes, and black hair, is dominant: lighter color simply means that the gene(s) responsible for pigment production are defective. Eye and hair color is largely a Mendelian trait. It is more complex with skin color: several genes are responsible for that, so we have many different shades, from really black Cameroonians (all genes are functional) to very blond Swedes (all genes are defective).

    But the facial features are not a Mendelian trait, and they are not dominant, but determined by a complex interplay of multiple genes. That’s why there are so many facial types. E.g., central American Indians are recognizably different from North American (whatever is left of them) or Andean Quechua people.

  167. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    The general looks like he could still pass the fitness test to get out of basic training.

    Replies: @Coconuts

    Is it supposed to be Rudolfo Graziani? Imo the real Graziani looked a bit more like a thin version of Tony Soprano than that actor. I guess the setting is Libya in the 1920s.

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @Coconuts


    that actor
     

    https://youtu.be/LYLx7KP1ucY?si=WdV2oDkNBi_ZYyPl
  168. @AP
    @A123


    The best questions would pair the policy with inevitable outcome. “Knowing that you will be paid less, do you support migrants coming to compete for your job?”
     
    How many Americans are gardeners, roofers, fruit pickers, maids, table bussers, etc. though?

    These are the ones whose wages get cut. Other Americans benefit from this stuff being a lot cheaper than it otherwise would have been. I know quite a few people who have saved a lot of money and avoided nursing home care for ages loved ones by having live-in illegals from Poland and Ukraine stay with elderly relatives.

    I’m not arguing in favor of mass immigration, but a lot of Americans do benefit from it. And those ones are the ones who also are wealthier and pay most of the taxes.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

    US society has changed significantly in the last 75 years in ways that are related to immigration. Some of the changes are “natural” and others are the result of intentional social engineering. Many of the costs of the social engineering are hidden by a debt-funded government and the whole process is influenced by gradually increasing prosperity.

    The illegals from the south are doing jobs that were previously done by citizens. Partially due to the rising average age of white Americans the demand for these jobs exceeds the supply of workers. On the other hand, if the jobs were priced with all the costs included (call them the externalities) then the supply and demand might work out just with local people.

    There are many different trends at work. Most are influenced by the pressure on the family and the destruction of education.

    • Replies: @A123
    @QCIC


    , if the jobs were priced with all the costs included (call them the externalities) then the supply and demand might work out just with local people.
     
    I concur.

    Over supply of migrants, both legal and illegal, suppressed 'blue collar' wages. Off shoring is another destructive force for wage suppression. These led to delayed marriage and two income couples as a necessity. Both factors are known to be detrimental to TFR.

    One cannot bring back the 50's. However, the idea of a husband being able to support a wife and multiple children can return. It requires tightly controlling migration and MAGA Reindustrialization. Some things may cost more and be less available. That is a reasonable trade off for a functioning society on Main Street.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @QCIC, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

  169. @Coconuts
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Is it supposed to be Rudolfo Graziani? Imo the real Graziani looked a bit more like a thin version of Tony Soprano than that actor. I guess the setting is Libya in the 1920s.

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    that actor

    [MORE]

  170. @AP
    @Beckow


    In absolute terms the two camps will be roughly equal, the big loser will be Europe that has minimal resources and its manufacturing is not competitive. US-Canada-Australia will do much better
     
    I actually agree with you here. But it is Western Europe that is declining. The East does not. Poland's economy keeps improving, year after year.

    – there is a strong opinion in EU that is why US is willing to do this – they are cannibalizing their Euro allies
     
    No one forced Germany to stupidly get rid of its nuclear power. Or to stupidly become overly dependent on Russian gas (these two phenomena are linked - Russia was funding the German anti-nuclear activists, though Germans shouldn't have listened to them). Such mistakes have consequences. German manufacturers are moving many of their operations to the USA. When peace comes to Ukraine they will move a lot there, also.

    The security-defense boom can cover some of it for a while but it will eventually (soon) lead to lower access to consumer goods and good life. Defense is a lot of things but it doesn’t increase living standards – it is an economic black hole: stuff goes in and nothing comes out…
     
    You do realize that you just described most of Russia's recent economic "growth," right?

    Much more true of Russia than of the West.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @Sean

    The situation with German economy is a lot more complicated than just the “nuclear power”, etc…The energy squeeze is happening everywhere and it is getting worse. Germany used eastern Europe for a lot of energy-intensive manufacturing and it is now gradually shutting down. The overall supply chain has been blown up and the consequences are just starting – in the next 2 to 5 years we will see it.

    Russia was also a very good market: high prices and they paid on time – high profit margins in Russia subsidized other business. The money Russia earned stayed in the Western banks allowing for an investment boom and lower interest rates. The one-time proposed theft is a bad idea – imagine if your bank takes your deposits, will anyone ever work with them? Russia will continue generating hundreds of billions in profits each year – that’s the money that matters and it is close to exiting permanently.

    You don’t understand economics or business well – even you pointing to “defense” boom in Russia is short-sighted: they are in an existential war and they have resources (forever), they can afford to do it, Europe can’t – Euros also don’t have any inclination to go into an existential fight. Poland is not “Europe”, it is just noise in the east.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Beckow


    The money Russia earned stayed in the Western banks allowing for an investment boom and lower interest rates. The one-time proposed theft is a bad idea – imagine if your bank takes your deposits, will anyone ever work with them?
     
    Banks often confiscate funds from criminals, in order to pay fines or restitution to the victims. The invasion of Ukraine was a crime, and Russia is getting its funds confiscated as a result.

    Do you think that when a criminal has his funds taken from him - this is "theft?"

    You don’t understand economics or business well – even you pointing to “defense” boom in Russia is short-sighted: they are in an existential war
     
    Nonsense, and they know it too. It's why they are not doing total war.

    and they have resources (forever), they can afford to do it
     
    Maybe. Does it contradict the below, however? It does not.

    The security-defense boom can cover some of it for a while but it will eventually (soon) lead to lower access to consumer goods and good life. Defense is a lot of things but it doesn’t increase living standards – it is an economic black hole: stuff goes in and nothing comes out…

    Europe can’t
     
    Europe's (and the West's) economy is large enough that they only need a fraction of it to match Russia's efforts. Europeans won't be willing to devote nearly the same % of their economy to helping Ukraine's war effort as Russia does to sustain it's invasion, but they don't have to.
    , @Another Polish Perspective
    @Beckow

    You are a real outlier among Slovaks I met in my life in your strong and active dislike of Poland. But as far as I remember you are just a naturalized Slovak, previously being a citizen of USA, now living, of course, in the big city of Bratislava...?
    You never present us with any insights abut culture of Slovakia (music, literature).... do you know Slovakian language fluently, more than B1 level demanded for citizenship?
    Czechs and Slovaks among themselves usually know very well who is who, a Slovak, a Czech or a Gypsie - how do they call you...?"Our American friend", "Our American", or maybe simply "American Mikulas"...?

    Anyway, your nick, "Beckow", suggests a Germanized Slav.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  171. @QCIC
    @Beckow

    Who in Europe actually wants the Third World migrants to be there?

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Beckow

    …Who in Europe actually wants the Third World migrants to be there?

    The coalition of people in power: globo-liberals and their genderite groupies, people living of migration: human rights hustlers, lawyers, charities…businessmen who want to keep wages low (even the migrant threat helps), and tens of millions of relatives who want to bring their cousins-friends to Europe or make money by bringing them.

    It is a very powerful ruling minority and open migration is a matter of utmost importance to them – so they won’t let it go, the same is true in US. The overwhelming majority that is against is unfocused and easily intimidated.

  172. @AP
    @Beckow


    I am proudly Euro-centric, made out of Europe, I won’t apologize. You will not find more European geography than the remote valleys and rolling hills north of the middle Danube…it is almost comically Euro. My priority is to preserve the good life here
     
    These are forces that sought to destroy it, in the last 100 years:

    Nazism
    Communism
    Mass non-European emigration
    Putin (he is working on Ukraine, Baltics probably next if Ukraine falls, but he supports gangsters further West also)

    You personally support two of those.

    Your country has supported/supports three of the four.

    We were good in the east or central-east\: steadily growing, normal, living safer and more comfortable lives
     
    You were too small to be self-sufficient. You could hope to be ignored for awhile, but it wouldn't last forever.

    The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere – in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia’s propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception
     
    Poles are the largest of the Visegrad countries, with the largest economy. There are more Poles than there are Slovaks, Hungarians, and Czechs combined, with about 10 million more Poles to spare. As such, Poles cannot be considered an exception. Considering Poles an "exception" among Visegrad is about as stupid as saying "Britain, with the exception of the English."

    And Czechs don't like Russians, either. It is only the non-Slavic Hungarians and their traditional lackeys, the Slovaks, who are the exceptional ones.

    I will note that of the 4 phenomena that tried to destroy Europe that I previously described, Poland alone of the Visegrad countries opposed all 4. Czechs and Slovaks supported Commies, Hungarians and Slovaks supported Nazis and support Putin, Poland was correct every time. And has suffered for it.

    who they really hate are the Ukies and Orthodox, but they can’t voice it now
     
    You are ignorant as usual. The small group of ex-colonists have their issues but most Poles like Ukrainians, particularly those who don't speak Russian. There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

    EU is just an Anglo-French-Germany combo – with US managing it, the two Western groupings combined. They also grabbed everything in the vicinity (including Poland). But when they tried to go further east and grab Ukraine, Belarus, Caucasus, the remaining Euro power, Russia, blocked it
     
    Biden chooses to slowly grind down the Russians using Ukrainians to do so. "Blocking" is an American, not Russian decision. Russia helpfully goes along and gets itself slowly demilitarized. Ukrainians have no choice - Russian rule is worse than fighting, so they fight. If America chose to flood Ukraine with better weapons, this would be over.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. XYZ, @Derer, @A123, @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    …There are more Poles than…

    Than what? Nobody cares about the Poles, they are only bloody tools for anyone who they are currently in love with. They line like lemmings and die for the others. What they think makes no difference because we don’t take their hatreds seriously.

    I was not limiting it to V4: Austria, Slovenia, Croatia, Serbia – even large parts of Germany and Italy are more level-headed. The Poles can march on and invade Russia with their Anglo allies – it would work like this: Anglos talk and ship “weapons” and the Poles die. Then you write a thank you note to your masters in London-Washington…maybe even to Berlin.

    100 years misery? You bark your inane “Habsburg” nonsense. Let me remind you that it was by far the worst in terms of human rights, freedom, oppression, number of people in prison for wrong views, under the Habsburg feudal monarchy that you so stupidly celebrate. Only Nazis exceeded it in WW2.

    If you want to compare, it was the Poles who sided first with the Nazi Germany in Munich 1938, Poland was a brutal dictatorship in the 1930’s…after 1945 there were 3 million Polish commies all the way till the end…in 1968 Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia the Poles were the second largest army – so you are hallucinating, but you are losing the war so we will give you some slack…:)

    • Replies: @AP
    @Beckow


    Than what? Nobody cares about the Poles
     
    Your words:

    "The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere – in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia’s propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception"

    You mentioned V4, I pointed out that Poles outnumber all other people within V4 combined.


    I was not limiting it to V4: Austria, Slovenia, Croatia, Serbia
     
    Serbia? Why not Syria also? And North Korea?

    Croatia helps Ukraine also. It gave Ukraine all of its Mi-8 helicopters.

    https://mpu.gov.hr/news-25399/croatia-strongly-supports-ukraine-and-the-ukrainian-people/27313


    it would work like this: Anglos talk and ship “weapons” and the Poles die.
     
    Last time Russia fought Poland, Russia lost. Russia can barely hold Ukraine to a stalemate.

    You bark your inane “Habsburg” nonsense. Let me remind you that it was by far the worst in terms of human rights, freedom, oppression, number of people in prison for wrong views, under the Habsburg feudal monarchy that you so stupidly celebrate
     
    Thanks for demonstrating the poor educational standards of Slovakia. So ignorant, so parochial. Poles lived under Hapsburgs, Romanovs and Hohenzollerns. Hapsburg rule was by far the mildest of the three. Ukrainians lived under Hapburgs and Romanovs. Hapsburgs were milder.

    So let's compare executions.

    Russia:

    https://www.rbth.com/history/331226-death-penalty-russia

    1826-1905: 526 people executed
    1905-1910: 3,700 people executed

    Germany:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_Germany

    1907-1932: 393 people executed (could not find data for 19th century)

    Austria (not the Hungarian-ruled part of Austria-Hungary):

    https://www.jstor.org/stable/2276063?seq=2

    1852-1897: 175 people executed

    England and Wales:

    https://www.acrosswalls.org/datasets/executions-england-wales-from-1800/

    1852-1897: 622 people executed


    Only Nazis exceeded it [Austria-Hungary] in WW2
     
    Poor uneducated Beckow apparently hasn't heard even of Stalin's or Lenin's crimes.

    If you want to compare, it was the Poles who sided first with the Nazi Germany in Munich 1938
     
    This lie of yours has already been debunked multiple times, many many people, some of whom aren't posting here anymore.

    Poland refused multiple offers of alliance with the Nazis (and also refused alliances with the Bolsheviks). when Czechoslovakia was betrayed by its allies and gave up German-0ihabioted lands to Germany, Poland asked for and peacefully received Polish-inhabited territories, that the Czechs had previously seized by attacking Poland and killing its soldiers. It was not part of some Polish-German alliance (this was no Molotov-Ribbentrop), indeed Poland refused such.


    After 1945 there were 3 million Polish commies all the way till the end
     
    Poles fought Commies in 1920 (and defeated them, saving Europe from a Russian commie invasion), 1939, and 1945.

    Poland fought Nazis in 1939 rather than join them as Germany asked them to do and as Slovakia did. Thereby saving Europe from Nazi victory (Russians were defeated by Poles in 1921, you think the Soviets would have defeated a German-Polish alliance?). Maybe that's why you can't forgive Poles? Your people were eager Nazi allies. Slovakia even paid the Nazis money to kill Slovak Jews. Who else would do that?


    in 1968 Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia the Poles were the second largest army
     
    They were about 25,000 troops out of 450,000. "Second largest" lol. And it was a commie vs. commie conflict anyways. Afterward, Czechoslovaks were such sincere and loyal commies that Poles were shocked when they visited Czechoslovakia.

    Polish resistance to Commies in the 1980s brought down the Soviet system in Eastern Europe. This is probably why you, a Commie sympathizer, can't forgive Poles.

    And of course Poles resist the importation of non-European Africans and Muslims into Europe. You Slovaks and Hungarians would not be able to resist the pressure alone.

    So Poland alone has resisted each of the evils plaguing Europe in the last 100+ years.

    While your people eagerly joined the Nazis, and voted for the Commies.


    you are losing the war
     
    Russia's staggering losses and lack of gaining even villages (taking the slag head outside Avdiivka, some wooded strips, and central Marinka doesn't count for much) suggest that its winter offensive is failing, so far.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @Gerard1234

  173. @QCIC
    @AP

    US society has changed significantly in the last 75 years in ways that are related to immigration. Some of the changes are "natural" and others are the result of intentional social engineering. Many of the costs of the social engineering are hidden by a debt-funded government and the whole process is influenced by gradually increasing prosperity.

    The illegals from the south are doing jobs that were previously done by citizens. Partially due to the rising average age of white Americans the demand for these jobs exceeds the supply of workers. On the other hand, if the jobs were priced with all the costs included (call them the externalities) then the supply and demand might work out just with local people.

    There are many different trends at work. Most are influenced by the pressure on the family and the destruction of education.

    Replies: @A123

    , if the jobs were priced with all the costs included (call them the externalities) then the supply and demand might work out just with local people.

    I concur.

    Over supply of migrants, both legal and illegal, suppressed ‘blue collar’ wages. Off shoring is another destructive force for wage suppression. These led to delayed marriage and two income couples as a necessity. Both factors are known to be detrimental to TFR.

    One cannot bring back the 50’s. However, the idea of a husband being able to support a wife and multiple children can return. It requires tightly controlling migration and MAGA Reindustrialization. Some things may cost more and be less available. That is a reasonable trade off for a functioning society on Main Street.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @A123

    I agree.

    The birth control pill and female awakening are important "organic" factors in the changes in the American family and racial demographics. On the other hand, memes such as the "population bomb" were being used to talk Americans into very small families even before offshoring and immigration fully cranked up.

    Replies: @songbird

    , @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    It is hard to understand why Israeli officials including senior political leaders and military commanders would publicly make these incriminating statements right before carrying out these acts. I can only assume it was through a mixture of rage post-Oct 7 and official arrogance.

    Why is Ireland the most outspoken pro-Palestinian nation in the Western world? Why is South Africa the most outspoken pro-Palestinian nation in the whole world? It's not coincidence.

    U.S. being dragged back into open-ended war in the Middle East by Israel. Pivot to Asia is now provisonally postponed to 2035

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F964zjXWkAASOfc.jpg

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  174. @AP
    @Beckow


    I would remind the pro-Nato contingent that if the power gets reshuffled to omit paper and other verbal stuff, it will be the West that will lose more. Its power will be less than the countries with material resources and actual manufacturing
     
    USA is the world’s top oil producer. USA + it’s semi-appendage Canada produce nearly twice as much oil as either Russia or Saudi Arabia.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_oil_production

    USA also world’s top natural gas producer:

    https://investingnews.com/top-natural-gas-producers/

    Lithium. South America, but USA exceeds China:

    https://www.nsenergybusiness.com/features/six-largest-lithium-reserves-world/

    USA is the world’s second largest manufacturer, after China. Here the picture is mixed.

    China dominates in steel production:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_steel_production

    Though the EU, Japan, and the USA each exceed Russian steel production.

    In terms of finished goods, a lot of what China manufactures (not all, of course), is cheap stuff that we in the West would not want to make because we’d rather it be very inexpensive. Like mass production of the trinkets including cheap electronics they sell in Walmart.

    Otherwise, USA is number 1 in aircraft production:

    https://www.aerotime.aero/articles/top-10-largest-aircraft-manufacturers-in-the-world

    Almost all Western, Brazil at number 9.

    China leads in automobile production but many Chinese cars are cheap and of poor quality. And the West (which includes Japan) collectively produces more automobiles than does China:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_motor_vehicle_production

    West leads in semiconductor manufacturing (a reason China won’t be given Taiwan for awhile):

    https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/semiconductor-manufacturing-by-country

    Machine tools, China number one, but collective West exceeds it:

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/264213/leading-countries-in-machine-tool-production-based-on-market-share/

    Overall, the combination of natural resources and manufacturing particular high end manufacturing favors the West, especially the USA.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    USA is the world’s top oil producer. USA + it’s semi-appendage Canada produce nearly twice as much oil as either Russia or Saudi Arabia.

    US is a net IMPORTER of oil relative to what it produces you bimbo dumbf**k, domestic consumption is of course huge, which limits US export potential. Power comes from ability to control supply and demand of the world market you idiot, not from the self-sufficiency. With situation as it is and continues developing, US will be deprived of significant power on oil and gas markets…..Europe deprived of oil and gas ( well, oil and gas and decent prices in addition to the volume issue)

    USA also world’s top natural gas producer:

    Again, satisfying domestic demands you idiot, that won’t come close to satisfying Europe’s demand and Pindostan’s inability for political and feasibility reasons to build a gas pipeline network connecting them to export all through south and central America (shipping of course export much less volume). Or, thanks to over a century of American scum f**king over that region….is South and central America likely to have enough demand for gas in comparison to Europe, despite their large populations…….because of course American “help” in the region has not lifted their living standards much.

    Otherwise, USA is number 1 in aircraft production:

    Of course aircraft manufacture has “nothing” in connection with Titanium and Aluminium , LMAO you POS!
    If you’re linking something then it is certain to be BS & totally Dishonest. Link does not list for most of them the number of aircraft produced, and Sukhoi and other Russian companies have more workers than most of those on the list you stupid retard.

    China leads in automobile production but many Chinese cars are cheap and of poor quality.

    Of course, you are completely clueless on the matter and only recycling something from somewhere else and have zero experience of the issue. In reality ( previous eras were far more superior in car design IMO) , there is becoming an equilibrium /near standardisation of saloon and SUV design around the world – petrol/hybrid/electric it doesn’t matter – even Romanian and Chinese car manufacturers are producing vehicles that look and drive the same as western manufacturers ….and for the interior have the same electronic features on the dashboard, same anti-collision warning, cameras, seat heating gadgets etc as them also.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Gerard1234


    US is a net IMPORTER of oil relative to what it produces
     
    https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/oil-and-petroleum-products/imports-and-exports.php#:~:text=Also%20in%202022%2C%20the%20United,about%2020.01%20million%20b%2Fd.

    In 2020, the United States became a net exporter of petroleum for the first time since at least 1949.1 In 2022, total petroleum exports were about 9.52 million barrels per day (b/d) and total petroleum imports were about 8.33 million b/d, making the United States an annual net total petroleum exporter for the third year in a row

    Although U.S. annual total petroleum exports were greater than total petroleum imports in 2020, 2021, and 2022, the United States still imported some crude oil and petroleum products from other countries to help to supply domestic demand for petroleum and to supply international markets.

    The United States remained a net crude oil importer in 2022, importing about 6.28 million b/d of crude oil and exporting about 3.58 million b/d. Some of the crude oil that the U.S. imports is refined by U.S. refineries into petroleum products—such as gasoline, heating oil, diesel fuel, and jet fuel—that the U.S. later exports. Also, some of imported petroleum may be stored and later exported.

    Of course, you are completely clueless on the matter and only recycling something from somewhere else and have zero experience of the issue
     
    Western cars made in China on Western standards are okay (though for example Chinese-made Volvos are less reliable than those made in Sweden or the USA, despite the engines not being made in China) but many Chinese cars are garbage that would not be allowed on roads in civilized countries.

    Replies: @QCIC

  175. Gonzalo Lira is no more.

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    : (

    , @Mikel
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    No mention of his death in the MSM but, as far as I can see, this looks unlikely to be fake. Several non-mainstream journalists are reporting it, including Tucker, who can be an idiot sometimes but I don't think would risk spreading false news of this type.

    AP told us here that Lira was making up his allegations of mistreatment in Ukrainian prison and that his prosecution was justified.

    He could have admitted that Ukraine is still not such a democratic country, even less during wartime, but he opted for justifying the imprisonment of an American for posting stuff on Youtube (ie exercising his freedom of expression). I guess once you decide to justify the killing of thousands of your co-ethnic civilians you're in a slippery slide with no breaks. Anything must become justifiable after that.

    If this gets confirmed we'll surely be reminded of what a creepy person he was (to the extent we hear anything from him at all). But it makes you wonder what it must be like in Ukraine for all the people who don't have a Tucker Carlson or a Glenn Greenwald to defend them. This is the country they tell us we must spend hundreds of billions of dollars in and risk nuclear war for, gentlemen.

    Replies: @AP, @Emil Nikola Richard

    , @AnonfromTN
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere


    Gonzalo Lira is no more.
     
    For honest and proud people there is only one way out of Ukie Gestapo: into the grave. At least now Ukies cannot torture him anymore.
  176. Sher Singh says:
    @Yahya
    @Sher Singh


    What’s your favorite bicep exercises?
     
    E-Z Bar Curls

    I used to train 5 times per week when bulking, but have since embarked on cutting phase and reduced my sessions to 4 times per week on a minimalist program a-la Jeff Nippard.

    https://youtu.be/xc4OtzAnVMI?si=lf8H_binuuLGsc2p

    Right now I’m pissed since I didn’t lose any weight over the past week despite being on a ~500 calorie deficit. Could be due to factors related to carb intake or water retention, but frustrating to see no gains in that area. Thinking of reducing my calorie deficit by another 200kcal per day, see if it will work.

    Replies: @Sher Singh

    I’m trying to cut without using macro factor atm.

    I find knowing you have X calories left encourages you to fill the bowl, so to speak.

    Instead, I make sure to get enough protein & then chill.

    With running too I just try to run after every session now – even if it’s a few Km.


    My ohp started climbing again since we last spoke.

    Saving that video though, thanks.

    https://bretcontreras.com/how-to-fix-glute-imbalances/

    No homo this fixed a 6 year old lifting injury I had literally days ago.

    I did iso contractions on weaker side & then during morning prayers after I think Good Mornings – my hip popped back into place.

    Took 3 days & yeah.

    Still wearing Talwar everyday & involved in cases wherever they try to restrict it.

    Fateh with Maharaj Blessings.

    ਅਕਾਲ

    • Replies: @Barbarossa
    @Sher Singh

    Do you like Indian snacks? I like stocking up at the Indian grocery when I'm up that way since they are way better than American snacks in terms of nutrition. They seem to have a great proportion of fat/ carbs/ fiber/ protein and a small handful is really filling. You can't scarf a whole bag like one can do with something like potato chips.

    Replies: @Sher Singh, @Mr. Hack

    , @Yahya
    @Sher Singh


    I’m trying to cut without using macro factor atm. I find knowing you have X calories left encourages you to fill the bowl, so to speak. Instead, I make sure to get enough protein & then chill.
     
    I’m going to try this strategy if my current regime doesn’t work for another week.

    One issue I see is that if the calorie deficit is too high, it may lead to more muscle loss than a calculated 15-20% calorie deficit.


    http://i.ibb.co/StCGqJt/0843-D46-C-E6-C3-43-D1-A15-E-E0203-F4-C8-F0-F.jpg


    ——

    What are your thoughts on body recomposition vs traditional bulking and cutting?

    Replies: @Sher Singh

  177. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    Gonzalo Lira is no more.


    https://twitter.com/TuckerCarlson/status/1745863377493143906

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Mikel, @AnonfromTN

    : (

  178. German_reader says:
    @Mikel
    @Gerard1234

    I don't have any strong opinions on the Riga architectural landscape. If all parties involved agree with you that the best parts were built by the Russians, that is something I can perfectly live with.

    However, it is just not true that LatW left because of you. She clearly left in indignation at the epithet that G_R directed at her. Even worse, then G_R proceeded to leave the blog himself, at a time when Dmitry, Bashi, Aaron and others had been absent for a while and Yahya has briefly reappeared to let us know what a waste of his time this geriatric ward had become really. The chances of any worthwhile debate taking place here have become infinitesimal.

    But I can't blame any of them really. We had long ago entered the law of diminishing returns, discussing ad nauseam the same old subjects with the same old arguments (me included). Who doesn't have better uses of their time than that?

    With that said, I think it's been quite a remarkable feat to keep this blog alive for 2 years after his author left (and actually break records of comment numbers on this website). Perhaps as important as the subjects we keep debating are the subjects the regulars of this blog never debate: transhumanism and technological singularities (AK's favorite topics) or the JQ (Unz's obsession). This clearly signals that it was never about AK or Unz. They both just happened to attract a group of disparate people with very different backgrounds and the group then took a life of its own, building very lively threads out of nothing that for one reason or another we all felt compelled to participate in. Though obviously AK and Ron deserve credit for the phenomenon.

    Alas, everything has an end and it looks like these threads are losing the vigor and interest they once had. On to the difficult task of finding other places to debate, vent and engage people of different persuasions without being censored, I guess.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @AP, @Yevardian, @German_reader, @Gerard1234

    The problem with any forum really is that familiarity breeds contempt. Over time you start to get into an antagonistic relationship with other users, maybe even into long-running “feuds”, mutual grievances accumulate and in the end you don’t have anything to say to each other anymore, because the fundamental differences are just too irreconcilable.
    I suppose to some extent it might just be me, but I’ve encountered such dynamics in every forum I ever participated in (this one here was by no means the worst btw, and I suspect without the war in Ukraine things wouldn’t have gotten as ugly as they did). As for Twitter, unlike Yevardian I don’t see that as an alternative. I tried it for a few weeks, and found the experience stressful and rather toxic.
    But yes, given the decline in active users, the mutual antagonisms, and the exhausting focus on Ukraine to the exclusion of everything else there doesn’t seem to be much life left here anymore (also noteworthy how Hyperborean who popped up after several years of absence already seems to have left again).
    Anyway, who knows, maybe 2024 will see some sort of resolution to the war in Ukraine (or at least freeze the fighting); here’s another possible sign:
    https://www.ft.com/content/e0c9a4bb-903a-48d9-b44c-f26b445499b0

    Italy’s defence minister Guido Crosetto has called for greater diplomatic efforts to end the war between Russia and Ukraine, despite Kyiv’s warnings that Moscow has no intention to do so.

    Crosetto told a parliamentary hearing on Wednesday that Italy would seek “a dual-track strategy” with military support for Kyiv to be coupled with more engagements towards a “negotiated settlement”.

    “We must be realistic and cannot ignore the military situation on the field,” Crosetto said as lawmakers approved more bilateral aid to Kyiv. “The time seems to have come for effective diplomatic action.”

    Yet in a sober analysis of Ukraine’s military and political strengths, Crosetto, who was previously president of Italy’s defence industry association, expressed concern about “the real Ukrainian ability to counter Russian forces . . . in a condition of persistent numerical and air inferiority”.

    “Unfortunately, Ukraine’s summer counteroffensive did not give the desired results,” he said, warning that 2024 would be a “critical year” for Ukraine’s future.

    He insisted diplomatic efforts would run in tandem with continued military aid for Ukraine — of which Italy is now preparing an eighth package, just as it has assumed the presidency of the G7.

    “We have two paths: that of aid without ‘ifs and buts’ — and that of attempting to build a diplomatic path that brings us to the end of the conflict,” he said. “The coming months will have to balance deterrence and diplomacy.”

    But Crosetto also said talks could only begin if Russia ceased its missile and drone attacks on Ukraine. “We can start talking when the bombs stop falling,” he said. “We have to convince those who are attacking to stop.”

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @German_reader


    ...Crosetto also said talks could only begin if Russia ceased its missile and drone attacks on Ukraine. “We can start talking when the bombs stop falling,” he said. “We have to convince those who are attacking to stop.”
     
    EU and Kiev need the "talks" more than Russia. Demanding a condition that amounts to a cease-fire is self-defeating - it gives Russia an easy way out since they have made it clear that they will not agree to a cease-fire. And they don't need to talk to Kiev.

    The Italian guy is trying to have it both ways - many people suddenly don't want to be too associated with the pro-Kiev-pro-war side, even BoJo is now claiming he didn't scuttle the peace talks in March 22. And Sholz seems to want out.

    What is that saying about rats on a sinking ship?

    Replies: @German_reader, @AnonfromTN

    , @Mikel
    @German_reader


    here’s another possible sign:
    https://www.ft.com/content/e0c9a4bb-903a-48d9-b44c-f26b445499b0
     
    The problem is that people like Italy's defense minister don't count. He'll be made to eat his words if the people who do count so decide. It is encouraging to see one more sign that we may be headed towards a diplomatic solution, and we've had plenty in the last months, but there are also powerful forces opposed to that in Europe, Kiev and the US. I wouldn't be too optimistic about the war ending this year, as Beckow was also saying above.

    Regardless of what happens with the Ukraine aid package in Congress (and it's difficult to see a total cut of US military aid to Ukraine, especially if diplomacy doesn't work and the conflict continues), Ukraine is soon going to receive the long-awaited F-16s, the Taurus (if I'm not mistaken) and plenty of other weapons. I think that the British PM was in Kiev just today, announcing a new aid package, and I read that the Poles also promised something the other day. In the meantime, Ukraine seems to be mobilizing many thousands of new recruits. There may be talk of negotiations but things seem to be heading towards another attempt to counterattack (probably in the spring) at the same time.

    Replies: @German_reader, @A123

    , @Hyperborean
    @German_reader


    I suppose to some extent it might just be me, but I’ve encountered such dynamics in every forum I ever participated in (this one here was by no means the worst btw, and I suspect without the war in Ukraine things wouldn’t have gotten as ugly as they did). As for Twitter, unlike Yevardian I don’t see that as an alternative. I tried it for a few weeks, and found the experience stressful and rather toxic.

    But yes, given the decline in active users, the mutual antagonisms, and the exhausting focus on Ukraine to the exclusion of everything else there doesn’t seem to be much life left here anymore (also noteworthy how Hyperborean who popped up after several years of absence already seems to have left again).
     

    I decided to occasionally check every couple of threads and skim read them. I don't really feel like I have much to say; a lot of people are either repeating the same arguments about the same old topics as they did five years ago (even though they know they will never agree) or picking "beef" with others. Unless one is monetising one's online presence, after a certain point it starts to head towards diminishing marginal utility.

    If it's any consolation it isn't just Unz' Wacky House of Weirdos that's gone insane, mainstream internet forums have been just as bad recently. The Russo-Ukrainian War and especially the Gaza War have ruined large sections of general internet forums that don't explicitly exclude or silo (geo)-political discussion.

    I tried having an active Twitter account a few years back, but I recognised that I can't handle the way the algorithm encourages attention-seeking and ruins one's mental health like the mentally ill streamer girl in the game Needy Girl Overdose so I deleted it. So now I just check in on a couple of people who tend to post interesting statistics or articles.

    I did read your comments about Karlin's manifesto and the "Rightoids Go to Jail" section. I noted the same thing about his very online mentality, a lot of the people he mentions are microcelebrities at best (though curiously no mention of failson Richard Spencer). Hilarious anecdotes, but rather niche in terms of actual real life political presence.

    Personally, I would have been interested in reading about his time in the Bay Area and the Effective Altruism sphere. I'm sure there's enough weirdos and quirky people to talk about that he could make a blog post about it, even without bringing up nasty disputes.

    Replies: @German_reader

  179. @Gerard1234
    @AP


    USA is the world’s top oil producer. USA + it’s semi-appendage Canada produce nearly twice as much oil as either Russia or Saudi Arabia.
     
    US is a net IMPORTER of oil relative to what it produces you bimbo dumbf**k, domestic consumption is of course huge, which limits US export potential. Power comes from ability to control supply and demand of the world market you idiot, not from the self-sufficiency. With situation as it is and continues developing, US will be deprived of significant power on oil and gas markets.....Europe deprived of oil and gas ( well, oil and gas and decent prices in addition to the volume issue)

    USA also world’s top natural gas producer:
     
    Again, satisfying domestic demands you idiot, that won't come close to satisfying Europe's demand and Pindostan's inability for political and feasibility reasons to build a gas pipeline network connecting them to export all through south and central America (shipping of course export much less volume). Or, thanks to over a century of American scum f**king over that region....is South and central America likely to have enough demand for gas in comparison to Europe, despite their large populations.......because of course American "help" in the region has not lifted their living standards much.


    Otherwise, USA is number 1 in aircraft production:
     
    Of course aircraft manufacture has "nothing" in connection with Titanium and Aluminium , LMAO you POS!
    If you're linking something then it is certain to be BS & totally Dishonest. Link does not list for most of them the number of aircraft produced, and Sukhoi and other Russian companies have more workers than most of those on the list you stupid retard.

    China leads in automobile production but many Chinese cars are cheap and of poor quality.
     
    Of course, you are completely clueless on the matter and only recycling something from somewhere else and have zero experience of the issue. In reality ( previous eras were far more superior in car design IMO) , there is becoming an equilibrium /near standardisation of saloon and SUV design around the world - petrol/hybrid/electric it doesn't matter - even Romanian and Chinese car manufacturers are producing vehicles that look and drive the same as western manufacturers ....and for the interior have the same electronic features on the dashboard, same anti-collision warning, cameras, seat heating gadgets etc as them also.

    Replies: @AP

    US is a net IMPORTER of oil relative to what it produces

    https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/oil-and-petroleum-products/imports-and-exports.php#:~:text=Also%20in%202022%2C%20the%20United,about%2020.01%20million%20b%2Fd.

    In 2020, the United States became a net exporter of petroleum for the first time since at least 1949.1 In 2022, total petroleum exports were about 9.52 million barrels per day (b/d) and total petroleum imports were about 8.33 million b/d, making the United States an annual net total petroleum exporter for the third year in a row

    Although U.S. annual total petroleum exports were greater than total petroleum imports in 2020, 2021, and 2022, the United States still imported some crude oil and petroleum products from other countries to help to supply domestic demand for petroleum and to supply international markets.

    The United States remained a net crude oil importer in 2022, importing about 6.28 million b/d of crude oil and exporting about 3.58 million b/d. Some of the crude oil that the U.S. imports is refined by U.S. refineries into petroleum products—such as gasoline, heating oil, diesel fuel, and jet fuel—that the U.S. later exports. Also, some of imported petroleum may be stored and later exported.

    Of course, you are completely clueless on the matter and only recycling something from somewhere else and have zero experience of the issue

    Western cars made in China on Western standards are okay (though for example Chinese-made Volvos are less reliable than those made in Sweden or the USA, despite the engines not being made in China) but many Chinese cars are garbage that would not be allowed on roads in civilized countries.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @AP

    AP's original list and G-man's criticisms are both valid. The USA still has a potent core economy which may yet recover with more reshoring. The successful US aviation industry is a swamp. The biggest companies listed are mostly defense contractors. Boeing is successful, but many of their commercial aircraft have a very high percentage of foreign content. I think the situation with Boeing commercial aircraft is a bit like GM/Detroit where a toxic mixture of management incompetence combined with unsustainable union wage costs may be driving it into the ground or at least out of the USA. The success of the Brazilian Embraer 190 was probably a wake up call to Boeing signifying that her historical profit margins would no longer be possible. The Russian commercial aircraft sector has not yet revived. If they can ship 20 SSJ100R and 10 MC-21 in 2024 they may be in good shape. These are tiny numbers compared to Airbus and Boeing but the Russian airliners are not in direct competition with the Western planes. The USA is dominant in the manufacture of private jets.

  180. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    Gonzalo Lira is no more.


    https://twitter.com/TuckerCarlson/status/1745863377493143906

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Mikel, @AnonfromTN

    No mention of his death in the MSM but, as far as I can see, this looks unlikely to be fake. Several non-mainstream journalists are reporting it, including Tucker, who can be an idiot sometimes but I don’t think would risk spreading false news of this type.

    AP told us here that Lira was making up his allegations of mistreatment in Ukrainian prison and that his prosecution was justified.

    He could have admitted that Ukraine is still not such a democratic country, even less during wartime, but he opted for justifying the imprisonment of an American for posting stuff on Youtube (ie exercising his freedom of expression). I guess once you decide to justify the killing of thousands of your co-ethnic civilians you’re in a slippery slide with no breaks. Anything must become justifiable after that.

    If this gets confirmed we’ll surely be reminded of what a creepy person he was (to the extent we hear anything from him at all). But it makes you wonder what it must be like in Ukraine for all the people who don’t have a Tucker Carlson or a Glenn Greenwald to defend them. This is the country they tell us we must spend hundreds of billions of dollars in and risk nuclear war for, gentlemen.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Mikel


    AP told us here that Lira was making up his allegations of mistreatment in Ukrainian prison and that his prosecution was justified
     
    Because no unhealthy people ever die in American prisons. Apparently he was not well for awhile, and was given medical care.

    He could have admitted that Ukraine is still not such a democratic country, even less during wartime, but he opted for justifying the imprisonment of an American for posting stuff on Youtube (ie exercising his freedom of expression

     

    He was allegedly posting positions and spreading foreign propaganda of an invader.

    Despite being an American he was not above the law in Ukraine.

    Were you on the Axis side during World War II because those Japanese were interred?

    I guess once you decide to justify the killing of thousands of your co-ethnic civilians
     
    I don’t justify Russians actions that led to those deaths.

    you’re in a slippery slide with no breaks. Anything must become justifiable after that.
     
    Interesting hierarchy of moral values for you. Donbassers getting killed is further up the slide than some Chilean-American psychopath allegedly committing crimes in a foreign country because he thought his passport would make him above the law, getting arrested and dying of illness in prison.

    This is the country they tell us we must spend hundreds of billions of dollars in and risk nuclear war for
     
    The hundreds of billions are spent not in Ukraine but in the USA. It pays for the upgraded weapons we get when we send the old stuff to Ukraine. It also pays to upgrade our military manufacturing potential.

    And of course no risk of nuclear war. It’s an excuse to do what Putin wants without explicitly supporting Putin.

    A fitting obituary:



    https://twitter.com/jayinkyiv/status/1745894825998582152?s=46&t=Qz3eXZWFYIvyHmaAk32tcg

    Replies: @Mikel

    , @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mikel

    The RT story is interesting. They wrote the American embassy wouldn't do anything for the American because Victoria Nuland "hated him personally".

    His episode on what a psycho Nuland is was great. He aired out all this stuff about her daddy, who went into a psych hospital when she was 13, received a bunch of electric shock treatments, and was never again the same. He was successful alpha monkey at the time he got depressed. Nuland became a hateful piece of work at a young age.

    Also he said she was pretty hot back then which I think surpasses the limits of credibility. Such things are pretty subjective though.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mikel

  181. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    Gonzalo Lira is no more.


    https://twitter.com/TuckerCarlson/status/1745863377493143906

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Mikel, @AnonfromTN

    Gonzalo Lira is no more.

    For honest and proud people there is only one way out of Ukie Gestapo: into the grave. At least now Ukies cannot torture him anymore.

  182. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    Writers have a very high proportion of alcoholism.

    Dick was a speed freak. Did you watch Through a Glass Darkly? The bugs crawling on the guy's skin in the shower is a speed thing. Speed is very destructive. Scott Alexander prescribes adderall and ritalin and he claims 2/3 of the programmers in the valley are on the stuff. And half the time when he gets a new patient, the guy wants a speed scrip.

    When Joe Biden appears lucid it probably is a temporary drug benefit.

    Through a Glass Darkly is pretty great if you haven't watched it. But the book is even better. The best line in the book was not in the movie. Protagonist's girlfriend calls him up in the middle of the day because she has a cockroach in her kitchen and she is scared. He goes over there and kills it. He tells her they are harmless. She says,


    If I had known it was harmless I would have killed it myself.
     
    The girlfriend is a psycho. All of Dick's girlfriends were psychos. In relationship therapy class they tell you that people do that because it's familiar. The subconscious always prefers the familiar, even when simple logic tells you she is a worthless and negative force.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

    The girlfriend is a psycho. All of Dick’s girlfriends were psychos. In relationship therapy class they tell you that people do that because it’s familiar. The subconscious always prefers the familiar, even when simple logic tells you she is a worthless and negative force.

    IMHO, her response doesn’t automatically qualify her as a psycho… It is a bit solipsistic, but applied solipsism is a female trait much too often.

    And why do you so easily believe in explanatory power of Freudian concepts? i would expect more discernment from you. The psychologists-peddled ideas like “the subconscious is irresistibly drawn to the familiar” just absolve us of any responsibility and hide ugly truths like “some humans really are (sado)masochists”, normalizing our suffering for us, with the exception of “trauma” 😉 (or “trauma” is a new name for “real” suffering).
    Psychology is a new religion of sinners 😉

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Another Polish Perspective

    Her response qualifies Dick as a comedian. When I read that I LOL'd. The context helps. She is a psycho from page 1.

    Freud is not good as a scientist but a great story teller. They do not use him in psychiatry at all and they do not use him in psychology except for history. In the Gleitman textbook edition I have Freud is only in a couple of those sidebar boxes. And Jung is not in there at all.

    One time I asked Scott Alexander on an internet board after he was practicing psychiatry about some Freud this or that and his reply was "I haven't read any Freud."

  183. @German_reader
    @Mikel

    The problem with any forum really is that familiarity breeds contempt. Over time you start to get into an antagonistic relationship with other users, maybe even into long-running "feuds", mutual grievances accumulate and in the end you don't have anything to say to each other anymore, because the fundamental differences are just too irreconcilable.
    I suppose to some extent it might just be me, but I've encountered such dynamics in every forum I ever participated in (this one here was by no means the worst btw, and I suspect without the war in Ukraine things wouldn't have gotten as ugly as they did). As for Twitter, unlike Yevardian I don't see that as an alternative. I tried it for a few weeks, and found the experience stressful and rather toxic.
    But yes, given the decline in active users, the mutual antagonisms, and the exhausting focus on Ukraine to the exclusion of everything else there doesn't seem to be much life left here anymore (also noteworthy how Hyperborean who popped up after several years of absence already seems to have left again).
    Anyway, who knows, maybe 2024 will see some sort of resolution to the war in Ukraine (or at least freeze the fighting); here's another possible sign:
    https://www.ft.com/content/e0c9a4bb-903a-48d9-b44c-f26b445499b0


    Italy’s defence minister Guido Crosetto has called for greater diplomatic efforts to end the war between Russia and Ukraine, despite Kyiv’s warnings that Moscow has no intention to do so.

    Crosetto told a parliamentary hearing on Wednesday that Italy would seek “a dual-track strategy” with military support for Kyiv to be coupled with more engagements towards a “negotiated settlement”.

    “We must be realistic and cannot ignore the military situation on the field,” Crosetto said as lawmakers approved more bilateral aid to Kyiv. “The time seems to have come for effective diplomatic action.”

     


    Yet in a sober analysis of Ukraine’s military and political strengths, Crosetto, who was previously president of Italy’s defence industry association, expressed concern about “the real Ukrainian ability to counter Russian forces . . . in a condition of persistent numerical and air inferiority”.

    “Unfortunately, Ukraine’s summer counteroffensive did not give the desired results,” he said, warning that 2024 would be a “critical year” for Ukraine’s future.

    He insisted diplomatic efforts would run in tandem with continued military aid for Ukraine — of which Italy is now preparing an eighth package, just as it has assumed the presidency of the G7.

    “We have two paths: that of aid without ‘ifs and buts’ — and that of attempting to build a diplomatic path that brings us to the end of the conflict,” he said. “The coming months will have to balance deterrence and diplomacy.”

    But Crosetto also said talks could only begin if Russia ceased its missile and drone attacks on Ukraine. “We can start talking when the bombs stop falling,” he said. “We have to convince those who are attacking to stop.”

     

    Replies: @Beckow, @Mikel, @Hyperborean

    …Crosetto also said talks could only begin if Russia ceased its missile and drone attacks on Ukraine. “We can start talking when the bombs stop falling,” he said. “We have to convince those who are attacking to stop.”

    EU and Kiev need the “talks” more than Russia. Demanding a condition that amounts to a cease-fire is self-defeating – it gives Russia an easy way out since they have made it clear that they will not agree to a cease-fire. And they don’t need to talk to Kiev.

    The Italian guy is trying to have it both ways – many people suddenly don’t want to be too associated with the pro-Kiev-pro-war side, even BoJo is now claiming he didn’t scuttle the peace talks in March 22. And Sholz seems to want out.

    What is that saying about rats on a sinking ship?

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @Beckow


    Demanding a condition that amounts to a cease-fire is self-defeating – it gives Russia an easy way out since they have made it clear that they will not agree to a cease-fire.
     
    It's a demand for Russia to stop killing civilians and demolishing Ukrainian infrastructure through missile/drone strikes (leading to Ukraine retaliating in a similar manner like recently at Belgorod), doesn't seem to refer to fighting at the front. Maybe not totally realistic, but much more so than Zelensky's absurd ten-point plan.
    Anyway, I suspect it will come to nothing, because in the end the Americans are the only ones who matter, and Biden's administration will probably continue on the set course. But imo it's the kind of approach that should at least be tried.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    , @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    EU and Kiev need the “talks” more than Russia.
     
    The only talks with current Kiev regime Russia will engage in will be unconditional capitulation. That will happen after regime collapse, not before it.

    What is that saying about rats on a sinking ship?
     
    By openly supporting criminal actions of Israel the empire and its minions got themselves into Gaza quagmire. That overshadowed Ukrainian quagmire and pushed it to the back of the scene. Now it looks like Iran successfully lured the empire and its British cocksuckers into Yemen quagmire. That will push Ukraine even further back.

    The empire is frantically seeking any success that might distract from Ukrainian failure. Success is unlikely, but Israeli failure in Gaza and US failure in Yemen will certainly distract from the failure of the imperial camp in Ukraine.

  184. German_reader says:
    @Beckow
    @German_reader


    ...Crosetto also said talks could only begin if Russia ceased its missile and drone attacks on Ukraine. “We can start talking when the bombs stop falling,” he said. “We have to convince those who are attacking to stop.”
     
    EU and Kiev need the "talks" more than Russia. Demanding a condition that amounts to a cease-fire is self-defeating - it gives Russia an easy way out since they have made it clear that they will not agree to a cease-fire. And they don't need to talk to Kiev.

    The Italian guy is trying to have it both ways - many people suddenly don't want to be too associated with the pro-Kiev-pro-war side, even BoJo is now claiming he didn't scuttle the peace talks in March 22. And Sholz seems to want out.

    What is that saying about rats on a sinking ship?

    Replies: @German_reader, @AnonfromTN

    Demanding a condition that amounts to a cease-fire is self-defeating – it gives Russia an easy way out since they have made it clear that they will not agree to a cease-fire.

    It’s a demand for Russia to stop killing civilians and demolishing Ukrainian infrastructure through missile/drone strikes (leading to Ukraine retaliating in a similar manner like recently at Belgorod), doesn’t seem to refer to fighting at the front. Maybe not totally realistic, but much more so than Zelensky’s absurd ten-point plan.
    Anyway, I suspect it will come to nothing, because in the end the Americans are the only ones who matter, and Biden’s administration will probably continue on the set course. But imo it’s the kind of approach that should at least be tried.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @German_reader

    I am not against trying it, I just think it is impossible to define - both sides claim that they are only aiming at military targets, that anything else is collateral damage (Nato invented the term), caused by defense missiles, or propaganda. Same is true in Gaza, and was true in the previous wars fought by Nato around the world.

    Saying that they will stop bombing civilians, when they deny doing it today, is impossible. The way to break the deadlock would have to be a very attractive offer by Kiev-Nato, e.g. they could admit the obvious and say that "Ukraine will not join Nato", or give some territorial concessions - they could offer to let people living in the "disputed" regions choose what they want: Ukraine, Russia, autonomy, or independence...

    Russia would have harder time rejecting it offhand. Once the talks start it would be difficult to restart the all-out war. It is the best option Kiev has left, or they can slowly bleed, destroy Ukraine, and end up with a worse deal.

    But I am skeptical that Russia would take the bite - after the Minsk fiasco. Being proud of lying in diplomacy never pays...

    Replies: @QCIC, @German_reader, @A123

    , @Gerard1234
    @German_reader


    It’s a demand for Russia to stop killing civilians and demolishing Ukrainian infrastructure through missile/drone strikes (leading to Ukraine retaliating in a similar manner like recently at Belgorod)
     
    Wow, you disgusting, intellectually lazy (and dishonest) scumbag.

    1. Ukraine has been targeting Belgorod, Bryansk,Kursk and non-border regions throughout the war you idiot. So the "retaliating in a similar manner in Belgorod" is a dumb and fake equivalence

    2. Russia doesn't kill civilians, Ukraine loves killing civilians

    3. Russia doesn't target civilians, Belgorod war crime was deliberate targeting of civilians, with no military target in centre of Belgorod ( the city targeted repeatedly, but for whatever reason this time they got through). Strike at busy daytime, New Year shopping and entertainment being done

    4. Those particular Cluster munitions are what caused particular harm from this (unguided) launch......hence why majority of civilians killed were those on street or those in cars driving all spread over a long distance ( absolutely ZERO equivalence of this from Russian massive airstrikes you severe dumbfuck from 100's of launches over 2 years) as what we target and when we use bomb/rocket/missile carrying cluster munitions on these targets is chosen for military, not PR reasons.

    5. not only did 404 target and repeatedly destroy electricity supply and water cuttoff to Donetsk, Lugansk for a long time, they initiated the whole infrastructure targeting from the scumbag tactic of using an (innocent) civilian vehicle to carry a bomb on the Crimean bridge and kill several other civilians. An absolute war crime, and pointless one as without targeting the central span (blocking shipping) or targeting the railbridge ( where most military equipment, that doesn't even need to be transported that way, can be transported in bulk)......this lowlife action had zero military justification. Again, it was typical PR action by the Nazis, just like this Belgorod attack. Russia does zero PR military actions all targets are military or infrastructure to disrupt the military effort of the Ukronazis.

    6. If you had a brain you dumb POS, you would think why air defence systems for 404 are mostly embedded in cities/highly populated areas when Russia is firing these missiles from 100s, 1000km'away from the target . Again, you stupid prick, Russia doesn't do this, even with Belgorod and its immediate distance to Kharkov.

    7. What is the purpose of a trashbag like you on here? You fake "balance" by saying one thing, and then contradict with the next thing. Particularly worse for a german to say this nonsense

    8. Stupid prick

    Replies: @German_reader

  185. @German_reader
    @Mikel

    The problem with any forum really is that familiarity breeds contempt. Over time you start to get into an antagonistic relationship with other users, maybe even into long-running "feuds", mutual grievances accumulate and in the end you don't have anything to say to each other anymore, because the fundamental differences are just too irreconcilable.
    I suppose to some extent it might just be me, but I've encountered such dynamics in every forum I ever participated in (this one here was by no means the worst btw, and I suspect without the war in Ukraine things wouldn't have gotten as ugly as they did). As for Twitter, unlike Yevardian I don't see that as an alternative. I tried it for a few weeks, and found the experience stressful and rather toxic.
    But yes, given the decline in active users, the mutual antagonisms, and the exhausting focus on Ukraine to the exclusion of everything else there doesn't seem to be much life left here anymore (also noteworthy how Hyperborean who popped up after several years of absence already seems to have left again).
    Anyway, who knows, maybe 2024 will see some sort of resolution to the war in Ukraine (or at least freeze the fighting); here's another possible sign:
    https://www.ft.com/content/e0c9a4bb-903a-48d9-b44c-f26b445499b0


    Italy’s defence minister Guido Crosetto has called for greater diplomatic efforts to end the war between Russia and Ukraine, despite Kyiv’s warnings that Moscow has no intention to do so.

    Crosetto told a parliamentary hearing on Wednesday that Italy would seek “a dual-track strategy” with military support for Kyiv to be coupled with more engagements towards a “negotiated settlement”.

    “We must be realistic and cannot ignore the military situation on the field,” Crosetto said as lawmakers approved more bilateral aid to Kyiv. “The time seems to have come for effective diplomatic action.”

     


    Yet in a sober analysis of Ukraine’s military and political strengths, Crosetto, who was previously president of Italy’s defence industry association, expressed concern about “the real Ukrainian ability to counter Russian forces . . . in a condition of persistent numerical and air inferiority”.

    “Unfortunately, Ukraine’s summer counteroffensive did not give the desired results,” he said, warning that 2024 would be a “critical year” for Ukraine’s future.

    He insisted diplomatic efforts would run in tandem with continued military aid for Ukraine — of which Italy is now preparing an eighth package, just as it has assumed the presidency of the G7.

    “We have two paths: that of aid without ‘ifs and buts’ — and that of attempting to build a diplomatic path that brings us to the end of the conflict,” he said. “The coming months will have to balance deterrence and diplomacy.”

    But Crosetto also said talks could only begin if Russia ceased its missile and drone attacks on Ukraine. “We can start talking when the bombs stop falling,” he said. “We have to convince those who are attacking to stop.”

     

    Replies: @Beckow, @Mikel, @Hyperborean

    here’s another possible sign:
    https://www.ft.com/content/e0c9a4bb-903a-48d9-b44c-f26b445499b0

    The problem is that people like Italy’s defense minister don’t count. He’ll be made to eat his words if the people who do count so decide. It is encouraging to see one more sign that we may be headed towards a diplomatic solution, and we’ve had plenty in the last months, but there are also powerful forces opposed to that in Europe, Kiev and the US. I wouldn’t be too optimistic about the war ending this year, as Beckow was also saying above.

    Regardless of what happens with the Ukraine aid package in Congress (and it’s difficult to see a total cut of US military aid to Ukraine, especially if diplomacy doesn’t work and the conflict continues), Ukraine is soon going to receive the long-awaited F-16s, the Taurus (if I’m not mistaken) and plenty of other weapons. I think that the British PM was in Kiev just today, announcing a new aid package, and I read that the Poles also promised something the other day. In the meantime, Ukraine seems to be mobilizing many thousands of new recruits. There may be talk of negotiations but things seem to be heading towards another attempt to counterattack (probably in the spring) at the same time.

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @Mikel


    I wouldn’t be too optimistic about the war ending this year
     
    imo there'll either be a diplomatic solution (less likely) or Ukraine will lose in the end, catastrophically.
    I'd prefer the first outcome, but if Ukraine and its Western supporters want to stick to the "total victory" approach, their choice. I'm beginning to no longer really care tbh. There's still a chance this could escalate into a direct NATO-Russia war that ends with nuclear incineration, but it looks less likely now than maybe a year ago. Most likely it will just end with Ukraine being wrecked and the West suffering a humiliating loss of prestige. A tragedy, but I'm not Ukrainian, and I despise the people running the West, so emotionally it's not my fight.

    Replies: @Mikel

    , @A123
    @Mikel


    Regardless of what happens with the Ukraine aid package in Congress (and it’s difficult to see a total cut of US military aid to Ukraine, especially if diplomacy doesn’t work and the conflict continues)
     
    Funding Kiev aggression is unpopular with MAGA, thus the House will load up any appropriation with things that do appeal to voters. Is Not-The-President Biden willing to agree to real border security and reinstating Trump's Stay in Mexico policy?

    It is easy to envision a near total cut during an election year. It is an "inch deep" issue. While the top line polling looks favourable, voters will not swing on this single policy. It may not be "total zero", but it looks like vastly less in 2024.

    A full end in 2025 seems certain. Cutting off the Veggie-In-Chief's foreign policy failures is a priority for Trump's 2nd term. The fact that it also highlights Burisma Biden's personal, corrupt cash flows makes it a double bonus.

    If Scholz and Macron want their puppet Zelensky to continue, Germany and France will have to foot the bill. Are they willing to spend €5 Billion/month?


    Ukraine is soon going to receive the long-awaited F-16s
     
    They are still training pilots. The window for a limited number of Netherlands transfers is now, at the earliest, in April. Suspiciously, no one is explaining the maintenance and logistics to keep the planes mission capable.

    What % of German provided Leopards are still in the field? Poor support is decommissioning them faster than combat losses. If Kiev cannot keep tanks in service, that does not bode well for much more complex combat aircraft.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Mr. XYZ

  186. @Beckow
    @German_reader


    ...Crosetto also said talks could only begin if Russia ceased its missile and drone attacks on Ukraine. “We can start talking when the bombs stop falling,” he said. “We have to convince those who are attacking to stop.”
     
    EU and Kiev need the "talks" more than Russia. Demanding a condition that amounts to a cease-fire is self-defeating - it gives Russia an easy way out since they have made it clear that they will not agree to a cease-fire. And they don't need to talk to Kiev.

    The Italian guy is trying to have it both ways - many people suddenly don't want to be too associated with the pro-Kiev-pro-war side, even BoJo is now claiming he didn't scuttle the peace talks in March 22. And Sholz seems to want out.

    What is that saying about rats on a sinking ship?

    Replies: @German_reader, @AnonfromTN

    EU and Kiev need the “talks” more than Russia.

    The only talks with current Kiev regime Russia will engage in will be unconditional capitulation. That will happen after regime collapse, not before it.

    What is that saying about rats on a sinking ship?

    By openly supporting criminal actions of Israel the empire and its minions got themselves into Gaza quagmire. That overshadowed Ukrainian quagmire and pushed it to the back of the scene. Now it looks like Iran successfully lured the empire and its British cocksuckers into Yemen quagmire. That will push Ukraine even further back.

    The empire is frantically seeking any success that might distract from Ukrainian failure. Success is unlikely, but Israeli failure in Gaza and US failure in Yemen will certainly distract from the failure of the imperial camp in Ukraine.

  187. German_reader says:
    @Mikel
    @German_reader


    here’s another possible sign:
    https://www.ft.com/content/e0c9a4bb-903a-48d9-b44c-f26b445499b0
     
    The problem is that people like Italy's defense minister don't count. He'll be made to eat his words if the people who do count so decide. It is encouraging to see one more sign that we may be headed towards a diplomatic solution, and we've had plenty in the last months, but there are also powerful forces opposed to that in Europe, Kiev and the US. I wouldn't be too optimistic about the war ending this year, as Beckow was also saying above.

    Regardless of what happens with the Ukraine aid package in Congress (and it's difficult to see a total cut of US military aid to Ukraine, especially if diplomacy doesn't work and the conflict continues), Ukraine is soon going to receive the long-awaited F-16s, the Taurus (if I'm not mistaken) and plenty of other weapons. I think that the British PM was in Kiev just today, announcing a new aid package, and I read that the Poles also promised something the other day. In the meantime, Ukraine seems to be mobilizing many thousands of new recruits. There may be talk of negotiations but things seem to be heading towards another attempt to counterattack (probably in the spring) at the same time.

    Replies: @German_reader, @A123

    I wouldn’t be too optimistic about the war ending this year

    imo there’ll either be a diplomatic solution (less likely) or Ukraine will lose in the end, catastrophically.
    I’d prefer the first outcome, but if Ukraine and its Western supporters want to stick to the “total victory” approach, their choice. I’m beginning to no longer really care tbh. There’s still a chance this could escalate into a direct NATO-Russia war that ends with nuclear incineration, but it looks less likely now than maybe a year ago. Most likely it will just end with Ukraine being wrecked and the West suffering a humiliating loss of prestige. A tragedy, but I’m not Ukrainian, and I despise the people running the West, so emotionally it’s not my fight.

    • Replies: @Mikel
    @German_reader


    A tragedy, but I’m not Ukrainian, and I despise the people running the West, so emotionally it’s not my fight.
     
    Exactly. There was never a good reason to take sides in the disputes between those two corrupt countries. In fact, if we hadn't taken any side, it would had probably never escalated to the tragedy it now is. Lira's predictable death (and the equally predictable reaction to it of all the scum that led us to that war) will be a permanent reminder of how f-cked up the whole idea was from the beginning.
  188. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    The girlfriend is a psycho. All of Dick’s girlfriends were psychos. In relationship therapy class they tell you that people do that because it’s familiar. The subconscious always prefers the familiar, even when simple logic tells you she is a worthless and negative force.
     
    IMHO, her response doesn't automatically qualify her as a psycho... It is a bit solipsistic, but applied solipsism is a female trait much too often.

    And why do you so easily believe in explanatory power of Freudian concepts? i would expect more discernment from you. The psychologists-peddled ideas like "the subconscious is irresistibly drawn to the familiar" just absolve us of any responsibility and hide ugly truths like "some humans really are (sado)masochists", normalizing our suffering for us, with the exception of "trauma" ;) (or "trauma" is a new name for "real" suffering).
    Psychology is a new religion of sinners ;)

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    Her response qualifies Dick as a comedian. When I read that I LOL’d. The context helps. She is a psycho from page 1.

    Freud is not good as a scientist but a great story teller. They do not use him in psychiatry at all and they do not use him in psychology except for history. In the Gleitman textbook edition I have Freud is only in a couple of those sidebar boxes. And Jung is not in there at all.

    One time I asked Scott Alexander on an internet board after he was practicing psychiatry about some Freud this or that and his reply was “I haven’t read any Freud.”

  189. @Mikel
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    No mention of his death in the MSM but, as far as I can see, this looks unlikely to be fake. Several non-mainstream journalists are reporting it, including Tucker, who can be an idiot sometimes but I don't think would risk spreading false news of this type.

    AP told us here that Lira was making up his allegations of mistreatment in Ukrainian prison and that his prosecution was justified.

    He could have admitted that Ukraine is still not such a democratic country, even less during wartime, but he opted for justifying the imprisonment of an American for posting stuff on Youtube (ie exercising his freedom of expression). I guess once you decide to justify the killing of thousands of your co-ethnic civilians you're in a slippery slide with no breaks. Anything must become justifiable after that.

    If this gets confirmed we'll surely be reminded of what a creepy person he was (to the extent we hear anything from him at all). But it makes you wonder what it must be like in Ukraine for all the people who don't have a Tucker Carlson or a Glenn Greenwald to defend them. This is the country they tell us we must spend hundreds of billions of dollars in and risk nuclear war for, gentlemen.

    Replies: @AP, @Emil Nikola Richard

    AP told us here that Lira was making up his allegations of mistreatment in Ukrainian prison and that his prosecution was justified

    Because no unhealthy people ever die in American prisons. Apparently he was not well for awhile, and was given medical care.

    He could have admitted that Ukraine is still not such a democratic country, even less during wartime, but he opted for justifying the imprisonment of an American for posting stuff on Youtube (ie exercising his freedom of expression

    He was allegedly posting positions and spreading foreign propaganda of an invader.

    Despite being an American he was not above the law in Ukraine.

    Were you on the Axis side during World War II because those Japanese were interred?

    I guess once you decide to justify the killing of thousands of your co-ethnic civilians

    I don’t justify Russians actions that led to those deaths.

    you’re in a slippery slide with no breaks. Anything must become justifiable after that.

    Interesting hierarchy of moral values for you. Donbassers getting killed is further up the slide than some Chilean-American psychopath allegedly committing crimes in a foreign country because he thought his passport would make him above the law, getting arrested and dying of illness in prison.

    This is the country they tell us we must spend hundreds of billions of dollars in and risk nuclear war for

    The hundreds of billions are spent not in Ukraine but in the USA. It pays for the upgraded weapons we get when we send the old stuff to Ukraine. It also pays to upgrade our military manufacturing potential.

    And of course no risk of nuclear war. It’s an excuse to do what Putin wants without explicitly supporting Putin.

    A fitting obituary:

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @Mikel
    @AP

    You guys are so predictable. Exactly as I said, no sooner you learn Ukraine has killed this man than you start throwing crap at him, as if that was going to help you justify that he was most likely tortured and, in the best case scenario, killed through negligence after spending months in a filthy prison with improper medical care for something he said. Not even woke, pro-Ukraine Youtube found objection to the posts that cost him his life. In one of his last tweets he correctly predicted that he would die if arrested, btw. Your moral standards are very repugnant.

    Replies: @AP

  190. @Mikel
    @German_reader


    here’s another possible sign:
    https://www.ft.com/content/e0c9a4bb-903a-48d9-b44c-f26b445499b0
     
    The problem is that people like Italy's defense minister don't count. He'll be made to eat his words if the people who do count so decide. It is encouraging to see one more sign that we may be headed towards a diplomatic solution, and we've had plenty in the last months, but there are also powerful forces opposed to that in Europe, Kiev and the US. I wouldn't be too optimistic about the war ending this year, as Beckow was also saying above.

    Regardless of what happens with the Ukraine aid package in Congress (and it's difficult to see a total cut of US military aid to Ukraine, especially if diplomacy doesn't work and the conflict continues), Ukraine is soon going to receive the long-awaited F-16s, the Taurus (if I'm not mistaken) and plenty of other weapons. I think that the British PM was in Kiev just today, announcing a new aid package, and I read that the Poles also promised something the other day. In the meantime, Ukraine seems to be mobilizing many thousands of new recruits. There may be talk of negotiations but things seem to be heading towards another attempt to counterattack (probably in the spring) at the same time.

    Replies: @German_reader, @A123

    Regardless of what happens with the Ukraine aid package in Congress (and it’s difficult to see a total cut of US military aid to Ukraine, especially if diplomacy doesn’t work and the conflict continues)

    Funding Kiev aggression is unpopular with MAGA, thus the House will load up any appropriation with things that do appeal to voters. Is Not-The-President Biden willing to agree to real border security and reinstating Trump’s Stay in Mexico policy?

    It is easy to envision a near total cut during an election year. It is an “inch deep” issue. While the top line polling looks favourable, voters will not swing on this single policy. It may not be “total zero”, but it looks like vastly less in 2024.

    A full end in 2025 seems certain. Cutting off the Veggie-In-Chief’s foreign policy failures is a priority for Trump’s 2nd term. The fact that it also highlights Burisma Biden’s personal, corrupt cash flows makes it a double bonus.

    If Scholz and Macron want their puppet Zelensky to continue, Germany and France will have to foot the bill. Are they willing to spend €5 Billion/month?

    Ukraine is soon going to receive the long-awaited F-16s

    They are still training pilots. The window for a limited number of Netherlands transfers is now, at the earliest, in April. Suspiciously, no one is explaining the maintenance and logistics to keep the planes mission capable.

    What % of German provided Leopards are still in the field? Poor support is decommissioning them faster than combat losses. If Kiev cannot keep tanks in service, that does not bode well for much more complex combat aircraft.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    Zionist framing of Hizbullah & allies electoral victory as an expansion of Iranian influence suggests democracy is a dangerous experiment unless its results are predetermined; it further strips the popular will of all agency & reduces the Lebanese people to foreign tools.

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FTGHEafXsAEl1Il.jpg

    Replies: @A123

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @A123


    Is Not-The-President Biden willing to agree to real border security and reinstating Trump’s Stay in Mexico policy?
     
    Biden could agree to this at least partially given that the US already has a lot of new Latin American migrants to integrate right now.

    Replies: @A123

  191. @Mikel
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    No mention of his death in the MSM but, as far as I can see, this looks unlikely to be fake. Several non-mainstream journalists are reporting it, including Tucker, who can be an idiot sometimes but I don't think would risk spreading false news of this type.

    AP told us here that Lira was making up his allegations of mistreatment in Ukrainian prison and that his prosecution was justified.

    He could have admitted that Ukraine is still not such a democratic country, even less during wartime, but he opted for justifying the imprisonment of an American for posting stuff on Youtube (ie exercising his freedom of expression). I guess once you decide to justify the killing of thousands of your co-ethnic civilians you're in a slippery slide with no breaks. Anything must become justifiable after that.

    If this gets confirmed we'll surely be reminded of what a creepy person he was (to the extent we hear anything from him at all). But it makes you wonder what it must be like in Ukraine for all the people who don't have a Tucker Carlson or a Glenn Greenwald to defend them. This is the country they tell us we must spend hundreds of billions of dollars in and risk nuclear war for, gentlemen.

    Replies: @AP, @Emil Nikola Richard

    The RT story is interesting. They wrote the American embassy wouldn’t do anything for the American because Victoria Nuland “hated him personally”.

    His episode on what a psycho Nuland is was great. He aired out all this stuff about her daddy, who went into a psych hospital when she was 13, received a bunch of electric shock treatments, and was never again the same. He was successful alpha monkey at the time he got depressed. Nuland became a hateful piece of work at a young age.

    Also he said she was pretty hot back then which I think surpasses the limits of credibility. Such things are pretty subjective though.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    There is little reason to believe anything about Lira and Ukraine is real. It could all be true, but he is a movie maker. Distrust and verify, or better yet, don't worry about it. If nothing else he knew what he was getting into.

    Here is Vicki's Dana Scully phase:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/89/Victoria_Nuland_State_Department.jpg

    , @Mikel
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    The RT story is interesting.
     
    The fact that you need to go to rt.com to find something out about an American blogger dead in Ukrainian custody for an opinion crime because the Western MSM will not touch the subject with a ten foot pole highlights all the sordid, hidden aspects of this war and why we should have never got involved. In fact, it pretty much says all you need to know to form yourself a sound opinion on the whole matter.
  192. @AP
    @Beckow


    In absolute terms the two camps will be roughly equal, the big loser will be Europe that has minimal resources and its manufacturing is not competitive. US-Canada-Australia will do much better
     
    I actually agree with you here. But it is Western Europe that is declining. The East does not. Poland's economy keeps improving, year after year.

    – there is a strong opinion in EU that is why US is willing to do this – they are cannibalizing their Euro allies
     
    No one forced Germany to stupidly get rid of its nuclear power. Or to stupidly become overly dependent on Russian gas (these two phenomena are linked - Russia was funding the German anti-nuclear activists, though Germans shouldn't have listened to them). Such mistakes have consequences. German manufacturers are moving many of their operations to the USA. When peace comes to Ukraine they will move a lot there, also.

    The security-defense boom can cover some of it for a while but it will eventually (soon) lead to lower access to consumer goods and good life. Defense is a lot of things but it doesn’t increase living standards – it is an economic black hole: stuff goes in and nothing comes out…
     
    You do realize that you just described most of Russia's recent economic "growth," right?

    Much more true of Russia than of the West.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @Sean

    When peace comes to Ukraine they will move a lot there, also

    Which is why Putin will never let peace come to Ukraine.

  193. This made me think of some of Mr XYZ’s comments here:

    https://nitter.net/Advo_Katy/status/1745792360313925648#m

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @German_reader

    Obviously pedophiles should not be allowed to reproduce through surrogacy. Though there's a chance that it might have helped matters had he had access to a realistic child sex doll/robot complete with AI programming that would allow it to have conversations with this pedophile. Right now, people with such inclinations are being legally punished even if they seek out completely harm-free outlets such as this for their sex drive.

  194. @Mikel
    @Gerard1234

    I don't have any strong opinions on the Riga architectural landscape. If all parties involved agree with you that the best parts were built by the Russians, that is something I can perfectly live with.

    However, it is just not true that LatW left because of you. She clearly left in indignation at the epithet that G_R directed at her. Even worse, then G_R proceeded to leave the blog himself, at a time when Dmitry, Bashi, Aaron and others had been absent for a while and Yahya has briefly reappeared to let us know what a waste of his time this geriatric ward had become really. The chances of any worthwhile debate taking place here have become infinitesimal.

    But I can't blame any of them really. We had long ago entered the law of diminishing returns, discussing ad nauseam the same old subjects with the same old arguments (me included). Who doesn't have better uses of their time than that?

    With that said, I think it's been quite a remarkable feat to keep this blog alive for 2 years after his author left (and actually break records of comment numbers on this website). Perhaps as important as the subjects we keep debating are the subjects the regulars of this blog never debate: transhumanism and technological singularities (AK's favorite topics) or the JQ (Unz's obsession). This clearly signals that it was never about AK or Unz. They both just happened to attract a group of disparate people with very different backgrounds and the group then took a life of its own, building very lively threads out of nothing that for one reason or another we all felt compelled to participate in. Though obviously AK and Ron deserve credit for the phenomenon.

    Alas, everything has an end and it looks like these threads are losing the vigor and interest they once had. On to the difficult task of finding other places to debate, vent and engage people of different persuasions without being censored, I guess.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @AP, @Yevardian, @German_reader, @Gerard1234

    She clearly left in indignation at the epithet that G_R directed at her.

    German reader is mild-mannered, certainly compared to myself on here.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Gerard1234

    He can use your crude image to emulate. I do hope that LatW is only taking a short, but long deserved vacation from this blogsite, and then decides to return and grace us with her presence.

  195. @A123
    @QCIC


    , if the jobs were priced with all the costs included (call them the externalities) then the supply and demand might work out just with local people.
     
    I concur.

    Over supply of migrants, both legal and illegal, suppressed 'blue collar' wages. Off shoring is another destructive force for wage suppression. These led to delayed marriage and two income couples as a necessity. Both factors are known to be detrimental to TFR.

    One cannot bring back the 50's. However, the idea of a husband being able to support a wife and multiple children can return. It requires tightly controlling migration and MAGA Reindustrialization. Some things may cost more and be less available. That is a reasonable trade off for a functioning society on Main Street.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @QCIC, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    I agree.

    The birth control pill and female awakening are important “organic” factors in the changes in the American family and racial demographics. On the other hand, memes such as the “population bomb” were being used to talk Americans into very small families even before offshoring and immigration fully cranked up.

    • Replies: @songbird
    @QCIC

    The Catholic Church in America actually warned how the population was already predicted to collapse in its booklet literature against contraception.
    _______
    If this were the '80s, the entire French government would have AIDS. Macron would not have been able to appoint Attal PM and Attal would not have been able to appoint Sejourne FM because they would all be dead of AIDS.

  196. @Gerard1234
    @Mikel


    She clearly left in indignation at the epithet that G_R directed at her.
     
    German reader is mild-mannered, certainly compared to myself on here.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    He can use your crude image to emulate. I do hope that LatW is only taking a short, but long deserved vacation from this blogsite, and then decides to return and grace us with her presence.

    • LOL: Mikhail
  197. @AP
    @Gerard1234


    US is a net IMPORTER of oil relative to what it produces
     
    https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/oil-and-petroleum-products/imports-and-exports.php#:~:text=Also%20in%202022%2C%20the%20United,about%2020.01%20million%20b%2Fd.

    In 2020, the United States became a net exporter of petroleum for the first time since at least 1949.1 In 2022, total petroleum exports were about 9.52 million barrels per day (b/d) and total petroleum imports were about 8.33 million b/d, making the United States an annual net total petroleum exporter for the third year in a row

    Although U.S. annual total petroleum exports were greater than total petroleum imports in 2020, 2021, and 2022, the United States still imported some crude oil and petroleum products from other countries to help to supply domestic demand for petroleum and to supply international markets.

    The United States remained a net crude oil importer in 2022, importing about 6.28 million b/d of crude oil and exporting about 3.58 million b/d. Some of the crude oil that the U.S. imports is refined by U.S. refineries into petroleum products—such as gasoline, heating oil, diesel fuel, and jet fuel—that the U.S. later exports. Also, some of imported petroleum may be stored and later exported.

    Of course, you are completely clueless on the matter and only recycling something from somewhere else and have zero experience of the issue
     
    Western cars made in China on Western standards are okay (though for example Chinese-made Volvos are less reliable than those made in Sweden or the USA, despite the engines not being made in China) but many Chinese cars are garbage that would not be allowed on roads in civilized countries.

    Replies: @QCIC

    AP’s original list and G-man’s criticisms are both valid. The USA still has a potent core economy which may yet recover with more reshoring. The successful US aviation industry is a swamp. The biggest companies listed are mostly defense contractors. Boeing is successful, but many of their commercial aircraft have a very high percentage of foreign content. I think the situation with Boeing commercial aircraft is a bit like GM/Detroit where a toxic mixture of management incompetence combined with unsustainable union wage costs may be driving it into the ground or at least out of the USA. The success of the Brazilian Embraer 190 was probably a wake up call to Boeing signifying that her historical profit margins would no longer be possible. The Russian commercial aircraft sector has not yet revived. If they can ship 20 SSJ100R and 10 MC-21 in 2024 they may be in good shape. These are tiny numbers compared to Airbus and Boeing but the Russian airliners are not in direct competition with the Western planes. The USA is dominant in the manufacture of private jets.

  198. @AP
    @Mikel


    AP told us here that Lira was making up his allegations of mistreatment in Ukrainian prison and that his prosecution was justified
     
    Because no unhealthy people ever die in American prisons. Apparently he was not well for awhile, and was given medical care.

    He could have admitted that Ukraine is still not such a democratic country, even less during wartime, but he opted for justifying the imprisonment of an American for posting stuff on Youtube (ie exercising his freedom of expression

     

    He was allegedly posting positions and spreading foreign propaganda of an invader.

    Despite being an American he was not above the law in Ukraine.

    Were you on the Axis side during World War II because those Japanese were interred?

    I guess once you decide to justify the killing of thousands of your co-ethnic civilians
     
    I don’t justify Russians actions that led to those deaths.

    you’re in a slippery slide with no breaks. Anything must become justifiable after that.
     
    Interesting hierarchy of moral values for you. Donbassers getting killed is further up the slide than some Chilean-American psychopath allegedly committing crimes in a foreign country because he thought his passport would make him above the law, getting arrested and dying of illness in prison.

    This is the country they tell us we must spend hundreds of billions of dollars in and risk nuclear war for
     
    The hundreds of billions are spent not in Ukraine but in the USA. It pays for the upgraded weapons we get when we send the old stuff to Ukraine. It also pays to upgrade our military manufacturing potential.

    And of course no risk of nuclear war. It’s an excuse to do what Putin wants without explicitly supporting Putin.

    A fitting obituary:



    https://twitter.com/jayinkyiv/status/1745894825998582152?s=46&t=Qz3eXZWFYIvyHmaAk32tcg

    Replies: @Mikel

    You guys are so predictable. Exactly as I said, no sooner you learn Ukraine has killed this man than you start throwing crap at him, as if that was going to help you justify that he was most likely tortured and, in the best case scenario, killed through negligence after spending months in a filthy prison with improper medical care for something he said. Not even woke, pro-Ukraine Youtube found objection to the posts that cost him his life. In one of his last tweets he correctly predicted that he would die if arrested, btw. Your moral standards are very repugnant.

    • Agree: Mikhail, Wielgus
    • Replies: @AP
    @Mikel


    Exactly as I said, no sooner you learn Ukraine has killed this man
     
    Evidence that Ukraine "killed this man?"

    Are you doing it again?

    he was most likely tortured
     
    Again, any evidence of that?

    killed through negligence after spending months in a filthy prison with improper medical care
     
    He was in a normal prison. It was probably bad by Western standards, but why should he have special treatment?

    for something he said.
     
    He allegedly broke the law. Germany and France imprison people for denying the Holocaust, so don't pretend that American-style free speech is universal among Western democracies.

    https://apnews.com/article/europe-crime-berlin-the-holocaust-15972809c1bf40f8eb8d2935d04c3b2d

    "A Berlin court has sentenced a 93-year-old German woman to 12 months in prison for denying that Jews were systematically murdered during the Holocaust."

    Gonzalo Lira moved to a foreign country, broke its laws by spreading and creating propaganda in support of the country that was invading the very country he had moved to and was killing its people. This is IMO worse than Holocaust denial but each country has its own laws.

    Not even woke, pro-Ukraine Youtube found objection to the posts that cost him his life.
     
    He took poor care of his health and chose to move to a foreign country and to break it's laws. He was even released to be in his apartment pending trial (such leniency! and casts doubt on the claim that he had been tortured) but chose to break the law again by fleeing, and was stupid enough to brag about it before he managed to cross the border, leading to his re-arrest.

    In one of his last tweets he correctly predicted that he would die if arrested, btw
     
    He also supposedly predicted he would die of heart problems a couple of years ago.

    Your moral standards are very repugnant.
     
    I'm not the one "conveniently" adopting positions that benefit the side that invades another country and kills 10,000s of its people and 100,000s of soldiers.

    And you slipped - you wrote that this Chilean-American psychopath's death was further down the slide from the killing of thousands of civilians in Donbas. This suggests that you think the life of Gonzalo Lira is > the lives of thousands of Donbassers.

    Replies: @Mikel, @LondonBob

  199. @QCIC
    @A123

    I agree.

    The birth control pill and female awakening are important "organic" factors in the changes in the American family and racial demographics. On the other hand, memes such as the "population bomb" were being used to talk Americans into very small families even before offshoring and immigration fully cranked up.

    Replies: @songbird

    The Catholic Church in America actually warned how the population was already predicted to collapse in its booklet literature against contraception.
    _______
    If this were the ’80s, the entire French government would have AIDS. Macron would not have been able to appoint Attal PM and Attal would not have been able to appoint Sejourne FM because they would all be dead of AIDS.

  200. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mikel

    The RT story is interesting. They wrote the American embassy wouldn't do anything for the American because Victoria Nuland "hated him personally".

    His episode on what a psycho Nuland is was great. He aired out all this stuff about her daddy, who went into a psych hospital when she was 13, received a bunch of electric shock treatments, and was never again the same. He was successful alpha monkey at the time he got depressed. Nuland became a hateful piece of work at a young age.

    Also he said she was pretty hot back then which I think surpasses the limits of credibility. Such things are pretty subjective though.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mikel

    There is little reason to believe anything about Lira and Ukraine is real. It could all be true, but he is a movie maker. Distrust and verify, or better yet, don’t worry about it. If nothing else he knew what he was getting into.

    Here is Vicki’s Dana Scully phase:

    [MORE]

  201. @songbird
    @AnonfromTN

    Lol. I was thinking more along the lines of speaking than typing.

    But to go off on a tangent, I've always felt there was something "off" about Philip K. Dick's writing. Not sure whether it was drugs or his unaltered mind, but I recall hearing some surprising statistic that a lot of the early Pulitzer winners were alcoholics, so I would lean towards some sort of substance-enhancement.

    Browsing the wiki article on logorrhea, I see it is linked to a number of disorders. But I was thinking of something more like the reverse: can the need to always be talking itself lead naturally to paranoia? Suppose it is hard to separate cause from effect.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AnonfromTN

    Suppose it is hard to separate cause from effect.

    Classical chicken and egg conundrum. Evolution solved it, although it took millions of years.

  202. @German_reader
    @Mikel


    I wouldn’t be too optimistic about the war ending this year
     
    imo there'll either be a diplomatic solution (less likely) or Ukraine will lose in the end, catastrophically.
    I'd prefer the first outcome, but if Ukraine and its Western supporters want to stick to the "total victory" approach, their choice. I'm beginning to no longer really care tbh. There's still a chance this could escalate into a direct NATO-Russia war that ends with nuclear incineration, but it looks less likely now than maybe a year ago. Most likely it will just end with Ukraine being wrecked and the West suffering a humiliating loss of prestige. A tragedy, but I'm not Ukrainian, and I despise the people running the West, so emotionally it's not my fight.

    Replies: @Mikel

    A tragedy, but I’m not Ukrainian, and I despise the people running the West, so emotionally it’s not my fight.

    Exactly. There was never a good reason to take sides in the disputes between those two corrupt countries. In fact, if we hadn’t taken any side, it would had probably never escalated to the tragedy it now is. Lira’s predictable death (and the equally predictable reaction to it of all the scum that led us to that war) will be a permanent reminder of how f-cked up the whole idea was from the beginning.

  203. The mayors of Berlin, London, and Paris ought to each sit on thrones made from melting all the knives from their criminals together.

    https://www.amren.com/news/2024/01/germany-knife-crime-reaches-10-year-high-in-berlin-as-immigration-soars/

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @songbird


    https://twitter.com/uMarhobane/status/1745861276008362325

  204. @German_reader
    @Beckow


    Demanding a condition that amounts to a cease-fire is self-defeating – it gives Russia an easy way out since they have made it clear that they will not agree to a cease-fire.
     
    It's a demand for Russia to stop killing civilians and demolishing Ukrainian infrastructure through missile/drone strikes (leading to Ukraine retaliating in a similar manner like recently at Belgorod), doesn't seem to refer to fighting at the front. Maybe not totally realistic, but much more so than Zelensky's absurd ten-point plan.
    Anyway, I suspect it will come to nothing, because in the end the Americans are the only ones who matter, and Biden's administration will probably continue on the set course. But imo it's the kind of approach that should at least be tried.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    I am not against trying it, I just think it is impossible to define – both sides claim that they are only aiming at military targets, that anything else is collateral damage (Nato invented the term), caused by defense missiles, or propaganda. Same is true in Gaza, and was true in the previous wars fought by Nato around the world.

    Saying that they will stop bombing civilians, when they deny doing it today, is impossible. The way to break the deadlock would have to be a very attractive offer by Kiev-Nato, e.g. they could admit the obvious and say that “Ukraine will not join Nato”, or give some territorial concessions – they could offer to let people living in the “disputed” regions choose what they want: Ukraine, Russia, autonomy, or independence…

    Russia would have harder time rejecting it offhand. Once the talks start it would be difficult to restart the all-out war. It is the best option Kiev has left, or they can slowly bleed, destroy Ukraine, and end up with a worse deal.

    But I am skeptical that Russia would take the bite – after the Minsk fiasco. Being proud of lying in diplomacy never pays…

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Beckow

    NATO is an anti-Russia military alliance. NATO’s main purpose in Ukraine is to apply military pressure against Russia. Russia has stated that removing NATO from Ukraine is one of the core requirements for the SMO. This eradication is not simply a military project, it also involves intrigue, diplomacy and post-SMO government. How can this removal be accomplished?

    For NATO countries, the cost in lives and money for the Ukrainian project generally seems small, with the exception of German economic trauma. This low cost gives NATO little incentive to end the project. On the other hand, the project has definitively failed by making Russia stronger both militarily and economically. Worse yet, Russian citizens are more unified behind the government compared to when this started. Will the NATO leaders and Neocons realize the net result of their efforts are terrible? History suggests these people will not figure this out. They might continue the project even if Ukraine capitulates. If NATO leaves Ukraine tomorrow, the planners may even consider the project a partial success along the lines of "'Tis better to have meddled and failed than never to have meddled at all." (with profuse apologies to Tennyson).

    I wonder if Russia and Ukraine can be free of NATO entanglements unless a new Ukrainian leadership gives NATO a serious public rebuke? To be meaningful and influential, this rebuke probably has to include war crimes trials of NATO personnel and their Ukrainian collaborators.

    Replies: @Beckow

    , @German_reader
    @Beckow


    I just think it is impossible to define
     
    It would mean Russia doesn't attack targets in Ukrainian cities away from the front line, imo that's not hard to define at all.

    Being proud of lying in diplomacy never pays…
     
    Russia has done plenty of lying too. Back in 2014/15 their official position was that they hadn't sent regular troops into Ukraine, didn't shell Ukrainian positions from across the border etc. which was just ridiculous. In February 2022 they also claimed there was no intent of invading Ukraine until right before the invasion actually happened. So it's not like the reasons for distrust are concentrated solely on the Western side (and despite my general loathing for her, I still don't believe Merkel's actions regarding the Minsk agreements were an intentional deception on her part).
    But anyway, not much point to discussing all of this anymore, and I'm getting pretty tired of it. With luck, there'll be a big Mideast war soon. At this point even Greasy William's nutty Messiah posting looks preferable to this endless Ukraine circle jerk.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Greasy William

    , @A123
    @Beckow


    I am not against trying it, I just think it is impossible to define – both sides claim that they are only aiming at military targets, that anything else is collateral damage (Nato invented the term), caused by defense missiles, or propaganda. Same is true in Gaza, and was true in the previous wars fought by Nato around the world.
     
    I agree. The concept of inevitable Collateral Damage preceded NATO by centuries or millennia, even if they were first to coin that exact phrase.

    There is a huge amount of SJW squealing and bleating over Israeli tactics. Yet, those expressing faux outrage never condemn Hamas use of human shields. Nor do they provide any realistic alternative option for Palestinian Jews.


    I am skeptical that Russia would take the bite – after the Minsk fiasco. Being proud of lying in diplomacy never pays…
     
    I concur.

    Merkel ordered Zelensky to engage in bad faith on the Minsk deal. There is no sign that Scholz is any different. SJW squealing and bleating over Russian tactics falls on deaf ears. There cannot be anything resembling a pause as long as Kiev is run by Zelensky. He shares Abbas's total absence of credibility and honesty.

    What Kiev needs most is new leadership. How can that happen after Zelensky nationalized non-state media, disbanded opposition parties, and suspended elections? Ukraine's subservience to European Elites and absence of democracy are severe impediments to meaningful negotiations.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

  205. @Beckow
    @AP

    The situation with German economy is a lot more complicated than just the "nuclear power", etc...The energy squeeze is happening everywhere and it is getting worse. Germany used eastern Europe for a lot of energy-intensive manufacturing and it is now gradually shutting down. The overall supply chain has been blown up and the consequences are just starting - in the next 2 to 5 years we will see it.

    Russia was also a very good market: high prices and they paid on time - high profit margins in Russia subsidized other business. The money Russia earned stayed in the Western banks allowing for an investment boom and lower interest rates. The one-time proposed theft is a bad idea - imagine if your bank takes your deposits, will anyone ever work with them? Russia will continue generating hundreds of billions in profits each year - that's the money that matters and it is close to exiting permanently.

    You don't understand economics or business well - even you pointing to "defense" boom in Russia is short-sighted: they are in an existential war and they have resources (forever), they can afford to do it, Europe can't - Euros also don't have any inclination to go into an existential fight. Poland is not "Europe", it is just noise in the east.

    Replies: @AP, @Another Polish Perspective

    The money Russia earned stayed in the Western banks allowing for an investment boom and lower interest rates. The one-time proposed theft is a bad idea – imagine if your bank takes your deposits, will anyone ever work with them?

    Banks often confiscate funds from criminals, in order to pay fines or restitution to the victims. The invasion of Ukraine was a crime, and Russia is getting its funds confiscated as a result.

    Do you think that when a criminal has his funds taken from him – this is “theft?”

    You don’t understand economics or business well – even you pointing to “defense” boom in Russia is short-sighted: they are in an existential war

    Nonsense, and they know it too. It’s why they are not doing total war.

    and they have resources (forever), they can afford to do it

    Maybe. Does it contradict the below, however? It does not.

    The security-defense boom can cover some of it for a while but it will eventually (soon) lead to lower access to consumer goods and good life. Defense is a lot of things but it doesn’t increase living standards – it is an economic black hole: stuff goes in and nothing comes out…

    Europe can’t

    Europe’s (and the West’s) economy is large enough that they only need a fraction of it to match Russia’s efforts. Europeans won’t be willing to devote nearly the same % of their economy to helping Ukraine’s war effort as Russia does to sustain it’s invasion, but they don’t have to.

  206. Lavrov Schools Presstitute

    You are much better than me at interrupting.” The below is an excellent primer on dealing with hack journalists. Along with his Hungarian and Indian peers, Lavrov is among the best active diplomats. Honestly, which trio is more competent – Biden, Yellen and Blinken or Putin, Nabiullina and Lavrov?

    • Replies: @Mikhail
    @Mikhail

    Among the highlights, Lavrov compares the NATO proxy war against Russia with the Napoleonic and Nazi attempts to defeat Russia, which ended up with Russia becoming stronger. He added that Napoleon and the Nazis used numerous other Europeans in their failed endeavor.

    Lavrov's comments regarding cancel culture, Russia-Ukraine and Israel-Palestine mesh with my commentary on these subjects.

  207. @Mikel
    @AP

    You guys are so predictable. Exactly as I said, no sooner you learn Ukraine has killed this man than you start throwing crap at him, as if that was going to help you justify that he was most likely tortured and, in the best case scenario, killed through negligence after spending months in a filthy prison with improper medical care for something he said. Not even woke, pro-Ukraine Youtube found objection to the posts that cost him his life. In one of his last tweets he correctly predicted that he would die if arrested, btw. Your moral standards are very repugnant.

    Replies: @AP

    Exactly as I said, no sooner you learn Ukraine has killed this man

    Evidence that Ukraine “killed this man?”

    Are you doing it again?

    he was most likely tortured

    Again, any evidence of that?

    killed through negligence after spending months in a filthy prison with improper medical care

    He was in a normal prison. It was probably bad by Western standards, but why should he have special treatment?

    for something he said.

    He allegedly broke the law. Germany and France imprison people for denying the Holocaust, so don’t pretend that American-style free speech is universal among Western democracies.

    https://apnews.com/article/europe-crime-berlin-the-holocaust-15972809c1bf40f8eb8d2935d04c3b2d

    “A Berlin court has sentenced a 93-year-old German woman to 12 months in prison for denying that Jews were systematically murdered during the Holocaust.”

    Gonzalo Lira moved to a foreign country, broke its laws by spreading and creating propaganda in support of the country that was invading the very country he had moved to and was killing its people. This is IMO worse than Holocaust denial but each country has its own laws.

    Not even woke, pro-Ukraine Youtube found objection to the posts that cost him his life.

    He took poor care of his health and chose to move to a foreign country and to break it’s laws. He was even released to be in his apartment pending trial (such leniency! and casts doubt on the claim that he had been tortured) but chose to break the law again by fleeing, and was stupid enough to brag about it before he managed to cross the border, leading to his re-arrest.

    In one of his last tweets he correctly predicted that he would die if arrested, btw

    He also supposedly predicted he would die of heart problems a couple of years ago.

    Your moral standards are very repugnant.

    I’m not the one “conveniently” adopting positions that benefit the side that invades another country and kills 10,000s of its people and 100,000s of soldiers.

    And you slipped – you wrote that this Chilean-American psychopath’s death was further down the slide from the killing of thousands of civilians in Donbas. This suggests that you think the life of Gonzalo Lira is > the lives of thousands of Donbassers.

    • Replies: @Mikel
    @AP


    Gonzalo Lira moved to a foreign country, broke its laws by spreading and creating propaganda
     
    Lira broke Ukrainian law in the same way that Navalny broke Russian law. By posting stuff on YT that the authorities didn't like. Or in the same way that I guess I have myself repeatedly broken Ukrainian "law": posting opinions in English-language media that would also land me in jail if the goons of the regime you support could lay his hands on me. In fact, Ukraine must be about the only country in the world that keeps lists of foreign citizens (mostly actors and other non-entities who at some point dared to say something Ukie nationalists didn't like) as "enemies of Ukraine".

    The bottom line is that both Russia and Ukraine are corrupt countries where Communism was succeeded in short order by oligarch rule (as you would expect from closely related societies), full of criminal people with power, private armies and very little respect for human life. Lira's latest video before being arrested listed a number of people who, like he predicted would happen to him, were killed by the Kiev scum.

    Some idiots in Europe (as full of crap as the American neocon nation-builders in Muslim lands) found it their duty to go to the rescue of the poor oppressed Ukrainians when some people in Kiev started jumping up and down to demand being accepted in the EU. Ukrainians had finally seen the light and and now would become exemplary citizens of the EU paradise they think they've built, abandoning their decades-long habits of fostering corruption at all levels of their society. As it happened, even to prove how different they were from the Russians they couldn't help bombing their own cities and killing thousands of their co-citizens. That's how attached to the so-called "EU values" they are. And the more they continued to receive support from all these idiots on both sides of the Atlantic, the more encouraged they felt to carry on, until their cousins to the North decided to unleash their own chimpout.

    You can also jump up and down all you want and try to explain to us how ordinary it is in any European country for American bloggers to die in prison after being arrested for expressing opinions critical of the countries where they live. But regardless of all your dialectical efforts, you're not going to change one iota about any of the facts above. And those cold, hard facts are the ones that are going to continue determining the developments in the country of your ancestors.

    Replies: @AP, @Mikhail

    , @LondonBob
    @AP

    Lira was only released so the goons could follow him and try and pick up any 'disloyal' Ukrainians, didn't happen, he was just posting his own opinions, there was no network. His wife is from Kharkhov and his children are too. In a civilised country like Russia he would simply have been deported, instead they forced him to stay, like so many others are, and then killed him. The Jews in the State Department didn't lift a finger to help him.

  208. @Beckow
    @German_reader

    I am not against trying it, I just think it is impossible to define - both sides claim that they are only aiming at military targets, that anything else is collateral damage (Nato invented the term), caused by defense missiles, or propaganda. Same is true in Gaza, and was true in the previous wars fought by Nato around the world.

    Saying that they will stop bombing civilians, when they deny doing it today, is impossible. The way to break the deadlock would have to be a very attractive offer by Kiev-Nato, e.g. they could admit the obvious and say that "Ukraine will not join Nato", or give some territorial concessions - they could offer to let people living in the "disputed" regions choose what they want: Ukraine, Russia, autonomy, or independence...

    Russia would have harder time rejecting it offhand. Once the talks start it would be difficult to restart the all-out war. It is the best option Kiev has left, or they can slowly bleed, destroy Ukraine, and end up with a worse deal.

    But I am skeptical that Russia would take the bite - after the Minsk fiasco. Being proud of lying in diplomacy never pays...

    Replies: @QCIC, @German_reader, @A123

    NATO is an anti-Russia military alliance. NATO’s main purpose in Ukraine is to apply military pressure against Russia. Russia has stated that removing NATO from Ukraine is one of the core requirements for the SMO. This eradication is not simply a military project, it also involves intrigue, diplomacy and post-SMO government. How can this removal be accomplished?

    For NATO countries, the cost in lives and money for the Ukrainian project generally seems small, with the exception of German economic trauma. This low cost gives NATO little incentive to end the project. On the other hand, the project has definitively failed by making Russia stronger both militarily and economically. Worse yet, Russian citizens are more unified behind the government compared to when this started. Will the NATO leaders and Neocons realize the net result of their efforts are terrible? History suggests these people will not figure this out. They might continue the project even if Ukraine capitulates. If NATO leaves Ukraine tomorrow, the planners may even consider the project a partial success along the lines of “‘Tis better to have meddled and failed than never to have meddled at all.” (with profuse apologies to Tennyson).

    I wonder if Russia and Ukraine can be free of NATO entanglements unless a new Ukrainian leadership gives NATO a serious public rebuke? To be meaningful and influential, this rebuke probably has to include war crimes trials of NATO personnel and their Ukrainian collaborators.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @QCIC


    ...Tis better to have meddled and failed than never to have meddled at all.
     
    Nothing ventured, nothing gained...:) Of course it is a "partial success" for the authors, they will be fine. It is a lot of fun and money: they fly around, gorge on buffets, talk "very important" stuff - the greatest dream for neo-con dorks and loser exiles. They don't want it to end, they are not risking anything.

    I agree the Western eastward push is semi-permanent, it goes on a hiatus and then it inevitably restarts. The players also don't change: the bloodied border-landers, Poles, Ukies, Balts, Belarussians are always in the mix.

    Nato's push is the latest initiative. We know how the previous ones ended. The best we can hope for is for the active part to stop: Nato packs the crazy plans and pulls back. Then the West can go back to the teasing business-culture soft attack that works better on the Russians. That will also need a 10-20 year break.

    It is hard to tell how far will Russia go - clearly Nato is playing for a draw and wants to protect some positions and be better prepared next time. Russia may not allow that - or they could. The global sh.t mother-of-all-wars that seems to be starting could make this meaningless.

  209. @AP
    @Derer


    There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

    Only illiterate.

     

    This guy was no illiterate:

    https://bi.im-g.pl/im/03/ed/1b/z29283587AMP,Pogrzeb-Daniela-Sztybera-na-Powazkach--Mezczyzne--.jpg

    https://www.polskieradio.pl/395/9766/artykul/3184898,in-memory-of-a-pole-who-died-for-free-ukraine

    Daniel, after volunteering for combat in Ukraine, served in Kyiv’s elite special forces as a reconnaissance team member. He had three university degrees and extensive military training, including at Poland's elite special-forces unit GROM.

    “I regret a bit my last message to him......He sent me a poem by Herbert, a famous Polish poet. There was a certain doubt in this piece, and the author described how no one would repay him, and that he would be mocked for what he had done. After reading it, I was stressed I felt that he needs me, so I wrote to him, "Son, you were the last to doubt. Be brave, you are fighting the army of darkness and you are on the side of good". And he answered me, Finally, Dad, thank you. I think I gave him permission to sacrifice himself. I think about it and ask myself, why I didn't write to him to be careful and not to risk it".

    “I respect what he did and have respected it from the beginning. He made his choice fully aware that he was taking a risk, but he wanted a free nation, protection of Poland, Europe, and the world,” Mirosław Sztyber added.

    Do not forget the J yoke in Poland is as strong as in Ukraine.
     
    You haven't heard of the problems between Poland and Israel?

    Replies: @A123, @Mr. XYZ

    You haven’t heard of the problems between Poland and Israel?

    Who do you personally support in this dispute, AP?

  210. @AP
    @A123


    The best questions would pair the policy with inevitable outcome. “Knowing that you will be paid less, do you support migrants coming to compete for your job?”
     
    How many Americans are gardeners, roofers, fruit pickers, maids, table bussers, etc. though?

    These are the ones whose wages get cut. Other Americans benefit from this stuff being a lot cheaper than it otherwise would have been. I know quite a few people who have saved a lot of money and avoided nursing home care for ages loved ones by having live-in illegals from Poland and Ukraine stay with elderly relatives.

    I’m not arguing in favor of mass immigration, but a lot of Americans do benefit from it. And those ones are the ones who also are wealthier and pay most of the taxes.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

    Worth noting that a sizable part of the mass immigration to the US, specifically the non-Latin American part, also largely consists of cognitive elites. Those people benefit the US by founding businesses, creating jobs, paying more taxes than they take out of the US budget, doing innovation and scientific research, et cetera.

  211. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    I actually agree with you here. But it is Western Europe that is declining. The East does not. Poland’s economy keeps improving, year after year.

     

    Eastern Europe often has booming economies, but it isn't producing elite science in the same quantities as Western Europe is. It's not even close:

    https://www.unz.com/akarlin/science-production/

    https://www.unz.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/map-nature-index-cities-europe-2017.png

    The US and East Asia also punch pretty well, but sadly Eastern Europe does not:

    https://www.unz.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/map-nature-index-cities-world-2017.png

    How much of this is due to brain drain, especially of the more creative and innovative people there, is hard to say.


    When peace comes to Ukraine they will move a lot there, also.
     
    If Ukraine's security will be solidly assured, then Yes, hopefully. South Korea was also in a state of frozen conflict over the last 70+ years but nevertheless managed to become an economic wonder story:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracle_on_the_Han_River

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/5f/GDP_history_Since_1950_~_2016.png

    Its total fertility rate (currently at just 0.72 children per woman per lifetime) is extremely dismal, though. Possibly worse than even Ukraine's during wartime, though hard to tell without concrete data.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    AP, what do you think is the cause of Eastern Europe’s lack of elite science production relative to Western Europe?

    It’s a similar story in regards to patents:

    https://jakubmarian.com/number-of-patent-applications-per-capita-by-region-in-europe/

    Seems like the most innovative place in the Eastern European part of the EU is Budapest. But I do suspect that there is a Communist legacy factor in holding Eastern Europe back at least a little bit. Estonia performs much, much worse than Finland does in spite of Estonians and Finns being genetically similar, after all. (Estonia might only be around 70% Estonian, but that’s still a solid majority.)

    • Replies: @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    Commie legacy plus brain drain (these are related).

    Poland is the only eastern European country other than Russia with a particle accelerator though:

    https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/4jy9s3/countries_with_particle_accelerators_1400_673/

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ

  212. @Yahya
    Gentlemen,

    I know that many of you despaired these past few months from the absence of Yahya's world famous film reviews. So I returned to this sacred forum to provide you with my unusually interesting and perspicuous takes on the films I watched this previous year. Overall, it has been a fruitful year for me cinematically, with a total of 141 films watched. I found it difficult to narrow down my selections to just the top 10 or 20; such was the large number of high-quality films I viewed in 2023. The key to maximizing quality films watched is to quit early when a film displays Goddard-tier dullness and pretentiousness. The Leopard will not change its spots. Just cut your losses and move on.

    1. The Godfather I (1972 - Coppola - American)
    2. The Godfather II (1974 - Coppola - American)
    3. Socrates (1971 - Rossellini - Italian)
    4. The Grand Illusion (1937 - Renoir - French)
    5. Batman Begins (2005 - Nolan - American)
    6. Gone With The Wind (1939 - Fleming - American)
    7. Wild Strawberries (1957 - Bergman - Swedish)
    8. North By Northwest (1959 - Hitchcock - American)
    9. Training Day (2001 - Fuqua - American)
    10. Great Expectations (1946 - Lean - British)
    11. Jane Eyre (1943 - Stevenson - British)
    12. Burnt By The Sun (1994 - Mikhalkov - Russian)
    13. Woman In The Dunes (1964 - Teshigahara - Japanese)
    14. Europe ‘51 (1952 - Rossellini - Italian)
    15. Annie Hall (1977 - Allen - American)
    16. Belle De Jour (1967 - Bunuel - French)
    17. The Searchers (1956 - Ford - American)
    18. The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1962 - Ford - American)
    19. Mulholland Drive (2001 - Lynch - American)
    20. The Gentlemen (2019 - Ritchie - British)

    Honorable Mentions
    1. The Equalizer (2014 - Fuqua - American)
    2. Kind Hearts & Coronets (1946 - Hamer - British)
    3. Winter Sleep (2014 - Ceylan - Turkish)
    4. Taxi Driver (1976 - Scorsese - American)
    5. Hamlet (1948 - Olivier - British)

    My ranking of national cinemas remains unchanged from my last post, though I realized that my high opinion of Anglo-American cinema may be biased by the ease of watching English-language movies. Especially towards the second half of the year, I couldn't be bothered with subtitles and strange cinematographic techniques, so my viewings were heavily tilted towards Anglo-American films. But that is a fault I aim to rectify in 2024.

    I've already written about some of these films in my posts throughout the year; so I'll stick to new selections here.

    The Grand Illusion centers around a group of French POWs held in captivity by the Germans; the most alluring of whom is the confident, self-assured Captain de Boeldieu, a French aristocratic officer whose untroubled bearing, upright posture, neat styling, and sardonic demeanor give him a Gaulle-esque aroma I found captivating. Renoir utilizes the setting of the film to comment upon class dynamics: "When I’m with Boeldieu, I never feel completely at ease. Call it the education barrier.” “He’s a fine type.” “Agreed, and he’s very decent. Suppose you and I went broke, we’d both be turned into beggars. If it happened to him, he’d still be Monsieur De Boeldieu.” Though I later found out Renoir is of the Socialistic bent, the film does not exude class hostility, but takes on a tolerant and matter-of-fact observational style as it relates to class and warfare. The film is also refreshing in its male-orientation; there is no romantic sub-plot to please female viewers (“Sentiment has no place in war” as de Boeldieu remarks); and it was a pleasure to view depictions of Old Europe such as the scene in the Gothic Cathedral at minute 50.

    Training Day explores the necessity of harshness, cruelty and rule-breaking in the fight against hard crime; in other words it touches upon the Jungian concept of Integrating The Shadow. "To protect the sheep you gotta catch the wolf, and it takes a wolf to catch a wolf." Washington's character represents the Wolf, he is willing to bend the rules and inflict cruelty on suspects to expedite the process of discovering and apprehending criminals. Denzel’s character is charismatic, bombastic, psychopathic, relentless, decisive. He asserts his will over subordinates by using his position of power and establishes his dominance fairly quickly over Hawke by use of verbal adeptness and charisma. Hawkes' character is initially naïve, rule-following, and considerate of others. Denzel takes advantage of him by deceiving him into the hands of the cartel, but Hawke survives by sheer chance of having rescued a cartel member's cousin earlier in the day. The script is stale when read on paper, but is brought to life by Washington's eloquence and force of personality. One the greatest performances I've seen on screen, and an overall worthy production by an African-American lead actor and director.

    Batman Begins is one of the few mass-market productions I found to be worthy and enjoyable, although it comes with attendant flaws such as two-dimensional characters, a predictable plotline, and a simple script. Nevertheless, it is possible for a blockbuster film to be of high artistic value despite the typical shortcomings; and one must not forget that stalwart classics such as The Godfather and North by Northwest were mass-market productions in their own time. Bruce Wayne presents an archetype of the masculine ideal; eliciting universal respect from all ranges of viewers, as his character and behavior tap into the collective unconscious. Batman's defining features are a) his strength, both mental and physical, which enable him to inflict damage on enemies and protect friends; b) handsome appearance in the traditional masculine sense, which though superficial, is critical to his status as a high-value male (he would not elicit respect had he been ugly and obese); c) an unbending sense of justice; and d) socio-economic status as one of the wealthiest individuals in Gotham.

    Batman is also a Dionysian figure, preferring action over knowledge-seeking. We do not see him sitting on a reclining chair, submerged in a book; but cultivating himself physically through intensive training. He mostly relies on intuition rather than logical reasoning to guide his actions. This was best evidenced in his confrontation with the Joker in the Dark Knight sequel. "The training is nothing, will is everything. The will to act", again emphasizing action over knowledge/training. Batman also develops a network of trust between himself Fox, Alfred, Rachel, and Commissioner Gordon. While Wayne is the central character in this network, he must rely on Fox for the technology, without which he cannot perform his duties.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow, @Mr. XYZ, @songbird, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Barbarossa

    Thanks Yahya, I’ll cherry pick a few of these for my own viewing as I have the chance. I really do appreciate your reviews.

    I’m particularly interested in giving the The Grand Illusion a try.

    One of the best films I’ve seen in a bit is the 1950’s version of A Christmas Carol with Alistair Sims. We always watched it at Christmas time when I was a kid and it’s been a couple decades since I’ve seen it but I would have to say that it is an excellently fleshed out Christmas Carol. It’s one of those films that is just nearly perfect in every way. The whole family loved it.

    My wife and I also saw The Boy and the Heron by Miyazaki in the theater a couple weeks ago and enjoyed it quite a bit. I you like Studio Ghibli fare it was a worthy addition. It was nice to see it on the big screen for the sake of the artwork, which gets a bit of short shrift on my small screen.

    I’m glad to hear that you are pushing your boundaries. Best of luck with the workouts, I think you’ll find it worthwhile!

    • Replies: @AP
    @Barbarossa


    My wife and I also saw The Boy and the Heron by Miyazaki in the theater a couple weeks ago and enjoyed it quite a bit. I you like Studio Ghibli fare it was a worthy addition. It was nice to see it on the big screen for the sake of the artwork, which gets a bit of short shrift on my small screen.
     
    I also took the kids to see it, what a beautiful movie. They are older now (oldest is not even a kid anymore), we had once taken the older one to see Spirited Away in theater when the kid was little.

    My kids saw more Miyazaki and Soviet cartoons (one of the few things done mostly right under the Soviets, even Pope John Paul II approved of them) than they did Disney, of the latter we only let them see the older classic ones.

    https://www.theonion.com/cool-dad-raising-daughter-on-media-that-will-put-her-en-1819572981

    Replies: @Barbarossa

    , @Yahya
    @Barbarossa


    One of the best films I’ve seen in a bit is the 1950’s version of A Christmas Carol with Alistair Sims.
     
    Dickensian stories tend to translate well onto the big screen. One of my favorite films is the 1984 rendition of Christmas Carol starring George C. Scott as Scrooge. The main theme resonated with me since I share Scrooge’s cynical mode of thinking. I haven’t been totally expunged of the rationalistic worldview, but I do remember the film striking a chord and making me re-examine my outlook and behavior.

    I you like Studio Ghibli fare it was a worthy addition.
     
    I’ve never watched Japanese anime. I’ll give one a go soon to expand my horizons.


    I’m glad to hear that you are pushing your boundaries. Best of luck with the workouts, I think you’ll find it worthwhile!
     
    I’ve been strength training for the past 4 months, and the impact has been nothing short of transformative. The positive effects spill over to other spheres of your life; it elevates your confidence, assertiveness and willpower. It is funny to look back at my previous attitude towards lifting weights as a vapid, time-wasting activity, aided by my impression that 85%+ of gym bros are shallow airheads.

    My outlook changed a full 180 degrees when I read Plato’s Republic, where in Chapter 4 he outlines the desirability of developing a harmonious balance of mental and physical qualities in future philosopher kings. Neglect of the former makes a person inelegant and brutish, and neglect of the latter makes you soft and timid. Only a combination of both can enable a person to reach a higher state of being.

    The previous 4 months have also changed my view of the nature vs nurture conundrum. While I still tend towards the hereditarian camp, I’ve since recalibrated upwards my appraisal of the environmental component in determining outcomes. It is quite possible for a person to change substantially if he is willing to step outside of his comfort zone and push the limits of what he hitherto thought was naturally capable. It only requires some gumption and a willingness to embrace fear and act despite of it, which I think most people are capable of.

    Replies: @AP, @Barbarossa

  213. @Sher Singh
    @Yahya

    I'm trying to cut without using macro factor atm.

    I find knowing you have X calories left encourages you to fill the bowl, so to speak.

    Instead, I make sure to get enough protein & then chill.

    With running too I just try to run after every session now - even if it's a few Km.

    --
    My ohp started climbing again since we last spoke.

    Saving that video though, thanks.

    https://bretcontreras.com/how-to-fix-glute-imbalances/

    No homo this fixed a 6 year old lifting injury I had literally days ago.

    I did iso contractions on weaker side & then during morning prayers after I think Good Mornings - my hip popped back into place.

    Took 3 days & yeah.
    --
    Still wearing Talwar everyday & involved in cases wherever they try to restrict it.

    Fateh with Maharaj Blessings.

    ਅਕਾਲ

    Replies: @Barbarossa, @Yahya

    Do you like Indian snacks? I like stocking up at the Indian grocery when I’m up that way since they are way better than American snacks in terms of nutrition. They seem to have a great proportion of fat/ carbs/ fiber/ protein and a small handful is really filling. You can’t scarf a whole bag like one can do with something like potato chips.

    • Replies: @Sher Singh
    @Barbarossa

    Na, mostly just home-made.
    If you name some stuff I can tell you if I know it.

    Been munching on mashing sesame flour + jaggery for the winter.
    All the online bros say Indian snacks lack protein - what u been eating?

    Replies: @Barbarossa

    , @Mr. Hack
    @Barbarossa

    What Indian snacks do you enjoy eating and would recommend? Here in Phoenix Land we have a great discount food store where I buy all sorts of treats at bargain basement prices. Recently, I was buying these great "Kind" and "Larabar" fruit and nut bars for $.10 a piece, even a few godiva chocolate bars for this ridiculously low price. I went there yesterday to repurchase some $.49 cans of cat food (my 3 feral cats scarf them down in no time), and was disappointed that the fruit bars (that had been on sale there for at least 2 months) were finally all gone. :-( I regularly buy all sorts of Starbucks coffees there between $3 - $6 per bag, the same ones that cost $7 - $11 per bag in the regular stores.

    On the upside, I did find some great 5 oz Terra Sweet Potato chips for $.99 a bag. Have you looked at the prices on potato chips in the regular grocery stores lately? $3 - $6 bucks a bag, highway robbery if you ask me, especially if you consider that you can still pick up a 5lb bag of great quality whole potatoes for only $3.

    Replies: @Barbarossa, @songbird

  214. @Beckow
    @AP


    ...There are more Poles than...
     
    Than what? Nobody cares about the Poles, they are only bloody tools for anyone who they are currently in love with. They line like lemmings and die for the others. What they think makes no difference because we don't take their hatreds seriously.

    I was not limiting it to V4: Austria, Slovenia, Croatia, Serbia - even large parts of Germany and Italy are more level-headed. The Poles can march on and invade Russia with their Anglo allies - it would work like this: Anglos talk and ship "weapons" and the Poles die. Then you write a thank you note to your masters in London-Washington...maybe even to Berlin.

    100 years misery? You bark your inane "Habsburg" nonsense. Let me remind you that it was by far the worst in terms of human rights, freedom, oppression, number of people in prison for wrong views, under the Habsburg feudal monarchy that you so stupidly celebrate. Only Nazis exceeded it in WW2.

    If you want to compare, it was the Poles who sided first with the Nazi Germany in Munich 1938, Poland was a brutal dictatorship in the 1930's...after 1945 there were 3 million Polish commies all the way till the end...in 1968 Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia the Poles were the second largest army - so you are hallucinating, but you are losing the war so we will give you some slack...:)

    Replies: @AP

    Than what? Nobody cares about the Poles

    Your words:

    The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere – in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia’s propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception

    You mentioned V4, I pointed out that Poles outnumber all other people within V4 combined.

    I was not limiting it to V4: Austria, Slovenia, Croatia, Serbia

    Serbia? Why not Syria also? And North Korea?

    Croatia helps Ukraine also. It gave Ukraine all of its Mi-8 helicopters.

    https://mpu.gov.hr/news-25399/croatia-strongly-supports-ukraine-and-the-ukrainian-people/27313

    it would work like this: Anglos talk and ship “weapons” and the Poles die.

    Last time Russia fought Poland, Russia lost. Russia can barely hold Ukraine to a stalemate.

    You bark your inane “Habsburg” nonsense. Let me remind you that it was by far the worst in terms of human rights, freedom, oppression, number of people in prison for wrong views, under the Habsburg feudal monarchy that you so stupidly celebrate

    Thanks for demonstrating the poor educational standards of Slovakia. So ignorant, so parochial. Poles lived under Hapsburgs, Romanovs and Hohenzollerns. Hapsburg rule was by far the mildest of the three. Ukrainians lived under Hapburgs and Romanovs. Hapsburgs were milder.

    So let’s compare executions.

    Russia:

    https://www.rbth.com/history/331226-death-penalty-russia

    1826-1905: 526 people executed
    1905-1910: 3,700 people executed

    Germany:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_Germany

    1907-1932: 393 people executed (could not find data for 19th century)

    Austria (not the Hungarian-ruled part of Austria-Hungary):

    https://www.jstor.org/stable/2276063?seq=2

    1852-1897: 175 people executed

    England and Wales:

    https://www.acrosswalls.org/datasets/executions-england-wales-from-1800/

    1852-1897: 622 people executed

    Only Nazis exceeded it [Austria-Hungary] in WW2

    Poor uneducated Beckow apparently hasn’t heard even of Stalin’s or Lenin’s crimes.

    If you want to compare, it was the Poles who sided first with the Nazi Germany in Munich 1938

    This lie of yours has already been debunked multiple times, many many people, some of whom aren’t posting here anymore.

    Poland refused multiple offers of alliance with the Nazis (and also refused alliances with the Bolsheviks). when Czechoslovakia was betrayed by its allies and gave up German-0ihabioted lands to Germany, Poland asked for and peacefully received Polish-inhabited territories, that the Czechs had previously seized by attacking Poland and killing its soldiers. It was not part of some Polish-German alliance (this was no Molotov-Ribbentrop), indeed Poland refused such.

    After 1945 there were 3 million Polish commies all the way till the end

    Poles fought Commies in 1920 (and defeated them, saving Europe from a Russian commie invasion), 1939, and 1945.

    Poland fought Nazis in 1939 rather than join them as Germany asked them to do and as Slovakia did. Thereby saving Europe from Nazi victory (Russians were defeated by Poles in 1921, you think the Soviets would have defeated a German-Polish alliance?). Maybe that’s why you can’t forgive Poles? Your people were eager Nazi allies. Slovakia even paid the Nazis money to kill Slovak Jews. Who else would do that?

    in 1968 Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia the Poles were the second largest army

    They were about 25,000 troops out of 450,000. “Second largest” lol. And it was a commie vs. commie conflict anyways. Afterward, Czechoslovaks were such sincere and loyal commies that Poles were shocked when they visited Czechoslovakia.

    Polish resistance to Commies in the 1980s brought down the Soviet system in Eastern Europe. This is probably why you, a Commie sympathizer, can’t forgive Poles.

    And of course Poles resist the importation of non-European Africans and Muslims into Europe. You Slovaks and Hungarians would not be able to resist the pressure alone.

    So Poland alone has resisted each of the evils plaguing Europe in the last 100+ years.

    While your people eagerly joined the Nazis, and voted for the Commies.

    you are losing the war

    Russia’s staggering losses and lack of gaining even villages (taking the slag head outside Avdiivka, some wooded strips, and central Marinka doesn’t count for much) suggest that its winter offensive is failing, so far.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    Poland fought Nazis in 1939 rather than join them as Germany asked them to do and as Slovakia did. Thereby saving Europe from Nazi victory (Russians were defeated by Poles in 1921, you think the Soviets would have defeated a German-Polish alliance?). Maybe that’s why you can’t forgive Poles? Your people were eager Nazi allies. Slovakia even paid the Nazis money to kill Slovak Jews. Who else would do that?

     

    Seems like a Franco-Anglo-Polish-Soviet alliance back in 1939 would have been better than what actually happened, no? At worst, the same outcome as in 1945, but at a much lower cost. Or is having a US military presence in Europe so crucial? With a Franco-Anglo-Polish-Soviet alliance in 1939, the US likely won't enter WWII at all but will nevertheless likely spend or loan a lot of its own money to help Europe rebuild after the end of the war, as it previously did after the end of WWI.

    While your people eagerly joined the Nazis, and voted for the Commies.

     

    IIRC, it was Czechs who voted for the Commies right after the end of WWII, not Slovaks:

    https://cs.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C4%8Ceskoslovensk%C3%A9_parlamentn%C3%AD_volby_1946

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/7c/Volby_1946_komunist%C3%A9.png

    Czechs were more pro-Commie in 1946 than Slovaks were, at least.

    , @Beckow
    @AP


    ...Why not Syria also? And North Korea?
     
    Because they are in Asia, get a map...

    Your lying about the recent history displays your desperation - or your very poor education. There were 3 million Polish commies....3 million, around 15% of adult population. So much for your Polish anti-communism...

    Small obvious points:
    - Habsburg Empire was substantially more brutal with prisons, poverty, mass emmigration and censorship than what followed after 1918. Period. No sane person in CE ever claims anything else and Habsburgs were never after 1918 asked back. We really don't care what was happening in Galicia pre-1918, it was a sh..thole province populated by Jews, Poles, Rusins, Romanians, with German overseers and massive emigration. Maybe that "Habsburg paradise" will come back, so you have that to look forward to.
    - Russia is winning the war in Ukraine. If you don't see it, I can't help you.
    - Polish troops invaded Czechoslovakia in 1968 - if they were "commies", what is this about you denying that Poles were also commies? Before that Poles invaded with Hitler after Munich in 1938. You can pretend that it didn't happen, but it just makes you look very, very stupid.

    In general, your obsessions about Habsburgs, Poles, commies, Russia, has led you to write some of the more bizarre hallucinations as if have created a completely made-up fake world - are you writing from a mental institution?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AP

    , @Gerard1234
    @AP

    Wow. What another despicable collection of lies and idiocy.

    Regarding Poles siding with the Nazis in 1938:


    This lie of yours has already been debunked multiple times, many many people, some of whom aren’t posting here anymore.
     
    Of course nobody has "debunked" this, because it's true. Nazi Poland was the first to sign agreement with Nazi Germany you dumbf*ck. They didn't "refuse" anything, they waited for even better deal with the Nazis as part of ongoing negotiation.

    An agreement of Poland, France and Czechoslovakia would have prevented WW2 you stupid idiot.
    Poles are effectively failed prostitutes of the French, many of their elites of French heritage,been closely connected for centuries, french help critical to them post-WW1........but Polish scum chose rejection of pact with their historically closest ally that would have stopped WW2 ( accumulative populations, military and industry potential advantage over the Nazis).....in favour of hoping for a better deal with the 2 main enemies of WW2 in Japan and Germany

    There was zero opposing of Nazism from fascist Poland, just the fact that sadistic "Greater Poland" (LOL) demands exceeded "Greater Germany " territorial ambitions you retarded cretin and they were desperate for a 3-side alliance with Japan to attack the Soviets from the East. Anti-Russianism was given precedence over pro-polish French - summarises why Poland such a failure of Europe for a millenium.

    Not only were they best allies of Nazi Germany and Japan.......they openly whored to both of them to the point it was criminal offense in Poland to insult Hitler!

    Poles fought Commies in 1920 (and defeated them, saving Europe from a Russian commie invasion), 1939, and 1945.
     
    LMFAO. Poland fought ( and got smashed) by the Soviets you dumb prick. Poland did not DECLARE war on Soviet Union, these prostitute parasites( state of Poland created by default and not from fighting for it in any way in WW1).....were such cowards and failures that they took war to Russia, a Russia in anarchy ,without any state and in civil war .....WITHOUT declaring it on anybody. It was zero ideological fight against Communism ( as proven towards Denikin and other stupid acts by Pilsudski such as to Lithuania) - just an opportunistic scumbag action

    As soon as Soviets organised to fight.....they proceeded to annihilate the Poles and throw them out of a mass area of land you idiot. A simple look at what the Poles (nearly unopposed) seized initially in the background of Russian civil war and what they finished with, makes everything clear. A simple look at even smaller targets of what parts of Belarus and Right bank Ukraine they wanted, initially took and then were kicked out of should make it ever more clearer.

    In reality French Generals, French air force, German & British & French artillery, rifles and ammunition, American and British huge amounts of money, and German, French and British intelligence in conjunction with the fact that Russia was in a state of civil war ( a far bigger conflict than the war with Poland you prick) and the Soviets were fighting about 3 million different wars at the same time........is entirely what stopped Soviet advance. Polish losers deserve ZERO credit for it - this why not a single Polish military officer from that war is studied in any western military academy ( by comparison, Tukhachevsky from his intended reforms and previous military achievements is). Advantage of officers with experience of serving in 3 of the great power militaries proved useless.

    So it was collective west and Tsarist Russia responsible for Polands post-WW1 territory you imbecile. Parasiting off their Nazi friends during the Munich Agreement in 1938 ( hundreds of thousands of Poles from those illegally seized lands fought with the Nazis in Barbarossa)........parasiting off collapse of Russian Empire

    Polish resistance to Commies in the 1980s brought down the Soviet system in Eastern Europe. This is probably why you, a Commie sympathizer, can’t forgive Poles.
     
    Again just lunatic idiocy. Slovaks resisted communism long before Poles did you idiot. "Solidarity" was nothing compared to violent/aggressive resistance Prague in 1968 and Budapest in 1956 ( that Poles only did this much later is very indicative) and Solidarity only developed because there was a Pole as secretary of State in the White House you idiot that pressurised USSR under threat of more sanctions not do what was correctly done in 56 and 1968. Overall context of Poland is.....(easily) held by Russia for 300 years, (easily) held by 3 different Empires for long period, (easily) defeated by Soviets and Nazis in embarrassingly quick time and (easily) held by Soviets for decades without any problems. Dumb American myths on what "brought down the Soviets" are demented.

    As Beckow said, huge number millions of Poles were pro-communist servants, millions more were fine with the system.

    And of course Poles resist the importation of non-European Africans and Muslims into Europe. You Slovaks and Hungarians would not be able to resist the pressure alone.
     
    Illiterate nonsense. Poles "resist" f*ck all. Its about 27th or 28th place of favoured destination for migrants into the EU. Slovaks and Hungarians clearly do "resist the pressure" alone you moron.
    Slovaks and Hungarians maintain population, economy and social cohesion........Poles have to rely on ukrops to maintain population - and "Ukrainians"to Poles are just like Africans or Pakistanis or Fillipinos to the western European nations. Of course Polish freaks are going to enjoy a rebirth of the Pan system to their traditional slaves, that has identical dynamic to west to 3rd world nations. If told take African or Muslim migrants or lose 100's of billion in EU AID and western investments....nothing to suggest they would resist.

    They were about 25,000 troops out of 450,000. “Second largest” lol. And it was a commie vs. commie conflict anyways. Afterward, Czechoslovaks
     
    That's a huge number of Poles you stupid prick. Poles were involved incredibly intensely in many aspects of Soviet life that you are too clueless to know about . That number of troops is much higher than percentage of ethnic "Ukrainians" in current ukronazi government too, LOL.

    Poland fought Nazis in 1939 rather than join them as Germany asked them to do and as Slovakia did. Thereby saving Europe from Nazi victory (
     
    Again,its just emphasising the fact you are a fantasist scumbag who has never been to Russia, Ukraine or Europe . Even the most deluded Polish nationalists or polish diaspora in the west don't say or claim this fantasist stuff composed of instantaneous BS. Yes , they make anti-Russian argument, but it's simple to see when a faker as yourself is attempting to mimic them and failing. Even worse than your medical "knowledge" which is very bizarre for a wakjob claiming to be a qualified medic, LOL!

    You are also entirely useless on Slovakia and its actions in WW2. Embarrassing to read.

    So Poland alone has resisted each of the evils plaguing Europe in the last 100+ years.
     
    Summary - Communism was not in any way "evil" you sick POS. Poles did the opposite of resist them. Poles certainly didn't resist the Nazis in any relevant way.

    In addition, more proof of why I don't waste time reading the links providing by a sociopathic worthless POS compulsive liar as yourself.....you even write number for executions that CONFIRM Russian Empire more lenient than the others you seriously disturbed retard!!!

    Just as being a Finn in Russia was a million times superior than one in Swedish Empire, Russian Empire was best place for cuckholded Poles out of the 3 different empires, Gruzian a million times better in union with Russia than as Ottoman or Persian etc. As for 1905-10 - time of first Russian revolution you idiot. One man gets assassinated in A-H and World war with tens of millions dead starts - in early 20th century Stolypin, Minister of Interior, Governor of Finland get assassinated in addition to a few others and several attempted assassinations ( Alexander 2nd assasinated a few decades earlier) and reaction by the authorities is extremely mild by comparison ( with nobodys heads cut off in execution either, different to the other places in Europe). In reality its because, different to Poland, Russia is a generator of intellectual ideas and big debate, PLUS the very generous treatment of areas of different ethnicities in laws, autonomy and money that actually fuelled these issues and rise of these socialistic ideas and nationalism. Completely different to the extreme repression in Austria-Hungary

    Replies: @AP

  215. German_reader says:
    @Beckow
    @German_reader

    I am not against trying it, I just think it is impossible to define - both sides claim that they are only aiming at military targets, that anything else is collateral damage (Nato invented the term), caused by defense missiles, or propaganda. Same is true in Gaza, and was true in the previous wars fought by Nato around the world.

    Saying that they will stop bombing civilians, when they deny doing it today, is impossible. The way to break the deadlock would have to be a very attractive offer by Kiev-Nato, e.g. they could admit the obvious and say that "Ukraine will not join Nato", or give some territorial concessions - they could offer to let people living in the "disputed" regions choose what they want: Ukraine, Russia, autonomy, or independence...

    Russia would have harder time rejecting it offhand. Once the talks start it would be difficult to restart the all-out war. It is the best option Kiev has left, or they can slowly bleed, destroy Ukraine, and end up with a worse deal.

    But I am skeptical that Russia would take the bite - after the Minsk fiasco. Being proud of lying in diplomacy never pays...

    Replies: @QCIC, @German_reader, @A123

    I just think it is impossible to define

    It would mean Russia doesn’t attack targets in Ukrainian cities away from the front line, imo that’s not hard to define at all.

    Being proud of lying in diplomacy never pays…

    Russia has done plenty of lying too. Back in 2014/15 their official position was that they hadn’t sent regular troops into Ukraine, didn’t shell Ukrainian positions from across the border etc. which was just ridiculous. In February 2022 they also claimed there was no intent of invading Ukraine until right before the invasion actually happened. So it’s not like the reasons for distrust are concentrated solely on the Western side (and despite my general loathing for her, I still don’t believe Merkel’s actions regarding the Minsk agreements were an intentional deception on her part).
    But anyway, not much point to discussing all of this anymore, and I’m getting pretty tired of it. With luck, there’ll be a big Mideast war soon. At this point even Greasy William’s nutty Messiah posting looks preferable to this endless Ukraine circle jerk.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @German_reader


    ...It would mean Russia doesn’t attack targets in Ukrainian cities away from the front line
     
    Excluding cities would create a safe zone to store weapons and shoot from. Some cities are on the front line, would they be a legitimate target?

    Russia has done plenty of lying too.
     
    Sure, they spin tales to media like all governments. But not about actual treaties - Russia has been legalistic about observing what they sign.

    It is possible Merkel was a secondary player not in on the Minsk deception. It would be worse: subservience and lack of control with an after-the-fact urge to please. Do you want a leader like that? Even a nominal leader needs dignity...

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @German_reader

    , @Greasy William
    @German_reader


    At this point even Greasy William’s nutty Messiah posting
     
    You think I'm nuts? We'll see in September

    With luck, there’ll be a big Mideast war soon.
     
    This line indicates to me that you secretly know that I'm right. I don't know anyone serving in Gaza but I do know a couple of people who know people who are serving there and they tell me that the reporting they are getting back from the front is that the IDF is getting posititively waxed.

    And this is only against Hamas, a poorly trained militia that is actually trying to lose. What chance does the IDF have against the combined forces of Lebanon, Syria, Iran and Russia? At this point, I'm wondering if Russia will even bother to join in. US is losing against Yemen as well.

    Ukraine, OTOH, is harder to read. Both sides claim to be winning but the situation on the ground is so opaque that I don't know what to think.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @German_reader

  216. @Barbarossa
    @Yahya

    Thanks Yahya, I'll cherry pick a few of these for my own viewing as I have the chance. I really do appreciate your reviews.

    I'm particularly interested in giving the The Grand Illusion a try.

    One of the best films I've seen in a bit is the 1950's version of A Christmas Carol with Alistair Sims. We always watched it at Christmas time when I was a kid and it's been a couple decades since I've seen it but I would have to say that it is an excellently fleshed out Christmas Carol. It's one of those films that is just nearly perfect in every way. The whole family loved it.

    My wife and I also saw The Boy and the Heron by Miyazaki in the theater a couple weeks ago and enjoyed it quite a bit. I you like Studio Ghibli fare it was a worthy addition. It was nice to see it on the big screen for the sake of the artwork, which gets a bit of short shrift on my small screen.

    I'm glad to hear that you are pushing your boundaries. Best of luck with the workouts, I think you'll find it worthwhile!

    Replies: @AP, @Yahya

    My wife and I also saw The Boy and the Heron by Miyazaki in the theater a couple weeks ago and enjoyed it quite a bit. I you like Studio Ghibli fare it was a worthy addition. It was nice to see it on the big screen for the sake of the artwork, which gets a bit of short shrift on my small screen.

    I also took the kids to see it, what a beautiful movie. They are older now (oldest is not even a kid anymore), we had once taken the older one to see Spirited Away in theater when the kid was little.

    My kids saw more Miyazaki and Soviet cartoons (one of the few things done mostly right under the Soviets, even Pope John Paul II approved of them) than they did Disney, of the latter we only let them see the older classic ones.

    https://www.theonion.com/cool-dad-raising-daughter-on-media-that-will-put-her-en-1819572981

    • Replies: @Barbarossa
    @AP

    I thought that The Boy and the Heron was very much in the fantastical tradition of Spirited Away but with a much richer character development. It really could have been at least a half hour longer to more fully explore facets of the story but I thought it did very well for what it covered in its' runtime.

    I wish we had taken all the kids to see the movie but we have some little ones and weren't sure about the PG13 rating. It would have been fine though. Ah well, we had a nice date just the two of us anyway!

    We are really picky about what the kids watch here too. We own a lot of Studio Ghibli but zero Disney. Some of the older Disney is okay but it's still doesn't come close. I really believe that kid's media can be just as high quality as adult media. If anything, it's even more critical since children are developing their moral and aesthetic imagination. I have a Russian friend that swears by Soviet cartoons but I haven't tried them myself. Do you have any favorites to recommend?

    That Onion spoof is funny! My nearly 16 year old is doubtless already hopelessly handicapped socially by her lack of phone! Just kidding, fortunately they all have other weird kids to hang out with.

    Replies: @AP

  217. @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. XYZ

    AP, what do you think is the cause of Eastern Europe's lack of elite science production relative to Western Europe?

    It's a similar story in regards to patents:

    https://jakubmarian.com/number-of-patent-applications-per-capita-by-region-in-europe/

    https://jakubmarian.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/nuts2-patents.jpg

    Seems like the most innovative place in the Eastern European part of the EU is Budapest. But I do suspect that there is a Communist legacy factor in holding Eastern Europe back at least a little bit. Estonia performs much, much worse than Finland does in spite of Estonians and Finns being genetically similar, after all. (Estonia might only be around 70% Estonian, but that's still a solid majority.)

    Replies: @AP

    Commie legacy plus brain drain (these are related).

    Poland is the only eastern European country other than Russia with a particle accelerator though:

    Countries with particle accelerators [1400 × 673]
    byu/thetvr inMapPorn

    • Thanks: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Yeah, that makes sense. I do wonder if Eastern Europe will see a brain gain in the coming decades if Western Europe, or large parts of it, will become ever-more dumpier, though. I could see Western Europeans who will dislike the crazy shit in their own countries relocating to better-off Eastern Europe in such a scenario, especially if the EU itself will still remain intact and even expand. But the prosperity in Eastern Europe would probably need to be comparable to that of Western Europe in such a scenario since a lot of the time, people make immigration decisions based on economic factors, at least in part.

    Interestingly enough, it appears that Eastern Europe's "human achievement" underperformance has deep roots:

    https://inquisitivebird.substack.com/p/the-rise-of-the-west?utm_source=profile&utm_medium=reader2

    https://inquisitivebird.substack.com/p/which-european-nations-are-overrepresented?utm_source=profile&utm_medium=reader2

    https://inquisitivebird.substack.com/p/notable-people-in-science-europe?utm_source=profile&utm_medium=reader2

    I mean centuries-old deep roots. I wonder what could explain it. Universities began popping up in Western Europe en masse before they did so in Eastern Europe, for instance. And this was back in the Middle Ages and/or Renaissance.

    Poland having a particle accelerator makes sense since it is the second-largest country in Eastern Europe by population, behind only Russia. It has already surpassed Ukraine by population and is in much better economic shape relative to Ukraine, which means that more money can be spent on scientific endeavors such as this. In contrast, Western Europe has many countries that have 40+ million people. Poland and Russia are unique in Eastern Europe in this regard, especially in light of Ukraine's depopulation.

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    What's interesting is that in spite of its own Communist legacy, the former East Germany performs way ahead in regards to patents relative to Eastern Europe. This makes me wonder if it's not just due to Communism, but also due to genes making Western Europeans more creative relative to Eastern Europeans. You're right, of course, that many creative Eastern Europeans end up moving further west.

    Replies: @QCIC

  218. @Beckow
    @German_reader

    I am not against trying it, I just think it is impossible to define - both sides claim that they are only aiming at military targets, that anything else is collateral damage (Nato invented the term), caused by defense missiles, or propaganda. Same is true in Gaza, and was true in the previous wars fought by Nato around the world.

    Saying that they will stop bombing civilians, when they deny doing it today, is impossible. The way to break the deadlock would have to be a very attractive offer by Kiev-Nato, e.g. they could admit the obvious and say that "Ukraine will not join Nato", or give some territorial concessions - they could offer to let people living in the "disputed" regions choose what they want: Ukraine, Russia, autonomy, or independence...

    Russia would have harder time rejecting it offhand. Once the talks start it would be difficult to restart the all-out war. It is the best option Kiev has left, or they can slowly bleed, destroy Ukraine, and end up with a worse deal.

    But I am skeptical that Russia would take the bite - after the Minsk fiasco. Being proud of lying in diplomacy never pays...

    Replies: @QCIC, @German_reader, @A123

    I am not against trying it, I just think it is impossible to define – both sides claim that they are only aiming at military targets, that anything else is collateral damage (Nato invented the term), caused by defense missiles, or propaganda. Same is true in Gaza, and was true in the previous wars fought by Nato around the world.

    I agree. The concept of inevitable Collateral Damage preceded NATO by centuries or millennia, even if they were first to coin that exact phrase.

    There is a huge amount of SJW squealing and bleating over Israeli tactics. Yet, those expressing faux outrage never condemn Hamas use of human shields. Nor do they provide any realistic alternative option for Palestinian Jews.

    I am skeptical that Russia would take the bite – after the Minsk fiasco. Being proud of lying in diplomacy never pays…

    I concur.

    Merkel ordered Zelensky to engage in bad faith on the Minsk deal. There is no sign that Scholz is any different. SJW squealing and bleating over Russian tactics falls on deaf ears. There cannot be anything resembling a pause as long as Kiev is run by Zelensky. He shares Abbas’s total absence of credibility and honesty.

    What Kiev needs most is new leadership. How can that happen after Zelensky nationalized non-state media, disbanded opposition parties, and suspended elections? Ukraine’s subservience to European Elites and absence of democracy are severe impediments to meaningful negotiations.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @A123

    Countries around the world view Zelensky with respect and he's good at cultivating support for Ukraine. He's a fiery leader intent in seeing his country through during these difficult and trying times. Most important, the people of Ukraine hold him in high esteem and trust in his leadership qualities. There's no reason now to change horses during this race. The constitution allows him to suspend elections during war time, so why wouldn't he do so during these dangerous and chaotic times? Of course you and Beckow are appeaseers by nature, so you don't want to see Zelensky's heroic qualities.
    It's Putler that needs to bow out now after 25 years of running the show in Russia, a dangerous man of deviant behavior only intent on seeing his own private megalomaniac fantasies prevail with no respect of human life.

    , @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    I ACCEPT YOUR SURRENDER
     
    You make that statement every time before you block someone.

    Why is that?

    How long is your blocklist now?

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

  219. @AP
    @Barbarossa


    My wife and I also saw The Boy and the Heron by Miyazaki in the theater a couple weeks ago and enjoyed it quite a bit. I you like Studio Ghibli fare it was a worthy addition. It was nice to see it on the big screen for the sake of the artwork, which gets a bit of short shrift on my small screen.
     
    I also took the kids to see it, what a beautiful movie. They are older now (oldest is not even a kid anymore), we had once taken the older one to see Spirited Away in theater when the kid was little.

    My kids saw more Miyazaki and Soviet cartoons (one of the few things done mostly right under the Soviets, even Pope John Paul II approved of them) than they did Disney, of the latter we only let them see the older classic ones.

    https://www.theonion.com/cool-dad-raising-daughter-on-media-that-will-put-her-en-1819572981

    Replies: @Barbarossa

    I thought that The Boy and the Heron was very much in the fantastical tradition of Spirited Away but with a much richer character development. It really could have been at least a half hour longer to more fully explore facets of the story but I thought it did very well for what it covered in its’ runtime.

    I wish we had taken all the kids to see the movie but we have some little ones and weren’t sure about the PG13 rating. It would have been fine though. Ah well, we had a nice date just the two of us anyway!

    We are really picky about what the kids watch here too. We own a lot of Studio Ghibli but zero Disney. Some of the older Disney is okay but it’s still doesn’t come close. I really believe that kid’s media can be just as high quality as adult media. If anything, it’s even more critical since children are developing their moral and aesthetic imagination. I have a Russian friend that swears by Soviet cartoons but I haven’t tried them myself. Do you have any favorites to recommend?

    That Onion spoof is funny! My nearly 16 year old is doubtless already hopelessly handicapped socially by her lack of phone! Just kidding, fortunately they all have other weird kids to hang out with.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Barbarossa


    I have a Russian friend that swears by Soviet cartoons but I haven’t tried them myself. Do you have any favorites to recommend?
     
    We used to have to get VHS tapes and a special VCR player that could play the European ones (Europe had a different system) but now it's so easy because it is all on Youtube.

    The most beautiful one is probably Hedgehog in a fog:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bFUi7inkAbs

    Generally there are a lot on Soyuzmultfilm.



    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_1i9oZR6Rns

    Soviet Winnie Pooh was very charming:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l3yhBEQlH_Y

    Spoof not to be seen with kids:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P7ddwBTxow0

    My kids liked this song when they were little:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tSq9jJwi7rM

    Ukrainian theme and folk music:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jQmBi7e8qjg

    Meanwhile Soviet Ukraine was making these Cossack cartoons:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R7hnykzUVxc

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TAGwhoMxXTg

    This is older:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BaF6oqHZ-GM&list=PLb7GduBVGH-lhgxbDZtbTqHQKN36pPiWk

    Others will pop up on youtube when you look at these. There are very many of them.

    Replies: @songbird, @Barbarossa

  220. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    Commie legacy plus brain drain (these are related).

    Poland is the only eastern European country other than Russia with a particle accelerator though:

    https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/4jy9s3/countries_with_particle_accelerators_1400_673/

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ

    Yeah, that makes sense. I do wonder if Eastern Europe will see a brain gain in the coming decades if Western Europe, or large parts of it, will become ever-more dumpier, though. I could see Western Europeans who will dislike the crazy shit in their own countries relocating to better-off Eastern Europe in such a scenario, especially if the EU itself will still remain intact and even expand. But the prosperity in Eastern Europe would probably need to be comparable to that of Western Europe in such a scenario since a lot of the time, people make immigration decisions based on economic factors, at least in part.

    Interestingly enough, it appears that Eastern Europe’s “human achievement” underperformance has deep roots:

    https://inquisitivebird.substack.com/p/the-rise-of-the-west?utm_source=profile&utm_medium=reader2

    https://inquisitivebird.substack.com/p/which-european-nations-are-overrepresented?utm_source=profile&utm_medium=reader2

    https://inquisitivebird.substack.com/p/notable-people-in-science-europe?utm_source=profile&utm_medium=reader2

    I mean centuries-old deep roots. I wonder what could explain it. Universities began popping up in Western Europe en masse before they did so in Eastern Europe, for instance. And this was back in the Middle Ages and/or Renaissance.

    Poland having a particle accelerator makes sense since it is the second-largest country in Eastern Europe by population, behind only Russia. It has already surpassed Ukraine by population and is in much better economic shape relative to Ukraine, which means that more money can be spent on scientific endeavors such as this. In contrast, Western Europe has many countries that have 40+ million people. Poland and Russia are unique in Eastern Europe in this regard, especially in light of Ukraine’s depopulation.

  221. @AP
    @Beckow


    Than what? Nobody cares about the Poles
     
    Your words:

    "The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere – in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia’s propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception"

    You mentioned V4, I pointed out that Poles outnumber all other people within V4 combined.


    I was not limiting it to V4: Austria, Slovenia, Croatia, Serbia
     
    Serbia? Why not Syria also? And North Korea?

    Croatia helps Ukraine also. It gave Ukraine all of its Mi-8 helicopters.

    https://mpu.gov.hr/news-25399/croatia-strongly-supports-ukraine-and-the-ukrainian-people/27313


    it would work like this: Anglos talk and ship “weapons” and the Poles die.
     
    Last time Russia fought Poland, Russia lost. Russia can barely hold Ukraine to a stalemate.

    You bark your inane “Habsburg” nonsense. Let me remind you that it was by far the worst in terms of human rights, freedom, oppression, number of people in prison for wrong views, under the Habsburg feudal monarchy that you so stupidly celebrate
     
    Thanks for demonstrating the poor educational standards of Slovakia. So ignorant, so parochial. Poles lived under Hapsburgs, Romanovs and Hohenzollerns. Hapsburg rule was by far the mildest of the three. Ukrainians lived under Hapburgs and Romanovs. Hapsburgs were milder.

    So let's compare executions.

    Russia:

    https://www.rbth.com/history/331226-death-penalty-russia

    1826-1905: 526 people executed
    1905-1910: 3,700 people executed

    Germany:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_Germany

    1907-1932: 393 people executed (could not find data for 19th century)

    Austria (not the Hungarian-ruled part of Austria-Hungary):

    https://www.jstor.org/stable/2276063?seq=2

    1852-1897: 175 people executed

    England and Wales:

    https://www.acrosswalls.org/datasets/executions-england-wales-from-1800/

    1852-1897: 622 people executed


    Only Nazis exceeded it [Austria-Hungary] in WW2
     
    Poor uneducated Beckow apparently hasn't heard even of Stalin's or Lenin's crimes.

    If you want to compare, it was the Poles who sided first with the Nazi Germany in Munich 1938
     
    This lie of yours has already been debunked multiple times, many many people, some of whom aren't posting here anymore.

    Poland refused multiple offers of alliance with the Nazis (and also refused alliances with the Bolsheviks). when Czechoslovakia was betrayed by its allies and gave up German-0ihabioted lands to Germany, Poland asked for and peacefully received Polish-inhabited territories, that the Czechs had previously seized by attacking Poland and killing its soldiers. It was not part of some Polish-German alliance (this was no Molotov-Ribbentrop), indeed Poland refused such.


    After 1945 there were 3 million Polish commies all the way till the end
     
    Poles fought Commies in 1920 (and defeated them, saving Europe from a Russian commie invasion), 1939, and 1945.

    Poland fought Nazis in 1939 rather than join them as Germany asked them to do and as Slovakia did. Thereby saving Europe from Nazi victory (Russians were defeated by Poles in 1921, you think the Soviets would have defeated a German-Polish alliance?). Maybe that's why you can't forgive Poles? Your people were eager Nazi allies. Slovakia even paid the Nazis money to kill Slovak Jews. Who else would do that?


    in 1968 Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia the Poles were the second largest army
     
    They were about 25,000 troops out of 450,000. "Second largest" lol. And it was a commie vs. commie conflict anyways. Afterward, Czechoslovaks were such sincere and loyal commies that Poles were shocked when they visited Czechoslovakia.

    Polish resistance to Commies in the 1980s brought down the Soviet system in Eastern Europe. This is probably why you, a Commie sympathizer, can't forgive Poles.

    And of course Poles resist the importation of non-European Africans and Muslims into Europe. You Slovaks and Hungarians would not be able to resist the pressure alone.

    So Poland alone has resisted each of the evils plaguing Europe in the last 100+ years.

    While your people eagerly joined the Nazis, and voted for the Commies.


    you are losing the war
     
    Russia's staggering losses and lack of gaining even villages (taking the slag head outside Avdiivka, some wooded strips, and central Marinka doesn't count for much) suggest that its winter offensive is failing, so far.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    Poland fought Nazis in 1939 rather than join them as Germany asked them to do and as Slovakia did. Thereby saving Europe from Nazi victory (Russians were defeated by Poles in 1921, you think the Soviets would have defeated a German-Polish alliance?). Maybe that’s why you can’t forgive Poles? Your people were eager Nazi allies. Slovakia even paid the Nazis money to kill Slovak Jews. Who else would do that?

    Seems like a Franco-Anglo-Polish-Soviet alliance back in 1939 would have been better than what actually happened, no? At worst, the same outcome as in 1945, but at a much lower cost. Or is having a US military presence in Europe so crucial? With a Franco-Anglo-Polish-Soviet alliance in 1939, the US likely won’t enter WWII at all but will nevertheless likely spend or loan a lot of its own money to help Europe rebuild after the end of the war, as it previously did after the end of WWI.

    While your people eagerly joined the Nazis, and voted for the Commies.

    IIRC, it was Czechs who voted for the Commies right after the end of WWII, not Slovaks:

    https://cs.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C4%8Ceskoslovensk%C3%A9_parlamentn%C3%AD_volby_1946

    Czechs were more pro-Commie in 1946 than Slovaks were, at least.

  222. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    Commie legacy plus brain drain (these are related).

    Poland is the only eastern European country other than Russia with a particle accelerator though:

    https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/4jy9s3/countries_with_particle_accelerators_1400_673/

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ

    What’s interesting is that in spite of its own Communist legacy, the former East Germany performs way ahead in regards to patents relative to Eastern Europe. This makes me wonder if it’s not just due to Communism, but also due to genes making Western Europeans more creative relative to Eastern Europeans. You’re right, of course, that many creative Eastern Europeans end up moving further west.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Mr. XYZ

    Patents in the modern world have as much to do with lawyers as with creativity. The number of patents may be a better metric for the number of start up companies than it is for actual innovation.

  223. @A123
    @Beckow


    I am not against trying it, I just think it is impossible to define – both sides claim that they are only aiming at military targets, that anything else is collateral damage (Nato invented the term), caused by defense missiles, or propaganda. Same is true in Gaza, and was true in the previous wars fought by Nato around the world.
     
    I agree. The concept of inevitable Collateral Damage preceded NATO by centuries or millennia, even if they were first to coin that exact phrase.

    There is a huge amount of SJW squealing and bleating over Israeli tactics. Yet, those expressing faux outrage never condemn Hamas use of human shields. Nor do they provide any realistic alternative option for Palestinian Jews.


    I am skeptical that Russia would take the bite – after the Minsk fiasco. Being proud of lying in diplomacy never pays…
     
    I concur.

    Merkel ordered Zelensky to engage in bad faith on the Minsk deal. There is no sign that Scholz is any different. SJW squealing and bleating over Russian tactics falls on deaf ears. There cannot be anything resembling a pause as long as Kiev is run by Zelensky. He shares Abbas's total absence of credibility and honesty.

    What Kiev needs most is new leadership. How can that happen after Zelensky nationalized non-state media, disbanded opposition parties, and suspended elections? Ukraine's subservience to European Elites and absence of democracy are severe impediments to meaningful negotiations.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Countries around the world view Zelensky with respect and he’s good at cultivating support for Ukraine. He’s a fiery leader intent in seeing his country through during these difficult and trying times. Most important, the people of Ukraine hold him in high esteem and trust in his leadership qualities. There’s no reason now to change horses during this race. The constitution allows him to suspend elections during war time, so why wouldn’t he do so during these dangerous and chaotic times? Of course you and Beckow are appeaseers by nature, so you don’t want to see Zelensky’s heroic qualities.
    It’s Putler that needs to bow out now after 25 years of running the show in Russia, a dangerous man of deviant behavior only intent on seeing his own private megalomaniac fantasies prevail with no respect of human life.

    • Agree: Mr. XYZ
    • LOL: Mikhail
  224. @Gerard1234
    @sudden death

    Peremoga! What is that, paying 40% more for gas + billions in infrastructure investment.........for "security" of about 25% of the original volume of gas received from Russia ( with some of that LNG coming from Russia anyway)! You couldn't invent this level of retardation.

    Black Russian retards have effectively killed Klaipeda dead as a port , by stopping receiving and delivering cargo to and from Belarus and Russia you imbecile. It appears to me more a pitiful sympathy gesture from the Germans - like offering 404 an EU "path to membership"

    Possibly it is part of the eternal rivalry between the Black Russian and Malo-Russian brothers!.....using the appearance of the opposite - stop Malo-Russia as a transit for gas to western Europe, and seize a small percentage of that amount delivered via BlackRussia-stan.

    Replies: @sudden death

    Before starting building own LNG import facility (state company “Klaipėdos nafta” was builder and operator for ten years since 2014), Lithuania was paying 550$ for 1000m3 of pipeline Gazprom natgas in 2010. Last year the average LNG spot price was hovering roughly around 350EUR, so accounting for inflation since, Lithuania is getting almost twice cheaper natgas now;)

    Regarding Germany, the average Gazprom natgas price in whole decade prior Covid was roughly around 330$ for 1000m3 IIRC. At the start of last summer there was publicised offer from US LNG industry representatives about being capable to supply longer term LNG deals for 380$ for 1000m3 for EU customers. So that was the starting negotiating point and even generously (for RF fans) assuming the price didn’t change at all when big deals were made after negotiations at the end of summer (e.g. BASF long term deal for US LNG), it was also roughly nearly the same price as Gazprom supplied natgas in previous decade for Germany, when accounting for inflation since.

    All “cargo to and from Belarus and Russia” essentially equaled one thing in Klaipeda – potash fertilizers from Belarus, just in relatively large quantities, roughly fluctuating about 10-12 million tonnes a year – 25% of all yearly load in Klaipeda. There was just one single port company (154 workers overall at the peak), partially owned by “Belaruskalij”, which was doing that job of loading fertilizers on the ships. Today this company has 45 workers, so it was grand total loss of 109 jobs in all port since 2022.

  225. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Yevardian


    Funny you mention that, the complete lack of interest in those two topics on this forum was quite striking to me as well.
     
    I am very interested in these topics. Are you?

    I read the manifesto. At least half. The varieties of alt-Russian politics were way over my head and I only skimmed those parts.

    Here is what stuck out to me:

    1. Sorrow that the fellow (I forget his name--Kolmogorov?--he is the fat guy who got drugged out and jumped to his death onto a Moscow street naked) died without a cryonics contract.

    1.a. It seems that Karlin's leader lights in this internet writing business (Anglo part) are:

    Hanania, Scott Alexander, Elizier Yudkowski.

    Yudkowski is PRO cryonics. Alexander used to be pro cryonics. In Alexander's reader surveys he had a cryonics question for years. He has deleted it and not mentioned why. I presume he is now ANTI but doesn't want to rock anybody's boat.

    1.b. So what exactly is the deal here?

    1.c. Personally I consider cryonics, as it exists, a complete waste of time and energy. But there is a fundamental question which is fascinating. What is life? It appears to me nobody has a good answer to this apart from faith and dogma.

    2. The turn towards impending AI Paperclips Doom and away from Russian Nationalism seems like a cop out. That is a point worth looking at. It is convenient for AK's self-esteem that he can put forth such an argument to trivialize losing his big bet on the Special Military Operation. If I was him I would be trying to figure out a way to pretend the latter never happened.

    3. I have more but I am skeptical that you would enjoy getting me started.

    Replies: @sudden death

    Kolmogorov?–he is the fat guy who got drugged out and jumped to his death onto a Moscow street naked

    He was called Egor Prosvirnin.

    I have more but I am skeptical that you would enjoy getting me started.

    You should continue on this, me previously missed the bit about gayparading countries ending all wars between them, so maybe something else entertaining will pop up too;)

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @sudden death

    His second most highest achievement is he was a first week adopter of the corona virus "vaccine". Hanania, who seems to be his leading living guide is a booster of the boosters and goes as far as to say injecting all these people with an experimental gene medicine is like the greatest feat of all humans in the 21st century.

    Have you ever heard of Dan Quayle? Before Kamela Harris he was the most dumbest American Vice President. There was an old Negro College Fund ad that television stations used to broadcast when they were required to allocate time for public service announcements and they said (every damn day)


    A mind is a terrible thing to waste.
     
    Dan Quayle was well known for inserting inappropriate mangled quotations. His best maybe was

    It is a terrible thing for a mind to be wasted.
     
    I don't know what the context was. It's not a good thing, what is now going on in Karlin's mind. : (

    Replies: @sudden death

  226. @Barbarossa
    @AP

    I thought that The Boy and the Heron was very much in the fantastical tradition of Spirited Away but with a much richer character development. It really could have been at least a half hour longer to more fully explore facets of the story but I thought it did very well for what it covered in its' runtime.

    I wish we had taken all the kids to see the movie but we have some little ones and weren't sure about the PG13 rating. It would have been fine though. Ah well, we had a nice date just the two of us anyway!

    We are really picky about what the kids watch here too. We own a lot of Studio Ghibli but zero Disney. Some of the older Disney is okay but it's still doesn't come close. I really believe that kid's media can be just as high quality as adult media. If anything, it's even more critical since children are developing their moral and aesthetic imagination. I have a Russian friend that swears by Soviet cartoons but I haven't tried them myself. Do you have any favorites to recommend?

    That Onion spoof is funny! My nearly 16 year old is doubtless already hopelessly handicapped socially by her lack of phone! Just kidding, fortunately they all have other weird kids to hang out with.

    Replies: @AP

    I have a Russian friend that swears by Soviet cartoons but I haven’t tried them myself. Do you have any favorites to recommend?

    We used to have to get VHS tapes and a special VCR player that could play the European ones (Europe had a different system) but now it’s so easy because it is all on Youtube.

    The most beautiful one is probably Hedgehog in a fog:

    Generally there are a lot on Soyuzmultfilm.

    [MORE]

    Soviet Winnie Pooh was very charming:

    Spoof not to be seen with kids:

    My kids liked this song when they were little:

    Ukrainian theme and folk music:

    Meanwhile Soviet Ukraine was making these Cossack cartoons:

    This is older:

    Others will pop up on youtube when you look at these. There are very many of them.

    • Thanks: Mr. Hack
    • Replies: @songbird
    @AP

    Doesn't the Snow Queen have a ripoff of Jiminy Cricket? A character I already don't like because it's too bizarre. Let's make a talking insect and then take away two of his limbs and give him human eyes. (BTW, crickets do bite)

    I only watched a few minutes of the movie once because I was interested in how it had been adapted to America. The other stuff I am unfamiliar with.

    , @Barbarossa
    @AP

    Thanks, those were good. The kids found the Cossacks particularly amusing. It was non-stop laughter the entire time!

    We haven't checked out the longer Snow Queen film yet but we'll give it a try some evening.

  227. @German_reader
    This made me think of some of Mr XYZ's comments here:

    https://nitter.net/Advo_Katy/status/1745792360313925648#m

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Obviously pedophiles should not be allowed to reproduce through surrogacy. Though there’s a chance that it might have helped matters had he had access to a realistic child sex doll/robot complete with AI programming that would allow it to have conversations with this pedophile. Right now, people with such inclinations are being legally punished even if they seek out completely harm-free outlets such as this for their sex drive.

  228. AP, would you say that the situation that Serbs and Russians experienced in the 1990s, post-Yugoslav and Soviet collapses, was similar to the situation that Germans and Hungarians (Magyars) experienced in the 1920s after the collapse of both the German and Austro-Hungarian Empires? As in, having a lot of their co-ethnics end up outside of their country’s borders, and ultimately waging revanchist wars in attempts to bring their co-ethnics back within their country’s borders.

    So, Hitler, Horthy, Milosevic, and Putin are all one of a kind, albeit with very different levels of brutality involved. Nationalist revanchists.

    • LOL: Mikhail
  229. Is anyone here an expert on Burma (Myanmar)? There’s currently a civil war going on there:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myanmar_civil_war_(2021%E2%80%93present)

    Any chance that the presence of various ethnic militias could cause Burma to break up in the long-run?

  230. @Barbarossa
    @Yahya

    Thanks Yahya, I'll cherry pick a few of these for my own viewing as I have the chance. I really do appreciate your reviews.

    I'm particularly interested in giving the The Grand Illusion a try.

    One of the best films I've seen in a bit is the 1950's version of A Christmas Carol with Alistair Sims. We always watched it at Christmas time when I was a kid and it's been a couple decades since I've seen it but I would have to say that it is an excellently fleshed out Christmas Carol. It's one of those films that is just nearly perfect in every way. The whole family loved it.

    My wife and I also saw The Boy and the Heron by Miyazaki in the theater a couple weeks ago and enjoyed it quite a bit. I you like Studio Ghibli fare it was a worthy addition. It was nice to see it on the big screen for the sake of the artwork, which gets a bit of short shrift on my small screen.

    I'm glad to hear that you are pushing your boundaries. Best of luck with the workouts, I think you'll find it worthwhile!

    Replies: @AP, @Yahya

    One of the best films I’ve seen in a bit is the 1950’s version of A Christmas Carol with Alistair Sims.

    Dickensian stories tend to translate well onto the big screen. One of my favorite films is the 1984 rendition of Christmas Carol starring George C. Scott as Scrooge. The main theme resonated with me since I share Scrooge’s cynical mode of thinking. I haven’t been totally expunged of the rationalistic worldview, but I do remember the film striking a chord and making me re-examine my outlook and behavior.

    I you like Studio Ghibli fare it was a worthy addition.

    I’ve never watched Japanese anime. I’ll give one a go soon to expand my horizons.

    [MORE]

    I’m glad to hear that you are pushing your boundaries. Best of luck with the workouts, I think you’ll find it worthwhile!

    I’ve been strength training for the past 4 months, and the impact has been nothing short of transformative. The positive effects spill over to other spheres of your life; it elevates your confidence, assertiveness and willpower. It is funny to look back at my previous attitude towards lifting weights as a vapid, time-wasting activity, aided by my impression that 85%+ of gym bros are shallow airheads.

    My outlook changed a full 180 degrees when I read Plato’s Republic, where in Chapter 4 he outlines the desirability of developing a harmonious balance of mental and physical qualities in future philosopher kings. Neglect of the former makes a person inelegant and brutish, and neglect of the latter makes you soft and timid. Only a combination of both can enable a person to reach a higher state of being.

    The previous 4 months have also changed my view of the nature vs nurture conundrum. While I still tend towards the hereditarian camp, I’ve since recalibrated upwards my appraisal of the environmental component in determining outcomes. It is quite possible for a person to change substantially if he is willing to step outside of his comfort zone and push the limits of what he hitherto thought was naturally capable. It only requires some gumption and a willingness to embrace fear and act despite of it, which I think most people are capable of.

    • Thanks: Mr. Hack
    • Replies: @AP
    @Yahya


    I’ve never watched Japanese anime. I’ll give one a go soon to expand my horizons.

     

    Princess Monanoke by Miyazaki would be a good start.

    Tell us what you think!

    Replies: @Yahya

    , @Barbarossa
    @Yahya


    the desirability of developing a harmonious balance of mental and physical qualities
     
    I'm a big believer in this as well. Being physically fit, competent and active directly effects mood, thought patterns and general confidence in life. Having a vigorous physical and mental life simultaneously form a self-reinforcing cycle of benefits. I'm glad that you are experiencing that for yourself. Plus, it's just really fun to be good at things physically. I get such a constant keen pleasure from just moving around the world with precision. I can't really imagine being deprived of that by obesity or lack of conditioning.

    Of course, as you observe, neglecting one or the other leads to incomplete humans (jocks or nerds). Either/or thinking in those regards is really self-defeating. I wonder why it is so common and stereotyped? People seem to tend to put themselves in the strangest boxes.

    In regards to nature versus nurture I definitely believe that people are born with many traits already present, but that whether those are a benefit or a detriment depend greatly on formation and conditioning. Something like stubbornness can be a superpower if utilized with restraint but can destroy a person if given free reign. I believe this is why parental influence on children is so important, parents have a huge responsibility to help each child with their individual strengths and weaknesses. And I firmly agree with you that people can change their trajectory but sadly it seems that many people are too complacent to do so. We are too often slaves to our conditioning, but we don't necessarily have to be.

    In reference to your Batman review, I do agree that Nolan's Batman is a generally good one but the best portrayals of Batman emphasize his intellect equally as his strength. Nolan definitely leaned into the physical power of the character and gave his character as detective short shrift. Batman was the only superhero I was really interested in as a kid so I had a pretty decent collection of Batman comics which generally threaded a fairer balance between Batman's physical power and intellectual brilliance. It ties into our discussion above pretty well. Maybe Plato would have nominated Batman for philosopher king? Well, maybe not, but entertaining to imagine.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  231. @Barbarossa
    @Sher Singh

    Do you like Indian snacks? I like stocking up at the Indian grocery when I'm up that way since they are way better than American snacks in terms of nutrition. They seem to have a great proportion of fat/ carbs/ fiber/ protein and a small handful is really filling. You can't scarf a whole bag like one can do with something like potato chips.

    Replies: @Sher Singh, @Mr. Hack

    Na, mostly just home-made.
    If you name some stuff I can tell you if I know it.

    Been munching on mashing sesame flour + jaggery for the winter.
    All the online bros say Indian snacks lack protein – what u been eating?

    • Replies: @Barbarossa
    @Sher Singh

    I'm sure homemade is better. I like keeping some snacks around at the jobsite and such and if I have something healthier on hand I won't be tempted to eat some total garbage.

    I would imagine that Indian snacks would be too low on protein if one is actually doing heavy duty training and I wouldn't call them a replacement for real food but for convenient casual snacking they are really reasonable.

    I've got some Navrattan mix by Haldiram's that has 12g fat, 14g carb w/4g fiber and 7g protein in a 1 cup serving. It's mostly chickpea, lentil, peanuts and such with oil salt and spices. Or Channa Dal which just split chickpeas fried with salt and chili powder.

    Like I said before it seems notable that the nutritional ratio seems to make it hard to mindlessly eat a ton of it. Partly because most have a decent amount of heat and spice. American snacks seemed engineered for mindless face stuffing.
    Not that this would be surprising looking around the general population.

    Replies: @Sher Singh

  232. @AP
    @Barbarossa


    I have a Russian friend that swears by Soviet cartoons but I haven’t tried them myself. Do you have any favorites to recommend?
     
    We used to have to get VHS tapes and a special VCR player that could play the European ones (Europe had a different system) but now it's so easy because it is all on Youtube.

    The most beautiful one is probably Hedgehog in a fog:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bFUi7inkAbs

    Generally there are a lot on Soyuzmultfilm.



    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_1i9oZR6Rns

    Soviet Winnie Pooh was very charming:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l3yhBEQlH_Y

    Spoof not to be seen with kids:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P7ddwBTxow0

    My kids liked this song when they were little:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tSq9jJwi7rM

    Ukrainian theme and folk music:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jQmBi7e8qjg

    Meanwhile Soviet Ukraine was making these Cossack cartoons:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R7hnykzUVxc

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TAGwhoMxXTg

    This is older:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BaF6oqHZ-GM&list=PLb7GduBVGH-lhgxbDZtbTqHQKN36pPiWk

    Others will pop up on youtube when you look at these. There are very many of them.

    Replies: @songbird, @Barbarossa

    Doesn’t the Snow Queen have a ripoff of Jiminy Cricket? A character I already don’t like because it’s too bizarre. Let’s make a talking insect and then take away two of his limbs and give him human eyes. (BTW, crickets do bite)

    I only watched a few minutes of the movie once because I was interested in how it had been adapted to America. The other stuff I am unfamiliar with.

  233. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    What's interesting is that in spite of its own Communist legacy, the former East Germany performs way ahead in regards to patents relative to Eastern Europe. This makes me wonder if it's not just due to Communism, but also due to genes making Western Europeans more creative relative to Eastern Europeans. You're right, of course, that many creative Eastern Europeans end up moving further west.

    Replies: @QCIC

    Patents in the modern world have as much to do with lawyers as with creativity. The number of patents may be a better metric for the number of start up companies than it is for actual innovation.

  234. @Mikhail
    Lavrov Schools Presstitute

    "You are much better than me at interrupting." The below is an excellent primer on dealing with hack journalists. Along with his Hungarian and Indian peers, Lavrov is among the best active diplomats. Honestly, which trio is more competent - Biden, Yellen and Blinken or Putin, Nabiullina and Lavrov?

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kXejR63hE_g

    Replies: @Mikhail

    Among the highlights, Lavrov compares the NATO proxy war against Russia with the Napoleonic and Nazi attempts to defeat Russia, which ended up with Russia becoming stronger. He added that Napoleon and the Nazis used numerous other Europeans in their failed endeavor.

    Lavrov’s comments regarding cancel culture, Russia-Ukraine and Israel-Palestine mesh with my commentary on these subjects.

  235. @Yahya
    @Barbarossa


    One of the best films I’ve seen in a bit is the 1950’s version of A Christmas Carol with Alistair Sims.
     
    Dickensian stories tend to translate well onto the big screen. One of my favorite films is the 1984 rendition of Christmas Carol starring George C. Scott as Scrooge. The main theme resonated with me since I share Scrooge’s cynical mode of thinking. I haven’t been totally expunged of the rationalistic worldview, but I do remember the film striking a chord and making me re-examine my outlook and behavior.

    I you like Studio Ghibli fare it was a worthy addition.
     
    I’ve never watched Japanese anime. I’ll give one a go soon to expand my horizons.


    I’m glad to hear that you are pushing your boundaries. Best of luck with the workouts, I think you’ll find it worthwhile!
     
    I’ve been strength training for the past 4 months, and the impact has been nothing short of transformative. The positive effects spill over to other spheres of your life; it elevates your confidence, assertiveness and willpower. It is funny to look back at my previous attitude towards lifting weights as a vapid, time-wasting activity, aided by my impression that 85%+ of gym bros are shallow airheads.

    My outlook changed a full 180 degrees when I read Plato’s Republic, where in Chapter 4 he outlines the desirability of developing a harmonious balance of mental and physical qualities in future philosopher kings. Neglect of the former makes a person inelegant and brutish, and neglect of the latter makes you soft and timid. Only a combination of both can enable a person to reach a higher state of being.

    The previous 4 months have also changed my view of the nature vs nurture conundrum. While I still tend towards the hereditarian camp, I’ve since recalibrated upwards my appraisal of the environmental component in determining outcomes. It is quite possible for a person to change substantially if he is willing to step outside of his comfort zone and push the limits of what he hitherto thought was naturally capable. It only requires some gumption and a willingness to embrace fear and act despite of it, which I think most people are capable of.

    Replies: @AP, @Barbarossa

    I’ve never watched Japanese anime. I’ll give one a go soon to expand my horizons.

    Princess Monanoke by Miyazaki would be a good start.

    Tell us what you think!

    • Replies: @Yahya
    @AP


    Princess Monanoke by Miyazaki would be a good start.
     
    I just watched 40 minutes of Princess Monanoke.

    It’s too catered to children, which is not to my taste.

    I much preferred Lord Of The Rings for adventure, which I felt was more adult-oriented.

    Replies: @A123, @Sher Singh, @A123

  236. @Sher Singh
    @Yahya

    I'm trying to cut without using macro factor atm.

    I find knowing you have X calories left encourages you to fill the bowl, so to speak.

    Instead, I make sure to get enough protein & then chill.

    With running too I just try to run after every session now - even if it's a few Km.

    --
    My ohp started climbing again since we last spoke.

    Saving that video though, thanks.

    https://bretcontreras.com/how-to-fix-glute-imbalances/

    No homo this fixed a 6 year old lifting injury I had literally days ago.

    I did iso contractions on weaker side & then during morning prayers after I think Good Mornings - my hip popped back into place.

    Took 3 days & yeah.
    --
    Still wearing Talwar everyday & involved in cases wherever they try to restrict it.

    Fateh with Maharaj Blessings.

    ਅਕਾਲ

    Replies: @Barbarossa, @Yahya

    I’m trying to cut without using macro factor atm. I find knowing you have X calories left encourages you to fill the bowl, so to speak. Instead, I make sure to get enough protein & then chill.

    I’m going to try this strategy if my current regime doesn’t work for another week.

    One issue I see is that if the calorie deficit is too high, it may lead to more muscle loss than a calculated 15-20% calorie deficit.

    ——

    What are your thoughts on body recomposition vs traditional bulking and cutting?

    • Replies: @Sher Singh
    @Yahya

    I think at least one big bulk is necessary on your journey but otherwise recomp is mostly OK.

    Think of it more like a BW & BF range though. Don't be afraid to get a bit fat, but don't be attached to a number on the scale.

    Objectively, the slow cut is better but diet fatigue is a thing.
    --

    Alpha Destiny does a big bulk every year just because he likes strength.

    I hit 20lb prs (10rm) on high pulls & pull downs yday but caught a left Erector strain from amraping the 4th Rdl set.
    ---
    Basically making noobs gains because of this app holy shit.

    Gonna take a deload week since it's week 7 & nurse this injury.

  237. The numbers are in: (1)

    Nielsen: President Trump Townhall on Fox News Nearly Doubles Viewership of CNN Debate Featuring Haley and DeSantis

    (Via The Hill) – Fox’s town hall with Trump averaged 4.3 million viewers from 9-10 p.m., according to early data from Nielsen Media Research, while the CNN debate featuring Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) and former United Nations Ambassador Nikki Haley averaged 2.5 million during the same hour.

    […] Wednesday night’s ratings returns are the latest signal that live events featuring Trump remain one of the largest drivers of audience for the nation’s cable news channels, all of which are facing major headwinds in the form of increased cord-cutting and changing media habits on the part of consumers.

    Not only were the ratings bad, Haley and DeSantis spent their time blasting each other.

    What are these two trying to prove? How much money they can spend without achieving anything? It is not helping their reputations or future prospects. Massive establishment entanglement has effectively wiped out DeSantis’s hope to be a MAGA leader at the national level.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/11/nielsen-president-trump-townhall-on-fox-news-nearly-doubles-viewership-of-cnn-debate-featuring-haley-and-desantis/

    • Replies: @Mikel
    @A123


    Massive establishment entanglement has effectively wiped out DeSantis’s hope to be a MAGA leader at the national level.
     
    You got that wrong, as usual. Massive Establishment media focus on Trump has solidified his position as the front runner, to the detriment of more solid MAGA candidates like DeSantis.

    And the Establishment is clearly with Nikki, who is getting all the big donor money while the MSM just can't hide how hopeful they are about her (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-67948573). I have no clue who the hell those ~4% of Christie's voters were but they're obviously all going to Nikki now. She is the clear Establishment GOP alternative to Trump and if they manage to make her be in second place when Trump is removed from the ballots, imprisoned, retired for poor health (he's obese and almost 80) or whatever, we have a perfect soft coup.

    I can't believe Trump can win in November anyway, no matter what the polls say. He's shown to have massive rejection levels, 3 times in a row after his 2016 victory. As someone said the other day on a conservative radio show, the Dems could nominate Jimmy Carter and more than half the country would vote for him rather than Trump.

    Replies: @A123

    , @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    You should remember the concept of “solidarity” doesn’t do justice to describing the outpouring of Arab and Muslim support for Palestine. The popular Arab saying “my blood is Palestinian” best conveys the visceral nature of this support which defines their very being and identity what it means to be a “real” Arab or Muslim.

    As a cause that is at once national, Islamic, and pan-Arab, there is no out-group offering “solidarity with” an in-group’s interests or values, which the concept suggests. Nor is it “solidarity among” a group of people sharing a commonality of interests or values because it transcends both.

    The amount of love and support shown by the Arab street and Ummah in general has been an eye opening experience.

    Replies: @A123

  238. @German_reader
    @Beckow


    Demanding a condition that amounts to a cease-fire is self-defeating – it gives Russia an easy way out since they have made it clear that they will not agree to a cease-fire.
     
    It's a demand for Russia to stop killing civilians and demolishing Ukrainian infrastructure through missile/drone strikes (leading to Ukraine retaliating in a similar manner like recently at Belgorod), doesn't seem to refer to fighting at the front. Maybe not totally realistic, but much more so than Zelensky's absurd ten-point plan.
    Anyway, I suspect it will come to nothing, because in the end the Americans are the only ones who matter, and Biden's administration will probably continue on the set course. But imo it's the kind of approach that should at least be tried.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    It’s a demand for Russia to stop killing civilians and demolishing Ukrainian infrastructure through missile/drone strikes (leading to Ukraine retaliating in a similar manner like recently at Belgorod)

    Wow, you disgusting, intellectually lazy (and dishonest) scumbag.

    1. Ukraine has been targeting Belgorod, Bryansk,Kursk and non-border regions throughout the war you idiot. So the “retaliating in a similar manner in Belgorod” is a dumb and fake equivalence

    2. Russia doesn’t kill civilians, Ukraine loves killing civilians

    3. Russia doesn’t target civilians, Belgorod war crime was deliberate targeting of civilians, with no military target in centre of Belgorod ( the city targeted repeatedly, but for whatever reason this time they got through). Strike at busy daytime, New Year shopping and entertainment being done

    4. Those particular Cluster munitions are what caused particular harm from this (unguided) launch……hence why majority of civilians killed were those on street or those in cars driving all spread over a long distance ( absolutely ZERO equivalence of this from Russian massive airstrikes you severe dumbfuck from 100’s of launches over 2 years) as what we target and when we use bomb/rocket/missile carrying cluster munitions on these targets is chosen for military, not PR reasons.

    5. not only did 404 target and repeatedly destroy electricity supply and water cuttoff to Donetsk, Lugansk for a long time, they initiated the whole infrastructure targeting from the scumbag tactic of using an (innocent) civilian vehicle to carry a bomb on the Crimean bridge and kill several other civilians. An absolute war crime, and pointless one as without targeting the central span (blocking shipping) or targeting the railbridge ( where most military equipment, that doesn’t even need to be transported that way, can be transported in bulk)……this lowlife action had zero military justification. Again, it was typical PR action by the Nazis, just like this Belgorod attack. Russia does zero PR military actions all targets are military or infrastructure to disrupt the military effort of the Ukronazis.

    6. If you had a brain you dumb POS, you would think why air defence systems for 404 are mostly embedded in cities/highly populated areas when Russia is firing these missiles from 100s, 1000km’away from the target . Again, you stupid prick, Russia doesn’t do this, even with Belgorod and its immediate distance to Kharkov.

    7. What is the purpose of a trashbag like you on here? You fake “balance” by saying one thing, and then contradict with the next thing. Particularly worse for a german to say this nonsense

    8. Stupid prick

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @Gerard1234


    Russia doesn’t kill civilians, Ukraine loves killing civilians
     
    Nah, you both don't have much compunction about killing civilians (nor about habitual lying). Very similar mentality. Not surprising too, you both stem from the same rotten tree after all.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Gerard1234

  239. @Gerard1234
    @German_reader


    It’s a demand for Russia to stop killing civilians and demolishing Ukrainian infrastructure through missile/drone strikes (leading to Ukraine retaliating in a similar manner like recently at Belgorod)
     
    Wow, you disgusting, intellectually lazy (and dishonest) scumbag.

    1. Ukraine has been targeting Belgorod, Bryansk,Kursk and non-border regions throughout the war you idiot. So the "retaliating in a similar manner in Belgorod" is a dumb and fake equivalence

    2. Russia doesn't kill civilians, Ukraine loves killing civilians

    3. Russia doesn't target civilians, Belgorod war crime was deliberate targeting of civilians, with no military target in centre of Belgorod ( the city targeted repeatedly, but for whatever reason this time they got through). Strike at busy daytime, New Year shopping and entertainment being done

    4. Those particular Cluster munitions are what caused particular harm from this (unguided) launch......hence why majority of civilians killed were those on street or those in cars driving all spread over a long distance ( absolutely ZERO equivalence of this from Russian massive airstrikes you severe dumbfuck from 100's of launches over 2 years) as what we target and when we use bomb/rocket/missile carrying cluster munitions on these targets is chosen for military, not PR reasons.

    5. not only did 404 target and repeatedly destroy electricity supply and water cuttoff to Donetsk, Lugansk for a long time, they initiated the whole infrastructure targeting from the scumbag tactic of using an (innocent) civilian vehicle to carry a bomb on the Crimean bridge and kill several other civilians. An absolute war crime, and pointless one as without targeting the central span (blocking shipping) or targeting the railbridge ( where most military equipment, that doesn't even need to be transported that way, can be transported in bulk)......this lowlife action had zero military justification. Again, it was typical PR action by the Nazis, just like this Belgorod attack. Russia does zero PR military actions all targets are military or infrastructure to disrupt the military effort of the Ukronazis.

    6. If you had a brain you dumb POS, you would think why air defence systems for 404 are mostly embedded in cities/highly populated areas when Russia is firing these missiles from 100s, 1000km'away from the target . Again, you stupid prick, Russia doesn't do this, even with Belgorod and its immediate distance to Kharkov.

    7. What is the purpose of a trashbag like you on here? You fake "balance" by saying one thing, and then contradict with the next thing. Particularly worse for a german to say this nonsense

    8. Stupid prick

    Replies: @German_reader

    Russia doesn’t kill civilians, Ukraine loves killing civilians

    Nah, you both don’t have much compunction about killing civilians (nor about habitual lying). Very similar mentality. Not surprising too, you both stem from the same rotten tree after all.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @German_reader

    And you guys, when you were rumbling through Eastern Europe went way out of your way to avoid civilian casualties? At least Ukrainians never had the distinct honor of building "work" and annihilation centers for civilians like Germany did in Auschwitz and Buchenwald or like the Russians did all over in Siberia (and closer to home too). :-(

    Replies: @German_reader

    , @Gerard1234
    @German_reader


    Nah, you both don’t have much compunction about killing civilians (nor about habitual lying). Very similar mentality. Not surprising too, you both stem from the same rotten tree after all.
     
    It just proves what a class act I am that I won't insult you for this particular comment. Why? Because although your comment is offensive and 100% disagree with it....its intellectually honest, so I have no problem . It's clear there is an eternal thought from German intellectuals that Slavs are untermensch compared to themselves. It's good to read from comments as yours that effectively you think Ukronazis and Russians are the same people - and probably why on some subconscious level think the insanely high levels of ukrainian deaths are "Russian deaths" anyway.

    When there is intellectually dishonest, repulsive filth like your garbage about the Belgorod war crime - then I correctly reply with insults.

    On the "don’t have much compunction about killing civilians ":

    1. Mariupol, Kramatorsk and other important places in 2014 were exited by LDNR heroes relatively peacefully and quickly to save and prioritise civilian lives, immediately when it became clear that Russia were not willing to commit enough resources or had the political will to take in this part of Donbass (i.e they were looking to do conciliatory gesture to help political settlement in allowing 404 these hugely economically important area.....even though more than enough men willing to go and fight and local support to continue fighting and annihilate the ukronazis in Slavyansk, Kramatorsk, anywhere). Remember dimwit, that all this with Slaviansk, Mariupol and others happened not too long before Banderastan were FORCED into 1st Minsk Agreements by LDNR smashing them and the potential for more of this.

    Western scum tactics and instructions for the Ukronazi plankton would ( as proved 8 years later) be the exact opposite


    2. Russia evacuates huge numbers of civilians from the frontline weeks before the start of the SMO (I think 80-120k at least). Ukronazis do ZERO evacuation in this time,while massively increasing their number of artillery strikes.

    3. Different to 404 and it's multiple waves of mobilisations and seizing of anybody off the street to then be cannon fodder..... we have done a partial one and every Russian is free to leave the country or return to it (important in the context of western historical lies and some truth about Soviet control of civilian border movement)

    4. Every single talk from the ukronazis of "repurposed" S-300 or S-200 missile strikes that have killed civilians.......are either ridiculous lies to cover for their air Defence mislaunches or outright false-flag attacks from the Nazi regime. There has been a very high number of these


    5.Kherson on wrong side of the Dnieper. We could easily defend and keep control of the city but it still remain an obviously dangerous situation for us and the civilians. Russia mass evacuates civilians and vacates Kherson. Again, compare to the exact opposite from ukronazi actions when evacuation is most sensible option.

    6.In 2022 SMO in Mariuopol, Ukronazi scum get smashed and destroyed embarrassingly easily as Russia secure key objective in SMO. These highly motivated and "elite" soldiers (LOL) then "resist" Russia.....by hiding underground the extensive tunnel network under the Azovstal plant, ocassionally coming out to "fight" by throwing a hand grenade into the air for social media video.....then return to the job of filming themselves dying from gangreme meme videos for social media!

    .......and these pussies are supposed to be the "heroes" of this freakshow.

    Our guys risked ( and sadly some of these heroes died) solely in the purpose of evacuating civilians from "agreed" safe routes out of the city , that of course the Banderites did not fullfil that agreement.

    Azov took nearly 2000 civilians with them underground, most not their families . So a white HAMAS situation for 404. I don't see how that isn't the exact same for 404 in Azovstal as with Hamas taking ( much less) Israeli hostages

    6. I already mentioned the use of a bomb on a civilian truck, killing more civilians for a pointless, evil but sick " PR stunt" on the Crimean bridge that the ukronazis did ( blatantly with the planning, assistance and order of Anglo-American scum).

    Clearly for myself evidence, logic, an IQ over 2, precedent,any knowledge of these people and how they think indicates that Ukronazis did all these crimes - Irpin/Bucha fakes, "rapes", Novaya Kakhovka Dam, several notable mass-murder of civilian events from MLRS fire - but let me be uneccesarily generous to you by saying it's an issue of faith for you as to giving responsibility to sifr for these crimes. We can all accept that if it's clear that ukronazi regime did the Novaya Kakhovka dam destruction, then all these other events mass killing civilians they are lying for every event.

    7. You aware of German , mass and sadistic crimes against civilians in WW2?

    Replies: @German_reader

  240. @Barbarossa
    @Sher Singh

    Do you like Indian snacks? I like stocking up at the Indian grocery when I'm up that way since they are way better than American snacks in terms of nutrition. They seem to have a great proportion of fat/ carbs/ fiber/ protein and a small handful is really filling. You can't scarf a whole bag like one can do with something like potato chips.

    Replies: @Sher Singh, @Mr. Hack

    What Indian snacks do you enjoy eating and would recommend? Here in Phoenix Land we have a great discount food store where I buy all sorts of treats at bargain basement prices. Recently, I was buying these great “Kind” and “Larabar” fruit and nut bars for $.10 a piece, even a few godiva chocolate bars for this ridiculously low price. I went there yesterday to repurchase some $.49 cans of cat food (my 3 feral cats scarf them down in no time), and was disappointed that the fruit bars (that had been on sale there for at least 2 months) were finally all gone. 🙁 I regularly buy all sorts of Starbucks coffees there between $3 – $6 per bag, the same ones that cost $7 – $11 per bag in the regular stores.

    On the upside, I did find some great 5 oz Terra Sweet Potato chips for $.99 a bag. Have you looked at the prices on potato chips in the regular grocery stores lately? $3 – $6 bucks a bag, highway robbery if you ask me, especially if you consider that you can still pick up a 5lb bag of great quality whole potatoes for only $3.

    • Replies: @Barbarossa
    @Mr. Hack

    We have a similar discount grocery place run by Amish around here. I've dubbed it the Amish Walmart. They buy overstock and nearly expired foodstuffs and sell them cheap. There is a lot of junk food but also some great deals. I stocked up on walnuts halves for $2 a lb. a while back.

    You don't have to tell me about the price of food these days. Feeding 7 in the household gets expensive even with raising our own meat. It's definitely our biggest single expense, though I don't have car payments or student loans so maybe that's not saying much.

    , @songbird
    @Mr. Hack

    Have you never made your own potato chips?

    It was quite common in my grandmother's day (as was making your own bread and donuts) Not quite sure how they did it. From what I can find, looks like a lot of effort. TBH, I would probably much prefer baked slices of potatoes or roasted potatoes.

    Only one of those discount food stores I recall ever seeing is a Pepperidge Farm one with their goldfish crackers, which seems remarkably niche. AFAIK, they went out of business like 20 years ago.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  241. @AP
    @Yahya


    I’ve never watched Japanese anime. I’ll give one a go soon to expand my horizons.

     

    Princess Monanoke by Miyazaki would be a good start.

    Tell us what you think!

    Replies: @Yahya

    Princess Monanoke by Miyazaki would be a good start.

    I just watched 40 minutes of Princess Monanoke.

    It’s too catered to children, which is not to my taste.

    I much preferred Lord Of The Rings for adventure, which I felt was more adult-oriented.

    • Replies: @A123
    @Yahya

    For adult anime series it is hard to beat Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex.

    https://ghostintheshell.fandom.com/wiki/Ghost_in_the_Shell:_Stand_Alone_Complex

    Cowboy Bebop is another winner. I enjoyed Samurai Champloo, but it may not be to everyone's taste.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    , @Sher Singh
    @Yahya

    Kingdom.
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingdom_(manga)

    , @A123
    @Yahya

    An obscure anime option is Blue Gender.


    In the early 21st century, the emergence of an incurable condition known as B-cell growth led some of the affected to become "Sleepers" - people put under stasis until a cure could be found. Yuji Kaido is one such Sleeper who awakens, several decades later, to a horrifying new reality. Giant bugs known as Blue have invaded the Earth, eating everything - and everyone - in sight. Now, all Yuji can do is escape from the city with the ones who saved him from his inevitable death, and make their way towards Second Earth: mankind's new home in space.
     
    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GODiRrT_CZ8&list=PLBf3yvoRhbKFoy2-qNsvn5k68ousu2tnt&index=1

    The YT rip will probably be taken down as a copyright strike. However, you can sample it, then buy if you want a proper quality version.

    PEACE 😇
  242. @German_reader
    @Gerard1234


    Russia doesn’t kill civilians, Ukraine loves killing civilians
     
    Nah, you both don't have much compunction about killing civilians (nor about habitual lying). Very similar mentality. Not surprising too, you both stem from the same rotten tree after all.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Gerard1234

    And you guys, when you were rumbling through Eastern Europe went way out of your way to avoid civilian casualties? At least Ukrainians never had the distinct honor of building “work” and annihilation centers for civilians like Germany did in Auschwitz and Buchenwald or like the Russians did all over in Siberia (and closer to home too). 🙁

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @Mr. Hack


    At least Ukrainians never had the distinct honor of building “work” and annihilation centers for civilians
     
    No, but Western Ukrainians (some of them) at least proved quite adept and enthusiastic at mass killings too.
    Anyway, I don't really care about this kind of discussion.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  243. @German_reader
    @Beckow


    I just think it is impossible to define
     
    It would mean Russia doesn't attack targets in Ukrainian cities away from the front line, imo that's not hard to define at all.

    Being proud of lying in diplomacy never pays…
     
    Russia has done plenty of lying too. Back in 2014/15 their official position was that they hadn't sent regular troops into Ukraine, didn't shell Ukrainian positions from across the border etc. which was just ridiculous. In February 2022 they also claimed there was no intent of invading Ukraine until right before the invasion actually happened. So it's not like the reasons for distrust are concentrated solely on the Western side (and despite my general loathing for her, I still don't believe Merkel's actions regarding the Minsk agreements were an intentional deception on her part).
    But anyway, not much point to discussing all of this anymore, and I'm getting pretty tired of it. With luck, there'll be a big Mideast war soon. At this point even Greasy William's nutty Messiah posting looks preferable to this endless Ukraine circle jerk.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Greasy William

    …It would mean Russia doesn’t attack targets in Ukrainian cities away from the front line

    Excluding cities would create a safe zone to store weapons and shoot from. Some cities are on the front line, would they be a legitimate target?

    Russia has done plenty of lying too.

    Sure, they spin tales to media like all governments. But not about actual treaties – Russia has been legalistic about observing what they sign.

    It is possible Merkel was a secondary player not in on the Minsk deception. It would be worse: subservience and lack of control with an after-the-fact urge to please. Do you want a leader like that? Even a nominal leader needs dignity…

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    Even a nominal leader needs dignity…
     
    That claim is anachronistic. Very few European “leaders” have any dignity. Most are either stuffed shirts (e.g., Scholz, Macron, Sunak) or clinical idiots (e.g., Baerbock, von der Leyen).

    Replies: @LT1488

    , @German_reader
    @Beckow


    It would be worse: subservience and lack of control with an after-the-fact urge to please. Do you want a leader like that?
     
    Of course, as our A123 has established I'm Merkel's biggest fan after all.

    But on a serious note, of course Germany is totally subservient in foreign policy, that has become more obvious than ever over the last two years. To some extent that may even be unavoidable. The extent of total identification with a militant Westernism among much of the "elite" is pretty creepy though (e.g. darkly funny how that midwit Habeck is defending Israel, also lots of militancy on Russia). Can't really explain it myself, it was never that bad even in the old federal republic.

    Replies: @Beckow, @A123

  244. @Mr. Hack
    @German_reader

    And you guys, when you were rumbling through Eastern Europe went way out of your way to avoid civilian casualties? At least Ukrainians never had the distinct honor of building "work" and annihilation centers for civilians like Germany did in Auschwitz and Buchenwald or like the Russians did all over in Siberia (and closer to home too). :-(

    Replies: @German_reader

    At least Ukrainians never had the distinct honor of building “work” and annihilation centers for civilians

    No, but Western Ukrainians (some of them) at least proved quite adept and enthusiastic at mass killings too.
    Anyway, I don’t really care about this kind of discussion.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @German_reader

    Well, then don't bring it up!

  245. @Yahya
    @AP


    Princess Monanoke by Miyazaki would be a good start.
     
    I just watched 40 minutes of Princess Monanoke.

    It’s too catered to children, which is not to my taste.

    I much preferred Lord Of The Rings for adventure, which I felt was more adult-oriented.

    Replies: @A123, @Sher Singh, @A123

    For adult anime series it is hard to beat Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex.

    https://ghostintheshell.fandom.com/wiki/Ghost_in_the_Shell:_Stand_Alone_Complex

    Cowboy Bebop is another winner. I enjoyed Samurai Champloo, but it may not be to everyone’s taste.

    PEACE 😇

    • Agree: Sher Singh
    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    https://www.unz.com/akarlin/open-thread-225/#comment-6097641

    Have you still got Mr. Hack blocked if so why?

    Please explain.


    https://youtu.be/NKxf7B2owV8?si=9rGd4jxFHQpK4au8

  246. @AP
    @Beckow


    I am proudly Euro-centric, made out of Europe, I won’t apologize. You will not find more European geography than the remote valleys and rolling hills north of the middle Danube…it is almost comically Euro. My priority is to preserve the good life here
     
    These are forces that sought to destroy it, in the last 100 years:

    Nazism
    Communism
    Mass non-European emigration
    Putin (he is working on Ukraine, Baltics probably next if Ukraine falls, but he supports gangsters further West also)

    You personally support two of those.

    Your country has supported/supports three of the four.

    We were good in the east or central-east\: steadily growing, normal, living safer and more comfortable lives
     
    You were too small to be self-sufficient. You could hope to be ignored for awhile, but it wouldn't last forever.

    The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere – in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia’s propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception
     
    Poles are the largest of the Visegrad countries, with the largest economy. There are more Poles than there are Slovaks, Hungarians, and Czechs combined, with about 10 million more Poles to spare. As such, Poles cannot be considered an exception. Considering Poles an "exception" among Visegrad is about as stupid as saying "Britain, with the exception of the English."

    And Czechs don't like Russians, either. It is only the non-Slavic Hungarians and their traditional lackeys, the Slovaks, who are the exceptional ones.

    I will note that of the 4 phenomena that tried to destroy Europe that I previously described, Poland alone of the Visegrad countries opposed all 4. Czechs and Slovaks supported Commies, Hungarians and Slovaks supported Nazis and support Putin, Poland was correct every time. And has suffered for it.

    who they really hate are the Ukies and Orthodox, but they can’t voice it now
     
    You are ignorant as usual. The small group of ex-colonists have their issues but most Poles like Ukrainians, particularly those who don't speak Russian. There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

    EU is just an Anglo-French-Germany combo – with US managing it, the two Western groupings combined. They also grabbed everything in the vicinity (including Poland). But when they tried to go further east and grab Ukraine, Belarus, Caucasus, the remaining Euro power, Russia, blocked it
     
    Biden chooses to slowly grind down the Russians using Ukrainians to do so. "Blocking" is an American, not Russian decision. Russia helpfully goes along and gets itself slowly demilitarized. Ukrainians have no choice - Russian rule is worse than fighting, so they fight. If America chose to flood Ukraine with better weapons, this would be over.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. XYZ, @Derer, @A123, @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    I will note that of the 4 phenomena that tried to destroy Europe that I previously described, Poland alone of the Visegrad countries opposed all 4.

    Nazism
    Communism
    Mass non-European emigration
    Putin (he is working on Ukraine, Baltics probably next if Ukraine falls, but he supports gangsters further West also)

    LMFAO, you dumbf**k fantasist

    1. Poles were Hitlers best alllies you stupid idiot. Poles were the Japanese best allies on the planet you stupid idiot. Poland was ideologically identical to Nazi Germany – even more fascist and just as anti-semitic.

    The 1939 disagreement with the Nazi’s and Poles was because Polish Nazis ( Poles) were even more imperialistic than the Nazis. They were hungry for far-more land than what even the Nazis were wanting.

    2. LOL a Poland-Czechoslovakia-France pact would have prevented WW2 immediately.

    3. Communism was not “evil” and did not try to destroy Europe you worthless scumbag. It of course cannot be compared to Nazism in attempt to destroy Europe.

    4. Poles, LMAO, took Communism up the a$$ for 50 years without attempting to resist it you POS

    5. Poland does not “resist mass non-European” migration. If it had to decide between being part of western institutions/receive FDI etc or “resisting mass non-European migration” ……..then it would choose being part of western institutions and the prostitute of other countries , as it has been for half a millennium. Its a pointless statement – for the average German, Scandinavian or Brit- the Pole is of course much closer to the African in their estimation than they are to themselves…….and they have allowed millions of Poles to migrate to their countries for cheap labour. So Poles are not “resisting” but as is typical for them, being hypocrites, parasites and pussies.

    6. Difficult to underscale the level of bimbo stupidity in “Putin trying to destroy Europe”, or “Poles resisting” comments. Putin has of course been looking to work with Europe …… that Europe and Pindostan have decided to go against the worlds biggest commodities supplier, important on many different issues…..for a failed, fake, poorest-country in Europe, shithole, whore-infected white 3rd world, nuthouse country, that manufactures nothing – is something they have to live with and is indirectly getting most of them voted out of power

    Poles are the largest of the Visegrad countries, with the largest economy. There are more Poles than there are Slovaks, Hungarians, and Czechs combined, with about 10 million more Poles to spare. As such, Poles cannot be considered an exception. Considering Poles an “exception” among Visegrad is about as stupid as saying “Britain, with the exception of the English.”

    That piece of retardation from yourself is like comparing Bangladeshis to Japanese in world importance despite their equalish size populations. In reality Slovaks/Czechs and Hungarians each have equal , well alot MORE prominence and prestige around the world now and historically , despite there much smaller populations and size than Poland. This is of course because Poland has been a blackhole in contribution to anything in Europe for its entire existence. The scientific, cultural contribution of those 3 countries is gigantic compared to Polands non-existant one. Slovaks/Czechs and Hungarians have real economy and stable populations……not ones artificially inflated by misleading and misdirected FDI and cheap labour from ukrops.

    The rest of your nonsense is even more bimbo-drivel

    You are ignorant as usual. The small group of ex-colonists have their issues but most Poles like Ukrainians, particularly those who don’t speak Russian. There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

    You have never been to Poland, Russia or Ukraine and, as proven many times, can’t speak a word of any of their languages. You have of course just done some more instantaneous BS there. Beckow, different to you has knowledge of this area and these people and speaks with credibility . Poles fighting there because they are illiterate anti-Russians, not because of “loving Ukrainians”, history has proven these 2 sets of dickheads can’t live together for 2 seconds. Russians and “Ukrainians” lived together for 300 years.

    • Replies: @China Japan and Korea Bromance of Three Kingdoms
    @Gerard1234


    Poles were Hitlers best alllies you stupid idiot. Poles were the Japanese best allies on the planet you stupid idiot.
     
    Poland-Japan alliance was for the main purpose of countering Soviets.

    Hitler was de facto ally with Chiang too, up until 1937, significantly for the purpose of countering Soviets as well. I don't think you would use that point to condemn China. Soviet infiltration was spreading everywhere at that period, i.e. Mongolian Revolution, CCP

    , @AP
    @Gerard1234


    You have never been to Poland, Russia or Ukraine and, as proven many times, can’t speak a word of any of their languages.
     
    All of this is untrue and you know it, you are trolling (probably to get me to say something that can get me doxed),, but in case someone else is reading this exchange, I did meet up with our former host, on one of my trips to Moscow:

    https://www.unz.com/akarlin/open-thread-40/

    https://i.imgur.com/aCRBRFv.png

    And I regularly posted photos of my travels.

    Look how quiet and undeveloped parts of central Moscow still were in the early 2000s. Looks like a provincial village but it's right off one of the boulevards:



    https://i.imgur.com/d4Frhiw.jpg

    https://i.imgur.com/LsyGyAx.jpg

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  247. @German_reader
    @Mr. Hack


    At least Ukrainians never had the distinct honor of building “work” and annihilation centers for civilians
     
    No, but Western Ukrainians (some of them) at least proved quite adept and enthusiastic at mass killings too.
    Anyway, I don't really care about this kind of discussion.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    Well, then don’t bring it up!

  248. @Beckow
    @German_reader


    ...It would mean Russia doesn’t attack targets in Ukrainian cities away from the front line
     
    Excluding cities would create a safe zone to store weapons and shoot from. Some cities are on the front line, would they be a legitimate target?

    Russia has done plenty of lying too.
     
    Sure, they spin tales to media like all governments. But not about actual treaties - Russia has been legalistic about observing what they sign.

    It is possible Merkel was a secondary player not in on the Minsk deception. It would be worse: subservience and lack of control with an after-the-fact urge to please. Do you want a leader like that? Even a nominal leader needs dignity...

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @German_reader

    Even a nominal leader needs dignity…

    That claim is anachronistic. Very few European “leaders” have any dignity. Most are either stuffed shirts (e.g., Scholz, Macron, Sunak) or clinical idiots (e.g., Baerbock, von der Leyen).

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @AnonfromTN

    Sunak isn't even European though.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

  249. German_reader says:
    @Beckow
    @German_reader


    ...It would mean Russia doesn’t attack targets in Ukrainian cities away from the front line
     
    Excluding cities would create a safe zone to store weapons and shoot from. Some cities are on the front line, would they be a legitimate target?

    Russia has done plenty of lying too.
     
    Sure, they spin tales to media like all governments. But not about actual treaties - Russia has been legalistic about observing what they sign.

    It is possible Merkel was a secondary player not in on the Minsk deception. It would be worse: subservience and lack of control with an after-the-fact urge to please. Do you want a leader like that? Even a nominal leader needs dignity...

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @German_reader

    It would be worse: subservience and lack of control with an after-the-fact urge to please. Do you want a leader like that?

    Of course, as our A123 has established I’m Merkel’s biggest fan after all.

    But on a serious note, of course Germany is totally subservient in foreign policy, that has become more obvious than ever over the last two years. To some extent that may even be unavoidable. The extent of total identification with a militant Westernism among much of the “elite” is pretty creepy though (e.g. darkly funny how that midwit Habeck is defending Israel, also lots of militancy on Russia). Can’t really explain it myself, it was never that bad even in the old federal republic.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @German_reader

    When the stakes get higher bosses demand full obedience...:) It has been getting worse if you look back at Euro leaders in 5-year intervals: the more independent ones are gradually removed and each new group is more subservient. The homo-couple that was just promoted to run the government in France would have been unthinkable a few years back. Or the Indian guy in UK.

    The restraints are gone, they don't care what it looks like. It could be desperation, stupidity, or they have us by the balls so fully that it doesn't matter. Or - a positive spin - they can't trust anyone else...

    , @A123
    @German_reader


    A123 has established I’m Merkel’s biggest fan after all.
     
    Some time ago, you attached the term "precious" to Trump in a malicious attempt to be inflammatory. Hence, I saddled you with "Your Precious Merkel" as an exact parallel. As you had been better behaved, I have comparably backed down in response.

    Why are you intentionally trying to restart a fight that is effectively over?
    ___

    On a serious note -- You may not be Merkel's biggest fan, but you have repeatedly gone out of your way to cover up & shift blame away from her misconduct. For example:

    Merkel's "Welcome Rape-ugee" policy was the leading voice for the Muslim invasion of European Christendom in the last decade. You certainly cannot blame America during Trump's 1st Term. Under Scholz, German flagged NGO vessels continue to transport combat aged male Muslims to Europe. IIRC, the German government even subsidies this activity.

    Who are the most responsible leaders, if not Merkel/Scholz?


    But on a serious note, of course Germany is totally subservient in foreign policy, that has become more obvious than ever over the last two years.
     
    Subservient to who?

    It has been clear for the last three years that Not-The-President Biden and his illegitimate administration have neither credibility nor influence. The subservient U.S. has been on the side lines handing out cash, while other nations form policy. It is incredibly obvious that every national leader ignores the current White House regime, including Scholz.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @German_reader

  250. @QCIC
    @Beckow

    NATO is an anti-Russia military alliance. NATO’s main purpose in Ukraine is to apply military pressure against Russia. Russia has stated that removing NATO from Ukraine is one of the core requirements for the SMO. This eradication is not simply a military project, it also involves intrigue, diplomacy and post-SMO government. How can this removal be accomplished?

    For NATO countries, the cost in lives and money for the Ukrainian project generally seems small, with the exception of German economic trauma. This low cost gives NATO little incentive to end the project. On the other hand, the project has definitively failed by making Russia stronger both militarily and economically. Worse yet, Russian citizens are more unified behind the government compared to when this started. Will the NATO leaders and Neocons realize the net result of their efforts are terrible? History suggests these people will not figure this out. They might continue the project even if Ukraine capitulates. If NATO leaves Ukraine tomorrow, the planners may even consider the project a partial success along the lines of "'Tis better to have meddled and failed than never to have meddled at all." (with profuse apologies to Tennyson).

    I wonder if Russia and Ukraine can be free of NATO entanglements unless a new Ukrainian leadership gives NATO a serious public rebuke? To be meaningful and influential, this rebuke probably has to include war crimes trials of NATO personnel and their Ukrainian collaborators.

    Replies: @Beckow

    Tis better to have meddled and failed than never to have meddled at all.

    Nothing ventured, nothing gained…:) Of course it is a “partial success” for the authors, they will be fine. It is a lot of fun and money: they fly around, gorge on buffets, talk “very important” stuff – the greatest dream for neo-con dorks and loser exiles. They don’t want it to end, they are not risking anything.

    I agree the Western eastward push is semi-permanent, it goes on a hiatus and then it inevitably restarts. The players also don’t change: the bloodied border-landers, Poles, Ukies, Balts, Belarussians are always in the mix.

    Nato’s push is the latest initiative. We know how the previous ones ended. The best we can hope for is for the active part to stop: Nato packs the crazy plans and pulls back. Then the West can go back to the teasing business-culture soft attack that works better on the Russians. That will also need a 10-20 year break.

    It is hard to tell how far will Russia go – clearly Nato is playing for a draw and wants to protect some positions and be better prepared next time. Russia may not allow that – or they could. The global sh.t mother-of-all-wars that seems to be starting could make this meaningless.

  251. @sudden death
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    Kolmogorov?–he is the fat guy who got drugged out and jumped to his death onto a Moscow street naked
     
    He was called Egor Prosvirnin.

    I have more but I am skeptical that you would enjoy getting me started.
     
    You should continue on this, me previously missed the bit about gayparading countries ending all wars between them, so maybe something else entertaining will pop up too;)

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    His second most highest achievement is he was a first week adopter of the corona virus “vaccine”. Hanania, who seems to be his leading living guide is a booster of the boosters and goes as far as to say injecting all these people with an experimental gene medicine is like the greatest feat of all humans in the 21st century.

    Have you ever heard of Dan Quayle? Before Kamela Harris he was the most dumbest American Vice President. There was an old Negro College Fund ad that television stations used to broadcast when they were required to allocate time for public service announcements and they said (every damn day)

    A mind is a terrible thing to waste.

    Dan Quayle was well known for inserting inappropriate mangled quotations. His best maybe was

    It is a terrible thing for a mind to be wasted.

    I don’t know what the context was. It’s not a good thing, what is now going on in Karlin’s mind. : (

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    Dan Quayle
     
    These days he looks like he could go straight into Hollywood main role in case if they decide to make new biopic about FDR;)

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/74/National_Veterans_Day_Observance_2019_%2849051656176%29.jpg
  252. @German_reader
    @Beckow


    It would be worse: subservience and lack of control with an after-the-fact urge to please. Do you want a leader like that?
     
    Of course, as our A123 has established I'm Merkel's biggest fan after all.

    But on a serious note, of course Germany is totally subservient in foreign policy, that has become more obvious than ever over the last two years. To some extent that may even be unavoidable. The extent of total identification with a militant Westernism among much of the "elite" is pretty creepy though (e.g. darkly funny how that midwit Habeck is defending Israel, also lots of militancy on Russia). Can't really explain it myself, it was never that bad even in the old federal republic.

    Replies: @Beckow, @A123

    When the stakes get higher bosses demand full obedience…:) It has been getting worse if you look back at Euro leaders in 5-year intervals: the more independent ones are gradually removed and each new group is more subservient. The homo-couple that was just promoted to run the government in France would have been unthinkable a few years back. Or the Indian guy in UK.

    The restraints are gone, they don’t care what it looks like. It could be desperation, stupidity, or they have us by the balls so fully that it doesn’t matter. Or – a positive spin – they can’t trust anyone else…

  253. @AP
    @Mikel


    Exactly as I said, no sooner you learn Ukraine has killed this man
     
    Evidence that Ukraine "killed this man?"

    Are you doing it again?

    he was most likely tortured
     
    Again, any evidence of that?

    killed through negligence after spending months in a filthy prison with improper medical care
     
    He was in a normal prison. It was probably bad by Western standards, but why should he have special treatment?

    for something he said.
     
    He allegedly broke the law. Germany and France imprison people for denying the Holocaust, so don't pretend that American-style free speech is universal among Western democracies.

    https://apnews.com/article/europe-crime-berlin-the-holocaust-15972809c1bf40f8eb8d2935d04c3b2d

    "A Berlin court has sentenced a 93-year-old German woman to 12 months in prison for denying that Jews were systematically murdered during the Holocaust."

    Gonzalo Lira moved to a foreign country, broke its laws by spreading and creating propaganda in support of the country that was invading the very country he had moved to and was killing its people. This is IMO worse than Holocaust denial but each country has its own laws.

    Not even woke, pro-Ukraine Youtube found objection to the posts that cost him his life.
     
    He took poor care of his health and chose to move to a foreign country and to break it's laws. He was even released to be in his apartment pending trial (such leniency! and casts doubt on the claim that he had been tortured) but chose to break the law again by fleeing, and was stupid enough to brag about it before he managed to cross the border, leading to his re-arrest.

    In one of his last tweets he correctly predicted that he would die if arrested, btw
     
    He also supposedly predicted he would die of heart problems a couple of years ago.

    Your moral standards are very repugnant.
     
    I'm not the one "conveniently" adopting positions that benefit the side that invades another country and kills 10,000s of its people and 100,000s of soldiers.

    And you slipped - you wrote that this Chilean-American psychopath's death was further down the slide from the killing of thousands of civilians in Donbas. This suggests that you think the life of Gonzalo Lira is > the lives of thousands of Donbassers.

    Replies: @Mikel, @LondonBob

    Gonzalo Lira moved to a foreign country, broke its laws by spreading and creating propaganda

    Lira broke Ukrainian law in the same way that Navalny broke Russian law. By posting stuff on YT that the authorities didn’t like. Or in the same way that I guess I have myself repeatedly broken Ukrainian “law”: posting opinions in English-language media that would also land me in jail if the goons of the regime you support could lay his hands on me. In fact, Ukraine must be about the only country in the world that keeps lists of foreign citizens (mostly actors and other non-entities who at some point dared to say something Ukie nationalists didn’t like) as “enemies of Ukraine”.

    The bottom line is that both Russia and Ukraine are corrupt countries where Communism was succeeded in short order by oligarch rule (as you would expect from closely related societies), full of criminal people with power, private armies and very little respect for human life. Lira’s latest video before being arrested listed a number of people who, like he predicted would happen to him, were killed by the Kiev scum.

    Some idiots in Europe (as full of crap as the American neocon nation-builders in Muslim lands) found it their duty to go to the rescue of the poor oppressed Ukrainians when some people in Kiev started jumping up and down to demand being accepted in the EU. Ukrainians had finally seen the light and and now would become exemplary citizens of the EU paradise they think they’ve built, abandoning their decades-long habits of fostering corruption at all levels of their society. As it happened, even to prove how different they were from the Russians they couldn’t help bombing their own cities and killing thousands of their co-citizens. That’s how attached to the so-called “EU values” they are. And the more they continued to receive support from all these idiots on both sides of the Atlantic, the more encouraged they felt to carry on, until their cousins to the North decided to unleash their own chimpout.

    You can also jump up and down all you want and try to explain to us how ordinary it is in any European country for American bloggers to die in prison after being arrested for expressing opinions critical of the countries where they live. But regardless of all your dialectical efforts, you’re not going to change one iota about any of the facts above. And those cold, hard facts are the ones that are going to continue determining the developments in the country of your ancestors.

    • Disagree: Mikhail
    • Replies: @AP
    @Mikel


    Lira broke Ukrainian law in the same way that Navalny broke Russian law
     
    Wrong as usual.

    He broke Ukrainian law in the same way that the 93 year old German lady broke German law and was arrested for it: by publicly saying things that were illegal to say in the country he was in. In her case, it was denying the Holocaust. In his case, it was making pro-Russian propaganda.

    Navalny was accused of corruption and was in a power conflict with the authorities, wanting to topple the government. In Ukraine governments get replaced through elections when pro-Westerners are in charge. Poroshenko lost his presidency that way, through a free election. That hasn't been possible in Russia. This equivalence you make between the two countries is rather stupid, sorry.

    Or in the same way that I guess I have myself repeatedly broken Ukrainian “law”:
     
    You are not in Ukraine.

    You must not know much about Europe, if you assume that Europe has America's 1st amendment. European countries often jail people for saying things deemed illegal to say.

    https://www.newstarget.com/2023-08-24-c-j-hopkins-sentenced-german-speech-case.html

    American playwright and humorist C.J. Hopkins, profiled in this space on numerous occasions, has been sent a “punishment order” by a German judge, offering him a Sophie’s Choice of 60 days in jail or 3,600 euros.

    His crime? Essentially, insulting the German health minister in a tweet, and using a scarcely-visible image of a Swastika on a mask in a book critical of the global pandemic response, The Rise of the New Normal Reich.

    Historian David Irving was sentenced to 3 years in prison on Austria for denying the Holocaust:

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2006/feb/20/austria.thefarright

    In fact, Ukraine must be about the only country in the world that keeps lists of foreign citizens (mostly actors and other non-entities who at some point dared to say something Ukie nationalists didn’t like) as “enemies of Ukraine”.
     
    The list has no official status:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myrotvorets

    You think CIA etc. have no unofficial lists?

    I suppose it being public is a novelty.

    The bottom line is that both Russia and Ukraine are corrupt countries
     
    Sure.

    full of criminal people with power, private armies and very little respect for human life.
     
    "Full of?"

    I don't remember running into private armies on my visits to Ukraine. Or Russia, for that matter.

    Do you also think that American flyover country is "full of" private militias? I never encountered them when I was there, either. Criminal people with power is also rather meaningless. What would you call Trump, Biden, Bush, Cheney, etc.?

    Lira’s latest video before being arrested listed a number of people who, like he predicted would happen to him, were killed by the Kiev scum
     
    And you believe him.

    I asked for evidence that Lira was "killed."

    You like to make claims without evidence. What do you think such claims can be called?

    Some idiots in Europe (as full of crap as the American neocon nation-builders in Muslim lands) found it their duty to go to the rescue of the poor oppressed Ukrainians
     
    Yes, you find it terrible to defend a nation in Europe that is being invaded. People wanting to do so are "idiots." By wanting Kiev to be left to its own devices when facing the Russian invaders, you have far more blood on your mind than any Kiev official from 2014 onward. Your desired inaction by the West would result in Mariupol or Grozny repeated in Kiev, Kharkiv, etc. What a bloodthristy person you are. But you are sneaky about it, like those so-called peace activists in 1939.

    As it happened, even to prove how different they were from the Russians they couldn’t help bombing their own cities and killing thousands of their co-citizens. That’s how attached to the so-called “EU values”
     
    Not a single European nation has been faced with the circumstances that Ukraine faced in Donbas, so this is an irrelevant criticism.

    For example, what would Spain had done if the Catalan activists had taken over their towns and started killing Spanish police officers, Spanish patriots, and Spanish soldiers while launching further armed incursions in order to grab more territory and declare it free of Spain? Retreat and give it all up?

    the more they continued to receive support from all these idiots on both sides of the Atlantic, the more encouraged they felt to carry on
     
    Violence in Donbas petered out, and did not accelerate as you imply above.

    You can also jump up and down all you want and try to explain to us how ordinary it is in any European country for American bloggers to die in prison
     
    He died because he did not take care of his health.

    He was in prison the second time because after he was released from house arrest he chose to skip bail and flee the country, and was stupid enough to post publicly about doing so, leading to his rearrests. I suspect that some Ukrainian officials hoped he would slip away (why release this guy with a foreign passport) but his taunting forced their hand, proving that releasing him was a mistake.

    I guess in your moral corruption you don't believe that laws should be followed.

    This reminds me of the guy who died in New York custody after he was arrested for illegally selling cigarettes'. The police supposedly "killed" him too. You have the logic of the BLM activists, congratulations.

    Replies: @Mikel

    , @Mikhail
    @Mikel

    Navalny and Gershkovich had court dates where the accusations and evidence were clearly stated. Lira's situation wasn't as transparent and more questionable. Navalny cheated Yves Rocher (in addition to disrespecting the judge, which doesn't help a defendant in any court and being involved in demos that didn't get zoning approval) and Gershkovich was reporting beyond the previously stated acceptable means on military security matter.

    Lira had a YouTube show featuring critical commentary on the Kiev regime. This video deals with Lira's situation:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2X7JmoXenw0&t=3740s

    Replies: @Derer, @Mikel

  254. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mikel

    The RT story is interesting. They wrote the American embassy wouldn't do anything for the American because Victoria Nuland "hated him personally".

    His episode on what a psycho Nuland is was great. He aired out all this stuff about her daddy, who went into a psych hospital when she was 13, received a bunch of electric shock treatments, and was never again the same. He was successful alpha monkey at the time he got depressed. Nuland became a hateful piece of work at a young age.

    Also he said she was pretty hot back then which I think surpasses the limits of credibility. Such things are pretty subjective though.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mikel

    The RT story is interesting.

    The fact that you need to go to rt.com to find something out about an American blogger dead in Ukrainian custody for an opinion crime because the Western MSM will not touch the subject with a ten foot pole highlights all the sordid, hidden aspects of this war and why we should have never got involved. In fact, it pretty much says all you need to know to form yourself a sound opinion on the whole matter.

  255. @German_reader
    @Beckow


    It would be worse: subservience and lack of control with an after-the-fact urge to please. Do you want a leader like that?
     
    Of course, as our A123 has established I'm Merkel's biggest fan after all.

    But on a serious note, of course Germany is totally subservient in foreign policy, that has become more obvious than ever over the last two years. To some extent that may even be unavoidable. The extent of total identification with a militant Westernism among much of the "elite" is pretty creepy though (e.g. darkly funny how that midwit Habeck is defending Israel, also lots of militancy on Russia). Can't really explain it myself, it was never that bad even in the old federal republic.

    Replies: @Beckow, @A123

    A123 has established I’m Merkel’s biggest fan after all.

    Some time ago, you attached the term “precious” to Trump in a malicious attempt to be inflammatory. Hence, I saddled you with “Your Precious Merkel” as an exact parallel. As you had been better behaved, I have comparably backed down in response.

    Why are you intentionally trying to restart a fight that is effectively over?
    ___

    On a serious note — You may not be Merkel’s biggest fan, but you have repeatedly gone out of your way to cover up & shift blame away from her misconduct. For example:

    Merkel’s “Welcome Rape-ugee” policy was the leading voice for the Muslim invasion of European Christendom in the last decade. You certainly cannot blame America during Trump’s 1st Term. Under Scholz, German flagged NGO vessels continue to transport combat aged male Muslims to Europe. IIRC, the German government even subsidies this activity.

    Who are the most responsible leaders, if not Merkel/Scholz?

    But on a serious note, of course Germany is totally subservient in foreign policy, that has become more obvious than ever over the last two years.

    Subservient to who?

    It has been clear for the last three years that Not-The-President Biden and his illegitimate administration have neither credibility nor influence. The subservient U.S. has been on the side lines handing out cash, while other nations form policy. It is incredibly obvious that every national leader ignores the current White House regime, including Scholz.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @A123


    Merkel’s “Welcome Rape-ugee” policy was the leading voice for the Muslim invasion of European Christendom in the last decade. You certainly cannot blame America during Trump’s 1st Term. Under Scholz, German flagged NGO vessels continue to transport combat aged male Muslims to Europe. IIRC, the German government even subsidies this activity.
     
    Sure, a lot of that is true, the German establishment wants this mass immigration to happen, it's their policy. However, US foreign policy isn't blameless either. In Syria the US contributed a lot to de-stabilizing the country in its attempt to overthrow Assad's regime, and is also systematically blocking re-construction efforts through its extreme sanctions regime. Of course there are other factors too (like the role of Turkey, the Gulf states, Iran and Russia), but I don't think it's unfair to believe that the US is partially responsible for all those hundreds of thousands of Syrians in Germany (who are continually reinforced by new arrivals).

    Subservient to who?
     
    Maybe those giant slug-like monsters lurking in the deep sea who destroyed the Nordstream pipelines? Like in a H. P. Lovecraft story.

    Replies: @Beckow, @A123

  256. German_reader says:
    @A123
    @German_reader


    A123 has established I’m Merkel’s biggest fan after all.
     
    Some time ago, you attached the term "precious" to Trump in a malicious attempt to be inflammatory. Hence, I saddled you with "Your Precious Merkel" as an exact parallel. As you had been better behaved, I have comparably backed down in response.

    Why are you intentionally trying to restart a fight that is effectively over?
    ___

    On a serious note -- You may not be Merkel's biggest fan, but you have repeatedly gone out of your way to cover up & shift blame away from her misconduct. For example:

    Merkel's "Welcome Rape-ugee" policy was the leading voice for the Muslim invasion of European Christendom in the last decade. You certainly cannot blame America during Trump's 1st Term. Under Scholz, German flagged NGO vessels continue to transport combat aged male Muslims to Europe. IIRC, the German government even subsidies this activity.

    Who are the most responsible leaders, if not Merkel/Scholz?


    But on a serious note, of course Germany is totally subservient in foreign policy, that has become more obvious than ever over the last two years.
     
    Subservient to who?

    It has been clear for the last three years that Not-The-President Biden and his illegitimate administration have neither credibility nor influence. The subservient U.S. has been on the side lines handing out cash, while other nations form policy. It is incredibly obvious that every national leader ignores the current White House regime, including Scholz.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @German_reader

    Merkel’s “Welcome Rape-ugee” policy was the leading voice for the Muslim invasion of European Christendom in the last decade. You certainly cannot blame America during Trump’s 1st Term. Under Scholz, German flagged NGO vessels continue to transport combat aged male Muslims to Europe. IIRC, the German government even subsidies this activity.

    Sure, a lot of that is true, the German establishment wants this mass immigration to happen, it’s their policy. However, US foreign policy isn’t blameless either. In Syria the US contributed a lot to de-stabilizing the country in its attempt to overthrow Assad’s regime, and is also systematically blocking re-construction efforts through its extreme sanctions regime. Of course there are other factors too (like the role of Turkey, the Gulf states, Iran and Russia), but I don’t think it’s unfair to believe that the US is partially responsible for all those hundreds of thousands of Syrians in Germany (who are continually reinforced by new arrivals).

    Subservient to who?

    Maybe those giant slug-like monsters lurking in the deep sea who destroyed the Nordstream pipelines? Like in a H. P. Lovecraft story.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @German_reader


    US is partially responsible for all those hundreds of thousands of Syrians in Germany
     
    How many were actually Syrians? It happened in 2015, before Trump. My sense at that time was that Obama&Co. were pressuring Germany. It looked like it was ordered and Merkel complied. When you say 'We can handle it' that suggests the "it" was a directive from someone else.

    the German establishment wants this mass immigration to happen,
     
    Not sure that's true. It is more that they want to stay in the 'establishment', it may not be their own preference. Not all are Welcome-culture crazies.

    I am often accused of a cynical view of the human nature - but the dynamic in certain situations dictate our responses. It is hard and often impossible to have free will. There is no "free will" in nature, and gods also presumably don't have free will. Humans are theoretically unique, but most of the time our ability to act freely recedes into the background. Merkel did what the situation required - that includes the reality that these decisions are made above her. (She is still a failure.)

    , @A123
    @German_reader


    US foreign policy isn’t blameless either. In Syria the US contributed a lot to de-stabilizing the country in its attempt to overthrow Assad’s regime, and is also systematically blocking re-construction efforts through its extreme sanctions regime. Of course there are other factors too (like the role of Turkey, the Gulf states, Iran and Russia)
     
    Certainly the Obama/Erdogan team up pushed regime change. However Trump walked the U.S. away from that unworkable idea.

    The ongoing presence of Turkey and Iran are the larger current issues. The small remaining U.S. presence plus IDF air strikes are all about Iran. A logical deal would be for Russia to stay as guarantor of the peace while Iran (including Hezbollah and other proxies), Turkey, and the U.S. all leave. This would largely free up Syria from sanctions and other impediments to reconstruction. However, there is so little trust among the parties, the concept is difficult to execute.


    unfair to believe that the US is partially responsible for all those hundreds of thousands of Syrians in Germany (who are continually reinforced by new arrivals).
     
    Would it not make more sense to blame German leadership for letting them in, paying benefits, and supporting "family reunification"? One cannot absolve Obama of incompetence, but Germany could have kept them out. Merkel laid out the welcome mat.

    We are facing something similar here in America. Trump's 1st Term Stay in Mexico policy was imperfect, but a good start. Then, Not-The-President Biden cancelled the program. Placing partial blame on the European WEF would make sense, but I doubt it would be productive. Keeping focus on our current regime avoids distraction.




    Germany is totally subservient in foreign policy,
     
    Subservient to who?
     
    Maybe those giant slug-like monsters lurking in the deep sea who destroyed the Nordstream pipelines? Like in a H. P. Lovecraft story.
     
    Given the length of time to investigate and still total absence of physical evidence, operator error is the mostly likely explanation for an industrial accident.

    If it was intentionally attacked, the primary (really only) possibilities remain Poland and/or Ukraine. Both of them would have kept the White House uninformed and out of the loop. I doubt that you are claiming that Berlin is subservient to Warsaw. Or, are you? Do you believe Tusk is a Lovecraftian monster destined to be Scholz master?

    PEACE 😇

     
    https://i.pinimg.com/736x/80/f6/bf/80f6bf74dddf3caca84896e88300c0ab.jpg

    Replies: @German_reader

  257. @German_reader
    @A123


    Merkel’s “Welcome Rape-ugee” policy was the leading voice for the Muslim invasion of European Christendom in the last decade. You certainly cannot blame America during Trump’s 1st Term. Under Scholz, German flagged NGO vessels continue to transport combat aged male Muslims to Europe. IIRC, the German government even subsidies this activity.
     
    Sure, a lot of that is true, the German establishment wants this mass immigration to happen, it's their policy. However, US foreign policy isn't blameless either. In Syria the US contributed a lot to de-stabilizing the country in its attempt to overthrow Assad's regime, and is also systematically blocking re-construction efforts through its extreme sanctions regime. Of course there are other factors too (like the role of Turkey, the Gulf states, Iran and Russia), but I don't think it's unfair to believe that the US is partially responsible for all those hundreds of thousands of Syrians in Germany (who are continually reinforced by new arrivals).

    Subservient to who?
     
    Maybe those giant slug-like monsters lurking in the deep sea who destroyed the Nordstream pipelines? Like in a H. P. Lovecraft story.

    Replies: @Beckow, @A123

    US is partially responsible for all those hundreds of thousands of Syrians in Germany

    How many were actually Syrians? It happened in 2015, before Trump. My sense at that time was that Obama&Co. were pressuring Germany. It looked like it was ordered and Merkel complied. When you say ‘We can handle it‘ that suggests the “it” was a directive from someone else.

    the German establishment wants this mass immigration to happen,

    Not sure that’s true. It is more that they want to stay in the ‘establishment’, it may not be their own preference. Not all are Welcome-culture crazies.

    I am often accused of a cynical view of the human nature – but the dynamic in certain situations dictate our responses. It is hard and often impossible to have free will. There is no “free will” in nature, and gods also presumably don’t have free will. Humans are theoretically unique, but most of the time our ability to act freely recedes into the background. Merkel did what the situation required – that includes the reality that these decisions are made above her. (She is still a failure.)

  258. @German_reader
    @A123


    Merkel’s “Welcome Rape-ugee” policy was the leading voice for the Muslim invasion of European Christendom in the last decade. You certainly cannot blame America during Trump’s 1st Term. Under Scholz, German flagged NGO vessels continue to transport combat aged male Muslims to Europe. IIRC, the German government even subsidies this activity.
     
    Sure, a lot of that is true, the German establishment wants this mass immigration to happen, it's their policy. However, US foreign policy isn't blameless either. In Syria the US contributed a lot to de-stabilizing the country in its attempt to overthrow Assad's regime, and is also systematically blocking re-construction efforts through its extreme sanctions regime. Of course there are other factors too (like the role of Turkey, the Gulf states, Iran and Russia), but I don't think it's unfair to believe that the US is partially responsible for all those hundreds of thousands of Syrians in Germany (who are continually reinforced by new arrivals).

    Subservient to who?
     
    Maybe those giant slug-like monsters lurking in the deep sea who destroyed the Nordstream pipelines? Like in a H. P. Lovecraft story.

    Replies: @Beckow, @A123

    US foreign policy isn’t blameless either. In Syria the US contributed a lot to de-stabilizing the country in its attempt to overthrow Assad’s regime, and is also systematically blocking re-construction efforts through its extreme sanctions regime. Of course there are other factors too (like the role of Turkey, the Gulf states, Iran and Russia)

    Certainly the Obama/Erdogan team up pushed regime change. However Trump walked the U.S. away from that unworkable idea.

    The ongoing presence of Turkey and Iran are the larger current issues. The small remaining U.S. presence plus IDF air strikes are all about Iran. A logical deal would be for Russia to stay as guarantor of the peace while Iran (including Hezbollah and other proxies), Turkey, and the U.S. all leave. This would largely free up Syria from sanctions and other impediments to reconstruction. However, there is so little trust among the parties, the concept is difficult to execute.

    unfair to believe that the US is partially responsible for all those hundreds of thousands of Syrians in Germany (who are continually reinforced by new arrivals).

    Would it not make more sense to blame German leadership for letting them in, paying benefits, and supporting “family reunification”? One cannot absolve Obama of incompetence, but Germany could have kept them out. Merkel laid out the welcome mat.

    We are facing something similar here in America. Trump’s 1st Term Stay in Mexico policy was imperfect, but a good start. Then, Not-The-President Biden cancelled the program. Placing partial blame on the European WEF would make sense, but I doubt it would be productive. Keeping focus on our current regime avoids distraction.

    Germany is totally subservient in foreign policy,

    Subservient to who?

    Maybe those giant slug-like monsters lurking in the deep sea who destroyed the Nordstream pipelines? Like in a H. P. Lovecraft story.

    Given the length of time to investigate and still total absence of physical evidence, operator error is the mostly likely explanation for an industrial accident.

    If it was intentionally attacked, the primary (really only) possibilities remain Poland and/or Ukraine. Both of them would have kept the White House uninformed and out of the loop. I doubt that you are claiming that Berlin is subservient to Warsaw. Or, are you? Do you believe Tusk is a Lovecraftian monster destined to be Scholz master?

    PEACE 😇

     

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @A123


    A logical deal would be for Russia to stay as guarantor of the peace while Iran (including Hezbollah and other proxies), Turkey, and the U.S. all leave. This would largely free up Syria from sanctions and other impediments to reconstruction. However, there is so little trust among the parties, the concept us difficult to execute.
     
    Something like that might indeed be a good solution for Syria. However, I still think the US sanctions policy is criminally misguided. Even from your pov, since arguably it increases Assad's dependence on Iran (which otherwise he might not be too happy about).

    Would it not make more sense to blame German leadership for letting them in
     
    Sure, the primary responsibility is theirs, I haven't denied that. In any case, there would be strong migratory pressures even if US foreign policy were different.

    Given the length of time to investigate and still total absence of physical evidence, operator error is the mostly likely explanation for an industrial accident.
     
    There is more than enough evidence and there's absolutely no doubt it was sabotage. I have no idea why you're so wedded to this nonsensical accident theory.
    Ukraine is indeed the logical culprit, but I'm still not convinced they could have pulled it off on their own.

    Replies: @A123

  259. German_reader says:
    @A123
    @German_reader


    US foreign policy isn’t blameless either. In Syria the US contributed a lot to de-stabilizing the country in its attempt to overthrow Assad’s regime, and is also systematically blocking re-construction efforts through its extreme sanctions regime. Of course there are other factors too (like the role of Turkey, the Gulf states, Iran and Russia)
     
    Certainly the Obama/Erdogan team up pushed regime change. However Trump walked the U.S. away from that unworkable idea.

    The ongoing presence of Turkey and Iran are the larger current issues. The small remaining U.S. presence plus IDF air strikes are all about Iran. A logical deal would be for Russia to stay as guarantor of the peace while Iran (including Hezbollah and other proxies), Turkey, and the U.S. all leave. This would largely free up Syria from sanctions and other impediments to reconstruction. However, there is so little trust among the parties, the concept is difficult to execute.


    unfair to believe that the US is partially responsible for all those hundreds of thousands of Syrians in Germany (who are continually reinforced by new arrivals).
     
    Would it not make more sense to blame German leadership for letting them in, paying benefits, and supporting "family reunification"? One cannot absolve Obama of incompetence, but Germany could have kept them out. Merkel laid out the welcome mat.

    We are facing something similar here in America. Trump's 1st Term Stay in Mexico policy was imperfect, but a good start. Then, Not-The-President Biden cancelled the program. Placing partial blame on the European WEF would make sense, but I doubt it would be productive. Keeping focus on our current regime avoids distraction.




    Germany is totally subservient in foreign policy,
     
    Subservient to who?
     
    Maybe those giant slug-like monsters lurking in the deep sea who destroyed the Nordstream pipelines? Like in a H. P. Lovecraft story.
     
    Given the length of time to investigate and still total absence of physical evidence, operator error is the mostly likely explanation for an industrial accident.

    If it was intentionally attacked, the primary (really only) possibilities remain Poland and/or Ukraine. Both of them would have kept the White House uninformed and out of the loop. I doubt that you are claiming that Berlin is subservient to Warsaw. Or, are you? Do you believe Tusk is a Lovecraftian monster destined to be Scholz master?

    PEACE 😇

     
    https://i.pinimg.com/736x/80/f6/bf/80f6bf74dddf3caca84896e88300c0ab.jpg

    Replies: @German_reader

    A logical deal would be for Russia to stay as guarantor of the peace while Iran (including Hezbollah and other proxies), Turkey, and the U.S. all leave. This would largely free up Syria from sanctions and other impediments to reconstruction. However, there is so little trust among the parties, the concept us difficult to execute.

    Something like that might indeed be a good solution for Syria. However, I still think the US sanctions policy is criminally misguided. Even from your pov, since arguably it increases Assad’s dependence on Iran (which otherwise he might not be too happy about).

    Would it not make more sense to blame German leadership for letting them in

    Sure, the primary responsibility is theirs, I haven’t denied that. In any case, there would be strong migratory pressures even if US foreign policy were different.

    Given the length of time to investigate and still total absence of physical evidence, operator error is the mostly likely explanation for an industrial accident.

    There is more than enough evidence and there’s absolutely no doubt it was sabotage. I have no idea why you’re so wedded to this nonsensical accident theory.
    Ukraine is indeed the logical culprit, but I’m still not convinced they could have pulled it off on their own.

    • Replies: @A123
    @German_reader



    Given the length of time to investigate and still total absence of physical evidence, operator error is the mostly likely explanation for an industrial accident.

     

    There is more than enough evidence and there’s absolutely no doubt it was sabotage. I have no idea why you’re so wedded to this nonsensical accident theory.
     
    There is no direct evidence, and the circumstantial is both flimsy and suspect.

    Let us recall the event pattern :
        • 17 hour time span
        • 50 miles of physical separation
        • Only 3 of 4 tubes ruptured

    This is 100% consistent with an industrial accident. And, it is remarkably unlike the pattern one would expect from an organized attack.

    I have worked in heavy industry. I thus intuitively grasp that a mistakes can last hours, potentially days before the consequences kick in. Gigantic systems have massive inertia and thus response lag.

    Those with no field experience immediately make a nonsensical jump that things going bang must be intentional. It simply is not so. Lack of relevant personal knowledge has led many astray.

    Ukraine is indeed the logical culprit, but I’m still not convinced they could have pulled it off on their own.
     
    If you insist on ignoring the likely industrial accident, Ukraine and Poland are your only suspects.

    The current White House regime leaks information faster than a sieve sheds water. You can be 100% certain that they would have been kept out of any loop. It would have been the only way to maintain operational security.

    PEACE 😇
  260. @Yahya
    @AP


    Princess Monanoke by Miyazaki would be a good start.
     
    I just watched 40 minutes of Princess Monanoke.

    It’s too catered to children, which is not to my taste.

    I much preferred Lord Of The Rings for adventure, which I felt was more adult-oriented.

    Replies: @A123, @Sher Singh, @A123

  261. Sher Singh says:
    @Yahya
    @Sher Singh


    I’m trying to cut without using macro factor atm. I find knowing you have X calories left encourages you to fill the bowl, so to speak. Instead, I make sure to get enough protein & then chill.
     
    I’m going to try this strategy if my current regime doesn’t work for another week.

    One issue I see is that if the calorie deficit is too high, it may lead to more muscle loss than a calculated 15-20% calorie deficit.


    http://i.ibb.co/StCGqJt/0843-D46-C-E6-C3-43-D1-A15-E-E0203-F4-C8-F0-F.jpg


    ——

    What are your thoughts on body recomposition vs traditional bulking and cutting?

    Replies: @Sher Singh

    I think at least one big bulk is necessary on your journey but otherwise recomp is mostly OK.

    Think of it more like a BW & BF range though. Don’t be afraid to get a bit fat, but don’t be attached to a number on the scale.

    Objectively, the slow cut is better but diet fatigue is a thing.

    Alpha Destiny does a big bulk every year just because he likes strength.

    I hit 20lb prs (10rm) on high pulls & pull downs yday but caught a left Erector strain from amraping the 4th Rdl set.

    Basically making noobs gains because of this app holy shit.

    Gonna take a deload week since it’s week 7 & nurse this injury.

    • Thanks: Yahya
  262. @Mikel
    @AP


    Gonzalo Lira moved to a foreign country, broke its laws by spreading and creating propaganda
     
    Lira broke Ukrainian law in the same way that Navalny broke Russian law. By posting stuff on YT that the authorities didn't like. Or in the same way that I guess I have myself repeatedly broken Ukrainian "law": posting opinions in English-language media that would also land me in jail if the goons of the regime you support could lay his hands on me. In fact, Ukraine must be about the only country in the world that keeps lists of foreign citizens (mostly actors and other non-entities who at some point dared to say something Ukie nationalists didn't like) as "enemies of Ukraine".

    The bottom line is that both Russia and Ukraine are corrupt countries where Communism was succeeded in short order by oligarch rule (as you would expect from closely related societies), full of criminal people with power, private armies and very little respect for human life. Lira's latest video before being arrested listed a number of people who, like he predicted would happen to him, were killed by the Kiev scum.

    Some idiots in Europe (as full of crap as the American neocon nation-builders in Muslim lands) found it their duty to go to the rescue of the poor oppressed Ukrainians when some people in Kiev started jumping up and down to demand being accepted in the EU. Ukrainians had finally seen the light and and now would become exemplary citizens of the EU paradise they think they've built, abandoning their decades-long habits of fostering corruption at all levels of their society. As it happened, even to prove how different they were from the Russians they couldn't help bombing their own cities and killing thousands of their co-citizens. That's how attached to the so-called "EU values" they are. And the more they continued to receive support from all these idiots on both sides of the Atlantic, the more encouraged they felt to carry on, until their cousins to the North decided to unleash their own chimpout.

    You can also jump up and down all you want and try to explain to us how ordinary it is in any European country for American bloggers to die in prison after being arrested for expressing opinions critical of the countries where they live. But regardless of all your dialectical efforts, you're not going to change one iota about any of the facts above. And those cold, hard facts are the ones that are going to continue determining the developments in the country of your ancestors.

    Replies: @AP, @Mikhail

    Lira broke Ukrainian law in the same way that Navalny broke Russian law

    Wrong as usual.

    He broke Ukrainian law in the same way that the 93 year old German lady broke German law and was arrested for it: by publicly saying things that were illegal to say in the country he was in. In her case, it was denying the Holocaust. In his case, it was making pro-Russian propaganda.

    Navalny was accused of corruption and was in a power conflict with the authorities, wanting to topple the government. In Ukraine governments get replaced through elections when pro-Westerners are in charge. Poroshenko lost his presidency that way, through a free election. That hasn’t been possible in Russia. This equivalence you make between the two countries is rather stupid, sorry.

    Or in the same way that I guess I have myself repeatedly broken Ukrainian “law”:

    You are not in Ukraine.

    You must not know much about Europe, if you assume that Europe has America’s 1st amendment. European countries often jail people for saying things deemed illegal to say.

    https://www.newstarget.com/2023-08-24-c-j-hopkins-sentenced-german-speech-case.html

    American playwright and humorist C.J. Hopkins, profiled in this space on numerous occasions, has been sent a “punishment order” by a German judge, offering him a Sophie’s Choice of 60 days in jail or 3,600 euros.

    His crime? Essentially, insulting the German health minister in a tweet, and using a scarcely-visible image of a Swastika on a mask in a book critical of the global pandemic response, The Rise of the New Normal Reich.

    Historian David Irving was sentenced to 3 years in prison on Austria for denying the Holocaust:

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2006/feb/20/austria.thefarright

    In fact, Ukraine must be about the only country in the world that keeps lists of foreign citizens (mostly actors and other non-entities who at some point dared to say something Ukie nationalists didn’t like) as “enemies of Ukraine”.

    The list has no official status:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myrotvorets

    You think CIA etc. have no unofficial lists?

    I suppose it being public is a novelty.

    The bottom line is that both Russia and Ukraine are corrupt countries

    Sure.

    full of criminal people with power, private armies and very little respect for human life.

    “Full of?”

    I don’t remember running into private armies on my visits to Ukraine. Or Russia, for that matter.

    Do you also think that American flyover country is “full of” private militias? I never encountered them when I was there, either. Criminal people with power is also rather meaningless. What would you call Trump, Biden, Bush, Cheney, etc.?

    Lira’s latest video before being arrested listed a number of people who, like he predicted would happen to him, were killed by the Kiev scum

    And you believe him.

    I asked for evidence that Lira was “killed.”

    You like to make claims without evidence. What do you think such claims can be called?

    Some idiots in Europe (as full of crap as the American neocon nation-builders in Muslim lands) found it their duty to go to the rescue of the poor oppressed Ukrainians

    Yes, you find it terrible to defend a nation in Europe that is being invaded. People wanting to do so are “idiots.” By wanting Kiev to be left to its own devices when facing the Russian invaders, you have far more blood on your mind than any Kiev official from 2014 onward. Your desired inaction by the West would result in Mariupol or Grozny repeated in Kiev, Kharkiv, etc. What a bloodthristy person you are. But you are sneaky about it, like those so-called peace activists in 1939.

    As it happened, even to prove how different they were from the Russians they couldn’t help bombing their own cities and killing thousands of their co-citizens. That’s how attached to the so-called “EU values”

    Not a single European nation has been faced with the circumstances that Ukraine faced in Donbas, so this is an irrelevant criticism.

    For example, what would Spain had done if the Catalan activists had taken over their towns and started killing Spanish police officers, Spanish patriots, and Spanish soldiers while launching further armed incursions in order to grab more territory and declare it free of Spain? Retreat and give it all up?

    the more they continued to receive support from all these idiots on both sides of the Atlantic, the more encouraged they felt to carry on

    Violence in Donbas petered out, and did not accelerate as you imply above.

    You can also jump up and down all you want and try to explain to us how ordinary it is in any European country for American bloggers to die in prison

    He died because he did not take care of his health.

    He was in prison the second time because after he was released from house arrest he chose to skip bail and flee the country, and was stupid enough to post publicly about doing so, leading to his rearrests. I suspect that some Ukrainian officials hoped he would slip away (why release this guy with a foreign passport) but his taunting forced their hand, proving that releasing him was a mistake.

    I guess in your moral corruption you don’t believe that laws should be followed.

    This reminds me of the guy who died in New York custody after he was arrested for illegally selling cigarettes’. The police supposedly “killed” him too. You have the logic of the BLM activists, congratulations.

    • Replies: @Mikel
    @AP


    I asked for evidence that Lira was “killed.”
     
    Cut the crap with your requests for "evidence" and "proof". We're talking about Ukraine. For obvious reasons we'll never know what exactly happened to this man, other than he would now be alive if he had stayed away from Ukrainian politics and kept blogging about his other subjects. And it's probably best that way for his relatives.

    We can also be pretty sure that the US won't do much to clarify the matter. Ukraine will never become a prosperous and peaceful European country but at least it has achieved the old status of "our son of a bitch", like in the previous cold war. They can keep doing all their dirty stuff as long as they keep playing the assigned role because nobody expects better from them. Congratulations.


    He died because he did not take care of his health.
     
    Yes, he probably ate too much candy in prison.

    You can't possibly be so thick to be unaware of how pathetic your attempts to normalize the death of an American political prisoner in a European prison sound. It is spectacularly clear that this is an unthinkable event outside of a banana republic. The closest equivalent we could find is perhaps Assange, also outrageous in its own way, but he is not an American imprisoned in a vassal country where the US is sending money to pay for the salaries of his very captors. And of course the British wouldn't let him die in prison of an untreated illness like a rabid dog. Which highlights another aspect of this tragedy: Ukrainians are not only criminals but also idiots. If they couldn't resist the urge to retaliate against a foreigner who was running his mouth too much they could have simply deported him and get rid of the problem. Instead, they chose the most imbecilic course of action. Just like their Russian cousins with Navalny and Skripal.


    I don’t remember running into private armies on my visits to Ukraine. Or Russia, for that matter.
     
    Perhaps Gerard is right after all? I don't know now but in the 90s you would find gangsters at the lobbies of any hotel in the ex-USSR countries, definitely in Ukraine and Russia. They were about the only locals you would find there, playing cards and doing their goon stuff. I was told about them in Poland and they were indeed easy to recognize with their all-black attire, rude manners and one of them, the capo, talking even louder than the rest. You would also find corruption even without trying but I think I prefer not to talk about that.

    For some reason you didn't see any of this in Poland, a country that would later become a rather prosperous EU country. Just a coincidence, I guess.


    what would Spain had done if the Catalan activists had taken over their towns and started killing Spanish police officers, Spanish patriots, and Spanish soldiers while launching further armed incursions in order to grab more territory and declare it free of Spain?
     
    ETA killed hundreds of Spanish police officers, soldiers, politicians, journalists and innocent civilians deep inside Spain that had nothing to do whatsoever with the Basque conflict, while certain parts of the Basque Country remained no-go areas for the police. There were always voices that demanded retribution but Spain spent decades combating this plague with the rule of law and negotiations. They did want to become a democratic and civilized society after 40 years of dictatorship and they understood what that entails.

    And even so, I have always thought that Spain is a rather crappy country that will never reach the levels of prosperity of its neighbors to the North. There is a reason why their empire declined so precipitously.

    We're talking about a different thing here though. Sorry to be blunt but you're not comparing an apple to an orange, you're comparing a rotten apple to a reasonably healthy orange. Two categories of differentiation.

    Replies: @AP

  263. china-russia-all-the-way says:

    US has only one carrier in the Middle East and refusing to send the Vinson and Reagan from the Western Pacific. (Ford is on the way back home after a 3 month extension.) The China obsession of the Pentagon is hurting Israeli security.

  264. Sher Singh says:

    http://www.journal.forces.gc.ca/cmj-article-en-page65.html

    Found it interesting these chuckle fucks thought parading around a skull made into a snuff box – was in any way OK.

    Their reputation as an obese yet ‘hyper masculine’ – racist yet black nephew organization is well deserved.

    I just care to wear a Talwar they can jump off a bridge – I’ll even pay for damage from the tidal wave.

    This sort of shit is what made me shift hard left.

    What a disgusting excuse for a ‘military culture’.
    Just beasts in human form.

    They don’t have a warrior culture & neither does Christianity allow for one. The ones that survived Christianity didn’t survive its surrender to modernity.

    Sad but expected & ultimately not my problem – one can only sacrifice so much.

    Vs

    https://web.archive.org/web/20201228143809/https://www.thestatesman.com/opinion/a-tradition-of-chivalry-83789.html

    ਅਕਾਲ

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Sher Singh

    Most military guys I have known do not give one flying fig what civilians like you or I think about them. : )

    , @songbird
    @Sher Singh


    They don’t have a warrior culture & neither does Christianity allow for one.
     
    WTF, never hear of the Knights of St. John?!

    On Malta, badly wounded knights, who couldn't stand, were put on chairs and given swords to help defend the forts from the Ottomans, who outnumbered them like 14:1.

    One such wounded knight would have routed an entire army of Sikhs. The fire hoops that they threw would have wreaked havoc on the beards and turbans of Singhs.

    Replies: @Sher Singh

    , @songbird
    @Sher Singh


    parading around a skull made into a snuff box

     

    More sensitivity should have been given to the fact that tobacco is often acidic and could damage the skull, distorting any cranial measurements and making it seem like the brainpan of Zulus is larger than the true volume.
  265. @AP
    @Beckow


    Than what? Nobody cares about the Poles
     
    Your words:

    "The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere – in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia’s propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception"

    You mentioned V4, I pointed out that Poles outnumber all other people within V4 combined.


    I was not limiting it to V4: Austria, Slovenia, Croatia, Serbia
     
    Serbia? Why not Syria also? And North Korea?

    Croatia helps Ukraine also. It gave Ukraine all of its Mi-8 helicopters.

    https://mpu.gov.hr/news-25399/croatia-strongly-supports-ukraine-and-the-ukrainian-people/27313


    it would work like this: Anglos talk and ship “weapons” and the Poles die.
     
    Last time Russia fought Poland, Russia lost. Russia can barely hold Ukraine to a stalemate.

    You bark your inane “Habsburg” nonsense. Let me remind you that it was by far the worst in terms of human rights, freedom, oppression, number of people in prison for wrong views, under the Habsburg feudal monarchy that you so stupidly celebrate
     
    Thanks for demonstrating the poor educational standards of Slovakia. So ignorant, so parochial. Poles lived under Hapsburgs, Romanovs and Hohenzollerns. Hapsburg rule was by far the mildest of the three. Ukrainians lived under Hapburgs and Romanovs. Hapsburgs were milder.

    So let's compare executions.

    Russia:

    https://www.rbth.com/history/331226-death-penalty-russia

    1826-1905: 526 people executed
    1905-1910: 3,700 people executed

    Germany:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_Germany

    1907-1932: 393 people executed (could not find data for 19th century)

    Austria (not the Hungarian-ruled part of Austria-Hungary):

    https://www.jstor.org/stable/2276063?seq=2

    1852-1897: 175 people executed

    England and Wales:

    https://www.acrosswalls.org/datasets/executions-england-wales-from-1800/

    1852-1897: 622 people executed


    Only Nazis exceeded it [Austria-Hungary] in WW2
     
    Poor uneducated Beckow apparently hasn't heard even of Stalin's or Lenin's crimes.

    If you want to compare, it was the Poles who sided first with the Nazi Germany in Munich 1938
     
    This lie of yours has already been debunked multiple times, many many people, some of whom aren't posting here anymore.

    Poland refused multiple offers of alliance with the Nazis (and also refused alliances with the Bolsheviks). when Czechoslovakia was betrayed by its allies and gave up German-0ihabioted lands to Germany, Poland asked for and peacefully received Polish-inhabited territories, that the Czechs had previously seized by attacking Poland and killing its soldiers. It was not part of some Polish-German alliance (this was no Molotov-Ribbentrop), indeed Poland refused such.


    After 1945 there were 3 million Polish commies all the way till the end
     
    Poles fought Commies in 1920 (and defeated them, saving Europe from a Russian commie invasion), 1939, and 1945.

    Poland fought Nazis in 1939 rather than join them as Germany asked them to do and as Slovakia did. Thereby saving Europe from Nazi victory (Russians were defeated by Poles in 1921, you think the Soviets would have defeated a German-Polish alliance?). Maybe that's why you can't forgive Poles? Your people were eager Nazi allies. Slovakia even paid the Nazis money to kill Slovak Jews. Who else would do that?


    in 1968 Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia the Poles were the second largest army
     
    They were about 25,000 troops out of 450,000. "Second largest" lol. And it was a commie vs. commie conflict anyways. Afterward, Czechoslovaks were such sincere and loyal commies that Poles were shocked when they visited Czechoslovakia.

    Polish resistance to Commies in the 1980s brought down the Soviet system in Eastern Europe. This is probably why you, a Commie sympathizer, can't forgive Poles.

    And of course Poles resist the importation of non-European Africans and Muslims into Europe. You Slovaks and Hungarians would not be able to resist the pressure alone.

    So Poland alone has resisted each of the evils plaguing Europe in the last 100+ years.

    While your people eagerly joined the Nazis, and voted for the Commies.


    you are losing the war
     
    Russia's staggering losses and lack of gaining even villages (taking the slag head outside Avdiivka, some wooded strips, and central Marinka doesn't count for much) suggest that its winter offensive is failing, so far.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    …Why not Syria also? And North Korea?

    Because they are in Asia, get a map…

    Your lying about the recent history displays your desperation – or your very poor education. There were 3 million Polish commies….3 million, around 15% of adult population. So much for your Polish anti-communism…

    Small obvious points:
    – Habsburg Empire was substantially more brutal with prisons, poverty, mass emmigration and censorship than what followed after 1918. Period. No sane person in CE ever claims anything else and Habsburgs were never after 1918 asked back. We really don’t care what was happening in Galicia pre-1918, it was a sh..thole province populated by Jews, Poles, Rusins, Romanians, with German overseers and massive emigration. Maybe that “Habsburg paradise” will come back, so you have that to look forward to.
    – Russia is winning the war in Ukraine. If you don’t see it, I can’t help you.
    – Polish troops invaded Czechoslovakia in 1968 – if they were “commies”, what is this about you denying that Poles were also commies? Before that Poles invaded with Hitler after Munich in 1938. You can pretend that it didn’t happen, but it just makes you look very, very stupid.

    In general, your obsessions about Habsburgs, Poles, commies, Russia, has led you to write some of the more bizarre hallucinations as if have created a completely made-up fake world – are you writing from a mental institution?

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Beckow

    Was the Hapsburg Empire like that because of the style of the subjects, or was it like that because of the style of the Hapsburgs? Some rabbles are more challenging to keep in line than others. : )

    Replies: @Beckow

    , @AP
    @Beckow


    There were 3 million Polish commies….3 million, around 15% of adult population. So much for your Polish anti-communism…
     
    People conquered and under the Soviet yoke had to adapt for a time.

    But when it mattered - Polish armies fought the Soviets and kept them out of Western Europe in 1920. Poles fought the Soviets in 1939 (couldn't win because the Germans had already attacked them) and in 1944-1945. And of course, Polish revolt ended Soviet rule in Eastern Europe in the 1980s.

    In Czechoslovakia there were 2.5 million Communist Party members in the late 1940s. In a country with a fraction of Poland's population.

    Habsburg Empire was substantially more brutal with prisons, poverty, mass emmigration and censorship than what followed after 1918.
     
    For whom, and when? It was not more brutal than Nazi and Soviet rule.

    Based on executions, it was less brutal than England/Wales, Russia, and probably Germany.

    We really don’t care what was happening in Galicia pre-1918, it was a sh..thole province populated by Jews, Poles, Rusins, Romanians, with German overseers and massive emigration.
     
    It was about a rich (or as poor) as your Slovakia, and better educated. It was poorer than the other Austrian provinces, other than Dalmatia. But it was richer than Portugal, Russia and the Balkans.

    Russia is winning the war in Ukraine
     
    It is currently losing its Winter Offensive.

    You were claiming that Ukraine's summer offensive failed, because Ukraine only captured 12 or so villages and stopped in order to conserve its soldiers and equipment.

    But what about Russia's winter offensive, which so far has seen the gain of parts of Marinka, a slag heap outside Avdiivka, some forest patches near Bakhmut, and massive loss of men and equipment. Less gain for far more loss.

    Polish troops invaded Czechoslovakia in 1968
     
    25,000 Poles were forced to be part of the 450,000-strong Soviet invasion force by their Soviet captors.

    Before that Poles invaded with Hitler after Munich in 1938
     
    Poland was demanded and was given Polish-inhabited lands before the Germans could take them.

    You as a member of a Nazi lackey country feels bad that the Germans didn't take that territory instead?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  266. @Mikel
    @AP


    Gonzalo Lira moved to a foreign country, broke its laws by spreading and creating propaganda
     
    Lira broke Ukrainian law in the same way that Navalny broke Russian law. By posting stuff on YT that the authorities didn't like. Or in the same way that I guess I have myself repeatedly broken Ukrainian "law": posting opinions in English-language media that would also land me in jail if the goons of the regime you support could lay his hands on me. In fact, Ukraine must be about the only country in the world that keeps lists of foreign citizens (mostly actors and other non-entities who at some point dared to say something Ukie nationalists didn't like) as "enemies of Ukraine".

    The bottom line is that both Russia and Ukraine are corrupt countries where Communism was succeeded in short order by oligarch rule (as you would expect from closely related societies), full of criminal people with power, private armies and very little respect for human life. Lira's latest video before being arrested listed a number of people who, like he predicted would happen to him, were killed by the Kiev scum.

    Some idiots in Europe (as full of crap as the American neocon nation-builders in Muslim lands) found it their duty to go to the rescue of the poor oppressed Ukrainians when some people in Kiev started jumping up and down to demand being accepted in the EU. Ukrainians had finally seen the light and and now would become exemplary citizens of the EU paradise they think they've built, abandoning their decades-long habits of fostering corruption at all levels of their society. As it happened, even to prove how different they were from the Russians they couldn't help bombing their own cities and killing thousands of their co-citizens. That's how attached to the so-called "EU values" they are. And the more they continued to receive support from all these idiots on both sides of the Atlantic, the more encouraged they felt to carry on, until their cousins to the North decided to unleash their own chimpout.

    You can also jump up and down all you want and try to explain to us how ordinary it is in any European country for American bloggers to die in prison after being arrested for expressing opinions critical of the countries where they live. But regardless of all your dialectical efforts, you're not going to change one iota about any of the facts above. And those cold, hard facts are the ones that are going to continue determining the developments in the country of your ancestors.

    Replies: @AP, @Mikhail

    Navalny and Gershkovich had court dates where the accusations and evidence were clearly stated. Lira’s situation wasn’t as transparent and more questionable. Navalny cheated Yves Rocher (in addition to disrespecting the judge, which doesn’t help a defendant in any court and being involved in demos that didn’t get zoning approval) and Gershkovich was reporting beyond the previously stated acceptable means on military security matter.

    Lira had a YouTube show featuring critical commentary on the Kiev regime. This video deals with Lira’s situation:

    • Replies: @Derer
    @Mikhail

    Navalny staged his poisoning and flew to Germany to fabricate the evidence - need a straight jacket.

    , @Mikel
    @Mikhail


    Navalny cheated Yves Rocher
     
    Nice to see you finally taking AP's side in an argument. Navalny cheated Yves Rocher, Lira didn't take proper care of his health, Skripal's poisoning was staged by the British,... nothing to see here, let's all move on.

    To be fair, one generally sees a bit more variety of argumentation among Russians than among Ukrainians. Plenty of Russians you see online are very vocal in their anti-Kremlin views, be it against the war or against the sloppy conduct of the war, but you are not one of them. You're more like the vast majority of Ukrainians, who feel the need to defend even the most abject and ridiculous acts of their government. Once the war is over and things settle down I could see you and AP becoming great friends, and inviting each other to taste your favorite varieties of Borscht. You even live close to each other, if I'm not mistaken.

    And to be fair to the Ukies too, contrary to what I thought, there does actually exist a Ukrainian Pacifist Movement. It was only founded in 2019 and seems to be largely a one-man show but well, something is something. You don't transit from a uniform Sovok mentality to the levels of free thinking prevalent West of those lands without small steps. Predictably, though, the Kiev regime is repressing this poor soul too and accusing him of being "pro-Russian": https://truthout.org/video/why-is-ukraine-prosecuting-a-pacifist-for-justifying-russian-aggression/ There's just no hope. If they can keep welcoming millions of illegal immigrants form the 3rd World, I guess they can also fast-tack Ukraine's membership in the EU but one way or another, they'll regret it. Or they'll just pretend that everything is fine while Europe's suicidal decline to irrelevance carries on.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

  267. @German_reader
    @A123


    A logical deal would be for Russia to stay as guarantor of the peace while Iran (including Hezbollah and other proxies), Turkey, and the U.S. all leave. This would largely free up Syria from sanctions and other impediments to reconstruction. However, there is so little trust among the parties, the concept us difficult to execute.
     
    Something like that might indeed be a good solution for Syria. However, I still think the US sanctions policy is criminally misguided. Even from your pov, since arguably it increases Assad's dependence on Iran (which otherwise he might not be too happy about).

    Would it not make more sense to blame German leadership for letting them in
     
    Sure, the primary responsibility is theirs, I haven't denied that. In any case, there would be strong migratory pressures even if US foreign policy were different.

    Given the length of time to investigate and still total absence of physical evidence, operator error is the mostly likely explanation for an industrial accident.
     
    There is more than enough evidence and there's absolutely no doubt it was sabotage. I have no idea why you're so wedded to this nonsensical accident theory.
    Ukraine is indeed the logical culprit, but I'm still not convinced they could have pulled it off on their own.

    Replies: @A123

    Given the length of time to investigate and still total absence of physical evidence, operator error is the mostly likely explanation for an industrial accident.

    There is more than enough evidence and there’s absolutely no doubt it was sabotage. I have no idea why you’re so wedded to this nonsensical accident theory.

    There is no direct evidence, and the circumstantial is both flimsy and suspect.

    Let us recall the event pattern :
        • 17 hour time span
        • 50 miles of physical separation
        • Only 3 of 4 tubes ruptured

    This is 100% consistent with an industrial accident. And, it is remarkably unlike the pattern one would expect from an organized attack.

    I have worked in heavy industry. I thus intuitively grasp that a mistakes can last hours, potentially days before the consequences kick in. Gigantic systems have massive inertia and thus response lag.

    Those with no field experience immediately make a nonsensical jump that things going bang must be intentional. It simply is not so. Lack of relevant personal knowledge has led many astray.

    Ukraine is indeed the logical culprit, but I’m still not convinced they could have pulled it off on their own.

    If you insist on ignoring the likely industrial accident, Ukraine and Poland are your only suspects.

    The current White House regime leaks information faster than a sieve sheds water. You can be 100% certain that they would have been kept out of any loop. It would have been the only way to maintain operational security.

    PEACE 😇

  268. @Sher Singh
    http://www.journal.forces.gc.ca/cmj-article-en-page65.html

    Found it interesting these chuckle fucks thought parading around a skull made into a snuff box - was in any way OK.

    Their reputation as an obese yet 'hyper masculine' - racist yet black nephew organization is well deserved.

    I just care to wear a Talwar they can jump off a bridge - I'll even pay for damage from the tidal wave.

    This sort of shit is what made me shift hard left.

    What a disgusting excuse for a 'military culture'.
    Just beasts in human form.

    They don't have a warrior culture & neither does Christianity allow for one. The ones that survived Christianity didn't survive its surrender to modernity.

    Sad but expected & ultimately not my problem - one can only sacrifice so much.

    Vs

    https://web.archive.org/web/20201228143809/https://www.thestatesman.com/opinion/a-tradition-of-chivalry-83789.html

    ਅਕਾਲ

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird, @songbird

    Most military guys I have known do not give one flying fig what civilians like you or I think about them. : )

  269. @Beckow
    @AP


    ...Why not Syria also? And North Korea?
     
    Because they are in Asia, get a map...

    Your lying about the recent history displays your desperation - or your very poor education. There were 3 million Polish commies....3 million, around 15% of adult population. So much for your Polish anti-communism...

    Small obvious points:
    - Habsburg Empire was substantially more brutal with prisons, poverty, mass emmigration and censorship than what followed after 1918. Period. No sane person in CE ever claims anything else and Habsburgs were never after 1918 asked back. We really don't care what was happening in Galicia pre-1918, it was a sh..thole province populated by Jews, Poles, Rusins, Romanians, with German overseers and massive emigration. Maybe that "Habsburg paradise" will come back, so you have that to look forward to.
    - Russia is winning the war in Ukraine. If you don't see it, I can't help you.
    - Polish troops invaded Czechoslovakia in 1968 - if they were "commies", what is this about you denying that Poles were also commies? Before that Poles invaded with Hitler after Munich in 1938. You can pretend that it didn't happen, but it just makes you look very, very stupid.

    In general, your obsessions about Habsburgs, Poles, commies, Russia, has led you to write some of the more bizarre hallucinations as if have created a completely made-up fake world - are you writing from a mental institution?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AP

    Was the Hapsburg Empire like that because of the style of the subjects, or was it like that because of the style of the Hapsburgs? Some rabbles are more challenging to keep in line than others. : )

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    ...Was the Hapsburg Empire like that because of the style of the subjects, or was it like that because of the style of the Hapsburgs?
     
    Vox populi, vox dei...I never blame the people...:)

    But neither. It was like that because of the heavy admin systems that the Habs created earlier and continued ad infinitum, everything was tracked, people, trade, "classes of people", newspapers, opinions - police literally kept track of who said what where and picked up suspects if a "circular" (memo) came saying that it was not allowed. They had more informers that E Germany - and were very proud of it, they thought it was the way it was supposed to be: wrong views meant prison or a fine.

    The prisons were full, sentences to heavy labor in mini-Gulag very common. In wars they proudly shot whole villages for "hostile sentiment", or just because they felt like it. The AP maniac is completely off, a moron with no knowledge of the region, we can see with his defense of the Lira murder that he lacks minimal morals.

    Replies: @German_reader

  270. Sher Singh says:

    https://nitter.net/Estimator91/with_replies

    Russian friend, based takes -NEW FAVORITE RUSSIAN POSTER – FK KARLIN

    No intellectual in the 19th or 20th century viewed Slavs as a part of Western civilization.
    Even Czechs were massively hated let alone to the East.
    The only reason this now exists is that Westerners want to be accepted as refuges or sexpats since there women are fat and annoying.

    Eh he had a good funny tweet like America will be majority brown & I will vote for it.
    He basically supports Westoid genocide due to their love of negroids.

    Here’s some more – I block him occasionally cuz he goes off the rails.
    Math teacher in California.

    [MORE]

    republicans switched to hating on immigration instead of blacks

    westoids will follow any legal pathway to harm ethnics, but will do nothing to harm monkeys, this is why I support ethnics in replacing every last one of them

    hating indians and jews is generally inversely proportional to hating blacks and Arabs (respectively)

    MENA/Turks can just be integrated MENA + German = Italian, look up admixture charts

    every single pensioner can leave ukraine and live on social benefits in the west, but Zelensky’s focus is on sucking slavs by ensuring only 16-25 year old girls leave

    he is aryan, you are not, I would support him nuking you and raping your women

    she’s Afrikaner and adopted joggers to only turn them into trannies, probably the most based Western woman

    I prefer Tajiks to Blacks
    Tajiks are the best possible Central Asians
    This obviously means I love Tajiks and want Tajiks to have sex with Natalia

    insecure girl will leave you when you raise her ego, its important to gaslight and to keep her insecure about herself

    california >>>> germany, Germany is below most large Asian countries
    Without Jewish particle physics what have Germans even invented past 100 years lmao?

    It’s honestly disgusting how the low IQ right is willing to accept literally any Соngоіd grifter, as long as he names “them”. It doesn’t matter how gross they are, what retardations they say, how they lust over our women — if they name “them” they must be perfectly tolerable!!!

    Jews (Ashkenazim) are part of an ethnic group with paternal line from the levant and maternal lineage linked to the Basque. Nuclear Fission, high end semiconductors and Helicopters (Sikorsky) are all Judeo-Slavic inventions.

    Italians are so bad at math that Italy has 3x fewer Gold Medals than a Bulgaria with 10x fewer people; they have roughly the same total medal counts as Serbia, despite Serbia having only competed since 2006 vs Italy since 1967

    Elites deserve elite things, regardless of where they come from. I am anti populist, anti nativist, anti nationalist, pro segregationist, pro classist, pro racist, pro elitist, pro casteist.

    “Herr derrrr why don’t you improve your own country”

    They are not responsible for that. The same way 95% of Westoids have nothing to do with their undeserved living conditions which are merely the result of democratic extraction from their superiors (me)

    The middle class is largely not responsible for its conditions its the result of policies which allow them to rent seek (protectionism)

    Name the greatest things you admire about each culture:
    Western Europe – Sentience
    Jews – Intelligence
    North East Asia – Memorization
    South East Asia – Repression
    South Asia – Caste System
    MENA – Women’s Rights
    Latin America – Torture

    regardless of who you try to shift the blame to, it doesn’t change my original point, america has no issues “assimilating’ migrants. Unless you’re talking about some culture that doesn’t exist. The average American watches monkey sports and average white American girl fucks them

    surely it was the fault of capitalism that British decided to destroy private property free market apartheid system with monkey communism where half the population lives on gibsmedats

    Supporting communist movements fighting westoids is fine, we did it because we hate westoids, anglos literally acted to end apartheid out of specific ideological love for black cock

    anglo saxons crush car of povertycel Iraqis for salvaging for wood in their own country, but offer their women and welfare on a. platter for looting feral shit filed monkeys that pollute their land

    how does assimilation into degenerate sexual liberal monkey culture have anything to do with being European

    I don’ think the golden billion deserve sole access to any of the wealth and capital in their countries. Now, for the EU I just want it delinked from the global reserve currency and for it to collapse into Argentina tier inflation

    most westoids are extremely comfortable, they re born into comfort that they had no role in creating, but was merely handed to them by their betters through the abolishment of serfdom
    Im an actual elitist, and belong to the class that created everything in the West. Immigrants>

    your women sleep with monkeys, I’d rather have swarths replace your race than seeing any more of these whores complaining that that they can’t live for free

    Suppressing Iranian diaspora and opponents of the Islamic Republic is a very good thing for the country
    Most of them are brown
    The Aryan population of Iran should increase from 30% to 50%

    you are a simp or cuck, she should be forced to work in sex slavery

    We kill joggers in my ancestral homeland, we don’t take too kindly to “monkey business”. This is a Westoid problem, but I agree, Westoids hate you more than they hate joggers, that’s why you should spread the world among your diaspora to crush them when you become a majority.

    this is an idea that I have been spreading for years, great to know the Indian community has caught on! Next time you’re in Anglo country, make sure to import your entire extended family by any means possible, and to do whatever you please.

    this roastie should be working more
    and we need more immigration to drive down wages because I don’t want simps to have money to take care of her

    Latinxs have complete control over the Catholic Church any nation with a significant Catholic population will eventually have a population of mfs acting like Mexicans I won’t be surprised if in 10 years Poles started acting like Mexicans

    India doesn’t have public education, the government wastes money on welfare. Even in richer states fewer than half the students go to public schools. PISA is just a test of education spending, unless you unironically think American blacks are smarter than Serbs

    You need to save money to invest money, this is also why Africa wont see any growth, it’ll just see growth in people on subsistence level , high TFR = automatic low growth or poverty for unindustrialized countries

    What about Israel?

    Israel is rich because of gibs, that’s part of why they are rich, they got free money, now do I oppose that? no better Israel than blacks, but without gibs Israel would likely be as poor as it was in the 70

    India doesn’t spend any money on scientific research, its space program gets a tenth of China’s funding. India practices a very cancerous type of populist agrarian socialism

    https://nitter.net/Estimator91/status/1744385048298631344#m

    So what?

    I don’t see the problem with this, I wil enforce hierarchies, there is no problem with DV, it is necessary actually, I live in a country that makes it legal, what are you going to do about it, cry?

    imagine how cucked the west is that the supposed incels and “misogynists” are like NOOOO YOU CANT HIT WOMEN

    LOL

    I admire Chechens and browns, they acid face whores. That is the rule. Rules must be followed.

    one of the primary reasons I support Chechen and muslims like Dargins becoming bigger is that even if they are 40% of russia it will only force Russians to behave like them and thats based

    https://nitter.net/datepsych/status/1744013390211645652#mv

    “Men with stronger misogynistic beliefs and higher levels of violated entitlement are more likely to engage in revenge planning, which in turn, predicts a stronger willingness to engage in violent extremism and interpersonal violence.”

    “More generally, engaging in misogyny may help to uplift men’s self/group image and worth, particularly if women are perceived to threaten traditional gender norms and hierarchies. Hence, the use of violence may be linked to men’s resentment toward their perceived loss of dominance and masculinity, in which revenge is seen to restore power and control. Our results are in line with studies that found hostile sexism among men to be related to (male) collective narcissism, while collective narcissism was further associated with retaliatory intergroup aggression and an increased desire for revenge, particularly against threatening outgroups.”

    TLDR Men who hit women are also likely to hit other men.

    russia should demand all Ukrainians are immediately deported to ukraine as a condition of ending the war, unless that happens as much of ukraine should be taken as possible

    slavs need to abandon orthodoxy, christianity and anything gay and cucked like that in general

    Christianity preaches forgiveness muh sins of the father slavs must always remember the children of their enemy is an even bigger enemy.

    the first and foremost enemy you need to take care of is any offspring of your enemy before going after the enemy itself

    you’re engaged to a slant, your kids will be incels LOL

    Japan should be replaced by as many immigrants as possible, stop sim-ping for slant eyed freaks if you’re pro Slavic, Eurasianism refers to West Asia, East Asia is to be used then nuked

    China will pass the EU in per capita GDP, because the EU is filled with lazy retards

    It won’t pass the US ever

    kazakhs and East Asians are worse than MENA or even south asians, they share neither a paternal line nor are genetically close, they are dirty monkeys

    >they hate women
    Based

    >they use their women
    Even more based

    I’m visiting India now and unfortunately most of this is false, I think Iran is better, would be based if true though, will visit RURAL punjab soon.

    It’s amazing how American whites will actively bootlick baboons and praise them over Indians. Truly insane. Nation of baboon lover

    All racism in the West not directed at baboons is at their defense

    No matter who it’s to, whether it’s to mestizos, jews, East Asians, blacks etc it’s all part of a primary purpose to defend baboons, no matter what you will ALWAYS see it intertwined with a defense of monkeys

    mexicans and MENA* most non western groups dont really understand the purpose of this racism, this racism ultimately applies to all of them because it’s founded on the core principle of the West: suck black cock or perish

    Ok I am convinced

    We need to import the entire population of India to the anglosphere

    That is the only way to solve every problem, as reward they get to breed as many anglo women as they want

    We already set out the tajiks on German women in 1945, it is your turn now

    I am convinced more than ever we need 250 million indians, 200 million south East Asians and 250 million sub saharan africans (the latter because there needs to be more lynchings for me to watch) imported into the United States

    https://nitter.net/Estimator91/status/1744129506216997113#m

    Azeri (Least white caucasians) + Russian = Italian
    Georgian + Russian = French/Hungarian
    Armenian + Russian = Romanian
    German + Syrian = Greek

    no we aren’t lol, we leave EU, you die, we remain, same for Jews

    Is Israel “threatened” because Westoid women are monkeylovers? lol no

    Keep coping

    Your death is our gain

    only yours is existentially threatened, why should I support slavic women to emigrate to your shithole to provide you women cause your women like monkeys and baboons? lol fuck off, better you die

    >Whines about East Asians and mexicans when your country is filled with blacks
    >Doesn’t say a word about blacks
    >Regfuses to blame white women being whores and instead tries to blame the “media”and “jews” for normies being degenerates that don’t deserve to pass on their genes

    https://www.cremieux.xyz/p/the-myth-of-nigerian-excellence

    • Replies: @Sher Singh
    @Sher Singh

    Can Unz delete this comment or edit out the math teacher in cali part, please?

  271. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Beckow

    Was the Hapsburg Empire like that because of the style of the subjects, or was it like that because of the style of the Hapsburgs? Some rabbles are more challenging to keep in line than others. : )

    Replies: @Beckow

    …Was the Hapsburg Empire like that because of the style of the subjects, or was it like that because of the style of the Hapsburgs?

    Vox populi, vox dei…I never blame the people…:)

    But neither. It was like that because of the heavy admin systems that the Habs created earlier and continued ad infinitum, everything was tracked, people, trade, “classes of people”, newspapers, opinions – police literally kept track of who said what where and picked up suspects if a “circular” (memo) came saying that it was not allowed. They had more informers that E Germany – and were very proud of it, they thought it was the way it was supposed to be: wrong views meant prison or a fine.

    The prisons were full, sentences to heavy labor in mini-Gulag very common. In wars they proudly shot whole villages for “hostile sentiment”, or just because they felt like it. The AP maniac is completely off, a moron with no knowledge of the region, we can see with his defense of the Lira murder that he lacks minimal morals.

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @Beckow


    In wars they proudly shot whole villages for “hostile sentiment”, or just because they felt like it.
     
    Where did they do something like that? I know the Austrians were pretty brutal in Serbia during WW1, and I suppose there was also repression against Russophiles in Galicia, but were wholesale massacres really common?

    Replies: @Beckow

  272. German_reader says:
    @Beckow
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    ...Was the Hapsburg Empire like that because of the style of the subjects, or was it like that because of the style of the Hapsburgs?
     
    Vox populi, vox dei...I never blame the people...:)

    But neither. It was like that because of the heavy admin systems that the Habs created earlier and continued ad infinitum, everything was tracked, people, trade, "classes of people", newspapers, opinions - police literally kept track of who said what where and picked up suspects if a "circular" (memo) came saying that it was not allowed. They had more informers that E Germany - and were very proud of it, they thought it was the way it was supposed to be: wrong views meant prison or a fine.

    The prisons were full, sentences to heavy labor in mini-Gulag very common. In wars they proudly shot whole villages for "hostile sentiment", or just because they felt like it. The AP maniac is completely off, a moron with no knowledge of the region, we can see with his defense of the Lira murder that he lacks minimal morals.

    Replies: @German_reader

    In wars they proudly shot whole villages for “hostile sentiment”, or just because they felt like it.

    Where did they do something like that? I know the Austrians were pretty brutal in Serbia during WW1, and I suppose there was also repression against Russophiles in Galicia, but were wholesale massacres really common?

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @German_reader

    In Serbia, Galicia, Volyn, Subcarpathia...previous to that in the Italian wars, look up Marshall Radetzky march that they play in Wien every New Year's Day, they don't play that march in Milano.

    Habsburgs were brutal as were the other powers at that time. The ahistorical claim that the mid-20th century brutality was very unusual and came out of nowhere is false - it grew out of the way major Euro powers acted for hundreds of years. The badly educated Americans who know only what they see in the movies weirdly worship the feudal societies and aristocrats ("knights") that their ancestors escaped to move to America.

    Predictably they demonize the locals who resisted and overthrew that system. Life under socialism ("commies") in the CE Europe was an order of magnitude better than life under the feudal systems and early capitalism. People like AP are not capable of understanding it so they fabulize about golden past that was destroyed by the 20th cent. socialists. But it was the 20th century socialism that created the prosperous Europe.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AnonfromTN, @German_reader, @AP

  273. Seems to me like stories where tough girls masquerade as guys are a common trope in Japan. (Not sure to what degree it extends to NE Asia as a whole.)

    Can imagine that there are a lot of local cultural factors that promote this. Probably easier in any place where depictions of fighting are highly stylized, and that easily includes manga which is the source material for a lot of Japanese culture.

    Still, it does pass my mind to wonder if HBD could contribute in some small way. Where does Japan rank in the sexual dimorphism of faces?

    • Replies: @China Japan and Korea Bromance of Three Kingdoms
    @songbird

    This was the "Manchurian Joan d'Arc". She was a Manchu princess, born Aisin Gioro Xianyu. She famously became a Manchukuo Army officer and spy for the Empire of Japan.

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/26/Photo_of_Ms.Yoshiko_Kawashima_with_her_signature_2.jpg

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/db/Y.Kawashima_wN.K2.jpg

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/ce/Gen_Yoshiko_Kawashima.jpg

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yoshiko_Kawashima

    After war Chiang liquidated her on charges of being a hanjian "traitor of Han". A bizarre charge since she wasn't Han Chinese. Although by other accounts she survived the war.

    Replies: @songbird

  274. @Sher Singh
    http://www.journal.forces.gc.ca/cmj-article-en-page65.html

    Found it interesting these chuckle fucks thought parading around a skull made into a snuff box - was in any way OK.

    Their reputation as an obese yet 'hyper masculine' - racist yet black nephew organization is well deserved.

    I just care to wear a Talwar they can jump off a bridge - I'll even pay for damage from the tidal wave.

    This sort of shit is what made me shift hard left.

    What a disgusting excuse for a 'military culture'.
    Just beasts in human form.

    They don't have a warrior culture & neither does Christianity allow for one. The ones that survived Christianity didn't survive its surrender to modernity.

    Sad but expected & ultimately not my problem - one can only sacrifice so much.

    Vs

    https://web.archive.org/web/20201228143809/https://www.thestatesman.com/opinion/a-tradition-of-chivalry-83789.html

    ਅਕਾਲ

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird, @songbird

    They don’t have a warrior culture & neither does Christianity allow for one.

    WTF, never hear of the Knights of St. John?!

    On Malta, badly wounded knights, who couldn’t stand, were put on chairs and given swords to help defend the forts from the Ottomans, who outnumbered them like 14:1.

    One such wounded knight would have routed an entire army of Sikhs. The fire hoops that they threw would have wreaked havoc on the beards and turbans of Singhs.

    • Replies: @Sher Singh
    @songbird

    We know and respect those.
    Their origins are Pagan.

    That's the point.
    Hindu warrior cultures were always non Hindu origin.

  275. Thought AP had great affinity for Lat-Ams, but one guy from the Southern Cone moves to Ukraine and marries a local girl and he seems to be rejoicing in his liquidation.

    Would hate to think what he would do if a Guatamalan moved there…

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @songbird

    AP dislikes people who are hostile towards Ukraine, especially if they also move to Ukraine.

    AP indeed likes Latin Americans, as do I. I also like law-abiding blacks. Though both blacks and Hispanics have a worse dysgenics problem relative to whites. Voluntary eugenics on a huge scale should hopefully fix or at least reduce this problem. It's sad that the duller average groups on average have more dysgenic fertility as well.

  276. @German_reader
    @Beckow


    In wars they proudly shot whole villages for “hostile sentiment”, or just because they felt like it.
     
    Where did they do something like that? I know the Austrians were pretty brutal in Serbia during WW1, and I suppose there was also repression against Russophiles in Galicia, but were wholesale massacres really common?

    Replies: @Beckow

    In Serbia, Galicia, Volyn, Subcarpathia…previous to that in the Italian wars, look up Marshall Radetzky march that they play in Wien every New Year’s Day, they don’t play that march in Milano.

    Habsburgs were brutal as were the other powers at that time. The ahistorical claim that the mid-20th century brutality was very unusual and came out of nowhere is false – it grew out of the way major Euro powers acted for hundreds of years. The badly educated Americans who know only what they see in the movies weirdly worship the feudal societies and aristocrats (“knights”) that their ancestors escaped to move to America.

    Predictably they demonize the locals who resisted and overthrew that system. Life under socialism (“commies”) in the CE Europe was an order of magnitude better than life under the feudal systems and early capitalism. People like AP are not capable of understanding it so they fabulize about golden past that was destroyed by the 20th cent. socialists. But it was the 20th century socialism that created the prosperous Europe.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Beckow


    But it was the 20th century socialism that created the prosperous Europe.
     
    No. Cheap oil and gas is the goose that laid the gold eggs. Socialism is one luxury out of many.
    , @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    But it was the 20th century socialism that created the prosperous Europe.
     
    This statement needs clarifiers. Socialism created certain level of development and prosperity in relatively backward Eastern Europe directly. Even now the majority of the population lives on its legacy: apartments built during that time, industry, infrastructure, etc. Some of this legacy was later destroyed by capitalism. Gdansk shipbuilding plant and nuclear power plant in Lithuania are clear examples, but a lot remained. E.g., steel was produced in Eastern Ukraine on plants built by the USSR. The technology was outdated, but cheap workforce still made this steel competitive. It’s low price benefited Western Europe. Russia was also exploiting what the USSR created a lot, both in industry and technology, particularly in military technology. Something not directly based on Soviet foundation started appearing only 10-15 years ago.

    In the West socialism created prosperity indirectly. The elites were scared of communist ideas, so they felt obliged to share with the population, creating the middle class. After the fall of the USSR middle class all over the West is disappearing, as the elites do not feel the need to curb their greed.

    Anyway, the past has passed, hence the name. New world order is emerging. We’ll see what it brings.

    Replies: @Derer

    , @German_reader
    @Beckow


    Life under socialism (“commies”) in the CE Europe was an order of magnitude better than life under the feudal systems and early capitalism.
     
    Sure, in world historical perspective the CSSR was preferable to most systems. But was it really preferable to interwar Czechoslovakia with its multi-party democracy? Didn't its economic system perform well below what could have been expected in a moderate capitalist system (e.g. one tempered by some form of social democracy)? Such questions don't have anything to do with romanticization of Habsburgs etc.

    Replies: @Beckow

    , @AP
    @Beckow


    [massacres during World War I] In Serbia, Galicia, Volyn, Subcarpathia
     
    In Galicia it was the Hungarians, not the Austrians. And they did not massacre entire villages.

    Habsburgs were brutal as were the other powers at that time
     
    Poles lived under Hapsburgs, Hohenzollerns and Romanovs. They know that Hapsburgs were clearly the best of the three. Under Hapsburgs, Prague became a Czech-speaking city. How did Dublin do under the British? Kiev under the Romanovs? What happened to the Sorbs under German rule?

    The ahistorical claim that the mid-20th century brutality was very unusual and came out of nowhere is false
     
    Nothing comes from nowhere, but don't pretend 1933-1945 was no worse than 1860-1914.

    badly educated Americans who know only what they see in the movies weirdly worship the feudal societies
     
    Americans hate feudal societies. They sometimes like the British royal family but that's ust celebrity worship. They only like the rich who talk like them and act like them. You are clueless as usual.

    Life under socialism (“commies”) in the CE Europe was an order of magnitude better than life under the feudal systems and early capitalism.
     
    That's as stupid as giving Bolsheviks credit for antibiotics and electricity, as if it would not have occurred if not for them.

    Almost all countries improve over time. Even Socialist ones did. But they improved more slowly than the others, they fell far behind. Of the three post-war economic systems in Europe (Euro-capitalist, Socialist, and semi-fascist), Socialist was the least successful.

    History provided the experiment. Compare the performance of Austria (Euro-capitalist) to Czechoslovakia/Hungary (Socialist) and Spain/Portugal (quasi-fascist).

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.
    Hungary: $2,200.
    Spain: $2,186
    Portugal: $2,046

    So prior to Socialism, Czechoslovakia was richer than Austria, Hungary was poorer but similar, Portugal and Spain were poorer than both Hungary and Czechoslovakia.

    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Spain: $11,582.
    Portugal: $10,372

    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768
    Hungary: $6,903.

    Austria now became not only the richest of the three former Hapsburg countries, but doubled the ones that got stuck under Communism. This is the most relevant comparison because these three countries are geographically close, and culturally and historically similar.

    But you see, Portugal and Spain passed up Czechoslovakia and Hungary and were a lot richer per capita than those two Commie countries. Quasi-fascism beat Socialism.

    Life expectancy divergence matched the economic divergence.

    People like AP are not capable of understanding it so they fabulize about golden past that was destroyed by the 20th cent. socialists
     
    19th century actually was a Golden Age for Europe, it ended in 1914. You doubt it? Compare cultural products, global power, etc.

    But it was the 20th century socialism that created the prosperous Europe
     
    Europe was improving in prosperity prior to the 20th century. You are too poorly educated to know that, of course. Your socialist teachers filled you little brain with fairy tales of socialist saviors and evil kings and nobles keeping everyone in the same squalor from the Middle Age until the 1920s. And you were gullible enough to believe them.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_regions_by_past_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita#1750%E2%80%931990_(Bairoch)

    Between 1870 and 1913, Austria's GDP per capita nearly doubled. Growth was accelerating, it had been slower before that. And there wasn't much difference between Austria's growth rate and that of non-monarchies or ones with powerless monarchs. It was universal in Europe.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Gerard1234

  277. @Beckow
    @German_reader

    In Serbia, Galicia, Volyn, Subcarpathia...previous to that in the Italian wars, look up Marshall Radetzky march that they play in Wien every New Year's Day, they don't play that march in Milano.

    Habsburgs were brutal as were the other powers at that time. The ahistorical claim that the mid-20th century brutality was very unusual and came out of nowhere is false - it grew out of the way major Euro powers acted for hundreds of years. The badly educated Americans who know only what they see in the movies weirdly worship the feudal societies and aristocrats ("knights") that their ancestors escaped to move to America.

    Predictably they demonize the locals who resisted and overthrew that system. Life under socialism ("commies") in the CE Europe was an order of magnitude better than life under the feudal systems and early capitalism. People like AP are not capable of understanding it so they fabulize about golden past that was destroyed by the 20th cent. socialists. But it was the 20th century socialism that created the prosperous Europe.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AnonfromTN, @German_reader, @AP

    But it was the 20th century socialism that created the prosperous Europe.

    No. Cheap oil and gas is the goose that laid the gold eggs. Socialism is one luxury out of many.

    • Agree: Barbarossa
  278. @Beckow
    @German_reader

    In Serbia, Galicia, Volyn, Subcarpathia...previous to that in the Italian wars, look up Marshall Radetzky march that they play in Wien every New Year's Day, they don't play that march in Milano.

    Habsburgs were brutal as were the other powers at that time. The ahistorical claim that the mid-20th century brutality was very unusual and came out of nowhere is false - it grew out of the way major Euro powers acted for hundreds of years. The badly educated Americans who know only what they see in the movies weirdly worship the feudal societies and aristocrats ("knights") that their ancestors escaped to move to America.

    Predictably they demonize the locals who resisted and overthrew that system. Life under socialism ("commies") in the CE Europe was an order of magnitude better than life under the feudal systems and early capitalism. People like AP are not capable of understanding it so they fabulize about golden past that was destroyed by the 20th cent. socialists. But it was the 20th century socialism that created the prosperous Europe.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AnonfromTN, @German_reader, @AP

    But it was the 20th century socialism that created the prosperous Europe.

    This statement needs clarifiers. Socialism created certain level of development and prosperity in relatively backward Eastern Europe directly. Even now the majority of the population lives on its legacy: apartments built during that time, industry, infrastructure, etc. Some of this legacy was later destroyed by capitalism. Gdansk shipbuilding plant and nuclear power plant in Lithuania are clear examples, but a lot remained. E.g., steel was produced in Eastern Ukraine on plants built by the USSR. The technology was outdated, but cheap workforce still made this steel competitive. It’s low price benefited Western Europe. Russia was also exploiting what the USSR created a lot, both in industry and technology, particularly in military technology. Something not directly based on Soviet foundation started appearing only 10-15 years ago.

    In the West socialism created prosperity indirectly. The elites were scared of communist ideas, so they felt obliged to share with the population, creating the middle class. After the fall of the USSR middle class all over the West is disappearing, as the elites do not feel the need to curb their greed.

    Anyway, the past has passed, hence the name. New world order is emerging. We’ll see what it brings.

    • Replies: @Derer
    @AnonfromTN

    In a survey 51% of East Germans responded with surprising...they were happier under the socialist East Germany than under present Germany. This answer is not about "better off" but "happier".

  279. @Sher Singh
    http://www.journal.forces.gc.ca/cmj-article-en-page65.html

    Found it interesting these chuckle fucks thought parading around a skull made into a snuff box - was in any way OK.

    Their reputation as an obese yet 'hyper masculine' - racist yet black nephew organization is well deserved.

    I just care to wear a Talwar they can jump off a bridge - I'll even pay for damage from the tidal wave.

    This sort of shit is what made me shift hard left.

    What a disgusting excuse for a 'military culture'.
    Just beasts in human form.

    They don't have a warrior culture & neither does Christianity allow for one. The ones that survived Christianity didn't survive its surrender to modernity.

    Sad but expected & ultimately not my problem - one can only sacrifice so much.

    Vs

    https://web.archive.org/web/20201228143809/https://www.thestatesman.com/opinion/a-tradition-of-chivalry-83789.html

    ਅਕਾਲ

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird, @songbird

    parading around a skull made into a snuff box

    More sensitivity should have been given to the fact that tobacco is often acidic and could damage the skull, distorting any cranial measurements and making it seem like the brainpan of Zulus is larger than the true volume.

  280. @songbird
    Seems to me like stories where tough girls masquerade as guys are a common trope in Japan. (Not sure to what degree it extends to NE Asia as a whole.)

    Can imagine that there are a lot of local cultural factors that promote this. Probably easier in any place where depictions of fighting are highly stylized, and that easily includes manga which is the source material for a lot of Japanese culture.

    Still, it does pass my mind to wonder if HBD could contribute in some small way. Where does Japan rank in the sexual dimorphism of faces?

    Replies: @China Japan and Korea Bromance of Three Kingdoms

    This was the “Manchurian Joan d’Arc”. She was a Manchu princess, born Aisin Gioro Xianyu. She famously became a Manchukuo Army officer and spy for the Empire of Japan.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yoshiko_Kawashima

    After war Chiang liquidated her on charges of being a hanjian “traitor of Han”. A bizarre charge since she wasn’t Han Chinese. Although by other accounts she survived the war.

    • Replies: @songbird
    @China Japan and Korea Bromance of Three Kingdoms

    Thanks, that was interesting, especially the part about Manchu concubines killing themselves after the death of their lord.

    A more minor character from the American Revolutionary War:
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deborah_Sampson

    I find it curious that her height made her part of an elite unit. Also that she died of Yellow Fever. Knew about it reaching Philadelphia, but didn't realize it got even further north.

  281. German_reader says:
    @Beckow
    @German_reader

    In Serbia, Galicia, Volyn, Subcarpathia...previous to that in the Italian wars, look up Marshall Radetzky march that they play in Wien every New Year's Day, they don't play that march in Milano.

    Habsburgs were brutal as were the other powers at that time. The ahistorical claim that the mid-20th century brutality was very unusual and came out of nowhere is false - it grew out of the way major Euro powers acted for hundreds of years. The badly educated Americans who know only what they see in the movies weirdly worship the feudal societies and aristocrats ("knights") that their ancestors escaped to move to America.

    Predictably they demonize the locals who resisted and overthrew that system. Life under socialism ("commies") in the CE Europe was an order of magnitude better than life under the feudal systems and early capitalism. People like AP are not capable of understanding it so they fabulize about golden past that was destroyed by the 20th cent. socialists. But it was the 20th century socialism that created the prosperous Europe.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AnonfromTN, @German_reader, @AP

    Life under socialism (“commies”) in the CE Europe was an order of magnitude better than life under the feudal systems and early capitalism.

    Sure, in world historical perspective the CSSR was preferable to most systems. But was it really preferable to interwar Czechoslovakia with its multi-party democracy? Didn’t its economic system perform well below what could have been expected in a moderate capitalist system (e.g. one tempered by some form of social democracy)? Such questions don’t have anything to do with romanticization of Habsburgs etc.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @German_reader


    ...was it really preferable to interwar Czechoslovakia with its multi-party democracy?
     
    The interwar democracy wasn't that great - by the late 30's more than 50% of the people were against it, from socialists to nationalists. It was a rather lame 'talking show" where poverty was quite severe and social services almost non-existent. The center in Prague run everything, it was a kind of middling oligarchy with legalistic methods to make sure that nothing changes - that's why it collapsed and why in the first free election in 1946 commies got 40% and allied socialists almost 30%.

    It was very common in the "democratic" Czechoslovakia for the police to shoot into demonstrators and for the opponents to be put in jail - with the exception of the crazy early 50's commie terror (1950-55), mostly against other commies and WW2 collaborators, the number of persecuted was substantially lower in 1955-89 than between 1918-38 - those are just numbers, data doesn't lie.


    Didn’t its economic system perform well below what could have been expected in a moderate capitalist system
     
    What if...I think we will never know. The GNP in Czechoslovakia quadrupled between 1948 and 1989, the population increased by 50%, universal education and healthcare were established, there was no unemployment (even most women joined workforce w generous maternity leave), very little crime, culture absolutely blossomed - movies, music, etc...by 1970's and 80's almost all people were able to travel to the West if they had the money.

    Could they have done better? Possibly, Austria did better during that time from around the same basis. Commies made huge economic mistakes - they stupidly tried to de-monetize the economy ("look, the prices are going down!") resulting in inefficiency and laziness. Towards the end small-scale corruption became endemic and so-called "market commies" wanted capitalism.

    But nobody was afraid of their boss and that is the kind of freedom the free capitalist societies can never have. Imagine having the freedom of not being afraid at work - the only real freedom that matters. Today people can only dream about that - close to 50% of people who lived in socialism consistently say that it was a better life. Who knows.

  282. @AP
    @Barbarossa


    I have a Russian friend that swears by Soviet cartoons but I haven’t tried them myself. Do you have any favorites to recommend?
     
    We used to have to get VHS tapes and a special VCR player that could play the European ones (Europe had a different system) but now it's so easy because it is all on Youtube.

    The most beautiful one is probably Hedgehog in a fog:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bFUi7inkAbs

    Generally there are a lot on Soyuzmultfilm.



    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_1i9oZR6Rns

    Soviet Winnie Pooh was very charming:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l3yhBEQlH_Y

    Spoof not to be seen with kids:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P7ddwBTxow0

    My kids liked this song when they were little:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tSq9jJwi7rM

    Ukrainian theme and folk music:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jQmBi7e8qjg

    Meanwhile Soviet Ukraine was making these Cossack cartoons:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R7hnykzUVxc

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TAGwhoMxXTg

    This is older:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BaF6oqHZ-GM&list=PLb7GduBVGH-lhgxbDZtbTqHQKN36pPiWk

    Others will pop up on youtube when you look at these. There are very many of them.

    Replies: @songbird, @Barbarossa

    Thanks, those were good. The kids found the Cossacks particularly amusing. It was non-stop laughter the entire time!

    We haven’t checked out the longer Snow Queen film yet but we’ll give it a try some evening.

  283. @Sher Singh
    @Barbarossa

    Na, mostly just home-made.
    If you name some stuff I can tell you if I know it.

    Been munching on mashing sesame flour + jaggery for the winter.
    All the online bros say Indian snacks lack protein - what u been eating?

    Replies: @Barbarossa

    I’m sure homemade is better. I like keeping some snacks around at the jobsite and such and if I have something healthier on hand I won’t be tempted to eat some total garbage.

    I would imagine that Indian snacks would be too low on protein if one is actually doing heavy duty training and I wouldn’t call them a replacement for real food but for convenient casual snacking they are really reasonable.

    I’ve got some Navrattan mix by Haldiram’s that has 12g fat, 14g carb w/4g fiber and 7g protein in a 1 cup serving. It’s mostly chickpea, lentil, peanuts and such with oil salt and spices. Or Channa Dal which just split chickpeas fried with salt and chili powder.

    Like I said before it seems notable that the nutritional ratio seems to make it hard to mindlessly eat a ton of it. Partly because most have a decent amount of heat and spice. American snacks seemed engineered for mindless face stuffing.
    Not that this would be surprising looking around the general population.

    • Replies: @Sher Singh
    @Barbarossa

    O, thought you meant like Ladoo or Barfi.
    If it works it works I guess.

    Mom never let that stuff in the house.
    Will check it out if need arises, thanks.

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinni

    Every family got own recipe - gonna try adding whey protein.

  284. @AP
    @Mikel


    Lira broke Ukrainian law in the same way that Navalny broke Russian law
     
    Wrong as usual.

    He broke Ukrainian law in the same way that the 93 year old German lady broke German law and was arrested for it: by publicly saying things that were illegal to say in the country he was in. In her case, it was denying the Holocaust. In his case, it was making pro-Russian propaganda.

    Navalny was accused of corruption and was in a power conflict with the authorities, wanting to topple the government. In Ukraine governments get replaced through elections when pro-Westerners are in charge. Poroshenko lost his presidency that way, through a free election. That hasn't been possible in Russia. This equivalence you make between the two countries is rather stupid, sorry.

    Or in the same way that I guess I have myself repeatedly broken Ukrainian “law”:
     
    You are not in Ukraine.

    You must not know much about Europe, if you assume that Europe has America's 1st amendment. European countries often jail people for saying things deemed illegal to say.

    https://www.newstarget.com/2023-08-24-c-j-hopkins-sentenced-german-speech-case.html

    American playwright and humorist C.J. Hopkins, profiled in this space on numerous occasions, has been sent a “punishment order” by a German judge, offering him a Sophie’s Choice of 60 days in jail or 3,600 euros.

    His crime? Essentially, insulting the German health minister in a tweet, and using a scarcely-visible image of a Swastika on a mask in a book critical of the global pandemic response, The Rise of the New Normal Reich.

    Historian David Irving was sentenced to 3 years in prison on Austria for denying the Holocaust:

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2006/feb/20/austria.thefarright

    In fact, Ukraine must be about the only country in the world that keeps lists of foreign citizens (mostly actors and other non-entities who at some point dared to say something Ukie nationalists didn’t like) as “enemies of Ukraine”.
     
    The list has no official status:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myrotvorets

    You think CIA etc. have no unofficial lists?

    I suppose it being public is a novelty.

    The bottom line is that both Russia and Ukraine are corrupt countries
     
    Sure.

    full of criminal people with power, private armies and very little respect for human life.
     
    "Full of?"

    I don't remember running into private armies on my visits to Ukraine. Or Russia, for that matter.

    Do you also think that American flyover country is "full of" private militias? I never encountered them when I was there, either. Criminal people with power is also rather meaningless. What would you call Trump, Biden, Bush, Cheney, etc.?

    Lira’s latest video before being arrested listed a number of people who, like he predicted would happen to him, were killed by the Kiev scum
     
    And you believe him.

    I asked for evidence that Lira was "killed."

    You like to make claims without evidence. What do you think such claims can be called?

    Some idiots in Europe (as full of crap as the American neocon nation-builders in Muslim lands) found it their duty to go to the rescue of the poor oppressed Ukrainians
     
    Yes, you find it terrible to defend a nation in Europe that is being invaded. People wanting to do so are "idiots." By wanting Kiev to be left to its own devices when facing the Russian invaders, you have far more blood on your mind than any Kiev official from 2014 onward. Your desired inaction by the West would result in Mariupol or Grozny repeated in Kiev, Kharkiv, etc. What a bloodthristy person you are. But you are sneaky about it, like those so-called peace activists in 1939.

    As it happened, even to prove how different they were from the Russians they couldn’t help bombing their own cities and killing thousands of their co-citizens. That’s how attached to the so-called “EU values”
     
    Not a single European nation has been faced with the circumstances that Ukraine faced in Donbas, so this is an irrelevant criticism.

    For example, what would Spain had done if the Catalan activists had taken over their towns and started killing Spanish police officers, Spanish patriots, and Spanish soldiers while launching further armed incursions in order to grab more territory and declare it free of Spain? Retreat and give it all up?

    the more they continued to receive support from all these idiots on both sides of the Atlantic, the more encouraged they felt to carry on
     
    Violence in Donbas petered out, and did not accelerate as you imply above.

    You can also jump up and down all you want and try to explain to us how ordinary it is in any European country for American bloggers to die in prison
     
    He died because he did not take care of his health.

    He was in prison the second time because after he was released from house arrest he chose to skip bail and flee the country, and was stupid enough to post publicly about doing so, leading to his rearrests. I suspect that some Ukrainian officials hoped he would slip away (why release this guy with a foreign passport) but his taunting forced their hand, proving that releasing him was a mistake.

    I guess in your moral corruption you don't believe that laws should be followed.

    This reminds me of the guy who died in New York custody after he was arrested for illegally selling cigarettes'. The police supposedly "killed" him too. You have the logic of the BLM activists, congratulations.

    Replies: @Mikel

    I asked for evidence that Lira was “killed.”

    Cut the crap with your requests for “evidence” and “proof”. We’re talking about Ukraine. For obvious reasons we’ll never know what exactly happened to this man, other than he would now be alive if he had stayed away from Ukrainian politics and kept blogging about his other subjects. And it’s probably best that way for his relatives.

    We can also be pretty sure that the US won’t do much to clarify the matter. Ukraine will never become a prosperous and peaceful European country but at least it has achieved the old status of “our son of a bitch”, like in the previous cold war. They can keep doing all their dirty stuff as long as they keep playing the assigned role because nobody expects better from them. Congratulations.

    He died because he did not take care of his health.

    Yes, he probably ate too much candy in prison.

    You can’t possibly be so thick to be unaware of how pathetic your attempts to normalize the death of an American political prisoner in a European prison sound. It is spectacularly clear that this is an unthinkable event outside of a banana republic. The closest equivalent we could find is perhaps Assange, also outrageous in its own way, but he is not an American imprisoned in a vassal country where the US is sending money to pay for the salaries of his very captors. And of course the British wouldn’t let him die in prison of an untreated illness like a rabid dog. Which highlights another aspect of this tragedy: Ukrainians are not only criminals but also idiots. If they couldn’t resist the urge to retaliate against a foreigner who was running his mouth too much they could have simply deported him and get rid of the problem. Instead, they chose the most imbecilic course of action. Just like their Russian cousins with Navalny and Skripal.

    I don’t remember running into private armies on my visits to Ukraine. Or Russia, for that matter.

    Perhaps Gerard is right after all? I don’t know now but in the 90s you would find gangsters at the lobbies of any hotel in the ex-USSR countries, definitely in Ukraine and Russia. They were about the only locals you would find there, playing cards and doing their goon stuff. I was told about them in Poland and they were indeed easy to recognize with their all-black attire, rude manners and one of them, the capo, talking even louder than the rest. You would also find corruption even without trying but I think I prefer not to talk about that.

    For some reason you didn’t see any of this in Poland, a country that would later become a rather prosperous EU country. Just a coincidence, I guess.

    what would Spain had done if the Catalan activists had taken over their towns and started killing Spanish police officers, Spanish patriots, and Spanish soldiers while launching further armed incursions in order to grab more territory and declare it free of Spain?

    ETA killed hundreds of Spanish police officers, soldiers, politicians, journalists and innocent civilians deep inside Spain that had nothing to do whatsoever with the Basque conflict, while certain parts of the Basque Country remained no-go areas for the police. There were always voices that demanded retribution but Spain spent decades combating this plague with the rule of law and negotiations. They did want to become a democratic and civilized society after 40 years of dictatorship and they understood what that entails.

    And even so, I have always thought that Spain is a rather crappy country that will never reach the levels of prosperity of its neighbors to the North. There is a reason why their empire declined so precipitously.

    We’re talking about a different thing here though. Sorry to be blunt but you’re not comparing an apple to an orange, you’re comparing a rotten apple to a reasonably healthy orange. Two categories of differentiation.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Mikel


    Cut the crap with your requests for “evidence” and “proof”.
     
    You keep repeating that he was "killed." Prove it.

    He got sick in jail, received medical care but it was too later and he died of his illness. He had been ill before he was arrested, some kind of heart problems. Even in a rich country like the USA people die of illnesses while incarcerated.

    You can’t possibly be so thick to be unaware of how pathetic your attempts to normalize the death of an American political prisoner in a European prison sound.
     
    Now he is a political prisoner?

    Do you consider the 93 year old German lady sentenced to prison for saying the Holocaust didn't happen to also be a political prisoner? You keep ignoring these examples.

    The closest equivalent we could find is perhaps Assange, also outrageous in its own way, but he is not an American imprisoned in a vassal country where the US is sending money to pay for the salaries of his very captors
     
    So you are suggesting that Ukraine isn't a puppet after all?

    Or are you going to go with the story that since Lira hated the USA, Ukraine was doing the USA's bidding by "killing" him.

    The reality is far more simple and straightforward (as is often the case). He chose to go to a different country, broke its laws, was arrested, got sick, and died. The prison administrators waited too long to provide medical care (as happens in prisons in the USA too) though they did eventually.

    You wanted him to get better care in the Ukrainian prison than many Americans get in American prisons?

    https://www.vera.org/news/health-care-behind-bars-missed-appointments-no-standards-and-high-costs

    The abysmal state of health care behind bars bears much of the blame for those figures. Medical neglect kills hundreds of incarcerated people every year despite the 1976 Supreme Court ruling that deliberate indifference to medical needs amounts to cruel and unusual punishment.

    :::::::::::::

    The Ukrainians even released him to house arrest. What did he do? Choose to skip bail and head for the border, while publicly announcing what he was doing.

    So the moron ended up in prison again, where he got sick and died.

    This is your "martyr."

    And of course the British wouldn’t let him die in prison of an untreated illness like a rabid dog.
     
    Lira got treatment. They waited too long, as is typical of prisons (not only in Ukraine), and it failed.

    I don’t remember running into private armies on my visits to Ukraine. Or Russia, for that matter.

    Perhaps Gerard is right after all? I don’t know now but in the 90s you would find gangsters at the lobbies of any hotel in the ex-USSR countries
     
    We weren't talking about gangsters, we were talking about "private armies" that you claimed Ukraine and Russia were full of. Why are you switching? I was in Ukraine in 1990 and Russia for the first time in 1999, otherwise I missed the 90s. And I avoided hotels and places where shady people go. The shadiest place I went to was Gorbushka in Moscow, a place to buy cheap pirated software.

    ETA killed hundreds of Spanish police officers, soldiers, politicians, journalists and innocent civilians deep inside Spain that had nothing to do whatsoever with the Basque conflict, while certain parts of the Basque Country remained no-go areas for the police. There were always voices that demanded retribution but Spain spent decades combating this plague with the rule of law and negotiations.
     
    Which cities did ETA control and did they try to advance on other cities in order to conquer them?

    You are comparing terrorism with civil war.

    As I said, no western European country had Ukraine's situation.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @John Johnson

  285. @China Japan and Korea Bromance of Three Kingdoms
    @songbird

    This was the "Manchurian Joan d'Arc". She was a Manchu princess, born Aisin Gioro Xianyu. She famously became a Manchukuo Army officer and spy for the Empire of Japan.

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/26/Photo_of_Ms.Yoshiko_Kawashima_with_her_signature_2.jpg

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/db/Y.Kawashima_wN.K2.jpg

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/ce/Gen_Yoshiko_Kawashima.jpg

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yoshiko_Kawashima

    After war Chiang liquidated her on charges of being a hanjian "traitor of Han". A bizarre charge since she wasn't Han Chinese. Although by other accounts she survived the war.

    Replies: @songbird

    Thanks, that was interesting, especially the part about Manchu concubines killing themselves after the death of their lord.

    A more minor character from the American Revolutionary War:
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deborah_Sampson

    I find it curious that her height made her part of an elite unit. Also that she died of Yellow Fever. Knew about it reaching Philadelphia, but didn’t realize it got even further north.

  286. @Gerard1234
    @AP


    I will note that of the 4 phenomena that tried to destroy Europe that I previously described, Poland alone of the Visegrad countries opposed all 4.

    Nazism
    Communism
    Mass non-European emigration
    Putin (he is working on Ukraine, Baltics probably next if Ukraine falls, but he supports gangsters further West also)
     
    LMFAO, you dumbf**k fantasist

    1. Poles were Hitlers best alllies you stupid idiot. Poles were the Japanese best allies on the planet you stupid idiot. Poland was ideologically identical to Nazi Germany - even more fascist and just as anti-semitic.

    The 1939 disagreement with the Nazi's and Poles was because Polish Nazis ( Poles) were even more imperialistic than the Nazis. They were hungry for far-more land than what even the Nazis were wanting.

    2. LOL a Poland-Czechoslovakia-France pact would have prevented WW2 immediately.

    3. Communism was not "evil" and did not try to destroy Europe you worthless scumbag. It of course cannot be compared to Nazism in attempt to destroy Europe.

    4. Poles, LMAO, took Communism up the a$$ for 50 years without attempting to resist it you POS

    5. Poland does not "resist mass non-European" migration. If it had to decide between being part of western institutions/receive FDI etc or "resisting mass non-European migration" ........then it would choose being part of western institutions and the prostitute of other countries , as it has been for half a millennium. Its a pointless statement - for the average German, Scandinavian or Brit- the Pole is of course much closer to the African in their estimation than they are to themselves.......and they have allowed millions of Poles to migrate to their countries for cheap labour. So Poles are not "resisting" but as is typical for them, being hypocrites, parasites and pussies.

    6. Difficult to underscale the level of bimbo stupidity in "Putin trying to destroy Europe", or "Poles resisting" comments. Putin has of course been looking to work with Europe ...... that Europe and Pindostan have decided to go against the worlds biggest commodities supplier, important on many different issues.....for a failed, fake, poorest-country in Europe, shithole, whore-infected white 3rd world, nuthouse country, that manufactures nothing - is something they have to live with and is indirectly getting most of them voted out of power

    Poles are the largest of the Visegrad countries, with the largest economy. There are more Poles than there are Slovaks, Hungarians, and Czechs combined, with about 10 million more Poles to spare. As such, Poles cannot be considered an exception. Considering Poles an “exception” among Visegrad is about as stupid as saying “Britain, with the exception of the English.”
     
    That piece of retardation from yourself is like comparing Bangladeshis to Japanese in world importance despite their equalish size populations. In reality Slovaks/Czechs and Hungarians each have equal , well alot MORE prominence and prestige around the world now and historically , despite there much smaller populations and size than Poland. This is of course because Poland has been a blackhole in contribution to anything in Europe for its entire existence. The scientific, cultural contribution of those 3 countries is gigantic compared to Polands non-existant one. Slovaks/Czechs and Hungarians have real economy and stable populations......not ones artificially inflated by misleading and misdirected FDI and cheap labour from ukrops.

    The rest of your nonsense is even more bimbo-drivel

    You are ignorant as usual. The small group of ex-colonists have their issues but most Poles like Ukrainians, particularly those who don’t speak Russian. There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

     

    You have never been to Poland, Russia or Ukraine and, as proven many times, can't speak a word of any of their languages. You have of course just done some more instantaneous BS there. Beckow, different to you has knowledge of this area and these people and speaks with credibility . Poles fighting there because they are illiterate anti-Russians, not because of "loving Ukrainians", history has proven these 2 sets of dickheads can't live together for 2 seconds. Russians and "Ukrainians" lived together for 300 years.

    Replies: @China Japan and Korea Bromance of Three Kingdoms, @AP

    Poles were Hitlers best alllies you stupid idiot. Poles were the Japanese best allies on the planet you stupid idiot.

    Poland-Japan alliance was for the main purpose of countering Soviets.

    Hitler was de facto ally with Chiang too, up until 1937, significantly for the purpose of countering Soviets as well. I don’t think you would use that point to condemn China. Soviet infiltration was spreading everywhere at that period, i.e. Mongolian Revolution, CCP

  287. @Yahya
    @Barbarossa


    One of the best films I’ve seen in a bit is the 1950’s version of A Christmas Carol with Alistair Sims.
     
    Dickensian stories tend to translate well onto the big screen. One of my favorite films is the 1984 rendition of Christmas Carol starring George C. Scott as Scrooge. The main theme resonated with me since I share Scrooge’s cynical mode of thinking. I haven’t been totally expunged of the rationalistic worldview, but I do remember the film striking a chord and making me re-examine my outlook and behavior.

    I you like Studio Ghibli fare it was a worthy addition.
     
    I’ve never watched Japanese anime. I’ll give one a go soon to expand my horizons.


    I’m glad to hear that you are pushing your boundaries. Best of luck with the workouts, I think you’ll find it worthwhile!
     
    I’ve been strength training for the past 4 months, and the impact has been nothing short of transformative. The positive effects spill over to other spheres of your life; it elevates your confidence, assertiveness and willpower. It is funny to look back at my previous attitude towards lifting weights as a vapid, time-wasting activity, aided by my impression that 85%+ of gym bros are shallow airheads.

    My outlook changed a full 180 degrees when I read Plato’s Republic, where in Chapter 4 he outlines the desirability of developing a harmonious balance of mental and physical qualities in future philosopher kings. Neglect of the former makes a person inelegant and brutish, and neglect of the latter makes you soft and timid. Only a combination of both can enable a person to reach a higher state of being.

    The previous 4 months have also changed my view of the nature vs nurture conundrum. While I still tend towards the hereditarian camp, I’ve since recalibrated upwards my appraisal of the environmental component in determining outcomes. It is quite possible for a person to change substantially if he is willing to step outside of his comfort zone and push the limits of what he hitherto thought was naturally capable. It only requires some gumption and a willingness to embrace fear and act despite of it, which I think most people are capable of.

    Replies: @AP, @Barbarossa

    the desirability of developing a harmonious balance of mental and physical qualities

    I’m a big believer in this as well. Being physically fit, competent and active directly effects mood, thought patterns and general confidence in life. Having a vigorous physical and mental life simultaneously form a self-reinforcing cycle of benefits. I’m glad that you are experiencing that for yourself. Plus, it’s just really fun to be good at things physically. I get such a constant keen pleasure from just moving around the world with precision. I can’t really imagine being deprived of that by obesity or lack of conditioning.

    Of course, as you observe, neglecting one or the other leads to incomplete humans (jocks or nerds). Either/or thinking in those regards is really self-defeating. I wonder why it is so common and stereotyped? People seem to tend to put themselves in the strangest boxes.

    In regards to nature versus nurture I definitely believe that people are born with many traits already present, but that whether those are a benefit or a detriment depend greatly on formation and conditioning. Something like stubbornness can be a superpower if utilized with restraint but can destroy a person if given free reign. I believe this is why parental influence on children is so important, parents have a huge responsibility to help each child with their individual strengths and weaknesses. And I firmly agree with you that people can change their trajectory but sadly it seems that many people are too complacent to do so. We are too often slaves to our conditioning, but we don’t necessarily have to be.

    In reference to your Batman review, I do agree that Nolan’s Batman is a generally good one but the best portrayals of Batman emphasize his intellect equally as his strength. Nolan definitely leaned into the physical power of the character and gave his character as detective short shrift. Batman was the only superhero I was really interested in as a kid so I had a pretty decent collection of Batman comics which generally threaded a fairer balance between Batman’s physical power and intellectual brilliance. It ties into our discussion above pretty well. Maybe Plato would have nominated Batman for philosopher king? Well, maybe not, but entertaining to imagine.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Barbarossa


    I believe this is why parental influence on children is so important, parents have a huge responsibility to help each child with their individual strengths and weaknesses.
     
    I have always blamed my problems on erroneous parental influences. See the "Can you blame someone else?" box.

    https://dangerousintersection.org/wp-content/uploads/2008/05/problem-solving-flow-chart.jpg
  288. @Barbarossa
    @Yahya


    the desirability of developing a harmonious balance of mental and physical qualities
     
    I'm a big believer in this as well. Being physically fit, competent and active directly effects mood, thought patterns and general confidence in life. Having a vigorous physical and mental life simultaneously form a self-reinforcing cycle of benefits. I'm glad that you are experiencing that for yourself. Plus, it's just really fun to be good at things physically. I get such a constant keen pleasure from just moving around the world with precision. I can't really imagine being deprived of that by obesity or lack of conditioning.

    Of course, as you observe, neglecting one or the other leads to incomplete humans (jocks or nerds). Either/or thinking in those regards is really self-defeating. I wonder why it is so common and stereotyped? People seem to tend to put themselves in the strangest boxes.

    In regards to nature versus nurture I definitely believe that people are born with many traits already present, but that whether those are a benefit or a detriment depend greatly on formation and conditioning. Something like stubbornness can be a superpower if utilized with restraint but can destroy a person if given free reign. I believe this is why parental influence on children is so important, parents have a huge responsibility to help each child with their individual strengths and weaknesses. And I firmly agree with you that people can change their trajectory but sadly it seems that many people are too complacent to do so. We are too often slaves to our conditioning, but we don't necessarily have to be.

    In reference to your Batman review, I do agree that Nolan's Batman is a generally good one but the best portrayals of Batman emphasize his intellect equally as his strength. Nolan definitely leaned into the physical power of the character and gave his character as detective short shrift. Batman was the only superhero I was really interested in as a kid so I had a pretty decent collection of Batman comics which generally threaded a fairer balance between Batman's physical power and intellectual brilliance. It ties into our discussion above pretty well. Maybe Plato would have nominated Batman for philosopher king? Well, maybe not, but entertaining to imagine.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    I believe this is why parental influence on children is so important, parents have a huge responsibility to help each child with their individual strengths and weaknesses.

    I have always blamed my problems on erroneous parental influences. See the “Can you blame someone else?” box.

    • LOL: Barbarossa
  289. @songbird
    @Sher Singh


    They don’t have a warrior culture & neither does Christianity allow for one.
     
    WTF, never hear of the Knights of St. John?!

    On Malta, badly wounded knights, who couldn't stand, were put on chairs and given swords to help defend the forts from the Ottomans, who outnumbered them like 14:1.

    One such wounded knight would have routed an entire army of Sikhs. The fire hoops that they threw would have wreaked havoc on the beards and turbans of Singhs.

    Replies: @Sher Singh

    We know and respect those.
    Their origins are Pagan.

    That’s the point.
    Hindu warrior cultures were always non Hindu origin.

  290. @Barbarossa
    @Sher Singh

    I'm sure homemade is better. I like keeping some snacks around at the jobsite and such and if I have something healthier on hand I won't be tempted to eat some total garbage.

    I would imagine that Indian snacks would be too low on protein if one is actually doing heavy duty training and I wouldn't call them a replacement for real food but for convenient casual snacking they are really reasonable.

    I've got some Navrattan mix by Haldiram's that has 12g fat, 14g carb w/4g fiber and 7g protein in a 1 cup serving. It's mostly chickpea, lentil, peanuts and such with oil salt and spices. Or Channa Dal which just split chickpeas fried with salt and chili powder.

    Like I said before it seems notable that the nutritional ratio seems to make it hard to mindlessly eat a ton of it. Partly because most have a decent amount of heat and spice. American snacks seemed engineered for mindless face stuffing.
    Not that this would be surprising looking around the general population.

    Replies: @Sher Singh

    O, thought you meant like Ladoo or Barfi.
    If it works it works I guess.

    Mom never let that stuff in the house.
    Will check it out if need arises, thanks.

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinni

    Every family got own recipe – gonna try adding whey protein.

  291. Biggest Japan Empire

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    Biggest Japan Empire
     
    Maybe it’s useful to remember how that ended. Japan is still an occupied emasculated country.
    , @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTBFfwGpA-xlIbveLZiyv2Jws7Y88Zz5p7uWA&usqp.jpg

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird, @Hyperborean, @Mr. XYZ

  292. @Emil Nikola Richard
    Biggest Japan Empire

    https://i.redd.it/sz9g61dgcvg91.jpg

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Biggest Japan Empire

    Maybe it’s useful to remember how that ended. Japan is still an occupied emasculated country.

  293. @Mr. XYZ
    @AnonfromTN

    Let's see what investigations in regards to this will say. But Yeah, in the East Slavic lands, unfortunately journalist and politician killings, shootings, and poisonings have not exactly been rare in the post-Soviet era. It really is a huge tragedy and shows just how much Communism and its legacy severely fucked over these countries. I'm not even sure if Central Asia has this problem on quite as large of a scale, even after adjusting for total population size.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. Hack, @Derer

    East Slavic lands, unfortunately journalist and politician killings, shootings,

    Only in East Slavic lands? You are badly misinformed…what about unexplained bodies disappearing and dying around H.Clinton, it perhaps started with Vince Foster.

  294. @Mikhail
    @Mikel

    Navalny and Gershkovich had court dates where the accusations and evidence were clearly stated. Lira's situation wasn't as transparent and more questionable. Navalny cheated Yves Rocher (in addition to disrespecting the judge, which doesn't help a defendant in any court and being involved in demos that didn't get zoning approval) and Gershkovich was reporting beyond the previously stated acceptable means on military security matter.

    Lira had a YouTube show featuring critical commentary on the Kiev regime. This video deals with Lira's situation:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2X7JmoXenw0&t=3740s

    Replies: @Derer, @Mikel

    Navalny staged his poisoning and flew to Germany to fabricate the evidence – need a straight jacket.

  295. Would like to see A123 and GR cowrite a monster movie where slugs loosely representing America take over Europe. I suggest that they be brain-slugs like in Heinlein’s Puppeteers , that would help explain the total alignment on policy.

    • LOL: A123
    • Replies: @German_reader
    @songbird


    Would like to see A123 and GR cowrite a monster movie where slugs loosely representing America take over Europe.
     
    I think the creative differences would be too large for such an undertaking. A123 would insist on a re-write where the slugs are actually German and control Biden's government (maybe have a scene where it's shown Biden is comatose in reality and only able to function once a slug has slipped through his ear and is controlling his brain, like in that early Star Trek: Next generation episode with the alien parasites). Hero of the movie would be a Trumpite Judeo-Christian from Arkansas or some other Southern state who's constantly wearing an "I love Israel" pin on his shirt.

    Replies: @QCIC, @A123

  296. @Mr. Hack
    @Barbarossa

    What Indian snacks do you enjoy eating and would recommend? Here in Phoenix Land we have a great discount food store where I buy all sorts of treats at bargain basement prices. Recently, I was buying these great "Kind" and "Larabar" fruit and nut bars for $.10 a piece, even a few godiva chocolate bars for this ridiculously low price. I went there yesterday to repurchase some $.49 cans of cat food (my 3 feral cats scarf them down in no time), and was disappointed that the fruit bars (that had been on sale there for at least 2 months) were finally all gone. :-( I regularly buy all sorts of Starbucks coffees there between $3 - $6 per bag, the same ones that cost $7 - $11 per bag in the regular stores.

    On the upside, I did find some great 5 oz Terra Sweet Potato chips for $.99 a bag. Have you looked at the prices on potato chips in the regular grocery stores lately? $3 - $6 bucks a bag, highway robbery if you ask me, especially if you consider that you can still pick up a 5lb bag of great quality whole potatoes for only $3.

    Replies: @Barbarossa, @songbird

    We have a similar discount grocery place run by Amish around here. I’ve dubbed it the Amish Walmart. They buy overstock and nearly expired foodstuffs and sell them cheap. There is a lot of junk food but also some great deals. I stocked up on walnuts halves for $2 a lb. a while back.

    You don’t have to tell me about the price of food these days. Feeding 7 in the household gets expensive even with raising our own meat. It’s definitely our biggest single expense, though I don’t have car payments or student loans so maybe that’s not saying much.

  297. @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    But it was the 20th century socialism that created the prosperous Europe.
     
    This statement needs clarifiers. Socialism created certain level of development and prosperity in relatively backward Eastern Europe directly. Even now the majority of the population lives on its legacy: apartments built during that time, industry, infrastructure, etc. Some of this legacy was later destroyed by capitalism. Gdansk shipbuilding plant and nuclear power plant in Lithuania are clear examples, but a lot remained. E.g., steel was produced in Eastern Ukraine on plants built by the USSR. The technology was outdated, but cheap workforce still made this steel competitive. It’s low price benefited Western Europe. Russia was also exploiting what the USSR created a lot, both in industry and technology, particularly in military technology. Something not directly based on Soviet foundation started appearing only 10-15 years ago.

    In the West socialism created prosperity indirectly. The elites were scared of communist ideas, so they felt obliged to share with the population, creating the middle class. After the fall of the USSR middle class all over the West is disappearing, as the elites do not feel the need to curb their greed.

    Anyway, the past has passed, hence the name. New world order is emerging. We’ll see what it brings.

    Replies: @Derer

    In a survey 51% of East Germans responded with surprising…they were happier under the socialist East Germany than under present Germany. This answer is not about “better off” but “happier”.

  298. @Gerard1234
    @AP


    I will note that of the 4 phenomena that tried to destroy Europe that I previously described, Poland alone of the Visegrad countries opposed all 4.

    Nazism
    Communism
    Mass non-European emigration
    Putin (he is working on Ukraine, Baltics probably next if Ukraine falls, but he supports gangsters further West also)
     
    LMFAO, you dumbf**k fantasist

    1. Poles were Hitlers best alllies you stupid idiot. Poles were the Japanese best allies on the planet you stupid idiot. Poland was ideologically identical to Nazi Germany - even more fascist and just as anti-semitic.

    The 1939 disagreement with the Nazi's and Poles was because Polish Nazis ( Poles) were even more imperialistic than the Nazis. They were hungry for far-more land than what even the Nazis were wanting.

    2. LOL a Poland-Czechoslovakia-France pact would have prevented WW2 immediately.

    3. Communism was not "evil" and did not try to destroy Europe you worthless scumbag. It of course cannot be compared to Nazism in attempt to destroy Europe.

    4. Poles, LMAO, took Communism up the a$$ for 50 years without attempting to resist it you POS

    5. Poland does not "resist mass non-European" migration. If it had to decide between being part of western institutions/receive FDI etc or "resisting mass non-European migration" ........then it would choose being part of western institutions and the prostitute of other countries , as it has been for half a millennium. Its a pointless statement - for the average German, Scandinavian or Brit- the Pole is of course much closer to the African in their estimation than they are to themselves.......and they have allowed millions of Poles to migrate to their countries for cheap labour. So Poles are not "resisting" but as is typical for them, being hypocrites, parasites and pussies.

    6. Difficult to underscale the level of bimbo stupidity in "Putin trying to destroy Europe", or "Poles resisting" comments. Putin has of course been looking to work with Europe ...... that Europe and Pindostan have decided to go against the worlds biggest commodities supplier, important on many different issues.....for a failed, fake, poorest-country in Europe, shithole, whore-infected white 3rd world, nuthouse country, that manufactures nothing - is something they have to live with and is indirectly getting most of them voted out of power

    Poles are the largest of the Visegrad countries, with the largest economy. There are more Poles than there are Slovaks, Hungarians, and Czechs combined, with about 10 million more Poles to spare. As such, Poles cannot be considered an exception. Considering Poles an “exception” among Visegrad is about as stupid as saying “Britain, with the exception of the English.”
     
    That piece of retardation from yourself is like comparing Bangladeshis to Japanese in world importance despite their equalish size populations. In reality Slovaks/Czechs and Hungarians each have equal , well alot MORE prominence and prestige around the world now and historically , despite there much smaller populations and size than Poland. This is of course because Poland has been a blackhole in contribution to anything in Europe for its entire existence. The scientific, cultural contribution of those 3 countries is gigantic compared to Polands non-existant one. Slovaks/Czechs and Hungarians have real economy and stable populations......not ones artificially inflated by misleading and misdirected FDI and cheap labour from ukrops.

    The rest of your nonsense is even more bimbo-drivel

    You are ignorant as usual. The small group of ex-colonists have their issues but most Poles like Ukrainians, particularly those who don’t speak Russian. There are even Poles fighting and dying alongside Ukrainians.

     

    You have never been to Poland, Russia or Ukraine and, as proven many times, can't speak a word of any of their languages. You have of course just done some more instantaneous BS there. Beckow, different to you has knowledge of this area and these people and speaks with credibility . Poles fighting there because they are illiterate anti-Russians, not because of "loving Ukrainians", history has proven these 2 sets of dickheads can't live together for 2 seconds. Russians and "Ukrainians" lived together for 300 years.

    Replies: @China Japan and Korea Bromance of Three Kingdoms, @AP

    You have never been to Poland, Russia or Ukraine and, as proven many times, can’t speak a word of any of their languages.

    All of this is untrue and you know it, you are trolling (probably to get me to say something that can get me doxed),, but in case someone else is reading this exchange, I did meet up with our former host, on one of my trips to Moscow:

    https://www.unz.com/akarlin/open-thread-40/

    And I regularly posted photos of my travels.

    Look how quiet and undeveloped parts of central Moscow still were in the early 2000s. Looks like a provincial village but it’s right off one of the boulevards:

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AP

    That looks like no provincial village in any country I have ever seen. How drunk are you?

    Replies: @AP

  299. @Emil Nikola Richard
    Biggest Japan Empire

    https://i.redd.it/sz9g61dgcvg91.jpg

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    It looks to me like the British got the choice cut. Clever.

    , @songbird
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Not really a masterpiece or anything, but in The Place Promised in Our Early Days, Hokkaido is part of a Soviet Zone, while the rest is American.
    https://youtu.be/mY975nWvWfs?si=sfCJ2yybjNRWsGSF

    BTW, I like the Japanese penchant for long titles. I feel like English titles tend towards the banal because they are too short. IMO, not every title should be one or two words.

    , @Hyperborean
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Very strange map, which alt-history story did you get this one from? Unless the Second World War turned out radically different it's highly implausible.

    First, it would just be the People's Republic of Japan. Not People's Republic of North Japan. Any of the cold war divided states would never relinquish their claims over the other half of the country.

    Second, South Korea suggests Korea still got divided into an American and Soviet zone. Previously occupied countries in the immediate
    post-war era usually didn't get to participate in occupation, this is why France getting occupation rights in Germany and Austria was such a coup for de Gaulle.
    In any case, one would believe that the South Koreans would be better off using their manpower guarding the inter-Korean border.

    Third, no division of Tokyo, why? One would expect the precedent of Berlin and Vienna to apply.

    Fourth, the PRC shouldn't hold an occupation zone. At the creation of the zones in 1945 it would be the ROC and after the civil war there's no way the Western Powers would hand over the zone to a government they don’t acknowledge as legitimate.

    Fifth, it says "Evolution of Allied Occupied Japan (1945-1990); hopefully this is just the first slide of several showing political changes, otherwise it really doesn't make sense to keep Japan occupied for so long instead of creating a satellite state with more internal and external legitimacy after a couple of years.

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Thank god that this scenario never actually happened since Communist rule in northern Japan would have likely reduced longevity there at least somewhat. Japan is very notable for its large verified supercentenarian population.

  300. @Mikel
    @AP


    I asked for evidence that Lira was “killed.”
     
    Cut the crap with your requests for "evidence" and "proof". We're talking about Ukraine. For obvious reasons we'll never know what exactly happened to this man, other than he would now be alive if he had stayed away from Ukrainian politics and kept blogging about his other subjects. And it's probably best that way for his relatives.

    We can also be pretty sure that the US won't do much to clarify the matter. Ukraine will never become a prosperous and peaceful European country but at least it has achieved the old status of "our son of a bitch", like in the previous cold war. They can keep doing all their dirty stuff as long as they keep playing the assigned role because nobody expects better from them. Congratulations.


    He died because he did not take care of his health.
     
    Yes, he probably ate too much candy in prison.

    You can't possibly be so thick to be unaware of how pathetic your attempts to normalize the death of an American political prisoner in a European prison sound. It is spectacularly clear that this is an unthinkable event outside of a banana republic. The closest equivalent we could find is perhaps Assange, also outrageous in its own way, but he is not an American imprisoned in a vassal country where the US is sending money to pay for the salaries of his very captors. And of course the British wouldn't let him die in prison of an untreated illness like a rabid dog. Which highlights another aspect of this tragedy: Ukrainians are not only criminals but also idiots. If they couldn't resist the urge to retaliate against a foreigner who was running his mouth too much they could have simply deported him and get rid of the problem. Instead, they chose the most imbecilic course of action. Just like their Russian cousins with Navalny and Skripal.


    I don’t remember running into private armies on my visits to Ukraine. Or Russia, for that matter.
     
    Perhaps Gerard is right after all? I don't know now but in the 90s you would find gangsters at the lobbies of any hotel in the ex-USSR countries, definitely in Ukraine and Russia. They were about the only locals you would find there, playing cards and doing their goon stuff. I was told about them in Poland and they were indeed easy to recognize with their all-black attire, rude manners and one of them, the capo, talking even louder than the rest. You would also find corruption even without trying but I think I prefer not to talk about that.

    For some reason you didn't see any of this in Poland, a country that would later become a rather prosperous EU country. Just a coincidence, I guess.


    what would Spain had done if the Catalan activists had taken over their towns and started killing Spanish police officers, Spanish patriots, and Spanish soldiers while launching further armed incursions in order to grab more territory and declare it free of Spain?
     
    ETA killed hundreds of Spanish police officers, soldiers, politicians, journalists and innocent civilians deep inside Spain that had nothing to do whatsoever with the Basque conflict, while certain parts of the Basque Country remained no-go areas for the police. There were always voices that demanded retribution but Spain spent decades combating this plague with the rule of law and negotiations. They did want to become a democratic and civilized society after 40 years of dictatorship and they understood what that entails.

    And even so, I have always thought that Spain is a rather crappy country that will never reach the levels of prosperity of its neighbors to the North. There is a reason why their empire declined so precipitously.

    We're talking about a different thing here though. Sorry to be blunt but you're not comparing an apple to an orange, you're comparing a rotten apple to a reasonably healthy orange. Two categories of differentiation.

    Replies: @AP

    Cut the crap with your requests for “evidence” and “proof”.

    You keep repeating that he was “killed.” Prove it.

    He got sick in jail, received medical care but it was too later and he died of his illness. He had been ill before he was arrested, some kind of heart problems. Even in a rich country like the USA people die of illnesses while incarcerated.

    You can’t possibly be so thick to be unaware of how pathetic your attempts to normalize the death of an American political prisoner in a European prison sound.

    Now he is a political prisoner?

    Do you consider the 93 year old German lady sentenced to prison for saying the Holocaust didn’t happen to also be a political prisoner? You keep ignoring these examples.

    The closest equivalent we could find is perhaps Assange, also outrageous in its own way, but he is not an American imprisoned in a vassal country where the US is sending money to pay for the salaries of his very captors

    So you are suggesting that Ukraine isn’t a puppet after all?

    Or are you going to go with the story that since Lira hated the USA, Ukraine was doing the USA’s bidding by “killing” him.

    The reality is far more simple and straightforward (as is often the case). He chose to go to a different country, broke its laws, was arrested, got sick, and died. The prison administrators waited too long to provide medical care (as happens in prisons in the USA too) though they did eventually.

    You wanted him to get better care in the Ukrainian prison than many Americans get in American prisons?

    https://www.vera.org/news/health-care-behind-bars-missed-appointments-no-standards-and-high-costs

    The abysmal state of health care behind bars bears much of the blame for those figures. Medical neglect kills hundreds of incarcerated people every year despite the 1976 Supreme Court ruling that deliberate indifference to medical needs amounts to cruel and unusual punishment.

    :::::::::::::

    The Ukrainians even released him to house arrest. What did he do? Choose to skip bail and head for the border, while publicly announcing what he was doing.

    So the moron ended up in prison again, where he got sick and died.

    This is your “martyr.”

    And of course the British wouldn’t let him die in prison of an untreated illness like a rabid dog.

    Lira got treatment. They waited too long, as is typical of prisons (not only in Ukraine), and it failed.

    I don’t remember running into private armies on my visits to Ukraine. Or Russia, for that matter.

    Perhaps Gerard is right after all? I don’t know now but in the 90s you would find gangsters at the lobbies of any hotel in the ex-USSR countries

    We weren’t talking about gangsters, we were talking about “private armies” that you claimed Ukraine and Russia were full of. Why are you switching? I was in Ukraine in 1990 and Russia for the first time in 1999, otherwise I missed the 90s. And I avoided hotels and places where shady people go. The shadiest place I went to was Gorbushka in Moscow, a place to buy cheap pirated software.

    ETA killed hundreds of Spanish police officers, soldiers, politicians, journalists and innocent civilians deep inside Spain that had nothing to do whatsoever with the Basque conflict, while certain parts of the Basque Country remained no-go areas for the police. There were always voices that demanded retribution but Spain spent decades combating this plague with the rule of law and negotiations.

    Which cities did ETA control and did they try to advance on other cities in order to conquer them?

    You are comparing terrorism with civil war.

    As I said, no western European country had Ukraine’s situation.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    despite the 1976 Supreme Court ruling that deliberate indifference to medical needs amounts to cruel and unusual punishment.
     
    Is being raped or murdered in prison also a form of cruel and unusual punishment? Or does it not count because it's not the state doing it? What about if the state is being deliberately indifferent towards rape and murder in prisons, such as for "chomos" (child molesters)?
    , @John Johnson
    @AP

    He got sick in jail, received medical care but it was too later and he died of his illness. He had been ill before he was arrested, some kind of heart problems.

    He spoke of getting double pneumonia and a collapsed lung but said nothing of the cause. No mention of COVID or complaints about getting something from the prisoners.

    Sure it is possible that he picked up something in prison but why wouldn't he state that?

    The guy chain smoked in his interviews. In one of the few videos he didn't remove you can see that one cigarette wasn't enough for the interview.

    Then he "just happens" to have lung problems in prison but doesn't ask his sister to contact the state department?

    I really don't like Anglin but he figured this one out. The guy wanted to die. Most likely had a terminal condition and wanted to go out as a martyr.

    Lira's fans seem to think he was a suppressed journalist that was killed by a Western conspiracy. Ok well let's see ONE essay from him on Russia since 2020. All I have seen are few videos where he chain smokes and talks about how Russia is about to win. He scrubbed all his "red pill" videos and there are few mentions of his wife. Highly suspicious.

    Replies: @AP

  301. @AP
    @Gerard1234


    You have never been to Poland, Russia or Ukraine and, as proven many times, can’t speak a word of any of their languages.
     
    All of this is untrue and you know it, you are trolling (probably to get me to say something that can get me doxed),, but in case someone else is reading this exchange, I did meet up with our former host, on one of my trips to Moscow:

    https://www.unz.com/akarlin/open-thread-40/

    https://i.imgur.com/aCRBRFv.png

    And I regularly posted photos of my travels.

    Look how quiet and undeveloped parts of central Moscow still were in the early 2000s. Looks like a provincial village but it's right off one of the boulevards:



    https://i.imgur.com/d4Frhiw.jpg

    https://i.imgur.com/LsyGyAx.jpg

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    That looks like no provincial village in any country I have ever seen. How drunk are you?

    • Replies: @AP
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    The first place pictured looks, okay, not like a village but like a small, quiet, sleepy provincial Russian town. Yet that was how parts of central Moscow were in the early 2000s. It was rather charming.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  302. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTBFfwGpA-xlIbveLZiyv2Jws7Y88Zz5p7uWA&usqp.jpg

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird, @Hyperborean, @Mr. XYZ

    It looks to me like the British got the choice cut. Clever.

  303. @Beckow
    @AP


    ...Why not Syria also? And North Korea?
     
    Because they are in Asia, get a map...

    Your lying about the recent history displays your desperation - or your very poor education. There were 3 million Polish commies....3 million, around 15% of adult population. So much for your Polish anti-communism...

    Small obvious points:
    - Habsburg Empire was substantially more brutal with prisons, poverty, mass emmigration and censorship than what followed after 1918. Period. No sane person in CE ever claims anything else and Habsburgs were never after 1918 asked back. We really don't care what was happening in Galicia pre-1918, it was a sh..thole province populated by Jews, Poles, Rusins, Romanians, with German overseers and massive emigration. Maybe that "Habsburg paradise" will come back, so you have that to look forward to.
    - Russia is winning the war in Ukraine. If you don't see it, I can't help you.
    - Polish troops invaded Czechoslovakia in 1968 - if they were "commies", what is this about you denying that Poles were also commies? Before that Poles invaded with Hitler after Munich in 1938. You can pretend that it didn't happen, but it just makes you look very, very stupid.

    In general, your obsessions about Habsburgs, Poles, commies, Russia, has led you to write some of the more bizarre hallucinations as if have created a completely made-up fake world - are you writing from a mental institution?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AP

    There were 3 million Polish commies….3 million, around 15% of adult population. So much for your Polish anti-communism…

    People conquered and under the Soviet yoke had to adapt for a time.

    But when it mattered – Polish armies fought the Soviets and kept them out of Western Europe in 1920. Poles fought the Soviets in 1939 (couldn’t win because the Germans had already attacked them) and in 1944-1945. And of course, Polish revolt ended Soviet rule in Eastern Europe in the 1980s.

    In Czechoslovakia there were 2.5 million Communist Party members in the late 1940s. In a country with a fraction of Poland’s population.

    Habsburg Empire was substantially more brutal with prisons, poverty, mass emmigration and censorship than what followed after 1918.

    For whom, and when? It was not more brutal than Nazi and Soviet rule.

    Based on executions, it was less brutal than England/Wales, Russia, and probably Germany.

    We really don’t care what was happening in Galicia pre-1918, it was a sh..thole province populated by Jews, Poles, Rusins, Romanians, with German overseers and massive emigration.

    It was about a rich (or as poor) as your Slovakia, and better educated. It was poorer than the other Austrian provinces, other than Dalmatia. But it was richer than Portugal, Russia and the Balkans.

    Russia is winning the war in Ukraine

    It is currently losing its Winter Offensive.

    You were claiming that Ukraine’s summer offensive failed, because Ukraine only captured 12 or so villages and stopped in order to conserve its soldiers and equipment.

    But what about Russia’s winter offensive, which so far has seen the gain of parts of Marinka, a slag heap outside Avdiivka, some forest patches near Bakhmut, and massive loss of men and equipment. Less gain for far more loss.

    Polish troops invaded Czechoslovakia in 1968

    25,000 Poles were forced to be part of the 450,000-strong Soviet invasion force by their Soviet captors.

    Before that Poles invaded with Hitler after Munich in 1938

    Poland was demanded and was given Polish-inhabited lands before the Germans could take them.

    You as a member of a Nazi lackey country feels bad that the Germans didn’t take that territory instead?

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Was Nazi Germany actually at risk of taking Teschen? It looks like there was still some remaining Czech territory in the way between the Sudetenland and Teschen:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/b5/Czechoslovakia_1939.SVG/1920px-Czechoslovakia_1939.SVG.png

    Or was Poland already anticipating the Nazi occupation of Czechia (which indeed happened in Mach 1939) back in late 1938?

    Replies: @AP, @Derer

  304. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AP

    That looks like no provincial village in any country I have ever seen. How drunk are you?

    Replies: @AP

    The first place pictured looks, okay, not like a village but like a small, quiet, sleepy provincial Russian town. Yet that was how parts of central Moscow were in the early 2000s. It was rather charming.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Could use more Central Asians, don't you think? And Hindus, Sikhs, and Jains, no?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  305. @AP
    @Beckow


    There were 3 million Polish commies….3 million, around 15% of adult population. So much for your Polish anti-communism…
     
    People conquered and under the Soviet yoke had to adapt for a time.

    But when it mattered - Polish armies fought the Soviets and kept them out of Western Europe in 1920. Poles fought the Soviets in 1939 (couldn't win because the Germans had already attacked them) and in 1944-1945. And of course, Polish revolt ended Soviet rule in Eastern Europe in the 1980s.

    In Czechoslovakia there were 2.5 million Communist Party members in the late 1940s. In a country with a fraction of Poland's population.

    Habsburg Empire was substantially more brutal with prisons, poverty, mass emmigration and censorship than what followed after 1918.
     
    For whom, and when? It was not more brutal than Nazi and Soviet rule.

    Based on executions, it was less brutal than England/Wales, Russia, and probably Germany.

    We really don’t care what was happening in Galicia pre-1918, it was a sh..thole province populated by Jews, Poles, Rusins, Romanians, with German overseers and massive emigration.
     
    It was about a rich (or as poor) as your Slovakia, and better educated. It was poorer than the other Austrian provinces, other than Dalmatia. But it was richer than Portugal, Russia and the Balkans.

    Russia is winning the war in Ukraine
     
    It is currently losing its Winter Offensive.

    You were claiming that Ukraine's summer offensive failed, because Ukraine only captured 12 or so villages and stopped in order to conserve its soldiers and equipment.

    But what about Russia's winter offensive, which so far has seen the gain of parts of Marinka, a slag heap outside Avdiivka, some forest patches near Bakhmut, and massive loss of men and equipment. Less gain for far more loss.

    Polish troops invaded Czechoslovakia in 1968
     
    25,000 Poles were forced to be part of the 450,000-strong Soviet invasion force by their Soviet captors.

    Before that Poles invaded with Hitler after Munich in 1938
     
    Poland was demanded and was given Polish-inhabited lands before the Germans could take them.

    You as a member of a Nazi lackey country feels bad that the Germans didn't take that territory instead?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Was Nazi Germany actually at risk of taking Teschen? It looks like there was still some remaining Czech territory in the way between the Sudetenland and Teschen:

    Or was Poland already anticipating the Nazi occupation of Czechia (which indeed happened in Mach 1939) back in late 1938?

    • Replies: @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    Germany claimed Bohumin but Poland demanded it form the Czechs and got it, this sparing the Polish population in Bohumin from being ruled by the Nazis.

    https://ipn.gov.pl/en/digital-resources/articles/7174,The-occupation-of-part-of-Cieszyn-Silesia-by-Poland-in-1938.html

    It bordered what the Germans took:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/07/PolishAnnexationsAfter1938.png

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    , @Derer
    @Mr. XYZ

    The behaviour of Horthy's (war criminal) Hungary was the most despicable by joining opportunistically Germany. After Stalingrad defeat they tried to kiss Stalin feet.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  306. @Beckow
    @German_reader

    In Serbia, Galicia, Volyn, Subcarpathia...previous to that in the Italian wars, look up Marshall Radetzky march that they play in Wien every New Year's Day, they don't play that march in Milano.

    Habsburgs were brutal as were the other powers at that time. The ahistorical claim that the mid-20th century brutality was very unusual and came out of nowhere is false - it grew out of the way major Euro powers acted for hundreds of years. The badly educated Americans who know only what they see in the movies weirdly worship the feudal societies and aristocrats ("knights") that their ancestors escaped to move to America.

    Predictably they demonize the locals who resisted and overthrew that system. Life under socialism ("commies") in the CE Europe was an order of magnitude better than life under the feudal systems and early capitalism. People like AP are not capable of understanding it so they fabulize about golden past that was destroyed by the 20th cent. socialists. But it was the 20th century socialism that created the prosperous Europe.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AnonfromTN, @German_reader, @AP

    [massacres during World War I] In Serbia, Galicia, Volyn, Subcarpathia

    In Galicia it was the Hungarians, not the Austrians. And they did not massacre entire villages.

    Habsburgs were brutal as were the other powers at that time

    Poles lived under Hapsburgs, Hohenzollerns and Romanovs. They know that Hapsburgs were clearly the best of the three. Under Hapsburgs, Prague became a Czech-speaking city. How did Dublin do under the British? Kiev under the Romanovs? What happened to the Sorbs under German rule?

    The ahistorical claim that the mid-20th century brutality was very unusual and came out of nowhere is false

    Nothing comes from nowhere, but don’t pretend 1933-1945 was no worse than 1860-1914.

    badly educated Americans who know only what they see in the movies weirdly worship the feudal societies

    Americans hate feudal societies. They sometimes like the British royal family but that’s ust celebrity worship. They only like the rich who talk like them and act like them. You are clueless as usual.

    Life under socialism (“commies”) in the CE Europe was an order of magnitude better than life under the feudal systems and early capitalism.

    That’s as stupid as giving Bolsheviks credit for antibiotics and electricity, as if it would not have occurred if not for them.

    Almost all countries improve over time. Even Socialist ones did. But they improved more slowly than the others, they fell far behind. Of the three post-war economic systems in Europe (Euro-capitalist, Socialist, and semi-fascist), Socialist was the least successful.

    History provided the experiment. Compare the performance of Austria (Euro-capitalist) to Czechoslovakia/Hungary (Socialist) and Spain/Portugal (quasi-fascist).

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.
    Hungary: $2,200.
    Spain: $2,186
    Portugal: $2,046

    So prior to Socialism, Czechoslovakia was richer than Austria, Hungary was poorer but similar, Portugal and Spain were poorer than both Hungary and Czechoslovakia.

    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Spain: $11,582.
    Portugal: $10,372

    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768
    Hungary: $6,903.

    Austria now became not only the richest of the three former Hapsburg countries, but doubled the ones that got stuck under Communism. This is the most relevant comparison because these three countries are geographically close, and culturally and historically similar.

    But you see, Portugal and Spain passed up Czechoslovakia and Hungary and were a lot richer per capita than those two Commie countries. Quasi-fascism beat Socialism.

    Life expectancy divergence matched the economic divergence.

    People like AP are not capable of understanding it so they fabulize about golden past that was destroyed by the 20th cent. socialists

    19th century actually was a Golden Age for Europe, it ended in 1914. You doubt it? Compare cultural products, global power, etc.

    But it was the 20th century socialism that created the prosperous Europe

    Europe was improving in prosperity prior to the 20th century. You are too poorly educated to know that, of course. Your socialist teachers filled you little brain with fairy tales of socialist saviors and evil kings and nobles keeping everyone in the same squalor from the Middle Age until the 1920s. And you were gullible enough to believe them.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_regions_by_past_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita#1750%E2%80%931990_(Bairoch)

    Between 1870 and 1913, Austria’s GDP per capita nearly doubled. Growth was accelerating, it had been slower before that. And there wasn’t much difference between Austria’s growth rate and that of non-monarchies or ones with powerless monarchs. It was universal in Europe.

    • Thanks: Mark G., Mr. Hack
    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    it ended in 1914.
     
    Thus making it all the more stupid to start WWI. Even if Austria-Hungary was morally entitled to crush Serbia, insisting on this moral entitlement, combined with Russian obstinance and hawkishness, resulted in a World War. Was a pro-Russian Serbia really so difficult to tolerate for A-H? If so, then A-H should have done regime change in Serbia back in 1904-1905 when Russia was still weak and busy fighting Japan rather than in 1914 when Russia was stronger and not busy elsewhere.

    A-H should have offered Serbia a deal: Serbia joins A-H as its own federal unit, thus creating Yugoslavia within A-H if Bosnia and perhaps some other territories (such as Dalmatia) would subsequently get added to this Serbian federal unit within A-H. Wouldn't that have been a much better outcome for everyone? A-H gets preserved *and* Serbs get their Yugoslavia. A similar deal could have been made with Romania but it would have first required breaking Magyar political power in Hungary and possibly having the Austrians win another A-H civil war.
    , @Gerard1234
    @AP


    Of the three post-war economic systems in Europe (Euro-capitalist, Socialist, and semi-fascist), Socialist was the least successful.
     
    Of course this is a nonsense statement. The salary numbers are stupid and You're comparing countries that didn't suffer much or at all in WW2.........with the majority of countries that did you imbecile. Countries that had access to money from untouched or relatively untouched by WW2 American, British, French, Scandinavian money/loans and investments - with ones that mostly received from a massively damaged from WW2 USSR and didn't have the China as it is now to help, and didn't have the advantage from the 1970's of the very good benefits that a communist China and USSR relationship would have had for Eastern Bloc if the problem between the 2 countries didn't happen. Even with all that it was a miracle how much the Soviets were able to rebuild and enhance in these countries

    Then you look at the global trade issue - British, French, American, Belgian scum etc were able to immediately take private ownership of the natural resources of these countries in Africa and Asia that declared themselves "independent". Those new Independent countries that wanted control of their own resources and nationalised companies for them, were either Marxist or Soviet sympathetic........and western scum ensured they f**ked up these countries with extensive sabotage efforts EVERY time for several decades. They could have advantage of globalised economy from former empire while destroying every place on the planet outside of Europe that could have helped Soviets and Eastern Bloc.

    It's obvious that with those disadvantages, the communist system did a brilliant and very successful job - defeated those facist and euro-capitalist countries in many aspects. For 25 years ( at least) a clear winner.

    If you knew or had every spoke to anyone who grew up in communist Czechoslovakia or Hungary ( which you haven't and won't as human garbage as yourself has never visited this part of the world) .......then you would hear the vast majority say that to be a kid then would have incredibly fun, adventurous and enriched lives you deranged idiot.

    As for the idiotic comparison with Spain and Portugal - both countries untouched by WW2, access to western capital.....and tourism is at least 10% of each of those countries GDP you imbecile, making any difference non-existent if you exclude tourism.

    Austria now became not only the richest of the three former Hapsburg countries, but doubled the ones that got stuck under Communism. This is the most relevant comparison because these three countries are geographically close, and culturally and historically similar.
     
    LOL - you are doing this stupid misdirection because its self-evidently retarded to be making comparisons of why Bulgaria or Romania wasn't as rich as Austria. Austria was much richer than what is stated in that fake link. Whatever the BS is your fake link, Vienna was one of the richest cities in Europe for centuries, and was part of the richest part of that empire

    But you see, Portugal and Spain passed up Czechoslovakia and Hungary and were a lot richer per capita than those two Commie countries. Quasi-fascism beat Socialism.
     
    LMFAO -as if you can make serious estimates of GDP immediately after WW2 you ridiculous cretin. How the f**k can you have relevant statistics for countries still rebuilding in 1947, dumbass? Austria did not suffer under the Nazi's like the Czechs, didn't degermanify, had no sudden switch from one system to the other. Didn't suffer as much population loss as Hungary. As I said, for over half a millenium Austrian land has been wealthier than what is now Czech and Hungarian land.

    Obviously in Poland, if you eliminate the Germans and import more Poles you are going to get a dumber and poorer population you moron. Obviously in Poland if you eliminate the Galician khokhols and import more Poles than you are going to get a less dumb and more productive population you moron.

    Hungary and particularly Czechs had large removal of german population after WW2. To anybody with a brain, the german factor is critical - not socialist, fascist or capitalist system you dumb prick. Anybody can make any argument they want - degermanification, non-Protestant, Catholic,Orthodox, atheist - affected by population loss and physical damage from WW2 etc.

    That’s as stupid as giving Bolsheviks credit for antibiotics and electricity, as if it would not have occurred if not for them.
     
    20th century socialism, CLEARLY is reponsible for Israeli tech sector you dipshit. 1990s economic growth and IT development in western economies is partially explained by ideas, human capital and other resources from Eastern Bloc after communist collapse. It doesn't explain all but certainly some of it

    Anyway, 100 years before - industrialisation ( alot of it fueled by colonialism and the raw material from it) resulted in masses of people flooding into towns and cities to work in the factories. People having the same amount of children as they had in rural areas, but now in urban, living filthy lives and breathing unclean air, not able to grown their own produce and feed themselves like when they were poor but had their own land to grow produce in the countryside. Rich got even more wealthier and owned more land and properties.....while by comparison the rest were working longer , but limited social mobility...while having the intellectual ability and urge to group together and form political groups. Whatever rises in medical science and education ( at best nothing more than not being illiterate) did not compensate for the problems in this new social situation.Without communism this unfair position would not have been corrected. WW1 had nothing to do with it. Either countries became communist or several of these western states implemented very communist social and even economic and engineering/ architectural policies to appease large section of their populations

    Anyway - what does it say that socialist Cuba is FAR richer than Banderastan???!!! LOL

    Comparisons between European countries are very misleading........better comparison would be with the disaster that is American control of South and central America . Capitalist in Latin American with close relation with Pindostan - extremely chaotic and not rich. Communist/Socialist - f**ked up by the Americans every time. Dictatorship - see capitalist.

    America gives the world the produce of the cocaine barons from Colombia and creates most of the heroin trade from Afghanistan. With Soviets this sick filth would never have happened.

    Germany today still has significant difference ( though both still wealthy by most of Europe standards) in wealth of east german land compared to west germany, despite trillions invested and 35 years since end of communism

    19th century actually was a Golden Age for Europe, it ended in 1914. You doubt it? Compare cultural products, global power, etc.
     
    For the retard who was exposed as completely inept and not knowing at all the foreign blood in every single European monarchy.......its just sick fantasist nonsense that you would then come up with this new statement. Very bizarre.

    Americans hate feudal societies. They sometimes like the British royal family but that’s ust celebrity worship. They only like the rich who talk like them and act like them. You are clueless as usual.
     
    Nonsense, Beckow is correct. Kennedy family , Bush family, ( if he wasn't such another american sleazebag) then Clinton family. Cuomo's in New York. Even the way the mafia control appears to have been viewed. That the so-called anti-elite politician, Trump, is probably one of the most "elite" of them all and doesn't appear to have any entrepreneur ability or the ability to actually make money and generate jobs, like a Henry Ford, create anything and involved in New York real estate market......supports Beckow's position.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

  307. @AP
    @Mikel


    Cut the crap with your requests for “evidence” and “proof”.
     
    You keep repeating that he was "killed." Prove it.

    He got sick in jail, received medical care but it was too later and he died of his illness. He had been ill before he was arrested, some kind of heart problems. Even in a rich country like the USA people die of illnesses while incarcerated.

    You can’t possibly be so thick to be unaware of how pathetic your attempts to normalize the death of an American political prisoner in a European prison sound.
     
    Now he is a political prisoner?

    Do you consider the 93 year old German lady sentenced to prison for saying the Holocaust didn't happen to also be a political prisoner? You keep ignoring these examples.

    The closest equivalent we could find is perhaps Assange, also outrageous in its own way, but he is not an American imprisoned in a vassal country where the US is sending money to pay for the salaries of his very captors
     
    So you are suggesting that Ukraine isn't a puppet after all?

    Or are you going to go with the story that since Lira hated the USA, Ukraine was doing the USA's bidding by "killing" him.

    The reality is far more simple and straightforward (as is often the case). He chose to go to a different country, broke its laws, was arrested, got sick, and died. The prison administrators waited too long to provide medical care (as happens in prisons in the USA too) though they did eventually.

    You wanted him to get better care in the Ukrainian prison than many Americans get in American prisons?

    https://www.vera.org/news/health-care-behind-bars-missed-appointments-no-standards-and-high-costs

    The abysmal state of health care behind bars bears much of the blame for those figures. Medical neglect kills hundreds of incarcerated people every year despite the 1976 Supreme Court ruling that deliberate indifference to medical needs amounts to cruel and unusual punishment.

    :::::::::::::

    The Ukrainians even released him to house arrest. What did he do? Choose to skip bail and head for the border, while publicly announcing what he was doing.

    So the moron ended up in prison again, where he got sick and died.

    This is your "martyr."

    And of course the British wouldn’t let him die in prison of an untreated illness like a rabid dog.
     
    Lira got treatment. They waited too long, as is typical of prisons (not only in Ukraine), and it failed.

    I don’t remember running into private armies on my visits to Ukraine. Or Russia, for that matter.

    Perhaps Gerard is right after all? I don’t know now but in the 90s you would find gangsters at the lobbies of any hotel in the ex-USSR countries
     
    We weren't talking about gangsters, we were talking about "private armies" that you claimed Ukraine and Russia were full of. Why are you switching? I was in Ukraine in 1990 and Russia for the first time in 1999, otherwise I missed the 90s. And I avoided hotels and places where shady people go. The shadiest place I went to was Gorbushka in Moscow, a place to buy cheap pirated software.

    ETA killed hundreds of Spanish police officers, soldiers, politicians, journalists and innocent civilians deep inside Spain that had nothing to do whatsoever with the Basque conflict, while certain parts of the Basque Country remained no-go areas for the police. There were always voices that demanded retribution but Spain spent decades combating this plague with the rule of law and negotiations.
     
    Which cities did ETA control and did they try to advance on other cities in order to conquer them?

    You are comparing terrorism with civil war.

    As I said, no western European country had Ukraine's situation.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @John Johnson

    despite the 1976 Supreme Court ruling that deliberate indifference to medical needs amounts to cruel and unusual punishment.

    Is being raped or murdered in prison also a form of cruel and unusual punishment? Or does it not count because it’s not the state doing it? What about if the state is being deliberately indifferent towards rape and murder in prisons, such as for “chomos” (child molesters)?

  308. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @sudden death

    His second most highest achievement is he was a first week adopter of the corona virus "vaccine". Hanania, who seems to be his leading living guide is a booster of the boosters and goes as far as to say injecting all these people with an experimental gene medicine is like the greatest feat of all humans in the 21st century.

    Have you ever heard of Dan Quayle? Before Kamela Harris he was the most dumbest American Vice President. There was an old Negro College Fund ad that television stations used to broadcast when they were required to allocate time for public service announcements and they said (every damn day)


    A mind is a terrible thing to waste.
     
    Dan Quayle was well known for inserting inappropriate mangled quotations. His best maybe was

    It is a terrible thing for a mind to be wasted.
     
    I don't know what the context was. It's not a good thing, what is now going on in Karlin's mind. : (

    Replies: @sudden death

    Dan Quayle

    These days he looks like he could go straight into Hollywood main role in case if they decide to make new biopic about FDR;)

  309. @AP
    @Beckow


    [massacres during World War I] In Serbia, Galicia, Volyn, Subcarpathia
     
    In Galicia it was the Hungarians, not the Austrians. And they did not massacre entire villages.

    Habsburgs were brutal as were the other powers at that time
     
    Poles lived under Hapsburgs, Hohenzollerns and Romanovs. They know that Hapsburgs were clearly the best of the three. Under Hapsburgs, Prague became a Czech-speaking city. How did Dublin do under the British? Kiev under the Romanovs? What happened to the Sorbs under German rule?

    The ahistorical claim that the mid-20th century brutality was very unusual and came out of nowhere is false
     
    Nothing comes from nowhere, but don't pretend 1933-1945 was no worse than 1860-1914.

    badly educated Americans who know only what they see in the movies weirdly worship the feudal societies
     
    Americans hate feudal societies. They sometimes like the British royal family but that's ust celebrity worship. They only like the rich who talk like them and act like them. You are clueless as usual.

    Life under socialism (“commies”) in the CE Europe was an order of magnitude better than life under the feudal systems and early capitalism.
     
    That's as stupid as giving Bolsheviks credit for antibiotics and electricity, as if it would not have occurred if not for them.

    Almost all countries improve over time. Even Socialist ones did. But they improved more slowly than the others, they fell far behind. Of the three post-war economic systems in Europe (Euro-capitalist, Socialist, and semi-fascist), Socialist was the least successful.

    History provided the experiment. Compare the performance of Austria (Euro-capitalist) to Czechoslovakia/Hungary (Socialist) and Spain/Portugal (quasi-fascist).

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.
    Hungary: $2,200.
    Spain: $2,186
    Portugal: $2,046

    So prior to Socialism, Czechoslovakia was richer than Austria, Hungary was poorer but similar, Portugal and Spain were poorer than both Hungary and Czechoslovakia.

    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Spain: $11,582.
    Portugal: $10,372

    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768
    Hungary: $6,903.

    Austria now became not only the richest of the three former Hapsburg countries, but doubled the ones that got stuck under Communism. This is the most relevant comparison because these three countries are geographically close, and culturally and historically similar.

    But you see, Portugal and Spain passed up Czechoslovakia and Hungary and were a lot richer per capita than those two Commie countries. Quasi-fascism beat Socialism.

    Life expectancy divergence matched the economic divergence.

    People like AP are not capable of understanding it so they fabulize about golden past that was destroyed by the 20th cent. socialists
     
    19th century actually was a Golden Age for Europe, it ended in 1914. You doubt it? Compare cultural products, global power, etc.

    But it was the 20th century socialism that created the prosperous Europe
     
    Europe was improving in prosperity prior to the 20th century. You are too poorly educated to know that, of course. Your socialist teachers filled you little brain with fairy tales of socialist saviors and evil kings and nobles keeping everyone in the same squalor from the Middle Age until the 1920s. And you were gullible enough to believe them.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_regions_by_past_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita#1750%E2%80%931990_(Bairoch)

    Between 1870 and 1913, Austria's GDP per capita nearly doubled. Growth was accelerating, it had been slower before that. And there wasn't much difference between Austria's growth rate and that of non-monarchies or ones with powerless monarchs. It was universal in Europe.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Gerard1234

    it ended in 1914.

    Thus making it all the more stupid to start WWI. Even if Austria-Hungary was morally entitled to crush Serbia, insisting on this moral entitlement, combined with Russian obstinance and hawkishness, resulted in a World War. Was a pro-Russian Serbia really so difficult to tolerate for A-H? If so, then A-H should have done regime change in Serbia back in 1904-1905 when Russia was still weak and busy fighting Japan rather than in 1914 when Russia was stronger and not busy elsewhere.

    A-H should have offered Serbia a deal: Serbia joins A-H as its own federal unit, thus creating Yugoslavia within A-H if Bosnia and perhaps some other territories (such as Dalmatia) would subsequently get added to this Serbian federal unit within A-H. Wouldn’t that have been a much better outcome for everyone? A-H gets preserved *and* Serbs get their Yugoslavia. A similar deal could have been made with Romania but it would have first required breaking Magyar political power in Hungary and possibly having the Austrians win another A-H civil war.

  310. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Was Nazi Germany actually at risk of taking Teschen? It looks like there was still some remaining Czech territory in the way between the Sudetenland and Teschen:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/b5/Czechoslovakia_1939.SVG/1920px-Czechoslovakia_1939.SVG.png

    Or was Poland already anticipating the Nazi occupation of Czechia (which indeed happened in Mach 1939) back in late 1938?

    Replies: @AP, @Derer

    Germany claimed Bohumin but Poland demanded it form the Czechs and got it, this sparing the Polish population in Bohumin from being ruled by the Nazis.

    https://ipn.gov.pl/en/digital-resources/articles/7174,The-occupation-of-part-of-Cieszyn-Silesia-by-Poland-in-1938.html

    It bordered what the Germans took:

    • Thanks: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Thanks for clarifying this part!

    BTW, off-topic, but do you think that Russia made a mistake in not supporting the Hungarians back in 1848-1849? After all, Austria(-Hungary) subsequently ended up being a rather troublesome partner and ally for Russia. I suspect that an independent Russian-aligned Hungary would have been more pliable to future Russian designs in the Balkans. It would likely have to be since Russia could always engage in regime change in such a Hungary and install a Hungarian government more to its own liking. Or, alternatively, supporting separatist movements in this Hungary. Magyar nationalists certainly aren't going to want that!

  311. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    Germany claimed Bohumin but Poland demanded it form the Czechs and got it, this sparing the Polish population in Bohumin from being ruled by the Nazis.

    https://ipn.gov.pl/en/digital-resources/articles/7174,The-occupation-of-part-of-Cieszyn-Silesia-by-Poland-in-1938.html

    It bordered what the Germans took:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/07/PolishAnnexationsAfter1938.png

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Thanks for clarifying this part!

    BTW, off-topic, but do you think that Russia made a mistake in not supporting the Hungarians back in 1848-1849? After all, Austria(-Hungary) subsequently ended up being a rather troublesome partner and ally for Russia. I suspect that an independent Russian-aligned Hungary would have been more pliable to future Russian designs in the Balkans. It would likely have to be since Russia could always engage in regime change in such a Hungary and install a Hungarian government more to its own liking. Or, alternatively, supporting separatist movements in this Hungary. Magyar nationalists certainly aren’t going to want that!

  312. @songbird
    Thought AP had great affinity for Lat-Ams, but one guy from the Southern Cone moves to Ukraine and marries a local girl and he seems to be rejoicing in his liquidation.

    Would hate to think what he would do if a Guatamalan moved there...

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    AP dislikes people who are hostile towards Ukraine, especially if they also move to Ukraine.

    AP indeed likes Latin Americans, as do I. I also like law-abiding blacks. Though both blacks and Hispanics have a worse dysgenics problem relative to whites. Voluntary eugenics on a huge scale should hopefully fix or at least reduce this problem. It’s sad that the duller average groups on average have more dysgenic fertility as well.

  313. AP, I have a question for you: Had Russia avoided decades of Bolshevik/Communist rule, either with or without WWI, do you eventually see there being large-scale migration to Russia from the countries further to the south? FWIW, I’m assuming that Central Asia remains part of Russia in this TL; rather, I’m talking about countries like Turkey, Iran, Afghanistan, Mongolia, China, Korea, the Arab world, and South Asia. Could there be tens of millions of migrants from these countries moving to Russia over the decades (or more) in this TL, perhaps encouraged by liberal Russian Jews in their pro-immigration activism?

  314. Karlin was always threatening to drop his magnum opus about the coming great bifurcation on us, but instead we got one about the great sissification, lol

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @sudden death

    In part Karlin's manifesto is a religious tract. All this talk about AI, the singularity etc. making all other issues irrelevant is quite eschatological.
    The anti-nationalist elements may of course be true to some extent, maybe it's really over for nations in any traditional sense (at least in the West). But in Karlin's case it's just motivated by pure spite, as he pretty much admits himself, by his own experiences as a deracinated immigrant who ended up disappointed when he returned to the country of his parents.

    Replies: @Sher Singh, @Barbarossa

  315. German_reader says:
    @songbird
    Would like to see A123 and GR cowrite a monster movie where slugs loosely representing America take over Europe. I suggest that they be brain-slugs like in Heinlein's Puppeteers , that would help explain the total alignment on policy.

    Replies: @German_reader

    Would like to see A123 and GR cowrite a monster movie where slugs loosely representing America take over Europe.

    I think the creative differences would be too large for such an undertaking. A123 would insist on a re-write where the slugs are actually German and control Biden’s government (maybe have a scene where it’s shown Biden is comatose in reality and only able to function once a slug has slipped through his ear and is controlling his brain, like in that early Star Trek: Next generation episode with the alien parasites). Hero of the movie would be a Trumpite Judeo-Christian from Arkansas or some other Southern state who’s constantly wearing an “I love Israel” pin on his shirt.

    • LOL: songbird
    • Replies: @QCIC
    @German_reader

    The slugs would have to be Islamo-slugs.

    , @A123
    @German_reader



    Would like to see A123 and GR cowrite a monster movie where slugs loosely representing America take over Europe.
     
    I think the creative differences would be too large for such an undertaking. A123 would insist on a re-write where the slugs are actually German and control Biden’s government (maybe have a scene where it’s shown Biden is comatose in reality and only able to function once a slug has slipped through his ear and is controlling his brain
     
    A one-shot orignial movie needs to wrap everything up with a happy ending in 90-120 minutes. Start with the end "The Hero gets The Girl" and work back towards the start.

    Trying to use Biden over complicates the ending:

    -- If terminating brain slugs doesn't fix Biden, does that mean Kamala takes over 😱? Not an acceptable ending.
    -- If both Kamala and Biden expire to brain slugs that would leave President Johnson, but bog the story with Constitutional exposition. Also, does this mean everyone with a brain slug dies? That could be a grim ending rather than happy one.

    It is easier to tie up loose ends if the sluggo President is only stylistically Biden-esque. The VP can then been portrayed as a competent white male avoiding the Kamala taint. When the veggie expires, an established character is sworn in and attempts to contact the hero. Queue "James Bond" style ending where the new President cannot reach the Hero.... (Nudge, nudge. wink, wink.)

    It also provides good material for the start of the story. The VP knows that the administration has been comprised. Therefore, he must go outside of the normal chain, instead contacting a plucky rogue. This sets our Hero, played by Alan Ritchson, into motion.

    The Girl can be an incredibly hot, blue eyed, blonde haired, mini skirt wearing German scientist coerced into working for Supreme Loathsome Unlimited Government [SLUG] against her will. The Hero will rescue The Girl who shares her knowledge thus ending the SLUG and slug threats. The villain would be some maniacal Merkel-esque figure plotting for whatever reason Bond villains plot.

    Yes... I pivoted from a monster movie to a camp action spy movie.... Sue me.


    @ G_R
    Judeo-Christian ... constantly wearing an “I love Israel” pin on his shirt.

    @ QCIC
    The slugs would have to be Islamo-slugs.
     

    Inserting religion into movies carries the same sort of problems as inserting SJW. Unless essential to the plot, it is to be avoided. It risks slowing things down. And, there would be all sorts of problematic questions, for example:

    Why are Germans using Islamo-slugs?

    -- Has Germany already quietly taken over one or more Muslim countries? The movie ending would have to contend with that.
    -- Or, has Germany been taken over? I suspect that G_R would object to America once again riding to Germany's rescue.

    All off this would distract from the core proposition, "The Hero gets The Girl". For a one-shot original movie, simple is better. Leave all of this out.

     

    You do not like my idea? Compare it to what Hollywood is putting out.

    Have you heard about Echo? It is an intersectional tale where the heroine is a female, Native American, body positivity, deaf, amputee with daddy issues.

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Ap5U7byBnSw

    Yes. My proposal contains more cheese than a Velveeta factory. But, people do buy cheese... And, enjoy it for what it is.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @QCIC

  316. Meanwhile half of winter is gone, but the things are going nicely in EU and should remain so in spring, unless the new ice age will begin to come over during the remaining winter half;)

    European natural gas futures climbed above €31 per megawatt-hour on Friday, but they are on track for an over 8% weekly loss. This decline is attributed to ample gas supplies resulting from prolonged mild weather in the region, despite the ongoing cold snap. The mild conditions led to reduced gas consumption for heating and lowered production by energy-intensive companies, resulting in decreased overall demand. Consequently, regional gas storage levels remain high, exceeding typical levels for this time of year. With current stockpiles around 82% after starting the season at 90%, Europe is expected to enter spring with over half of its underground gas storage capacity still available, surpassing the 10-year average of 35%.

    https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/eu-natural-gas

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @sudden death


    things are going nicely in EU
     
    European natural gas prices have fallen massively from 2022 levels, so why is European manufacturing doing so badly?

    Because even with all the declines since 2022 natural gas prices are over 60% ABOVE their historical averages. There's a huge adverse energy shock hitting Europe.

    Replies: @sudden death

  317. German_reader says:
    @sudden death
    Karlin was always threatening to drop his magnum opus about the coming great bifurcation on us, but instead we got one about the great sissification, lol

    Replies: @German_reader

    In part Karlin’s manifesto is a religious tract. All this talk about AI, the singularity etc. making all other issues irrelevant is quite eschatological.
    The anti-nationalist elements may of course be true to some extent, maybe it’s really over for nations in any traditional sense (at least in the West). But in Karlin’s case it’s just motivated by pure spite, as he pretty much admits himself, by his own experiences as a deracinated immigrant who ended up disappointed when he returned to the country of his parents.

    • Replies: @Sher Singh
    @German_reader

    I don't really get how he failed to integrate both in America & Russia - I assume the UK as well.
    I don't really feel alienated from Western or Eastern society & you guys see my antics.

    It says something that his 3rd culture or w/e posts attracted tranny Laxa.

    I think a lot of this is knowing your own & other people's limits.
    --
    Not everyone is going to be your best friend.

    Every relationship requires sacrifice - whether logistics, time, annoyance.
    If it's not worth it then cut loose & you'll be happier.
    --
    Have a few hobbies that you're passionate (autistic) about & that routine will keep you going.
    Prayer, fitness, family.

    War.

    https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/825657548765921280/1013311527320825926/IMG_8968.png?ex=65b5dee6&is=65a369e6&hm=b283d3113f3a048a3280272732a1ba6d8b7ac951c41c4c95450b18845165f82c&
    ਅਕਾਲ

    Replies: @German_reader

    , @Barbarossa
    @German_reader

    I'm out of the loop, but I would be interested in reading Karlin's manifesto for whatever it says about the mindset he espouses nowadays. Where can it be found?

  318. @German_reader
    @Mikel

    The problem with any forum really is that familiarity breeds contempt. Over time you start to get into an antagonistic relationship with other users, maybe even into long-running "feuds", mutual grievances accumulate and in the end you don't have anything to say to each other anymore, because the fundamental differences are just too irreconcilable.
    I suppose to some extent it might just be me, but I've encountered such dynamics in every forum I ever participated in (this one here was by no means the worst btw, and I suspect without the war in Ukraine things wouldn't have gotten as ugly as they did). As for Twitter, unlike Yevardian I don't see that as an alternative. I tried it for a few weeks, and found the experience stressful and rather toxic.
    But yes, given the decline in active users, the mutual antagonisms, and the exhausting focus on Ukraine to the exclusion of everything else there doesn't seem to be much life left here anymore (also noteworthy how Hyperborean who popped up after several years of absence already seems to have left again).
    Anyway, who knows, maybe 2024 will see some sort of resolution to the war in Ukraine (or at least freeze the fighting); here's another possible sign:
    https://www.ft.com/content/e0c9a4bb-903a-48d9-b44c-f26b445499b0


    Italy’s defence minister Guido Crosetto has called for greater diplomatic efforts to end the war between Russia and Ukraine, despite Kyiv’s warnings that Moscow has no intention to do so.

    Crosetto told a parliamentary hearing on Wednesday that Italy would seek “a dual-track strategy” with military support for Kyiv to be coupled with more engagements towards a “negotiated settlement”.

    “We must be realistic and cannot ignore the military situation on the field,” Crosetto said as lawmakers approved more bilateral aid to Kyiv. “The time seems to have come for effective diplomatic action.”

     


    Yet in a sober analysis of Ukraine’s military and political strengths, Crosetto, who was previously president of Italy’s defence industry association, expressed concern about “the real Ukrainian ability to counter Russian forces . . . in a condition of persistent numerical and air inferiority”.

    “Unfortunately, Ukraine’s summer counteroffensive did not give the desired results,” he said, warning that 2024 would be a “critical year” for Ukraine’s future.

    He insisted diplomatic efforts would run in tandem with continued military aid for Ukraine — of which Italy is now preparing an eighth package, just as it has assumed the presidency of the G7.

    “We have two paths: that of aid without ‘ifs and buts’ — and that of attempting to build a diplomatic path that brings us to the end of the conflict,” he said. “The coming months will have to balance deterrence and diplomacy.”

    But Crosetto also said talks could only begin if Russia ceased its missile and drone attacks on Ukraine. “We can start talking when the bombs stop falling,” he said. “We have to convince those who are attacking to stop.”

     

    Replies: @Beckow, @Mikel, @Hyperborean

    I suppose to some extent it might just be me, but I’ve encountered such dynamics in every forum I ever participated in (this one here was by no means the worst btw, and I suspect without the war in Ukraine things wouldn’t have gotten as ugly as they did). As for Twitter, unlike Yevardian I don’t see that as an alternative. I tried it for a few weeks, and found the experience stressful and rather toxic.

    But yes, given the decline in active users, the mutual antagonisms, and the exhausting focus on Ukraine to the exclusion of everything else there doesn’t seem to be much life left here anymore (also noteworthy how Hyperborean who popped up after several years of absence already seems to have left again).

    I decided to occasionally check every couple of threads and skim read them. I don’t really feel like I have much to say; a lot of people are either repeating the same arguments about the same old topics as they did five years ago (even though they know they will never agree) or picking “beef” with others. Unless one is monetising one’s online presence, after a certain point it starts to head towards diminishing marginal utility.

    If it’s any consolation it isn’t just Unz’ Wacky House of Weirdos that’s gone insane, mainstream internet forums have been just as bad recently. The Russo-Ukrainian War and especially the Gaza War have ruined large sections of general internet forums that don’t explicitly exclude or silo (geo)-political discussion.

    I tried having an active Twitter account a few years back, but I recognised that I can’t handle the way the algorithm encourages attention-seeking and ruins one’s mental health like the mentally ill streamer girl in the game Needy Girl Overdose so I deleted it. So now I just check in on a couple of people who tend to post interesting statistics or articles.

    I did read your comments about Karlin’s manifesto and the “Rightoids Go to Jail” section. I noted the same thing about his very online mentality, a lot of the people he mentions are microcelebrities at best (though curiously no mention of failson Richard Spencer). Hilarious anecdotes, but rather niche in terms of actual real life political presence.

    Personally, I would have been interested in reading about his time in the Bay Area and the Effective Altruism sphere. I’m sure there’s enough weirdos and quirky people to talk about that he could make a blog post about it, even without bringing up nasty disputes.

    • Agree: LT1488
    • Replies: @German_reader
    @Hyperborean


    though curiously no mention of failson Richard Spencer
     
    He did write quite a bit about Spencer earlier in his manifesto, in this part:
    https://akarlin.com/soypill-manifesto/

    I agree with your assessment both of this comments space and the internet in general. I often feel it would be better, if I went totally silent (not like writing comments on the net changes anything anyway), but alas, I haven't been able to muster up the necessary will power so far.

    EDIT: @Barbarossa: It's on Karlin's site https://akarlin.com/ (in four parts, with more than 50 000 words...).

  319. Sher Singh says:
    @German_reader
    @sudden death

    In part Karlin's manifesto is a religious tract. All this talk about AI, the singularity etc. making all other issues irrelevant is quite eschatological.
    The anti-nationalist elements may of course be true to some extent, maybe it's really over for nations in any traditional sense (at least in the West). But in Karlin's case it's just motivated by pure spite, as he pretty much admits himself, by his own experiences as a deracinated immigrant who ended up disappointed when he returned to the country of his parents.

    Replies: @Sher Singh, @Barbarossa

    I don’t really get how he failed to integrate both in America & Russia – I assume the UK as well.
    I don’t really feel alienated from Western or Eastern society & you guys see my antics.

    It says something that his 3rd culture or w/e posts attracted tranny Laxa.

    I think a lot of this is knowing your own & other people’s limits.

    Not everyone is going to be your best friend.

    Every relationship requires sacrifice – whether logistics, time, annoyance.
    If it’s not worth it then cut loose & you’ll be happier.

    Have a few hobbies that you’re passionate (autistic) about & that routine will keep you going.
    Prayer, fitness, family.

    [MORE]

    War.


    ਅਕਾਲ

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @Sher Singh


    I don’t really get how he failed to integrate both in America & Russia – I assume the UK as well.
     
    His accent was very thick, to a surprising extent. I assume that alone would have been a formidable barrier to integration.
    I got the impression he had quite a bit of resentment about his life story...his parents (scientists, so members of the Soviet Union's intellectual elite) being forced to emigrate because of the collapse of their country, and he having to grow up in a foreign country (in Preston, of all places) where he never felt he quite belonged. Like he was robbed of his rightful heritage. It's pretty sad actually.

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

  320. • Replies: @Derer
    @Sher Singh

    I have the same sentiment. They keep rebuilding wooden shacks just to be destroyed by tornadoes again - economic activity, good for a fake GDP.

    Replies: @Sher Singh

  321. @sudden death
    Meanwhile half of winter is gone, but the things are going nicely in EU and should remain so in spring, unless the new ice age will begin to come over during the remaining winter half;)

    European natural gas futures climbed above €31 per megawatt-hour on Friday, but they are on track for an over 8% weekly loss. This decline is attributed to ample gas supplies resulting from prolonged mild weather in the region, despite the ongoing cold snap. The mild conditions led to reduced gas consumption for heating and lowered production by energy-intensive companies, resulting in decreased overall demand. Consequently, regional gas storage levels remain high, exceeding typical levels for this time of year. With current stockpiles around 82% after starting the season at 90%, Europe is expected to enter spring with over half of its underground gas storage capacity still available, surpassing the 10-year average of 35%.
     
    https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/eu-natural-gas

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    things are going nicely in EU

    European natural gas prices have fallen massively from 2022 levels, so why is European manufacturing doing so badly?

    Because even with all the declines since 2022 natural gas prices are over 60% ABOVE their historical averages. There’s a huge adverse energy shock hitting Europe.

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Truly "badly" doing was during initial coronavirus shutdowns, what has been happening since&lately - just fluctuations in a very volatile geopolitical/economical environment over last 2 years and even not that much different from longterm trends in big picture:

    https://i.postimg.cc/RZ73YWYR/EU-Industrial-production-for-total-industry-and-main-industrial-groupings-2010-2023-15-11-2023.png

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

  322. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @sudden death


    things are going nicely in EU
     
    European natural gas prices have fallen massively from 2022 levels, so why is European manufacturing doing so badly?

    Because even with all the declines since 2022 natural gas prices are over 60% ABOVE their historical averages. There's a huge adverse energy shock hitting Europe.

    Replies: @sudden death

    Truly “badly” doing was during initial coronavirus shutdowns, what has been happening since&lately – just fluctuations in a very volatile geopolitical/economical environment over last 2 years and even not that much different from longterm trends in big picture:

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @sudden death


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GC2o0xAWIAA4cR4.jpg

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GC2mG_1WEAAfzPB.jpg

    Replies: @QCIC

  323. @songbird
    The mayors of Berlin, London, and Paris ought to each sit on thrones made from melting all the knives from their criminals together.

    https://www.amren.com/news/2024/01/germany-knife-crime-reaches-10-year-high-in-berlin-as-immigration-soars/

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    [MORE]

    • Thanks: songbird
  324. @sudden death
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Truly "badly" doing was during initial coronavirus shutdowns, what has been happening since&lately - just fluctuations in a very volatile geopolitical/economical environment over last 2 years and even not that much different from longterm trends in big picture:

    https://i.postimg.cc/RZ73YWYR/EU-Industrial-production-for-total-industry-and-main-industrial-groupings-2010-2023-15-11-2023.png

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Many and possibly most German export products have relatively high value-added. This business model is based on applying large amounts of capital to production. It strikes me as slightly odd that their economy should be hit so hard by energy costs. If one is making commodity products energy costs may be a very important factor in the price, but as value-added goes up this effect should decrease.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  325. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTBFfwGpA-xlIbveLZiyv2Jws7Y88Zz5p7uWA&usqp.jpg

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird, @Hyperborean, @Mr. XYZ

    Not really a masterpiece or anything, but in The Place Promised in Our Early Days, Hokkaido is part of a Soviet Zone, while the rest is American.

    [MORE]

    BTW, I like the Japanese penchant for long titles. I feel like English titles tend towards the banal because they are too short. IMO, not every title should be one or two words.

  326. @Mr. Hack
    @Barbarossa

    What Indian snacks do you enjoy eating and would recommend? Here in Phoenix Land we have a great discount food store where I buy all sorts of treats at bargain basement prices. Recently, I was buying these great "Kind" and "Larabar" fruit and nut bars for $.10 a piece, even a few godiva chocolate bars for this ridiculously low price. I went there yesterday to repurchase some $.49 cans of cat food (my 3 feral cats scarf them down in no time), and was disappointed that the fruit bars (that had been on sale there for at least 2 months) were finally all gone. :-( I regularly buy all sorts of Starbucks coffees there between $3 - $6 per bag, the same ones that cost $7 - $11 per bag in the regular stores.

    On the upside, I did find some great 5 oz Terra Sweet Potato chips for $.99 a bag. Have you looked at the prices on potato chips in the regular grocery stores lately? $3 - $6 bucks a bag, highway robbery if you ask me, especially if you consider that you can still pick up a 5lb bag of great quality whole potatoes for only $3.

    Replies: @Barbarossa, @songbird

    Have you never made your own potato chips?

    It was quite common in my grandmother’s day (as was making your own bread and donuts) Not quite sure how they did it. From what I can find, looks like a lot of effort. TBH, I would probably much prefer baked slices of potatoes or roasted potatoes.

    Only one of those discount food stores I recall ever seeing is a Pepperidge Farm one with their goldfish crackers, which seems remarkably niche. AFAIK, they went out of business like 20 years ago.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    I enjoy eating potatoes anyway I get them. At home, I usually just bake or boil them (at least once or twice a week.. I'm glad to see that our health food gurus seem to have taken them off of the verboten list, alongside eggs, butter, bacon, etc. I'm patiently waiting for bread to be taken off of this list too, although I continued to eat all of these items during these draconian times. I've always enjoyed eating potato chips throughout my life, although since I'm trying to limit my salt intake, try to limit eating them all of the time. I don' think that I'll take up making potato chips anytime soon, and stick to eating potatoes in the usual manner. The Discount grocery stores here come and go...they last about 10 years and then disappear only to have other ones take their place in a few years. They're fun to visit and you never know what you might find. The last one had all sorts of different TV dinners, the new one doesn't, all for the best, probably...

    Replies: @songbird

  327. @German_reader
    @songbird


    Would like to see A123 and GR cowrite a monster movie where slugs loosely representing America take over Europe.
     
    I think the creative differences would be too large for such an undertaking. A123 would insist on a re-write where the slugs are actually German and control Biden's government (maybe have a scene where it's shown Biden is comatose in reality and only able to function once a slug has slipped through his ear and is controlling his brain, like in that early Star Trek: Next generation episode with the alien parasites). Hero of the movie would be a Trumpite Judeo-Christian from Arkansas or some other Southern state who's constantly wearing an "I love Israel" pin on his shirt.

    Replies: @QCIC, @A123

    The slugs would have to be Islamo-slugs.

    • Agree: songbird
  328. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTBFfwGpA-xlIbveLZiyv2Jws7Y88Zz5p7uWA&usqp.jpg

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird, @Hyperborean, @Mr. XYZ

    Very strange map, which alt-history story did you get this one from? Unless the Second World War turned out radically different it’s highly implausible.

    First, it would just be the People’s Republic of Japan. Not People’s Republic of North Japan. Any of the cold war divided states would never relinquish their claims over the other half of the country.

    Second, South Korea suggests Korea still got divided into an American and Soviet zone. Previously occupied countries in the immediate
    post-war era usually didn’t get to participate in occupation, this is why France getting occupation rights in Germany and Austria was such a coup for de Gaulle.
    In any case, one would believe that the South Koreans would be better off using their manpower guarding the inter-Korean border.

    Third, no division of Tokyo, why? One would expect the precedent of Berlin and Vienna to apply.

    Fourth, the PRC shouldn’t hold an occupation zone. At the creation of the zones in 1945 it would be the ROC and after the civil war there’s no way the Western Powers would hand over the zone to a government they don’t acknowledge as legitimate.

    Fifth, it says “Evolution of Allied Occupied Japan (1945-1990); hopefully this is just the first slide of several showing political changes, otherwise it really doesn’t make sense to keep Japan occupied for so long instead of creating a satellite state with more internal and external legitimacy after a couple of years.

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @Hyperborean

    Looks like Somalia is seriously unhappy about the port deal Ethiopia did with Somaliland, things are starting to heat up along the border.

    Are you keeping up with the details?

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FVJbYH4XoAIUek6.jpg

    Replies: @QCIC, @Hyperborean

  329. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @sudden death


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GC2o0xAWIAA4cR4.jpg

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GC2mG_1WEAAfzPB.jpg

    Replies: @QCIC

    Many and possibly most German export products have relatively high value-added. This business model is based on applying large amounts of capital to production. It strikes me as slightly odd that their economy should be hit so hard by energy costs. If one is making commodity products energy costs may be a very important factor in the price, but as value-added goes up this effect should decrease.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @QCIC

    Many and possibly most German export products have relatively high value-added. This business model is based on applying large amounts of capital to production.

    German products are overrated. Anyone who has worked on cars is aware of that.

    They sell the perception of quality based on the past.

    Audi/VW reliability dropped below Ford/Chevy ages ago and yet Mericans (especially liberals) think German car = better. They have no interest in the data.

    Owning an 2010ish Audi A4/A6 in rural America is a nightmare. People buy a used Audi and then learn they have to get it towed 2 hours to the nearest dealer when it breaks. Then said dealer can charge whatever they want. Oh well that's a German part. +$500.

    The gas mileage on them drops as they get older and they are oil burners. They end up getting the MPG of an SUV. What a joke. I hate these cars and good luck to all the boyfriends/husbands that have to work on them.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Barbarossa

  330. @German_reader
    @sudden death

    In part Karlin's manifesto is a religious tract. All this talk about AI, the singularity etc. making all other issues irrelevant is quite eschatological.
    The anti-nationalist elements may of course be true to some extent, maybe it's really over for nations in any traditional sense (at least in the West). But in Karlin's case it's just motivated by pure spite, as he pretty much admits himself, by his own experiences as a deracinated immigrant who ended up disappointed when he returned to the country of his parents.

    Replies: @Sher Singh, @Barbarossa

    I’m out of the loop, but I would be interested in reading Karlin’s manifesto for whatever it says about the mindset he espouses nowadays. Where can it be found?

  331. German_reader says:
    @Hyperborean
    @German_reader


    I suppose to some extent it might just be me, but I’ve encountered such dynamics in every forum I ever participated in (this one here was by no means the worst btw, and I suspect without the war in Ukraine things wouldn’t have gotten as ugly as they did). As for Twitter, unlike Yevardian I don’t see that as an alternative. I tried it for a few weeks, and found the experience stressful and rather toxic.

    But yes, given the decline in active users, the mutual antagonisms, and the exhausting focus on Ukraine to the exclusion of everything else there doesn’t seem to be much life left here anymore (also noteworthy how Hyperborean who popped up after several years of absence already seems to have left again).
     

    I decided to occasionally check every couple of threads and skim read them. I don't really feel like I have much to say; a lot of people are either repeating the same arguments about the same old topics as they did five years ago (even though they know they will never agree) or picking "beef" with others. Unless one is monetising one's online presence, after a certain point it starts to head towards diminishing marginal utility.

    If it's any consolation it isn't just Unz' Wacky House of Weirdos that's gone insane, mainstream internet forums have been just as bad recently. The Russo-Ukrainian War and especially the Gaza War have ruined large sections of general internet forums that don't explicitly exclude or silo (geo)-political discussion.

    I tried having an active Twitter account a few years back, but I recognised that I can't handle the way the algorithm encourages attention-seeking and ruins one's mental health like the mentally ill streamer girl in the game Needy Girl Overdose so I deleted it. So now I just check in on a couple of people who tend to post interesting statistics or articles.

    I did read your comments about Karlin's manifesto and the "Rightoids Go to Jail" section. I noted the same thing about his very online mentality, a lot of the people he mentions are microcelebrities at best (though curiously no mention of failson Richard Spencer). Hilarious anecdotes, but rather niche in terms of actual real life political presence.

    Personally, I would have been interested in reading about his time in the Bay Area and the Effective Altruism sphere. I'm sure there's enough weirdos and quirky people to talk about that he could make a blog post about it, even without bringing up nasty disputes.

    Replies: @German_reader

    though curiously no mention of failson Richard Spencer

    He did write quite a bit about Spencer earlier in his manifesto, in this part:
    https://akarlin.com/soypill-manifesto/

    I agree with your assessment both of this comments space and the internet in general. I often feel it would be better, if I went totally silent (not like writing comments on the net changes anything anyway), but alas, I haven’t been able to muster up the necessary will power so far.

    EDIT: : It’s on Karlin’s site https://akarlin.com/ (in four parts, with more than 50 000 words…).

  332. German_reader says:
    @Sher Singh
    @German_reader

    I don't really get how he failed to integrate both in America & Russia - I assume the UK as well.
    I don't really feel alienated from Western or Eastern society & you guys see my antics.

    It says something that his 3rd culture or w/e posts attracted tranny Laxa.

    I think a lot of this is knowing your own & other people's limits.
    --
    Not everyone is going to be your best friend.

    Every relationship requires sacrifice - whether logistics, time, annoyance.
    If it's not worth it then cut loose & you'll be happier.
    --
    Have a few hobbies that you're passionate (autistic) about & that routine will keep you going.
    Prayer, fitness, family.

    War.

    https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/825657548765921280/1013311527320825926/IMG_8968.png?ex=65b5dee6&is=65a369e6&hm=b283d3113f3a048a3280272732a1ba6d8b7ac951c41c4c95450b18845165f82c&
    ਅਕਾਲ

    Replies: @German_reader

    I don’t really get how he failed to integrate both in America & Russia – I assume the UK as well.

    His accent was very thick, to a surprising extent. I assume that alone would have been a formidable barrier to integration.
    I got the impression he had quite a bit of resentment about his life story…his parents (scientists, so members of the Soviet Union’s intellectual elite) being forced to emigrate because of the collapse of their country, and he having to grow up in a foreign country (in Preston, of all places) where he never felt he quite belonged. Like he was robbed of his rightful heritage. It’s pretty sad actually.

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @German_reader

    Preston bus station built in the Brutalist architectural style between 1968 and 1969, designed by Keith Ingham and Charles Wilson of Building Design Partnership with E. H. Stazicker, it had (until 2017) a capacity of 80 double-decker buses, 40 along each side of the building. Anatoly claimed that it was the largest bus station in Western Europe.

    He should've simply embraced his latent Lak identity!

  333. Been a while, since there had been a good cow post, so I’ll bring this up:

    When a cow gives birth to twins of different sexes, the female one is always infertile. While the male often has reduced fertility.

    In utero, the blood vessels are conjoined, and this causes the female to be exposed to the hormones of the male, as well as to acquire the male’s cells chimerically.

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freemartin

  334. @songbird
    @Mr. Hack

    Have you never made your own potato chips?

    It was quite common in my grandmother's day (as was making your own bread and donuts) Not quite sure how they did it. From what I can find, looks like a lot of effort. TBH, I would probably much prefer baked slices of potatoes or roasted potatoes.

    Only one of those discount food stores I recall ever seeing is a Pepperidge Farm one with their goldfish crackers, which seems remarkably niche. AFAIK, they went out of business like 20 years ago.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    I enjoy eating potatoes anyway I get them. At home, I usually just bake or boil them (at least once or twice a week.. I’m glad to see that our health food gurus seem to have taken them off of the verboten list, alongside eggs, butter, bacon, etc. I’m patiently waiting for bread to be taken off of this list too, although I continued to eat all of these items during these draconian times. I’ve always enjoyed eating potato chips throughout my life, although since I’m trying to limit my salt intake, try to limit eating them all of the time. I don’ think that I’ll take up making potato chips anytime soon, and stick to eating potatoes in the usual manner. The Discount grocery stores here come and go…they last about 10 years and then disappear only to have other ones take their place in a few years. They’re fun to visit and you never know what you might find. The last one had all sorts of different TV dinners, the new one doesn’t, all for the best, probably…

    • Replies: @songbird
    @Mr. Hack

    I am also quite fond of potatoes. I used to quite enjoy eating the skins, but with some of the stuff they put on fields, not sure it is a great idea.

    It is surprising to me that the chip manufacturers don't have better quality-control and you often find green ones.

    My favorite potato chips are the sour cream and onion ones or the kettle kind. But, overall, I think I prefer that other great Amerind-inspired addition to snackfoods: corn chips, and especially the lighter tortilla kind.

    I have had blue corn chips before,but never these blue potato chips:
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adirondack_Blue

    I once ate banana chips and they caused me to have terrible stomach pains. I do not recommend eating dehydrated bananas.

  335. @German_reader
    @Sher Singh


    I don’t really get how he failed to integrate both in America & Russia – I assume the UK as well.
     
    His accent was very thick, to a surprising extent. I assume that alone would have been a formidable barrier to integration.
    I got the impression he had quite a bit of resentment about his life story...his parents (scientists, so members of the Soviet Union's intellectual elite) being forced to emigrate because of the collapse of their country, and he having to grow up in a foreign country (in Preston, of all places) where he never felt he quite belonged. Like he was robbed of his rightful heritage. It's pretty sad actually.

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Preston bus station built in the Brutalist architectural style between 1968 and 1969, designed by Keith Ingham and Charles Wilson of Building Design Partnership with E. H. Stazicker, it had (until 2017) a capacity of 80 double-decker buses, 40 along each side of the building. Anatoly claimed that it was the largest bus station in Western Europe.

    He should’ve simply embraced his latent Lak identity!

  336. @German_reader
    @songbird


    Would like to see A123 and GR cowrite a monster movie where slugs loosely representing America take over Europe.
     
    I think the creative differences would be too large for such an undertaking. A123 would insist on a re-write where the slugs are actually German and control Biden's government (maybe have a scene where it's shown Biden is comatose in reality and only able to function once a slug has slipped through his ear and is controlling his brain, like in that early Star Trek: Next generation episode with the alien parasites). Hero of the movie would be a Trumpite Judeo-Christian from Arkansas or some other Southern state who's constantly wearing an "I love Israel" pin on his shirt.

    Replies: @QCIC, @A123

    Would like to see A123 and GR cowrite a monster movie where slugs loosely representing America take over Europe.

    I think the creative differences would be too large for such an undertaking. A123 would insist on a re-write where the slugs are actually German and control Biden’s government (maybe have a scene where it’s shown Biden is comatose in reality and only able to function once a slug has slipped through his ear and is controlling his brain

    A one-shot orignial movie needs to wrap everything up with a happy ending in 90-120 minutes. Start with the end “The Hero gets The Girl” and work back towards the start.

    Trying to use Biden over complicates the ending:

    — If terminating brain slugs doesn’t fix Biden, does that mean Kamala takes over 😱? Not an acceptable ending.
    — If both Kamala and Biden expire to brain slugs that would leave President Johnson, but bog the story with Constitutional exposition. Also, does this mean everyone with a brain slug dies? That could be a grim ending rather than happy one.

    It is easier to tie up loose ends if the sluggo President is only stylistically Biden-esque. The VP can then been portrayed as a competent white male avoiding the Kamala taint. When the veggie expires, an established character is sworn in and attempts to contact the hero. Queue “James Bond” style ending where the new President cannot reach the Hero…. (Nudge, nudge. wink, wink.)

    It also provides good material for the start of the story. The VP knows that the administration has been comprised. Therefore, he must go outside of the normal chain, instead contacting a plucky rogue. This sets our Hero, played by Alan Ritchson, into motion.

    The Girl can be an incredibly hot, blue eyed, blonde haired, mini skirt wearing German scientist coerced into working for Supreme Loathsome Unlimited Government [SLUG] against her will. The Hero will rescue The Girl who shares her knowledge thus ending the SLUG and slug threats. The villain would be some maniacal Merkel-esque figure plotting for whatever reason Bond villains plot.

    Yes… I pivoted from a monster movie to a camp action spy movie…. Sue me.

    @ G_R
    Judeo-Christian … constantly wearing an “I love Israel” pin on his shirt.

    @ QCIC
    The slugs would have to be Islamo-slugs.

    Inserting religion into movies carries the same sort of problems as inserting SJW. Unless essential to the plot, it is to be avoided. It risks slowing things down. And, there would be all sorts of problematic questions, for example:

    Why are Germans using Islamo-slugs?

    — Has Germany already quietly taken over one or more Muslim countries? The movie ending would have to contend with that.
    — Or, has Germany been taken over? I suspect that G_R would object to America once again riding to Germany’s rescue.

    All off this would distract from the core proposition, “The Hero gets The Girl“. For a one-shot original movie, simple is better. Leave all of this out.

    You do not like my idea? Compare it to what Hollywood is putting out.

    Have you heard about Echo? It is an intersectional tale where the heroine is a female, Native American, body positivity, deaf, amputee with daddy issues.

    Yes. My proposal contains more cheese than a Velveeta factory. But, people do buy cheese… And, enjoy it for what it is.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @A123

    There is Velveeta and then there is Cheez Whiz. Be careful not to cross the line!

    Replies: @A123

  337. @A123
    @German_reader



    Would like to see A123 and GR cowrite a monster movie where slugs loosely representing America take over Europe.
     
    I think the creative differences would be too large for such an undertaking. A123 would insist on a re-write where the slugs are actually German and control Biden’s government (maybe have a scene where it’s shown Biden is comatose in reality and only able to function once a slug has slipped through his ear and is controlling his brain
     
    A one-shot orignial movie needs to wrap everything up with a happy ending in 90-120 minutes. Start with the end "The Hero gets The Girl" and work back towards the start.

    Trying to use Biden over complicates the ending:

    -- If terminating brain slugs doesn't fix Biden, does that mean Kamala takes over 😱? Not an acceptable ending.
    -- If both Kamala and Biden expire to brain slugs that would leave President Johnson, but bog the story with Constitutional exposition. Also, does this mean everyone with a brain slug dies? That could be a grim ending rather than happy one.

    It is easier to tie up loose ends if the sluggo President is only stylistically Biden-esque. The VP can then been portrayed as a competent white male avoiding the Kamala taint. When the veggie expires, an established character is sworn in and attempts to contact the hero. Queue "James Bond" style ending where the new President cannot reach the Hero.... (Nudge, nudge. wink, wink.)

    It also provides good material for the start of the story. The VP knows that the administration has been comprised. Therefore, he must go outside of the normal chain, instead contacting a plucky rogue. This sets our Hero, played by Alan Ritchson, into motion.

    The Girl can be an incredibly hot, blue eyed, blonde haired, mini skirt wearing German scientist coerced into working for Supreme Loathsome Unlimited Government [SLUG] against her will. The Hero will rescue The Girl who shares her knowledge thus ending the SLUG and slug threats. The villain would be some maniacal Merkel-esque figure plotting for whatever reason Bond villains plot.

    Yes... I pivoted from a monster movie to a camp action spy movie.... Sue me.


    @ G_R
    Judeo-Christian ... constantly wearing an “I love Israel” pin on his shirt.

    @ QCIC
    The slugs would have to be Islamo-slugs.
     

    Inserting religion into movies carries the same sort of problems as inserting SJW. Unless essential to the plot, it is to be avoided. It risks slowing things down. And, there would be all sorts of problematic questions, for example:

    Why are Germans using Islamo-slugs?

    -- Has Germany already quietly taken over one or more Muslim countries? The movie ending would have to contend with that.
    -- Or, has Germany been taken over? I suspect that G_R would object to America once again riding to Germany's rescue.

    All off this would distract from the core proposition, "The Hero gets The Girl". For a one-shot original movie, simple is better. Leave all of this out.

     

    You do not like my idea? Compare it to what Hollywood is putting out.

    Have you heard about Echo? It is an intersectional tale where the heroine is a female, Native American, body positivity, deaf, amputee with daddy issues.

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Ap5U7byBnSw

    Yes. My proposal contains more cheese than a Velveeta factory. But, people do buy cheese... And, enjoy it for what it is.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @QCIC

    There is Velveeta and then there is Cheez Whiz. Be careful not to cross the line!

    • Replies: @A123
    @QCIC


    There is Velveeta and then there is Cheez Whiz. Be careful not to cross the line!
     
    Lines are for other people.. I spray Cheez Whiz on Velveeta. Bam!

    PEACE 😇



    https://www.directom.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/emeril-bam.gif
  338. @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    I enjoy eating potatoes anyway I get them. At home, I usually just bake or boil them (at least once or twice a week.. I'm glad to see that our health food gurus seem to have taken them off of the verboten list, alongside eggs, butter, bacon, etc. I'm patiently waiting for bread to be taken off of this list too, although I continued to eat all of these items during these draconian times. I've always enjoyed eating potato chips throughout my life, although since I'm trying to limit my salt intake, try to limit eating them all of the time. I don' think that I'll take up making potato chips anytime soon, and stick to eating potatoes in the usual manner. The Discount grocery stores here come and go...they last about 10 years and then disappear only to have other ones take their place in a few years. They're fun to visit and you never know what you might find. The last one had all sorts of different TV dinners, the new one doesn't, all for the best, probably...

    Replies: @songbird

    I am also quite fond of potatoes. I used to quite enjoy eating the skins, but with some of the stuff they put on fields, not sure it is a great idea.

    It is surprising to me that the chip manufacturers don’t have better quality-control and you often find green ones.

    My favorite potato chips are the sour cream and onion ones or the kettle kind. But, overall, I think I prefer that other great Amerind-inspired addition to snackfoods: corn chips, and especially the lighter tortilla kind.

    I have had blue corn chips before,but never these blue potato chips:
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adirondack_Blue

    I once ate banana chips and they caused me to have terrible stomach pains. I do not recommend eating dehydrated bananas.

  339. @QCIC
    @A123

    There is Velveeta and then there is Cheez Whiz. Be careful not to cross the line!

    Replies: @A123

    There is Velveeta and then there is Cheez Whiz. Be careful not to cross the line!

    Lines are for other people.. I spray Cheez Whiz on Velveeta. Bam!

    PEACE 😇

    [MORE]

  340. @AP
    @Mikel


    Cut the crap with your requests for “evidence” and “proof”.
     
    You keep repeating that he was "killed." Prove it.

    He got sick in jail, received medical care but it was too later and he died of his illness. He had been ill before he was arrested, some kind of heart problems. Even in a rich country like the USA people die of illnesses while incarcerated.

    You can’t possibly be so thick to be unaware of how pathetic your attempts to normalize the death of an American political prisoner in a European prison sound.
     
    Now he is a political prisoner?

    Do you consider the 93 year old German lady sentenced to prison for saying the Holocaust didn't happen to also be a political prisoner? You keep ignoring these examples.

    The closest equivalent we could find is perhaps Assange, also outrageous in its own way, but he is not an American imprisoned in a vassal country where the US is sending money to pay for the salaries of his very captors
     
    So you are suggesting that Ukraine isn't a puppet after all?

    Or are you going to go with the story that since Lira hated the USA, Ukraine was doing the USA's bidding by "killing" him.

    The reality is far more simple and straightforward (as is often the case). He chose to go to a different country, broke its laws, was arrested, got sick, and died. The prison administrators waited too long to provide medical care (as happens in prisons in the USA too) though they did eventually.

    You wanted him to get better care in the Ukrainian prison than many Americans get in American prisons?

    https://www.vera.org/news/health-care-behind-bars-missed-appointments-no-standards-and-high-costs

    The abysmal state of health care behind bars bears much of the blame for those figures. Medical neglect kills hundreds of incarcerated people every year despite the 1976 Supreme Court ruling that deliberate indifference to medical needs amounts to cruel and unusual punishment.

    :::::::::::::

    The Ukrainians even released him to house arrest. What did he do? Choose to skip bail and head for the border, while publicly announcing what he was doing.

    So the moron ended up in prison again, where he got sick and died.

    This is your "martyr."

    And of course the British wouldn’t let him die in prison of an untreated illness like a rabid dog.
     
    Lira got treatment. They waited too long, as is typical of prisons (not only in Ukraine), and it failed.

    I don’t remember running into private armies on my visits to Ukraine. Or Russia, for that matter.

    Perhaps Gerard is right after all? I don’t know now but in the 90s you would find gangsters at the lobbies of any hotel in the ex-USSR countries
     
    We weren't talking about gangsters, we were talking about "private armies" that you claimed Ukraine and Russia were full of. Why are you switching? I was in Ukraine in 1990 and Russia for the first time in 1999, otherwise I missed the 90s. And I avoided hotels and places where shady people go. The shadiest place I went to was Gorbushka in Moscow, a place to buy cheap pirated software.

    ETA killed hundreds of Spanish police officers, soldiers, politicians, journalists and innocent civilians deep inside Spain that had nothing to do whatsoever with the Basque conflict, while certain parts of the Basque Country remained no-go areas for the police. There were always voices that demanded retribution but Spain spent decades combating this plague with the rule of law and negotiations.
     
    Which cities did ETA control and did they try to advance on other cities in order to conquer them?

    You are comparing terrorism with civil war.

    As I said, no western European country had Ukraine's situation.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @John Johnson

    He got sick in jail, received medical care but it was too later and he died of his illness. He had been ill before he was arrested, some kind of heart problems.

    He spoke of getting double pneumonia and a collapsed lung but said nothing of the cause. No mention of COVID or complaints about getting something from the prisoners.

    Sure it is possible that he picked up something in prison but why wouldn’t he state that?

    The guy chain smoked in his interviews. In one of the few videos he didn’t remove you can see that one cigarette wasn’t enough for the interview.

    Then he “just happens” to have lung problems in prison but doesn’t ask his sister to contact the state department?

    I really don’t like Anglin but he figured this one out. The guy wanted to die. Most likely had a terminal condition and wanted to go out as a martyr.

    Lira’s fans seem to think he was a suppressed journalist that was killed by a Western conspiracy. Ok well let’s see ONE essay from him on Russia since 2020. All I have seen are few videos where he chain smokes and talks about how Russia is about to win. He scrubbed all his “red pill” videos and there are few mentions of his wife. Highly suspicious.

    • Replies: @AP
    @John Johnson


    The guy chain smoked in his interviews. In one of the few videos he didn’t remove you can see that one cigarette wasn’t enough for the interview.

    Then he “just happens” to have lung problems in prison but doesn’t ask his sister to contact the state department?

    I really don’t like Anglin but he figured this one out. The guy wanted to die. Most likely had a terminal condition and wanted to go out as a martyr.
     
    Totally agree. His decision to brag about skipping bail, basically forcing the authorities to arrest him, supports this.


    And idiots or people who should know better play along, pretend he is a real martyr.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  341. @Mikhail
    @Mikel

    Navalny and Gershkovich had court dates where the accusations and evidence were clearly stated. Lira's situation wasn't as transparent and more questionable. Navalny cheated Yves Rocher (in addition to disrespecting the judge, which doesn't help a defendant in any court and being involved in demos that didn't get zoning approval) and Gershkovich was reporting beyond the previously stated acceptable means on military security matter.

    Lira had a YouTube show featuring critical commentary on the Kiev regime. This video deals with Lira's situation:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2X7JmoXenw0&t=3740s

    Replies: @Derer, @Mikel

    Navalny cheated Yves Rocher

    Nice to see you finally taking AP’s side in an argument. Navalny cheated Yves Rocher, Lira didn’t take proper care of his health, Skripal’s poisoning was staged by the British,… nothing to see here, let’s all move on.

    To be fair, one generally sees a bit more variety of argumentation among Russians than among Ukrainians. Plenty of Russians you see online are very vocal in their anti-Kremlin views, be it against the war or against the sloppy conduct of the war, but you are not one of them. You’re more like the vast majority of Ukrainians, who feel the need to defend even the most abject and ridiculous acts of their government. Once the war is over and things settle down I could see you and AP becoming great friends, and inviting each other to taste your favorite varieties of Borscht. You even live close to each other, if I’m not mistaken.

    And to be fair to the Ukies too, contrary to what I thought, there does actually exist a Ukrainian Pacifist Movement. It was only founded in 2019 and seems to be largely a one-man show but well, something is something. You don’t transit from a uniform Sovok mentality to the levels of free thinking prevalent West of those lands without small steps. Predictably, though, the Kiev regime is repressing this poor soul too and accusing him of being “pro-Russian”: https://truthout.org/video/why-is-ukraine-prosecuting-a-pacifist-for-justifying-russian-aggression/ There’s just no hope. If they can keep welcoming millions of illegal immigrants form the 3rd World, I guess they can also fast-tack Ukraine’s membership in the EU but one way or another, they’ll regret it. Or they’ll just pretend that everything is fine while Europe’s suicidal decline to irrelevance carries on.

    • LOL: Mikhail
    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Mikel


    If they can keep welcoming millions of illegal immigrants form the 3rd World, I guess they can also fast-tack Ukraine’s membership in the EU but one way or another, they’ll regret it. Or they’ll just pretend that everything is fine while Europe’s suicidal decline to irrelevance carries on.
     
    You might as well stop worrying about Europe. The chicken is still running, but it’s headless, and that’s irreversible. The EU can fast-track whatever remains of Ukraine by the time their fast-tracking gets anywhere, or not. Without that monstrosity it will die slower and possibly less painful death. The end result won’t change.

    If you are in the States, I advise you to pray to whatever god(s) you believe in that the US does not suffer the same fate it arranged for Europe.
  342. @QCIC
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Many and possibly most German export products have relatively high value-added. This business model is based on applying large amounts of capital to production. It strikes me as slightly odd that their economy should be hit so hard by energy costs. If one is making commodity products energy costs may be a very important factor in the price, but as value-added goes up this effect should decrease.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Many and possibly most German export products have relatively high value-added. This business model is based on applying large amounts of capital to production.

    German products are overrated. Anyone who has worked on cars is aware of that.

    They sell the perception of quality based on the past.

    Audi/VW reliability dropped below Ford/Chevy ages ago and yet Mericans (especially liberals) think German car = better. They have no interest in the data.

    Owning an 2010ish Audi A4/A6 in rural America is a nightmare. People buy a used Audi and then learn they have to get it towed 2 hours to the nearest dealer when it breaks. Then said dealer can charge whatever they want. Oh well that’s a German part. +$500.

    The gas mileage on them drops as they get older and they are oil burners. They end up getting the MPG of an SUV. What a joke. I hate these cars and good luck to all the boyfriends/husbands that have to work on them.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    I agree that German cars are overrated, but that doesn't change the market niche they are in.

    German cars have been very complicated for a long time. They seem to add complexity to distinguish the product. Now that Asian competitors are up to speed (for decades) the main thing left for the Germans is luxury branding. I wish they made a car with a 1980's level of complexity using best current automotive engineering practice.

    I think Mercedes-Benz was better than other cars for many decades, though still expensive to maintain in the US. BMW, Audi and VW tried to ride on the coattails of MB. Other brands have had comparable quality for a long time since they explicitly worked to meet and then surpass MB.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @AnonfromTN

    , @Barbarossa
    @John Johnson

    My experience is that German engineering often means that a given problem is solved by an unnecessarily complicated solution when a simpler one would do just as well. They also seem to make it hard for plebs to service things. I think the thought of non-specialists servicing their machines give German engineers palpitations.

    I totally agree with you on Audis/ BMWs. They are usually money pits to maintain.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  343. @A123
    The numbers are in: (1)

    Nielsen: President Trump Townhall on Fox News Nearly Doubles Viewership of CNN Debate Featuring Haley and DeSantis

    (Via The Hill) – Fox’s town hall with Trump averaged 4.3 million viewers from 9-10 p.m., according to early data from Nielsen Media Research, while the CNN debate featuring Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) and former United Nations Ambassador Nikki Haley averaged 2.5 million during the same hour.

    […] Wednesday night’s ratings returns are the latest signal that live events featuring Trump remain one of the largest drivers of audience for the nation’s cable news channels, all of which are facing major headwinds in the form of increased cord-cutting and changing media habits on the part of consumers.
     

     
    Not only were the ratings bad, Haley and DeSantis spent their time blasting each other.

    What are these two trying to prove? How much money they can spend without achieving anything? It is not helping their reputations or future prospects. Massive establishment entanglement has effectively wiped out DeSantis's hope to be a MAGA leader at the national level.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/11/nielsen-president-trump-townhall-on-fox-news-nearly-doubles-viewership-of-cnn-debate-featuring-haley-and-desantis/

    Replies: @Mikel, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Massive establishment entanglement has effectively wiped out DeSantis’s hope to be a MAGA leader at the national level.

    You got that wrong, as usual. Massive Establishment media focus on Trump has solidified his position as the front runner, to the detriment of more solid MAGA candidates like DeSantis.

    And the Establishment is clearly with Nikki, who is getting all the big donor money while the MSM just can’t hide how hopeful they are about her (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-67948573). I have no clue who the hell those ~4% of Christie’s voters were but they’re obviously all going to Nikki now. She is the clear Establishment GOP alternative to Trump and if they manage to make her be in second place when Trump is removed from the ballots, imprisoned, retired for poor health (he’s obese and almost 80) or whatever, we have a perfect soft coup.

    I can’t believe Trump can win in November anyway, no matter what the polls say. He’s shown to have massive rejection levels, 3 times in a row after his 2016 victory. As someone said the other day on a conservative radio show, the Dems could nominate Jimmy Carter and more than half the country would vote for him rather than Trump.

    • Replies: @A123
    @Mikel


    more solid MAGA candidates like DeSantis. ... And the Establishment is clearly with Nikki, who is getting all the big donor money while the MSM just can’t hide how hopeful they are about her
     
    Everyone knows that DeSantis and Haley are peas in the same establishment pod. (1)

    DeSantis was the GOPe foil; everything planned to enhance and support the DeSantis candidacy was planned long ago. Long before the DeSantis campaign launched, the RGA/RNC and Sea Island billionaire donors had that plan well in place. The 2022, a $20 million contribution from the RGA to DeSantis was part of that laundry mechanism to provide support for a 2024 presidential bid.

    It’s not a goofy conspiracy theory any longer to admit; the institutions of the party apparatus (RNC and DNC), two wings of the same UniParty vulture, are every bit as corrupt as the DC system they were developed to support.
    ...
    DeSantis and Nikki Haley were battling for Sea Island money. Each of them positioning to be the destination of the funds to support the Never Trump coalition of globalists. Haley appears to have won the most favor amid that control group, after months of visible failure by the DeSantis team.

    On a pure messaging and candidate viability scale, Haley is worse -a lot worse- than DeSantis. Yet, the billionaire class do not measure success by the same metrics as voters; so, she is viewed more favorably. Both will fail; the upshot of Haley will be of much shorter duration than the climb/fall of DeSantis. That’s the club problem, and it cannot be cured.

     

    Hundreds of millions went to the anti-MAGA campaign of DeSantis. When that failed, the establishment tried to activate Haley as their back up.

    Why do you insist on backing wholly implausible non-MAGA candidates like DeSantis? You could build bridges back to actual MAGA/Trump, but instead you keep trying to help Not-The-President Biden. Your #NeverTrump zealotry is self destructive.

    I can’t believe Trump can win in November anyway, no matter what the polls say. He’s shown to have massive rejection levels, 3 times in a row after his 2016 victory.
     
    The 90%+ success rate of his endorsements is, in your book, "massive rejection"? What unusual linguistics. What do you call the Veggie-In-Chief's much worse yield?

    What Trump has done is help the party move away from RINO GOP(e) failure. Of the 10 worst House Republican members, Trump supported primaries challenging them resulting in 8 outright retirements or losses. That is an unprecedented result unseating incumbents. Those seats are now MAGA, and Liz Cheney is gone. How obvious does the MAGA track record of winning have to be before you will acknowledge Trump's victories?

    As Trump is mortal, he has had some losses. One of the ten worst RINO's was reelected to the House. Some endorsements did not work, such as the Pennsylvania Senate. No politician can ever deliver 100% of Everything! Instantly! It just does not work that way.

    =================================
        "Politics is the art of the possible,
    the attainable, the art of the next best"
                 -- Otto von Bismarck --
    =================================


    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2023/11/18/billionaire-donor-twitches-desantis-falls-to-fifth-place-in-bifurcated-new-hampshire/
  344. @Mikel
    @Mikhail


    Navalny cheated Yves Rocher
     
    Nice to see you finally taking AP's side in an argument. Navalny cheated Yves Rocher, Lira didn't take proper care of his health, Skripal's poisoning was staged by the British,... nothing to see here, let's all move on.

    To be fair, one generally sees a bit more variety of argumentation among Russians than among Ukrainians. Plenty of Russians you see online are very vocal in their anti-Kremlin views, be it against the war or against the sloppy conduct of the war, but you are not one of them. You're more like the vast majority of Ukrainians, who feel the need to defend even the most abject and ridiculous acts of their government. Once the war is over and things settle down I could see you and AP becoming great friends, and inviting each other to taste your favorite varieties of Borscht. You even live close to each other, if I'm not mistaken.

    And to be fair to the Ukies too, contrary to what I thought, there does actually exist a Ukrainian Pacifist Movement. It was only founded in 2019 and seems to be largely a one-man show but well, something is something. You don't transit from a uniform Sovok mentality to the levels of free thinking prevalent West of those lands without small steps. Predictably, though, the Kiev regime is repressing this poor soul too and accusing him of being "pro-Russian": https://truthout.org/video/why-is-ukraine-prosecuting-a-pacifist-for-justifying-russian-aggression/ There's just no hope. If they can keep welcoming millions of illegal immigrants form the 3rd World, I guess they can also fast-tack Ukraine's membership in the EU but one way or another, they'll regret it. Or they'll just pretend that everything is fine while Europe's suicidal decline to irrelevance carries on.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    If they can keep welcoming millions of illegal immigrants form the 3rd World, I guess they can also fast-tack Ukraine’s membership in the EU but one way or another, they’ll regret it. Or they’ll just pretend that everything is fine while Europe’s suicidal decline to irrelevance carries on.

    You might as well stop worrying about Europe. The chicken is still running, but it’s headless, and that’s irreversible. The EU can fast-track whatever remains of Ukraine by the time their fast-tracking gets anywhere, or not. Without that monstrosity it will die slower and possibly less painful death. The end result won’t change.

    If you are in the States, I advise you to pray to whatever god(s) you believe in that the US does not suffer the same fate it arranged for Europe.

  345. @Mikel
    @A123


    Massive establishment entanglement has effectively wiped out DeSantis’s hope to be a MAGA leader at the national level.
     
    You got that wrong, as usual. Massive Establishment media focus on Trump has solidified his position as the front runner, to the detriment of more solid MAGA candidates like DeSantis.

    And the Establishment is clearly with Nikki, who is getting all the big donor money while the MSM just can't hide how hopeful they are about her (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-67948573). I have no clue who the hell those ~4% of Christie's voters were but they're obviously all going to Nikki now. She is the clear Establishment GOP alternative to Trump and if they manage to make her be in second place when Trump is removed from the ballots, imprisoned, retired for poor health (he's obese and almost 80) or whatever, we have a perfect soft coup.

    I can't believe Trump can win in November anyway, no matter what the polls say. He's shown to have massive rejection levels, 3 times in a row after his 2016 victory. As someone said the other day on a conservative radio show, the Dems could nominate Jimmy Carter and more than half the country would vote for him rather than Trump.

    Replies: @A123

    more solid MAGA candidates like DeSantis. … And the Establishment is clearly with Nikki, who is getting all the big donor money while the MSM just can’t hide how hopeful they are about her

    Everyone knows that DeSantis and Haley are peas in the same establishment pod. (1)

    DeSantis was the GOPe foil; everything planned to enhance and support the DeSantis candidacy was planned long ago. Long before the DeSantis campaign launched, the RGA/RNC and Sea Island billionaire donors had that plan well in place. The 2022, a $20 million contribution from the RGA to DeSantis was part of that laundry mechanism to provide support for a 2024 presidential bid.

    It’s not a goofy conspiracy theory any longer to admit; the institutions of the party apparatus (RNC and DNC), two wings of the same UniParty vulture, are every bit as corrupt as the DC system they were developed to support.

    DeSantis and Nikki Haley were battling for Sea Island money. Each of them positioning to be the destination of the funds to support the Never Trump coalition of globalists. Haley appears to have won the most favor amid that control group, after months of visible failure by the DeSantis team.

    On a pure messaging and candidate viability scale, Haley is worse -a lot worse- than DeSantis. Yet, the billionaire class do not measure success by the same metrics as voters; so, she is viewed more favorably. Both will fail; the upshot of Haley will be of much shorter duration than the climb/fall of DeSantis. That’s the club problem, and it cannot be cured.

    Hundreds of millions went to the anti-MAGA campaign of DeSantis. When that failed, the establishment tried to activate Haley as their back up.

    Why do you insist on backing wholly implausible non-MAGA candidates like DeSantis? You could build bridges back to actual MAGA/Trump, but instead you keep trying to help Not-The-President Biden. Your #NeverTrump zealotry is self destructive.

    I can’t believe Trump can win in November anyway, no matter what the polls say. He’s shown to have massive rejection levels, 3 times in a row after his 2016 victory.

    The 90%+ success rate of his endorsements is, in your book, “massive rejection”? What unusual linguistics. What do you call the Veggie-In-Chief’s much worse yield?

    What Trump has done is help the party move away from RINO GOP(e) failure. Of the 10 worst House Republican members, Trump supported primaries challenging them resulting in 8 outright retirements or losses. That is an unprecedented result unseating incumbents. Those seats are now MAGA, and Liz Cheney is gone. How obvious does the MAGA track record of winning have to be before you will acknowledge Trump’s victories?

    As Trump is mortal, he has had some losses. One of the ten worst RINO’s was reelected to the House. Some endorsements did not work, such as the Pennsylvania Senate. No politician can ever deliver 100% of Everything! Instantly! It just does not work that way.

    =================================
        “Politics is the art of the possible,
    the attainable, the art of the next best”
                 — Otto von Bismarck —
    =================================

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2023/11/18/billionaire-donor-twitches-desantis-falls-to-fifth-place-in-bifurcated-new-hampshire/

  346. @John Johnson
    @QCIC

    Many and possibly most German export products have relatively high value-added. This business model is based on applying large amounts of capital to production.

    German products are overrated. Anyone who has worked on cars is aware of that.

    They sell the perception of quality based on the past.

    Audi/VW reliability dropped below Ford/Chevy ages ago and yet Mericans (especially liberals) think German car = better. They have no interest in the data.

    Owning an 2010ish Audi A4/A6 in rural America is a nightmare. People buy a used Audi and then learn they have to get it towed 2 hours to the nearest dealer when it breaks. Then said dealer can charge whatever they want. Oh well that's a German part. +$500.

    The gas mileage on them drops as they get older and they are oil burners. They end up getting the MPG of an SUV. What a joke. I hate these cars and good luck to all the boyfriends/husbands that have to work on them.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Barbarossa

    I agree that German cars are overrated, but that doesn’t change the market niche they are in.

    German cars have been very complicated for a long time. They seem to add complexity to distinguish the product. Now that Asian competitors are up to speed (for decades) the main thing left for the Germans is luxury branding. I wish they made a car with a 1980’s level of complexity using best current automotive engineering practice.

    I think Mercedes-Benz was better than other cars for many decades, though still expensive to maintain in the US. BMW, Audi and VW tried to ride on the coattails of MB. Other brands have had comparable quality for a long time since they explicitly worked to meet and then surpass MB.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @QCIC

    German cars have been very complicated for a long time. They seem to add complexity to distinguish the product. Now that Asian competitors are up to speed (for decades) the main thing left for the Germans is luxury branding. I wish they made a car with a 1980’s level of complexity using best current automotive engineering practice.

    Chevrolet interiors were garbage for a long period. I could see someone in 2005 choosing a German car over Chevrolet for the look and feel. The Silverado interiors from that period look like they are from the 80s. I can't believe Chevy thought that was "good enough" at the time.

    But that is in the past. You can get a decked out leather car from any brand. 7 way power front seat, heated, etc. Might as well add $1000 if you are buying a new car.

    Why buy a German car today? There just aren't many reasons. They had a better offering when US cars mostly sold as daily drivers. Chevy had the top rated SUV last year and the reviews gushed over the interior.

    I think Mercedes-Benz was better than other cars for many decades, though still expensive to maintain in the US. BMW, Audi and VW tried to ride on the coattails of MB.

    I agree and would not put Mercedes in the same category for reliability. However they still use the model of expecting wealthy people to take the car to the dealer for a simple fix. Volvo does the same thing. I will never touch another Volvo again. They want you to drop it off and pay the premium for something easily fixable in a Ford or Chevy. The dealers are usually not friendly as their clientele are normally rich assholes. It's all a major hassle even if you can afford it.

    I honestly don't have experience with BMWs. But I can tell you that there a lot of 5 and 7 series on the used market. The same is true for the SUVs. I know they don't get great gas mileage but I can't comment on the reliability. I assume the gas is a factor because I've seen a lot of V8s at low prices. The used BMW 3 has become a teenager car. I never see grown men driving them.

    , @AnonfromTN
    @QCIC


    the main thing left for the Germans is luxury branding.
     
    That’s true for Mercedes, BMW, and even Audi, where at least half of the price is for the brand, not for the car itself. This is not true for VW. In fact, VW of similar quality is cheaper than Japanese cars. When I bought my first Tiguan, it was ~$7,000 cheaper than Subaru Outback, which was not better in any way (I test-drove both). Besides, German cars protect you because they are made of metal, whereas Japanese cars are made of some crap or other: you can dent any Japanese car by kicking it with your booted foot. If you once see results of an accident involving German or American car and a Japanese car (regardless of the manufacturer), you would never buy a Japanese car.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  347. Trump is Biden’s best bet for re-election.

    Biden can only win against a felon and his cult following.

    Polls show Haley beating Biden by 17 points:
    https://www.wsj.com/livecoverage/gop-republican-debate-iowa/card/behind-haley-s-17-point-lead-over-biden-in-wsj-polling-qByTNcx5uHOCTq443PVW

    Trump does not have independents and only carries about half of them when he runs against Biden.

    Independents only vote for Trump when forced.

    This is terrible politics. You don’t back the guy who requires an even bigger loser to win….and barely if he pulls it off.

    What will happen if Trump ends up with jail time? Are you still going to support him?

    • Replies: @A123
    @John Johnson


    What will happen if Trump ends up with jail time? Are you still going to support him?
     
    What will happen if I end up with a Victoria's Secret model? Am I going to enjoy it?

    Both are very silly propositions. Hypothetical questions are generally weak. They are not useful for gathering information when the scenario in question has a probability of 0%.

    Absolutely everyone understands that the cases being thrown at Trump are laughable: (1)


    Everything about the case in New York City against the Trump Organization business operations is ridiculous. There are no victims. There was no fraud. All of the lenders did their own due diligence. All of the loans were paid back without issue, and the statement of financial condition was factual and accurate. There were no defaults or banking interests adversely impacted. There are no victims of what the State calls “fraud.”

    New York Attorney General Latisha James campaigned for office with promises to target the Trump Organization and Donald Trump himself. This is malicious Lawfare in the extreme. Additionally, the statute being used as the predicate for the case is a consumer fraud statute, intended to protect borrowers from predatory lenders. In the four corners of this case, Trump is the borrower, and the banks were the lenders. New York is flipping the statute to claim the borrower defrauded the lenders, despite the lenders denying there was any fraud and there was no harm. The entire case is ridiculous.

    Appearing on CNN, O’Leary Ventures Chairman Kevin O’Leary outlines, to a perplexed Laura Coates, why Donald Trump’s civil fraud trial in New York is political nonsense.

    https://youtu.be/80RZs9Fhz3Y


     

    Every abuse makes Trump more popular with Independents and swing voters.

    Trump does not have independents and only carries about half of them when he runs against Biden.
     
    Trump is up by 8% in the swing state of Michigan. The presence of third parties, such as Green and No Labels, increases Trump's spread to 12% [41-29] (2)

    Michigan is going to be a tough contest, because Wayne County is one of the primary places where Democrat operatives manufacture ballots. However, that said, President Trump is now leading Joe Biden by 8 points, slightly more than the estimated 5% fraudulent ballots the Democrats can create.
     
    The same observation I made for Mikel applies to you as well. Your #NeverTrump zealotry is self destructive. You would be better served by being more realistic and less histrionic.


    #LetsGoBrandon 😇
    ____________________

    (1) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/12/kevin-oleary-explains-to-stunned-cnn-audience-why-new-york-case-against-president-trump-is-nonsense/

    (2) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/09/president-trump-holds-8-point-lead-over-joe-biden-in-michigan/

    Replies: @John Johnson, @songbird, @Mr. XYZ

  348. @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    I agree that German cars are overrated, but that doesn't change the market niche they are in.

    German cars have been very complicated for a long time. They seem to add complexity to distinguish the product. Now that Asian competitors are up to speed (for decades) the main thing left for the Germans is luxury branding. I wish they made a car with a 1980's level of complexity using best current automotive engineering practice.

    I think Mercedes-Benz was better than other cars for many decades, though still expensive to maintain in the US. BMW, Audi and VW tried to ride on the coattails of MB. Other brands have had comparable quality for a long time since they explicitly worked to meet and then surpass MB.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @AnonfromTN

    German cars have been very complicated for a long time. They seem to add complexity to distinguish the product. Now that Asian competitors are up to speed (for decades) the main thing left for the Germans is luxury branding. I wish they made a car with a 1980’s level of complexity using best current automotive engineering practice.

    Chevrolet interiors were garbage for a long period. I could see someone in 2005 choosing a German car over Chevrolet for the look and feel. The Silverado interiors from that period look like they are from the 80s. I can’t believe Chevy thought that was “good enough” at the time.

    But that is in the past. You can get a decked out leather car from any brand. 7 way power front seat, heated, etc. Might as well add $1000 if you are buying a new car.

    Why buy a German car today? There just aren’t many reasons. They had a better offering when US cars mostly sold as daily drivers. Chevy had the top rated SUV last year and the reviews gushed over the interior.

    I think Mercedes-Benz was better than other cars for many decades, though still expensive to maintain in the US. BMW, Audi and VW tried to ride on the coattails of MB.

    I agree and would not put Mercedes in the same category for reliability. However they still use the model of expecting wealthy people to take the car to the dealer for a simple fix. Volvo does the same thing. I will never touch another Volvo again. They want you to drop it off and pay the premium for something easily fixable in a Ford or Chevy. The dealers are usually not friendly as their clientele are normally rich assholes. It’s all a major hassle even if you can afford it.

    I honestly don’t have experience with BMWs. But I can tell you that there a lot of 5 and 7 series on the used market. The same is true for the SUVs. I know they don’t get great gas mileage but I can’t comment on the reliability. I assume the gas is a factor because I’ve seen a lot of V8s at low prices. The used BMW 3 has become a teenager car. I never see grown men driving them.

  349. @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    I agree that German cars are overrated, but that doesn't change the market niche they are in.

    German cars have been very complicated for a long time. They seem to add complexity to distinguish the product. Now that Asian competitors are up to speed (for decades) the main thing left for the Germans is luxury branding. I wish they made a car with a 1980's level of complexity using best current automotive engineering practice.

    I think Mercedes-Benz was better than other cars for many decades, though still expensive to maintain in the US. BMW, Audi and VW tried to ride on the coattails of MB. Other brands have had comparable quality for a long time since they explicitly worked to meet and then surpass MB.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @AnonfromTN

    the main thing left for the Germans is luxury branding.

    That’s true for Mercedes, BMW, and even Audi, where at least half of the price is for the brand, not for the car itself. This is not true for VW. In fact, VW of similar quality is cheaper than Japanese cars. When I bought my first Tiguan, it was ~$7,000 cheaper than Subaru Outback, which was not better in any way (I test-drove both). Besides, German cars protect you because they are made of metal, whereas Japanese cars are made of some crap or other: you can dent any Japanese car by kicking it with your booted foot. If you once see results of an accident involving German or American car and a Japanese car (regardless of the manufacturer), you would never buy a Japanese car.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @AnonfromTN

    Besides, German cars protect you because they are made of metal, whereas Japanese cars are made of some crap or other: you can dent any Japanese car by kicking it with your booted foot.

    Oh give me a break.

    German and Japanese cars are subjected to the same strict auto safety standards in the US.

    They all have metal frames. They would fail with anything else.

    I find most Japanese cars to be boring and soulless but there is no reason to assume they are subpar when it comes to safety. The Mazda 3 has a 5 star safety rating:
    https://www.iihs.org/ratings/vehicle/mazda/3-4-door-sedan/2021

    You do want to be in a lot of metal when driving in the US which is why I would avoid compacts of any brand. I've seen what happens when they meet an F150. Not good.

  350. Sher Singh says:

    I was thinking that the difference between religion and custom is rarely discussed.

    Martial prowess or patriarchy come from the latter.

    Europe had a strong 1000 years of feudalism due to German kings.

    Islam had something similar under Persianized Turks.

    Sikhi does have the ਖਾਲਸਾ but it somehow feels wrong to ignore the above.

    I don’t know & I feel that one warrior ruled society tends to produce others.

    Almost a shared struggle – akin to how monarchies never used to support the overthrow of another.

    The Baathist led insurgency counts & maybe the early Taliban.

    Not the more recent ones though – they’re priest centric.

    Barbarossa, it’s on akarlin.com he’s even taken down some of his best earlier works.

    • Thanks: songbird
  351. @John Johnson
    Trump is Biden's best bet for re-election.

    Biden can only win against a felon and his cult following.

    Polls show Haley beating Biden by 17 points:
    https://www.wsj.com/livecoverage/gop-republican-debate-iowa/card/behind-haley-s-17-point-lead-over-biden-in-wsj-polling-qByTNcx5uHOCTq443PVW

    Trump does not have independents and only carries about half of them when he runs against Biden.

    Independents only vote for Trump when forced.

    This is terrible politics. You don't back the guy who requires an even bigger loser to win....and barely if he pulls it off.

    What will happen if Trump ends up with jail time? Are you still going to support him?

    Replies: @A123

    What will happen if Trump ends up with jail time? Are you still going to support him?

    What will happen if I end up with a Victoria’s Secret model? Am I going to enjoy it?

    Both are very silly propositions. Hypothetical questions are generally weak. They are not useful for gathering information when the scenario in question has a probability of 0%.

    Absolutely everyone understands that the cases being thrown at Trump are laughable: (1)

    Everything about the case in New York City against the Trump Organization business operations is ridiculous. There are no victims. There was no fraud. All of the lenders did their own due diligence. All of the loans were paid back without issue, and the statement of financial condition was factual and accurate. There were no defaults or banking interests adversely impacted. There are no victims of what the State calls “fraud.”

    New York Attorney General Latisha James campaigned for office with promises to target the Trump Organization and Donald Trump himself. This is malicious Lawfare in the extreme. Additionally, the statute being used as the predicate for the case is a consumer fraud statute, intended to protect borrowers from predatory lenders. In the four corners of this case, Trump is the borrower, and the banks were the lenders. New York is flipping the statute to claim the borrower defrauded the lenders, despite the lenders denying there was any fraud and there was no harm. The entire case is ridiculous.

    Appearing on CNN, O’Leary Ventures Chairman Kevin O’Leary outlines, to a perplexed Laura Coates, why Donald Trump’s civil fraud trial in New York is political nonsense.

    Every abuse makes Trump more popular with Independents and swing voters.

    Trump does not have independents and only carries about half of them when he runs against Biden.

    Trump is up by 8% in the swing state of Michigan. The presence of third parties, such as Green and No Labels, increases Trump’s spread to 12% [41-29] (2)

    Michigan is going to be a tough contest, because Wayne County is one of the primary places where Democrat operatives manufacture ballots. However, that said, President Trump is now leading Joe Biden by 8 points, slightly more than the estimated 5% fraudulent ballots the Democrats can create.

    The same observation I made for Mikel applies to you as well. Your #NeverTrump zealotry is self destructive. You would be better served by being more realistic and less histrionic.

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇
    ____________________

    (1) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/12/kevin-oleary-explains-to-stunned-cnn-audience-why-new-york-case-against-president-trump-is-nonsense/

    (2) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/09/president-trump-holds-8-point-lead-over-joe-biden-in-michigan/

    • Agree: Derer
    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @A123


    What will happen if Trump ends up with jail time? Are you still going to support him?
     
    What will happen if I end up with a Victoria’s Secret model? Am I going to enjoy it?

    Both are very silly propositions. Hypothetical questions are generally weak.

    An underwear model would indeed be a silly proposition when one isn't running.

    Trump however is facing over 91 felonies spread across four cases.

    It's an entirely possible scenario for him to receive jail time in one or more cases.

    I've noticed that Trump fans have a hard time with this question.

    It tells me they are trying to block out his legal problems instead of facing them.

    Every abuse makes Trump more popular with Independents and swing voters.

    Trump has only gained independents because of Biden's low polling.

    You do acknowledge that independents favor Haley over Trump?

    Why should Trump be the candidate if Haley polls better with independents?

    Replies: @A123, @Mr. XYZ

    , @songbird
    @A123


    What will happen if I end up with a Victoria’s Secret model? Am I going to enjoy it?
     
    Highly temporally conditional.

    With a time machine, able to go back ten years or more? Maybe. Currently? When they have a bloat of racially-diverse, obese women and trannies?
    _______
    Musk is predicting that SpaceX will do 90% of global mass to orbit this year.

    Replies: @A123

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @A123

    If Democrats manufacture ballots in minority-heavy areas, then why did Trump do better among minorities in 2020 than in 2016?

    Replies: @A123

  352. @Sher Singh
    https://blog.reaction.la/war/the-end-of-empire/

    Thoughts?

    https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1150620697639530561/1196070247329960016/image.png?ex=65b64a38&is=65a3d538&hm=be39dbddaa2de2c8b678219f4f972838dd3c0207158f69a01bdf453e9b95c5b4&

    Replies: @Derer

    I have the same sentiment. They keep rebuilding wooden shacks just to be destroyed by tornadoes again – economic activity, good for a fake GDP.

    • Replies: @Sher Singh
    @Derer

    https://neociceroniantimes.wordpress.com/2024/01/13/ready-for-it-to-get-spicy/

    Dems trying to ban private training + Texas kicking out border patrol to enforce laws itself.
    Interesting times ahead,

    Idk - just focused on immediate objectives/surroundings.

    Focused on the Sword.

    ਅਕਾਲ

  353. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Was Nazi Germany actually at risk of taking Teschen? It looks like there was still some remaining Czech territory in the way between the Sudetenland and Teschen:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/b5/Czechoslovakia_1939.SVG/1920px-Czechoslovakia_1939.SVG.png

    Or was Poland already anticipating the Nazi occupation of Czechia (which indeed happened in Mach 1939) back in late 1938?

    Replies: @AP, @Derer

    The behaviour of Horthy’s (war criminal) Hungary was the most despicable by joining opportunistically Germany. After Stalingrad defeat they tried to kiss Stalin feet.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Derer

    Horthy's biggest mistake was trying to backstab Hitler in 1944 by trying to make a separate peace, possibly in an attempt to keep some of Hungary's territorial gains in the post-WWII era. It failed miserably and resulted in the mass murder of hundreds of thousands of Hungarian Jews. And Hungary didn't even get to keep any of its 1938-1941 territorial gains after the end of WWII, so it was all for nothing! At least Horthy could have been proud of not getting hanged by the Allies, I guess.

    Replies: @Beckow

  354. @AnonfromTN
    @QCIC


    the main thing left for the Germans is luxury branding.
     
    That’s true for Mercedes, BMW, and even Audi, where at least half of the price is for the brand, not for the car itself. This is not true for VW. In fact, VW of similar quality is cheaper than Japanese cars. When I bought my first Tiguan, it was ~$7,000 cheaper than Subaru Outback, which was not better in any way (I test-drove both). Besides, German cars protect you because they are made of metal, whereas Japanese cars are made of some crap or other: you can dent any Japanese car by kicking it with your booted foot. If you once see results of an accident involving German or American car and a Japanese car (regardless of the manufacturer), you would never buy a Japanese car.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Besides, German cars protect you because they are made of metal, whereas Japanese cars are made of some crap or other: you can dent any Japanese car by kicking it with your booted foot.

    Oh give me a break.

    German and Japanese cars are subjected to the same strict auto safety standards in the US.

    They all have metal frames. They would fail with anything else.

    I find most Japanese cars to be boring and soulless but there is no reason to assume they are subpar when it comes to safety. The Mazda 3 has a 5 star safety rating:
    https://www.iihs.org/ratings/vehicle/mazda/3-4-door-sedan/2021

    You do want to be in a lot of metal when driving in the US which is why I would avoid compacts of any brand. I’ve seen what happens when they meet an F150. Not good.

  355. @A123
    @John Johnson


    What will happen if Trump ends up with jail time? Are you still going to support him?
     
    What will happen if I end up with a Victoria's Secret model? Am I going to enjoy it?

    Both are very silly propositions. Hypothetical questions are generally weak. They are not useful for gathering information when the scenario in question has a probability of 0%.

    Absolutely everyone understands that the cases being thrown at Trump are laughable: (1)


    Everything about the case in New York City against the Trump Organization business operations is ridiculous. There are no victims. There was no fraud. All of the lenders did their own due diligence. All of the loans were paid back without issue, and the statement of financial condition was factual and accurate. There were no defaults or banking interests adversely impacted. There are no victims of what the State calls “fraud.”

    New York Attorney General Latisha James campaigned for office with promises to target the Trump Organization and Donald Trump himself. This is malicious Lawfare in the extreme. Additionally, the statute being used as the predicate for the case is a consumer fraud statute, intended to protect borrowers from predatory lenders. In the four corners of this case, Trump is the borrower, and the banks were the lenders. New York is flipping the statute to claim the borrower defrauded the lenders, despite the lenders denying there was any fraud and there was no harm. The entire case is ridiculous.

    Appearing on CNN, O’Leary Ventures Chairman Kevin O’Leary outlines, to a perplexed Laura Coates, why Donald Trump’s civil fraud trial in New York is political nonsense.

    https://youtu.be/80RZs9Fhz3Y


     

    Every abuse makes Trump more popular with Independents and swing voters.

    Trump does not have independents and only carries about half of them when he runs against Biden.
     
    Trump is up by 8% in the swing state of Michigan. The presence of third parties, such as Green and No Labels, increases Trump's spread to 12% [41-29] (2)

    Michigan is going to be a tough contest, because Wayne County is one of the primary places where Democrat operatives manufacture ballots. However, that said, President Trump is now leading Joe Biden by 8 points, slightly more than the estimated 5% fraudulent ballots the Democrats can create.
     
    The same observation I made for Mikel applies to you as well. Your #NeverTrump zealotry is self destructive. You would be better served by being more realistic and less histrionic.


    #LetsGoBrandon 😇
    ____________________

    (1) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/12/kevin-oleary-explains-to-stunned-cnn-audience-why-new-york-case-against-president-trump-is-nonsense/

    (2) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/09/president-trump-holds-8-point-lead-over-joe-biden-in-michigan/

    Replies: @John Johnson, @songbird, @Mr. XYZ

    What will happen if Trump ends up with jail time? Are you still going to support him?

    What will happen if I end up with a Victoria’s Secret model? Am I going to enjoy it?

    Both are very silly propositions. Hypothetical questions are generally weak.

    An underwear model would indeed be a silly proposition when one isn’t running.

    Trump however is facing over 91 felonies spread across four cases.

    It’s an entirely possible scenario for him to receive jail time in one or more cases.

    I’ve noticed that Trump fans have a hard time with this question.

    It tells me they are trying to block out his legal problems instead of facing them.

    Every abuse makes Trump more popular with Independents and swing voters.

    Trump has only gained independents because of Biden’s low polling.

    You do acknowledge that independents favor Haley over Trump?

    Why should Trump be the candidate if Haley polls better with independents?

    • Agree: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @A123
    @John Johnson


    It’s an entirely possible scenario for him to receive jail time in one or more cases. I’ve noticed that Trump fans have a hard time with this question. It tells me they are trying to block out his legal problems instead of facing them.
     
    I have noticed that #NeverTrump zealots have serious problems with this fantasy. It tells me they are trying to block out Trump's inevitable 2nd Term instead of facing it.

    There is no, nada, zilch, zero possible scenario for Trump to receive jail time in any of these obviously ludicrous cases. They all keep blowing up in ways that make him popular. (2)

    Well, well, well… isn’t this interesting. In a court filing today, one of the co-defendants in the Fulton County election case against President Trump is presenting very specific details of an intimate relationship between District Attorney Fani Willis and the Special Prosecutor she hired, Nathan Wade.

    At first review, if the allegations are true, DA Willis had a financial motivation to initiate the case against Trump, as her boyfriend was the primary financial beneficiary. The filing documents how Fani Willis and Nathan Wade took several extravagant vacations and indulged in an exclusive lifestyle as the result of payments Willis’s office made to Wade.

    If investigated as accurate, this could be very legally problematic for the Fulton County District Attorney and her case against President Trump. The conflict of interest is very bright under this spotlight. [Also, lolol 😂]
     
    You really need to be less delusional and more attuned to the real world. You have to accept the objective reality that Trump is genuinely popular with independents and swing voters.

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇
    _____________________

    (1) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/08/georgia-court-filing-alleges-da-fani-willis-appointed-and-paid-her-lover-nathan-wade-654000-to-prosecute-donald-trump/

    Replies: @John Johnson

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson

    I think that Trump's supporters view him as the second coming of Jesus and would thus be unwilling to sacrifice their support of him even if it means getting a much more electable GOP presidential candidate in 2024. They're fanatically devoted to Trump, after all, not necessarily to the GOP ("The Stupid Party") as a whole.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  356. @John Johnson
    @A123


    What will happen if Trump ends up with jail time? Are you still going to support him?
     
    What will happen if I end up with a Victoria’s Secret model? Am I going to enjoy it?

    Both are very silly propositions. Hypothetical questions are generally weak.

    An underwear model would indeed be a silly proposition when one isn't running.

    Trump however is facing over 91 felonies spread across four cases.

    It's an entirely possible scenario for him to receive jail time in one or more cases.

    I've noticed that Trump fans have a hard time with this question.

    It tells me they are trying to block out his legal problems instead of facing them.

    Every abuse makes Trump more popular with Independents and swing voters.

    Trump has only gained independents because of Biden's low polling.

    You do acknowledge that independents favor Haley over Trump?

    Why should Trump be the candidate if Haley polls better with independents?

    Replies: @A123, @Mr. XYZ

    It’s an entirely possible scenario for him to receive jail time in one or more cases. I’ve noticed that Trump fans have a hard time with this question. It tells me they are trying to block out his legal problems instead of facing them.

    I have noticed that #NeverTrump zealots have serious problems with this fantasy. It tells me they are trying to block out Trump’s inevitable 2nd Term instead of facing it.

    There is no, nada, zilch, zero possible scenario for Trump to receive jail time in any of these obviously ludicrous cases. They all keep blowing up in ways that make him popular. (2)

    Well, well, well… isn’t this interesting. In a court filing today, one of the co-defendants in the Fulton County election case against President Trump is presenting very specific details of an intimate relationship between District Attorney Fani Willis and the Special Prosecutor she hired, Nathan Wade.

    At first review, if the allegations are true, DA Willis had a financial motivation to initiate the case against Trump, as her boyfriend was the primary financial beneficiary. The filing documents how Fani Willis and Nathan Wade took several extravagant vacations and indulged in an exclusive lifestyle as the result of payments Willis’s office made to Wade.

    If investigated as accurate, this could be very legally problematic for the Fulton County District Attorney and her case against President Trump. The conflict of interest is very bright under this spotlight. [Also, lolol 😂]

    You really need to be less delusional and more attuned to the real world. You have to accept the objective reality that Trump is genuinely popular with independents and swing voters.

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇
    _____________________

    (1) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/08/georgia-court-filing-alleges-da-fani-willis-appointed-and-paid-her-lover-nathan-wade-654000-to-prosecute-donald-trump/

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @A123

    I have noticed that #NeverTrump zealots have serious problems with this fantasy. It tells me they are trying to block out Trump’s inevitable 2nd Term instead of facing it.

    So you can't answer a simple question.

    I don't have fantasies of Trump going to prison. I would like him to leave the race on his own. That would be the ideal scenario. He quits and his pending felonies are no longer a risk factor.

    The best chance of Biden losing is for Trump to leave. I can back that with data. No fantasy required.

    There is no, nada, zilch, zero possible scenario for Trump to receive jail time in any of these obviously ludicrous cases.

    Did you state in the previously election that he would definitely win?

    You really need to be less delusional and more attuned to the real world. You have to accept the objective reality that Trump is genuinely popular with independents and swing voters.

    How exactly am I being delusional?

    Do you deny that polls show Haley doing better against Biden?

    Replies: @A123, @Mikel

  357. @John Johnson
    @AP

    He got sick in jail, received medical care but it was too later and he died of his illness. He had been ill before he was arrested, some kind of heart problems.

    He spoke of getting double pneumonia and a collapsed lung but said nothing of the cause. No mention of COVID or complaints about getting something from the prisoners.

    Sure it is possible that he picked up something in prison but why wouldn't he state that?

    The guy chain smoked in his interviews. In one of the few videos he didn't remove you can see that one cigarette wasn't enough for the interview.

    Then he "just happens" to have lung problems in prison but doesn't ask his sister to contact the state department?

    I really don't like Anglin but he figured this one out. The guy wanted to die. Most likely had a terminal condition and wanted to go out as a martyr.

    Lira's fans seem to think he was a suppressed journalist that was killed by a Western conspiracy. Ok well let's see ONE essay from him on Russia since 2020. All I have seen are few videos where he chain smokes and talks about how Russia is about to win. He scrubbed all his "red pill" videos and there are few mentions of his wife. Highly suspicious.

    Replies: @AP

    The guy chain smoked in his interviews. In one of the few videos he didn’t remove you can see that one cigarette wasn’t enough for the interview.

    Then he “just happens” to have lung problems in prison but doesn’t ask his sister to contact the state department?

    I really don’t like Anglin but he figured this one out. The guy wanted to die. Most likely had a terminal condition and wanted to go out as a martyr.

    Totally agree. His decision to brag about skipping bail, basically forcing the authorities to arrest him, supports this.

    And idiots or people who should know better play along, pretend he is a real martyr.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @AP

    Totally agree. His decision to brag about skipping bail, basically forcing the authorities to arrest him, supports this.

    And idiots or people who should know better play along, pretend he is a real martyr.

    His supporters haven't provided me with a single article where he challenges the system or common assumptions. I honestly expected one by now but no one has provided a single source.

    As far as I can tell he mostly blabbed to youtube videos while smoking and then later removed them.

    I don't buy for one second that the guy was a pickup artist. I watched one of his "coach redpill" videos and he came across as bitter and lacking experience with women. We're supposed to believe that a guy with slob style who chain smokes and calls women houers is an expert at picking them up. Yea.....sure.

  358. @A123
    @John Johnson


    What will happen if Trump ends up with jail time? Are you still going to support him?
     
    What will happen if I end up with a Victoria's Secret model? Am I going to enjoy it?

    Both are very silly propositions. Hypothetical questions are generally weak. They are not useful for gathering information when the scenario in question has a probability of 0%.

    Absolutely everyone understands that the cases being thrown at Trump are laughable: (1)


    Everything about the case in New York City against the Trump Organization business operations is ridiculous. There are no victims. There was no fraud. All of the lenders did their own due diligence. All of the loans were paid back without issue, and the statement of financial condition was factual and accurate. There were no defaults or banking interests adversely impacted. There are no victims of what the State calls “fraud.”

    New York Attorney General Latisha James campaigned for office with promises to target the Trump Organization and Donald Trump himself. This is malicious Lawfare in the extreme. Additionally, the statute being used as the predicate for the case is a consumer fraud statute, intended to protect borrowers from predatory lenders. In the four corners of this case, Trump is the borrower, and the banks were the lenders. New York is flipping the statute to claim the borrower defrauded the lenders, despite the lenders denying there was any fraud and there was no harm. The entire case is ridiculous.

    Appearing on CNN, O’Leary Ventures Chairman Kevin O’Leary outlines, to a perplexed Laura Coates, why Donald Trump’s civil fraud trial in New York is political nonsense.

    https://youtu.be/80RZs9Fhz3Y


     

    Every abuse makes Trump more popular with Independents and swing voters.

    Trump does not have independents and only carries about half of them when he runs against Biden.
     
    Trump is up by 8% in the swing state of Michigan. The presence of third parties, such as Green and No Labels, increases Trump's spread to 12% [41-29] (2)

    Michigan is going to be a tough contest, because Wayne County is one of the primary places where Democrat operatives manufacture ballots. However, that said, President Trump is now leading Joe Biden by 8 points, slightly more than the estimated 5% fraudulent ballots the Democrats can create.
     
    The same observation I made for Mikel applies to you as well. Your #NeverTrump zealotry is self destructive. You would be better served by being more realistic and less histrionic.


    #LetsGoBrandon 😇
    ____________________

    (1) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/12/kevin-oleary-explains-to-stunned-cnn-audience-why-new-york-case-against-president-trump-is-nonsense/

    (2) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/09/president-trump-holds-8-point-lead-over-joe-biden-in-michigan/

    Replies: @John Johnson, @songbird, @Mr. XYZ

    What will happen if I end up with a Victoria’s Secret model? Am I going to enjoy it?

    Highly temporally conditional.

    With a time machine, able to go back ten years or more? Maybe. Currently? When they have a bloat of racially-diverse, obese women and trannies?
    _______
    Musk is predicting that SpaceX will do 90% of global mass to orbit this year.

    • Agree: A123
    • Replies: @A123
    @songbird

    Those around for a while should assume the proper context -- the prior era of VS, not current day. Perhaps I should have been more specific for new readers.

    PEACE 😇



     
    https://images5.fanpop.com/image/photos/31500000/angels-victorias-secret-angels-31559235-720-720.jpg

    Replies: @songbird

  359. @Derer
    @Sher Singh

    I have the same sentiment. They keep rebuilding wooden shacks just to be destroyed by tornadoes again - economic activity, good for a fake GDP.

    Replies: @Sher Singh

    https://neociceroniantimes.wordpress.com/2024/01/13/ready-for-it-to-get-spicy/

    Dems trying to ban private training + Texas kicking out border patrol to enforce laws itself.
    Interesting times ahead,

    Idk – just focused on immediate objectives/surroundings.

    Focused on the Sword.

    ਅਕਾਲ

  360. @songbird
    @A123


    What will happen if I end up with a Victoria’s Secret model? Am I going to enjoy it?
     
    Highly temporally conditional.

    With a time machine, able to go back ten years or more? Maybe. Currently? When they have a bloat of racially-diverse, obese women and trannies?
    _______
    Musk is predicting that SpaceX will do 90% of global mass to orbit this year.

    Replies: @A123

    Those around for a while should assume the proper context — the prior era of VS, not current day. Perhaps I should have been more specific for new readers.

    PEACE 😇

    [MORE]

     

    • Replies: @songbird
    @A123

    The change in advertising across the West is more significant than the men airbrushed out of Soviet pictures, IMO. I have no doubt that it will enter into history books.

  361. @A123
    @John Johnson


    It’s an entirely possible scenario for him to receive jail time in one or more cases. I’ve noticed that Trump fans have a hard time with this question. It tells me they are trying to block out his legal problems instead of facing them.
     
    I have noticed that #NeverTrump zealots have serious problems with this fantasy. It tells me they are trying to block out Trump's inevitable 2nd Term instead of facing it.

    There is no, nada, zilch, zero possible scenario for Trump to receive jail time in any of these obviously ludicrous cases. They all keep blowing up in ways that make him popular. (2)

    Well, well, well… isn’t this interesting. In a court filing today, one of the co-defendants in the Fulton County election case against President Trump is presenting very specific details of an intimate relationship between District Attorney Fani Willis and the Special Prosecutor she hired, Nathan Wade.

    At first review, if the allegations are true, DA Willis had a financial motivation to initiate the case against Trump, as her boyfriend was the primary financial beneficiary. The filing documents how Fani Willis and Nathan Wade took several extravagant vacations and indulged in an exclusive lifestyle as the result of payments Willis’s office made to Wade.

    If investigated as accurate, this could be very legally problematic for the Fulton County District Attorney and her case against President Trump. The conflict of interest is very bright under this spotlight. [Also, lolol 😂]
     
    You really need to be less delusional and more attuned to the real world. You have to accept the objective reality that Trump is genuinely popular with independents and swing voters.

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇
    _____________________

    (1) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/08/georgia-court-filing-alleges-da-fani-willis-appointed-and-paid-her-lover-nathan-wade-654000-to-prosecute-donald-trump/

    Replies: @John Johnson

    I have noticed that #NeverTrump zealots have serious problems with this fantasy. It tells me they are trying to block out Trump’s inevitable 2nd Term instead of facing it.

    So you can’t answer a simple question.

    I don’t have fantasies of Trump going to prison. I would like him to leave the race on his own. That would be the ideal scenario. He quits and his pending felonies are no longer a risk factor.

    The best chance of Biden losing is for Trump to leave. I can back that with data. No fantasy required.

    There is no, nada, zilch, zero possible scenario for Trump to receive jail time in any of these obviously ludicrous cases.

    Did you state in the previously election that he would definitely win?

    You really need to be less delusional and more attuned to the real world. You have to accept the objective reality that Trump is genuinely popular with independents and swing voters.

    How exactly am I being delusional?

    Do you deny that polls show Haley doing better against Biden?

    • Replies: @A123
    @John Johnson


    So you can’t answer a simple question.
     
    I can answer simple questions.

    I cannot answer delusional ones reliant on circumstances only present in a Marvel multiverse fiasco.

    How exactly am I being delusional?
     
    Your delusion is that there is any chance of Trump going to jail. There is no, nada, zilch, zero possible scenario for Trump to receive jail time in any of these obviously ludicrous cases.

    Do you deny that polls show Haley doing better against Biden?
     
    Do you deny that Trump is doing better against Haley?

    She is an anti-MAGA establishment RINO with no chance of winning the primary. Therefore, her theoretical polling in a "never going to happen" Haley-Biden matchup is irrelevant. Much like your irrelevant & unanswerable question about Trump jail time that will never happen.

    He quits and his pending felonies are no longer a risk factor.
     
    Thank you for admitting the persecutions targeting Trump are about politics, not justice.

    This is a huge step forward for you.

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    , @Mikel
    @John Johnson


    Do you deny that polls show Haley doing better against Biden?
     
    So, if polls showed Hillary Clinton doing better than Trump against Biden, should we nominate her the Republican candidate? How is Haley better than Biden for those who liked the MAGA-16 agenda: end forever wars, bring US troops back home, build the wall, deport the illegals, combat wokeness,...? Just because she's right of Biden on tax cuts?

    And if Dems should be so worried about Haley, why are many of them registering as Republicans and voting for her today in Iowa?

    Just like I find it hard to believe that Trump can beat Biden in November, I find it even harder to believe that there is a legitimate path for such a RINO as Haley to become the Republican nominee. That ship has sailed, the Republican party is not going back to where you'd like it. Millions of voters would rather vote for RFK or stay home, me and A123 included (for different reasons, I care about the policies and he cares about the man but we both represent very important parts of the current American electorate).


    The guy wanted to die.
     
    Just because he had some weird death wish (why, if not, would anyone stay in Ukraine after the Russian invasion and post videos against the Kiev regime? That could have costed him his life even before the start of the war) it doesn't mean that Kiev had to comply with his wish.

    Perhaps Billy Hayes, imprisoned and tortured in Turkey, or Charles Horman, killed by the Pinochet regime, also had weird death wishes and that's why they decided to travel to s-thole countries and "break their laws" but that doesn't mean that the authorities in those countries acted in a moral way.

    I never saw any of Lira's videos (certainly not in full) before he re-appeared from prison. I flagged him early on as somebody I wasn't going to get any valuable information from and ignored the creepy-looking and sounding guy. But I'm pretty sure that I have posted here and elsewhere content as objectionable to the Kiev goons as what he said in those videos that would also land me in jail, as have so many of the regulars here. In fact, long before this war started I received personal threats in English-language Ukrainian media from Ukrainians who couldn't stomach my views opposing the shelling of civilians in Donbass. The Sovok/goon mentality that I encountered in Kiev in the 90s is clearly alive and well still in Ukraine.

    I have obviously no intention of visiting Ukraine again, though I don't know why I should be afraid of visiting a country whose civil servants, including the thugs that would possibly arrest me, are receiving their salaries with money from my taxes. But someone telling me that the Ukrainians did nothing wrong in Lira's death is essentially telling me that they wouldn't give a hoot either if they learned that I had died in a filthy Ukrainian prison for posting what I am posting here. OK, fair enough, you don't know me personally so why should you care about my life more about Ukraine's sovereignty and all those high principles of yours? But then go fuck yourselves too. I can't have any respect at a personal level for people who make excuses for the death of a blogger in a country of goons. It could have been Lira or it could have been any of us here.

    Replies: @A123, @John Johnson

  362. @Sher Singh
    https://nitter.net/Estimator91/with_replies

    Russian friend, based takes -NEW FAVORITE RUSSIAN POSTER - FK KARLIN

    No intellectual in the 19th or 20th century viewed Slavs as a part of Western civilization.
    Even Czechs were massively hated let alone to the East.
    The only reason this now exists is that Westerners want to be accepted as refuges or sexpats since there women are fat and annoying.

    Eh he had a good funny tweet like America will be majority brown & I will vote for it.
    He basically supports Westoid genocide due to their love of negroids.

    Here's some more - I block him occasionally cuz he goes off the rails.
    Math teacher in California.


    republicans switched to hating on immigration instead of blacks

    westoids will follow any legal pathway to harm ethnics, but will do nothing to harm monkeys, this is why I support ethnics in replacing every last one of them

    hating indians and jews is generally inversely proportional to hating blacks and Arabs (respectively)

    MENA/Turks can just be integrated MENA + German = Italian, look up admixture charts

    every single pensioner can leave ukraine and live on social benefits in the west, but Zelensky's focus is on sucking slavs by ensuring only 16-25 year old girls leave

    he is aryan, you are not, I would support him nuking you and raping your women

    she's Afrikaner and adopted joggers to only turn them into trannies, probably the most based Western woman

    I prefer Tajiks to Blacks
    Tajiks are the best possible Central Asians
    This obviously means I love Tajiks and want Tajiks to have sex with Natalia

    insecure girl will leave you when you raise her ego, its important to gaslight and to keep her insecure about herself

    california >>>> germany, Germany is below most large Asian countries
    Without Jewish particle physics what have Germans even invented past 100 years lmao?


    It's honestly disgusting how the low IQ right is willing to accept literally any Соngоіd grifter, as long as he names "them". It doesn't matter how gross they are, what retardations they say, how they lust over our women -- if they name "them" they must be perfectly tolerable!!!

    Jews (Ashkenazim) are part of an ethnic group with paternal line from the levant and maternal lineage linked to the Basque. Nuclear Fission, high end semiconductors and Helicopters (Sikorsky) are all Judeo-Slavic inventions.


    Italians are so bad at math that Italy has 3x fewer Gold Medals than a Bulgaria with 10x fewer people; they have roughly the same total medal counts as Serbia, despite Serbia having only competed since 2006 vs Italy since 1967

    Elites deserve elite things, regardless of where they come from. I am anti populist, anti nativist, anti nationalist, pro segregationist, pro classist, pro racist, pro elitist, pro casteist.
     
    "Herr derrrr why don't you improve your own country"

    They are not responsible for that. The same way 95% of Westoids have nothing to do with their undeserved living conditions which are merely the result of democratic extraction from their superiors (me)

    The middle class is largely not responsible for its conditions its the result of policies which allow them to rent seek (protectionism)

    Name the greatest things you admire about each culture:
    Western Europe - Sentience
    Jews - Intelligence
    North East Asia - Memorization
    South East Asia - Repression
    South Asia - Caste System
    MENA - Women's Rights
    Latin America - Torture
     
    regardless of who you try to shift the blame to, it doesn't change my original point, america has no issues "assimilating' migrants. Unless you're talking about some culture that doesn't exist. The average American watches monkey sports and average white American girl fucks them

    surely it was the fault of capitalism that British decided to destroy private property free market apartheid system with monkey communism where half the population lives on gibsmedats

    Supporting communist movements fighting westoids is fine, we did it because we hate westoids, anglos literally acted to end apartheid out of specific ideological love for black cock

    anglo saxons crush car of povertycel Iraqis for salvaging for wood in their own country, but offer their women and welfare on a. platter for looting feral shit filed monkeys that pollute their land
     
    how does assimilation into degenerate sexual liberal monkey culture have anything to do with being European

    I don' think the golden billion deserve sole access to any of the wealth and capital in their countries. Now, for the EU I just want it delinked from the global reserve currency and for it to collapse into Argentina tier inflation

    most westoids are extremely comfortable, they re born into comfort that they had no role in creating, but was merely handed to them by their betters through the abolishment of serfdom
    Im an actual elitist, and belong to the class that created everything in the West. Immigrants>

    your women sleep with monkeys, I'd rather have swarths replace your race than seeing any more of these whores complaining that that they can't live for free
     
    Suppressing Iranian diaspora and opponents of the Islamic Republic is a very good thing for the country
    Most of them are brown
    The Aryan population of Iran should increase from 30% to 50%

    you are a simp or cuck, she should be forced to work in sex slavery

    We kill joggers in my ancestral homeland, we don't take too kindly to "monkey business". This is a Westoid problem, but I agree, Westoids hate you more than they hate joggers, that's why you should spread the world among your diaspora to crush them when you become a majority.

    this is an idea that I have been spreading for years, great to know the Indian community has caught on! Next time you're in Anglo country, make sure to import your entire extended family by any means possible, and to do whatever you please.

    this roastie should be working more
    and we need more immigration to drive down wages because I don't want simps to have money to take care of her

    Latinxs have complete control over the Catholic Church any nation with a significant Catholic population will eventually have a population of mfs acting like Mexicans I won’t be surprised if in 10 years Poles started acting like Mexicans

    India doesn't have public education, the government wastes money on welfare. Even in richer states fewer than half the students go to public schools. PISA is just a test of education spending, unless you unironically think American blacks are smarter than Serbs
     
    You need to save money to invest money, this is also why Africa wont see any growth, it'll just see growth in people on subsistence level , high TFR = automatic low growth or poverty for unindustrialized countries

    What about Israel?

    Israel is rich because of gibs, that's part of why they are rich, they got free money, now do I oppose that? no better Israel than blacks, but without gibs Israel would likely be as poor as it was in the 70

    India doesn't spend any money on scientific research, its space program gets a tenth of China's funding. India practices a very cancerous type of populist agrarian socialism

    https://nitter.net/Estimator91/status/1744385048298631344#m

    So what?

    I don't see the problem with this, I wil enforce hierarchies, there is no problem with DV, it is necessary actually, I live in a country that makes it legal, what are you going to do about it, cry?

    imagine how cucked the west is that the supposed incels and "misogynists" are like NOOOO YOU CANT HIT WOMEN

    LOL

    I admire Chechens and browns, they acid face whores. That is the rule. Rules must be followed.

    one of the primary reasons I support Chechen and muslims like Dargins becoming bigger is that even if they are 40% of russia it will only force Russians to behave like them and thats based
     
    https://nitter.net/datepsych/status/1744013390211645652#mv

    “Men with stronger misogynistic beliefs and higher levels of violated entitlement are more likely to engage in revenge planning, which in turn, predicts a stronger willingness to engage in violent extremism and interpersonal violence.”

    “More generally, engaging in misogyny may help to uplift men’s self/group image and worth, particularly if women are perceived to threaten traditional gender norms and hierarchies. Hence, the use of violence may be linked to men’s resentment toward their perceived loss of dominance and masculinity, in which revenge is seen to restore power and control. Our results are in line with studies that found hostile sexism among men to be related to (male) collective narcissism, while collective narcissism was further associated with retaliatory intergroup aggression and an increased desire for revenge, particularly against threatening outgroups.”

     

    TLDR Men who hit women are also likely to hit other men.

    russia should demand all Ukrainians are immediately deported to ukraine as a condition of ending the war, unless that happens as much of ukraine should be taken as possible
     
    slavs need to abandon orthodoxy, christianity and anything gay and cucked like that in general

    Christianity preaches forgiveness muh sins of the father slavs must always remember the children of their enemy is an even bigger enemy.

    the first and foremost enemy you need to take care of is any offspring of your enemy before going after the enemy itself

    you're engaged to a slant, your kids will be incels LOL

    Japan should be replaced by as many immigrants as possible, stop sim-ping for slant eyed freaks if you're pro Slavic, Eurasianism refers to West Asia, East Asia is to be used then nuked
     
    China will pass the EU in per capita GDP, because the EU is filled with lazy retards

    It won't pass the US ever

    kazakhs and East Asians are worse than MENA or even south asians, they share neither a paternal line nor are genetically close, they are dirty monkeys

    >they hate women
    Based

    >they use their women
    Even more based

    I'm visiting India now and unfortunately most of this is false, I think Iran is better, would be based if true though, will visit RURAL punjab soon.


    It's amazing how American whites will actively bootlick baboons and praise them over Indians. Truly insane. Nation of baboon lover

    All racism in the West not directed at baboons is at their defense

    No matter who it's to, whether it's to mestizos, jews, East Asians, blacks etc it's all part of a primary purpose to defend baboons, no matter what you will ALWAYS see it intertwined with a defense of monkeys

    mexicans and MENA* most non western groups dont really understand the purpose of this racism, this racism ultimately applies to all of them because it's founded on the core principle of the West: suck black cock or perish

    Ok I am convinced

    We need to import the entire population of India to the anglosphere

    That is the only way to solve every problem, as reward they get to breed as many anglo women as they want

    We already set out the tajiks on German women in 1945, it is your turn now

    I am convinced more than ever we need 250 million indians, 200 million south East Asians and 250 million sub saharan africans (the latter because there needs to be more lynchings for me to watch) imported into the United States


    https://nitter.net/Estimator91/status/1744129506216997113#m

    Azeri (Least white caucasians) + Russian = Italian
    Georgian + Russian = French/Hungarian
    Armenian + Russian = Romanian
    German + Syrian = Greek


    no we aren't lol, we leave EU, you die, we remain, same for Jews

    Is Israel "threatened" because Westoid women are monkeylovers? lol no

    Keep coping

    Your death is our gain

    only yours is existentially threatened, why should I support slavic women to emigrate to your shithole to provide you women cause your women like monkeys and baboons? lol fuck off, better you die

    >Whines about East Asians and mexicans when your country is filled with blacks
    >Doesn't say a word about blacks
    >Regfuses to blame white women being whores and instead tries to blame the "media"and "jews" for normies being degenerates that don't deserve to pass on their genes









    https://www.cremieux.xyz/p/the-myth-of-nigerian-excellence

    Replies: @Sher Singh

    Can Unz delete this comment or edit out the math teacher in cali part, please?

  363. @AP
    @John Johnson


    The guy chain smoked in his interviews. In one of the few videos he didn’t remove you can see that one cigarette wasn’t enough for the interview.

    Then he “just happens” to have lung problems in prison but doesn’t ask his sister to contact the state department?

    I really don’t like Anglin but he figured this one out. The guy wanted to die. Most likely had a terminal condition and wanted to go out as a martyr.
     
    Totally agree. His decision to brag about skipping bail, basically forcing the authorities to arrest him, supports this.


    And idiots or people who should know better play along, pretend he is a real martyr.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Totally agree. His decision to brag about skipping bail, basically forcing the authorities to arrest him, supports this.

    And idiots or people who should know better play along, pretend he is a real martyr.

    His supporters haven’t provided me with a single article where he challenges the system or common assumptions. I honestly expected one by now but no one has provided a single source.

    As far as I can tell he mostly blabbed to youtube videos while smoking and then later removed them.

    I don’t buy for one second that the guy was a pickup artist. I watched one of his “coach redpill” videos and he came across as bitter and lacking experience with women. We’re supposed to believe that a guy with slob style who chain smokes and calls women houers is an expert at picking them up. Yea…..sure.

  364. @John Johnson
    @A123

    I have noticed that #NeverTrump zealots have serious problems with this fantasy. It tells me they are trying to block out Trump’s inevitable 2nd Term instead of facing it.

    So you can't answer a simple question.

    I don't have fantasies of Trump going to prison. I would like him to leave the race on his own. That would be the ideal scenario. He quits and his pending felonies are no longer a risk factor.

    The best chance of Biden losing is for Trump to leave. I can back that with data. No fantasy required.

    There is no, nada, zilch, zero possible scenario for Trump to receive jail time in any of these obviously ludicrous cases.

    Did you state in the previously election that he would definitely win?

    You really need to be less delusional and more attuned to the real world. You have to accept the objective reality that Trump is genuinely popular with independents and swing voters.

    How exactly am I being delusional?

    Do you deny that polls show Haley doing better against Biden?

    Replies: @A123, @Mikel

    So you can’t answer a simple question.

    I can answer simple questions.

    I cannot answer delusional ones reliant on circumstances only present in a Marvel multiverse fiasco.

    How exactly am I being delusional?

    Your delusion is that there is any chance of Trump going to jail. There is no, nada, zilch, zero possible scenario for Trump to receive jail time in any of these obviously ludicrous cases.

    Do you deny that polls show Haley doing better against Biden?

    Do you deny that Trump is doing better against Haley?

    She is an anti-MAGA establishment RINO with no chance of winning the primary. Therefore, her theoretical polling in a “never going to happen” Haley-Biden matchup is irrelevant. Much like your irrelevant & unanswerable question about Trump jail time that will never happen.

    He quits and his pending felonies are no longer a risk factor.

    Thank you for admitting the persecutions targeting Trump are about politics, not justice.

    This is a huge step forward for you.

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @A123


    He quits and his pending felonies are no longer a risk factor.
     
    Thank you for admitting the persecutions targeting Trump are about politics, not justice.

    I admitted no such thing.

    If he quits then his pending felonies are no longer a risk factor in defeating Biden. That is what I meant.

    It wouldn't matter if he goes to jail or if a judge bars him from politics. Haley would get the nomination and she has the best chance of defeating Biden.

    If Trump was only facing the Trump U case and juicing his properties then his fans would have less to worry about.

    But the documents case is a problem. It's not merely Trump against a judge.

    He asked an employee to delete footage of them moving documents
    https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/7/27/us-special-counsel-names-third-defendant-in-trump-classified-document-case

    That's tampering with evidence in a Federal case.

    You can't do that. Trump really screwed up.

    , @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GD1KUaBa8AAkBoK.jpg

  365. Big spikes in the magnetosphere thousands of years ago, as evidenced by clay tablets from the Middle East.

    Remains to be seen what effect such a change would have on satellites and other electrical equipment.

    [MORE]

  366. @A123
    @songbird

    Those around for a while should assume the proper context -- the prior era of VS, not current day. Perhaps I should have been more specific for new readers.

    PEACE 😇



     
    https://images5.fanpop.com/image/photos/31500000/angels-victorias-secret-angels-31559235-720-720.jpg

    Replies: @songbird

    The change in advertising across the West is more significant than the men airbrushed out of Soviet pictures, IMO. I have no doubt that it will enter into history books.

  367. Am amazed by this gigantic office building in India that has 70,000 employees. Would have thought that artificial diamonds would have crushed a lot of the diamond market by now.

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @songbird


    Would have thought that artificial diamonds would have crushed a lot of the diamond market by now.
     
    Artificial diamonds are a different commodity, they are much cheaper than natural ones. Any jeweler can tell the difference: artificial ones are perfect, whereas all natural have micro-inclusions. But the fewer it has and the smaller they are, the more diamond costs per carat: there is no logic.
    , @QCIC
    @songbird

    It looks nice. Do they have indoor plumbing?

    Replies: @songbird

  368. @A123
    @John Johnson


    So you can’t answer a simple question.
     
    I can answer simple questions.

    I cannot answer delusional ones reliant on circumstances only present in a Marvel multiverse fiasco.

    How exactly am I being delusional?
     
    Your delusion is that there is any chance of Trump going to jail. There is no, nada, zilch, zero possible scenario for Trump to receive jail time in any of these obviously ludicrous cases.

    Do you deny that polls show Haley doing better against Biden?
     
    Do you deny that Trump is doing better against Haley?

    She is an anti-MAGA establishment RINO with no chance of winning the primary. Therefore, her theoretical polling in a "never going to happen" Haley-Biden matchup is irrelevant. Much like your irrelevant & unanswerable question about Trump jail time that will never happen.

    He quits and his pending felonies are no longer a risk factor.
     
    Thank you for admitting the persecutions targeting Trump are about politics, not justice.

    This is a huge step forward for you.

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    He quits and his pending felonies are no longer a risk factor.

    Thank you for admitting the persecutions targeting Trump are about politics, not justice.

    I admitted no such thing.

    If he quits then his pending felonies are no longer a risk factor in defeating Biden. That is what I meant.

    It wouldn’t matter if he goes to jail or if a judge bars him from politics. Haley would get the nomination and she has the best chance of defeating Biden.

    If Trump was only facing the Trump U case and juicing his properties then his fans would have less to worry about.

    But the documents case is a problem. It’s not merely Trump against a judge.

    He asked an employee to delete footage of them moving documents
    https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/7/27/us-special-counsel-names-third-defendant-in-trump-classified-document-case

    That’s tampering with evidence in a Federal case.

    You can’t do that. Trump really screwed up.

    • LOL: A123
  369. @songbird
    Am amazed by this gigantic office building in India that has 70,000 employees. Would have thought that artificial diamonds would have crushed a lot of the diamond market by now.
    https://youtu.be/lOJO1osi9po?si=pne3Ppbwsi7KFC2a

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @QCIC

    Would have thought that artificial diamonds would have crushed a lot of the diamond market by now.

    Artificial diamonds are a different commodity, they are much cheaper than natural ones. Any jeweler can tell the difference: artificial ones are perfect, whereas all natural have micro-inclusions. But the fewer it has and the smaller they are, the more diamond costs per carat: there is no logic.

  370. @songbird
    Am amazed by this gigantic office building in India that has 70,000 employees. Would have thought that artificial diamonds would have crushed a lot of the diamond market by now.
    https://youtu.be/lOJO1osi9po?si=pne3Ppbwsi7KFC2a

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @QCIC

    It looks nice. Do they have indoor plumbing?

    • Replies: @songbird
    @QCIC

    Apparently, it was built by the government of Gujarat.

    Surat is considered by some to be the fastest-growing city in the world. In 1994, they had an outbreak of plague.

    The Egyptian vulture (which is partly known for eating feces) has a subspecies in India.

  371. @QCIC
    @songbird

    It looks nice. Do they have indoor plumbing?

    Replies: @songbird

    Apparently, it was built by the government of Gujarat.

    Surat is considered by some to be the fastest-growing city in the world. In 1994, they had an outbreak of plague.

    The Egyptian vulture (which is partly known for eating feces) has a subspecies in India.

  372. @John Johnson
    @QCIC

    Many and possibly most German export products have relatively high value-added. This business model is based on applying large amounts of capital to production.

    German products are overrated. Anyone who has worked on cars is aware of that.

    They sell the perception of quality based on the past.

    Audi/VW reliability dropped below Ford/Chevy ages ago and yet Mericans (especially liberals) think German car = better. They have no interest in the data.

    Owning an 2010ish Audi A4/A6 in rural America is a nightmare. People buy a used Audi and then learn they have to get it towed 2 hours to the nearest dealer when it breaks. Then said dealer can charge whatever they want. Oh well that's a German part. +$500.

    The gas mileage on them drops as they get older and they are oil burners. They end up getting the MPG of an SUV. What a joke. I hate these cars and good luck to all the boyfriends/husbands that have to work on them.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Barbarossa

    My experience is that German engineering often means that a given problem is solved by an unnecessarily complicated solution when a simpler one would do just as well. They also seem to make it hard for plebs to service things. I think the thought of non-specialists servicing their machines give German engineers palpitations.

    I totally agree with you on Audis/ BMWs. They are usually money pits to maintain.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Barbarossa

    They also seem to make it hard for plebs to service things. I think the thought of non-specialists servicing their machines give German engineers palpitations.

    This is how I felt working on a Volvo. It really felt engineered to discourage you from working on it. Maybe they copied the German model?

    I've cussed at Japanese cars but only because I've come across stuff that expects you to be a 110 lb mechanic with 1.5" forearms.

    All new cars can honestly be pretty annoying. There are definitely parts where they have moved them to some needlessly annoying spot where they want you to give up and take it in upon seeing what is required. Well it's two weeks around here to even see a mechanic. So I've actually planned on taking a car in and then fixed it myself because I'm not waiting 2-3 weeks.

    Replies: @Barbarossa

  373. @Derer
    @Mr. XYZ

    The behaviour of Horthy's (war criminal) Hungary was the most despicable by joining opportunistically Germany. After Stalingrad defeat they tried to kiss Stalin feet.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Horthy’s biggest mistake was trying to backstab Hitler in 1944 by trying to make a separate peace, possibly in an attempt to keep some of Hungary’s territorial gains in the post-WWII era. It failed miserably and resulted in the mass murder of hundreds of thousands of Hungarian Jews. And Hungary didn’t even get to keep any of its 1938-1941 territorial gains after the end of WWII, so it was all for nothing! At least Horthy could have been proud of not getting hanged by the Allies, I guess.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ


    ...Horthy’s biggest mistake was trying to backstab Hitler in 1944 by trying to make a separate peace
     
    Horthy's biggest mistakes were joining Nazi Germany in 1938 Munich Treaty to dismember Czechoslovakia (together with Poland), then grabbing territories of all surrounding countries, and sending 300k Magyars with Nazis in 1941 to invade Russia.

    What he did or didn't do in "1944" was irrelevant - by then Hungary was done, a defeated nation. You are analyzing it without understanding: by 1944 Germany was thoroughly defeated by Russia, the sad switche-roos by Italy, Romania, Hungary...were pointless. US-UK finally joining the war in June 1944 with the Normandy landing was similar, a belated attempt to join in and mitigate the defeat of Germany. (They then went ape-shit claiming the credit - Anglos are like that.)

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Hyperborean, @Mr. XYZ

  374. @A123
    @John Johnson


    What will happen if Trump ends up with jail time? Are you still going to support him?
     
    What will happen if I end up with a Victoria's Secret model? Am I going to enjoy it?

    Both are very silly propositions. Hypothetical questions are generally weak. They are not useful for gathering information when the scenario in question has a probability of 0%.

    Absolutely everyone understands that the cases being thrown at Trump are laughable: (1)


    Everything about the case in New York City against the Trump Organization business operations is ridiculous. There are no victims. There was no fraud. All of the lenders did their own due diligence. All of the loans were paid back without issue, and the statement of financial condition was factual and accurate. There were no defaults or banking interests adversely impacted. There are no victims of what the State calls “fraud.”

    New York Attorney General Latisha James campaigned for office with promises to target the Trump Organization and Donald Trump himself. This is malicious Lawfare in the extreme. Additionally, the statute being used as the predicate for the case is a consumer fraud statute, intended to protect borrowers from predatory lenders. In the four corners of this case, Trump is the borrower, and the banks were the lenders. New York is flipping the statute to claim the borrower defrauded the lenders, despite the lenders denying there was any fraud and there was no harm. The entire case is ridiculous.

    Appearing on CNN, O’Leary Ventures Chairman Kevin O’Leary outlines, to a perplexed Laura Coates, why Donald Trump’s civil fraud trial in New York is political nonsense.

    https://youtu.be/80RZs9Fhz3Y


     

    Every abuse makes Trump more popular with Independents and swing voters.

    Trump does not have independents and only carries about half of them when he runs against Biden.
     
    Trump is up by 8% in the swing state of Michigan. The presence of third parties, such as Green and No Labels, increases Trump's spread to 12% [41-29] (2)

    Michigan is going to be a tough contest, because Wayne County is one of the primary places where Democrat operatives manufacture ballots. However, that said, President Trump is now leading Joe Biden by 8 points, slightly more than the estimated 5% fraudulent ballots the Democrats can create.
     
    The same observation I made for Mikel applies to you as well. Your #NeverTrump zealotry is self destructive. You would be better served by being more realistic and less histrionic.


    #LetsGoBrandon 😇
    ____________________

    (1) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/12/kevin-oleary-explains-to-stunned-cnn-audience-why-new-york-case-against-president-trump-is-nonsense/

    (2) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/09/president-trump-holds-8-point-lead-over-joe-biden-in-michigan/

    Replies: @John Johnson, @songbird, @Mr. XYZ

    If Democrats manufacture ballots in minority-heavy areas, then why did Trump do better among minorities in 2020 than in 2016?

    • Replies: @A123
    @Mr. XYZ


    If Democrats manufacture ballots in minority-heavy areas, then why did Trump do better among minorities in 2020 than in 2016?
     
    The DNC primarily manufactured additional ballots. They rarely replaced ones that were actually cast. Thus, Trump's authentic support from minority men seeped through in a visible manner.

    Those who want "good jobs at good wages", regardless of ethnicity, will be voting for Trump in November. MAGA/GOP is now the Main Street labour party. SJW/DNC is for progressive Wall Street banks.


    They’re fanatically devoted to Trump, after all, not necessarily to the GOP (“The Stupid Party”) as a whole.
    ....
    unwilling to sacrifice their support of him even if it means getting a much more electable GOP presidential candidate in 2024
     
    The commitment is to MAGA, not specifically to Trump. Opposition to GOP establishment RINO's is locked in. Despite what the #NeverTrump zealots post here, Trump is by far the most electable MAGA nominee. In large part because he is the only authentic MAGA candidate.

    Regardless of what Leftoid polls seem to return, establishment RINO's like DeSantis and Haley are actually unelectable. These Anti-MAGA shills would not be able to generate MAGA base turnout. Likely a MAGA candidate would appear via a 3rd party nomination to capture those votes. Anti-MAGA DeSantis could easily lose all 50 states, including Florida.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  375. @John Johnson
    @A123


    What will happen if Trump ends up with jail time? Are you still going to support him?
     
    What will happen if I end up with a Victoria’s Secret model? Am I going to enjoy it?

    Both are very silly propositions. Hypothetical questions are generally weak.

    An underwear model would indeed be a silly proposition when one isn't running.

    Trump however is facing over 91 felonies spread across four cases.

    It's an entirely possible scenario for him to receive jail time in one or more cases.

    I've noticed that Trump fans have a hard time with this question.

    It tells me they are trying to block out his legal problems instead of facing them.

    Every abuse makes Trump more popular with Independents and swing voters.

    Trump has only gained independents because of Biden's low polling.

    You do acknowledge that independents favor Haley over Trump?

    Why should Trump be the candidate if Haley polls better with independents?

    Replies: @A123, @Mr. XYZ

    I think that Trump’s supporters view him as the second coming of Jesus and would thus be unwilling to sacrifice their support of him even if it means getting a much more electable GOP presidential candidate in 2024. They’re fanatically devoted to Trump, after all, not necessarily to the GOP (“The Stupid Party”) as a whole.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    I think that Trump’s supporters view him as the second coming of Jesus and would thus be unwilling to sacrifice their support of him even if it means getting a much more electable GOP presidential candidate in 2024. T

    I do think that a lot of them have some type of religious belief surrounding his comeback.

    The weird thing is that they tend to overlap with the anti-vaxxer crowd.

    They just ignore that Trump oversaw Operation Warpspeed and told his fans to get vaccinated.

    I've had multiple Trump fans tell me that he only did that under pressure and never actually got the vaccine.

    Unreal.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @sudden death

  376. @Mr. XYZ
    @A123

    If Democrats manufacture ballots in minority-heavy areas, then why did Trump do better among minorities in 2020 than in 2016?

    Replies: @A123

    If Democrats manufacture ballots in minority-heavy areas, then why did Trump do better among minorities in 2020 than in 2016?

    The DNC primarily manufactured additional ballots. They rarely replaced ones that were actually cast. Thus, Trump’s authentic support from minority men seeped through in a visible manner.

    Those who want “good jobs at good wages”, regardless of ethnicity, will be voting for Trump in November. MAGA/GOP is now the Main Street labour party. SJW/DNC is for progressive Wall Street banks.

    They’re fanatically devoted to Trump, after all, not necessarily to the GOP (“The Stupid Party”) as a whole.
    ….
    unwilling to sacrifice their support of him even if it means getting a much more electable GOP presidential candidate in 2024

    The commitment is to MAGA, not specifically to Trump. Opposition to GOP establishment RINO’s is locked in. Despite what the #NeverTrump zealots post here, Trump is by far the most electable MAGA nominee. In large part because he is the only authentic MAGA candidate.

    Regardless of what Leftoid polls seem to return, establishment RINO’s like DeSantis and Haley are actually unelectable. These Anti-MAGA shills would not be able to generate MAGA base turnout. Likely a MAGA candidate would appear via a 3rd party nomination to capture those votes. Anti-MAGA DeSantis could easily lose all 50 states, including Florida.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @A123


    The DNC primarily manufactured additional ballots. They rarely replaced ones that were actually cast. Thus, Trump’s authentic support from minority men seeped through in a visible manner.
     
    But one would think that the Democrats would manufacture so many additional ballots that this would overcome Trump's increased support among minority men, no?

    Replies: @A123

  377. @Barbarossa
    @John Johnson

    My experience is that German engineering often means that a given problem is solved by an unnecessarily complicated solution when a simpler one would do just as well. They also seem to make it hard for plebs to service things. I think the thought of non-specialists servicing their machines give German engineers palpitations.

    I totally agree with you on Audis/ BMWs. They are usually money pits to maintain.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    They also seem to make it hard for plebs to service things. I think the thought of non-specialists servicing their machines give German engineers palpitations.

    This is how I felt working on a Volvo. It really felt engineered to discourage you from working on it. Maybe they copied the German model?

    I’ve cussed at Japanese cars but only because I’ve come across stuff that expects you to be a 110 lb mechanic with 1.5″ forearms.

    All new cars can honestly be pretty annoying. There are definitely parts where they have moved them to some needlessly annoying spot where they want you to give up and take it in upon seeing what is required. Well it’s two weeks around here to even see a mechanic. So I’ve actually planned on taking a car in and then fixed it myself because I’m not waiting 2-3 weeks.

    • Replies: @Barbarossa
    @John Johnson

    As I've mentioned before around here all my vehicles are over 20 years old and I can do all my own work in my service bay. We are just finishing up popping a new engine into my 89 F350. Fortunately for something that age I could get a clean used engine for $600. Hard to beat the price of maintenance.

    Interestingly, I know a guy with a lawncare/ plowing business and he said that he had more upkeep costs per year on his 6 year old bought new truck than the older 90's and early 00's trucks which were a fraction of the purchase price.

    I recently borrowed a 2018 F350 to do a hauling run and it was a nice truck but I wouldn't buy it. I just couldn't stop thinking about how much each of the souped-up components would cost to replace. What a headache.

    Plus, I hate it when my robot slaves get lippy and this truck kept on bugging me with all manner of idiotic notifications across the dash. "Trailer has been connected." "Trailer has been disconnected." "Door is open" etc. Criminy, it made me cranky and I groused at the truck all night. I sure don't need my truck nagging me like I'm some hapless babe.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  378. @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson

    I think that Trump's supporters view him as the second coming of Jesus and would thus be unwilling to sacrifice their support of him even if it means getting a much more electable GOP presidential candidate in 2024. They're fanatically devoted to Trump, after all, not necessarily to the GOP ("The Stupid Party") as a whole.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    I think that Trump’s supporters view him as the second coming of Jesus and would thus be unwilling to sacrifice their support of him even if it means getting a much more electable GOP presidential candidate in 2024. T

    I do think that a lot of them have some type of religious belief surrounding his comeback.

    The weird thing is that they tend to overlap with the anti-vaxxer crowd.

    They just ignore that Trump oversaw Operation Warpspeed and told his fans to get vaccinated.

    I’ve had multiple Trump fans tell me that he only did that under pressure and never actually got the vaccine.

    Unreal.

    • LOL: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson

    I suspect that they love him so much that they're willing to tolerate one or more deviations from their own desired worldview on his part. They just love the rest of what he's selling them as well as his general style and personality. He's essentially a shock jock former US President.

    Replies: @QCIC

    , @sudden death
    @John Johnson


    They just ignore that Trump oversaw Operation Warpspeed and told his fans to get vaccinated.

    I’ve had multiple Trump fans tell me that he only did that under pressure and never actually got the vaccine.
     

    If somebody has a desire to be swindled, reality will never be enough of an obstacle to such wish;)

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uCGD9dT12C0


    But I couldn't find a way
    So I'll settle for one day to believe in you
    Tell me, tell me, tell me lies
    Tell me lies, tell me sweet little lies
     
  379. @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    I think that Trump’s supporters view him as the second coming of Jesus and would thus be unwilling to sacrifice their support of him even if it means getting a much more electable GOP presidential candidate in 2024. T

    I do think that a lot of them have some type of religious belief surrounding his comeback.

    The weird thing is that they tend to overlap with the anti-vaxxer crowd.

    They just ignore that Trump oversaw Operation Warpspeed and told his fans to get vaccinated.

    I've had multiple Trump fans tell me that he only did that under pressure and never actually got the vaccine.

    Unreal.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @sudden death

    I suspect that they love him so much that they’re willing to tolerate one or more deviations from their own desired worldview on his part. They just love the rest of what he’s selling them as well as his general style and personality. He’s essentially a shock jock former US President.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Mr. XYZ

    People like Trump because there is a chance he is DIFFERENT. The other candidates are all totally crooked and part of the same uniparty. It is too early to tell if Trump is actually different, since the MSM stance against him could be part of the game. On the other hand, the Trump hatred seems sincere, more so than other things which spew out of the MSM.

    This leaves open the question if Trump is different in a good way or bad way. He is antiwar, if only because he doesn't want a war in his epitaph. As the dollar system winds down, war may become the defining issue.

    Trump is pro-USA, but I think he has an elite noblesse oblige view of things. Many of his backers tacitly accept this.

    Replies: @Wokechoke

  380. @A123
    @Mr. XYZ


    If Democrats manufacture ballots in minority-heavy areas, then why did Trump do better among minorities in 2020 than in 2016?
     
    The DNC primarily manufactured additional ballots. They rarely replaced ones that were actually cast. Thus, Trump's authentic support from minority men seeped through in a visible manner.

    Those who want "good jobs at good wages", regardless of ethnicity, will be voting for Trump in November. MAGA/GOP is now the Main Street labour party. SJW/DNC is for progressive Wall Street banks.


    They’re fanatically devoted to Trump, after all, not necessarily to the GOP (“The Stupid Party”) as a whole.
    ....
    unwilling to sacrifice their support of him even if it means getting a much more electable GOP presidential candidate in 2024
     
    The commitment is to MAGA, not specifically to Trump. Opposition to GOP establishment RINO's is locked in. Despite what the #NeverTrump zealots post here, Trump is by far the most electable MAGA nominee. In large part because he is the only authentic MAGA candidate.

    Regardless of what Leftoid polls seem to return, establishment RINO's like DeSantis and Haley are actually unelectable. These Anti-MAGA shills would not be able to generate MAGA base turnout. Likely a MAGA candidate would appear via a 3rd party nomination to capture those votes. Anti-MAGA DeSantis could easily lose all 50 states, including Florida.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    The DNC primarily manufactured additional ballots. They rarely replaced ones that were actually cast. Thus, Trump’s authentic support from minority men seeped through in a visible manner.

    But one would think that the Democrats would manufacture so many additional ballots that this would overcome Trump’s increased support among minority men, no?

    • Replies: @A123
    @Mr. XYZ


    But one would think that the Democrats would manufacture so many additional ballots that this would overcome Trump’s increased support among minority men, no?
     
    No. The math does not work that way.

    It is not that easy to conceal a significant shift. Let me illustrate for a district of 100,000; 5,000 is 5%; 10,000 is 10%. How many forged ballots would be required to make the 10,000 read as 5%?

    It would take 100,000 more for 10,000 of 200,000 is 5%. Would that doubling of turnout in a district appear suspicious and draw investigation? Yes. Even in the places with massive fraud, the attitude change still bleeds thru into the final results.
    ___

    Please remember the massive fraud was concentrated in specific swing states. The attitude shift in safe states was not diluted the same way it was in swing states.

    Also, some fraud techniques involve rerunning the same ballots rather than manufacturing additional. This has huge recount risk because the total number of votes will not equal the number of paper ballots in storage. Nevertheless, it is 100% proven that this happened in Georgia. This method leaves % increase the same.

    PEACE 😇
  381. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTBFfwGpA-xlIbveLZiyv2Jws7Y88Zz5p7uWA&usqp.jpg

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird, @Hyperborean, @Mr. XYZ

    Thank god that this scenario never actually happened since Communist rule in northern Japan would have likely reduced longevity there at least somewhat. Japan is very notable for its large verified supercentenarian population.

  382. @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    I think that Trump’s supporters view him as the second coming of Jesus and would thus be unwilling to sacrifice their support of him even if it means getting a much more electable GOP presidential candidate in 2024. T

    I do think that a lot of them have some type of religious belief surrounding his comeback.

    The weird thing is that they tend to overlap with the anti-vaxxer crowd.

    They just ignore that Trump oversaw Operation Warpspeed and told his fans to get vaccinated.

    I've had multiple Trump fans tell me that he only did that under pressure and never actually got the vaccine.

    Unreal.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @sudden death

    They just ignore that Trump oversaw Operation Warpspeed and told his fans to get vaccinated.

    I’ve had multiple Trump fans tell me that he only did that under pressure and never actually got the vaccine.

    If somebody has a desire to be swindled, reality will never be enough of an obstacle to such wish;)

    But I couldn’t find a way
    So I’ll settle for one day to believe in you
    Tell me, tell me, tell me lies
    Tell me lies, tell me sweet little lies

    • Agree: Mr. XYZ
  383. RIP Gonzalo Lira, a braver man than most.

    • Agree: AnonfromTN
  384. Will obese black women counting the votes in Atlanta, Detroit and Milwaukee be disenfranchising white voter in 2024?

    Will Jewish oligarchs like Sam Bankman Fried and that Facebook guy be financing more voter fraud?

  385. @AP
    @Mikel


    Exactly as I said, no sooner you learn Ukraine has killed this man
     
    Evidence that Ukraine "killed this man?"

    Are you doing it again?

    he was most likely tortured
     
    Again, any evidence of that?

    killed through negligence after spending months in a filthy prison with improper medical care
     
    He was in a normal prison. It was probably bad by Western standards, but why should he have special treatment?

    for something he said.
     
    He allegedly broke the law. Germany and France imprison people for denying the Holocaust, so don't pretend that American-style free speech is universal among Western democracies.

    https://apnews.com/article/europe-crime-berlin-the-holocaust-15972809c1bf40f8eb8d2935d04c3b2d

    "A Berlin court has sentenced a 93-year-old German woman to 12 months in prison for denying that Jews were systematically murdered during the Holocaust."

    Gonzalo Lira moved to a foreign country, broke its laws by spreading and creating propaganda in support of the country that was invading the very country he had moved to and was killing its people. This is IMO worse than Holocaust denial but each country has its own laws.

    Not even woke, pro-Ukraine Youtube found objection to the posts that cost him his life.
     
    He took poor care of his health and chose to move to a foreign country and to break it's laws. He was even released to be in his apartment pending trial (such leniency! and casts doubt on the claim that he had been tortured) but chose to break the law again by fleeing, and was stupid enough to brag about it before he managed to cross the border, leading to his re-arrest.

    In one of his last tweets he correctly predicted that he would die if arrested, btw
     
    He also supposedly predicted he would die of heart problems a couple of years ago.

    Your moral standards are very repugnant.
     
    I'm not the one "conveniently" adopting positions that benefit the side that invades another country and kills 10,000s of its people and 100,000s of soldiers.

    And you slipped - you wrote that this Chilean-American psychopath's death was further down the slide from the killing of thousands of civilians in Donbas. This suggests that you think the life of Gonzalo Lira is > the lives of thousands of Donbassers.

    Replies: @Mikel, @LondonBob

    Lira was only released so the goons could follow him and try and pick up any ‘disloyal’ Ukrainians, didn’t happen, he was just posting his own opinions, there was no network. His wife is from Kharkhov and his children are too. In a civilised country like Russia he would simply have been deported, instead they forced him to stay, like so many others are, and then killed him. The Jews in the State Department didn’t lift a finger to help him.

  386. any chance that Karlin returns to this Blog?

    • Replies: @Barbarossa
    @LT1488

    He popped in a couple threads ago. Ya never know.

  387. @Beckow
    @AP

    The situation with German economy is a lot more complicated than just the "nuclear power", etc...The energy squeeze is happening everywhere and it is getting worse. Germany used eastern Europe for a lot of energy-intensive manufacturing and it is now gradually shutting down. The overall supply chain has been blown up and the consequences are just starting - in the next 2 to 5 years we will see it.

    Russia was also a very good market: high prices and they paid on time - high profit margins in Russia subsidized other business. The money Russia earned stayed in the Western banks allowing for an investment boom and lower interest rates. The one-time proposed theft is a bad idea - imagine if your bank takes your deposits, will anyone ever work with them? Russia will continue generating hundreds of billions in profits each year - that's the money that matters and it is close to exiting permanently.

    You don't understand economics or business well - even you pointing to "defense" boom in Russia is short-sighted: they are in an existential war and they have resources (forever), they can afford to do it, Europe can't - Euros also don't have any inclination to go into an existential fight. Poland is not "Europe", it is just noise in the east.

    Replies: @AP, @Another Polish Perspective

    You are a real outlier among Slovaks I met in my life in your strong and active dislike of Poland. But as far as I remember you are just a naturalized Slovak, previously being a citizen of USA, now living, of course, in the big city of Bratislava…?
    You never present us with any insights abut culture of Slovakia (music, literature)…. do you know Slovakian language fluently, more than B1 level demanded for citizenship?
    Czechs and Slovaks among themselves usually know very well who is who, a Slovak, a Czech or a Gypsie – how do they call you…?”Our American friend”, “Our American”, or maybe simply “American Mikulas”…?

    Anyway, your nick, “Beckow”, suggests a Germanized Slav.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Another Polish Perspective

    I somehow never bought the image of Beckow being a real Slovak, always grandstanding so very vociferously for Putler's Russia. When I first encountered him, I thought for sure that he must have finished some sort of Russian troll factory school, maybe even developing his life and persona somewhere in a St. Petersburg basement. I queeried AP about this distinct possibility, who always seemed to be involved with him here, but he didn't seem to think so. I still wonder sometimes....but a Slovacized American? Would go a long way in explaining his above average English language skills and his ability to waste time looking for hookers along Scottsdale Rd in Scottsdale AZ. :-)

    https://s3-eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/cartoons-s3/styles/product_detail_image/s3/IMG_20230930_0002%20english.jpg?itok=YBHkw0rJ

    Replies: @LT1488

  388. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Beckow

    You are a real outlier among Slovaks I met in my life in your strong and active dislike of Poland. But as far as I remember you are just a naturalized Slovak, previously being a citizen of USA, now living, of course, in the big city of Bratislava...?
    You never present us with any insights abut culture of Slovakia (music, literature).... do you know Slovakian language fluently, more than B1 level demanded for citizenship?
    Czechs and Slovaks among themselves usually know very well who is who, a Slovak, a Czech or a Gypsie - how do they call you...?"Our American friend", "Our American", or maybe simply "American Mikulas"...?

    Anyway, your nick, "Beckow", suggests a Germanized Slav.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    I somehow never bought the image of Beckow being a real Slovak, always grandstanding so very vociferously for Putler’s Russia. When I first encountered him, I thought for sure that he must have finished some sort of Russian troll factory school, maybe even developing his life and persona somewhere in a St. Petersburg basement. I queeried AP about this distinct possibility, who always seemed to be involved with him here, but he didn’t seem to think so. I still wonder sometimes….but a Slovacized American? Would go a long way in explaining his above average English language skills and his ability to waste time looking for hookers along Scottsdale Rd in Scottsdale AZ. 🙂

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @Mr. Hack

    Slovaks are an odd case in Central Europe where many have pro-Russian opinions.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Derer, @AP

  389. Uniparty in action – both Trump&Biden seem to be quite equally decreasing CCP’ied China share;)

    • Agree: A123
    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @sudden death

    o"Re-shoring" re-routes Chinese exports to the US via Mexico, ASEAN, India etc. and gives China MORE leverage with US trading partners.

    China shifted production to Vietnam, India, Mexico, etc. to get round tariffs.

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F-WR_VVawAAyxcz.jpg

    Mexico imports parts from China, white-labels them, and sells to the US.


    Trump's tariffs shifted the US deficit to Vietnam, Mexico,India. But China's exports to these countries rose with their exports to the US. The world just white-labeled Chinese goods.

    Replies: @A123

    , @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @sudden death

    What matters is if China trade decoupling is economically meaningful. All the data says no. You just have to look at Mexico's growing trade deficit with China and the rising US surplus.

    The fact that there's any kind of narrative on how global trade is decoupling from China is pretty baffling. After all, China's trade surplus with the rest of the world is at record highs and not even its bilateral surplus with the US is down in any meaningful way.

    Globally, China's surplus is way way up. On global level that only balances with the US deficit. Lots of evidence that supply chains have been extended with intermediate steps rather than there been deep decoupling.

    Intuitively, we know that trans-shipments from China to the US must be happening because China is the world's biggest producer of goods and the US is the biggest consumer of goods. Supply and demand will meet. If it has to be on a more circuitous route, so be it.


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GDQ7cVaWgAA81lZ.jpg


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GDVR6yIWwAAa_RU.jpg


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GDSYGhdWgAAXUHu.jpg

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  390. @sudden death
    Uniparty in action - both Trump&Biden seem to be quite equally decreasing CCP'ied China share;)


    https://i.postimg.cc/50hWh5yk/US-imports.jpg

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    o”Re-shoring” re-routes Chinese exports to the US via Mexico, ASEAN, India etc. and gives China MORE leverage with US trading partners.

    China shifted production to Vietnam, India, Mexico, etc. to get round tariffs.

    Mexico imports parts from China, white-labels them, and sells to the US.

    Trump’s tariffs shifted the US deficit to Vietnam, Mexico,India. But China’s exports to these countries rose with their exports to the US. The world just white-labeled Chinese goods.

    • Disagree: A123
    • Replies: @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Gradual decoupling needs to be a concerted process over decades. It will not happen in one or two years.


    Mexico imports parts from China, white-labels them, and sells to the US.
     
    A bit of an oversimplification, there are USMCA content requirements on cars and auto parts. To meet this requirement Mexico is taking the better value added tasks. The CCP is thus pushed to less critical, lower value parts.

    However, you are correct that the overall Mexico numbers point out a serious gap in regional & national industrial policy. America needs to help itself by helping Mexico become more resilient. MMGA is not as catchy as MAGA, it needs evocative marketing in Spanish.


    Trump’s tariffs shifted the US deficit to Vietnam, Mexico,India. But China’s exports to these countries rose with their exports to the US. The world just white-labeled Chinese goods.
     
    Making CCP influence more diffuse weakens their trade leverage as they cannot effectively black mail the world by creating an obstacle in a single location. This is desirable, however re-shoring is only an intermediate step.

    Not-The-President Biden was stuck with certain high profile policies from Trump's 1st term. Outside of those he has been weak in national security/trade. The only thing potentially making him look slightly better is the EU. Brussels is even worse than America on regional industrial security/trade policy.

    The long term goal is MAGA Reindustrialization. Again, I point out that this will take decades. Raw material extraction and goods manufacturing critical to national security, need to be brought back on shore. Restarting mines, building refineries, etc. are long lead time projects.

    Where necessary this can be expanded to regional in addition to national production. A solid partnership with Mexico would pay dividends in areas like immigration in addition to trade & economics. Imagine how much better our southern border would be with Mexico engaging in maximum enforcement against illegals as they tried to leave Guatemala.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

  391. @sudden death
    Uniparty in action - both Trump&Biden seem to be quite equally decreasing CCP'ied China share;)


    https://i.postimg.cc/50hWh5yk/US-imports.jpg

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    What matters is if China trade decoupling is economically meaningful. All the data says no. You just have to look at Mexico’s growing trade deficit with China and the rising US surplus.

    The fact that there’s any kind of narrative on how global trade is decoupling from China is pretty baffling. After all, China’s trade surplus with the rest of the world is at record highs and not even its bilateral surplus with the US is down in any meaningful way.

    Globally, China’s surplus is way way up. On global level that only balances with the US deficit. Lots of evidence that supply chains have been extended with intermediate steps rather than there been deep decoupling.

    Intuitively, we know that trans-shipments from China to the US must be happening because China is the world’s biggest producer of goods and the US is the biggest consumer of goods. Supply and demand will meet. If it has to be on a more circuitous route, so be it.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Your statistics look good. It might help to add 2 or 3 real world examples for context and impact. My eyes just kind of glaze over looking at charts.

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

  392. @Mr. Hack
    @Another Polish Perspective

    I somehow never bought the image of Beckow being a real Slovak, always grandstanding so very vociferously for Putler's Russia. When I first encountered him, I thought for sure that he must have finished some sort of Russian troll factory school, maybe even developing his life and persona somewhere in a St. Petersburg basement. I queeried AP about this distinct possibility, who always seemed to be involved with him here, but he didn't seem to think so. I still wonder sometimes....but a Slovacized American? Would go a long way in explaining his above average English language skills and his ability to waste time looking for hookers along Scottsdale Rd in Scottsdale AZ. :-)

    https://s3-eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/cartoons-s3/styles/product_detail_image/s3/IMG_20230930_0002%20english.jpg?itok=YBHkw0rJ

    Replies: @LT1488

    Slovaks are an odd case in Central Europe where many have pro-Russian opinions.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @LT1488

    They probably acquired this trait from their former Hungarian masters, "Follow the Leader":

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F7asH_-WYAABSQ0.jpg:large

    Replies: @LT1488

    , @Derer
    @LT1488

    It is a right choice for Slovakia...the West's hate of Slavs make it easy. Actually, Polaks are odd case, despite their tourist buses in Western Europe are usually soil by eggs or tomatoes, they still cannot get the message.

    , @AP
    @LT1488

    They are a little bit like Central Europe's analogue to Belarusians. Except their "Russia" is Hungary.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  393. Things aren’t always what they seem with trade flows.

    Does anyone have the data for Lithuania?

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    The data won't be reliable because in Lithuania lots and lots of businesses still operate in Russia under different names. For example Kaunas mayor has a food business in Russia and he lies about leaving the country. His business still produces food there and has factories that are renovated in Kaliningrad.

  394. @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    Even a nominal leader needs dignity…
     
    That claim is anachronistic. Very few European “leaders” have any dignity. Most are either stuffed shirts (e.g., Scholz, Macron, Sunak) or clinical idiots (e.g., Baerbock, von der Leyen).

    Replies: @LT1488

    Sunak isn’t even European though.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @LT1488


    Sunak isn’t even European though.
     
    Apparently from elites’ point of view a Paki is European enough to serve as a figurehead. The “lady” before him was British, but if anything, she was even more pathetic. As they say, formerly Great formerly Britain.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @LT1488

  395. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    Things aren't always what they seem with trade flows.

    Does anyone have the data for Lithuania?


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GDzgDamXwAE7y1D.jpg

    Replies: @LT1488

    The data won’t be reliable because in Lithuania lots and lots of businesses still operate in Russia under different names. For example Kaunas mayor has a food business in Russia and he lies about leaving the country. His business still produces food there and has factories that are renovated in Kaliningrad.

  396. @Hyperborean
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Very strange map, which alt-history story did you get this one from? Unless the Second World War turned out radically different it's highly implausible.

    First, it would just be the People's Republic of Japan. Not People's Republic of North Japan. Any of the cold war divided states would never relinquish their claims over the other half of the country.

    Second, South Korea suggests Korea still got divided into an American and Soviet zone. Previously occupied countries in the immediate
    post-war era usually didn't get to participate in occupation, this is why France getting occupation rights in Germany and Austria was such a coup for de Gaulle.
    In any case, one would believe that the South Koreans would be better off using their manpower guarding the inter-Korean border.

    Third, no division of Tokyo, why? One would expect the precedent of Berlin and Vienna to apply.

    Fourth, the PRC shouldn't hold an occupation zone. At the creation of the zones in 1945 it would be the ROC and after the civil war there's no way the Western Powers would hand over the zone to a government they don’t acknowledge as legitimate.

    Fifth, it says "Evolution of Allied Occupied Japan (1945-1990); hopefully this is just the first slide of several showing political changes, otherwise it really doesn't make sense to keep Japan occupied for so long instead of creating a satellite state with more internal and external legitimacy after a couple of years.

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Looks like Somalia is seriously unhappy about the port deal Ethiopia did with Somaliland, things are starting to heat up along the border.

    Are you keeping up with the details?

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Her left hand is morphing into a claw.

    , @Hyperborean
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere


    Looks like Somalia is seriously unhappy about the port deal Ethiopia did with Somaliland, things are starting to heat up along the border.

    Are you keeping up with the details?
     

    So far the regional dynamics seem to be:

    Somalia is threatening war while regional powers' stance is

    UAE favouring Ethiopia and Somaliland
    VS
    Eritrea, Egypt and Turkey favouring Somalia

    But of course the significance of this depends on how much any of the other powers actively get involved.

    I think Eritrea is likely to intervene directly, the rest - no idea. Probably some of the others will supply weapons.

  397. Chrome is supposed to do something against cookies later this year. Don’t use it, but hopefully it will be adopted by other browsers.

    Right now even the BBC Pigdin site employs cookies. Why the heck are they trying to track Pidgin speakers? Do they sell the data to NGOs?

  398. @Mr. XYZ
    @A123


    The DNC primarily manufactured additional ballots. They rarely replaced ones that were actually cast. Thus, Trump’s authentic support from minority men seeped through in a visible manner.
     
    But one would think that the Democrats would manufacture so many additional ballots that this would overcome Trump's increased support among minority men, no?

    Replies: @A123

    But one would think that the Democrats would manufacture so many additional ballots that this would overcome Trump’s increased support among minority men, no?

    No. The math does not work that way.

    It is not that easy to conceal a significant shift. Let me illustrate for a district of 100,000; 5,000 is 5%; 10,000 is 10%. How many forged ballots would be required to make the 10,000 read as 5%?

    It would take 100,000 more for 10,000 of 200,000 is 5%. Would that doubling of turnout in a district appear suspicious and draw investigation? Yes. Even in the places with massive fraud, the attitude change still bleeds thru into the final results.
    ___

    Please remember the massive fraud was concentrated in specific swing states. The attitude shift in safe states was not diluted the same way it was in swing states.

    Also, some fraud techniques involve rerunning the same ballots rather than manufacturing additional. This has huge recount risk because the total number of votes will not equal the number of paper ballots in storage. Nevertheless, it is 100% proven that this happened in Georgia. This method leaves % increase the same.

    PEACE 😇

  399. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @Hyperborean

    Looks like Somalia is seriously unhappy about the port deal Ethiopia did with Somaliland, things are starting to heat up along the border.

    Are you keeping up with the details?

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FVJbYH4XoAIUek6.jpg

    Replies: @QCIC, @Hyperborean

    Her left hand is morphing into a claw.

  400. @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson

    I suspect that they love him so much that they're willing to tolerate one or more deviations from their own desired worldview on his part. They just love the rest of what he's selling them as well as his general style and personality. He's essentially a shock jock former US President.

    Replies: @QCIC

    People like Trump because there is a chance he is DIFFERENT. The other candidates are all totally crooked and part of the same uniparty. It is too early to tell if Trump is actually different, since the MSM stance against him could be part of the game. On the other hand, the Trump hatred seems sincere, more so than other things which spew out of the MSM.

    This leaves open the question if Trump is different in a good way or bad way. He is antiwar, if only because he doesn’t want a war in his epitaph. As the dollar system winds down, war may become the defining issue.

    Trump is pro-USA, but I think he has an elite noblesse oblige view of things. Many of his backers tacitly accept this.

    • Replies: @Wokechoke
    @QCIC

    A good argument for Reagan or Trump. Both instill something like Gaelic clan loyalty from whites which is the backbone of the State. They raise armies. Whatever virtues Carter had or Bush I or Obama have, and we can argue those virtues, Reagan was beloved by Whitey. Trump was beloved by Whitey. Had there been an epic international fight with China or the USSR Reagan would have been Chief with gusto. Whatever his limitations were. Same with Trump. What got Trump was an internal nigger revolt backed by jews and sections of the Intelligence apparatus.

    It's the mystery of Command.


    Biden cannot really command loyalty from 200,000,000 whites in a war with a host like China or Russia could field. Even the great and the good of the establishment knows this now.

    Replies: @sudden death

  401. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @sudden death

    o"Re-shoring" re-routes Chinese exports to the US via Mexico, ASEAN, India etc. and gives China MORE leverage with US trading partners.

    China shifted production to Vietnam, India, Mexico, etc. to get round tariffs.

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F-WR_VVawAAyxcz.jpg

    Mexico imports parts from China, white-labels them, and sells to the US.


    Trump's tariffs shifted the US deficit to Vietnam, Mexico,India. But China's exports to these countries rose with their exports to the US. The world just white-labeled Chinese goods.

    Replies: @A123

    Gradual decoupling needs to be a concerted process over decades. It will not happen in one or two years.

    Mexico imports parts from China, white-labels them, and sells to the US.

    A bit of an oversimplification, there are USMCA content requirements on cars and auto parts. To meet this requirement Mexico is taking the better value added tasks. The CCP is thus pushed to less critical, lower value parts.

    However, you are correct that the overall Mexico numbers point out a serious gap in regional & national industrial policy. America needs to help itself by helping Mexico become more resilient. MMGA is not as catchy as MAGA, it needs evocative marketing in Spanish.

    Trump’s tariffs shifted the US deficit to Vietnam, Mexico,India. But China’s exports to these countries rose with their exports to the US. The world just white-labeled Chinese goods.

    Making CCP influence more diffuse weakens their trade leverage as they cannot effectively black mail the world by creating an obstacle in a single location. This is desirable, however re-shoring is only an intermediate step.

    Not-The-President Biden was stuck with certain high profile policies from Trump’s 1st term. Outside of those he has been weak in national security/trade. The only thing potentially making him look slightly better is the EU. Brussels is even worse than America on regional industrial security/trade policy.

    The long term goal is MAGA Reindustrialization. Again, I point out that this will take decades. Raw material extraction and goods manufacturing critical to national security, need to be brought back on shore. Restarting mines, building refineries, etc. are long lead time projects.

    Where necessary this can be expanded to regional in addition to national production. A solid partnership with Mexico would pay dividends in areas like immigration in addition to trade & economics. Imagine how much better our southern border would be with Mexico engaging in maximum enforcement against illegals as they tried to leave Guatemala.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    To meet this requirement Mexico is taking the better value added tasks. China is thus pushed to less critical, lower value parts.
     
    Fundamentally, if there is a lot of value-added in Mexico (if shipments from China aren't just unloaded and repackaged before going to the US), shouldn't the growth contribution of net exports be positive and rising in Mexico? It isn't. It's negative & getting worse (pink).


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GDVTKyRWAAAOZ0k.jpg


    The US trade deficit with China has shrunk by $90 bn since 2018, but that's more than offset by wider US trade deficits with especially Vietnam and Mexico. There is no trade decoupling of the US from China. China just sends its products to the US on more circuitous routes.

    Since 2019, Mexico's bilateral trade surplus with the US is up 40% (blue). Most of that is due to China, which ships goods to Mexico (red) that then go to the US. We see trade diversion of western goods to Russia via Central Asia. The same is happening with China via Mexico.


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GCISSz7XIAAdLi1.jpg

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F_d1xbFXUAAl7Ow.jpg


    The "churn" in Mexico's trade balance is up massively since COVID. Exports to the US have risen, but so have imports from everywhere. Mexico benefits from this churn it is a logistics hub not a production hub.

    If it's re-shoring, shouldn't you see export volumes rise more relative to import volumes? I think that's the puzzle. Mexico's net exports are basically flat.

    Replies: @A123

  402. @QCIC
    @Mr. XYZ

    People like Trump because there is a chance he is DIFFERENT. The other candidates are all totally crooked and part of the same uniparty. It is too early to tell if Trump is actually different, since the MSM stance against him could be part of the game. On the other hand, the Trump hatred seems sincere, more so than other things which spew out of the MSM.

    This leaves open the question if Trump is different in a good way or bad way. He is antiwar, if only because he doesn't want a war in his epitaph. As the dollar system winds down, war may become the defining issue.

    Trump is pro-USA, but I think he has an elite noblesse oblige view of things. Many of his backers tacitly accept this.

    Replies: @Wokechoke

    A good argument for Reagan or Trump. Both instill something like Gaelic clan loyalty from whites which is the backbone of the State. They raise armies. Whatever virtues Carter had or Bush I or Obama have, and we can argue those virtues, Reagan was beloved by Whitey. Trump was beloved by Whitey. Had there been an epic international fight with China or the USSR Reagan would have been Chief with gusto. Whatever his limitations were. Same with Trump. What got Trump was an internal nigger revolt backed by jews and sections of the Intelligence apparatus.

    It’s the mystery of Command.

    Biden cannot really command loyalty from 200,000,000 whites in a war with a host like China or Russia could field. Even the great and the good of the establishment knows this now.

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @Wokechoke

    Was FDR beloved by Whitey too?;)

  403. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @sudden death

    What matters is if China trade decoupling is economically meaningful. All the data says no. You just have to look at Mexico's growing trade deficit with China and the rising US surplus.

    The fact that there's any kind of narrative on how global trade is decoupling from China is pretty baffling. After all, China's trade surplus with the rest of the world is at record highs and not even its bilateral surplus with the US is down in any meaningful way.

    Globally, China's surplus is way way up. On global level that only balances with the US deficit. Lots of evidence that supply chains have been extended with intermediate steps rather than there been deep decoupling.

    Intuitively, we know that trans-shipments from China to the US must be happening because China is the world's biggest producer of goods and the US is the biggest consumer of goods. Supply and demand will meet. If it has to be on a more circuitous route, so be it.


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GDQ7cVaWgAA81lZ.jpg


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GDVR6yIWwAAa_RU.jpg


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GDSYGhdWgAAXUHu.jpg

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    Your statistics look good. It might help to add 2 or 3 real world examples for context and impact. My eyes just kind of glaze over looking at charts.

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    It might help to add 2 or 3 real world examples
     
    https://www.timesofisrael.com/suspected-spy-devices-found-in-gifts-given-to-ministers-by-chinese-embassy-reports/

    An alleged bug found in a travel mug given as a gift by the Chinese embassy to an Israeli ministry. The mug and others like it proved not to contain anything untoward, the Shin Bet security agency said after investigation, on April 12, 2022.

    https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSdfrcJOXd_0IUkJHUT0xSDdNfrGFZL7zC22Q&usqp.jpg


    https://youtu.be/F48qVKo9f0E?si=wwStCJas0L_lOUko
  404. @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Gradual decoupling needs to be a concerted process over decades. It will not happen in one or two years.


    Mexico imports parts from China, white-labels them, and sells to the US.
     
    A bit of an oversimplification, there are USMCA content requirements on cars and auto parts. To meet this requirement Mexico is taking the better value added tasks. The CCP is thus pushed to less critical, lower value parts.

    However, you are correct that the overall Mexico numbers point out a serious gap in regional & national industrial policy. America needs to help itself by helping Mexico become more resilient. MMGA is not as catchy as MAGA, it needs evocative marketing in Spanish.


    Trump’s tariffs shifted the US deficit to Vietnam, Mexico,India. But China’s exports to these countries rose with their exports to the US. The world just white-labeled Chinese goods.
     
    Making CCP influence more diffuse weakens their trade leverage as they cannot effectively black mail the world by creating an obstacle in a single location. This is desirable, however re-shoring is only an intermediate step.

    Not-The-President Biden was stuck with certain high profile policies from Trump's 1st term. Outside of those he has been weak in national security/trade. The only thing potentially making him look slightly better is the EU. Brussels is even worse than America on regional industrial security/trade policy.

    The long term goal is MAGA Reindustrialization. Again, I point out that this will take decades. Raw material extraction and goods manufacturing critical to national security, need to be brought back on shore. Restarting mines, building refineries, etc. are long lead time projects.

    Where necessary this can be expanded to regional in addition to national production. A solid partnership with Mexico would pay dividends in areas like immigration in addition to trade & economics. Imagine how much better our southern border would be with Mexico engaging in maximum enforcement against illegals as they tried to leave Guatemala.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    To meet this requirement Mexico is taking the better value added tasks. China is thus pushed to less critical, lower value parts.

    Fundamentally, if there is a lot of value-added in Mexico (if shipments from China aren’t just unloaded and repackaged before going to the US), shouldn’t the growth contribution of net exports be positive and rising in Mexico? It isn’t. It’s negative & getting worse (pink).

    The US trade deficit with China has shrunk by $90 bn since 2018, but that’s more than offset by wider US trade deficits with especially Vietnam and Mexico. There is no trade decoupling of the US from China. China just sends its products to the US on more circuitous routes.

    Since 2019, Mexico’s bilateral trade surplus with the US is up 40% (blue). Most of that is due to China, which ships goods to Mexico (red) that then go to the US. We see trade diversion of western goods to Russia via Central Asia. The same is happening with China via Mexico.

    [MORE]

    The “churn” in Mexico’s trade balance is up massively since COVID. Exports to the US have risen, but so have imports from everywhere. Mexico benefits from this churn it is a logistics hub not a production hub.

    If it’s re-shoring, shouldn’t you see export volumes rise more relative to import volumes? I think that’s the puzzle. Mexico’s net exports are basically flat.

    • Disagree: A123
    • Replies: @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere



    Gradual decoupling needs to be a concerted process over decades. It will not happen in one or two years.
    ...
    Not-The-President Biden was stuck with certain high profile policies from Trump’s 1st term. Outside of those he has been weak in national security/trade.
    ...
    USMCA content requirements on cars and auto parts. To meet this requirement Mexico is taking the better value added tasks. The CCP is thus pushed to less critical, lower value parts.

     

    The “churn” in Mexico’s trade balance is up massively since COVID. Exports to the US have risen, but so have imports from everywhere. Mexico benefits from this churn it is a logistics hub not a production hub.

    If it’s re-shoring, shouldn’t you see export volumes rise more relative to import volumes? I think that’s the puzzle. Mexico’s net exports are basically flat.
     

    As I pointed out re-shoring and eventually Onshoring is a process that will take decades. Not-The-President Biden is an impediment to progress. You are correct to add in WUHAN-19 disruptions.

    The net of all if this is that you are not seeing much in the end statistics, because there is not yet much to see. These are the early days laying the ground work, such as spending capital to restart mining.
    ___

    You are commingling auto in Mexico with other industries in Mexico, thus missing my point. I was referring specifically to the auto sector which has explicit USMCA provisions causing the CCP movement down the value chain.

    You are correct that the net for all Mexico sectors (not auto only) is stagnant because of CCP increases in sectors other than auto. Fortunately, the USMCA has a five year cycle for review built in. This will allow weakness to be fixed, in future preventing non value added pass thru that does not help the Mexican or American workers. Again, gradual decoupling takes a significant amount of time.
    ____

    Part of the problem is we are having two rather different conversations that only slightly overlap:

    • You are focusing on the most recent year-over-year statistics
    • I am focusing on long term strategy that will not be visible in the year year-over-year statistics for a decade or more.

    I suspect we largely concur in the shortest of short-term analysis -- Not much has changed on net. U.S. gains are in specific, highly targeted, products and sectors. Many of those gains are offset by backsliding elsewhere (e.g. foolish green energy initiatives). And, the view is extremely muddled by WUHAN-19 disruptions.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

  405. @A123
    @John Johnson


    So you can’t answer a simple question.
     
    I can answer simple questions.

    I cannot answer delusional ones reliant on circumstances only present in a Marvel multiverse fiasco.

    How exactly am I being delusional?
     
    Your delusion is that there is any chance of Trump going to jail. There is no, nada, zilch, zero possible scenario for Trump to receive jail time in any of these obviously ludicrous cases.

    Do you deny that polls show Haley doing better against Biden?
     
    Do you deny that Trump is doing better against Haley?

    She is an anti-MAGA establishment RINO with no chance of winning the primary. Therefore, her theoretical polling in a "never going to happen" Haley-Biden matchup is irrelevant. Much like your irrelevant & unanswerable question about Trump jail time that will never happen.

    He quits and his pending felonies are no longer a risk factor.
     
    Thank you for admitting the persecutions targeting Trump are about politics, not justice.

    This is a huge step forward for you.

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    [MORE]

  406. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Your statistics look good. It might help to add 2 or 3 real world examples for context and impact. My eyes just kind of glaze over looking at charts.

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    It might help to add 2 or 3 real world examples

    https://www.timesofisrael.com/suspected-spy-devices-found-in-gifts-given-to-ministers-by-chinese-embassy-reports/

    An alleged bug found in a travel mug given as a gift by the Chinese embassy to an Israeli ministry. The mug and others like it proved not to contain anything untoward, the Shin Bet security agency said after investigation, on April 12, 2022.

  407. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    To meet this requirement Mexico is taking the better value added tasks. China is thus pushed to less critical, lower value parts.
     
    Fundamentally, if there is a lot of value-added in Mexico (if shipments from China aren't just unloaded and repackaged before going to the US), shouldn't the growth contribution of net exports be positive and rising in Mexico? It isn't. It's negative & getting worse (pink).


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GDVTKyRWAAAOZ0k.jpg


    The US trade deficit with China has shrunk by $90 bn since 2018, but that's more than offset by wider US trade deficits with especially Vietnam and Mexico. There is no trade decoupling of the US from China. China just sends its products to the US on more circuitous routes.

    Since 2019, Mexico's bilateral trade surplus with the US is up 40% (blue). Most of that is due to China, which ships goods to Mexico (red) that then go to the US. We see trade diversion of western goods to Russia via Central Asia. The same is happening with China via Mexico.


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GCISSz7XIAAdLi1.jpg

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F_d1xbFXUAAl7Ow.jpg


    The "churn" in Mexico's trade balance is up massively since COVID. Exports to the US have risen, but so have imports from everywhere. Mexico benefits from this churn it is a logistics hub not a production hub.

    If it's re-shoring, shouldn't you see export volumes rise more relative to import volumes? I think that's the puzzle. Mexico's net exports are basically flat.

    Replies: @A123

    Gradual decoupling needs to be a concerted process over decades. It will not happen in one or two years.

    Not-The-President Biden was stuck with certain high profile policies from Trump’s 1st term. Outside of those he has been weak in national security/trade.

    USMCA content requirements on cars and auto parts. To meet this requirement Mexico is taking the better value added tasks. The CCP is thus pushed to less critical, lower value parts.

    The “churn” in Mexico’s trade balance is up massively since COVID. Exports to the US have risen, but so have imports from everywhere. Mexico benefits from this churn it is a logistics hub not a production hub.

    If it’s re-shoring, shouldn’t you see export volumes rise more relative to import volumes? I think that’s the puzzle. Mexico’s net exports are basically flat.

    As I pointed out re-shoring and eventually Onshoring is a process that will take decades. Not-The-President Biden is an impediment to progress. You are correct to add in WUHAN-19 disruptions.

    The net of all if this is that you are not seeing much in the end statistics, because there is not yet much to see. These are the early days laying the ground work, such as spending capital to restart mining.
    ___

    You are commingling auto in Mexico with other industries in Mexico, thus missing my point. I was referring specifically to the auto sector which has explicit USMCA provisions causing the CCP movement down the value chain.

    You are correct that the net for all Mexico sectors (not auto only) is stagnant because of CCP increases in sectors other than auto. Fortunately, the USMCA has a five year cycle for review built in. This will allow weakness to be fixed, in future preventing non value added pass thru that does not help the Mexican or American workers. Again, gradual decoupling takes a significant amount of time.
    ____

    Part of the problem is we are having two rather different conversations that only slightly overlap:

    • You are focusing on the most recent year-over-year statistics
    • I am focusing on long term strategy that will not be visible in the year year-over-year statistics for a decade or more.

    I suspect we largely concur in the shortest of short-term analysis — Not much has changed on net. U.S. gains are in specific, highly targeted, products and sectors. Many of those gains are offset by backsliding elsewhere (e.g. foolish green energy initiatives). And, the view is extremely muddled by WUHAN-19 disruptions.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    You are commingling auto in Mexico with other industries in Mexico
     
    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Fli4ZNLXoAQH5ZW.jpg

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GACSZMZXIAAb115.jpg

    Mexico has absorbed huge amounts of auto manufacturing FDI from the US since NAFTA in the '90s, but has yet to build a single globally competitive auto or auto supplier company.

    The FDI was just used to exploit Mexican labor, without any transfer of the US knowledge.

    1/5 new cars sold in Mexico = from China, and they aren't primarily Teslas or EVs.

    And port capacity is a constraint on China's export growth in Mexico as well:

    The port authorities in Michoacán announced that there weren’t enough trailers to remove the Chinese cars from their ships.

    Chinese firms producing in Mexico tho count as Mexican in my book. Location of actual work trumps ownership. But reliance on imported Chinese parts could be significant so worth looking at that.

    Chinese producers set up shop in Mexico and use a north american supply chain to supply the US market with enough North American content to qualify.

    China is producing more goods for consumption in Mexico; which frees up more Mexican production for US market.

    https://youtu.be/vvkBV9AwD0o?si=WgQriJjlRQsOljVc

    Replies: @QCIC, @A123, @Yahya

  408. @LT1488
    @AnonfromTN

    Sunak isn't even European though.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    Sunak isn’t even European though.

    Apparently from elites’ point of view a Paki is European enough to serve as a figurehead. The “lady” before him was British, but if anything, she was even more pathetic. As they say, formerly Great formerly Britain.

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @AnonfromTN

    It is plutocracy. Look whom Sunak married.
    The Rich of the Commonwealth rule UK.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    , @LT1488
    @AnonfromTN

    As they say, formerly Great formerly Britain.

    well well well don't tell that to Mr Galkovsky and his fans

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

  409. @AnonfromTN
    @LT1488


    Sunak isn’t even European though.
     
    Apparently from elites’ point of view a Paki is European enough to serve as a figurehead. The “lady” before him was British, but if anything, she was even more pathetic. As they say, formerly Great formerly Britain.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @LT1488

    It is plutocracy. Look whom Sunak married.
    The Rich of the Commonwealth rule UK.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Another Polish Perspective


    It is plutocracy. Look whom Sunak married.
    The Rich of the Commonwealth rule UK.
     
    My point exactly.

    There is Russian joke:
    - Может ли брак по расчету быть счастливым?
    - Может, если расчет верный.

    Loose translation:
    - Can marriage of convenience be happy?
    - Yes, if convenience was determined correctly.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  410. @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere



    Gradual decoupling needs to be a concerted process over decades. It will not happen in one or two years.
    ...
    Not-The-President Biden was stuck with certain high profile policies from Trump’s 1st term. Outside of those he has been weak in national security/trade.
    ...
    USMCA content requirements on cars and auto parts. To meet this requirement Mexico is taking the better value added tasks. The CCP is thus pushed to less critical, lower value parts.

     

    The “churn” in Mexico’s trade balance is up massively since COVID. Exports to the US have risen, but so have imports from everywhere. Mexico benefits from this churn it is a logistics hub not a production hub.

    If it’s re-shoring, shouldn’t you see export volumes rise more relative to import volumes? I think that’s the puzzle. Mexico’s net exports are basically flat.
     

    As I pointed out re-shoring and eventually Onshoring is a process that will take decades. Not-The-President Biden is an impediment to progress. You are correct to add in WUHAN-19 disruptions.

    The net of all if this is that you are not seeing much in the end statistics, because there is not yet much to see. These are the early days laying the ground work, such as spending capital to restart mining.
    ___

    You are commingling auto in Mexico with other industries in Mexico, thus missing my point. I was referring specifically to the auto sector which has explicit USMCA provisions causing the CCP movement down the value chain.

    You are correct that the net for all Mexico sectors (not auto only) is stagnant because of CCP increases in sectors other than auto. Fortunately, the USMCA has a five year cycle for review built in. This will allow weakness to be fixed, in future preventing non value added pass thru that does not help the Mexican or American workers. Again, gradual decoupling takes a significant amount of time.
    ____

    Part of the problem is we are having two rather different conversations that only slightly overlap:

    • You are focusing on the most recent year-over-year statistics
    • I am focusing on long term strategy that will not be visible in the year year-over-year statistics for a decade or more.

    I suspect we largely concur in the shortest of short-term analysis -- Not much has changed on net. U.S. gains are in specific, highly targeted, products and sectors. Many of those gains are offset by backsliding elsewhere (e.g. foolish green energy initiatives). And, the view is extremely muddled by WUHAN-19 disruptions.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    You are commingling auto in Mexico with other industries in Mexico

    Mexico has absorbed huge amounts of auto manufacturing FDI from the US since NAFTA in the ’90s, but has yet to build a single globally competitive auto or auto supplier company.

    The FDI was just used to exploit Mexican labor, without any transfer of the US knowledge.

    1/5 new cars sold in Mexico = from China, and they aren’t primarily Teslas or EVs.

    And port capacity is a constraint on China’s export growth in Mexico as well:

    The port authorities in Michoacán announced that there weren’t enough trailers to remove the Chinese cars from their ships.

    Chinese firms producing in Mexico tho count as Mexican in my book. Location of actual work trumps ownership. But reliance on imported Chinese parts could be significant so worth looking at that.

    Chinese producers set up shop in Mexico and use a north american supply chain to supply the US market with enough North American content to qualify.

    China is producing more goods for consumption in Mexico; which frees up more Mexican production for US market.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    NoviopCPS wrote:


    The FDI was just used to exploit Mexican labor, without any transfer of the US knowledge.
     
    Hmmm, I wonder why? IQ ~ 88 may be a factor. At 88 there are a substantial number of intelligent people in the population available to do challenging things. But there is no 'excess' of such minds (none to spare!), so new starts are difficult.
    , @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere


    Chinese producers set up shop in Mexico and use a north american supply chain to supply the US market with enough North American content to qualify.
     
    Indeed, this re-shoring helps bring economic activity from Asia to North America which is a solid step towards gradual decoupling. USMCA has a five year cycle where the % of North American content can be increased, resulting in more re-shoring and decoupling.

    China is producing more goods for consumption in Mexico; which frees up more Mexican production for US market.
     
    You identify a valid problem. Clearly the North American content rules need expansion beyond vehicles & parts. Gradual decoupling needs to cover other sectors vital to regional security/trade.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    , @Yahya
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    https://youtu.be/eJWyzfJafmI?si=XMWbtYuBylvy8AdZ

  411. @LT1488
    @Mr. Hack

    Slovaks are an odd case in Central Europe where many have pro-Russian opinions.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Derer, @AP

    They probably acquired this trait from their former Hungarian masters, “Follow the Leader”:

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @Mr. Hack

    Well don't tell slovaks in the face that they are similar to ''Magyars'', they take great offence to that.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

  412. @Another Polish Perspective
    @AnonfromTN

    It is plutocracy. Look whom Sunak married.
    The Rich of the Commonwealth rule UK.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    It is plutocracy. Look whom Sunak married.
    The Rich of the Commonwealth rule UK.

    My point exactly.

    There is Russian joke:
    – Может ли брак по расчету быть счастливым?
    – Может, если расчет верный.

    Loose translation:
    – Can marriage of convenience be happy?
    – Yes, if convenience was determined correctly.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @AnonfromTN


    – Can marriage of convenience be happy?
    – Yes, if convenience was determined correctly.
     
    You should know, Janissary. How long has it been now that you've decided to leave your first love, Mother Russia, and live with your new one, America? "Convenient", eh? Here you find your dream job, make way more money that you ever could in Russia, and are still able to badmouth America. What a duplicitous existence you live. :-(

    Replies: @QCIC, @Derer

  413. @Mr. XYZ
    @Derer

    Horthy's biggest mistake was trying to backstab Hitler in 1944 by trying to make a separate peace, possibly in an attempt to keep some of Hungary's territorial gains in the post-WWII era. It failed miserably and resulted in the mass murder of hundreds of thousands of Hungarian Jews. And Hungary didn't even get to keep any of its 1938-1941 territorial gains after the end of WWII, so it was all for nothing! At least Horthy could have been proud of not getting hanged by the Allies, I guess.

    Replies: @Beckow

    …Horthy’s biggest mistake was trying to backstab Hitler in 1944 by trying to make a separate peace

    Horthy’s biggest mistakes were joining Nazi Germany in 1938 Munich Treaty to dismember Czechoslovakia (together with Poland), then grabbing territories of all surrounding countries, and sending 300k Magyars with Nazis in 1941 to invade Russia.

    What he did or didn’t do in “1944” was irrelevant – by then Hungary was done, a defeated nation. You are analyzing it without understanding: by 1944 Germany was thoroughly defeated by Russia, the sad switche-roos by Italy, Romania, Hungary…were pointless. US-UK finally joining the war in June 1944 with the Normandy landing was similar, a belated attempt to join in and mitigate the defeat of Germany. (They then went ape-shit claiming the credit – Anglos are like that.)

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    the sad switche-roos by Italy, Romania, Hungary…were pointless.
     
    Not quite. Romanian king even got the Order of Victory from Stalin.

    Besides, as US and UK agreed to keep Romania and Hungary in the Soviet zone, Soviet propaganda never mentioned the atrocities committed by Romanian and Hungarian troops. In fact, Romanians murdered most Jews in Odessa, whereas by the accounts of those who happened to be on temporarily occupied Soviet territories, Hungarians were worse for the civilians than Germans. By their brutality Hungarians far exceeded Germans, approaching banderites:
    https://www.ilawjournals.com/why-vatutin-ordered-not-to-take-prisoners-hungarian-soldiers-of-hitler/
    That’s why in the battle of Voronezh Soviet commander Vatutin issued an order that Hungarians should not be taken prisoners. The order was followed: virtually all Hungarian troops near Voronezh were killed.


    US-UK finally joining the war in June 1944 with the Normandy landing was similar, a belated attempt to join in and mitigate the defeat of Germany.
     
    Yes, by June 1944 the outcome of the war was already assured. However, late entrance of “Allies” in the war against Nazi Germany was mostly to participate in the division of spoils with minimal investment into actual fighting. Saving and then using numerous Nazis was probably not the main goal.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Beckow, @LT1488, @Mr. XYZ

    , @Hyperborean
    @Beckow


    US-UK finally joining the war in June 1944 with the Normandy landing was similar, a belated attempt to join in and mitigate the defeat of Germany.
     
    Ignoring the humilating Dieppe Raid of August 1942 as well as the successful landings at Sicily starting July 1943 that led to the further invasion of Italy, if we are purely counting army battles on European soil.

    I dislike the hazy Dunkirk to D-Day pop culture narrative that is prevalent, but there's no reason to say things that people can easily contradict.

    Replies: @Coconuts, @Beckow

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @Beckow

    Romania at least chose a smart moment to switch sides during WWII. Prevented its own Jews from being mass murdered by the Nazis (at least in the Old Kingdom of Romania territories) and saved most of Budapest's Jews as well by compelling the Nazis to postpone their deportation to Auschwitz, which ultimately ended up never happening, though a lot of them (but apparently not a majority) did subsequently die in forced Nazi death marches.

    Could Hungary have avoided invading the USSR in 1941?

    Replies: @Beckow

  414. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    You are commingling auto in Mexico with other industries in Mexico
     
    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Fli4ZNLXoAQH5ZW.jpg

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GACSZMZXIAAb115.jpg

    Mexico has absorbed huge amounts of auto manufacturing FDI from the US since NAFTA in the '90s, but has yet to build a single globally competitive auto or auto supplier company.

    The FDI was just used to exploit Mexican labor, without any transfer of the US knowledge.

    1/5 new cars sold in Mexico = from China, and they aren't primarily Teslas or EVs.

    And port capacity is a constraint on China's export growth in Mexico as well:

    The port authorities in Michoacán announced that there weren’t enough trailers to remove the Chinese cars from their ships.

    Chinese firms producing in Mexico tho count as Mexican in my book. Location of actual work trumps ownership. But reliance on imported Chinese parts could be significant so worth looking at that.

    Chinese producers set up shop in Mexico and use a north american supply chain to supply the US market with enough North American content to qualify.

    China is producing more goods for consumption in Mexico; which frees up more Mexican production for US market.

    https://youtu.be/vvkBV9AwD0o?si=WgQriJjlRQsOljVc

    Replies: @QCIC, @A123, @Yahya

    NoviopCPS wrote:

    The FDI was just used to exploit Mexican labor, without any transfer of the US knowledge.

    Hmmm, I wonder why? IQ ~ 88 may be a factor. At 88 there are a substantial number of intelligent people in the population available to do challenging things. But there is no ‘excess’ of such minds (none to spare!), so new starts are difficult.

  415. @AnonfromTN
    @Another Polish Perspective


    It is plutocracy. Look whom Sunak married.
    The Rich of the Commonwealth rule UK.
     
    My point exactly.

    There is Russian joke:
    - Может ли брак по расчету быть счастливым?
    - Может, если расчет верный.

    Loose translation:
    - Can marriage of convenience be happy?
    - Yes, if convenience was determined correctly.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    – Can marriage of convenience be happy?
    – Yes, if convenience was determined correctly.

    You should know, Janissary. How long has it been now that you’ve decided to leave your first love, Mother Russia, and live with your new one, America? “Convenient”, eh? Here you find your dream job, make way more money that you ever could in Russia, and are still able to badmouth America. What a duplicitous existence you live. 🙁

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Mr. Hack

    Go back to your cartoons. The USA needs all the good people it can get.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    , @Derer
    @Mr. Hack

    And what is your situation Mr.Hack?

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  416. @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ


    ...Horthy’s biggest mistake was trying to backstab Hitler in 1944 by trying to make a separate peace
     
    Horthy's biggest mistakes were joining Nazi Germany in 1938 Munich Treaty to dismember Czechoslovakia (together with Poland), then grabbing territories of all surrounding countries, and sending 300k Magyars with Nazis in 1941 to invade Russia.

    What he did or didn't do in "1944" was irrelevant - by then Hungary was done, a defeated nation. You are analyzing it without understanding: by 1944 Germany was thoroughly defeated by Russia, the sad switche-roos by Italy, Romania, Hungary...were pointless. US-UK finally joining the war in June 1944 with the Normandy landing was similar, a belated attempt to join in and mitigate the defeat of Germany. (They then went ape-shit claiming the credit - Anglos are like that.)

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Hyperborean, @Mr. XYZ

    the sad switche-roos by Italy, Romania, Hungary…were pointless.

    Not quite. Romanian king even got the Order of Victory from Stalin.

    Besides, as US and UK agreed to keep Romania and Hungary in the Soviet zone, Soviet propaganda never mentioned the atrocities committed by Romanian and Hungarian troops. In fact, Romanians murdered most Jews in Odessa, whereas by the accounts of those who happened to be on temporarily occupied Soviet territories, Hungarians were worse for the civilians than Germans. By their brutality Hungarians far exceeded Germans, approaching banderites:
    https://www.ilawjournals.com/why-vatutin-ordered-not-to-take-prisoners-hungarian-soldiers-of-hitler/
    That’s why in the battle of Voronezh Soviet commander Vatutin issued an order that Hungarians should not be taken prisoners. The order was followed: virtually all Hungarian troops near Voronezh were killed.

    US-UK finally joining the war in June 1944 with the Normandy landing was similar, a belated attempt to join in and mitigate the defeat of Germany.

    Yes, by June 1944 the outcome of the war was already assured. However, late entrance of “Allies” in the war against Nazi Germany was mostly to participate in the division of spoils with minimal investment into actual fighting. Saving and then using numerous Nazis was probably not the main goal.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @AnonfromTN

    Yes, by June 1944 the outcome of the war was already assured. However, late entrance of “Allies” in the war against Nazi Germany was mostly to participate in the division of spoils with minimal investment into actual fighting. Saving and then using numerous Nazis was probably not the main goal.

    The problem with this type of thinking is that it assumes the main form of attack by the Allies was on the ground.

    The main Allied attack against the Nazis was from the air. The Allies dropped 2.7 million tons of ordinance on Nazi Germany in 1.5 million sorties which is absolutely mind boggling. That is what massively helped the USSR as the Germans were short on supplies due to their factories being constantly bombed. If you read diaries from the German retreat in the East you will see that they were half starving and covered in lice. It's extremely hard to maintain a front in a cold area when your supply line can't provide the basics.

    The war would not have been over in 1945 if the Allies had chosen to let the Germans fight the USSR on their own. That is what many anti-Communists at the time wanted. Let the two belligerents destroy each other and then enter by ground to clean up the mess.

    Hollywood certainly overrates the Western front and D-day which shouldn't be a surprise. But it underestimates how much of Germany was destroyed from the air. The Germans would have built thousands more aircraft if not for Allied bombing attacks. A thousand more bombers at Kursk would have turned the tide in favor of the Germans. The attack was a poor decision by Hitler but it would have easily worked if they had a thousand additional bombers to soften up Soviet defenses. The Soviets had the stronger defensive position, knew the full German battleplans from Turing and yet they still had more casualties. If German factories were at full capacity then it would have been an Axis victory.

    Replies: @Derer

    , @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN

    You are right that the Romanians got of lightly, they were - and can be again - among the more determined anti-Russian fanatics. Maybe the fact that they were so pathetic and poor endeared them to the commie leaders in Moscow. When Romies switched, their armies without real weapons or often even shoes marched alongside Red Army into CE. My grandparents said they were begging in villages door to door for food. But then they got Causescu, so I suppose that was enough of a retribution.


    mostly to participate in the division of spoils with minimal investment into actual fighting. Saving and then using numerous Nazis was probably not the main goal.
     
    That sounds plausible until one realizes that the material spoils were not that great. It is very likely that from early on Anglos played a double game and were in touch with many Nazis promising leniency for cooperation. Rudolf Hess wasn't mad and didn't fly to Britain un-announced.

    The original plan to see if Nazi Germany with help of most of Europe can destroy Russia, changed into "let's bleed them both", and eventually once Russia was obviously winning big to "let's see what can be salvaged from the Nazi drang-nach-Osten" - at least not allowing for it to be fully extinguished. The resources, or even specific borders, are not that important for the Anglo supremacists, it is the crazy geo-political desire for unchallenged dominance. Once they have it, all else would follow.

    The Ukie tragedy is a minor version of the same old plan - by now the Anglos are so incompetent that it is almost absurd: weaker forces, no real commitment or fallback plan, focus on winning in the media and not on the ground. But the impulse is the same.

    , @LT1488
    @AnonfromTN

    Hungarians when they took over Vojvodina in Serbia, they treated it better than say Croats or Albanians treated their parts of occupied Serbia.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AnonfromTN


    Not quite. Romanian king even got the Order of Victory from Stalin.

     

    He also got Stalin to agree to return Northern Transylvania to Romania in its entirety after the end of WWII. Quite an accomplishment.
  417. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    You are commingling auto in Mexico with other industries in Mexico
     
    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Fli4ZNLXoAQH5ZW.jpg

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GACSZMZXIAAb115.jpg

    Mexico has absorbed huge amounts of auto manufacturing FDI from the US since NAFTA in the '90s, but has yet to build a single globally competitive auto or auto supplier company.

    The FDI was just used to exploit Mexican labor, without any transfer of the US knowledge.

    1/5 new cars sold in Mexico = from China, and they aren't primarily Teslas or EVs.

    And port capacity is a constraint on China's export growth in Mexico as well:

    The port authorities in Michoacán announced that there weren’t enough trailers to remove the Chinese cars from their ships.

    Chinese firms producing in Mexico tho count as Mexican in my book. Location of actual work trumps ownership. But reliance on imported Chinese parts could be significant so worth looking at that.

    Chinese producers set up shop in Mexico and use a north american supply chain to supply the US market with enough North American content to qualify.

    China is producing more goods for consumption in Mexico; which frees up more Mexican production for US market.

    https://youtu.be/vvkBV9AwD0o?si=WgQriJjlRQsOljVc

    Replies: @QCIC, @A123, @Yahya

    Chinese producers set up shop in Mexico and use a north american supply chain to supply the US market with enough North American content to qualify.

    Indeed, this re-shoring helps bring economic activity from Asia to North America which is a solid step towards gradual decoupling. USMCA has a five year cycle where the % of North American content can be increased, resulting in more re-shoring and decoupling.

    China is producing more goods for consumption in Mexico; which frees up more Mexican production for US market.

    You identify a valid problem. Clearly the North American content rules need expansion beyond vehicles & parts. Gradual decoupling needs to cover other sectors vital to regional security/trade.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    a solid step towards gradual decoupling.
     
    At the launching of BYD Dolphin in Mexico, Stella Li of BYD announced it's looking into building a factory there.


    https://www.elsoldemexico.com.mx/finanzas/byd-evalua-construir-una-planta-en-mexico-10732051.html


    Expecting around 20-30k sales in Mexico next yr with BYD Dolphin in the product mix.

    I've long believed BYD will have plant in Mexico to serve North America. Mexico has huge car industry around Puebla area & very friendly policies toward Chinese companies.

    Governor of Puebla welcomed a new BYD "agency" there.

    VW group has major factories in Puebla area (very close to Mexico City). If BYD opens a factory in Mexico for North American market, Puebla would be a logical location to do so!

    A Mexico plant, with batteries that satisfy IRA tax credits, would be great way to enter the U.S. market.

    You're right tho a lot of this "decoupling" is just Chinese companies moving production to Mexico and ASEAN countries to evade tariffs. But even aside from this, China is moving up value chain. Supplying battery/chips for EVs and renewables is the way to go!


    https://twitter.com/SergioSalomonC/status/1709775926291034270

  418. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @Hyperborean

    Looks like Somalia is seriously unhappy about the port deal Ethiopia did with Somaliland, things are starting to heat up along the border.

    Are you keeping up with the details?

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FVJbYH4XoAIUek6.jpg

    Replies: @QCIC, @Hyperborean

    Looks like Somalia is seriously unhappy about the port deal Ethiopia did with Somaliland, things are starting to heat up along the border.

    Are you keeping up with the details?

    So far the regional dynamics seem to be:

    Somalia is threatening war while regional powers’ stance is

    UAE favouring Ethiopia and Somaliland
    VS
    Eritrea, Egypt and Turkey favouring Somalia

    But of course the significance of this depends on how much any of the other powers actively get involved.

    I think Eritrea is likely to intervene directly, the rest – no idea. Probably some of the others will supply weapons.

  419. @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere


    Chinese producers set up shop in Mexico and use a north american supply chain to supply the US market with enough North American content to qualify.
     
    Indeed, this re-shoring helps bring economic activity from Asia to North America which is a solid step towards gradual decoupling. USMCA has a five year cycle where the % of North American content can be increased, resulting in more re-shoring and decoupling.

    China is producing more goods for consumption in Mexico; which frees up more Mexican production for US market.
     
    You identify a valid problem. Clearly the North American content rules need expansion beyond vehicles & parts. Gradual decoupling needs to cover other sectors vital to regional security/trade.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    a solid step towards gradual decoupling.

    At the launching of BYD Dolphin in Mexico, Stella Li of BYD announced it’s looking into building a factory there.

    https://www.elsoldemexico.com.mx/finanzas/byd-evalua-construir-una-planta-en-mexico-10732051.html

    Expecting around 20-30k sales in Mexico next yr with BYD Dolphin in the product mix.

    I’ve long believed BYD will have plant in Mexico to serve North America. Mexico has huge car industry around Puebla area & very friendly policies toward Chinese companies.

    Governor of Puebla welcomed a new BYD “agency” there.

    VW group has major factories in Puebla area (very close to Mexico City). If BYD opens a factory in Mexico for North American market, Puebla would be a logical location to do so!

    A Mexico plant, with batteries that satisfy IRA tax credits, would be great way to enter the U.S. market.

    You’re right tho a lot of this “decoupling” is just Chinese companies moving production to Mexico and ASEAN countries to evade tariffs. But even aside from this, China is moving up value chain. Supplying battery/chips for EVs and renewables is the way to go!

    [MORE]

  420. @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ


    ...Horthy’s biggest mistake was trying to backstab Hitler in 1944 by trying to make a separate peace
     
    Horthy's biggest mistakes were joining Nazi Germany in 1938 Munich Treaty to dismember Czechoslovakia (together with Poland), then grabbing territories of all surrounding countries, and sending 300k Magyars with Nazis in 1941 to invade Russia.

    What he did or didn't do in "1944" was irrelevant - by then Hungary was done, a defeated nation. You are analyzing it without understanding: by 1944 Germany was thoroughly defeated by Russia, the sad switche-roos by Italy, Romania, Hungary...were pointless. US-UK finally joining the war in June 1944 with the Normandy landing was similar, a belated attempt to join in and mitigate the defeat of Germany. (They then went ape-shit claiming the credit - Anglos are like that.)

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Hyperborean, @Mr. XYZ

    US-UK finally joining the war in June 1944 with the Normandy landing was similar, a belated attempt to join in and mitigate the defeat of Germany.

    Ignoring the humilating Dieppe Raid of August 1942 as well as the successful landings at Sicily starting July 1943 that led to the further invasion of Italy, if we are purely counting army battles on European soil.

    I dislike the hazy Dunkirk to D-Day pop culture narrative that is prevalent, but there’s no reason to say things that people can easily contradict.

    • Replies: @Coconuts
    @Hyperborean


    I dislike the hazy Dunkirk to D-Day pop culture narrative that is prevalent, but there’s no reason to say things that people can easily contradict.
     
    Beckow tends to make these strange statements about WW2.

    Imo it looks like claiming the Soviet victory as a great victory of humanity, but at the same time making it a statement of racial or ethnic supremacism.

    There is a Franco-Russian researcher who wrote about this type of phenomena, and how the treatment of Nazism particularly has been an inspiration for it:



    https://www.amazon.co.uk/force-pr%C3%A9jug%C3%A9-Essai-racisme-doubles/dp/2070719774/ref=sr_1_1?crid=1PLGEKOJNQSCC&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.kvra4MuzTCnRTfEjMuTjQQ.bINUIvQsj4bA56iJLcZpceLOkcryI02PrrF8c2iHY5A&dib_tag=se&keywords=Pierre+Andre+Taguieff+La+Force+du+Prejuge&qid=1705346217&sprefix=pierre+andre+taguieff+la+force+du+prejuge%2Caps%2C102&sr=8-1

    I think this was translated into English back in the 1980s when it first came out, but hard to find.

    Replies: @Hyperborean

    , @Beckow
    @Hyperborean


    ...Ignoring the humilating Dieppe Raid of August 1942 as well as the successful landings at Sicily starting July 1943
     
    I am not ignoring it - it was so minor that to call it a war against Germany is not credible. Anglos had active air war against Germany that really got going in the last two years of the war. Same with the land-lease for Russia that didn't start in volume until late 1943.

    By late 1943 Germany and its allies were defeated by Russiat: the defeat happened gradually in 1943, starting in January in Stalingrad. Once Anglos realized that there won't be a German victory or a stalemate they joined the war. But if you look at the timing the Anglos finally got going in the summer of 1943, with Normandy happening 10 months before the end of the war. At the same time as Normandy invasion, Russian did an Operation Bagration that was about 4 times the size of Normandy and Germans lost up to half million soldiers. These comparisons are not even close. It was unquestionably mainly Russia that defeated Germany.

  421. @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    the sad switche-roos by Italy, Romania, Hungary…were pointless.
     
    Not quite. Romanian king even got the Order of Victory from Stalin.

    Besides, as US and UK agreed to keep Romania and Hungary in the Soviet zone, Soviet propaganda never mentioned the atrocities committed by Romanian and Hungarian troops. In fact, Romanians murdered most Jews in Odessa, whereas by the accounts of those who happened to be on temporarily occupied Soviet territories, Hungarians were worse for the civilians than Germans. By their brutality Hungarians far exceeded Germans, approaching banderites:
    https://www.ilawjournals.com/why-vatutin-ordered-not-to-take-prisoners-hungarian-soldiers-of-hitler/
    That’s why in the battle of Voronezh Soviet commander Vatutin issued an order that Hungarians should not be taken prisoners. The order was followed: virtually all Hungarian troops near Voronezh were killed.


    US-UK finally joining the war in June 1944 with the Normandy landing was similar, a belated attempt to join in and mitigate the defeat of Germany.
     
    Yes, by June 1944 the outcome of the war was already assured. However, late entrance of “Allies” in the war against Nazi Germany was mostly to participate in the division of spoils with minimal investment into actual fighting. Saving and then using numerous Nazis was probably not the main goal.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Beckow, @LT1488, @Mr. XYZ

    Yes, by June 1944 the outcome of the war was already assured. However, late entrance of “Allies” in the war against Nazi Germany was mostly to participate in the division of spoils with minimal investment into actual fighting. Saving and then using numerous Nazis was probably not the main goal.

    The problem with this type of thinking is that it assumes the main form of attack by the Allies was on the ground.

    The main Allied attack against the Nazis was from the air. The Allies dropped 2.7 million tons of ordinance on Nazi Germany in 1.5 million sorties which is absolutely mind boggling. That is what massively helped the USSR as the Germans were short on supplies due to their factories being constantly bombed. If you read diaries from the German retreat in the East you will see that they were half starving and covered in lice. It’s extremely hard to maintain a front in a cold area when your supply line can’t provide the basics.

    The war would not have been over in 1945 if the Allies had chosen to let the Germans fight the USSR on their own. That is what many anti-Communists at the time wanted. Let the two belligerents destroy each other and then enter by ground to clean up the mess.

    Hollywood certainly overrates the Western front and D-day which shouldn’t be a surprise. But it underestimates how much of Germany was destroyed from the air. The Germans would have built thousands more aircraft if not for Allied bombing attacks. A thousand more bombers at Kursk would have turned the tide in favor of the Germans. The attack was a poor decision by Hitler but it would have easily worked if they had a thousand additional bombers to soften up Soviet defenses. The Soviets had the stronger defensive position, knew the full German battleplans from Turing and yet they still had more casualties. If German factories were at full capacity then it would have been an Axis victory.

    • Replies: @Derer
    @John Johnson


    The Allies dropped 2.7 million tons of ordinance on Nazi Germany in 1.5 million sorties which is absolutely mind boggling.
     
    Unfortunately, they were mostly killing civilians in the cities - technically a war crime including the treatment of millions of POW. American involvement in the WWII European arena is dated just 7 months before the war end (do not count Italian holidays)...and was mostly motivated by getting seat at the Yalta agreement and thus spoils of the war in Europe. Of course American school textbooks will not say that.
  422. @A123
    @AnonfromTN


    Iran announced that in the Gulf of Oman it seized a loaded oil tanker (formerly known as Suez Rajan) that was, along with Iranian crude oil it carried, previously stolen by the US.
     
    The Iranian piracy offended many countries:

    • Greece -- owner
    • Iraq -- cargo
    • Türkiye -- destination
    • Philippines -- crew

    Regardless of the earlier event, this is a very bad play on Khamenei's part. His attack did not directly impact the U.S. Khamenei has never been politically deft, but this seems unusually incompetent. When is the last time the Ayatollah spoke in public?

    It’s an illustration of the fact that highway robbery game the empire loves so much can be played by others, as well. Those who foam at the mouth advocating stealing Russian assets should take notice.
     
    I concur. Stealing the private assets of Russian nationals is clearly inappropriate. And, unlike Khamenei's error, potential responses could be much more accurately wielded.

    The good news is that America is unlikely to make such a mistake. First, a law would have to be passed through a divided Congress. Funding Kiev aggression is not a priority. In the unlikely event a bill is signed, it would be tied up in court for years.

    Add this to the already long list of "Symbolism Over Substance". Politicians obtain some constituency credit for talking about such ideas, even though they know they will never happen.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Yep. Even CCP lines like COSCO are avoiding the Red Sea - Suez route. Do you notice the near absence of European involvement? France sent one ship. Is that it for the EU?

    Asian imports becoming slower and more expensive is good for domestic European suppliers. Keeping the canal closed and subsidizing Egypt/Greece for lost employment is a net win. You have to like decoupling when you see it.

    I wonder how long Xi will accept Khamenei's shut down.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

  423. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GDp0mNoWIAEaVcU.jpg

    Replies: @A123

    Yep. Even CCP lines like COSCO are avoiding the Red Sea – Suez route. Do you notice the near absence of European involvement? France sent one ship. Is that it for the EU?

    Asian imports becoming slower and more expensive is good for domestic European suppliers. Keeping the canal closed and subsidizing Egypt/Greece for lost employment is a net win. You have to like decoupling when you see it.

    I wonder how long Xi will accept Khamenei’s shut down.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    Yep. Even Chinese lines like COSCO are avoiding the Red Sea – Suez route.
     
    Vessels transiting the Red Sea are using their signals to say they have links to China, the latest measure taken to avoid interdiction by Houthi militants in the Red Sea.

    Each of the ships is signaling “all Chinese crew” or something similar in a field that would normally contain its destination.

    The ship's destinations show that their crew or the companies that own the carriers know that being affiliated with the Asian country avert interdiction. Ship destinations are normally entered manually by the crew and are then visible to almost anyone on the internet.


    https://finance.yahoo.com/news/ships-advertise-chinese-links-avoid-122921861.html


    https://www.reuters.com/business/chinas-cosco-halts-shipping-israel-israeli-media-2024-01-07/


    You have to like decoupling when you see it.
     
    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GBDnfplXIAArIei.jpg

    Replies: @A123

  424. @John Johnson
    @A123

    I have noticed that #NeverTrump zealots have serious problems with this fantasy. It tells me they are trying to block out Trump’s inevitable 2nd Term instead of facing it.

    So you can't answer a simple question.

    I don't have fantasies of Trump going to prison. I would like him to leave the race on his own. That would be the ideal scenario. He quits and his pending felonies are no longer a risk factor.

    The best chance of Biden losing is for Trump to leave. I can back that with data. No fantasy required.

    There is no, nada, zilch, zero possible scenario for Trump to receive jail time in any of these obviously ludicrous cases.

    Did you state in the previously election that he would definitely win?

    You really need to be less delusional and more attuned to the real world. You have to accept the objective reality that Trump is genuinely popular with independents and swing voters.

    How exactly am I being delusional?

    Do you deny that polls show Haley doing better against Biden?

    Replies: @A123, @Mikel

    Do you deny that polls show Haley doing better against Biden?

    So, if polls showed Hillary Clinton doing better than Trump against Biden, should we nominate her the Republican candidate? How is Haley better than Biden for those who liked the MAGA-16 agenda: end forever wars, bring US troops back home, build the wall, deport the illegals, combat wokeness,…? Just because she’s right of Biden on tax cuts?

    And if Dems should be so worried about Haley, why are many of them registering as Republicans and voting for her today in Iowa?

    Just like I find it hard to believe that Trump can beat Biden in November, I find it even harder to believe that there is a legitimate path for such a RINO as Haley to become the Republican nominee. That ship has sailed, the Republican party is not going back to where you’d like it. Millions of voters would rather vote for RFK or stay home, me and A123 included (for different reasons, I care about the policies and he cares about the man but we both represent very important parts of the current American electorate).

    The guy wanted to die.

    Just because he had some weird death wish (why, if not, would anyone stay in Ukraine after the Russian invasion and post videos against the Kiev regime? That could have costed him his life even before the start of the war) it doesn’t mean that Kiev had to comply with his wish.

    Perhaps Billy Hayes, imprisoned and tortured in Turkey, or Charles Horman, killed by the Pinochet regime, also had weird death wishes and that’s why they decided to travel to s-thole countries and “break their laws” but that doesn’t mean that the authorities in those countries acted in a moral way.

    I never saw any of Lira’s videos (certainly not in full) before he re-appeared from prison. I flagged him early on as somebody I wasn’t going to get any valuable information from and ignored the creepy-looking and sounding guy. But I’m pretty sure that I have posted here and elsewhere content as objectionable to the Kiev goons as what he said in those videos that would also land me in jail, as have so many of the regulars here. In fact, long before this war started I received personal threats in English-language Ukrainian media from Ukrainians who couldn’t stomach my views opposing the shelling of civilians in Donbass. The Sovok/goon mentality that I encountered in Kiev in the 90s is clearly alive and well still in Ukraine.

    I have obviously no intention of visiting Ukraine again, though I don’t know why I should be afraid of visiting a country whose civil servants, including the thugs that would possibly arrest me, are receiving their salaries with money from my taxes. But someone telling me that the Ukrainians did nothing wrong in Lira’s death is essentially telling me that they wouldn’t give a hoot either if they learned that I had died in a filthy Ukrainian prison for posting what I am posting here. OK, fair enough, you don’t know me personally so why should you care about my life more about Ukraine’s sovereignty and all those high principles of yours? But then go fuck yourselves too. I can’t have any respect at a personal level for people who make excuses for the death of a blogger in a country of goons. It could have been Lira or it could have been any of us here.

    • Replies: @A123
    @Mikel

    Did you notice what I wrote earlier about my alignement to MAGA (not Trump)? (1)


    The commitment is to MAGA, not specifically to Trump. Opposition to GOP establishment RINO’s is locked in. Despite what the #NeverTrump zealots post here, Trump is by far the most electable MAGA nominee. In large part because he is the only authentic MAGA candidate.

    Regardless of what Leftoid polls seem to return, establishment RINO’s like DeSantis and Haley are actually unelectable. These Anti-MAGA shills would not be able to generate MAGA base turnout. Likely a MAGA candidate would appear via a 3rd party nomination to capture those votes. Anti-MAGA DeSantis could easily lose all 50 states, including Florida.

     

    Why did try to copy my position with your statement? Should I take your desire to imitate me as the sincerest form of flattery?

    Millions of voters would rather vote for RFK or stay home, me and A123 included (for different reasons, I care about the policies and he cares about the man but we both represent very important parts of the current American electorate).

     

    I care about MAGA policies. And, what you care about us exceedingly unclear. You:
        • Oppose MAGA by supporting anti-MAGA DeSantis
        • Claim to support MAGA while opposing MAGA Trump.

    If you actually care about MAGA -- Have you considered building bridges back to the electable candidate Trump instead of sticking with the unelectable establishment shill DeSantis?

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇
    _____________________

    (1) https://www.unz.com/akarlin/open-thread-239/#comment-6364384

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    , @John Johnson
    @Mikel


    Do you deny that polls show Haley doing better against Biden?

     

    So, if polls showed Hillary Clinton doing better than Trump against Biden, should we nominate her the Republican candidate?

    I'm asking a question based on what the polls show.

    Clinton is a Democrat and not in the race. She would have to primary Biden.

    How is Haley better than Biden for those who liked the MAGA-16 agenda: end forever wars, bring US troops back home, build the wall, deport the illegals, combat wokeness,…?

    Haley does not have an incredibly dangerous and incompetent VP that could become president at any moment. I also do not believe that Haley would be the same as Biden on immigration. Biden is clearly in the camp of flooding the country with illegals to create new generations of Democrat voters. Such demographic changes don't favor the Republicans.

    I also fail to see why anyone would expect Trump to govern much differently than any mainstream Republican. He had a chance to lock down the border with Schumer's offer and turned it down. Trump was good in some ways but on most issues was a mainstream. Quite a disappointment in that regard. If you look past his rhetoric and focus on actual policy he was mostly a servant to the party.

    I find it even harder to believe that there is a legitimate path for such a RINO as Haley to become the Republican nominee.

    Desantis quits and unites not-Trump voters. Trump is barred from politics by a judge. Haley continues to gain against Trump. There are numerous possibilities.

    That ship has sailed, the Republican party is not going back to where you’d like it.

    I've never once stated that I have any faith in the Republican party to do anything. I would like Biden out more than I want Trump elected and the polls suggest that Haley is the best path.

    But someone telling me that the Ukrainians did nothing wrong in Lira’s death

    I never said that and I don't think anyone is clear on what exactly happened.

    I wouldn't trust the authorities in any Slavic country. Pissing anyone off in power East of Poland is a bad idea. I support Ukraine but I don't view them as a Western country. They inherited an attitude of corruption from the Soviet era and they only rank barely above Russia by international organizations in that regard.

    Most Western countries pass anti-propaganda laws in times of war where their autonomy is threatened. I don't think they are the answer. Lira should have been invited to a live debate on Ukrainian television. He of course would have turned it down but it would have undermined the confidence of his fans.

    As for Lira it appears that he never contacted the state department. The conservative media that is defending him is not making that point. All evidence suggests that Lira wanted to be a martyr. His fans still haven't provided me with a single essay related to Russia since 2020. They view him as a hero journalist and yet don't have a single article.

  425. @John Johnson
    @AnonfromTN

    Yes, by June 1944 the outcome of the war was already assured. However, late entrance of “Allies” in the war against Nazi Germany was mostly to participate in the division of spoils with minimal investment into actual fighting. Saving and then using numerous Nazis was probably not the main goal.

    The problem with this type of thinking is that it assumes the main form of attack by the Allies was on the ground.

    The main Allied attack against the Nazis was from the air. The Allies dropped 2.7 million tons of ordinance on Nazi Germany in 1.5 million sorties which is absolutely mind boggling. That is what massively helped the USSR as the Germans were short on supplies due to their factories being constantly bombed. If you read diaries from the German retreat in the East you will see that they were half starving and covered in lice. It's extremely hard to maintain a front in a cold area when your supply line can't provide the basics.

    The war would not have been over in 1945 if the Allies had chosen to let the Germans fight the USSR on their own. That is what many anti-Communists at the time wanted. Let the two belligerents destroy each other and then enter by ground to clean up the mess.

    Hollywood certainly overrates the Western front and D-day which shouldn't be a surprise. But it underestimates how much of Germany was destroyed from the air. The Germans would have built thousands more aircraft if not for Allied bombing attacks. A thousand more bombers at Kursk would have turned the tide in favor of the Germans. The attack was a poor decision by Hitler but it would have easily worked if they had a thousand additional bombers to soften up Soviet defenses. The Soviets had the stronger defensive position, knew the full German battleplans from Turing and yet they still had more casualties. If German factories were at full capacity then it would have been an Axis victory.

    Replies: @Derer

    The Allies dropped 2.7 million tons of ordinance on Nazi Germany in 1.5 million sorties which is absolutely mind boggling.

    Unfortunately, they were mostly killing civilians in the cities – technically a war crime including the treatment of millions of POW. American involvement in the WWII European arena is dated just 7 months before the war end (do not count Italian holidays)…and was mostly motivated by getting seat at the Yalta agreement and thus spoils of the war in Europe. Of course American school textbooks will not say that.

  426. @Mr. Hack
    @AnonfromTN


    – Can marriage of convenience be happy?
    – Yes, if convenience was determined correctly.
     
    You should know, Janissary. How long has it been now that you've decided to leave your first love, Mother Russia, and live with your new one, America? "Convenient", eh? Here you find your dream job, make way more money that you ever could in Russia, and are still able to badmouth America. What a duplicitous existence you live. :-(

    Replies: @QCIC, @Derer

    Go back to your cartoons. The USA needs all the good people it can get.

    • Thanks: Mr. Hack
    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @QCIC

    Coming from a true/blue fifth columnist, this is quite the compliment!

    Replies: @QCIC

  427. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    You are commingling auto in Mexico with other industries in Mexico
     
    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Fli4ZNLXoAQH5ZW.jpg

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GACSZMZXIAAb115.jpg

    Mexico has absorbed huge amounts of auto manufacturing FDI from the US since NAFTA in the '90s, but has yet to build a single globally competitive auto or auto supplier company.

    The FDI was just used to exploit Mexican labor, without any transfer of the US knowledge.

    1/5 new cars sold in Mexico = from China, and they aren't primarily Teslas or EVs.

    And port capacity is a constraint on China's export growth in Mexico as well:

    The port authorities in Michoacán announced that there weren’t enough trailers to remove the Chinese cars from their ships.

    Chinese firms producing in Mexico tho count as Mexican in my book. Location of actual work trumps ownership. But reliance on imported Chinese parts could be significant so worth looking at that.

    Chinese producers set up shop in Mexico and use a north american supply chain to supply the US market with enough North American content to qualify.

    China is producing more goods for consumption in Mexico; which frees up more Mexican production for US market.

    https://youtu.be/vvkBV9AwD0o?si=WgQriJjlRQsOljVc

    Replies: @QCIC, @A123, @Yahya

  428. @Hyperborean
    @Beckow


    US-UK finally joining the war in June 1944 with the Normandy landing was similar, a belated attempt to join in and mitigate the defeat of Germany.
     
    Ignoring the humilating Dieppe Raid of August 1942 as well as the successful landings at Sicily starting July 1943 that led to the further invasion of Italy, if we are purely counting army battles on European soil.

    I dislike the hazy Dunkirk to D-Day pop culture narrative that is prevalent, but there's no reason to say things that people can easily contradict.

    Replies: @Coconuts, @Beckow

    I dislike the hazy Dunkirk to D-Day pop culture narrative that is prevalent, but there’s no reason to say things that people can easily contradict.

    Beckow tends to make these strange statements about WW2.

    Imo it looks like claiming the Soviet victory as a great victory of humanity, but at the same time making it a statement of racial or ethnic supremacism.

    There is a Franco-Russian researcher who wrote about this type of phenomena, and how the treatment of Nazism particularly has been an inspiration for it:

    [MORE]

    I think this was translated into English back in the 1980s when it first came out, but hard to find.

    • Replies: @Hyperborean
    @Coconuts


    I think this was translated into English back in the 1980s when it first came out, but hard to find.
     
    The English translation seems to be available on Library Genesis.

    http://libgen.rs/book/index.php?md5=E91FFD4F4C65931CC5E3E8F2B4690D6F

    I'm lazy when it comes to improving my French, I really should work on it more. I can get by with newspapers or short articles, but when it comes to books I get frustrated at not being able to read as fast and easily as in English.

    Replies: @Coconuts

  429. @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Yep. Even CCP lines like COSCO are avoiding the Red Sea - Suez route. Do you notice the near absence of European involvement? France sent one ship. Is that it for the EU?

    Asian imports becoming slower and more expensive is good for domestic European suppliers. Keeping the canal closed and subsidizing Egypt/Greece for lost employment is a net win. You have to like decoupling when you see it.

    I wonder how long Xi will accept Khamenei's shut down.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Yep. Even Chinese lines like COSCO are avoiding the Red Sea – Suez route.

    Vessels transiting the Red Sea are using their signals to say they have links to China, the latest measure taken to avoid interdiction by Houthi militants in the Red Sea.

    Each of the ships is signaling “all Chinese crew” or something similar in a field that would normally contain its destination.

    The ship’s destinations show that their crew or the companies that own the carriers know that being affiliated with the Asian country avert interdiction. Ship destinations are normally entered manually by the crew and are then visible to almost anyone on the internet.

    https://finance.yahoo.com/news/ships-advertise-chinese-links-avoid-122921861.html

    https://www.reuters.com/business/chinas-cosco-halts-shipping-israel-israeli-media-2024-01-07/

    You have to like decoupling when you see it.

    • Replies: @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere


    Vessels transiting the Red Sea are using their signals to say they have links to China, the latest measure taken to avoid interdiction by Houthi militants in the Red Sea.

     


    Each of the ships is signaling “all Chinese crew” or something similar in a field that would normally contain its destination. Two are currently in the Red Sea, while two more have navigated the risky waterway and are now sailing to Asia.

     

    If this is happening, why are they not on the shipping map that you provided?

     
    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GDp0mNoWIAEaVcU.jpg
     

    The Red Sea looks pretty empty to me.
    ___

    If you read this article you can put 2+2 together, despite anti-Semitic Leftoid media burying the lede: (1)


    Orient Overseas Container Line (OOCL), which is a part of Cosco Shipping Group, has also suspended sailing to the Red Sea and stopped accepting Israel-bound cargo since December, citing operational issues.
     
    Parse that out carefully and you will grasp that OOCL/COSCO actually stated that they:

    Suspended all Red Sea transits
    • And, are not accepting Israeli bound cargo (via other routes)

    The latter is not much of an impediment. Cargo bound to Israel could easily be offloaded from the COSCO ship in Greece, or another port, thus completing the insurance slight of hand.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/chinas-largest-shipper-reportedly-suspends-trips-to-israel-as-red-sea-tensions-mount/ar-AA1mBJON

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

  430. @Mikel
    @John Johnson


    Do you deny that polls show Haley doing better against Biden?
     
    So, if polls showed Hillary Clinton doing better than Trump against Biden, should we nominate her the Republican candidate? How is Haley better than Biden for those who liked the MAGA-16 agenda: end forever wars, bring US troops back home, build the wall, deport the illegals, combat wokeness,...? Just because she's right of Biden on tax cuts?

    And if Dems should be so worried about Haley, why are many of them registering as Republicans and voting for her today in Iowa?

    Just like I find it hard to believe that Trump can beat Biden in November, I find it even harder to believe that there is a legitimate path for such a RINO as Haley to become the Republican nominee. That ship has sailed, the Republican party is not going back to where you'd like it. Millions of voters would rather vote for RFK or stay home, me and A123 included (for different reasons, I care about the policies and he cares about the man but we both represent very important parts of the current American electorate).


    The guy wanted to die.
     
    Just because he had some weird death wish (why, if not, would anyone stay in Ukraine after the Russian invasion and post videos against the Kiev regime? That could have costed him his life even before the start of the war) it doesn't mean that Kiev had to comply with his wish.

    Perhaps Billy Hayes, imprisoned and tortured in Turkey, or Charles Horman, killed by the Pinochet regime, also had weird death wishes and that's why they decided to travel to s-thole countries and "break their laws" but that doesn't mean that the authorities in those countries acted in a moral way.

    I never saw any of Lira's videos (certainly not in full) before he re-appeared from prison. I flagged him early on as somebody I wasn't going to get any valuable information from and ignored the creepy-looking and sounding guy. But I'm pretty sure that I have posted here and elsewhere content as objectionable to the Kiev goons as what he said in those videos that would also land me in jail, as have so many of the regulars here. In fact, long before this war started I received personal threats in English-language Ukrainian media from Ukrainians who couldn't stomach my views opposing the shelling of civilians in Donbass. The Sovok/goon mentality that I encountered in Kiev in the 90s is clearly alive and well still in Ukraine.

    I have obviously no intention of visiting Ukraine again, though I don't know why I should be afraid of visiting a country whose civil servants, including the thugs that would possibly arrest me, are receiving their salaries with money from my taxes. But someone telling me that the Ukrainians did nothing wrong in Lira's death is essentially telling me that they wouldn't give a hoot either if they learned that I had died in a filthy Ukrainian prison for posting what I am posting here. OK, fair enough, you don't know me personally so why should you care about my life more about Ukraine's sovereignty and all those high principles of yours? But then go fuck yourselves too. I can't have any respect at a personal level for people who make excuses for the death of a blogger in a country of goons. It could have been Lira or it could have been any of us here.

    Replies: @A123, @John Johnson

    Did you notice what I wrote earlier about my alignement to MAGA (not Trump)? (1)

    The commitment is to MAGA, not specifically to Trump. Opposition to GOP establishment RINO’s is locked in. Despite what the #NeverTrump zealots post here, Trump is by far the most electable MAGA nominee. In large part because he is the only authentic MAGA candidate.

    Regardless of what Leftoid polls seem to return, establishment RINO’s like DeSantis and Haley are actually unelectable. These Anti-MAGA shills would not be able to generate MAGA base turnout. Likely a MAGA candidate would appear via a 3rd party nomination to capture those votes. Anti-MAGA DeSantis could easily lose all 50 states, including Florida.

    Why did try to copy my position with your statement? Should I take your desire to imitate me as the sincerest form of flattery?

    Millions of voters would rather vote for RFK or stay home, me and A123 included (for different reasons, I care about the policies and he cares about the man but we both represent very important parts of the current American electorate).

    I care about MAGA policies. And, what you care about us exceedingly unclear. You:
        • Oppose MAGA by supporting anti-MAGA DeSantis
        • Claim to support MAGA while opposing MAGA Trump.

    If you actually care about MAGA — Have you considered building bridges back to the electable candidate Trump instead of sticking with the unelectable establishment shill DeSantis?

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇
    _____________________

    (1) https://www.unz.com/akarlin/open-thread-239/#comment-6364384

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    Trump: I thought Israelis would do anything for peace, but found that not to be true.


    In newly released interview excerpts, former United States president Donald Trump offered more startlingly frank views on Israel’s leadership during his time in office, a day after he was quoted in an astounding assault on ex-premier Benjamin Netanyahu.

    In the latest taped comments broadcast by Channel 12, Trump said he believed Netanyahu “did not want to make peace. Never did”; claimed he prevented the Israeli leader from annexing West Bank land (“I got angry and I stopped it”) and his evolving view on the Israel-Palestinian conflict (“I [had] thought the Palestinians were impossible, and the Israelis would do anything to make peace and a deal. I found that not to be true.

    Speaking to journalist Barak Ravid earlier this year for an upcoming book, the ex-president commented on his efforts to mediate between Jerusalem and Ramallah, and his feeling as time went on that Netanyahu wasn’t truly interested in reaching a settlement.

    Trump said that when he came into office, he’d asked Netanyahu for overtures toward the Palestinians, raising the possibility of a construction freeze in the West Bank, but the Israeli leader often demurred.

    “Bibi did not want to make a deal,” he said, using Netanyahu’s nickname. “Even most recently, when we came up with the maps” as part of his administration’s peace plan, Netanyahu’s reaction was “‘Oh this is good, good,’ everything was always great, but he was never… he did not want to make a deal.

    “Now I don’t know if he didn’t want to make it for political reasons, or for other reasons. I wish he would have said he didn’t want to make a deal, instead of…. Because a lot of people devoted a lot of work. But I don’t think Bibi would have ever made a deal. That’s my opinion. I think the general [Gantz] wanted to make a deal.”

    Trump said he believed that Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas “wanted to make a deal more than Netanyahu. And I will be honest, I had a great meeting with him, Abbas, right. I had a great meeting with him. And we spent a lot of time together, talking about many things. And it was almost like a father. I mean, he was so nice, couldn’t have been nicer.”

    Trump: I thought Israelis would do anything for peace, but found that not to be true.

    Trump recalled he then told Netanyahu that “I had a very good meeting with Abbas. We can definitely do a deal.” The Israeli leader’s response? “‘Well, let’s think about it. Let’s not move too fast, you know.’ After he started talking, I said, wait a minute, you don’t want to make a deal.

    “And he said, ‘Well, uh, uh, uh.’ And the fact is I don’t think Bibi ever wanted to make a deal.

    “I had thought the Palestinians were impossible, and the Israelis would do anything to make peace and a deal. I found that not to be true.”

    Despite Trump’s frustration with Netanyahu, he went on to recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and announce the relocation there of the American embassy, leading the Palestinians to break off ties with Washington.

    “I don’t think Bibi ever wanted to make peace,” Trump repeated. “I think he just tapped us along… ‘No, no, we want to, we want to’… But I think Bibi did not want to make peace. Never did.

    😇

    https://youtu.be/B-VLeqZkQcg?si=Ns7x0k4Gi9JOVIvS

    Replies: @A123, @Emil Nikola Richard

  431. @LT1488
    @Mr. Hack

    Slovaks are an odd case in Central Europe where many have pro-Russian opinions.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Derer, @AP

    It is a right choice for Slovakia…the West’s hate of Slavs make it easy. Actually, Polaks are odd case, despite their tourist buses in Western Europe are usually soil by eggs or tomatoes, they still cannot get the message.

    • Agree: LT1488
  432. @Mr. Hack
    @AnonfromTN


    – Can marriage of convenience be happy?
    – Yes, if convenience was determined correctly.
     
    You should know, Janissary. How long has it been now that you've decided to leave your first love, Mother Russia, and live with your new one, America? "Convenient", eh? Here you find your dream job, make way more money that you ever could in Russia, and are still able to badmouth America. What a duplicitous existence you live. :-(

    Replies: @QCIC, @Derer

    And what is your situation Mr.Hack?

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Derer

    Let me know first about your pedigree, land of birth, what Russian troll school you matriculated from and I'll be glad to reciprocate. Professor Janissary has been good enough to provide all of this information beforehand, you're a new "stooge" here, an unknown product, I don't know how much I want to expose to you?...

  433. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    Yep. Even Chinese lines like COSCO are avoiding the Red Sea – Suez route.
     
    Vessels transiting the Red Sea are using their signals to say they have links to China, the latest measure taken to avoid interdiction by Houthi militants in the Red Sea.

    Each of the ships is signaling “all Chinese crew” or something similar in a field that would normally contain its destination.

    The ship's destinations show that their crew or the companies that own the carriers know that being affiliated with the Asian country avert interdiction. Ship destinations are normally entered manually by the crew and are then visible to almost anyone on the internet.


    https://finance.yahoo.com/news/ships-advertise-chinese-links-avoid-122921861.html


    https://www.reuters.com/business/chinas-cosco-halts-shipping-israel-israeli-media-2024-01-07/


    You have to like decoupling when you see it.
     
    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GBDnfplXIAArIei.jpg

    Replies: @A123

    Vessels transiting the Red Sea are using their signals to say they have links to China, the latest measure taken to avoid interdiction by Houthi militants in the Red Sea.

    Each of the ships is signaling “all Chinese crew” or something similar in a field that would normally contain its destination. Two are currently in the Red Sea, while two more have navigated the risky waterway and are now sailing to Asia.

    If this is happening, why are they not on the shipping map that you provided?

      

    The Red Sea looks pretty empty to me.
    ___

    If you read this article you can put 2+2 together, despite anti-Semitic Leftoid media burying the lede: (1)

    Orient Overseas Container Line (OOCL), which is a part of Cosco Shipping Group, has also suspended sailing to the Red Sea and stopped accepting Israel-bound cargo since December, citing operational issues.

    Parse that out carefully and you will grasp that OOCL/COSCO actually stated that they:

    Suspended all Red Sea transits
    • And, are not accepting Israeli bound cargo (via other routes)

    The latter is not much of an impediment. Cargo bound to Israel could easily be offloaded from the COSCO ship in Greece, or another port, thus completing the insurance slight of hand.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/chinas-largest-shipper-reportedly-suspends-trips-to-israel-as-red-sea-tensions-mount/ar-AA1mBJON

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    I wonder how long Xi will support Khamenei’s sanctions
     


    https://twitter.com/MyLordBebo/status/1746910863125053813

    Replies: @A123

  434. @A123
    Let us start off the OT with Motorsports.

    The Dakar Rally (which does not visit Dakar) is under way kicking off 2024.

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Mi_HBDImFQw

    America's season will start next weekend, the 19th, with the "Roar Before the 24", introducing new GTD/GT3 cars for both Corvette and Ford Mustang. The full "24 Hours of Daytona" will take place on the 28th and 29th.

    PEACE 😇

     
    https://bloximages.newyork1.vip.townnews.com/midfloridanewspapers.com/content/tncms/assets/v3/editorial/1/dd/1ddb851a-aa5e-11ee-818f-371cf2542b17/65959a41ebae0.image.jpg

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Asian imports becoming slower and more expensive is good for domestic European suppliers.

    I don’t know who you’re trying to fool but I guess it’s people who have never shipped between Europe and China. Shipping time between Shanghai and Rotterdam maxes out at 4 weeks and routing away from Suez adds 1 week. Customs clearance is a day either way.

    Production lead time is of course determined by product but anything that takes 30 days to make in China expect to get quoted double or triple that to make in Europe. The Suez blockage mostly harms India where rerouting across the Cape of Good Hope adds a lot more cost and time relative to China.

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere


    I don’t know who you’re trying to fool ... routing away from Suez adds 1 week.
     
    I am not fooling anyone, and you just agreed with me. For Rotterdam it is 7-8 days additional transit. For Mediterranean ports the net delay is even larger, 11+ days for Greek and Adriatic delivery. Losing time transiting east in the Med is effectively a double penalty.

    I guess you do not understand the industries that use shipping between Europe and China. Having goods trapped an extra week and half has significant negative impact on supply chain management. The extra fuel burn and ship time also ramps up shipping cost.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

  435. Is there a soy parachute, if you are sitting on a plane too close to some bulkhead panel where the screws haven’t been properly torqued because of DIE?

  436. @Coconuts
    @Hyperborean


    I dislike the hazy Dunkirk to D-Day pop culture narrative that is prevalent, but there’s no reason to say things that people can easily contradict.
     
    Beckow tends to make these strange statements about WW2.

    Imo it looks like claiming the Soviet victory as a great victory of humanity, but at the same time making it a statement of racial or ethnic supremacism.

    There is a Franco-Russian researcher who wrote about this type of phenomena, and how the treatment of Nazism particularly has been an inspiration for it:



    https://www.amazon.co.uk/force-pr%C3%A9jug%C3%A9-Essai-racisme-doubles/dp/2070719774/ref=sr_1_1?crid=1PLGEKOJNQSCC&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.kvra4MuzTCnRTfEjMuTjQQ.bINUIvQsj4bA56iJLcZpceLOkcryI02PrrF8c2iHY5A&dib_tag=se&keywords=Pierre+Andre+Taguieff+La+Force+du+Prejuge&qid=1705346217&sprefix=pierre+andre+taguieff+la+force+du+prejuge%2Caps%2C102&sr=8-1

    I think this was translated into English back in the 1980s when it first came out, but hard to find.

    Replies: @Hyperborean

    I think this was translated into English back in the 1980s when it first came out, but hard to find.

    The English translation seems to be available on Library Genesis.

    http://libgen.rs/book/index.php?md5=E91FFD4F4C65931CC5E3E8F2B4690D6F

    I’m lazy when it comes to improving my French, I really should work on it more. I can get by with newspapers or short articles, but when it comes to books I get frustrated at not being able to read as fast and easily as in English.

    • Replies: @Coconuts
    @Hyperborean

    It's useful that it is on libgen and in English.

    It isn't the most scintillating read in the original but imo it is good for the exhaustive analysis of anti-racism and its potential political abuses, a lot of what is going on now with anti-racism in the Anglosphere seems to be predicted quite early on. I thought that that was not bad for a book written 35+ years ago.

    His argument about Nazism as a constant reference point is also interesting in the light of the kind of arguments made by Paul Gottfried etc. about the central importance of Anti-Fascism in politics and culture since 1945.

  437. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    https://youtu.be/21T5u9qtBlk?si=BkVajSDxVRHSspxC


    Asian imports becoming slower and more expensive is good for domestic European suppliers.
     
    I don't know who you're trying to fool but I guess it's people who have never shipped between Europe and China. Shipping time between Shanghai and Rotterdam maxes out at 4 weeks and routing away from Suez adds 1 week. Customs clearance is a day either way.

    Production lead time is of course determined by product but anything that takes 30 days to make in China expect to get quoted double or triple that to make in Europe. The Suez blockage mostly harms India where rerouting across the Cape of Good Hope adds a lot more cost and time relative to China.



    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F8iv4iOXwAIxpIL.jpg

    Replies: @A123

    I don’t know who you’re trying to fool … routing away from Suez adds 1 week.

    I am not fooling anyone, and you just agreed with me. For Rotterdam it is 7-8 days additional transit. For Mediterranean ports the net delay is even larger, 11+ days for Greek and Adriatic delivery. Losing time transiting east in the Med is effectively a double penalty.

    I guess you do not understand the industries that use shipping between Europe and China. Having goods trapped an extra week and half has significant negative impact on supply chain management. The extra fuel burn and ship time also ramps up shipping cost.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    I guess you do not understand the industries that use shipping between Israel and Asia. Having goods sanctioned has significant negative impact on israeli supply chain management. The extra fuel burn and ship time also ramps up shipping cost for those been sanctioned, not those supplying the goods.

    It's the right time to build this, so Chinese goods can resume their timely arrival.


    https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQ5W3mWShbG5OPa4w9jtOpifDXudOeWKmiIsw&usqp.jpg

    😇

    Replies: @A123

  438. @Derer
    @Mr. Hack

    And what is your situation Mr.Hack?

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    Let me know first about your pedigree, land of birth, what Russian troll school you matriculated from and I’ll be glad to reciprocate. Professor Janissary has been good enough to provide all of this information beforehand, you’re a new “stooge” here, an unknown product, I don’t know how much I want to expose to you?…

  439. @QCIC
    @Mr. Hack

    Go back to your cartoons. The USA needs all the good people it can get.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    Coming from a true/blue fifth columnist, this is quite the compliment!

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Mr. Hack

    I am a pro-human American.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

  440. @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere


    Vessels transiting the Red Sea are using their signals to say they have links to China, the latest measure taken to avoid interdiction by Houthi militants in the Red Sea.

     


    Each of the ships is signaling “all Chinese crew” or something similar in a field that would normally contain its destination. Two are currently in the Red Sea, while two more have navigated the risky waterway and are now sailing to Asia.

     

    If this is happening, why are they not on the shipping map that you provided?

     
    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GDp0mNoWIAEaVcU.jpg
     

    The Red Sea looks pretty empty to me.
    ___

    If you read this article you can put 2+2 together, despite anti-Semitic Leftoid media burying the lede: (1)


    Orient Overseas Container Line (OOCL), which is a part of Cosco Shipping Group, has also suspended sailing to the Red Sea and stopped accepting Israel-bound cargo since December, citing operational issues.
     
    Parse that out carefully and you will grasp that OOCL/COSCO actually stated that they:

    Suspended all Red Sea transits
    • And, are not accepting Israeli bound cargo (via other routes)

    The latter is not much of an impediment. Cargo bound to Israel could easily be offloaded from the COSCO ship in Greece, or another port, thus completing the insurance slight of hand.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/chinas-largest-shipper-reportedly-suspends-trips-to-israel-as-red-sea-tensions-mount/ar-AA1mBJON

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    I wonder how long Xi will support Khamenei’s sanctions

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    If you use block quotes, please try to be more precise. It also help if you thread to the correct post.

    What I actually stated was: (1)


    I wonder how long Xi will accept Khamenei’s shut down.
     
    Your post is non-responsive

    China calls for a lasting two state solution.
     
    Iranian backed Houthi are attacking vessels that have nothing to do with Israel. Let me re ask the question more explicitly.

    How long will Xi to tolerate Khamenei's Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.unz.com/akarlin/open-thread-239/#comment-6365449

  441. @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere


    I don’t know who you’re trying to fool ... routing away from Suez adds 1 week.
     
    I am not fooling anyone, and you just agreed with me. For Rotterdam it is 7-8 days additional transit. For Mediterranean ports the net delay is even larger, 11+ days for Greek and Adriatic delivery. Losing time transiting east in the Med is effectively a double penalty.

    I guess you do not understand the industries that use shipping between Europe and China. Having goods trapped an extra week and half has significant negative impact on supply chain management. The extra fuel burn and ship time also ramps up shipping cost.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    I guess you do not understand the industries that use shipping between Israel and Asia. Having goods sanctioned has significant negative impact on israeli supply chain management. The extra fuel burn and ship time also ramps up shipping cost for those been sanctioned, not those supplying the goods.

    It’s the right time to build this, so Chinese goods can resume their timely arrival.


    😇

    • Replies: @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere


    The extra fuel burn and ship time also ramps up shipping cost for those been sanctioned, not those supplying the goods.
     
    I guess that you do not understand the economics of supply and demand. Increasing intermediate expenses, like transportation, reduces willingness to buy.

    Given that the Red Sea is not being transited by large container vessels, "everyone" is is effectively sanctioned. This is a problem for all Asian suppliers, but it is particularly inconvenient for the more planned CCP economy, which is highly export dependent.


    It’s the right time to build this, so Chinese goods can resume their timely arrival.
     
    The map is politically interesting, but it calls for ship--train--ship. That is two additional lading cycles. It is not the craziest idea I have ever heard, however I find the value proposition dubious.

    One interesting idea for this was that the Indian Ocean leg would involve a new class of rail car carrier vessels. Track On Track Off [TOTO]. Sort of like RORO on steroids.

    PEACE 😇

  442. @Mr. Hack
    @QCIC

    Coming from a true/blue fifth columnist, this is quite the compliment!

    Replies: @QCIC

    I am a pro-human American.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @QCIC


    I am a pro-human American.
     
    That’s politically incorrect. From the point of view of Western elites, there are “good humans” and “bad humans”. E.g., Gonzalo Lira, who’s only “crime” was honesty, is “bad human”, whereas Netanyahu and Ukrainian clown-in-chief, who are both thieves and have a lot of blood on their hands, are “good humans”, or at least “our sons of bitches”, like Nicaraguan criminal Somoza.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  443. Interview with Arestovych:
    https://unherd.com/2024/01/oleksiy-arestovych-zelenskyys-challenger/

    Quite interesting in parts. But also strange.

    • Replies: @songbird
    @German_reader

    Guess it is a political impossibility from a regime standpoint, but , IMO, it is a pity that something like Srinivasan's blockchain voting doesn't exist for Ukraine, where war sentiment could be tested, weighed, and aired.

    Have a feeling that most people wouldn't have these unrealistic views of 10-15 years more war, and possibly take back Crimea in 5-10 or so.

    Replies: @German_reader

  444. @A123
    @Mikel

    Did you notice what I wrote earlier about my alignement to MAGA (not Trump)? (1)


    The commitment is to MAGA, not specifically to Trump. Opposition to GOP establishment RINO’s is locked in. Despite what the #NeverTrump zealots post here, Trump is by far the most electable MAGA nominee. In large part because he is the only authentic MAGA candidate.

    Regardless of what Leftoid polls seem to return, establishment RINO’s like DeSantis and Haley are actually unelectable. These Anti-MAGA shills would not be able to generate MAGA base turnout. Likely a MAGA candidate would appear via a 3rd party nomination to capture those votes. Anti-MAGA DeSantis could easily lose all 50 states, including Florida.

     

    Why did try to copy my position with your statement? Should I take your desire to imitate me as the sincerest form of flattery?

    Millions of voters would rather vote for RFK or stay home, me and A123 included (for different reasons, I care about the policies and he cares about the man but we both represent very important parts of the current American electorate).

     

    I care about MAGA policies. And, what you care about us exceedingly unclear. You:
        • Oppose MAGA by supporting anti-MAGA DeSantis
        • Claim to support MAGA while opposing MAGA Trump.

    If you actually care about MAGA -- Have you considered building bridges back to the electable candidate Trump instead of sticking with the unelectable establishment shill DeSantis?

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇
    _____________________

    (1) https://www.unz.com/akarlin/open-thread-239/#comment-6364384

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Trump: I thought Israelis would do anything for peace, but found that not to be true.

    In newly released interview excerpts, former United States president Donald Trump offered more startlingly frank views on Israel’s leadership during his time in office, a day after he was quoted in an astounding assault on ex-premier Benjamin Netanyahu.

    In the latest taped comments broadcast by Channel 12, Trump said he believed Netanyahu “did not want to make peace. Never did”; claimed he prevented the Israeli leader from annexing West Bank land (“I got angry and I stopped it”) and his evolving view on the Israel-Palestinian conflict (“I [had] thought the Palestinians were impossible, and the Israelis would do anything to make peace and a deal. I found that not to be true.

    Speaking to journalist Barak Ravid earlier this year for an upcoming book, the ex-president commented on his efforts to mediate between Jerusalem and Ramallah, and his feeling as time went on that Netanyahu wasn’t truly interested in reaching a settlement.

    Trump said that when he came into office, he’d asked Netanyahu for overtures toward the Palestinians, raising the possibility of a construction freeze in the West Bank, but the Israeli leader often demurred.

    “Bibi did not want to make a deal,” he said, using Netanyahu’s nickname. “Even most recently, when we came up with the maps” as part of his administration’s peace plan, Netanyahu’s reaction was “‘Oh this is good, good,’ everything was always great, but he was never… he did not want to make a deal.

    “Now I don’t know if he didn’t want to make it for political reasons, or for other reasons. I wish he would have said he didn’t want to make a deal, instead of…. Because a lot of people devoted a lot of work. But I don’t think Bibi would have ever made a deal. That’s my opinion. I think the general [Gantz] wanted to make a deal.”

    Trump said he believed that Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas “wanted to make a deal more than Netanyahu. And I will be honest, I had a great meeting with him, Abbas, right. I had a great meeting with him. And we spent a lot of time together, talking about many things. And it was almost like a father. I mean, he was so nice, couldn’t have been nicer.”

    Trump: I thought Israelis would do anything for peace, but found that not to be true.

    Trump recalled he then told Netanyahu that “I had a very good meeting with Abbas. We can definitely do a deal.” The Israeli leader’s response? “‘Well, let’s think about it. Let’s not move too fast, you know.’ After he started talking, I said, wait a minute, you don’t want to make a deal.

    “And he said, ‘Well, uh, uh, uh.’ And the fact is I don’t think Bibi ever wanted to make a deal.

    “I had thought the Palestinians were impossible, and the Israelis would do anything to make peace and a deal. I found that not to be true.”

    Despite Trump’s frustration with Netanyahu, he went on to recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and announce the relocation there of the American embassy, leading the Palestinians to break off ties with Washington.

    “I don’t think Bibi ever wanted to make peace,” Trump repeated. “I think he just tapped us along… ‘No, no, we want to, we want to’… But I think Bibi did not want to make peace. Never did.

    😇

    • Replies: @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Citation please.

    Also, one transcript on one day of one conversation may not be a reliable indication of overall policy. Have you ever spend a couple of days angry with someone, and then fixed it later when emotions had cooled?

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    , @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Complete B.S. like everything Donald the Fat offers.

    https://bostonglobe-prod.cdn.arcpublishing.com/resizer/AntZ7EnkWP-0gvq-Jmy9h4LllOM=/960x0/arc-anglerfish-arc2-prod-bostonglobe.s3.amazonaws.com/public/QAMYHDB66II6PI7W3BZZV22WQQ.jpg

    Replies: @QCIC

  445. @QCIC
    @Mr. Hack

    I am a pro-human American.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    I am a pro-human American.

    That’s politically incorrect. From the point of view of Western elites, there are “good humans” and “bad humans”. E.g., Gonzalo Lira, who’s only “crime” was honesty, is “bad human”, whereas Netanyahu and Ukrainian clown-in-chief, who are both thieves and have a lot of blood on their hands, are “good humans”, or at least “our sons of bitches”, like Nicaraguan criminal Somoza.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @AnonfromTN

    That’s politically incorrect. From the point of view of Western elites, there are “good humans” and “bad humans”. E.g., Gonzalo Lira, who’s only “crime” was honesty

    If Lira was an honest person then why did he scrub practically all of his videos?

    Where are his criticisms of Ukraine?

    This Lira case stinks to high heaven. Duran or Ritter would be able to point to a long list of videos that could aggravate Ukrainian authorities. But Lira? Where are the videos or articles?

    He wanted to get arrested more than he wanted to get a message out. He also most likely scrubbed his earlier "Ukraine is doomed" rants because he was wrong in predicting a quick Russian victory. Supposedly he also ranted about how Russia would never attack.

    Attention seeking behavior from a "red pill coach" fraudster. I don't buy his act for one second. He was never on par with professional Putin shills like Duran or Ritter. He wanted the attention but didn't have the message. Alt-right is desperate for heroes if they rally around a Chilean chain smoker who didn't have a coherent message. He never contacted the state department which tells me his condition was terminal and there was no point in doing it.

    Replies: @QCIC

  446. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    I guess you do not understand the industries that use shipping between Israel and Asia. Having goods sanctioned has significant negative impact on israeli supply chain management. The extra fuel burn and ship time also ramps up shipping cost for those been sanctioned, not those supplying the goods.

    It's the right time to build this, so Chinese goods can resume their timely arrival.


    https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQ5W3mWShbG5OPa4w9jtOpifDXudOeWKmiIsw&usqp.jpg

    😇

    Replies: @A123

    The extra fuel burn and ship time also ramps up shipping cost for those been sanctioned, not those supplying the goods.

    I guess that you do not understand the economics of supply and demand. Increasing intermediate expenses, like transportation, reduces willingness to buy.

    Given that the Red Sea is not being transited by large container vessels, “everyone” is is effectively sanctioned. This is a problem for all Asian suppliers, but it is particularly inconvenient for the more planned CCP economy, which is highly export dependent.

    It’s the right time to build this, so Chinese goods can resume their timely arrival.

    The map is politically interesting, but it calls for ship–train–ship. That is two additional lading cycles. It is not the craziest idea I have ever heard, however I find the value proposition dubious.

    One interesting idea for this was that the Indian Ocean leg would involve a new class of rail car carrier vessels. Track On Track Off [TOTO]. Sort of like RORO on steroids.

    PEACE 😇

  447. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    Trump: I thought Israelis would do anything for peace, but found that not to be true.


    In newly released interview excerpts, former United States president Donald Trump offered more startlingly frank views on Israel’s leadership during his time in office, a day after he was quoted in an astounding assault on ex-premier Benjamin Netanyahu.

    In the latest taped comments broadcast by Channel 12, Trump said he believed Netanyahu “did not want to make peace. Never did”; claimed he prevented the Israeli leader from annexing West Bank land (“I got angry and I stopped it”) and his evolving view on the Israel-Palestinian conflict (“I [had] thought the Palestinians were impossible, and the Israelis would do anything to make peace and a deal. I found that not to be true.

    Speaking to journalist Barak Ravid earlier this year for an upcoming book, the ex-president commented on his efforts to mediate between Jerusalem and Ramallah, and his feeling as time went on that Netanyahu wasn’t truly interested in reaching a settlement.

    Trump said that when he came into office, he’d asked Netanyahu for overtures toward the Palestinians, raising the possibility of a construction freeze in the West Bank, but the Israeli leader often demurred.

    “Bibi did not want to make a deal,” he said, using Netanyahu’s nickname. “Even most recently, when we came up with the maps” as part of his administration’s peace plan, Netanyahu’s reaction was “‘Oh this is good, good,’ everything was always great, but he was never… he did not want to make a deal.

    “Now I don’t know if he didn’t want to make it for political reasons, or for other reasons. I wish he would have said he didn’t want to make a deal, instead of…. Because a lot of people devoted a lot of work. But I don’t think Bibi would have ever made a deal. That’s my opinion. I think the general [Gantz] wanted to make a deal.”

    Trump said he believed that Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas “wanted to make a deal more than Netanyahu. And I will be honest, I had a great meeting with him, Abbas, right. I had a great meeting with him. And we spent a lot of time together, talking about many things. And it was almost like a father. I mean, he was so nice, couldn’t have been nicer.”

    Trump: I thought Israelis would do anything for peace, but found that not to be true.

    Trump recalled he then told Netanyahu that “I had a very good meeting with Abbas. We can definitely do a deal.” The Israeli leader’s response? “‘Well, let’s think about it. Let’s not move too fast, you know.’ After he started talking, I said, wait a minute, you don’t want to make a deal.

    “And he said, ‘Well, uh, uh, uh.’ And the fact is I don’t think Bibi ever wanted to make a deal.

    “I had thought the Palestinians were impossible, and the Israelis would do anything to make peace and a deal. I found that not to be true.”

    Despite Trump’s frustration with Netanyahu, he went on to recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and announce the relocation there of the American embassy, leading the Palestinians to break off ties with Washington.

    “I don’t think Bibi ever wanted to make peace,” Trump repeated. “I think he just tapped us along… ‘No, no, we want to, we want to’… But I think Bibi did not want to make peace. Never did.

    😇

    https://youtu.be/B-VLeqZkQcg?si=Ns7x0k4Gi9JOVIvS

    Replies: @A123, @Emil Nikola Richard

    Citation please.

    Also, one transcript on one day of one conversation may not be a reliable indication of overall policy. Have you ever spend a couple of days angry with someone, and then fixed it later when emotions had cooled?

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    Citation please.
     
    https://www.timesofisrael.com/trump-i-thought-israelis-would-do-anything-for-peace-but-found-that-not-to-be-true/

    😇
  448. @Mikel
    @John Johnson


    Do you deny that polls show Haley doing better against Biden?
     
    So, if polls showed Hillary Clinton doing better than Trump against Biden, should we nominate her the Republican candidate? How is Haley better than Biden for those who liked the MAGA-16 agenda: end forever wars, bring US troops back home, build the wall, deport the illegals, combat wokeness,...? Just because she's right of Biden on tax cuts?

    And if Dems should be so worried about Haley, why are many of them registering as Republicans and voting for her today in Iowa?

    Just like I find it hard to believe that Trump can beat Biden in November, I find it even harder to believe that there is a legitimate path for such a RINO as Haley to become the Republican nominee. That ship has sailed, the Republican party is not going back to where you'd like it. Millions of voters would rather vote for RFK or stay home, me and A123 included (for different reasons, I care about the policies and he cares about the man but we both represent very important parts of the current American electorate).


    The guy wanted to die.
     
    Just because he had some weird death wish (why, if not, would anyone stay in Ukraine after the Russian invasion and post videos against the Kiev regime? That could have costed him his life even before the start of the war) it doesn't mean that Kiev had to comply with his wish.

    Perhaps Billy Hayes, imprisoned and tortured in Turkey, or Charles Horman, killed by the Pinochet regime, also had weird death wishes and that's why they decided to travel to s-thole countries and "break their laws" but that doesn't mean that the authorities in those countries acted in a moral way.

    I never saw any of Lira's videos (certainly not in full) before he re-appeared from prison. I flagged him early on as somebody I wasn't going to get any valuable information from and ignored the creepy-looking and sounding guy. But I'm pretty sure that I have posted here and elsewhere content as objectionable to the Kiev goons as what he said in those videos that would also land me in jail, as have so many of the regulars here. In fact, long before this war started I received personal threats in English-language Ukrainian media from Ukrainians who couldn't stomach my views opposing the shelling of civilians in Donbass. The Sovok/goon mentality that I encountered in Kiev in the 90s is clearly alive and well still in Ukraine.

    I have obviously no intention of visiting Ukraine again, though I don't know why I should be afraid of visiting a country whose civil servants, including the thugs that would possibly arrest me, are receiving their salaries with money from my taxes. But someone telling me that the Ukrainians did nothing wrong in Lira's death is essentially telling me that they wouldn't give a hoot either if they learned that I had died in a filthy Ukrainian prison for posting what I am posting here. OK, fair enough, you don't know me personally so why should you care about my life more about Ukraine's sovereignty and all those high principles of yours? But then go fuck yourselves too. I can't have any respect at a personal level for people who make excuses for the death of a blogger in a country of goons. It could have been Lira or it could have been any of us here.

    Replies: @A123, @John Johnson

    Do you deny that polls show Haley doing better against Biden?

    So, if polls showed Hillary Clinton doing better than Trump against Biden, should we nominate her the Republican candidate?

    I’m asking a question based on what the polls show.

    Clinton is a Democrat and not in the race. She would have to primary Biden.

    How is Haley better than Biden for those who liked the MAGA-16 agenda: end forever wars, bring US troops back home, build the wall, deport the illegals, combat wokeness,…?

    Haley does not have an incredibly dangerous and incompetent VP that could become president at any moment. I also do not believe that Haley would be the same as Biden on immigration. Biden is clearly in the camp of flooding the country with illegals to create new generations of Democrat voters. Such demographic changes don’t favor the Republicans.

    I also fail to see why anyone would expect Trump to govern much differently than any mainstream Republican. He had a chance to lock down the border with Schumer’s offer and turned it down. Trump was good in some ways but on most issues was a mainstream. Quite a disappointment in that regard. If you look past his rhetoric and focus on actual policy he was mostly a servant to the party.

    [MORE]

    I find it even harder to believe that there is a legitimate path for such a RINO as Haley to become the Republican nominee.

    Desantis quits and unites not-Trump voters. Trump is barred from politics by a judge. Haley continues to gain against Trump. There are numerous possibilities.

    That ship has sailed, the Republican party is not going back to where you’d like it.

    I’ve never once stated that I have any faith in the Republican party to do anything. I would like Biden out more than I want Trump elected and the polls suggest that Haley is the best path.

    But someone telling me that the Ukrainians did nothing wrong in Lira’s death

    I never said that and I don’t think anyone is clear on what exactly happened.

    I wouldn’t trust the authorities in any Slavic country. Pissing anyone off in power East of Poland is a bad idea. I support Ukraine but I don’t view them as a Western country. They inherited an attitude of corruption from the Soviet era and they only rank barely above Russia by international organizations in that regard.

    Most Western countries pass anti-propaganda laws in times of war where their autonomy is threatened. I don’t think they are the answer. Lira should have been invited to a live debate on Ukrainian television. He of course would have turned it down but it would have undermined the confidence of his fans.

    As for Lira it appears that he never contacted the state department. The conservative media that is defending him is not making that point. All evidence suggests that Lira wanted to be a martyr. His fans still haven’t provided me with a single essay related to Russia since 2020. They view him as a hero journalist and yet don’t have a single article.

  449. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    I wonder how long Xi will support Khamenei’s sanctions
     


    https://twitter.com/MyLordBebo/status/1746910863125053813

    Replies: @A123

    If you use block quotes, please try to be more precise. It also help if you thread to the correct post.

    What I actually stated was: (1)

    I wonder how long Xi will accept Khamenei’s shut down.

    Your post is non-responsive

    China calls for a lasting two state solution.

    Iranian backed Houthi are attacking vessels that have nothing to do with Israel. Let me re ask the question more explicitly.

    How long will Xi to tolerate Khamenei’s Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.unz.com/akarlin/open-thread-239/#comment-6365449

  450. @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Citation please.

    Also, one transcript on one day of one conversation may not be a reliable indication of overall policy. Have you ever spend a couple of days angry with someone, and then fixed it later when emotions had cooled?

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    • Thanks: A123
  451. @LT1488
    @Mr. Hack

    Slovaks are an odd case in Central Europe where many have pro-Russian opinions.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Derer, @AP

    They are a little bit like Central Europe’s analogue to Belarusians. Except their “Russia” is Hungary.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    It's quite interesting that throughout history Slovaks have served as the younger brothers to both the Hungarians and the Czechs. They served as the younger brothers to the Hungarians for much, much longer, but Czech rule was probably better for them than Hungarian rule, at least so long as the Czechs actually had a foreign protector behind themselves and the Slovaks (they didn't in 1938-1939). I don't seem to recall Czechia trying to forcibly Czechify the Slovaks like Hungary did with the Slovaks with its decades-long pre-WWI Magyarization campaign:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magyarization

    I do suspect that, out of Greater Hungary's large subject peoples, the Slovaks were probably the easiest ones to successfully Magyarize had Hungary had even more time to do so:

    https://preview.redd.it/9z2zzo6am2r71.png?width=640&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=097af65f11c92335d05889c085d6e243b595125b

    Slovaks, after all, are mostly Catholic just like Hungarians (Magyars) themselves are. Ruthenians (Ukrainians), Romanians, Serbs, and Croats are not Catholic.

    (Hungarian Jews were, of course, largely successfully Magyarized, but they are a much smaller group and their high average IQ and large amounts of success made them stand out from the Magyars and thus often made Magyars unwilling to accept them as their own even when these Jews themselves were indeed willing to be Magyarized. In contrast, AFAIK, Slovaks and Hungarians (Magyars) have a roughly equal average IQ, so there's no superiority/inferiority complex going on between them in regards to each other, at least in regards to their mental abilities.)

    BTW, it would be cool if Hungary, Slovakia, and Croatia formed a Greater Hungary within the EU (a confederation within a confederation) while Czechia, Austria, and Slovenia formed a Greater Austria within the EU (another confederation within a confederation).

    Replies: @Derer, @WS, @AP, @Beckow

  452. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    Trump: I thought Israelis would do anything for peace, but found that not to be true.


    In newly released interview excerpts, former United States president Donald Trump offered more startlingly frank views on Israel’s leadership during his time in office, a day after he was quoted in an astounding assault on ex-premier Benjamin Netanyahu.

    In the latest taped comments broadcast by Channel 12, Trump said he believed Netanyahu “did not want to make peace. Never did”; claimed he prevented the Israeli leader from annexing West Bank land (“I got angry and I stopped it”) and his evolving view on the Israel-Palestinian conflict (“I [had] thought the Palestinians were impossible, and the Israelis would do anything to make peace and a deal. I found that not to be true.

    Speaking to journalist Barak Ravid earlier this year for an upcoming book, the ex-president commented on his efforts to mediate between Jerusalem and Ramallah, and his feeling as time went on that Netanyahu wasn’t truly interested in reaching a settlement.

    Trump said that when he came into office, he’d asked Netanyahu for overtures toward the Palestinians, raising the possibility of a construction freeze in the West Bank, but the Israeli leader often demurred.

    “Bibi did not want to make a deal,” he said, using Netanyahu’s nickname. “Even most recently, when we came up with the maps” as part of his administration’s peace plan, Netanyahu’s reaction was “‘Oh this is good, good,’ everything was always great, but he was never… he did not want to make a deal.

    “Now I don’t know if he didn’t want to make it for political reasons, or for other reasons. I wish he would have said he didn’t want to make a deal, instead of…. Because a lot of people devoted a lot of work. But I don’t think Bibi would have ever made a deal. That’s my opinion. I think the general [Gantz] wanted to make a deal.”

    Trump said he believed that Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas “wanted to make a deal more than Netanyahu. And I will be honest, I had a great meeting with him, Abbas, right. I had a great meeting with him. And we spent a lot of time together, talking about many things. And it was almost like a father. I mean, he was so nice, couldn’t have been nicer.”

    Trump: I thought Israelis would do anything for peace, but found that not to be true.

    Trump recalled he then told Netanyahu that “I had a very good meeting with Abbas. We can definitely do a deal.” The Israeli leader’s response? “‘Well, let’s think about it. Let’s not move too fast, you know.’ After he started talking, I said, wait a minute, you don’t want to make a deal.

    “And he said, ‘Well, uh, uh, uh.’ And the fact is I don’t think Bibi ever wanted to make a deal.

    “I had thought the Palestinians were impossible, and the Israelis would do anything to make peace and a deal. I found that not to be true.”

    Despite Trump’s frustration with Netanyahu, he went on to recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and announce the relocation there of the American embassy, leading the Palestinians to break off ties with Washington.

    “I don’t think Bibi ever wanted to make peace,” Trump repeated. “I think he just tapped us along… ‘No, no, we want to, we want to’… But I think Bibi did not want to make peace. Never did.

    😇

    https://youtu.be/B-VLeqZkQcg?si=Ns7x0k4Gi9JOVIvS

    Replies: @A123, @Emil Nikola Richard

    Complete B.S. like everything Donald the Fat offers.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Don't cross the streams!

  453. @AnonfromTN
    @QCIC


    I am a pro-human American.
     
    That’s politically incorrect. From the point of view of Western elites, there are “good humans” and “bad humans”. E.g., Gonzalo Lira, who’s only “crime” was honesty, is “bad human”, whereas Netanyahu and Ukrainian clown-in-chief, who are both thieves and have a lot of blood on their hands, are “good humans”, or at least “our sons of bitches”, like Nicaraguan criminal Somoza.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    That’s politically incorrect. From the point of view of Western elites, there are “good humans” and “bad humans”. E.g., Gonzalo Lira, who’s only “crime” was honesty

    If Lira was an honest person then why did he scrub practically all of his videos?

    Where are his criticisms of Ukraine?

    This Lira case stinks to high heaven. Duran or Ritter would be able to point to a long list of videos that could aggravate Ukrainian authorities. But Lira? Where are the videos or articles?

    He wanted to get arrested more than he wanted to get a message out. He also most likely scrubbed his earlier “Ukraine is doomed” rants because he was wrong in predicting a quick Russian victory. Supposedly he also ranted about how Russia would never attack.

    Attention seeking behavior from a “red pill coach” fraudster. I don’t buy his act for one second. He was never on par with professional Putin shills like Duran or Ritter. He wanted the attention but didn’t have the message. Alt-right is desperate for heroes if they rally around a Chilean chain smoker who didn’t have a coherent message. He never contacted the state department which tells me his condition was terminal and there was no point in doing it.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    We may never know Lira's full story. Whatever his motives he may have supported the side that is against WW3.

    On the other hand, there is good evidence that Zelensky is a Jewish actor pretending to be a president. In this role his main function is to get as many Slavs killed as possible.

    Replies: @Matra

  454. @A123
    😆 Some headlines are better than others: (1) 😀

    GOP Field Thins as Chris Christie Drops Out Ahead of Iowa Caucuses
     
    Of course there is always the master: (2)

    Chris Christie Suspends Campaign To Spend More Time With Family-Sized 12-Piece Chicken Meal From KFC
    ___

    The beloved former governor and folk hero then got into his large SUV with his family-sized 12-piece chicken meal from KFC and closed the tinted windows for privacy.

    At publishing time, Christie had also been seen spending quality time with his family-sized box of Oreos from Costco.
     
    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.breitbart.com/2024-election/2024/01/10/gop-field-thins-as-chris-christie-drops-out-ahead-of-iowa-caucuses/

    (2) https://babylonbee.com/news/chris-christie-suspends-campaign-to-spend-more-time-with-family-sized-12-piece-chicken-meal-from-kfc

    Replies: @songbird, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Ansar Allah are sanctioning vessels that have nothing to do with Israel.

    You’re technically correct, they are actually sanctioning the Zionist Entity.

    How long will Xi support Ansar Allah interrupting Zionist Entity commerce?

    [MORE]

    😇

    • Replies: @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    What are you quoting?

    You need to include attribution with block quotes. None of the above are anything I ever said.
    ____

    Here is my exact question that you ducked: (1)


    How long will Xi to tolerate Khamenei’s Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?
     
    Your posts continue to be non-responsive. 95%+ of container traffic through the Suez has ceased due to fear of Houthi attacks. Your own graphic showed zero vessels in the Red Sea. Khamenei's proxies have far exceeded theoretical sanctions on indigenous Palestinian Jews.

    Your Xi quote has nothing to do with*all* OOCL/COSCO container shipping routing away from the Red Sea/Suez Canal. Let me re-re-ask the question:

    How long will Xi to tolerate Khamenei’s Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?

    Try to answer directly this time, instead of using non-responsive content about unrelated issues.

    PEACE 😇
    ___________

    (1) https://www.unz.com/akarlin/open-thread-239/#comment-6365734

  455. @A123
    @Beckow

    The quiescence of Kiev aggression will open up bandwidth to talk about other things.

    For example, we have a full fledged U.S. election year to go. To be followed by 4 years of Trump's 2nd Term. Given how much the #NeverTrump zealots hate MAGA/Trump, that will generate significant content.

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇

    Replies: @Beckow, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    I guess that you do not understand the economics of supply and demand. Increasing intermediate expenses, like transportation, reduces the Zionist Entity’s ability to buy.

    Given that the Red Sea is not being transited by sanctioned container vessels, “israel” is is effectively sanctioned. This is a problem Asian suppliers who are to closely aligned with the Zionist Entity, but it is particularly inconvenient for the “israeli” economy, which is highly import dependent.

    😇

    • LOL: A123
  456. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    Ansar Allah are sanctioning vessels that have nothing to do with Israel.

     

    You're technically correct, they are actually sanctioning the Zionist Entity.

    How long will Xi support Ansar Allah interrupting Zionist Entity commerce?
     

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F7-tHFvbQAAvG9M.jpg


    😇

    Replies: @A123

    What are you quoting?

    You need to include attribution with block quotes. None of the above are anything I ever said.
    ____

    Here is my exact question that you ducked: (1)

    How long will Xi to tolerate Khamenei’s Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?

    Your posts continue to be non-responsive. 95%+ of container traffic through the Suez has ceased due to fear of Houthi attacks. Your own graphic showed zero vessels in the Red Sea. Khamenei’s proxies have far exceeded theoretical sanctions on indigenous Palestinian Jews.

    Your Xi quote has nothing to do with*all* OOCL/COSCO container shipping routing away from the Red Sea/Suez Canal. Let me re-re-ask the question:

    How long will Xi to tolerate Khamenei’s Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?

    Try to answer directly this time, instead of using non-responsive content about unrelated issues.

    PEACE 😇
    ___________

    (1) https://www.unz.com/akarlin/open-thread-239/#comment-6365734

  457. @A123
    @Beckow


    The drama with Trump will be this year. If he gets into the office – I am skeptical – everything will change.
     
    This goes back to the discussions I have had with Mikel. Expectations have to be reasonable. There will be "some positive change" not "everything will change".

    In his 1st term -- House, Senate, Judiciary, and deep state were all in opposition to MAGA. Trump's 2nd term should feature more MAGA support from the House and Senate, which will correspondingly yield more appropriations and better confirmations. However, it will still be short of Mikel's impossible standard, 100% of absolutely everything! Instantly!

    Trump has spent the last 4 years building up what Barbarosa refers to as Soft Power. RINO's have been primaried and driven from office, notably the reprehensible Liz Cheney. Endorsements, rallies, and fund raisers give Trump favours to call in on critical votes.

    It took decades to dig the SJW Islamophile Globalist hole America is in. It will take a comparable amount of time to recover. Trump's 2nd term is only one step on the MAGA road. Key will be finding a successor (who may not be the VP). Kari Lake perhaps?

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    You claim what Ansarullah are doing in the Red Sea is separate from the situation in Gaza, and your reasoning?

    Both Hizbullah’s and Ansarullah’s military campaigns are in support of Palestine.

    How long will Xi support Ansar Allah interrupting Zionist Entity commerce?

    Chinese proverb

    [MORE]

    A single child’s life is worth more than all the cargo that goes through the Bab al-Mandab Strait.

    😇

    • Replies: @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere


    You claim what Ansarullah are doing in the Red Sea is separate from the situation in Gaza, and your reasoning?
     
    I am stating that vessels with no connection to Gaza and Palestinian Jews are rerouting to avoid the Houthi threat. This is objectively true. Even your own source shows no container vessels in the Red Sea.

    The Iranian Houthi "sanctions" as you call them are impacting everyone. They are not exclusive to legal commerce with indigenous Palestinian Jews. Your tweet has nothing to do with*all* OOCL/COSCO container shipping routing away from the Red Sea/Suez Canal.

    Everyone notices that you are in a complete panic, repeatedly and frantically ducking the question in a desperate attempt to escape. Let me re-re-re-ask it.

    How long will Xi tolerate Khamenei’s Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?

    Please try not to be wildly and obviously evasive again.

    PEACE 😇
  458. @Wokechoke
    @QCIC

    A good argument for Reagan or Trump. Both instill something like Gaelic clan loyalty from whites which is the backbone of the State. They raise armies. Whatever virtues Carter had or Bush I or Obama have, and we can argue those virtues, Reagan was beloved by Whitey. Trump was beloved by Whitey. Had there been an epic international fight with China or the USSR Reagan would have been Chief with gusto. Whatever his limitations were. Same with Trump. What got Trump was an internal nigger revolt backed by jews and sections of the Intelligence apparatus.

    It's the mystery of Command.


    Biden cannot really command loyalty from 200,000,000 whites in a war with a host like China or Russia could field. Even the great and the good of the establishment knows this now.

    Replies: @sudden death

    Was FDR beloved by Whitey too?;)

  459. @German_reader
    Interview with Arestovych:
    https://unherd.com/2024/01/oleksiy-arestovych-zelenskyys-challenger/

    Quite interesting in parts. But also strange.

    Replies: @songbird

    Guess it is a political impossibility from a regime standpoint, but , IMO, it is a pity that something like Srinivasan’s blockchain voting doesn’t exist for Ukraine, where war sentiment could be tested, weighed, and aired.

    Have a feeling that most people wouldn’t have these unrealistic views of 10-15 years more war, and possibly take back Crimea in 5-10 or so.

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @songbird


    Have a feeling that most people wouldn’t have these unrealistic views of 10-15 years more war, and possibly take back Crimea in 5-10 or so.
     
    He says things like that (pretty crazy imo...and what does he mean when he says that the war won't stay limited to Ukraine and Russia?), but then he also says that there ought to be a grand settlement to create a new collective security system, with acknowledgement of Russian views. Or his critical comments about Ukrainian nationalism ("only 20% believe in it"). I really wonder what this guy is about. And wtf is the deal with the criminal charges against him..."they made up that I hate women"???
    He also seems to confirm that there was a real chance of a negotiated end to the war in spring 2022, and that news of the atrocities in Bucha somehow played a role in stopping that process (iirc Israel's Naftali Bennett also implied something like that). If true, what a disaster that this chance was missed.

    Replies: @sudden death, @Mr. XYZ, @songbird

  460. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    You claim what Ansarullah are doing in the Red Sea is separate from the situation in Gaza, and your reasoning?

    Both Hizbullah's and Ansarullah's military campaigns are in support of Palestine.


    How long will Xi support Ansar Allah interrupting Zionist Entity commerce?
     
    Chinese proverb

    A single child’s life is worth more than all the cargo that goes through the Bab al-Mandab Strait.


    https://twitter.com/Aldanmarki/status/1746180754713846023


    😇

    Replies: @A123

    You claim what Ansarullah are doing in the Red Sea is separate from the situation in Gaza, and your reasoning?

    I am stating that vessels with no connection to Gaza and Palestinian Jews are rerouting to avoid the Houthi threat. This is objectively true. Even your own source shows no container vessels in the Red Sea.

    The Iranian Houthi “sanctions” as you call them are impacting everyone. They are not exclusive to legal commerce with indigenous Palestinian Jews. Your tweet has nothing to do with*all* OOCL/COSCO container shipping routing away from the Red Sea/Suez Canal.

    Everyone notices that you are in a complete panic, repeatedly and frantically ducking the question in a desperate attempt to escape. Let me re-re-re-ask it.

    How long will Xi tolerate Khamenei’s Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?

    Please try not to be wildly and obviously evasive again.

    PEACE 😇

  461. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Complete B.S. like everything Donald the Fat offers.

    https://bostonglobe-prod.cdn.arcpublishing.com/resizer/AntZ7EnkWP-0gvq-Jmy9h4LllOM=/960x0/arc-anglerfish-arc2-prod-bostonglobe.s3.amazonaws.com/public/QAMYHDB66II6PI7W3BZZV22WQQ.jpg

    Replies: @QCIC

    Don’t cross the streams!

  462. @A123
    @AP


    These are forces that sought to destroy [Europe], in the last 100 years:

    Nazism
    Communism
    Mass non-European emigration
    Putin
     
    The problem with your assertion is that Putin seeks to avoid being destroyed by IslamoGloboHomo Europe. Merkel constructed Zelensky as a dagger to slit Russia's throat. She missed the cut, and Ukraine is going to pay a steep price for her failure. Other European leaders like Scholz and Macron, all-in on Kiev aggression, continue to make the situation worse.

    Mass non-European migration, especially of Muslims has been disastrous. Again, Angela "Welcome Rape-ugees" Merkel is again central to this initiating this attack on Judeo-Christians. Germany funds transports bringing invaders to Europe. And, Scholz is outraged that AfD supports "re-migration".

    It extraordinarily obvious that:

    -- Muslim Colonists are the problem.
    -- Muslim Decolonization is the answer.

    How many problems would be immediately solved if European Christendom was 99%+ Muslim free? Crime would plummet. The need for public assistance would shrink. Housing would be less expensive. Wages would be higher. Almost everything would be better.

    Why must Christian European workers suffer for the balance sheets of Islamophile Frankfurt banks? It makes no sense.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    You don’t seem to understand what Ansarullah is. It’s the de facto Yemeni state, not some Iranian proxy you can hand wave into submission. And while it’s a rational political actor, it’s very similar to an uber ideological Hizbullah, circa 1980s, but with ballistic missiles.

  463. @A123
    @Beckow


    the big loser will be Europe that has minimal resources and its manufacturing is not competitive. US-Canada-Australia will do much better – there is a strong opinion in EU that is why US is willing to do this – they are cannibalizing their Euro allies.
     
    America realizes that the CCP is the biggest manufacturing foe for everyone. Thus, gradual decoupling from Asia generally, and the CCP specifically, is a minimum requirement for national security.

    America would like Europe to be a partner in this. There is no "cannibalizing". The problem is that EU bureaucracy cannot (or choses not to) keep up.

    It is no secret hat the CCP builds industry based on IP theft and dumping to damage competitors. The obvious responses are guaranteeing national industrial champions and brutally punishing IP theft. The EU is distracted by other things like keeping borders open and green/ESG/DEI indoctrination. Individual nations, burdened by EU over reach, cannot focus on core employment and industrial priorities.

    Europe needs MEGA to match MAGA. Sadly, that is much more than 12 months away. And, it may be too late for some countries.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Everyone notices that you are in a complete panic, repeatedly and frantically ducking the question in a desperate attempt to escape.

    PEACE 😇
    _________

    Is this list current or have you added more people to it?

    My current BLOCKED TROLLS if anyone needs a starting place:

    Alexander Turok
    Art
    Blinky Bill
    Corvinus
    Daniel Chieh
    Druid
    Dr. Doom
    FB
    HeebHunter
    Iris
    JohnPlywood
    Kratic
    Majority of One
    Mr. Hack
    Mulga Mumblebrain
    Nokangaroos
    obwandiyag
    Pat Kittle
    Rev. Spooner
    Schuetze
    Supply and Demand
    Talha

    I will never block you, promise to do the same!

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    LOL why do you even bother with an open forum if you are going to block that many people?

    Why is Mr. Hack on that list? Corvinus?

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Mr. Hack

    , @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Everyone notices that you are in a complete panic, repeatedly and frantically ducking the question in a desperate attempt to escape. Let me re-re-re-re-ask it yet again:

    How long will Xi tolerate Khamenei’s Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?

    Are you going to:
        • Answer this time?
        • Or, wildly, pathetically, and feebly attempt evade yet again?

    How many times are you going to cower and tremble instead of answering? Your gibbering mindless fear is providing comic relief to the thread. Remember:

    ========================
    No one is laughing with you.
    Everyone is laughing at you.
    ========================


    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

  464. @John Johnson
    @AnonfromTN

    That’s politically incorrect. From the point of view of Western elites, there are “good humans” and “bad humans”. E.g., Gonzalo Lira, who’s only “crime” was honesty

    If Lira was an honest person then why did he scrub practically all of his videos?

    Where are his criticisms of Ukraine?

    This Lira case stinks to high heaven. Duran or Ritter would be able to point to a long list of videos that could aggravate Ukrainian authorities. But Lira? Where are the videos or articles?

    He wanted to get arrested more than he wanted to get a message out. He also most likely scrubbed his earlier "Ukraine is doomed" rants because he was wrong in predicting a quick Russian victory. Supposedly he also ranted about how Russia would never attack.

    Attention seeking behavior from a "red pill coach" fraudster. I don't buy his act for one second. He was never on par with professional Putin shills like Duran or Ritter. He wanted the attention but didn't have the message. Alt-right is desperate for heroes if they rally around a Chilean chain smoker who didn't have a coherent message. He never contacted the state department which tells me his condition was terminal and there was no point in doing it.

    Replies: @QCIC

    We may never know Lira’s full story. Whatever his motives he may have supported the side that is against WW3.

    On the other hand, there is good evidence that Zelensky is a Jewish actor pretending to be a president. In this role his main function is to get as many Slavs killed as possible.

    • Replies: @Matra
    @QCIC

    Lira's wife (presumably the mother of his two kids) is from eastern Ukraine. I believe he said something about them going to stay with relatives or friends in Belgorod early in the war - something he should've done too. Yes, he was an attention seeker, no question about that, but given that his family seems to identify with Russia that alone may explain his pro-Russian views. He also studied Russian history at university and hated the "GAE" and did so for at least the decade he was somewhat famous, probably longer, so I don't think we need to rack our brains trying to figure out why he preferred Russia to Ukraine or assuming sinister motives. (Scott Ritter, who I don't think has ever been right about anything, accused Lira of working for Zelensky or NATO or something like that).

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @John Johnson

  465. @Hyperborean
    @Coconuts


    I think this was translated into English back in the 1980s when it first came out, but hard to find.
     
    The English translation seems to be available on Library Genesis.

    http://libgen.rs/book/index.php?md5=E91FFD4F4C65931CC5E3E8F2B4690D6F

    I'm lazy when it comes to improving my French, I really should work on it more. I can get by with newspapers or short articles, but when it comes to books I get frustrated at not being able to read as fast and easily as in English.

    Replies: @Coconuts

    It’s useful that it is on libgen and in English.

    It isn’t the most scintillating read in the original but imo it is good for the exhaustive analysis of anti-racism and its potential political abuses, a lot of what is going on now with anti-racism in the Anglosphere seems to be predicted quite early on. I thought that that was not bad for a book written 35+ years ago.

    His argument about Nazism as a constant reference point is also interesting in the light of the kind of arguments made by Paul Gottfried etc. about the central importance of Anti-Fascism in politics and culture since 1945.

  466. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    Everyone notices that you are in a complete panic, repeatedly and frantically ducking the question in a desperate attempt to escape.
     
    PEACE 😇
    _________

    Is this list current or have you added more people to it?

    My current BLOCKED TROLLS if anyone needs a starting place:

    Alexander Turok
    Art
    Blinky Bill
    Corvinus
    Daniel Chieh
    Druid
    Dr. Doom
    FB
    HeebHunter
    Iris
    JohnPlywood
    Kratic
    Majority of One
    Mr. Hack
    Mulga Mumblebrain
    Nokangaroos
    obwandiyag
    Pat Kittle
    Rev. Spooner
    Schuetze
    Supply and Demand
    Talha

    I will never block you, promise to do the same!

    Replies: @John Johnson, @A123

    LOL why do you even bother with an open forum if you are going to block that many people?

    Why is Mr. Hack on that list? Corvinus?

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @John Johnson

    Do you know who's block list that is?

    I have never and will never block anyone.

    , @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @John Johnson


    LOL why do you even bother with an open forum if you are going to block that many people?
     
    He doesn't actually block any of them and continues to read their comments to this day.

    He simply uses it as an ineffective strategy to end discussion by pretending he can't see their comments anymore.
    , @Mr. Hack
    @John Johnson

    In kremlinstooge A123's case, he's not only a "blockhead" but he's also a coward too. His bizarre conspiracy theories help complete the whole package:

    https://www.cartoonistgroup.com/properties/bennett/art_images/cg5d9ac782f1bc1.jpg
    kremlnstoogeA123 composing his next unbelievable conspiracy theory

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  467. German_reader says:
    @songbird
    @German_reader

    Guess it is a political impossibility from a regime standpoint, but , IMO, it is a pity that something like Srinivasan's blockchain voting doesn't exist for Ukraine, where war sentiment could be tested, weighed, and aired.

    Have a feeling that most people wouldn't have these unrealistic views of 10-15 years more war, and possibly take back Crimea in 5-10 or so.

    Replies: @German_reader

    Have a feeling that most people wouldn’t have these unrealistic views of 10-15 years more war, and possibly take back Crimea in 5-10 or so.

    He says things like that (pretty crazy imo…and what does he mean when he says that the war won’t stay limited to Ukraine and Russia?), but then he also says that there ought to be a grand settlement to create a new collective security system, with acknowledgement of Russian views. Or his critical comments about Ukrainian nationalism (“only 20% believe in it”). I really wonder what this guy is about. And wtf is the deal with the criminal charges against him…”they made up that I hate women”???
    He also seems to confirm that there was a real chance of a negotiated end to the war in spring 2022, and that news of the atrocities in Bucha somehow played a role in stopping that process (iirc Israel’s Naftali Bennett also implied something like that). If true, what a disaster that this chance was missed.

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @German_reader


    also says that there ought to be a grand settlement to create a new collective security system, with acknowledgement of Russian views. Or his critical comments about Ukrainian nationalism (“only 20% believe in it”). I really wonder what this guy is about
     
    He might have done full circle, returning where he began in 2005 - by doing joint press conferences with Dugin about the danger of Maidan, lol

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F3gLcPnXIAERpqS.jpg


    The ideologist of Russian "Eurasianism" Alexander Dugin, the leader of the "Brotherhood" party Dmitry Korchinsky and his then deputy Alexei Arestovich, 2005 press conference.The event was dedicated to joint actions of Ukrainian and Russian anti-Maidan forces
     
    .

    https://twitter.com/RussiaPost_tw/status/1691117627567898625
    , @Mr. XYZ
    @German_reader

    Makes one wonder if Putin would have actually honored any peace treaty with Ukraine given just how he dealt with Prigozhin after the latter made peace with Putin.

    Zelensky actually subsequently invoked this as an argument not to make peace with Russia:

    https://www.cnn.com/2023/09/08/europe/zelensky-zakaria-interview-ukraine-putin-intl/index.html

    , @songbird
    @German_reader


    and what does he mean when he says that the war won’t stay limited to Ukraine and Russia?
     
    I probably can't understand the EE mindset, but my own estimation would be that he is trying to play to the fears of Poles and Balts.

    Thought it was very bizarre and amusing when he evoked the Thirty Years' War. (Does not seem calculated to win further German support, or perhaps it is about sending the big ticket items to break the logjam?).

    Can't figure the guy out. It is like he is talking to multiple audiences, but to what purpose? Is he even serious, or just like a Ukrainian Mike Pence, who is "running" without a chance, for personal profit. (Pence suspended his campaign, which means he gets to keep the money)

    And wtf is the deal with the criminal charges against him…”they made up that I hate women”???
     
    That video is linked to on Wikipedia, but not timestamped. I nominate AP to spend like 40 minutes listening to it at 3x speed.

    The Ukrainian page leads to sources which state the main claim is that he said something like "Women are beings that must be suppressed." (But possibly while quoting someone else. Who knows or cares?)
  468. @John Johnson
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    LOL why do you even bother with an open forum if you are going to block that many people?

    Why is Mr. Hack on that list? Corvinus?

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Mr. Hack

    Do you know who’s block list that is?

    I have never and will never block anyone.

  469. @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    We may never know Lira's full story. Whatever his motives he may have supported the side that is against WW3.

    On the other hand, there is good evidence that Zelensky is a Jewish actor pretending to be a president. In this role his main function is to get as many Slavs killed as possible.

    Replies: @Matra

    Lira’s wife (presumably the mother of his two kids) is from eastern Ukraine. I believe he said something about them going to stay with relatives or friends in Belgorod early in the war – something he should’ve done too. Yes, he was an attention seeker, no question about that, but given that his family seems to identify with Russia that alone may explain his pro-Russian views. He also studied Russian history at university and hated the “GAE” and did so for at least the decade he was somewhat famous, probably longer, so I don’t think we need to rack our brains trying to figure out why he preferred Russia to Ukraine or assuming sinister motives. (Scott Ritter, who I don’t think has ever been right about anything, accused Lira of working for Zelensky or NATO or something like that).

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Matra

    The Ukraine arrested him once before, confiscated his hardware, and let him go after a couple days custody. Ritter's point was they wouldn't have ever let him back out if he wasn't serving some purpose for them. This would be true if the only use was they collected his contacts' identification.

    Coach Red Pill wasn't necessarily a pathological attention seeker, but his occupation was pumping social media. His twitter followers and youtube subscribers went up 1000 X when the special military operation war started and the buzz depended on him being in the war zone. It seems he was planning on the front line passing over him and the Ukraine goons being on the other side from him and the Russian goons in which case he would have been mostly in the clear but that didn't happen. He bet big and he lost everything. Sort of kind of like Anatoly Karlin who bet big and claims he didn't lose much.

    , @John Johnson
    @Matra

    Lira’s wife (presumably the mother of his two kids) is from eastern Ukraine. I believe he said something about them going to stay with relatives or friends in Belgorod early in the war – something he should’ve done too. Yes, he was an attention seeker, no question about that, but given that his family seems to identify with Russia that alone may explain his pro-Russian views.

    Lira never denied doxxing Western journalists.

    That's pretty low for someone who claims to promote journalistic freedom.

    I actually wonder if the Russians did their homework and wanted nothing to do with him.

    Maybe they knew about his medical condition and didn't want to take him. Perhaps they offered him a job at the front and nothing more.

    I certainly don't take any glee over his fate. Anyone who chain smokes and defends a mass murderer clearly has mental problems. I suspect he was at one point spurned or cheated on by a woman. His "red pill" videos are bitter and spiteful. I don't buy for one second that he was ever living some bachelor lifestyle where he was banging random Ukrainian girls. Not one second.

    His smoking habit most likely caught up to him and this is how he chose to go out. Depict himself as a free speech martyr that was oppressed by Ukraine even though he didn't need to be there and had nothing to say.

    In the videos you can see that he has an extreme nicotine addiction. Chain smoking is very bad for your health since your lungs never get a break. It's really just a form of suicide. His age is about right where it catches up to people. 2 or packs a day will just straight up f-cking kill you. People that smoke that much also tend to drink.

    Replies: @Matra, @Derer

  470. This video clip is so good.

    Everyone should watch it!

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Fascinating. The last minute is the most interesting.

    I didn't realize that Jared Taylor is fluent in Japanese and French. I suppose that is why he sounds very strange, at least to me. His idiosyncratic accent and intonation do not help his communication on such a divisive issue.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  471. @Matra
    @QCIC

    Lira's wife (presumably the mother of his two kids) is from eastern Ukraine. I believe he said something about them going to stay with relatives or friends in Belgorod early in the war - something he should've done too. Yes, he was an attention seeker, no question about that, but given that his family seems to identify with Russia that alone may explain his pro-Russian views. He also studied Russian history at university and hated the "GAE" and did so for at least the decade he was somewhat famous, probably longer, so I don't think we need to rack our brains trying to figure out why he preferred Russia to Ukraine or assuming sinister motives. (Scott Ritter, who I don't think has ever been right about anything, accused Lira of working for Zelensky or NATO or something like that).

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @John Johnson

    The Ukraine arrested him once before, confiscated his hardware, and let him go after a couple days custody. Ritter’s point was they wouldn’t have ever let him back out if he wasn’t serving some purpose for them. This would be true if the only use was they collected his contacts’ identification.

    Coach Red Pill wasn’t necessarily a pathological attention seeker, but his occupation was pumping social media. His twitter followers and youtube subscribers went up 1000 X when the special military operation war started and the buzz depended on him being in the war zone. It seems he was planning on the front line passing over him and the Ukraine goons being on the other side from him and the Russian goons in which case he would have been mostly in the clear but that didn’t happen. He bet big and he lost everything. Sort of kind of like Anatoly Karlin who bet big and claims he didn’t lose much.

    • Thanks: Matra
  472. @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ


    ...Horthy’s biggest mistake was trying to backstab Hitler in 1944 by trying to make a separate peace
     
    Horthy's biggest mistakes were joining Nazi Germany in 1938 Munich Treaty to dismember Czechoslovakia (together with Poland), then grabbing territories of all surrounding countries, and sending 300k Magyars with Nazis in 1941 to invade Russia.

    What he did or didn't do in "1944" was irrelevant - by then Hungary was done, a defeated nation. You are analyzing it without understanding: by 1944 Germany was thoroughly defeated by Russia, the sad switche-roos by Italy, Romania, Hungary...were pointless. US-UK finally joining the war in June 1944 with the Normandy landing was similar, a belated attempt to join in and mitigate the defeat of Germany. (They then went ape-shit claiming the credit - Anglos are like that.)

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Hyperborean, @Mr. XYZ

    Romania at least chose a smart moment to switch sides during WWII. Prevented its own Jews from being mass murdered by the Nazis (at least in the Old Kingdom of Romania territories) and saved most of Budapest’s Jews as well by compelling the Nazis to postpone their deportation to Auschwitz, which ultimately ended up never happening, though a lot of them (but apparently not a majority) did subsequently die in forced Nazi death marches.

    Could Hungary have avoided invading the USSR in 1941?

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    I would be careful about Romania, they were absolute swines and murderers. Read even in wikipedia:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Holocaust_in_Romania

    "...Romania ranks first among Holocaust perpetrator countries other than Germany...Romania being the only ally of the Third Reich that carried out its genocidal campaign without German intervention...the slaughter of Jews in Romanian-occupied territories was "a genocide separate from the Nazi Final Solution"... "


    Could Hungary have avoided invading the USSR in 1941?
     
    What makes you think they wanted to avoid it? Hungary thought that Germany will win and the spoils will be shared with those who help. Of course they could have avoided it - other German allies like Vichy-France and Bulgaria didn't join the invasion. Hungary chose to attack Russia and they paid a high price. That's the way it works - today Hungary is trying to be smarter, we will see how that turns out.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

  473. @German_reader
    @songbird


    Have a feeling that most people wouldn’t have these unrealistic views of 10-15 years more war, and possibly take back Crimea in 5-10 or so.
     
    He says things like that (pretty crazy imo...and what does he mean when he says that the war won't stay limited to Ukraine and Russia?), but then he also says that there ought to be a grand settlement to create a new collective security system, with acknowledgement of Russian views. Or his critical comments about Ukrainian nationalism ("only 20% believe in it"). I really wonder what this guy is about. And wtf is the deal with the criminal charges against him..."they made up that I hate women"???
    He also seems to confirm that there was a real chance of a negotiated end to the war in spring 2022, and that news of the atrocities in Bucha somehow played a role in stopping that process (iirc Israel's Naftali Bennett also implied something like that). If true, what a disaster that this chance was missed.

    Replies: @sudden death, @Mr. XYZ, @songbird

    also says that there ought to be a grand settlement to create a new collective security system, with acknowledgement of Russian views. Or his critical comments about Ukrainian nationalism (“only 20% believe in it”). I really wonder what this guy is about

    He might have done full circle, returning where he began in 2005 – by doing joint press conferences with Dugin about the danger of Maidan, lol

    The ideologist of Russian “Eurasianism” Alexander Dugin, the leader of the “Brotherhood” party Dmitry Korchinsky and his then deputy Alexei Arestovich, 2005 press conference.The event was dedicated to joint actions of Ukrainian and Russian anti-Maidan forces

    .

    [MORE]

    • LOL: Mr. XYZ
  474. @German_reader
    @songbird


    Have a feeling that most people wouldn’t have these unrealistic views of 10-15 years more war, and possibly take back Crimea in 5-10 or so.
     
    He says things like that (pretty crazy imo...and what does he mean when he says that the war won't stay limited to Ukraine and Russia?), but then he also says that there ought to be a grand settlement to create a new collective security system, with acknowledgement of Russian views. Or his critical comments about Ukrainian nationalism ("only 20% believe in it"). I really wonder what this guy is about. And wtf is the deal with the criminal charges against him..."they made up that I hate women"???
    He also seems to confirm that there was a real chance of a negotiated end to the war in spring 2022, and that news of the atrocities in Bucha somehow played a role in stopping that process (iirc Israel's Naftali Bennett also implied something like that). If true, what a disaster that this chance was missed.

    Replies: @sudden death, @Mr. XYZ, @songbird

    Makes one wonder if Putin would have actually honored any peace treaty with Ukraine given just how he dealt with Prigozhin after the latter made peace with Putin.

    Zelensky actually subsequently invoked this as an argument not to make peace with Russia:

    https://www.cnn.com/2023/09/08/europe/zelensky-zakaria-interview-ukraine-putin-intl/index.html

  475. Germany is essentially paralyzed by farmers’ protests, which were joined by truck drivers. All major roads are blocked by tractors. Farmers dumped tons of manure on the streets and squares of major German cities. This news is all over the internet (here are just two of thousands of sites):
    https://www.scmp.com/news/world/europe/article/3248539/german-farmers-drive-tractors-berlin-protest-fuel-subsidy-cuts-government-must-resign
    https://news.yahoo.com/german-farmers-round-off-week-123517187.html
    but not in American MSM.
    Even though >60% of Germans support these protests and want current compradore government to resign.

    Compare this to the coverage of a demo by 20-30 navalnista misfits in Russia, where Navalny never even reached 3% electoral support.

    Another example: alternative news sites and social media are full of comments about the death od American citizen Gonzalo Lira in Ukrainian dungeon. American MSM keep mum.

    If these two examples do not tell you all you need to know about American MSM, you are hopeless.

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @AnonfromTN


    not in American MSM.
     
    Damn, somehow managed to miss the news about California breaking off from USA;)

    Yahoo! is an American web services provider. It is headquartered in Sunnyvale, California, and operated by the namesake company Yahoo! Inc., which is 90% owned by investment funds managed by Apollo Global Management and 10% by Verizon Communications.
     

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

  476. @Matra
    @QCIC

    Lira's wife (presumably the mother of his two kids) is from eastern Ukraine. I believe he said something about them going to stay with relatives or friends in Belgorod early in the war - something he should've done too. Yes, he was an attention seeker, no question about that, but given that his family seems to identify with Russia that alone may explain his pro-Russian views. He also studied Russian history at university and hated the "GAE" and did so for at least the decade he was somewhat famous, probably longer, so I don't think we need to rack our brains trying to figure out why he preferred Russia to Ukraine or assuming sinister motives. (Scott Ritter, who I don't think has ever been right about anything, accused Lira of working for Zelensky or NATO or something like that).

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @John Johnson

    Lira’s wife (presumably the mother of his two kids) is from eastern Ukraine. I believe he said something about them going to stay with relatives or friends in Belgorod early in the war – something he should’ve done too. Yes, he was an attention seeker, no question about that, but given that his family seems to identify with Russia that alone may explain his pro-Russian views.

    Lira never denied doxxing Western journalists.

    That’s pretty low for someone who claims to promote journalistic freedom.

    I actually wonder if the Russians did their homework and wanted nothing to do with him.

    Maybe they knew about his medical condition and didn’t want to take him. Perhaps they offered him a job at the front and nothing more.

    I certainly don’t take any glee over his fate. Anyone who chain smokes and defends a mass murderer clearly has mental problems. I suspect he was at one point spurned or cheated on by a woman. His “red pill” videos are bitter and spiteful. I don’t buy for one second that he was ever living some bachelor lifestyle where he was banging random Ukrainian girls. Not one second.

    His smoking habit most likely caught up to him and this is how he chose to go out. Depict himself as a free speech martyr that was oppressed by Ukraine even though he didn’t need to be there and had nothing to say.

    In the videos you can see that he has an extreme nicotine addiction. Chain smoking is very bad for your health since your lungs never get a break. It’s really just a form of suicide. His age is about right where it catches up to people. 2 or packs a day will just straight up f-cking kill you. People that smoke that much also tend to drink.

    • Replies: @Matra
    @John Johnson


    Anyone who chain smokes and defends a mass murderer clearly has mental problems
     
    So anyone who chain smokes has mental issues or do they also have to support a mass murderer like...just about every US president, except Trump, of the last forty years? You probably don't realise far more people on earth consider what Israel is doing in Gaza to be mass murder (genocide?) than anything happening in Ukraine, and virtually all of them believe #GenocideJoe has given the go-ahead. Are all Joe Biden supporters suffering from mental problems?

    I don’t buy for one second that he was ever living some bachelor lifestyle where he was banging random Ukrainian girls. Not one second
     
    He didn't claim to. If you've evidence to the contrary you should provide it. He did his Coach Red Pill videos when he lived in London's Notting Hill. I watched maybe 20 or so of them and based on memory they were about politics - leftist psychology, Pinochet, the media, Solzhenitsyn & the USSR - along with advice for young men about women, and Alt-Right bickering & feuding, which he contributed mightily to as he was a shit-stirrer.

    He then moved to Kharkiv because of his wife & kids - separated I'm guessing. In Kharkiv he built some large work room, which he filmed every minute of, then I lost track of him for a couple of years as he stopped talking politics, before he reappeared just before the Ukraine war. If he was claiming to be a pick-up artist I don't know when that was but it wasn't within the last 7 or 8 years.

    His smoking habit most likely caught up to him and this is how he chose to go out.
     
    Can't wait for some Russian liberal to die in prison & have Putin fans claim he was a chain smoker or former vodka drinker therefore he chose his death in prison.

    Chain smoking is very bad for your health since your lungs never get a break. It’s really just a form of suicide
     
    Prisoners in Western countries receive medical treatment. Ukraine supporters claim Ukraine is on its way to becoming a liberal democracy that we should support because our values are at stake. lol His death came too soon after his imprisonment to not be suspicious. Given the accusations from him and his family along with rare USGov. silence about an imprisoned American things look pretty suspicious. Ukraine is known for its corruption, human rights abuses, and even for putting foreign residents on hit lists for not agreeing with the regime. One has to assume the worst of such people.

    People that smoke that much also tend to drink.
     
    He claimed to be anti-alcohol. One of the advice videos I watched from maybe five years ago was about men who need alcohol to socialise. I think he was explaining why he went from idolising James Joyce to despising him. He seemed to have a low opinion of drinkers.

    But keep on trying to justify why people who die in the custody of US allies/proxies deserve to die because everyone here knows that's what you really believe. You demonstrated at least a year ago on these boards that you are a US über alles (or perhaps über allen would be more apt) patriotard who lives vicariously through American wars.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    , @Derer
    @John Johnson


    Chain smoking is very bad for your health since your lungs never get a break.
     
    I agree...however some examples make mockery of that assertion, namely former German Chancellor Helmut Schmidt smoked 2 packs a day until his death at 97 year old - poster boy for tobacco industry.

    Another myth is stress which is considered to be bad for your heath. There was no greater stress than for former Stalin's politburo members, living constantly under enormous stress. They died fat and old Kaganovich 98, Molotov 96, Malenkov 87, Voroshilov 88 etc.

    Replies: @Mikel

  477. @AnonfromTN
    Germany is essentially paralyzed by farmers’ protests, which were joined by truck drivers. All major roads are blocked by tractors. Farmers dumped tons of manure on the streets and squares of major German cities. This news is all over the internet (here are just two of thousands of sites):
    https://www.scmp.com/news/world/europe/article/3248539/german-farmers-drive-tractors-berlin-protest-fuel-subsidy-cuts-government-must-resign
    https://news.yahoo.com/german-farmers-round-off-week-123517187.html
    but not in American MSM.
    Even though >60% of Germans support these protests and want current compradore government to resign.

    Compare this to the coverage of a demo by 20-30 navalnista misfits in Russia, where Navalny never even reached 3% electoral support.

    Another example: alternative news sites and social media are full of comments about the death od American citizen Gonzalo Lira in Ukrainian dungeon. American MSM keep mum.

    If these two examples do not tell you all you need to know about American MSM, you are hopeless.

    Replies: @sudden death

    not in American MSM.

    Damn, somehow managed to miss the news about California breaking off from USA;)

    Yahoo! is an American web services provider. It is headquartered in Sunnyvale, California, and operated by the namesake company Yahoo! Inc., which is 90% owned by investment funds managed by Apollo Global Management and 10% by Verizon Communications.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @sudden death

    Are you saying that this is the level of coverage in the US MSM you’d get if something like that were happening in Russia? In this case count yourself as hopeless.

    Replies: @sudden death

  478. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    Everyone notices that you are in a complete panic, repeatedly and frantically ducking the question in a desperate attempt to escape.
     
    PEACE 😇
    _________

    Is this list current or have you added more people to it?

    My current BLOCKED TROLLS if anyone needs a starting place:

    Alexander Turok
    Art
    Blinky Bill
    Corvinus
    Daniel Chieh
    Druid
    Dr. Doom
    FB
    HeebHunter
    Iris
    JohnPlywood
    Kratic
    Majority of One
    Mr. Hack
    Mulga Mumblebrain
    Nokangaroos
    obwandiyag
    Pat Kittle
    Rev. Spooner
    Schuetze
    Supply and Demand
    Talha

    I will never block you, promise to do the same!

    Replies: @John Johnson, @A123

    Everyone notices that you are in a complete panic, repeatedly and frantically ducking the question in a desperate attempt to escape. Let me re-re-re-re-ask it yet again:

    How long will Xi tolerate Khamenei’s Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?

    Are you going to:
        • Answer this time?
        • Or, wildly, pathetically, and feebly attempt evade yet again?

    How many times are you going to cower and tremble instead of answering? Your gibbering mindless fear is providing comic relief to the thread. Remember:

    ========================
    No one is laughing with you.
    Everyone is laughing at you.
    ========================

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    How many times are you going to cower and tremble instead of answering? Your gibbering mindless fear is providing comic relief to the thread.

    https://www.unz.com/proems/why-germans-are-hated/#comment-4941871


    A123 says: • Website
    October 7, 2021 at 7:50 pm GMT • 2.3 years ago • 200 Words ↑
    @AaronB
    At some level there has to be a value judgement. Some people are so stupid and so offensive that the hope of intelligent conversation does not exist. They simply are Trolls. My personal list of blocked TROLLS is below [MORE].

    TL is not someone I am likely I to engage with on a regular basis as her interests are completely different. She managed to annoy Mr. Unz to the point where there was a sanction. Given that he puts up with me, it is a pretty heavy load to draw that type of response.

    Sparing use of a block can have value. Overuse is destructive. Each person has to judge the appropriate level on their own.

    PEACE 😇

    [Hide MORE]
    I could probably trim this back. A number of these TROLLS are no longer around.

    Alexander Turok
    Art
    Blinky Bill
    Cohen
    Corvinus
    Daniel Chieh
    Druid
    Dr. Doom
    FB
    HeebHunter
    Iris
    JohnPlywood
    Kratic
    Majority of One
    Mario Partisan
    Mulga Mumblebrain
    Nokangaroos
    obwandiyag
    Pat Kittle
    Rev. Spooner
    Schuetze
    Supply and Demand
     
    😇

    Replies: @A123

  479. @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Everyone notices that you are in a complete panic, repeatedly and frantically ducking the question in a desperate attempt to escape. Let me re-re-re-re-ask it yet again:

    How long will Xi tolerate Khamenei’s Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?

    Are you going to:
        • Answer this time?
        • Or, wildly, pathetically, and feebly attempt evade yet again?

    How many times are you going to cower and tremble instead of answering? Your gibbering mindless fear is providing comic relief to the thread. Remember:

    ========================
    No one is laughing with you.
    Everyone is laughing at you.
    ========================


    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    How many times are you going to cower and tremble instead of answering? Your gibbering mindless fear is providing comic relief to the thread.

    https://www.unz.com/proems/why-germans-are-hated/#comment-4941871

    A123 says: • Website
    October 7, 2021 at 7:50 pm GMT • 2.3 years ago • 200 Words ↑
    @AaronB
    At some level there has to be a value judgement. Some people are so stupid and so offensive that the hope of intelligent conversation does not exist. They simply are Trolls. My personal list of blocked TROLLS is below [MORE].

    TL is not someone I am likely I to engage with on a regular basis as her interests are completely different. She managed to annoy Mr. Unz to the point where there was a sanction. Given that he puts up with me, it is a pretty heavy load to draw that type of response.

    Sparing use of a block can have value. Overuse is destructive. Each person has to judge the appropriate level on their own.

    PEACE 😇

    [Hide MORE]
    I could probably trim this back. A number of these TROLLS are no longer around.

    Alexander Turok
    Art
    Blinky Bill
    Cohen
    Corvinus
    Daniel Chieh
    Druid
    Dr. Doom
    FB
    HeebHunter
    Iris
    JohnPlywood
    Kratic
    Majority of One
    Mario Partisan
    Mulga Mumblebrain
    Nokangaroos
    obwandiyag
    Pat Kittle
    Rev. Spooner
    Schuetze
    Supply and Demand

    😇

    • Replies: @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Everyone notices that you are in a complete panic, repeatedly and frantically ducking the question in a desperate attempt to escape. Let me re-re-re-re-re-ask it yet again:

    How long will Xi tolerate Khamenei’s Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?

    Are you going to:

    • Answer this time?
    • Or, wildly, pathetically, and feebly attempt evade yet again?

    Futile attempts to change the subject are not helping you.

    How many times are you going to cower and tremble instead of answering? Your gibbering mindless fear is providing comic relief to the thread. Remember:

    ========================
    No one is laughing with you.
    Everyone is laughing at you.
    ========================


    PEACE 😇

  480. @sudden death
    @AnonfromTN


    not in American MSM.
     
    Damn, somehow managed to miss the news about California breaking off from USA;)

    Yahoo! is an American web services provider. It is headquartered in Sunnyvale, California, and operated by the namesake company Yahoo! Inc., which is 90% owned by investment funds managed by Apollo Global Management and 10% by Verizon Communications.
     

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    Are you saying that this is the level of coverage in the US MSM you’d get if something like that were happening in Russia? In this case count yourself as hopeless.

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @AnonfromTN


    level of coverage in the US MSM
     
    Quite apparently also managed to miss the news about CNN relocating out of USA, lol

    Updated 12:54 PM EST, Mon January 15, 2024

    Berlin has nearly been brought to a standstill as thousands of farmers rally against tax rises and subsidy cuts, the culmination of a week of protests that have piled misery on German Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s governing coalition.

    Streets leading to Berlin’s Brandenburg Gate were clogged with trucks and tractors on Monday, as more than 10,000 farmers descended on the capital in conjunction with the German freight industry, police said.

    Multiple other protests are planned across the country, which come as Scholz’s coalition struggles to fix a budget crisis and official data showed Germany’s economy shrank last year for the first time since the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic.
     

    https://edition.cnn.com/2024/01/15/europe/farmer-protests-germany-far-right-afd-intl/index.html
  481. @German_reader
    @songbird


    Have a feeling that most people wouldn’t have these unrealistic views of 10-15 years more war, and possibly take back Crimea in 5-10 or so.
     
    He says things like that (pretty crazy imo...and what does he mean when he says that the war won't stay limited to Ukraine and Russia?), but then he also says that there ought to be a grand settlement to create a new collective security system, with acknowledgement of Russian views. Or his critical comments about Ukrainian nationalism ("only 20% believe in it"). I really wonder what this guy is about. And wtf is the deal with the criminal charges against him..."they made up that I hate women"???
    He also seems to confirm that there was a real chance of a negotiated end to the war in spring 2022, and that news of the atrocities in Bucha somehow played a role in stopping that process (iirc Israel's Naftali Bennett also implied something like that). If true, what a disaster that this chance was missed.

    Replies: @sudden death, @Mr. XYZ, @songbird

    and what does he mean when he says that the war won’t stay limited to Ukraine and Russia?

    I probably can’t understand the EE mindset, but my own estimation would be that he is trying to play to the fears of Poles and Balts.

    Thought it was very bizarre and amusing when he evoked the Thirty Years’ War. (Does not seem calculated to win further German support, or perhaps it is about sending the big ticket items to break the logjam?).

    [MORE]

    Can’t figure the guy out. It is like he is talking to multiple audiences, but to what purpose? Is he even serious, or just like a Ukrainian Mike Pence, who is “running” without a chance, for personal profit. (Pence suspended his campaign, which means he gets to keep the money)

    And wtf is the deal with the criminal charges against him…”they made up that I hate women”???

    That video is linked to on Wikipedia, but not timestamped. I nominate AP to spend like 40 minutes listening to it at 3x speed.

    The Ukrainian page leads to sources which state the main claim is that he said something like “Women are beings that must be suppressed.” (But possibly while quoting someone else. Who knows or cares?)

  482. @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    the sad switche-roos by Italy, Romania, Hungary…were pointless.
     
    Not quite. Romanian king even got the Order of Victory from Stalin.

    Besides, as US and UK agreed to keep Romania and Hungary in the Soviet zone, Soviet propaganda never mentioned the atrocities committed by Romanian and Hungarian troops. In fact, Romanians murdered most Jews in Odessa, whereas by the accounts of those who happened to be on temporarily occupied Soviet territories, Hungarians were worse for the civilians than Germans. By their brutality Hungarians far exceeded Germans, approaching banderites:
    https://www.ilawjournals.com/why-vatutin-ordered-not-to-take-prisoners-hungarian-soldiers-of-hitler/
    That’s why in the battle of Voronezh Soviet commander Vatutin issued an order that Hungarians should not be taken prisoners. The order was followed: virtually all Hungarian troops near Voronezh were killed.


    US-UK finally joining the war in June 1944 with the Normandy landing was similar, a belated attempt to join in and mitigate the defeat of Germany.
     
    Yes, by June 1944 the outcome of the war was already assured. However, late entrance of “Allies” in the war against Nazi Germany was mostly to participate in the division of spoils with minimal investment into actual fighting. Saving and then using numerous Nazis was probably not the main goal.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Beckow, @LT1488, @Mr. XYZ

    You are right that the Romanians got of lightly, they were – and can be again – among the more determined anti-Russian fanatics. Maybe the fact that they were so pathetic and poor endeared them to the commie leaders in Moscow. When Romies switched, their armies without real weapons or often even shoes marched alongside Red Army into CE. My grandparents said they were begging in villages door to door for food. But then they got Causescu, so I suppose that was enough of a retribution.

    mostly to participate in the division of spoils with minimal investment into actual fighting. Saving and then using numerous Nazis was probably not the main goal.

    That sounds plausible until one realizes that the material spoils were not that great. It is very likely that from early on Anglos played a double game and were in touch with many Nazis promising leniency for cooperation. Rudolf Hess wasn’t mad and didn’t fly to Britain un-announced.

    The original plan to see if Nazi Germany with help of most of Europe can destroy Russia, changed into “let’s bleed them both“, and eventually once Russia was obviously winning big to “let’s see what can be salvaged from the Nazi drang-nach-Osten” – at least not allowing for it to be fully extinguished. The resources, or even specific borders, are not that important for the Anglo supremacists, it is the crazy geo-political desire for unchallenged dominance. Once they have it, all else would follow.

    The Ukie tragedy is a minor version of the same old plan – by now the Anglos are so incompetent that it is almost absurd: weaker forces, no real commitment or fallback plan, focus on winning in the media and not on the ground. But the impulse is the same.

  483. @A123
    @QCIC


    Did the survey ask about ILLEGAL immigration by name? If not, the results are possibly very misleading.
     
    I had that same insight. The poll does not effectively distinguish between legal & illegal.

    Another problem is the "inch deep" phenomenon. People will say they are "for" something that sounds unobjectionable, but that superficial count is meaningless. It vanishes in methods such as Top 5 Issues. Border Security will frequently appear in the Top 5 for many voters. Keeping or increasing migration will be a tiny fraction in comparison.

    The best questions would pair the policy with inevitable outcome. "Knowing that you will be paid less, do you support migrants coming to compete for your job?" The more that people understand cause & effect, the less willing they are to be self destructive.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @AP, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Former Israeli Shin Bet chief Ami Ayalon reiterates his call to release Palestinian leader Marwan Barghouti and negotiate a two-state solution.

    😇

  484. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    How many times are you going to cower and tremble instead of answering? Your gibbering mindless fear is providing comic relief to the thread.

    https://www.unz.com/proems/why-germans-are-hated/#comment-4941871


    A123 says: • Website
    October 7, 2021 at 7:50 pm GMT • 2.3 years ago • 200 Words ↑
    @AaronB
    At some level there has to be a value judgement. Some people are so stupid and so offensive that the hope of intelligent conversation does not exist. They simply are Trolls. My personal list of blocked TROLLS is below [MORE].

    TL is not someone I am likely I to engage with on a regular basis as her interests are completely different. She managed to annoy Mr. Unz to the point where there was a sanction. Given that he puts up with me, it is a pretty heavy load to draw that type of response.

    Sparing use of a block can have value. Overuse is destructive. Each person has to judge the appropriate level on their own.

    PEACE 😇

    [Hide MORE]
    I could probably trim this back. A number of these TROLLS are no longer around.

    Alexander Turok
    Art
    Blinky Bill
    Cohen
    Corvinus
    Daniel Chieh
    Druid
    Dr. Doom
    FB
    HeebHunter
    Iris
    JohnPlywood
    Kratic
    Majority of One
    Mario Partisan
    Mulga Mumblebrain
    Nokangaroos
    obwandiyag
    Pat Kittle
    Rev. Spooner
    Schuetze
    Supply and Demand
     
    😇

    Replies: @A123

    Everyone notices that you are in a complete panic, repeatedly and frantically ducking the question in a desperate attempt to escape. Let me re-re-re-re-re-ask it yet again:

    How long will Xi tolerate Khamenei’s Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?

    Are you going to:

    • Answer this time?
    • Or, wildly, pathetically, and feebly attempt evade yet again?

    Futile attempts to change the subject are not helping you.

    How many times are you going to cower and tremble instead of answering? Your gibbering mindless fear is providing comic relief to the thread. Remember:

    ========================
    No one is laughing with you.
    Everyone is laughing at you.
    ========================

    PEACE 😇

  485. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    This video clip is so good.

    Everyone should watch it!



    https://twitter.com/FromKulak/status/1746643650791063874

    Replies: @QCIC

    Fascinating. The last minute is the most interesting.

    I didn’t realize that Jared Taylor is fluent in Japanese and French. I suppose that is why he sounds very strange, at least to me. His idiosyncratic accent and intonation do not help his communication on such a divisive issue.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @QCIC

    I think that his accent is Southern. IIRC, he was born in Virginia. He's a true old-school Southern gentleman, complete with a general repulsion towards miscegenation (albeit thankfully NOT up to the point of actually supporting anti-miscegenation laws since he rightfully views such laws as being contrary to his desired principle of freedom of association).

    Replies: @Matra, @QCIC

  486. @A123
    @AP

    Why would Judaism have anything to do with someone volunteering to fight in Ukraine?

    What is the Jewish population in Poland? IIRC, less than 20K. Judaism has effectively no impact on Polish culture or politics.



    Do not forget the J yoke in Poland is as strong as in Ukraine.
     
    You haven’t heard of the problems between Poland and Israel?
     
    The friction between Poland and Palestinian Jews is quite limited. These days, most of it is related to the fact that Israel is officially neutral to Russia leaning.

    I find it puzzling that everyone seems to miss that the current Kiev regime hates Jews. Here is the latest offense: (1)

    [Volodymyr Zelenskyy] is undermining a 1994 agreement with the United States, and is violating the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, by digging up a Jewish cemetery in Uman, Ukraine, to build condos.

    A project that began in the summer of 2016 in the Ukrainian city of Uman, a well-known site of Jewish pilgrimage as the burial place of Rabbi Nachman of Breslov, as well as a mass grave of victims of the Haidamacks massacre, has seen human remains being dug up as early as summer of 2022, according to a report in Ukrainian media. The site sees tens of thousands of Jewish visitors from around the world on Rosh Hashana alone, and thousands more throughout the year, even during wartime.
     
    Post Judaic apostate Zelensky's track record of anti-Semitism has been clear for years.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2024/01/10/morris-ukraine-seeks-billions-from-u-s-as-it-desecrates-jewish-cemetery-to-build-condo/

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Whereas Israel was being asked before the war to make a relatively limited commitment to eventual establishment of a Palestinian state, it will now need to go further in demonstrating that commitment while accepting return of the Palestinian Authority.

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    I will assume you went for this because you are wholly ignorant of international shipping.

    • High value CONTAINER ships such as the MAERSK HANGZHOU, which was attacked, run 18 meters of draft.
    • You are trying to draw a comparison to the GREAT OCEAN. Check the stats (1).


    The vessel GREAT OCEAN (IMO: 9278557, MMSI: 636019834) is a Bulk Carrier that was built in 2003 ( 21 years old ). It's sailing under the flag of [LR] Liberia.
    ...
    The current draught of GREAT OCEAN as reported by AIS is 11.1 meters
     
    It is bulk (not container) so the cargo is much less valuable. And, at 7 meters less draft it is lightly loaded. This makes it uninteresting to Iranian backed Houthi pirates.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.myshiptracking.com/vessels/great-ocean-mmsi-636019834-imo-9278557

  487. Not relevant to anything going on at the moment, but I still can’t get over the fact that Bin Laden’s Swiss niece is a Republican Ameriboo. Is it more or less bizarre than Stalin’s American granddaughter?

    Bin Ladin (whose branch of the family has always spelled their name differently than her infamous uncle) lives in Switzerland but said she considers herself “an American at heart.” A full-size US flag hung in her childhood room at age 12 and her dream vacation is an RV trip across America.

    […]

    “I have been a supporter of President Trump since he announced he was running in the early days in 2015. I have watched from afar and I admire this man’s resolve,” she said. “He must be re-elected … It’s vital for the future of not only America, but Western civilization as a whole.”

    “You look at all the terrorist attacks that have happened in Europe over the past 19 years. They have completely shaken us to the core … [Radical Islam] has completely infiltrated our society,” bin Ladin continued. “In the US it’s very worrying that the left has aligned itself completely with the people who share that ideology.”

    […]

    Noor, who said she regularly wears a “Make America Great Again” hat (and occasionally a Trump bedtime onesie), has had to confront many Trump-haters on her side of the Atlantic. During a recent trip to the grocery store while wearing the iconic red cap, Noor was accosted.

    […]

    And it’s not just Trump. From her perch in Western Europe, Noor bin Ladin has been a keen and meticulous consumer of conservative media and advocate of their most hot-button causes. Though soft-spoken with aristocratic graces, she can offer lengthy monologues railing against Spygate, tech censorship of conservative voices, mandatory mask-wearing, the New York Times’ discredited 1619 Project, and even Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s controversial executive order requiring nursing homes to accept seniors with COVID-19.

    Her favorite television show is Fox News’ “Tucker Carlson Tonight” and she’s chummy with Laura Loomer. The rising GOP star running for Congress in Florida is a ferocious opponent of radical Islam, but has also been accused by critics of Islamophobic remarks.

    “Laura has been very vocal about this and I commend her for being brave enough and speaking out,” said bin Ladin, who was not raised with any religion.

    Bin Ladin didn’t mince words about The Squad either, and offered high praise to The Post’s front page calling out Rep. Ilhan Omar’s “some people did something” remarks about 9/11.

    “You do have a situation now in America where you have people like Ilhan Omar who actively hate your country,” bin Ladin said, noting how Omar had urged “compassionate” sentences for 13 ISIS recruits busted in her home state of Minnesota.

    “It’s an honor to be able to go and live in the United States and make the most out of all the opportunities,” bin Ladin said, choking up. “If she hates it so much, why doesn’t she leave.”

    https://nypost.com/2020/09/05/osama-bin-ladens-niece-says-only-trump-can-prevent-another-9-11/

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Hyperborean

    What is surprising? I thought Bin Laden was fully CIA.

    , @songbird
    @Hyperborean

    Possibly, the sister of one of our commenters might know her.

    Would unironically put her in charge of the deportation squads.

    Replies: @Yahya

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @Hyperborean

    I think that this plays into the "stupid Arab" stereotype in both directions. Or maybe this is just an example of a specific stupid prominent Arab family in both directions and that one shouldn't generalize from them.

  488. @Hyperborean
    @Beckow


    US-UK finally joining the war in June 1944 with the Normandy landing was similar, a belated attempt to join in and mitigate the defeat of Germany.
     
    Ignoring the humilating Dieppe Raid of August 1942 as well as the successful landings at Sicily starting July 1943 that led to the further invasion of Italy, if we are purely counting army battles on European soil.

    I dislike the hazy Dunkirk to D-Day pop culture narrative that is prevalent, but there's no reason to say things that people can easily contradict.

    Replies: @Coconuts, @Beckow

    …Ignoring the humilating Dieppe Raid of August 1942 as well as the successful landings at Sicily starting July 1943

    I am not ignoring it – it was so minor that to call it a war against Germany is not credible. Anglos had active air war against Germany that really got going in the last two years of the war. Same with the land-lease for Russia that didn’t start in volume until late 1943.

    By late 1943 Germany and its allies were defeated by Russiat: the defeat happened gradually in 1943, starting in January in Stalingrad. Once Anglos realized that there won’t be a German victory or a stalemate they joined the war. But if you look at the timing the Anglos finally got going in the summer of 1943, with Normandy happening 10 months before the end of the war. At the same time as Normandy invasion, Russian did an Operation Bagration that was about 4 times the size of Normandy and Germans lost up to half million soldiers. These comparisons are not even close. It was unquestionably mainly Russia that defeated Germany.

  489. This recent interview with Douglas Macgregor is interesting. It is not about Ukraine, rather more a big picture of the West. He has a few comments to nudge team Trump. He was very candid about Lloyd Austin. He claims the word in the Islamic centers of power is that Sykes-Picot is dead. As he is pro-Nationalism I would like to know how he thinks of the Ukrainian view that they are fighting a Nationalist fight which he should therefore support.

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @QCIC

    I had never heard he claims kinship with MacArthur. Old soldiers never die!

    Did you catch the McGovern comment that everybody he knew from the CIA was dead? He said he didn't have "any inside sources any more".

    Replies: @QCIC

  490. @Hyperborean
    Not relevant to anything going on at the moment, but I still can't get over the fact that Bin Laden's Swiss niece is a Republican Ameriboo. Is it more or less bizarre than Stalin's American granddaughter?

    Bin Ladin (whose branch of the family has always spelled their name differently than her infamous uncle) lives in Switzerland but said she considers herself “an American at heart.” A full-size US flag hung in her childhood room at age 12 and her dream vacation is an RV trip across America.

    [...]

    “I have been a supporter of President Trump since he announced he was running in the early days in 2015. I have watched from afar and I admire this man’s resolve,” she said. “He must be re-elected … It’s vital for the future of not only America, but Western civilization as a whole.”

    “You look at all the terrorist attacks that have happened in Europe over the past 19 years. They have completely shaken us to the core … [Radical Islam] has completely infiltrated our society,” bin Ladin continued. “In the US it’s very worrying that the left has aligned itself completely with the people who share that ideology.”

    [...]

    Noor, who said she regularly wears a “Make America Great Again” hat (and occasionally a Trump bedtime onesie), has had to confront many Trump-haters on her side of the Atlantic. During a recent trip to the grocery store while wearing the iconic red cap, Noor was accosted.

    [...]

    And it’s not just Trump. From her perch in Western Europe, Noor bin Ladin has been a keen and meticulous consumer of conservative media and advocate of their most hot-button causes. Though soft-spoken with aristocratic graces, she can offer lengthy monologues railing against Spygate, tech censorship of conservative voices, mandatory mask-wearing, the New York Times’ discredited 1619 Project, and even Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s controversial executive order requiring nursing homes to accept seniors with COVID-19.

    Her favorite television show is Fox News’ “Tucker Carlson Tonight” and she’s chummy with Laura Loomer. The rising GOP star running for Congress in Florida is a ferocious opponent of radical Islam, but has also been accused by critics of Islamophobic remarks.

    “Laura has been very vocal about this and I commend her for being brave enough and speaking out,” said bin Ladin, who was not raised with any religion.

    Bin Ladin didn’t mince words about The Squad either, and offered high praise to The Post’s front page calling out Rep. Ilhan Omar’s “some people did something” remarks about 9/11.

    “You do have a situation now in America where you have people like Ilhan Omar who actively hate your country,” bin Ladin said, noting how Omar had urged “compassionate” sentences for 13 ISIS recruits busted in her home state of Minnesota.

    “It’s an honor to be able to go and live in the United States and make the most out of all the opportunities,” bin Ladin said, choking up. “If she hates it so much, why doesn’t she leave.”
     
    https://nypost.com/2020/09/05/osama-bin-ladens-niece-says-only-trump-can-prevent-another-9-11/

    Replies: @QCIC, @songbird, @Mr. XYZ

    What is surprising? I thought Bin Laden was fully CIA.

  491. @Hyperborean
    Not relevant to anything going on at the moment, but I still can't get over the fact that Bin Laden's Swiss niece is a Republican Ameriboo. Is it more or less bizarre than Stalin's American granddaughter?

    Bin Ladin (whose branch of the family has always spelled their name differently than her infamous uncle) lives in Switzerland but said she considers herself “an American at heart.” A full-size US flag hung in her childhood room at age 12 and her dream vacation is an RV trip across America.

    [...]

    “I have been a supporter of President Trump since he announced he was running in the early days in 2015. I have watched from afar and I admire this man’s resolve,” she said. “He must be re-elected … It’s vital for the future of not only America, but Western civilization as a whole.”

    “You look at all the terrorist attacks that have happened in Europe over the past 19 years. They have completely shaken us to the core … [Radical Islam] has completely infiltrated our society,” bin Ladin continued. “In the US it’s very worrying that the left has aligned itself completely with the people who share that ideology.”

    [...]

    Noor, who said she regularly wears a “Make America Great Again” hat (and occasionally a Trump bedtime onesie), has had to confront many Trump-haters on her side of the Atlantic. During a recent trip to the grocery store while wearing the iconic red cap, Noor was accosted.

    [...]

    And it’s not just Trump. From her perch in Western Europe, Noor bin Ladin has been a keen and meticulous consumer of conservative media and advocate of their most hot-button causes. Though soft-spoken with aristocratic graces, she can offer lengthy monologues railing against Spygate, tech censorship of conservative voices, mandatory mask-wearing, the New York Times’ discredited 1619 Project, and even Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s controversial executive order requiring nursing homes to accept seniors with COVID-19.

    Her favorite television show is Fox News’ “Tucker Carlson Tonight” and she’s chummy with Laura Loomer. The rising GOP star running for Congress in Florida is a ferocious opponent of radical Islam, but has also been accused by critics of Islamophobic remarks.

    “Laura has been very vocal about this and I commend her for being brave enough and speaking out,” said bin Ladin, who was not raised with any religion.

    Bin Ladin didn’t mince words about The Squad either, and offered high praise to The Post’s front page calling out Rep. Ilhan Omar’s “some people did something” remarks about 9/11.

    “You do have a situation now in America where you have people like Ilhan Omar who actively hate your country,” bin Ladin said, noting how Omar had urged “compassionate” sentences for 13 ISIS recruits busted in her home state of Minnesota.

    “It’s an honor to be able to go and live in the United States and make the most out of all the opportunities,” bin Ladin said, choking up. “If she hates it so much, why doesn’t she leave.”
     
    https://nypost.com/2020/09/05/osama-bin-ladens-niece-says-only-trump-can-prevent-another-9-11/

    Replies: @QCIC, @songbird, @Mr. XYZ

    Possibly, the sister of one of our commenters might know her.

    Would unironically put her in charge of the deportation squads.

    • Replies: @Yahya
    @songbird


    Possibly, the sister of one of our commenters might know her.

     

    Is this referring to yours truly?

    I'm close friends with one Bin Laden (Osama's nephew), and know of his close family members from a distance. I showed him Noor Bin Laden's twitter profile but he said he never met her (she is one of ~140 or so cousins).

    The Bin Ladens I know are fairly Westernized and have cosmopolitan backgrounds. My above-mentioned friend is half-English and currently lives in London. Completely secular and about as far away from an Islamist as you can get (his favorite pastime is drinking whiskey and smoking weed in his studio). Typical really of wealthy Arabs, who tend towards secularism rather than Islamism. Osama was kind of a fluke.

    Many of the male members of the Bin Laden family enjoy flying planes as a hobby, my friend included. Runs in the family.

    Replies: @songbird

  492. @Mr. XYZ
    @Beckow

    Romania at least chose a smart moment to switch sides during WWII. Prevented its own Jews from being mass murdered by the Nazis (at least in the Old Kingdom of Romania territories) and saved most of Budapest's Jews as well by compelling the Nazis to postpone their deportation to Auschwitz, which ultimately ended up never happening, though a lot of them (but apparently not a majority) did subsequently die in forced Nazi death marches.

    Could Hungary have avoided invading the USSR in 1941?

    Replies: @Beckow

    I would be careful about Romania, they were absolute swines and murderers. Read even in wikipedia:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Holocaust_in_Romania

    “…Romania ranks first among Holocaust perpetrator countries other than Germany…Romania being the only ally of the Third Reich that carried out its genocidal campaign without German intervention…the slaughter of Jews in Romanian-occupied territories was “a genocide separate from the Nazi Final Solution”…

    Could Hungary have avoided invading the USSR in 1941?

    What makes you think they wanted to avoid it? Hungary thought that Germany will win and the spoils will be shared with those who help. Of course they could have avoided it – other German allies like Vichy-France and Bulgaria didn’t join the invasion. Hungary chose to attack Russia and they paid a high price. That’s the way it works – today Hungary is trying to be smarter, we will see how that turns out.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Beckow


    I would be careful about Romania, they were absolute swines and murderers. Read even in wikipedia:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Holocaust_in_Romania

    “…Romania ranks first among Holocaust perpetrator countries other than Germany…Romania being the only ally of the Third Reich that carried out its genocidal campaign without German intervention…the slaughter of Jews in Romanian-occupied territories was “a genocide separate from the Nazi Final Solution”… ”
     

    Yes, I'm well-aware of what Antonescu did. Interestingly enough, in spite of his extreme brutality towards the Jews in Bessarabia and Bukovina, he was more well-disposed towards the Jews of the former Romanian Old Kingdom territories, with the exception of the 1941 Iasi pogrom, of course:

    https://web.archive.org/web/20160602145649/http://foreignpolicy.com/2016/02/05/the-antonescu-paradox-romania-world-war-ii-hitler/

    Of course, Antonescu's regime was overthrown in late August 1944 with King Michael's Coup in Romania, after which Romania immediately switched sides in WWII without getting its own remaining surviving Jews killed. It was even able to save most of the Jews of Budapest from mass murder (planned for August 27, 1944, four days after King Michael's Coup in Romania, before these planned mass deportations of Budapest Jews to Auschwitz got cancelled indefinitely) since the Nazis now had to devote extra resources of their own to deal with the Romanian defection.

    , @LT1488
    @Beckow

    “…Romania ranks first among Holocaust perpetrator countries other than Germany…Romania being the only ally of the Third Reich that carried out its genocidal campaign without German intervention…the slaughter of Jews in Romanian-occupied territories was “a genocide separate from the Nazi Final Solution”… ”

    Umm 6 million bros at it again......
    You really think there was a Holocaust lmao?

  493. Iowa live stream for those who are interested.

    With about 1/10 of locations reporting. Trump is ahead at over 50%. DeSantis and Haley are massively behind at 18% each. Vivek is stuck in 4th with a single digit performance.

    Will DeSantis or Haley call it quits after this humiliating defeat? Or, will they continue to New Hampshire on the 23rd?

    PEACE 😇

  494. @John Johnson
    @Barbarossa

    They also seem to make it hard for plebs to service things. I think the thought of non-specialists servicing their machines give German engineers palpitations.

    This is how I felt working on a Volvo. It really felt engineered to discourage you from working on it. Maybe they copied the German model?

    I've cussed at Japanese cars but only because I've come across stuff that expects you to be a 110 lb mechanic with 1.5" forearms.

    All new cars can honestly be pretty annoying. There are definitely parts where they have moved them to some needlessly annoying spot where they want you to give up and take it in upon seeing what is required. Well it's two weeks around here to even see a mechanic. So I've actually planned on taking a car in and then fixed it myself because I'm not waiting 2-3 weeks.

    Replies: @Barbarossa

    As I’ve mentioned before around here all my vehicles are over 20 years old and I can do all my own work in my service bay. We are just finishing up popping a new engine into my 89 F350. Fortunately for something that age I could get a clean used engine for $600. Hard to beat the price of maintenance.

    Interestingly, I know a guy with a lawncare/ plowing business and he said that he had more upkeep costs per year on his 6 year old bought new truck than the older 90’s and early 00’s trucks which were a fraction of the purchase price.

    I recently borrowed a 2018 F350 to do a hauling run and it was a nice truck but I wouldn’t buy it. I just couldn’t stop thinking about how much each of the souped-up components would cost to replace. What a headache.

    Plus, I hate it when my robot slaves get lippy and this truck kept on bugging me with all manner of idiotic notifications across the dash. “Trailer has been connected.” “Trailer has been disconnected.” “Door is open” etc. Criminy, it made me cranky and I groused at the truck all night. I sure don’t need my truck nagging me like I’m some hapless babe.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Barbarossa

    Interestingly, I know a guy with a lawncare/ plowing business and he said that he had more upkeep costs per year on his 6 year old bought new truck than the older 90’s and early 00’s trucks which were a fraction of the purchase price.

    I'm of the opinion that the late 90s cars and early 00s are some of the worst. That is when they were experimenting with a lot of electronic systems. Those are also the years where the bluetooth was garbage but they would do needless integrations with the stereo system. For example on chevrolets they actually ran the door ding through the speakers.

    But trucks are a different breed. The US companies wisely didn't experiment as much with the trucks.

    The SUVs in that period were also truck based and shared a lot of established technology.

    Plus, I hate it when my robot slaves get lippy and this truck kept on bugging me with all manner of idiotic notifications across the dash. “Trailer has been connected.” “Trailer has been disconnected.”

    Or the seatbelt ding when it thinks a bag on the passenger seat is a person.

    Replies: @Barbarossa

  495. @LT1488
    any chance that Karlin returns to this Blog?

    Replies: @Barbarossa

    He popped in a couple threads ago. Ya never know.

  496. @A123
    @QCIC


    , if the jobs were priced with all the costs included (call them the externalities) then the supply and demand might work out just with local people.
     
    I concur.

    Over supply of migrants, both legal and illegal, suppressed 'blue collar' wages. Off shoring is another destructive force for wage suppression. These led to delayed marriage and two income couples as a necessity. Both factors are known to be detrimental to TFR.

    One cannot bring back the 50's. However, the idea of a husband being able to support a wife and multiple children can return. It requires tightly controlling migration and MAGA Reindustrialization. Some things may cost more and be less available. That is a reasonable trade off for a functioning society on Main Street.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @QCIC, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    It is hard to understand why Israeli officials including senior political leaders and military commanders would publicly make these incriminating statements right before carrying out these acts. I can only assume it was through a mixture of rage post-Oct 7 and official arrogance.

    [MORE]

    Why is Ireland the most outspoken pro-Palestinian nation in the Western world? Why is South Africa the most outspoken pro-Palestinian nation in the whole world? It’s not coincidence.

    U.S. being dragged back into open-ended war in the Middle East by Israel. Pivot to Asia is now provisonally postponed to 2035

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere


    It is hard to understand why Israeli officials including senior political leaders and military commanders would publicly make these incriminating statements right before carrying out these acts. I can only assume it was through a mixture of rage post-Oct 7 and official arrogance.

     

    Israel's current government is full of stupid, intolerant morons. They also wanted to repeal the Grandchild Clause of Israel's Law of Return before the October 7 mass terrorist attack forced them to indefinitely postpone these extremely atrocious plans of theirs, thankfully. People such as myself (I currently live in the US, BTW, and have done so since March 2001) have no place in their Israel because my own Jewish ancestry is on the "wrong" branch of my family tree (Jewish paternal grandfather).
  497. @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    I would be careful about Romania, they were absolute swines and murderers. Read even in wikipedia:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Holocaust_in_Romania

    "...Romania ranks first among Holocaust perpetrator countries other than Germany...Romania being the only ally of the Third Reich that carried out its genocidal campaign without German intervention...the slaughter of Jews in Romanian-occupied territories was "a genocide separate from the Nazi Final Solution"... "


    Could Hungary have avoided invading the USSR in 1941?
     
    What makes you think they wanted to avoid it? Hungary thought that Germany will win and the spoils will be shared with those who help. Of course they could have avoided it - other German allies like Vichy-France and Bulgaria didn't join the invasion. Hungary chose to attack Russia and they paid a high price. That's the way it works - today Hungary is trying to be smarter, we will see how that turns out.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

    I would be careful about Romania, they were absolute swines and murderers. Read even in wikipedia:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Holocaust_in_Romania

    “…Romania ranks first among Holocaust perpetrator countries other than Germany…Romania being the only ally of the Third Reich that carried out its genocidal campaign without German intervention…the slaughter of Jews in Romanian-occupied territories was “a genocide separate from the Nazi Final Solution”… ”

    Yes, I’m well-aware of what Antonescu did. Interestingly enough, in spite of his extreme brutality towards the Jews in Bessarabia and Bukovina, he was more well-disposed towards the Jews of the former Romanian Old Kingdom territories, with the exception of the 1941 Iasi pogrom, of course:

    https://web.archive.org/web/20160602145649/http://foreignpolicy.com/2016/02/05/the-antonescu-paradox-romania-world-war-ii-hitler/

    Of course, Antonescu’s regime was overthrown in late August 1944 with King Michael’s Coup in Romania, after which Romania immediately switched sides in WWII without getting its own remaining surviving Jews killed. It was even able to save most of the Jews of Budapest from mass murder (planned for August 27, 1944, four days after King Michael’s Coup in Romania, before these planned mass deportations of Budapest Jews to Auschwitz got cancelled indefinitely) since the Nazis now had to devote extra resources of their own to deal with the Romanian defection.

  498. @Hyperborean
    Not relevant to anything going on at the moment, but I still can't get over the fact that Bin Laden's Swiss niece is a Republican Ameriboo. Is it more or less bizarre than Stalin's American granddaughter?

    Bin Ladin (whose branch of the family has always spelled their name differently than her infamous uncle) lives in Switzerland but said she considers herself “an American at heart.” A full-size US flag hung in her childhood room at age 12 and her dream vacation is an RV trip across America.

    [...]

    “I have been a supporter of President Trump since he announced he was running in the early days in 2015. I have watched from afar and I admire this man’s resolve,” she said. “He must be re-elected … It’s vital for the future of not only America, but Western civilization as a whole.”

    “You look at all the terrorist attacks that have happened in Europe over the past 19 years. They have completely shaken us to the core … [Radical Islam] has completely infiltrated our society,” bin Ladin continued. “In the US it’s very worrying that the left has aligned itself completely with the people who share that ideology.”

    [...]

    Noor, who said she regularly wears a “Make America Great Again” hat (and occasionally a Trump bedtime onesie), has had to confront many Trump-haters on her side of the Atlantic. During a recent trip to the grocery store while wearing the iconic red cap, Noor was accosted.

    [...]

    And it’s not just Trump. From her perch in Western Europe, Noor bin Ladin has been a keen and meticulous consumer of conservative media and advocate of their most hot-button causes. Though soft-spoken with aristocratic graces, she can offer lengthy monologues railing against Spygate, tech censorship of conservative voices, mandatory mask-wearing, the New York Times’ discredited 1619 Project, and even Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s controversial executive order requiring nursing homes to accept seniors with COVID-19.

    Her favorite television show is Fox News’ “Tucker Carlson Tonight” and she’s chummy with Laura Loomer. The rising GOP star running for Congress in Florida is a ferocious opponent of radical Islam, but has also been accused by critics of Islamophobic remarks.

    “Laura has been very vocal about this and I commend her for being brave enough and speaking out,” said bin Ladin, who was not raised with any religion.

    Bin Ladin didn’t mince words about The Squad either, and offered high praise to The Post’s front page calling out Rep. Ilhan Omar’s “some people did something” remarks about 9/11.

    “You do have a situation now in America where you have people like Ilhan Omar who actively hate your country,” bin Ladin said, noting how Omar had urged “compassionate” sentences for 13 ISIS recruits busted in her home state of Minnesota.

    “It’s an honor to be able to go and live in the United States and make the most out of all the opportunities,” bin Ladin said, choking up. “If she hates it so much, why doesn’t she leave.”
     
    https://nypost.com/2020/09/05/osama-bin-ladens-niece-says-only-trump-can-prevent-another-9-11/

    Replies: @QCIC, @songbird, @Mr. XYZ

    I think that this plays into the “stupid Arab” stereotype in both directions. Or maybe this is just an example of a specific stupid prominent Arab family in both directions and that one shouldn’t generalize from them.

  499. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GD0EYSDXIAEpXCJ.jpg

    Whereas Israel was being asked before the war to make a relatively limited commitment to eventual establishment of a Palestinian state, it will now need to go further in demonstrating that commitment while accepting return of the Palestinian Authority.


    https://twitter.com/TuckerCarlson/status/1745914010669609065

    Replies: @A123

    I will assume you went for this because you are wholly ignorant of international shipping.

    • High value CONTAINER ships such as the MAERSK HANGZHOU, which was attacked, run 18 meters of draft.
    • You are trying to draw a comparison to the GREAT OCEAN. Check the stats (1).

    The vessel GREAT OCEAN (IMO: 9278557, MMSI: 636019834) is a Bulk Carrier that was built in 2003 ( 21 years old ). It’s sailing under the flag of [LR] Liberia.

    The current draught of GREAT OCEAN as reported by AIS is 11.1 meters

    It is bulk (not container) so the cargo is much less valuable. And, at 7 meters less draft it is lightly loaded. This makes it uninteresting to Iranian backed Houthi pirates.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.myshiptracking.com/vessels/great-ocean-mmsi-636019834-imo-9278557

  500. @QCIC
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Fascinating. The last minute is the most interesting.

    I didn't realize that Jared Taylor is fluent in Japanese and French. I suppose that is why he sounds very strange, at least to me. His idiosyncratic accent and intonation do not help his communication on such a divisive issue.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    I think that his accent is Southern. IIRC, he was born in Virginia. He’s a true old-school Southern gentleman, complete with a general repulsion towards miscegenation (albeit thankfully NOT up to the point of actually supporting anti-miscegenation laws since he rightfully views such laws as being contrary to his desired principle of freedom of association).

    • Replies: @Matra
    @Mr. XYZ

    Maybe living in Japan away from other Americans he was overly influenced by his parents' accents which would've been formed before TV became ubiquitous. His accent doesn't really sound like old Virginia but does have the cadence of old American movies set in Waspy environments.

    , @QCIC
    @Mr. XYZ

    To my slightly Southern ears he has a non-standard speech pattern. He is recognizably from the South, though I always thought he had an affected style. Now I suspect his multilingualism is a better explanation. His Japanese in the video interview is impressive.

  501. @German_reader
    @Beckow


    Life under socialism (“commies”) in the CE Europe was an order of magnitude better than life under the feudal systems and early capitalism.
     
    Sure, in world historical perspective the CSSR was preferable to most systems. But was it really preferable to interwar Czechoslovakia with its multi-party democracy? Didn't its economic system perform well below what could have been expected in a moderate capitalist system (e.g. one tempered by some form of social democracy)? Such questions don't have anything to do with romanticization of Habsburgs etc.

    Replies: @Beckow

    …was it really preferable to interwar Czechoslovakia with its multi-party democracy?

    The interwar democracy wasn’t that great – by the late 30’s more than 50% of the people were against it, from socialists to nationalists. It was a rather lame ‘talking show” where poverty was quite severe and social services almost non-existent. The center in Prague run everything, it was a kind of middling oligarchy with legalistic methods to make sure that nothing changes – that’s why it collapsed and why in the first free election in 1946 commies got 40% and allied socialists almost 30%.

    It was very common in the “democratic” Czechoslovakia for the police to shoot into demonstrators and for the opponents to be put in jail – with the exception of the crazy early 50’s commie terror (1950-55), mostly against other commies and WW2 collaborators, the number of persecuted was substantially lower in 1955-89 than between 1918-38 – those are just numbers, data doesn’t lie.

    Didn’t its economic system perform well below what could have been expected in a moderate capitalist system

    What if...I think we will never know. The GNP in Czechoslovakia quadrupled between 1948 and 1989, the population increased by 50%, universal education and healthcare were established, there was no unemployment (even most women joined workforce w generous maternity leave), very little crime, culture absolutely blossomed – movies, music, etc…by 1970’s and 80’s almost all people were able to travel to the West if they had the money.

    Could they have done better? Possibly, Austria did better during that time from around the same basis. Commies made huge economic mistakes – they stupidly tried to de-monetize the economy (“look, the prices are going down!”) resulting in inefficiency and laziness. Towards the end small-scale corruption became endemic and so-called “market commies” wanted capitalism.

    But nobody was afraid of their boss and that is the kind of freedom the free capitalist societies can never have. Imagine having the freedom of not being afraid at work – the only real freedom that matters. Today people can only dream about that – close to 50% of people who lived in socialism consistently say that it was a better life. Who knows.

  502. @John Johnson
    @Matra

    Lira’s wife (presumably the mother of his two kids) is from eastern Ukraine. I believe he said something about them going to stay with relatives or friends in Belgorod early in the war – something he should’ve done too. Yes, he was an attention seeker, no question about that, but given that his family seems to identify with Russia that alone may explain his pro-Russian views.

    Lira never denied doxxing Western journalists.

    That's pretty low for someone who claims to promote journalistic freedom.

    I actually wonder if the Russians did their homework and wanted nothing to do with him.

    Maybe they knew about his medical condition and didn't want to take him. Perhaps they offered him a job at the front and nothing more.

    I certainly don't take any glee over his fate. Anyone who chain smokes and defends a mass murderer clearly has mental problems. I suspect he was at one point spurned or cheated on by a woman. His "red pill" videos are bitter and spiteful. I don't buy for one second that he was ever living some bachelor lifestyle where he was banging random Ukrainian girls. Not one second.

    His smoking habit most likely caught up to him and this is how he chose to go out. Depict himself as a free speech martyr that was oppressed by Ukraine even though he didn't need to be there and had nothing to say.

    In the videos you can see that he has an extreme nicotine addiction. Chain smoking is very bad for your health since your lungs never get a break. It's really just a form of suicide. His age is about right where it catches up to people. 2 or packs a day will just straight up f-cking kill you. People that smoke that much also tend to drink.

    Replies: @Matra, @Derer

    Anyone who chain smokes and defends a mass murderer clearly has mental problems

    So anyone who chain smokes has mental issues or do they also have to support a mass murderer like…just about every US president, except Trump, of the last forty years? You probably don’t realise far more people on earth consider what Israel is doing in Gaza to be mass murder (genocide?) than anything happening in Ukraine, and virtually all of them believe #GenocideJoe has given the go-ahead. Are all Joe Biden supporters suffering from mental problems?

    I don’t buy for one second that he was ever living some bachelor lifestyle where he was banging random Ukrainian girls. Not one second

    He didn’t claim to. If you’ve evidence to the contrary you should provide it. He did his Coach Red Pill videos when he lived in London’s Notting Hill. I watched maybe 20 or so of them and based on memory they were about politics – leftist psychology, Pinochet, the media, Solzhenitsyn & the USSR – along with advice for young men about women, and Alt-Right bickering & feuding, which he contributed mightily to as he was a shit-stirrer.

    He then moved to Kharkiv because of his wife & kids – separated I’m guessing. In Kharkiv he built some large work room, which he filmed every minute of, then I lost track of him for a couple of years as he stopped talking politics, before he reappeared just before the Ukraine war. If he was claiming to be a pick-up artist I don’t know when that was but it wasn’t within the last 7 or 8 years.

    His smoking habit most likely caught up to him and this is how he chose to go out.

    Can’t wait for some Russian liberal to die in prison & have Putin fans claim he was a chain smoker or former vodka drinker therefore he chose his death in prison.

    Chain smoking is very bad for your health since your lungs never get a break. It’s really just a form of suicide

    Prisoners in Western countries receive medical treatment. Ukraine supporters claim Ukraine is on its way to becoming a liberal democracy that we should support because our values are at stake. lol His death came too soon after his imprisonment to not be suspicious. Given the accusations from him and his family along with rare USGov. silence about an imprisoned American things look pretty suspicious. Ukraine is known for its corruption, human rights abuses, and even for putting foreign residents on hit lists for not agreeing with the regime. One has to assume the worst of such people.

    People that smoke that much also tend to drink.

    He claimed to be anti-alcohol. One of the advice videos I watched from maybe five years ago was about men who need alcohol to socialise. I think he was explaining why he went from idolising James Joyce to despising him. He seemed to have a low opinion of drinkers.

    But keep on trying to justify why people who die in the custody of US allies/proxies deserve to die because everyone here knows that’s what you really believe. You demonstrated at least a year ago on these boards that you are a US über alles (or perhaps über allen would be more apt) patriotard who lives vicariously through American wars.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Matra


    Anyone who chain smokes and defends a mass murderer clearly has mental problems
     
    So anyone who chain smokes has mental issues or do they also have to support a mass murderer like…just about every US president, except Trump, of the last forty years?

    The Iraqis view Saddam as the mass murder and not GWB. They have a functioning democracy despite naysayers predictions of civil war and collapse. They had a better turnout than many US areas:
    https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/iraq-holds-first-provincial-elections-decade-2023-12-18/

    We will see how history judges Putin but so far it isn't looking good.

    You probably don’t realise far more people on earth consider what Israel is doing in Gaza to be mass murder (genocide?) than anything happening in Ukraine

    Not convinced but my views are indeed in line with the UN. They view both Russia and Israel as aggressors at the moment and I agree. I think Israel has gone too far and I agree with the 143-5 UN vote on the Russian invasion being illegal.

    He didn’t claim to. If you’ve evidence to the contrary you should provide it. He did his Coach Red Pill videos when he lived in London’s Notting Hill.

    He discouraged marriage and told men to not date women in their 30s. That's encouraging a bachelor lifestyle. Are you suggesting he didn't follow his own advice? Well that is what I was saying. The guy was full of shit.

    He wiped all of his red pill videos so it is hard to quote him. But he is on record discouraging marriage and telling men to avoid women in their 30s and also single moms. Well for men in America that is excluding a huge chunk of women which is bad advice.

    How a sleezy dating coach became a pro-Putin shill
    https://news.yahoo.com/sleazy-american-dating-coach-became-013002090.html

    There are videos of him ranting about women on youtube. Like I said he comes across as bitter and resentful and not someone experienced with women.

    Can’t wait for some Russian liberal to die in prison & have Putin fans claim he was a chain smoker or former vodka drinker therefore he chose his death in prison.

    Are you suggesting he wasn't a chain smoker? I can source a video where he lights up multiple times during a discussion. The way he smokes is exactly like a chain smoker.

    But keep on trying to justify why people who die in the custody of US allies/proxies deserve to die because everyone here knows that’s what you really believe.

    What are you talking about? I already said that they should have put him in a debate instead of a jail cell. We don't know what happened and all evidence suggests he didn't ask the state department for help. The letter to his sister is odd and he doesn't explain how he got double pneumonia.
  503. Am fascinated by this new study which links the increased risk of MS in Northern Euros to a Yamnaya origin, with the speculation that it evolved for dealing with their animal diseases.

    In the past, I have dismissed similar speculations, thinking that it was probably more related to being a nomad (i.e. diarrhea is likely quite a bit more deadly, if you are traveling.) But zoonosis does catch my fancy now.

    I am tantalized by the idea that cows (for such are my biases) may have changed multiple genes, and that perhaps there was no benefit to lactose tolerance until some immune package was in place. (Which might help explain why it is not more widespread)

  504. @A123
    @Mikel


    Regardless of what happens with the Ukraine aid package in Congress (and it’s difficult to see a total cut of US military aid to Ukraine, especially if diplomacy doesn’t work and the conflict continues)
     
    Funding Kiev aggression is unpopular with MAGA, thus the House will load up any appropriation with things that do appeal to voters. Is Not-The-President Biden willing to agree to real border security and reinstating Trump's Stay in Mexico policy?

    It is easy to envision a near total cut during an election year. It is an "inch deep" issue. While the top line polling looks favourable, voters will not swing on this single policy. It may not be "total zero", but it looks like vastly less in 2024.

    A full end in 2025 seems certain. Cutting off the Veggie-In-Chief's foreign policy failures is a priority for Trump's 2nd term. The fact that it also highlights Burisma Biden's personal, corrupt cash flows makes it a double bonus.

    If Scholz and Macron want their puppet Zelensky to continue, Germany and France will have to foot the bill. Are they willing to spend €5 Billion/month?


    Ukraine is soon going to receive the long-awaited F-16s
     
    They are still training pilots. The window for a limited number of Netherlands transfers is now, at the earliest, in April. Suspiciously, no one is explaining the maintenance and logistics to keep the planes mission capable.

    What % of German provided Leopards are still in the field? Poor support is decommissioning them faster than combat losses. If Kiev cannot keep tanks in service, that does not bode well for much more complex combat aircraft.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Mr. XYZ

    Zionist framing of Hizbullah & allies electoral victory as an expansion of Iranian influence suggests democracy is a dangerous experiment unless its results are predetermined; it further strips the popular will of all agency & reduces the Lebanese people to foreign tools.

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    Are you aware that this site has a function [THIS THREAD]? There is a grey button for it on every post. For that function to work properly, you need to use REPLY to link your comments to the posts you are responding to (not a random one). This maintains thread integrity.

    • You attached your above rant about sociopath Khamenei's aggression as a connection to #192 about Ukraine. Nothing to do with your hatred of indigenous Palestinian Jews.
    • You threaded a different bit of unhinged gibberish to comment #1 about motor sports.

    If you intentionally and maliciously break site functionality, that is trolling that will get you added to the "Commenters to Ignore" list. Deliberately causing structural damage to website services is unacceptable.

    PEACE 😇

  505. @Mr. XYZ
    @QCIC

    I think that his accent is Southern. IIRC, he was born in Virginia. He's a true old-school Southern gentleman, complete with a general repulsion towards miscegenation (albeit thankfully NOT up to the point of actually supporting anti-miscegenation laws since he rightfully views such laws as being contrary to his desired principle of freedom of association).

    Replies: @Matra, @QCIC

    Maybe living in Japan away from other Americans he was overly influenced by his parents’ accents which would’ve been formed before TV became ubiquitous. His accent doesn’t really sound like old Virginia but does have the cadence of old American movies set in Waspy environments.

  506. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    Zionist framing of Hizbullah & allies electoral victory as an expansion of Iranian influence suggests democracy is a dangerous experiment unless its results are predetermined; it further strips the popular will of all agency & reduces the Lebanese people to foreign tools.

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FTGHEafXsAEl1Il.jpg

    Replies: @A123

    Are you aware that this site has a function [THIS THREAD]? There is a grey button for it on every post. For that function to work properly, you need to use REPLY to link your comments to the posts you are responding to (not a random one). This maintains thread integrity.

    • You attached your above rant about sociopath Khamenei’s aggression as a connection to #192 about Ukraine. Nothing to do with your hatred of indigenous Palestinian Jews.
    • You threaded a different bit of unhinged gibberish to comment #1 about motor sports.

    If you intentionally and maliciously break site functionality, that is trolling that will get you added to the “Commenters to Ignore” list. Deliberately causing structural damage to website services is unacceptable.

    PEACE 😇

  507. @QCIC
    This recent interview with Douglas Macgregor is interesting. It is not about Ukraine, rather more a big picture of the West. He has a few comments to nudge team Trump. He was very candid about Lloyd Austin. He claims the word in the Islamic centers of power is that Sykes-Picot is dead. As he is pro-Nationalism I would like to know how he thinks of the Ukrainian view that they are fighting a Nationalist fight which he should therefore support.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DtCS7vxuhyQ

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    I had never heard he claims kinship with MacArthur. Old soldiers never die!

    Did you catch the McGovern comment that everybody he knew from the CIA was dead? He said he didn’t have “any inside sources any more”.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    No, but since he is ex-CIA I assume he is lying :)

  508. @Mr. XYZ
    @QCIC

    I think that his accent is Southern. IIRC, he was born in Virginia. He's a true old-school Southern gentleman, complete with a general repulsion towards miscegenation (albeit thankfully NOT up to the point of actually supporting anti-miscegenation laws since he rightfully views such laws as being contrary to his desired principle of freedom of association).

    Replies: @Matra, @QCIC

    To my slightly Southern ears he has a non-standard speech pattern. He is recognizably from the South, though I always thought he had an affected style. Now I suspect his multilingualism is a better explanation. His Japanese in the video interview is impressive.

  509. @German_reader
    @Gerard1234


    Russia doesn’t kill civilians, Ukraine loves killing civilians
     
    Nah, you both don't have much compunction about killing civilians (nor about habitual lying). Very similar mentality. Not surprising too, you both stem from the same rotten tree after all.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Gerard1234

    Nah, you both don’t have much compunction about killing civilians (nor about habitual lying). Very similar mentality. Not surprising too, you both stem from the same rotten tree after all.

    It just proves what a class act I am that I won’t insult you for this particular comment. Why? Because although your comment is offensive and 100% disagree with it….its intellectually honest, so I have no problem . It’s clear there is an eternal thought from German intellectuals that Slavs are untermensch compared to themselves. It’s good to read from comments as yours that effectively you think Ukronazis and Russians are the same people – and probably why on some subconscious level think the insanely high levels of ukrainian deaths are “Russian deaths” anyway.

    When there is intellectually dishonest, repulsive filth like your garbage about the Belgorod war crime – then I correctly reply with insults.

    On the “don’t have much compunction about killing civilians “:

    1. Mariupol, Kramatorsk and other important places in 2014 were exited by LDNR heroes relatively peacefully and quickly to save and prioritise civilian lives, immediately when it became clear that Russia were not willing to commit enough resources or had the political will to take in this part of Donbass (i.e they were looking to do conciliatory gesture to help political settlement in allowing 404 these hugely economically important area…..even though more than enough men willing to go and fight and local support to continue fighting and annihilate the ukronazis in Slavyansk, Kramatorsk, anywhere). Remember dimwit, that all this with Slaviansk, Mariupol and others happened not too long before Banderastan were FORCED into 1st Minsk Agreements by LDNR smashing them and the potential for more of this.

    Western scum tactics and instructions for the Ukronazi plankton would ( as proved 8 years later) be the exact opposite

    2. Russia evacuates huge numbers of civilians from the frontline weeks before the start of the SMO (I think 80-120k at least). Ukronazis do ZERO evacuation in this time,while massively increasing their number of artillery strikes.

    3. Different to 404 and it’s multiple waves of mobilisations and seizing of anybody off the street to then be cannon fodder….. we have done a partial one and every Russian is free to leave the country or return to it (important in the context of western historical lies and some truth about Soviet control of civilian border movement)

    4. Every single talk from the ukronazis of “repurposed” S-300 or S-200 missile strikes that have killed civilians…….are either ridiculous lies to cover for their air Defence mislaunches or outright false-flag attacks from the Nazi regime. There has been a very high number of these

    5.Kherson on wrong side of the Dnieper. We could easily defend and keep control of the city but it still remain an obviously dangerous situation for us and the civilians. Russia mass evacuates civilians and vacates Kherson. Again, compare to the exact opposite from ukronazi actions when evacuation is most sensible option.

    6.In 2022 SMO in Mariuopol, Ukronazi scum get smashed and destroyed embarrassingly easily as Russia secure key objective in SMO. These highly motivated and “elite” soldiers (LOL) then “resist” Russia…..by hiding underground the extensive tunnel network under the Azovstal plant, ocassionally coming out to “fight” by throwing a hand grenade into the air for social media video…..then return to the job of filming themselves dying from gangreme meme videos for social media!

    …….and these pussies are supposed to be the “heroes” of this freakshow.

    Our guys risked ( and sadly some of these heroes died) solely in the purpose of evacuating civilians from “agreed” safe routes out of the city , that of course the Banderites did not fullfil that agreement.

    Azov took nearly 2000 civilians with them underground, most not their families . So a white HAMAS situation for 404. I don’t see how that isn’t the exact same for 404 in Azovstal as with Hamas taking ( much less) Israeli hostages

    6. I already mentioned the use of a bomb on a civilian truck, killing more civilians for a pointless, evil but sick ” PR stunt” on the Crimean bridge that the ukronazis did ( blatantly with the planning, assistance and order of Anglo-American scum).

    Clearly for myself evidence, logic, an IQ over 2, precedent,any knowledge of these people and how they think indicates that Ukronazis did all these crimes – Irpin/Bucha fakes, “rapes”, Novaya Kakhovka Dam, several notable mass-murder of civilian events from MLRS fire – but let me be uneccesarily generous to you by saying it’s an issue of faith for you as to giving responsibility to sifr for these crimes. We can all accept that if it’s clear that ukronazi regime did the Novaya Kakhovka dam destruction, then all these other events mass killing civilians they are lying for every event.

    7. You aware of German , mass and sadistic crimes against civilians in WW2?

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @Gerard1234


    You aware of German , mass and sadistic crimes against civilians in WW2?
     
    No, I have never heard of that, totally news to me.

    It’s clear there is an eternal thought from German intellectuals that Slavs are untermensch compared to themselves.
     
    I wasn't thinking of it being so much a Slav thing. More like a "Soviet legacy" thing (not just regarding civilians, e.g. Arestovych in the interview I linked to said Ukraine was throwing away lives of its soldiers in a careless manner, and also attributed that to a Soviet-like mentality). But I know of course you'll disagree since you're one of those who thinks the Soviet Union was wonderful in every respect.
    As for whether specific incidents in the current war included deliberate targeting of civilians or not, I don't care to discuss it all in detail. I think both sides have done some pretty dubious stuff (if it makes you happy: I did feel revulsion at Ukraine's under-handed bombing of the Kerch bridge, also wasn't positively impressed by the recent Belgorod strike, as my comment indicates that Ukraine shouldn't receive Western long-range missiles when it does something like that. But I also think that Russian troops killed civilians at Bucha; it wasn't quite the massacre Western msm tried to present it as, but definitely war crimes).
    However, as I've written before, so far at least war crimes against civilians aren't the dominant feature of this war. It's mostly a conventional war, in which large numbers of regular troops are being killed at the front. So focus on civilian deaths is more for propaganda purposes than anything else.

    Replies: @Gerard1234, @Mikel

  510. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @QCIC

    I had never heard he claims kinship with MacArthur. Old soldiers never die!

    Did you catch the McGovern comment that everybody he knew from the CIA was dead? He said he didn't have "any inside sources any more".

    Replies: @QCIC

    No, but since he is ex-CIA I assume he is lying 🙂

  511. @Barbarossa
    @John Johnson

    As I've mentioned before around here all my vehicles are over 20 years old and I can do all my own work in my service bay. We are just finishing up popping a new engine into my 89 F350. Fortunately for something that age I could get a clean used engine for $600. Hard to beat the price of maintenance.

    Interestingly, I know a guy with a lawncare/ plowing business and he said that he had more upkeep costs per year on his 6 year old bought new truck than the older 90's and early 00's trucks which were a fraction of the purchase price.

    I recently borrowed a 2018 F350 to do a hauling run and it was a nice truck but I wouldn't buy it. I just couldn't stop thinking about how much each of the souped-up components would cost to replace. What a headache.

    Plus, I hate it when my robot slaves get lippy and this truck kept on bugging me with all manner of idiotic notifications across the dash. "Trailer has been connected." "Trailer has been disconnected." "Door is open" etc. Criminy, it made me cranky and I groused at the truck all night. I sure don't need my truck nagging me like I'm some hapless babe.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Interestingly, I know a guy with a lawncare/ plowing business and he said that he had more upkeep costs per year on his 6 year old bought new truck than the older 90’s and early 00’s trucks which were a fraction of the purchase price.

    I’m of the opinion that the late 90s cars and early 00s are some of the worst. That is when they were experimenting with a lot of electronic systems. Those are also the years where the bluetooth was garbage but they would do needless integrations with the stereo system. For example on chevrolets they actually ran the door ding through the speakers.

    But trucks are a different breed. The US companies wisely didn’t experiment as much with the trucks.

    The SUVs in that period were also truck based and shared a lot of established technology.

    Plus, I hate it when my robot slaves get lippy and this truck kept on bugging me with all manner of idiotic notifications across the dash. “Trailer has been connected.” “Trailer has been disconnected.”

    Or the seatbelt ding when it thinks a bag on the passenger seat is a person.

    • Replies: @Barbarossa
    @John Johnson


    I’m of the opinion that the late 90s cars and early 00s are some of the worst.
     
    I feel like GM had a particularly bad period around this time. Their vehicles looked spectacularly awful and seemed very issue prone. I go out of my way to get the most basic trim package on vehicles so I've been kind of insulated. My current non-truck vehicles are a 93 Plymouth Voyager and a 96 Ford E150 and I feel like the early 90's era is pretty ideal. They had enough sophistication to be really efficient and reliable but were still quite simple and easy to diagnose. It's too much diminished returns for the added failure points and complication from there on out.

    In addition to my 89F350 I have Ford F250's from 99 and 00 and they are the best. Just fantastic bulletproof trucks and much better in every system than the 89. Ford only ditched the 7.3 Turbodiesel because of Federal emissions requirements which is a shame. The current 6.7 seems like a good motor finally but I don't really need all the power (and price tag) anyway. I prefer to keep under the 26k gross weight limit allowing me to keep away from the next tiers of DOT regs. My 7.3s have never failed to pull my 14k trailer with gusto so I don't see why I'd want to upgrade.

    The thing that was most striking driving the borrowed newer Ford was how much it was loaded with gimmicky stuff. I guess that is the nature of the vehicle arms race these days.

    Replies: @Sher Singh, @Sher Singh

  512. @AP
    @LT1488

    They are a little bit like Central Europe's analogue to Belarusians. Except their "Russia" is Hungary.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    It’s quite interesting that throughout history Slovaks have served as the younger brothers to both the Hungarians and the Czechs. They served as the younger brothers to the Hungarians for much, much longer, but Czech rule was probably better for them than Hungarian rule, at least so long as the Czechs actually had a foreign protector behind themselves and the Slovaks (they didn’t in 1938-1939). I don’t seem to recall Czechia trying to forcibly Czechify the Slovaks like Hungary did with the Slovaks with its decades-long pre-WWI Magyarization campaign:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magyarization

    I do suspect that, out of Greater Hungary’s large subject peoples, the Slovaks were probably the easiest ones to successfully Magyarize had Hungary had even more time to do so:

    Slovaks, after all, are mostly Catholic just like Hungarians (Magyars) themselves are. Ruthenians (Ukrainians), Romanians, Serbs, and Croats are not Catholic.

    (Hungarian Jews were, of course, largely successfully Magyarized, but they are a much smaller group and their high average IQ and large amounts of success made them stand out from the Magyars and thus often made Magyars unwilling to accept them as their own even when these Jews themselves were indeed willing to be Magyarized. In contrast, AFAIK, Slovaks and Hungarians (Magyars) have a roughly equal average IQ, so there’s no superiority/inferiority complex going on between them in regards to each other, at least in regards to their mental abilities.)

    BTW, it would be cool if Hungary, Slovakia, and Croatia formed a Greater Hungary within the EU (a confederation within a confederation) while Czechia, Austria, and Slovenia formed a Greater Austria within the EU (another confederation within a confederation).

    • Replies: @Derer
    @Mr. XYZ

    People usually make mistake by assuming Hungarians in Hungary interchangeably with ethnic Magyars. During Hapsburg years there were only 39% Magyars in the area of Hungary, the rest comprised mostly of Slavs.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    , @WS
    @Mr. XYZ

    Croats are very, very Catholic!?
    and BTW why to make some new superstructure out of very homogeneous states?
    K&K monarchy looks simphatietic only on old postcards and maybe as well in many very new Sisi dedicated movies financially supported by EU.
    Coincidence that this very issue (restoration of Habsburgs) is open here again and again in past year?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    , @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    Last summer, Orban was even more popular in Slovakia than he was in Hungary. Slovaks might wish they could be reunited with their older Magyar brothers and resume their servitude:

    https://hungarytoday.hu/survey-viktor-orban-most-popular-in-slovakia-and-bulgaria/

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    , @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    I am not sure what "younger brothers" means, but ok. In Czecho-slovakia in 1918 there was the ideology of a single nation, that we were the "same". The western Slovak dialect spoken by most educated Slovaks was very similar to the Moravian dialect - around the border it was identical, and the sense of unity was very strong. That region is very Protestant and most leaders of the Slovak national movement were Protestants from the central-western region who studied in Prague.

    Masaryk's father was Slovak, so were Stefanik, Bata (biggest businessman), Dubcek, Husak - in the 70-80's the complaint in Prague was that that they were ruled by Slovaks, but they were actually consciously Czechoslovak. It is different now, but we are very inter-mixed.

    With Magyars it was hard in 1900-1914, and the languages are too far apart. But calling them "Asiats" is idiotic, AP is living in some half-baked 'merican' world were he misunderstands things.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Mr. XYZ

  513. @Mr. Hack
    @LT1488

    They probably acquired this trait from their former Hungarian masters, "Follow the Leader":

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F7asH_-WYAABSQ0.jpg:large

    Replies: @LT1488

    Well don’t tell slovaks in the face that they are similar to ”Magyars”, they take great offence to that.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @LT1488


    Well don’t tell slovaks in the face that they are similar to ”Magyars”, they take great offence to that.
     
    Yea, these things are often unpredictable. I was surprised to learn from my grad student from Sicily that calling a Sicilian “Italian” is a grave offense. One of my colleagues has a boyfriend from Barcelona. When he went to visit his family, she asked him in a message how are things in Spain. He angrily answered that he is not in Spain, he is in Catalonia. My take-home message: you gotta be sensitive and sensible.
  514. @AnonfromTN
    @LT1488


    Sunak isn’t even European though.
     
    Apparently from elites’ point of view a Paki is European enough to serve as a figurehead. The “lady” before him was British, but if anything, she was even more pathetic. As they say, formerly Great formerly Britain.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @LT1488

    As they say, formerly Great formerly Britain.

    well well well don’t tell that to Mr Galkovsky and his fans

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @LT1488


    don’t tell that to Mr Galkovsky and his fans
     
    I won’t: you must be nice to people with limited abilities, including people with incurable mental disorders.
  515. @AP
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    The first place pictured looks, okay, not like a village but like a small, quiet, sleepy provincial Russian town. Yet that was how parts of central Moscow were in the early 2000s. It was rather charming.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Could use more Central Asians, don’t you think? And Hindus, Sikhs, and Jains, no?

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. XYZ

    It's a very interesting question, actually. Specifically whether the Muslims that Western Europe got could have done a better job of integrating had they ended up in Russia instead (especially assuming no decades of Communist rule for Russia during the 20th century, that is), especially in a Russia that would have been more Muslim by keeping Central Asia.

    Russia was already described as being a positive influence on its Muslims as early as 1918:

    https://books.google.com/books?id=0O4-AQAAMAAJ&pg=PA361&dq=afghanistan+macedonia&hl=en&newbks=1&newbks_redir=0&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwj2j8-9496DAxX5OUQIHXgBBcoQ6AF6BAgMEAI#v=onepage&q=afghanistan%20macedonia&f=false

    Groups such as South Asian Muslims should, at least, be fairly close in culture to Central Asian Muslims, or at least Central Asian Muslims before they were exposed to decades of Communist rule, no?

    What do you think about this, AP?

  516. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    It is hard to understand why Israeli officials including senior political leaders and military commanders would publicly make these incriminating statements right before carrying out these acts. I can only assume it was through a mixture of rage post-Oct 7 and official arrogance.

    Why is Ireland the most outspoken pro-Palestinian nation in the Western world? Why is South Africa the most outspoken pro-Palestinian nation in the whole world? It's not coincidence.

    U.S. being dragged back into open-ended war in the Middle East by Israel. Pivot to Asia is now provisonally postponed to 2035

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F964zjXWkAASOfc.jpg

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    It is hard to understand why Israeli officials including senior political leaders and military commanders would publicly make these incriminating statements right before carrying out these acts. I can only assume it was through a mixture of rage post-Oct 7 and official arrogance.

    Israel’s current government is full of stupid, intolerant morons. They also wanted to repeal the Grandchild Clause of Israel’s Law of Return before the October 7 mass terrorist attack forced them to indefinitely postpone these extremely atrocious plans of theirs, thankfully. People such as myself (I currently live in the US, BTW, and have done so since March 2001) have no place in their Israel because my own Jewish ancestry is on the “wrong” branch of my family tree (Jewish paternal grandfather).

  517. @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    the sad switche-roos by Italy, Romania, Hungary…were pointless.
     
    Not quite. Romanian king even got the Order of Victory from Stalin.

    Besides, as US and UK agreed to keep Romania and Hungary in the Soviet zone, Soviet propaganda never mentioned the atrocities committed by Romanian and Hungarian troops. In fact, Romanians murdered most Jews in Odessa, whereas by the accounts of those who happened to be on temporarily occupied Soviet territories, Hungarians were worse for the civilians than Germans. By their brutality Hungarians far exceeded Germans, approaching banderites:
    https://www.ilawjournals.com/why-vatutin-ordered-not-to-take-prisoners-hungarian-soldiers-of-hitler/
    That’s why in the battle of Voronezh Soviet commander Vatutin issued an order that Hungarians should not be taken prisoners. The order was followed: virtually all Hungarian troops near Voronezh were killed.


    US-UK finally joining the war in June 1944 with the Normandy landing was similar, a belated attempt to join in and mitigate the defeat of Germany.
     
    Yes, by June 1944 the outcome of the war was already assured. However, late entrance of “Allies” in the war against Nazi Germany was mostly to participate in the division of spoils with minimal investment into actual fighting. Saving and then using numerous Nazis was probably not the main goal.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Beckow, @LT1488, @Mr. XYZ

    Hungarians when they took over Vojvodina in Serbia, they treated it better than say Croats or Albanians treated their parts of occupied Serbia.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @LT1488


    Hungarians when they took over Vojvodina in Serbia, they treated it better than say Croats or Albanians treated their parts of occupied Serbia.
     
    I am sure they did: only German Nazis and Ukies can compete in brutality with those occupiers. Considering the comparison, it was not hard. Say, a dog does not need to be exceptionally smart to be smarter than Baerbock or Biden.
  518. @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    I would be careful about Romania, they were absolute swines and murderers. Read even in wikipedia:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Holocaust_in_Romania

    "...Romania ranks first among Holocaust perpetrator countries other than Germany...Romania being the only ally of the Third Reich that carried out its genocidal campaign without German intervention...the slaughter of Jews in Romanian-occupied territories was "a genocide separate from the Nazi Final Solution"... "


    Could Hungary have avoided invading the USSR in 1941?
     
    What makes you think they wanted to avoid it? Hungary thought that Germany will win and the spoils will be shared with those who help. Of course they could have avoided it - other German allies like Vichy-France and Bulgaria didn't join the invasion. Hungary chose to attack Russia and they paid a high price. That's the way it works - today Hungary is trying to be smarter, we will see how that turns out.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

    “…Romania ranks first among Holocaust perpetrator countries other than Germany…Romania being the only ally of the Third Reich that carried out its genocidal campaign without German intervention…the slaughter of Jews in Romanian-occupied territories was “a genocide separate from the Nazi Final Solution”… ”

    Umm 6 million bros at it again……
    You really think there was a Holocaust lmao?

  519. @John Johnson
    @Matra

    Lira’s wife (presumably the mother of his two kids) is from eastern Ukraine. I believe he said something about them going to stay with relatives or friends in Belgorod early in the war – something he should’ve done too. Yes, he was an attention seeker, no question about that, but given that his family seems to identify with Russia that alone may explain his pro-Russian views.

    Lira never denied doxxing Western journalists.

    That's pretty low for someone who claims to promote journalistic freedom.

    I actually wonder if the Russians did their homework and wanted nothing to do with him.

    Maybe they knew about his medical condition and didn't want to take him. Perhaps they offered him a job at the front and nothing more.

    I certainly don't take any glee over his fate. Anyone who chain smokes and defends a mass murderer clearly has mental problems. I suspect he was at one point spurned or cheated on by a woman. His "red pill" videos are bitter and spiteful. I don't buy for one second that he was ever living some bachelor lifestyle where he was banging random Ukrainian girls. Not one second.

    His smoking habit most likely caught up to him and this is how he chose to go out. Depict himself as a free speech martyr that was oppressed by Ukraine even though he didn't need to be there and had nothing to say.

    In the videos you can see that he has an extreme nicotine addiction. Chain smoking is very bad for your health since your lungs never get a break. It's really just a form of suicide. His age is about right where it catches up to people. 2 or packs a day will just straight up f-cking kill you. People that smoke that much also tend to drink.

    Replies: @Matra, @Derer

    Chain smoking is very bad for your health since your lungs never get a break.

    I agree…however some examples make mockery of that assertion, namely former German Chancellor Helmut Schmidt smoked 2 packs a day until his death at 97 year old – poster boy for tobacco industry.

    Another myth is stress which is considered to be bad for your heath. There was no greater stress than for former Stalin’s politburo members, living constantly under enormous stress. They died fat and old Kaganovich 98, Molotov 96, Malenkov 87, Voroshilov 88 etc.

    • Replies: @Mikel
    @Derer


    German Chancellor Helmut Schmidt smoked 2 packs a day until his death at 97 year old
     
    Not to mention that a guy in such poor health that he was about to die of natural causes would be utterly unable to ride a motorbike from Kharkiv to the Hungarian border, as anyone who has ever ridden a bike would know. The only thing that killed Lira was not keeping his mouth shut.

    I guess it's not worth it to focus too much on the death of this man when so many others have died probably more nonsensically in that part of the world and will surely continue to do so but so many ironies to exploit here. Among them the fact that JJ has spent months lecturing us on how terrible Putin's regime is because people who oppose him are made to die early and when that is exactly what happens to someone who dared to open his mouth against the regime he supports right next door (a citizen of his own country at that), he makes all kinds of excuses to minimize the incident.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  520. @John Johnson
    @Barbarossa

    Interestingly, I know a guy with a lawncare/ plowing business and he said that he had more upkeep costs per year on his 6 year old bought new truck than the older 90’s and early 00’s trucks which were a fraction of the purchase price.

    I'm of the opinion that the late 90s cars and early 00s are some of the worst. That is when they were experimenting with a lot of electronic systems. Those are also the years where the bluetooth was garbage but they would do needless integrations with the stereo system. For example on chevrolets they actually ran the door ding through the speakers.

    But trucks are a different breed. The US companies wisely didn't experiment as much with the trucks.

    The SUVs in that period were also truck based and shared a lot of established technology.

    Plus, I hate it when my robot slaves get lippy and this truck kept on bugging me with all manner of idiotic notifications across the dash. “Trailer has been connected.” “Trailer has been disconnected.”

    Or the seatbelt ding when it thinks a bag on the passenger seat is a person.

    Replies: @Barbarossa

    I’m of the opinion that the late 90s cars and early 00s are some of the worst.

    I feel like GM had a particularly bad period around this time. Their vehicles looked spectacularly awful and seemed very issue prone. I go out of my way to get the most basic trim package on vehicles so I’ve been kind of insulated. My current non-truck vehicles are a 93 Plymouth Voyager and a 96 Ford E150 and I feel like the early 90’s era is pretty ideal. They had enough sophistication to be really efficient and reliable but were still quite simple and easy to diagnose. It’s too much diminished returns for the added failure points and complication from there on out.

    In addition to my 89F350 I have Ford F250’s from 99 and 00 and they are the best. Just fantastic bulletproof trucks and much better in every system than the 89. Ford only ditched the 7.3 Turbodiesel because of Federal emissions requirements which is a shame. The current 6.7 seems like a good motor finally but I don’t really need all the power (and price tag) anyway. I prefer to keep under the 26k gross weight limit allowing me to keep away from the next tiers of DOT regs. My 7.3s have never failed to pull my 14k trailer with gusto so I don’t see why I’d want to upgrade.

    The thing that was most striking driving the borrowed newer Ford was how much it was loaded with gimmicky stuff. I guess that is the nature of the vehicle arms race these days.

    • Replies: @Sher Singh
    @Barbarossa

    Post 2020 it's gotten better due to the chip shortage.
    I like features such as adaptive cruise or lane keep/blind spot warning.

    Driving in a big metro is a hella dif experience or on the 401 with drunk/asleep truckers.
    Fuel efficiency + cab size is also a plus.
    ---

    My main gripe about newer trucks is the death of the small truck due to CAFE standards.
    However, hybrid or plug-in hybrid promises to bring that back.

    ===
    I don't bother to connect my phone or use the in-car nav though.

    , @Sher Singh
    @Barbarossa

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khoa

    Water Buffalo raw milk is legal up here so gonna get into that.

    Mom wants to make Khoa Pinnia - I'm 50-50.
    Khoa has like 400cal in 100g.
    Only 20g protein for 400cal.

    Gonna look into how I can use whey protein in it.
    Ultimately, a Pinni is like flour, jaggery, khoa & dry fruit.
    Could probably replace the flour with protein powder & jaggery with splenda?

    https://cookpad.com/in/recipes/13811024-pinni-a-simple-easy-recipe-of-making-pinni

    https://www.nutritionix.com/i/nutritionix/khoya-1-cup/5c925dd6a119d5c65924d02a

    Tweet on structure of raw milk, blood & pasteurized milk.

    https://twitter.com/mmiakapro/status/1747783710844289379

  521. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Could use more Central Asians, don't you think? And Hindus, Sikhs, and Jains, no?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    It’s a very interesting question, actually. Specifically whether the Muslims that Western Europe got could have done a better job of integrating had they ended up in Russia instead (especially assuming no decades of Communist rule for Russia during the 20th century, that is), especially in a Russia that would have been more Muslim by keeping Central Asia.

    Russia was already described as being a positive influence on its Muslims as early as 1918:

    https://books.google.com/books?id=0O4-AQAAMAAJ&pg=PA361&dq=afghanistan+macedonia&hl=en&newbks=1&newbks_redir=0&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwj2j8-9496DAxX5OUQIHXgBBcoQ6AF6BAgMEAI#v=onepage&q=afghanistan%20macedonia&f=false

    Groups such as South Asian Muslims should, at least, be fairly close in culture to Central Asian Muslims, or at least Central Asian Muslims before they were exposed to decades of Communist rule, no?

    What do you think about this, AP?

  522. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    It's quite interesting that throughout history Slovaks have served as the younger brothers to both the Hungarians and the Czechs. They served as the younger brothers to the Hungarians for much, much longer, but Czech rule was probably better for them than Hungarian rule, at least so long as the Czechs actually had a foreign protector behind themselves and the Slovaks (they didn't in 1938-1939). I don't seem to recall Czechia trying to forcibly Czechify the Slovaks like Hungary did with the Slovaks with its decades-long pre-WWI Magyarization campaign:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magyarization

    I do suspect that, out of Greater Hungary's large subject peoples, the Slovaks were probably the easiest ones to successfully Magyarize had Hungary had even more time to do so:

    https://preview.redd.it/9z2zzo6am2r71.png?width=640&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=097af65f11c92335d05889c085d6e243b595125b

    Slovaks, after all, are mostly Catholic just like Hungarians (Magyars) themselves are. Ruthenians (Ukrainians), Romanians, Serbs, and Croats are not Catholic.

    (Hungarian Jews were, of course, largely successfully Magyarized, but they are a much smaller group and their high average IQ and large amounts of success made them stand out from the Magyars and thus often made Magyars unwilling to accept them as their own even when these Jews themselves were indeed willing to be Magyarized. In contrast, AFAIK, Slovaks and Hungarians (Magyars) have a roughly equal average IQ, so there's no superiority/inferiority complex going on between them in regards to each other, at least in regards to their mental abilities.)

    BTW, it would be cool if Hungary, Slovakia, and Croatia formed a Greater Hungary within the EU (a confederation within a confederation) while Czechia, Austria, and Slovenia formed a Greater Austria within the EU (another confederation within a confederation).

    Replies: @Derer, @WS, @AP, @Beckow

    People usually make mistake by assuming Hungarians in Hungary interchangeably with ethnic Magyars. During Hapsburg years there were only 39% Magyars in the area of Hungary, the rest comprised mostly of Slavs.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Derer

    Yes, I know what Greater Hungary's ethnic demographics were:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/de/Hungarians_in_Hungary_%281890%29.png

    It's still interesting that it survived as a compact political unit for many centuries, however, albeit with a break during slightly over 1.5 centuries of Ottoman rule.

    Magyars generally lived on the Hungarian plains (Pannonian Basin) while minorities generally lived on or near the mountains:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/01/Carpathian_Basin-Pannonian_Basin.jpg

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/2/23/Pannonian_Basin.svg/1280px-Pannonian_Basin.svg.png

    This also helps explain why Hungarian-majority areas near the border with the new (1920) Trianon Hungary got handed over to neighboring countries:

    https://english.atlatszo.hu/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Trianonline.jpg

    Specifically, in some cases, such as for Czechoslovakia and Romania, the main lines of communication (roads and railroads) can through those areas in those regions because those were the low-elevation plains areas.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Derer

  523. @Derer
    @Mr. XYZ

    People usually make mistake by assuming Hungarians in Hungary interchangeably with ethnic Magyars. During Hapsburg years there were only 39% Magyars in the area of Hungary, the rest comprised mostly of Slavs.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Yes, I know what Greater Hungary’s ethnic demographics were:

    It’s still interesting that it survived as a compact political unit for many centuries, however, albeit with a break during slightly over 1.5 centuries of Ottoman rule.

    Magyars generally lived on the Hungarian plains (Pannonian Basin) while minorities generally lived on or near the mountains:

    This also helps explain why Hungarian-majority areas near the border with the new (1920) Trianon Hungary got handed over to neighboring countries:

    Specifically, in some cases, such as for Czechoslovakia and Romania, the main lines of communication (roads and railroads) can through those areas in those regions because those were the low-elevation plains areas.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    The 1890 and 1910 censuses are generally considered very manipulated by the Budapest Magyar government. For example almost all government employees, students and soldiers were listed as of Magyar ethnicity, they were in no position to disagree. The census takers would ask if a person understood the Magyar language and if they said yes, they were listed as Magyars. All Jews also declared Magyar nationality. After WW1 censuses showed around 15-20% fewer Magyars. Some of it was a reverse manipulation by the new states, but most of it was people saying who they really were.

    Trianon was a massive shrinkage of Hungary - they were punished much more than the Austrians, actually Austria got the region of Burgerland from Hungary. But there was no other way: in the last 20 years before WW1 the Hungarians went on a nationalist rampage trying to "magyarize" everyone, being totally unreasonable, suffering from a narcissistic vertigo. Then they lost a war.

    The new lines mostly followed geographic boundaries, rivers, mountains. The Hungarians refused to negotiate and insisted on keeping everything - thus the borders were drawn for them. There is a lesson there for others, like the Ukies: if a situation is unsustainable make a deal early and be reasonable.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. XYZ

    , @Derer
    @Mr. XYZ

    The term "Hungarians" during the Austria-Hungary Empire applied to inhabitants of the area but it comprised of: Magyars, Germans, Romanians and Slavs such as Slovaks, Croats, Serbs, Slovene.

    Regardless, Magyars won in c.a. 999 and lost in 1918 and 1945. Twice lost, from appetite for greater Hungary. The borders are created by blood.

  524. @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    the sad switche-roos by Italy, Romania, Hungary…were pointless.
     
    Not quite. Romanian king even got the Order of Victory from Stalin.

    Besides, as US and UK agreed to keep Romania and Hungary in the Soviet zone, Soviet propaganda never mentioned the atrocities committed by Romanian and Hungarian troops. In fact, Romanians murdered most Jews in Odessa, whereas by the accounts of those who happened to be on temporarily occupied Soviet territories, Hungarians were worse for the civilians than Germans. By their brutality Hungarians far exceeded Germans, approaching banderites:
    https://www.ilawjournals.com/why-vatutin-ordered-not-to-take-prisoners-hungarian-soldiers-of-hitler/
    That’s why in the battle of Voronezh Soviet commander Vatutin issued an order that Hungarians should not be taken prisoners. The order was followed: virtually all Hungarian troops near Voronezh were killed.


    US-UK finally joining the war in June 1944 with the Normandy landing was similar, a belated attempt to join in and mitigate the defeat of Germany.
     
    Yes, by June 1944 the outcome of the war was already assured. However, late entrance of “Allies” in the war against Nazi Germany was mostly to participate in the division of spoils with minimal investment into actual fighting. Saving and then using numerous Nazis was probably not the main goal.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Beckow, @LT1488, @Mr. XYZ

    Not quite. Romanian king even got the Order of Victory from Stalin.

    He also got Stalin to agree to return Northern Transylvania to Romania in its entirety after the end of WWII. Quite an accomplishment.

  525. @A123
    @Mikel


    Regardless of what happens with the Ukraine aid package in Congress (and it’s difficult to see a total cut of US military aid to Ukraine, especially if diplomacy doesn’t work and the conflict continues)
     
    Funding Kiev aggression is unpopular with MAGA, thus the House will load up any appropriation with things that do appeal to voters. Is Not-The-President Biden willing to agree to real border security and reinstating Trump's Stay in Mexico policy?

    It is easy to envision a near total cut during an election year. It is an "inch deep" issue. While the top line polling looks favourable, voters will not swing on this single policy. It may not be "total zero", but it looks like vastly less in 2024.

    A full end in 2025 seems certain. Cutting off the Veggie-In-Chief's foreign policy failures is a priority for Trump's 2nd term. The fact that it also highlights Burisma Biden's personal, corrupt cash flows makes it a double bonus.

    If Scholz and Macron want their puppet Zelensky to continue, Germany and France will have to foot the bill. Are they willing to spend €5 Billion/month?


    Ukraine is soon going to receive the long-awaited F-16s
     
    They are still training pilots. The window for a limited number of Netherlands transfers is now, at the earliest, in April. Suspiciously, no one is explaining the maintenance and logistics to keep the planes mission capable.

    What % of German provided Leopards are still in the field? Poor support is decommissioning them faster than combat losses. If Kiev cannot keep tanks in service, that does not bode well for much more complex combat aircraft.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Mr. XYZ

    Is Not-The-President Biden willing to agree to real border security and reinstating Trump’s Stay in Mexico policy?

    Biden could agree to this at least partially given that the US already has a lot of new Latin American migrants to integrate right now.

    • Replies: @A123
    @Mr. XYZ



    Is Not-The-President Biden willing to agree to real border security and reinstating Trump’s Stay in Mexico policy?
     
    Biden could agree to this at least partially given that the US already has a lot of new Latin American migrants to integrate right now.
     
    It would give Trump a victory he could use on the campaign trail.

    If Not-The-President Biden's regime is truly passionate about Ukraine, they would take a political hit to make the deal. It seems more likely that they do not actuality care about backing Kiev aggression and will go down the more politically expedient refusal path.

    PEACE 😇
  526. Sher Singh says:
    @Barbarossa
    @John Johnson


    I’m of the opinion that the late 90s cars and early 00s are some of the worst.
     
    I feel like GM had a particularly bad period around this time. Their vehicles looked spectacularly awful and seemed very issue prone. I go out of my way to get the most basic trim package on vehicles so I've been kind of insulated. My current non-truck vehicles are a 93 Plymouth Voyager and a 96 Ford E150 and I feel like the early 90's era is pretty ideal. They had enough sophistication to be really efficient and reliable but were still quite simple and easy to diagnose. It's too much diminished returns for the added failure points and complication from there on out.

    In addition to my 89F350 I have Ford F250's from 99 and 00 and they are the best. Just fantastic bulletproof trucks and much better in every system than the 89. Ford only ditched the 7.3 Turbodiesel because of Federal emissions requirements which is a shame. The current 6.7 seems like a good motor finally but I don't really need all the power (and price tag) anyway. I prefer to keep under the 26k gross weight limit allowing me to keep away from the next tiers of DOT regs. My 7.3s have never failed to pull my 14k trailer with gusto so I don't see why I'd want to upgrade.

    The thing that was most striking driving the borrowed newer Ford was how much it was loaded with gimmicky stuff. I guess that is the nature of the vehicle arms race these days.

    Replies: @Sher Singh, @Sher Singh

    Post 2020 it’s gotten better due to the chip shortage.
    I like features such as adaptive cruise or lane keep/blind spot warning.

    Driving in a big metro is a hella dif experience or on the 401 with drunk/asleep truckers.
    Fuel efficiency + cab size is also a plus.

    My main gripe about newer trucks is the death of the small truck due to CAFE standards.
    However, hybrid or plug-in hybrid promises to bring that back.

    ===
    I don’t bother to connect my phone or use the in-car nav though.

  527. Sher Singh says:

    Tail end of the 90s seemed like there would be a racial civil war.

    https://web.archive.org/web/20170123025002/https://whitenationalism.com/ms/ms-39.htm

    Books such as civil war 2 were written etc.
    Today – that seems laughable.

    What happened?

    Also, noticed that blacks have this idea that the more expensive car gets right of way.
    No, the more expensive sword does. xD

    • Replies: @songbird
    @Sher Singh

    IMO, rap should be banned on the rez, just as spirits.

  528. [MORE]

    ਅਕਾਲ

  529. @A123
    @Beckow


    I am not against trying it, I just think it is impossible to define – both sides claim that they are only aiming at military targets, that anything else is collateral damage (Nato invented the term), caused by defense missiles, or propaganda. Same is true in Gaza, and was true in the previous wars fought by Nato around the world.
     
    I agree. The concept of inevitable Collateral Damage preceded NATO by centuries or millennia, even if they were first to coin that exact phrase.

    There is a huge amount of SJW squealing and bleating over Israeli tactics. Yet, those expressing faux outrage never condemn Hamas use of human shields. Nor do they provide any realistic alternative option for Palestinian Jews.


    I am skeptical that Russia would take the bite – after the Minsk fiasco. Being proud of lying in diplomacy never pays…
     
    I concur.

    Merkel ordered Zelensky to engage in bad faith on the Minsk deal. There is no sign that Scholz is any different. SJW squealing and bleating over Russian tactics falls on deaf ears. There cannot be anything resembling a pause as long as Kiev is run by Zelensky. He shares Abbas's total absence of credibility and honesty.

    What Kiev needs most is new leadership. How can that happen after Zelensky nationalized non-state media, disbanded opposition parties, and suspended elections? Ukraine's subservience to European Elites and absence of democracy are severe impediments to meaningful negotiations.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    I ACCEPT YOUR SURRENDER

    You make that statement every time before you block someone.

    Why is that?

    How long is your blocklist now?

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    It’s a standard American procedure: when you are losing, declare victory and leave.

    Replies: @A123

  530. @Mr. XYZ
    @Derer

    Yes, I know what Greater Hungary's ethnic demographics were:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/de/Hungarians_in_Hungary_%281890%29.png

    It's still interesting that it survived as a compact political unit for many centuries, however, albeit with a break during slightly over 1.5 centuries of Ottoman rule.

    Magyars generally lived on the Hungarian plains (Pannonian Basin) while minorities generally lived on or near the mountains:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/01/Carpathian_Basin-Pannonian_Basin.jpg

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/2/23/Pannonian_Basin.svg/1280px-Pannonian_Basin.svg.png

    This also helps explain why Hungarian-majority areas near the border with the new (1920) Trianon Hungary got handed over to neighboring countries:

    https://english.atlatszo.hu/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Trianonline.jpg

    Specifically, in some cases, such as for Czechoslovakia and Romania, the main lines of communication (roads and railroads) can through those areas in those regions because those were the low-elevation plains areas.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Derer

    The 1890 and 1910 censuses are generally considered very manipulated by the Budapest Magyar government. For example almost all government employees, students and soldiers were listed as of Magyar ethnicity, they were in no position to disagree. The census takers would ask if a person understood the Magyar language and if they said yes, they were listed as Magyars. All Jews also declared Magyar nationality. After WW1 censuses showed around 15-20% fewer Magyars. Some of it was a reverse manipulation by the new states, but most of it was people saying who they really were.

    Trianon was a massive shrinkage of Hungary – they were punished much more than the Austrians, actually Austria got the region of Burgerland from Hungary. But there was no other way: in the last 20 years before WW1 the Hungarians went on a nationalist rampage trying to “magyarize” everyone, being totally unreasonable, suffering from a narcissistic vertigo. Then they lost a war.

    The new lines mostly followed geographic boundaries, rivers, mountains. The Hungarians refused to negotiate and insisted on keeping everything – thus the borders were drawn for them. There is a lesson there for others, like the Ukies: if a situation is unsustainable make a deal early and be reasonable.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Beckow


    The census takers would ask if a person understood the Magyar language and if they said yes, they were listed as Magyars. All Jews also declared Magyar nationality.
     
    I realize you might not be the person to ask, but was the census in Hungary different from the one in Austria? In Austria they asked about language and about religion, but not about ethnicity (which could usually be inferred from language). So an urban Polish-speaking Ukrainian would be Polish by language and Greek Catholic by religion. Many ethnic Jews were Polish by language but Jewish by religion. There was no “ethnicity” to declare.

    Trianon was a massive shrinkage of Hungary
     
    Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder and squatter in the heart of Slavic lands, separating Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians from their Slovenian and Croatian brothers. The product of Asian invaders and plains-dwelling Slavs whom they conquered and assimilated, Magyars behaved terribly towards Slavs. During the first world war, Hungarian troops engaged in numerous massacres of various Slavs including Ukrainians. During the Second World War, they were Hitler’s partners. They were lucky that they weren’t deported en masse to their ancient Eurasian homeland. They must miss it on some level, as evidenced by their love of Putin. In the case of Putin’s war, Hungary again chooses the side that is killing Slavs - Russia.

    And in their insolence these historical persecutors of Slavs dare to whine about Hungarian language schools in Ukraine.

    Ukrainians lived under Austria, Hungary and Russia. Hungarian-controlled Ukraine was the worst, a land of poverty, persecution, aggressive Magyarization, illiteracy. Russia was terrible by policy, but it’s administration was incompetent and rather non-intrusive so the policies were not terribly harmful to regular people. Austria was the best. Under benevolent Austrian rule, Galicians were the most educated and wealthiest of the Eastern Slavs, the first to achieve full literacy of students, Ukrainian-language university courses, etc.

    Slovaks seem to have been willing lackeys of the Magyars. I wonder if without Czech pushing (or Wilson’s encouragement) they would even have chosen independence from them. The patterns repeat themselves with Fico. Though there are plenty of decent Slovaks too.

    The Hungarians refused to negotiate

     

    There is a small but not zero chance that the Hungarians will manage to get themselves out of EU and NATO protection (probably not formally, but perhaps in terms of voting rights).

    Replies: @German_reader, @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @Beckow

    What about the 1900 Hungarian census? And the 1880 Hungarian census? And the 1869 Hungarian census?

  531. @A123
    The numbers are in: (1)

    Nielsen: President Trump Townhall on Fox News Nearly Doubles Viewership of CNN Debate Featuring Haley and DeSantis

    (Via The Hill) – Fox’s town hall with Trump averaged 4.3 million viewers from 9-10 p.m., according to early data from Nielsen Media Research, while the CNN debate featuring Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) and former United Nations Ambassador Nikki Haley averaged 2.5 million during the same hour.

    […] Wednesday night’s ratings returns are the latest signal that live events featuring Trump remain one of the largest drivers of audience for the nation’s cable news channels, all of which are facing major headwinds in the form of increased cord-cutting and changing media habits on the part of consumers.
     

     
    Not only were the ratings bad, Haley and DeSantis spent their time blasting each other.

    What are these two trying to prove? How much money they can spend without achieving anything? It is not helping their reputations or future prospects. Massive establishment entanglement has effectively wiped out DeSantis's hope to be a MAGA leader at the national level.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/11/nielsen-president-trump-townhall-on-fox-news-nearly-doubles-viewership-of-cnn-debate-featuring-haley-and-desantis/

    Replies: @Mikel, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    You should remember the concept of “solidarity” doesn’t do justice to describing the outpouring of Arab and Muslim support for Palestine. The popular Arab saying “my blood is Palestinian” best conveys the visceral nature of this support which defines their very being and identity what it means to be a “real” Arab or Muslim.

    As a cause that is at once national, Islamic, and pan-Arab, there is no out-group offering “solidarity with” an in-group’s interests or values, which the concept suggests. Nor is it “solidarity among” a group of people sharing a commonality of interests or values because it transcends both.

    The amount of love and support shown by the Arab street and Ummah in general has been an eye opening experience.

    • Replies: @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere


    You should remember the concept of “solidarity” doesn’t do justice to describing the outpouring of Arab and Muslim support for Palestine.
     
    Xi is neither Arab nor Muslim. Ummah is thus not a reason for him to accept Iranian misbehavior.

    How long will Xi tolerate Khamenei’s Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?

    Are you going to:

    • Answer this time?
    • Or, wildly, pathetically, and feebly attempt evade yet again?

    Futile attempts to change the subject are not helping you. Everyone sees that you are losing.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    P..S. Mr. Hack is mentally ill. I added him to "Commenters to Ignore" on the grounds of medical compassion. I do not want to personally contribute to his psychiatric problems becoming worse.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  532. @A123
    @Yahya

    For adult anime series it is hard to beat Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex.

    https://ghostintheshell.fandom.com/wiki/Ghost_in_the_Shell:_Stand_Alone_Complex

    Cowboy Bebop is another winner. I enjoyed Samurai Champloo, but it may not be to everyone's taste.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    https://www.unz.com/akarlin/open-thread-225/#comment-6097641

    Have you still got Mr. Hack blocked if so why?

    Please explain.

    [MORE]

  533. @John Johnson
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    LOL why do you even bother with an open forum if you are going to block that many people?

    Why is Mr. Hack on that list? Corvinus?

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Mr. Hack

    LOL why do you even bother with an open forum if you are going to block that many people?

    He doesn’t actually block any of them and continues to read their comments to this day.

    He simply uses it as an ineffective strategy to end discussion by pretending he can’t see their comments anymore.

    • Agree: Mr. Hack
  534. @AnonfromTN
    @sudden death

    Are you saying that this is the level of coverage in the US MSM you’d get if something like that were happening in Russia? In this case count yourself as hopeless.

    Replies: @sudden death

    level of coverage in the US MSM

    Quite apparently also managed to miss the news about CNN relocating out of USA, lol

    Updated 12:54 PM EST, Mon January 15, 2024

    Berlin has nearly been brought to a standstill as thousands of farmers rally against tax rises and subsidy cuts, the culmination of a week of protests that have piled misery on German Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s governing coalition.

    Streets leading to Berlin’s Brandenburg Gate were clogged with trucks and tractors on Monday, as more than 10,000 farmers descended on the capital in conjunction with the German freight industry, police said.

    Multiple other protests are planned across the country, which come as Scholz’s coalition struggles to fix a budget crisis and official data showed Germany’s economy shrank last year for the first time since the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic.

    https://edition.cnn.com/2024/01/15/europe/farmer-protests-germany-far-right-afd-intl/index.html

  535. German_reader says:
    @Gerard1234
    @German_reader


    Nah, you both don’t have much compunction about killing civilians (nor about habitual lying). Very similar mentality. Not surprising too, you both stem from the same rotten tree after all.
     
    It just proves what a class act I am that I won't insult you for this particular comment. Why? Because although your comment is offensive and 100% disagree with it....its intellectually honest, so I have no problem . It's clear there is an eternal thought from German intellectuals that Slavs are untermensch compared to themselves. It's good to read from comments as yours that effectively you think Ukronazis and Russians are the same people - and probably why on some subconscious level think the insanely high levels of ukrainian deaths are "Russian deaths" anyway.

    When there is intellectually dishonest, repulsive filth like your garbage about the Belgorod war crime - then I correctly reply with insults.

    On the "don’t have much compunction about killing civilians ":

    1. Mariupol, Kramatorsk and other important places in 2014 were exited by LDNR heroes relatively peacefully and quickly to save and prioritise civilian lives, immediately when it became clear that Russia were not willing to commit enough resources or had the political will to take in this part of Donbass (i.e they were looking to do conciliatory gesture to help political settlement in allowing 404 these hugely economically important area.....even though more than enough men willing to go and fight and local support to continue fighting and annihilate the ukronazis in Slavyansk, Kramatorsk, anywhere). Remember dimwit, that all this with Slaviansk, Mariupol and others happened not too long before Banderastan were FORCED into 1st Minsk Agreements by LDNR smashing them and the potential for more of this.

    Western scum tactics and instructions for the Ukronazi plankton would ( as proved 8 years later) be the exact opposite


    2. Russia evacuates huge numbers of civilians from the frontline weeks before the start of the SMO (I think 80-120k at least). Ukronazis do ZERO evacuation in this time,while massively increasing their number of artillery strikes.

    3. Different to 404 and it's multiple waves of mobilisations and seizing of anybody off the street to then be cannon fodder..... we have done a partial one and every Russian is free to leave the country or return to it (important in the context of western historical lies and some truth about Soviet control of civilian border movement)

    4. Every single talk from the ukronazis of "repurposed" S-300 or S-200 missile strikes that have killed civilians.......are either ridiculous lies to cover for their air Defence mislaunches or outright false-flag attacks from the Nazi regime. There has been a very high number of these


    5.Kherson on wrong side of the Dnieper. We could easily defend and keep control of the city but it still remain an obviously dangerous situation for us and the civilians. Russia mass evacuates civilians and vacates Kherson. Again, compare to the exact opposite from ukronazi actions when evacuation is most sensible option.

    6.In 2022 SMO in Mariuopol, Ukronazi scum get smashed and destroyed embarrassingly easily as Russia secure key objective in SMO. These highly motivated and "elite" soldiers (LOL) then "resist" Russia.....by hiding underground the extensive tunnel network under the Azovstal plant, ocassionally coming out to "fight" by throwing a hand grenade into the air for social media video.....then return to the job of filming themselves dying from gangreme meme videos for social media!

    .......and these pussies are supposed to be the "heroes" of this freakshow.

    Our guys risked ( and sadly some of these heroes died) solely in the purpose of evacuating civilians from "agreed" safe routes out of the city , that of course the Banderites did not fullfil that agreement.

    Azov took nearly 2000 civilians with them underground, most not their families . So a white HAMAS situation for 404. I don't see how that isn't the exact same for 404 in Azovstal as with Hamas taking ( much less) Israeli hostages

    6. I already mentioned the use of a bomb on a civilian truck, killing more civilians for a pointless, evil but sick " PR stunt" on the Crimean bridge that the ukronazis did ( blatantly with the planning, assistance and order of Anglo-American scum).

    Clearly for myself evidence, logic, an IQ over 2, precedent,any knowledge of these people and how they think indicates that Ukronazis did all these crimes - Irpin/Bucha fakes, "rapes", Novaya Kakhovka Dam, several notable mass-murder of civilian events from MLRS fire - but let me be uneccesarily generous to you by saying it's an issue of faith for you as to giving responsibility to sifr for these crimes. We can all accept that if it's clear that ukronazi regime did the Novaya Kakhovka dam destruction, then all these other events mass killing civilians they are lying for every event.

    7. You aware of German , mass and sadistic crimes against civilians in WW2?

    Replies: @German_reader

    You aware of German , mass and sadistic crimes against civilians in WW2?

    No, I have never heard of that, totally news to me.

    It’s clear there is an eternal thought from German intellectuals that Slavs are untermensch compared to themselves.

    I wasn’t thinking of it being so much a Slav thing. More like a “Soviet legacy” thing (not just regarding civilians, e.g. Arestovych in the interview I linked to said Ukraine was throwing away lives of its soldiers in a careless manner, and also attributed that to a Soviet-like mentality). But I know of course you’ll disagree since you’re one of those who thinks the Soviet Union was wonderful in every respect.
    As for whether specific incidents in the current war included deliberate targeting of civilians or not, I don’t care to discuss it all in detail. I think both sides have done some pretty dubious stuff (if it makes you happy: I did feel revulsion at Ukraine’s under-handed bombing of the Kerch bridge, also wasn’t positively impressed by the recent Belgorod strike, as my comment indicates that Ukraine shouldn’t receive Western long-range missiles when it does something like that. But I also think that Russian troops killed civilians at Bucha; it wasn’t quite the massacre Western msm tried to present it as, but definitely war crimes).
    However, as I’ve written before, so far at least war crimes against civilians aren’t the dominant feature of this war. It’s mostly a conventional war, in which large numbers of regular troops are being killed at the front. So focus on civilian deaths is more for propaganda purposes than anything else.

    • Replies: @Gerard1234
    @German_reader


    I wasn’t thinking of it being so much a Slav thing. More like a “Soviet legacy” thing (not just regarding civilians, e.g. Arestovych in the interview I linked to said Ukraine was throwing away lives of its soldiers in a careless manner, and also attributed that to a Soviet-like mentality).
     
    It's true that Banderastan is a magnet for every misconception and every actual bad thing about the Soviet Union. It's a caricature of it. Much of their fake nationalism is just a sick form of provincial Sovietism. Arestovich is just some irrelevant subhuman freak - he says that the Atlantic Ocean is wet, then I would attempt to drive across it assuming there is no water there - that's how credible and honest I view the POS . A huge amount of ukronazi propaganda, is just recycled old western and liberast lies about Soviet Union in WW2 - they need to do this to convince the plankton section of their population that they are "defeating" Russia by faking that "masses" of Russians are dying by using "Soviet" human wave tactics. The rape fakes part of this also. I wrote this just before SMO ( that ukrops would claim this) on Runet.

    The schizophrenic attitude towards the Soviet Union (officially hating it while practically parasiting off it and in many aspects living with it) is one of the main reasons 404 is such a disaster post-1991.

    But I know of course you’ll disagree since you’re one of those who thinks the Soviet Union was wonderful in every respect.
     
    Nazi German scum made Red Army fight for every brick, every staircase in nearly every town and city when they were in retreat. Costing the lives of about 2-5-3 million of our soldiers when we forced the Nazis back through western Europe . How many allies lives lost on western front and Mediterranean front by comparison? How many western soldiers lives lost if forced by Nazi scum to fight for Paris, Rome, Berlin, Hamburg, Amsterdam like Russia had to fight for Stalingrad, Budapest, Prague, Kiev, Berlin etc? (note I am not even considering the severe battles for Soviet cities during the Nazi offensives from 41-42)

    Every military operation is difficult, every terrain has it's own challenges so of course all western land operations since 43 and June 1944 have to be respected, and naval/air operations all interconnected of course......but its an obvious fact that if the positions were reversed regarding intense urban warfare, then several million more American and British lives would be lost and several million Soviet lives would have been saved.

    No, I have never heard of that, totally news to me.
     
    When you use silly sarcasm as that then you discredit yourself. Soviet Officers forcing waves of meat tactics on 15 year old infantry are just extreme western lies and exaggerations (i.e there is some truth, but not much to it), but if one side (Anglo-US) have all the major cities peacefully surrendered to , but the other side are forced into viscous fights for nearly every city - then I think its extremely disrespectful and stupid to have these (mis) conceptions of Red Army

    I suppose all this relies on assumption that Soviet casualty lists are accurate and not 15+, or 20 million military deaths , instead of the official 8.5 million figure. The truth is that we will never know, but I do know that much of Wehrmacht anecdotal "evidence" about the Red Army is obvious propaganda BS. You could still say that the official 8.5 million number indicates reckless tactics from Red Army, even taking out numbers killed from battles for all the cities - I don't. Outside of sickening Nazi crimes to Soviet POW's , military deaths from the 8.5 million are 1 to 1 between Nazis and Soviets ( that isn't the sole measure , but I am just mentioning it)

    The sarcasm is also ridiculous as the massive numbers of Soviet civilians killed would suggest Red Army losses that weren't disproportionate.

    On another issue - a Soviet pilot was was by far the safest job of any other pilot in WW2, even though we flew nearly 4 million sorties ( far more than everyone else) . The Luftwaffe flew about 1/3rd of that but received about the same number of losses.
    Japan of course had kamikaze pilots, British pilot was near death sentence ( well, one in every 2 killed), American appear to have abnormal loss of pilots and planes in non-combat missions (JFK's brother was I think killed in UK performing test flight on reconnaissance plane that he was told not to fly). An individual fighter or attack pilot is , in practical terms, worth far more than an individual soldier or sailor - so intelligent deployment, training, protection of them to create this relatively lower number of losses does not suggest a reckless Soviet military command.

    Air defence of our cities and important locations was far superior to German air defence of their cities and British defence of their key locations. Air Defence of cities and losses of our airforce does suggest leadership who were not uninterested and do value Soviet citizens life

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @German_reader, @Sean

    , @Mikel
    @German_reader


    Arestovych in the interview I linked to said Ukraine was throwing away lives of its soldiers in a careless manner, and also attributed that to a Soviet-like mentality
     
    Even the NYT ran a story about Ukraine ignoring the right to conscientious objection that they have in their constitution. A right that by its very nature is designed to be applied in times of war. I didn't read the paywalled piece but I've read about it elsewhere and people who ask to be given non-combat duties in compliance with the law are punished for being pro-Russian and sent to the front anyway. The laughter of the thugs rounding up biomass for the war when one of the poor souls invokes the constitution must be heard from miles away. But hey, the Russians probably don't even have that right in their constitution so let's give as much military and financial aid as they need to the ones with the nicer constitution. They're fighting for our values.
  536. @John Johnson
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    LOL why do you even bother with an open forum if you are going to block that many people?

    Why is Mr. Hack on that list? Corvinus?

    Replies: @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere, @Mr. Hack

    In kremlinstooge A123’s case, he’s not only a “blockhead” but he’s also a coward too. His bizarre conspiracy theories help complete the whole package:


    kremlnstoogeA123 composing his next unbelievable conspiracy theory

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Mr. Hack

    Also, kremlinstoogeA123's propensity is to place commenters on his blocklist when he runs into difficulties countering his opponent's arguments. By coming up with some bizarre reason to block somebody, this spares him with the possibility of looking foolish. With me, I was able to disparage his Russian water rights issues in Crimea, and was soon to be honored by inclusion into his long list of verboten commenters.

  537. @Mr. Hack
    @John Johnson

    In kremlinstooge A123's case, he's not only a "blockhead" but he's also a coward too. His bizarre conspiracy theories help complete the whole package:

    https://www.cartoonistgroup.com/properties/bennett/art_images/cg5d9ac782f1bc1.jpg
    kremlnstoogeA123 composing his next unbelievable conspiracy theory

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    Also, kremlinstoogeA123’s propensity is to place commenters on his blocklist when he runs into difficulties countering his opponent’s arguments. By coming up with some bizarre reason to block somebody, this spares him with the possibility of looking foolish. With me, I was able to disparage his Russian water rights issues in Crimea, and was soon to be honored by inclusion into his long list of verboten commenters.

  538. @Sher Singh
    @songbird Tail end of the 90s seemed like there would be a racial civil war.

    https://web.archive.org/web/20170123025002/https://whitenationalism.com/ms/ms-39.htm

    Books such as civil war 2 were written etc.
    Today - that seems laughable.
    --
    What happened?

    Also, noticed that blacks have this idea that the more expensive car gets right of way.
    No, the more expensive sword does. xD

    Replies: @songbird

    IMO, rap should be banned on the rez, just as spirits.

    • Agree: Sher Singh
  539. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123

    You should remember the concept of “solidarity” doesn’t do justice to describing the outpouring of Arab and Muslim support for Palestine. The popular Arab saying “my blood is Palestinian” best conveys the visceral nature of this support which defines their very being and identity what it means to be a “real” Arab or Muslim.

    As a cause that is at once national, Islamic, and pan-Arab, there is no out-group offering “solidarity with” an in-group’s interests or values, which the concept suggests. Nor is it “solidarity among” a group of people sharing a commonality of interests or values because it transcends both.

    The amount of love and support shown by the Arab street and Ummah in general has been an eye opening experience.

    Replies: @A123

    You should remember the concept of “solidarity” doesn’t do justice to describing the outpouring of Arab and Muslim support for Palestine.

    Xi is neither Arab nor Muslim. Ummah is thus not a reason for him to accept Iranian misbehavior.

    How long will Xi tolerate Khamenei’s Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?

    Are you going to:

    • Answer this time?
    • Or, wildly, pathetically, and feebly attempt evade yet again?

    Futile attempts to change the subject are not helping you. Everyone sees that you are losing.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    P..S. Mr. Hack is mentally ill. I added him to “Commenters to Ignore” on the grounds of medical compassion. I do not want to personally contribute to his psychiatric problems becoming worse.

    • Troll: Mr. Hack
    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @A123


    P..S. Mr. Hack is mentally ill. I added him to “Commenters to Ignore” on the grounds of medical compassion. I do not want to personally contribute to his psychiatric problems becoming worse.
     
    One of your favorite tropes, kremlinstoogeA123. Don't you see that everybody here sees right though you and the foolish games that you like to play? JJ and Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere have got you pegged perfectly for the dishonest lout that you really are:

    LOL why do you even bother with an open forum if you are going to block that many people?

    He doesn’t actually block any of them and continues to read their comments to this day.

    He simply uses it as an ineffective strategy to end discussion by pretending he can’t see their comments anymore.

     

  540. @songbird
    @Hyperborean

    Possibly, the sister of one of our commenters might know her.

    Would unironically put her in charge of the deportation squads.

    Replies: @Yahya

    Possibly, the sister of one of our commenters might know her.

    Is this referring to yours truly?

    I’m close friends with one Bin Laden (Osama’s nephew), and know of his close family members from a distance. I showed him Noor Bin Laden’s twitter profile but he said he never met her (she is one of ~140 or so cousins).

    The Bin Ladens I know are fairly Westernized and have cosmopolitan backgrounds. My above-mentioned friend is half-English and currently lives in London. Completely secular and about as far away from an Islamist as you can get (his favorite pastime is drinking whiskey and smoking weed in his studio). Typical really of wealthy Arabs, who tend towards secularism rather than Islamism. Osama was kind of a fluke.

    Many of the male members of the Bin Laden family enjoy flying planes as a hobby, my friend included. Runs in the family.

    • Replies: @songbird
    @Yahya

    Thanks.

    As for anime: a pretty cliched recommendation, but if you haven't seen it and can tolerate a romance, I'd say Your Name (2016.)

    https://youtu.be/xU47nhruN-Q?si=FiI6Hhj5N-2-jK1d

    It is a pretty good showcase of modern techniques to show light and capture real life locations. The plot does involve some elements of Japanese culture like shrine maidens and the red thread of fate. And Shinkai has become the most famous director, after Miyazaki.

    On the negative side, it is a bit poppy - missing the moments of silence often considered to be characteristic of anime.

    If you want something more action-orienated, there is Sword of the Stranger.

    https://youtu.be/ECRj6TKwPBg?si=e_SVeNtWIZDEAmfv

    Not the most original story certainly, but pretty watchable.

  541. @Mr. XYZ
    @A123


    Is Not-The-President Biden willing to agree to real border security and reinstating Trump’s Stay in Mexico policy?
     
    Biden could agree to this at least partially given that the US already has a lot of new Latin American migrants to integrate right now.

    Replies: @A123

    Is Not-The-President Biden willing to agree to real border security and reinstating Trump’s Stay in Mexico policy?

    Biden could agree to this at least partially given that the US already has a lot of new Latin American migrants to integrate right now.

    It would give Trump a victory he could use on the campaign trail.

    If Not-The-President Biden’s regime is truly passionate about Ukraine, they would take a political hit to make the deal. It seems more likely that they do not actuality care about backing Kiev aggression and will go down the more politically expedient refusal path.

    PEACE 😇

  542. @A123
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere


    You should remember the concept of “solidarity” doesn’t do justice to describing the outpouring of Arab and Muslim support for Palestine.
     
    Xi is neither Arab nor Muslim. Ummah is thus not a reason for him to accept Iranian misbehavior.

    How long will Xi tolerate Khamenei’s Houthi proxies interrupting CCP commerce?

    Are you going to:

    • Answer this time?
    • Or, wildly, pathetically, and feebly attempt evade yet again?

    Futile attempts to change the subject are not helping you. Everyone sees that you are losing.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    P..S. Mr. Hack is mentally ill. I added him to "Commenters to Ignore" on the grounds of medical compassion. I do not want to personally contribute to his psychiatric problems becoming worse.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    P..S. Mr. Hack is mentally ill. I added him to “Commenters to Ignore” on the grounds of medical compassion. I do not want to personally contribute to his psychiatric problems becoming worse.

    One of your favorite tropes, kremlinstoogeA123. Don’t you see that everybody here sees right though you and the foolish games that you like to play? JJ and Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere have got you pegged perfectly for the dishonest lout that you really are:

    LOL why do you even bother with an open forum if you are going to block that many people?

    He doesn’t actually block any of them and continues to read their comments to this day.

    He simply uses it as an ineffective strategy to end discussion by pretending he can’t see their comments anymore.

  543. The Iowa Caucus tally is in.

    51% — Trump
    21% — DeSantis
    19% — Haley
      8% — Vivek

    After finishing 4th, Vivek suspended his campaign and endorsed Trump (1). New Hampshire is on the 23rd.

    PEACE 😇
    _________

    (1) https://www.foxnews.com/politics/vivek-ramaswamy-ends-presidential-bid-following-iowa-caucuses

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @A123

    Joint 40% of Republican voters who aren't prefering old boomer geezer as first choice is awesome result tbh. Can even add 9% Vivek voters here too, whom are obviously mostly very sympathetic to oldie granpa Trump, but still would like to see way younger face instead;)

    Replies: @QCIC

    , @John Johnson
    @A123

    The Iowa Caucus tally is in.

    51% — Trump

    Which was predicted months ago.

    Trump lost another attorney:
    https://news.yahoo.com/trump-lawyer-quits-legal-team-211322283.html

    If these are politically motivated cases then why have so many attorneys quit? Should be easy money.

    Trump's next trial is the porn star hush money case. The Good Christian Folk of states like Iowa will learn about how their hero cheated on his wife with a porn star and tried to pay her off.

  544. @A123
    The Iowa Caucus tally is in.

    51% -- Trump
    21% -- DeSantis
    19% -- Haley
      8% -- Vivek

    After finishing 4th, Vivek suspended his campaign and endorsed Trump (1). New Hampshire is on the 23rd.

    PEACE 😇
    _________

    (1) https://www.foxnews.com/politics/vivek-ramaswamy-ends-presidential-bid-following-iowa-caucuses

    Replies: @sudden death, @John Johnson

    Joint 40% of Republican voters who aren’t prefering old boomer geezer as first choice is awesome result tbh. Can even add 9% Vivek voters here too, whom are obviously mostly very sympathetic to oldie granpa Trump, but still would like to see way younger face instead;)

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @sudden death

    So who will the Demonrats swap in to run instead of Biden?

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @sudden death

  545. @sudden death
    @A123

    Joint 40% of Republican voters who aren't prefering old boomer geezer as first choice is awesome result tbh. Can even add 9% Vivek voters here too, whom are obviously mostly very sympathetic to oldie granpa Trump, but still would like to see way younger face instead;)

    Replies: @QCIC

    So who will the Demonrats swap in to run instead of Biden?

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @QCIC


    So who will the Demonrats swap in to run instead of Biden?
     
    They don’t need to swap. As US “elections” in 2020 and several “elections” in Zimbabwe before that showed, with necessary level of fraud corrupt senile half-corpse wins.

    Replies: @Beckow

    , @sudden death
    @QCIC

    They don't feel the urgent need to swap, cause Trump nomination is convenient for them - any old age related attacks fall notably flat when you have standing pudgy allegedly smelly geriatric candidate in the corner against lean allegedly smelly geriatric candidate in the other corner, lol

    With Vivek dropping out, most probably roughly 5-6% of his votes goes to Trump, the rest 2-3% to Desantis, so Trump should get roughly 55-57% along remaining way, with Ron coming second with roughly 23-24% and getting VP nomination, even if some individual fluctuations in separate states are not out of the question.

    However this would be logical course of events, so I won't be making this prediction as there was nothing logical about Trump behaviour since corona started, he always did the worst imaginable course of action, so it wouldn't be out of character for him to chose some open putinist bootlicker like Kari Lake as VP.

    This would also ensure at least 10% missing R votes for Trump (5% of Nikki voters not coming to vote at all and another 5% voting for Biden in autumn) with the rest 10% probably taking it out for the team and still voting R ticket nevertheless, especially if Haley endorses even in such case.

    Replies: @sudden death

  546. @Matra
    @John Johnson


    Anyone who chain smokes and defends a mass murderer clearly has mental problems
     
    So anyone who chain smokes has mental issues or do they also have to support a mass murderer like...just about every US president, except Trump, of the last forty years? You probably don't realise far more people on earth consider what Israel is doing in Gaza to be mass murder (genocide?) than anything happening in Ukraine, and virtually all of them believe #GenocideJoe has given the go-ahead. Are all Joe Biden supporters suffering from mental problems?

    I don’t buy for one second that he was ever living some bachelor lifestyle where he was banging random Ukrainian girls. Not one second
     
    He didn't claim to. If you've evidence to the contrary you should provide it. He did his Coach Red Pill videos when he lived in London's Notting Hill. I watched maybe 20 or so of them and based on memory they were about politics - leftist psychology, Pinochet, the media, Solzhenitsyn & the USSR - along with advice for young men about women, and Alt-Right bickering & feuding, which he contributed mightily to as he was a shit-stirrer.

    He then moved to Kharkiv because of his wife & kids - separated I'm guessing. In Kharkiv he built some large work room, which he filmed every minute of, then I lost track of him for a couple of years as he stopped talking politics, before he reappeared just before the Ukraine war. If he was claiming to be a pick-up artist I don't know when that was but it wasn't within the last 7 or 8 years.

    His smoking habit most likely caught up to him and this is how he chose to go out.
     
    Can't wait for some Russian liberal to die in prison & have Putin fans claim he was a chain smoker or former vodka drinker therefore he chose his death in prison.

    Chain smoking is very bad for your health since your lungs never get a break. It’s really just a form of suicide
     
    Prisoners in Western countries receive medical treatment. Ukraine supporters claim Ukraine is on its way to becoming a liberal democracy that we should support because our values are at stake. lol His death came too soon after his imprisonment to not be suspicious. Given the accusations from him and his family along with rare USGov. silence about an imprisoned American things look pretty suspicious. Ukraine is known for its corruption, human rights abuses, and even for putting foreign residents on hit lists for not agreeing with the regime. One has to assume the worst of such people.

    People that smoke that much also tend to drink.
     
    He claimed to be anti-alcohol. One of the advice videos I watched from maybe five years ago was about men who need alcohol to socialise. I think he was explaining why he went from idolising James Joyce to despising him. He seemed to have a low opinion of drinkers.

    But keep on trying to justify why people who die in the custody of US allies/proxies deserve to die because everyone here knows that's what you really believe. You demonstrated at least a year ago on these boards that you are a US über alles (or perhaps über allen would be more apt) patriotard who lives vicariously through American wars.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Anyone who chain smokes and defends a mass murderer clearly has mental problems

    So anyone who chain smokes has mental issues or do they also have to support a mass murderer like…just about every US president, except Trump, of the last forty years?

    The Iraqis view Saddam as the mass murder and not GWB. They have a functioning democracy despite naysayers predictions of civil war and collapse. They had a better turnout than many US areas:
    https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/iraq-holds-first-provincial-elections-decade-2023-12-18/

    We will see how history judges Putin but so far it isn’t looking good.

    You probably don’t realise far more people on earth consider what Israel is doing in Gaza to be mass murder (genocide?) than anything happening in Ukraine

    Not convinced but my views are indeed in line with the UN. They view both Russia and Israel as aggressors at the moment and I agree. I think Israel has gone too far and I agree with the 143-5 UN vote on the Russian invasion being illegal.

    He didn’t claim to. If you’ve evidence to the contrary you should provide it. He did his Coach Red Pill videos when he lived in London’s Notting Hill.

    He discouraged marriage and told men to not date women in their 30s. That’s encouraging a bachelor lifestyle. Are you suggesting he didn’t follow his own advice? Well that is what I was saying. The guy was full of shit.

    He wiped all of his red pill videos so it is hard to quote him. But he is on record discouraging marriage and telling men to avoid women in their 30s and also single moms. Well for men in America that is excluding a huge chunk of women which is bad advice.

    How a sleezy dating coach became a pro-Putin shill
    https://news.yahoo.com/sleazy-american-dating-coach-became-013002090.html

    There are videos of him ranting about women on youtube. Like I said he comes across as bitter and resentful and not someone experienced with women.

    Can’t wait for some Russian liberal to die in prison & have Putin fans claim he was a chain smoker or former vodka drinker therefore he chose his death in prison.

    Are you suggesting he wasn’t a chain smoker? I can source a video where he lights up multiple times during a discussion. The way he smokes is exactly like a chain smoker.

    But keep on trying to justify why people who die in the custody of US allies/proxies deserve to die because everyone here knows that’s what you really believe.

    What are you talking about? I already said that they should have put him in a debate instead of a jail cell. We don’t know what happened and all evidence suggests he didn’t ask the state department for help. The letter to his sister is odd and he doesn’t explain how he got double pneumonia.

  547. @A123
    The Iowa Caucus tally is in.

    51% -- Trump
    21% -- DeSantis
    19% -- Haley
      8% -- Vivek

    After finishing 4th, Vivek suspended his campaign and endorsed Trump (1). New Hampshire is on the 23rd.

    PEACE 😇
    _________

    (1) https://www.foxnews.com/politics/vivek-ramaswamy-ends-presidential-bid-following-iowa-caucuses

    Replies: @sudden death, @John Johnson

    The Iowa Caucus tally is in.

    51% — Trump

    Which was predicted months ago.

    Trump lost another attorney:
    https://news.yahoo.com/trump-lawyer-quits-legal-team-211322283.html

    If these are politically motivated cases then why have so many attorneys quit? Should be easy money.

    Trump’s next trial is the porn star hush money case. The Good Christian Folk of states like Iowa will learn about how their hero cheated on his wife with a porn star and tried to pay her off.

  548. @LT1488
    @Mr. Hack

    Well don't tell slovaks in the face that they are similar to ''Magyars'', they take great offence to that.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    Well don’t tell slovaks in the face that they are similar to ”Magyars”, they take great offence to that.

    Yea, these things are often unpredictable. I was surprised to learn from my grad student from Sicily that calling a Sicilian “Italian” is a grave offense. One of my colleagues has a boyfriend from Barcelona. When he went to visit his family, she asked him in a message how are things in Spain. He angrily answered that he is not in Spain, he is in Catalonia. My take-home message: you gotta be sensitive and sensible.

  549. @LT1488
    @AnonfromTN

    Hungarians when they took over Vojvodina in Serbia, they treated it better than say Croats or Albanians treated their parts of occupied Serbia.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    Hungarians when they took over Vojvodina in Serbia, they treated it better than say Croats or Albanians treated their parts of occupied Serbia.

    I am sure they did: only German Nazis and Ukies can compete in brutality with those occupiers. Considering the comparison, it was not hard. Say, a dog does not need to be exceptionally smart to be smarter than Baerbock or Biden.

  550. @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere
    @A123


    I ACCEPT YOUR SURRENDER
     
    You make that statement every time before you block someone.

    Why is that?

    How long is your blocklist now?

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    It’s a standard American procedure: when you are losing, declare victory and leave.

    • Replies: @A123
    @AnonfromTN


    It’s a standard American procedure: when you are losing, declare victory and leave.
     
    Well.... It is standard establishment Uniparty procedure. We saw it with GW Bush, Stacey Abrams, etc.

    Of course for MAGA, behaviour is the exact opposite. It would only be brought out when the other side comprehensively collapses.

    For example, Iranian Houthi proxies are widening their misconduct: (1)

    There have been several fresh incidents in the Red Sea, including a Greek-owned tanker coming attack off the coast of Yemen on Tuesday. It comes amid a string of similar attacks, causing Shell to be the latest to suspend all Red Sea shipments
    ...
    On Tuesday, British maritime security firm Ambrey has identified that the Zografia, a Malta-flagged Greek-owned bulk carrier, has suffered direct hit by a missile while going northbound in the Red Sea, near the Yemeni port city of Saleef.
    ...
    In a fresh statement, CENTCOM has announced, "On 11 January 2024, while conducting a flag verification, U.S. CENTCOM Navy forces conducted a night-time seizure of a dhow conducting illegal transport of advanced lethal aid from Iran to resupply Houthi forces in Yemen as part of the Houthis’ ongoing campaign of attacks against international merchant shipping." So Iranian weapons are continuing to be shipped to the Houthis of Yemen, and thus it looks like Operation Prosperity Guardian is having no significant deterrent impact.
     
    We have further attacks on Greek and Maltese shipping, having nothing to do with indigenous Palestinian Jews. We have conclusive evidence of Iran's direct involvement. And, a sensible conclusion that Xi's first attempt, via his puppet Not-The-President Biden, failed to resolve the issue.

    Xi's has one best (possibly only) option to get CCP, and everyone else's, cargo flowing normally again. He has to go to the source of the problem, Ayatollah Khamenei, and stop it there. As long as Khamenei's proxies are a threat to everyone, Asian cargo to Europe will be slower and more costly to deliver.

    It is really not that hard to figure out what is going on. Alas, common sense is not always common.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/two-fresh-houthi-attacks-tankers-red-sea-one-suffers-direct-missile-strike

    Replies: @Philip Owen

  551. @German_reader
    @Gerard1234


    You aware of German , mass and sadistic crimes against civilians in WW2?
     
    No, I have never heard of that, totally news to me.

    It’s clear there is an eternal thought from German intellectuals that Slavs are untermensch compared to themselves.
     
    I wasn't thinking of it being so much a Slav thing. More like a "Soviet legacy" thing (not just regarding civilians, e.g. Arestovych in the interview I linked to said Ukraine was throwing away lives of its soldiers in a careless manner, and also attributed that to a Soviet-like mentality). But I know of course you'll disagree since you're one of those who thinks the Soviet Union was wonderful in every respect.
    As for whether specific incidents in the current war included deliberate targeting of civilians or not, I don't care to discuss it all in detail. I think both sides have done some pretty dubious stuff (if it makes you happy: I did feel revulsion at Ukraine's under-handed bombing of the Kerch bridge, also wasn't positively impressed by the recent Belgorod strike, as my comment indicates that Ukraine shouldn't receive Western long-range missiles when it does something like that. But I also think that Russian troops killed civilians at Bucha; it wasn't quite the massacre Western msm tried to present it as, but definitely war crimes).
    However, as I've written before, so far at least war crimes against civilians aren't the dominant feature of this war. It's mostly a conventional war, in which large numbers of regular troops are being killed at the front. So focus on civilian deaths is more for propaganda purposes than anything else.

    Replies: @Gerard1234, @Mikel

    I wasn’t thinking of it being so much a Slav thing. More like a “Soviet legacy” thing (not just regarding civilians, e.g. Arestovych in the interview I linked to said Ukraine was throwing away lives of its soldiers in a careless manner, and also attributed that to a Soviet-like mentality).

    It’s true that Banderastan is a magnet for every misconception and every actual bad thing about the Soviet Union. It’s a caricature of it. Much of their fake nationalism is just a sick form of provincial Sovietism. Arestovich is just some irrelevant subhuman freak – he says that the Atlantic Ocean is wet, then I would attempt to drive across it assuming there is no water there – that’s how credible and honest I view the POS . A huge amount of ukronazi propaganda, is just recycled old western and liberast lies about Soviet Union in WW2 – they need to do this to convince the plankton section of their population that they are “defeating” Russia by faking that “masses” of Russians are dying by using “Soviet” human wave tactics. The rape fakes part of this also. I wrote this just before SMO ( that ukrops would claim this) on Runet.

    The schizophrenic attitude towards the Soviet Union (officially hating it while practically parasiting off it and in many aspects living with it) is one of the main reasons 404 is such a disaster post-1991.

    But I know of course you’ll disagree since you’re one of those who thinks the Soviet Union was wonderful in every respect.

    Nazi German scum made Red Army fight for every brick, every staircase in nearly every town and city when they were in retreat. Costing the lives of about 2-5-3 million of our soldiers when we forced the Nazis back through western Europe . How many allies lives lost on western front and Mediterranean front by comparison? How many western soldiers lives lost if forced by Nazi scum to fight for Paris, Rome, Berlin, Hamburg, Amsterdam like Russia had to fight for Stalingrad, Budapest, Prague, Kiev, Berlin etc? (note I am not even considering the severe battles for Soviet cities during the Nazi offensives from 41-42)

    Every military operation is difficult, every terrain has it’s own challenges so of course all western land operations since 43 and June 1944 have to be respected, and naval/air operations all interconnected of course……but its an obvious fact that if the positions were reversed regarding intense urban warfare, then several million more American and British lives would be lost and several million Soviet lives would have been saved.

    No, I have never heard of that, totally news to me.

    When you use silly sarcasm as that then you discredit yourself. Soviet Officers forcing waves of meat tactics on 15 year old infantry are just extreme western lies and exaggerations (i.e there is some truth, but not much to it), but if one side (Anglo-US) have all the major cities peacefully surrendered to , but the other side are forced into viscous fights for nearly every city – then I think its extremely disrespectful and stupid to have these (mis) conceptions of Red Army

    I suppose all this relies on assumption that Soviet casualty lists are accurate and not 15+, or 20 million military deaths , instead of the official 8.5 million figure. The truth is that we will never know, but I do know that much of Wehrmacht anecdotal “evidence” about the Red Army is obvious propaganda BS. You could still say that the official 8.5 million number indicates reckless tactics from Red Army, even taking out numbers killed from battles for all the cities – I don’t. Outside of sickening Nazi crimes to Soviet POW’s , military deaths from the 8.5 million are 1 to 1 between Nazis and Soviets ( that isn’t the sole measure , but I am just mentioning it)

    The sarcasm is also ridiculous as the massive numbers of Soviet civilians killed would suggest Red Army losses that weren’t disproportionate.

    On another issue – a Soviet pilot was was by far the safest job of any other pilot in WW2, even though we flew nearly 4 million sorties ( far more than everyone else) . The Luftwaffe flew about 1/3rd of that but received about the same number of losses.
    Japan of course had kamikaze pilots, British pilot was near death sentence ( well, one in every 2 killed), American appear to have abnormal loss of pilots and planes in non-combat missions (JFK’s brother was I think killed in UK performing test flight on reconnaissance plane that he was told not to fly). An individual fighter or attack pilot is , in practical terms, worth far more than an individual soldier or sailor – so intelligent deployment, training, protection of them to create this relatively lower number of losses does not suggest a reckless Soviet military command.

    Air defence of our cities and important locations was far superior to German air defence of their cities and British defence of their key locations. Air Defence of cities and losses of our airforce does suggest leadership who were not uninterested and do value Soviet citizens life

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Gerard1234

    In John Merriman's History of Europe he has two numbers.

    Dead Soviets WWII: somewhere between 20 and 30 million.

    Dead Jews WWII: around 6.2 million.

    Accurate to the nearest 10 million v. accurate to the nearest hundred thousand. Having an error bar of 100 000 indicates an epic catastrophe. What do you call 100 simultaneous epic catastrophes? In Russian they might have a word for this but in English they do not. Any way 1.) they both are obviously invented numbers; 2.) hope we never see such but YOU NEVER KNOW.

    Merriman has done some fine history despite being innumerate.

    , @German_reader
    @Gerard1234


    When you use silly sarcasm as that then you discredit yourself.
     
    Well, what do you expect? I don't think I've denied German crimes, but it's been 80 years and the tendency to treat WW2 as if it happened yesterday is irritating. Given what kind of site this is, you should be content that I'm not some full-on "revisionist" who argues WW2 Germans did nothing wrong.
    Another factor: The kind of Germans who constantly go on about their "historical responsibility", German guilt etc. are frequently the ones who are most fanatical about current-day issues. People like Baerbock, the sort of people who want to see Russia totally defeated and re-constructed (because Putin is a "fascist" and then they'd be on the right side for once, or whatever). Or the clowns who have now made it their mission to defend Israel at the ICC. So careful what you wish for.
    As for the historical arguments, sure, the perception of the Red army as an unskilled horde winning only through sheer mass is inaccurate and unfair. I don't think I've ever argued along those lines myself either. However, you make some nonsensical arguments yourself, e.g.

    Air defence of our cities and important locations was far superior to German air defence of their cities and British defence of their key locations.
     
    this is a totally misleading comparison. Soviet Union in WW2 never faced a combined day-and-night offensive of heavy four-engined bombers (plus fighter escorts, eventually) like the British and Americans carried out against Germany in the last three years or so of the war. German bombing in the Soviet Union wasn't even on as concentrated a level as it had been against Britain in 1940. It did kill quite a few civilians (40 000-50 000 iirc, according to Richard Overy who's probably the leading expert), but it was mostly of the tactical kind, nothing like a concentrated strategic offensive. And after 1942 at the latest Luftwaffe mostly had to focus on defense against the Anglo-American bomber offensive anyway.
    As for

    Air Defence of cities and losses of our airforce does suggest leadership who were not uninterested and do value Soviet citizens life
     
    I'm completely unconvinced. But not much point arguing about it.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    , @Sean
    @Gerard1234

    I have read that after the fall of communism pit with thousands of men women and children, ordinary Soviet people shot in the Great Terror were discovered. Some were discovered by accident which suggest large numbers still exist undisturbed. Moreover it is said that the Soviets would force their own civilians ahead of them to clear a path through a minefield.

    Many Soviet aces scored most of their kills using the Bell Air Cobra, which was given to the Russians because it was loathed and though they were in production and available, got rejected by the British and Americans . The US's current earning to debt ratio was last as high as high at the end 0f WW2 The Russians were delighted with the Air Cobras because previous Western aid planes were trashed Hurricanes from the RAF. All this stuff was a gift from American taxpayers to the companies producing it , Ditto the near half million trucks the Soviets were given that certainly were the key to their victories as they moved West. Eventually the Russians took from imported technology and produced greatly improved fighter planes years into the war, but they were always inferior to the best American ones during WW2.

    From all this we can take the following lessons:-
    1 Russians are incredibly ruthless with their own people.

    2 Home produced Russian stuff is technically backward, but with a bit of input from allies they can cobble together fairly effective weapons in great numbers, although this takes them quite a lot of time.

    3 The Russian way is slow mass effect while accepting not inconsiderable casualties; their problems advancing in a sustained way are few as long as they don't over extend themselves.

    The (relatively primitive) FPV drone production on an industrial scale raining on Ukrainian infantry positions and the FAB lash ups of 1950s bombs obliterating real strongpoints are the keys to the war now. The propinquity and importance of Ukraine makes it very unlikely that Russia would in any circumstances feel the need to cut its losses in Ukraine. So an inexorable advance by Russia at considerable cost to them is the most likely outlook for the future of the war.

  552. Why NOBODY will build EV charging stations

    • Replies: @A123
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    Why NOBODY will build EV charging stations
     
    The largest charging station in the U.S. runs on diesel fuel. Many are fed by coal plants.

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=vVUDNNmPTeQ

    Plug-in EV's do not help the environment, pose serious fire risks, and periodically have outrageous repair bills. The technology is not ready for mass commercialization. And, absent extensive, inexpensive nuclear electricity development, may never be suitable.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @John Johnson

  553. @AnonfromTN
    @Noviop Co-Prosperity Sphere

    It’s a standard American procedure: when you are losing, declare victory and leave.

    Replies: @A123

    It’s a standard American procedure: when you are losing, declare victory and leave.

    Well…. It is standard establishment Uniparty procedure. We saw it with GW Bush, Stacey Abrams, etc.

    Of course for MAGA, behaviour is the exact opposite. It would only be brought out when the other side comprehensively collapses.

    For example, Iranian Houthi proxies are widening their misconduct: (1)

    There have been several fresh incidents in the Red Sea, including a Greek-owned tanker coming attack off the coast of Yemen on Tuesday. It comes amid a string of similar attacks, causing Shell to be the latest to suspend all Red Sea shipments

    On Tuesday, British maritime security firm Ambrey has identified that the Zografia, a Malta-flagged Greek-owned bulk carrier, has suffered direct hit by a missile while going northbound in the Red Sea, near the Yemeni port city of Saleef.

    In a fresh statement, CENTCOM has announced, “On 11 January 2024, while conducting a flag verification, U.S. CENTCOM Navy forces conducted a night-time seizure of a dhow conducting illegal transport of advanced lethal aid from Iran to resupply Houthi forces in Yemen as part of the Houthis’ ongoing campaign of attacks against international merchant shipping.” So Iranian weapons are continuing to be shipped to the Houthis of Yemen, and thus it looks like Operation Prosperity Guardian is having no significant deterrent impact.

    We have further attacks on Greek and Maltese shipping, having nothing to do with indigenous Palestinian Jews. We have conclusive evidence of Iran’s direct involvement. And, a sensible conclusion that Xi’s first attempt, via his puppet Not-The-President Biden, failed to resolve the issue.

    Xi’s has one best (possibly only) option to get CCP, and everyone else’s, cargo flowing normally again. He has to go to the source of the problem, Ayatollah Khamenei, and stop it there. As long as Khamenei’s proxies are a threat to everyone, Asian cargo to Europe will be slower and more costly to deliver.

    It is really not that hard to figure out what is going on. Alas, common sense is not always common.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/two-fresh-houthi-attacks-tankers-red-sea-one-suffers-direct-missile-strike

    • Replies: @Philip Owen
    @A123

    Meanwhile, Saudi Arabia is backing away from the BRICS+ saying it hasn't really joined yet. Realized who protects it when things get violent? Doesn't want to make up to Iran any more?

  554. @Gerard1234
    @German_reader


    I wasn’t thinking of it being so much a Slav thing. More like a “Soviet legacy” thing (not just regarding civilians, e.g. Arestovych in the interview I linked to said Ukraine was throwing away lives of its soldiers in a careless manner, and also attributed that to a Soviet-like mentality).
     
    It's true that Banderastan is a magnet for every misconception and every actual bad thing about the Soviet Union. It's a caricature of it. Much of their fake nationalism is just a sick form of provincial Sovietism. Arestovich is just some irrelevant subhuman freak - he says that the Atlantic Ocean is wet, then I would attempt to drive across it assuming there is no water there - that's how credible and honest I view the POS . A huge amount of ukronazi propaganda, is just recycled old western and liberast lies about Soviet Union in WW2 - they need to do this to convince the plankton section of their population that they are "defeating" Russia by faking that "masses" of Russians are dying by using "Soviet" human wave tactics. The rape fakes part of this also. I wrote this just before SMO ( that ukrops would claim this) on Runet.

    The schizophrenic attitude towards the Soviet Union (officially hating it while practically parasiting off it and in many aspects living with it) is one of the main reasons 404 is such a disaster post-1991.

    But I know of course you’ll disagree since you’re one of those who thinks the Soviet Union was wonderful in every respect.
     
    Nazi German scum made Red Army fight for every brick, every staircase in nearly every town and city when they were in retreat. Costing the lives of about 2-5-3 million of our soldiers when we forced the Nazis back through western Europe . How many allies lives lost on western front and Mediterranean front by comparison? How many western soldiers lives lost if forced by Nazi scum to fight for Paris, Rome, Berlin, Hamburg, Amsterdam like Russia had to fight for Stalingrad, Budapest, Prague, Kiev, Berlin etc? (note I am not even considering the severe battles for Soviet cities during the Nazi offensives from 41-42)

    Every military operation is difficult, every terrain has it's own challenges so of course all western land operations since 43 and June 1944 have to be respected, and naval/air operations all interconnected of course......but its an obvious fact that if the positions were reversed regarding intense urban warfare, then several million more American and British lives would be lost and several million Soviet lives would have been saved.

    No, I have never heard of that, totally news to me.
     
    When you use silly sarcasm as that then you discredit yourself. Soviet Officers forcing waves of meat tactics on 15 year old infantry are just extreme western lies and exaggerations (i.e there is some truth, but not much to it), but if one side (Anglo-US) have all the major cities peacefully surrendered to , but the other side are forced into viscous fights for nearly every city - then I think its extremely disrespectful and stupid to have these (mis) conceptions of Red Army

    I suppose all this relies on assumption that Soviet casualty lists are accurate and not 15+, or 20 million military deaths , instead of the official 8.5 million figure. The truth is that we will never know, but I do know that much of Wehrmacht anecdotal "evidence" about the Red Army is obvious propaganda BS. You could still say that the official 8.5 million number indicates reckless tactics from Red Army, even taking out numbers killed from battles for all the cities - I don't. Outside of sickening Nazi crimes to Soviet POW's , military deaths from the 8.5 million are 1 to 1 between Nazis and Soviets ( that isn't the sole measure , but I am just mentioning it)

    The sarcasm is also ridiculous as the massive numbers of Soviet civilians killed would suggest Red Army losses that weren't disproportionate.

    On another issue - a Soviet pilot was was by far the safest job of any other pilot in WW2, even though we flew nearly 4 million sorties ( far more than everyone else) . The Luftwaffe flew about 1/3rd of that but received about the same number of losses.
    Japan of course had kamikaze pilots, British pilot was near death sentence ( well, one in every 2 killed), American appear to have abnormal loss of pilots and planes in non-combat missions (JFK's brother was I think killed in UK performing test flight on reconnaissance plane that he was told not to fly). An individual fighter or attack pilot is , in practical terms, worth far more than an individual soldier or sailor - so intelligent deployment, training, protection of them to create this relatively lower number of losses does not suggest a reckless Soviet military command.

    Air defence of our cities and important locations was far superior to German air defence of their cities and British defence of their key locations. Air Defence of cities and losses of our airforce does suggest leadership who were not uninterested and do value Soviet citizens life

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @German_reader, @Sean

    In John Merriman’s History of Europe he has two numbers.

    Dead Soviets WWII: somewhere between 20 and 30 million.

    Dead Jews WWII: around 6.2 million.

    Accurate to the nearest 10 million v. accurate to the nearest hundred thousand. Having an error bar of 100 000 indicates an epic catastrophe. What do you call 100 simultaneous epic catastrophes? In Russian they might have a word for this but in English they do not. Any way 1.) they both are obviously invented numbers; 2.) hope we never see such but YOU NEVER KNOW.

    Merriman has done some fine history despite being innumerate.

  555. German_reader says:
    @Gerard1234
    @German_reader


    I wasn’t thinking of it being so much a Slav thing. More like a “Soviet legacy” thing (not just regarding civilians, e.g. Arestovych in the interview I linked to said Ukraine was throwing away lives of its soldiers in a careless manner, and also attributed that to a Soviet-like mentality).
     
    It's true that Banderastan is a magnet for every misconception and every actual bad thing about the Soviet Union. It's a caricature of it. Much of their fake nationalism is just a sick form of provincial Sovietism. Arestovich is just some irrelevant subhuman freak - he says that the Atlantic Ocean is wet, then I would attempt to drive across it assuming there is no water there - that's how credible and honest I view the POS . A huge amount of ukronazi propaganda, is just recycled old western and liberast lies about Soviet Union in WW2 - they need to do this to convince the plankton section of their population that they are "defeating" Russia by faking that "masses" of Russians are dying by using "Soviet" human wave tactics. The rape fakes part of this also. I wrote this just before SMO ( that ukrops would claim this) on Runet.

    The schizophrenic attitude towards the Soviet Union (officially hating it while practically parasiting off it and in many aspects living with it) is one of the main reasons 404 is such a disaster post-1991.

    But I know of course you’ll disagree since you’re one of those who thinks the Soviet Union was wonderful in every respect.
     
    Nazi German scum made Red Army fight for every brick, every staircase in nearly every town and city when they were in retreat. Costing the lives of about 2-5-3 million of our soldiers when we forced the Nazis back through western Europe . How many allies lives lost on western front and Mediterranean front by comparison? How many western soldiers lives lost if forced by Nazi scum to fight for Paris, Rome, Berlin, Hamburg, Amsterdam like Russia had to fight for Stalingrad, Budapest, Prague, Kiev, Berlin etc? (note I am not even considering the severe battles for Soviet cities during the Nazi offensives from 41-42)

    Every military operation is difficult, every terrain has it's own challenges so of course all western land operations since 43 and June 1944 have to be respected, and naval/air operations all interconnected of course......but its an obvious fact that if the positions were reversed regarding intense urban warfare, then several million more American and British lives would be lost and several million Soviet lives would have been saved.

    No, I have never heard of that, totally news to me.
     
    When you use silly sarcasm as that then you discredit yourself. Soviet Officers forcing waves of meat tactics on 15 year old infantry are just extreme western lies and exaggerations (i.e there is some truth, but not much to it), but if one side (Anglo-US) have all the major cities peacefully surrendered to , but the other side are forced into viscous fights for nearly every city - then I think its extremely disrespectful and stupid to have these (mis) conceptions of Red Army

    I suppose all this relies on assumption that Soviet casualty lists are accurate and not 15+, or 20 million military deaths , instead of the official 8.5 million figure. The truth is that we will never know, but I do know that much of Wehrmacht anecdotal "evidence" about the Red Army is obvious propaganda BS. You could still say that the official 8.5 million number indicates reckless tactics from Red Army, even taking out numbers killed from battles for all the cities - I don't. Outside of sickening Nazi crimes to Soviet POW's , military deaths from the 8.5 million are 1 to 1 between Nazis and Soviets ( that isn't the sole measure , but I am just mentioning it)

    The sarcasm is also ridiculous as the massive numbers of Soviet civilians killed would suggest Red Army losses that weren't disproportionate.

    On another issue - a Soviet pilot was was by far the safest job of any other pilot in WW2, even though we flew nearly 4 million sorties ( far more than everyone else) . The Luftwaffe flew about 1/3rd of that but received about the same number of losses.
    Japan of course had kamikaze pilots, British pilot was near death sentence ( well, one in every 2 killed), American appear to have abnormal loss of pilots and planes in non-combat missions (JFK's brother was I think killed in UK performing test flight on reconnaissance plane that he was told not to fly). An individual fighter or attack pilot is , in practical terms, worth far more than an individual soldier or sailor - so intelligent deployment, training, protection of them to create this relatively lower number of losses does not suggest a reckless Soviet military command.

    Air defence of our cities and important locations was far superior to German air defence of their cities and British defence of their key locations. Air Defence of cities and losses of our airforce does suggest leadership who were not uninterested and do value Soviet citizens life

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @German_reader, @Sean

    When you use silly sarcasm as that then you discredit yourself.

    Well, what do you expect? I don’t think I’ve denied German crimes, but it’s been 80 years and the tendency to treat WW2 as if it happened yesterday is irritating. Given what kind of site this is, you should be content that I’m not some full-on “revisionist” who argues WW2 Germans did nothing wrong.
    Another factor: The kind of Germans who constantly go on about their “historical responsibility”, German guilt etc. are frequently the ones who are most fanatical about current-day issues. People like Baerbock, the sort of people who want to see Russia totally defeated and re-constructed (because Putin is a “fascist” and then they’d be on the right side for once, or whatever). Or the clowns who have now made it their mission to defend Israel at the ICC. So careful what you wish for.
    As for the historical arguments, sure, the perception of the Red army as an unskilled horde winning only through sheer mass is inaccurate and unfair. I don’t think I’ve ever argued along those lines myself either. However, you make some nonsensical arguments yourself, e.g.

    Air defence of our cities and important locations was far superior to German air defence of their cities and British defence of their key locations.

    this is a totally misleading comparison. Soviet Union in WW2 never faced a combined day-and-night offensive of heavy four-engined bombers (plus fighter escorts, eventually) like the British and Americans carried out against Germany in the last three years or so of the war. German bombing in the Soviet Union wasn’t even on as concentrated a level as it had been against Britain in 1940. It did kill quite a few civilians (40 000-50 000 iirc, according to Richard Overy who’s probably the leading expert), but it was mostly of the tactical kind, nothing like a concentrated strategic offensive. And after 1942 at the latest Luftwaffe mostly had to focus on defense against the Anglo-American bomber offensive anyway.
    As for

    Air Defence of cities and losses of our airforce does suggest leadership who were not uninterested and do value Soviet citizens life

    I’m completely unconvinced. But not much point arguing about it.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @German_reader


    ...Baerbock, the sort of people who want to see Russia totally defeated and re-constructed...because Putin is a “fascist” and then they’d be on the right side for once
     
    I think Baerbock is driven by her strong green instincts: she sees Russia as messy, wasteful and fears it could spread. She is also the classical obedient "over-achieving" girl.

    I am more puzzled by Olaf: mild guy who says off-the-wall stuff and reacts like an irritable introverted uncle. His eyes are very shifty, he seems unable to focus. Does he have a mild form of Asperger's?

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    , @Gerard1234
    @German_reader


    This is a totally misleading comparison. Soviet Union in WW2 never faced a combined day-and-night air offensive
     
    Well I did suspect that would be your response, but it's clear to me that because of successful Soviet air defence the Nazis were forced to greatly reduce their bombing campaign. You can still see the small chamber at the top of a few buildings in Moscow today where the anti-aircraft guns were installed.


    British didn't have successful Air defence, so Nazis encouraged to bomb them more.

    Britain didn't have to face 4-engine heavy bombers from the Luftwaffe either. For the British/Americans strategic bombing on Nazi Germany then you are correct - but I don't think my comment about superiority of Soviet air defence is disproven. Western allied bombing wasn't close to the level you describe until mid-1943 so I do think comparisons of British vs Soviet air defences from 1941-43 are useful


    Though the threat is much greater, the Lancaster and the other heavy bombers are easier to intercept, and the distance for spotting and early warning as RAF & USAF planes fly over the sea and several Nazi controlled countries before reaching targets in Germany..... is about the same as from Nazi seized airfields in the east to Soviet targets.
    W

    Replies: @German_reader

  556. @Emil Nikola Richard
    Why NOBODY will build EV charging stations

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a05eu1N42c0&ab_channel=MGUYAustralia

    Replies: @A123

    Why NOBODY will build EV charging stations

    The largest charging station in the U.S. runs on diesel fuel. Many are fed by coal plants.

    Plug-in EV’s do not help the environment, pose serious fire risks, and periodically have outrageous repair bills. The technology is not ready for mass commercialization. And, absent extensive, inexpensive nuclear electricity development, may never be suitable.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @A123

    Plug-in EV’s do not help the environment, pose serious fire risks, and periodically have outrageous repair bills. The technology is not ready for mass commercialization. And, absent extensive, inexpensive nuclear electricity development, may never be suitable.

    Why would nuclear towers need to be built for EVs when they can charge at night when excess energy is available?

    I don't care for the Federal push over EVs but they will reach mass commercialization on their own in 5-7 years.

    The lease price will eventually be below the monthly gas bill for enough commuters.

    The EV market does appear that it could crash but that is because too many auto companies overestimated demand. They all got Tesla envy and overinvested.

    But there are some core economics that favor EVs. Right now they are too expensive but gas is not getting cheaper.

    Replies: @A123

  557. @LT1488
    @AnonfromTN

    As they say, formerly Great formerly Britain.

    well well well don't tell that to Mr Galkovsky and his fans

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    don’t tell that to Mr Galkovsky and his fans

    I won’t: you must be nice to people with limited abilities, including people with incurable mental disorders.

  558. @QCIC
    @sudden death

    So who will the Demonrats swap in to run instead of Biden?

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @sudden death

    So who will the Demonrats swap in to run instead of Biden?

    They don’t need to swap. As US “elections” in 2020 and several “elections” in Zimbabwe before that showed, with necessary level of fraud corrupt senile half-corpse wins.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN


    ...They don’t need to swap.
     
    For a "swap" they will need an event, Biden's health scare or something with that Indian VP woman.

    Plan B is showing its contours: accept Trump, but force the other Indian woman on him as VP. (The swarthy squaws are running wild in the land of the free.) Senate is ruled by never-Trumpers and that would put Trump under full control: president in name only.

    Trump would be allowed to do his stand-up comedy routine but the wars and lib idiocy would go on - Heyderabad harridan would stand over him like a sword of Damocles.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @AnonfromTN, @AnonfromTN

  559. @Gerard1234
    @German_reader


    I wasn’t thinking of it being so much a Slav thing. More like a “Soviet legacy” thing (not just regarding civilians, e.g. Arestovych in the interview I linked to said Ukraine was throwing away lives of its soldiers in a careless manner, and also attributed that to a Soviet-like mentality).
     
    It's true that Banderastan is a magnet for every misconception and every actual bad thing about the Soviet Union. It's a caricature of it. Much of their fake nationalism is just a sick form of provincial Sovietism. Arestovich is just some irrelevant subhuman freak - he says that the Atlantic Ocean is wet, then I would attempt to drive across it assuming there is no water there - that's how credible and honest I view the POS . A huge amount of ukronazi propaganda, is just recycled old western and liberast lies about Soviet Union in WW2 - they need to do this to convince the plankton section of their population that they are "defeating" Russia by faking that "masses" of Russians are dying by using "Soviet" human wave tactics. The rape fakes part of this also. I wrote this just before SMO ( that ukrops would claim this) on Runet.

    The schizophrenic attitude towards the Soviet Union (officially hating it while practically parasiting off it and in many aspects living with it) is one of the main reasons 404 is such a disaster post-1991.

    But I know of course you’ll disagree since you’re one of those who thinks the Soviet Union was wonderful in every respect.
     
    Nazi German scum made Red Army fight for every brick, every staircase in nearly every town and city when they were in retreat. Costing the lives of about 2-5-3 million of our soldiers when we forced the Nazis back through western Europe . How many allies lives lost on western front and Mediterranean front by comparison? How many western soldiers lives lost if forced by Nazi scum to fight for Paris, Rome, Berlin, Hamburg, Amsterdam like Russia had to fight for Stalingrad, Budapest, Prague, Kiev, Berlin etc? (note I am not even considering the severe battles for Soviet cities during the Nazi offensives from 41-42)

    Every military operation is difficult, every terrain has it's own challenges so of course all western land operations since 43 and June 1944 have to be respected, and naval/air operations all interconnected of course......but its an obvious fact that if the positions were reversed regarding intense urban warfare, then several million more American and British lives would be lost and several million Soviet lives would have been saved.

    No, I have never heard of that, totally news to me.
     
    When you use silly sarcasm as that then you discredit yourself. Soviet Officers forcing waves of meat tactics on 15 year old infantry are just extreme western lies and exaggerations (i.e there is some truth, but not much to it), but if one side (Anglo-US) have all the major cities peacefully surrendered to , but the other side are forced into viscous fights for nearly every city - then I think its extremely disrespectful and stupid to have these (mis) conceptions of Red Army

    I suppose all this relies on assumption that Soviet casualty lists are accurate and not 15+, or 20 million military deaths , instead of the official 8.5 million figure. The truth is that we will never know, but I do know that much of Wehrmacht anecdotal "evidence" about the Red Army is obvious propaganda BS. You could still say that the official 8.5 million number indicates reckless tactics from Red Army, even taking out numbers killed from battles for all the cities - I don't. Outside of sickening Nazi crimes to Soviet POW's , military deaths from the 8.5 million are 1 to 1 between Nazis and Soviets ( that isn't the sole measure , but I am just mentioning it)

    The sarcasm is also ridiculous as the massive numbers of Soviet civilians killed would suggest Red Army losses that weren't disproportionate.

    On another issue - a Soviet pilot was was by far the safest job of any other pilot in WW2, even though we flew nearly 4 million sorties ( far more than everyone else) . The Luftwaffe flew about 1/3rd of that but received about the same number of losses.
    Japan of course had kamikaze pilots, British pilot was near death sentence ( well, one in every 2 killed), American appear to have abnormal loss of pilots and planes in non-combat missions (JFK's brother was I think killed in UK performing test flight on reconnaissance plane that he was told not to fly). An individual fighter or attack pilot is , in practical terms, worth far more than an individual soldier or sailor - so intelligent deployment, training, protection of them to create this relatively lower number of losses does not suggest a reckless Soviet military command.

    Air defence of our cities and important locations was far superior to German air defence of their cities and British defence of their key locations. Air Defence of cities and losses of our airforce does suggest leadership who were not uninterested and do value Soviet citizens life

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @German_reader, @Sean

    I have read that after the fall of communism pit with thousands of men women and children, ordinary Soviet people shot in the Great Terror were discovered. Some were discovered by accident which suggest large numbers still exist undisturbed. Moreover it is said that the Soviets would force their own civilians ahead of them to clear a path through a minefield.

    Many Soviet aces scored most of their kills using the Bell Air Cobra, which was given to the Russians because it was loathed and though they were in production and available, got rejected by the British and Americans . The US’s current earning to debt ratio was last as high as high at the end 0f WW2 The Russians were delighted with the Air Cobras because previous Western aid planes were trashed Hurricanes from the RAF. All this stuff was a gift from American taxpayers to the companies producing it , Ditto the near half million trucks the Soviets were given that certainly were the key to their victories as they moved West. Eventually the Russians took from imported technology and produced greatly improved fighter planes years into the war, but they were always inferior to the best American ones during WW2.

    From all this we can take the following lessons:-
    1 Russians are incredibly ruthless with their own people.

    2 Home produced Russian stuff is technically backward, but with a bit of input from allies they can cobble together fairly effective weapons in great numbers, although this takes them quite a lot of time.

    3 The Russian way is slow mass effect while accepting not inconsiderable casualties; their problems advancing in a sustained way are few as long as they don’t over extend themselves.

    The (relatively primitive) FPV drone production on an industrial scale raining on Ukrainian infantry positions and the FAB lash ups of 1950s bombs obliterating real strongpoints are the keys to the war now. The propinquity and importance of Ukraine makes it very unlikely that Russia would in any circumstances feel the need to cut its losses in Ukraine. So an inexorable advance by Russia at considerable cost to them is the most likely outlook for the future of the war.

  560. @A123
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    Why NOBODY will build EV charging stations
     
    The largest charging station in the U.S. runs on diesel fuel. Many are fed by coal plants.

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=vVUDNNmPTeQ

    Plug-in EV's do not help the environment, pose serious fire risks, and periodically have outrageous repair bills. The technology is not ready for mass commercialization. And, absent extensive, inexpensive nuclear electricity development, may never be suitable.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Plug-in EV’s do not help the environment, pose serious fire risks, and periodically have outrageous repair bills. The technology is not ready for mass commercialization. And, absent extensive, inexpensive nuclear electricity development, may never be suitable.

    Why would nuclear towers need to be built for EVs when they can charge at night when excess energy is available?

    I don’t care for the Federal push over EVs but they will reach mass commercialization on their own in 5-7 years.

    The lease price will eventually be below the monthly gas bill for enough commuters.

    The EV market does appear that it could crash but that is because too many auto companies overestimated demand. They all got Tesla envy and overinvested.

    But there are some core economics that favor EVs. Right now they are too expensive but gas is not getting cheaper.

    • Replies: @A123
    @John Johnson


    Why would nuclear towers need to be built for EVs when they can charge at night when excess energy is available?
     
    You are assuming everyone has access to night charging. House owners may not be able to afford a dedicated rig. Renters and condo owners who street/lot park likely will have no options.

    The lease price will eventually be below the monthly gas bill for enough commuters.
     
    Cost will remain difficult for some time. Those dependent on fast charge stations often have HIGHER per mile expense versus liquid fuel. Combine that with higher electric vehicle prices and the economics do not look promising.
    ____

    Here is another issue -- How will hurricane evacuations work with EV's?

    Gas stations are often backed up trying to dispense adequate liquid consumables. Plug in recharging is vastly slower. And, incoming inclement weather is potentially extremely negative for wind/solar.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @John Johnson, @QCIC, @songbird

  561. @AnonfromTN
    @QCIC


    So who will the Demonrats swap in to run instead of Biden?
     
    They don’t need to swap. As US “elections” in 2020 and several “elections” in Zimbabwe before that showed, with necessary level of fraud corrupt senile half-corpse wins.

    Replies: @Beckow

    …They don’t need to swap.

    For a “swap” they will need an event, Biden’s health scare or something with that Indian VP woman.

    Plan B is showing its contours: accept Trump, but force the other Indian woman on him as VP. (The swarthy squaws are running wild in the land of the free.) Senate is ruled by never-Trumpers and that would put Trump under full control: president in name only.

    Trump would be allowed to do his stand-up comedy routine but the wars and lib idiocy would go on – Heyderabad harridan would stand over him like a sword of Damocles.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Beckow

    For a “swap” they will need an event, Biden’s health scare or something with that Indian VP woman.

    Such a swap could have been planned over a year ago.

    Biden could plan to announce a last minute health problem and then hand it to Kamala. Boom female minority president overnight.

    I'd really not like that scenario to be plausible but Biden has a serious case of the White guilts. This is the guy that told an audience that a Black man invented the light bulb.

    I wouldn't put anything past him. In his mind he may think he is putting the world on some divine path towards equality.

    Or Biden knows that Kamala is awful and wants to get rid of her. We know he doesn't like her on a personal level but Biden still may see himself as some "bringer of the new age" and egalitarian savior.

    Or maybe Kamala knows that she is in over her head and plans on leaving to avoid inevitable embarrassment if she becomes president.

    There is too much uncertainty with Biden. If Trump really cared about defeating Biden then he would quit and endorse Haley. She polls not only better with independents but also moderate Democrats. Biden would flip if he had to face her. His best chance is a run-off with a Trump that catches a felony while leading the primary. That then leads to division in the GOP as to how they should proceed.

    Replies: @AP, @A123, @Beckow

    , @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    Trump would be allowed to do his stand-up comedy routine but the wars and lib idiocy would go on
     
    If the US elites have any brains (which is a big if, considering what they have been doing lately), that would be plan B. We’ll see whether they are smart enough to have a plan. Their activity in Ukraine suggests that they are not.

    BTW, blame game is in full swing: Western MSM accuse clown’s regime of all sorts of sins; clown in Davos accused the West of working for Russia. Reminds me of the saying that you don’t need elaborate conspiracy theories when simple stupidity explains everything satisfactorily.
    , @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    Heyderabad harridan would stand over him like a sword of Damocles.
     
    Frankly, I do not have a generally negative view of Indians. I personally know maybe a couple of dozen (in many cases I don’t know whether they are Hindus, Muslims, or do not believe in any fairy tales at all). The Indians I know cover the same spectrum as Whites and Chinese: some are very bright, some quite dumb, many in between; some are hard-working, some lazy, most in between; some honest, some most certainly not.

    As Western politicians go, they are all scum, regardless of their color and origin. I have yet to see a politician more trustworthy than a used car salesman.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow

  562. Russian conscripts told to get in hole and f-ck each other:
    https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/1855307/russian-conscripts-stripped-ukraine-war-latest

    This must be that healthy Orthodox culture that Tucker has talked about.

    World’s highest abortion rate and they have actually have a video of their conscripts being told to butt-fuck each other as punishment.

    Oh and it sounds like they are gunning for the #1 spot in alcoholism. Watch out Belarus!
    https://www.msn.com/en-us/health/other/alcoholism-surges-in-russia-amid-ukraine-war/ar-AA1n09tJ

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @John Johnson

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/1034529/russia-total-number-of-abortions/

    Abortions in Russia have declined from 2 million in 2000 to less than 400,000 in 2022 and will further decline to 250,000 by 2025.

  563. @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN


    ...They don’t need to swap.
     
    For a "swap" they will need an event, Biden's health scare or something with that Indian VP woman.

    Plan B is showing its contours: accept Trump, but force the other Indian woman on him as VP. (The swarthy squaws are running wild in the land of the free.) Senate is ruled by never-Trumpers and that would put Trump under full control: president in name only.

    Trump would be allowed to do his stand-up comedy routine but the wars and lib idiocy would go on - Heyderabad harridan would stand over him like a sword of Damocles.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @AnonfromTN, @AnonfromTN

    For a “swap” they will need an event, Biden’s health scare or something with that Indian VP woman.

    Such a swap could have been planned over a year ago.

    Biden could plan to announce a last minute health problem and then hand it to Kamala. Boom female minority president overnight.

    I’d really not like that scenario to be plausible but Biden has a serious case of the White guilts. This is the guy that told an audience that a Black man invented the light bulb.

    I wouldn’t put anything past him. In his mind he may think he is putting the world on some divine path towards equality.

    Or Biden knows that Kamala is awful and wants to get rid of her. We know he doesn’t like her on a personal level but Biden still may see himself as some “bringer of the new age” and egalitarian savior.

    Or maybe Kamala knows that she is in over her head and plans on leaving to avoid inevitable embarrassment if she becomes president.

    There is too much uncertainty with Biden. If Trump really cared about defeating Biden then he would quit and endorse Haley. She polls not only better with independents but also moderate Democrats. Biden would flip if he had to face her. His best chance is a run-off with a Trump that catches a felony while leading the primary. That then leads to division in the GOP as to how they should proceed.

    • Replies: @AP
    @John Johnson


    There is too much uncertainty with Biden. If Trump really cared about defeating Biden then he would quit and endorse Haley. She polls not only better with independents but also moderate Democrats. Biden would flip if he had to face her. His best chance is a run-off with a Trump that catches a felony while leading the primary. That then leads to division in the GOP as to how they should proceed.
     
    The Democrats’ only chance of retaining the presidency is if Trump wins the primary and then gets convicted of something. So they will do what they can to help him become the Republican candidate. It may backfire and he may win the presidency anyways, but at least (for them) he is much less effective than a president DeSantis would have been.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ

    , @A123
    @John Johnson


    If Trump really cared about defeating Biden then he would quit and endorse Haley.
     
    Trump cares about America / MAGA. Nikki Biden and Joe Haley are different wrappers for virtually identical anti-MAGA policy. Trump has no motivation to endorse a pro-war, establishment Globalist.

    Those of us who believe in MAGA policy (not necessarily Trump) would vote 3rd party or write-in against warmonger Nikki Haley. She has no chance of winning, regardless of how it may seem in Leftoid polls.

    Perhaps the DNC will nominate Nikki Haley. She ticks the necessary boxes over there, and has 0% chance of being Trump's VP. You state she polls well with moderate Democrats.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @QCIC

    , @Beckow
    @John Johnson

    Well, I don't know the details - and unlike you I don't browse for silly unverifiable videos that could, and probably are, made by some security service with an agenda - but it seems to any observer that Biden is not the one to make that decision. So his feelings and aspirations for women of color are irrelevant.

    The Indian shrew, who is very unpleasant to look and listen to, has no different positions than Biden: she is identical on everything: foreign policy, wars, business, social stuff...I can see why an uncritical uber-conformist like you would like her.

    It has been said that no matter who competes in the US election you always get a John McCain: militarist a..hole with liberal social policies, mindlessly "capitalist", devoted to MIC and easy money, globalist, always a fan of open borders. Even Trump for all the demonization didn't depart too far from that formula - he openly praised open borders and "competitive" labor markets. Quite a democracy you have there, why do you even bother?

    But in your defense the original celebrated Greek 'democracy' was not much better. Or the Roman 'republic'. You live on half-ass myths and that is a sad existence. Reality is so much more interesting....:)

    Replies: @John Johnson

  564. @German_reader
    @Gerard1234


    When you use silly sarcasm as that then you discredit yourself.
     
    Well, what do you expect? I don't think I've denied German crimes, but it's been 80 years and the tendency to treat WW2 as if it happened yesterday is irritating. Given what kind of site this is, you should be content that I'm not some full-on "revisionist" who argues WW2 Germans did nothing wrong.
    Another factor: The kind of Germans who constantly go on about their "historical responsibility", German guilt etc. are frequently the ones who are most fanatical about current-day issues. People like Baerbock, the sort of people who want to see Russia totally defeated and re-constructed (because Putin is a "fascist" and then they'd be on the right side for once, or whatever). Or the clowns who have now made it their mission to defend Israel at the ICC. So careful what you wish for.
    As for the historical arguments, sure, the perception of the Red army as an unskilled horde winning only through sheer mass is inaccurate and unfair. I don't think I've ever argued along those lines myself either. However, you make some nonsensical arguments yourself, e.g.

    Air defence of our cities and important locations was far superior to German air defence of their cities and British defence of their key locations.
     
    this is a totally misleading comparison. Soviet Union in WW2 never faced a combined day-and-night offensive of heavy four-engined bombers (plus fighter escorts, eventually) like the British and Americans carried out against Germany in the last three years or so of the war. German bombing in the Soviet Union wasn't even on as concentrated a level as it had been against Britain in 1940. It did kill quite a few civilians (40 000-50 000 iirc, according to Richard Overy who's probably the leading expert), but it was mostly of the tactical kind, nothing like a concentrated strategic offensive. And after 1942 at the latest Luftwaffe mostly had to focus on defense against the Anglo-American bomber offensive anyway.
    As for

    Air Defence of cities and losses of our airforce does suggest leadership who were not uninterested and do value Soviet citizens life
     
    I'm completely unconvinced. But not much point arguing about it.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    …Baerbock, the sort of people who want to see Russia totally defeated and re-constructed…because Putin is a “fascist” and then they’d be on the right side for once

    I think Baerbock is driven by her strong green instincts: she sees Russia as messy, wasteful and fears it could spread. She is also the classical obedient “over-achieving” girl.

    I am more puzzled by Olaf: mild guy who says off-the-wall stuff and reacts like an irritable introverted uncle. His eyes are very shifty, he seems unable to focus. Does he have a mild form of Asperger’s?

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    I am more puzzled by Olaf: mild guy who says off-the-wall stuff and reacts like an irritable introverted uncle. His eyes are very shifty, he seems unable to focus. Does he have a mild form of Asperger’s?
     
    Let me remind you that idiocy is also a clinical condition. Incurable, like other mental disorders.
  565. @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    The 1890 and 1910 censuses are generally considered very manipulated by the Budapest Magyar government. For example almost all government employees, students and soldiers were listed as of Magyar ethnicity, they were in no position to disagree. The census takers would ask if a person understood the Magyar language and if they said yes, they were listed as Magyars. All Jews also declared Magyar nationality. After WW1 censuses showed around 15-20% fewer Magyars. Some of it was a reverse manipulation by the new states, but most of it was people saying who they really were.

    Trianon was a massive shrinkage of Hungary - they were punished much more than the Austrians, actually Austria got the region of Burgerland from Hungary. But there was no other way: in the last 20 years before WW1 the Hungarians went on a nationalist rampage trying to "magyarize" everyone, being totally unreasonable, suffering from a narcissistic vertigo. Then they lost a war.

    The new lines mostly followed geographic boundaries, rivers, mountains. The Hungarians refused to negotiate and insisted on keeping everything - thus the borders were drawn for them. There is a lesson there for others, like the Ukies: if a situation is unsustainable make a deal early and be reasonable.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. XYZ

    The census takers would ask if a person understood the Magyar language and if they said yes, they were listed as Magyars. All Jews also declared Magyar nationality.

    I realize you might not be the person to ask, but was the census in Hungary different from the one in Austria? In Austria they asked about language and about religion, but not about ethnicity (which could usually be inferred from language). So an urban Polish-speaking Ukrainian would be Polish by language and Greek Catholic by religion. Many ethnic Jews were Polish by language but Jewish by religion. There was no “ethnicity” to declare.

    Trianon was a massive shrinkage of Hungary

    Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder and squatter in the heart of Slavic lands, separating Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians from their Slovenian and Croatian brothers. The product of Asian invaders and plains-dwelling Slavs whom they conquered and assimilated, Magyars behaved terribly towards Slavs. During the first world war, Hungarian troops engaged in numerous massacres of various Slavs including Ukrainians. During the Second World War, they were Hitler’s partners. They were lucky that they weren’t deported en masse to their ancient Eurasian homeland. They must miss it on some level, as evidenced by their love of Putin. In the case of Putin’s war, Hungary again chooses the side that is killing Slavs – Russia.

    And in their insolence these historical persecutors of Slavs dare to whine about Hungarian language schools in Ukraine.

    Ukrainians lived under Austria, Hungary and Russia. Hungarian-controlled Ukraine was the worst, a land of poverty, persecution, aggressive Magyarization, illiteracy. Russia was terrible by policy, but it’s administration was incompetent and rather non-intrusive so the policies were not terribly harmful to regular people. Austria was the best. Under benevolent Austrian rule, Galicians were the most educated and wealthiest of the Eastern Slavs, the first to achieve full literacy of students, Ukrainian-language university courses, etc.

    Slovaks seem to have been willing lackeys of the Magyars. I wonder if without Czech pushing (or Wilson’s encouragement) they would even have chosen independence from them. The patterns repeat themselves with Fico. Though there are plenty of decent Slovaks too.

    The Hungarians refused to negotiate

    There is a small but not zero chance that the Hungarians will manage to get themselves out of EU and NATO protection (probably not formally, but perhaps in terms of voting rights).

    • Agree: Mr. Hack
    • Replies: @German_reader
    @AP


    Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder and squatter in the heart of Slavic lands, separating Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians from their Slovenian and Croatian brothers. The product of Asian invaders and plains-dwelling Slavs whom they conquered and assimilated, Magyars behaved terribly towards Slavs. During the first world war, Hungarian troops engaged in numerous massacres of various Slavs including Ukrainians. During the Second World War, they were Hitler’s partners. They were lucky that they weren’t deported en masse to their ancient Eurasian homeland. They must miss it on some level, as evidenced by their love of Putin. In the case of Putin’s war, Hungary again chooses the side that is killing Slavs – Russia.
    And in their insolence these historical persecutors of Slavs dare to whine about Hungarian language schools in Ukraine.
     
    Sentiments like these must be the perfect advertisement for Ukraine's European aspirations.

    Replies: @AP

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder and squatter in the heart of Slavic lands, separating Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians from their Slovenian and Croatian brothers. The product of Asian invaders and plains-dwelling Slavs whom they conquered and assimilated, Magyars behaved terribly towards Slavs. During the first world war, Hungarian troops engaged in numerous massacres of various Slavs including Ukrainians. During the Second World War, they were Hitler’s partners. They were lucky that they weren’t deported en masse to their ancient Eurasian homeland. They must miss it on some level, as evidenced by their love of Putin. In the case of Putin’s war, Hungary again chooses the side that is killing Slavs – Russia.

    And in their insolence these historical persecutors of Slavs dare to whine about Hungarian language schools in Ukraine.
     

    Seems like Eurasian Russia really did choose the wrong side to back back in 1848-1849, no? A Eurasian Russian allied with a newly independent Eurasian Hungary and without any opposition from Austria in its desire to expand its sphere of influence into the Balkans in subsequent decades must have been an ideal scenario for Eurasian Russia, no?

    Also ironic that Eurasian Hungary is so hostile towards Muslims given that Islam, like Christianity, is a Eurasian religion.


    There is a small but not zero chance that the Hungarians will manage to get themselves out of EU and NATO protection (probably not formally, but perhaps in terms of voting rights).

     

    Is there any legal procedure/process for stripping an existing EU or NATO member country of its voting rights? And even if there is, it would need to be unanimous, no? So, Poland, Slovakia, et cetera would all need to be on board for this. Good luck getting Robert Fico's Slovakia to agree to this for fear of subsequently having this EU procedure/process be used by the EU against their own country as well!
    , @Beckow
    @AP


    ...was the census in Hungary different from the one in Austria?
     
    The census was a combination of administration and nationalist goals: in Hungary the nationalist impulse by 1890 became very dominant, in Austria it was a lot more professional. Austria was definitely a lot better place.

    Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder
     
    It was 1100 years ago and I am not going to worry about anything that far back. The people the incoming Magyars assimilated were mostly Latin Panonians, Germanic tribes and Slavs, there were also other populations like Illyrians, leftover Avars, etc...it was 1,000 years ago and it is not relevant.

    Hungarians have their point of view, many don't like the Slavs and Germans, but many do...they celebrate their "Asian" heritage and also run away from it. You are oversimplifying.

    Slovaks have lived side by side with Magyars for 1,000 years without much mixing. We used Latin in admin and German in commerce and until the nationalist era in the 19th century we got along quite well. But you are wrong, after the unfortunate Magyar failed attempt at "Magyarization" that happened only in the last 20-25 years befor 1918 there is a lot of bad blood. To put it bluntly: we don't like each other. Fico is a nationalist with strong anti-Magyar policies - it is the pro-Western liberals who are pro-Magyar. The fact that both Orban and Fico are kind of anti-EU and neutral in the Ukie war changes nothing (neutral means being in effect pro-Russia). They find areas to agree on.

    Kiev is being told to negotiate the best deal they can get by more EU leaders, the latest one is Italy. The Ukies screwed up: they went for everything and will end up with less than they easily could have had. The Nato membership nonsense put a fork in it. They only have themselves to blame and the idiot remote cheerleaders who put them up to it.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    Slovaks seem to have been willing lackeys of the Magyars. I wonder if without Czech pushing (or Wilson’s encouragement) they would even have chosen independence from them. The patterns repeat themselves with Fico. Though there are plenty of decent Slovaks too.

     

    Without the Czechs pushing for independence, it's unlikely that the Slovaks would have either. After all, an independent Slovakia would be easier to bully than a unified Czechoslovakia would. However, if the Czechs push for independence, they are virtually certain to also push for Slovak independence in order for their new country to become a bigger power than it would have otherwise been. An independent Czechia would also be around 30% German, which would be quite a significant demographic problem. Adding Slovakia into the mix would reduce the German percentage in Czechoslovakia to around 22%.

    FWIW, the arguments that Czechoslovakia supporters invoked during WWI, especially in 1917-1918, for the necessity of the creation of Czechoslovakia is that a surviving Austria-Hungary is likely to remain a German satellite state and that thus it's best to weaken German power by destroying Austria-Hungary and freeing a huge part of Austria-Hungary's subject peoples and utilizing their manpower for the Allied cause. I can't say that their logic was completely wrong. After all, Austria eagerly joined the German Reich in early 1938 and Hungary was a loyal lapdog to Nazi Germany in the 1938-1944/5* time period. The main weakness of this approach is that the Bolsheviks removed Russia from Europe and thus it was harder to rely on Russia to help maintain the European balance of power in the post-WWI decades.

    *Hungary tried to switch sides in 1944 but was replaced with a more pliant Hungarian government.
    , @LT1488
    @AP

    ''Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder and squatter in the heart of Slavic lands, separating Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians from their Slovenian and Croatian brothers. The product of Asian invaders and plains-dwelling Slavs whom they conquered and assimilated, Magyars behaved terribly towards Slavs. During the first world war, Hungarian troops engaged in numerous massacres of various Slavs including Ukrainians. During the Second World War, they were Hitler’s partners. They were lucky that they weren’t deported en masse to their ancient Eurasian homeland. They must miss it on some level, as evidenced by their love of Putin. In the case of Putin’s war, Hungary again chooses the side that is killing Slavs – Russia.''

    First of all even the Ugric Hungarians had majority R1B haplogroup.
    And on top of that most Hungarians aren't Ugric, they are a slavo-germanic populace.
    The ''Ukrainians'' in Carpathia, are actually a distinct ethnic group called the Rusyns, whose rights are recognized by Hungary, Slovakia, Serbia, Croatia and Poland.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  566. @John Johnson
    @A123

    Plug-in EV’s do not help the environment, pose serious fire risks, and periodically have outrageous repair bills. The technology is not ready for mass commercialization. And, absent extensive, inexpensive nuclear electricity development, may never be suitable.

    Why would nuclear towers need to be built for EVs when they can charge at night when excess energy is available?

    I don't care for the Federal push over EVs but they will reach mass commercialization on their own in 5-7 years.

    The lease price will eventually be below the monthly gas bill for enough commuters.

    The EV market does appear that it could crash but that is because too many auto companies overestimated demand. They all got Tesla envy and overinvested.

    But there are some core economics that favor EVs. Right now they are too expensive but gas is not getting cheaper.

    Replies: @A123

    Why would nuclear towers need to be built for EVs when they can charge at night when excess energy is available?

    You are assuming everyone has access to night charging. House owners may not be able to afford a dedicated rig. Renters and condo owners who street/lot park likely will have no options.

    The lease price will eventually be below the monthly gas bill for enough commuters.

    Cost will remain difficult for some time. Those dependent on fast charge stations often have HIGHER per mile expense versus liquid fuel. Combine that with higher electric vehicle prices and the economics do not look promising.
    ____

    Here is another issue — How will hurricane evacuations work with EV’s?

    Gas stations are often backed up trying to dispense adequate liquid consumables. Plug in recharging is vastly slower. And, incoming inclement weather is potentially extremely negative for wind/solar.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @A123


    Why would nuclear towers need to be built for EVs when they can charge at night when excess energy is available?
     
    You are assuming everyone has access to night charging. House owners may not be able to afford a dedicated rig. Renters and condo owners who street/lot park likely will have no options.

    I'm not assuming that at all. I never said they are for everyone or that they will replace gas engines.

    I said they will reach mass commercialization on their own. Which means a viable commercial market just like hybrids.

    Cost will remain difficult for some time. Those dependent on fast charge stations often have HIGHER per mile expense versus liquid fuel.

    It depends on where you live and if you use the commercial charging stations. EV range will increase while gas will go up. It's entirely possible that the commercial charging model is flawed. They may work best for people that charge at home.

    Here is another issue — How will hurricane evacuations work with EV’s?

    They may indeed be worse off in that situation. In other situations they will be better like California where gas is a rip and fuel lines are common. Have you ever gassed up in an area like Santa Barbara in the summer? People in areas like California and NY will buy them to avoid gas stations.

    The economics will work on their own and in fact we don't need any Federal subsidies. This is an area where the private market can optimize usage. The MAGA crowd is wrong that the whole thing is some subsidized conspiracy by big government. The subsidies were actually drastically cut this year.

    If anything this is an ideal market. The wealthy have lined up to be the guinea pigs so the kinks will be worked out by the time they are affordable for the middle class. I really don't care if commercial charging stations go broke based on optimistic models. I never invested in them. It may even benefit rural America to have Wall street capital fund them and then bail.

    , @QCIC
    @A123

    A good hybrid car would solve the charging and range problem for situations beyond commuting and city car applications. The range extender engine needs to have enough power to charge the battery and move the car at near-highway speeds if the battery is croaked. I think this is around 30 horsepower.

    This has been understood for a long time, but I have not heard of a hybrid that gets it right. The Honda Insight should have been OK but the engine was too large and the battery too small. I think the climate crowd is against any car that burns dead dinosaurs which may have hampered growth of hybrids. Never mind that most EV juice comes from fossil fuel generation.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @AnonfromTN, @Emil Nikola Richard

    , @songbird
    @A123

    In the early '80s, there was a TV show by Glen Larson costarring the son of Lucille Ball and Desi Arnez called Automan.

    https://youtu.be/kA1NT4I0s34?si=opxYaKP-jQh8rVev

    Only ever saw one episode, that I caught on Archive. But the basic premise was that this nerdy cop used computers to create a hologram super-hero, to help him fight crime.

    What made the show interesting in a way was how they tied it to the working of the grid. Automan could only appear at night, when he could draw on the excess capacity of the grid. Once people woke up and began using their toasters, he disappeared, until the next night.

  567. @John Johnson
    @Beckow

    For a “swap” they will need an event, Biden’s health scare or something with that Indian VP woman.

    Such a swap could have been planned over a year ago.

    Biden could plan to announce a last minute health problem and then hand it to Kamala. Boom female minority president overnight.

    I'd really not like that scenario to be plausible but Biden has a serious case of the White guilts. This is the guy that told an audience that a Black man invented the light bulb.

    I wouldn't put anything past him. In his mind he may think he is putting the world on some divine path towards equality.

    Or Biden knows that Kamala is awful and wants to get rid of her. We know he doesn't like her on a personal level but Biden still may see himself as some "bringer of the new age" and egalitarian savior.

    Or maybe Kamala knows that she is in over her head and plans on leaving to avoid inevitable embarrassment if she becomes president.

    There is too much uncertainty with Biden. If Trump really cared about defeating Biden then he would quit and endorse Haley. She polls not only better with independents but also moderate Democrats. Biden would flip if he had to face her. His best chance is a run-off with a Trump that catches a felony while leading the primary. That then leads to division in the GOP as to how they should proceed.

    Replies: @AP, @A123, @Beckow

    There is too much uncertainty with Biden. If Trump really cared about defeating Biden then he would quit and endorse Haley. She polls not only better with independents but also moderate Democrats. Biden would flip if he had to face her. His best chance is a run-off with a Trump that catches a felony while leading the primary. That then leads to division in the GOP as to how they should proceed.

    The Democrats’ only chance of retaining the presidency is if Trump wins the primary and then gets convicted of something. So they will do what they can to help him become the Republican candidate. It may backfire and he may win the presidency anyways, but at least (for them) he is much less effective than a president DeSantis would have been.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @AP

    The Democrats’ only chance of retaining the presidency is if Trump wins the primary and then gets convicted of something. So they will do what they can to help him become the Republican candidate. It may backfire and he may win the presidency anyways, but at least (for them) he is much less effective than a president DeSantis would have been.

    The irony is that the Democrats spend so much time obsessing over Trump and yet he is their best chance to retain the white house.

    Practically any non-Biden no-name Democrat defeats Trump because of independents in swing states.

    Trump only wins a slight majority of independents when they are forced to choose between a felon and a president that gets lost when getting off the airplane. But that is according to current data and Trump still has the documents trial. He could easily sour more independents if he actually catches a felony which would erase his small gains.

    Both Biden and Trump are ego maniacs. If Biden really wanted to defeat Trump then he would announce that he won't run for a second term as he originally promised.

    DeSantis should quit. He isn't a bad guy but he is splitting the pot and Haley does better with independents.

    Replies: @Sean, @Mikel, @Mr. XYZ

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    So they will do what they can to help him become the Republican candidate.
     
    Possibly, but at the same time, they're trying to disqualify him based on the 14th Amendment as well. Is that a backup option for them? Because I get the impression that Democrats really care about the US and thus aggressively don't want Trump to win reelection, even if that means another Republican such as Haley winning in his place.
  568. German_reader says:
    @AP
    @Beckow


    The census takers would ask if a person understood the Magyar language and if they said yes, they were listed as Magyars. All Jews also declared Magyar nationality.
     
    I realize you might not be the person to ask, but was the census in Hungary different from the one in Austria? In Austria they asked about language and about religion, but not about ethnicity (which could usually be inferred from language). So an urban Polish-speaking Ukrainian would be Polish by language and Greek Catholic by religion. Many ethnic Jews were Polish by language but Jewish by religion. There was no “ethnicity” to declare.

    Trianon was a massive shrinkage of Hungary
     
    Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder and squatter in the heart of Slavic lands, separating Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians from their Slovenian and Croatian brothers. The product of Asian invaders and plains-dwelling Slavs whom they conquered and assimilated, Magyars behaved terribly towards Slavs. During the first world war, Hungarian troops engaged in numerous massacres of various Slavs including Ukrainians. During the Second World War, they were Hitler’s partners. They were lucky that they weren’t deported en masse to their ancient Eurasian homeland. They must miss it on some level, as evidenced by their love of Putin. In the case of Putin’s war, Hungary again chooses the side that is killing Slavs - Russia.

    And in their insolence these historical persecutors of Slavs dare to whine about Hungarian language schools in Ukraine.

    Ukrainians lived under Austria, Hungary and Russia. Hungarian-controlled Ukraine was the worst, a land of poverty, persecution, aggressive Magyarization, illiteracy. Russia was terrible by policy, but it’s administration was incompetent and rather non-intrusive so the policies were not terribly harmful to regular people. Austria was the best. Under benevolent Austrian rule, Galicians were the most educated and wealthiest of the Eastern Slavs, the first to achieve full literacy of students, Ukrainian-language university courses, etc.

    Slovaks seem to have been willing lackeys of the Magyars. I wonder if without Czech pushing (or Wilson’s encouragement) they would even have chosen independence from them. The patterns repeat themselves with Fico. Though there are plenty of decent Slovaks too.

    The Hungarians refused to negotiate

     

    There is a small but not zero chance that the Hungarians will manage to get themselves out of EU and NATO protection (probably not formally, but perhaps in terms of voting rights).

    Replies: @German_reader, @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

    Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder and squatter in the heart of Slavic lands, separating Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians from their Slovenian and Croatian brothers. The product of Asian invaders and plains-dwelling Slavs whom they conquered and assimilated, Magyars behaved terribly towards Slavs. During the first world war, Hungarian troops engaged in numerous massacres of various Slavs including Ukrainians. During the Second World War, they were Hitler’s partners. They were lucky that they weren’t deported en masse to their ancient Eurasian homeland. They must miss it on some level, as evidenced by their love of Putin. In the case of Putin’s war, Hungary again chooses the side that is killing Slavs – Russia.
    And in their insolence these historical persecutors of Slavs dare to whine about Hungarian language schools in Ukraine.

    Sentiments like these must be the perfect advertisement for Ukraine’s European aspirations.

    • LOL: songbird
    • Replies: @AP
    @German_reader

    Lol, I’m not a diplomat so I described the reality openly. Don’t pretend that other Eastern Europeans (the ones who have a better future) don’t have similar thoughts.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

  569. @John Johnson
    @Beckow

    For a “swap” they will need an event, Biden’s health scare or something with that Indian VP woman.

    Such a swap could have been planned over a year ago.

    Biden could plan to announce a last minute health problem and then hand it to Kamala. Boom female minority president overnight.

    I'd really not like that scenario to be plausible but Biden has a serious case of the White guilts. This is the guy that told an audience that a Black man invented the light bulb.

    I wouldn't put anything past him. In his mind he may think he is putting the world on some divine path towards equality.

    Or Biden knows that Kamala is awful and wants to get rid of her. We know he doesn't like her on a personal level but Biden still may see himself as some "bringer of the new age" and egalitarian savior.

    Or maybe Kamala knows that she is in over her head and plans on leaving to avoid inevitable embarrassment if she becomes president.

    There is too much uncertainty with Biden. If Trump really cared about defeating Biden then he would quit and endorse Haley. She polls not only better with independents but also moderate Democrats. Biden would flip if he had to face her. His best chance is a run-off with a Trump that catches a felony while leading the primary. That then leads to division in the GOP as to how they should proceed.

    Replies: @AP, @A123, @Beckow

    If Trump really cared about defeating Biden then he would quit and endorse Haley.

    Trump cares about America / MAGA. Nikki Biden and Joe Haley are different wrappers for virtually identical anti-MAGA policy. Trump has no motivation to endorse a pro-war, establishment Globalist.

    Those of us who believe in MAGA policy (not necessarily Trump) would vote 3rd party or write-in against warmonger Nikki Haley. She has no chance of winning, regardless of how it may seem in Leftoid polls.

    Perhaps the DNC will nominate Nikki Haley. She ticks the necessary boxes over there, and has 0% chance of being Trump’s VP. You state she polls well with moderate Democrats.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @A123

    Nimarata as Democrat candidate might not be impossible, especially as part of another rigged vote scenario. They could give her credit for a bunch of Republican cross-over votes.

  570. @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN


    ...They don’t need to swap.
     
    For a "swap" they will need an event, Biden's health scare or something with that Indian VP woman.

    Plan B is showing its contours: accept Trump, but force the other Indian woman on him as VP. (The swarthy squaws are running wild in the land of the free.) Senate is ruled by never-Trumpers and that would put Trump under full control: president in name only.

    Trump would be allowed to do his stand-up comedy routine but the wars and lib idiocy would go on - Heyderabad harridan would stand over him like a sword of Damocles.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @AnonfromTN, @AnonfromTN

    Trump would be allowed to do his stand-up comedy routine but the wars and lib idiocy would go on

    If the US elites have any brains (which is a big if, considering what they have been doing lately), that would be plan B. We’ll see whether they are smart enough to have a plan. Their activity in Ukraine suggests that they are not.

    BTW, blame game is in full swing: Western MSM accuse clown’s regime of all sorts of sins; clown in Davos accused the West of working for Russia. Reminds me of the saying that you don’t need elaborate conspiracy theories when simple stupidity explains everything satisfactorily.

  571. @Beckow
    @German_reader


    ...Baerbock, the sort of people who want to see Russia totally defeated and re-constructed...because Putin is a “fascist” and then they’d be on the right side for once
     
    I think Baerbock is driven by her strong green instincts: she sees Russia as messy, wasteful and fears it could spread. She is also the classical obedient "over-achieving" girl.

    I am more puzzled by Olaf: mild guy who says off-the-wall stuff and reacts like an irritable introverted uncle. His eyes are very shifty, he seems unable to focus. Does he have a mild form of Asperger's?

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    I am more puzzled by Olaf: mild guy who says off-the-wall stuff and reacts like an irritable introverted uncle. His eyes are very shifty, he seems unable to focus. Does he have a mild form of Asperger’s?

    Let me remind you that idiocy is also a clinical condition. Incurable, like other mental disorders.

  572. @AP
    @John Johnson


    There is too much uncertainty with Biden. If Trump really cared about defeating Biden then he would quit and endorse Haley. She polls not only better with independents but also moderate Democrats. Biden would flip if he had to face her. His best chance is a run-off with a Trump that catches a felony while leading the primary. That then leads to division in the GOP as to how they should proceed.
     
    The Democrats’ only chance of retaining the presidency is if Trump wins the primary and then gets convicted of something. So they will do what they can to help him become the Republican candidate. It may backfire and he may win the presidency anyways, but at least (for them) he is much less effective than a president DeSantis would have been.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ

    The Democrats’ only chance of retaining the presidency is if Trump wins the primary and then gets convicted of something. So they will do what they can to help him become the Republican candidate. It may backfire and he may win the presidency anyways, but at least (for them) he is much less effective than a president DeSantis would have been.

    The irony is that the Democrats spend so much time obsessing over Trump and yet he is their best chance to retain the white house.

    Practically any non-Biden no-name Democrat defeats Trump because of independents in swing states.

    Trump only wins a slight majority of independents when they are forced to choose between a felon and a president that gets lost when getting off the airplane. But that is according to current data and Trump still has the documents trial. He could easily sour more independents if he actually catches a felony which would erase his small gains.

    Both Biden and Trump are ego maniacs. If Biden really wanted to defeat Trump then he would announce that he won’t run for a second term as he originally promised.

    DeSantis should quit. He isn’t a bad guy but he is splitting the pot and Haley does better with independents.

    • Replies: @Sean
    @John Johnson

    Haley is a woman and with a woman as the main opposition, candidates previously thought unelectable get into the White House (Obama and Trump).

    Replies: @John Johnson

    , @Mikel
    @John Johnson


    DeSantis should quit.
     
    To give way to the candidate in 3rd position that he has nothing in common with. You wish.

    It's probably more important than ever that DeSantis stays in the race (unless Haley quits too). The last thing we need if Trump doesn't make it to November is no MAGAs in the race and a Nikki leading in delegates after Trump. The fact that she polls so well among liberals is the very reason why no one should vote for her. Forget those polls and put your signature here instead: https://nevernikki.net/

    Replies: @John Johnson

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson


    Practically any non-Biden no-name Democrat defeats Trump because of independents in swing states.

     

    Even Pete Buttigieg?
  573. @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN


    ...They don’t need to swap.
     
    For a "swap" they will need an event, Biden's health scare or something with that Indian VP woman.

    Plan B is showing its contours: accept Trump, but force the other Indian woman on him as VP. (The swarthy squaws are running wild in the land of the free.) Senate is ruled by never-Trumpers and that would put Trump under full control: president in name only.

    Trump would be allowed to do his stand-up comedy routine but the wars and lib idiocy would go on - Heyderabad harridan would stand over him like a sword of Damocles.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @AnonfromTN, @AnonfromTN

    Heyderabad harridan would stand over him like a sword of Damocles.

    Frankly, I do not have a generally negative view of Indians. I personally know maybe a couple of dozen (in many cases I don’t know whether they are Hindus, Muslims, or do not believe in any fairy tales at all). The Indians I know cover the same spectrum as Whites and Chinese: some are very bright, some quite dumb, many in between; some are hard-working, some lazy, most in between; some honest, some most certainly not.

    As Western politicians go, they are all scum, regardless of their color and origin. I have yet to see a politician more trustworthy than a used car salesman.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @AnonfromTN

    The Indians I know cover the same spectrum as Whites and Chinese: some are very bright, some quite dumb, many in between; some are hard-working, some lazy, most in between; some honest, some most certainly not.

    Yea I really doubt you have worked with many of them.

    The common annoyance factor is arrogance.

    Dot Indians privately view themselves as superior to Americans. Even though India is covered in child beggars and filth they actually view India as the birthplace of higher civilization. Their class system ramps up the arrogance even further.

    Americans hate dealing with them over phone support and this is why. An Indian in some office hell doing support all day still views himself as a superior being. They can be extremely condescending as they view Whites as crude brutes with a few lucky geniuses. As in White inventions were mostly luck. They really believe India is going to be some great country and is just temporarily covered in garbage.

    They move to America and ironically look down on Americans. Well why did you move here? I've never seen them at community fundraisers for non-profits. They buy German luxury cars and isolate themselves. I guess they are gods among us for owning a mini mart and buying a BMW. I've stopped in the middle America in the most rural area and still had a Dot Indian give me a condensing look. Such an eyeroll.

    Replies: @QCIC

    , @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AnonfromTN

    https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/DVUAAOSwdnJkneb3/s-l1200.jpg


    Frankly, I do not have a generally negative view of Indians.
     
    I guess you are very high on the visible status ladder.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    , @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN


    ...The Indians I know cover the same spectrum as Whites and Chinese...As Western politicians go, they are all scum
     
    I have to disagree. You are probably more exposed to the higher-achieving Indians in the academia. The context of "Whites" is also different. Indians came to our societies after throughly trashing their own previous quite nice subcontinent. Their behavior happens in that context - and it is in general toxic. There is a reason the larger-India looks the way it does - they are not very capable people: they have failed to sustain a civilization.

    People on Unz often obsess about individual IQ - but what matters is the society's IQ (or national) and the only way to measure it is by what the resulting society looks like. By that standard it is immediately obvious that the Indian-Paki society's IQ is very low: they live in a crap country getting worse. (Or Austria's IQ is higher than UK or Sweden.)

    The Indians are desperately trying to leave their sh..hole country, it is a career: to migrate to the West. But the destructive behaviors come with them, you can see it in politicians like Sunak, Haley. Kamala...a combination of servility and arrogance, as if the compradors arrived home. There are exceptions, but the overall impact has been to make an already bad situation worse.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

  574. @A123
    @John Johnson


    If Trump really cared about defeating Biden then he would quit and endorse Haley.
     
    Trump cares about America / MAGA. Nikki Biden and Joe Haley are different wrappers for virtually identical anti-MAGA policy. Trump has no motivation to endorse a pro-war, establishment Globalist.

    Those of us who believe in MAGA policy (not necessarily Trump) would vote 3rd party or write-in against warmonger Nikki Haley. She has no chance of winning, regardless of how it may seem in Leftoid polls.

    Perhaps the DNC will nominate Nikki Haley. She ticks the necessary boxes over there, and has 0% chance of being Trump's VP. You state she polls well with moderate Democrats.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @QCIC

    Nimarata as Democrat candidate might not be impossible, especially as part of another rigged vote scenario. They could give her credit for a bunch of Republican cross-over votes.

  575. @A123
    @John Johnson


    Why would nuclear towers need to be built for EVs when they can charge at night when excess energy is available?
     
    You are assuming everyone has access to night charging. House owners may not be able to afford a dedicated rig. Renters and condo owners who street/lot park likely will have no options.

    The lease price will eventually be below the monthly gas bill for enough commuters.
     
    Cost will remain difficult for some time. Those dependent on fast charge stations often have HIGHER per mile expense versus liquid fuel. Combine that with higher electric vehicle prices and the economics do not look promising.
    ____

    Here is another issue -- How will hurricane evacuations work with EV's?

    Gas stations are often backed up trying to dispense adequate liquid consumables. Plug in recharging is vastly slower. And, incoming inclement weather is potentially extremely negative for wind/solar.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @John Johnson, @QCIC, @songbird

    Why would nuclear towers need to be built for EVs when they can charge at night when excess energy is available?

    You are assuming everyone has access to night charging. House owners may not be able to afford a dedicated rig. Renters and condo owners who street/lot park likely will have no options.

    I’m not assuming that at all. I never said they are for everyone or that they will replace gas engines.

    I said they will reach mass commercialization on their own. Which means a viable commercial market just like hybrids.

    Cost will remain difficult for some time. Those dependent on fast charge stations often have HIGHER per mile expense versus liquid fuel.

    It depends on where you live and if you use the commercial charging stations. EV range will increase while gas will go up. It’s entirely possible that the commercial charging model is flawed. They may work best for people that charge at home.

    Here is another issue — How will hurricane evacuations work with EV’s?

    They may indeed be worse off in that situation. In other situations they will be better like California where gas is a rip and fuel lines are common. Have you ever gassed up in an area like Santa Barbara in the summer? People in areas like California and NY will buy them to avoid gas stations.

    The economics will work on their own and in fact we don’t need any Federal subsidies. This is an area where the private market can optimize usage. The MAGA crowd is wrong that the whole thing is some subsidized conspiracy by big government. The subsidies were actually drastically cut this year.

    If anything this is an ideal market. The wealthy have lined up to be the guinea pigs so the kinks will be worked out by the time they are affordable for the middle class. I really don’t care if commercial charging stations go broke based on optimistic models. I never invested in them. It may even benefit rural America to have Wall street capital fund them and then bail.

  576. @A123
    @John Johnson


    Why would nuclear towers need to be built for EVs when they can charge at night when excess energy is available?
     
    You are assuming everyone has access to night charging. House owners may not be able to afford a dedicated rig. Renters and condo owners who street/lot park likely will have no options.

    The lease price will eventually be below the monthly gas bill for enough commuters.
     
    Cost will remain difficult for some time. Those dependent on fast charge stations often have HIGHER per mile expense versus liquid fuel. Combine that with higher electric vehicle prices and the economics do not look promising.
    ____

    Here is another issue -- How will hurricane evacuations work with EV's?

    Gas stations are often backed up trying to dispense adequate liquid consumables. Plug in recharging is vastly slower. And, incoming inclement weather is potentially extremely negative for wind/solar.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @John Johnson, @QCIC, @songbird

    A good hybrid car would solve the charging and range problem for situations beyond commuting and city car applications. The range extender engine needs to have enough power to charge the battery and move the car at near-highway speeds if the battery is croaked. I think this is around 30 horsepower.

    This has been understood for a long time, but I have not heard of a hybrid that gets it right. The Honda Insight should have been OK but the engine was too large and the battery too small. I think the climate crowd is against any car that burns dead dinosaurs which may have hampered growth of hybrids. Never mind that most EV juice comes from fossil fuel generation.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @QCIC

    The range extender engine needs to have enough power to charge the battery and move the car at near-highway speeds if the battery is croaked. I think this is around 30 horsepower.

    You are talking about a hybrid where the gas engine only exists to charge the battery? Ram is coming out with that.

    A key problem with that model is that the randomness of the gas engine can be unnerving. It already happens with hybrids where the engine kicks in at high RPM to charge the battery if it gets too low. Imagine pulling away slowly in heavy traffic and then the engine kicks into high RPM. It sort of makes a disconnected driving experience. I'd rather have an EV that simply worked as a second car. Then use a gas vehicle for trips.

    This has been understood for a long time, but I have not heard of a hybrid that gets it right. The Honda Insight should have been OK but the engine was too large and the battery too small.

    The Prius definitely works as intended but I hate how they drive. They are too clunky and the regenerative brakes are rough. I'd rather a car that had 10 less mpg but actually drove like a car. I think Fusion had the right idea but Ford got rid of it.

    Replies: @QCIC, @A123

    , @AnonfromTN
    @QCIC


    I think the climate crowd is against any car that burns dead dinosaurs which may have hampered growth of hybrids. Never mind that most EV juice comes from fossil fuel generation.
     
    The whole “climate change” fable is BS, promoted by powerful interests that reap huge financial benefits from “carbon tax”, “environmental” tax breaks, production of solar panels, batteries, etc. “Climate change” people can never answer two questions: 1) how come the Mesozoic era (that lasted almost 200 million years) on Earth was so warm, even though there were no humans, no burning fossil fuels, etc.; 2) why would a sensible person believe the predictions about climate in 50-100 years by the same people who cannot predict the weather tomorrow. Although I know the answer to the second one: it is safe to “predict” distant future, as your “predictions” will be forgotten, so there would be no one to point out that they were wrong.

    BTW, oil has nothing to do with dead dinosaurs: the amount of oil on Earth, as well as the abundance of similar hydrocarbons on some moons of Jupiter prove beyond reasonable doubt its abiotic origin.

    As far as environmental damage and CO2 emissions are concerned, if you take into account manufacture and subsequent disposal, EV batteries and solar panels are at least as bad as coal-powered generation, much worse for the environment then power plants using natural gas, and many times worse than nuclear. The main drawback of traditional nuclear power plants was spent fuel rods that contain most of radioactive uranium and will be radioactive for millions of years. Russia built a mid-size nuclear reactor that uses “spent” fuel and returns it really spent, essentially non-radioactive. Based on its success, it is now building a large reactor using the same technology. However, Western MSM would never tell you this, as the reality is politically incorrect.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @songbird

    , @Emil Nikola Richard
    @QCIC

    Chicago-area Tesla charging stations lined with dead cars in freezing cold: 'A bunch of dead robots out here'

    https://www.foxbusiness.com/technology/chicago-area-tesla-charging-stations-lined-with-dead-cars-in-freezing-cold-a-bunch-of-dead-robots-out-here

    no paywall: https://archive.is/OonFh#selection-965.0-965.109

    Replies: @songbird, @QCIC

  577. @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    Heyderabad harridan would stand over him like a sword of Damocles.
     
    Frankly, I do not have a generally negative view of Indians. I personally know maybe a couple of dozen (in many cases I don’t know whether they are Hindus, Muslims, or do not believe in any fairy tales at all). The Indians I know cover the same spectrum as Whites and Chinese: some are very bright, some quite dumb, many in between; some are hard-working, some lazy, most in between; some honest, some most certainly not.

    As Western politicians go, they are all scum, regardless of their color and origin. I have yet to see a politician more trustworthy than a used car salesman.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow

    The Indians I know cover the same spectrum as Whites and Chinese: some are very bright, some quite dumb, many in between; some are hard-working, some lazy, most in between; some honest, some most certainly not.

    Yea I really doubt you have worked with many of them.

    The common annoyance factor is arrogance.

    Dot Indians privately view themselves as superior to Americans. Even though India is covered in child beggars and filth they actually view India as the birthplace of higher civilization. Their class system ramps up the arrogance even further.

    Americans hate dealing with them over phone support and this is why. An Indian in some office hell doing support all day still views himself as a superior being. They can be extremely condescending as they view Whites as crude brutes with a few lucky geniuses. As in White inventions were mostly luck. They really believe India is going to be some great country and is just temporarily covered in garbage.

    They move to America and ironically look down on Americans. Well why did you move here? I’ve never seen them at community fundraisers for non-profits. They buy German luxury cars and isolate themselves. I guess they are gods among us for owning a mini mart and buying a BMW. I’ve stopped in the middle America in the most rural area and still had a Dot Indian give me a condensing look. Such an eyeroll.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    I assume there is an Indian organized crime element in the USA but have not read about it.

  578. @Yahya
    @songbird


    Possibly, the sister of one of our commenters might know her.

     

    Is this referring to yours truly?

    I'm close friends with one Bin Laden (Osama's nephew), and know of his close family members from a distance. I showed him Noor Bin Laden's twitter profile but he said he never met her (she is one of ~140 or so cousins).

    The Bin Ladens I know are fairly Westernized and have cosmopolitan backgrounds. My above-mentioned friend is half-English and currently lives in London. Completely secular and about as far away from an Islamist as you can get (his favorite pastime is drinking whiskey and smoking weed in his studio). Typical really of wealthy Arabs, who tend towards secularism rather than Islamism. Osama was kind of a fluke.

    Many of the male members of the Bin Laden family enjoy flying planes as a hobby, my friend included. Runs in the family.

    Replies: @songbird

    Thanks.

    As for anime: a pretty cliched recommendation, but if you haven’t seen it and can tolerate a romance, I’d say Your Name (2016.)

    [MORE]

    It is a pretty good showcase of modern techniques to show light and capture real life locations. The plot does involve some elements of Japanese culture like shrine maidens and the red thread of fate. And Shinkai has become the most famous director, after Miyazaki.

    On the negative side, it is a bit poppy – missing the moments of silence often considered to be characteristic of anime.

    If you want something more action-orienated, there is Sword of the Stranger.

    Not the most original story certainly, but pretty watchable.

  579. @QCIC
    @A123

    A good hybrid car would solve the charging and range problem for situations beyond commuting and city car applications. The range extender engine needs to have enough power to charge the battery and move the car at near-highway speeds if the battery is croaked. I think this is around 30 horsepower.

    This has been understood for a long time, but I have not heard of a hybrid that gets it right. The Honda Insight should have been OK but the engine was too large and the battery too small. I think the climate crowd is against any car that burns dead dinosaurs which may have hampered growth of hybrids. Never mind that most EV juice comes from fossil fuel generation.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @AnonfromTN, @Emil Nikola Richard

    The range extender engine needs to have enough power to charge the battery and move the car at near-highway speeds if the battery is croaked. I think this is around 30 horsepower.

    You are talking about a hybrid where the gas engine only exists to charge the battery? Ram is coming out with that.

    A key problem with that model is that the randomness of the gas engine can be unnerving. It already happens with hybrids where the engine kicks in at high RPM to charge the battery if it gets too low. Imagine pulling away slowly in heavy traffic and then the engine kicks into high RPM. It sort of makes a disconnected driving experience. I’d rather have an EV that simply worked as a second car. Then use a gas vehicle for trips.

    This has been understood for a long time, but I have not heard of a hybrid that gets it right. The Honda Insight should have been OK but the engine was too large and the battery too small.

    The Prius definitely works as intended but I hate how they drive. They are too clunky and the regenerative brakes are rough. I’d rather a car that had 10 less mpg but actually drove like a car. I think Fusion had the right idea but Ford got rid of it.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    The Prius is OK. Most of these also have a non-ideal ratio of engine size to battery capacity. I guess Toyota has not fully bought into the "range extender"concept. As electric motors keep getting smaller this should change. Making the very small engines efficient and clean is also challenging.

    I hate the stop-start engines of many hybrid cars. A range extender hybrid should break out of this by decoupling the engine from driving actions (except in emergencies when the battery has a problem). In the best case the engine is just a very quiet genset and is only coupled to the wheels electrically. Historically the engineers probably needed to use the generator as a motor as well, which gets into various complicated drivetrain arrangements.

    Replies: @QCIC

    , @A123
    @John Johnson

    In addition to the Southern hurricane problem, there is also a Northern one: (1)


    The overwhelming majority of Americans said on Tuesday they are unlikely to consider buying an electric vehicle (EV). The poll comes as EVs strand drivers at their homes and off the sides of roads amid a winter freeze sweeping the United States.

    Rasmussen Reports released the poll, finding that 65 percent of American adults said they are not likely to consider buying an EV when purchasing their next car — including 37 percent who said they are “not at all likely” to buy an EV. Fewer than 3-in-10 Americans said they would consider buying an EV.
     

    Unless there are changes in technology and cost, EV's will remain a niche market.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.breitbart.com/economy/2024/01/16/poll-65-americans-unlikely-buy-electric-cars-they-strand-drivers-winter-freeze/

  580. @John Johnson
    @Beckow

    For a “swap” they will need an event, Biden’s health scare or something with that Indian VP woman.

    Such a swap could have been planned over a year ago.

    Biden could plan to announce a last minute health problem and then hand it to Kamala. Boom female minority president overnight.

    I'd really not like that scenario to be plausible but Biden has a serious case of the White guilts. This is the guy that told an audience that a Black man invented the light bulb.

    I wouldn't put anything past him. In his mind he may think he is putting the world on some divine path towards equality.

    Or Biden knows that Kamala is awful and wants to get rid of her. We know he doesn't like her on a personal level but Biden still may see himself as some "bringer of the new age" and egalitarian savior.

    Or maybe Kamala knows that she is in over her head and plans on leaving to avoid inevitable embarrassment if she becomes president.

    There is too much uncertainty with Biden. If Trump really cared about defeating Biden then he would quit and endorse Haley. She polls not only better with independents but also moderate Democrats. Biden would flip if he had to face her. His best chance is a run-off with a Trump that catches a felony while leading the primary. That then leads to division in the GOP as to how they should proceed.

    Replies: @AP, @A123, @Beckow

    Well, I don’t know the details – and unlike you I don’t browse for silly unverifiable videos that could, and probably are, made by some security service with an agenda – but it seems to any observer that Biden is not the one to make that decision. So his feelings and aspirations for women of color are irrelevant.

    The Indian shrew, who is very unpleasant to look and listen to, has no different positions than Biden: she is identical on everything: foreign policy, wars, business, social stuff…I can see why an uncritical uber-conformist like you would like her.

    It has been said that no matter who competes in the US election you always get a John McCain: militarist a..hole with liberal social policies, mindlessly “capitalist”, devoted to MIC and easy money, globalist, always a fan of open borders. Even Trump for all the demonization didn’t depart too far from that formula – he openly praised open borders and “competitive” labor markets. Quite a democracy you have there, why do you even bother?

    But in your defense the original celebrated Greek ‘democracy’ was not much better. Or the Roman ‘republic’. You live on half-ass myths and that is a sad existence. Reality is so much more interesting….:)

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Beckow

    but it seems to any observer that Biden is not the one to make that decision. So his feelings and aspirations for women of color are irrelevant.

    There is no secret hand that chooses the president. The proof is in that the establishment never wanted Biden. They wanted a woman. Biden was in fact written off before being saved by Blacks in the primary.

    Similar conspiracy theories against Trump are also lacking. Why didn't the conspirators give Biden his desired majority? They only needed to cheat in a couple more races.

    We may not know the president until well into 2025. Even if Biden wins he may plan on quitting partway through the year.

    But in your defense the original celebrated Greek ‘democracy’ was not much better. Or the Roman ‘republic’. You live on half-ass myths and that is a sad existence. Reality is so much more interesting….:)

    I've never once tried to upsell democracy. I don't live on myths and I've gone over political problems in both classical Greece and Rome.

    Democracy is a mess but better than competing systems like the Russian dictatorship.

    I can criticize my government without having to worry about being hauled off in the night.

    The dwarf is terrified of even dissent. He seems scared of women:

    Russian artist given seven years for anti-war protest
    https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/11/17/russian-artist-jailed-for-seven-years-over-anti-war-price-tag-protest

    What a wimp. Locks up a 33 year old woman for being against the war. Real men can explain their actions and take criticism. Putin is a shell of a man and riddled with insecurities.

    Replies: @Sean, @Beckow

  581. @QCIC
    @A123

    A good hybrid car would solve the charging and range problem for situations beyond commuting and city car applications. The range extender engine needs to have enough power to charge the battery and move the car at near-highway speeds if the battery is croaked. I think this is around 30 horsepower.

    This has been understood for a long time, but I have not heard of a hybrid that gets it right. The Honda Insight should have been OK but the engine was too large and the battery too small. I think the climate crowd is against any car that burns dead dinosaurs which may have hampered growth of hybrids. Never mind that most EV juice comes from fossil fuel generation.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @AnonfromTN, @Emil Nikola Richard

    I think the climate crowd is against any car that burns dead dinosaurs which may have hampered growth of hybrids. Never mind that most EV juice comes from fossil fuel generation.

    The whole “climate change” fable is BS, promoted by powerful interests that reap huge financial benefits from “carbon tax”, “environmental” tax breaks, production of solar panels, batteries, etc. “Climate change” people can never answer two questions: 1) how come the Mesozoic era (that lasted almost 200 million years) on Earth was so warm, even though there were no humans, no burning fossil fuels, etc.; 2) why would a sensible person believe the predictions about climate in 50-100 years by the same people who cannot predict the weather tomorrow. Although I know the answer to the second one: it is safe to “predict” distant future, as your “predictions” will be forgotten, so there would be no one to point out that they were wrong.

    BTW, oil has nothing to do with dead dinosaurs: the amount of oil on Earth, as well as the abundance of similar hydrocarbons on some moons of Jupiter prove beyond reasonable doubt its abiotic origin.

    As far as environmental damage and CO2 emissions are concerned, if you take into account manufacture and subsequent disposal, EV batteries and solar panels are at least as bad as coal-powered generation, much worse for the environment then power plants using natural gas, and many times worse than nuclear. The main drawback of traditional nuclear power plants was spent fuel rods that contain most of radioactive uranium and will be radioactive for millions of years. Russia built a mid-size nuclear reactor that uses “spent” fuel and returns it really spent, essentially non-radioactive. Based on its success, it is now building a large reactor using the same technology. However, Western MSM would never tell you this, as the reality is politically incorrect.

    • Agree: QCIC, A123
    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @AnonfromTN

    The main drawback of traditional nuclear power plants was spent fuel rods that contain most of radioactive uranium and will be radioactive for millions of years. Russia built a mid-size nuclear reactor that uses “spent” fuel and returns it really spent, essentially non-radioactive. Based on its success, it is now building a large reactor using the same technology. However, Western MSM would never tell you this, as the reality is politically incorrect.

    There is no conspiracy against nuclear power by the MSM.

    The utility companies don't want to build them. They're too expensive.

    Any Republican that proposed a Federal nuclear plan would be opposed by the MAGA libertarian wing. That would be "big government" overstepping its bounds by intervening in a free market.

    Talking about nuclear is pointless in this country. The "minimal government" Republicans will align with dishonest greenies. Forget about it.

    Here is the pattern:
    1. Republican candidate talks about how we need nuclear power. People nod their heads in agreement.
    2. Republican gets into office.
    3. Republican passes tax cuts for the rich
    4. Republican leaves office and nothing changes over nuclear power

    Both Democrats and Republicans are full of shit. Two parties of con artists.

    Replies: @QCIC, @A123

    , @songbird
    @AnonfromTN

    Supposedly, machine-learning is vastly improving the accuracy of weather forecasting.

    My vague understanding is that it actually takes less energy and time than traditional approaches, as it does not do the same level of number-crunching, but relies more on patterns.

    However, a lot of these AI models in other fields seem to use up a fair amount of juice. If they are really as useful as they say, I have modest hopes that the need for this power will drive a saner energy policy.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  582. @A123
    @John Johnson


    Why would nuclear towers need to be built for EVs when they can charge at night when excess energy is available?
     
    You are assuming everyone has access to night charging. House owners may not be able to afford a dedicated rig. Renters and condo owners who street/lot park likely will have no options.

    The lease price will eventually be below the monthly gas bill for enough commuters.
     
    Cost will remain difficult for some time. Those dependent on fast charge stations often have HIGHER per mile expense versus liquid fuel. Combine that with higher electric vehicle prices and the economics do not look promising.
    ____

    Here is another issue -- How will hurricane evacuations work with EV's?

    Gas stations are often backed up trying to dispense adequate liquid consumables. Plug in recharging is vastly slower. And, incoming inclement weather is potentially extremely negative for wind/solar.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @John Johnson, @QCIC, @songbird

    In the early ’80s, there was a TV show by Glen Larson costarring the son of Lucille Ball and Desi Arnez called Automan.

    [MORE]

    Only ever saw one episode, that I caught on Archive. But the basic premise was that this nerdy cop used computers to create a hologram super-hero, to help him fight crime.

    What made the show interesting in a way was how they tied it to the working of the grid. Automan could only appear at night, when he could draw on the excess capacity of the grid. Once people woke up and began using their toasters, he disappeared, until the next night.

  583. @German_reader
    @AP


    Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder and squatter in the heart of Slavic lands, separating Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians from their Slovenian and Croatian brothers. The product of Asian invaders and plains-dwelling Slavs whom they conquered and assimilated, Magyars behaved terribly towards Slavs. During the first world war, Hungarian troops engaged in numerous massacres of various Slavs including Ukrainians. During the Second World War, they were Hitler’s partners. They were lucky that they weren’t deported en masse to their ancient Eurasian homeland. They must miss it on some level, as evidenced by their love of Putin. In the case of Putin’s war, Hungary again chooses the side that is killing Slavs – Russia.
    And in their insolence these historical persecutors of Slavs dare to whine about Hungarian language schools in Ukraine.
     
    Sentiments like these must be the perfect advertisement for Ukraine's European aspirations.

    Replies: @AP

    Lol, I’m not a diplomat so I described the reality openly. Don’t pretend that other Eastern Europeans (the ones who have a better future) don’t have similar thoughts.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Do you think that, had Austria-Hungary survived, Hungary would have been a pro-Russian pole within Austria-Hungary?

    Was Hungary a pro-Russian pole within Austria-Hungary during the last several decades of its existence in real life? After all, any Russian claims to Galicia (unlike Subcarpathian Ruthenia) did not affect Hungary itself, only Austria. And Russia having a common border with Hungary would not necessarily be to Hungary's disadvantage since Hungary could have used this to extort much more defense spending from Austria on Hungarian territory, such as on the Carpathians (in order to better fortify them and Hungary against any future hypothetical Russian invasion).

    , @LT1488
    @AP

    Hungarians are not hated by most slavic eastern europeans
    Poles,Russians, Czechs, Croats etc like the Hungarians and Poles even consider them their brothers.
    Slovaks and Serbs have some issues with the Magyars, but the current Slovak and Serbian leadership is very friendly with the current Magyar leadership.
    As for other neighbouring eastern Europeans, the Romanians indeed do not like Hungary and haven't even allowed their Hungarian minority right to autonomy. And as for Ukraine, as you said, the Hungarian minority's rights to speak and learn Hungarian are being infringed upon.
    I do not know where you got this logic of slavs and other eastern europeans intensely disliking Hungary when the opposite is true.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

  584. @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    Heyderabad harridan would stand over him like a sword of Damocles.
     
    Frankly, I do not have a generally negative view of Indians. I personally know maybe a couple of dozen (in many cases I don’t know whether they are Hindus, Muslims, or do not believe in any fairy tales at all). The Indians I know cover the same spectrum as Whites and Chinese: some are very bright, some quite dumb, many in between; some are hard-working, some lazy, most in between; some honest, some most certainly not.

    As Western politicians go, they are all scum, regardless of their color and origin. I have yet to see a politician more trustworthy than a used car salesman.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow

    Frankly, I do not have a generally negative view of Indians.

    I guess you are very high on the visible status ladder.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    I guess you are very high on the visible status ladder.
     
    You mean, they respect me out of fear? I think the answer is more prosaic: my cohort is not representative. I work in science, so I only know Indians who work in research. Scientists (real ones, not “humanities” bullshitters and frauds) tend to be nicer people than average (e.g., like visitors in national parks).

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  585. @Beckow
    @John Johnson

    Well, I don't know the details - and unlike you I don't browse for silly unverifiable videos that could, and probably are, made by some security service with an agenda - but it seems to any observer that Biden is not the one to make that decision. So his feelings and aspirations for women of color are irrelevant.

    The Indian shrew, who is very unpleasant to look and listen to, has no different positions than Biden: she is identical on everything: foreign policy, wars, business, social stuff...I can see why an uncritical uber-conformist like you would like her.

    It has been said that no matter who competes in the US election you always get a John McCain: militarist a..hole with liberal social policies, mindlessly "capitalist", devoted to MIC and easy money, globalist, always a fan of open borders. Even Trump for all the demonization didn't depart too far from that formula - he openly praised open borders and "competitive" labor markets. Quite a democracy you have there, why do you even bother?

    But in your defense the original celebrated Greek 'democracy' was not much better. Or the Roman 'republic'. You live on half-ass myths and that is a sad existence. Reality is so much more interesting....:)

    Replies: @John Johnson

    but it seems to any observer that Biden is not the one to make that decision. So his feelings and aspirations for women of color are irrelevant.

    There is no secret hand that chooses the president. The proof is in that the establishment never wanted Biden. They wanted a woman. Biden was in fact written off before being saved by Blacks in the primary.

    Similar conspiracy theories against Trump are also lacking. Why didn’t the conspirators give Biden his desired majority? They only needed to cheat in a couple more races.

    We may not know the president until well into 2025. Even if Biden wins he may plan on quitting partway through the year.

    But in your defense the original celebrated Greek ‘democracy’ was not much better. Or the Roman ‘republic’. You live on half-ass myths and that is a sad existence. Reality is so much more interesting….:)

    I’ve never once tried to upsell democracy. I don’t live on myths and I’ve gone over political problems in both classical Greece and Rome.

    Democracy is a mess but better than competing systems like the Russian dictatorship.

    I can criticize my government without having to worry about being hauled off in the night.

    The dwarf is terrified of even dissent. He seems scared of women:

    Russian artist given seven years for anti-war protest
    https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/11/17/russian-artist-jailed-for-seven-years-over-anti-war-price-tag-protest

    What a wimp. Locks up a 33 year old woman for being against the war. Real men can explain their actions and take criticism. Putin is a shell of a man and riddled with insecurities.

    • Replies: @Sean
    @John Johnson


    The proof is in that the establishment never wanted Biden.
     
    They thought Hillary was a viable candidate even after Obama was preferred to her. And her team failed to court their traditional base of Catholics.

    What a wimp. Locks up a 33 year old woman for being against the war. Real men can explain their actions and take criticism. Putin is a shell of a man and riddled with insecurities
     
    You could say the same about Churchill. By the way, during WW2 a woman who criticized Churchill's leadership in a London pub got five years' hard labour. Women and effeminates men tend towards unsustainably impractical solutions to conflict

    Democracy is a mess but better than competing systems like the Russian dictatorship.
     
    If Washington was trying to make Russia a Western style democracy, the method they chose of attaining their object (fobbing off Putin's attempts to join Nato while advancing Nato to RusFed's borders and chortling at his complaints) did not turn out to be a very effective method, did it?

    What a wimp.
     
    Harvey Mansfield's definition of manliness is "confidence in a situation of risk". In his book, Why We Fight, Mike Martin says the motivation for war is "status and belonging".

    We may not know the president until well into 2025. Even if Biden wins he may plan on quitting partway through the year
     

    It was said Biden would quit before his first term was up, but having achieved the supreme position a man is not gong to give up that status.

    There is no secret hand that chooses the president.
     
    The mass of US states chose Obama, Trump was LOATHED by the elite, and more so now..
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5zQ7_bc64j8

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    , @Beckow
    @John Johnson


    ...The proof is in that the establishment never wanted Biden. They wanted a woman.
     
    No, they simply didn't want Trump and tried everything to make sure it didn't happen. The guiding hand is always flexible and works with what it has.

    Democracy is a mess but better than competing systems like the Russian dictatorship.
    I can criticize my government without having to worry about being hauled off in the night.
     
    A cliche that doesn't translate into anything real. Assange and 1k demonstrators are in jail in a "democracy", many were hauled in the middle of the night. You just refuse to see the same thing as being the same. You either lie, pretend that it didn't happen, or say that you are against it as if that mattered.

    There are better and worse democracies. Russia is not a dictatorship by any standard - it does what the West does, it suppresses dissent (they are in a war), it reduces choices, but for 99.9% of people there is no "dictate", they live their ordinary lives undisturbed. They vote from the approved choices and they are largely powerless to impact most decisions: very similar to what one sees in Germany, UK, France, US....don't preach about a perfect democracy if you haven't been able to have one at home.

    The only way to rationally evaluate a democracy is by results: are the preferences of the majority reflected in what happens. By that standard Russia does rather well - most policies that the majority wants are done. The West less so - there are endless examples from wars to migration to LGbtqX...where the opposite of what the majority wants is done. For decades. So where is the democracy? And don't hide behind the process, how it happens is actually completely irrelevant....

    Replies: @John Johnson

  586. @AnonfromTN
    @QCIC


    I think the climate crowd is against any car that burns dead dinosaurs which may have hampered growth of hybrids. Never mind that most EV juice comes from fossil fuel generation.
     
    The whole “climate change” fable is BS, promoted by powerful interests that reap huge financial benefits from “carbon tax”, “environmental” tax breaks, production of solar panels, batteries, etc. “Climate change” people can never answer two questions: 1) how come the Mesozoic era (that lasted almost 200 million years) on Earth was so warm, even though there were no humans, no burning fossil fuels, etc.; 2) why would a sensible person believe the predictions about climate in 50-100 years by the same people who cannot predict the weather tomorrow. Although I know the answer to the second one: it is safe to “predict” distant future, as your “predictions” will be forgotten, so there would be no one to point out that they were wrong.

    BTW, oil has nothing to do with dead dinosaurs: the amount of oil on Earth, as well as the abundance of similar hydrocarbons on some moons of Jupiter prove beyond reasonable doubt its abiotic origin.

    As far as environmental damage and CO2 emissions are concerned, if you take into account manufacture and subsequent disposal, EV batteries and solar panels are at least as bad as coal-powered generation, much worse for the environment then power plants using natural gas, and many times worse than nuclear. The main drawback of traditional nuclear power plants was spent fuel rods that contain most of radioactive uranium and will be radioactive for millions of years. Russia built a mid-size nuclear reactor that uses “spent” fuel and returns it really spent, essentially non-radioactive. Based on its success, it is now building a large reactor using the same technology. However, Western MSM would never tell you this, as the reality is politically incorrect.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @songbird

    The main drawback of traditional nuclear power plants was spent fuel rods that contain most of radioactive uranium and will be radioactive for millions of years. Russia built a mid-size nuclear reactor that uses “spent” fuel and returns it really spent, essentially non-radioactive. Based on its success, it is now building a large reactor using the same technology. However, Western MSM would never tell you this, as the reality is politically incorrect.

    There is no conspiracy against nuclear power by the MSM.

    The utility companies don’t want to build them. They’re too expensive.

    Any Republican that proposed a Federal nuclear plan would be opposed by the MAGA libertarian wing. That would be “big government” overstepping its bounds by intervening in a free market.

    Talking about nuclear is pointless in this country. The “minimal government” Republicans will align with dishonest greenies. Forget about it.

    Here is the pattern:
    1. Republican candidate talks about how we need nuclear power. People nod their heads in agreement.
    2. Republican gets into office.
    3. Republican passes tax cuts for the rich
    4. Republican leaves office and nothing changes over nuclear power

    Both Democrats and Republicans are full of shit. Two parties of con artists.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    Nuclear power is highly subsidized and would not be commercially available otherwise. The liability from a plant is so high that no one can insure it, so it cannot be funded without subsidies.

    In the long term nuclear power will be important. The Russians are doing good work, including the Brest technology. This may have something to do with having a climate where winter heating is a life or death issue for much of the population. Same idea with nuclear-powered icebreakers.

    Agree on the Republicrats.

    Replies: @A123

    , @A123
    @John Johnson


    the MAGA libertarian wing. That would be “big government” overstepping its bounds by intervening in a free market.
     
    MAGA is avowedly Populist. MAGA Reindustrialization, as an industrial security/trade policy, is actively anti-Libertarian. MAGA wants to use government force against corporations to actively rein in laissez-faire elites who seek to abuse workers via immigration or offshoring. There is nothing Libertarian about that.

    Libertarian exporting of jobs and open borders are now Democrat party policies. The emotionalist dogma of DNC zealots is mind rotting and incoherent. So, I suspect the Sheeple do not realize that they are embracing Libertarianism part of the time.

    PEACE 😇

  587. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AnonfromTN

    https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/DVUAAOSwdnJkneb3/s-l1200.jpg


    Frankly, I do not have a generally negative view of Indians.
     
    I guess you are very high on the visible status ladder.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    I guess you are very high on the visible status ladder.

    You mean, they respect me out of fear? I think the answer is more prosaic: my cohort is not representative. I work in science, so I only know Indians who work in research. Scientists (real ones, not “humanities” bullshitters and frauds) tend to be nicer people than average (e.g., like visitors in national parks).

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AnonfromTN

    The Indians I have known well were all science types. My experience was not good. Such that I agree with Gurdjieff's assessment and Steve Jobs' assessment. Their experience was probably not good either.

    I could tell you stories. A lot of stories. They aren't really that interesting.

  588. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    It's quite interesting that throughout history Slovaks have served as the younger brothers to both the Hungarians and the Czechs. They served as the younger brothers to the Hungarians for much, much longer, but Czech rule was probably better for them than Hungarian rule, at least so long as the Czechs actually had a foreign protector behind themselves and the Slovaks (they didn't in 1938-1939). I don't seem to recall Czechia trying to forcibly Czechify the Slovaks like Hungary did with the Slovaks with its decades-long pre-WWI Magyarization campaign:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magyarization

    I do suspect that, out of Greater Hungary's large subject peoples, the Slovaks were probably the easiest ones to successfully Magyarize had Hungary had even more time to do so:

    https://preview.redd.it/9z2zzo6am2r71.png?width=640&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=097af65f11c92335d05889c085d6e243b595125b

    Slovaks, after all, are mostly Catholic just like Hungarians (Magyars) themselves are. Ruthenians (Ukrainians), Romanians, Serbs, and Croats are not Catholic.

    (Hungarian Jews were, of course, largely successfully Magyarized, but they are a much smaller group and their high average IQ and large amounts of success made them stand out from the Magyars and thus often made Magyars unwilling to accept them as their own even when these Jews themselves were indeed willing to be Magyarized. In contrast, AFAIK, Slovaks and Hungarians (Magyars) have a roughly equal average IQ, so there's no superiority/inferiority complex going on between them in regards to each other, at least in regards to their mental abilities.)

    BTW, it would be cool if Hungary, Slovakia, and Croatia formed a Greater Hungary within the EU (a confederation within a confederation) while Czechia, Austria, and Slovenia formed a Greater Austria within the EU (another confederation within a confederation).

    Replies: @Derer, @WS, @AP, @Beckow

    Croats are very, very Catholic!?
    and BTW why to make some new superstructure out of very homogeneous states?
    K&K monarchy looks simphatietic only on old postcards and maybe as well in many very new Sisi dedicated movies financially supported by EU.
    Coincidence that this very issue (restoration of Habsburgs) is open here again and again in past year?

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @WS

    Yeah, FWIW, my new superstructure talk was primarily just that--as in, empty talk. It's pointless to actually do it because the much larger European Union already exists.

    And Yes, Croatia is a mostly Catholic country:

    https://www.state.gov/reports/2022-report-on-international-religious-freedom/croatia/#:~:text=According%20to%20Croatian%20government%202021,identify%20as%20nonreligious%20or%20atheist.

    "According to Croatian government 2021 census data released on September 22, 79 percent of the population is Catholic, 3.3 percent Serbian Orthodox, and 1.3 percent Muslim. Nearly 5 percent identify as nonreligious or atheist."

    As are Hungary and Slovakia.

  589. @John Johnson
    @AP

    The Democrats’ only chance of retaining the presidency is if Trump wins the primary and then gets convicted of something. So they will do what they can to help him become the Republican candidate. It may backfire and he may win the presidency anyways, but at least (for them) he is much less effective than a president DeSantis would have been.

    The irony is that the Democrats spend so much time obsessing over Trump and yet he is their best chance to retain the white house.

    Practically any non-Biden no-name Democrat defeats Trump because of independents in swing states.

    Trump only wins a slight majority of independents when they are forced to choose between a felon and a president that gets lost when getting off the airplane. But that is according to current data and Trump still has the documents trial. He could easily sour more independents if he actually catches a felony which would erase his small gains.

    Both Biden and Trump are ego maniacs. If Biden really wanted to defeat Trump then he would announce that he won't run for a second term as he originally promised.

    DeSantis should quit. He isn't a bad guy but he is splitting the pot and Haley does better with independents.

    Replies: @Sean, @Mikel, @Mr. XYZ

    Haley is a woman and with a woman as the main opposition, candidates previously thought unelectable get into the White House (Obama and Trump).

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Sean

    Haley is a woman and with a woman as the main opposition, candidates previously thought unelectable get into the White House (Obama and Trump).

    Haley is not Hillary Clinton.

    Independents have never like Hillary. Independents were also tired of the Clinton/Bush dynasties.

    Haley polls a whopping 17 points over Biden
    https://www.wsj.com/livecoverage/gop-republican-debate-iowa/card/behind-haley-s-17-point-lead-over-biden-in-wsj-polling-qByTNcx5uHOCTq443PVW

    Not even close.

    Trump is a needless risk. He has barely gained against Biden in the last year and hasn't recovered his support from independents. Polls show that independents dislike both candidates.

  590. @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    I guess you are very high on the visible status ladder.
     
    You mean, they respect me out of fear? I think the answer is more prosaic: my cohort is not representative. I work in science, so I only know Indians who work in research. Scientists (real ones, not “humanities” bullshitters and frauds) tend to be nicer people than average (e.g., like visitors in national parks).

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    The Indians I have known well were all science types. My experience was not good. Such that I agree with Gurdjieff’s assessment and Steve Jobs’ assessment. Their experience was probably not good either.

    I could tell you stories. A lot of stories. They aren’t really that interesting.

  591. @John Johnson
    @AnonfromTN

    The main drawback of traditional nuclear power plants was spent fuel rods that contain most of radioactive uranium and will be radioactive for millions of years. Russia built a mid-size nuclear reactor that uses “spent” fuel and returns it really spent, essentially non-radioactive. Based on its success, it is now building a large reactor using the same technology. However, Western MSM would never tell you this, as the reality is politically incorrect.

    There is no conspiracy against nuclear power by the MSM.

    The utility companies don't want to build them. They're too expensive.

    Any Republican that proposed a Federal nuclear plan would be opposed by the MAGA libertarian wing. That would be "big government" overstepping its bounds by intervening in a free market.

    Talking about nuclear is pointless in this country. The "minimal government" Republicans will align with dishonest greenies. Forget about it.

    Here is the pattern:
    1. Republican candidate talks about how we need nuclear power. People nod their heads in agreement.
    2. Republican gets into office.
    3. Republican passes tax cuts for the rich
    4. Republican leaves office and nothing changes over nuclear power

    Both Democrats and Republicans are full of shit. Two parties of con artists.

    Replies: @QCIC, @A123

    Nuclear power is highly subsidized and would not be commercially available otherwise. The liability from a plant is so high that no one can insure it, so it cannot be funded without subsidies.

    In the long term nuclear power will be important. The Russians are doing good work, including the Brest technology. This may have something to do with having a climate where winter heating is a life or death issue for much of the population. Same idea with nuclear-powered icebreakers.

    Agree on the Republicrats.

    • Replies: @A123
    @QCIC


    Nuclear power is highly subsidized and would not be commercially available otherwise. The liability from a plant is so high that no one can insure it, so it cannot be funded without subsidies.
     
    These problems are exclusive to the long carried over water cooled uranium cycle.

    Other options, such as LFTR, are inherently safe. Thus, they would be insurable. The problem is that brutally excessive U.S. regulation keeps this effective fuel cycle at bay. India, China, and others are on their way to inexpensive electricity. America has to get rid of obsolete regulation to catch up, or be left behind.

    What does not receive subsidies now days? Sad but true, it is about everything. If subsidies are inevitable, is it not better to spend them on a technically sound LFTR program? The other option is wasting it on useless solar and wind fiascos that are a thread to grid stability.

    If you can get to "no subsidies for anything", I would gladly take it. However, idealism and naivety are good ways to wind up squashed.

    PEACE 😇

  592. @John Johnson
    @AnonfromTN

    The Indians I know cover the same spectrum as Whites and Chinese: some are very bright, some quite dumb, many in between; some are hard-working, some lazy, most in between; some honest, some most certainly not.

    Yea I really doubt you have worked with many of them.

    The common annoyance factor is arrogance.

    Dot Indians privately view themselves as superior to Americans. Even though India is covered in child beggars and filth they actually view India as the birthplace of higher civilization. Their class system ramps up the arrogance even further.

    Americans hate dealing with them over phone support and this is why. An Indian in some office hell doing support all day still views himself as a superior being. They can be extremely condescending as they view Whites as crude brutes with a few lucky geniuses. As in White inventions were mostly luck. They really believe India is going to be some great country and is just temporarily covered in garbage.

    They move to America and ironically look down on Americans. Well why did you move here? I've never seen them at community fundraisers for non-profits. They buy German luxury cars and isolate themselves. I guess they are gods among us for owning a mini mart and buying a BMW. I've stopped in the middle America in the most rural area and still had a Dot Indian give me a condensing look. Such an eyeroll.

    Replies: @QCIC

    I assume there is an Indian organized crime element in the USA but have not read about it.

  593. @German_reader
    @Gerard1234


    When you use silly sarcasm as that then you discredit yourself.
     
    Well, what do you expect? I don't think I've denied German crimes, but it's been 80 years and the tendency to treat WW2 as if it happened yesterday is irritating. Given what kind of site this is, you should be content that I'm not some full-on "revisionist" who argues WW2 Germans did nothing wrong.
    Another factor: The kind of Germans who constantly go on about their "historical responsibility", German guilt etc. are frequently the ones who are most fanatical about current-day issues. People like Baerbock, the sort of people who want to see Russia totally defeated and re-constructed (because Putin is a "fascist" and then they'd be on the right side for once, or whatever). Or the clowns who have now made it their mission to defend Israel at the ICC. So careful what you wish for.
    As for the historical arguments, sure, the perception of the Red army as an unskilled horde winning only through sheer mass is inaccurate and unfair. I don't think I've ever argued along those lines myself either. However, you make some nonsensical arguments yourself, e.g.

    Air defence of our cities and important locations was far superior to German air defence of their cities and British defence of their key locations.
     
    this is a totally misleading comparison. Soviet Union in WW2 never faced a combined day-and-night offensive of heavy four-engined bombers (plus fighter escorts, eventually) like the British and Americans carried out against Germany in the last three years or so of the war. German bombing in the Soviet Union wasn't even on as concentrated a level as it had been against Britain in 1940. It did kill quite a few civilians (40 000-50 000 iirc, according to Richard Overy who's probably the leading expert), but it was mostly of the tactical kind, nothing like a concentrated strategic offensive. And after 1942 at the latest Luftwaffe mostly had to focus on defense against the Anglo-American bomber offensive anyway.
    As for

    Air Defence of cities and losses of our airforce does suggest leadership who were not uninterested and do value Soviet citizens life
     
    I'm completely unconvinced. But not much point arguing about it.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    This is a totally misleading comparison. Soviet Union in WW2 never faced a combined day-and-night air offensive

    Well I did suspect that would be your response, but it’s clear to me that because of successful Soviet air defence the Nazis were forced to greatly reduce their bombing campaign. You can still see the small chamber at the top of a few buildings in Moscow today where the anti-aircraft guns were installed.

    British didn’t have successful Air defence, so Nazis encouraged to bomb them more.

    Britain didn’t have to face 4-engine heavy bombers from the Luftwaffe either. For the British/Americans strategic bombing on Nazi Germany then you are correct – but I don’t think my comment about superiority of Soviet air defence is disproven. Western allied bombing wasn’t close to the level you describe until mid-1943 so I do think comparisons of British vs Soviet air defences from 1941-43 are useful

    Though the threat is much greater, the Lancaster and the other heavy bombers are easier to intercept, and the distance for spotting and early warning as RAF & USAF planes fly over the sea and several Nazi controlled countries before reaching targets in Germany….. is about the same as from Nazi seized airfields in the east to Soviet targets.
    W

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @Gerard1234


    British didn’t have successful Air defence
     
    Britain was the first country in the world to have a coordinated, radar-based air defence system, its effectiveness was proven in 1940. Obviously Soviet Union later developed very sophisticated anti-air and radar systems of its own, but I don't think they had something like that during WW2. They didn't need to anyway, since Germany lacked the resources for a sustained bomber offensive against Soviet Union and much industry could be evacuated beyond the Urals (i.e. beyond the range of German bombers).

    Replies: @songbird, @Gerard1234, @China Japan and Korea Bromance of Three Kingdoms

  594. @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    Nuclear power is highly subsidized and would not be commercially available otherwise. The liability from a plant is so high that no one can insure it, so it cannot be funded without subsidies.

    In the long term nuclear power will be important. The Russians are doing good work, including the Brest technology. This may have something to do with having a climate where winter heating is a life or death issue for much of the population. Same idea with nuclear-powered icebreakers.

    Agree on the Republicrats.

    Replies: @A123

    Nuclear power is highly subsidized and would not be commercially available otherwise. The liability from a plant is so high that no one can insure it, so it cannot be funded without subsidies.

    These problems are exclusive to the long carried over water cooled uranium cycle.

    Other options, such as LFTR, are inherently safe. Thus, they would be insurable. The problem is that brutally excessive U.S. regulation keeps this effective fuel cycle at bay. India, China, and others are on their way to inexpensive electricity. America has to get rid of obsolete regulation to catch up, or be left behind.

    What does not receive subsidies now days? Sad but true, it is about everything. If subsidies are inevitable, is it not better to spend them on a technically sound LFTR program? The other option is wasting it on useless solar and wind fiascos that are a thread to grid stability.

    If you can get to “no subsidies for anything”, I would gladly take it. However, idealism and naivety are good ways to wind up squashed.

    PEACE 😇

  595. @John Johnson
    @AnonfromTN

    The main drawback of traditional nuclear power plants was spent fuel rods that contain most of radioactive uranium and will be radioactive for millions of years. Russia built a mid-size nuclear reactor that uses “spent” fuel and returns it really spent, essentially non-radioactive. Based on its success, it is now building a large reactor using the same technology. However, Western MSM would never tell you this, as the reality is politically incorrect.

    There is no conspiracy against nuclear power by the MSM.

    The utility companies don't want to build them. They're too expensive.

    Any Republican that proposed a Federal nuclear plan would be opposed by the MAGA libertarian wing. That would be "big government" overstepping its bounds by intervening in a free market.

    Talking about nuclear is pointless in this country. The "minimal government" Republicans will align with dishonest greenies. Forget about it.

    Here is the pattern:
    1. Republican candidate talks about how we need nuclear power. People nod their heads in agreement.
    2. Republican gets into office.
    3. Republican passes tax cuts for the rich
    4. Republican leaves office and nothing changes over nuclear power

    Both Democrats and Republicans are full of shit. Two parties of con artists.

    Replies: @QCIC, @A123

    the MAGA libertarian wing. That would be “big government” overstepping its bounds by intervening in a free market.

    MAGA is avowedly Populist. MAGA Reindustrialization, as an industrial security/trade policy, is actively anti-Libertarian. MAGA wants to use government force against corporations to actively rein in laissez-faire elites who seek to abuse workers via immigration or offshoring. There is nothing Libertarian about that.

    Libertarian exporting of jobs and open borders are now Democrat party policies. The emotionalist dogma of DNC zealots is mind rotting and incoherent. So, I suspect the Sheeple do not realize that they are embracing Libertarianism part of the time.

    PEACE 😇

  596. @John Johnson
    @QCIC

    The range extender engine needs to have enough power to charge the battery and move the car at near-highway speeds if the battery is croaked. I think this is around 30 horsepower.

    You are talking about a hybrid where the gas engine only exists to charge the battery? Ram is coming out with that.

    A key problem with that model is that the randomness of the gas engine can be unnerving. It already happens with hybrids where the engine kicks in at high RPM to charge the battery if it gets too low. Imagine pulling away slowly in heavy traffic and then the engine kicks into high RPM. It sort of makes a disconnected driving experience. I'd rather have an EV that simply worked as a second car. Then use a gas vehicle for trips.

    This has been understood for a long time, but I have not heard of a hybrid that gets it right. The Honda Insight should have been OK but the engine was too large and the battery too small.

    The Prius definitely works as intended but I hate how they drive. They are too clunky and the regenerative brakes are rough. I'd rather a car that had 10 less mpg but actually drove like a car. I think Fusion had the right idea but Ford got rid of it.

    Replies: @QCIC, @A123

    The Prius is OK. Most of these also have a non-ideal ratio of engine size to battery capacity. I guess Toyota has not fully bought into the “range extender”concept. As electric motors keep getting smaller this should change. Making the very small engines efficient and clean is also challenging.

    I hate the stop-start engines of many hybrid cars. A range extender hybrid should break out of this by decoupling the engine from driving actions (except in emergencies when the battery has a problem). In the best case the engine is just a very quiet genset and is only coupled to the wheels electrically. Historically the engineers probably needed to use the generator as a motor as well, which gets into various complicated drivetrain arrangements.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @QCIC

    There is a hybrid version of the BMW i3 (i3 Rex) with a small range extender engine and decent-sized battery. Unfortunately they have a goofy 2 gallon gas tank to meet US regulations. It uses a 650 cc Taiwanese engine from a BMW scooter. Roughly $50K to show you care about the climate!

  597. @John Johnson
    @Beckow

    but it seems to any observer that Biden is not the one to make that decision. So his feelings and aspirations for women of color are irrelevant.

    There is no secret hand that chooses the president. The proof is in that the establishment never wanted Biden. They wanted a woman. Biden was in fact written off before being saved by Blacks in the primary.

    Similar conspiracy theories against Trump are also lacking. Why didn't the conspirators give Biden his desired majority? They only needed to cheat in a couple more races.

    We may not know the president until well into 2025. Even if Biden wins he may plan on quitting partway through the year.

    But in your defense the original celebrated Greek ‘democracy’ was not much better. Or the Roman ‘republic’. You live on half-ass myths and that is a sad existence. Reality is so much more interesting….:)

    I've never once tried to upsell democracy. I don't live on myths and I've gone over political problems in both classical Greece and Rome.

    Democracy is a mess but better than competing systems like the Russian dictatorship.

    I can criticize my government without having to worry about being hauled off in the night.

    The dwarf is terrified of even dissent. He seems scared of women:

    Russian artist given seven years for anti-war protest
    https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/11/17/russian-artist-jailed-for-seven-years-over-anti-war-price-tag-protest

    What a wimp. Locks up a 33 year old woman for being against the war. Real men can explain their actions and take criticism. Putin is a shell of a man and riddled with insecurities.

    Replies: @Sean, @Beckow

    The proof is in that the establishment never wanted Biden.

    They thought Hillary was a viable candidate even after Obama was preferred to her. And her team failed to court their traditional base of Catholics.

    What a wimp. Locks up a 33 year old woman for being against the war. Real men can explain their actions and take criticism. Putin is a shell of a man and riddled with insecurities

    You could say the same about Churchill. By the way, during WW2 a woman who criticized Churchill’s leadership in a London pub got five years’ hard labour. Women and effeminates men tend towards unsustainably impractical solutions to conflict

    Democracy is a mess but better than competing systems like the Russian dictatorship.

    If Washington was trying to make Russia a Western style democracy, the method they chose of attaining their object (fobbing off Putin’s attempts to join Nato while advancing Nato to RusFed’s borders and chortling at his complaints) did not turn out to be a very effective method, did it?

    What a wimp.

    Harvey Mansfield’s definition of manliness is “confidence in a situation of risk”. In his book, Why We Fight, Mike Martin says the motivation for war is “status and belonging”.

    We may not know the president until well into 2025. Even if Biden wins he may plan on quitting partway through the year

    It was said Biden would quit before his first term was up, but having achieved the supreme position a man is not gong to give up that status.

    There is no secret hand that chooses the president.

    The mass of US states chose Obama, Trump was LOATHED by the elite, and more so now..

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Sean


    If Washington was trying to make Russia a Western style democracy, the method they chose of attaining their object (fobbing off Putin’s attempts to join Nato while advancing Nato to RusFed’s borders and chortling at his complaints) did not turn out to be a very effective method, did it?
     
    Would having Russia join NATO have made Russia a Western-style democracy? Or would it have simply resulted in Putin being an East Slavic version of Erdogan for the West? Which, admittedly, would still be a significant improvement over real life.

    Replies: @Sean

  598. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    It's quite interesting that throughout history Slovaks have served as the younger brothers to both the Hungarians and the Czechs. They served as the younger brothers to the Hungarians for much, much longer, but Czech rule was probably better for them than Hungarian rule, at least so long as the Czechs actually had a foreign protector behind themselves and the Slovaks (they didn't in 1938-1939). I don't seem to recall Czechia trying to forcibly Czechify the Slovaks like Hungary did with the Slovaks with its decades-long pre-WWI Magyarization campaign:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magyarization

    I do suspect that, out of Greater Hungary's large subject peoples, the Slovaks were probably the easiest ones to successfully Magyarize had Hungary had even more time to do so:

    https://preview.redd.it/9z2zzo6am2r71.png?width=640&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=097af65f11c92335d05889c085d6e243b595125b

    Slovaks, after all, are mostly Catholic just like Hungarians (Magyars) themselves are. Ruthenians (Ukrainians), Romanians, Serbs, and Croats are not Catholic.

    (Hungarian Jews were, of course, largely successfully Magyarized, but they are a much smaller group and their high average IQ and large amounts of success made them stand out from the Magyars and thus often made Magyars unwilling to accept them as their own even when these Jews themselves were indeed willing to be Magyarized. In contrast, AFAIK, Slovaks and Hungarians (Magyars) have a roughly equal average IQ, so there's no superiority/inferiority complex going on between them in regards to each other, at least in regards to their mental abilities.)

    BTW, it would be cool if Hungary, Slovakia, and Croatia formed a Greater Hungary within the EU (a confederation within a confederation) while Czechia, Austria, and Slovenia formed a Greater Austria within the EU (another confederation within a confederation).

    Replies: @Derer, @WS, @AP, @Beckow

    Last summer, Orban was even more popular in Slovakia than he was in Hungary. Slovaks might wish they could be reunited with their older Magyar brothers and resume their servitude:

    https://hungarytoday.hu/survey-viktor-orban-most-popular-in-slovakia-and-bulgaria/

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Maybe it's more of a matter of Slovaks wanting a politician like Orban leading them rather than a matter of Slovaks wanting to be led by Orban himself?

    Had Slovaks wanted to be reannexed by Hungary, March 1939 was a golden time for this to happen, at least temporarily. But apparently back then Slovaks weren't interested in this, which is why it didn't happen. Did Slovaks really change their attitudes in regards to this over the last 85 years?

    BTW, AFAIK, Slovaks have a rather amicable relationship with Czechs. Their divorce brought them no hard feelings, after all. But Yeah, if Slovaks can't even live in the same small house together with their very close Czech co-ethnics, I'm unsure that Slovaks nowadays could do this with the Hungarians either, especially after over a century of being separated from them. It's mostly pointless anyway when both Czechs and Slovaks and Hungarians are all part of a giant confederation known as the European Union.

  599. @John Johnson
    @QCIC

    The range extender engine needs to have enough power to charge the battery and move the car at near-highway speeds if the battery is croaked. I think this is around 30 horsepower.

    You are talking about a hybrid where the gas engine only exists to charge the battery? Ram is coming out with that.

    A key problem with that model is that the randomness of the gas engine can be unnerving. It already happens with hybrids where the engine kicks in at high RPM to charge the battery if it gets too low. Imagine pulling away slowly in heavy traffic and then the engine kicks into high RPM. It sort of makes a disconnected driving experience. I'd rather have an EV that simply worked as a second car. Then use a gas vehicle for trips.

    This has been understood for a long time, but I have not heard of a hybrid that gets it right. The Honda Insight should have been OK but the engine was too large and the battery too small.

    The Prius definitely works as intended but I hate how they drive. They are too clunky and the regenerative brakes are rough. I'd rather a car that had 10 less mpg but actually drove like a car. I think Fusion had the right idea but Ford got rid of it.

    Replies: @QCIC, @A123

    In addition to the Southern hurricane problem, there is also a Northern one: (1)

    The overwhelming majority of Americans said on Tuesday they are unlikely to consider buying an electric vehicle (EV). The poll comes as EVs strand drivers at their homes and off the sides of roads amid a winter freeze sweeping the United States.

    Rasmussen Reports released the poll, finding that 65 percent of American adults said they are not likely to consider buying an EV when purchasing their next car — including 37 percent who said they are “not at all likely” to buy an EV. Fewer than 3-in-10 Americans said they would consider buying an EV.

    Unless there are changes in technology and cost, EV’s will remain a niche market.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.breitbart.com/economy/2024/01/16/poll-65-americans-unlikely-buy-electric-cars-they-strand-drivers-winter-freeze/

  600. @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    Heyderabad harridan would stand over him like a sword of Damocles.
     
    Frankly, I do not have a generally negative view of Indians. I personally know maybe a couple of dozen (in many cases I don’t know whether they are Hindus, Muslims, or do not believe in any fairy tales at all). The Indians I know cover the same spectrum as Whites and Chinese: some are very bright, some quite dumb, many in between; some are hard-working, some lazy, most in between; some honest, some most certainly not.

    As Western politicians go, they are all scum, regardless of their color and origin. I have yet to see a politician more trustworthy than a used car salesman.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Beckow

    …The Indians I know cover the same spectrum as Whites and Chinese…As Western politicians go, they are all scum

    I have to disagree. You are probably more exposed to the higher-achieving Indians in the academia. The context of “Whites” is also different. Indians came to our societies after throughly trashing their own previous quite nice subcontinent. Their behavior happens in that context – and it is in general toxic. There is a reason the larger-India looks the way it does – they are not very capable people: they have failed to sustain a civilization.

    People on Unz often obsess about individual IQ – but what matters is the society’s IQ (or national) and the only way to measure it is by what the resulting society looks like. By that standard it is immediately obvious that the Indian-Paki society’s IQ is very low: they live in a crap country getting worse. (Or Austria’s IQ is higher than UK or Sweden.)

    The Indians are desperately trying to leave their sh..hole country, it is a career: to migrate to the West. But the destructive behaviors come with them, you can see it in politicians like Sunak, Haley. Kamala…a combination of servility and arrogance, as if the compradors arrived home. There are exceptions, but the overall impact has been to make an already bad situation worse.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Beckow

    An important concept related to immigration is reversion to different means for disparate populations. From my simplified perspective, this gives some insight into the overall picture of what is occurring with mass immigration to the West, though less information in any particular personal example. In large, relatively low-IQ populations such as India and Africa there will always be a significant number of high IQ people. I am referring to the genetic lottery winners who are much smarter than their families. If possible they often like to migrate to the West. They usually bring their cultural baggage and perhaps an extended family with them. Then they have children who often revert to the mean genetic IQ of a third-world country. So the result is a family cluster of immigrants and only one is above average for India and perhaps for the US as well. So the net result is a clear case of "not sending their best", even when the initial immigrant was above average.

    Replies: @Beckow

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @Beckow

    FWIW, Anatoly Karlin has previously speculated that India's average IQ might be depressed by as much as 10-15 points due to the poor environmental conditions in India.

    Genetic studies are rather preliminary, but South Asians appear to have roughly the same genetic phenotypic IQ score (based on the IQ genes found and located so far) as Latin Americans have:

    https://www.mdpi.com/2624-8611/1/1/5

    https://www.mdpi.com/psych/psych-01-00005/article_deploy/html/images/psych-01-00005-g003.png

    So, they could probably maintain a society as functional as Romania or Bulgaria if they will raise their average IQ up to its full potential. That's essentially almost some Latin American countries today, only much more homicidal than Bulgaria and Romania are. But India is nowhere near as homicidal as Latin America is, thankfully.

  601. @Derer
    @John Johnson


    Chain smoking is very bad for your health since your lungs never get a break.
     
    I agree...however some examples make mockery of that assertion, namely former German Chancellor Helmut Schmidt smoked 2 packs a day until his death at 97 year old - poster boy for tobacco industry.

    Another myth is stress which is considered to be bad for your heath. There was no greater stress than for former Stalin's politburo members, living constantly under enormous stress. They died fat and old Kaganovich 98, Molotov 96, Malenkov 87, Voroshilov 88 etc.

    Replies: @Mikel

    German Chancellor Helmut Schmidt smoked 2 packs a day until his death at 97 year old

    Not to mention that a guy in such poor health that he was about to die of natural causes would be utterly unable to ride a motorbike from Kharkiv to the Hungarian border, as anyone who has ever ridden a bike would know. The only thing that killed Lira was not keeping his mouth shut.

    I guess it’s not worth it to focus too much on the death of this man when so many others have died probably more nonsensically in that part of the world and will surely continue to do so but so many ironies to exploit here. Among them the fact that JJ has spent months lecturing us on how terrible Putin’s regime is because people who oppose him are made to die early and when that is exactly what happens to someone who dared to open his mouth against the regime he supports right next door (a citizen of his own country at that), he makes all kinds of excuses to minimize the incident.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Mikel

    Among them the fact that JJ has spent months lecturing us on how terrible Putin’s regime is because people who oppose him are made to die early and when that is exactly what happens to someone who dared to open his mouth against the regime he supports right next door (a citizen of his own country at that), he makes all kinds of excuses to minimize the incident.

    The event is still a half-mystery and no one seems to know what happened. Why don't you try quoting me directly? How am I making excuses when we don't even know what kind of condition he had or what was prevented?

    Care to explain why he didn't ask his sister to contact the state department if he was in poor health? Or why he said he had double pneumonia with a collapsed lung without any explanation as to how he got it? Does that sound normal to you?

    I still haven't had a Lira fan provide a ONE essay or article related to Ukraine. You don't find that rather peculiar? A supposed suppressed journalist that left us nothing? Who scrubbed his videos?

    It was Anglin's theory that Lira had a deathwish and wanted to go out as a martyr. I think it fits all available evidence and Anglin gets the credit. Feel free to disagree and state your case.

    Replies: @Mikel

  602. @John Johnson
    @Beckow

    but it seems to any observer that Biden is not the one to make that decision. So his feelings and aspirations for women of color are irrelevant.

    There is no secret hand that chooses the president. The proof is in that the establishment never wanted Biden. They wanted a woman. Biden was in fact written off before being saved by Blacks in the primary.

    Similar conspiracy theories against Trump are also lacking. Why didn't the conspirators give Biden his desired majority? They only needed to cheat in a couple more races.

    We may not know the president until well into 2025. Even if Biden wins he may plan on quitting partway through the year.

    But in your defense the original celebrated Greek ‘democracy’ was not much better. Or the Roman ‘republic’. You live on half-ass myths and that is a sad existence. Reality is so much more interesting….:)

    I've never once tried to upsell democracy. I don't live on myths and I've gone over political problems in both classical Greece and Rome.

    Democracy is a mess but better than competing systems like the Russian dictatorship.

    I can criticize my government without having to worry about being hauled off in the night.

    The dwarf is terrified of even dissent. He seems scared of women:

    Russian artist given seven years for anti-war protest
    https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/11/17/russian-artist-jailed-for-seven-years-over-anti-war-price-tag-protest

    What a wimp. Locks up a 33 year old woman for being against the war. Real men can explain their actions and take criticism. Putin is a shell of a man and riddled with insecurities.

    Replies: @Sean, @Beckow

    …The proof is in that the establishment never wanted Biden. They wanted a woman.

    No, they simply didn’t want Trump and tried everything to make sure it didn’t happen. The guiding hand is always flexible and works with what it has.

    Democracy is a mess but better than competing systems like the Russian dictatorship.
    I can criticize my government without having to worry about being hauled off in the night.

    A cliche that doesn’t translate into anything real. Assange and 1k demonstrators are in jail in a “democracy”, many were hauled in the middle of the night. You just refuse to see the same thing as being the same. You either lie, pretend that it didn’t happen, or say that you are against it as if that mattered.

    There are better and worse democracies. Russia is not a dictatorship by any standard – it does what the West does, it suppresses dissent (they are in a war), it reduces choices, but for 99.9% of people there is no “dictate”, they live their ordinary lives undisturbed. They vote from the approved choices and they are largely powerless to impact most decisions: very similar to what one sees in Germany, UK, France, US….don’t preach about a perfect democracy if you haven’t been able to have one at home.

    The only way to rationally evaluate a democracy is by results: are the preferences of the majority reflected in what happens. By that standard Russia does rather well – most policies that the majority wants are done. The West less so – there are endless examples from wars to migration to LGbtqX…where the opposite of what the majority wants is done. For decades. So where is the democracy? And don’t hide behind the process, how it happens is actually completely irrelevant….

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Beckow


    …The proof is in that the establishment never wanted Biden. They wanted a woman.
     
    No, they simply didn’t want Trump and tried everything to make sure it didn’t happen. The guiding hand is always flexible and works with what it has.

    Of course they didn't want Trump.

    But I was talking about the Democrat primary. They wanted a minority woman and in fact wrote editorials about how they didn't want "another White guy". They only accepted Biden as the last man standing against Bernie. The establishment never wanted him and in fact Obama only endorsed him after Bernie lost.

    I'm no fan of Obama but he was right about Biden. It should have been a red flag that Obama wouldn't endorse his own VP until no one else was left.

    A cliche that doesn’t translate into anything real. Assange and 1k demonstrators are in jail in a “democracy”

    Assange was not exercising free speech rights. You do not have the right to release thousands of classified documents to the internet.

    The fact that you have to go back to Assange speaks volumes. Putin kills a journalist about once a month and your best example is from the Iraq war.

    Assange has since been accused of rape. Some hero.

    As for Jan 6th no one was hauled off for criticizing the government. You don't have the right to riot, break into a Federal building or throw rocks at police officers. Most of the officers were Trump voters. The MAGA rioters were freaking idiots. A total waste of time that fed the MSM.

    Russia is not a dictatorship by any standard

    So you believe Russian votes can be trusted? Is that right?

    Do you believe that occupied Zaporizhzhia Oblast voted to join Russia even though they overwhelmingly voted for Zelensky in 2019?

    I can post videos where Russians describe their own government as a dictatorship where the vote doesn't matter. You are saying they are wrong?

    Replies: @Beckow

  603. @Sean
    @John Johnson

    Haley is a woman and with a woman as the main opposition, candidates previously thought unelectable get into the White House (Obama and Trump).

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Haley is a woman and with a woman as the main opposition, candidates previously thought unelectable get into the White House (Obama and Trump).

    Haley is not Hillary Clinton.

    Independents have never like Hillary. Independents were also tired of the Clinton/Bush dynasties.

    Haley polls a whopping 17 points over Biden
    https://www.wsj.com/livecoverage/gop-republican-debate-iowa/card/behind-haley-s-17-point-lead-over-biden-in-wsj-polling-qByTNcx5uHOCTq443PVW

    Not even close.

    Trump is a needless risk. He has barely gained against Biden in the last year and hasn’t recovered his support from independents. Polls show that independents dislike both candidates.

  604. @Beckow
    @John Johnson


    ...The proof is in that the establishment never wanted Biden. They wanted a woman.
     
    No, they simply didn't want Trump and tried everything to make sure it didn't happen. The guiding hand is always flexible and works with what it has.

    Democracy is a mess but better than competing systems like the Russian dictatorship.
    I can criticize my government without having to worry about being hauled off in the night.
     
    A cliche that doesn't translate into anything real. Assange and 1k demonstrators are in jail in a "democracy", many were hauled in the middle of the night. You just refuse to see the same thing as being the same. You either lie, pretend that it didn't happen, or say that you are against it as if that mattered.

    There are better and worse democracies. Russia is not a dictatorship by any standard - it does what the West does, it suppresses dissent (they are in a war), it reduces choices, but for 99.9% of people there is no "dictate", they live their ordinary lives undisturbed. They vote from the approved choices and they are largely powerless to impact most decisions: very similar to what one sees in Germany, UK, France, US....don't preach about a perfect democracy if you haven't been able to have one at home.

    The only way to rationally evaluate a democracy is by results: are the preferences of the majority reflected in what happens. By that standard Russia does rather well - most policies that the majority wants are done. The West less so - there are endless examples from wars to migration to LGbtqX...where the opposite of what the majority wants is done. For decades. So where is the democracy? And don't hide behind the process, how it happens is actually completely irrelevant....

    Replies: @John Johnson

    …The proof is in that the establishment never wanted Biden. They wanted a woman.

    No, they simply didn’t want Trump and tried everything to make sure it didn’t happen. The guiding hand is always flexible and works with what it has.

    Of course they didn’t want Trump.

    But I was talking about the Democrat primary. They wanted a minority woman and in fact wrote editorials about how they didn’t want “another White guy”. They only accepted Biden as the last man standing against Bernie. The establishment never wanted him and in fact Obama only endorsed him after Bernie lost.

    I’m no fan of Obama but he was right about Biden. It should have been a red flag that Obama wouldn’t endorse his own VP until no one else was left.

    A cliche that doesn’t translate into anything real. Assange and 1k demonstrators are in jail in a “democracy”

    Assange was not exercising free speech rights. You do not have the right to release thousands of classified documents to the internet.

    The fact that you have to go back to Assange speaks volumes. Putin kills a journalist about once a month and your best example is from the Iraq war.

    Assange has since been accused of rape. Some hero.

    As for Jan 6th no one was hauled off for criticizing the government. You don’t have the right to riot, break into a Federal building or throw rocks at police officers. Most of the officers were Trump voters. The MAGA rioters were freaking idiots. A total waste of time that fed the MSM.

    Russia is not a dictatorship by any standard

    So you believe Russian votes can be trusted? Is that right?

    Do you believe that occupied Zaporizhzhia Oblast voted to join Russia even though they overwhelmingly voted for Zelensky in 2019?

    I can post videos where Russians describe their own government as a dictatorship where the vote doesn’t matter. You are saying they are wrong?

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @John Johnson

    Assange is in prison now, not in the "Iraq war". If you ok with putting people in prison for publishing embarrassing stuff then all Russia, China have to do is claim what the journalists published was "classified" - very easy to do especially in a war. And they are doing it. If US-UK can do it, why are you objecting when Russia does it? Do they have to be better?

    Assange was accused of 'rape' and it was dropped, so don't lie. Any floozie in Moscow can accuse Navalny of unwanted sex, it is literally in the first chapter of the Intelligence Manual on how to discredit opponents. Are you so clueless? Read the f...ing Manual...:)

    If you can put in jail in 1k demonstrators for mayhem-graffiti-vandalism that inevitably happens during protests (see BLM), why can't Russia do the same? Your inability to use the same standard is making your arguments sound like blabbing by an isolated, not-very-smart narcissist...


    you believe Russian votes can be trusted?
     
    I don't know if any votes anywhere can be fully trusted. There are always corner cases, people voting who shouldn't, others voting for them - it probably happens as much in Philadelphia as in Krasnodar. (90% plus in black districts).

    The real issue is whether the resulting government has majority support: in Russia by all accounts and all analysts Putin has a huge majority, 60-80%. Nobody denies it other than you. In many Western countries there are governments that have a lot lower support, Macron in the 20's, the Indian guy in UK around 30, also Biden, Scholz. Those are real numbers - they rule because the system was structured in a way to prevent a viable alternative.

    In Russia if Putin would run in a completely unrestricted all-media-open-to-all ideal democracy he would still win. You don't have anything like an ideal democracy at home, but you demand that others do it? Are you so disconnected from the real life?

  605. @German_reader
    @Gerard1234


    You aware of German , mass and sadistic crimes against civilians in WW2?
     
    No, I have never heard of that, totally news to me.

    It’s clear there is an eternal thought from German intellectuals that Slavs are untermensch compared to themselves.
     
    I wasn't thinking of it being so much a Slav thing. More like a "Soviet legacy" thing (not just regarding civilians, e.g. Arestovych in the interview I linked to said Ukraine was throwing away lives of its soldiers in a careless manner, and also attributed that to a Soviet-like mentality). But I know of course you'll disagree since you're one of those who thinks the Soviet Union was wonderful in every respect.
    As for whether specific incidents in the current war included deliberate targeting of civilians or not, I don't care to discuss it all in detail. I think both sides have done some pretty dubious stuff (if it makes you happy: I did feel revulsion at Ukraine's under-handed bombing of the Kerch bridge, also wasn't positively impressed by the recent Belgorod strike, as my comment indicates that Ukraine shouldn't receive Western long-range missiles when it does something like that. But I also think that Russian troops killed civilians at Bucha; it wasn't quite the massacre Western msm tried to present it as, but definitely war crimes).
    However, as I've written before, so far at least war crimes against civilians aren't the dominant feature of this war. It's mostly a conventional war, in which large numbers of regular troops are being killed at the front. So focus on civilian deaths is more for propaganda purposes than anything else.

    Replies: @Gerard1234, @Mikel

    Arestovych in the interview I linked to said Ukraine was throwing away lives of its soldiers in a careless manner, and also attributed that to a Soviet-like mentality

    Even the NYT ran a story about Ukraine ignoring the right to conscientious objection that they have in their constitution. A right that by its very nature is designed to be applied in times of war. I didn’t read the paywalled piece but I’ve read about it elsewhere and people who ask to be given non-combat duties in compliance with the law are punished for being pro-Russian and sent to the front anyway. The laughter of the thugs rounding up biomass for the war when one of the poor souls invokes the constitution must be heard from miles away. But hey, the Russians probably don’t even have that right in their constitution so let’s give as much military and financial aid as they need to the ones with the nicer constitution. They’re fighting for our values.

  606. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    Last summer, Orban was even more popular in Slovakia than he was in Hungary. Slovaks might wish they could be reunited with their older Magyar brothers and resume their servitude:

    https://hungarytoday.hu/survey-viktor-orban-most-popular-in-slovakia-and-bulgaria/

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Maybe it’s more of a matter of Slovaks wanting a politician like Orban leading them rather than a matter of Slovaks wanting to be led by Orban himself?

    Had Slovaks wanted to be reannexed by Hungary, March 1939 was a golden time for this to happen, at least temporarily. But apparently back then Slovaks weren’t interested in this, which is why it didn’t happen. Did Slovaks really change their attitudes in regards to this over the last 85 years?

    BTW, AFAIK, Slovaks have a rather amicable relationship with Czechs. Their divorce brought them no hard feelings, after all. But Yeah, if Slovaks can’t even live in the same small house together with their very close Czech co-ethnics, I’m unsure that Slovaks nowadays could do this with the Hungarians either, especially after over a century of being separated from them. It’s mostly pointless anyway when both Czechs and Slovaks and Hungarians are all part of a giant confederation known as the European Union.

  607. @Sean
    @John Johnson


    The proof is in that the establishment never wanted Biden.
     
    They thought Hillary was a viable candidate even after Obama was preferred to her. And her team failed to court their traditional base of Catholics.

    What a wimp. Locks up a 33 year old woman for being against the war. Real men can explain their actions and take criticism. Putin is a shell of a man and riddled with insecurities
     
    You could say the same about Churchill. By the way, during WW2 a woman who criticized Churchill's leadership in a London pub got five years' hard labour. Women and effeminates men tend towards unsustainably impractical solutions to conflict

    Democracy is a mess but better than competing systems like the Russian dictatorship.
     
    If Washington was trying to make Russia a Western style democracy, the method they chose of attaining their object (fobbing off Putin's attempts to join Nato while advancing Nato to RusFed's borders and chortling at his complaints) did not turn out to be a very effective method, did it?

    What a wimp.
     
    Harvey Mansfield's definition of manliness is "confidence in a situation of risk". In his book, Why We Fight, Mike Martin says the motivation for war is "status and belonging".

    We may not know the president until well into 2025. Even if Biden wins he may plan on quitting partway through the year
     

    It was said Biden would quit before his first term was up, but having achieved the supreme position a man is not gong to give up that status.

    There is no secret hand that chooses the president.
     
    The mass of US states chose Obama, Trump was LOATHED by the elite, and more so now..
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5zQ7_bc64j8

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    If Washington was trying to make Russia a Western style democracy, the method they chose of attaining their object (fobbing off Putin’s attempts to join Nato while advancing Nato to RusFed’s borders and chortling at his complaints) did not turn out to be a very effective method, did it?

    Would having Russia join NATO have made Russia a Western-style democracy? Or would it have simply resulted in Putin being an East Slavic version of Erdogan for the West? Which, admittedly, would still be a significant improvement over real life.

    • Replies: @Sean
    @Mr. XYZ

    Countries join Nato so they don't have to spend serious money on their own defence, Russia had always been a military autocracy, so Putin asking if Russia could join Nato was a sign he wanted to take Russia in a less defenced spending Western direction. It soon became clear to Putin as he was fobbed of that Russia was not welcome in Nato, and it was an anti Russian military alliance.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  608. @Mikel
    @Derer


    German Chancellor Helmut Schmidt smoked 2 packs a day until his death at 97 year old
     
    Not to mention that a guy in such poor health that he was about to die of natural causes would be utterly unable to ride a motorbike from Kharkiv to the Hungarian border, as anyone who has ever ridden a bike would know. The only thing that killed Lira was not keeping his mouth shut.

    I guess it's not worth it to focus too much on the death of this man when so many others have died probably more nonsensically in that part of the world and will surely continue to do so but so many ironies to exploit here. Among them the fact that JJ has spent months lecturing us on how terrible Putin's regime is because people who oppose him are made to die early and when that is exactly what happens to someone who dared to open his mouth against the regime he supports right next door (a citizen of his own country at that), he makes all kinds of excuses to minimize the incident.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Among them the fact that JJ has spent months lecturing us on how terrible Putin’s regime is because people who oppose him are made to die early and when that is exactly what happens to someone who dared to open his mouth against the regime he supports right next door (a citizen of his own country at that), he makes all kinds of excuses to minimize the incident.

    The event is still a half-mystery and no one seems to know what happened. Why don’t you try quoting me directly? How am I making excuses when we don’t even know what kind of condition he had or what was prevented?

    Care to explain why he didn’t ask his sister to contact the state department if he was in poor health? Or why he said he had double pneumonia with a collapsed lung without any explanation as to how he got it? Does that sound normal to you?

    I still haven’t had a Lira fan provide a ONE essay or article related to Ukraine. You don’t find that rather peculiar? A supposed suppressed journalist that left us nothing? Who scrubbed his videos?

    It was Anglin’s theory that Lira had a deathwish and wanted to go out as a martyr. I think it fits all available evidence and Anglin gets the credit. Feel free to disagree and state your case.

    • Replies: @Mikel
    @John Johnson


    Care to explain why he didn’t ask his sister to contact the state department if he was in poor health?
     
    Stop embarrassing yourself. His father begged the State Department in front of the camera to save his son's life but nobody moved a finger. Millions watched it on Tucker's channel.

    You don't need to stop supporting Ukraine in this war, retract anything you've ever said about Russia or anything like that. All you have to do is simply not be a part of the smelly scum: the State Department, Cirillo, the lying MSM that will do everything in their power to memory-hole the death of a compatriot (or shove piles of dirt on him if they are forced to acknowledge his existence) and the CIA who perfectly knew where he was and what his health condition was. Even in Ukraine prisons must have some doctor with a stethoscope capable of detecting a double pneumonia (unless they're stealing even that part of our taxes).


    It was Anglin’s theory that Lira had a deathwish
     
    And what is Kim Kardashian's theory?
  609. @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN


    ...The Indians I know cover the same spectrum as Whites and Chinese...As Western politicians go, they are all scum
     
    I have to disagree. You are probably more exposed to the higher-achieving Indians in the academia. The context of "Whites" is also different. Indians came to our societies after throughly trashing their own previous quite nice subcontinent. Their behavior happens in that context - and it is in general toxic. There is a reason the larger-India looks the way it does - they are not very capable people: they have failed to sustain a civilization.

    People on Unz often obsess about individual IQ - but what matters is the society's IQ (or national) and the only way to measure it is by what the resulting society looks like. By that standard it is immediately obvious that the Indian-Paki society's IQ is very low: they live in a crap country getting worse. (Or Austria's IQ is higher than UK or Sweden.)

    The Indians are desperately trying to leave their sh..hole country, it is a career: to migrate to the West. But the destructive behaviors come with them, you can see it in politicians like Sunak, Haley. Kamala...a combination of servility and arrogance, as if the compradors arrived home. There are exceptions, but the overall impact has been to make an already bad situation worse.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

    An important concept related to immigration is reversion to different means for disparate populations. From my simplified perspective, this gives some insight into the overall picture of what is occurring with mass immigration to the West, though less information in any particular personal example. In large, relatively low-IQ populations such as India and Africa there will always be a significant number of high IQ people. I am referring to the genetic lottery winners who are much smarter than their families. If possible they often like to migrate to the West. They usually bring their cultural baggage and perhaps an extended family with them. Then they have children who often revert to the mean genetic IQ of a third-world country. So the result is a family cluster of immigrants and only one is above average for India and perhaps for the US as well. So the net result is a clear case of “not sending their best”, even when the initial immigrant was above average.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @QCIC


    ...the net result is a clear case of “not sending their best”, even when the initial immigrant was above average.
     
    True. But it is obviously the way open-borders were going to play out - so the people who kept the borders open had to know it and wanted this outcome.

    What now? The logic of massive chain-migration, family reunification, in-place ethnic migrant lobbies, business desire for cheaper labor, liberal gment-charity fanatics who live of the migrants -
    this will continue. It can go fast or slow, but at the end there will new population in Western Europe, US, Canada. The previous people will be pushed out - completely or marginalized.

    The result will be overpopulated societies with lower overall IQ, internal hostilities and no long-term cultural continuity - both natives and migrants are losing their cultures in the process. The consequences will be from bad to possibly catastrophic: some regions will be natives, others will be completely migrant dominated.

    Western societies will be divided and poorer with scores to settle. Thank you, liberals. They have missed the point of having countries and nations:there is no existence in freedom...but they like it that way, their vacuous minds crave vacuum and chaos.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @QCIC

  610. @John Johnson
    @AP

    The Democrats’ only chance of retaining the presidency is if Trump wins the primary and then gets convicted of something. So they will do what they can to help him become the Republican candidate. It may backfire and he may win the presidency anyways, but at least (for them) he is much less effective than a president DeSantis would have been.

    The irony is that the Democrats spend so much time obsessing over Trump and yet he is their best chance to retain the white house.

    Practically any non-Biden no-name Democrat defeats Trump because of independents in swing states.

    Trump only wins a slight majority of independents when they are forced to choose between a felon and a president that gets lost when getting off the airplane. But that is according to current data and Trump still has the documents trial. He could easily sour more independents if he actually catches a felony which would erase his small gains.

    Both Biden and Trump are ego maniacs. If Biden really wanted to defeat Trump then he would announce that he won't run for a second term as he originally promised.

    DeSantis should quit. He isn't a bad guy but he is splitting the pot and Haley does better with independents.

    Replies: @Sean, @Mikel, @Mr. XYZ

    DeSantis should quit.

    To give way to the candidate in 3rd position that he has nothing in common with. You wish.

    It’s probably more important than ever that DeSantis stays in the race (unless Haley quits too). The last thing we need if Trump doesn’t make it to November is no MAGAs in the race and a Nikki leading in delegates after Trump. The fact that she polls so well among liberals is the very reason why no one should vote for her. Forget those polls and put your signature here instead: https://nevernikki.net/

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Mikel


    DeSantis should quit.
     
    To give way to the candidate in 3rd position that he has nothing in common with. You wish.

    It's a suggestion based on data and not wishes. Haley polls better with independents.

    If the goal is to remove Biden then Haley is the answer and not DeSantis. The data is resounding clear on that.

    Those that want a second coming of Trump of course don't want Haley. But Trump running is Biden's best chance.

    The last thing we need if Trump doesn’t make it to November is no MAGAs in the race and a Nikki leading in delegates after Trump. The fact that she polls so well among liberals is the very reason why no one should vote for her.

    She doesn't poll well with liberals. I cited a poll showing that she polls well with moderate Democrats. Liberals are not moderate Democrats.

    There is no reason to believe that Trump would govern any different than Haley. For all of his talk he mostly governed like a mainstream Republican. All he had to do was close the border but his fans seem to think he needs two terms to do it. Well he turned down a good deal from Schumer early in his presidency and never got his wall built. I voted for him twice but I don't buy for one second that he is some type of rebel against the establishment. He may sell that image but his actual policies suggest he will buckle under pressure. When he moved to DC he joined the establishment. He ditched Bannon and let the swamp talk him into tax cuts for the rich. Bannon wanted tax cuts only for the middle class and Trump fired him. Why do the wealthy need tax cuts? It's such a stupid policy.

    Trump has become a cult of personality. His MAGA followers are uninterested in looking at his actual policy decisions. They are also uninterested in reading about the documents case as they tell themselves it is political in origin when Trump really f-cked up on his own. He is on tape trying to cover it up. The rape in the department case smells of BS but the take home documents really is a felony violation.

    Replies: @A123, @Mikel

  611. @AP
    @Beckow


    The census takers would ask if a person understood the Magyar language and if they said yes, they were listed as Magyars. All Jews also declared Magyar nationality.
     
    I realize you might not be the person to ask, but was the census in Hungary different from the one in Austria? In Austria they asked about language and about religion, but not about ethnicity (which could usually be inferred from language). So an urban Polish-speaking Ukrainian would be Polish by language and Greek Catholic by religion. Many ethnic Jews were Polish by language but Jewish by religion. There was no “ethnicity” to declare.

    Trianon was a massive shrinkage of Hungary
     
    Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder and squatter in the heart of Slavic lands, separating Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians from their Slovenian and Croatian brothers. The product of Asian invaders and plains-dwelling Slavs whom they conquered and assimilated, Magyars behaved terribly towards Slavs. During the first world war, Hungarian troops engaged in numerous massacres of various Slavs including Ukrainians. During the Second World War, they were Hitler’s partners. They were lucky that they weren’t deported en masse to their ancient Eurasian homeland. They must miss it on some level, as evidenced by their love of Putin. In the case of Putin’s war, Hungary again chooses the side that is killing Slavs - Russia.

    And in their insolence these historical persecutors of Slavs dare to whine about Hungarian language schools in Ukraine.

    Ukrainians lived under Austria, Hungary and Russia. Hungarian-controlled Ukraine was the worst, a land of poverty, persecution, aggressive Magyarization, illiteracy. Russia was terrible by policy, but it’s administration was incompetent and rather non-intrusive so the policies were not terribly harmful to regular people. Austria was the best. Under benevolent Austrian rule, Galicians were the most educated and wealthiest of the Eastern Slavs, the first to achieve full literacy of students, Ukrainian-language university courses, etc.

    Slovaks seem to have been willing lackeys of the Magyars. I wonder if without Czech pushing (or Wilson’s encouragement) they would even have chosen independence from them. The patterns repeat themselves with Fico. Though there are plenty of decent Slovaks too.

    The Hungarians refused to negotiate

     

    There is a small but not zero chance that the Hungarians will manage to get themselves out of EU and NATO protection (probably not formally, but perhaps in terms of voting rights).

    Replies: @German_reader, @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

    Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder and squatter in the heart of Slavic lands, separating Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians from their Slovenian and Croatian brothers. The product of Asian invaders and plains-dwelling Slavs whom they conquered and assimilated, Magyars behaved terribly towards Slavs. During the first world war, Hungarian troops engaged in numerous massacres of various Slavs including Ukrainians. During the Second World War, they were Hitler’s partners. They were lucky that they weren’t deported en masse to their ancient Eurasian homeland. They must miss it on some level, as evidenced by their love of Putin. In the case of Putin’s war, Hungary again chooses the side that is killing Slavs – Russia.

    And in their insolence these historical persecutors of Slavs dare to whine about Hungarian language schools in Ukraine.

    Seems like Eurasian Russia really did choose the wrong side to back back in 1848-1849, no? A Eurasian Russian allied with a newly independent Eurasian Hungary and without any opposition from Austria in its desire to expand its sphere of influence into the Balkans in subsequent decades must have been an ideal scenario for Eurasian Russia, no?

    Also ironic that Eurasian Hungary is so hostile towards Muslims given that Islam, like Christianity, is a Eurasian religion.

    There is a small but not zero chance that the Hungarians will manage to get themselves out of EU and NATO protection (probably not formally, but perhaps in terms of voting rights).

    Is there any legal procedure/process for stripping an existing EU or NATO member country of its voting rights? And even if there is, it would need to be unanimous, no? So, Poland, Slovakia, et cetera would all need to be on board for this. Good luck getting Robert Fico’s Slovakia to agree to this for fear of subsequently having this EU procedure/process be used by the EU against their own country as well!

  612. @AP
    @Beckow


    The census takers would ask if a person understood the Magyar language and if they said yes, they were listed as Magyars. All Jews also declared Magyar nationality.
     
    I realize you might not be the person to ask, but was the census in Hungary different from the one in Austria? In Austria they asked about language and about religion, but not about ethnicity (which could usually be inferred from language). So an urban Polish-speaking Ukrainian would be Polish by language and Greek Catholic by religion. Many ethnic Jews were Polish by language but Jewish by religion. There was no “ethnicity” to declare.

    Trianon was a massive shrinkage of Hungary
     
    Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder and squatter in the heart of Slavic lands, separating Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians from their Slovenian and Croatian brothers. The product of Asian invaders and plains-dwelling Slavs whom they conquered and assimilated, Magyars behaved terribly towards Slavs. During the first world war, Hungarian troops engaged in numerous massacres of various Slavs including Ukrainians. During the Second World War, they were Hitler’s partners. They were lucky that they weren’t deported en masse to their ancient Eurasian homeland. They must miss it on some level, as evidenced by their love of Putin. In the case of Putin’s war, Hungary again chooses the side that is killing Slavs - Russia.

    And in their insolence these historical persecutors of Slavs dare to whine about Hungarian language schools in Ukraine.

    Ukrainians lived under Austria, Hungary and Russia. Hungarian-controlled Ukraine was the worst, a land of poverty, persecution, aggressive Magyarization, illiteracy. Russia was terrible by policy, but it’s administration was incompetent and rather non-intrusive so the policies were not terribly harmful to regular people. Austria was the best. Under benevolent Austrian rule, Galicians were the most educated and wealthiest of the Eastern Slavs, the first to achieve full literacy of students, Ukrainian-language university courses, etc.

    Slovaks seem to have been willing lackeys of the Magyars. I wonder if without Czech pushing (or Wilson’s encouragement) they would even have chosen independence from them. The patterns repeat themselves with Fico. Though there are plenty of decent Slovaks too.

    The Hungarians refused to negotiate

     

    There is a small but not zero chance that the Hungarians will manage to get themselves out of EU and NATO protection (probably not formally, but perhaps in terms of voting rights).

    Replies: @German_reader, @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

    …was the census in Hungary different from the one in Austria?

    The census was a combination of administration and nationalist goals: in Hungary the nationalist impulse by 1890 became very dominant, in Austria it was a lot more professional. Austria was definitely a lot better place.

    Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder

    It was 1100 years ago and I am not going to worry about anything that far back. The people the incoming Magyars assimilated were mostly Latin Panonians, Germanic tribes and Slavs, there were also other populations like Illyrians, leftover Avars, etc…it was 1,000 years ago and it is not relevant.

    Hungarians have their point of view, many don’t like the Slavs and Germans, but many do…they celebrate their “Asian” heritage and also run away from it. You are oversimplifying.

    Slovaks have lived side by side with Magyars for 1,000 years without much mixing. We used Latin in admin and German in commerce and until the nationalist era in the 19th century we got along quite well. But you are wrong, after the unfortunate Magyar failed attempt at “Magyarization” that happened only in the last 20-25 years befor 1918 there is a lot of bad blood. To put it bluntly: we don’t like each other. Fico is a nationalist with strong anti-Magyar policies – it is the pro-Western liberals who are pro-Magyar. The fact that both Orban and Fico are kind of anti-EU and neutral in the Ukie war changes nothing (neutral means being in effect pro-Russia). They find areas to agree on.

    Kiev is being told to negotiate the best deal they can get by more EU leaders, the latest one is Italy. The Ukies screwed up: they went for everything and will end up with less than they easily could have had. The Nato membership nonsense put a fork in it. They only have themselves to blame and the idiot remote cheerleaders who put them up to it.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Beckow


    Slovaks have lived side by side with Magyars for 1,000 years without much mixing. We used Latin in admin and German in commerce and until the nationalist era in the 19th century we got along quite well. But you are wrong, after the unfortunate Magyar failed attempt at “Magyarization” that happened only in the last 20-25 years befor 1918 there is a lot of bad blood. To put it bluntly: we don’t like each other. Fico is a nationalist with strong anti-Magyar policies – it is the pro-Western liberals who are pro-Magyar. The fact that both Orban and Fico are kind of anti-EU and neutral in the Ukie war changes nothing (neutral means being in effect pro-Russia). They find areas to agree on.

     

    Wasn't Magyarization actually a significant success among the urban and educated minorities of Greater Hungary in the pre-WWI decades? It was mostly the peasants and rural folks who retained their old/existing cultures during this time period, IIRC.
  613. @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    The Prius is OK. Most of these also have a non-ideal ratio of engine size to battery capacity. I guess Toyota has not fully bought into the "range extender"concept. As electric motors keep getting smaller this should change. Making the very small engines efficient and clean is also challenging.

    I hate the stop-start engines of many hybrid cars. A range extender hybrid should break out of this by decoupling the engine from driving actions (except in emergencies when the battery has a problem). In the best case the engine is just a very quiet genset and is only coupled to the wheels electrically. Historically the engineers probably needed to use the generator as a motor as well, which gets into various complicated drivetrain arrangements.

    Replies: @QCIC

    There is a hybrid version of the BMW i3 (i3 Rex) with a small range extender engine and decent-sized battery. Unfortunately they have a goofy 2 gallon gas tank to meet US regulations. It uses a 650 cc Taiwanese engine from a BMW scooter. Roughly $50K to show you care about the climate!

  614. @AnonfromTN
    @QCIC


    I think the climate crowd is against any car that burns dead dinosaurs which may have hampered growth of hybrids. Never mind that most EV juice comes from fossil fuel generation.
     
    The whole “climate change” fable is BS, promoted by powerful interests that reap huge financial benefits from “carbon tax”, “environmental” tax breaks, production of solar panels, batteries, etc. “Climate change” people can never answer two questions: 1) how come the Mesozoic era (that lasted almost 200 million years) on Earth was so warm, even though there were no humans, no burning fossil fuels, etc.; 2) why would a sensible person believe the predictions about climate in 50-100 years by the same people who cannot predict the weather tomorrow. Although I know the answer to the second one: it is safe to “predict” distant future, as your “predictions” will be forgotten, so there would be no one to point out that they were wrong.

    BTW, oil has nothing to do with dead dinosaurs: the amount of oil on Earth, as well as the abundance of similar hydrocarbons on some moons of Jupiter prove beyond reasonable doubt its abiotic origin.

    As far as environmental damage and CO2 emissions are concerned, if you take into account manufacture and subsequent disposal, EV batteries and solar panels are at least as bad as coal-powered generation, much worse for the environment then power plants using natural gas, and many times worse than nuclear. The main drawback of traditional nuclear power plants was spent fuel rods that contain most of radioactive uranium and will be radioactive for millions of years. Russia built a mid-size nuclear reactor that uses “spent” fuel and returns it really spent, essentially non-radioactive. Based on its success, it is now building a large reactor using the same technology. However, Western MSM would never tell you this, as the reality is politically incorrect.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @songbird

    Supposedly, machine-learning is vastly improving the accuracy of weather forecasting.

    My vague understanding is that it actually takes less energy and time than traditional approaches, as it does not do the same level of number-crunching, but relies more on patterns.

    However, a lot of these AI models in other fields seem to use up a fair amount of juice. If they are really as useful as they say, I have modest hopes that the need for this power will drive a saner energy policy.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird


    Supposedly, machine-learning is vastly improving the accuracy of weather forecasting.
     
    Do you have a good source for this supposition?

    Replies: @songbird

  615. @WS
    @Mr. XYZ

    Croats are very, very Catholic!?
    and BTW why to make some new superstructure out of very homogeneous states?
    K&K monarchy looks simphatietic only on old postcards and maybe as well in many very new Sisi dedicated movies financially supported by EU.
    Coincidence that this very issue (restoration of Habsburgs) is open here again and again in past year?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Yeah, FWIW, my new superstructure talk was primarily just that–as in, empty talk. It’s pointless to actually do it because the much larger European Union already exists.

    And Yes, Croatia is a mostly Catholic country:

    https://www.state.gov/reports/2022-report-on-international-religious-freedom/croatia/#:~:text=According%20to%20Croatian%20government%202021,identify%20as%20nonreligious%20or%20atheist.

    “According to Croatian government 2021 census data released on September 22, 79 percent of the population is Catholic, 3.3 percent Serbian Orthodox, and 1.3 percent Muslim. Nearly 5 percent identify as nonreligious or atheist.”

    As are Hungary and Slovakia.

  616. @Beckow
    @AP


    ...was the census in Hungary different from the one in Austria?
     
    The census was a combination of administration and nationalist goals: in Hungary the nationalist impulse by 1890 became very dominant, in Austria it was a lot more professional. Austria was definitely a lot better place.

    Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder
     
    It was 1100 years ago and I am not going to worry about anything that far back. The people the incoming Magyars assimilated were mostly Latin Panonians, Germanic tribes and Slavs, there were also other populations like Illyrians, leftover Avars, etc...it was 1,000 years ago and it is not relevant.

    Hungarians have their point of view, many don't like the Slavs and Germans, but many do...they celebrate their "Asian" heritage and also run away from it. You are oversimplifying.

    Slovaks have lived side by side with Magyars for 1,000 years without much mixing. We used Latin in admin and German in commerce and until the nationalist era in the 19th century we got along quite well. But you are wrong, after the unfortunate Magyar failed attempt at "Magyarization" that happened only in the last 20-25 years befor 1918 there is a lot of bad blood. To put it bluntly: we don't like each other. Fico is a nationalist with strong anti-Magyar policies - it is the pro-Western liberals who are pro-Magyar. The fact that both Orban and Fico are kind of anti-EU and neutral in the Ukie war changes nothing (neutral means being in effect pro-Russia). They find areas to agree on.

    Kiev is being told to negotiate the best deal they can get by more EU leaders, the latest one is Italy. The Ukies screwed up: they went for everything and will end up with less than they easily could have had. The Nato membership nonsense put a fork in it. They only have themselves to blame and the idiot remote cheerleaders who put them up to it.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Slovaks have lived side by side with Magyars for 1,000 years without much mixing. We used Latin in admin and German in commerce and until the nationalist era in the 19th century we got along quite well. But you are wrong, after the unfortunate Magyar failed attempt at “Magyarization” that happened only in the last 20-25 years befor 1918 there is a lot of bad blood. To put it bluntly: we don’t like each other. Fico is a nationalist with strong anti-Magyar policies – it is the pro-Western liberals who are pro-Magyar. The fact that both Orban and Fico are kind of anti-EU and neutral in the Ukie war changes nothing (neutral means being in effect pro-Russia). They find areas to agree on.

    Wasn’t Magyarization actually a significant success among the urban and educated minorities of Greater Hungary in the pre-WWI decades? It was mostly the peasants and rural folks who retained their old/existing cultures during this time period, IIRC.

  617. @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN


    ...The Indians I know cover the same spectrum as Whites and Chinese...As Western politicians go, they are all scum
     
    I have to disagree. You are probably more exposed to the higher-achieving Indians in the academia. The context of "Whites" is also different. Indians came to our societies after throughly trashing their own previous quite nice subcontinent. Their behavior happens in that context - and it is in general toxic. There is a reason the larger-India looks the way it does - they are not very capable people: they have failed to sustain a civilization.

    People on Unz often obsess about individual IQ - but what matters is the society's IQ (or national) and the only way to measure it is by what the resulting society looks like. By that standard it is immediately obvious that the Indian-Paki society's IQ is very low: they live in a crap country getting worse. (Or Austria's IQ is higher than UK or Sweden.)

    The Indians are desperately trying to leave their sh..hole country, it is a career: to migrate to the West. But the destructive behaviors come with them, you can see it in politicians like Sunak, Haley. Kamala...a combination of servility and arrogance, as if the compradors arrived home. There are exceptions, but the overall impact has been to make an already bad situation worse.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

    FWIW, Anatoly Karlin has previously speculated that India’s average IQ might be depressed by as much as 10-15 points due to the poor environmental conditions in India.

    Genetic studies are rather preliminary, but South Asians appear to have roughly the same genetic phenotypic IQ score (based on the IQ genes found and located so far) as Latin Americans have:

    https://www.mdpi.com/2624-8611/1/1/5

    So, they could probably maintain a society as functional as Romania or Bulgaria if they will raise their average IQ up to its full potential. That’s essentially almost some Latin American countries today, only much more homicidal than Bulgaria and Romania are. But India is nowhere near as homicidal as Latin America is, thankfully.

  618. @John Johnson
    @Mikel

    Among them the fact that JJ has spent months lecturing us on how terrible Putin’s regime is because people who oppose him are made to die early and when that is exactly what happens to someone who dared to open his mouth against the regime he supports right next door (a citizen of his own country at that), he makes all kinds of excuses to minimize the incident.

    The event is still a half-mystery and no one seems to know what happened. Why don't you try quoting me directly? How am I making excuses when we don't even know what kind of condition he had or what was prevented?

    Care to explain why he didn't ask his sister to contact the state department if he was in poor health? Or why he said he had double pneumonia with a collapsed lung without any explanation as to how he got it? Does that sound normal to you?

    I still haven't had a Lira fan provide a ONE essay or article related to Ukraine. You don't find that rather peculiar? A supposed suppressed journalist that left us nothing? Who scrubbed his videos?

    It was Anglin's theory that Lira had a deathwish and wanted to go out as a martyr. I think it fits all available evidence and Anglin gets the credit. Feel free to disagree and state your case.

    Replies: @Mikel

    Care to explain why he didn’t ask his sister to contact the state department if he was in poor health?

    Stop embarrassing yourself. His father begged the State Department in front of the camera to save his son’s life but nobody moved a finger. Millions watched it on Tucker’s channel.

    You don’t need to stop supporting Ukraine in this war, retract anything you’ve ever said about Russia or anything like that. All you have to do is simply not be a part of the smelly scum: the State Department, Cirillo, the lying MSM that will do everything in their power to memory-hole the death of a compatriot (or shove piles of dirt on him if they are forced to acknowledge his existence) and the CIA who perfectly knew where he was and what his health condition was. Even in Ukraine prisons must have some doctor with a stethoscope capable of detecting a double pneumonia (unless they’re stealing even that part of our taxes).

    It was Anglin’s theory that Lira had a deathwish

    And what is Kim Kardashian’s theory?

  619. Manchus like Koreans because they have made three films where the villains actually speak Manchu. (SK might be conspiring to create a Manchu state…)

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Manchu-language_films

    I have seen 2 of the 3, which means they would probably let me live in the walled city, as if I were one of their Mongol allies.

  620. @AP
    @Beckow


    The census takers would ask if a person understood the Magyar language and if they said yes, they were listed as Magyars. All Jews also declared Magyar nationality.
     
    I realize you might not be the person to ask, but was the census in Hungary different from the one in Austria? In Austria they asked about language and about religion, but not about ethnicity (which could usually be inferred from language). So an urban Polish-speaking Ukrainian would be Polish by language and Greek Catholic by religion. Many ethnic Jews were Polish by language but Jewish by religion. There was no “ethnicity” to declare.

    Trianon was a massive shrinkage of Hungary
     
    Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder and squatter in the heart of Slavic lands, separating Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians from their Slovenian and Croatian brothers. The product of Asian invaders and plains-dwelling Slavs whom they conquered and assimilated, Magyars behaved terribly towards Slavs. During the first world war, Hungarian troops engaged in numerous massacres of various Slavs including Ukrainians. During the Second World War, they were Hitler’s partners. They were lucky that they weren’t deported en masse to their ancient Eurasian homeland. They must miss it on some level, as evidenced by their love of Putin. In the case of Putin’s war, Hungary again chooses the side that is killing Slavs - Russia.

    And in their insolence these historical persecutors of Slavs dare to whine about Hungarian language schools in Ukraine.

    Ukrainians lived under Austria, Hungary and Russia. Hungarian-controlled Ukraine was the worst, a land of poverty, persecution, aggressive Magyarization, illiteracy. Russia was terrible by policy, but it’s administration was incompetent and rather non-intrusive so the policies were not terribly harmful to regular people. Austria was the best. Under benevolent Austrian rule, Galicians were the most educated and wealthiest of the Eastern Slavs, the first to achieve full literacy of students, Ukrainian-language university courses, etc.

    Slovaks seem to have been willing lackeys of the Magyars. I wonder if without Czech pushing (or Wilson’s encouragement) they would even have chosen independence from them. The patterns repeat themselves with Fico. Though there are plenty of decent Slovaks too.

    The Hungarians refused to negotiate

     

    There is a small but not zero chance that the Hungarians will manage to get themselves out of EU and NATO protection (probably not formally, but perhaps in terms of voting rights).

    Replies: @German_reader, @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

    Slovaks seem to have been willing lackeys of the Magyars. I wonder if without Czech pushing (or Wilson’s encouragement) they would even have chosen independence from them. The patterns repeat themselves with Fico. Though there are plenty of decent Slovaks too.

    Without the Czechs pushing for independence, it’s unlikely that the Slovaks would have either. After all, an independent Slovakia would be easier to bully than a unified Czechoslovakia would. However, if the Czechs push for independence, they are virtually certain to also push for Slovak independence in order for their new country to become a bigger power than it would have otherwise been. An independent Czechia would also be around 30% German, which would be quite a significant demographic problem. Adding Slovakia into the mix would reduce the German percentage in Czechoslovakia to around 22%.

    FWIW, the arguments that Czechoslovakia supporters invoked during WWI, especially in 1917-1918, for the necessity of the creation of Czechoslovakia is that a surviving Austria-Hungary is likely to remain a German satellite state and that thus it’s best to weaken German power by destroying Austria-Hungary and freeing a huge part of Austria-Hungary’s subject peoples and utilizing their manpower for the Allied cause. I can’t say that their logic was completely wrong. After all, Austria eagerly joined the German Reich in early 1938 and Hungary was a loyal lapdog to Nazi Germany in the 1938-1944/5* time period. The main weakness of this approach is that the Bolsheviks removed Russia from Europe and thus it was harder to rely on Russia to help maintain the European balance of power in the post-WWI decades.

    *Hungary tried to switch sides in 1944 but was replaced with a more pliant Hungarian government.

  621. @AP
    @John Johnson


    There is too much uncertainty with Biden. If Trump really cared about defeating Biden then he would quit and endorse Haley. She polls not only better with independents but also moderate Democrats. Biden would flip if he had to face her. His best chance is a run-off with a Trump that catches a felony while leading the primary. That then leads to division in the GOP as to how they should proceed.
     
    The Democrats’ only chance of retaining the presidency is if Trump wins the primary and then gets convicted of something. So they will do what they can to help him become the Republican candidate. It may backfire and he may win the presidency anyways, but at least (for them) he is much less effective than a president DeSantis would have been.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ

    So they will do what they can to help him become the Republican candidate.

    Possibly, but at the same time, they’re trying to disqualify him based on the 14th Amendment as well. Is that a backup option for them? Because I get the impression that Democrats really care about the US and thus aggressively don’t want Trump to win reelection, even if that means another Republican such as Haley winning in his place.

  622. @AP
    @German_reader

    Lol, I’m not a diplomat so I described the reality openly. Don’t pretend that other Eastern Europeans (the ones who have a better future) don’t have similar thoughts.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

    Do you think that, had Austria-Hungary survived, Hungary would have been a pro-Russian pole within Austria-Hungary?

    Was Hungary a pro-Russian pole within Austria-Hungary during the last several decades of its existence in real life? After all, any Russian claims to Galicia (unlike Subcarpathian Ruthenia) did not affect Hungary itself, only Austria. And Russia having a common border with Hungary would not necessarily be to Hungary’s disadvantage since Hungary could have used this to extort much more defense spending from Austria on Hungarian territory, such as on the Carpathians (in order to better fortify them and Hungary against any future hypothetical Russian invasion).

  623. https://www.unz.com/akarlin/open-thread-233/#comment-6241572

    Russia of course is only 80% Slavic if one doesn’t count the illegals from Central Asia, and in occupied Ukraine is sending in Buryat and Muslim settlers who steal apartments from natives. Russia is viable though, in the sense that it has always been Eurasia. If it becomes 30% or 50% Asiatic and/or Muslim this will only be a return to more historical roots.

    I fantasize about Asians and/or Muslims becoming Russia’s version of what Latin Americans are to the US. The core Russian population needs to increase to around 300 million by adopting an Israeli-like mentality in regards to encouraging greater fertility/natalism, though.

    Russian nationalism should go into the dustbin of history where it belongs. Multicultural Eurasia for the win!

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Mr. XYZ

    So do you see Putler as being more of a Russian nationalist or more of a Eurasianist, or some kind of hybrid of the two inclinations?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Sher Singh

  624. @songbird
    @AnonfromTN

    Supposedly, machine-learning is vastly improving the accuracy of weather forecasting.

    My vague understanding is that it actually takes less energy and time than traditional approaches, as it does not do the same level of number-crunching, but relies more on patterns.

    However, a lot of these AI models in other fields seem to use up a fair amount of juice. If they are really as useful as they say, I have modest hopes that the need for this power will drive a saner energy policy.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    Supposedly, machine-learning is vastly improving the accuracy of weather forecasting.

    Do you have a good source for this supposition?

    • Replies: @songbird
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Mostly, just what the machine-learning people are saying, like:
    https://deepmind.google/discover/blog/graphcast-ai-model-for-faster-and-more-accurate-global-weather-forecasting/

    What's the latest critical look at it? I don't know. But it seems like there might be ways to improve it, including more data collection. They can re-evaluate their predictions fairly quickly, in theory. Main limitation is that it takes so long for the standard processes that they have to wait to make the comparison.

    Replies: @Mikel

  625. @Mr. XYZ
    https://www.unz.com/akarlin/open-thread-233/#comment-6241572

    Russia of course is only 80% Slavic if one doesn’t count the illegals from Central Asia, and in occupied Ukraine is sending in Buryat and Muslim settlers who steal apartments from natives. Russia is viable though, in the sense that it has always been Eurasia. If it becomes 30% or 50% Asiatic and/or Muslim this will only be a return to more historical roots.
     
    I fantasize about Asians and/or Muslims becoming Russia's version of what Latin Americans are to the US. The core Russian population needs to increase to around 300 million by adopting an Israeli-like mentality in regards to encouraging greater fertility/natalism, though.

    Russian nationalism should go into the dustbin of history where it belongs. Multicultural Eurasia for the win!

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    So do you see Putler as being more of a Russian nationalist or more of a Eurasianist, or some kind of hybrid of the two inclinations?

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. Hack

    He strikes me as being a kind of hybrid fellow. On the one hand, he has the Eurasian Economic Union and guest workers from Central Asia (with him naturalizing large numbers of Tajiks, apparently). On the other hand, he appears to have taken a sharp Russian nationalist turn since 2018:

    https://www.unz.com/akarlin/russias-nationalist-turn/

    Putin did say something that I agreed with recently, though:

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/vladimir-putin-women-eight-children-ukraine-war-b2455957.html

    Though 2.5-3 children along the Israeli model sounds like a much more desirable and attainable long-term goal, at least if the Russian people will become fully immersed in their nationalist mentality. But this goal could easily fail. Israeli Jews might be unique.

    I'm just saying that Russia should try learning from Israeli Jews and try compensating for its extremely terrible 20th century by breeding much more. That's much easier said than done, of course.

    I also think that since Russia could have experienced large-scale Muslim and other (East Asian, Hindu, et cetera) immigration without Communism, maybe Russia should consider this approach right now, especially considering that working-class Muslims might integrate better in Russia than in the West, at least if Russia's experience ruling over Central Asia is anything to go by. Chechens, of course, have integrated less well, though this might not be true of other Dagestanis such as Laks.

    , @Sher Singh
    @Mr. Hack


    https://twitter.com/Kharagket_/status/1747362620938535325

    https://twitter.com/ParminderK86876/status/1746919036179579079

    https://twitter.com/Yatt47/status/1747153745400508824

    https://twitter.com/ipsinghTOI/status/1747130520272519329

    ਅਕਾਲ

    Replies: @Sher Singh

  626. @Mr. Hack
    @Mr. XYZ

    So do you see Putler as being more of a Russian nationalist or more of a Eurasianist, or some kind of hybrid of the two inclinations?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Sher Singh

    He strikes me as being a kind of hybrid fellow. On the one hand, he has the Eurasian Economic Union and guest workers from Central Asia (with him naturalizing large numbers of Tajiks, apparently). On the other hand, he appears to have taken a sharp Russian nationalist turn since 2018:

    https://www.unz.com/akarlin/russias-nationalist-turn/

    Putin did say something that I agreed with recently, though:

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/vladimir-putin-women-eight-children-ukraine-war-b2455957.html

    Though 2.5-3 children along the Israeli model sounds like a much more desirable and attainable long-term goal, at least if the Russian people will become fully immersed in their nationalist mentality. But this goal could easily fail. Israeli Jews might be unique.

    I’m just saying that Russia should try learning from Israeli Jews and try compensating for its extremely terrible 20th century by breeding much more. That’s much easier said than done, of course.

    I also think that since Russia could have experienced large-scale Muslim and other (East Asian, Hindu, et cetera) immigration without Communism, maybe Russia should consider this approach right now, especially considering that working-class Muslims might integrate better in Russia than in the West, at least if Russia’s experience ruling over Central Asia is anything to go by. Chechens, of course, have integrated less well, though this might not be true of other Dagestanis such as Laks.

  627. @Mr. Hack
    @Mr. XYZ

    So do you see Putler as being more of a Russian nationalist or more of a Eurasianist, or some kind of hybrid of the two inclinations?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Sher Singh

    [MORE]

    https://twitter.com/Yatt47/status/1747153745400508824

    ਅਕਾਲ

    • Replies: @Sher Singh
    @Sher Singh

    Eh, moving away from the cultic stuff back to a pursual of strength.

    ਅਕਾਲ

  628. @Sher Singh
    @Mr. Hack


    https://twitter.com/Kharagket_/status/1747362620938535325

    https://twitter.com/ParminderK86876/status/1746919036179579079

    https://twitter.com/Yatt47/status/1747153745400508824

    https://twitter.com/ipsinghTOI/status/1747130520272519329

    ਅਕਾਲ

    Replies: @Sher Singh

    Eh, moving away from the cultic stuff back to a pursual of strength.

    ਅਕਾਲ

  629. @John Johnson
    Russian conscripts told to get in hole and f-ck each other:
    https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/1855307/russian-conscripts-stripped-ukraine-war-latest

    This must be that healthy Orthodox culture that Tucker has talked about.

    World's highest abortion rate and they have actually have a video of their conscripts being told to butt-fuck each other as punishment.

    Oh and it sounds like they are gunning for the #1 spot in alcoholism. Watch out Belarus!
    https://www.msn.com/en-us/health/other/alcoholism-surges-in-russia-amid-ukraine-war/ar-AA1n09tJ

    Replies: @LT1488

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/1034529/russia-total-number-of-abortions/

    Abortions in Russia have declined from 2 million in 2000 to less than 400,000 in 2022 and will further decline to 250,000 by 2025.

  630. @AP
    @Beckow


    The census takers would ask if a person understood the Magyar language and if they said yes, they were listed as Magyars. All Jews also declared Magyar nationality.
     
    I realize you might not be the person to ask, but was the census in Hungary different from the one in Austria? In Austria they asked about language and about religion, but not about ethnicity (which could usually be inferred from language). So an urban Polish-speaking Ukrainian would be Polish by language and Greek Catholic by religion. Many ethnic Jews were Polish by language but Jewish by religion. There was no “ethnicity” to declare.

    Trianon was a massive shrinkage of Hungary
     
    Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder and squatter in the heart of Slavic lands, separating Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians from their Slovenian and Croatian brothers. The product of Asian invaders and plains-dwelling Slavs whom they conquered and assimilated, Magyars behaved terribly towards Slavs. During the first world war, Hungarian troops engaged in numerous massacres of various Slavs including Ukrainians. During the Second World War, they were Hitler’s partners. They were lucky that they weren’t deported en masse to their ancient Eurasian homeland. They must miss it on some level, as evidenced by their love of Putin. In the case of Putin’s war, Hungary again chooses the side that is killing Slavs - Russia.

    And in their insolence these historical persecutors of Slavs dare to whine about Hungarian language schools in Ukraine.

    Ukrainians lived under Austria, Hungary and Russia. Hungarian-controlled Ukraine was the worst, a land of poverty, persecution, aggressive Magyarization, illiteracy. Russia was terrible by policy, but it’s administration was incompetent and rather non-intrusive so the policies were not terribly harmful to regular people. Austria was the best. Under benevolent Austrian rule, Galicians were the most educated and wealthiest of the Eastern Slavs, the first to achieve full literacy of students, Ukrainian-language university courses, etc.

    Slovaks seem to have been willing lackeys of the Magyars. I wonder if without Czech pushing (or Wilson’s encouragement) they would even have chosen independence from them. The patterns repeat themselves with Fico. Though there are plenty of decent Slovaks too.

    The Hungarians refused to negotiate

     

    There is a small but not zero chance that the Hungarians will manage to get themselves out of EU and NATO protection (probably not formally, but perhaps in terms of voting rights).

    Replies: @German_reader, @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

    ”Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder and squatter in the heart of Slavic lands, separating Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians from their Slovenian and Croatian brothers. The product of Asian invaders and plains-dwelling Slavs whom they conquered and assimilated, Magyars behaved terribly towards Slavs. During the first world war, Hungarian troops engaged in numerous massacres of various Slavs including Ukrainians. During the Second World War, they were Hitler’s partners. They were lucky that they weren’t deported en masse to their ancient Eurasian homeland. They must miss it on some level, as evidenced by their love of Putin. In the case of Putin’s war, Hungary again chooses the side that is killing Slavs – Russia.”

    First of all even the Ugric Hungarians had majority R1B haplogroup.
    And on top of that most Hungarians aren’t Ugric, they are a slavo-germanic populace.
    The ”Ukrainians” in Carpathia, are actually a distinct ethnic group called the Rusyns, whose rights are recognized by Hungary, Slovakia, Serbia, Croatia and Poland.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @LT1488

    The Rusyn ethnonym and name is an old one that at one time was shared by all Ukrainians. Linguists (even Paul Magocsi) have no trouble in clearly identifying the Rusyn dialect(s) being clearly old Ukrainian ones. Why you bring this up here and now when discussing the Hungarian question is strange and proves exactly what? There are over one million people living within Zakarpttya today that are perfectly comfortable living with their Ukrainian identiry. The other 10,000 sheep hearders, KGB implants and grant eaters will just have to learn to get along with their Ukrainian neighbors.

    https://euromaidanpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/comic2.jpg

    Replies: @LT1488, @Beckow, @Derer

  631. @AP
    @German_reader

    Lol, I’m not a diplomat so I described the reality openly. Don’t pretend that other Eastern Europeans (the ones who have a better future) don’t have similar thoughts.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

    Hungarians are not hated by most slavic eastern europeans
    Poles,Russians, Czechs, Croats etc like the Hungarians and Poles even consider them their brothers.
    Slovaks and Serbs have some issues with the Magyars, but the current Slovak and Serbian leadership is very friendly with the current Magyar leadership.
    As for other neighbouring eastern Europeans, the Romanians indeed do not like Hungary and haven’t even allowed their Hungarian minority right to autonomy. And as for Ukraine, as you said, the Hungarian minority’s rights to speak and learn Hungarian are being infringed upon.
    I do not know where you got this logic of slavs and other eastern europeans intensely disliking Hungary when the opposite is true.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488


    I do not know where you got this logic of slavs and other eastern europeans intensely disliking Hungary when the opposite is true.

     

    Well, Hungary oppressed Slavs (and Romanians) as part of its Magyarization policy in the 1867 to 1918 time period. But that was over a century ago by now.

    Replies: @LT1488

    , @AP
    @LT1488


    Hungarians are not hated by most slavic eastern europeans
    Poles,Russians, Czechs, Croats etc like the Hungarians and Poles even consider them their brothers
     
    Poles no longer like Hungarians.

    https://notesfrompoland.com/2023/03/27/poles-dislike-of-russians-belarusians-hungarians-and-germans-has-grown-amid-war-finds-study/

    “Apart from Russians, the largest decline in positive sentiment was recorded towards Hungarians, who fell 21 percentage points from 57% to 36%”


    And as for Ukraine, as you said, the Hungarian minority’s rights to speak and learn Hungarian are being infringed upon
     
    I didn’t say that.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

  632. German_reader says:
    @Gerard1234
    @German_reader


    This is a totally misleading comparison. Soviet Union in WW2 never faced a combined day-and-night air offensive
     
    Well I did suspect that would be your response, but it's clear to me that because of successful Soviet air defence the Nazis were forced to greatly reduce their bombing campaign. You can still see the small chamber at the top of a few buildings in Moscow today where the anti-aircraft guns were installed.


    British didn't have successful Air defence, so Nazis encouraged to bomb them more.

    Britain didn't have to face 4-engine heavy bombers from the Luftwaffe either. For the British/Americans strategic bombing on Nazi Germany then you are correct - but I don't think my comment about superiority of Soviet air defence is disproven. Western allied bombing wasn't close to the level you describe until mid-1943 so I do think comparisons of British vs Soviet air defences from 1941-43 are useful


    Though the threat is much greater, the Lancaster and the other heavy bombers are easier to intercept, and the distance for spotting and early warning as RAF & USAF planes fly over the sea and several Nazi controlled countries before reaching targets in Germany..... is about the same as from Nazi seized airfields in the east to Soviet targets.
    W

    Replies: @German_reader

    British didn’t have successful Air defence

    Britain was the first country in the world to have a coordinated, radar-based air defence system, its effectiveness was proven in 1940. Obviously Soviet Union later developed very sophisticated anti-air and radar systems of its own, but I don’t think they had something like that during WW2. They didn’t need to anyway, since Germany lacked the resources for a sustained bomber offensive against Soviet Union and much industry could be evacuated beyond the Urals (i.e. beyond the range of German bombers).

    • Agree: Philip Owen
    • Replies: @songbird
    @German_reader


    its effectiveness was proven in 1940
     
    Have heard claims they killed more civilians than the Germans by firing a lot of useless guns into the air, to put on a show.
    https://youtu.be/dW6C0WDYlhg?si=QQkh4G9qVMNvv97X

    Replies: @German_reader

    , @Gerard1234
    @German_reader

    All good points.

    However does it in any way disprove that Soviet air defence was superior?
    I just haven't any idea of how much of whichever type of bomb was dropped on London or the UK as a whole.......but for London surely they had the same amount, probably much less air raids done against them and less bombs dropped than Leningrad suffered? Need to know the numbers. And planes shot down proportional to the number of raids.

    True, a co-ordinated mass attack over a short time is worse than the same amount of bombs dropped over 2-3 years, but overall evidence suggest Soviet cities were better defended from the air.

    In 3 years, damage to Leningrad from the air was not too bad. Civilian deaths much less. Several landmarks in London got hit - I know Buckingham Palace and St Pauls Cathedral, maybe the Parliament got hit. Leningrad/Saint Petersburg did not suffer like this in damage. Both Soviet cities and London not much wooden buildings ( had great fire in 17th century then city was rebuilt) compared to German cities like Dresden or the Japanese ones like Toyko.

    A-A guns in the city and on the ships of the Baltic Fleet in the Neva and off the Baltic coast, together with the work of our air force ensured the Nazi's were not successful in the air raids on Leningrad.


    They didn’t need to anyway, since Germany lacked the resources for a sustained bomber offensive against Soviet Union and much industry could be evacuated beyond the Urals (i.e. beyond the range of German bombers).

     

    For four months ( not much shorter than the main bombing phase against the UK) , before production moved to the Urals, Moscow was the most targeted city on the planet from Autumn 1941-beginning of 1942. Other places the same pattern - though Kiev was taken, air defence against the Nazi invasion worked well. Having Leningrad destroyed from the air, and Moscow in the period till 1942 were far more important and neccessary objectives for the Nazi's than London or even the UK's industrial production sites ever was.

    There is no excuse for London, but the only excuse that could be given for the rest of the UK in air defence is that they have lots of cities very close together ( UK appears very strange in that no other place I have visited has such radically different regional accent over such short distance, which must have occured because of these close, different industrial centres) , each historically with their own industrial importance. With most European cities it's one metropolitan area to defend, in UK you could have 5 different cities, each of own industrial importance to the war......within about 10 minutes of flying time of german bombers if spotted in a certain area. Knowing which cities should be on high alert for a night air raid from that point then becomes very difficult. Doesn't excuse London defence though.

    Replies: @Philip Owen, @Sean

    , @China Japan and Korea Bromance of Three Kingdoms
    @German_reader

    Soviet Air Force had an extensive purge in 1941, in spite of Barbarossa:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1941_Red_Army_Purge

    Soviets sent in clandestine, a considerable "volunteer" air fleet to China. Over 1200 aircrafts and 3000+ personnel. They took part in extensive action against Japan, including a bombing of Taiwan, and performed well.

    They painted Republic of China colors on the planes. After the Japanese shot some down and discovered the pilots were Russians, Soviets still denied the operation.

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f0/Soviet_volunteer.jpg

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/eb/Soviet_Aviators_in_China.jpg

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_Volunteer_Group

    One of those pilots in China was promoted to Commander of the Soviet Air Forces in '41 and was liquidated by NKVD that October.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pavel_Rychagov

  633. @Mr. XYZ
    @Sean


    If Washington was trying to make Russia a Western style democracy, the method they chose of attaining their object (fobbing off Putin’s attempts to join Nato while advancing Nato to RusFed’s borders and chortling at his complaints) did not turn out to be a very effective method, did it?
     
    Would having Russia join NATO have made Russia a Western-style democracy? Or would it have simply resulted in Putin being an East Slavic version of Erdogan for the West? Which, admittedly, would still be a significant improvement over real life.

    Replies: @Sean

    Countries join Nato so they don’t have to spend serious money on their own defence, Russia had always been a military autocracy, so Putin asking if Russia could join Nato was a sign he wanted to take Russia in a less defenced spending Western direction. It soon became clear to Putin as he was fobbed of that Russia was not welcome in Nato, and it was an anti Russian military alliance.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Sean

    Spending less on defense doesn't necessarily mean that Russia is going to become less of an autocracy. It would be less hostile towards the West, of course, though probably not being willing to be the West's tool either in regards to China, et cetera.

    Replies: @Sean

  634. @QCIC
    @sudden death

    So who will the Demonrats swap in to run instead of Biden?

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @sudden death

    They don’t feel the urgent need to swap, cause Trump nomination is convenient for them – any old age related attacks fall notably flat when you have standing pudgy allegedly smelly geriatric candidate in the corner against lean allegedly smelly geriatric candidate in the other corner, lol

    With Vivek dropping out, most probably roughly 5-6% of his votes goes to Trump, the rest 2-3% to Desantis, so Trump should get roughly 55-57% along remaining way, with Ron coming second with roughly 23-24% and getting VP nomination, even if some individual fluctuations in separate states are not out of the question.

    However this would be logical course of events, so I won’t be making this prediction as there was nothing logical about Trump behaviour since corona started, he always did the worst imaginable course of action, so it wouldn’t be out of character for him to chose some open putinist bootlicker like Kari Lake as VP.

    This would also ensure at least 10% missing R votes for Trump (5% of Nikki voters not coming to vote at all and another 5% voting for Biden in autumn) with the rest 10% probably taking it out for the team and still voting R ticket nevertheless, especially if Haley endorses even in such case.

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @sudden death

    btw, now remembered once A123 mentioning, that DeSantis can't be chosen as VP for the technical legal reason alone that both Trump and him live in the same state of Florida, but at the same time could barely imagine Trump voluntarily choosing Haley, which should come third, as his VP.

    Replies: @A123

  635. @sudden death
    @QCIC

    They don't feel the urgent need to swap, cause Trump nomination is convenient for them - any old age related attacks fall notably flat when you have standing pudgy allegedly smelly geriatric candidate in the corner against lean allegedly smelly geriatric candidate in the other corner, lol

    With Vivek dropping out, most probably roughly 5-6% of his votes goes to Trump, the rest 2-3% to Desantis, so Trump should get roughly 55-57% along remaining way, with Ron coming second with roughly 23-24% and getting VP nomination, even if some individual fluctuations in separate states are not out of the question.

    However this would be logical course of events, so I won't be making this prediction as there was nothing logical about Trump behaviour since corona started, he always did the worst imaginable course of action, so it wouldn't be out of character for him to chose some open putinist bootlicker like Kari Lake as VP.

    This would also ensure at least 10% missing R votes for Trump (5% of Nikki voters not coming to vote at all and another 5% voting for Biden in autumn) with the rest 10% probably taking it out for the team and still voting R ticket nevertheless, especially if Haley endorses even in such case.

    Replies: @sudden death

    btw, now remembered once A123 mentioning, that DeSantis can’t be chosen as VP for the technical legal reason alone that both Trump and him live in the same state of Florida, but at the same time could barely imagine Trump voluntarily choosing Haley, which should come third, as his VP.

    • Replies: @A123
    @sudden death


    now remembered once A123 mentioning, that DeSantis can’t be chosen as VP for the technical legal reason alone that both Trump and him live in the same state of Florida, but at the same time could barely imagine Trump voluntarily choosing Haley, which should come third, as his VP.
     
    In days long past, Dick Cheney changed from TX to WY before becoming VP candidate. This was questioned but not challenged, as he and his family had long standing ties to Wyoming.

    Does DeSantis have comparable ties elsewhere? Not that I am aware of. And, he would have to step down as governor.

    Trump already changed residence from NY to FL. This has high credibility as New York City is a sh!thole. Florida has low taxes, better laws, and an improved quality of life. There is no reason to believe he would go through another relocation.

    Plus, we are now in the age of "lawfare". If any candidate makes such a move late, the change of residency would wind up in court. There is no good reason for any ticket to create this problem for themselves.
    ___

    Nikki Haley publicly stated that she does not want to be Trump's VP (1). I am not sure why people keep suggesting her. She is neither loyal nor MAGA. Both defects are disqualifying.

    If Trump wants to pick a minority, Tim Scott is the most plausible choice from the primary candidates.

    PEACE 😇
    ___________

    (1) https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2024/01/14/nikki_haley_im_not_interested_in_being_vice_president.html

  636. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird


    Supposedly, machine-learning is vastly improving the accuracy of weather forecasting.
     
    Do you have a good source for this supposition?

    Replies: @songbird

    Mostly, just what the machine-learning people are saying, like:
    https://deepmind.google/discover/blog/graphcast-ai-model-for-faster-and-more-accurate-global-weather-forecasting/

    What’s the latest critical look at it? I don’t know. But it seems like there might be ways to improve it, including more data collection. They can re-evaluate their predictions fairly quickly, in theory. Main limitation is that it takes so long for the standard processes that they have to wait to make the comparison.

    • Replies: @Mikel
    @songbird


    They can re-evaluate their predictions fairly quickly, in theory. Main limitation is that it takes so long for the standard processes that they have to wait to make the comparison.
     
    Thanks for that article but, as a lifelong weather nut, I don't see too much of a groundbreaking advance here.

    If I understand things correctly, their system makes much faster calculations than the standard numerical models used currently at the cost of using a crude data-intensive model trained on 45 years of data and corresponding outcomes instead of the computationally intensive physical equations that drive the standard models.

    I'm not sure how this higher computing speed on a cruder model improves things much. Historical outcomes may not repeat themselves, as per the well-known butterfly effect, and numerical models are already quite good at short lead times. As they say themselves in the article, all they were able to do for a hurricane landfall prediction is lengthen it to 9 days as opposed to 6 days of the numerical models. A bit of an advantage for disaster preparedness, if you trust the 9-day out prediction, but I doubt anybody is doing much nowadays even 6 days in advance.

    I even fail to see where the ML and AI component of this model is but admittedly, I don't know much about those subjects. As I understand it, perhaps incorrectly, ML would only kick in once they have a good set of predictions that they can compare to real-life outcomes. In any case, no AI is going to overcome the aforementioned butterfly effect, formulated by the great Lorentz, that makes prediction of a chaotic system impossible past a number of days. In the future AI may be able to do stuff like generate new mathematical theorems but I'm totally sure that weather forecasting is going to be limited by Lorentz's theories for a very long time to come (perhaps forever, if our current understanding of chaotic systems is correct).

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird

  637. Mr. Hack has been posting clips of his cats on YouTube.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    Just purchased and finished building a cat house for them in my backyard. They're slowly getting used to it and can be seen going in and out of their new castle. Let's see, they've got all of the shots that the vet prescribed, food 2-3 times per day and water, and now a house that they can inhabit when it's cold, windy or raining outside. My conscience is clear and I can sleep soundly again at night...BTW, I avoided the problem of overpopulation by having my three cats spaded and neutered (the best idea that I ever had).

    Replies: @songbird, @Sher Singh

  638. @LT1488
    @AP

    ''Hungary has historically been a Eurasian intruder and squatter in the heart of Slavic lands, separating Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians from their Slovenian and Croatian brothers. The product of Asian invaders and plains-dwelling Slavs whom they conquered and assimilated, Magyars behaved terribly towards Slavs. During the first world war, Hungarian troops engaged in numerous massacres of various Slavs including Ukrainians. During the Second World War, they were Hitler’s partners. They were lucky that they weren’t deported en masse to their ancient Eurasian homeland. They must miss it on some level, as evidenced by their love of Putin. In the case of Putin’s war, Hungary again chooses the side that is killing Slavs – Russia.''

    First of all even the Ugric Hungarians had majority R1B haplogroup.
    And on top of that most Hungarians aren't Ugric, they are a slavo-germanic populace.
    The ''Ukrainians'' in Carpathia, are actually a distinct ethnic group called the Rusyns, whose rights are recognized by Hungary, Slovakia, Serbia, Croatia and Poland.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    The Rusyn ethnonym and name is an old one that at one time was shared by all Ukrainians. Linguists (even Paul Magocsi) have no trouble in clearly identifying the Rusyn dialect(s) being clearly old Ukrainian ones. Why you bring this up here and now when discussing the Hungarian question is strange and proves exactly what? There are over one million people living within Zakarpttya today that are perfectly comfortable living with their Ukrainian identiry. The other 10,000 sheep hearders, KGB implants and grant eaters will just have to learn to get along with their Ukrainian neighbors.

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @Mr. Hack

    I guess countries like Croatia and Poland that recognize them as an independent ethnic group from Ukrainians, must be Kremlin implants too!

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    , @Beckow
    @Mr. Hack

    As so often you know nothing about the actual situation on the ground. In Slovakia and Czechia a large proportion of the recent migrants from Ukraine are Rusyns from Zakarpatia, they consciously identify differently. There is a Rusyn church, university, in Prague they have churches, clubs, restaurants...in my experience most are neutral in the war - you read into it whatever you want.

    Rusyns are distinct people with their own language or dialect, music, history. There is some loose talk to rejoin Czechia, Slovakia or Hungary - to be in EU immediately. But it is very messy and the geography is too remote. They don't like Galicians from over the Carpathian mountains and don't want to be like them, they have no Bandera worship or hatred of Russia. Their preference was to be in a multi-ethnic Ukraine with cultural autonomy - then the dumb Ukie nationalists blew it apart. My sense is that hundreds of thousands of them will stay and assimilate - they are very similar to our Rusyns.

    By the way the previous Czech PM Andrej Babis was from Zakarpathia on his mother's side. We were one country not that long ago.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @AP

    , @Derer
    @Mr. Hack


    There are over one million people living within Zakarpttya today that are perfectly comfortable living with their Ukrainian identiry.
     
    BS. You do not know their desire - need for referendum. Few years back they were caught making underground tunnels to Slovakia. They prefer earning Euro in Slovakia to Ukie worthless paper. They prefer Latin alphabet to Cyrillic.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  639. @songbird
    Mr. Hack has been posting clips of his cats on YouTube.

    His back door:
    https://youtu.be/9EYZnSXEla0?si=ssJuMDRALdrOklXh

    His front;
    https://youtube.com/shorts/W4uUSTcC8UM?si=1QVwob3vKDM9oJJo

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    Just purchased and finished building a cat house for them in my backyard. They’re slowly getting used to it and can be seen going in and out of their new castle. Let’s see, they’ve got all of the shots that the vet prescribed, food 2-3 times per day and water, and now a house that they can inhabit when it’s cold, windy or raining outside. My conscience is clear and I can sleep soundly again at night…BTW, I avoided the problem of overpopulation by having my three cats spaded and neutered (the best idea that I ever had).

    • Replies: @songbird
    @Mr. Hack

    Most likely, the bird people would still be after you. But you are okay in my book.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    , @Sher Singh
    @Mr. Hack


    https://twitter.com/SohamSSJ/status/1747516369544077722?s=20

    ਅਕਾਲ

  640. @sudden death
    @sudden death

    btw, now remembered once A123 mentioning, that DeSantis can't be chosen as VP for the technical legal reason alone that both Trump and him live in the same state of Florida, but at the same time could barely imagine Trump voluntarily choosing Haley, which should come third, as his VP.

    Replies: @A123

    now remembered once A123 mentioning, that DeSantis can’t be chosen as VP for the technical legal reason alone that both Trump and him live in the same state of Florida, but at the same time could barely imagine Trump voluntarily choosing Haley, which should come third, as his VP.

    In days long past, Dick Cheney changed from TX to WY before becoming VP candidate. This was questioned but not challenged, as he and his family had long standing ties to Wyoming.

    Does DeSantis have comparable ties elsewhere? Not that I am aware of. And, he would have to step down as governor.

    Trump already changed residence from NY to FL. This has high credibility as New York City is a sh!thole. Florida has low taxes, better laws, and an improved quality of life. There is no reason to believe he would go through another relocation.

    Plus, we are now in the age of “lawfare”. If any candidate makes such a move late, the change of residency would wind up in court. There is no good reason for any ticket to create this problem for themselves.
    ___

    Nikki Haley publicly stated that she does not want to be Trump’s VP (1). I am not sure why people keep suggesting her. She is neither loyal nor MAGA. Both defects are disqualifying.

    If Trump wants to pick a minority, Tim Scott is the most plausible choice from the primary candidates.

    PEACE 😇
    ___________

    (1) https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2024/01/14/nikki_haley_im_not_interested_in_being_vice_president.html

  641. @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    Just purchased and finished building a cat house for them in my backyard. They're slowly getting used to it and can be seen going in and out of their new castle. Let's see, they've got all of the shots that the vet prescribed, food 2-3 times per day and water, and now a house that they can inhabit when it's cold, windy or raining outside. My conscience is clear and I can sleep soundly again at night...BTW, I avoided the problem of overpopulation by having my three cats spaded and neutered (the best idea that I ever had).

    Replies: @songbird, @Sher Singh

    Most likely, the bird people would still be after you. But you are okay in my book.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    Actually, I'm on pretty good terms with the bird people (here they're called pigeons), even though I wish that they'd leave my backyard alone. They're a messy and persistent group that act like vultures when it coms to food scavenging. There's an interesting back and forth war game going on between "the cats" and "the pigeons". Actually, both groups are rather tame now and leave each other alone.

    A funny thing occurred recently. Sometimes, I'll leave my back sliding door open in order to lure my cats indoors. One time, a pigeon made his way in...and one cat too. They both got tangled up in my window curtain, however even though they were less than a foot apart, the cat did not attack the pigeon! Did you know that pigeons enjoy eating all sorts of flesh? They always manage to clean out any crumbs left inside of cat food cans.

    https://i.ytimg.com/vi/CYr3Psqh32Q/hqdefault.jpg

    Replies: @songbird

  642. @German_reader
    @Gerard1234


    British didn’t have successful Air defence
     
    Britain was the first country in the world to have a coordinated, radar-based air defence system, its effectiveness was proven in 1940. Obviously Soviet Union later developed very sophisticated anti-air and radar systems of its own, but I don't think they had something like that during WW2. They didn't need to anyway, since Germany lacked the resources for a sustained bomber offensive against Soviet Union and much industry could be evacuated beyond the Urals (i.e. beyond the range of German bombers).

    Replies: @songbird, @Gerard1234, @China Japan and Korea Bromance of Three Kingdoms

    its effectiveness was proven in 1940

    Have heard claims they killed more civilians than the Germans by firing a lot of useless guns into the air, to put on a show.

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @songbird

    Sounds pretty questionable to me, one can take myth deconstruction too far. Where does the guy in the video get the number of "30 000 killed by artillery shells" figure from? That would have been half of all British civilians killed in the air war (for the entire war, including the sporadic German air raids and V-weapons attacks later in the war). Seems highly implausible to me, probably one more case of revisionism gone wild.

    Replies: @songbird

  643. German_reader says:
    @songbird
    @German_reader


    its effectiveness was proven in 1940
     
    Have heard claims they killed more civilians than the Germans by firing a lot of useless guns into the air, to put on a show.
    https://youtu.be/dW6C0WDYlhg?si=QQkh4G9qVMNvv97X

    Replies: @German_reader

    Sounds pretty questionable to me, one can take myth deconstruction too far. Where does the guy in the video get the number of “30 000 killed by artillery shells” figure from? That would have been half of all British civilians killed in the air war (for the entire war, including the sporadic German air raids and V-weapons attacks later in the war). Seems highly implausible to me, probably one more case of revisionism gone wild.

    • Replies: @songbird
    @German_reader


    Where does the guy in the video get the number of “30 000 killed by artillery shells” figure from?
     
    Assume he sources it in this book, which is on libgen
    https://www.amazon.co.uk/Secret-Casualties-World-War-Two/dp/1399021230/?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_w=AkT3U&content-id=amzn1.sym.3413293e-3815-4359-96ba-1ec5110e0b30&pf_rd_p=3413293e-3815-4359-96ba-1ec5110e0b30&pf_rd_r=257-7647916-8236209&pd_rd_wg=A7s9Q&pd_rd_r=12a21129-61ca-48e7-92a2-dfe26744b72c&ref_=aufs_ap_sc_dsk

    Of course, I have a soft spot for many forms of revisionism. BTW, you need to get behind this anti-gay revisionism:
    https://youtu.be/7QVh3kj7CjA?si=XHJvlsCLP_9RwQIE

    And help revive this law that existed under Julius Caesar, where one was not required to sit next to a gay, at a public event.

    But I think Keith Woods went a little too far in his recent video claiming that Romans had an ethno-nationalist feeling extending to the toe of Italy:
    https://youtu.be/tcu0qMULtcc?si=j3G018lChyQT0JUh

    Anyway, the civilian deaths during the Blitz do seem semi-plausible to me based on my lazy anti-government biases and a few other very circumstantial things.

    The torpedos that the US employed during WW2 were incredibly horrible (would guess much more important than Pearl Harbor or Clark Field, as it was submarines that brought the Japanese to their knees), so it is believable to me that the timing mechanism for British AA shells might have been quite faulty.

    Britain was a naval nation, so seeing a few pics of naval guns installed as AA, I can believe they went overboard.

    Replies: @German_reader

  644. Scapegoats are being found for the more frequent than usual utility problems. After all, it can’t be Putin or the war.

    https://www.vzsar.ru/news/2024/01/17/arestovan-eksministr-stroitelstva-i-jkh-saratovskoy-oblasti-dmitriy-tepin.html

  645. @Mr. Hack
    @LT1488

    The Rusyn ethnonym and name is an old one that at one time was shared by all Ukrainians. Linguists (even Paul Magocsi) have no trouble in clearly identifying the Rusyn dialect(s) being clearly old Ukrainian ones. Why you bring this up here and now when discussing the Hungarian question is strange and proves exactly what? There are over one million people living within Zakarpttya today that are perfectly comfortable living with their Ukrainian identiry. The other 10,000 sheep hearders, KGB implants and grant eaters will just have to learn to get along with their Ukrainian neighbors.

    https://euromaidanpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/comic2.jpg

    Replies: @LT1488, @Beckow, @Derer

    I guess countries like Croatia and Poland that recognize them as an independent ethnic group from Ukrainians, must be Kremlin implants too!

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @LT1488

    Would you say that before the break-up of the Soviet Union and the fall of the iron curtain there were no "Soviet implants" in these east European countries? When were these laws passed that recognized an independent rusyn ethnos? What countries had the most to gain from such an interpretation? Why is Rusyn independence least popular in the Rusyn homeland of Zakarpattya? Why do the Rusyns in Zakarpattya honor their most prolific and popular writer of the 20th century, an undeniable Ukrainophile from these regions, Vasyl Grendzha-Donsky?

    Replies: @LT1488

  646. @QCIC
    @A123

    A good hybrid car would solve the charging and range problem for situations beyond commuting and city car applications. The range extender engine needs to have enough power to charge the battery and move the car at near-highway speeds if the battery is croaked. I think this is around 30 horsepower.

    This has been understood for a long time, but I have not heard of a hybrid that gets it right. The Honda Insight should have been OK but the engine was too large and the battery too small. I think the climate crowd is against any car that burns dead dinosaurs which may have hampered growth of hybrids. Never mind that most EV juice comes from fossil fuel generation.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @AnonfromTN, @Emil Nikola Richard

    • Replies: @songbird
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Saw a clip of man-on-the-street interviews about this.

    Not sure, if it was just the neighborhood or not, but I was shocked by how many of the Tesla owners seemed to be black. Over half, I'd say.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    , @QCIC
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    A hybrid vehicle addresses this cold charging problem, though the driver may have to wait a long time for the munchkin engine to warm up the passenger compartment.

  647. @German_reader
    @songbird

    Sounds pretty questionable to me, one can take myth deconstruction too far. Where does the guy in the video get the number of "30 000 killed by artillery shells" figure from? That would have been half of all British civilians killed in the air war (for the entire war, including the sporadic German air raids and V-weapons attacks later in the war). Seems highly implausible to me, probably one more case of revisionism gone wild.

    Replies: @songbird

    Where does the guy in the video get the number of “30 000 killed by artillery shells” figure from?

    Assume he sources it in this book, which is on libgen

    [MORE]

    Of course, I have a soft spot for many forms of revisionism. BTW, you need to get behind this anti-gay revisionism:

    And help revive this law that existed under Julius Caesar, where one was not required to sit next to a gay, at a public event.

    But I think Keith Woods went a little too far in his recent video claiming that Romans had an ethno-nationalist feeling extending to the toe of Italy:

    Anyway, the civilian deaths during the Blitz do seem semi-plausible to me based on my lazy anti-government biases and a few other very circumstantial things.

    The torpedos that the US employed during WW2 were incredibly horrible (would guess much more important than Pearl Harbor or Clark Field, as it was submarines that brought the Japanese to their knees), so it is believable to me that the timing mechanism for British AA shells might have been quite faulty.

    Britain was a naval nation, so seeing a few pics of naval guns installed as AA, I can believe they went overboard.

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @songbird


    But I think Keith Woods went a little too far in his recent video claiming that Romans had an ethno-nationalist feeling extending to the toe of Italy:
     
    Watched the video, and while I think Keith is somewhat over-stating his case, he's not wrong (though one could argue his focus on the mid-republic to early empire is a bit manipulative, since Romanness did evolve into a sort of universal identity). More generally, I agree ethnicity and ethnic conflict have been significant throughout history, even if they're not everything.

    Replies: @songbird

  648. @A123
    @AnonfromTN


    It’s a standard American procedure: when you are losing, declare victory and leave.
     
    Well.... It is standard establishment Uniparty procedure. We saw it with GW Bush, Stacey Abrams, etc.

    Of course for MAGA, behaviour is the exact opposite. It would only be brought out when the other side comprehensively collapses.

    For example, Iranian Houthi proxies are widening their misconduct: (1)

    There have been several fresh incidents in the Red Sea, including a Greek-owned tanker coming attack off the coast of Yemen on Tuesday. It comes amid a string of similar attacks, causing Shell to be the latest to suspend all Red Sea shipments
    ...
    On Tuesday, British maritime security firm Ambrey has identified that the Zografia, a Malta-flagged Greek-owned bulk carrier, has suffered direct hit by a missile while going northbound in the Red Sea, near the Yemeni port city of Saleef.
    ...
    In a fresh statement, CENTCOM has announced, "On 11 January 2024, while conducting a flag verification, U.S. CENTCOM Navy forces conducted a night-time seizure of a dhow conducting illegal transport of advanced lethal aid from Iran to resupply Houthi forces in Yemen as part of the Houthis’ ongoing campaign of attacks against international merchant shipping." So Iranian weapons are continuing to be shipped to the Houthis of Yemen, and thus it looks like Operation Prosperity Guardian is having no significant deterrent impact.
     
    We have further attacks on Greek and Maltese shipping, having nothing to do with indigenous Palestinian Jews. We have conclusive evidence of Iran's direct involvement. And, a sensible conclusion that Xi's first attempt, via his puppet Not-The-President Biden, failed to resolve the issue.

    Xi's has one best (possibly only) option to get CCP, and everyone else's, cargo flowing normally again. He has to go to the source of the problem, Ayatollah Khamenei, and stop it there. As long as Khamenei's proxies are a threat to everyone, Asian cargo to Europe will be slower and more costly to deliver.

    It is really not that hard to figure out what is going on. Alas, common sense is not always common.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/two-fresh-houthi-attacks-tankers-red-sea-one-suffers-direct-missile-strike

    Replies: @Philip Owen

    Meanwhile, Saudi Arabia is backing away from the BRICS+ saying it hasn’t really joined yet. Realized who protects it when things get violent? Doesn’t want to make up to Iran any more?

  649. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @QCIC

    Chicago-area Tesla charging stations lined with dead cars in freezing cold: 'A bunch of dead robots out here'

    https://www.foxbusiness.com/technology/chicago-area-tesla-charging-stations-lined-with-dead-cars-in-freezing-cold-a-bunch-of-dead-robots-out-here

    no paywall: https://archive.is/OonFh#selection-965.0-965.109

    Replies: @songbird, @QCIC

    Saw a clip of man-on-the-street interviews about this.

    Not sure, if it was just the neighborhood or not, but I was shocked by how many of the Tesla owners seemed to be black. Over half, I’d say.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    Negroes love to borrow money. My dad sold stuff to negroes. The price doesn't enter their calculation; just the size of the payments. Dad was as much money lender as salesman. There is a lot of this in our economy.

    "How much are the notes?"

    Replies: @QCIC

  650. @songbird
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Saw a clip of man-on-the-street interviews about this.

    Not sure, if it was just the neighborhood or not, but I was shocked by how many of the Tesla owners seemed to be black. Over half, I'd say.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    Negroes love to borrow money. My dad sold stuff to negroes. The price doesn’t enter their calculation; just the size of the payments. Dad was as much money lender as salesman. There is a lot of this in our economy.

    “How much are the notes?”

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Subsidies?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  651. A kid from Mariupol explain how he started to support Russia as a consequence of the Russophobe Ukrainian propaganda before the liberation of the city. It seems that the Russophobe Maidan project was rotten from the start.

  652. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    Negroes love to borrow money. My dad sold stuff to negroes. The price doesn't enter their calculation; just the size of the payments. Dad was as much money lender as salesman. There is a lot of this in our economy.

    "How much are the notes?"

    Replies: @QCIC

    Subsidies?

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @QCIC

    The Tesla machines are subsidized big time. A more clever fellow than myself should be able to front run the coming day when the stupid fat cats finally figure out that subsidized charging stations is where the real money is to be made.

  653. German_reader says:
    @songbird
    @German_reader


    Where does the guy in the video get the number of “30 000 killed by artillery shells” figure from?
     
    Assume he sources it in this book, which is on libgen
    https://www.amazon.co.uk/Secret-Casualties-World-War-Two/dp/1399021230/?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_w=AkT3U&content-id=amzn1.sym.3413293e-3815-4359-96ba-1ec5110e0b30&pf_rd_p=3413293e-3815-4359-96ba-1ec5110e0b30&pf_rd_r=257-7647916-8236209&pd_rd_wg=A7s9Q&pd_rd_r=12a21129-61ca-48e7-92a2-dfe26744b72c&ref_=aufs_ap_sc_dsk

    Of course, I have a soft spot for many forms of revisionism. BTW, you need to get behind this anti-gay revisionism:
    https://youtu.be/7QVh3kj7CjA?si=XHJvlsCLP_9RwQIE

    And help revive this law that existed under Julius Caesar, where one was not required to sit next to a gay, at a public event.

    But I think Keith Woods went a little too far in his recent video claiming that Romans had an ethno-nationalist feeling extending to the toe of Italy:
    https://youtu.be/tcu0qMULtcc?si=j3G018lChyQT0JUh

    Anyway, the civilian deaths during the Blitz do seem semi-plausible to me based on my lazy anti-government biases and a few other very circumstantial things.

    The torpedos that the US employed during WW2 were incredibly horrible (would guess much more important than Pearl Harbor or Clark Field, as it was submarines that brought the Japanese to their knees), so it is believable to me that the timing mechanism for British AA shells might have been quite faulty.

    Britain was a naval nation, so seeing a few pics of naval guns installed as AA, I can believe they went overboard.

    Replies: @German_reader

    But I think Keith Woods went a little too far in his recent video claiming that Romans had an ethno-nationalist feeling extending to the toe of Italy:

    Watched the video, and while I think Keith is somewhat over-stating his case, he’s not wrong (though one could argue his focus on the mid-republic to early empire is a bit manipulative, since Romanness did evolve into a sort of universal identity). More generally, I agree ethnicity and ethnic conflict have been significant throughout history, even if they’re not everything.

    • Replies: @songbird
    @German_reader

    Am not sure that feeling exists in modern Italy. I once spoke of my shock seeing Northern Italians for the first time.

    I do like recounting that time in WWI, when elderly Italian farmers in some zone that had been reoccupied tried to attack the Italian army with pitchforks - apparently out of fear.


    More generally, I agree ethnicity and ethnic conflict have been significant throughout history, even if they’re not everything.
     
    I seem to vaguely recall that the Romans tried to exploit differences between the Punics and the Berbers, just as Hannibal tried to exploit the Celts in the Po Valley.

    Of course, the modern historical narrative seems to promote the idea that everyone was miscegenating and fusing together in a vibrant culture, only the Romans were racist against the Punics or something.
  654. @Mr. Hack
    @LT1488

    The Rusyn ethnonym and name is an old one that at one time was shared by all Ukrainians. Linguists (even Paul Magocsi) have no trouble in clearly identifying the Rusyn dialect(s) being clearly old Ukrainian ones. Why you bring this up here and now when discussing the Hungarian question is strange and proves exactly what? There are over one million people living within Zakarpttya today that are perfectly comfortable living with their Ukrainian identiry. The other 10,000 sheep hearders, KGB implants and grant eaters will just have to learn to get along with their Ukrainian neighbors.

    https://euromaidanpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/comic2.jpg

    Replies: @LT1488, @Beckow, @Derer

    As so often you know nothing about the actual situation on the ground. In Slovakia and Czechia a large proportion of the recent migrants from Ukraine are Rusyns from Zakarpatia, they consciously identify differently. There is a Rusyn church, university, in Prague they have churches, clubs, restaurants…in my experience most are neutral in the war – you read into it whatever you want.

    Rusyns are distinct people with their own language or dialect, music, history. There is some loose talk to rejoin Czechia, Slovakia or Hungary – to be in EU immediately. But it is very messy and the geography is too remote. They don’t like Galicians from over the Carpathian mountains and don’t want to be like them, they have no Bandera worship or hatred of Russia. Their preference was to be in a multi-ethnic Ukraine with cultural autonomy – then the dumb Ukie nationalists blew it apart. My sense is that hundreds of thousands of them will stay and assimilate – they are very similar to our Rusyns.

    By the way the previous Czech PM Andrej Babis was from Zakarpathia on his mother’s side. We were one country not that long ago.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Beckow

    Like I stated earlier, there are some 10,000 "rusyns" that identify as such within Ukraine comprised of sheep herders, KGB agents, grant eaters and even a couple of priests. They propagate all sorts of nonsense - "you read into it whatever you want". :-)


    They don’t like Galicians from over the Carpathian mountains and don’t want to be like them, they have no Bandera worship or hatred of Russia.
     
    Strange if this is true, that the most popular electronic website in Zakarpattya is Zakarpattya Online: https://zakarpattya.net.ua/. It always espouses a pro-Ukrainian and anti rusyn approach. If not Bandera worship then certainly Grendzha-Donsky worship who was a straight arrow Ukrainaphile, who to this day has books. blogsites etc dedicated to his honor.
    , @AP
    @Beckow


    As so often you know nothing about the actual situation on the ground
     
    Says the guy whose “knowledge” led him to assume that Ukrainians would surrender or flee right away in early 2022.

    Rusyns are distinct people with their own language or dialect, music, history
     
    Their name is the same and their dialect similar to Galician 150 years ago.

    They don’t like Galicians from over the Carpathian mountains and don’t want to be like them, they have no Bandera worship or hatred of Russia
     
    This is the closest you come to being truthful.

    A consequence of the Magyars keeping the Rusyns under their control illiterate was that they avoided the nationalization that occurred across the mountains in Galicia and retained their original pre-literate identity. They achieved mass literacy (which brought with it a national identity) in the 1920-1940s, under a patchwork of Ukrainian nationalist, exiled Russian White, and later Soviet Ukrainian teachers (the Soviets ironically Russified central and eastern Ukraine but promoted a pro-Soviet sort of Ukrainianism in Zakarpatya as a strategy against potential Magyar and Czechoslovak claims).

    The result is that these people are not nationalistic like Galicians, not even close, but more like central Ukrainians. Desperate Russian nationalists hope that Zakarpatya is some sort of Donbas or at least Kharkiv, but it is rather another Poltava or Kirovohrad. So not a Bandera-land, but still solidly pro-Ukrainian.

    For example in the 2012 parliamentary election under Yanukovich, 57% of people in Zakarpatya voted for the 3 pro-Western nationalist parties. Factoring in the 10% Hungarian population in the region, over 60% of East Slavs in Zakarpatya voted for pro-Western nationalists.

    8.35% of Zakarpatya voted for the Banderist Svoboda party. That is a lot lower than the 38% in Lviv oblast and 34% in Ivano-Frankivsk oblast right on the other side of the Carpathians. But is is similar to results in Vynnytsia and Poltava. It is higher than the Banderist vote in central regions such as Zhytomir (7.5%).

    BTW the result for Svoboda in 2012 in Zakarpatya (8.35%) was higher than the result for the Slovak National Party in 2023 (5.6%).

    So Zakarpatyans are more “Banderists” than Slovaks are “nationalists.”
  655. Iran has recently struck targets in Syria, Iraq and Pakistan by firing missiles from Iran.

    The strike in Syria was against the Turkestan Islamic Party, the Iraq one in Erbil against “Mossad spies” (a Kurdish businessman and the Pakistan one against Jaish al-Adl (a Sunni Baloch terrorist group).

    The attack against the TIP makes sense, if the intent was to demonstrate the range of Iranian missiles.

    However, the strikes in Iraq and Pakistan don’t seem to have actually been cleared with these governments (yesterday pro-IRGC accounts made clowns of themselves by claiming this attack was a joint operation with Pakistan). In Pakistan they misfired and killed two civilian girls with several other girls wounded.

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/jan/17/iran-hails-strikes-in-pakistan-as-it-is-warned-of-serious-consequences

    https://www.france24.com/en/middle-east/20240116-iran-launch-ballistic-missile-attacks-a-terrorist-targets-in-iraq-syria

    Clashes have apparently broken out on the Iran-Pakistan border with Jaish al-Adl attacking a convoy, a checkpoint and a car carrying an IRGC colonel. Three deaths so far, including the IRGC.

    Granted this last part is from Telegram, so I’ll wait for more official news. I understand there is a need to respond to the Kerman bombing, but with the geopolitical situation as it is and the randomness of it, I don’t see how picking a fight in Pakistan makes sense for Iran.

    • Thanks: Sher Singh
    • Replies: @German_reader
    @Hyperborean


    the Iraq one in Erbil
     
    I read that it hit close to the US consulate. Seems like a message that Iran is willing to escalate. Pretty worrying sign, since so far it seemed Iran wanted to keep tensions below the line where it could to a regional conflagration.
    , @Hyperborean
    @Hyperborean


    Clashes have apparently broken out on the Iran-Pakistan border with Jaish al-Adl attacking a convoy, a checkpoint and a car carrying an IRGC colonel. Three deaths so far, including the IRGC.
     
    So Pakistan carried out retaliatory strikes in Iran and arrested two Iranian agents in Karachi. Chinese mediation not working so far.

    Pakistan Military statement on strikes inside Iran:

    Pakistan's strikes into Iran used "killer drones, rockets, loitering munitions and stand-off weapons" says a Pakistani military statement on its strikes today.

    The official media wing of military statement added that "Pakistan Armed Forces remain in a perpetual state of readiness to ensure safety of Pakistan citizens against acts of terrorism."

    [...]

    Pakistan military spokesman reveals names of the terrorists targeted in attacks inside Iran:

    The statement maintained that targeted hideouts were being used by notorious terrorists including Dosta alias Chairman, Bajjar alias Soghat, Sahil, alias Shafaq, Asghar alias Basham and Wazir alias Wazi, amongst others.
     
    I'll admit I have no idea who these people are supposed to be. But it is a bizarre situation, Iran and Pakistan are both attacking terrorist groups within each other's borders, while claiming to avoid harm to government forces.

    I get why they're doing it, the Pakistanis don't want to establish a precedent that India can take advantage of in the future. But it is still bizarre.

    I don't think they are intentionally angling for war with each other, but this is the sort of situation that could easily go wrong.

    The Taliban of all people are joining the call for de-escalation.

    Replies: @sudden death

  656. @songbird
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Mostly, just what the machine-learning people are saying, like:
    https://deepmind.google/discover/blog/graphcast-ai-model-for-faster-and-more-accurate-global-weather-forecasting/

    What's the latest critical look at it? I don't know. But it seems like there might be ways to improve it, including more data collection. They can re-evaluate their predictions fairly quickly, in theory. Main limitation is that it takes so long for the standard processes that they have to wait to make the comparison.

    Replies: @Mikel

    They can re-evaluate their predictions fairly quickly, in theory. Main limitation is that it takes so long for the standard processes that they have to wait to make the comparison.

    Thanks for that article but, as a lifelong weather nut, I don’t see too much of a groundbreaking advance here.

    If I understand things correctly, their system makes much faster calculations than the standard numerical models used currently at the cost of using a crude data-intensive model trained on 45 years of data and corresponding outcomes instead of the computationally intensive physical equations that drive the standard models.

    I’m not sure how this higher computing speed on a cruder model improves things much. Historical outcomes may not repeat themselves, as per the well-known butterfly effect, and numerical models are already quite good at short lead times. As they say themselves in the article, all they were able to do for a hurricane landfall prediction is lengthen it to 9 days as opposed to 6 days of the numerical models. A bit of an advantage for disaster preparedness, if you trust the 9-day out prediction, but I doubt anybody is doing much nowadays even 6 days in advance.

    I even fail to see where the ML and AI component of this model is but admittedly, I don’t know much about those subjects. As I understand it, perhaps incorrectly, ML would only kick in once they have a good set of predictions that they can compare to real-life outcomes. In any case, no AI is going to overcome the aforementioned butterfly effect, formulated by the great Lorentz, that makes prediction of a chaotic system impossible past a number of days. In the future AI may be able to do stuff like generate new mathematical theorems but I’m totally sure that weather forecasting is going to be limited by Lorentz’s theories for a very long time to come (perhaps forever, if our current understanding of chaotic systems is correct).

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mikel

    Google's AI geniuses are busily destroying their search capabilities, their reason for Being in the first place. How intelligent is that?

    Replies: @Mikel

    , @songbird
    @Mikel


    I even fail to see where the ML and AI component of this model
     
    can't explain it because I don't really understand it myself. But here is the IBM page attempting to explain the basic idea:
    https://www.ibm.com/topics/neural-networks

    Seems like the real bottleneck right now is the slow creep of time and future weather data. And the longer cycles and supercycles that we don't really have good data on.

    If I understand correctly, a lot of the current neural networks are trained on geographically and perhaps even temporally interpolated data.

    Obviously, there is an enormous potential to get more reads. And there are things like the Parker Solar Probe. I wouldn't necessarily discount the possibility of much longer predictions, provided enough time elapses, without substantial technological or economic regression.

    I wonder whether better and faster predictions may eventually feed into the re-establishment of attempts to change the weather.

    Like, in the '50s or '60s, they used to light oil slicks on fire, in an attempt to change the path of hurricanes. I don't expect the Greens would allow that, but if there were ever massive solar arrays in space beaming energy down, then it would probably become practicable. (Really big if - I don't see how it would work - and I am not the techno optimist AK is - but people have been talking about it since at least the '70s.)

    Replies: @Mikel

  657. @QCIC
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Subsidies?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    The Tesla machines are subsidized big time. A more clever fellow than myself should be able to front run the coming day when the stupid fat cats finally figure out that subsidized charging stations is where the real money is to be made.

  658. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @QCIC

    Chicago-area Tesla charging stations lined with dead cars in freezing cold: 'A bunch of dead robots out here'

    https://www.foxbusiness.com/technology/chicago-area-tesla-charging-stations-lined-with-dead-cars-in-freezing-cold-a-bunch-of-dead-robots-out-here

    no paywall: https://archive.is/OonFh#selection-965.0-965.109

    Replies: @songbird, @QCIC

    A hybrid vehicle addresses this cold charging problem, though the driver may have to wait a long time for the munchkin engine to warm up the passenger compartment.

  659. @Mikel
    @songbird


    They can re-evaluate their predictions fairly quickly, in theory. Main limitation is that it takes so long for the standard processes that they have to wait to make the comparison.
     
    Thanks for that article but, as a lifelong weather nut, I don't see too much of a groundbreaking advance here.

    If I understand things correctly, their system makes much faster calculations than the standard numerical models used currently at the cost of using a crude data-intensive model trained on 45 years of data and corresponding outcomes instead of the computationally intensive physical equations that drive the standard models.

    I'm not sure how this higher computing speed on a cruder model improves things much. Historical outcomes may not repeat themselves, as per the well-known butterfly effect, and numerical models are already quite good at short lead times. As they say themselves in the article, all they were able to do for a hurricane landfall prediction is lengthen it to 9 days as opposed to 6 days of the numerical models. A bit of an advantage for disaster preparedness, if you trust the 9-day out prediction, but I doubt anybody is doing much nowadays even 6 days in advance.

    I even fail to see where the ML and AI component of this model is but admittedly, I don't know much about those subjects. As I understand it, perhaps incorrectly, ML would only kick in once they have a good set of predictions that they can compare to real-life outcomes. In any case, no AI is going to overcome the aforementioned butterfly effect, formulated by the great Lorentz, that makes prediction of a chaotic system impossible past a number of days. In the future AI may be able to do stuff like generate new mathematical theorems but I'm totally sure that weather forecasting is going to be limited by Lorentz's theories for a very long time to come (perhaps forever, if our current understanding of chaotic systems is correct).

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird

    Google’s AI geniuses are busily destroying their search capabilities, their reason for Being in the first place. How intelligent is that?

    • Replies: @Mikel
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    I couldn't agree more.

    The other day Google decided that what I really need in every search I do is Spanish language results. I must have visited some Spanish-language website or something, and their "intelligent" algorithms, perhaps trained to apply cultural-sensitive filters, only gave me Spanish trash for every search I tried. I set my language and region, which were undefined, to the US but it didn't make any difference. Google knew better than me what I needed. For several days the only way to get English results in my searches was to modify the URL and append ?lang=en. Finally, they must have realized that I really meant "give me English results please" and the problem is gone for now.

    The existing AI systems have such a steep learning curve ahead that AK's talk of an impending singularity making his previous ideology obsolete sounds like a laughable cope. I used to have intellectual respect for him. His Covid-19 prediction was impressive. But I can't take him seriously anymore.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Negronicus

  660. German_reader says:
    @Hyperborean
    Iran has recently struck targets in Syria, Iraq and Pakistan by firing missiles from Iran.

    The strike in Syria was against the Turkestan Islamic Party, the Iraq one in Erbil against "Mossad spies" (a Kurdish businessman and the Pakistan one against Jaish al-Adl (a Sunni Baloch terrorist group).

    The attack against the TIP makes sense, if the intent was to demonstrate the range of Iranian missiles.

    However, the strikes in Iraq and Pakistan don't seem to have actually been cleared with these governments (yesterday pro-IRGC accounts made clowns of themselves by claiming this attack was a joint operation with Pakistan). In Pakistan they misfired and killed two civilian girls with several other girls wounded.

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/jan/17/iran-hails-strikes-in-pakistan-as-it-is-warned-of-serious-consequences

    https://www.france24.com/en/middle-east/20240116-iran-launch-ballistic-missile-attacks-a-terrorist-targets-in-iraq-syria

    Clashes have apparently broken out on the Iran-Pakistan border with Jaish al-Adl attacking a convoy, a checkpoint and a car carrying an IRGC colonel. Three deaths so far, including the IRGC.

    Granted this last part is from Telegram, so I'll wait for more official news. I understand there is a need to respond to the Kerman bombing, but with the geopolitical situation as it is and the randomness of it, I don't see how picking a fight in Pakistan makes sense for Iran.

    Replies: @German_reader, @Hyperborean

    the Iraq one in Erbil

    I read that it hit close to the US consulate. Seems like a message that Iran is willing to escalate. Pretty worrying sign, since so far it seemed Iran wanted to keep tensions below the line where it could to a regional conflagration.

  661. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    It's quite interesting that throughout history Slovaks have served as the younger brothers to both the Hungarians and the Czechs. They served as the younger brothers to the Hungarians for much, much longer, but Czech rule was probably better for them than Hungarian rule, at least so long as the Czechs actually had a foreign protector behind themselves and the Slovaks (they didn't in 1938-1939). I don't seem to recall Czechia trying to forcibly Czechify the Slovaks like Hungary did with the Slovaks with its decades-long pre-WWI Magyarization campaign:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magyarization

    I do suspect that, out of Greater Hungary's large subject peoples, the Slovaks were probably the easiest ones to successfully Magyarize had Hungary had even more time to do so:

    https://preview.redd.it/9z2zzo6am2r71.png?width=640&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=097af65f11c92335d05889c085d6e243b595125b

    Slovaks, after all, are mostly Catholic just like Hungarians (Magyars) themselves are. Ruthenians (Ukrainians), Romanians, Serbs, and Croats are not Catholic.

    (Hungarian Jews were, of course, largely successfully Magyarized, but they are a much smaller group and their high average IQ and large amounts of success made them stand out from the Magyars and thus often made Magyars unwilling to accept them as their own even when these Jews themselves were indeed willing to be Magyarized. In contrast, AFAIK, Slovaks and Hungarians (Magyars) have a roughly equal average IQ, so there's no superiority/inferiority complex going on between them in regards to each other, at least in regards to their mental abilities.)

    BTW, it would be cool if Hungary, Slovakia, and Croatia formed a Greater Hungary within the EU (a confederation within a confederation) while Czechia, Austria, and Slovenia formed a Greater Austria within the EU (another confederation within a confederation).

    Replies: @Derer, @WS, @AP, @Beckow

    I am not sure what “younger brothers” means, but ok. In Czecho-slovakia in 1918 there was the ideology of a single nation, that we were the “same”. The western Slovak dialect spoken by most educated Slovaks was very similar to the Moravian dialect – around the border it was identical, and the sense of unity was very strong. That region is very Protestant and most leaders of the Slovak national movement were Protestants from the central-western region who studied in Prague.

    Masaryk’s father was Slovak, so were Stefanik, Bata (biggest businessman), Dubcek, Husak – in the 70-80’s the complaint in Prague was that that they were ruled by Slovaks, but they were actually consciously Czechoslovak. It is different now, but we are very inter-mixed.

    With Magyars it was hard in 1900-1914, and the languages are too far apart. But calling them “Asiats” is idiotic, AP is living in some half-baked ‘merican’ world were he misunderstands things.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    With Magyars it was hard in 1900-1914, and the languages are too far apart. But calling them “Asiats” is idiotic, AP is living in some half-baked ‘merican’ world were he misunderstands things.
     
    Of course, calling Hungarians “Asiats” is a sign of purely American ignorance, a good illustration of the joke “what is the correct spelling, Iran or Iraq”.

    As to language, having been in Hungary and Wales I learned that if you see something written with Latin letters where you cannot understand anything at all, it must be either in Hungarian or in Welsh.

    Replies: @Beckow

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @Beckow

    Interesting; thank you.

    BTW, speaking of Stefanik, the US could have a Vice President Stefanik next year if Trump will win again this year:

    https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2024-election/trump-elise-stefanik-vp-pick-prospect-rcna133599

    She's of mixed Italian and Slovak descent. She's also got dangerous curves:

    https://encrypted-tbn2.gstatic.com/licensed-image?q=tbn:ANd9GcTXcQ-ojfRsvqIdCHGr44jFSoHXW9GY9D55e5cE0XfwiJCdpcWlF0E3vfAwa3gV1O80CnjFEEIn_NVK96E

    https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2021/11/stefanikelise_110321gn_lead.jpg?w=1280

    For a curvy woman, she is relatively attractive.

    Replies: @Beckow

  662. Proper treatment delivered to a pro terror loony: (1)

    More and more, social justice types are finding out that the general public simply isn’t willing to put up with their obnoxious “protest” actions anymore.

    Especially in Texas.

    One of the usual Lilly-livered pro-Palestinian sorts crashed a Greg Abbott event to protest Israel pounding the snot out of Hamas. He quickly found out why you don’t mess with Texas.

    A pro-Palestine heckler attempted to disrupt Texas Governor Greg Abbott’s address in Collin County, Texas but was swiftly drowned out by the crowd’s boos.

    The heckler was grabbed and forced out of the event by the audience, with several people wearing cowboy hats seen escorting him out.

    The incident occurred during a campaign gathering for Abbott’s re-election.

    Note: The next Texas gubernatorial election isn’t until 2026. Abbott is getting quite the jump here.

    “Grabbed and forced out” is a nice way to put it. He got manhandled.

    Let us face facts. IslamoGloboHomo is so evil that cannot exist in civil society. This type of ejection is required.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.battleswarmblog.com/?p=56971

  663. @QCIC
    @Beckow

    An important concept related to immigration is reversion to different means for disparate populations. From my simplified perspective, this gives some insight into the overall picture of what is occurring with mass immigration to the West, though less information in any particular personal example. In large, relatively low-IQ populations such as India and Africa there will always be a significant number of high IQ people. I am referring to the genetic lottery winners who are much smarter than their families. If possible they often like to migrate to the West. They usually bring their cultural baggage and perhaps an extended family with them. Then they have children who often revert to the mean genetic IQ of a third-world country. So the result is a family cluster of immigrants and only one is above average for India and perhaps for the US as well. So the net result is a clear case of "not sending their best", even when the initial immigrant was above average.

    Replies: @Beckow

    …the net result is a clear case of “not sending their best”, even when the initial immigrant was above average.

    True. But it is obviously the way open-borders were going to play out – so the people who kept the borders open had to know it and wanted this outcome.

    What now? The logic of massive chain-migration, family reunification, in-place ethnic migrant lobbies, business desire for cheaper labor, liberal gment-charity fanatics who live of the migrants –
    this will continue. It can go fast or slow, but at the end there will new population in Western Europe, US, Canada. The previous people will be pushed out – completely or marginalized.

    The result will be overpopulated societies with lower overall IQ, internal hostilities and no long-term cultural continuity – both natives and migrants are losing their cultures in the process. The consequences will be from bad to possibly catastrophic: some regions will be natives, others will be completely migrant dominated.

    Western societies will be divided and poorer with scores to settle. Thank you, liberals. They have missed the point of having countries and nations:there is no existence in freedom…but they like it that way, their vacuous minds crave vacuum and chaos.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Beckow

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/f/f2/OrdoAbChaoCover.jpg

    Ordo Ad Chao is the fourth full-length album by the Norwegian black metal band Mayhem.

    You might need to be a little drunk to like this.

    , @QCIC
    @Beckow

    I'm not sure liberals are smart enough to cause this much trouble on their own.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

  664. @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    I am not sure what "younger brothers" means, but ok. In Czecho-slovakia in 1918 there was the ideology of a single nation, that we were the "same". The western Slovak dialect spoken by most educated Slovaks was very similar to the Moravian dialect - around the border it was identical, and the sense of unity was very strong. That region is very Protestant and most leaders of the Slovak national movement were Protestants from the central-western region who studied in Prague.

    Masaryk's father was Slovak, so were Stefanik, Bata (biggest businessman), Dubcek, Husak - in the 70-80's the complaint in Prague was that that they were ruled by Slovaks, but they were actually consciously Czechoslovak. It is different now, but we are very inter-mixed.

    With Magyars it was hard in 1900-1914, and the languages are too far apart. But calling them "Asiats" is idiotic, AP is living in some half-baked 'merican' world were he misunderstands things.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Mr. XYZ

    With Magyars it was hard in 1900-1914, and the languages are too far apart. But calling them “Asiats” is idiotic, AP is living in some half-baked ‘merican’ world were he misunderstands things.

    Of course, calling Hungarians “Asiats” is a sign of purely American ignorance, a good illustration of the joke “what is the correct spelling, Iran or Iraq”.

    As to language, having been in Hungary and Wales I learned that if you see something written with Latin letters where you cannot understand anything at all, it must be either in Hungarian or in Welsh.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN


    ...the joke “what is the correct spelling, Iran or Iraq?”
     
    I like it....:)

    How do you run the world with human material like that? Instead they are getting played by ethnic hustlers from all over the world who spin one-sided stories and use them for their revenge fantasies.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @QCIC

  665. @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    With Magyars it was hard in 1900-1914, and the languages are too far apart. But calling them “Asiats” is idiotic, AP is living in some half-baked ‘merican’ world were he misunderstands things.
     
    Of course, calling Hungarians “Asiats” is a sign of purely American ignorance, a good illustration of the joke “what is the correct spelling, Iran or Iraq”.

    As to language, having been in Hungary and Wales I learned that if you see something written with Latin letters where you cannot understand anything at all, it must be either in Hungarian or in Welsh.

    Replies: @Beckow

    …the joke “what is the correct spelling, Iran or Iraq?”

    I like it….:)

    How do you run the world with human material like that? Instead they are getting played by ethnic hustlers from all over the world who spin one-sided stories and use them for their revenge fantasies.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    How do you run the world with human material like that?
     
    The quality of American “running the world” fully reflects the quality of the “runners”. But the reality reasserts itself: “American century” did not happen, “frustrated American century” is in full swing. However, we are not out of the woods yet. There is Russian joke:
    - What is more dangerous than nuclear war?
    - A pro-active moron.
    , @QCIC
    @Beckow

    Yes, this joke is a winner!

  666. @Beckow
    @QCIC


    ...the net result is a clear case of “not sending their best”, even when the initial immigrant was above average.
     
    True. But it is obviously the way open-borders were going to play out - so the people who kept the borders open had to know it and wanted this outcome.

    What now? The logic of massive chain-migration, family reunification, in-place ethnic migrant lobbies, business desire for cheaper labor, liberal gment-charity fanatics who live of the migrants -
    this will continue. It can go fast or slow, but at the end there will new population in Western Europe, US, Canada. The previous people will be pushed out - completely or marginalized.

    The result will be overpopulated societies with lower overall IQ, internal hostilities and no long-term cultural continuity - both natives and migrants are losing their cultures in the process. The consequences will be from bad to possibly catastrophic: some regions will be natives, others will be completely migrant dominated.

    Western societies will be divided and poorer with scores to settle. Thank you, liberals. They have missed the point of having countries and nations:there is no existence in freedom...but they like it that way, their vacuous minds crave vacuum and chaos.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @QCIC

    Ordo Ad Chao is the fourth full-length album by the Norwegian black metal band Mayhem.

    You might need to be a little drunk to like this.

  667. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mikel

    Google's AI geniuses are busily destroying their search capabilities, their reason for Being in the first place. How intelligent is that?

    Replies: @Mikel

    I couldn’t agree more.

    The other day Google decided that what I really need in every search I do is Spanish language results. I must have visited some Spanish-language website or something, and their “intelligent” algorithms, perhaps trained to apply cultural-sensitive filters, only gave me Spanish trash for every search I tried. I set my language and region, which were undefined, to the US but it didn’t make any difference. Google knew better than me what I needed. For several days the only way to get English results in my searches was to modify the URL and append ?lang=en. Finally, they must have realized that I really meant “give me English results please” and the problem is gone for now.

    The existing AI systems have such a steep learning curve ahead that AK’s talk of an impending singularity making his previous ideology obsolete sounds like a laughable cope. I used to have intellectual respect for him. His Covid-19 prediction was impressive. But I can’t take him seriously anymore.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @Mikel


    ...AK’s talk of an impending singularity making his previous ideology obsolete sounds like a laughable cope.
     
    Quality cannot be sustained. Complex AI systems deteriorate over time - the learning is only a partial fix. What we get is the slow decoupling of systems from their primary function. Only 'marketing' will work - that's what they are for.

    The inability of most people to function without the apps ('apes') will get worse. Mankind should never obsolete the building blocks of the current technology - but we are doing it. AI's real danger is in the lack of system maintenance...the layers of dysfunction are accumulating.

    The solution offered is to have two 80-year old guys fight it out...yes, it is a clown world.

    , @Negronicus
    @Mikel

    Let him go. He belong to the streets now.

  668. @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN


    ...the joke “what is the correct spelling, Iran or Iraq?”
     
    I like it....:)

    How do you run the world with human material like that? Instead they are getting played by ethnic hustlers from all over the world who spin one-sided stories and use them for their revenge fantasies.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @QCIC

    How do you run the world with human material like that?

    The quality of American “running the world” fully reflects the quality of the “runners”. But the reality reasserts itself: “American century” did not happen, “frustrated American century” is in full swing. However, we are not out of the woods yet. There is Russian joke:
    – What is more dangerous than nuclear war?
    – A pro-active moron.

  669. @Mr. XYZ
    @Derer

    Yes, I know what Greater Hungary's ethnic demographics were:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/de/Hungarians_in_Hungary_%281890%29.png

    It's still interesting that it survived as a compact political unit for many centuries, however, albeit with a break during slightly over 1.5 centuries of Ottoman rule.

    Magyars generally lived on the Hungarian plains (Pannonian Basin) while minorities generally lived on or near the mountains:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/01/Carpathian_Basin-Pannonian_Basin.jpg

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/2/23/Pannonian_Basin.svg/1280px-Pannonian_Basin.svg.png

    This also helps explain why Hungarian-majority areas near the border with the new (1920) Trianon Hungary got handed over to neighboring countries:

    https://english.atlatszo.hu/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Trianonline.jpg

    Specifically, in some cases, such as for Czechoslovakia and Romania, the main lines of communication (roads and railroads) can through those areas in those regions because those were the low-elevation plains areas.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Derer

    The term “Hungarians” during the Austria-Hungary Empire applied to inhabitants of the area but it comprised of: Magyars, Germans, Romanians and Slavs such as Slovaks, Croats, Serbs, Slovene.

    Regardless, Magyars won in c.a. 999 and lost in 1918 and 1945. Twice lost, from appetite for greater Hungary. The borders are created by blood.

  670. @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN


    ...the joke “what is the correct spelling, Iran or Iraq?”
     
    I like it....:)

    How do you run the world with human material like that? Instead they are getting played by ethnic hustlers from all over the world who spin one-sided stories and use them for their revenge fantasies.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @QCIC

    Yes, this joke is a winner!

  671. @Beckow
    @QCIC


    ...the net result is a clear case of “not sending their best”, even when the initial immigrant was above average.
     
    True. But it is obviously the way open-borders were going to play out - so the people who kept the borders open had to know it and wanted this outcome.

    What now? The logic of massive chain-migration, family reunification, in-place ethnic migrant lobbies, business desire for cheaper labor, liberal gment-charity fanatics who live of the migrants -
    this will continue. It can go fast or slow, but at the end there will new population in Western Europe, US, Canada. The previous people will be pushed out - completely or marginalized.

    The result will be overpopulated societies with lower overall IQ, internal hostilities and no long-term cultural continuity - both natives and migrants are losing their cultures in the process. The consequences will be from bad to possibly catastrophic: some regions will be natives, others will be completely migrant dominated.

    Western societies will be divided and poorer with scores to settle. Thank you, liberals. They have missed the point of having countries and nations:there is no existence in freedom...but they like it that way, their vacuous minds crave vacuum and chaos.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @QCIC

    I’m not sure liberals are smart enough to cause this much trouble on their own.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @QCIC


    I’m not sure liberals are smart enough to cause this much trouble on their own.
     
    Never underestimate the power of stupidity. As Einstein supposedly said, "only two things are infinite, human stupidity and the Universe, and I am not sure about the Universe".
  672. @Mr. Hack
    @LT1488

    The Rusyn ethnonym and name is an old one that at one time was shared by all Ukrainians. Linguists (even Paul Magocsi) have no trouble in clearly identifying the Rusyn dialect(s) being clearly old Ukrainian ones. Why you bring this up here and now when discussing the Hungarian question is strange and proves exactly what? There are over one million people living within Zakarpttya today that are perfectly comfortable living with their Ukrainian identiry. The other 10,000 sheep hearders, KGB implants and grant eaters will just have to learn to get along with their Ukrainian neighbors.

    https://euromaidanpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/comic2.jpg

    Replies: @LT1488, @Beckow, @Derer

    There are over one million people living within Zakarpttya today that are perfectly comfortable living with their Ukrainian identiry.

    BS. You do not know their desire – need for referendum. Few years back they were caught making underground tunnels to Slovakia. They prefer earning Euro in Slovakia to Ukie worthless paper. They prefer Latin alphabet to Cyrillic.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Derer

    There was a referendum, in 1991, and 92.5% of respondents voted to stay within Ukraine. Going to a richer, western area to make some money, sending it back home and then to finally moving back to retire is not a good gauge of people's loyalties. Holding referendums during war time is not a good idea. I don't of any other country that has done this?

  673. @QCIC
    @Beckow

    I'm not sure liberals are smart enough to cause this much trouble on their own.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    I’m not sure liberals are smart enough to cause this much trouble on their own.

    Never underestimate the power of stupidity. As Einstein supposedly said, “only two things are infinite, human stupidity and the Universe, and I am not sure about the Universe”.

  674. There is some common sense in Germany. The resolution proposing to give Ukraine German Taurus rockets in 666-person German parliament got 178 votes for and 485 votes against (3 members abstained). I wonder whether common sense will ever affect German government. Judging by its current performance the chances are slim to none. Maybe GR knows more about it?

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @AnonfromTN

    I don't know why the vote went that way, both the parties of the government coalition and leading CDU/CSU politicians have all spoken in favour of delivering Taurus missiles to Ukraine. One of the most bellicose Greens, Anton Hofreiter, who has demanded sending Taurus missiles (and much else) for months said he would vote against the resolution, because CDU/CSU isn't serious enough about supporting Ukraine and the resolution is just for show. So maybe it's all merely party politics. Whatever. Germany's role in this mess won't go beyond scapegoat and paypig anyway, the decisions that matter will be taken elsewhere.

    Replies: @German_reader

  675. German_reader says:
    @AnonfromTN
    There is some common sense in Germany. The resolution proposing to give Ukraine German Taurus rockets in 666-person German parliament got 178 votes for and 485 votes against (3 members abstained). I wonder whether common sense will ever affect German government. Judging by its current performance the chances are slim to none. Maybe GR knows more about it?

    Replies: @German_reader

    I don’t know why the vote went that way, both the parties of the government coalition and leading CDU/CSU politicians have all spoken in favour of delivering Taurus missiles to Ukraine. One of the most bellicose Greens, Anton Hofreiter, who has demanded sending Taurus missiles (and much else) for months said he would vote against the resolution, because CDU/CSU isn’t serious enough about supporting Ukraine and the resolution is just for show. So maybe it’s all merely party politics. Whatever. Germany’s role in this mess won’t go beyond scapegoat and paypig anyway, the decisions that matter will be taken elsewhere.

    • Replies: @German_reader
    @German_reader

    https://nitter.net/cducsubt/status/1747577187002147281#m

    Bizarre choice of motive.

    Replies: @Beckow

  676. The Sarkozy clique now have a majority in Macron’s cabinet. I wonder what sort of promises were made behind closed doors to arrange this?

    Eight of the small team of 14 key ministers have a background in Sarkozy’s party, Les Républicains, including the surprise appointment as culture minister of Rachida Dati, who served as Sarkozy’s justice minister from 2007 to 2009. Catherine Vautrin, a Sarkozy loyalist, who served in government 20 years ago under the rightwing Jacques Chirac, was given a large ministry covering health, labour and solidarity. When first tipped for Macron’s government in 2022, she was criticised by the left of Macron’s centrist party because she opposed the legalisation of same-sex marriage in France in 2013.

    Two other long-serving politicians from the right, who were previously in government under Sarkozy, Gérald Darmanin at the interior ministry, and Bruno Le Maire at the finance ministry, kept their jobs.

    Emmanuel Moulin, a former adviser to Sarkozy and former Treasury director, took the pivotal role of chief of staff to the new prime minister.

    […]

    The government was deliberately streamlined to a small number of ministers.

    “It’s the smallest cabinet since world war two,” said a source in Macron’s entourage. The source defended the merging of key ministries, such as placing labour and solidarity in the same brief, because “it’s through work, that we get out of poverty”. Crucially, the sports minister will also take on the education brief, which the source said showed that this summer’s Olympic Games in Paris was “not just an event in itself but an education project for the nation”.

    […]

    Dati’s appointment continued to spark controversy. French media speculated that Dati, who has been mayor of Paris’s 7th arrondissement, may have done a deal with Macron to facilitate her running for mayor of the city in 2026. Emmanuel Grégoire, the Socialist deputy mayor of Paris, said it was “an indelible moral fault” that Dati had been appointed to government despite being under formal investigation for alleged corruption over consulting services to a subsidiary of Renault-Nissan. She has denied any wrongdoing.

    https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2024/jan/12/macron-looks-to-sarko-connection-to-head-off-far-right-in-france

    • Thanks: Emil Nikola Richard
    • Replies: @Hyperborean
    @Hyperborean


    The Sarkozy clique now have a majority in Macron’s cabinet. I wonder what sort of promises were made behind closed doors to arrange this?
     
    In case there is anyone other than I who is interested in this, here is the protocol rank order:

    1. Gabriel Attal
    Prime minister in charge of environment and energy planning – 34 years old
    Previously education minister

    (Jewish homosexual with origins in the Socialist Party, used to be together with Stéphane Séjourné; the two have been helping each another slide up the political ladder)

    2. Bruno Le Maire
    Economy, finance, industrial and digital sovereignty minister – 54 years old

    (Énarque, Sarkozyist)

    3. Gérald Darmanin
    Interior and french overseas territories minister – 41 years old

    (Sarkozyist)

    4. Catherine Vautrin
    Labor, health, and solidarity minister – 63 years old
    Previously president of the greater Reims urban community and the national agence for urban renovation

    (Sarkozyist, known for her old stance of anti-homosexual marriage, was expected to become PM in 2022)

    5. Amélie Oudéa-Castéra
    Education, Youth, sports, olympic and paralympic games minister – 45 years old
    Previously sports, olympic and paralympic games minister

    (Énarque, no former political affiliations before Macron's party Renaissance, has apparently three children at a conservative Catholic private school)

    6. Marc Fesneau
    Agriculture and food sovereignty minister – 53 years old

    (Liberal, Vice-president of the pro-Macronist party MoDem)

    7. Rachida Dati
    Culture minister – 58 years old
    Previously mayor of Paris' 7th arrondissement (a posh district)

    (Sarkozyist, like many, many French politicians, male and female, she has also has a history of being a major slut)

    8.
    Sébastien Lecornu
    Armed forces minister – 37 years old

    (Sarkozyist since he was 16)

    9. Eric Dupond-Moretti
    Justice minister – 62 years old

    (Old connection to the Socialists before joining Macron, celebrity lawyer with a lawyer's sense of ethics - has been accused of using his position to attack old legal enemies, including joint enemies of Dupond-Moretti and Sarkozy, such as the magistrates who once investigated him because they suspected he might be a mole for Sarkozy)

    10. Stéphane Séjourné
    European and foreign affairs minister – 38 years old
    Previously mEP, general secretary of Macron's Renaissance party

    (Former Socialist, Attal's former (?) lover)

    11.
    Christophe Béchu
    Environment transition and territorial cohesion minister – 49 years old

    (Sarkozyist)

    12. Sylvie Retailleau
    Higher education and research minister – 58 years old

    (Physicist, academic, no political career, unhappy about the recent tighter immigration law)

    13.
    Prisca Thevenot
    Democratic renewal junior minister, government spokewoman – 38 years old
    Previously youth and universal national service junior minister

    (Macronist)

    14.
    Marie Lebec
    Parliamentary relations junior minister – 33 years old
    Previously vice-president of Macron's Renaissance party's parliamentary group in the Assemblée Nationale

    (Sarkozyist)

    15.
    Aurore Bergé
    Gender equality and combating discrimination junior minister – 37 years old
    Previously solidarity and family minister

    (Sarkozyist, daughter of soixante-huitards, was for gay marriage during its legalisation and defended jus soli citizenship, 2021 proposed an amendment of the separatism law to ban the wearing of hijabs by minors in public in order to defend the rights of young girls and fight back against islamism.)

    https://www.lemonde.fr/en/les-decodeurs/article/2024/01/12/french-government-who-are-the-ministers-in-gabriel-attal-s-cabinet_6426649_8.html
  677. @German_reader
    @AnonfromTN

    I don't know why the vote went that way, both the parties of the government coalition and leading CDU/CSU politicians have all spoken in favour of delivering Taurus missiles to Ukraine. One of the most bellicose Greens, Anton Hofreiter, who has demanded sending Taurus missiles (and much else) for months said he would vote against the resolution, because CDU/CSU isn't serious enough about supporting Ukraine and the resolution is just for show. So maybe it's all merely party politics. Whatever. Germany's role in this mess won't go beyond scapegoat and paypig anyway, the decisions that matter will be taken elsewhere.

    Replies: @German_reader

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @German_reader

    Ok, so Germany ships Taurus missiles and Kiev fires them at Crimea or Moscow. They either work or not, but let's say there is massive damage. At that point if Russia takes out downtown Lviv, Vinnitsa or Kiev (they can do it), what exactly would the West complain about? Dead invite more dead...read Greek tragedies or Shakespeare...

    The problem with escalation is that it empowers the stronger side - at this point nobody doubts that Russia has regional dominance, they are stronger. Nudging Russia to use all it has is a very bad strategy - that's how we got to this mess. And there is a non-zero chance that if Tauruses happen and there is escalation Germans would also be hit - maybe the troops in Lithuania or something secondary. Is that what Germany wants?

    Kiev needs to make peace. If they don't they will be forced to make much worse peace in not so distant future. (Or it can go to the ultimate weapons...come to think of it, why not? what are we holding on to?)

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AP

  678. @Mikel
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    I couldn't agree more.

    The other day Google decided that what I really need in every search I do is Spanish language results. I must have visited some Spanish-language website or something, and their "intelligent" algorithms, perhaps trained to apply cultural-sensitive filters, only gave me Spanish trash for every search I tried. I set my language and region, which were undefined, to the US but it didn't make any difference. Google knew better than me what I needed. For several days the only way to get English results in my searches was to modify the URL and append ?lang=en. Finally, they must have realized that I really meant "give me English results please" and the problem is gone for now.

    The existing AI systems have such a steep learning curve ahead that AK's talk of an impending singularity making his previous ideology obsolete sounds like a laughable cope. I used to have intellectual respect for him. His Covid-19 prediction was impressive. But I can't take him seriously anymore.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Negronicus

    …AK’s talk of an impending singularity making his previous ideology obsolete sounds like a laughable cope.

    Quality cannot be sustained. Complex AI systems deteriorate over time – the learning is only a partial fix. What we get is the slow decoupling of systems from their primary function. Only ‘marketing’ will work – that’s what they are for.

    The inability of most people to function without the apps (‘apes‘) will get worse. Mankind should never obsolete the building blocks of the current technology – but we are doing it. AI’s real danger is in the lack of system maintenance…the layers of dysfunction are accumulating.

    The solution offered is to have two 80-year old guys fight it out…yes, it is a clown world.

  679. @German_reader
    @songbird


    But I think Keith Woods went a little too far in his recent video claiming that Romans had an ethno-nationalist feeling extending to the toe of Italy:
     
    Watched the video, and while I think Keith is somewhat over-stating his case, he's not wrong (though one could argue his focus on the mid-republic to early empire is a bit manipulative, since Romanness did evolve into a sort of universal identity). More generally, I agree ethnicity and ethnic conflict have been significant throughout history, even if they're not everything.

    Replies: @songbird

    Am not sure that feeling exists in modern Italy. I once spoke of my shock seeing Northern Italians for the first time.

    I do like recounting that time in WWI, when elderly Italian farmers in some zone that had been reoccupied tried to attack the Italian army with pitchforks – apparently out of fear.

    More generally, I agree ethnicity and ethnic conflict have been significant throughout history, even if they’re not everything.

    I seem to vaguely recall that the Romans tried to exploit differences between the Punics and the Berbers, just as Hannibal tried to exploit the Celts in the Po Valley.

    Of course, the modern historical narrative seems to promote the idea that everyone was miscegenating and fusing together in a vibrant culture, only the Romans were racist against the Punics or something.

  680. @John Johnson
    @Beckow


    …The proof is in that the establishment never wanted Biden. They wanted a woman.
     
    No, they simply didn’t want Trump and tried everything to make sure it didn’t happen. The guiding hand is always flexible and works with what it has.

    Of course they didn't want Trump.

    But I was talking about the Democrat primary. They wanted a minority woman and in fact wrote editorials about how they didn't want "another White guy". They only accepted Biden as the last man standing against Bernie. The establishment never wanted him and in fact Obama only endorsed him after Bernie lost.

    I'm no fan of Obama but he was right about Biden. It should have been a red flag that Obama wouldn't endorse his own VP until no one else was left.

    A cliche that doesn’t translate into anything real. Assange and 1k demonstrators are in jail in a “democracy”

    Assange was not exercising free speech rights. You do not have the right to release thousands of classified documents to the internet.

    The fact that you have to go back to Assange speaks volumes. Putin kills a journalist about once a month and your best example is from the Iraq war.

    Assange has since been accused of rape. Some hero.

    As for Jan 6th no one was hauled off for criticizing the government. You don't have the right to riot, break into a Federal building or throw rocks at police officers. Most of the officers were Trump voters. The MAGA rioters were freaking idiots. A total waste of time that fed the MSM.

    Russia is not a dictatorship by any standard

    So you believe Russian votes can be trusted? Is that right?

    Do you believe that occupied Zaporizhzhia Oblast voted to join Russia even though they overwhelmingly voted for Zelensky in 2019?

    I can post videos where Russians describe their own government as a dictatorship where the vote doesn't matter. You are saying they are wrong?

    Replies: @Beckow

    Assange is in prison now, not in the “Iraq war”. If you ok with putting people in prison for publishing embarrassing stuff then all Russia, China have to do is claim what the journalists published was “classified” – very easy to do especially in a war. And they are doing it. If US-UK can do it, why are you objecting when Russia does it? Do they have to be better?

    Assange was accused of ‘rape’ and it was dropped, so don’t lie. Any floozie in Moscow can accuse Navalny of unwanted sex, it is literally in the first chapter of the Intelligence Manual on how to discredit opponents. Are you so clueless? Read the f…ing Manual…:)

    If you can put in jail in 1k demonstrators for mayhem-graffiti-vandalism that inevitably happens during protests (see BLM), why can’t Russia do the same? Your inability to use the same standard is making your arguments sound like blabbing by an isolated, not-very-smart narcissist…

    you believe Russian votes can be trusted?

    I don’t know if any votes anywhere can be fully trusted. There are always corner cases, people voting who shouldn’t, others voting for them – it probably happens as much in Philadelphia as in Krasnodar. (90% plus in black districts).

    The real issue is whether the resulting government has majority support: in Russia by all accounts and all analysts Putin has a huge majority, 60-80%. Nobody denies it other than you. In many Western countries there are governments that have a lot lower support, Macron in the 20’s, the Indian guy in UK around 30, also Biden, Scholz. Those are real numbers – they rule because the system was structured in a way to prevent a viable alternative.

    In Russia if Putin would run in a completely unrestricted all-media-open-to-all ideal democracy he would still win. You don’t have anything like an ideal democracy at home, but you demand that others do it? Are you so disconnected from the real life?

  681. @German_reader
    @German_reader

    https://nitter.net/cducsubt/status/1747577187002147281#m

    Bizarre choice of motive.

    Replies: @Beckow

    Ok, so Germany ships Taurus missiles and Kiev fires them at Crimea or Moscow. They either work or not, but let’s say there is massive damage. At that point if Russia takes out downtown Lviv, Vinnitsa or Kiev (they can do it), what exactly would the West complain about? Dead invite more dead…read Greek tragedies or Shakespeare…

    The problem with escalation is that it empowers the stronger side – at this point nobody doubts that Russia has regional dominance, they are stronger. Nudging Russia to use all it has is a very bad strategy – that’s how we got to this mess. And there is a non-zero chance that if Tauruses happen and there is escalation Germans would also be hit – maybe the troops in Lithuania or something secondary. Is that what Germany wants?

    Kiev needs to make peace. If they don’t they will be forced to make much worse peace in not so distant future. (Or it can go to the ultimate weapons…come to think of it, why not? what are we holding on to?)

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Beckow

    Yesterday the Russians did a long range missile [?] attack on French mercs after France announces long range missiles for the Ukraine.

    https://www.france24.com/en/europe/20240118-russia-says-targeted-french-mercenaries-in-long-range-strike-on-ukraine-s-kharkiv

    https://www.thedefensepost.com/2024/01/17/france-long-range-missiles-ukraine/

    Putin must read Beckow's comments is the first thing I thought. We know NSA bots read Beckow's comments. : )

    Isn't Kharkov practically on the front line?

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    , @AP
    @Beckow


    Kiev needs to make peace
     
    With whom? Russia only agrees to “peace” in the form of loss of Ukrainian statehood. So calls for Kiev to make peace are nothing more than demands that Ukrainians abandon their country’s independence. It’s like demanding Czechoslovakia or Poland to make peace with Germany in 1938-1939. Czechs went for it, but Ukrainians are not 1939 Czechs.

    Replies: @A123, @Beckow

  682. @LT1488
    @Mr. Hack

    I guess countries like Croatia and Poland that recognize them as an independent ethnic group from Ukrainians, must be Kremlin implants too!

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    Would you say that before the break-up of the Soviet Union and the fall of the iron curtain there were no “Soviet implants” in these east European countries? When were these laws passed that recognized an independent rusyn ethnos? What countries had the most to gain from such an interpretation? Why is Rusyn independence least popular in the Rusyn homeland of Zakarpattya? Why do the Rusyns in Zakarpattya honor their most prolific and popular writer of the 20th century, an undeniable Ukrainophile from these regions, Vasyl Grendzha-Donsky?

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @Mr. Hack

    Rusyn autonomy is very popular though and Ukraine refuses to give it to them
    Here is an article from Wikipedia
    ''Zakarpattia in independent Ukraine
    After the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991, Ukraine held an independence referendum in which the residents of Zakarpattia were asked about the Zakarpattia Oblast Council's proposal for self-rule.[7] About 78% of the oblast's population voted in favour of autonomy; however, it was not granted.[7]''

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zakarpattia_Oblast#Zakarpattia_in_independent_Ukraine

    Fun fact
    Rusyn diasporas in America and Canada have seperate religious organizations from Ukrainians


    ''Many Rusyn Americans left Catholicism for Eastern Orthodoxy in the 19th century due to disputes with the Latin Church bishops, who viewed different practices in the Byzantine Rite (such as married clergy) with suspicion.


    St Nicholas Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Church, Jacobs Creek Pennsylvania, USA
    Another large segment of Rusyn Americans belong to the American Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Diocese, which is headquartered in Johnstown, Pennsylvania. From its early days, this group was recognized by the Ecumenical Patriarchate as a self-governing diocese.''

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rusyns#Religion

    I guess all of them are ''KGB implants''

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. Hack, @AP

  683. @Derer
    @Mr. Hack


    There are over one million people living within Zakarpttya today that are perfectly comfortable living with their Ukrainian identiry.
     
    BS. You do not know their desire - need for referendum. Few years back they were caught making underground tunnels to Slovakia. They prefer earning Euro in Slovakia to Ukie worthless paper. They prefer Latin alphabet to Cyrillic.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    There was a referendum, in 1991, and 92.5% of respondents voted to stay within Ukraine. Going to a richer, western area to make some money, sending it back home and then to finally moving back to retire is not a good gauge of people’s loyalties. Holding referendums during war time is not a good idea. I don’t of any other country that has done this?

  684. @Beckow
    @Mr. Hack

    As so often you know nothing about the actual situation on the ground. In Slovakia and Czechia a large proportion of the recent migrants from Ukraine are Rusyns from Zakarpatia, they consciously identify differently. There is a Rusyn church, university, in Prague they have churches, clubs, restaurants...in my experience most are neutral in the war - you read into it whatever you want.

    Rusyns are distinct people with their own language or dialect, music, history. There is some loose talk to rejoin Czechia, Slovakia or Hungary - to be in EU immediately. But it is very messy and the geography is too remote. They don't like Galicians from over the Carpathian mountains and don't want to be like them, they have no Bandera worship or hatred of Russia. Their preference was to be in a multi-ethnic Ukraine with cultural autonomy - then the dumb Ukie nationalists blew it apart. My sense is that hundreds of thousands of them will stay and assimilate - they are very similar to our Rusyns.

    By the way the previous Czech PM Andrej Babis was from Zakarpathia on his mother's side. We were one country not that long ago.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @AP

    Like I stated earlier, there are some 10,000 “rusyns” that identify as such within Ukraine comprised of sheep herders, KGB agents, grant eaters and even a couple of priests. They propagate all sorts of nonsense – “you read into it whatever you want”. 🙂

    They don’t like Galicians from over the Carpathian mountains and don’t want to be like them, they have no Bandera worship or hatred of Russia.

    Strange if this is true, that the most popular electronic website in Zakarpattya is Zakarpattya Online: https://zakarpattya.net.ua/. It always espouses a pro-Ukrainian and anti rusyn approach. If not Bandera worship then certainly Grendzha-Donsky worship who was a straight arrow Ukrainaphile, who to this day has books. blogsites etc dedicated to his honor.

  685. @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    Just purchased and finished building a cat house for them in my backyard. They're slowly getting used to it and can be seen going in and out of their new castle. Let's see, they've got all of the shots that the vet prescribed, food 2-3 times per day and water, and now a house that they can inhabit when it's cold, windy or raining outside. My conscience is clear and I can sleep soundly again at night...BTW, I avoided the problem of overpopulation by having my three cats spaded and neutered (the best idea that I ever had).

    Replies: @songbird, @Sher Singh

    [MORE]

    ਅਕਾਲ

  686. @Sean
    @Mr. XYZ

    Countries join Nato so they don't have to spend serious money on their own defence, Russia had always been a military autocracy, so Putin asking if Russia could join Nato was a sign he wanted to take Russia in a less defenced spending Western direction. It soon became clear to Putin as he was fobbed of that Russia was not welcome in Nato, and it was an anti Russian military alliance.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Spending less on defense doesn’t necessarily mean that Russia is going to become less of an autocracy. It would be less hostile towards the West, of course, though probably not being willing to be the West’s tool either in regards to China, et cetera.

    • Replies: @Sean
    @Mr. XYZ

    Why Kiev thought any regime in the Kremli--even a democratic one--might ultimately brook Ukraine becoming aligned with Washington is mysterious to me. That Putin's modern version of Tsarist military autocracy would allow it in the end is a truly catastrophic failure of statecraft. Was the idea that Putin would put morality over other considerations, if so Ukraine ought to have borne in mind that the Russian leadership are under no obligation whatsoever to put their nation's security interests as they saw them in second place to the democratic free choices of an entirely separate country.

    I think America thinks Russia will ultimately see China as being in being in too much propinquity for any kind of partnership, unless America aids Ukraine to totally defeat the Russian invasion. In my view Washington's desired outcome is for Russia to win a limited and rather pyrrhic victory over Ukraine. European freeloading on the US (even Britain has long cut its defence capabilitiesn order to balance budget without taxes until now it is unable to really contribute) makes trouble with Russia a diversion. Against China, the US's only solid ally with military and naval might is Japan.

  687. @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    I am not sure what "younger brothers" means, but ok. In Czecho-slovakia in 1918 there was the ideology of a single nation, that we were the "same". The western Slovak dialect spoken by most educated Slovaks was very similar to the Moravian dialect - around the border it was identical, and the sense of unity was very strong. That region is very Protestant and most leaders of the Slovak national movement were Protestants from the central-western region who studied in Prague.

    Masaryk's father was Slovak, so were Stefanik, Bata (biggest businessman), Dubcek, Husak - in the 70-80's the complaint in Prague was that that they were ruled by Slovaks, but they were actually consciously Czechoslovak. It is different now, but we are very inter-mixed.

    With Magyars it was hard in 1900-1914, and the languages are too far apart. But calling them "Asiats" is idiotic, AP is living in some half-baked 'merican' world were he misunderstands things.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Mr. XYZ

    Interesting; thank you.

    BTW, speaking of Stefanik, the US could have a Vice President Stefanik next year if Trump will win again this year:

    https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2024-election/trump-elise-stefanik-vp-pick-prospect-rcna133599

    She’s of mixed Italian and Slovak descent. She’s also got dangerous curves:

    https://encrypted-tbn2.gstatic.com/licensed-image?q=tbn:ANd9GcTXcQ-ojfRsvqIdCHGr44jFSoHXW9GY9D55e5cE0XfwiJCdpcWlF0E3vfAwa3gV1O80CnjFEEIn_NVK96E

    For a curvy woman, she is relatively attractive.

    • Disagree: AP
    • Replies: @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    The curves could be the Italian pasta-mama...our Stefaniks are famously trim - the austere Protestant genes...

    That also won't age well, so she better get the VP now. But isn't Trump also from NY so it would be un-Constitutional?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  688. @Mikel
    @songbird


    They can re-evaluate their predictions fairly quickly, in theory. Main limitation is that it takes so long for the standard processes that they have to wait to make the comparison.
     
    Thanks for that article but, as a lifelong weather nut, I don't see too much of a groundbreaking advance here.

    If I understand things correctly, their system makes much faster calculations than the standard numerical models used currently at the cost of using a crude data-intensive model trained on 45 years of data and corresponding outcomes instead of the computationally intensive physical equations that drive the standard models.

    I'm not sure how this higher computing speed on a cruder model improves things much. Historical outcomes may not repeat themselves, as per the well-known butterfly effect, and numerical models are already quite good at short lead times. As they say themselves in the article, all they were able to do for a hurricane landfall prediction is lengthen it to 9 days as opposed to 6 days of the numerical models. A bit of an advantage for disaster preparedness, if you trust the 9-day out prediction, but I doubt anybody is doing much nowadays even 6 days in advance.

    I even fail to see where the ML and AI component of this model is but admittedly, I don't know much about those subjects. As I understand it, perhaps incorrectly, ML would only kick in once they have a good set of predictions that they can compare to real-life outcomes. In any case, no AI is going to overcome the aforementioned butterfly effect, formulated by the great Lorentz, that makes prediction of a chaotic system impossible past a number of days. In the future AI may be able to do stuff like generate new mathematical theorems but I'm totally sure that weather forecasting is going to be limited by Lorentz's theories for a very long time to come (perhaps forever, if our current understanding of chaotic systems is correct).

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird

    I even fail to see where the ML and AI component of this model

    can’t explain it because I don’t really understand it myself.

    [MORE]
    But here is the IBM page attempting to explain the basic idea:
    https://www.ibm.com/topics/neural-networks

    Seems like the real bottleneck right now is the slow creep of time and future weather data. And the longer cycles and supercycles that we don’t really have good data on.

    If I understand correctly, a lot of the current neural networks are trained on geographically and perhaps even temporally interpolated data.

    Obviously, there is an enormous potential to get more reads. And there are things like the Parker Solar Probe. I wouldn’t necessarily discount the possibility of much longer predictions, provided enough time elapses, without substantial technological or economic regression.

    I wonder whether better and faster predictions may eventually feed into the re-establishment of attempts to change the weather.

    Like, in the ’50s or ’60s, they used to light oil slicks on fire, in an attempt to change the path of hurricanes. I don’t expect the Greens would allow that, but if there were ever massive solar arrays in space beaming energy down, then it would probably become practicable. (Really big if – I don’t see how it would work – and I am not the techno optimist AK is – but people have been talking about it since at least the ’70s.)

    • Replies: @Mikel
    @songbird

    Thanks for that link too. Quite dense for me but it does provide some clarifying definitions and follow-on links.


    I wouldn’t necessarily discount the possibility of much longer predictions
     
    I have to disagree here. The reason why weather predictions are all over the place past the 10-15 day window is not for lack of data or computing power/speed. It's because of the nature of how fluids (or any other chaotic system) behave over time. Lorentz's example of the flap of the wings of a butterfly causing a hurricane on the other side of the world is not be taken literally but in these systems minute differences in initial conditions of comparable magnitude do give rise to exponentially disparate outcomes as time progresses so prediction becomes impossible. I don't see how AI could overcome this essential problem.

    but people have been talking about it since at least the ’70s
     
    That's when Nixon declared his war on cancer too. But it's still a leading cause of death and not too much progress has been done really. Most metastatic cancers continue to be incurable and there's no way to detect most of them before they reach that stage. And yet AK seems to think that we're going to cure aging, a more intractable problem that would imply curing cancer among many other deadly diseases (or else we would continue dying of the same causes and there wouldn't be any life extension), in the coming decades. I do have some hopes of living enough to see those limited successes they've had with mouse models translated to humans but De Grey's "longevity escape velocity" ideas (that I've seen AK base his predictions on) look far too optimistic.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird

  689. @John Johnson
    @AP

    The Democrats’ only chance of retaining the presidency is if Trump wins the primary and then gets convicted of something. So they will do what they can to help him become the Republican candidate. It may backfire and he may win the presidency anyways, but at least (for them) he is much less effective than a president DeSantis would have been.

    The irony is that the Democrats spend so much time obsessing over Trump and yet he is their best chance to retain the white house.

    Practically any non-Biden no-name Democrat defeats Trump because of independents in swing states.

    Trump only wins a slight majority of independents when they are forced to choose between a felon and a president that gets lost when getting off the airplane. But that is according to current data and Trump still has the documents trial. He could easily sour more independents if he actually catches a felony which would erase his small gains.

    Both Biden and Trump are ego maniacs. If Biden really wanted to defeat Trump then he would announce that he won't run for a second term as he originally promised.

    DeSantis should quit. He isn't a bad guy but he is splitting the pot and Haley does better with independents.

    Replies: @Sean, @Mikel, @Mr. XYZ

    Practically any non-Biden no-name Democrat defeats Trump because of independents in swing states.

    Even Pete Buttigieg?

  690. @songbird
    @Mikel


    I even fail to see where the ML and AI component of this model
     
    can't explain it because I don't really understand it myself. But here is the IBM page attempting to explain the basic idea:
    https://www.ibm.com/topics/neural-networks

    Seems like the real bottleneck right now is the slow creep of time and future weather data. And the longer cycles and supercycles that we don't really have good data on.

    If I understand correctly, a lot of the current neural networks are trained on geographically and perhaps even temporally interpolated data.

    Obviously, there is an enormous potential to get more reads. And there are things like the Parker Solar Probe. I wouldn't necessarily discount the possibility of much longer predictions, provided enough time elapses, without substantial technological or economic regression.

    I wonder whether better and faster predictions may eventually feed into the re-establishment of attempts to change the weather.

    Like, in the '50s or '60s, they used to light oil slicks on fire, in an attempt to change the path of hurricanes. I don't expect the Greens would allow that, but if there were ever massive solar arrays in space beaming energy down, then it would probably become practicable. (Really big if - I don't see how it would work - and I am not the techno optimist AK is - but people have been talking about it since at least the '70s.)

    Replies: @Mikel

    Thanks for that link too. Quite dense for me but it does provide some clarifying definitions and follow-on links.

    I wouldn’t necessarily discount the possibility of much longer predictions

    I have to disagree here. The reason why weather predictions are all over the place past the 10-15 day window is not for lack of data or computing power/speed. It’s because of the nature of how fluids (or any other chaotic system) behave over time. Lorentz’s example of the flap of the wings of a butterfly causing a hurricane on the other side of the world is not be taken literally but in these systems minute differences in initial conditions of comparable magnitude do give rise to exponentially disparate outcomes as time progresses so prediction becomes impossible. I don’t see how AI could overcome this essential problem.

    but people have been talking about it since at least the ’70s

    That’s when Nixon declared his war on cancer too. But it’s still a leading cause of death and not too much progress has been done really. Most metastatic cancers continue to be incurable and there’s no way to detect most of them before they reach that stage. And yet AK seems to think that we’re going to cure aging, a more intractable problem that would imply curing cancer among many other deadly diseases (or else we would continue dying of the same causes and there wouldn’t be any life extension), in the coming decades. I do have some hopes of living enough to see those limited successes they’ve had with mouse models translated to humans but De Grey’s “longevity escape velocity” ideas (that I’ve seen AK base his predictions on) look far too optimistic.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mikel

    Roko's Basilisk has a plan for you buddy.

    It would be weird if AK believes that stuff himself. There is a market for it. He is writing to that. Sincerity and consistency are not his character strengths.

    Yudkowsky is sincerely deluded. I wonder how close he has approached using an AI on any real world problems.

    https://i.redd.it/7w243oj0c6h01.jpg

    , @songbird
    @Mikel


    That’s when Nixon declared his war on cancer too. But it’s still a leading cause of death and not too much progress has been done really.
     
    Well, "War" is certainly hyperbolic rhetoric, but people are living longer nowadays, so that leads to more cancers.

    I have known several people who kicked the bucket due to cancer. One quite tragic case, where it killed all the women in the family, and two very young, and one a new mother.

    But I have also known people who survived who would have died, if not for the progress that has been made. Survival rates of some common cancers like breast and bowel have doubled since the '70s. (Of course, colonoscopies should only be given to people with a family history of such things - and I suspect it might be related to gay politics the movent to popularize them, often somewhat forcefully).

    Granted, I still think the idea of power stations in space is quite fantastical, there seems to be some reason to be cautiously optimistic about space.

    There has been enormous growth recently in mass to orbit, and we haven't seen it top off yet. And a lot of new rockets are coming on-line soon.

    Replies: @Mikel

  691. @LT1488
    @AP

    Hungarians are not hated by most slavic eastern europeans
    Poles,Russians, Czechs, Croats etc like the Hungarians and Poles even consider them their brothers.
    Slovaks and Serbs have some issues with the Magyars, but the current Slovak and Serbian leadership is very friendly with the current Magyar leadership.
    As for other neighbouring eastern Europeans, the Romanians indeed do not like Hungary and haven't even allowed their Hungarian minority right to autonomy. And as for Ukraine, as you said, the Hungarian minority's rights to speak and learn Hungarian are being infringed upon.
    I do not know where you got this logic of slavs and other eastern europeans intensely disliking Hungary when the opposite is true.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    I do not know where you got this logic of slavs and other eastern europeans intensely disliking Hungary when the opposite is true.

    Well, Hungary oppressed Slavs (and Romanians) as part of its Magyarization policy in the 1867 to 1918 time period. But that was over a century ago by now.

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    Fun fact
    Hungarian Translyvania had more Romanian schools than all of Romania COMBINED.
    Even today Translyvanian Romanians are more educated and well off than the rest.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  692. @Mikel
    @songbird

    Thanks for that link too. Quite dense for me but it does provide some clarifying definitions and follow-on links.


    I wouldn’t necessarily discount the possibility of much longer predictions
     
    I have to disagree here. The reason why weather predictions are all over the place past the 10-15 day window is not for lack of data or computing power/speed. It's because of the nature of how fluids (or any other chaotic system) behave over time. Lorentz's example of the flap of the wings of a butterfly causing a hurricane on the other side of the world is not be taken literally but in these systems minute differences in initial conditions of comparable magnitude do give rise to exponentially disparate outcomes as time progresses so prediction becomes impossible. I don't see how AI could overcome this essential problem.

    but people have been talking about it since at least the ’70s
     
    That's when Nixon declared his war on cancer too. But it's still a leading cause of death and not too much progress has been done really. Most metastatic cancers continue to be incurable and there's no way to detect most of them before they reach that stage. And yet AK seems to think that we're going to cure aging, a more intractable problem that would imply curing cancer among many other deadly diseases (or else we would continue dying of the same causes and there wouldn't be any life extension), in the coming decades. I do have some hopes of living enough to see those limited successes they've had with mouse models translated to humans but De Grey's "longevity escape velocity" ideas (that I've seen AK base his predictions on) look far too optimistic.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird

    Roko’s Basilisk has a plan for you buddy.

    It would be weird if AK believes that stuff himself. There is a market for it. He is writing to that. Sincerity and consistency are not his character strengths.

    Yudkowsky is sincerely deluded. I wonder how close he has approached using an AI on any real world problems.

  693. @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488


    I do not know where you got this logic of slavs and other eastern europeans intensely disliking Hungary when the opposite is true.

     

    Well, Hungary oppressed Slavs (and Romanians) as part of its Magyarization policy in the 1867 to 1918 time period. But that was over a century ago by now.

    Replies: @LT1488

    Fun fact
    Hungarian Translyvania had more Romanian schools than all of Romania COMBINED.
    Even today Translyvanian Romanians are more educated and well off than the rest.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    Does Transylvania perform better academically (such as on the PISA exam) than the rest of Romania does?

    Ex-Austrian Poles perform better academically than Poles in the rest of Poland do:

    https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0147596718305006

    Not sure why since Prussia also had a top-notch educational system which made almost all of their Poles literate. Ex-Prussian Poles, even in areas that did not involve mass migration, do not appear to perform better academically than Poles in the rest of Poland do.

    Prussia was actually more successful at promoting literacy among Poles than Austria was, who in turn was more successful at promoting literacy among Poles than Russia was:

    https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S0147596718305006-gr2.jpg

    Replies: @LT1488, @AP

  694. @Mr. Hack
    @LT1488

    Would you say that before the break-up of the Soviet Union and the fall of the iron curtain there were no "Soviet implants" in these east European countries? When were these laws passed that recognized an independent rusyn ethnos? What countries had the most to gain from such an interpretation? Why is Rusyn independence least popular in the Rusyn homeland of Zakarpattya? Why do the Rusyns in Zakarpattya honor their most prolific and popular writer of the 20th century, an undeniable Ukrainophile from these regions, Vasyl Grendzha-Donsky?

    Replies: @LT1488

    Rusyn autonomy is very popular though and Ukraine refuses to give it to them
    Here is an article from Wikipedia
    ”Zakarpattia in independent Ukraine
    After the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991, Ukraine held an independence referendum in which the residents of Zakarpattia were asked about the Zakarpattia Oblast Council’s proposal for self-rule.[7] About 78% of the oblast’s population voted in favour of autonomy; however, it was not granted.[7]”

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zakarpattia_Oblast#Zakarpattia_in_independent_Ukraine

    Fun fact
    Rusyn diasporas in America and Canada have seperate religious organizations from Ukrainians

    ”Many Rusyn Americans left Catholicism for Eastern Orthodoxy in the 19th century due to disputes with the Latin Church bishops, who viewed different practices in the Byzantine Rite (such as married clergy) with suspicion.

    St Nicholas Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Church, Jacobs Creek Pennsylvania, USA
    Another large segment of Rusyn Americans belong to the American Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Diocese, which is headquartered in Johnstown, Pennsylvania. From its early days, this group was recognized by the Ecumenical Patriarchate as a self-governing diocese.”

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rusyns#Religion

    I guess all of them are ”KGB implants”

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @LT1488

    Have you ever heard Peter Levenda's spiel about the Ukraine Orthodox in the Bronx in the 1960's? It is pretty entertaining if you have not. CIA + JFK assassination characters. I can not testify to if it's factual.

    Replies: @LT1488

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    Married clergy actually makes sense if one supports eugenic fertility since it allows clergy, who typically come from a society's more intelligent population, to breed (or at least breed more). Religion should embrace such a eugenic policy instead of shunning away from it. At least religious people could claim that preventing abortions of Down's syndrome fetuses saves lives; here, there's no similar reason/justification for them to support a public policy with dysgenic effects.

    Replies: @LT1488

    , @Mr. Hack
    @LT1488

    Do you know how many voters in Zakarpattya took part in the oblast council's referendum, which by the way was held on the very same day as the general referendum of Ukrainian independence? Sounds a little bit fishy to me. As some independent researchers have concluded:


    One survey by Jordan and Klemencic inquired: “To what country should Transcarpathia belong?” Over 60 percent of those who considered themselves to be Ukrainian or Rusyn-Ukrainian viewed the region as an integral part of Ukraine. Only ten percent of Ukrainians and seven percentof Rusyn-Ukrainians preferred an independent Trans-Carpathia. Even among Rusyns the survey found that they were divided. Forty percent of the small number who considered themselves to be a separate Rusyn people supported independent statehood. Nearly the same number, 37 percent, favoured maintaining Trans-Carpathia as part of Ukraine. Separatism is not alive and well in Trans-Carpathia.
     
    Jordan and Klemencic, “Transcarpathia,” 503.

    I think that the ability to create a separate Rusyn state has more chance of success in Pennsylvania than in Zakarpattya.

    , @AP
    @LT1488


    Rusyn autonomy is very popular though and Ukraine refuses to give it to them
    Here is an article from Wikipedia
    ”Zakarpattia in independent Ukraine
    After the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991
     
    Who wouldn’t have wanted autonomy from the Soviet government in 1991?

    Fun fact
    Rusyn diasporas in America and Canada have seperate religious organizations from Ukrainians
     
    Hungarian rule in Zakarpatya meant very high illiteracy. This shielded the Rusyns there from Ukrainian nation-building efforts, which by the late 19th century resulted in a rather literate, Ukrainian nationalist population in Galicia.

    The immigrants to the USA avoiding Ukrainian organizations reflected these circumstances.

    The Russian self-identification and conversion to Orthodoxy was in large part the result of aggressive funding by the pre-Soviet Russian government.

    :::::::::

    In post-Soviet Ukrainian Zakarpatya, about 1% of the Eastern Slavs consider themselves to belong to a separate nation than the Ukrainian one. The Alaska Independence Party has more support in Alaska, than Rusyn independence has in Zakarpatya.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaskan_Independence_Party

    Across the border in Slovakia, the Rusyn identity was rather actively promoted. About 2/3 of the Eastern Slavs there consider themselves to be a separate nation from Ukrainians and about 1/3 consider themselves to be Ukrainians. In terms of alternative history for Mr. XYZ, this suggests that if Zakarpatya would have been returned to Czechoslovakia after World War II, there would be an independent Ruthenia (after Czechs and Slovaks split), about 40% of whose population would consider themselves to be ethnic Ukrainians. (it would be more than 1/3 because there were pockets of Ukrainian nationalists in Eastern Zakarpatya).

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  695. @LT1488
    @Mr. Hack

    Rusyn autonomy is very popular though and Ukraine refuses to give it to them
    Here is an article from Wikipedia
    ''Zakarpattia in independent Ukraine
    After the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991, Ukraine held an independence referendum in which the residents of Zakarpattia were asked about the Zakarpattia Oblast Council's proposal for self-rule.[7] About 78% of the oblast's population voted in favour of autonomy; however, it was not granted.[7]''

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zakarpattia_Oblast#Zakarpattia_in_independent_Ukraine

    Fun fact
    Rusyn diasporas in America and Canada have seperate religious organizations from Ukrainians


    ''Many Rusyn Americans left Catholicism for Eastern Orthodoxy in the 19th century due to disputes with the Latin Church bishops, who viewed different practices in the Byzantine Rite (such as married clergy) with suspicion.


    St Nicholas Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Church, Jacobs Creek Pennsylvania, USA
    Another large segment of Rusyn Americans belong to the American Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Diocese, which is headquartered in Johnstown, Pennsylvania. From its early days, this group was recognized by the Ecumenical Patriarchate as a self-governing diocese.''

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rusyns#Religion

    I guess all of them are ''KGB implants''

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. Hack, @AP

    Have you ever heard Peter Levenda’s spiel about the Ukraine Orthodox in the Bronx in the 1960’s? It is pretty entertaining if you have not. CIA + JFK assassination characters. I can not testify to if it’s factual.

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Yes I have heard of them, however I'm not sure exactly as to how true it is.

  696. @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    Fun fact
    Hungarian Translyvania had more Romanian schools than all of Romania COMBINED.
    Even today Translyvanian Romanians are more educated and well off than the rest.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Does Transylvania perform better academically (such as on the PISA exam) than the rest of Romania does?

    Ex-Austrian Poles perform better academically than Poles in the rest of Poland do:

    https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0147596718305006

    Not sure why since Prussia also had a top-notch educational system which made almost all of their Poles literate. Ex-Prussian Poles, even in areas that did not involve mass migration, do not appear to perform better academically than Poles in the rest of Poland do.

    Prussia was actually more successful at promoting literacy among Poles than Austria was, who in turn was more successful at promoting literacy among Poles than Russia was:

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    Can't find data on PISA scores, but on economy, HDI, foreign investments and overall quality of life is much higher in Translyvania than in Wallachia or Moldavia regions.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    , @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    The very high literacy rates in former Prussian lands were mostly due to ethnic Germans.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  697. @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    The 1890 and 1910 censuses are generally considered very manipulated by the Budapest Magyar government. For example almost all government employees, students and soldiers were listed as of Magyar ethnicity, they were in no position to disagree. The census takers would ask if a person understood the Magyar language and if they said yes, they were listed as Magyars. All Jews also declared Magyar nationality. After WW1 censuses showed around 15-20% fewer Magyars. Some of it was a reverse manipulation by the new states, but most of it was people saying who they really were.

    Trianon was a massive shrinkage of Hungary - they were punished much more than the Austrians, actually Austria got the region of Burgerland from Hungary. But there was no other way: in the last 20 years before WW1 the Hungarians went on a nationalist rampage trying to "magyarize" everyone, being totally unreasonable, suffering from a narcissistic vertigo. Then they lost a war.

    The new lines mostly followed geographic boundaries, rivers, mountains. The Hungarians refused to negotiate and insisted on keeping everything - thus the borders were drawn for them. There is a lesson there for others, like the Ukies: if a situation is unsustainable make a deal early and be reasonable.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. XYZ

    What about the 1900 Hungarian census? And the 1880 Hungarian census? And the 1869 Hungarian census?

  698. @LT1488
    @Mr. Hack

    Rusyn autonomy is very popular though and Ukraine refuses to give it to them
    Here is an article from Wikipedia
    ''Zakarpattia in independent Ukraine
    After the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991, Ukraine held an independence referendum in which the residents of Zakarpattia were asked about the Zakarpattia Oblast Council's proposal for self-rule.[7] About 78% of the oblast's population voted in favour of autonomy; however, it was not granted.[7]''

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zakarpattia_Oblast#Zakarpattia_in_independent_Ukraine

    Fun fact
    Rusyn diasporas in America and Canada have seperate religious organizations from Ukrainians


    ''Many Rusyn Americans left Catholicism for Eastern Orthodoxy in the 19th century due to disputes with the Latin Church bishops, who viewed different practices in the Byzantine Rite (such as married clergy) with suspicion.


    St Nicholas Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Church, Jacobs Creek Pennsylvania, USA
    Another large segment of Rusyn Americans belong to the American Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Diocese, which is headquartered in Johnstown, Pennsylvania. From its early days, this group was recognized by the Ecumenical Patriarchate as a self-governing diocese.''

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rusyns#Religion

    I guess all of them are ''KGB implants''

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. Hack, @AP

    Married clergy actually makes sense if one supports eugenic fertility since it allows clergy, who typically come from a society’s more intelligent population, to breed (or at least breed more). Religion should embrace such a eugenic policy instead of shunning away from it. At least religious people could claim that preventing abortions of Down’s syndrome fetuses saves lives; here, there’s no similar reason/justification for them to support a public policy with dysgenic effects.

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    Clergy used to be intelligent in the past as they often were the only literate men in the region. However that is not true today, so I'm not sure if modern clergymen have higher intelligence than other sectors.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  699. @LT1488
    @Mr. Hack

    Rusyn autonomy is very popular though and Ukraine refuses to give it to them
    Here is an article from Wikipedia
    ''Zakarpattia in independent Ukraine
    After the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991, Ukraine held an independence referendum in which the residents of Zakarpattia were asked about the Zakarpattia Oblast Council's proposal for self-rule.[7] About 78% of the oblast's population voted in favour of autonomy; however, it was not granted.[7]''

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zakarpattia_Oblast#Zakarpattia_in_independent_Ukraine

    Fun fact
    Rusyn diasporas in America and Canada have seperate religious organizations from Ukrainians


    ''Many Rusyn Americans left Catholicism for Eastern Orthodoxy in the 19th century due to disputes with the Latin Church bishops, who viewed different practices in the Byzantine Rite (such as married clergy) with suspicion.


    St Nicholas Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Church, Jacobs Creek Pennsylvania, USA
    Another large segment of Rusyn Americans belong to the American Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Diocese, which is headquartered in Johnstown, Pennsylvania. From its early days, this group was recognized by the Ecumenical Patriarchate as a self-governing diocese.''

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rusyns#Religion

    I guess all of them are ''KGB implants''

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. Hack, @AP

    Do you know how many voters in Zakarpattya took part in the oblast council’s referendum, which by the way was held on the very same day as the general referendum of Ukrainian independence? Sounds a little bit fishy to me. As some independent researchers have concluded:

    One survey by Jordan and Klemencic inquired: “To what country should Transcarpathia belong?” Over 60 percent of those who considered themselves to be Ukrainian or Rusyn-Ukrainian viewed the region as an integral part of Ukraine. Only ten percent of Ukrainians and seven percentof Rusyn-Ukrainians preferred an independent Trans-Carpathia. Even among Rusyns the survey found that they were divided. Forty percent of the small number who considered themselves to be a separate Rusyn people supported independent statehood. Nearly the same number, 37 percent, favoured maintaining Trans-Carpathia as part of Ukraine. Separatism is not alive and well in Trans-Carpathia.

    Jordan and Klemencic, “Transcarpathia,” 503.

    I think that the ability to create a separate Rusyn state has more chance of success in Pennsylvania than in Zakarpattya.

    • Agree: AP
  700. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @LT1488

    Have you ever heard Peter Levenda's spiel about the Ukraine Orthodox in the Bronx in the 1960's? It is pretty entertaining if you have not. CIA + JFK assassination characters. I can not testify to if it's factual.

    Replies: @LT1488

    Yes I have heard of them, however I’m not sure exactly as to how true it is.

  701. @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    Does Transylvania perform better academically (such as on the PISA exam) than the rest of Romania does?

    Ex-Austrian Poles perform better academically than Poles in the rest of Poland do:

    https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0147596718305006

    Not sure why since Prussia also had a top-notch educational system which made almost all of their Poles literate. Ex-Prussian Poles, even in areas that did not involve mass migration, do not appear to perform better academically than Poles in the rest of Poland do.

    Prussia was actually more successful at promoting literacy among Poles than Austria was, who in turn was more successful at promoting literacy among Poles than Russia was:

    https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S0147596718305006-gr2.jpg

    Replies: @LT1488, @AP

    Can’t find data on PISA scores, but on economy, HDI, foreign investments and overall quality of life is much higher in Translyvania than in Wallachia or Moldavia regions.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    Yep, this is accurate:

    xxxhttps://www.reddit.com/r/Maps/comments/a73tjz/map_of_development_in_romania_2017/

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Romanian_regions_by_Human_Development_Index

    In Romania, other than Bucharest (the Romanian capital), there's a clear pattern that the areas that were under Hapsburg rule for a longer time period are more developed than the ones that weren't. Transylvania is ahead of Oltenia, which in turn is ahead of the rest of Romania other than Bucharest. (Bukovina was also under Austro-Hungarian rule but apparently isn't large/populous enough to affect the HDI score for Moldavia too much.)

    For GDP, it's a slightly more complex picture:

    https://qph.cf2.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-184336671f4edede1f12ff7bc1c8c68f-pjlq

    The wealthiest parts appear to be Bucharest, Transylvania, the coast, and Iasi, in that order. But eastern Transylvania seems like it's roughly as poor as Moldavia is.

    Replies: @LT1488

  702. @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    Married clergy actually makes sense if one supports eugenic fertility since it allows clergy, who typically come from a society's more intelligent population, to breed (or at least breed more). Religion should embrace such a eugenic policy instead of shunning away from it. At least religious people could claim that preventing abortions of Down's syndrome fetuses saves lives; here, there's no similar reason/justification for them to support a public policy with dysgenic effects.

    Replies: @LT1488

    Clergy used to be intelligent in the past as they often were the only literate men in the region. However that is not true today, so I’m not sure if modern clergymen have higher intelligence than other sectors.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    Even if clergy are nowadays average in intelligence, it would still benefit society in having them reproduce vs. not reproduce. It still counters dysgenic trends and creates a larger total population for the society.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  703. Dire report from the Empire State Manufacturing Index.

    https://mishtalk.com/economics/empire-state-manufacturing-index-stunning-drop-to-43-7-new-orders-49-4/

    Worst New Orders reading ever, worse than the financial crisis of 08.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @LondonBob

    At the moment, growth in the US economy is driven by real estate, the real estate industry is driven by debt and debt growth is driven by low interest rates combined with inflation.

    In the southern part of the US, I see a lot of low end housing constructed largely by illegal immigrant labor. I have a hunch the market for this housing is in fact the illegal immigrant population, but I don't know what particular subsidies exist to close that loop.

    Once illegal immigration is staunched the next growth industry will be deportation.

  704. What the neocons have wanted to do to Russia, Hamas has done to Israel.

    Bogged down in war of attrition and occupation they are losing.
    Very real loss of image regarding military strength.
    Reservists called up with a real strain on society and the economy.
    Diplomatically isolated and moral pariah across the world.
    Trade embargo imposing real costs.

    • Replies: @A123
    @LondonBob

    What IslamoGloboHomo wanted to do in Ukraine, indigenous Palestinians Jews are doing to Hamas.

    • Winning 20:1 versus terrorists
    • Having the enemy cut off from resupply, thus winning by attrition
    • Releasing reservists back to the civilian economy
    • Reducing the enemy to futile PR gestures, such as non-courts with no jurisdiction


    Trade embargo imposing real costs.
     
    There is no focused embargo on Palestinian Jews. Are you talking about the Iranian Houthi closure of the Red Sea to everyone's container ships?

    The big losers there are Asian exporters, notably China. How long will Xi tolerate Khamenei’s proxy interrupting CCP commerce? Iran is in a terrible position. They can alienate their primary oil buyer, or appear weak by reeling in their Houthi proxy.

    Iran's fearful flailing has set off a border conflict with Pakistan. There is significant internal strife over water and excessive violence by "morality" enforcers. The no longer particularly Revolutionary Guard is engaged in base capitalism via their Stated Owned Enterprises. There are many reasons to believe that Khamenei will the last Ayatollah.

    PEACE 😇
  705. @Hyperborean
    Iran has recently struck targets in Syria, Iraq and Pakistan by firing missiles from Iran.

    The strike in Syria was against the Turkestan Islamic Party, the Iraq one in Erbil against "Mossad spies" (a Kurdish businessman and the Pakistan one against Jaish al-Adl (a Sunni Baloch terrorist group).

    The attack against the TIP makes sense, if the intent was to demonstrate the range of Iranian missiles.

    However, the strikes in Iraq and Pakistan don't seem to have actually been cleared with these governments (yesterday pro-IRGC accounts made clowns of themselves by claiming this attack was a joint operation with Pakistan). In Pakistan they misfired and killed two civilian girls with several other girls wounded.

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/jan/17/iran-hails-strikes-in-pakistan-as-it-is-warned-of-serious-consequences

    https://www.france24.com/en/middle-east/20240116-iran-launch-ballistic-missile-attacks-a-terrorist-targets-in-iraq-syria

    Clashes have apparently broken out on the Iran-Pakistan border with Jaish al-Adl attacking a convoy, a checkpoint and a car carrying an IRGC colonel. Three deaths so far, including the IRGC.

    Granted this last part is from Telegram, so I'll wait for more official news. I understand there is a need to respond to the Kerman bombing, but with the geopolitical situation as it is and the randomness of it, I don't see how picking a fight in Pakistan makes sense for Iran.

    Replies: @German_reader, @Hyperborean

    Clashes have apparently broken out on the Iran-Pakistan border with Jaish al-Adl attacking a convoy, a checkpoint and a car carrying an IRGC colonel. Three deaths so far, including the IRGC.

    So Pakistan carried out retaliatory strikes in Iran and arrested two Iranian agents in Karachi. Chinese mediation not working so far.

    Pakistan Military statement on strikes inside Iran:

    Pakistan’s strikes into Iran used “killer drones, rockets, loitering munitions and stand-off weapons” says a Pakistani military statement on its strikes today.

    The official media wing of military statement added that “Pakistan Armed Forces remain in a perpetual state of readiness to ensure safety of Pakistan citizens against acts of terrorism.”

    […]

    Pakistan military spokesman reveals names of the terrorists targeted in attacks inside Iran:

    The statement maintained that targeted hideouts were being used by notorious terrorists including Dosta alias Chairman, Bajjar alias Soghat, Sahil, alias Shafaq, Asghar alias Basham and Wazir alias Wazi, amongst others.

    I’ll admit I have no idea who these people are supposed to be. But it is a bizarre situation, Iran and Pakistan are both attacking terrorist groups within each other’s borders, while claiming to avoid harm to government forces.

    I get why they’re doing it, the Pakistanis don’t want to establish a precedent that India can take advantage of in the future. But it is still bizarre.

    I don’t think they are intentionally angling for war with each other, but this is the sort of situation that could easily go wrong.

    The Taliban of all people are joining the call for de-escalation.

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @Hyperborean


    I don’t think they are intentionally angling for war with each other, but this is the sort of situation that could easily go wrong.
     
    You said it as if Iranians and Pakis starting smacking each other for real would be something bad;)

    Replies: @Hyperborean

  706. Antiracist/equalizer propagandists suck at their work, when it’s only from Hanania threads you discover that the author of Three Musketeers and Count of Monte Cristo was a negro by modern standards like Pushkin, lol

    His father, technically “”only half” negro 19th century French general, pictured below:

    • Replies: @Hyperborean
    @sudden death


    Antiracist/equalizer propagandists suck at their work, when it’s only from Hanania threads you discover that the author of Three Musketeers and Count of Monte Cristo was a negro by modern standards like Pushkin, lol
     
    I thought his origins were pretty well known? But I've always thought the American one-drop rule to be weird. I've always liked more the Spanish imperial guidelines of having a name for every possible racial combination.

    Alexandre Dumas père seems respectably swarthy.

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/06/Alexander_Dumas_p%C3%A8re_par_Nadar_-_Google_Art_Project.jpg/640px-Alexander_Dumas_p%C3%A8re_par_Nadar_-_Google_Art_Project.jpg

    But Alexandre Dumas fils, is he also black?

    https://www.myartprints.co.uk/kunst/leon_joseph_florentin_bonnat/alexandre-dumas-fils.jpg

    Then there's historical African American accomplishment lists where they include people like

    Norris Wright Cuney, holder of the "highest-ranking appointed position of any African American in the late 19th-century South".

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/3/31/Norris_Wright_Cuney.jpg

    Or

    Walter F. White - Leader of the NAACP, 1929-1955.

    https://images.nypl.org/index.php?id=5027558&t=w

    https://www.npr.org/2022/03/30/1089640442/how-one-civil-rights-activist-posed-as-a-white-man-in-order-to-investigate-lynch

    "Posing as white", kek.

    Replies: @sudden death

    , @songbird
    @sudden death

    I feel like the anti-racists are often too tepid.

    Color me cynical, but it doesn't really feel like they are trying to fight racism ideologically, but rather just promulgate and maintain some alliance against Euros.

    For example, they will say something like, "Haley too brown for racist GOP in Iowa." But they will never mention her mudshark daughter, or say "DNC welcomes Indians who want their daughters to miscegenate with blacks. We want more Kamalas and to eliminate castes."

  707. @Hyperborean
    @Hyperborean


    Clashes have apparently broken out on the Iran-Pakistan border with Jaish al-Adl attacking a convoy, a checkpoint and a car carrying an IRGC colonel. Three deaths so far, including the IRGC.
     
    So Pakistan carried out retaliatory strikes in Iran and arrested two Iranian agents in Karachi. Chinese mediation not working so far.

    Pakistan Military statement on strikes inside Iran:

    Pakistan's strikes into Iran used "killer drones, rockets, loitering munitions and stand-off weapons" says a Pakistani military statement on its strikes today.

    The official media wing of military statement added that "Pakistan Armed Forces remain in a perpetual state of readiness to ensure safety of Pakistan citizens against acts of terrorism."

    [...]

    Pakistan military spokesman reveals names of the terrorists targeted in attacks inside Iran:

    The statement maintained that targeted hideouts were being used by notorious terrorists including Dosta alias Chairman, Bajjar alias Soghat, Sahil, alias Shafaq, Asghar alias Basham and Wazir alias Wazi, amongst others.
     
    I'll admit I have no idea who these people are supposed to be. But it is a bizarre situation, Iran and Pakistan are both attacking terrorist groups within each other's borders, while claiming to avoid harm to government forces.

    I get why they're doing it, the Pakistanis don't want to establish a precedent that India can take advantage of in the future. But it is still bizarre.

    I don't think they are intentionally angling for war with each other, but this is the sort of situation that could easily go wrong.

    The Taliban of all people are joining the call for de-escalation.

    Replies: @sudden death

    I don’t think they are intentionally angling for war with each other, but this is the sort of situation that could easily go wrong.

    You said it as if Iranians and Pakis starting smacking each other for real would be something bad;)

    • Replies: @Hyperborean
    @sudden death


    You said it as if Iranians and Pakis starting smacking each other for real would be something bad;)
     
    It's not the deaths that I care about, it's the instability that it brings to the broader Middle Eastern situation at an already tense moment.

    Let's assume for the sake of the argument Iran and Pakistan end up going to war. Israel then gets emboldened and uses the situation to try and eliminate Hezbollah. Iran is then put in a difficult position so they escalate against Israel and the USA even though they are at war with Pakistan because they feel they can't afford to look weak. Et cetera.

    Replies: @sudden death, @A123

  708. @sudden death
    @Hyperborean


    I don’t think they are intentionally angling for war with each other, but this is the sort of situation that could easily go wrong.
     
    You said it as if Iranians and Pakis starting smacking each other for real would be something bad;)

    Replies: @Hyperborean

    You said it as if Iranians and Pakis starting smacking each other for real would be something bad;)

    It’s not the deaths that I care about, it’s the instability that it brings to the broader Middle Eastern situation at an already tense moment.

    Let’s assume for the sake of the argument Iran and Pakistan end up going to war. Israel then gets emboldened and uses the situation to try and eliminate Hezbollah. Iran is then put in a difficult position so they escalate against Israel and the USA even though they are at war with Pakistan because they feel they can’t afford to look weak. Et cetera.

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @Hyperborean

    Serious smackdown of Iran by Pakistan-Israel coalition would be beautiful to look at, lol
    On a more serious note, wonder what India would in such case as they seem to like Israel's ongoing smackdown on Gazans;)

    , @A123
    @Hyperborean

    When is the last time Khamenei has had public dialogue that was not pre-scripted?

    Khamenei is almost surely better off healthwise than the Veggie-In-Chief, but that is quite a low bar. He has had a long run by enthusiastically suppressing rivals. But, that leaves the situation without an strong successor.

    A "hot war" would be a good mechanism for Iranians to 100% internally replace the theocracy with military rule. And, the border with Pakistan is comfortably far away from Tehran. Hmmm....

    PEACE 😇

  709. @Hyperborean
    @sudden death


    You said it as if Iranians and Pakis starting smacking each other for real would be something bad;)
     
    It's not the deaths that I care about, it's the instability that it brings to the broader Middle Eastern situation at an already tense moment.

    Let's assume for the sake of the argument Iran and Pakistan end up going to war. Israel then gets emboldened and uses the situation to try and eliminate Hezbollah. Iran is then put in a difficult position so they escalate against Israel and the USA even though they are at war with Pakistan because they feel they can't afford to look weak. Et cetera.

    Replies: @sudden death, @A123

    Serious smackdown of Iran by Pakistan-Israel coalition would be beautiful to look at, lol
    On a more serious note, wonder what India would in such case as they seem to like Israel’s ongoing smackdown on Gazans;)

    • Troll: LondonBob
  710. @sudden death
    Antiracist/equalizer propagandists suck at their work, when it's only from Hanania threads you discover that the author of Three Musketeers and Count of Monte Cristo was a negro by modern standards like Pushkin, lol

    His father, technically ""only half" negro 19th century French general, pictured below:

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GEEzEJjWcAAH9aB.jpg

    Replies: @Hyperborean, @songbird

    Antiracist/equalizer propagandists suck at their work, when it’s only from Hanania threads you discover that the author of Three Musketeers and Count of Monte Cristo was a negro by modern standards like Pushkin, lol

    I thought his origins were pretty well known? But I’ve always thought the American one-drop rule to be weird. I’ve always liked more the Spanish imperial guidelines of having a name for every possible racial combination.

    Alexandre Dumas père seems respectably swarthy.

    But Alexandre Dumas fils, is he also black?

    Then there’s historical African American accomplishment lists where they include people like

    Norris Wright Cuney, holder of the “highest-ranking appointed position of any African American in the late 19th-century South”.

    Or

    Walter F. White – Leader of the NAACP, 1929-1955.

    https://images.nypl.org/index.php?id=5027558&t=w

    https://www.npr.org/2022/03/30/1089640442/how-one-civil-rights-activist-posed-as-a-white-man-in-order-to-investigate-lynch

    “Posing as white”, kek.

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @Hyperborean

    Dumas with his hair reminds Don King somewhat;)

    https://images.sportsbrief.com/images/720/8f4a4a961afe790c.webp

    Have no idea about affairs in France, but maybe in US antiracist discourse he's not that widely promoted not only for being foreigner, but also because of bit inconvenient fact about having collaborating white ghostwriter Auguste Maquet in all his most known popular books?

    Replies: @Hyperborean

  711. @songbird
    @Mr. Hack

    Most likely, the bird people would still be after you. But you are okay in my book.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    Actually, I’m on pretty good terms with the bird people (here they’re called pigeons), even though I wish that they’d leave my backyard alone. They’re a messy and persistent group that act like vultures when it coms to food scavenging. There’s an interesting back and forth war game going on between “the cats” and “the pigeons”. Actually, both groups are rather tame now and leave each other alone.

    A funny thing occurred recently. Sometimes, I’ll leave my back sliding door open in order to lure my cats indoors. One time, a pigeon made his way in…and one cat too. They both got tangled up in my window curtain, however even though they were less than a foot apart, the cat did not attack the pigeon! Did you know that pigeons enjoy eating all sorts of flesh? They always manage to clean out any crumbs left inside of cat food cans.

    • Replies: @songbird
    @Mr. Hack

    One of my cousins in Ireland used to raise pidgeons as a hobby. My mother was over there once and she picked up the phone, and a man said something like, "Have you released him yet?" (He was referring to a racing pigeon.)

    Cats supposedly kill between 1.3-4 billion birds every year in America. Oddly enough, I don't remember any of the family cats ever grabbing a bird. But snakes and mice, yes.

    The bird people I was referring to were of course bird-watchers.

    I have dissected a pigeon before. I think it was the most interesting animal I ever dissected. Surprising to see all the muscle mass and the stones in the crop.

    I was once walking down a stream and found a big nest of pigeons under a bridge. The stream was not so pristine down there.

    I try not to watch Sci-Show on YouTube because they are super-pozzed, but I did watch the segment they put out recently about synthetic cat pheromones. This is a new product that has come to market. There are different types that you can buy. Some supposedly make cats less agressive towards each other.

    https://youtu.be/lwGZVphV4Pw?si=9aOfCqk2IiJTQuGb

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. Hack, @Mr. Hack

  712. @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    Actually, I'm on pretty good terms with the bird people (here they're called pigeons), even though I wish that they'd leave my backyard alone. They're a messy and persistent group that act like vultures when it coms to food scavenging. There's an interesting back and forth war game going on between "the cats" and "the pigeons". Actually, both groups are rather tame now and leave each other alone.

    A funny thing occurred recently. Sometimes, I'll leave my back sliding door open in order to lure my cats indoors. One time, a pigeon made his way in...and one cat too. They both got tangled up in my window curtain, however even though they were less than a foot apart, the cat did not attack the pigeon! Did you know that pigeons enjoy eating all sorts of flesh? They always manage to clean out any crumbs left inside of cat food cans.

    https://i.ytimg.com/vi/CYr3Psqh32Q/hqdefault.jpg

    Replies: @songbird

    One of my cousins in Ireland used to raise pidgeons as a hobby. My mother was over there once and she picked up the phone, and a man said something like, “Have you released him yet?” (He was referring to a racing pigeon.)

    [MORE]

    Cats supposedly kill between 1.3-4 billion birds every year in America. Oddly enough, I don’t remember any of the family cats ever grabbing a bird. But snakes and mice, yes.

    The bird people I was referring to were of course bird-watchers.

    I have dissected a pigeon before. I think it was the most interesting animal I ever dissected. Surprising to see all the muscle mass and the stones in the crop.

    I was once walking down a stream and found a big nest of pigeons under a bridge. The stream was not so pristine down there.

    I try not to watch Sci-Show on YouTube because they are super-pozzed, but I did watch the segment they put out recently about synthetic cat pheromones. This is a new product that has come to market. There are different types that you can buy. Some supposedly make cats less agressive towards each other.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @songbird

    Many people consider pigeons to be flying rats. A different group says the baby pigeon (squab) is very tasty. I guess the cat didn't get the memo.

    During my childhood, most of the cats in the family killed birds. They become captivated by the prey while hunting.

    , @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    Flippity fish even has a small built in pouch that can be filled with catnip:

    https://youtu.be/JpBEkmVnCVM

    Replies: @LondonBob

    , @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    We had an old Ukie in the neighborhood that used to raise homing pigeons. His nephew would invite me over and in between smoking cigarettes we'd go up on the roof of the two story house and watch them inside of their wire cages. Occasionally, old Yurko would let one out and give us a big thrill. This was all very close to down town Mpls. I think that there was an old Byelorussian in the neighborhood too that raised such pigeons. Don't get me started, I'll end up telling you about the Ukrainian speaking Romanian (whose wife was a real gypsy) who had a little monkey holed up in his house. He would accompany the little critter with his accordian playing old time european tunes. Ah, such precious memories, thanks for helping to conjure them up in my mind this morning (sounds a bit Fellinesque, eh?). :-)

    Replies: @songbird

  713. @Mikel
    @songbird

    Thanks for that link too. Quite dense for me but it does provide some clarifying definitions and follow-on links.


    I wouldn’t necessarily discount the possibility of much longer predictions
     
    I have to disagree here. The reason why weather predictions are all over the place past the 10-15 day window is not for lack of data or computing power/speed. It's because of the nature of how fluids (or any other chaotic system) behave over time. Lorentz's example of the flap of the wings of a butterfly causing a hurricane on the other side of the world is not be taken literally but in these systems minute differences in initial conditions of comparable magnitude do give rise to exponentially disparate outcomes as time progresses so prediction becomes impossible. I don't see how AI could overcome this essential problem.

    but people have been talking about it since at least the ’70s
     
    That's when Nixon declared his war on cancer too. But it's still a leading cause of death and not too much progress has been done really. Most metastatic cancers continue to be incurable and there's no way to detect most of them before they reach that stage. And yet AK seems to think that we're going to cure aging, a more intractable problem that would imply curing cancer among many other deadly diseases (or else we would continue dying of the same causes and there wouldn't be any life extension), in the coming decades. I do have some hopes of living enough to see those limited successes they've had with mouse models translated to humans but De Grey's "longevity escape velocity" ideas (that I've seen AK base his predictions on) look far too optimistic.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @songbird

    That’s when Nixon declared his war on cancer too. But it’s still a leading cause of death and not too much progress has been done really.

    Well, “War” is certainly hyperbolic rhetoric, but people are living longer nowadays, so that leads to more cancers.

    [MORE]

    I have known several people who kicked the bucket due to cancer. One quite tragic case, where it killed all the women in the family, and two very young, and one a new mother.

    But I have also known people who survived who would have died, if not for the progress that has been made. Survival rates of some common cancers like breast and bowel have doubled since the ’70s. (Of course, colonoscopies should only be given to people with a family history of such things – and I suspect it might be related to gay politics the movent to popularize them, often somewhat forcefully).

    Granted, I still think the idea of power stations in space is quite fantastical, there seems to be some reason to be cautiously optimistic about space.

    There has been enormous growth recently in mass to orbit, and we haven’t seen it top off yet. And a lot of new rockets are coming on-line soon.

    • Replies: @Mikel
    @songbird


    Well, “War” is certainly hyperbolic rhetoric, but people are living longer nowadays, so that leads to more cancers.
     
    Good point. But I'm sure they were hoping to get much further than we are half a century later. Like the goal you still hear of turning cancer into a treatable chronic condition. But the more they study the disease, the more elusive they find it is. I read that hopes of cataloguing genetically all cancers to be able to target their signature genes are vanishing as they discover that the bastards even change their genetic composition over time so you'd be shooting at a moving target. They're shifting mutants.

    Of course, colonoscopies should only be given to people with a family history of such things
     
    I understand the feeling but, after listening to Peter Attia, that I got acquainted with thanks to Emil, I've come around to the idea that, dreary as it sounds, frequent colonoscopies are the only way of preventing that leading cause of mortality. Apparently, colon cancer never develops without first going through the polyp phase, which is when they can easily extirpate it of they find it in a colonoscopy. But it can do it in as little as 1 or 2 years, so the current screening protocols only make sense from a cost perspective. It should definitely be an optional procedure though, no discussion there. No free man on this planet should ever be forced to go though such an ignoble violation of his body against his will.
  714. @LondonBob
    Dire report from the Empire State Manufacturing Index.

    https://mishtalk.com/economics/empire-state-manufacturing-index-stunning-drop-to-43-7-new-orders-49-4/

    Worst New Orders reading ever, worse than the financial crisis of 08.

    Replies: @QCIC

    At the moment, growth in the US economy is driven by real estate, the real estate industry is driven by debt and debt growth is driven by low interest rates combined with inflation.

    In the southern part of the US, I see a lot of low end housing constructed largely by illegal immigrant labor. I have a hunch the market for this housing is in fact the illegal immigrant population, but I don’t know what particular subsidies exist to close that loop.

    Once illegal immigration is staunched the next growth industry will be deportation.

  715. @songbird
    @Mr. Hack

    One of my cousins in Ireland used to raise pidgeons as a hobby. My mother was over there once and she picked up the phone, and a man said something like, "Have you released him yet?" (He was referring to a racing pigeon.)

    Cats supposedly kill between 1.3-4 billion birds every year in America. Oddly enough, I don't remember any of the family cats ever grabbing a bird. But snakes and mice, yes.

    The bird people I was referring to were of course bird-watchers.

    I have dissected a pigeon before. I think it was the most interesting animal I ever dissected. Surprising to see all the muscle mass and the stones in the crop.

    I was once walking down a stream and found a big nest of pigeons under a bridge. The stream was not so pristine down there.

    I try not to watch Sci-Show on YouTube because they are super-pozzed, but I did watch the segment they put out recently about synthetic cat pheromones. This is a new product that has come to market. There are different types that you can buy. Some supposedly make cats less agressive towards each other.

    https://youtu.be/lwGZVphV4Pw?si=9aOfCqk2IiJTQuGb

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. Hack, @Mr. Hack

    Many people consider pigeons to be flying rats. A different group says the baby pigeon (squab) is very tasty. I guess the cat didn’t get the memo.

    During my childhood, most of the cats in the family killed birds. They become captivated by the prey while hunting.

  716. @sudden death
    Antiracist/equalizer propagandists suck at their work, when it's only from Hanania threads you discover that the author of Three Musketeers and Count of Monte Cristo was a negro by modern standards like Pushkin, lol

    His father, technically ""only half" negro 19th century French general, pictured below:

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GEEzEJjWcAAH9aB.jpg

    Replies: @Hyperborean, @songbird

    I feel like the anti-racists are often too tepid.

    Color me cynical, but it doesn’t really feel like they are trying to fight racism ideologically, but rather just promulgate and maintain some alliance against Euros.

    For example, they will say something like, “Haley too brown for racist GOP in Iowa.” But they will never mention her mudshark daughter, or say “DNC welcomes Indians who want their daughters to miscegenate with blacks. We want more Kamalas and to eliminate castes.”

  717. @songbird
    @Mr. Hack

    One of my cousins in Ireland used to raise pidgeons as a hobby. My mother was over there once and she picked up the phone, and a man said something like, "Have you released him yet?" (He was referring to a racing pigeon.)

    Cats supposedly kill between 1.3-4 billion birds every year in America. Oddly enough, I don't remember any of the family cats ever grabbing a bird. But snakes and mice, yes.

    The bird people I was referring to were of course bird-watchers.

    I have dissected a pigeon before. I think it was the most interesting animal I ever dissected. Surprising to see all the muscle mass and the stones in the crop.

    I was once walking down a stream and found a big nest of pigeons under a bridge. The stream was not so pristine down there.

    I try not to watch Sci-Show on YouTube because they are super-pozzed, but I did watch the segment they put out recently about synthetic cat pheromones. This is a new product that has come to market. There are different types that you can buy. Some supposedly make cats less agressive towards each other.

    https://youtu.be/lwGZVphV4Pw?si=9aOfCqk2IiJTQuGb

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. Hack, @Mr. Hack

    Flippity fish even has a small built in pouch that can be filled with catnip:

    • Replies: @LondonBob
    @Mr. Hack

    I find the habitat of Americans keeping house cats very strange, ours have always gone out all night, much happier and healthy they are for it. No need for such toys.

    Replies: @QCIC

  718. @LondonBob
    What the neocons have wanted to do to Russia, Hamas has done to Israel.

    Bogged down in war of attrition and occupation they are losing.
    Very real loss of image regarding military strength.
    Reservists called up with a real strain on society and the economy.
    Diplomatically isolated and moral pariah across the world.
    Trade embargo imposing real costs.

    Replies: @A123

    What IslamoGloboHomo wanted to do in Ukraine, indigenous Palestinians Jews are doing to Hamas.

    • Winning 20:1 versus terrorists
    • Having the enemy cut off from resupply, thus winning by attrition
    • Releasing reservists back to the civilian economy
    • Reducing the enemy to futile PR gestures, such as non-courts with no jurisdiction

    Trade embargo imposing real costs.

    There is no focused embargo on Palestinian Jews. Are you talking about the Iranian Houthi closure of the Red Sea to everyone’s container ships?

    The big losers there are Asian exporters, notably China. How long will Xi tolerate Khamenei’s proxy interrupting CCP commerce? Iran is in a terrible position. They can alienate their primary oil buyer, or appear weak by reeling in their Houthi proxy.

    Iran’s fearful flailing has set off a border conflict with Pakistan. There is significant internal strife over water and excessive violence by “morality” enforcers. The no longer particularly Revolutionary Guard is engaged in base capitalism via their Stated Owned Enterprises. There are many reasons to believe that Khamenei will the last Ayatollah.

    PEACE 😇

  719. @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    Does Transylvania perform better academically (such as on the PISA exam) than the rest of Romania does?

    Ex-Austrian Poles perform better academically than Poles in the rest of Poland do:

    https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0147596718305006

    Not sure why since Prussia also had a top-notch educational system which made almost all of their Poles literate. Ex-Prussian Poles, even in areas that did not involve mass migration, do not appear to perform better academically than Poles in the rest of Poland do.

    Prussia was actually more successful at promoting literacy among Poles than Austria was, who in turn was more successful at promoting literacy among Poles than Russia was:

    https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S0147596718305006-gr2.jpg

    Replies: @LT1488, @AP

    The very high literacy rates in former Prussian lands were mostly due to ethnic Germans.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Polish illiteracy could not have been more than 10% or so in the former German parts of Poland since otherwise the numbers wouldn't make sense. There was 92+% literacy in almost all of ex-German Poland, including in areas that were 80+% Polish, such as in Posen Province:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/be/Sprachen_Provinz_Posen_1910.svg/800px-Sprachen_Provinz_Posen_1910.svg.png

    Upper Silesia also contained some 80+% Polish areas, albeit with some of these Poles being politically loyal to Germany rather than to Poland:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a8/Sprachen_in_Schlesien_1905_06.svg/1920px-Sprachen_in_Schlesien_1905_06.svg.png

    (They still ended up in Poland either after WWI or after WWII, unless they subsequently emigrated back home to Germany, of course.)

    It's primarily West Prussia were 80+% Polish areas (even if one counts Kashubians as Polish) did not exist on a large level:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a9/Sprachen_Westpreussen_en.svg/1280px-Sprachen_Westpreussen_en.svg.png

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

  720. @songbird
    @Mr. Hack

    One of my cousins in Ireland used to raise pidgeons as a hobby. My mother was over there once and she picked up the phone, and a man said something like, "Have you released him yet?" (He was referring to a racing pigeon.)

    Cats supposedly kill between 1.3-4 billion birds every year in America. Oddly enough, I don't remember any of the family cats ever grabbing a bird. But snakes and mice, yes.

    The bird people I was referring to were of course bird-watchers.

    I have dissected a pigeon before. I think it was the most interesting animal I ever dissected. Surprising to see all the muscle mass and the stones in the crop.

    I was once walking down a stream and found a big nest of pigeons under a bridge. The stream was not so pristine down there.

    I try not to watch Sci-Show on YouTube because they are super-pozzed, but I did watch the segment they put out recently about synthetic cat pheromones. This is a new product that has come to market. There are different types that you can buy. Some supposedly make cats less agressive towards each other.

    https://youtu.be/lwGZVphV4Pw?si=9aOfCqk2IiJTQuGb

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. Hack, @Mr. Hack

    We had an old Ukie in the neighborhood that used to raise homing pigeons. His nephew would invite me over and in between smoking cigarettes we’d go up on the roof of the two story house and watch them inside of their wire cages. Occasionally, old Yurko would let one out and give us a big thrill. This was all very close to down town Mpls. I think that there was an old Byelorussian in the neighborhood too that raised such pigeons. Don’t get me started, I’ll end up telling you about the Ukrainian speaking Romanian (whose wife was a real gypsy) who had a little monkey holed up in his house. He would accompany the little critter with his accordian playing old time european tunes. Ah, such precious memories, thanks for helping to conjure them up in my mind this morning (sounds a bit Fellinesque, eh?). 🙂

    • Replies: @songbird
    @Mr. Hack

    Sounds like you have known a lot of curious characters. Have never even seen a monkey on the streets, that I can recall, only in zoos, and I suspect they would arrest someone with one today.

    I found this old story about a pigeon racing the internet in South Africa interesting:
    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/8248056.stm

    Of course, that was a long time ago. (2009) Not sure what the experience is today, though I understand that a lot of servers aren't in South Africa, but in places like Malaysia. If we have any South Africans, would be curious about their experience.

    Don't believe I have ever seen one of Fellini's films. Only old Italian movies I recall watching are Black Sabbath (I quite liked the story about the wurdulac, but didn't care much for the others) , The Bicycle Thief (which is a favorite of critics and directors), and Planet of the Vampires (which was influential on Alien and an episode or two or Star Trek). (You can see my interests run towards the fantastical.)
    _________
    I like the idea for this solar plane mission to Venus. I hope it becomes a reality, provided the price tag isn't too high:

    https://www.universetoday.com/165122/nasa-selects-a-sample-return-mission-to-venus/#more-165122

    Replies: @AP, @Emil Nikola Richard

  721. @Hyperborean
    @sudden death


    You said it as if Iranians and Pakis starting smacking each other for real would be something bad;)
     
    It's not the deaths that I care about, it's the instability that it brings to the broader Middle Eastern situation at an already tense moment.

    Let's assume for the sake of the argument Iran and Pakistan end up going to war. Israel then gets emboldened and uses the situation to try and eliminate Hezbollah. Iran is then put in a difficult position so they escalate against Israel and the USA even though they are at war with Pakistan because they feel they can't afford to look weak. Et cetera.

    Replies: @sudden death, @A123

    When is the last time Khamenei has had public dialogue that was not pre-scripted?

    Khamenei is almost surely better off healthwise than the Veggie-In-Chief, but that is quite a low bar. He has had a long run by enthusiastically suppressing rivals. But, that leaves the situation without an strong successor.

    A “hot war” would be a good mechanism for Iranians to 100% internally replace the theocracy with military rule. And, the border with Pakistan is comfortably far away from Tehran. Hmmm….

    PEACE 😇

  722. @LT1488
    @Mr. Hack

    Rusyn autonomy is very popular though and Ukraine refuses to give it to them
    Here is an article from Wikipedia
    ''Zakarpattia in independent Ukraine
    After the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991, Ukraine held an independence referendum in which the residents of Zakarpattia were asked about the Zakarpattia Oblast Council's proposal for self-rule.[7] About 78% of the oblast's population voted in favour of autonomy; however, it was not granted.[7]''

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zakarpattia_Oblast#Zakarpattia_in_independent_Ukraine

    Fun fact
    Rusyn diasporas in America and Canada have seperate religious organizations from Ukrainians


    ''Many Rusyn Americans left Catholicism for Eastern Orthodoxy in the 19th century due to disputes with the Latin Church bishops, who viewed different practices in the Byzantine Rite (such as married clergy) with suspicion.


    St Nicholas Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Church, Jacobs Creek Pennsylvania, USA
    Another large segment of Rusyn Americans belong to the American Carpatho-Russian Orthodox Diocese, which is headquartered in Johnstown, Pennsylvania. From its early days, this group was recognized by the Ecumenical Patriarchate as a self-governing diocese.''

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rusyns#Religion

    I guess all of them are ''KGB implants''

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. Hack, @AP

    Rusyn autonomy is very popular though and Ukraine refuses to give it to them
    Here is an article from Wikipedia
    ”Zakarpattia in independent Ukraine
    After the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991

    Who wouldn’t have wanted autonomy from the Soviet government in 1991?

    Fun fact
    Rusyn diasporas in America and Canada have seperate religious organizations from Ukrainians

    Hungarian rule in Zakarpatya meant very high illiteracy. This shielded the Rusyns there from Ukrainian nation-building efforts, which by the late 19th century resulted in a rather literate, Ukrainian nationalist population in Galicia.

    The immigrants to the USA avoiding Ukrainian organizations reflected these circumstances.

    The Russian self-identification and conversion to Orthodoxy was in large part the result of aggressive funding by the pre-Soviet Russian government.

    :::::::::

    In post-Soviet Ukrainian Zakarpatya, about 1% of the Eastern Slavs consider themselves to belong to a separate nation than the Ukrainian one. The Alaska Independence Party has more support in Alaska, than Rusyn independence has in Zakarpatya.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaskan_Independence_Party

    Across the border in Slovakia, the Rusyn identity was rather actively promoted. About 2/3 of the Eastern Slavs there consider themselves to be a separate nation from Ukrainians and about 1/3 consider themselves to be Ukrainians. In terms of alternative history for Mr. XYZ, this suggests that if Zakarpatya would have been returned to Czechoslovakia after World War II, there would be an independent Ruthenia (after Czechs and Slovaks split), about 40% of whose population would consider themselves to be ethnic Ukrainians. (it would be more than 1/3 because there were pockets of Ukrainian nationalists in Eastern Zakarpatya).

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @AP


    The Russian self-identification and conversion to Orthodoxy was in large part the result of aggressive funding by the pre-Soviet Russian government.
     
    You're very correct in pointing this out. I lived only a couple of blocks away from the historic ROC cathedral in Minneapolis, St. Mary's Orthodox Cathedral (formerly known and consecrated as St. Mary's Russian Orthodox Cathedral). Bishop Alexis Toth was sent to North America to help establish the ROC and at about the same time a large donation made by Czar Alexander was made to help build the new and extravagant cathedral. In Minneapolis at that time (late 1890's), there were mostly "Rusyns" from both Slovakia and Galicia, and many were attracted by the beautiful Orthodox symbolism to be found within this new cathedral. It became in effect a new center to help proselytize these new poor immigrants to the Russian cultural cause. Bishop Toth's proselytizing talents were utilized in Pennsylvania too, where he was finally laid to rest. Today, no longer able to conceal the Rusyn and not Russian origins of the parish, the church is not a part of the ROC, but has reverted to the Orthodox Church of America. It still remains a spectacular testament to Orthodoxy and is worth a visit if ever you visit Mpls.

    https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-gG89Ntn/0/XL/i-gG89Ntn-XL.jpg
    https://stmarysoca.org/
  723. @Beckow
    @German_reader

    Ok, so Germany ships Taurus missiles and Kiev fires them at Crimea or Moscow. They either work or not, but let's say there is massive damage. At that point if Russia takes out downtown Lviv, Vinnitsa or Kiev (they can do it), what exactly would the West complain about? Dead invite more dead...read Greek tragedies or Shakespeare...

    The problem with escalation is that it empowers the stronger side - at this point nobody doubts that Russia has regional dominance, they are stronger. Nudging Russia to use all it has is a very bad strategy - that's how we got to this mess. And there is a non-zero chance that if Tauruses happen and there is escalation Germans would also be hit - maybe the troops in Lithuania or something secondary. Is that what Germany wants?

    Kiev needs to make peace. If they don't they will be forced to make much worse peace in not so distant future. (Or it can go to the ultimate weapons...come to think of it, why not? what are we holding on to?)

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AP

    Yesterday the Russians did a long range missile [?] attack on French mercs after France announces long range missiles for the Ukraine.

    https://www.france24.com/en/europe/20240118-russia-says-targeted-french-mercenaries-in-long-range-strike-on-ukraine-s-kharkiv

    https://www.thedefensepost.com/2024/01/17/france-long-range-missiles-ukraine/

    Putin must read Beckow’s comments is the first thing I thought. We know NSA bots read Beckow’s comments. : )

    Isn’t Kharkov practically on the front line?

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    Yesterday the Russians did a long range missile [?] attack on French mercs after France announces long range missiles for the Ukraine.
     
    Reportedly ~60 French soldiers were killed and ~20 wounded. However, we are unlikely to learn real casualty numbers among Western scum serving Ukraine: Western military does not want the public to know, and obsequious Western lugenpresse “reports” accordingly.

    BTW, did you see the "news" alleging that two US Navy SEALs drowned in the Red see under very murky circumstances? We should remember that you can easily “drown in the Red sea” while being in a hotel in Kharkov targeted by Russians.

    Isn’t Kharkov practically on the front line?
     
    Not yet. All in good time.

    Replies: @Beckow

  724. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Beckow

    Yesterday the Russians did a long range missile [?] attack on French mercs after France announces long range missiles for the Ukraine.

    https://www.france24.com/en/europe/20240118-russia-says-targeted-french-mercenaries-in-long-range-strike-on-ukraine-s-kharkiv

    https://www.thedefensepost.com/2024/01/17/france-long-range-missiles-ukraine/

    Putin must read Beckow's comments is the first thing I thought. We know NSA bots read Beckow's comments. : )

    Isn't Kharkov practically on the front line?

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    Yesterday the Russians did a long range missile [?] attack on French mercs after France announces long range missiles for the Ukraine.

    Reportedly ~60 French soldiers were killed and ~20 wounded. However, we are unlikely to learn real casualty numbers among Western scum serving Ukraine: Western military does not want the public to know, and obsequious Western lugenpresse “reports” accordingly.

    BTW, did you see the “news” alleging that two US Navy SEALs drowned in the Red see under very murky circumstances? We should remember that you can easily “drown in the Red sea” while being in a hotel in Kharkov targeted by Russians.

    Isn’t Kharkov practically on the front line?

    Not yet. All in good time.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN


    ...Reportedly ~60 French soldiers were killed and ~20 wounded.
     
    I am not sure about that story. If Russia could have done this before, why didn't they? Was Lira kept at the facility? The story suggests that they have local informers or electronic intercepts, but the precision sounds like human sources. Or it could be made up. It's a war, all is fair...

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

  725. @Beckow
    @German_reader

    Ok, so Germany ships Taurus missiles and Kiev fires them at Crimea or Moscow. They either work or not, but let's say there is massive damage. At that point if Russia takes out downtown Lviv, Vinnitsa or Kiev (they can do it), what exactly would the West complain about? Dead invite more dead...read Greek tragedies or Shakespeare...

    The problem with escalation is that it empowers the stronger side - at this point nobody doubts that Russia has regional dominance, they are stronger. Nudging Russia to use all it has is a very bad strategy - that's how we got to this mess. And there is a non-zero chance that if Tauruses happen and there is escalation Germans would also be hit - maybe the troops in Lithuania or something secondary. Is that what Germany wants?

    Kiev needs to make peace. If they don't they will be forced to make much worse peace in not so distant future. (Or it can go to the ultimate weapons...come to think of it, why not? what are we holding on to?)

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AP

    Kiev needs to make peace

    With whom? Russia only agrees to “peace” in the form of loss of Ukrainian statehood. So calls for Kiev to make peace are nothing more than demands that Ukrainians abandon their country’s independence. It’s like demanding Czechoslovakia or Poland to make peace with Germany in 1938-1939. Czechs went for it, but Ukrainians are not 1939 Czechs.

    • Replies: @A123
    @AP



    Kiev needs to make peace
     
    With whom? Russia only agrees to “peace” in the form of loss of Ukrainian statehood.
     
    This was untrue the first time you said it, and it remains equally untrue now.

    Russia would accept a peace the prevents Kiev aggression from starting a "Round 2". Critical is not repeating the 8+ years where Ukrainian misconduct spun up the "Round 1" mess that led to the SMO.

    The current land bridge line provides water and security for Russians in Crimea. A wide DMZ and limits on Kiev offense rearmament would not conflict with Ukrainian statehood. Such essential measures would simply head off Kiev's irrational aggression from starting another war a few years down the line.

    Ukraine's statehood could, and presumably would, pursue EU membership and other Western economic integration. Only NATO and military misadventures would be prohibited by the deal (armistice or treaty).

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @AP

    , @Beckow
    @AP

    You can parade your infantile boastfulness and ancient myths all you want, this is a completely new situation: Kiev is losing a war they didn't have to fight over membership in Nato and language rights for its 10-million Russian minority.

    They can go on, more dead and destruction, at the end Russia will win. Longer it takes, the worse the deal will be for two reasons:
    - Russia has added territorial security to its goals - meaning a wide demilitarized buffer
    - Kiev will be weaker.

    Ukie statehood is a slogan, you can read into it whatever you want. Are Latin American countries states? Or the Euro Nato vassals? It has always been like that - you don't get to point missiles at a stronger neighbor and ally with their sworn enemies and argue that it is your statehood right...it is not that complicated.

  726. @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    We had an old Ukie in the neighborhood that used to raise homing pigeons. His nephew would invite me over and in between smoking cigarettes we'd go up on the roof of the two story house and watch them inside of their wire cages. Occasionally, old Yurko would let one out and give us a big thrill. This was all very close to down town Mpls. I think that there was an old Byelorussian in the neighborhood too that raised such pigeons. Don't get me started, I'll end up telling you about the Ukrainian speaking Romanian (whose wife was a real gypsy) who had a little monkey holed up in his house. He would accompany the little critter with his accordian playing old time european tunes. Ah, such precious memories, thanks for helping to conjure them up in my mind this morning (sounds a bit Fellinesque, eh?). :-)

    Replies: @songbird

    Sounds like you have known a lot of curious characters. Have never even seen a monkey on the streets, that I can recall, only in zoos, and I suspect they would arrest someone with one today.

    [MORE]

    I found this old story about a pigeon racing the internet in South Africa interesting:
    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/8248056.stm

    Of course, that was a long time ago. (2009) Not sure what the experience is today, though I understand that a lot of servers aren’t in South Africa, but in places like Malaysia. If we have any South Africans, would be curious about their experience.

    Don’t believe I have ever seen one of Fellini’s films. Only old Italian movies I recall watching are Black Sabbath (I quite liked the story about the wurdulac, but didn’t care much for the others) , The Bicycle Thief (which is a favorite of critics and directors), and Planet of the Vampires (which was influential on Alien and an episode or two or Star Trek). (You can see my interests run towards the fantastical.)
    _________
    I like the idea for this solar plane mission to Venus. I hope it becomes a reality, provided the price tag isn’t too high:

    https://www.universetoday.com/165122/nasa-selects-a-sample-return-mission-to-venus/#more-165122

    • Replies: @AP
    @songbird

    Many states in the American Midwest allow full freedom for animal ownership. I knew someone who as a child had a pet monkey that would chase squirrels into trees and kill them. This must have been a horror movie nightmare for the poor squirrels!

    The South is rather free also. There is now a population of feral macaques in the Florida wilderness. Released pets, I think.

    Replies: @songbird

    , @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    In order to train a monkey to be an organ grinder performer you first have to beat the hell out of it for dozens of training sessions. It was a poor man's trade. It is easier to go on welfare or be a homeless bum.

  727. @songbird
    @Mikel


    That’s when Nixon declared his war on cancer too. But it’s still a leading cause of death and not too much progress has been done really.
     
    Well, "War" is certainly hyperbolic rhetoric, but people are living longer nowadays, so that leads to more cancers.

    I have known several people who kicked the bucket due to cancer. One quite tragic case, where it killed all the women in the family, and two very young, and one a new mother.

    But I have also known people who survived who would have died, if not for the progress that has been made. Survival rates of some common cancers like breast and bowel have doubled since the '70s. (Of course, colonoscopies should only be given to people with a family history of such things - and I suspect it might be related to gay politics the movent to popularize them, often somewhat forcefully).

    Granted, I still think the idea of power stations in space is quite fantastical, there seems to be some reason to be cautiously optimistic about space.

    There has been enormous growth recently in mass to orbit, and we haven't seen it top off yet. And a lot of new rockets are coming on-line soon.

    Replies: @Mikel

    Well, “War” is certainly hyperbolic rhetoric, but people are living longer nowadays, so that leads to more cancers.

    Good point. But I’m sure they were hoping to get much further than we are half a century later. Like the goal you still hear of turning cancer into a treatable chronic condition. But the more they study the disease, the more elusive they find it is. I read that hopes of cataloguing genetically all cancers to be able to target their signature genes are vanishing as they discover that the bastards even change their genetic composition over time so you’d be shooting at a moving target. They’re shifting mutants.

    Of course, colonoscopies should only be given to people with a family history of such things

    I understand the feeling but, after listening to Peter Attia, that I got acquainted with thanks to Emil, I’ve come around to the idea that, dreary as it sounds, frequent colonoscopies are the only way of preventing that leading cause of mortality. Apparently, colon cancer never develops without first going through the polyp phase, which is when they can easily extirpate it of they find it in a colonoscopy. But it can do it in as little as 1 or 2 years, so the current screening protocols only make sense from a cost perspective. It should definitely be an optional procedure though, no discussion there. No free man on this planet should ever be forced to go though such an ignoble violation of his body against his will.

    • Agree: songbird
  728. @AP
    @LT1488


    Rusyn autonomy is very popular though and Ukraine refuses to give it to them
    Here is an article from Wikipedia
    ”Zakarpattia in independent Ukraine
    After the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991
     
    Who wouldn’t have wanted autonomy from the Soviet government in 1991?

    Fun fact
    Rusyn diasporas in America and Canada have seperate religious organizations from Ukrainians
     
    Hungarian rule in Zakarpatya meant very high illiteracy. This shielded the Rusyns there from Ukrainian nation-building efforts, which by the late 19th century resulted in a rather literate, Ukrainian nationalist population in Galicia.

    The immigrants to the USA avoiding Ukrainian organizations reflected these circumstances.

    The Russian self-identification and conversion to Orthodoxy was in large part the result of aggressive funding by the pre-Soviet Russian government.

    :::::::::

    In post-Soviet Ukrainian Zakarpatya, about 1% of the Eastern Slavs consider themselves to belong to a separate nation than the Ukrainian one. The Alaska Independence Party has more support in Alaska, than Rusyn independence has in Zakarpatya.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaskan_Independence_Party

    Across the border in Slovakia, the Rusyn identity was rather actively promoted. About 2/3 of the Eastern Slavs there consider themselves to be a separate nation from Ukrainians and about 1/3 consider themselves to be Ukrainians. In terms of alternative history for Mr. XYZ, this suggests that if Zakarpatya would have been returned to Czechoslovakia after World War II, there would be an independent Ruthenia (after Czechs and Slovaks split), about 40% of whose population would consider themselves to be ethnic Ukrainians. (it would be more than 1/3 because there were pockets of Ukrainian nationalists in Eastern Zakarpatya).

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    The Russian self-identification and conversion to Orthodoxy was in large part the result of aggressive funding by the pre-Soviet Russian government.

    You’re very correct in pointing this out. I lived only a couple of blocks away from the historic ROC cathedral in Minneapolis, St. Mary’s Orthodox Cathedral (formerly known and consecrated as St. Mary’s Russian Orthodox Cathedral). Bishop Alexis Toth was sent to North America to help establish the ROC and at about the same time a large donation made by Czar Alexander was made to help build the new and extravagant cathedral. In Minneapolis at that time (late 1890’s), there were mostly “Rusyns” from both Slovakia and Galicia, and many were attracted by the beautiful Orthodox symbolism to be found within this new cathedral. It became in effect a new center to help proselytize these new poor immigrants to the Russian cultural cause. Bishop Toth’s proselytizing talents were utilized in Pennsylvania too, where he was finally laid to rest. Today, no longer able to conceal the Rusyn and not Russian origins of the parish, the church is not a part of the ROC, but has reverted to the Orthodox Church of America. It still remains a spectacular testament to Orthodoxy and is worth a visit if ever you visit Mpls.


    https://stmarysoca.org/

  729. @Beckow
    @Mr. Hack

    As so often you know nothing about the actual situation on the ground. In Slovakia and Czechia a large proportion of the recent migrants from Ukraine are Rusyns from Zakarpatia, they consciously identify differently. There is a Rusyn church, university, in Prague they have churches, clubs, restaurants...in my experience most are neutral in the war - you read into it whatever you want.

    Rusyns are distinct people with their own language or dialect, music, history. There is some loose talk to rejoin Czechia, Slovakia or Hungary - to be in EU immediately. But it is very messy and the geography is too remote. They don't like Galicians from over the Carpathian mountains and don't want to be like them, they have no Bandera worship or hatred of Russia. Their preference was to be in a multi-ethnic Ukraine with cultural autonomy - then the dumb Ukie nationalists blew it apart. My sense is that hundreds of thousands of them will stay and assimilate - they are very similar to our Rusyns.

    By the way the previous Czech PM Andrej Babis was from Zakarpathia on his mother's side. We were one country not that long ago.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @AP

    As so often you know nothing about the actual situation on the ground

    Says the guy whose “knowledge” led him to assume that Ukrainians would surrender or flee right away in early 2022.

    Rusyns are distinct people with their own language or dialect, music, history

    Their name is the same and their dialect similar to Galician 150 years ago.

    They don’t like Galicians from over the Carpathian mountains and don’t want to be like them, they have no Bandera worship or hatred of Russia

    This is the closest you come to being truthful.

    A consequence of the Magyars keeping the Rusyns under their control illiterate was that they avoided the nationalization that occurred across the mountains in Galicia and retained their original pre-literate identity. They achieved mass literacy (which brought with it a national identity) in the 1920-1940s, under a patchwork of Ukrainian nationalist, exiled Russian White, and later Soviet Ukrainian teachers (the Soviets ironically Russified central and eastern Ukraine but promoted a pro-Soviet sort of Ukrainianism in Zakarpatya as a strategy against potential Magyar and Czechoslovak claims).

    The result is that these people are not nationalistic like Galicians, not even close, but more like central Ukrainians. Desperate Russian nationalists hope that Zakarpatya is some sort of Donbas or at least Kharkiv, but it is rather another Poltava or Kirovohrad. So not a Bandera-land, but still solidly pro-Ukrainian.

    For example in the 2012 parliamentary election under Yanukovich, 57% of people in Zakarpatya voted for the 3 pro-Western nationalist parties. Factoring in the 10% Hungarian population in the region, over 60% of East Slavs in Zakarpatya voted for pro-Western nationalists.

    8.35% of Zakarpatya voted for the Banderist Svoboda party. That is a lot lower than the 38% in Lviv oblast and 34% in Ivano-Frankivsk oblast right on the other side of the Carpathians. But is is similar to results in Vynnytsia and Poltava. It is higher than the Banderist vote in central regions such as Zhytomir (7.5%).

    BTW the result for Svoboda in 2012 in Zakarpatya (8.35%) was higher than the result for the Slovak National Party in 2023 (5.6%).

    So Zakarpatyans are more “Banderists” than Slovaks are “nationalists.”

  730. @songbird
    @Mr. Hack

    Sounds like you have known a lot of curious characters. Have never even seen a monkey on the streets, that I can recall, only in zoos, and I suspect they would arrest someone with one today.

    I found this old story about a pigeon racing the internet in South Africa interesting:
    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/8248056.stm

    Of course, that was a long time ago. (2009) Not sure what the experience is today, though I understand that a lot of servers aren't in South Africa, but in places like Malaysia. If we have any South Africans, would be curious about their experience.

    Don't believe I have ever seen one of Fellini's films. Only old Italian movies I recall watching are Black Sabbath (I quite liked the story about the wurdulac, but didn't care much for the others) , The Bicycle Thief (which is a favorite of critics and directors), and Planet of the Vampires (which was influential on Alien and an episode or two or Star Trek). (You can see my interests run towards the fantastical.)
    _________
    I like the idea for this solar plane mission to Venus. I hope it becomes a reality, provided the price tag isn't too high:

    https://www.universetoday.com/165122/nasa-selects-a-sample-return-mission-to-venus/#more-165122

    Replies: @AP, @Emil Nikola Richard

    Many states in the American Midwest allow full freedom for animal ownership. I knew someone who as a child had a pet monkey that would chase squirrels into trees and kill them. This must have been a horror movie nightmare for the poor squirrels!

    The South is rather free also. There is now a population of feral macaques in the Florida wilderness. Released pets, I think.

    • Replies: @songbird
    @AP

    Last time I saw a monkey in the zoo, I was quite impressed with its agility and leaping distance.


    I knew someone who as a child had a pet monkey that would chase squirrels into trees and kill them. This must have been a horror movie nightmare for the poor squirrels!
     
    When I was a boy, for school, I once read a book called Summer of the Monkeys about a boy who tries to capture escaped monkeys for the reward. I forget whether it mentioned them eating anything.

    I've probably known people who would rent them out, for such a purpose, as squirrels can be very destructive.

    @Emil

    In order to train a monkey to be an organ grinder performer you first have to beat the hell out of it for dozens of training sessions.
     
    I am mainly interested in the goat-riding variety, as the Romans had and can be found on YouTube.
  731. @songbird
    @Mr. Hack

    Sounds like you have known a lot of curious characters. Have never even seen a monkey on the streets, that I can recall, only in zoos, and I suspect they would arrest someone with one today.

    I found this old story about a pigeon racing the internet in South Africa interesting:
    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/8248056.stm

    Of course, that was a long time ago. (2009) Not sure what the experience is today, though I understand that a lot of servers aren't in South Africa, but in places like Malaysia. If we have any South Africans, would be curious about their experience.

    Don't believe I have ever seen one of Fellini's films. Only old Italian movies I recall watching are Black Sabbath (I quite liked the story about the wurdulac, but didn't care much for the others) , The Bicycle Thief (which is a favorite of critics and directors), and Planet of the Vampires (which was influential on Alien and an episode or two or Star Trek). (You can see my interests run towards the fantastical.)
    _________
    I like the idea for this solar plane mission to Venus. I hope it becomes a reality, provided the price tag isn't too high:

    https://www.universetoday.com/165122/nasa-selects-a-sample-return-mission-to-venus/#more-165122

    Replies: @AP, @Emil Nikola Richard

    In order to train a monkey to be an organ grinder performer you first have to beat the hell out of it for dozens of training sessions. It was a poor man’s trade. It is easier to go on welfare or be a homeless bum.

  732. @AP
    @Beckow


    Kiev needs to make peace
     
    With whom? Russia only agrees to “peace” in the form of loss of Ukrainian statehood. So calls for Kiev to make peace are nothing more than demands that Ukrainians abandon their country’s independence. It’s like demanding Czechoslovakia or Poland to make peace with Germany in 1938-1939. Czechs went for it, but Ukrainians are not 1939 Czechs.

    Replies: @A123, @Beckow

    Kiev needs to make peace

    With whom? Russia only agrees to “peace” in the form of loss of Ukrainian statehood.

    This was untrue the first time you said it, and it remains equally untrue now.

    Russia would accept a peace the prevents Kiev aggression from starting a “Round 2”. Critical is not repeating the 8+ years where Ukrainian misconduct spun up the “Round 1” mess that led to the SMO.

    The current land bridge line provides water and security for Russians in Crimea. A wide DMZ and limits on Kiev offense rearmament would not conflict with Ukrainian statehood. Such essential measures would simply head off Kiev’s irrational aggression from starting another war a few years down the line.

    Ukraine’s statehood could, and presumably would, pursue EU membership and other Western economic integration. Only NATO and military misadventures would be prohibited by the deal (armistice or treaty).

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @AP
    @A123

    Deputy chairman of Russia’s security council:

    Why Ukraine is dangerous for its inhabitants.

    The existence of Ukraine is mortally dangerous for Ukrainians. And I don’t mean only the current state, Bandera’s political regime. I'm talking about any, absolutely any Ukraine.

    Why?
    The presence of an independent state on historical Russian lands will now be a constant reason for the resumption of hostilities.

    It's too late. No matter who is at the helm of the cancerous growth under the name of Ukraine, this will not add legitimacy to his rule and the legal viability of the “country” itself. And, therefore, the likelihood of a new battle will persist indefinitely. Almost always.

    Moreover, there is a 100% probability of a new conflict, no matter what security papers the West signs with the puppet Kyiv regime. Neither Ukraine’s association with the EU, nor even the entry of this artificial country into NATO will prevent it. This could happen in ten or fifty years.

    That is why the existence of Ukraine is fatal for Ukrainians. They are practical people at the end of the day. No matter how they now wish the Russians to die. No matter how much they hate the Russian leadership. No matter how much they strive to join the mythical European Union and NATO.

    Choosing between eternal war and inevitable death and life, the vast majority of Ukrainians (well, perhaps with the exception of a minimal number of out-of-touch nationalists) will ultimately choose life.

    They will understand that life in a large common state, which they do not like very much now, is better than death. Their deaths and the deaths of their loved ones. And the sooner Ukrainians realize this, the better.”

    Replies: @A123, @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

  733. @Mikel
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    I couldn't agree more.

    The other day Google decided that what I really need in every search I do is Spanish language results. I must have visited some Spanish-language website or something, and their "intelligent" algorithms, perhaps trained to apply cultural-sensitive filters, only gave me Spanish trash for every search I tried. I set my language and region, which were undefined, to the US but it didn't make any difference. Google knew better than me what I needed. For several days the only way to get English results in my searches was to modify the URL and append ?lang=en. Finally, they must have realized that I really meant "give me English results please" and the problem is gone for now.

    The existing AI systems have such a steep learning curve ahead that AK's talk of an impending singularity making his previous ideology obsolete sounds like a laughable cope. I used to have intellectual respect for him. His Covid-19 prediction was impressive. But I can't take him seriously anymore.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Negronicus

    Let him go. He belong to the streets now.

  734. @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    Flippity fish even has a small built in pouch that can be filled with catnip:

    https://youtu.be/JpBEkmVnCVM

    Replies: @LondonBob

    I find the habitat of Americans keeping house cats very strange, ours have always gone out all night, much happier and healthy they are for it. No need for such toys.

    • Agree: LT1488
    • Replies: @QCIC
    @LondonBob

    In many suburban areas of the US cats and some dogs are now prey for coyotes.

    As people have fewer kids and live longer, the pet as substitute friend becomes more precious so people are overly protective.

    Replies: @songbird

  735. One of the very few things Scott Ritter has got wrong about the war was Gonzalo Lira, shame he hasn’t apologised yet, as far as I am aware.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @LondonBob


    One of the very few things Scott Ritter has got wrong about the war was Gonzalo Lira, shame he hasn’t apologised yet, as far as I am aware.
     
    Let me remind you that Kiev regime is not monolithic, it’s a snake pit. In and of itself the fact that Lira was essentially murdered by regime functionaries does not mean that he was not working for a competing group within the same regime. Most likely, neither we, nor Scott Ritter will learn the truth (unless Russians capture relevant documents and publish them).

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    , @John Johnson
    @LondonBob

    One of the very few things Scott Ritter has got wrong about the war was Gonzalo Lira, shame he hasn’t apologised yet, as far as I am aware.

    Other than the video where he claimed the war was over a few weeks after it started?

    I guess you also missed the dozen or so videos where he said Ukraine was about to be crushed.

    His prediction on GAZA was that the Hamas tunnels would give IDF hell.

    What happened is that the IDF simply blew them up.

    Ritter also predicted a massive battle where Hamas fighters would use hit and run attacks to blow up IDF tanks. In reality the older RPGs from Iran proved to be useless against trophy armor. It was pretty much a walk-in for the IDF.

    Prediction: Ritter will scrub his Hamas videos just like he did with earlier Ukraine videos.

    Replies: @Sean

  736. @LT1488
    @AP

    Hungarians are not hated by most slavic eastern europeans
    Poles,Russians, Czechs, Croats etc like the Hungarians and Poles even consider them their brothers.
    Slovaks and Serbs have some issues with the Magyars, but the current Slovak and Serbian leadership is very friendly with the current Magyar leadership.
    As for other neighbouring eastern Europeans, the Romanians indeed do not like Hungary and haven't even allowed their Hungarian minority right to autonomy. And as for Ukraine, as you said, the Hungarian minority's rights to speak and learn Hungarian are being infringed upon.
    I do not know where you got this logic of slavs and other eastern europeans intensely disliking Hungary when the opposite is true.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    Hungarians are not hated by most slavic eastern europeans
    Poles,Russians, Czechs, Croats etc like the Hungarians and Poles even consider them their brothers

    Poles no longer like Hungarians.

    https://notesfrompoland.com/2023/03/27/poles-dislike-of-russians-belarusians-hungarians-and-germans-has-grown-amid-war-finds-study/

    “Apart from Russians, the largest decline in positive sentiment was recorded towards Hungarians, who fell 21 percentage points from 57% to 36%”

    And as for Ukraine, as you said, the Hungarian minority’s rights to speak and learn Hungarian are being infringed upon

    I didn’t say that.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    “Apart from Russians, the largest decline in positive sentiment was recorded towards Hungarians, who fell 21 percentage points from 57% to 36%”

     

    Do Poles dislike all of these peoples for their attitude towards Ukraine? Granted, it seems like the Germans are the least deserving of dislike from Poles, but maybe Poles simply remember Germans' long history of appeasement towards Russia even if Germany is now taking a harder line on Russia. But why aren't Poles souring on the French as much, who have also historically been Russia appeasers? Positive ancestral memories of France (passed on via oral storytelling to the next generations) from both World Wars?
    , @LT1488
    @AP

    It seems that the Poles change their opinion on everything every year
    https://www.cnn.com/2023/10/13/europe/poland-ukraine-tensions-election-cmd-intl/index.html
    Last year there were the biggest promoters of Ukrainians, this year they do not seem to be that enthusiastic.
    I assume once the war stagnates even further and things return to 2016-2022 era, Poles will have a positive opinion on Hungary again.

    Replies: @AP

  737. @LondonBob
    One of the very few things Scott Ritter has got wrong about the war was Gonzalo Lira, shame he hasn't apologised yet, as far as I am aware.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @John Johnson

    One of the very few things Scott Ritter has got wrong about the war was Gonzalo Lira, shame he hasn’t apologised yet, as far as I am aware.

    Let me remind you that Kiev regime is not monolithic, it’s a snake pit. In and of itself the fact that Lira was essentially murdered by regime functionaries does not mean that he was not working for a competing group within the same regime. Most likely, neither we, nor Scott Ritter will learn the truth (unless Russians capture relevant documents and publish them).

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AnonfromTN

    I don't watch any Ritter videos since early 2022. I find him repetitious. I read his blog post. The way I read that is that Lira was useful or he would not have been released after his first arrest. And I thought he said unambiguously that this was true even if only he was unwittingly useful as a person to watch closely and record who contacted him. If Ritter accused Lira of being a paid accomplice I missed it.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

  738. @Mr. XYZ
    @Sean

    Spending less on defense doesn't necessarily mean that Russia is going to become less of an autocracy. It would be less hostile towards the West, of course, though probably not being willing to be the West's tool either in regards to China, et cetera.

    Replies: @Sean

    Why Kiev thought any regime in the Kremli–even a democratic one–might ultimately brook Ukraine becoming aligned with Washington is mysterious to me. That Putin’s modern version of Tsarist military autocracy would allow it in the end is a truly catastrophic failure of statecraft. Was the idea that Putin would put morality over other considerations, if so Ukraine ought to have borne in mind that the Russian leadership are under no obligation whatsoever to put their nation’s security interests as they saw them in second place to the democratic free choices of an entirely separate country.

    I think America thinks Russia will ultimately see China as being in being in too much propinquity for any kind of partnership, unless America aids Ukraine to totally defeat the Russian invasion. In my view Washington’s desired outcome is for Russia to win a limited and rather pyrrhic victory over Ukraine. European freeloading on the US (even Britain has long cut its defence capabilitiesn order to balance budget without taxes until now it is unable to really contribute) makes trouble with Russia a diversion. Against China, the US’s only solid ally with military and naval might is Japan.

  739. @A123
    @AP



    Kiev needs to make peace
     
    With whom? Russia only agrees to “peace” in the form of loss of Ukrainian statehood.
     
    This was untrue the first time you said it, and it remains equally untrue now.

    Russia would accept a peace the prevents Kiev aggression from starting a "Round 2". Critical is not repeating the 8+ years where Ukrainian misconduct spun up the "Round 1" mess that led to the SMO.

    The current land bridge line provides water and security for Russians in Crimea. A wide DMZ and limits on Kiev offense rearmament would not conflict with Ukrainian statehood. Such essential measures would simply head off Kiev's irrational aggression from starting another war a few years down the line.

    Ukraine's statehood could, and presumably would, pursue EU membership and other Western economic integration. Only NATO and military misadventures would be prohibited by the deal (armistice or treaty).

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @AP

    Deputy chairman of Russia’s security council:

    Why Ukraine is dangerous for its inhabitants.

    The existence of Ukraine is mortally dangerous for Ukrainians. And I don’t mean only the current state, Bandera’s political regime. I’m talking about any, absolutely any Ukraine.

    Why?
    The presence of an independent state on historical Russian lands will now be a constant reason for the resumption of hostilities.

    It’s too late. No matter who is at the helm of the cancerous growth under the name of Ukraine, this will not add legitimacy to his rule and the legal viability of the “country” itself. And, therefore, the likelihood of a new battle will persist indefinitely. Almost always.

    Moreover, there is a 100% probability of a new conflict, no matter what security papers the West signs with the puppet Kyiv regime. Neither Ukraine’s association with the EU, nor even the entry of this artificial country into NATO will prevent it. This could happen in ten or fifty years.

    That is why the existence of Ukraine is fatal for Ukrainians. They are practical people at the end of the day. No matter how they now wish the Russians to die. No matter how much they hate the Russian leadership. No matter how much they strive to join the mythical European Union and NATO.

    Choosing between eternal war and inevitable death and life, the vast majority of Ukrainians (well, perhaps with the exception of a minimal number of out-of-touch nationalists) will ultimately choose life.

    They will understand that life in a large common state, which they do not like very much now, is better than death. Their deaths and the deaths of their loved ones. And the sooner Ukrainians realize this, the better.”

    • Thanks: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @A123
    @AP


    Deputy chairman of Russia’s security council:
     
    How many elected officials are there?
    How many chairs and ministers under these officials?
    How many deputies under the ministers and chairmen?

    In any sufficiently large group you can find a small number of people saying unwise things. In politics this count is often higher as they play to domestic constituencies. Is what this deputy said helpful? Of course not. However, your panicked over reaction to a deputy is also unhelpful.

    There is no reason to believe this is Putin's (and thus Russia's) official policy.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @sudden death

    , @QCIC
    @AP

    Putin was socializing a similar idea in a recent speech, saying something along the lines of "Ukraine will cease to exist." He doesn't mean kill everyone, he means remove Ukraine's geopolitical autonomy to protect Ukrainians from themselves and the West. The main reason is to protect Russia, but since many in the Kremlin see Ukraine as essentially Russian these issues are intertwined.

    The West seems insanely committed to the plan of injuring Russia at any cost to Ukraine. With this in mind, the comments by the Deputy Chairman are probably accurate. The recent increase in the Russian tempo makes me wonder if they want to wrap this up in 2024. Considering their constraints this seems too soon.

    Replies: @AP

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Sounds a lot like Nazi rhetoric, no?

  740. @AnonfromTN
    @LondonBob


    One of the very few things Scott Ritter has got wrong about the war was Gonzalo Lira, shame he hasn’t apologised yet, as far as I am aware.
     
    Let me remind you that Kiev regime is not monolithic, it’s a snake pit. In and of itself the fact that Lira was essentially murdered by regime functionaries does not mean that he was not working for a competing group within the same regime. Most likely, neither we, nor Scott Ritter will learn the truth (unless Russians capture relevant documents and publish them).

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    I don’t watch any Ritter videos since early 2022. I find him repetitious. I read his blog post. The way I read that is that Lira was useful or he would not have been released after his first arrest. And I thought he said unambiguously that this was true even if only he was unwittingly useful as a person to watch closely and record who contacted him. If Ritter accused Lira of being a paid accomplice I missed it.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    The way I read that is that Lira was useful or he would not have been released after his first arrest.
     
    I don’t watch or read Scott Ritter at all. Don’t need to: I get my info directly from the people who live in Russia and remaining Ukraine.

    My guess why Lira was released and then rearrested and helped to die is more prosaic. There are two defining features of all Kiev regime functionaries, from the clown to the lowliest clerk: corruption and cowardice. I guess when he was arrested the first time, he was released because someone got scared of his US citizenship. Most likely before the second arrest Ukie authorities got explicit message from Washington that it’s OK to jail him and help him die.
  741. @Mikel
    @John Johnson


    DeSantis should quit.
     
    To give way to the candidate in 3rd position that he has nothing in common with. You wish.

    It's probably more important than ever that DeSantis stays in the race (unless Haley quits too). The last thing we need if Trump doesn't make it to November is no MAGAs in the race and a Nikki leading in delegates after Trump. The fact that she polls so well among liberals is the very reason why no one should vote for her. Forget those polls and put your signature here instead: https://nevernikki.net/

    Replies: @John Johnson

    DeSantis should quit.

    To give way to the candidate in 3rd position that he has nothing in common with. You wish.

    It’s a suggestion based on data and not wishes. Haley polls better with independents.

    If the goal is to remove Biden then Haley is the answer and not DeSantis. The data is resounding clear on that.

    Those that want a second coming of Trump of course don’t want Haley. But Trump running is Biden’s best chance.

    The last thing we need if Trump doesn’t make it to November is no MAGAs in the race and a Nikki leading in delegates after Trump. The fact that she polls so well among liberals is the very reason why no one should vote for her.

    She doesn’t poll well with liberals. I cited a poll showing that she polls well with moderate Democrats. Liberals are not moderate Democrats.

    There is no reason to believe that Trump would govern any different than Haley. For all of his talk he mostly governed like a mainstream Republican. All he had to do was close the border but his fans seem to think he needs two terms to do it. Well he turned down a good deal from Schumer early in his presidency and never got his wall built. I voted for him twice but I don’t buy for one second that he is some type of rebel against the establishment. He may sell that image but his actual policies suggest he will buckle under pressure. When he moved to DC he joined the establishment. He ditched Bannon and let the swamp talk him into tax cuts for the rich. Bannon wanted tax cuts only for the middle class and Trump fired him. Why do the wealthy need tax cuts? It’s such a stupid policy.

    Trump has become a cult of personality. His MAGA followers are uninterested in looking at his actual policy decisions. They are also uninterested in reading about the documents case as they tell themselves it is political in origin when Trump really f-cked up on his own. He is on tape trying to cover it up. The rape in the department case smells of BS but the take home documents really is a felony violation.

    • Replies: @A123
    @John Johnson

    Have you checked the Polls recently? (1) (2)

    Trump +1.6% over Biden
    Haley +0.4% over Biden

    By your logic, Haley should drop out because Trump is polling better than her. But we all know as a #NeverTrump zealot, you will make up some excuse.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.realclearpolling.com/polls/president/general/2024/trump-vs-biden

    (2) https://www.realclearpolling.com/polls/president/general/2024/haley-vs-biden

    Replies: @John Johnson

    , @Mikel
    @John Johnson


    If the goal is to remove Biden then Haley is the answer
     
    The goal is to remove Biden and replace with someone better not worse.

    Haley has been calling for war with Iran and her position on immigration is basically open borders:

    "Anyone willing to work hard, abide by our laws, and love our traditions is welcome in our country.” Nikki Haley.

    That's about 2 billion people Nikki wants to welcome in the US. How is that better than Biden's southern border calamity?

    Good try but no, I'll pass. I do understand how much you'd enjoy those videos of missiles blowing up people in Iran though.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ

  742. @AP
    @A123

    Deputy chairman of Russia’s security council:

    Why Ukraine is dangerous for its inhabitants.

    The existence of Ukraine is mortally dangerous for Ukrainians. And I don’t mean only the current state, Bandera’s political regime. I'm talking about any, absolutely any Ukraine.

    Why?
    The presence of an independent state on historical Russian lands will now be a constant reason for the resumption of hostilities.

    It's too late. No matter who is at the helm of the cancerous growth under the name of Ukraine, this will not add legitimacy to his rule and the legal viability of the “country” itself. And, therefore, the likelihood of a new battle will persist indefinitely. Almost always.

    Moreover, there is a 100% probability of a new conflict, no matter what security papers the West signs with the puppet Kyiv regime. Neither Ukraine’s association with the EU, nor even the entry of this artificial country into NATO will prevent it. This could happen in ten or fifty years.

    That is why the existence of Ukraine is fatal for Ukrainians. They are practical people at the end of the day. No matter how they now wish the Russians to die. No matter how much they hate the Russian leadership. No matter how much they strive to join the mythical European Union and NATO.

    Choosing between eternal war and inevitable death and life, the vast majority of Ukrainians (well, perhaps with the exception of a minimal number of out-of-touch nationalists) will ultimately choose life.

    They will understand that life in a large common state, which they do not like very much now, is better than death. Their deaths and the deaths of their loved ones. And the sooner Ukrainians realize this, the better.”

    Replies: @A123, @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

    Deputy chairman of Russia’s security council:

    How many elected officials are there?
    How many chairs and ministers under these officials?
    How many deputies under the ministers and chairmen?

    In any sufficiently large group you can find a small number of people saying unwise things. In politics this count is often higher as they play to domestic constituencies. Is what this deputy said helpful? Of course not. However, your panicked over reaction to a deputy is also unhelpful.

    There is no reason to believe this is Putin’s (and thus Russia’s) official policy.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @A123

    That deputy also happens to be former RF official president like Putin;)

  743. @John Johnson
    @Mikel


    DeSantis should quit.
     
    To give way to the candidate in 3rd position that he has nothing in common with. You wish.

    It's a suggestion based on data and not wishes. Haley polls better with independents.

    If the goal is to remove Biden then Haley is the answer and not DeSantis. The data is resounding clear on that.

    Those that want a second coming of Trump of course don't want Haley. But Trump running is Biden's best chance.

    The last thing we need if Trump doesn’t make it to November is no MAGAs in the race and a Nikki leading in delegates after Trump. The fact that she polls so well among liberals is the very reason why no one should vote for her.

    She doesn't poll well with liberals. I cited a poll showing that she polls well with moderate Democrats. Liberals are not moderate Democrats.

    There is no reason to believe that Trump would govern any different than Haley. For all of his talk he mostly governed like a mainstream Republican. All he had to do was close the border but his fans seem to think he needs two terms to do it. Well he turned down a good deal from Schumer early in his presidency and never got his wall built. I voted for him twice but I don't buy for one second that he is some type of rebel against the establishment. He may sell that image but his actual policies suggest he will buckle under pressure. When he moved to DC he joined the establishment. He ditched Bannon and let the swamp talk him into tax cuts for the rich. Bannon wanted tax cuts only for the middle class and Trump fired him. Why do the wealthy need tax cuts? It's such a stupid policy.

    Trump has become a cult of personality. His MAGA followers are uninterested in looking at his actual policy decisions. They are also uninterested in reading about the documents case as they tell themselves it is political in origin when Trump really f-cked up on his own. He is on tape trying to cover it up. The rape in the department case smells of BS but the take home documents really is a felony violation.

    Replies: @A123, @Mikel

    Have you checked the Polls recently? (1) (2)

    Trump +1.6% over Biden
    Haley +0.4% over Biden

    By your logic, Haley should drop out because Trump is polling better than her. But we all know as a #NeverTrump zealot, you will make up some excuse.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.realclearpolling.com/polls/president/general/2024/trump-vs-biden

    (2) https://www.realclearpolling.com/polls/president/general/2024/haley-vs-biden

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @A123

    Trump +1.6% over Biden
    Haley +0.4% over Biden

    By your logic, Haley should drop out because Trump is polling better than her.

    That's weighted by outline polls which are less reliable. Fox News and CBS show her winning by 6/8.

    1.6% would be within the margin of error. So impressed.

    He still has over 30 pending felonies and you are actually excited about a lead by a margin of error.

    Color me skeptical that this is a good idea.

    "Trump will win, you'll see"

    - Every MAGA voter in the last election

    Replies: @A123

  744. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AnonfromTN

    I don't watch any Ritter videos since early 2022. I find him repetitious. I read his blog post. The way I read that is that Lira was useful or he would not have been released after his first arrest. And I thought he said unambiguously that this was true even if only he was unwittingly useful as a person to watch closely and record who contacted him. If Ritter accused Lira of being a paid accomplice I missed it.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    The way I read that is that Lira was useful or he would not have been released after his first arrest.

    I don’t watch or read Scott Ritter at all. Don’t need to: I get my info directly from the people who live in Russia and remaining Ukraine.

    My guess why Lira was released and then rearrested and helped to die is more prosaic. There are two defining features of all Kiev regime functionaries, from the clown to the lowliest clerk: corruption and cowardice. I guess when he was arrested the first time, he was released because someone got scared of his US citizenship. Most likely before the second arrest Ukie authorities got explicit message from Washington that it’s OK to jail him and help him die.

  745. @LondonBob
    One of the very few things Scott Ritter has got wrong about the war was Gonzalo Lira, shame he hasn't apologised yet, as far as I am aware.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @John Johnson

    One of the very few things Scott Ritter has got wrong about the war was Gonzalo Lira, shame he hasn’t apologised yet, as far as I am aware.

    Other than the video where he claimed the war was over a few weeks after it started?

    I guess you also missed the dozen or so videos where he said Ukraine was about to be crushed.

    His prediction on GAZA was that the Hamas tunnels would give IDF hell.

    What happened is that the IDF simply blew them up.

    Ritter also predicted a massive battle where Hamas fighters would use hit and run attacks to blow up IDF tanks. In reality the older RPGs from Iran proved to be useless against trophy armor. It was pretty much a walk-in for the IDF.

    Prediction: Ritter will scrub his Hamas videos just like he did with earlier Ukraine videos.

    • Replies: @Sean
    @John Johnson


    His prediction on GAZA was that the Hamas tunnels would give IDF hell.
     
    Gaza is not a state, it is a part of Israel.

    His prediction on GAZA was that the Hamas tunnels would give IDF hell.

    He is a professional Youtuber, and gets way more views on vids that say Russia is carrying all before it.

    What happened is that the IDF simply blew them up.
     
    On Imo Jima the Americans simply poured gasoline into the tunnels and immolated tens of thousands of Nips.

    Ritter will scrub his Hamas videos just like he did with earlier Ukraine videos.
     
    America needs Russia for a future Chinese Megapower; the US does not want Ukraine to _win_ and that is why a limited Russia victory will suit Washington.
     

     
  746. @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    Clergy used to be intelligent in the past as they often were the only literate men in the region. However that is not true today, so I'm not sure if modern clergymen have higher intelligence than other sectors.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Even if clergy are nowadays average in intelligence, it would still benefit society in having them reproduce vs. not reproduce. It still counters dysgenic trends and creates a larger total population for the society.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    Even if clergy are nowadays average in intelligence, it would still benefit society in having them reproduce vs. not reproduce. It still counters dysgenic trends and creates a larger total population for the society.

    LT1488 is wrong and has not been around the public if he thinks clergy are average. Nearly half of all priests hold a master's degree:
    https://www.zippia.com/priest-jobs/education/

    He has also not been around nuns or priests. Nuns are surprisingly clever and church authorities in general tend to have a sense of humor behind the scenes.

    Clergy are basically middle class social workers. The level of burden they deal with in the US is unreal. US society has a very poor social safety net and the churches are stretched thin.

    Not having them reproduce is most likely dysgenic. However it should be noted that the position also attracts homosexuals and the asexual. Since most US churches are not Catholic I'm not sure of how much of a difference it would make. It would help if we understood how the gay gene worked. I suspect it is like other recessive genes where it can't be bred out as it requires two carriers to express. Basically everyone in the family gets part of it but only with a certain dice role does it express. That is why the Catholic family can get the gay kid but everyone else is not only straight but even strongly so (aggressive brothers early on). The priesthood has long been a way for Catholic families to *cough* help the one kid find his way. He really likes the service. Very spiritual.

    I knew someone that went into the priesthood and society certainly did not miss out on losing his genes. He was hopelessly asexual and was uncomfortable around straight men. He really didn't understand how someone could spend time on women or sports. Television and movies were completely foreign to him. Numerous people in the community tried helping him with various jobs and nothing worked until he entered the priesthood.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  747. @A123
    @John Johnson

    Have you checked the Polls recently? (1) (2)

    Trump +1.6% over Biden
    Haley +0.4% over Biden

    By your logic, Haley should drop out because Trump is polling better than her. But we all know as a #NeverTrump zealot, you will make up some excuse.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.realclearpolling.com/polls/president/general/2024/trump-vs-biden

    (2) https://www.realclearpolling.com/polls/president/general/2024/haley-vs-biden

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Trump +1.6% over Biden
    Haley +0.4% over Biden

    By your logic, Haley should drop out because Trump is polling better than her.

    That’s weighted by outline polls which are less reliable. Fox News and CBS show her winning by 6/8.

    1.6% would be within the margin of error. So impressed.

    He still has over 30 pending felonies and you are actually excited about a lead by a margin of error.

    Color me skeptical that this is a good idea.

    “Trump will win, you’ll see”

    – Every MAGA voter in the last election

    • LOL: A123
    • Replies: @A123
    @John Johnson

    Do you realize that your anti-MAGA cultist, #NeverTrump zealotry actually makes Trump more appealing as a candidate?

    Your fake charges are not working: (1)


    Circumstances aren't looking good for Fani Willis. The Fulton County, Ga., district attorney who has made a personal crusade out of trying to prosecute Donald Trump now has to give account to a judge regarding the allegations that she is in an improper relationship with one of the special counsels she hired for the Trump case.

    "The judge overseeing the election interference case against former president Donald Trump in Georgia has reportedly scheduled a hearing for Feb. 15 to examine recent allegations that Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis and her lead prosecutor 'engaged in an improper relationship and mishandled public money,'” reports Nicole Bennett at WSB Radio.
     
    Those of us who care about MAGA will vote MAGA.

    We are not locked to Trump, but in the 2024 cycle neither DeSantis nor Nikki "Warmonger" Haley make the cut. Haley should switch to the DNC. If you are correct about overwhelming appeal with Leftoids, it would be a great move for her. She is basically a younger version of Liz Cheney.

    PEACE 😇
    ___________

    (1) https://pjmedia.com/chris-queen/2024/01/18/breaking-judge-orders-hearing-on-fani-willis-investigations-n4925615

    Replies: @John Johnson

  748. @Yahya
    @AP


    Princess Monanoke by Miyazaki would be a good start.
     
    I just watched 40 minutes of Princess Monanoke.

    It’s too catered to children, which is not to my taste.

    I much preferred Lord Of The Rings for adventure, which I felt was more adult-oriented.

    Replies: @A123, @Sher Singh, @A123

    An obscure anime option is Blue Gender.

    In the early 21st century, the emergence of an incurable condition known as B-cell growth led some of the affected to become “Sleepers” – people put under stasis until a cure could be found. Yuji Kaido is one such Sleeper who awakens, several decades later, to a horrifying new reality. Giant bugs known as Blue have invaded the Earth, eating everything – and everyone – in sight. Now, all Yuji can do is escape from the city with the ones who saved him from his inevitable death, and make their way towards Second Earth: mankind’s new home in space.

    The YT rip will probably be taken down as a copyright strike. However, you can sample it, then buy if you want a proper quality version.

    PEACE 😇

  749. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    The very high literacy rates in former Prussian lands were mostly due to ethnic Germans.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Polish illiteracy could not have been more than 10% or so in the former German parts of Poland since otherwise the numbers wouldn’t make sense. There was 92+% literacy in almost all of ex-German Poland, including in areas that were 80+% Polish, such as in Posen Province:

    Upper Silesia also contained some 80+% Polish areas, albeit with some of these Poles being politically loyal to Germany rather than to Poland:

    (They still ended up in Poland either after WWI or after WWII, unless they subsequently emigrated back home to Germany, of course.)

    It’s primarily West Prussia were 80+% Polish areas (even if one counts Kashubians as Polish) did not exist on a large level:

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. XYZ

    To clarify, the maps here are of Posen Province, Silesia Province (with Upper Silesia in the east being the blue Polish-majority part), and West Prussia Province of Imperial Germany.

    , @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    I'm not saying the Poles there were illiterate (sorry of I wasn't clear), but that the German population boosted the overall literacy rate there by about 10%-15%. The ethnic Poles there were probably at around the Austrian level of literacy.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  750. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Polish illiteracy could not have been more than 10% or so in the former German parts of Poland since otherwise the numbers wouldn't make sense. There was 92+% literacy in almost all of ex-German Poland, including in areas that were 80+% Polish, such as in Posen Province:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/be/Sprachen_Provinz_Posen_1910.svg/800px-Sprachen_Provinz_Posen_1910.svg.png

    Upper Silesia also contained some 80+% Polish areas, albeit with some of these Poles being politically loyal to Germany rather than to Poland:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a8/Sprachen_in_Schlesien_1905_06.svg/1920px-Sprachen_in_Schlesien_1905_06.svg.png

    (They still ended up in Poland either after WWI or after WWII, unless they subsequently emigrated back home to Germany, of course.)

    It's primarily West Prussia were 80+% Polish areas (even if one counts Kashubians as Polish) did not exist on a large level:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a9/Sprachen_Westpreussen_en.svg/1280px-Sprachen_Westpreussen_en.svg.png

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    To clarify, the maps here are of Posen Province, Silesia Province (with Upper Silesia in the east being the blue Polish-majority part), and West Prussia Province of Imperial Germany.

  751. @LondonBob
    @Mr. Hack

    I find the habitat of Americans keeping house cats very strange, ours have always gone out all night, much happier and healthy they are for it. No need for such toys.

    Replies: @QCIC

    In many suburban areas of the US cats and some dogs are now prey for coyotes.

    As people have fewer kids and live longer, the pet as substitute friend becomes more precious so people are overly protective.

    • Replies: @songbird
    @QCIC

    There is also cat AIDS, of which I very much wish I knew the origin.

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feline_immunodeficiency_virus

    My guesses:
    1.) Cat lady in the state department who was stationed in Nigeria
    2.) Nigerian elites who brought their housecat over.

    Possibly, I may be misattributing it geographically, but it is thought to have had a relatively recent origin in domestic cats.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Emil Nikola Richard

  752. @AP
    @songbird

    Many states in the American Midwest allow full freedom for animal ownership. I knew someone who as a child had a pet monkey that would chase squirrels into trees and kill them. This must have been a horror movie nightmare for the poor squirrels!

    The South is rather free also. There is now a population of feral macaques in the Florida wilderness. Released pets, I think.

    Replies: @songbird

    Last time I saw a monkey in the zoo, I was quite impressed with its agility and leaping distance.

    I knew someone who as a child had a pet monkey that would chase squirrels into trees and kill them. This must have been a horror movie nightmare for the poor squirrels!

    When I was a boy, for school, I once read a book called Summer of the Monkeys about a boy who tries to capture escaped monkeys for the reward. I forget whether it mentioned them eating anything.

    I’ve probably known people who would rent them out, for such a purpose, as squirrels can be very destructive.

    @Emil

    In order to train a monkey to be an organ grinder performer you first have to beat the hell out of it for dozens of training sessions.

    I am mainly interested in the goat-riding variety, as the Romans had and can be found on YouTube.

  753. @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    Even if clergy are nowadays average in intelligence, it would still benefit society in having them reproduce vs. not reproduce. It still counters dysgenic trends and creates a larger total population for the society.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Even if clergy are nowadays average in intelligence, it would still benefit society in having them reproduce vs. not reproduce. It still counters dysgenic trends and creates a larger total population for the society.

    LT1488 is wrong and has not been around the public if he thinks clergy are average. Nearly half of all priests hold a master’s degree:
    https://www.zippia.com/priest-jobs/education/

    He has also not been around nuns or priests. Nuns are surprisingly clever and church authorities in general tend to have a sense of humor behind the scenes.

    Clergy are basically middle class social workers. The level of burden they deal with in the US is unreal. US society has a very poor social safety net and the churches are stretched thin.

    Not having them reproduce is most likely dysgenic. However it should be noted that the position also attracts homosexuals and the asexual. Since most US churches are not Catholic I’m not sure of how much of a difference it would make. It would help if we understood how the gay gene worked. I suspect it is like other recessive genes where it can’t be bred out as it requires two carriers to express. Basically everyone in the family gets part of it but only with a certain dice role does it express. That is why the Catholic family can get the gay kid but everyone else is not only straight but even strongly so (aggressive brothers early on). The priesthood has long been a way for Catholic families to *cough* help the one kid find his way. He really likes the service. Very spiritual.

    I knew someone that went into the priesthood and society certainly did not miss out on losing his genes. He was hopelessly asexual and was uncomfortable around straight men. He really didn’t understand how someone could spend time on women or sports. Television and movies were completely foreign to him. Numerous people in the community tried helping him with various jobs and nothing worked until he entered the priesthood.

    • Thanks: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson

    TBF, wouldn't priesthood be sub-optimal for a gay Catholic man who is primarily into adults? If he's into both adults and minors, and lacks any sense of decent morality, however, then the priesthood seems perfect for him. Or if he's primarily attracted to minors and lacks any sense of decent morality.

    Makes one wonder whether priests should be given the option of voluntary castration. After his affair with Eloise, Pierre Abelard chose surgical castration:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Abelard


    In history and popular culture, he is best known for his passionate and tragic love affair, and intense philosophical exchange, with his brilliant student and eventual wife, Héloïse d'Argenteuil. He was a defender of women and of their education. After having sent Héloïse to a convent in Brittany to protect her from her abusive uncle who did not want her to pursue this forbidden love, he was castrated by men sent by the uncle. Still considering herself as his spouse even though both retired to monasteries after this event, Héloïse publicly defended him when his doctrine was condemned by Pope Innocent II and Abelard considered a heretic. Among these opinions, Abelard professed the innocence of a woman who commits a sin out of love.[7]
     

    Replies: @John Johnson

  754. @AP
    @Beckow


    Than what? Nobody cares about the Poles
     
    Your words:

    "The under-appreciated fact has been the collapse of V4, Ukies running amok, weapons everywhere – in any Euro war we are the primary battleground. We also have the most level-headed view of Russia: good and bad, grateful for what they sacrificed for us, a little bit scornful of Russia’s propensity for gigantism, but we get along. (Poles are the exception"

    You mentioned V4, I pointed out that Poles outnumber all other people within V4 combined.


    I was not limiting it to V4: Austria, Slovenia, Croatia, Serbia
     
    Serbia? Why not Syria also? And North Korea?

    Croatia helps Ukraine also. It gave Ukraine all of its Mi-8 helicopters.

    https://mpu.gov.hr/news-25399/croatia-strongly-supports-ukraine-and-the-ukrainian-people/27313


    it would work like this: Anglos talk and ship “weapons” and the Poles die.
     
    Last time Russia fought Poland, Russia lost. Russia can barely hold Ukraine to a stalemate.

    You bark your inane “Habsburg” nonsense. Let me remind you that it was by far the worst in terms of human rights, freedom, oppression, number of people in prison for wrong views, under the Habsburg feudal monarchy that you so stupidly celebrate
     
    Thanks for demonstrating the poor educational standards of Slovakia. So ignorant, so parochial. Poles lived under Hapsburgs, Romanovs and Hohenzollerns. Hapsburg rule was by far the mildest of the three. Ukrainians lived under Hapburgs and Romanovs. Hapsburgs were milder.

    So let's compare executions.

    Russia:

    https://www.rbth.com/history/331226-death-penalty-russia

    1826-1905: 526 people executed
    1905-1910: 3,700 people executed

    Germany:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_Germany

    1907-1932: 393 people executed (could not find data for 19th century)

    Austria (not the Hungarian-ruled part of Austria-Hungary):

    https://www.jstor.org/stable/2276063?seq=2

    1852-1897: 175 people executed

    England and Wales:

    https://www.acrosswalls.org/datasets/executions-england-wales-from-1800/

    1852-1897: 622 people executed


    Only Nazis exceeded it [Austria-Hungary] in WW2
     
    Poor uneducated Beckow apparently hasn't heard even of Stalin's or Lenin's crimes.

    If you want to compare, it was the Poles who sided first with the Nazi Germany in Munich 1938
     
    This lie of yours has already been debunked multiple times, many many people, some of whom aren't posting here anymore.

    Poland refused multiple offers of alliance with the Nazis (and also refused alliances with the Bolsheviks). when Czechoslovakia was betrayed by its allies and gave up German-0ihabioted lands to Germany, Poland asked for and peacefully received Polish-inhabited territories, that the Czechs had previously seized by attacking Poland and killing its soldiers. It was not part of some Polish-German alliance (this was no Molotov-Ribbentrop), indeed Poland refused such.


    After 1945 there were 3 million Polish commies all the way till the end
     
    Poles fought Commies in 1920 (and defeated them, saving Europe from a Russian commie invasion), 1939, and 1945.

    Poland fought Nazis in 1939 rather than join them as Germany asked them to do and as Slovakia did. Thereby saving Europe from Nazi victory (Russians were defeated by Poles in 1921, you think the Soviets would have defeated a German-Polish alliance?). Maybe that's why you can't forgive Poles? Your people were eager Nazi allies. Slovakia even paid the Nazis money to kill Slovak Jews. Who else would do that?


    in 1968 Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia the Poles were the second largest army
     
    They were about 25,000 troops out of 450,000. "Second largest" lol. And it was a commie vs. commie conflict anyways. Afterward, Czechoslovaks were such sincere and loyal commies that Poles were shocked when they visited Czechoslovakia.

    Polish resistance to Commies in the 1980s brought down the Soviet system in Eastern Europe. This is probably why you, a Commie sympathizer, can't forgive Poles.

    And of course Poles resist the importation of non-European Africans and Muslims into Europe. You Slovaks and Hungarians would not be able to resist the pressure alone.

    So Poland alone has resisted each of the evils plaguing Europe in the last 100+ years.

    While your people eagerly joined the Nazis, and voted for the Commies.


    you are losing the war
     
    Russia's staggering losses and lack of gaining even villages (taking the slag head outside Avdiivka, some wooded strips, and central Marinka doesn't count for much) suggest that its winter offensive is failing, so far.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @Gerard1234

    Wow. What another despicable collection of lies and idiocy.

    Regarding Poles siding with the Nazis in 1938:

    This lie of yours has already been debunked multiple times, many many people, some of whom aren’t posting here anymore.

    Of course nobody has “debunked” this, because it’s true. Nazi Poland was the first to sign agreement with Nazi Germany you dumbf*ck. They didn’t “refuse” anything, they waited for even better deal with the Nazis as part of ongoing negotiation.

    An agreement of Poland, France and Czechoslovakia would have prevented WW2 you stupid idiot.
    Poles are effectively failed prostitutes of the French, many of their elites of French heritage,been closely connected for centuries, french help critical to them post-WW1……..but Polish scum chose rejection of pact with their historically closest ally that would have stopped WW2 ( accumulative populations, military and industry potential advantage over the Nazis)…..in favour of hoping for a better deal with the 2 main enemies of WW2 in Japan and Germany

    There was zero opposing of Nazism from fascist Poland, just the fact that sadistic “Greater Poland” (LOL) demands exceeded “Greater Germany ” territorial ambitions you retarded cretin and they were desperate for a 3-side alliance with Japan to attack the Soviets from the East. Anti-Russianism was given precedence over pro-polish French – summarises why Poland such a failure of Europe for a millenium.

    Not only were they best allies of Nazi Germany and Japan…….they openly whored to both of them to the point it was criminal offense in Poland to insult Hitler!

    Poles fought Commies in 1920 (and defeated them, saving Europe from a Russian commie invasion), 1939, and 1945.

    LMFAO. Poland fought ( and got smashed) by the Soviets you dumb prick. Poland did not DECLARE war on Soviet Union, these prostitute parasites( state of Poland created by default and not from fighting for it in any way in WW1)…..were such cowards and failures that they took war to Russia, a Russia in anarchy ,without any state and in civil war …..WITHOUT declaring it on anybody. It was zero ideological fight against Communism ( as proven towards Denikin and other stupid acts by Pilsudski such as to Lithuania) – just an opportunistic scumbag action

    As soon as Soviets organised to fight…..they proceeded to annihilate the Poles and throw them out of a mass area of land you idiot. A simple look at what the Poles (nearly unopposed) seized initially in the background of Russian civil war and what they finished with, makes everything clear. A simple look at even smaller targets of what parts of Belarus and Right bank Ukraine they wanted, initially took and then were kicked out of should make it ever more clearer.

    In reality French Generals, French air force, German & British & French artillery, rifles and ammunition, American and British huge amounts of money, and German, French and British intelligence in conjunction with the fact that Russia was in a state of civil war ( a far bigger conflict than the war with Poland you prick) and the Soviets were fighting about 3 million different wars at the same time……..is entirely what stopped Soviet advance. Polish losers deserve ZERO credit for it – this why not a single Polish military officer from that war is studied in any western military academy ( by comparison, Tukhachevsky from his intended reforms and previous military achievements is). Advantage of officers with experience of serving in 3 of the great power militaries proved useless.

    So it was collective west and Tsarist Russia responsible for Polands post-WW1 territory you imbecile. Parasiting off their Nazi friends during the Munich Agreement in 1938 ( hundreds of thousands of Poles from those illegally seized lands fought with the Nazis in Barbarossa)……..parasiting off collapse of Russian Empire

    Polish resistance to Commies in the 1980s brought down the Soviet system in Eastern Europe. This is probably why you, a Commie sympathizer, can’t forgive Poles.

    Again just lunatic idiocy. Slovaks resisted communism long before Poles did you idiot. “Solidarity” was nothing compared to violent/aggressive resistance Prague in 1968 and Budapest in 1956 ( that Poles only did this much later is very indicative) and Solidarity only developed because there was a Pole as secretary of State in the White House you idiot that pressurised USSR under threat of more sanctions not do what was correctly done in 56 and 1968. Overall context of Poland is…..(easily) held by Russia for 300 years, (easily) held by 3 different Empires for long period, (easily) defeated by Soviets and Nazis in embarrassingly quick time and (easily) held by Soviets for decades without any problems. Dumb American myths on what “brought down the Soviets” are demented.

    As Beckow said, huge number millions of Poles were pro-communist servants, millions more were fine with the system.

    And of course Poles resist the importation of non-European Africans and Muslims into Europe. You Slovaks and Hungarians would not be able to resist the pressure alone.

    Illiterate nonsense. Poles “resist” f*ck all. Its about 27th or 28th place of favoured destination for migrants into the EU. Slovaks and Hungarians clearly do “resist the pressure” alone you moron.
    Slovaks and Hungarians maintain population, economy and social cohesion……..Poles have to rely on ukrops to maintain population – and “Ukrainians”to Poles are just like Africans or Pakistanis or Fillipinos to the western European nations. Of course Polish freaks are going to enjoy a rebirth of the Pan system to their traditional slaves, that has identical dynamic to west to 3rd world nations. If told take African or Muslim migrants or lose 100’s of billion in EU AID and western investments….nothing to suggest they would resist.

    They were about 25,000 troops out of 450,000. “Second largest” lol. And it was a commie vs. commie conflict anyways. Afterward, Czechoslovaks

    That’s a huge number of Poles you stupid prick. Poles were involved incredibly intensely in many aspects of Soviet life that you are too clueless to know about . That number of troops is much higher than percentage of ethnic “Ukrainians” in current ukronazi government too, LOL.

    Poland fought Nazis in 1939 rather than join them as Germany asked them to do and as Slovakia did. Thereby saving Europe from Nazi victory (

    Again,its just emphasising the fact you are a fantasist scumbag who has never been to Russia, Ukraine or Europe . Even the most deluded Polish nationalists or polish diaspora in the west don’t say or claim this fantasist stuff composed of instantaneous BS. Yes , they make anti-Russian argument, but it’s simple to see when a faker as yourself is attempting to mimic them and failing. Even worse than your medical “knowledge” which is very bizarre for a wakjob claiming to be a qualified medic, LOL!

    You are also entirely useless on Slovakia and its actions in WW2. Embarrassing to read.

    So Poland alone has resisted each of the evils plaguing Europe in the last 100+ years.

    Summary – Communism was not in any way “evil” you sick POS. Poles did the opposite of resist them. Poles certainly didn’t resist the Nazis in any relevant way.

    In addition, more proof of why I don’t waste time reading the links providing by a sociopathic worthless POS compulsive liar as yourself…..you even write number for executions that CONFIRM Russian Empire more lenient than the others you seriously disturbed retard!!!

    Just as being a Finn in Russia was a million times superior than one in Swedish Empire, Russian Empire was best place for cuckholded Poles out of the 3 different empires, Gruzian a million times better in union with Russia than as Ottoman or Persian etc. As for 1905-10 – time of first Russian revolution you idiot. One man gets assassinated in A-H and World war with tens of millions dead starts – in early 20th century Stolypin, Minister of Interior, Governor of Finland get assassinated in addition to a few others and several attempted assassinations ( Alexander 2nd assasinated a few decades earlier) and reaction by the authorities is extremely mild by comparison ( with nobodys heads cut off in execution either, different to the other places in Europe). In reality its because, different to Poland, Russia is a generator of intellectual ideas and big debate, PLUS the very generous treatment of areas of different ethnicities in laws, autonomy and money that actually fuelled these issues and rise of these socialistic ideas and nationalism. Completely different to the extreme repression in Austria-Hungary

    • Replies: @AP
    @Gerard1234


    Summary – Communism was not in any way “evil” you sick POS. Poles did the opposite of resist them
     
    If it were true that Poles did the "opposite" of resist Communism, you would have liked the Poles.

    So you disprove your own claims.

    Regarding Poles siding with the Nazis in 1938:

    This lie of yours has already been debunked multiple times, many many people, some of whom aren’t posting here anymore.


    Of course nobody has “debunked” this, because it’s true.

    Nazi Poland was the first to sign agreement with Nazi Germany ...
     
    A nonaggression agreement is not an alliance. They agreed to recognize the borders and not to attack one another.

    The Soviets in contrast actually had an alliance with the Nazis.

    There was zero opposing of Nazism from fascist Poland
     
    Unlike Czechia, Poland fought against the Nazis. The first to do so.

    Poles fought Commies in 1920 (and defeated them, saving Europe from a Russian commie invasion), 1939, and 1945.

    LMFAO. Poland fought ( and got smashed) by the Soviets you dumb prick
     
    Poland stopped the Soviets outside Warsaw and drove them East to Minsk.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Warsaw_(1920)

    The Battle of Warsaw (Polish: Bitwa Warszawska; Russian: Варшавская битва, Varshavskaya bitva), also known as the Miracle on the Vistula (Polish: Cud nad Wisłą), was a series of battles that resulted in a decisive Polish victory in 1920 during the Polish–Soviet War. Poland, on the verge of total defeat, repulsed and defeated the Red Army.

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/2/27/Gu%C3%A8rra_Sovietopolonesa_%281919-1921%29.png/800px-Gu%C3%A8rra_Sovietopolonesa_%281919-1921%29.png

    [Poles] took war to Russia, a Russia in anarchy ,without any state
     
    Bolsheviks did not have a state in December 1919?

    and in civil war
     
    The Civil War was wrapping up by the time the Soviets and Poles were fighting. By the end of 1919 the Soviets controlled all of Russia's large cities, almost all of European Russia plus the Urals and much of Siberia (Omsk was captured in November 1919).

    A simple look at what the Poles (nearly unopposed) seized initially in the background of Russian civil war and what they finished with, makes everything clear.
     
    Poles had more territory in the nd than they had in March 2019. And a lot more than they had in August 1920.

    In reality French Generals, French air force, German & British & French artillery, rifles and ammunition, American and British huge amounts of money, and German, French and British intelligence
     
    Yes, Poland got a lot of Western help, without which it would not have defeated the much-larger Soviets. Kind of like about 20 years later, the Soviets got a lot of help, without which they would have lost to much-smaller Germany.

    Parasiting off their Nazi friends during the Munich Agreement in 1938 ( hundreds of thousands of Poles from those illegally seized lands fought with the Nazis in Barbarossa)…
     
    100.00s of Poles from Teszen (total [population 227,000) fought with Nazis in Barbarossa?

    Is this another example of your math skills as a Soviet Civil "Engineer?" Lol.

    Slovaks resisted communism long before Poles did you idiot. “Solidarity” was nothing compared to violent/aggressive resistance Prague in 1968
     
    1. Did you know Prague is not in Slovakia?
    2. Solidarity ended with Soviet retreat from Poland. Prague 1968 was not successful.

    Solidarity only developed because there was a Pole as secretary of State in the White House you idiot that pressurised USSR under threat of more sanctions
     
    So you admit that Poles in America also contributed to the destruction of the Soviet system, not only Poles in Poland. Good. You may be a dumb Soviet "engineer" but you are capable of occasionally writing something that is correct.

    you even write number for executions that CONFIRM Russian Empire more lenient than the others
     
    Russia:

    https://www.rbth.com/history/331226-death-penalty-russia

    1826-1905: 526 people executed
    1905-1910: 3,700 people executed

    Germany:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_Germany

    1907-1932: 393 people executed (could not find data for 19th century)

    Austria (not the Hungarian-ruled part of Austria-Hungary):

    https://www.jstor.org/stable/2276063?seq=2

    1852-1897: 175 people executed

    England and Wales:

    https://www.acrosswalls.org/datasets/executions-england-wales-from-1800/

    1852-1897: 622 people executed

    The rest that you wrote is desperate nonsense.

    One man gets assassinated in A-H and World war with tens of millions dead starts
     
    Austria-Hungary didn't execute thousands after Empress Sissi was assassinated.

    The war became a world war due to Russia.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ, @Sean

  755. @AP
    @A123

    Deputy chairman of Russia’s security council:

    Why Ukraine is dangerous for its inhabitants.

    The existence of Ukraine is mortally dangerous for Ukrainians. And I don’t mean only the current state, Bandera’s political regime. I'm talking about any, absolutely any Ukraine.

    Why?
    The presence of an independent state on historical Russian lands will now be a constant reason for the resumption of hostilities.

    It's too late. No matter who is at the helm of the cancerous growth under the name of Ukraine, this will not add legitimacy to his rule and the legal viability of the “country” itself. And, therefore, the likelihood of a new battle will persist indefinitely. Almost always.

    Moreover, there is a 100% probability of a new conflict, no matter what security papers the West signs with the puppet Kyiv regime. Neither Ukraine’s association with the EU, nor even the entry of this artificial country into NATO will prevent it. This could happen in ten or fifty years.

    That is why the existence of Ukraine is fatal for Ukrainians. They are practical people at the end of the day. No matter how they now wish the Russians to die. No matter how much they hate the Russian leadership. No matter how much they strive to join the mythical European Union and NATO.

    Choosing between eternal war and inevitable death and life, the vast majority of Ukrainians (well, perhaps with the exception of a minimal number of out-of-touch nationalists) will ultimately choose life.

    They will understand that life in a large common state, which they do not like very much now, is better than death. Their deaths and the deaths of their loved ones. And the sooner Ukrainians realize this, the better.”

    Replies: @A123, @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

    Putin was socializing a similar idea in a recent speech, saying something along the lines of “Ukraine will cease to exist.” He doesn’t mean kill everyone, he means remove Ukraine’s geopolitical autonomy to protect Ukrainians from themselves and the West. The main reason is to protect Russia, but since many in the Kremlin see Ukraine as essentially Russian these issues are intertwined.

    The West seems insanely committed to the plan of injuring Russia at any cost to Ukraine. With this in mind, the comments by the Deputy Chairman are probably accurate. The recent increase in the Russian tempo makes me wonder if they want to wrap this up in 2024. Considering their constraints this seems too soon.

    • Replies: @AP
    @QCIC


    He doesn’t mean kill everyone, he means remove Ukraine’s geopolitical autonomy to protect Ukrainians from themselves and the West. The main reason is to protect Russia, but since many in the Kremlin see Ukraine as essentially Russian these issues are intertwined.
     
    Thanks for confirming that Russia is fighting to end Ukraine's independence from Russia, and that Ukrainians are fighting to prevent a Russian takeover of their country.

    Thanks also for confirming that you implicitly hope that Ukrainians get conquered by Russia.

    Replies: @QCIC

  756. @John Johnson
    @A123

    Trump +1.6% over Biden
    Haley +0.4% over Biden

    By your logic, Haley should drop out because Trump is polling better than her.

    That's weighted by outline polls which are less reliable. Fox News and CBS show her winning by 6/8.

    1.6% would be within the margin of error. So impressed.

    He still has over 30 pending felonies and you are actually excited about a lead by a margin of error.

    Color me skeptical that this is a good idea.

    "Trump will win, you'll see"

    - Every MAGA voter in the last election

    Replies: @A123

    Do you realize that your anti-MAGA cultist, #NeverTrump zealotry actually makes Trump more appealing as a candidate?

    Your fake charges are not working: (1)

    Circumstances aren’t looking good for Fani Willis. The Fulton County, Ga., district attorney who has made a personal crusade out of trying to prosecute Donald Trump now has to give account to a judge regarding the allegations that she is in an improper relationship with one of the special counsels she hired for the Trump case.

    “The judge overseeing the election interference case against former president Donald Trump in Georgia has reportedly scheduled a hearing for Feb. 15 to examine recent allegations that Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis and her lead prosecutor ‘engaged in an improper relationship and mishandled public money,’” reports Nicole Bennett at WSB Radio.

    Those of us who care about MAGA will vote MAGA.

    We are not locked to Trump, but in the 2024 cycle neither DeSantis nor Nikki “Warmonger” Haley make the cut. Haley should switch to the DNC. If you are correct about overwhelming appeal with Leftoids, it would be a great move for her. She is basically a younger version of Liz Cheney.

    PEACE 😇
    ___________

    (1) https://pjmedia.com/chris-queen/2024/01/18/breaking-judge-orders-hearing-on-fani-willis-investigations-n4925615

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @A123

    Do you realize that your anti-MAGA cultist, #NeverTrump zealotry actually makes Trump more appealing as a candidate?

    The NeverTrump zealot that voted for Trump twice?

    A zealot that looks at the data and concludes that Haley is the better bet against Biden?

    I'm not emotionally attached to any of these candidates. I found the MAGA cult weird even at their peak. Grown men fawning over a man for any reason is weird. I know the MAGA cult mentality because I shoot with them. You could totally pull red hat discounts in my area. Wearing a cheap red hat signals to fellow cult members that you are 100% trustable.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B2oLFKYNInQ

    Those of us who care about MAGA will vote MAGA.

    No doubt about that. But Trump would need a lucky rabbit's foot stuffed up his butt to somehow evade every felony charge.

    Your fake charges are not working

    My fake charges? I'm on record that some accusations are politically motivated but not the documents.

    You're in for a world of disappointment if you think Trump's handling of the documents is all just an MSM conspiracy. His own employees are going to testify against him.

    Silver spoon brats like Trump eventually disappoint their own fans. They never developed real character because everything was handed to them. Their parents raised them to believe that rules and laws are for the little people.

    Replies: @Sean

  757. @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    Can't find data on PISA scores, but on economy, HDI, foreign investments and overall quality of life is much higher in Translyvania than in Wallachia or Moldavia regions.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Yep, this is accurate:

    xxxhttps://www.reddit.com/r/Maps/comments/a73tjz/map_of_development_in_romania_2017/

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Romanian_regions_by_Human_Development_Index

    In Romania, other than Bucharest (the Romanian capital), there’s a clear pattern that the areas that were under Hapsburg rule for a longer time period are more developed than the ones that weren’t. Transylvania is ahead of Oltenia, which in turn is ahead of the rest of Romania other than Bucharest. (Bukovina was also under Austro-Hungarian rule but apparently isn’t large/populous enough to affect the HDI score for Moldavia too much.)

    For GDP, it’s a slightly more complex picture:

    https://qph.cf2.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-184336671f4edede1f12ff7bc1c8c68f-pjlq

    The wealthiest parts appear to be Bucharest, Transylvania, the coast, and Iasi, in that order. But eastern Transylvania seems like it’s roughly as poor as Moldavia is.

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    ''But eastern Transylvania seems like it’s roughly as poor as Moldavia is.''

    Yeah because it has too many gypsies (Cluj is full of them).

  758. @German_reader
    @Gerard1234


    British didn’t have successful Air defence
     
    Britain was the first country in the world to have a coordinated, radar-based air defence system, its effectiveness was proven in 1940. Obviously Soviet Union later developed very sophisticated anti-air and radar systems of its own, but I don't think they had something like that during WW2. They didn't need to anyway, since Germany lacked the resources for a sustained bomber offensive against Soviet Union and much industry could be evacuated beyond the Urals (i.e. beyond the range of German bombers).

    Replies: @songbird, @Gerard1234, @China Japan and Korea Bromance of Three Kingdoms

    All good points.

    However does it in any way disprove that Soviet air defence was superior?
    I just haven’t any idea of how much of whichever type of bomb was dropped on London or the UK as a whole…….but for London surely they had the same amount, probably much less air raids done against them and less bombs dropped than Leningrad suffered? Need to know the numbers. And planes shot down proportional to the number of raids.

    True, a co-ordinated mass attack over a short time is worse than the same amount of bombs dropped over 2-3 years, but overall evidence suggest Soviet cities were better defended from the air.

    In 3 years, damage to Leningrad from the air was not too bad. Civilian deaths much less. Several landmarks in London got hit – I know Buckingham Palace and St Pauls Cathedral, maybe the Parliament got hit. Leningrad/Saint Petersburg did not suffer like this in damage. Both Soviet cities and London not much wooden buildings ( had great fire in 17th century then city was rebuilt) compared to German cities like Dresden or the Japanese ones like Toyko.

    A-A guns in the city and on the ships of the Baltic Fleet in the Neva and off the Baltic coast, together with the work of our air force ensured the Nazi’s were not successful in the air raids on Leningrad.

    They didn’t need to anyway, since Germany lacked the resources for a sustained bomber offensive against Soviet Union and much industry could be evacuated beyond the Urals (i.e. beyond the range of German bombers).

    For four months ( not much shorter than the main bombing phase against the UK) , before production moved to the Urals, Moscow was the most targeted city on the planet from Autumn 1941-beginning of 1942. Other places the same pattern – though Kiev was taken, air defence against the Nazi invasion worked well. Having Leningrad destroyed from the air, and Moscow in the period till 1942 were far more important and neccessary objectives for the Nazi’s than London or even the UK’s industrial production sites ever was.

    There is no excuse for London, but the only excuse that could be given for the rest of the UK in air defence is that they have lots of cities very close together ( UK appears very strange in that no other place I have visited has such radically different regional accent over such short distance, which must have occured because of these close, different industrial centres) , each historically with their own industrial importance. With most European cities it’s one metropolitan area to defend, in UK you could have 5 different cities, each of own industrial importance to the war……within about 10 minutes of flying time of german bombers if spotted in a certain area. Knowing which cities should be on high alert for a night air raid from that point then becomes very difficult. Doesn’t excuse London defence though.

    • Replies: @Philip Owen
    @Gerard1234

    The Britsh broke the Luftwaffe by killing or downing the pilots until Hitler had to call off the invasion. They could never retrain enough pilots. The Battle of Britain you know. Russia typically only faced about a third of German airpower.

    Both sides used Bofors AA guns as well as their own. Bofors were said to be twice as good as British guns. British AA were manned by servicemen. German AA even early in war were often manned by boys and sometimes women. That said, the British QF107, the main AA gun ws good enough to keep in service until 1957. It started in 1937.

    What goes up must come down everywhere but when attacking London the Germans usually came up the Thames for ease of navigation. The could be shot there. So it is unlikely that British civilians had a harder time from friendly fire than Russian or German simply down to less exposure.

    Replies: @Gerard1234

    , @Sean
    @Gerard1234

    Germany did not understand the significance of the rather vulnerable radar masts. if it had it had drop tanks for fighter-bombers capable of destroying them. Luftwaffe attacks on southern RAF aerodromes were begining to crack the defences, but the attacks were broken off to concentrate on London around the time the invasion of Russia led to the transfer of the main German Airforce to the East .

  759. @A123
    @John Johnson

    Do you realize that your anti-MAGA cultist, #NeverTrump zealotry actually makes Trump more appealing as a candidate?

    Your fake charges are not working: (1)


    Circumstances aren't looking good for Fani Willis. The Fulton County, Ga., district attorney who has made a personal crusade out of trying to prosecute Donald Trump now has to give account to a judge regarding the allegations that she is in an improper relationship with one of the special counsels she hired for the Trump case.

    "The judge overseeing the election interference case against former president Donald Trump in Georgia has reportedly scheduled a hearing for Feb. 15 to examine recent allegations that Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis and her lead prosecutor 'engaged in an improper relationship and mishandled public money,'” reports Nicole Bennett at WSB Radio.
     
    Those of us who care about MAGA will vote MAGA.

    We are not locked to Trump, but in the 2024 cycle neither DeSantis nor Nikki "Warmonger" Haley make the cut. Haley should switch to the DNC. If you are correct about overwhelming appeal with Leftoids, it would be a great move for her. She is basically a younger version of Liz Cheney.

    PEACE 😇
    ___________

    (1) https://pjmedia.com/chris-queen/2024/01/18/breaking-judge-orders-hearing-on-fani-willis-investigations-n4925615

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Do you realize that your anti-MAGA cultist, #NeverTrump zealotry actually makes Trump more appealing as a candidate?

    The NeverTrump zealot that voted for Trump twice?

    A zealot that looks at the data and concludes that Haley is the better bet against Biden?

    I’m not emotionally attached to any of these candidates. I found the MAGA cult weird even at their peak. Grown men fawning over a man for any reason is weird. I know the MAGA cult mentality because I shoot with them. You could totally pull red hat discounts in my area. Wearing a cheap red hat signals to fellow cult members that you are 100% trustable.

    Those of us who care about MAGA will vote MAGA.

    No doubt about that. But Trump would need a lucky rabbit’s foot stuffed up his butt to somehow evade every felony charge.

    Your fake charges are not working

    My fake charges? I’m on record that some accusations are politically motivated but not the documents.

    You’re in for a world of disappointment if you think Trump’s handling of the documents is all just an MSM conspiracy. His own employees are going to testify against him.

    Silver spoon brats like Trump eventually disappoint their own fans. They never developed real character because everything was handed to them. Their parents raised them to believe that rules and laws are for the little people.

    • LOL: A123
    • Replies: @Sean
    @John Johnson


    Silver spoon brats like Trump eventually disappoint their own fans. They never developed real character because everything was handed to them. Their parents raised them to believe that rules and laws are for the little people.
     
    Dershowitz takes a different view. He says it is selective prosecution and its wrong.

    Trump would need a lucky rabbit’s foot stuffed up his butt to somehow evade every felony charge.
     
    Not Trump (or Putin): Xi. There is some kind of a fight coming with China, and as he publicly said not so long ago, Biden does not take China seriously as competition. Yes, Xi wants Biden or anybody rather than Trump. as China is the engine of the globised economy, we better do as Xi wants.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  760. @John Johnson
    @LondonBob

    One of the very few things Scott Ritter has got wrong about the war was Gonzalo Lira, shame he hasn’t apologised yet, as far as I am aware.

    Other than the video where he claimed the war was over a few weeks after it started?

    I guess you also missed the dozen or so videos where he said Ukraine was about to be crushed.

    His prediction on GAZA was that the Hamas tunnels would give IDF hell.

    What happened is that the IDF simply blew them up.

    Ritter also predicted a massive battle where Hamas fighters would use hit and run attacks to blow up IDF tanks. In reality the older RPGs from Iran proved to be useless against trophy armor. It was pretty much a walk-in for the IDF.

    Prediction: Ritter will scrub his Hamas videos just like he did with earlier Ukraine videos.

    Replies: @Sean

    His prediction on GAZA was that the Hamas tunnels would give IDF hell.

    Gaza is not a state, it is a part of Israel.

    His prediction on GAZA was that the Hamas tunnels would give IDF hell.

    He is a professional Youtuber, and gets way more views on vids that say Russia is carrying all before it.

    What happened is that the IDF simply blew them up.

    On Imo Jima the Americans simply poured gasoline into the tunnels and immolated tens of thousands of Nips.

    Ritter will scrub his Hamas videos just like he did with earlier Ukraine videos.

    America needs Russia for a future Chinese Megapower; the US does not want Ukraine to _win_ and that is why a limited Russia victory will suit Washington.

  761. @John Johnson
    @A123

    Do you realize that your anti-MAGA cultist, #NeverTrump zealotry actually makes Trump more appealing as a candidate?

    The NeverTrump zealot that voted for Trump twice?

    A zealot that looks at the data and concludes that Haley is the better bet against Biden?

    I'm not emotionally attached to any of these candidates. I found the MAGA cult weird even at their peak. Grown men fawning over a man for any reason is weird. I know the MAGA cult mentality because I shoot with them. You could totally pull red hat discounts in my area. Wearing a cheap red hat signals to fellow cult members that you are 100% trustable.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B2oLFKYNInQ

    Those of us who care about MAGA will vote MAGA.

    No doubt about that. But Trump would need a lucky rabbit's foot stuffed up his butt to somehow evade every felony charge.

    Your fake charges are not working

    My fake charges? I'm on record that some accusations are politically motivated but not the documents.

    You're in for a world of disappointment if you think Trump's handling of the documents is all just an MSM conspiracy. His own employees are going to testify against him.

    Silver spoon brats like Trump eventually disappoint their own fans. They never developed real character because everything was handed to them. Their parents raised them to believe that rules and laws are for the little people.

    Replies: @Sean

    Silver spoon brats like Trump eventually disappoint their own fans. They never developed real character because everything was handed to them. Their parents raised them to believe that rules and laws are for the little people.

    Dershowitz takes a different view. He says it is selective prosecution and its wrong.

    Trump would need a lucky rabbit’s foot stuffed up his butt to somehow evade every felony charge.

    Not Trump (or Putin): Xi. There is some kind of a fight coming with China, and as he publicly said not so long ago, Biden does not take China seriously as competition. Yes, Xi wants Biden or anybody rather than Trump. as China is the engine of the globised economy, we better do as Xi wants.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Sean

    Dershowitz takes a different view. He says it is selective prosecution and its wrong.

    A former Trump lawyer and Fox News contributor says everything will be fine. Yea nothing to worry about.

    You didn't provide a source so I looked up his opinion:
    The cases against Trump have not met that standard, Dershowitz said, except “maybe” his second federal indictment alleging he mishandled classified documents.
    https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/764990/dershowitz-says-no-prosecution-likely-as-biden-and-trump-docs-neutralize-each-other/

    He thinks Trump will skate the charges because the Feds mishandled it. Meaning Trump is guilty but will get away with it.

    Note that he considers the documents case to have the most weight. That is what I have been saying for months. It's not some random case that a bunch of Democrats contrived. Trump really messed up.

    Two former employees plan to testify against Trump. This is not merely a case of Trump accidentally bringing home documents. He had boxes of them and asked his employees to help cover up the evidence. That's Federal tampering. Not good.

    Not Trump (or Putin): Xi. There is some kind of a fight coming with China, and as he publicly said not so long ago

    Not sure what you mean here. I wasn't saying anything about China.

    By saying he needs a rabbit foot up his butt I mean he needs pure luck. The odds are against him in the documents case. The property juicing and 3 minute rape at the department store cases are weak but the documents case is a problem. His fans are mistakenly assuming it is all conspiracy.

    Replies: @Sean

  762. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Polish illiteracy could not have been more than 10% or so in the former German parts of Poland since otherwise the numbers wouldn't make sense. There was 92+% literacy in almost all of ex-German Poland, including in areas that were 80+% Polish, such as in Posen Province:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/be/Sprachen_Provinz_Posen_1910.svg/800px-Sprachen_Provinz_Posen_1910.svg.png

    Upper Silesia also contained some 80+% Polish areas, albeit with some of these Poles being politically loyal to Germany rather than to Poland:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a8/Sprachen_in_Schlesien_1905_06.svg/1920px-Sprachen_in_Schlesien_1905_06.svg.png

    (They still ended up in Poland either after WWI or after WWII, unless they subsequently emigrated back home to Germany, of course.)

    It's primarily West Prussia were 80+% Polish areas (even if one counts Kashubians as Polish) did not exist on a large level:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a9/Sprachen_Westpreussen_en.svg/1280px-Sprachen_Westpreussen_en.svg.png

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    I’m not saying the Poles there were illiterate (sorry of I wasn’t clear), but that the German population boosted the overall literacy rate there by about 10%-15%. The ethnic Poles there were probably at around the Austrian level of literacy.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Question: Were Jews in Galicia more literate than Poles were? I know that Jews (and Germans) in Russia were more literate than Russians (and other Eastern Slavs) were back in 1897.

    I'm asking this because while the figures in ex-German Poland could have been inflated by Germans, is there any chance that the figures in ex-Austrian Poland could have been inflated by Jews?

    There were more Jews in ex-Austrian Poland (Galicia) than in ex-German Poland pre-Holocaust:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/3b/Jews-in-europe-percentage-ca-1900.png

    Replies: @AP

  763. @Gerard1234
    @German_reader

    All good points.

    However does it in any way disprove that Soviet air defence was superior?
    I just haven't any idea of how much of whichever type of bomb was dropped on London or the UK as a whole.......but for London surely they had the same amount, probably much less air raids done against them and less bombs dropped than Leningrad suffered? Need to know the numbers. And planes shot down proportional to the number of raids.

    True, a co-ordinated mass attack over a short time is worse than the same amount of bombs dropped over 2-3 years, but overall evidence suggest Soviet cities were better defended from the air.

    In 3 years, damage to Leningrad from the air was not too bad. Civilian deaths much less. Several landmarks in London got hit - I know Buckingham Palace and St Pauls Cathedral, maybe the Parliament got hit. Leningrad/Saint Petersburg did not suffer like this in damage. Both Soviet cities and London not much wooden buildings ( had great fire in 17th century then city was rebuilt) compared to German cities like Dresden or the Japanese ones like Toyko.

    A-A guns in the city and on the ships of the Baltic Fleet in the Neva and off the Baltic coast, together with the work of our air force ensured the Nazi's were not successful in the air raids on Leningrad.


    They didn’t need to anyway, since Germany lacked the resources for a sustained bomber offensive against Soviet Union and much industry could be evacuated beyond the Urals (i.e. beyond the range of German bombers).

     

    For four months ( not much shorter than the main bombing phase against the UK) , before production moved to the Urals, Moscow was the most targeted city on the planet from Autumn 1941-beginning of 1942. Other places the same pattern - though Kiev was taken, air defence against the Nazi invasion worked well. Having Leningrad destroyed from the air, and Moscow in the period till 1942 were far more important and neccessary objectives for the Nazi's than London or even the UK's industrial production sites ever was.

    There is no excuse for London, but the only excuse that could be given for the rest of the UK in air defence is that they have lots of cities very close together ( UK appears very strange in that no other place I have visited has such radically different regional accent over such short distance, which must have occured because of these close, different industrial centres) , each historically with their own industrial importance. With most European cities it's one metropolitan area to defend, in UK you could have 5 different cities, each of own industrial importance to the war......within about 10 minutes of flying time of german bombers if spotted in a certain area. Knowing which cities should be on high alert for a night air raid from that point then becomes very difficult. Doesn't excuse London defence though.

    Replies: @Philip Owen, @Sean

    The Britsh broke the Luftwaffe by killing or downing the pilots until Hitler had to call off the invasion. They could never retrain enough pilots. The Battle of Britain you know. Russia typically only faced about a third of German airpower.

    Both sides used Bofors AA guns as well as their own. Bofors were said to be twice as good as British guns. British AA were manned by servicemen. German AA even early in war were often manned by boys and sometimes women. That said, the British QF107, the main AA gun ws good enough to keep in service until 1957. It started in 1937.

    What goes up must come down everywhere but when attacking London the Germans usually came up the Thames for ease of navigation. The could be shot there. So it is unlikely that British civilians had a harder time from friendly fire than Russian or German simply down to less exposure.

    • Replies: @Gerard1234
    @Philip Owen


    Both sides used Bofors AA guns as well as their own. Bofors were said to be twice as good as British guns. British AA were manned by servicemen. German AA even early in war were often manned by boys and sometimes women. That said, the British QF107, the main AA gun ws good enough to keep in service until 1957. It started in 1937.
     
    Thanks for that information!

    The Britsh broke the Luftwaffe by killing or downing the pilots until Hitler had to call off the invasion.

     

    Nazis lost more planes in the first few months of invasion of USSR than they did in France, Battle of Britain and rest of Europe combined.

    Statistics there are that British and German pilot losses were identical, but the British lost about 1/6th the number of planes as the Nazis ( and much less than anyone else of the major sides). This of course because air strategy focused on the heavy bombers flying into Europe and the bomber crew for the british were 7 or 8 airmen, compared to 3 or 4 depending on which bomber aircraft of the Luftwaffe. I would guess the Nazis weren't able to much successfully target masses of British planes parked at airbases - as the Soviets especially and others were able to to do them ( I think at least 25000 Luftwaffe planes lost on the ground)

    As for your conclusion on the Battle of Britain.....why then invade USSR a month later if the Luftwaffe were taught such a lesson? Does not appear plausible.

    Russia typically only faced about a third of German airpower.
     
    Facing more than a third of their pilots and aircraft does not necessarily indicate more than a third of their airpower........but it's absolutely impossible that Russia did not face the large majority of German airforce compared to the other allies. If 80% + of Nazi land forces are fighting USSR, and though Nazi navy more focused on other arenas - the British and Americans are using many ships to deliver things to USSR ( so engaging a decent amount of the Kriegsmarine along this northern route in addition to them vs Black Sea Fleet in the south area of the war) .....then it's ridiculous to think that a corresponding number of Nazi air power is not directed towards Russia. If not 80% to match the land forces, then certainly over 50%
  764. @AP
    @A123

    Deputy chairman of Russia’s security council:

    Why Ukraine is dangerous for its inhabitants.

    The existence of Ukraine is mortally dangerous for Ukrainians. And I don’t mean only the current state, Bandera’s political regime. I'm talking about any, absolutely any Ukraine.

    Why?
    The presence of an independent state on historical Russian lands will now be a constant reason for the resumption of hostilities.

    It's too late. No matter who is at the helm of the cancerous growth under the name of Ukraine, this will not add legitimacy to his rule and the legal viability of the “country” itself. And, therefore, the likelihood of a new battle will persist indefinitely. Almost always.

    Moreover, there is a 100% probability of a new conflict, no matter what security papers the West signs with the puppet Kyiv regime. Neither Ukraine’s association with the EU, nor even the entry of this artificial country into NATO will prevent it. This could happen in ten or fifty years.

    That is why the existence of Ukraine is fatal for Ukrainians. They are practical people at the end of the day. No matter how they now wish the Russians to die. No matter how much they hate the Russian leadership. No matter how much they strive to join the mythical European Union and NATO.

    Choosing between eternal war and inevitable death and life, the vast majority of Ukrainians (well, perhaps with the exception of a minimal number of out-of-touch nationalists) will ultimately choose life.

    They will understand that life in a large common state, which they do not like very much now, is better than death. Their deaths and the deaths of their loved ones. And the sooner Ukrainians realize this, the better.”

    Replies: @A123, @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

    Sounds a lot like Nazi rhetoric, no?

  765. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    I'm not saying the Poles there were illiterate (sorry of I wasn't clear), but that the German population boosted the overall literacy rate there by about 10%-15%. The ethnic Poles there were probably at around the Austrian level of literacy.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Question: Were Jews in Galicia more literate than Poles were? I know that Jews (and Germans) in Russia were more literate than Russians (and other Eastern Slavs) were back in 1897.

    I’m asking this because while the figures in ex-German Poland could have been inflated by Germans, is there any chance that the figures in ex-Austrian Poland could have been inflated by Jews?

    There were more Jews in ex-Austrian Poland (Galicia) than in ex-German Poland pre-Holocaust:

    • Replies: @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    I haven't found specific data about Jewish literacy rates in Galicia but supposedly the Jews in Galicia were far less literate than were other Jews, so they might not have been much different than Poles. Western (German) Jews were highly educated, Easterners were less so, and among eastern Jews the Galician ones were more backward than the Lithuanian ones. The19th century Jewish immigrants who scored poorly on IQ tests were ones from the East.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ

  766. @John Johnson
    @Mikel


    DeSantis should quit.
     
    To give way to the candidate in 3rd position that he has nothing in common with. You wish.

    It's a suggestion based on data and not wishes. Haley polls better with independents.

    If the goal is to remove Biden then Haley is the answer and not DeSantis. The data is resounding clear on that.

    Those that want a second coming of Trump of course don't want Haley. But Trump running is Biden's best chance.

    The last thing we need if Trump doesn’t make it to November is no MAGAs in the race and a Nikki leading in delegates after Trump. The fact that she polls so well among liberals is the very reason why no one should vote for her.

    She doesn't poll well with liberals. I cited a poll showing that she polls well with moderate Democrats. Liberals are not moderate Democrats.

    There is no reason to believe that Trump would govern any different than Haley. For all of his talk he mostly governed like a mainstream Republican. All he had to do was close the border but his fans seem to think he needs two terms to do it. Well he turned down a good deal from Schumer early in his presidency and never got his wall built. I voted for him twice but I don't buy for one second that he is some type of rebel against the establishment. He may sell that image but his actual policies suggest he will buckle under pressure. When he moved to DC he joined the establishment. He ditched Bannon and let the swamp talk him into tax cuts for the rich. Bannon wanted tax cuts only for the middle class and Trump fired him. Why do the wealthy need tax cuts? It's such a stupid policy.

    Trump has become a cult of personality. His MAGA followers are uninterested in looking at his actual policy decisions. They are also uninterested in reading about the documents case as they tell themselves it is political in origin when Trump really f-cked up on his own. He is on tape trying to cover it up. The rape in the department case smells of BS but the take home documents really is a felony violation.

    Replies: @A123, @Mikel

    If the goal is to remove Biden then Haley is the answer

    The goal is to remove Biden and replace with someone better not worse.

    Haley has been calling for war with Iran and her position on immigration is basically open borders:

    “Anyone willing to work hard, abide by our laws, and love our traditions is welcome in our country.” Nikki Haley.

    That’s about 2 billion people Nikki wants to welcome in the US. How is that better than Biden’s southern border calamity?

    Good try but no, I’ll pass. I do understand how much you’d enjoy those videos of missiles blowing up people in Iran though.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Mikel

    The goal is to remove Biden and replace with someone better not worse.

    Haley isn't for open borders and would sign every current GOP proposal on the border.

    That’s about 2 billion people Nikki wants to welcome in the US. How is that better than Biden’s southern border calamity?

    She supports legal immigration like most Republicans including Trump. Trump has never proposed rolling back the 1965 immigration act. Most Republicans don't have the guts to even talk about it.

    I'm not a Republican and I would impose a moratorium on all immigration.

    But right now we have an open borders president. The Republicans including Haley want to end the amnesty loophole and Biden wants to keep it open. Haley is the safer bet if the goal is to remove Biden and the even more noxious VP that could take over at any moment.

    Trump was president for 4 years and left the border open. He in fact turned down a generous offer from the Democrats that included a partial wall along with electronic monitoring. The remote areas really don't need a wall and Trump showed his ignorance by insisting on one. Mr. "art of the deal" screwed it up and then let his pal Bannon run a fundraising scam for the border. With friends like these.

    Bannon charged with border fundraising scheme
    https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-53853297

    Replies: @Mikel

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @Mikel

    Interestingly enough, the US already has a little small-scale experiment with mostly open borders in the form of the Diversity Visa Lottery, and the results are not too bad:

    https://www.migrationpolicy.org/news/diversity-visa-program-holds-lessons-future-legal-immigration-reform

    https://www.migrationpolicy.org/sites/default/files/resize/DiversityVisaCommentaryFig1%202.9.2018-650x509.PNG

    Of course, it's not fully open borders because it's very small-scale and it does have some minimum entry requirements, but still, we do get a lot of educated immigrants even from it.

  767. @Hyperborean
    The Sarkozy clique now have a majority in Macron’s cabinet. I wonder what sort of promises were made behind closed doors to arrange this?

    Eight of the small team of 14 key ministers have a background in Sarkozy’s party, Les Républicains, including the surprise appointment as culture minister of Rachida Dati, who served as Sarkozy’s justice minister from 2007 to 2009. Catherine Vautrin, a Sarkozy loyalist, who served in government 20 years ago under the rightwing Jacques Chirac, was given a large ministry covering health, labour and solidarity. When first tipped for Macron’s government in 2022, she was criticised by the left of Macron’s centrist party because she opposed the legalisation of same-sex marriage in France in 2013.

    Two other long-serving politicians from the right, who were previously in government under Sarkozy, Gérald Darmanin at the interior ministry, and Bruno Le Maire at the finance ministry, kept their jobs.

    Emmanuel Moulin, a former adviser to Sarkozy and former Treasury director, took the pivotal role of chief of staff to the new prime minister.

    [...]

    The government was deliberately streamlined to a small number of ministers.

    “It’s the smallest cabinet since world war two,” said a source in Macron’s entourage. The source defended the merging of key ministries, such as placing labour and solidarity in the same brief, because “it’s through work, that we get out of poverty”. Crucially, the sports minister will also take on the education brief, which the source said showed that this summer’s Olympic Games in Paris was “not just an event in itself but an education project for the nation”.

    [...]

    Dati’s appointment continued to spark controversy. French media speculated that Dati, who has been mayor of Paris’s 7th arrondissement, may have done a deal with Macron to facilitate her running for mayor of the city in 2026. Emmanuel Grégoire, the Socialist deputy mayor of Paris, said it was “an indelible moral fault” that Dati had been appointed to government despite being under formal investigation for alleged corruption over consulting services to a subsidiary of Renault-Nissan. She has denied any wrongdoing.
     
    https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2024/jan/12/macron-looks-to-sarko-connection-to-head-off-far-right-in-france

    Replies: @Hyperborean

    The Sarkozy clique now have a majority in Macron’s cabinet. I wonder what sort of promises were made behind closed doors to arrange this?

    In case there is anyone other than I who is interested in this, here is the protocol rank order:

    1. Gabriel Attal
    Prime minister in charge of environment and energy planning – 34 years old
    Previously education minister

    (Jewish homosexual with origins in the Socialist Party, used to be together with Stéphane Séjourné; the two have been helping each another slide up the political ladder)

    2. Bruno Le Maire
    Economy, finance, industrial and digital sovereignty minister – 54 years old

    (Énarque, Sarkozyist)

    3. Gérald Darmanin
    Interior and french overseas territories minister – 41 years old

    (Sarkozyist)

    4. Catherine Vautrin
    Labor, health, and solidarity minister – 63 years old
    Previously president of the greater Reims urban community and the national agence for urban renovation

    (Sarkozyist, known for her old stance of anti-homosexual marriage, was expected to become PM in 2022)

    5. Amélie Oudéa-Castéra
    Education, Youth, sports, olympic and paralympic games minister – 45 years old
    Previously sports, olympic and paralympic games minister

    (Énarque, no former political affiliations before Macron’s party Renaissance, has apparently three children at a conservative Catholic private school)

    6. Marc Fesneau
    Agriculture and food sovereignty minister – 53 years old

    (Liberal, Vice-president of the pro-Macronist party MoDem)

    7. Rachida Dati
    Culture minister – 58 years old
    Previously mayor of Paris’ 7th arrondissement (a posh district)

    (Sarkozyist, like many, many French politicians, male and female, she has also has a history of being a major slut)

    8.
    Sébastien Lecornu
    Armed forces minister – 37 years old

    (Sarkozyist since he was 16)

    9. Eric Dupond-Moretti
    Justice minister – 62 years old

    (Old connection to the Socialists before joining Macron, celebrity lawyer with a lawyer’s sense of ethics – has been accused of using his position to attack old legal enemies, including joint enemies of Dupond-Moretti and Sarkozy, such as the magistrates who once investigated him because they suspected he might be a mole for Sarkozy)

    10. Stéphane Séjourné
    European and foreign affairs minister – 38 years old
    Previously mEP, general secretary of Macron’s Renaissance party

    (Former Socialist, Attal’s former (?) lover)

    11.
    Christophe Béchu
    Environment transition and territorial cohesion minister – 49 years old

    (Sarkozyist)

    12. Sylvie Retailleau
    Higher education and research minister – 58 years old

    (Physicist, academic, no political career, unhappy about the recent tighter immigration law)

    13.
    Prisca Thevenot
    Democratic renewal junior minister, government spokewoman – 38 years old
    Previously youth and universal national service junior minister

    (Macronist)

    14.
    Marie Lebec
    Parliamentary relations junior minister – 33 years old
    Previously vice-president of Macron’s Renaissance party’s parliamentary group in the Assemblée Nationale

    (Sarkozyist)

    15.
    Aurore Bergé
    Gender equality and combating discrimination junior minister – 37 years old
    Previously solidarity and family minister

    (Sarkozyist, daughter of soixante-huitards, was for gay marriage during its legalisation and defended jus soli citizenship, 2021 proposed an amendment of the separatism law to ban the wearing of hijabs by minors in public in order to defend the rights of young girls and fight back against islamism.)

    https://www.lemonde.fr/en/les-decodeurs/article/2024/01/12/french-government-who-are-the-ministers-in-gabriel-attal-s-cabinet_6426649_8.html

  768. @AP
    @LT1488


    Hungarians are not hated by most slavic eastern europeans
    Poles,Russians, Czechs, Croats etc like the Hungarians and Poles even consider them their brothers
     
    Poles no longer like Hungarians.

    https://notesfrompoland.com/2023/03/27/poles-dislike-of-russians-belarusians-hungarians-and-germans-has-grown-amid-war-finds-study/

    “Apart from Russians, the largest decline in positive sentiment was recorded towards Hungarians, who fell 21 percentage points from 57% to 36%”


    And as for Ukraine, as you said, the Hungarian minority’s rights to speak and learn Hungarian are being infringed upon
     
    I didn’t say that.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

    “Apart from Russians, the largest decline in positive sentiment was recorded towards Hungarians, who fell 21 percentage points from 57% to 36%”

    Do Poles dislike all of these peoples for their attitude towards Ukraine? Granted, it seems like the Germans are the least deserving of dislike from Poles, but maybe Poles simply remember Germans’ long history of appeasement towards Russia even if Germany is now taking a harder line on Russia. But why aren’t Poles souring on the French as much, who have also historically been Russia appeasers? Positive ancestral memories of France (passed on via oral storytelling to the next generations) from both World Wars?

  769. @Sean
    @John Johnson


    Silver spoon brats like Trump eventually disappoint their own fans. They never developed real character because everything was handed to them. Their parents raised them to believe that rules and laws are for the little people.
     
    Dershowitz takes a different view. He says it is selective prosecution and its wrong.

    Trump would need a lucky rabbit’s foot stuffed up his butt to somehow evade every felony charge.
     
    Not Trump (or Putin): Xi. There is some kind of a fight coming with China, and as he publicly said not so long ago, Biden does not take China seriously as competition. Yes, Xi wants Biden or anybody rather than Trump. as China is the engine of the globised economy, we better do as Xi wants.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Dershowitz takes a different view. He says it is selective prosecution and its wrong.

    A former Trump lawyer and Fox News contributor says everything will be fine. Yea nothing to worry about.

    You didn’t provide a source so I looked up his opinion:
    The cases against Trump have not met that standard, Dershowitz said, except “maybe” his second federal indictment alleging he mishandled classified documents.
    https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/764990/dershowitz-says-no-prosecution-likely-as-biden-and-trump-docs-neutralize-each-other/

    He thinks Trump will skate the charges because the Feds mishandled it. Meaning Trump is guilty but will get away with it.

    Note that he considers the documents case to have the most weight. That is what I have been saying for months. It’s not some random case that a bunch of Democrats contrived. Trump really messed up.

    Two former employees plan to testify against Trump. This is not merely a case of Trump accidentally bringing home documents. He had boxes of them and asked his employees to help cover up the evidence. That’s Federal tampering. Not good.

    Not Trump (or Putin): Xi. There is some kind of a fight coming with China, and as he publicly said not so long ago

    Not sure what you mean here. I wasn’t saying anything about China.

    By saying he needs a rabbit foot up his butt I mean he needs pure luck. The odds are against him in the documents case. The property juicing and 3 minute rape at the department store cases are weak but the documents case is a problem. His fans are mistakenly assuming it is all conspiracy.

    • Thanks: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @Sean
    @John Johnson

    Dershowitz says Trump will be convicted. The NY prosecutor ran for that office on a promise to bring a case against Trump. So it is not impermissible technically, but it is clear cut selective prosecution.

  770. @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    Even if clergy are nowadays average in intelligence, it would still benefit society in having them reproduce vs. not reproduce. It still counters dysgenic trends and creates a larger total population for the society.

    LT1488 is wrong and has not been around the public if he thinks clergy are average. Nearly half of all priests hold a master's degree:
    https://www.zippia.com/priest-jobs/education/

    He has also not been around nuns or priests. Nuns are surprisingly clever and church authorities in general tend to have a sense of humor behind the scenes.

    Clergy are basically middle class social workers. The level of burden they deal with in the US is unreal. US society has a very poor social safety net and the churches are stretched thin.

    Not having them reproduce is most likely dysgenic. However it should be noted that the position also attracts homosexuals and the asexual. Since most US churches are not Catholic I'm not sure of how much of a difference it would make. It would help if we understood how the gay gene worked. I suspect it is like other recessive genes where it can't be bred out as it requires two carriers to express. Basically everyone in the family gets part of it but only with a certain dice role does it express. That is why the Catholic family can get the gay kid but everyone else is not only straight but even strongly so (aggressive brothers early on). The priesthood has long been a way for Catholic families to *cough* help the one kid find his way. He really likes the service. Very spiritual.

    I knew someone that went into the priesthood and society certainly did not miss out on losing his genes. He was hopelessly asexual and was uncomfortable around straight men. He really didn't understand how someone could spend time on women or sports. Television and movies were completely foreign to him. Numerous people in the community tried helping him with various jobs and nothing worked until he entered the priesthood.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    TBF, wouldn’t priesthood be sub-optimal for a gay Catholic man who is primarily into adults? If he’s into both adults and minors, and lacks any sense of decent morality, however, then the priesthood seems perfect for him. Or if he’s primarily attracted to minors and lacks any sense of decent morality.

    Makes one wonder whether priests should be given the option of voluntary castration. After his affair with Eloise, Pierre Abelard chose surgical castration:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Abelard

    In history and popular culture, he is best known for his passionate and tragic love affair, and intense philosophical exchange, with his brilliant student and eventual wife, Héloïse d’Argenteuil. He was a defender of women and of their education. After having sent Héloïse to a convent in Brittany to protect her from her abusive uncle who did not want her to pursue this forbidden love, he was castrated by men sent by the uncle. Still considering herself as his spouse even though both retired to monasteries after this event, Héloïse publicly defended him when his doctrine was condemned by Pope Innocent II and Abelard considered a heretic. Among these opinions, Abelard professed the innocence of a woman who commits a sin out of love.[7]

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    TBF, wouldn’t priesthood be sub-optimal for a gay Catholic man who is primarily into adults? If he’s into both adults and minors, and lacks any sense of decent morality, however, then the priesthood seems perfect for him. Or if he’s primarily attracted to minors and lacks any sense of decent morality.

    I'm not sure if we should assume that gay priests are attracted to both men and minors. I really don't know but I'm not going to make the assumption without any evidence. It entirely could be true but the subject of course is under liberal protection.

    For the record I don't support allowing certain positions of employment to be covers for gays.

    I know from working with gays that more are celibate than one would assume. The promiscuous STD ridden gay is more of a city phenomenon and not so much in in rural America where they don't have as many dating options. I think everyone in rural America has met the "lone woman" with goats or horses. It's a dyke that doesn't want to be publicly gay. Some of them have religious families that would be absolutely crushed and would disown them. These Christian families really just tell themselves that Jane never met a man and now has a farm by herself. Seriously, the delusion is unreal. I've seen it first hand. Oh he just never met a woman despite having a house and high paying job. Just unlucky I guess. But he makes great desserts for the family get togethers. His house sure is clean.

    There are gays that can live without sex and just want to hide and have people assume they are "married to the cloth" as they say. The Catholic churches provide an occupation that gives them cover. It unfortunately also happens in protestant churches where they marry a beard but the Catholic church will attract more of them. I suspect the Mormon church has a lot more gays than they want to admit. They value the men based on having a family and they can be very effete as long as they drive a mini van with kids.

    Makes one wonder whether priests should be given the option of voluntary castration.

    I think they should allow priests the choice of marriage or celibacy. They shouldn't reject a man who wants to be a priest and also be married. I think allowing straight baby makers would do more for the church than trying to identify gays or encouraging castration.

    We can talk about this openly but Catholics are horrified by such frank discussions. They would never allow the idea of castration because they really don't think this happens. It's some Catholic priest somewhere else that is gay. Some city fag. Like one or two in LA or something. Not our priest! James is a good man! He just chose to isolate himself from women for low pay. Totally normal.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Another Polish Perspective

  771. @Mikel
    @John Johnson


    If the goal is to remove Biden then Haley is the answer
     
    The goal is to remove Biden and replace with someone better not worse.

    Haley has been calling for war with Iran and her position on immigration is basically open borders:

    "Anyone willing to work hard, abide by our laws, and love our traditions is welcome in our country.” Nikki Haley.

    That's about 2 billion people Nikki wants to welcome in the US. How is that better than Biden's southern border calamity?

    Good try but no, I'll pass. I do understand how much you'd enjoy those videos of missiles blowing up people in Iran though.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ

    The goal is to remove Biden and replace with someone better not worse.

    Haley isn’t for open borders and would sign every current GOP proposal on the border.

    That’s about 2 billion people Nikki wants to welcome in the US. How is that better than Biden’s southern border calamity?

    She supports legal immigration like most Republicans including Trump. Trump has never proposed rolling back the 1965 immigration act. Most Republicans don’t have the guts to even talk about it.

    I’m not a Republican and I would impose a moratorium on all immigration.

    But right now we have an open borders president. The Republicans including Haley want to end the amnesty loophole and Biden wants to keep it open. Haley is the safer bet if the goal is to remove Biden and the even more noxious VP that could take over at any moment.

    Trump was president for 4 years and left the border open. He in fact turned down a generous offer from the Democrats that included a partial wall along with electronic monitoring. The remote areas really don’t need a wall and Trump showed his ignorance by insisting on one. Mr. “art of the deal” screwed it up and then let his pal Bannon run a fundraising scam for the border. With friends like these.

    Bannon charged with border fundraising scheme
    https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-53853297

    • Replies: @Mikel
    @John Johnson


    Trump has never proposed rolling back the 1965 immigration act. Most Republicans don’t have the guts to even talk about it.

    I’m not a Republican and I would impose a moratorium on all immigration.
     

    You are wrong, as always. Trump explicitly talked about an immigration moratorium during the 2016 debates. I remember it perfectly (it could have potentially affected me as I wasn't naturalized yet but I could perfectly understand what a tremendous task the US had even then to assimilate the tens of millions of new arrivals of the previous decades). He was still being counseled by Coulter and other immigration restrictionists at the time. It must have been one of the taboos that he dared to break and later brought us Russiagate, massive censorship and his current legal problems, that yes, of course, are all politically motivated (how can anyone doubt it?)

    Even when he was in office and the restrictionists no longer had his ear he kept talking about switching to a merit-based system that would be a total overhaul of the 1965 act so you're dead wrong.

    You may favor an immigration moratorium but it must be much lower in your list of priorities than starting new wars because Nikki may back whatever the dominant position in the GOP seems to be at the moment to win the election but she's sure as hell not going to build the wall or do anything of significance on the demographic replacement front. She's being funded by the Koch brothers and the globalist donors, come on.

    But one has to admit that your position is the exact opposite of the Dems' on this matter. You care more about continuing to fight wars abroad than about the demographic replacement taking place in your country. The Dems, even though they would also love to give billions and billions to Ukraine, care more about keeping the borders open and prefer to leave Kiev defenseless rather than making any concessions on that front.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  772. @Mikel
    @John Johnson


    If the goal is to remove Biden then Haley is the answer
     
    The goal is to remove Biden and replace with someone better not worse.

    Haley has been calling for war with Iran and her position on immigration is basically open borders:

    "Anyone willing to work hard, abide by our laws, and love our traditions is welcome in our country.” Nikki Haley.

    That's about 2 billion people Nikki wants to welcome in the US. How is that better than Biden's southern border calamity?

    Good try but no, I'll pass. I do understand how much you'd enjoy those videos of missiles blowing up people in Iran though.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ

    Interestingly enough, the US already has a little small-scale experiment with mostly open borders in the form of the Diversity Visa Lottery, and the results are not too bad:

    https://www.migrationpolicy.org/news/diversity-visa-program-holds-lessons-future-legal-immigration-reform

    Of course, it’s not fully open borders because it’s very small-scale and it does have some minimum entry requirements, but still, we do get a lot of educated immigrants even from it.

  773. @QCIC
    @LondonBob

    In many suburban areas of the US cats and some dogs are now prey for coyotes.

    As people have fewer kids and live longer, the pet as substitute friend becomes more precious so people are overly protective.

    Replies: @songbird

    There is also cat AIDS, of which I very much wish I knew the origin.

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feline_immunodeficiency_virus

    My guesses:
    1.) Cat lady in the state department who was stationed in Nigeria
    2.) Nigerian elites who brought their housecat over.

    Possibly, I may be misattributing it geographically, but it is thought to have had a relatively recent origin in domestic cats.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @songbird

    FIV = Fauci Invented Virus?

    In your best Tony voice: "Here, kitty kitty...."

    Replies: @songbird

    , @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    If you are a dog person there is some good stuff in Sailer's dog eugenics thread.

  774. @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson

    TBF, wouldn't priesthood be sub-optimal for a gay Catholic man who is primarily into adults? If he's into both adults and minors, and lacks any sense of decent morality, however, then the priesthood seems perfect for him. Or if he's primarily attracted to minors and lacks any sense of decent morality.

    Makes one wonder whether priests should be given the option of voluntary castration. After his affair with Eloise, Pierre Abelard chose surgical castration:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Abelard


    In history and popular culture, he is best known for his passionate and tragic love affair, and intense philosophical exchange, with his brilliant student and eventual wife, Héloïse d'Argenteuil. He was a defender of women and of their education. After having sent Héloïse to a convent in Brittany to protect her from her abusive uncle who did not want her to pursue this forbidden love, he was castrated by men sent by the uncle. Still considering herself as his spouse even though both retired to monasteries after this event, Héloïse publicly defended him when his doctrine was condemned by Pope Innocent II and Abelard considered a heretic. Among these opinions, Abelard professed the innocence of a woman who commits a sin out of love.[7]
     

    Replies: @John Johnson

    TBF, wouldn’t priesthood be sub-optimal for a gay Catholic man who is primarily into adults? If he’s into both adults and minors, and lacks any sense of decent morality, however, then the priesthood seems perfect for him. Or if he’s primarily attracted to minors and lacks any sense of decent morality.

    I’m not sure if we should assume that gay priests are attracted to both men and minors. I really don’t know but I’m not going to make the assumption without any evidence. It entirely could be true but the subject of course is under liberal protection.

    For the record I don’t support allowing certain positions of employment to be covers for gays.

    I know from working with gays that more are celibate than one would assume. The promiscuous STD ridden gay is more of a city phenomenon and not so much in in rural America where they don’t have as many dating options. I think everyone in rural America has met the “lone woman” with goats or horses. It’s a dyke that doesn’t want to be publicly gay. Some of them have religious families that would be absolutely crushed and would disown them. These Christian families really just tell themselves that Jane never met a man and now has a farm by herself. Seriously, the delusion is unreal. I’ve seen it first hand. Oh he just never met a woman despite having a house and high paying job. Just unlucky I guess. But he makes great desserts for the family get togethers. His house sure is clean.

    There are gays that can live without sex and just want to hide and have people assume they are “married to the cloth” as they say. The Catholic churches provide an occupation that gives them cover. It unfortunately also happens in protestant churches where they marry a beard but the Catholic church will attract more of them. I suspect the Mormon church has a lot more gays than they want to admit. They value the men based on having a family and they can be very effete as long as they drive a mini van with kids.

    Makes one wonder whether priests should be given the option of voluntary castration.

    I think they should allow priests the choice of marriage or celibacy. They shouldn’t reject a man who wants to be a priest and also be married. I think allowing straight baby makers would do more for the church than trying to identify gays or encouraging castration.

    We can talk about this openly but Catholics are horrified by such frank discussions. They would never allow the idea of castration because they really don’t think this happens. It’s some Catholic priest somewhere else that is gay. Some city fag. Like one or two in LA or something. Not our priest! James is a good man! He just chose to isolate himself from women for low pay. Totally normal.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson


    I’m not sure if we should assume that gay priests are attracted to both men and minors. I really don’t know but I’m not going to make the assumption without any evidence. It entirely could be true but the subject of course is under liberal protection.

     

    Well, I was simply referring to the huge numbers of boys that get molested by Catholic priests. You think that such priests are simply pedophiles and molest boys rather than girls because boys are much easier to access for them? Or do you think that some of them have a preference for both boys and adult men but they can't get adult men but they can get boys and they also lack a decent moral compass, so they become child molester priests?

    Replies: @John Johnson

    , @Another Polish Perspective
    @John Johnson

    Castration for priests is banned by the Old Testament.

    As for homosexuality, it certainly is transferred by recessive genes in some population. It has higher incidence in cousin-marrying populations like South Asia wherefrom the notion of third sex comes. Since cousin marriages tend to conserve chromosome X, it is on this chromosome where homosexuality should be coded (actually all recessive traits are X-chromosome related).It means that homosexuality in family should be observed above all on mother's side. This is true.


    In 1998, Sanders et al. reported on their similar study, in which they found that 13% of uncles of gay brothers on the maternal side were homosexual, compared with 6% on the paternal side.
     
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biology_and_sexual_orientation


    In general, the homosexual genes seem to be somehow connected to promiscuity, here euphemised as "fecundity". This is in line with very strong sexual drive reported among many homosexuals and bisexuals.
    Clearly even the Biblical story of Sodom conveys element of promiscuity - Sodomites strongly wanting angels just for sex, despite them being their guests

    https://www.nature.com/articles/news041011-5

    But homo propaganda will never tell you that - they just "happen" to be.

  775. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Question: Were Jews in Galicia more literate than Poles were? I know that Jews (and Germans) in Russia were more literate than Russians (and other Eastern Slavs) were back in 1897.

    I'm asking this because while the figures in ex-German Poland could have been inflated by Germans, is there any chance that the figures in ex-Austrian Poland could have been inflated by Jews?

    There were more Jews in ex-Austrian Poland (Galicia) than in ex-German Poland pre-Holocaust:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/3b/Jews-in-europe-percentage-ca-1900.png

    Replies: @AP

    I haven’t found specific data about Jewish literacy rates in Galicia but supposedly the Jews in Galicia were far less literate than were other Jews, so they might not have been much different than Poles. Western (German) Jews were highly educated, Easterners were less so, and among eastern Jews the Galician ones were more backward than the Lithuanian ones. The19th century Jewish immigrants who scored poorly on IQ tests were ones from the East.

    • Thanks: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Thanks! Though FWIW, it would take slight nitpick with your assumption that Jews scored poorly on IQ tests, at least in the early 20th century (not sure about earlier). For instance, this 1922 study/article provides data that shows that Jews scored about as well as Anglos on IQ tests:

    https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/6403.pdf

    Search for "Hebrew" in the text in the PDF above (it's a PDF of the relevant 1922 study/article) and you'll see what I'm talking about here. "Hebrew" in this study/article is used as a synonym for "Jew"/"Jewish".

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    BTW, this is off-topic, but it's worth pointing out that out of all of Ukrainian Jewry, Galician, Volhynian, and Subcarpathian Ruthenia was by far the most demographically devastated in the Holocaust since moving and escaping to the east was not a realistic option for most of them. In contrast, many more Ukrainian Jews from further to the east, even from Vinnytsia and Zhytomyr, were able to escape the Holocaust by moving to the Soviet interior in the 1920s or 1930s or by fleeing to the Soviet interior in 1941, when Operation Barbarossa occurred but before the Nazis actually reached their own cities in Ukraine. This is why far western Ukraine* had few Jews in 1959 while the Ukrainian territories further to the east still had considerably more Jews back then:

    https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/7n4jn3/jews_as_a_percentage_of_the_total_population_in/

    *Lviv's Jews were likely migrants from further to the east. It's a similar story with post-WWII Riga's Jews. Subcarpathian Ruthenia was around (or almost) 15% Jewish in early 1944 and if 10% of them survived the Holocaust and subsequently returned back home, then a Jewish percentage of 1.3% for it in 1959 would make sense.

    Replies: @LT1488

  776. @German_reader
    @Gerard1234


    British didn’t have successful Air defence
     
    Britain was the first country in the world to have a coordinated, radar-based air defence system, its effectiveness was proven in 1940. Obviously Soviet Union later developed very sophisticated anti-air and radar systems of its own, but I don't think they had something like that during WW2. They didn't need to anyway, since Germany lacked the resources for a sustained bomber offensive against Soviet Union and much industry could be evacuated beyond the Urals (i.e. beyond the range of German bombers).

    Replies: @songbird, @Gerard1234, @China Japan and Korea Bromance of Three Kingdoms

    Soviet Air Force had an extensive purge in 1941, in spite of Barbarossa:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1941_Red_Army_Purge

    Soviets sent in clandestine, a considerable “volunteer” air fleet to China. Over 1200 aircrafts and 3000+ personnel. They took part in extensive action against Japan, including a bombing of Taiwan, and performed well.

    They painted Republic of China colors on the planes. After the Japanese shot some down and discovered the pilots were Russians, Soviets still denied the operation.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_Volunteer_Group

    One of those pilots in China was promoted to Commander of the Soviet Air Forces in ’41 and was liquidated by NKVD that October.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pavel_Rychagov

    • Thanks: Emil Nikola Richard
  777. @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    TBF, wouldn’t priesthood be sub-optimal for a gay Catholic man who is primarily into adults? If he’s into both adults and minors, and lacks any sense of decent morality, however, then the priesthood seems perfect for him. Or if he’s primarily attracted to minors and lacks any sense of decent morality.

    I'm not sure if we should assume that gay priests are attracted to both men and minors. I really don't know but I'm not going to make the assumption without any evidence. It entirely could be true but the subject of course is under liberal protection.

    For the record I don't support allowing certain positions of employment to be covers for gays.

    I know from working with gays that more are celibate than one would assume. The promiscuous STD ridden gay is more of a city phenomenon and not so much in in rural America where they don't have as many dating options. I think everyone in rural America has met the "lone woman" with goats or horses. It's a dyke that doesn't want to be publicly gay. Some of them have religious families that would be absolutely crushed and would disown them. These Christian families really just tell themselves that Jane never met a man and now has a farm by herself. Seriously, the delusion is unreal. I've seen it first hand. Oh he just never met a woman despite having a house and high paying job. Just unlucky I guess. But he makes great desserts for the family get togethers. His house sure is clean.

    There are gays that can live without sex and just want to hide and have people assume they are "married to the cloth" as they say. The Catholic churches provide an occupation that gives them cover. It unfortunately also happens in protestant churches where they marry a beard but the Catholic church will attract more of them. I suspect the Mormon church has a lot more gays than they want to admit. They value the men based on having a family and they can be very effete as long as they drive a mini van with kids.

    Makes one wonder whether priests should be given the option of voluntary castration.

    I think they should allow priests the choice of marriage or celibacy. They shouldn't reject a man who wants to be a priest and also be married. I think allowing straight baby makers would do more for the church than trying to identify gays or encouraging castration.

    We can talk about this openly but Catholics are horrified by such frank discussions. They would never allow the idea of castration because they really don't think this happens. It's some Catholic priest somewhere else that is gay. Some city fag. Like one or two in LA or something. Not our priest! James is a good man! He just chose to isolate himself from women for low pay. Totally normal.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Another Polish Perspective

    I’m not sure if we should assume that gay priests are attracted to both men and minors. I really don’t know but I’m not going to make the assumption without any evidence. It entirely could be true but the subject of course is under liberal protection.

    Well, I was simply referring to the huge numbers of boys that get molested by Catholic priests. You think that such priests are simply pedophiles and molest boys rather than girls because boys are much easier to access for them? Or do you think that some of them have a preference for both boys and adult men but they can’t get adult men but they can get boys and they also lack a decent moral compass, so they become child molester priests?

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    Well, I was simply referring to the huge numbers of boys that get molested by Catholic priests.

    It was mostly in the past and in liberal cities where the Catholic churches attracted homosexual predators. That was when they weren't doing background checks and some of those cases were covered up.

    They now have a watchdog system in place. They really don't want homosexuals in the priesthood.

    Or do you think that some of them have a preference for both boys and adult men but they can’t get adult men but they can get boys and they also lack a decent moral compass, so they become child molester priests?

    I don't know. I find it all to be pretty horrifying.

    From what I have read they are adept at picking boys from broken homes. I don't know if they target them with the intent of hiding their homosexuality.

    I also wonder how much child molesters and sexual predators simply hate society. Attacking a child is an attack against society. It's an attack against innocence. It's not something society can always protect against and it does an extreme amount of damage. I've looked up sexual predators in my area and they were all losers. A surprising number had deformities. I suspect it has a different component when compared to male-female rape.

    I had a friend who was molested by a relative who was the biggest loser in his area. Messed him up for life. Full on anal rape. I really think they should all be executed and psychoanalysis should be used for other criminal groups. But I suppose that won't happen so maybe we need to figure out how they tick. I'm amazed that society tolerates them. I read about multi-offenders in the news and I just shake my head. At least they get attacked in prison.

    Replies: @Ennui

  778. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    I haven't found specific data about Jewish literacy rates in Galicia but supposedly the Jews in Galicia were far less literate than were other Jews, so they might not have been much different than Poles. Western (German) Jews were highly educated, Easterners were less so, and among eastern Jews the Galician ones were more backward than the Lithuanian ones. The19th century Jewish immigrants who scored poorly on IQ tests were ones from the East.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ

    Thanks! Though FWIW, it would take slight nitpick with your assumption that Jews scored poorly on IQ tests, at least in the early 20th century (not sure about earlier). For instance, this 1922 study/article provides data that shows that Jews scored about as well as Anglos on IQ tests:

    https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/6403.pdf

    Search for “Hebrew” in the text in the PDF above (it’s a PDF of the relevant 1922 study/article) and you’ll see what I’m talking about here. “Hebrew” in this study/article is used as a synonym for “Jew”/”Jewish”.

  779. BTW, AP, I have a question for you: Do you think that Poland made a huge blunder in not allying with the Soviet Union in 1939 together with the Anglo-French? Poland could have at least said that it was open to such an alliance if the Anglo-French will legally commit in writing to expelling the Soviet Union from Poland after the end of the war if the Soviet Union will refuse to voluntarily leave Poland after the end of the war in the event of an Allied victory.

    Of course, the Soviet Union could have very well insisted on having the Baltic countries and Finland be handed over to it as the price of such an alliance, but it would have also significantly reduced the risk of the 1940 Fall of France and ensured that the subsequent Allied victory against the Nazis would come at a heavy Soviet cost, not just Anglo-French cost. And the scope of the Holocaust would be significantly reduced in magnitude even in the worst-case scenario here, since no 1940 (or later) Fall of France means no Operation Barbarossa at all.

    Poland should have also, of course, at least agreed to Danzig’s reunion with the German Reich (along with, of course, the construction of a physically elevated extraterritorial German road across the Polish Corridor) since a majority of Danzigers appear to have been Nazi supporters anyway and since if Germany will attack Poland after this anyway, then Poland can get Danzig and much more after the end of the war in the event of victory as the spoils of war/victory.

  780. @songbird
    @QCIC

    There is also cat AIDS, of which I very much wish I knew the origin.

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feline_immunodeficiency_virus

    My guesses:
    1.) Cat lady in the state department who was stationed in Nigeria
    2.) Nigerian elites who brought their housecat over.

    Possibly, I may be misattributing it geographically, but it is thought to have had a relatively recent origin in domestic cats.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Emil Nikola Richard

    FIV = Fauci Invented Virus?

    In your best Tony voice: “Here, kitty kitty….”

    • Replies: @songbird
    @QCIC

    I started out by thinking one couldn't blame gays, as it can't infect humans. But I suppose one can't necessarily eliminate the possibility it escaped from a lab, where they were doing research on HIV and related viruses.

    But am unclear on an exact timeline or how fast something like that would spread across the country.

    @Emil
    Have read the dog thread. I agree with the general sentiment that much of recent dog breeding seems superficial and directionless.

    Disagree with the commonly expressed idea that people don't want intelligent dogs.

    It's good to have a dog that won't eat your dinner, if you leave the room. Personally, I would like a dog that would be as friendly as a retriever in general, but not to a burglar. Probably one that wouldn't dominance-hump other dogs or eat animal waste.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  781. @Gerard1234
    @AP

    Wow. What another despicable collection of lies and idiocy.

    Regarding Poles siding with the Nazis in 1938:


    This lie of yours has already been debunked multiple times, many many people, some of whom aren’t posting here anymore.
     
    Of course nobody has "debunked" this, because it's true. Nazi Poland was the first to sign agreement with Nazi Germany you dumbf*ck. They didn't "refuse" anything, they waited for even better deal with the Nazis as part of ongoing negotiation.

    An agreement of Poland, France and Czechoslovakia would have prevented WW2 you stupid idiot.
    Poles are effectively failed prostitutes of the French, many of their elites of French heritage,been closely connected for centuries, french help critical to them post-WW1........but Polish scum chose rejection of pact with their historically closest ally that would have stopped WW2 ( accumulative populations, military and industry potential advantage over the Nazis).....in favour of hoping for a better deal with the 2 main enemies of WW2 in Japan and Germany

    There was zero opposing of Nazism from fascist Poland, just the fact that sadistic "Greater Poland" (LOL) demands exceeded "Greater Germany " territorial ambitions you retarded cretin and they were desperate for a 3-side alliance with Japan to attack the Soviets from the East. Anti-Russianism was given precedence over pro-polish French - summarises why Poland such a failure of Europe for a millenium.

    Not only were they best allies of Nazi Germany and Japan.......they openly whored to both of them to the point it was criminal offense in Poland to insult Hitler!

    Poles fought Commies in 1920 (and defeated them, saving Europe from a Russian commie invasion), 1939, and 1945.
     
    LMFAO. Poland fought ( and got smashed) by the Soviets you dumb prick. Poland did not DECLARE war on Soviet Union, these prostitute parasites( state of Poland created by default and not from fighting for it in any way in WW1).....were such cowards and failures that they took war to Russia, a Russia in anarchy ,without any state and in civil war .....WITHOUT declaring it on anybody. It was zero ideological fight against Communism ( as proven towards Denikin and other stupid acts by Pilsudski such as to Lithuania) - just an opportunistic scumbag action

    As soon as Soviets organised to fight.....they proceeded to annihilate the Poles and throw them out of a mass area of land you idiot. A simple look at what the Poles (nearly unopposed) seized initially in the background of Russian civil war and what they finished with, makes everything clear. A simple look at even smaller targets of what parts of Belarus and Right bank Ukraine they wanted, initially took and then were kicked out of should make it ever more clearer.

    In reality French Generals, French air force, German & British & French artillery, rifles and ammunition, American and British huge amounts of money, and German, French and British intelligence in conjunction with the fact that Russia was in a state of civil war ( a far bigger conflict than the war with Poland you prick) and the Soviets were fighting about 3 million different wars at the same time........is entirely what stopped Soviet advance. Polish losers deserve ZERO credit for it - this why not a single Polish military officer from that war is studied in any western military academy ( by comparison, Tukhachevsky from his intended reforms and previous military achievements is). Advantage of officers with experience of serving in 3 of the great power militaries proved useless.

    So it was collective west and Tsarist Russia responsible for Polands post-WW1 territory you imbecile. Parasiting off their Nazi friends during the Munich Agreement in 1938 ( hundreds of thousands of Poles from those illegally seized lands fought with the Nazis in Barbarossa)........parasiting off collapse of Russian Empire

    Polish resistance to Commies in the 1980s brought down the Soviet system in Eastern Europe. This is probably why you, a Commie sympathizer, can’t forgive Poles.
     
    Again just lunatic idiocy. Slovaks resisted communism long before Poles did you idiot. "Solidarity" was nothing compared to violent/aggressive resistance Prague in 1968 and Budapest in 1956 ( that Poles only did this much later is very indicative) and Solidarity only developed because there was a Pole as secretary of State in the White House you idiot that pressurised USSR under threat of more sanctions not do what was correctly done in 56 and 1968. Overall context of Poland is.....(easily) held by Russia for 300 years, (easily) held by 3 different Empires for long period, (easily) defeated by Soviets and Nazis in embarrassingly quick time and (easily) held by Soviets for decades without any problems. Dumb American myths on what "brought down the Soviets" are demented.

    As Beckow said, huge number millions of Poles were pro-communist servants, millions more were fine with the system.

    And of course Poles resist the importation of non-European Africans and Muslims into Europe. You Slovaks and Hungarians would not be able to resist the pressure alone.
     
    Illiterate nonsense. Poles "resist" f*ck all. Its about 27th or 28th place of favoured destination for migrants into the EU. Slovaks and Hungarians clearly do "resist the pressure" alone you moron.
    Slovaks and Hungarians maintain population, economy and social cohesion........Poles have to rely on ukrops to maintain population - and "Ukrainians"to Poles are just like Africans or Pakistanis or Fillipinos to the western European nations. Of course Polish freaks are going to enjoy a rebirth of the Pan system to their traditional slaves, that has identical dynamic to west to 3rd world nations. If told take African or Muslim migrants or lose 100's of billion in EU AID and western investments....nothing to suggest they would resist.

    They were about 25,000 troops out of 450,000. “Second largest” lol. And it was a commie vs. commie conflict anyways. Afterward, Czechoslovaks
     
    That's a huge number of Poles you stupid prick. Poles were involved incredibly intensely in many aspects of Soviet life that you are too clueless to know about . That number of troops is much higher than percentage of ethnic "Ukrainians" in current ukronazi government too, LOL.

    Poland fought Nazis in 1939 rather than join them as Germany asked them to do and as Slovakia did. Thereby saving Europe from Nazi victory (
     
    Again,its just emphasising the fact you are a fantasist scumbag who has never been to Russia, Ukraine or Europe . Even the most deluded Polish nationalists or polish diaspora in the west don't say or claim this fantasist stuff composed of instantaneous BS. Yes , they make anti-Russian argument, but it's simple to see when a faker as yourself is attempting to mimic them and failing. Even worse than your medical "knowledge" which is very bizarre for a wakjob claiming to be a qualified medic, LOL!

    You are also entirely useless on Slovakia and its actions in WW2. Embarrassing to read.

    So Poland alone has resisted each of the evils plaguing Europe in the last 100+ years.
     
    Summary - Communism was not in any way "evil" you sick POS. Poles did the opposite of resist them. Poles certainly didn't resist the Nazis in any relevant way.

    In addition, more proof of why I don't waste time reading the links providing by a sociopathic worthless POS compulsive liar as yourself.....you even write number for executions that CONFIRM Russian Empire more lenient than the others you seriously disturbed retard!!!

    Just as being a Finn in Russia was a million times superior than one in Swedish Empire, Russian Empire was best place for cuckholded Poles out of the 3 different empires, Gruzian a million times better in union with Russia than as Ottoman or Persian etc. As for 1905-10 - time of first Russian revolution you idiot. One man gets assassinated in A-H and World war with tens of millions dead starts - in early 20th century Stolypin, Minister of Interior, Governor of Finland get assassinated in addition to a few others and several attempted assassinations ( Alexander 2nd assasinated a few decades earlier) and reaction by the authorities is extremely mild by comparison ( with nobodys heads cut off in execution either, different to the other places in Europe). In reality its because, different to Poland, Russia is a generator of intellectual ideas and big debate, PLUS the very generous treatment of areas of different ethnicities in laws, autonomy and money that actually fuelled these issues and rise of these socialistic ideas and nationalism. Completely different to the extreme repression in Austria-Hungary

    Replies: @AP

    Summary – Communism was not in any way “evil” you sick POS. Poles did the opposite of resist them

    If it were true that Poles did the “opposite” of resist Communism, you would have liked the Poles.

    So you disprove your own claims.

    Regarding Poles siding with the Nazis in 1938:

    This lie of yours has already been debunked multiple times, many many people, some of whom aren’t posting here anymore.

    Of course nobody has “debunked” this, because it’s true.

    Nazi Poland was the first to sign agreement with Nazi Germany …

    A nonaggression agreement is not an alliance. They agreed to recognize the borders and not to attack one another.

    The Soviets in contrast actually had an alliance with the Nazis.

    There was zero opposing of Nazism from fascist Poland

    Unlike Czechia, Poland fought against the Nazis. The first to do so.

    Poles fought Commies in 1920 (and defeated them, saving Europe from a Russian commie invasion), 1939, and 1945.

    LMFAO. Poland fought ( and got smashed) by the Soviets you dumb prick

    Poland stopped the Soviets outside Warsaw and drove them East to Minsk.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Warsaw_(1920)

    The Battle of Warsaw (Polish: Bitwa Warszawska; Russian: Варшавская битва, Varshavskaya bitva), also known as the Miracle on the Vistula (Polish: Cud nad Wisłą), was a series of battles that resulted in a decisive Polish victory in 1920 during the Polish–Soviet War. Poland, on the verge of total defeat, repulsed and defeated the Red Army.

    [Poles] took war to Russia, a Russia in anarchy ,without any state

    Bolsheviks did not have a state in December 1919?

    and in civil war

    The Civil War was wrapping up by the time the Soviets and Poles were fighting. By the end of 1919 the Soviets controlled all of Russia’s large cities, almost all of European Russia plus the Urals and much of Siberia (Omsk was captured in November 1919).

    A simple look at what the Poles (nearly unopposed) seized initially in the background of Russian civil war and what they finished with, makes everything clear.

    Poles had more territory in the nd than they had in March 2019. And a lot more than they had in August 1920.

    In reality French Generals, French air force, German & British & French artillery, rifles and ammunition, American and British huge amounts of money, and German, French and British intelligence

    Yes, Poland got a lot of Western help, without which it would not have defeated the much-larger Soviets. Kind of like about 20 years later, the Soviets got a lot of help, without which they would have lost to much-smaller Germany.

    Parasiting off their Nazi friends during the Munich Agreement in 1938 ( hundreds of thousands of Poles from those illegally seized lands fought with the Nazis in Barbarossa)…

    100.00s of Poles from Teszen (total [population 227,000) fought with Nazis in Barbarossa?

    Is this another example of your math skills as a Soviet Civil “Engineer?” Lol.

    Slovaks resisted communism long before Poles did you idiot. “Solidarity” was nothing compared to violent/aggressive resistance Prague in 1968

    1. Did you know Prague is not in Slovakia?
    2. Solidarity ended with Soviet retreat from Poland. Prague 1968 was not successful.

    Solidarity only developed because there was a Pole as secretary of State in the White House you idiot that pressurised USSR under threat of more sanctions

    So you admit that Poles in America also contributed to the destruction of the Soviet system, not only Poles in Poland. Good. You may be a dumb Soviet “engineer” but you are capable of occasionally writing something that is correct.

    you even write number for executions that CONFIRM Russian Empire more lenient than the others

    Russia:

    https://www.rbth.com/history/331226-death-penalty-russia

    1826-1905: 526 people executed
    1905-1910: 3,700 people executed

    Germany:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_Germany

    1907-1932: 393 people executed (could not find data for 19th century)

    Austria (not the Hungarian-ruled part of Austria-Hungary):

    https://www.jstor.org/stable/2276063?seq=2

    1852-1897: 175 people executed

    England and Wales:

    https://www.acrosswalls.org/datasets/executions-england-wales-from-1800/

    1852-1897: 622 people executed

    The rest that you wrote is desperate nonsense.

    One man gets assassinated in A-H and World war with tens of millions dead starts

    Austria-Hungary didn’t execute thousands after Empress Sissi was assassinated.

    The war became a world war due to Russia.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    Austria-Hungary didn’t execute thousands after Empress Sissi was assassinated.

     

    Nor did it execute thousands when a wannabe Italian tried to assassinate Franz Josef back in 1882:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guglielmo_Oberdan

    The war became a world war due to Russia.

     

    Well, I still think that Austria-Hungary also made a mistake by doing to war against Serbia back in 1914 (1904-1905 was a better time for this). This authors explains this argument in more detail even ignoring the Russian factor:

    https://books.google.com/books?id=F5QDAAAAMAAJ&printsec=frontcover&dq=The+Habsburg+Monarchy+wickham+steed&hl=en&newbks=1&newbks_redir=0&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwidvv-43uCDAxUOIUQIHUfNDIkQ6AF6BAgHEAI#v=snippet&q=suicide&f=false

    It is mentioned specifically on page VIII here. Specifically, the argument is that Austria-Hungary would bankrupt itself occupying and garrisoning Serbia, create an even larger Slavic political headache for itself, and become even more dependent on Germany as a result of all of this. Similar to how Russia is becoming even more dependent on China right now as a result of its attempts to subjugate and then conquer Ukraine over the past decade.

    That said, though, Russia did make two big mistakes in the 1914-1917 time period: The first one was actually going to war for Serbia (against Rasputin's own advice, actually; he was anti-war) and the second one was not keeping sufficient order and stability on the home front once Russia actually went to war, thus paving the way for Russia's takeover by the Bolsheviks in late 1917.
    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    "Poles had more territory in the *end* than they had in March *1919*. And a lot more than they had in August 1920."

    There--corrected your two errors for you. :)

    , @Sean
    @AP

    It was predicted years before by the half Malaysian Admiral Fisher that Germany would start the war once the Kiel Ship Canal widening was completed, and that was almost exactly when it did start.

  782. @QCIC
    @AP

    Putin was socializing a similar idea in a recent speech, saying something along the lines of "Ukraine will cease to exist." He doesn't mean kill everyone, he means remove Ukraine's geopolitical autonomy to protect Ukrainians from themselves and the West. The main reason is to protect Russia, but since many in the Kremlin see Ukraine as essentially Russian these issues are intertwined.

    The West seems insanely committed to the plan of injuring Russia at any cost to Ukraine. With this in mind, the comments by the Deputy Chairman are probably accurate. The recent increase in the Russian tempo makes me wonder if they want to wrap this up in 2024. Considering their constraints this seems too soon.

    Replies: @AP

    He doesn’t mean kill everyone, he means remove Ukraine’s geopolitical autonomy to protect Ukrainians from themselves and the West. The main reason is to protect Russia, but since many in the Kremlin see Ukraine as essentially Russian these issues are intertwined.

    Thanks for confirming that Russia is fighting to end Ukraine’s independence from Russia, and that Ukrainians are fighting to prevent a Russian takeover of their country.

    Thanks also for confirming that you implicitly hope that Ukrainians get conquered by Russia.

    • Agree: Mr. XYZ, Mr. Hack
    • Replies: @QCIC
    @AP

    I am against WW3 which the West is trying to start. Everything else follows.

    I do not write about what I hope will happen in Ukraine, simply what I expect to happen. I hate the murders on all sides. I recognize the West created this mess using Ukraine as a pawn against Russia, so I am not persuaded by shrill claims that "Putin started it!"

    Ukraine could have created what you and Hack dream of, but the leadership chose to pursue this autonomy as puppets of the West. In addition to being a contradiction, this was a sellout, not a mistake. Once this sellout happened, probably starting in the 1990's, Ukraine was simply working on her own destruction.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. Hack, @John Johnson

  783. @songbird
    @QCIC

    There is also cat AIDS, of which I very much wish I knew the origin.

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feline_immunodeficiency_virus

    My guesses:
    1.) Cat lady in the state department who was stationed in Nigeria
    2.) Nigerian elites who brought their housecat over.

    Possibly, I may be misattributing it geographically, but it is thought to have had a relatively recent origin in domestic cats.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Emil Nikola Richard

    If you are a dog person there is some good stuff in Sailer’s dog eugenics thread.

  784. @A123
    @AP


    Deputy chairman of Russia’s security council:
     
    How many elected officials are there?
    How many chairs and ministers under these officials?
    How many deputies under the ministers and chairmen?

    In any sufficiently large group you can find a small number of people saying unwise things. In politics this count is often higher as they play to domestic constituencies. Is what this deputy said helpful? Of course not. However, your panicked over reaction to a deputy is also unhelpful.

    There is no reason to believe this is Putin's (and thus Russia's) official policy.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @sudden death

    That deputy also happens to be former RF official president like Putin;)

  785. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ

    I haven't found specific data about Jewish literacy rates in Galicia but supposedly the Jews in Galicia were far less literate than were other Jews, so they might not have been much different than Poles. Western (German) Jews were highly educated, Easterners were less so, and among eastern Jews the Galician ones were more backward than the Lithuanian ones. The19th century Jewish immigrants who scored poorly on IQ tests were ones from the East.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ

    BTW, this is off-topic, but it’s worth pointing out that out of all of Ukrainian Jewry, Galician, Volhynian, and Subcarpathian Ruthenia was by far the most demographically devastated in the Holocaust since moving and escaping to the east was not a realistic option for most of them. In contrast, many more Ukrainian Jews from further to the east, even from Vinnytsia and Zhytomyr, were able to escape the Holocaust by moving to the Soviet interior in the 1920s or 1930s or by fleeing to the Soviet interior in 1941, when Operation Barbarossa occurred but before the Nazis actually reached their own cities in Ukraine. This is why far western Ukraine* had few Jews in 1959 while the Ukrainian territories further to the east still had considerably more Jews back then:

    Jews (as a percentage of the total population) in Ukrainian oblasts in 1959 [569 × 410].
    by inMapPorn

    *Lviv’s Jews were likely migrants from further to the east. It’s a similar story with post-WWII Riga’s Jews. Subcarpathian Ruthenia was around (or almost) 15% Jewish in early 1944 and if 10% of them survived the Holocaust and subsequently returned back home, then a Jewish percentage of 1.3% for it in 1959 would make sense.

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    This is why the Holohoax is just a myth
    Most of the jews escaped to Siberia (or were deported). The remaining 1 million or so that died, died due to famine and disease, not magical gassing/masturbation chambers.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ

  786. @Philip Owen
    @Gerard1234

    The Britsh broke the Luftwaffe by killing or downing the pilots until Hitler had to call off the invasion. They could never retrain enough pilots. The Battle of Britain you know. Russia typically only faced about a third of German airpower.

    Both sides used Bofors AA guns as well as their own. Bofors were said to be twice as good as British guns. British AA were manned by servicemen. German AA even early in war were often manned by boys and sometimes women. That said, the British QF107, the main AA gun ws good enough to keep in service until 1957. It started in 1937.

    What goes up must come down everywhere but when attacking London the Germans usually came up the Thames for ease of navigation. The could be shot there. So it is unlikely that British civilians had a harder time from friendly fire than Russian or German simply down to less exposure.

    Replies: @Gerard1234

    Both sides used Bofors AA guns as well as their own. Bofors were said to be twice as good as British guns. British AA were manned by servicemen. German AA even early in war were often manned by boys and sometimes women. That said, the British QF107, the main AA gun ws good enough to keep in service until 1957. It started in 1937.

    Thanks for that information!

    The Britsh broke the Luftwaffe by killing or downing the pilots until Hitler had to call off the invasion.

    Nazis lost more planes in the first few months of invasion of USSR than they did in France, Battle of Britain and rest of Europe combined.

    Statistics there are that British and German pilot losses were identical, but the British lost about 1/6th the number of planes as the Nazis ( and much less than anyone else of the major sides). This of course because air strategy focused on the heavy bombers flying into Europe and the bomber crew for the british were 7 or 8 airmen, compared to 3 or 4 depending on which bomber aircraft of the Luftwaffe. I would guess the Nazis weren’t able to much successfully target masses of British planes parked at airbases – as the Soviets especially and others were able to to do them ( I think at least 25000 Luftwaffe planes lost on the ground)

    As for your conclusion on the Battle of Britain…..why then invade USSR a month later if the Luftwaffe were taught such a lesson? Does not appear plausible.

    Russia typically only faced about a third of German airpower.

    Facing more than a third of their pilots and aircraft does not necessarily indicate more than a third of their airpower……..but it’s absolutely impossible that Russia did not face the large majority of German airforce compared to the other allies. If 80% + of Nazi land forces are fighting USSR, and though Nazi navy more focused on other arenas – the British and Americans are using many ships to deliver things to USSR ( so engaging a decent amount of the Kriegsmarine along this northern route in addition to them vs Black Sea Fleet in the south area of the war) …..then it’s ridiculous to think that a corresponding number of Nazi air power is not directed towards Russia. If not 80% to match the land forces, then certainly over 50%

  787. @AP
    @Gerard1234


    Summary – Communism was not in any way “evil” you sick POS. Poles did the opposite of resist them
     
    If it were true that Poles did the "opposite" of resist Communism, you would have liked the Poles.

    So you disprove your own claims.

    Regarding Poles siding with the Nazis in 1938:

    This lie of yours has already been debunked multiple times, many many people, some of whom aren’t posting here anymore.


    Of course nobody has “debunked” this, because it’s true.

    Nazi Poland was the first to sign agreement with Nazi Germany ...
     
    A nonaggression agreement is not an alliance. They agreed to recognize the borders and not to attack one another.

    The Soviets in contrast actually had an alliance with the Nazis.

    There was zero opposing of Nazism from fascist Poland
     
    Unlike Czechia, Poland fought against the Nazis. The first to do so.

    Poles fought Commies in 1920 (and defeated them, saving Europe from a Russian commie invasion), 1939, and 1945.

    LMFAO. Poland fought ( and got smashed) by the Soviets you dumb prick
     
    Poland stopped the Soviets outside Warsaw and drove them East to Minsk.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Warsaw_(1920)

    The Battle of Warsaw (Polish: Bitwa Warszawska; Russian: Варшавская битва, Varshavskaya bitva), also known as the Miracle on the Vistula (Polish: Cud nad Wisłą), was a series of battles that resulted in a decisive Polish victory in 1920 during the Polish–Soviet War. Poland, on the verge of total defeat, repulsed and defeated the Red Army.

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/2/27/Gu%C3%A8rra_Sovietopolonesa_%281919-1921%29.png/800px-Gu%C3%A8rra_Sovietopolonesa_%281919-1921%29.png

    [Poles] took war to Russia, a Russia in anarchy ,without any state
     
    Bolsheviks did not have a state in December 1919?

    and in civil war
     
    The Civil War was wrapping up by the time the Soviets and Poles were fighting. By the end of 1919 the Soviets controlled all of Russia's large cities, almost all of European Russia plus the Urals and much of Siberia (Omsk was captured in November 1919).

    A simple look at what the Poles (nearly unopposed) seized initially in the background of Russian civil war and what they finished with, makes everything clear.
     
    Poles had more territory in the nd than they had in March 2019. And a lot more than they had in August 1920.

    In reality French Generals, French air force, German & British & French artillery, rifles and ammunition, American and British huge amounts of money, and German, French and British intelligence
     
    Yes, Poland got a lot of Western help, without which it would not have defeated the much-larger Soviets. Kind of like about 20 years later, the Soviets got a lot of help, without which they would have lost to much-smaller Germany.

    Parasiting off their Nazi friends during the Munich Agreement in 1938 ( hundreds of thousands of Poles from those illegally seized lands fought with the Nazis in Barbarossa)…
     
    100.00s of Poles from Teszen (total [population 227,000) fought with Nazis in Barbarossa?

    Is this another example of your math skills as a Soviet Civil "Engineer?" Lol.

    Slovaks resisted communism long before Poles did you idiot. “Solidarity” was nothing compared to violent/aggressive resistance Prague in 1968
     
    1. Did you know Prague is not in Slovakia?
    2. Solidarity ended with Soviet retreat from Poland. Prague 1968 was not successful.

    Solidarity only developed because there was a Pole as secretary of State in the White House you idiot that pressurised USSR under threat of more sanctions
     
    So you admit that Poles in America also contributed to the destruction of the Soviet system, not only Poles in Poland. Good. You may be a dumb Soviet "engineer" but you are capable of occasionally writing something that is correct.

    you even write number for executions that CONFIRM Russian Empire more lenient than the others
     
    Russia:

    https://www.rbth.com/history/331226-death-penalty-russia

    1826-1905: 526 people executed
    1905-1910: 3,700 people executed

    Germany:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_Germany

    1907-1932: 393 people executed (could not find data for 19th century)

    Austria (not the Hungarian-ruled part of Austria-Hungary):

    https://www.jstor.org/stable/2276063?seq=2

    1852-1897: 175 people executed

    England and Wales:

    https://www.acrosswalls.org/datasets/executions-england-wales-from-1800/

    1852-1897: 622 people executed

    The rest that you wrote is desperate nonsense.

    One man gets assassinated in A-H and World war with tens of millions dead starts
     
    Austria-Hungary didn't execute thousands after Empress Sissi was assassinated.

    The war became a world war due to Russia.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ, @Sean

    Austria-Hungary didn’t execute thousands after Empress Sissi was assassinated.

    Nor did it execute thousands when a wannabe Italian tried to assassinate Franz Josef back in 1882:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guglielmo_Oberdan

    The war became a world war due to Russia.

    Well, I still think that Austria-Hungary also made a mistake by doing to war against Serbia back in 1914 (1904-1905 was a better time for this). This authors explains this argument in more detail even ignoring the Russian factor:

    https://books.google.com/books?id=F5QDAAAAMAAJ&printsec=frontcover&dq=The+Habsburg+Monarchy+wickham+steed&hl=en&newbks=1&newbks_redir=0&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwidvv-43uCDAxUOIUQIHUfNDIkQ6AF6BAgHEAI#v=snippet&q=suicide&f=false

    It is mentioned specifically on page VIII here. Specifically, the argument is that Austria-Hungary would bankrupt itself occupying and garrisoning Serbia, create an even larger Slavic political headache for itself, and become even more dependent on Germany as a result of all of this. Similar to how Russia is becoming even more dependent on China right now as a result of its attempts to subjugate and then conquer Ukraine over the past decade.

    That said, though, Russia did make two big mistakes in the 1914-1917 time period: The first one was actually going to war for Serbia (against Rasputin’s own advice, actually; he was anti-war) and the second one was not keeping sufficient order and stability on the home front once Russia actually went to war, thus paving the way for Russia’s takeover by the Bolsheviks in late 1917.

  788. @AP
    @Gerard1234


    Summary – Communism was not in any way “evil” you sick POS. Poles did the opposite of resist them
     
    If it were true that Poles did the "opposite" of resist Communism, you would have liked the Poles.

    So you disprove your own claims.

    Regarding Poles siding with the Nazis in 1938:

    This lie of yours has already been debunked multiple times, many many people, some of whom aren’t posting here anymore.


    Of course nobody has “debunked” this, because it’s true.

    Nazi Poland was the first to sign agreement with Nazi Germany ...
     
    A nonaggression agreement is not an alliance. They agreed to recognize the borders and not to attack one another.

    The Soviets in contrast actually had an alliance with the Nazis.

    There was zero opposing of Nazism from fascist Poland
     
    Unlike Czechia, Poland fought against the Nazis. The first to do so.

    Poles fought Commies in 1920 (and defeated them, saving Europe from a Russian commie invasion), 1939, and 1945.

    LMFAO. Poland fought ( and got smashed) by the Soviets you dumb prick
     
    Poland stopped the Soviets outside Warsaw and drove them East to Minsk.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Warsaw_(1920)

    The Battle of Warsaw (Polish: Bitwa Warszawska; Russian: Варшавская битва, Varshavskaya bitva), also known as the Miracle on the Vistula (Polish: Cud nad Wisłą), was a series of battles that resulted in a decisive Polish victory in 1920 during the Polish–Soviet War. Poland, on the verge of total defeat, repulsed and defeated the Red Army.

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/2/27/Gu%C3%A8rra_Sovietopolonesa_%281919-1921%29.png/800px-Gu%C3%A8rra_Sovietopolonesa_%281919-1921%29.png

    [Poles] took war to Russia, a Russia in anarchy ,without any state
     
    Bolsheviks did not have a state in December 1919?

    and in civil war
     
    The Civil War was wrapping up by the time the Soviets and Poles were fighting. By the end of 1919 the Soviets controlled all of Russia's large cities, almost all of European Russia plus the Urals and much of Siberia (Omsk was captured in November 1919).

    A simple look at what the Poles (nearly unopposed) seized initially in the background of Russian civil war and what they finished with, makes everything clear.
     
    Poles had more territory in the nd than they had in March 2019. And a lot more than they had in August 1920.

    In reality French Generals, French air force, German & British & French artillery, rifles and ammunition, American and British huge amounts of money, and German, French and British intelligence
     
    Yes, Poland got a lot of Western help, without which it would not have defeated the much-larger Soviets. Kind of like about 20 years later, the Soviets got a lot of help, without which they would have lost to much-smaller Germany.

    Parasiting off their Nazi friends during the Munich Agreement in 1938 ( hundreds of thousands of Poles from those illegally seized lands fought with the Nazis in Barbarossa)…
     
    100.00s of Poles from Teszen (total [population 227,000) fought with Nazis in Barbarossa?

    Is this another example of your math skills as a Soviet Civil "Engineer?" Lol.

    Slovaks resisted communism long before Poles did you idiot. “Solidarity” was nothing compared to violent/aggressive resistance Prague in 1968
     
    1. Did you know Prague is not in Slovakia?
    2. Solidarity ended with Soviet retreat from Poland. Prague 1968 was not successful.

    Solidarity only developed because there was a Pole as secretary of State in the White House you idiot that pressurised USSR under threat of more sanctions
     
    So you admit that Poles in America also contributed to the destruction of the Soviet system, not only Poles in Poland. Good. You may be a dumb Soviet "engineer" but you are capable of occasionally writing something that is correct.

    you even write number for executions that CONFIRM Russian Empire more lenient than the others
     
    Russia:

    https://www.rbth.com/history/331226-death-penalty-russia

    1826-1905: 526 people executed
    1905-1910: 3,700 people executed

    Germany:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_Germany

    1907-1932: 393 people executed (could not find data for 19th century)

    Austria (not the Hungarian-ruled part of Austria-Hungary):

    https://www.jstor.org/stable/2276063?seq=2

    1852-1897: 175 people executed

    England and Wales:

    https://www.acrosswalls.org/datasets/executions-england-wales-from-1800/

    1852-1897: 622 people executed

    The rest that you wrote is desperate nonsense.

    One man gets assassinated in A-H and World war with tens of millions dead starts
     
    Austria-Hungary didn't execute thousands after Empress Sissi was assassinated.

    The war became a world war due to Russia.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ, @Sean

    “Poles had more territory in the *end* than they had in March *1919*. And a lot more than they had in August 1920.”

    There–corrected your two errors for you. 🙂

  789. @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    Yep, this is accurate:

    xxxhttps://www.reddit.com/r/Maps/comments/a73tjz/map_of_development_in_romania_2017/

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Romanian_regions_by_Human_Development_Index

    In Romania, other than Bucharest (the Romanian capital), there's a clear pattern that the areas that were under Hapsburg rule for a longer time period are more developed than the ones that weren't. Transylvania is ahead of Oltenia, which in turn is ahead of the rest of Romania other than Bucharest. (Bukovina was also under Austro-Hungarian rule but apparently isn't large/populous enough to affect the HDI score for Moldavia too much.)

    For GDP, it's a slightly more complex picture:

    https://qph.cf2.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-184336671f4edede1f12ff7bc1c8c68f-pjlq

    The wealthiest parts appear to be Bucharest, Transylvania, the coast, and Iasi, in that order. But eastern Transylvania seems like it's roughly as poor as Moldavia is.

    Replies: @LT1488

    ”But eastern Transylvania seems like it’s roughly as poor as Moldavia is.”

    Yeah because it has too many gypsies (Cluj is full of them).

  790. @AP
    @LT1488


    Hungarians are not hated by most slavic eastern europeans
    Poles,Russians, Czechs, Croats etc like the Hungarians and Poles even consider them their brothers
     
    Poles no longer like Hungarians.

    https://notesfrompoland.com/2023/03/27/poles-dislike-of-russians-belarusians-hungarians-and-germans-has-grown-amid-war-finds-study/

    “Apart from Russians, the largest decline in positive sentiment was recorded towards Hungarians, who fell 21 percentage points from 57% to 36%”


    And as for Ukraine, as you said, the Hungarian minority’s rights to speak and learn Hungarian are being infringed upon
     
    I didn’t say that.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

    It seems that the Poles change their opinion on everything every year
    https://www.cnn.com/2023/10/13/europe/poland-ukraine-tensions-election-cmd-intl/index.html
    Last year there were the biggest promoters of Ukrainians, this year they do not seem to be that enthusiastic.
    I assume once the war stagnates even further and things return to 2016-2022 era, Poles will have a positive opinion on Hungary again.

    • LOL: Mr. Hack
    • Replies: @AP
    @LT1488

    Since the article was published in October, the less pro-Ukrainian confederation party did horribly in the Polish election.

    Pro-Ukrainian feelings in Poland have faded somewhat in part due to the fact that many of the Ukrainian-speaking Ukrainians have returned to Ukraine (their regions are not in so much danger) and the ones in Poland tend to be more Russian-speaking. Male draft-dodgers have also been showing up. But Poland still overwhelmingly supports Ukraine.

    Replies: @LT1488

  791. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    BTW, this is off-topic, but it's worth pointing out that out of all of Ukrainian Jewry, Galician, Volhynian, and Subcarpathian Ruthenia was by far the most demographically devastated in the Holocaust since moving and escaping to the east was not a realistic option for most of them. In contrast, many more Ukrainian Jews from further to the east, even from Vinnytsia and Zhytomyr, were able to escape the Holocaust by moving to the Soviet interior in the 1920s or 1930s or by fleeing to the Soviet interior in 1941, when Operation Barbarossa occurred but before the Nazis actually reached their own cities in Ukraine. This is why far western Ukraine* had few Jews in 1959 while the Ukrainian territories further to the east still had considerably more Jews back then:

    https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/7n4jn3/jews_as_a_percentage_of_the_total_population_in/

    *Lviv's Jews were likely migrants from further to the east. It's a similar story with post-WWII Riga's Jews. Subcarpathian Ruthenia was around (or almost) 15% Jewish in early 1944 and if 10% of them survived the Holocaust and subsequently returned back home, then a Jewish percentage of 1.3% for it in 1959 would make sense.

    Replies: @LT1488

    This is why the Holohoax is just a myth
    Most of the jews escaped to Siberia (or were deported). The remaining 1 million or so that died, died due to famine and disease, not magical gassing/masturbation chambers.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @LT1488

    Most of the jews escaped to Siberia (or were deported). The remaining 1 million or so that died, died due to famine and disease, not magical gassing/masturbation chambers.

    I don't doubt that a lot of Ukrainian Jews ran across the border when the Nazis approached. Amusingly a lot of the Putin fans seem to think Ukraine is heavily Jewish even though that changed in WW2. Russia has more Jews in both demographics and government. Some of his fans even talk of Odessa as Jewish. I guess they didn't get the memo that the demographics completely changed by 1945.

    But what about Polish Jews? If 1 million Polish Jews went to Siberia then we would know about it. You can't hide a million Jews in Siberia.

    It would be pretty hard to argue that Hitler didn't kill the Hungarian Jews. There was a documented fight over them and there are pictures of them lined up.

    I'm open to skepticism over the numbers but the best explanation is that the gas chambers were real. I don't think they should be used as a tool for White guilt but they probably existed.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @A123, @QCIC

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488


    The remaining 1 million or so that died, died due to famine and disease, not magical gassing/masturbation chambers.
     
    Sure, Sherlock:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Last_Jew_in_Vinnitsa

    In any case, this still doesn't account for the missing Polish, Hungarian, et cetera Jews. Where exactly did they go? There are three million missing Polish Jews alone, after all. And several hundred thousand missing Hungarian Jews.

    Replies: @LT1488

  792. @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson


    I’m not sure if we should assume that gay priests are attracted to both men and minors. I really don’t know but I’m not going to make the assumption without any evidence. It entirely could be true but the subject of course is under liberal protection.

     

    Well, I was simply referring to the huge numbers of boys that get molested by Catholic priests. You think that such priests are simply pedophiles and molest boys rather than girls because boys are much easier to access for them? Or do you think that some of them have a preference for both boys and adult men but they can't get adult men but they can get boys and they also lack a decent moral compass, so they become child molester priests?

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Well, I was simply referring to the huge numbers of boys that get molested by Catholic priests.

    It was mostly in the past and in liberal cities where the Catholic churches attracted homosexual predators. That was when they weren’t doing background checks and some of those cases were covered up.

    They now have a watchdog system in place. They really don’t want homosexuals in the priesthood.

    Or do you think that some of them have a preference for both boys and adult men but they can’t get adult men but they can get boys and they also lack a decent moral compass, so they become child molester priests?

    I don’t know. I find it all to be pretty horrifying.

    From what I have read they are adept at picking boys from broken homes. I don’t know if they target them with the intent of hiding their homosexuality.

    I also wonder how much child molesters and sexual predators simply hate society. Attacking a child is an attack against society. It’s an attack against innocence. It’s not something society can always protect against and it does an extreme amount of damage. I’ve looked up sexual predators in my area and they were all losers. A surprising number had deformities. I suspect it has a different component when compared to male-female rape.

    I had a friend who was molested by a relative who was the biggest loser in his area. Messed him up for life. Full on anal rape. I really think they should all be executed and psychoanalysis should be used for other criminal groups. But I suppose that won’t happen so maybe we need to figure out how they tick. I’m amazed that society tolerates them. I read about multi-offenders in the news and I just shake my head. At least they get attacked in prison.

    • Replies: @Ennui
    @John Johnson

    We tolerate monsters in our midst because of liberal conceit. By liberal, I don't mean antifa degenerates. I mean narcissistic, self-righteous centrists who see themselves as Atticus Finch. The kind of people who used to quote from a Man for All Seasons.


    Libs are the biggest obstacle to building a civil, well-run society.

  793. @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    This is why the Holohoax is just a myth
    Most of the jews escaped to Siberia (or were deported). The remaining 1 million or so that died, died due to famine and disease, not magical gassing/masturbation chambers.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ

    Most of the jews escaped to Siberia (or were deported). The remaining 1 million or so that died, died due to famine and disease, not magical gassing/masturbation chambers.

    I don’t doubt that a lot of Ukrainian Jews ran across the border when the Nazis approached. Amusingly a lot of the Putin fans seem to think Ukraine is heavily Jewish even though that changed in WW2. Russia has more Jews in both demographics and government. Some of his fans even talk of Odessa as Jewish. I guess they didn’t get the memo that the demographics completely changed by 1945.

    But what about Polish Jews? If 1 million Polish Jews went to Siberia then we would know about it. You can’t hide a million Jews in Siberia.

    It would be pretty hard to argue that Hitler didn’t kill the Hungarian Jews. There was a documented fight over them and there are pictures of them lined up.

    I’m open to skepticism over the numbers but the best explanation is that the gas chambers were real. I don’t think they should be used as a tool for White guilt but they probably existed.

    • Agree: Sean
    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson

    Completely agreed. Indeed, we have a rather detailed report of the gas chambers at Auschwitz-Birkenau from two Jewish inmates who escaped from there in mid-1944:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vrba%E2%80%93Wetzler_report

    Their report allowed most of Budapest's Jewry to be saved from the Holocaust.

    , @A123
    @John Johnson


    If 1 million Polish Jews went to Siberia then we would know about it. You can’t hide a million Jews in Siberia
     
    Post-WWII Russia performed a comprehensive census. This was discussed at some length when Karlin was still here. There is no chance that a huge population in Siberia was covered up.

    The numbers show 5-6 million excess deaths among the Jewish population above & beyond the generic war dead rate of other groups.

    I’m open to skepticism over the numbers but the best explanation is that the gas chambers were real.
     
    One could discuss how to allocate causes that created that excess death count -- general brutality, ghettos, transportation, death camps, etc. There were many options for government forces to permanently dispose of those they deemed as undesirable.

    The ghettos were particularly lethal due to systematic food deprivation combined with various diseases.

    PEACE 😇
    , @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    Some of us who oppose the Western-sponsored war against Russia currently taking place in Ukraine recognize there are not very many Jews in Ukraine. We also notice that Jewish people seem to be highly influential in that country much as they are in the USA and Russia.

    My speculation is there are interesting Jewish aspects of Ukrainian history including the Pale of Settlement, pogroms and the Holodomor. Recent intrigues include Jewish Ukrainian oligarchs funding NeoNazi groups and allowing them to publicly interact with the government. Then there is the Jewish clown pretending to be a president, presiding over a war which seems to have the main purpose of killing Slavs, oops, I mean Goyim.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @A123

  794. @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    This is why the Holohoax is just a myth
    Most of the jews escaped to Siberia (or were deported). The remaining 1 million or so that died, died due to famine and disease, not magical gassing/masturbation chambers.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ

    The remaining 1 million or so that died, died due to famine and disease, not magical gassing/masturbation chambers.

    Sure, Sherlock:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Last_Jew_in_Vinnitsa

    In any case, this still doesn’t account for the missing Polish, Hungarian, et cetera Jews. Where exactly did they go? There are three million missing Polish Jews alone, after all. And several hundred thousand missing Hungarian Jews.

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    three million missing Polish Jews

    Polish jews lived in ''Kresy'' (ie modern westerm Ukraine, western Belarus and Vilinius region Lithuania)

    And as we said 1.5 million of them went far-east to Siberia
    As for the remaining Polish jews, lots of them died, not due to gas chambers, but due to famines and disease, the survivors just mass emigrated to Israel.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  795. @Gerard1234
    @German_reader

    All good points.

    However does it in any way disprove that Soviet air defence was superior?
    I just haven't any idea of how much of whichever type of bomb was dropped on London or the UK as a whole.......but for London surely they had the same amount, probably much less air raids done against them and less bombs dropped than Leningrad suffered? Need to know the numbers. And planes shot down proportional to the number of raids.

    True, a co-ordinated mass attack over a short time is worse than the same amount of bombs dropped over 2-3 years, but overall evidence suggest Soviet cities were better defended from the air.

    In 3 years, damage to Leningrad from the air was not too bad. Civilian deaths much less. Several landmarks in London got hit - I know Buckingham Palace and St Pauls Cathedral, maybe the Parliament got hit. Leningrad/Saint Petersburg did not suffer like this in damage. Both Soviet cities and London not much wooden buildings ( had great fire in 17th century then city was rebuilt) compared to German cities like Dresden or the Japanese ones like Toyko.

    A-A guns in the city and on the ships of the Baltic Fleet in the Neva and off the Baltic coast, together with the work of our air force ensured the Nazi's were not successful in the air raids on Leningrad.


    They didn’t need to anyway, since Germany lacked the resources for a sustained bomber offensive against Soviet Union and much industry could be evacuated beyond the Urals (i.e. beyond the range of German bombers).

     

    For four months ( not much shorter than the main bombing phase against the UK) , before production moved to the Urals, Moscow was the most targeted city on the planet from Autumn 1941-beginning of 1942. Other places the same pattern - though Kiev was taken, air defence against the Nazi invasion worked well. Having Leningrad destroyed from the air, and Moscow in the period till 1942 were far more important and neccessary objectives for the Nazi's than London or even the UK's industrial production sites ever was.

    There is no excuse for London, but the only excuse that could be given for the rest of the UK in air defence is that they have lots of cities very close together ( UK appears very strange in that no other place I have visited has such radically different regional accent over such short distance, which must have occured because of these close, different industrial centres) , each historically with their own industrial importance. With most European cities it's one metropolitan area to defend, in UK you could have 5 different cities, each of own industrial importance to the war......within about 10 minutes of flying time of german bombers if spotted in a certain area. Knowing which cities should be on high alert for a night air raid from that point then becomes very difficult. Doesn't excuse London defence though.

    Replies: @Philip Owen, @Sean

    Germany did not understand the significance of the rather vulnerable radar masts. if it had it had drop tanks for fighter-bombers capable of destroying them. Luftwaffe attacks on southern RAF aerodromes were begining to crack the defences, but the attacks were broken off to concentrate on London around the time the invasion of Russia led to the transfer of the main German Airforce to the East .

  796. @AP
    @Gerard1234


    Summary – Communism was not in any way “evil” you sick POS. Poles did the opposite of resist them
     
    If it were true that Poles did the "opposite" of resist Communism, you would have liked the Poles.

    So you disprove your own claims.

    Regarding Poles siding with the Nazis in 1938:

    This lie of yours has already been debunked multiple times, many many people, some of whom aren’t posting here anymore.


    Of course nobody has “debunked” this, because it’s true.

    Nazi Poland was the first to sign agreement with Nazi Germany ...
     
    A nonaggression agreement is not an alliance. They agreed to recognize the borders and not to attack one another.

    The Soviets in contrast actually had an alliance with the Nazis.

    There was zero opposing of Nazism from fascist Poland
     
    Unlike Czechia, Poland fought against the Nazis. The first to do so.

    Poles fought Commies in 1920 (and defeated them, saving Europe from a Russian commie invasion), 1939, and 1945.

    LMFAO. Poland fought ( and got smashed) by the Soviets you dumb prick
     
    Poland stopped the Soviets outside Warsaw and drove them East to Minsk.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Warsaw_(1920)

    The Battle of Warsaw (Polish: Bitwa Warszawska; Russian: Варшавская битва, Varshavskaya bitva), also known as the Miracle on the Vistula (Polish: Cud nad Wisłą), was a series of battles that resulted in a decisive Polish victory in 1920 during the Polish–Soviet War. Poland, on the verge of total defeat, repulsed and defeated the Red Army.

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/2/27/Gu%C3%A8rra_Sovietopolonesa_%281919-1921%29.png/800px-Gu%C3%A8rra_Sovietopolonesa_%281919-1921%29.png

    [Poles] took war to Russia, a Russia in anarchy ,without any state
     
    Bolsheviks did not have a state in December 1919?

    and in civil war
     
    The Civil War was wrapping up by the time the Soviets and Poles were fighting. By the end of 1919 the Soviets controlled all of Russia's large cities, almost all of European Russia plus the Urals and much of Siberia (Omsk was captured in November 1919).

    A simple look at what the Poles (nearly unopposed) seized initially in the background of Russian civil war and what they finished with, makes everything clear.
     
    Poles had more territory in the nd than they had in March 2019. And a lot more than they had in August 1920.

    In reality French Generals, French air force, German & British & French artillery, rifles and ammunition, American and British huge amounts of money, and German, French and British intelligence
     
    Yes, Poland got a lot of Western help, without which it would not have defeated the much-larger Soviets. Kind of like about 20 years later, the Soviets got a lot of help, without which they would have lost to much-smaller Germany.

    Parasiting off their Nazi friends during the Munich Agreement in 1938 ( hundreds of thousands of Poles from those illegally seized lands fought with the Nazis in Barbarossa)…
     
    100.00s of Poles from Teszen (total [population 227,000) fought with Nazis in Barbarossa?

    Is this another example of your math skills as a Soviet Civil "Engineer?" Lol.

    Slovaks resisted communism long before Poles did you idiot. “Solidarity” was nothing compared to violent/aggressive resistance Prague in 1968
     
    1. Did you know Prague is not in Slovakia?
    2. Solidarity ended with Soviet retreat from Poland. Prague 1968 was not successful.

    Solidarity only developed because there was a Pole as secretary of State in the White House you idiot that pressurised USSR under threat of more sanctions
     
    So you admit that Poles in America also contributed to the destruction of the Soviet system, not only Poles in Poland. Good. You may be a dumb Soviet "engineer" but you are capable of occasionally writing something that is correct.

    you even write number for executions that CONFIRM Russian Empire more lenient than the others
     
    Russia:

    https://www.rbth.com/history/331226-death-penalty-russia

    1826-1905: 526 people executed
    1905-1910: 3,700 people executed

    Germany:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_Germany

    1907-1932: 393 people executed (could not find data for 19th century)

    Austria (not the Hungarian-ruled part of Austria-Hungary):

    https://www.jstor.org/stable/2276063?seq=2

    1852-1897: 175 people executed

    England and Wales:

    https://www.acrosswalls.org/datasets/executions-england-wales-from-1800/

    1852-1897: 622 people executed

    The rest that you wrote is desperate nonsense.

    One man gets assassinated in A-H and World war with tens of millions dead starts
     
    Austria-Hungary didn't execute thousands after Empress Sissi was assassinated.

    The war became a world war due to Russia.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ, @Sean

    It was predicted years before by the half Malaysian Admiral Fisher that Germany would start the war once the Kiel Ship Canal widening was completed, and that was almost exactly when it did start.

  797. @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488


    The remaining 1 million or so that died, died due to famine and disease, not magical gassing/masturbation chambers.
     
    Sure, Sherlock:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Last_Jew_in_Vinnitsa

    In any case, this still doesn't account for the missing Polish, Hungarian, et cetera Jews. Where exactly did they go? There are three million missing Polish Jews alone, after all. And several hundred thousand missing Hungarian Jews.

    Replies: @LT1488

    three million missing Polish Jews

    Polish jews lived in ”Kresy” (ie modern westerm Ukraine, western Belarus and Vilinius region Lithuania)

    And as we said 1.5 million of them went far-east to Siberia
    As for the remaining Polish jews, lots of them died, not due to gas chambers, but due to famines and disease, the survivors just mass emigrated to Israel.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    I should have said two million rather than three million. I'm sorry. The Polish territories west of the Curzon Line had slightly over two million Jews, not three million Jews. The remaining 1+ million Polish Jews were in the Kresy.

    Anyway, you're suggesting that two million Poles died due to famines and diseases that did not affect neighboring populations such as the Poles? Why didn't the Nazis mention anything about starving Jews to death at Nuremberg, et cetera?

    There weren't too many Polish Jewish survivors of the Holocaust relative to the prewar Polish Jewish population. After 1948, slightly under 175,000 Jews immigrated from Poland to Israel:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aliyah#:~:text=Aliyah%20(US%3A%20%2F%CB%8C%C3%A6,by%20the%20State%20of%20Israel.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  798. @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    three million missing Polish Jews

    Polish jews lived in ''Kresy'' (ie modern westerm Ukraine, western Belarus and Vilinius region Lithuania)

    And as we said 1.5 million of them went far-east to Siberia
    As for the remaining Polish jews, lots of them died, not due to gas chambers, but due to famines and disease, the survivors just mass emigrated to Israel.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    I should have said two million rather than three million. I’m sorry. The Polish territories west of the Curzon Line had slightly over two million Jews, not three million Jews. The remaining 1+ million Polish Jews were in the Kresy.

    Anyway, you’re suggesting that two million Poles died due to famines and diseases that did not affect neighboring populations such as the Poles? Why didn’t the Nazis mention anything about starving Jews to death at Nuremberg, et cetera?

    There weren’t too many Polish Jewish survivors of the Holocaust relative to the prewar Polish Jewish population. After 1948, slightly under 175,000 Jews immigrated from Poland to Israel:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aliyah#:~:text=Aliyah%20(US%3A%20%2F%CB%8C%C3%A6,by%20the%20State%20of%20Israel.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mr. XYZ


    I should have said two million rather than three million. I’m sorry.
     
    Oops.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V4WGsMplGxU

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  799. @John Johnson
    @LT1488

    Most of the jews escaped to Siberia (or were deported). The remaining 1 million or so that died, died due to famine and disease, not magical gassing/masturbation chambers.

    I don't doubt that a lot of Ukrainian Jews ran across the border when the Nazis approached. Amusingly a lot of the Putin fans seem to think Ukraine is heavily Jewish even though that changed in WW2. Russia has more Jews in both demographics and government. Some of his fans even talk of Odessa as Jewish. I guess they didn't get the memo that the demographics completely changed by 1945.

    But what about Polish Jews? If 1 million Polish Jews went to Siberia then we would know about it. You can't hide a million Jews in Siberia.

    It would be pretty hard to argue that Hitler didn't kill the Hungarian Jews. There was a documented fight over them and there are pictures of them lined up.

    I'm open to skepticism over the numbers but the best explanation is that the gas chambers were real. I don't think they should be used as a tool for White guilt but they probably existed.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @A123, @QCIC

    Completely agreed. Indeed, we have a rather detailed report of the gas chambers at Auschwitz-Birkenau from two Jewish inmates who escaped from there in mid-1944:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vrba%E2%80%93Wetzler_report

    Their report allowed most of Budapest’s Jewry to be saved from the Holocaust.

  800. Sher Singh says:
    @Barbarossa
    @John Johnson


    I’m of the opinion that the late 90s cars and early 00s are some of the worst.
     
    I feel like GM had a particularly bad period around this time. Their vehicles looked spectacularly awful and seemed very issue prone. I go out of my way to get the most basic trim package on vehicles so I've been kind of insulated. My current non-truck vehicles are a 93 Plymouth Voyager and a 96 Ford E150 and I feel like the early 90's era is pretty ideal. They had enough sophistication to be really efficient and reliable but were still quite simple and easy to diagnose. It's too much diminished returns for the added failure points and complication from there on out.

    In addition to my 89F350 I have Ford F250's from 99 and 00 and they are the best. Just fantastic bulletproof trucks and much better in every system than the 89. Ford only ditched the 7.3 Turbodiesel because of Federal emissions requirements which is a shame. The current 6.7 seems like a good motor finally but I don't really need all the power (and price tag) anyway. I prefer to keep under the 26k gross weight limit allowing me to keep away from the next tiers of DOT regs. My 7.3s have never failed to pull my 14k trailer with gusto so I don't see why I'd want to upgrade.

    The thing that was most striking driving the borrowed newer Ford was how much it was loaded with gimmicky stuff. I guess that is the nature of the vehicle arms race these days.

    Replies: @Sher Singh, @Sher Singh

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khoa

    Water Buffalo raw milk is legal up here so gonna get into that.

    Mom wants to make Khoa Pinnia – I’m 50-50.
    Khoa has like 400cal in 100g.
    Only 20g protein for 400cal.

    Gonna look into how I can use whey protein in it.
    Ultimately, a Pinni is like flour, jaggery, khoa & dry fruit.
    Could probably replace the flour with protein powder & jaggery with splenda?

    https://cookpad.com/in/recipes/13811024-pinni-a-simple-easy-recipe-of-making-pinni

    https://www.nutritionix.com/i/nutritionix/khoya-1-cup/5c925dd6a119d5c65924d02a

    Tweet on structure of raw milk, blood & pasteurized milk.

    [MORE]

  801. @Hyperborean
    @sudden death


    Antiracist/equalizer propagandists suck at their work, when it’s only from Hanania threads you discover that the author of Three Musketeers and Count of Monte Cristo was a negro by modern standards like Pushkin, lol
     
    I thought his origins were pretty well known? But I've always thought the American one-drop rule to be weird. I've always liked more the Spanish imperial guidelines of having a name for every possible racial combination.

    Alexandre Dumas père seems respectably swarthy.

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/06/Alexander_Dumas_p%C3%A8re_par_Nadar_-_Google_Art_Project.jpg/640px-Alexander_Dumas_p%C3%A8re_par_Nadar_-_Google_Art_Project.jpg

    But Alexandre Dumas fils, is he also black?

    https://www.myartprints.co.uk/kunst/leon_joseph_florentin_bonnat/alexandre-dumas-fils.jpg

    Then there's historical African American accomplishment lists where they include people like

    Norris Wright Cuney, holder of the "highest-ranking appointed position of any African American in the late 19th-century South".

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/3/31/Norris_Wright_Cuney.jpg

    Or

    Walter F. White - Leader of the NAACP, 1929-1955.

    https://images.nypl.org/index.php?id=5027558&t=w

    https://www.npr.org/2022/03/30/1089640442/how-one-civil-rights-activist-posed-as-a-white-man-in-order-to-investigate-lynch

    "Posing as white", kek.

    Replies: @sudden death

    Dumas with his hair reminds Don King somewhat;)

    Have no idea about affairs in France, but maybe in US antiracist discourse he’s not that widely promoted not only for being foreigner, but also because of bit inconvenient fact about having collaborating white ghostwriter Auguste Maquet in all his most known popular books?

    • Replies: @Hyperborean
    @sudden death


    Have no idea about affairs in France, but maybe in US antiracist discourse he’s not that widely promoted not only for being foreigner, but also because of bit inconvenient fact about having collaborating white ghostwriter Auguste Maquet in all his most known popular books?
     
    I think it is just parochialism, Americans tend to focus on domestic American personalities. A UK example is Mary Seacole. She seems to have been a non-entity, but for historical revisionists she is being used to replace Florence Nightingale, who is too white and too Protestant for the foreign nurses in the UK to relate to. But I have only ever heard about this active "debate" regarding Nightingale and Seacole in the UK, not in other Western countries.
  802. @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    TBF, wouldn’t priesthood be sub-optimal for a gay Catholic man who is primarily into adults? If he’s into both adults and minors, and lacks any sense of decent morality, however, then the priesthood seems perfect for him. Or if he’s primarily attracted to minors and lacks any sense of decent morality.

    I'm not sure if we should assume that gay priests are attracted to both men and minors. I really don't know but I'm not going to make the assumption without any evidence. It entirely could be true but the subject of course is under liberal protection.

    For the record I don't support allowing certain positions of employment to be covers for gays.

    I know from working with gays that more are celibate than one would assume. The promiscuous STD ridden gay is more of a city phenomenon and not so much in in rural America where they don't have as many dating options. I think everyone in rural America has met the "lone woman" with goats or horses. It's a dyke that doesn't want to be publicly gay. Some of them have religious families that would be absolutely crushed and would disown them. These Christian families really just tell themselves that Jane never met a man and now has a farm by herself. Seriously, the delusion is unreal. I've seen it first hand. Oh he just never met a woman despite having a house and high paying job. Just unlucky I guess. But he makes great desserts for the family get togethers. His house sure is clean.

    There are gays that can live without sex and just want to hide and have people assume they are "married to the cloth" as they say. The Catholic churches provide an occupation that gives them cover. It unfortunately also happens in protestant churches where they marry a beard but the Catholic church will attract more of them. I suspect the Mormon church has a lot more gays than they want to admit. They value the men based on having a family and they can be very effete as long as they drive a mini van with kids.

    Makes one wonder whether priests should be given the option of voluntary castration.

    I think they should allow priests the choice of marriage or celibacy. They shouldn't reject a man who wants to be a priest and also be married. I think allowing straight baby makers would do more for the church than trying to identify gays or encouraging castration.

    We can talk about this openly but Catholics are horrified by such frank discussions. They would never allow the idea of castration because they really don't think this happens. It's some Catholic priest somewhere else that is gay. Some city fag. Like one or two in LA or something. Not our priest! James is a good man! He just chose to isolate himself from women for low pay. Totally normal.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Another Polish Perspective

    Castration for priests is banned by the Old Testament.

    As for homosexuality, it certainly is transferred by recessive genes in some population. It has higher incidence in cousin-marrying populations like South Asia wherefrom the notion of third sex comes. Since cousin marriages tend to conserve chromosome X, it is on this chromosome where homosexuality should be coded (actually all recessive traits are X-chromosome related).It means that homosexuality in family should be observed above all on mother’s side. This is true.

    In 1998, Sanders et al. reported on their similar study, in which they found that 13% of uncles of gay brothers on the maternal side were homosexual, compared with 6% on the paternal side.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biology_and_sexual_orientation

    In general, the homosexual genes seem to be somehow connected to promiscuity, here euphemised as “fecundity”. This is in line with very strong sexual drive reported among many homosexuals and bisexuals.
    Clearly even the Biblical story of Sodom conveys element of promiscuity – Sodomites strongly wanting angels just for sex, despite them being their guests

    https://www.nature.com/articles/news041011-5

    But homo propaganda will never tell you that – they just “happen” to be.

  803. The biggest territorial beneficiary of WW1.

    https://www.unz.com/pfrost/they-really-did-start-it/

    The Archduke’s dream was a nightmare for Serbia’s rulers. Today, few of us know just how much that country was viewed as a rogue state in 1914. About a decade earlier, a group of army officers had staged a coup d’état, killing the king, the queen, her two brothers, the prime minister, and the minister of the army (May Coup, 2015). The coup outraged the international community, with most countries freezing diplomatic relations and imposing sanctions. Great Britain restored relations only three years later, after the senior conspirators had been removed from office. Nonetheless, they and like-minded people continued to exercise much authority through a secret society called The Black Hand. More importantly, nothing was done to change the radical shift in Serbian foreign policy, which was now anti-Austro-Hungary and pro-Greater-Serbia: […]

    Conclusion

    Can a small country deliberately cause a big war? Yes, in the right context, especially one of relative peace when the major powers have their hands free to engage in war (or think they do). A small country may exploit this potential for global conflict if it sees no other way to achieve its national aims and if the alternatives seem humiliating or intolerable. This mental calculation would also include the costs of global conflict … which are borne overwhelmingly by the citizenries of other countries.

    Serbia paid dearly for the First World War, but the payback was considerable. When the spoils were divided up in 1918, Serbia more than doubled in land area, becoming comparable in size to the large states of Western Europe. The dream of Greater Serbia had come true.

  804. @John Johnson
    @Sean

    Dershowitz takes a different view. He says it is selective prosecution and its wrong.

    A former Trump lawyer and Fox News contributor says everything will be fine. Yea nothing to worry about.

    You didn't provide a source so I looked up his opinion:
    The cases against Trump have not met that standard, Dershowitz said, except “maybe” his second federal indictment alleging he mishandled classified documents.
    https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/764990/dershowitz-says-no-prosecution-likely-as-biden-and-trump-docs-neutralize-each-other/

    He thinks Trump will skate the charges because the Feds mishandled it. Meaning Trump is guilty but will get away with it.

    Note that he considers the documents case to have the most weight. That is what I have been saying for months. It's not some random case that a bunch of Democrats contrived. Trump really messed up.

    Two former employees plan to testify against Trump. This is not merely a case of Trump accidentally bringing home documents. He had boxes of them and asked his employees to help cover up the evidence. That's Federal tampering. Not good.

    Not Trump (or Putin): Xi. There is some kind of a fight coming with China, and as he publicly said not so long ago

    Not sure what you mean here. I wasn't saying anything about China.

    By saying he needs a rabbit foot up his butt I mean he needs pure luck. The odds are against him in the documents case. The property juicing and 3 minute rape at the department store cases are weak but the documents case is a problem. His fans are mistakenly assuming it is all conspiracy.

    Replies: @Sean

    Dershowitz says Trump will be convicted. The NY prosecutor ran for that office on a promise to bring a case against Trump. So it is not impermissible technically, but it is clear cut selective prosecution.

  805. @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    Well, I was simply referring to the huge numbers of boys that get molested by Catholic priests.

    It was mostly in the past and in liberal cities where the Catholic churches attracted homosexual predators. That was when they weren't doing background checks and some of those cases were covered up.

    They now have a watchdog system in place. They really don't want homosexuals in the priesthood.

    Or do you think that some of them have a preference for both boys and adult men but they can’t get adult men but they can get boys and they also lack a decent moral compass, so they become child molester priests?

    I don't know. I find it all to be pretty horrifying.

    From what I have read they are adept at picking boys from broken homes. I don't know if they target them with the intent of hiding their homosexuality.

    I also wonder how much child molesters and sexual predators simply hate society. Attacking a child is an attack against society. It's an attack against innocence. It's not something society can always protect against and it does an extreme amount of damage. I've looked up sexual predators in my area and they were all losers. A surprising number had deformities. I suspect it has a different component when compared to male-female rape.

    I had a friend who was molested by a relative who was the biggest loser in his area. Messed him up for life. Full on anal rape. I really think they should all be executed and psychoanalysis should be used for other criminal groups. But I suppose that won't happen so maybe we need to figure out how they tick. I'm amazed that society tolerates them. I read about multi-offenders in the news and I just shake my head. At least they get attacked in prison.

    Replies: @Ennui

    We tolerate monsters in our midst because of liberal conceit. By liberal, I don’t mean antifa degenerates. I mean narcissistic, self-righteous centrists who see themselves as Atticus Finch. The kind of people who used to quote from a Man for All Seasons.

    Libs are the biggest obstacle to building a civil, well-run society.

  806. @sudden death
    @Hyperborean

    Dumas with his hair reminds Don King somewhat;)

    https://images.sportsbrief.com/images/720/8f4a4a961afe790c.webp

    Have no idea about affairs in France, but maybe in US antiracist discourse he's not that widely promoted not only for being foreigner, but also because of bit inconvenient fact about having collaborating white ghostwriter Auguste Maquet in all his most known popular books?

    Replies: @Hyperborean

    Have no idea about affairs in France, but maybe in US antiracist discourse he’s not that widely promoted not only for being foreigner, but also because of bit inconvenient fact about having collaborating white ghostwriter Auguste Maquet in all his most known popular books?

    I think it is just parochialism, Americans tend to focus on domestic American personalities. A UK example is Mary Seacole. She seems to have been a non-entity, but for historical revisionists she is being used to replace Florence Nightingale, who is too white and too Protestant for the foreign nurses in the UK to relate to. But I have only ever heard about this active “debate” regarding Nightingale and Seacole in the UK, not in other Western countries.

  807. @QCIC
    @songbird

    FIV = Fauci Invented Virus?

    In your best Tony voice: "Here, kitty kitty...."

    Replies: @songbird

    I started out by thinking one couldn’t blame gays, as it can’t infect humans. But I suppose one can’t necessarily eliminate the possibility it escaped from a lab, where they were doing research on HIV and related viruses.

    But am unclear on an exact timeline or how fast something like that would spread across the country.

    @Emil
    Have read the dog thread. I agree with the general sentiment that much of recent dog breeding seems superficial and directionless.

    Disagree with the commonly expressed idea that people don’t want intelligent dogs.

    It’s good to have a dog that won’t eat your dinner, if you leave the room. Personally, I would like a dog that would be as friendly as a retriever in general, but not to a burglar. Probably one that wouldn’t dominance-hump other dogs or eat animal waste.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    All dogs eat poop. It is part of a dog's well-balanced diet.

    I have known people who let dogs sleep in their bed and lick their face. Agree that dog eugenics [sic] is an excellent thought experiment for science fiction gene editing humans.

    Did you ever take a catechism class where they taught you that all of the church dogmas are rooted in Ten Commandments, Lord's Prayer, and Apostles' Creed? There is a tradition that the commandment to not take God's name in vain implies that man is commanded not to play God. Also implied:

    Thou shalt not abort fetuses
    Thou shalt not chop off your nuts
    Thou shalt not snip out that gene for aggro behavior
    Thou shalt not snip out that gene for dumb and tomfoolery
    Thou shalt not cut and paste in that gene for high SAT scores

    + &c.

    This is the logic chain where Sarah Palin was applauded by fundies for carrying her Down's Syndrome fetus all the way. That was a deliberate and extreme righteousness display.

    The part about poop being part of a dog's well-balanced diet might be pseudo science but I am not a dog person. Dogs are way too much work if you ask me.

    My favorite comment was the Rottweiler one which I also have no idea if it is true. The fellow who posted it said the breed has been selected huge. The NBA player who was attacked by his dog on Christmas and knocked out of a couple games with dog bites has a Rottweiler. I haven't seen a report on how big the dog was but the NBA guy is 6ft 8in 235lb. I am curious how big that dog was.

    Replies: @songbird, @Philip Owen

  808. @John Johnson
    @LT1488

    Most of the jews escaped to Siberia (or were deported). The remaining 1 million or so that died, died due to famine and disease, not magical gassing/masturbation chambers.

    I don't doubt that a lot of Ukrainian Jews ran across the border when the Nazis approached. Amusingly a lot of the Putin fans seem to think Ukraine is heavily Jewish even though that changed in WW2. Russia has more Jews in both demographics and government. Some of his fans even talk of Odessa as Jewish. I guess they didn't get the memo that the demographics completely changed by 1945.

    But what about Polish Jews? If 1 million Polish Jews went to Siberia then we would know about it. You can't hide a million Jews in Siberia.

    It would be pretty hard to argue that Hitler didn't kill the Hungarian Jews. There was a documented fight over them and there are pictures of them lined up.

    I'm open to skepticism over the numbers but the best explanation is that the gas chambers were real. I don't think they should be used as a tool for White guilt but they probably existed.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @A123, @QCIC

    If 1 million Polish Jews went to Siberia then we would know about it. You can’t hide a million Jews in Siberia

    Post-WWII Russia performed a comprehensive census. This was discussed at some length when Karlin was still here. There is no chance that a huge population in Siberia was covered up.

    The numbers show 5-6 million excess deaths among the Jewish population above & beyond the generic war dead rate of other groups.

    I’m open to skepticism over the numbers but the best explanation is that the gas chambers were real.

    One could discuss how to allocate causes that created that excess death count — general brutality, ghettos, transportation, death camps, etc. There were many options for government forces to permanently dispose of those they deemed as undesirable.

    The ghettos were particularly lethal due to systematic food deprivation combined with various diseases.

    PEACE 😇

  809. @AP
    @QCIC


    He doesn’t mean kill everyone, he means remove Ukraine’s geopolitical autonomy to protect Ukrainians from themselves and the West. The main reason is to protect Russia, but since many in the Kremlin see Ukraine as essentially Russian these issues are intertwined.
     
    Thanks for confirming that Russia is fighting to end Ukraine's independence from Russia, and that Ukrainians are fighting to prevent a Russian takeover of their country.

    Thanks also for confirming that you implicitly hope that Ukrainians get conquered by Russia.

    Replies: @QCIC

    I am against WW3 which the West is trying to start. Everything else follows.

    I do not write about what I hope will happen in Ukraine, simply what I expect to happen. I hate the murders on all sides. I recognize the West created this mess using Ukraine as a pawn against Russia, so I am not persuaded by shrill claims that “Putin started it!”

    Ukraine could have created what you and Hack dream of, but the leadership chose to pursue this autonomy as puppets of the West. In addition to being a contradiction, this was a sellout, not a mistake. Once this sellout happened, probably starting in the 1990’s, Ukraine was simply working on her own destruction.

    • Replies: @AP
    @QCIC


    I am against WW3 which the West is trying to start
     
    You are a contrarian who likes to think the opposite of reality and who for some reason hates the West, your place of origin. Your supposed fear of World War III is not a very convincing excuse or cover for your self-hatred. If Ukraine is conquered (unlikely) and Putin demands the Baltics next, you will argue that they should be given to him because of the risk of World War III. You will blame them for anti-Russian policies, provocations, being “pawns” of the West, etc. Is that right?

    And then if Russia demands the return of the War-era spheres of control and a NATO withdrawal from Poland, Czechia etc. you will also support that, in order to prevent World War III of course. Correct?

    I recognize the West created this mess using Ukraine as a pawn against Russia, so I am not persuaded by shrill claims that “Putin started it!”

     

    A normal person assigns blame for starting a war on the side that invades. America, not Saddam, started the Iraq war, Saddam did not start it by abusing Kurds and Shiites or trying to get weapons. Russia, not Ukraine or the West, started the Russia-Ukraine war.

    Ukraine could have created what you and Hack dream of, but the leadership chose to pursue this autonomy as puppets of the West
     
    According to the Russian state concerns (which you ape), any separation of Ukraine from Russia is seen as by definition puppetry by the West, thus no separation is allowed. War is inevitable as long as Ukraine seeks independence from Russia. Medvedev has made that quite clear, and you agree. Good to know where everyone stands.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

    , @Mr. Hack
    @QCIC


    Ukraine could have created what you and Hack dream of, but the leadership chose to pursue this autonomy as puppets of the West. In addition to being a contradiction, this was a sellout, not a mistake. Once this sellout happened, probably starting in the 1990’s, Ukraine was simply working on her own destruction.
     
    There is no contradiction a all, except the one that you seem to cultivate within your own cowardly mind. Ukrainians could see, as verified by the current Russian aggressive moves culminating in the full onset of this current war, that pursuing autonomy was not possible with a Russia that was hellbent on reestablishing its imperial dreams. To fall into line with the Kremlin's plans would have meant abandoning any hope of autonomy and instead succumb to a constant and historical march towards full russification and become something akin to Belarus or even Kuban. Ukraine is indeed fortunate to have western partners that are fully on board to help Ukraine, both financially and militarily during the huge current existential threat to its very survival as a nation.
    , @John Johnson
    @QCIC

    I recognize the West created this mess using Ukraine as a pawn against Russia, so I am not persuaded by shrill claims that “Putin started it!”

    Well the UN voted 143-5 that Russia is the aggressor. That 5 included Russia, Belarus and North Korea. Putin couldn't even pull his pal India.

    I guess the world is a shrill claim.

    Oh and your dwarf slipped up and called it a conquest in an interview:
    "As for this negotiation process, it is an attempt to encourage us to abandon our conquests from the past year and a half," Putin told the heads of municipalities from throughout the country in comments posted on the Kremlin website.

    WHOOPS
    Putin boasts of conquests in Ukraine
    https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/ukrainealert/confident-putin-boasts-of-russian-conquests-in-ukraine/

    When this war started I said that insecure pricks like Putin always make it hard for their own defenders. That is what they do.

  810. @LT1488
    @AP

    It seems that the Poles change their opinion on everything every year
    https://www.cnn.com/2023/10/13/europe/poland-ukraine-tensions-election-cmd-intl/index.html
    Last year there were the biggest promoters of Ukrainians, this year they do not seem to be that enthusiastic.
    I assume once the war stagnates even further and things return to 2016-2022 era, Poles will have a positive opinion on Hungary again.

    Replies: @AP

    Since the article was published in October, the less pro-Ukrainian confederation party did horribly in the Polish election.

    Pro-Ukrainian feelings in Poland have faded somewhat in part due to the fact that many of the Ukrainian-speaking Ukrainians have returned to Ukraine (their regions are not in so much danger) and the ones in Poland tend to be more Russian-speaking. Male draft-dodgers have also been showing up. But Poland still overwhelmingly supports Ukraine.

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @AP

    Konfedaracja did horribly because their former leader Korwin kept on praising Hitler every 5 minutes on Twitter.

    Replies: @AP

  811. @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    I should have said two million rather than three million. I'm sorry. The Polish territories west of the Curzon Line had slightly over two million Jews, not three million Jews. The remaining 1+ million Polish Jews were in the Kresy.

    Anyway, you're suggesting that two million Poles died due to famines and diseases that did not affect neighboring populations such as the Poles? Why didn't the Nazis mention anything about starving Jews to death at Nuremberg, et cetera?

    There weren't too many Polish Jewish survivors of the Holocaust relative to the prewar Polish Jewish population. After 1948, slightly under 175,000 Jews immigrated from Poland to Israel:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aliyah#:~:text=Aliyah%20(US%3A%20%2F%CB%8C%C3%A6,by%20the%20State%20of%20Israel.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    I should have said two million rather than three million. I’m sorry.

    Oops.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    It doesn't cardinally change the overall picture, though. I confused the Jewish population figures for all of interwar Poland with those for interwar Poland west of the Curzon Line. An understandable mistake.

  812. @QCIC
    @AP

    I am against WW3 which the West is trying to start. Everything else follows.

    I do not write about what I hope will happen in Ukraine, simply what I expect to happen. I hate the murders on all sides. I recognize the West created this mess using Ukraine as a pawn against Russia, so I am not persuaded by shrill claims that "Putin started it!"

    Ukraine could have created what you and Hack dream of, but the leadership chose to pursue this autonomy as puppets of the West. In addition to being a contradiction, this was a sellout, not a mistake. Once this sellout happened, probably starting in the 1990's, Ukraine was simply working on her own destruction.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. Hack, @John Johnson

    I am against WW3 which the West is trying to start

    You are a contrarian who likes to think the opposite of reality and who for some reason hates the West, your place of origin. Your supposed fear of World War III is not a very convincing excuse or cover for your self-hatred. If Ukraine is conquered (unlikely) and Putin demands the Baltics next, you will argue that they should be given to him because of the risk of World War III. You will blame them for anti-Russian policies, provocations, being “pawns” of the West, etc. Is that right?

    And then if Russia demands the return of the War-era spheres of control and a NATO withdrawal from Poland, Czechia etc. you will also support that, in order to prevent World War III of course. Correct?

    I recognize the West created this mess using Ukraine as a pawn against Russia, so I am not persuaded by shrill claims that “Putin started it!”

    A normal person assigns blame for starting a war on the side that invades. America, not Saddam, started the Iraq war, Saddam did not start it by abusing Kurds and Shiites or trying to get weapons. Russia, not Ukraine or the West, started the Russia-Ukraine war.

    Ukraine could have created what you and Hack dream of, but the leadership chose to pursue this autonomy as puppets of the West

    According to the Russian state concerns (which you ape), any separation of Ukraine from Russia is seen as by definition puppetry by the West, thus no separation is allowed. War is inevitable as long as Ukraine seeks independence from Russia. Medvedev has made that quite clear, and you agree. Good to know where everyone stands.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @AP

    As long as you believe this conflict is primarily about Ukraine versus Russia you will never understand what I am describing.

    Proxy wars are confusing. This makes it easy for people to drop the context and delude themselves about what is actually occurring.

    I love the USA and our fading version of Western post-Enlightenment culture. I hate to see losers and liars start wars of choice which reduce freedom and prosperity for most Americans and risk greater conflict which could lead to billions of murders. The risk of WW3 is non-trivial and the potential loss is unimaginable.

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    A normal person assigns blame for starting a war on the side that invades. America, not Saddam, started the Iraq war, Saddam did not start it by abusing Kurds and Shiites or trying to get weapons. Russia, not Ukraine or the West, started the Russia-Ukraine war.

     

    By that logic, JFK would have started WWIII had Vasily Arkhipov not had some common sense since he was the one who ordered the blockade of Cuba, which by international law is a declaration of war, right?
  813. @QCIC
    @AP

    I am against WW3 which the West is trying to start. Everything else follows.

    I do not write about what I hope will happen in Ukraine, simply what I expect to happen. I hate the murders on all sides. I recognize the West created this mess using Ukraine as a pawn against Russia, so I am not persuaded by shrill claims that "Putin started it!"

    Ukraine could have created what you and Hack dream of, but the leadership chose to pursue this autonomy as puppets of the West. In addition to being a contradiction, this was a sellout, not a mistake. Once this sellout happened, probably starting in the 1990's, Ukraine was simply working on her own destruction.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. Hack, @John Johnson

    Ukraine could have created what you and Hack dream of, but the leadership chose to pursue this autonomy as puppets of the West. In addition to being a contradiction, this was a sellout, not a mistake. Once this sellout happened, probably starting in the 1990’s, Ukraine was simply working on her own destruction.

    There is no contradiction a all, except the one that you seem to cultivate within your own cowardly mind. Ukrainians could see, as verified by the current Russian aggressive moves culminating in the full onset of this current war, that pursuing autonomy was not possible with a Russia that was hellbent on reestablishing its imperial dreams. To fall into line with the Kremlin’s plans would have meant abandoning any hope of autonomy and instead succumb to a constant and historical march towards full russification and become something akin to Belarus or even Kuban. Ukraine is indeed fortunate to have western partners that are fully on board to help Ukraine, both financially and militarily during the huge current existential threat to its very survival as a nation.

  814. @John Johnson
    @LT1488

    Most of the jews escaped to Siberia (or were deported). The remaining 1 million or so that died, died due to famine and disease, not magical gassing/masturbation chambers.

    I don't doubt that a lot of Ukrainian Jews ran across the border when the Nazis approached. Amusingly a lot of the Putin fans seem to think Ukraine is heavily Jewish even though that changed in WW2. Russia has more Jews in both demographics and government. Some of his fans even talk of Odessa as Jewish. I guess they didn't get the memo that the demographics completely changed by 1945.

    But what about Polish Jews? If 1 million Polish Jews went to Siberia then we would know about it. You can't hide a million Jews in Siberia.

    It would be pretty hard to argue that Hitler didn't kill the Hungarian Jews. There was a documented fight over them and there are pictures of them lined up.

    I'm open to skepticism over the numbers but the best explanation is that the gas chambers were real. I don't think they should be used as a tool for White guilt but they probably existed.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @A123, @QCIC

    Some of us who oppose the Western-sponsored war against Russia currently taking place in Ukraine recognize there are not very many Jews in Ukraine. We also notice that Jewish people seem to be highly influential in that country much as they are in the USA and Russia.

    My speculation is there are interesting Jewish aspects of Ukrainian history including the Pale of Settlement, pogroms and the Holodomor. Recent intrigues include Jewish Ukrainian oligarchs funding NeoNazi groups and allowing them to publicly interact with the government. Then there is the Jewish clown pretending to be a president, presiding over a war which seems to have the main purpose of killing Slavs, oops, I mean Goyim.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @QCIC

    The biggest jewish community center on earth is in Dnipro.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Menorah_center,_Dnipro

    Paid for by Kolomoyskyi's loot. Zelensky was originally paid for by Kolomoyskyi's loot before he got the blank check from the Congress. Kolomoyskyi just did the start up funding for that project.

    , @A123
    @QCIC

    Some of us who oppose the Western-sponsored war against Russia currently taking place in Ukraine recognize there are not very many Jews in Ukraine. We also notice that anti-Semitic neo-Nazi people are very influential in the country. Post-Judiac apostate Zelensky travelled to Israel to offend Jews. The anti-Semitism of his Azov Brigade is less than subtle.

     
    https://media.snopes.com/2022/03/GettyImages-1207144800-azov-battallion.jpg
     

    While Kolomoyskyi outwardly funds Jewish projects, he does not appear to personally follow the tenents of Judaism. He has a number of outlandish behaviours such as keeping live sharks in his office, sort of like a bond villan.

    Realistically, trying to attach Judaism to either side of the conflict is a lengthy reach. However, if you must do so, then Russia is much more aligned with Jews versus neo-Nazi, anti-Semitic Ukraine.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. Hack

  815. @songbird
    @QCIC

    I started out by thinking one couldn't blame gays, as it can't infect humans. But I suppose one can't necessarily eliminate the possibility it escaped from a lab, where they were doing research on HIV and related viruses.

    But am unclear on an exact timeline or how fast something like that would spread across the country.

    @Emil
    Have read the dog thread. I agree with the general sentiment that much of recent dog breeding seems superficial and directionless.

    Disagree with the commonly expressed idea that people don't want intelligent dogs.

    It's good to have a dog that won't eat your dinner, if you leave the room. Personally, I would like a dog that would be as friendly as a retriever in general, but not to a burglar. Probably one that wouldn't dominance-hump other dogs or eat animal waste.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    All dogs eat poop. It is part of a dog’s well-balanced diet.

    I have known people who let dogs sleep in their bed and lick their face. Agree that dog eugenics [sic] is an excellent thought experiment for science fiction gene editing humans.

    Did you ever take a catechism class where they taught you that all of the church dogmas are rooted in Ten Commandments, Lord’s Prayer, and Apostles’ Creed? There is a tradition that the commandment to not take God’s name in vain implies that man is commanded not to play God. Also implied:

    Thou shalt not abort fetuses
    Thou shalt not chop off your nuts
    Thou shalt not snip out that gene for aggro behavior
    Thou shalt not snip out that gene for dumb and tomfoolery
    Thou shalt not cut and paste in that gene for high SAT scores

    + &c.

    This is the logic chain where Sarah Palin was applauded by fundies for carrying her Down’s Syndrome fetus all the way. That was a deliberate and extreme righteousness display.

    The part about poop being part of a dog’s well-balanced diet might be pseudo science but I am not a dog person. Dogs are way too much work if you ask me.

    My favorite comment was the Rottweiler one which I also have no idea if it is true. The fellow who posted it said the breed has been selected huge. The NBA player who was attacked by his dog on Christmas and knocked out of a couple games with dog bites has a Rottweiler. I haven’t seen a report on how big the dog was but the NBA guy is 6ft 8in 235lb. I am curious how big that dog was.

    • Replies: @songbird
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Coprophagia is almost as interesting as it is disgusting.

    Leaving a lot of sticks in a pile over winter where it snows can be a lesson in it, as it is sometimes possible to observe enormous quantities of rabbit waste. No idea if that is the type they re-eat, or whether it has already come out a second time.

    I've generally heard the attribute in dogs explained by reference to scavenging. But there is a theory that they do it for the enzymes, since they don't consume it after it is two days old.

    I've personally wondered if it is a youthful trait - one of the many ways dogs resemble wolf cubs. (No idea if wolves or cubs do it, but I remember from a documentary that baby elephants do.)

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coprophagia

    Think I heard somewhere that bacterial diversity in the gut is considered a good thing, and the growing lack of it as we age can cause problems.

    Have wanted to see this old TV movie about Dobermans for a while:
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trapped_(1973_film)
    Have seen Chopping Mall, which was a sort of rip off of it with robots.

    At the very least, I think disease-resistance editing would be popular. I still vividly remember seeing a film in the 9th grade that showed heartworms.

    , @Philip Owen
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Where I come from, dogs worked at herding sheep. They stayed outside in the barn or a kennel. Absolutely no one touched a dog's mouth or nose. Far less kissed it. It was a perfect way to catch liver fluke.

    Replies: @Sean

  816. @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    Some of us who oppose the Western-sponsored war against Russia currently taking place in Ukraine recognize there are not very many Jews in Ukraine. We also notice that Jewish people seem to be highly influential in that country much as they are in the USA and Russia.

    My speculation is there are interesting Jewish aspects of Ukrainian history including the Pale of Settlement, pogroms and the Holodomor. Recent intrigues include Jewish Ukrainian oligarchs funding NeoNazi groups and allowing them to publicly interact with the government. Then there is the Jewish clown pretending to be a president, presiding over a war which seems to have the main purpose of killing Slavs, oops, I mean Goyim.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @A123

    The biggest jewish community center on earth is in Dnipro.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Menorah_center,_Dnipro

    Paid for by Kolomoyskyi’s loot. Zelensky was originally paid for by Kolomoyskyi’s loot before he got the blank check from the Congress. Kolomoyskyi just did the start up funding for that project.

  817. @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    Some of us who oppose the Western-sponsored war against Russia currently taking place in Ukraine recognize there are not very many Jews in Ukraine. We also notice that Jewish people seem to be highly influential in that country much as they are in the USA and Russia.

    My speculation is there are interesting Jewish aspects of Ukrainian history including the Pale of Settlement, pogroms and the Holodomor. Recent intrigues include Jewish Ukrainian oligarchs funding NeoNazi groups and allowing them to publicly interact with the government. Then there is the Jewish clown pretending to be a president, presiding over a war which seems to have the main purpose of killing Slavs, oops, I mean Goyim.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @A123

    Some of us who oppose the Western-sponsored war against Russia currently taking place in Ukraine recognize there are not very many Jews in Ukraine. We also notice that anti-Semitic neo-Nazi people are very influential in the country. Post-Judiac apostate Zelensky travelled to Israel to offend Jews. The anti-Semitism of his Azov Brigade is less than subtle.

     

     

    While Kolomoyskyi outwardly funds Jewish projects, he does not appear to personally follow the tenents of Judaism. He has a number of outlandish behaviours such as keeping live sharks in his office, sort of like a bond villan.

    Realistically, trying to attach Judaism to either side of the conflict is a lengthy reach. However, if you must do so, then Russia is much more aligned with Jews versus neo-Nazi, anti-Semitic Ukraine.

    PEACE 😇

    • LOL: Mr. Hack
    • Replies: @QCIC
    @A123

    The Ukrainian NeoNazi's were funded by Jewish people who are widely recognized as being very supportive of Jewish causes locally and internationally. This blatantly contradictory move is maximum chutzpah, meaning the people driving this war are not hiding. It is obviously a Jewish project and they do not care one iota if everyone knows it. Same as killing all the civilians in Gaza, they really do not care.

    These disturbing facts do not fit into your Zio-Christian perspective so your explanations of the issues are a total failure. Keep trying though. Maybe you will turn over some rock which is covering an important piece of the puzzle.

    Reactionary and mystical Jewish people subscribe to ideas encompassing strange and even outlandish behaviors and rituals. More secularized Jewish people have outgrown this, but it is not clear if they pull any of the strings.

    Replies: @A123

    , @Mr. Hack
    @A123


    Post-Judiac apostate Zelensky travelled to Israel to offend Jews.
     
    Here's is a photo of him engaged in such activity while in Israel:

    https://www.president.gov.ua/storage/j-image-storage/14/91/29/8cbf95f3ed3e9c505d3b6debcb330649_1579778177_extra_large.jpeg

    If your only example of Zelensky being an anti-Semite is that he once compared the Holodomor to the Holocaust and managed to irritate a couple of hard corp Zionists, then I think that your skating on thin ice here with this example. You'll have to do better than this to convince anybody that Zelensky is a Nazi. But you never really try very hard do you, only repeating the same stupid stuff all of the time.

  818. @German_reader
    @Beckow


    I just think it is impossible to define
     
    It would mean Russia doesn't attack targets in Ukrainian cities away from the front line, imo that's not hard to define at all.

    Being proud of lying in diplomacy never pays…
     
    Russia has done plenty of lying too. Back in 2014/15 their official position was that they hadn't sent regular troops into Ukraine, didn't shell Ukrainian positions from across the border etc. which was just ridiculous. In February 2022 they also claimed there was no intent of invading Ukraine until right before the invasion actually happened. So it's not like the reasons for distrust are concentrated solely on the Western side (and despite my general loathing for her, I still don't believe Merkel's actions regarding the Minsk agreements were an intentional deception on her part).
    But anyway, not much point to discussing all of this anymore, and I'm getting pretty tired of it. With luck, there'll be a big Mideast war soon. At this point even Greasy William's nutty Messiah posting looks preferable to this endless Ukraine circle jerk.

    Replies: @Beckow, @Greasy William

    At this point even Greasy William’s nutty Messiah posting

    You think I’m nuts? We’ll see in September

    With luck, there’ll be a big Mideast war soon.

    This line indicates to me that you secretly know that I’m right. I don’t know anyone serving in Gaza but I do know a couple of people who know people who are serving there and they tell me that the reporting they are getting back from the front is that the IDF is getting posititively waxed.

    And this is only against Hamas, a poorly trained militia that is actually trying to lose. What chance does the IDF have against the combined forces of Lebanon, Syria, Iran and Russia? At this point, I’m wondering if Russia will even bother to join in. US is losing against Yemen as well.

    Ukraine, OTOH, is harder to read. Both sides claim to be winning but the situation on the ground is so opaque that I don’t know what to think.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Greasy William

    And this is only against Hamas, a poorly trained militia that is actually trying to lose. What chance does the IDF have against the combined forces of Lebanon, Syria, Iran and Russia?

    Hamas doesn't even have proper weapons for IDF tanks. Iran gave them older weapons that were defeated by trophy armor. Hamas was out in tank tops while IDF has body armor. Not much of a fight.

    Ritter predicted some great battle that never happened.

    At this point, I’m wondering if Russia will even bother to join in.

    Why would they do that? Russia sells Israel oil and diamonds. Putin will complain about the US in the ME and then go back to selling whatever he can.

    US is losing against Yemen as well.

    How so? Blowing up skinnies with rockets is losing?

    Replies: @Greasy William

    , @German_reader
    @Greasy William


    who know people who are serving there and they tell me that the reporting they are getting back from the front is that the IDF is getting posititively waxed.
     
    I don't believe that. Urban combat is certainly difficult, but there's no possibility of Hamas actually winning in military terms. The real problem for Israel is political, since its actions in Gaza are extreme enough to potentially cause it a lot of trouble in its foreign relations, but as it stands now there's no prospect either of ending the issue once and for all by expelling or exterminating the Palestinians in Gaza.
    But I also think that's why a part of the Israeli right might actually welcome a big Mideast war involving Hezbollah and Iran, maybe even seek to bring it about. Presumably they think the US would enter such a war on Israel's side, and it might finally provide the conditions for effecting the expulsion of a large part of the Palestinians. imo that would be a crazy gamble and quite irresponsible. But on the other hand, it might also be entertaining to watch, and might speed on the end of this rotten system one has to live under in the West, so in that sense I'm beyond caring.

    Replies: @Greasy William, @Mr. XYZ

  819. @QCIC
    @AP

    I am against WW3 which the West is trying to start. Everything else follows.

    I do not write about what I hope will happen in Ukraine, simply what I expect to happen. I hate the murders on all sides. I recognize the West created this mess using Ukraine as a pawn against Russia, so I am not persuaded by shrill claims that "Putin started it!"

    Ukraine could have created what you and Hack dream of, but the leadership chose to pursue this autonomy as puppets of the West. In addition to being a contradiction, this was a sellout, not a mistake. Once this sellout happened, probably starting in the 1990's, Ukraine was simply working on her own destruction.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. Hack, @John Johnson

    I recognize the West created this mess using Ukraine as a pawn against Russia, so I am not persuaded by shrill claims that “Putin started it!”

    Well the UN voted 143-5 that Russia is the aggressor. That 5 included Russia, Belarus and North Korea. Putin couldn’t even pull his pal India.

    I guess the world is a shrill claim.

    Oh and your dwarf slipped up and called it a conquest in an interview:
    “As for this negotiation process, it is an attempt to encourage us to abandon our conquests from the past year and a half,” Putin told the heads of municipalities from throughout the country in comments posted on the Kremlin website.

    WHOOPS
    Putin boasts of conquests in Ukraine
    https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/ukrainealert/confident-putin-boasts-of-russian-conquests-in-ukraine/

    When this war started I said that insecure pricks like Putin always make it hard for their own defenders. That is what they do.

  820. @Greasy William
    @German_reader


    At this point even Greasy William’s nutty Messiah posting
     
    You think I'm nuts? We'll see in September

    With luck, there’ll be a big Mideast war soon.
     
    This line indicates to me that you secretly know that I'm right. I don't know anyone serving in Gaza but I do know a couple of people who know people who are serving there and they tell me that the reporting they are getting back from the front is that the IDF is getting posititively waxed.

    And this is only against Hamas, a poorly trained militia that is actually trying to lose. What chance does the IDF have against the combined forces of Lebanon, Syria, Iran and Russia? At this point, I'm wondering if Russia will even bother to join in. US is losing against Yemen as well.

    Ukraine, OTOH, is harder to read. Both sides claim to be winning but the situation on the ground is so opaque that I don't know what to think.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @German_reader

    And this is only against Hamas, a poorly trained militia that is actually trying to lose. What chance does the IDF have against the combined forces of Lebanon, Syria, Iran and Russia?

    Hamas doesn’t even have proper weapons for IDF tanks. Iran gave them older weapons that were defeated by trophy armor. Hamas was out in tank tops while IDF has body armor. Not much of a fight.

    Ritter predicted some great battle that never happened.

    At this point, I’m wondering if Russia will even bother to join in.

    Why would they do that? Russia sells Israel oil and diamonds. Putin will complain about the US in the ME and then go back to selling whatever he can.

    US is losing against Yemen as well.

    How so? Blowing up skinnies with rockets is losing?

    • Replies: @Greasy William
    @John Johnson


    Ritter predicted some great battle that never happened.
     
    We can all agree that Ritter is a total moron

    Not much of a fight.
     
    The guys at the front are reporting back to their parents that the IDF has already been defeated and that the situation is much more grim than is being portrayed in the Israeli media

    Why would they do that?
     
    Because Putin is insane

    How so?
     
    Red Sea shipping is still unsafe and it isn't going to be until Yemen calls off the attacks on shipping. The US has no capability of halting said attacks. The US just appears impotent

    Replies: @John Johnson

  821. @John Johnson
    @Greasy William

    And this is only against Hamas, a poorly trained militia that is actually trying to lose. What chance does the IDF have against the combined forces of Lebanon, Syria, Iran and Russia?

    Hamas doesn't even have proper weapons for IDF tanks. Iran gave them older weapons that were defeated by trophy armor. Hamas was out in tank tops while IDF has body armor. Not much of a fight.

    Ritter predicted some great battle that never happened.

    At this point, I’m wondering if Russia will even bother to join in.

    Why would they do that? Russia sells Israel oil and diamonds. Putin will complain about the US in the ME and then go back to selling whatever he can.

    US is losing against Yemen as well.

    How so? Blowing up skinnies with rockets is losing?

    Replies: @Greasy William

    Ritter predicted some great battle that never happened.

    We can all agree that Ritter is a total moron

    Not much of a fight.

    The guys at the front are reporting back to their parents that the IDF has already been defeated and that the situation is much more grim than is being portrayed in the Israeli media

    Why would they do that?

    Because Putin is insane

    How so?

    Red Sea shipping is still unsafe and it isn’t going to be until Yemen calls off the attacks on shipping. The US has no capability of halting said attacks. The US just appears impotent

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Greasy William

    The guys at the front are reporting back to their parents that the IDF has already been defeated and that the situation is much more grim than is being portrayed in the Israeli media

    I haven't seen a single video of an IDF tank blowing up or a platoon caught in an ambush. Feel free to source one if you have it. The videos I have seen from Hamas are edited where they don't show the results. The trophy system is obviously blowing up the RPGs before they tank out the tank.

    On day one of the dwarf's invasion there were Ukrainians posting videos of them blowing up tanks and APCs.

    I think Israel has gone too far but I see no reason to believe that Hamas is winning. That is incredibly deluded.

    Red Sea shipping is still unsafe and it isn’t going to be until Yemen calls off the attacks on shipping. The US has no capability of halting said attacks. The US just appears impotent

    Impotent how? Did you expect the US to destroy them overnight?

    It doesn't work that way. This is closer to Somali pirates. The US will start arming ships and setting traps for them. More of a nuisance than any serious threat. They're in fact complete idiots for attacking US ships in a hope of pressuring Israel. Blinken actually wants Israel to back down. The conspiracy theorists here depict Blinken as part of some Jewish conspiracy and yet it is Blinken that is wanting Israel to back down while Biden twiddles his thumbs.

  822. Was writing in previous thread about the need for Baltic states to build Mannerheim line equivalents just in case, but was bit sceptical about quick decision possibilities in real life – however now thanx whomever reads me in NATO HQ and their defense ministries, lol

    19. January 2024 – 16:14

    Baltic countries to build defensive installations on their borders

    Today, the defence ministers of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania approved the concept of building anti-mobility defensive installations on the borders with Russia and Belarus. The ministers signed an agreement in Riga, according to which Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania will construct anti-mobility defensive installations in the coming years to deter and, if necessary, defend against military threats.

    “To build the anti-mobility defensive installations is a carefully considered and thought-out project, the need of which stems from the current security situation. Russia’s war in Ukraine has shown that, in addition to equipment, ammunition, and manpower, physical defensive installations on the border are also needed to defend Estonia from the first meter,” said Hanno Pevkur, Minister of Defence of Estonia. He emphasized that the purpose of defence installations is to prevent a military conflict in our region. “We are undertaking this effort so that the people of Estonia can feel safe, but if the slightest risk emerged, we would be ready for various developments more promptly,” Pevkur added.

    The concept of defensive installations is based on the decisions made at the NATO Madrid Summit which emphasized that Allies must be ready to defend the territory from the first meter and new regional defence plans must be developed. The concept combines prevention and field security measures. Elements on the terrain support the activities of the defending units at the base points to stop the aggressor´s troops if necessary. The elements are positioned in the landscape, taking into account the results of the analysis of the enemy´s intent, the environment, and the defence plan. The Baltic countries are one area of operations, and therefore defence installations will be built in coordination with Latvia and Lithuania.

    In peacetime, no explosives, cutting wires or other obstacles are placed on the border of Estonia. Instead, a network of bunkers, support points and distribution lines is established. The building process is carried out in cooperation with local communities and with the agreement of landowners.

    The defence ministers also signed a Letter of Intent for HIMARS multiple rocket launchers, aiming to create a framework for the joint use of the weapon system in both peace and wartime. The defence ministers of Estonia and Latvia also signed a cooperation agreement to conduct NATO Air Policing from Latvia’s Lielvarde air base while the runway at Ämari air base is under repair.

    In addition, the defence ministers discussed issues related to supporting Ukraine, capability development and the upcoming NATO Washington Summit. Issues related to defence cooperation and the Baltic Defence College were also discussed.

    https://www.kaitseministeerium.ee/en/news/baltic-countries-build-defensive-installations-their-borders

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @sudden death

    Do they have stock in Throwflame?

    https://en.defence-ua.com/weapon_and_tech/robot_dog_with_flamethrower_for_trench_burning_this_is_a_real_horror_that_can_be_legally_purchased_in_the_usa-7324.html

    Replies: @sudden death

  823. @sudden death
    Was writing in previous thread about the need for Baltic states to build Mannerheim line equivalents just in case, but was bit sceptical about quick decision possibilities in real life - however now thanx whomever reads me in NATO HQ and their defense ministries, lol

    19. January 2024 - 16:14

    Baltic countries to build defensive installations on their borders

    Today, the defence ministers of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania approved the concept of building anti-mobility defensive installations on the borders with Russia and Belarus. The ministers signed an agreement in Riga, according to which Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania will construct anti-mobility defensive installations in the coming years to deter and, if necessary, defend against military threats.

    "To build the anti-mobility defensive installations is a carefully considered and thought-out project, the need of which stems from the current security situation. Russia's war in Ukraine has shown that, in addition to equipment, ammunition, and manpower, physical defensive installations on the border are also needed to defend Estonia from the first meter," said Hanno Pevkur, Minister of Defence of Estonia. He emphasized that the purpose of defence installations is to prevent a military conflict in our region. "We are undertaking this effort so that the people of Estonia can feel safe, but if the slightest risk emerged, we would be ready for various developments more promptly," Pevkur added.

    The concept of defensive installations is based on the decisions made at the NATO Madrid Summit which emphasized that Allies must be ready to defend the territory from the first meter and new regional defence plans must be developed. The concept combines prevention and field security measures. Elements on the terrain support the activities of the defending units at the base points to stop the aggressor´s troops if necessary. The elements are positioned in the landscape, taking into account the results of the analysis of the enemy´s intent, the environment, and the defence plan. The Baltic countries are one area of operations, and therefore defence installations will be built in coordination with Latvia and Lithuania.

    In peacetime, no explosives, cutting wires or other obstacles are placed on the border of Estonia. Instead, a network of bunkers, support points and distribution lines is established. The building process is carried out in cooperation with local communities and with the agreement of landowners.

    The defence ministers also signed a Letter of Intent for HIMARS multiple rocket launchers, aiming to create a framework for the joint use of the weapon system in both peace and wartime. The defence ministers of Estonia and Latvia also signed a cooperation agreement to conduct NATO Air Policing from Latvia's Lielvarde air base while the runway at Ämari air base is under repair.

    In addition, the defence ministers discussed issues related to supporting Ukraine, capability development and the upcoming NATO Washington Summit. Issues related to defence cooperation and the Baltic Defence College were also discussed.
     

    https://www.kaitseministeerium.ee/en/news/baltic-countries-build-defensive-installations-their-borders

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    idk, but also special thanx to our great pal Putler who might have helped to speed up all the procedural hassle with his recent barkings about great threat to RF national security coming from mighty Latvia;)

  824. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @sudden death

    Do they have stock in Throwflame?

    https://en.defence-ua.com/weapon_and_tech/robot_dog_with_flamethrower_for_trench_burning_this_is_a_real_horror_that_can_be_legally_purchased_in_the_usa-7324.html

    Replies: @sudden death

    idk, but also special thanx to our great pal Putler who might have helped to speed up all the procedural hassle with his recent barkings about great threat to RF national security coming from mighty Latvia;)

  825. @AP
    @LT1488

    Since the article was published in October, the less pro-Ukrainian confederation party did horribly in the Polish election.

    Pro-Ukrainian feelings in Poland have faded somewhat in part due to the fact that many of the Ukrainian-speaking Ukrainians have returned to Ukraine (their regions are not in so much danger) and the ones in Poland tend to be more Russian-speaking. Male draft-dodgers have also been showing up. But Poland still overwhelmingly supports Ukraine.

    Replies: @LT1488

    Konfedaracja did horribly because their former leader Korwin kept on praising Hitler every 5 minutes on Twitter.

    • Replies: @AP
    @LT1488

    I doubt that a party’s former leader saying stuff on Twitter would significantly affect Polish voting patterns. People aren’t as online as you may believe.

  826. @Greasy William
    @John Johnson


    Ritter predicted some great battle that never happened.
     
    We can all agree that Ritter is a total moron

    Not much of a fight.
     
    The guys at the front are reporting back to their parents that the IDF has already been defeated and that the situation is much more grim than is being portrayed in the Israeli media

    Why would they do that?
     
    Because Putin is insane

    How so?
     
    Red Sea shipping is still unsafe and it isn't going to be until Yemen calls off the attacks on shipping. The US has no capability of halting said attacks. The US just appears impotent

    Replies: @John Johnson

    The guys at the front are reporting back to their parents that the IDF has already been defeated and that the situation is much more grim than is being portrayed in the Israeli media

    I haven’t seen a single video of an IDF tank blowing up or a platoon caught in an ambush. Feel free to source one if you have it. The videos I have seen from Hamas are edited where they don’t show the results. The trophy system is obviously blowing up the RPGs before they tank out the tank.

    On day one of the dwarf’s invasion there were Ukrainians posting videos of them blowing up tanks and APCs.

    I think Israel has gone too far but I see no reason to believe that Hamas is winning. That is incredibly deluded.

    Red Sea shipping is still unsafe and it isn’t going to be until Yemen calls off the attacks on shipping. The US has no capability of halting said attacks. The US just appears impotent

    Impotent how? Did you expect the US to destroy them overnight?

    It doesn’t work that way. This is closer to Somali pirates. The US will start arming ships and setting traps for them. More of a nuisance than any serious threat. They’re in fact complete idiots for attacking US ships in a hope of pressuring Israel. Blinken actually wants Israel to back down. The conspiracy theorists here depict Blinken as part of some Jewish conspiracy and yet it is Blinken that is wanting Israel to back down while Biden twiddles his thumbs.

  827. @John Johnson
    @Mikel

    The goal is to remove Biden and replace with someone better not worse.

    Haley isn't for open borders and would sign every current GOP proposal on the border.

    That’s about 2 billion people Nikki wants to welcome in the US. How is that better than Biden’s southern border calamity?

    She supports legal immigration like most Republicans including Trump. Trump has never proposed rolling back the 1965 immigration act. Most Republicans don't have the guts to even talk about it.

    I'm not a Republican and I would impose a moratorium on all immigration.

    But right now we have an open borders president. The Republicans including Haley want to end the amnesty loophole and Biden wants to keep it open. Haley is the safer bet if the goal is to remove Biden and the even more noxious VP that could take over at any moment.

    Trump was president for 4 years and left the border open. He in fact turned down a generous offer from the Democrats that included a partial wall along with electronic monitoring. The remote areas really don't need a wall and Trump showed his ignorance by insisting on one. Mr. "art of the deal" screwed it up and then let his pal Bannon run a fundraising scam for the border. With friends like these.

    Bannon charged with border fundraising scheme
    https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-53853297

    Replies: @Mikel

    Trump has never proposed rolling back the 1965 immigration act. Most Republicans don’t have the guts to even talk about it.

    I’m not a Republican and I would impose a moratorium on all immigration.

    You are wrong, as always. Trump explicitly talked about an immigration moratorium during the 2016 debates. I remember it perfectly (it could have potentially affected me as I wasn’t naturalized yet but I could perfectly understand what a tremendous task the US had even then to assimilate the tens of millions of new arrivals of the previous decades). He was still being counseled by Coulter and other immigration restrictionists at the time. It must have been one of the taboos that he dared to break and later brought us Russiagate, massive censorship and his current legal problems, that yes, of course, are all politically motivated (how can anyone doubt it?)

    Even when he was in office and the restrictionists no longer had his ear he kept talking about switching to a merit-based system that would be a total overhaul of the 1965 act so you’re dead wrong.

    You may favor an immigration moratorium but it must be much lower in your list of priorities than starting new wars because Nikki may back whatever the dominant position in the GOP seems to be at the moment to win the election but she’s sure as hell not going to build the wall or do anything of significance on the demographic replacement front. She’s being funded by the Koch brothers and the globalist donors, come on.

    But one has to admit that your position is the exact opposite of the Dems’ on this matter. You care more about continuing to fight wars abroad than about the demographic replacement taking place in your country. The Dems, even though they would also love to give billions and billions to Ukraine, care more about keeping the borders open and prefer to leave Kiev defenseless rather than making any concessions on that front.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Mikel


    Trump has never proposed rolling back the 1965 immigration act. Most Republicans don’t have the guts to even talk about it.
     

    I’m not a Republican and I would impose a moratorium on all immigration.
     
    You are wrong, as always. Trump explicitly talked about an immigration moratorium during the 2016 debates.

    The fact that you have to go back to 2016 debates speaks volumes. He obviously didn't try to enact anything of the sort during his presidency and left the border open.

    Politicians say all kinds of things during the debates. They're trying to get elected and their actions are what matter. Of course I was talking about actual proposals while in office.

    In the 2016 debates he also depicted himself as a centrist on health care. Then he later took the swamp Republican view after getting elected. A complete reversal.

    Even when he was in office and the restrictionists no longer had his ear he kept talking about switching to a merit-based system that would be a total overhaul of the 1965 act so you’re dead wrong.

    No I'm not dead wrong. Do you have an excuse for why he turned down a generous border offer from the Democrats that would have built a combination of a wall and electronic monitoring for the remote areas? A wall across the remote desert areas was never needed. Trump showed everyone how he didn't understand the problem areas by turning down the deal. Why couldn't he take the deal and then later demand a full wall if it didn't work? Terrible bargaining on his part.

    You speak of Trump being restricted and yet he turned down a deal that would have locked down the border.

    Do you think he was unaware that his pal Bannon was scamming MAGA followers by eliciting donations for a wall? Got an excuse for that? Trump supposedly wanted a locked down border and then was either unaware of Bannon scamming his fans or didn't care. How is either one excusable?

    You may favor an immigration moratorium but it must be much lower in your list of priorities than starting new wars because Nikki may back whatever the dominant position in the GOP seems to be at the moment to win the election but she’s sure as hell not going to build the wall or do anything of significance on the demographic replacement front.

    I said I would impose a immigration moratorium if I were in charge. I have absolutely zero expectation of any politician implementing one in this environment. It was hypothetical and to make it clear that I don't identify with either party. My main priority is to remove Biden who has stubbornly pushed for an open border even to the opposition of numerous Democrats. He is dragging his feet and trying to get as many illegals in as possible. He believes in the left-wing plan of turning America non-White to gain a permanent Democrat supermajority. It's common on Unz to blame Jews over immigration and yet there are Jewish Republicans and Democrats that oppose this guilt ridden fake Catholic in office. Haley supports every current GOP proposal on the border which includes fixing the asylum loophole.

    Why would Trump need a second term to prove he is serious about immigration when he turned down an immigration deal while in office? This time around he will stick to his own beliefs? That is if he doesn't get jail time or isn't banned from politics?

    She’s being funded by the Koch brothers and the globalist donors, come on.

    Trump will have his own list of globalist donors. The Adelsons gave 90 million in the last election. All major presidential candidates have globalists that place bets on them.

    But one has to admit that your position is the exact opposite of the Dems’ on this matter. You care more about continuing to fight wars abroad than about the demographic replacement taking place in your country.

    The US is not fighting a war abroad in Ukraine. It's giving aid to Ukraine and most of the equipment was scheduled to be decommissioned.

    On Syria I would like both the US and Russia to leave. The US currently has 900 troops in a corner Syria while Russia is propping up the unwanted government of Assad.

    So do explain these foreign wars that I supposedly support. You keep projecting as if I represent the United States. I have my own opinions and I do not take the common tribal position here that any side or dictator against the US must be some kind of ally that should be defended. I have no problem taking the position that most governments are ran by assholes that don't serve the best interest of the people. That position is typically unwelcome here where most posters have tribal brain and feel they have to take an all encompassing side to everything.

  828. @AP
    @QCIC


    I am against WW3 which the West is trying to start
     
    You are a contrarian who likes to think the opposite of reality and who for some reason hates the West, your place of origin. Your supposed fear of World War III is not a very convincing excuse or cover for your self-hatred. If Ukraine is conquered (unlikely) and Putin demands the Baltics next, you will argue that they should be given to him because of the risk of World War III. You will blame them for anti-Russian policies, provocations, being “pawns” of the West, etc. Is that right?

    And then if Russia demands the return of the War-era spheres of control and a NATO withdrawal from Poland, Czechia etc. you will also support that, in order to prevent World War III of course. Correct?

    I recognize the West created this mess using Ukraine as a pawn against Russia, so I am not persuaded by shrill claims that “Putin started it!”

     

    A normal person assigns blame for starting a war on the side that invades. America, not Saddam, started the Iraq war, Saddam did not start it by abusing Kurds and Shiites or trying to get weapons. Russia, not Ukraine or the West, started the Russia-Ukraine war.

    Ukraine could have created what you and Hack dream of, but the leadership chose to pursue this autonomy as puppets of the West
     
    According to the Russian state concerns (which you ape), any separation of Ukraine from Russia is seen as by definition puppetry by the West, thus no separation is allowed. War is inevitable as long as Ukraine seeks independence from Russia. Medvedev has made that quite clear, and you agree. Good to know where everyone stands.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

    As long as you believe this conflict is primarily about Ukraine versus Russia you will never understand what I am describing.

    Proxy wars are confusing. This makes it easy for people to drop the context and delude themselves about what is actually occurring.

    I love the USA and our fading version of Western post-Enlightenment culture. I hate to see losers and liars start wars of choice which reduce freedom and prosperity for most Americans and risk greater conflict which could lead to billions of murders. The risk of WW3 is non-trivial and the potential loss is unimaginable.

  829. German_reader says:
    @Greasy William
    @German_reader


    At this point even Greasy William’s nutty Messiah posting
     
    You think I'm nuts? We'll see in September

    With luck, there’ll be a big Mideast war soon.
     
    This line indicates to me that you secretly know that I'm right. I don't know anyone serving in Gaza but I do know a couple of people who know people who are serving there and they tell me that the reporting they are getting back from the front is that the IDF is getting posititively waxed.

    And this is only against Hamas, a poorly trained militia that is actually trying to lose. What chance does the IDF have against the combined forces of Lebanon, Syria, Iran and Russia? At this point, I'm wondering if Russia will even bother to join in. US is losing against Yemen as well.

    Ukraine, OTOH, is harder to read. Both sides claim to be winning but the situation on the ground is so opaque that I don't know what to think.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @German_reader

    who know people who are serving there and they tell me that the reporting they are getting back from the front is that the IDF is getting posititively waxed.

    I don’t believe that. Urban combat is certainly difficult, but there’s no possibility of Hamas actually winning in military terms. The real problem for Israel is political, since its actions in Gaza are extreme enough to potentially cause it a lot of trouble in its foreign relations, but as it stands now there’s no prospect either of ending the issue once and for all by expelling or exterminating the Palestinians in Gaza.
    But I also think that’s why a part of the Israeli right might actually welcome a big Mideast war involving Hezbollah and Iran, maybe even seek to bring it about. Presumably they think the US would enter such a war on Israel’s side, and it might finally provide the conditions for effecting the expulsion of a large part of the Palestinians. imo that would be a crazy gamble and quite irresponsible. But on the other hand, it might also be entertaining to watch, and might speed on the end of this rotten system one has to live under in the West, so in that sense I’m beyond caring.

    • Replies: @Greasy William
    @German_reader

    The US military would get rolled in any boots on the ground conflict. If the Israeli right is counting on the Americans to bail them out, they are dreaming

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @German_reader

    If Israel was smart, they would say something along the lines of "We support an independent Palestinian state, but as an Israeli vassal state". That would be unfair to the Palestinians, of course, but it would also ensure Israel's security. What I mean by this is some kind of military alliance between Israel and this independent Palestinian state with a lot of military cooperation between the two of them, similar to what's going on with NATO, while the Palestinians are allowed to run their own domestic affairs however they see fit just so long as they don't engage in any Jew hatred. In other words, an arrangement with Israel similar to what Cuba had with the US with the Platt Amendment, before Fidel Castro came to power there.

    This is a good map for any peace settlement:

    https://www.shaularieli.com/en/maps/negotiations/

    https://www.shaularieli.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/A-Stable-Border-Proposal-for-land-swaps-2020-scaled.jpg

    Though I would prefer it if E-1 will also remain in Israeli hands. However, I won't insist on it for the sake of peace.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @A123

  830. @LT1488
    @AP

    Konfedaracja did horribly because their former leader Korwin kept on praising Hitler every 5 minutes on Twitter.

    Replies: @AP

    I doubt that a party’s former leader saying stuff on Twitter would significantly affect Polish voting patterns. People aren’t as online as you may believe.

  831. @A123
    @QCIC

    Some of us who oppose the Western-sponsored war against Russia currently taking place in Ukraine recognize there are not very many Jews in Ukraine. We also notice that anti-Semitic neo-Nazi people are very influential in the country. Post-Judiac apostate Zelensky travelled to Israel to offend Jews. The anti-Semitism of his Azov Brigade is less than subtle.

     
    https://media.snopes.com/2022/03/GettyImages-1207144800-azov-battallion.jpg
     

    While Kolomoyskyi outwardly funds Jewish projects, he does not appear to personally follow the tenents of Judaism. He has a number of outlandish behaviours such as keeping live sharks in his office, sort of like a bond villan.

    Realistically, trying to attach Judaism to either side of the conflict is a lengthy reach. However, if you must do so, then Russia is much more aligned with Jews versus neo-Nazi, anti-Semitic Ukraine.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. Hack

    The Ukrainian NeoNazi’s were funded by Jewish people who are widely recognized as being very supportive of Jewish causes locally and internationally. This blatantly contradictory move is maximum chutzpah, meaning the people driving this war are not hiding. It is obviously a Jewish project and they do not care one iota if everyone knows it. Same as killing all the civilians in Gaza, they really do not care.

    These disturbing facts do not fit into your Zio-Christian perspective so your explanations of the issues are a total failure. Keep trying though. Maybe you will turn over some rock which is covering an important piece of the puzzle.

    Reactionary and mystical Jewish people subscribe to ideas encompassing strange and even outlandish behaviors and rituals. More secularized Jewish people have outgrown this, but it is not clear if they pull any of the strings.

    • Replies: @A123
    @QCIC

    The Ukrainian NeoNazi’s were funded by non-Jewish people including apostate former Jews. There is no contradiction. Appearing supportive of "Jewish causes" is great cover for fake Jews. And, many "Jewish causes" are in practice anti-Jewish. We see this here in the states where the Antisemitic Defaming League [ADL] cares more about Muslims than Jews.

    These facts do not fit into your open hatred of Judeo-Christian values, so you wildly attack. However, your bizarre formulations are total failures causing you to constantly miss. The truth is plain to see, you simply have to stop being willingly blind.

    Consider this -- Russia is much more Jewish than Ukraine. If you label Kiev Jewish, then using your own standard, Moscow is also Jewish. What do you get out of labelling the conflict as Jew versus Jew? It will be easier for you to understand what is going on if you avoid such superficial labels.

    The reality is -- Neither side is steeped in the practice of Judaism.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @QCIC

  832. @German_reader
    @Greasy William


    who know people who are serving there and they tell me that the reporting they are getting back from the front is that the IDF is getting posititively waxed.
     
    I don't believe that. Urban combat is certainly difficult, but there's no possibility of Hamas actually winning in military terms. The real problem for Israel is political, since its actions in Gaza are extreme enough to potentially cause it a lot of trouble in its foreign relations, but as it stands now there's no prospect either of ending the issue once and for all by expelling or exterminating the Palestinians in Gaza.
    But I also think that's why a part of the Israeli right might actually welcome a big Mideast war involving Hezbollah and Iran, maybe even seek to bring it about. Presumably they think the US would enter such a war on Israel's side, and it might finally provide the conditions for effecting the expulsion of a large part of the Palestinians. imo that would be a crazy gamble and quite irresponsible. But on the other hand, it might also be entertaining to watch, and might speed on the end of this rotten system one has to live under in the West, so in that sense I'm beyond caring.

    Replies: @Greasy William, @Mr. XYZ

    The US military would get rolled in any boots on the ground conflict. If the Israeli right is counting on the Americans to bail them out, they are dreaming

  833. @Mikel
    @John Johnson


    Trump has never proposed rolling back the 1965 immigration act. Most Republicans don’t have the guts to even talk about it.

    I’m not a Republican and I would impose a moratorium on all immigration.
     

    You are wrong, as always. Trump explicitly talked about an immigration moratorium during the 2016 debates. I remember it perfectly (it could have potentially affected me as I wasn't naturalized yet but I could perfectly understand what a tremendous task the US had even then to assimilate the tens of millions of new arrivals of the previous decades). He was still being counseled by Coulter and other immigration restrictionists at the time. It must have been one of the taboos that he dared to break and later brought us Russiagate, massive censorship and his current legal problems, that yes, of course, are all politically motivated (how can anyone doubt it?)

    Even when he was in office and the restrictionists no longer had his ear he kept talking about switching to a merit-based system that would be a total overhaul of the 1965 act so you're dead wrong.

    You may favor an immigration moratorium but it must be much lower in your list of priorities than starting new wars because Nikki may back whatever the dominant position in the GOP seems to be at the moment to win the election but she's sure as hell not going to build the wall or do anything of significance on the demographic replacement front. She's being funded by the Koch brothers and the globalist donors, come on.

    But one has to admit that your position is the exact opposite of the Dems' on this matter. You care more about continuing to fight wars abroad than about the demographic replacement taking place in your country. The Dems, even though they would also love to give billions and billions to Ukraine, care more about keeping the borders open and prefer to leave Kiev defenseless rather than making any concessions on that front.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Trump has never proposed rolling back the 1965 immigration act. Most Republicans don’t have the guts to even talk about it.

    I’m not a Republican and I would impose a moratorium on all immigration.

    You are wrong, as always. Trump explicitly talked about an immigration moratorium during the 2016 debates.

    The fact that you have to go back to 2016 debates speaks volumes. He obviously didn’t try to enact anything of the sort during his presidency and left the border open.

    Politicians say all kinds of things during the debates. They’re trying to get elected and their actions are what matter. Of course I was talking about actual proposals while in office.

    In the 2016 debates he also depicted himself as a centrist on health care. Then he later took the swamp Republican view after getting elected. A complete reversal.

    Even when he was in office and the restrictionists no longer had his ear he kept talking about switching to a merit-based system that would be a total overhaul of the 1965 act so you’re dead wrong.

    No I’m not dead wrong. Do you have an excuse for why he turned down a generous border offer from the Democrats that would have built a combination of a wall and electronic monitoring for the remote areas? A wall across the remote desert areas was never needed. Trump showed everyone how he didn’t understand the problem areas by turning down the deal. Why couldn’t he take the deal and then later demand a full wall if it didn’t work? Terrible bargaining on his part.

    You speak of Trump being restricted and yet he turned down a deal that would have locked down the border.

    Do you think he was unaware that his pal Bannon was scamming MAGA followers by eliciting donations for a wall? Got an excuse for that? Trump supposedly wanted a locked down border and then was either unaware of Bannon scamming his fans or didn’t care. How is either one excusable?

    You may favor an immigration moratorium but it must be much lower in your list of priorities than starting new wars because Nikki may back whatever the dominant position in the GOP seems to be at the moment to win the election but she’s sure as hell not going to build the wall or do anything of significance on the demographic replacement front.

    I said I would impose a immigration moratorium if I were in charge. I have absolutely zero expectation of any politician implementing one in this environment. It was hypothetical and to make it clear that I don’t identify with either party. My main priority is to remove Biden who has stubbornly pushed for an open border even to the opposition of numerous Democrats. He is dragging his feet and trying to get as many illegals in as possible. He believes in the left-wing plan of turning America non-White to gain a permanent Democrat supermajority. It’s common on Unz to blame Jews over immigration and yet there are Jewish Republicans and Democrats that oppose this guilt ridden fake Catholic in office. Haley supports every current GOP proposal on the border which includes fixing the asylum loophole.

    Why would Trump need a second term to prove he is serious about immigration when he turned down an immigration deal while in office? This time around he will stick to his own beliefs? That is if he doesn’t get jail time or isn’t banned from politics?

    [MORE]

    She’s being funded by the Koch brothers and the globalist donors, come on.

    Trump will have his own list of globalist donors. The Adelsons gave 90 million in the last election. All major presidential candidates have globalists that place bets on them.

    But one has to admit that your position is the exact opposite of the Dems’ on this matter. You care more about continuing to fight wars abroad than about the demographic replacement taking place in your country.

    The US is not fighting a war abroad in Ukraine. It’s giving aid to Ukraine and most of the equipment was scheduled to be decommissioned.

    On Syria I would like both the US and Russia to leave. The US currently has 900 troops in a corner Syria while Russia is propping up the unwanted government of Assad.

    So do explain these foreign wars that I supposedly support. You keep projecting as if I represent the United States. I have my own opinions and I do not take the common tribal position here that any side or dictator against the US must be some kind of ally that should be defended. I have no problem taking the position that most governments are ran by assholes that don’t serve the best interest of the people. That position is typically unwelcome here where most posters have tribal brain and feel they have to take an all encompassing side to everything.

  834. @A123
    @QCIC

    Some of us who oppose the Western-sponsored war against Russia currently taking place in Ukraine recognize there are not very many Jews in Ukraine. We also notice that anti-Semitic neo-Nazi people are very influential in the country. Post-Judiac apostate Zelensky travelled to Israel to offend Jews. The anti-Semitism of his Azov Brigade is less than subtle.

     
    https://media.snopes.com/2022/03/GettyImages-1207144800-azov-battallion.jpg
     

    While Kolomoyskyi outwardly funds Jewish projects, he does not appear to personally follow the tenents of Judaism. He has a number of outlandish behaviours such as keeping live sharks in his office, sort of like a bond villan.

    Realistically, trying to attach Judaism to either side of the conflict is a lengthy reach. However, if you must do so, then Russia is much more aligned with Jews versus neo-Nazi, anti-Semitic Ukraine.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. Hack

    Post-Judiac apostate Zelensky travelled to Israel to offend Jews.

    Here’s is a photo of him engaged in such activity while in Israel:

    If your only example of Zelensky being an anti-Semite is that he once compared the Holodomor to the Holocaust and managed to irritate a couple of hard corp Zionists, then I think that your skating on thin ice here with this example. You’ll have to do better than this to convince anybody that Zelensky is a Nazi. But you never really try very hard do you, only repeating the same stupid stuff all of the time.

  835. @QCIC
    @A123

    The Ukrainian NeoNazi's were funded by Jewish people who are widely recognized as being very supportive of Jewish causes locally and internationally. This blatantly contradictory move is maximum chutzpah, meaning the people driving this war are not hiding. It is obviously a Jewish project and they do not care one iota if everyone knows it. Same as killing all the civilians in Gaza, they really do not care.

    These disturbing facts do not fit into your Zio-Christian perspective so your explanations of the issues are a total failure. Keep trying though. Maybe you will turn over some rock which is covering an important piece of the puzzle.

    Reactionary and mystical Jewish people subscribe to ideas encompassing strange and even outlandish behaviors and rituals. More secularized Jewish people have outgrown this, but it is not clear if they pull any of the strings.

    Replies: @A123

    The Ukrainian NeoNazi’s were funded by non-Jewish people including apostate former Jews. There is no contradiction. Appearing supportive of “Jewish causes” is great cover for fake Jews. And, many “Jewish causes” are in practice anti-Jewish. We see this here in the states where the Antisemitic Defaming League [ADL] cares more about Muslims than Jews.

    These facts do not fit into your open hatred of Judeo-Christian values, so you wildly attack. However, your bizarre formulations are total failures causing you to constantly miss. The truth is plain to see, you simply have to stop being willingly blind.

    Consider this — Russia is much more Jewish than Ukraine. If you label Kiev Jewish, then using your own standard, Moscow is also Jewish. What do you get out of labelling the conflict as Jew versus Jew? It will be easier for you to understand what is going on if you avoid such superficial labels.

    The reality is — Neither side is steeped in the practice of Judaism.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @A123

    The notion of false Jews, or "Jews who call themselves Jews but are not" in the words of Revelation of St John is essential for understanding of the current situation around JQ. It was already problem in the Old Testament, when Canaanites tried to infiltrate Jews. They finally did.
    It is also understandable that such false Jews would cooperate with Nazis to bring hate upon Jews. The modern, Talmudic concept of Jew (matrilineal), as someone obsessed with Oral Law (Talmud) and Moschiach is far away from that of the Old Testament: patrilineal, tribe-, Written Law-oriented.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Greasy William

    , @QCIC
    @A123

    I hold many Christian values.

    I did not label Kiev Jewish. I agree that Russia has a similar degree of elite/deep state Jewish influence which makes sense considering they are part of the same country! That last part was hyperbole for the Ukies, LOL.

    Just remember, when you finally can no longer juggle the contradictory pieces of your worldview, there are people who may be able to help you rebuild. Who knows, maybe Hack can hook you up with some catnip?

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @A123

  836. @A123
    @QCIC

    The Ukrainian NeoNazi’s were funded by non-Jewish people including apostate former Jews. There is no contradiction. Appearing supportive of "Jewish causes" is great cover for fake Jews. And, many "Jewish causes" are in practice anti-Jewish. We see this here in the states where the Antisemitic Defaming League [ADL] cares more about Muslims than Jews.

    These facts do not fit into your open hatred of Judeo-Christian values, so you wildly attack. However, your bizarre formulations are total failures causing you to constantly miss. The truth is plain to see, you simply have to stop being willingly blind.

    Consider this -- Russia is much more Jewish than Ukraine. If you label Kiev Jewish, then using your own standard, Moscow is also Jewish. What do you get out of labelling the conflict as Jew versus Jew? It will be easier for you to understand what is going on if you avoid such superficial labels.

    The reality is -- Neither side is steeped in the practice of Judaism.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @QCIC

    The notion of false Jews, or “Jews who call themselves Jews but are not” in the words of Revelation of St John is essential for understanding of the current situation around JQ. It was already problem in the Old Testament, when Canaanites tried to infiltrate Jews. They finally did.
    It is also understandable that such false Jews would cooperate with Nazis to bring hate upon Jews. The modern, Talmudic concept of Jew (matrilineal), as someone obsessed with Oral Law (Talmud) and Moschiach is far away from that of the Old Testament: patrilineal, tribe-, Written Law-oriented.

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @Another Polish Perspective

    Christianity is infiltrated too. Ever wondered why all apostles hauled from Galilea, a place whose capital now is Safed, the city of Kabbalists? Well, Galilea was given by Salomon as payment for the Temple to Tyre…Thus, in a sense, the apostles came from Tyre, not Jerusalem.
    And which god ruled Tyre? Certainly, not Jahwe.

    , @Greasy William
    @Another Polish Perspective

    So wouldn't that make the Samaritans the real Jews, in that case? I'm not sure what you are trying to say

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

  837. @Another Polish Perspective
    @A123

    The notion of false Jews, or "Jews who call themselves Jews but are not" in the words of Revelation of St John is essential for understanding of the current situation around JQ. It was already problem in the Old Testament, when Canaanites tried to infiltrate Jews. They finally did.
    It is also understandable that such false Jews would cooperate with Nazis to bring hate upon Jews. The modern, Talmudic concept of Jew (matrilineal), as someone obsessed with Oral Law (Talmud) and Moschiach is far away from that of the Old Testament: patrilineal, tribe-, Written Law-oriented.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Greasy William

    Christianity is infiltrated too. Ever wondered why all apostles hauled from Galilea, a place whose capital now is Safed, the city of Kabbalists? Well, Galilea was given by Salomon as payment for the Temple to Tyre…Thus, in a sense, the apostles came from Tyre, not Jerusalem.
    And which god ruled Tyre? Certainly, not Jahwe.

  838. @A123
    @QCIC

    The Ukrainian NeoNazi’s were funded by non-Jewish people including apostate former Jews. There is no contradiction. Appearing supportive of "Jewish causes" is great cover for fake Jews. And, many "Jewish causes" are in practice anti-Jewish. We see this here in the states where the Antisemitic Defaming League [ADL] cares more about Muslims than Jews.

    These facts do not fit into your open hatred of Judeo-Christian values, so you wildly attack. However, your bizarre formulations are total failures causing you to constantly miss. The truth is plain to see, you simply have to stop being willingly blind.

    Consider this -- Russia is much more Jewish than Ukraine. If you label Kiev Jewish, then using your own standard, Moscow is also Jewish. What do you get out of labelling the conflict as Jew versus Jew? It will be easier for you to understand what is going on if you avoid such superficial labels.

    The reality is -- Neither side is steeped in the practice of Judaism.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @QCIC

    I hold many Christian values.

    I did not label Kiev Jewish. I agree that Russia has a similar degree of elite/deep state Jewish influence which makes sense considering they are part of the same country! That last part was hyperbole for the Ukies, LOL.

    Just remember, when you finally can no longer juggle the contradictory pieces of your worldview, there are people who may be able to help you rebuild. Who knows, maybe Hack can hook you up with some catnip?

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @QCIC

    It's extremely difficult to get an inveterate glue sniffer like kremlinstoogeA123 to substitute his preferred hallucinogen, airplane glue, with a mild euphoric like catnip. In his case, what's done is done, and we'll continue to be bombarded with his foolish analysis regarding who's a real Jew and who is not. :-(

    Has kremlinstoogeA123 been able to determine which category best describes his own orientation yet? :-)

    , @A123
    @QCIC

    ROTFL -- My beliefs are wholly consistent.

    You are the one incoherently blaming Joooooozzzzz for everything, which carries serious contradictions. Your belief in large numbers of "anti-Semitic Jew Nazis" is particularly irrational. Do you believe they are hiding in your closet right now?

    Let me offer you your own advice -- When you finally want to end your hatred of Judeo-Christian values, there are people who may be able to help you rebuild. Until then, as a Christian, I offer forgiveness.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @John Johnson

  839. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    All dogs eat poop. It is part of a dog's well-balanced diet.

    I have known people who let dogs sleep in their bed and lick their face. Agree that dog eugenics [sic] is an excellent thought experiment for science fiction gene editing humans.

    Did you ever take a catechism class where they taught you that all of the church dogmas are rooted in Ten Commandments, Lord's Prayer, and Apostles' Creed? There is a tradition that the commandment to not take God's name in vain implies that man is commanded not to play God. Also implied:

    Thou shalt not abort fetuses
    Thou shalt not chop off your nuts
    Thou shalt not snip out that gene for aggro behavior
    Thou shalt not snip out that gene for dumb and tomfoolery
    Thou shalt not cut and paste in that gene for high SAT scores

    + &c.

    This is the logic chain where Sarah Palin was applauded by fundies for carrying her Down's Syndrome fetus all the way. That was a deliberate and extreme righteousness display.

    The part about poop being part of a dog's well-balanced diet might be pseudo science but I am not a dog person. Dogs are way too much work if you ask me.

    My favorite comment was the Rottweiler one which I also have no idea if it is true. The fellow who posted it said the breed has been selected huge. The NBA player who was attacked by his dog on Christmas and knocked out of a couple games with dog bites has a Rottweiler. I haven't seen a report on how big the dog was but the NBA guy is 6ft 8in 235lb. I am curious how big that dog was.

    Replies: @songbird, @Philip Owen

    Coprophagia is almost as interesting as it is disgusting.

    [MORE]

    Leaving a lot of sticks in a pile over winter where it snows can be a lesson in it, as it is sometimes possible to observe enormous quantities of rabbit waste. No idea if that is the type they re-eat, or whether it has already come out a second time.

    I’ve generally heard the attribute in dogs explained by reference to scavenging. But there is a theory that they do it for the enzymes, since they don’t consume it after it is two days old.

    I’ve personally wondered if it is a youthful trait – one of the many ways dogs resemble wolf cubs. (No idea if wolves or cubs do it, but I remember from a documentary that baby elephants do.)

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coprophagia

    Think I heard somewhere that bacterial diversity in the gut is considered a good thing, and the growing lack of it as we age can cause problems.

    Have wanted to see this old TV movie about Dobermans for a while:
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trapped_(1973_film)
    Have seen Chopping Mall, which was a sort of rip off of it with robots.

    At the very least, I think disease-resistance editing would be popular. I still vividly remember seeing a film in the 9th grade that showed heartworms.

  840. @AP
    @QCIC


    I am against WW3 which the West is trying to start
     
    You are a contrarian who likes to think the opposite of reality and who for some reason hates the West, your place of origin. Your supposed fear of World War III is not a very convincing excuse or cover for your self-hatred. If Ukraine is conquered (unlikely) and Putin demands the Baltics next, you will argue that they should be given to him because of the risk of World War III. You will blame them for anti-Russian policies, provocations, being “pawns” of the West, etc. Is that right?

    And then if Russia demands the return of the War-era spheres of control and a NATO withdrawal from Poland, Czechia etc. you will also support that, in order to prevent World War III of course. Correct?

    I recognize the West created this mess using Ukraine as a pawn against Russia, so I am not persuaded by shrill claims that “Putin started it!”

     

    A normal person assigns blame for starting a war on the side that invades. America, not Saddam, started the Iraq war, Saddam did not start it by abusing Kurds and Shiites or trying to get weapons. Russia, not Ukraine or the West, started the Russia-Ukraine war.

    Ukraine could have created what you and Hack dream of, but the leadership chose to pursue this autonomy as puppets of the West
     
    According to the Russian state concerns (which you ape), any separation of Ukraine from Russia is seen as by definition puppetry by the West, thus no separation is allowed. War is inevitable as long as Ukraine seeks independence from Russia. Medvedev has made that quite clear, and you agree. Good to know where everyone stands.

    Replies: @QCIC, @Mr. XYZ

    A normal person assigns blame for starting a war on the side that invades. America, not Saddam, started the Iraq war, Saddam did not start it by abusing Kurds and Shiites or trying to get weapons. Russia, not Ukraine or the West, started the Russia-Ukraine war.

    By that logic, JFK would have started WWIII had Vasily Arkhipov not had some common sense since he was the one who ordered the blockade of Cuba, which by international law is a declaration of war, right?

  841. @QCIC
    @A123

    I hold many Christian values.

    I did not label Kiev Jewish. I agree that Russia has a similar degree of elite/deep state Jewish influence which makes sense considering they are part of the same country! That last part was hyperbole for the Ukies, LOL.

    Just remember, when you finally can no longer juggle the contradictory pieces of your worldview, there are people who may be able to help you rebuild. Who knows, maybe Hack can hook you up with some catnip?

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @A123

    It’s extremely difficult to get an inveterate glue sniffer like kremlinstoogeA123 to substitute his preferred hallucinogen, airplane glue, with a mild euphoric like catnip. In his case, what’s done is done, and we’ll continue to be bombarded with his foolish analysis regarding who’s a real Jew and who is not. 🙁

    Has kremlinstoogeA123 been able to determine which category best describes his own orientation yet? 🙂

  842. @Mr. XYZ
    @Beckow

    Interesting; thank you.

    BTW, speaking of Stefanik, the US could have a Vice President Stefanik next year if Trump will win again this year:

    https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2024-election/trump-elise-stefanik-vp-pick-prospect-rcna133599

    She's of mixed Italian and Slovak descent. She's also got dangerous curves:

    https://encrypted-tbn2.gstatic.com/licensed-image?q=tbn:ANd9GcTXcQ-ojfRsvqIdCHGr44jFSoHXW9GY9D55e5cE0XfwiJCdpcWlF0E3vfAwa3gV1O80CnjFEEIn_NVK96E

    https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2021/11/stefanikelise_110321gn_lead.jpg?w=1280

    For a curvy woman, she is relatively attractive.

    Replies: @Beckow

    The curves could be the Italian pasta-mama…our Stefaniks are famously trim – the austere Protestant genes…

    That also won’t age well, so she better get the VP now. But isn’t Trump also from NY so it would be un-Constitutional?

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Beckow


    That also won’t age well, so she better get the VP now. But isn’t Trump also from NY so it would be un-Constitutional?

     

    Trump can change his voter registration to Florida, no? After all, he has a house there (Mar-a-Lago). Dick Cheney did this back in 2000 when he changed his voter registration from Texas back to Wyoming so that he could be Bush Jr.'s VP pick. Had Cheney remained registered in Texas, it would not have worked since then both Bush Jr. and Cheney would have been from Texas.

    Replies: @A123

  843. @QCIC
    @A123

    I hold many Christian values.

    I did not label Kiev Jewish. I agree that Russia has a similar degree of elite/deep state Jewish influence which makes sense considering they are part of the same country! That last part was hyperbole for the Ukies, LOL.

    Just remember, when you finally can no longer juggle the contradictory pieces of your worldview, there are people who may be able to help you rebuild. Who knows, maybe Hack can hook you up with some catnip?

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @A123

    ROTFL — My beliefs are wholly consistent.

    You are the one incoherently blaming Joooooozzzzz for everything, which carries serious contradictions. Your belief in large numbers of “anti-Semitic Jew Nazis” is particularly irrational. Do you believe they are hiding in your closet right now?

    Let me offer you your own advice — When you finally want to end your hatred of Judeo-Christian values, there are people who may be able to help you rebuild. Until then, as a Christian, I offer forgiveness.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @A123

    Your belief in large numbers of “anti-Semitic Jew Nazis” is particularly irrational. Do you believe they are hiding in your closet right now?

    Anti-Semitic Jew Nazis?

    Is that a Troma movie?
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fg5IsQKBE4g

    Replies: @QCIC

  844. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mr. XYZ


    I should have said two million rather than three million. I’m sorry.
     
    Oops.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V4WGsMplGxU

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    It doesn’t cardinally change the overall picture, though. I confused the Jewish population figures for all of interwar Poland with those for interwar Poland west of the Curzon Line. An understandable mistake.

  845. @AP
    @Beckow


    Kiev needs to make peace
     
    With whom? Russia only agrees to “peace” in the form of loss of Ukrainian statehood. So calls for Kiev to make peace are nothing more than demands that Ukrainians abandon their country’s independence. It’s like demanding Czechoslovakia or Poland to make peace with Germany in 1938-1939. Czechs went for it, but Ukrainians are not 1939 Czechs.

    Replies: @A123, @Beckow

    You can parade your infantile boastfulness and ancient myths all you want, this is a completely new situation: Kiev is losing a war they didn’t have to fight over membership in Nato and language rights for its 10-million Russian minority.

    They can go on, more dead and destruction, at the end Russia will win. Longer it takes, the worse the deal will be for two reasons:
    – Russia has added territorial security to its goals – meaning a wide demilitarized buffer
    – Kiev will be weaker.

    Ukie statehood is a slogan, you can read into it whatever you want. Are Latin American countries states? Or the Euro Nato vassals? It has always been like that – you don’t get to point missiles at a stronger neighbor and ally with their sworn enemies and argue that it is your statehood right…it is not that complicated.

  846. @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    The curves could be the Italian pasta-mama...our Stefaniks are famously trim - the austere Protestant genes...

    That also won't age well, so she better get the VP now. But isn't Trump also from NY so it would be un-Constitutional?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    That also won’t age well, so she better get the VP now. But isn’t Trump also from NY so it would be un-Constitutional?

    Trump can change his voter registration to Florida, no? After all, he has a house there (Mar-a-Lago). Dick Cheney did this back in 2000 when he changed his voter registration from Texas back to Wyoming so that he could be Bush Jr.’s VP pick. Had Cheney remained registered in Texas, it would not have worked since then both Bush Jr. and Cheney would have been from Texas.

    • Replies: @A123
    @Mr. XYZ



    That also won’t age well, so she better get the VP now. But isn’t Trump also from NY so it would be un-Constitutional?
     
    Trump can change his voter registration to Florida, no? After all, he has a house there (Mar-a-Lago).
     
    Trump changed his legal residence to Florida years ago. So, there would be no problem selecting Stefanik.

    Also, strictly speaking, it is not "unconstitutional". The penalty is -- If both candidates are from the same state, they cannot receive that state's delegates in the Electoral College.


    Dick Cheney did this back in 2000 when he changed his voter registration from Texas back to Wyoming so that he could be Bush Jr.’s VP
     
    That was a much friendlier era with fewer silly lawsuits. If attempted nowadays, such a residence change would be dragged through court. Given the need to win Florida in the Electoral College, we can be fairly confident that Trump's VP pick will not be from Florida. No Trump/DeSantis ticket.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  847. @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    Yesterday the Russians did a long range missile [?] attack on French mercs after France announces long range missiles for the Ukraine.
     
    Reportedly ~60 French soldiers were killed and ~20 wounded. However, we are unlikely to learn real casualty numbers among Western scum serving Ukraine: Western military does not want the public to know, and obsequious Western lugenpresse “reports” accordingly.

    BTW, did you see the "news" alleging that two US Navy SEALs drowned in the Red see under very murky circumstances? We should remember that you can easily “drown in the Red sea” while being in a hotel in Kharkov targeted by Russians.

    Isn’t Kharkov practically on the front line?
     
    Not yet. All in good time.

    Replies: @Beckow

    …Reportedly ~60 French soldiers were killed and ~20 wounded.

    I am not sure about that story. If Russia could have done this before, why didn’t they? Was Lira kept at the facility? The story suggests that they have local informers or electronic intercepts, but the precision sounds like human sources. Or it could be made up. It’s a war, all is fair…

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    If Russia could have done this before, why didn’t they?
     
    I also wonder why didn’t they do it earlier. Putin appears to be playing a complex game I am not privy to. The most parsimonious explanation is that he holds a lot of trump cards to use at the moment of his choosing. France just announced that it will give Ukies some long-range rockets, so the extermination of French pro-Ukie fighters was a targeted just-in-time response.

    The story suggests that they have local informers or electronic intercepts, but the precision sounds like human sources.
     
    Russia has many human informers in Kharkov, so this is certainly HUMINT. HIMINT also explains many other precise strikes in various parts of Ukraine. A significant proportion of current Ukraine residents wants the places they live in to become Russia. A lot of people in Ukraine hate current Ukie regime and want it gone. Some of them want a decent Ukraine to remain, others don’t want even that.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  848. @Mr. XYZ
    @Beckow


    That also won’t age well, so she better get the VP now. But isn’t Trump also from NY so it would be un-Constitutional?

     

    Trump can change his voter registration to Florida, no? After all, he has a house there (Mar-a-Lago). Dick Cheney did this back in 2000 when he changed his voter registration from Texas back to Wyoming so that he could be Bush Jr.'s VP pick. Had Cheney remained registered in Texas, it would not have worked since then both Bush Jr. and Cheney would have been from Texas.

    Replies: @A123

    That also won’t age well, so she better get the VP now. But isn’t Trump also from NY so it would be un-Constitutional?

    Trump can change his voter registration to Florida, no? After all, he has a house there (Mar-a-Lago).

    Trump changed his legal residence to Florida years ago. So, there would be no problem selecting Stefanik.

    Also, strictly speaking, it is not “unconstitutional”. The penalty is — If both candidates are from the same state, they cannot receive that state’s delegates in the Electoral College.

    Dick Cheney did this back in 2000 when he changed his voter registration from Texas back to Wyoming so that he could be Bush Jr.’s VP

    That was a much friendlier era with fewer silly lawsuits. If attempted nowadays, such a residence change would be dragged through court. Given the need to win Florida in the Electoral College, we can be fairly confident that Trump’s VP pick will not be from Florida. No Trump/DeSantis ticket.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @A123


    Also, strictly speaking, it is not “unconstitutional”. The penalty is — If both candidates are from the same state, they cannot receive that state’s delegates in the Electoral College.

     

    So, even if Trump stayed in New York, it wouldn't matter since he and Stefanik would have no hope of winning New York's electoral votes?
  849. @Beckow
    @AnonfromTN


    ...Reportedly ~60 French soldiers were killed and ~20 wounded.
     
    I am not sure about that story. If Russia could have done this before, why didn't they? Was Lira kept at the facility? The story suggests that they have local informers or electronic intercepts, but the precision sounds like human sources. Or it could be made up. It's a war, all is fair...

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    If Russia could have done this before, why didn’t they?

    I also wonder why didn’t they do it earlier. Putin appears to be playing a complex game I am not privy to. The most parsimonious explanation is that he holds a lot of trump cards to use at the moment of his choosing. France just announced that it will give Ukies some long-range rockets, so the extermination of French pro-Ukie fighters was a targeted just-in-time response.

    The story suggests that they have local informers or electronic intercepts, but the precision sounds like human sources.

    Russia has many human informers in Kharkov, so this is certainly HUMINT. HIMINT also explains many other precise strikes in various parts of Ukraine. A significant proportion of current Ukraine residents wants the places they live in to become Russia. A lot of people in Ukraine hate current Ukie regime and want it gone. Some of them want a decent Ukraine to remain, others don’t want even that.

    • LOL: Mr. Hack
    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AnonfromTN

    France is denying everything

    https://www.france24.com/en/europe/20240118-paris-dismisses-russian-claim-of-french-mercenaries-in-ukraine

    Which of course is one reason why mercenaries are useful. About once a week on r/military they have an obituary for another American merc.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @AnonfromTN

  850. @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    If Russia could have done this before, why didn’t they?
     
    I also wonder why didn’t they do it earlier. Putin appears to be playing a complex game I am not privy to. The most parsimonious explanation is that he holds a lot of trump cards to use at the moment of his choosing. France just announced that it will give Ukies some long-range rockets, so the extermination of French pro-Ukie fighters was a targeted just-in-time response.

    The story suggests that they have local informers or electronic intercepts, but the precision sounds like human sources.
     
    Russia has many human informers in Kharkov, so this is certainly HUMINT. HIMINT also explains many other precise strikes in various parts of Ukraine. A significant proportion of current Ukraine residents wants the places they live in to become Russia. A lot of people in Ukraine hate current Ukie regime and want it gone. Some of them want a decent Ukraine to remain, others don’t want even that.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    France is denying everything

    https://www.france24.com/en/europe/20240118-paris-dismisses-russian-claim-of-french-mercenaries-in-ukraine

    Which of course is one reason why mercenaries are useful. About once a week on r/military they have an obituary for another American merc.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Could have been French volunteers. Maybe that is what Russia meant by mercenaries. They might be trying to scare off volunteer squads.

    What matters is that France is sending 40 scalp missiles to Ukraine.
    https://www.aerotime.aero/articles/france-ukraine-weapons-support

    Can't wait to see another Russian ship destroyed while in a Crimean dock.

    Bradley tearing apart a T-90
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=es-yxUtbGmU

    They most likely have depleted uranium rounds. I actually wonder if they can penetrate the T-90 in some spots.

    , @AnonfromTN
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    France is denying everything
     
    As the saying goes, “it isn’t true unless the government denies it”.
  851. I support Israel in its war against Hamas, but after the end of the war, once Hamas is overthrown, there needs to be a Palestinian state, even as an Israeli vassal state if necessary (think of an independent Cuba under the Platt Amendment in the early 20th century):

    https://www.timesofisrael.com/us-says-no-way-to-ensure-israels-long-term-security-without-a-palestinian-state/

    I agree that significant international pressure post-war to make this happen might very well be a good idea. Israel can have security control over this Palestinian state so long as it has decent borders and is allowed to autonomously run its own internal affairs. Israel should aggressively prop up any moderate Palestinian government to prevent the likes of Hamas from ever coming to power in an independent Palestine, though.

  852. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AnonfromTN

    France is denying everything

    https://www.france24.com/en/europe/20240118-paris-dismisses-russian-claim-of-french-mercenaries-in-ukraine

    Which of course is one reason why mercenaries are useful. About once a week on r/military they have an obituary for another American merc.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @AnonfromTN

    Could have been French volunteers. Maybe that is what Russia meant by mercenaries. They might be trying to scare off volunteer squads.

    What matters is that France is sending 40 scalp missiles to Ukraine.
    https://www.aerotime.aero/articles/france-ukraine-weapons-support

    Can’t wait to see another Russian ship destroyed while in a Crimean dock.

    Bradley tearing apart a T-90

    They most likely have depleted uranium rounds. I actually wonder if they can penetrate the T-90 in some spots.

    • Thanks: Mr. Hack
  853. @A123
    @QCIC

    ROTFL -- My beliefs are wholly consistent.

    You are the one incoherently blaming Joooooozzzzz for everything, which carries serious contradictions. Your belief in large numbers of "anti-Semitic Jew Nazis" is particularly irrational. Do you believe they are hiding in your closet right now?

    Let me offer you your own advice -- When you finally want to end your hatred of Judeo-Christian values, there are people who may be able to help you rebuild. Until then, as a Christian, I offer forgiveness.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Your belief in large numbers of “anti-Semitic Jew Nazis” is particularly irrational. Do you believe they are hiding in your closet right now?

    Anti-Semitic Jew Nazis?

    Is that a Troma movie?

    • LOL: A123
    • Replies: @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    Is that a Walther P38?

  854. @A123
    @Mr. XYZ



    That also won’t age well, so she better get the VP now. But isn’t Trump also from NY so it would be un-Constitutional?
     
    Trump can change his voter registration to Florida, no? After all, he has a house there (Mar-a-Lago).
     
    Trump changed his legal residence to Florida years ago. So, there would be no problem selecting Stefanik.

    Also, strictly speaking, it is not "unconstitutional". The penalty is -- If both candidates are from the same state, they cannot receive that state's delegates in the Electoral College.


    Dick Cheney did this back in 2000 when he changed his voter registration from Texas back to Wyoming so that he could be Bush Jr.’s VP
     
    That was a much friendlier era with fewer silly lawsuits. If attempted nowadays, such a residence change would be dragged through court. Given the need to win Florida in the Electoral College, we can be fairly confident that Trump's VP pick will not be from Florida. No Trump/DeSantis ticket.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Also, strictly speaking, it is not “unconstitutional”. The penalty is — If both candidates are from the same state, they cannot receive that state’s delegates in the Electoral College.

    So, even if Trump stayed in New York, it wouldn’t matter since he and Stefanik would have no hope of winning New York’s electoral votes?

  855. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    All dogs eat poop. It is part of a dog's well-balanced diet.

    I have known people who let dogs sleep in their bed and lick their face. Agree that dog eugenics [sic] is an excellent thought experiment for science fiction gene editing humans.

    Did you ever take a catechism class where they taught you that all of the church dogmas are rooted in Ten Commandments, Lord's Prayer, and Apostles' Creed? There is a tradition that the commandment to not take God's name in vain implies that man is commanded not to play God. Also implied:

    Thou shalt not abort fetuses
    Thou shalt not chop off your nuts
    Thou shalt not snip out that gene for aggro behavior
    Thou shalt not snip out that gene for dumb and tomfoolery
    Thou shalt not cut and paste in that gene for high SAT scores

    + &c.

    This is the logic chain where Sarah Palin was applauded by fundies for carrying her Down's Syndrome fetus all the way. That was a deliberate and extreme righteousness display.

    The part about poop being part of a dog's well-balanced diet might be pseudo science but I am not a dog person. Dogs are way too much work if you ask me.

    My favorite comment was the Rottweiler one which I also have no idea if it is true. The fellow who posted it said the breed has been selected huge. The NBA player who was attacked by his dog on Christmas and knocked out of a couple games with dog bites has a Rottweiler. I haven't seen a report on how big the dog was but the NBA guy is 6ft 8in 235lb. I am curious how big that dog was.

    Replies: @songbird, @Philip Owen

    Where I come from, dogs worked at herding sheep. They stayed outside in the barn or a kennel. Absolutely no one touched a dog’s mouth or nose. Far less kissed it. It was a perfect way to catch liver fluke.

    • Replies: @Sean
    @Philip Owen

    A working line dog (bred for herding or hunting ETC) is a completely different creature.

  856. @AP
    @Beckow


    [massacres during World War I] In Serbia, Galicia, Volyn, Subcarpathia
     
    In Galicia it was the Hungarians, not the Austrians. And they did not massacre entire villages.

    Habsburgs were brutal as were the other powers at that time
     
    Poles lived under Hapsburgs, Hohenzollerns and Romanovs. They know that Hapsburgs were clearly the best of the three. Under Hapsburgs, Prague became a Czech-speaking city. How did Dublin do under the British? Kiev under the Romanovs? What happened to the Sorbs under German rule?

    The ahistorical claim that the mid-20th century brutality was very unusual and came out of nowhere is false
     
    Nothing comes from nowhere, but don't pretend 1933-1945 was no worse than 1860-1914.

    badly educated Americans who know only what they see in the movies weirdly worship the feudal societies
     
    Americans hate feudal societies. They sometimes like the British royal family but that's ust celebrity worship. They only like the rich who talk like them and act like them. You are clueless as usual.

    Life under socialism (“commies”) in the CE Europe was an order of magnitude better than life under the feudal systems and early capitalism.
     
    That's as stupid as giving Bolsheviks credit for antibiotics and electricity, as if it would not have occurred if not for them.

    Almost all countries improve over time. Even Socialist ones did. But they improved more slowly than the others, they fell far behind. Of the three post-war economic systems in Europe (Euro-capitalist, Socialist, and semi-fascist), Socialist was the least successful.

    History provided the experiment. Compare the performance of Austria (Euro-capitalist) to Czechoslovakia/Hungary (Socialist) and Spain/Portugal (quasi-fascist).

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.
    Hungary: $2,200.
    Spain: $2,186
    Portugal: $2,046

    So prior to Socialism, Czechoslovakia was richer than Austria, Hungary was poorer but similar, Portugal and Spain were poorer than both Hungary and Czechoslovakia.

    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Spain: $11,582.
    Portugal: $10,372

    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768
    Hungary: $6,903.

    Austria now became not only the richest of the three former Hapsburg countries, but doubled the ones that got stuck under Communism. This is the most relevant comparison because these three countries are geographically close, and culturally and historically similar.

    But you see, Portugal and Spain passed up Czechoslovakia and Hungary and were a lot richer per capita than those two Commie countries. Quasi-fascism beat Socialism.

    Life expectancy divergence matched the economic divergence.

    People like AP are not capable of understanding it so they fabulize about golden past that was destroyed by the 20th cent. socialists
     
    19th century actually was a Golden Age for Europe, it ended in 1914. You doubt it? Compare cultural products, global power, etc.

    But it was the 20th century socialism that created the prosperous Europe
     
    Europe was improving in prosperity prior to the 20th century. You are too poorly educated to know that, of course. Your socialist teachers filled you little brain with fairy tales of socialist saviors and evil kings and nobles keeping everyone in the same squalor from the Middle Age until the 1920s. And you were gullible enough to believe them.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_regions_by_past_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita#1750%E2%80%931990_(Bairoch)

    Between 1870 and 1913, Austria's GDP per capita nearly doubled. Growth was accelerating, it had been slower before that. And there wasn't much difference between Austria's growth rate and that of non-monarchies or ones with powerless monarchs. It was universal in Europe.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Gerard1234

    Of the three post-war economic systems in Europe (Euro-capitalist, Socialist, and semi-fascist), Socialist was the least successful.

    Of course this is a nonsense statement. The salary numbers are stupid and You’re comparing countries that didn’t suffer much or at all in WW2………with the majority of countries that did you imbecile. Countries that had access to money from untouched or relatively untouched by WW2 American, British, French, Scandinavian money/loans and investments – with ones that mostly received from a massively damaged from WW2 USSR and didn’t have the China as it is now to help, and didn’t have the advantage from the 1970’s of the very good benefits that a communist China and USSR relationship would have had for Eastern Bloc if the problem between the 2 countries didn’t happen. Even with all that it was a miracle how much the Soviets were able to rebuild and enhance in these countries

    Then you look at the global trade issue – British, French, American, Belgian scum etc were able to immediately take private ownership of the natural resources of these countries in Africa and Asia that declared themselves “independent”. Those new Independent countries that wanted control of their own resources and nationalised companies for them, were either Marxist or Soviet sympathetic……..and western scum ensured they f**ked up these countries with extensive sabotage efforts EVERY time for several decades. They could have advantage of globalised economy from former empire while destroying every place on the planet outside of Europe that could have helped Soviets and Eastern Bloc.

    It’s obvious that with those disadvantages, the communist system did a brilliant and very successful job – defeated those facist and euro-capitalist countries in many aspects. For 25 years ( at least) a clear winner.

    If you knew or had every spoke to anyone who grew up in communist Czechoslovakia or Hungary ( which you haven’t and won’t as human garbage as yourself has never visited this part of the world) …….then you would hear the vast majority say that to be a kid then would have incredibly fun, adventurous and enriched lives you deranged idiot.

    As for the idiotic comparison with Spain and Portugal – both countries untouched by WW2, access to western capital…..and tourism is at least 10% of each of those countries GDP you imbecile, making any difference non-existent if you exclude tourism.

    Austria now became not only the richest of the three former Hapsburg countries, but doubled the ones that got stuck under Communism. This is the most relevant comparison because these three countries are geographically close, and culturally and historically similar.

    LOL – you are doing this stupid misdirection because its self-evidently retarded to be making comparisons of why Bulgaria or Romania wasn’t as rich as Austria. Austria was much richer than what is stated in that fake link. Whatever the BS is your fake link, Vienna was one of the richest cities in Europe for centuries, and was part of the richest part of that empire

    But you see, Portugal and Spain passed up Czechoslovakia and Hungary and were a lot richer per capita than those two Commie countries. Quasi-fascism beat Socialism.

    LMFAO -as if you can make serious estimates of GDP immediately after WW2 you ridiculous cretin. How the f**k can you have relevant statistics for countries still rebuilding in 1947, dumbass? Austria did not suffer under the Nazi’s like the Czechs, didn’t degermanify, had no sudden switch from one system to the other. Didn’t suffer as much population loss as Hungary. As I said, for over half a millenium Austrian land has been wealthier than what is now Czech and Hungarian land.

    Obviously in Poland, if you eliminate the Germans and import more Poles you are going to get a dumber and poorer population you moron. Obviously in Poland if you eliminate the Galician khokhols and import more Poles than you are going to get a less dumb and more productive population you moron.

    Hungary and particularly Czechs had large removal of german population after WW2. To anybody with a brain, the german factor is critical – not socialist, fascist or capitalist system you dumb prick. Anybody can make any argument they want – degermanification, non-Protestant, Catholic,Orthodox, atheist – affected by population loss and physical damage from WW2 etc.

    That’s as stupid as giving Bolsheviks credit for antibiotics and electricity, as if it would not have occurred if not for them.

    20th century socialism, CLEARLY is reponsible for Israeli tech sector you dipshit. 1990s economic growth and IT development in western economies is partially explained by ideas, human capital and other resources from Eastern Bloc after communist collapse. It doesn’t explain all but certainly some of it

    Anyway, 100 years before – industrialisation ( alot of it fueled by colonialism and the raw material from it) resulted in masses of people flooding into towns and cities to work in the factories. People having the same amount of children as they had in rural areas, but now in urban, living filthy lives and breathing unclean air, not able to grown their own produce and feed themselves like when they were poor but had their own land to grow produce in the countryside. Rich got even more wealthier and owned more land and properties…..while by comparison the rest were working longer , but limited social mobility…while having the intellectual ability and urge to group together and form political groups. Whatever rises in medical science and education ( at best nothing more than not being illiterate) did not compensate for the problems in this new social situation.Without communism this unfair position would not have been corrected. WW1 had nothing to do with it. Either countries became communist or several of these western states implemented very communist social and even economic and engineering/ architectural policies to appease large section of their populations

    Anyway – what does it say that socialist Cuba is FAR richer than Banderastan???!!! LOL

    Comparisons between European countries are very misleading……..better comparison would be with the disaster that is American control of South and central America . Capitalist in Latin American with close relation with Pindostan – extremely chaotic and not rich. Communist/Socialist – f**ked up by the Americans every time. Dictatorship – see capitalist.

    America gives the world the produce of the cocaine barons from Colombia and creates most of the heroin trade from Afghanistan. With Soviets this sick filth would never have happened.

    Germany today still has significant difference ( though both still wealthy by most of Europe standards) in wealth of east german land compared to west germany, despite trillions invested and 35 years since end of communism

    19th century actually was a Golden Age for Europe, it ended in 1914. You doubt it? Compare cultural products, global power, etc.

    For the retard who was exposed as completely inept and not knowing at all the foreign blood in every single European monarchy…….its just sick fantasist nonsense that you would then come up with this new statement. Very bizarre.

    Americans hate feudal societies. They sometimes like the British royal family but that’s ust celebrity worship. They only like the rich who talk like them and act like them. You are clueless as usual.

    Nonsense, Beckow is correct. Kennedy family , Bush family, ( if he wasn’t such another american sleazebag) then Clinton family. Cuomo’s in New York. Even the way the mafia control appears to have been viewed. That the so-called anti-elite politician, Trump, is probably one of the most “elite” of them all and doesn’t appear to have any entrepreneur ability or the ability to actually make money and generate jobs, like a Henry Ford, create anything and involved in New York real estate market……supports Beckow’s position.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Gerard1234


    Austria did not suffer under the Nazi’s like the Czechs, didn’t degermanify, had no sudden switch from one system to the other. Didn’t suffer as much population loss as Hungary.
     
    Austria lost a huge number of its young and middle-aged men during WWII since Austrian men were also drafted into the German Army en masse (or volunteered for this) since Austria was a part of the German Reich during WWII.
    , @AP
    @Gerard1234


    Of the three post-war economic systems in Europe (Euro-capitalist, Socialist, and semi-fascist), Socialist was the least successful.

    Of course this is a nonsense statement. The salary numbers are stupid and You’re comparing countries that didn’t suffer much or at all in WW2………with the majority of countries that did you imbecile.
     
    Austria had more deaths than Czechoslovakia during World War II:

    https://www.nationalww2museum.org/students-teachers/student-resources/research-starters/research-starters-worldwide-deaths-world-war

    384,000 (Austria) vs. 345,000 (Czechoslovakia)


    Countries that had access to money from untouched or relatively untouched by WW2 American, British, French, Scandinavian money/loans and investments
     
    This wouldn't explain the fact that the Socialist counties kept falling further and further behind, even decades after the war ended.

    Then you look at the global trade issue – British, French, American, Belgian scum etc were able to immediately take private ownership of the natural resources of these countries in Africa and Asia that declared themselves “independent”. Those new Independent countries that wanted control of their own resources and nationalised companies for them, were either Marxist or Soviet sympathetic……..and western scum ensured they f**ked up these countries
     
    All those countries got richer when they dropped Socialism.

    It’s obvious that with those disadvantages, the communist system did a brilliant and very successful job – defeated those facist and euro-capitalist countries in many aspects
     
    They won the competition for ugly and small housing.

    As for the idiotic comparison with Spain and Portugal – both countries untouched by WW2
     
    You are unaware of the fact that Spain had a bloody civil war.

    About 500,000 died in Spain during the Civil War.

    And it surpassed Commie central Europe long after Word War II anyways.


    .and tourism is at least 10% of each of those countries GDP
     
    Tourism doesn't count as "capitalism" now?

    If you are going to play this game, exclude oil and coal from your calculations.


    Austria now became not only the richest of the three former Hapsburg countries, but doubled the ones that got stuck under Communism. This is the most relevant comparison because these three countries are geographically close, and culturally and historically similar.

    Austria was much richer than what is stated in that fake link
     

    Link for economic data was to Maddison project, hosted by University of Groningen:

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.
    Hungary: $2,200.
    Spain: $2,186
    Portugal: $2,046

    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Spain: $11,582.
    Portugal: $10,372

    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768
    Hungary: $6,903.


    Austria did not suffer under the Nazi’s like the Czechs, didn’t degermanify, had no sudden switch from one system to the other.
     
    Austria lost more people during World War II - lots of productive young men who were killed during the war.

    So in 1948 Austria was poorer than Czechoslovakia.

    In 1989 after Czechoslovakia languished under Socialism and Austria enjoyed capitalism for 40 years, Austria was about 2x richer.


    As I said, for over half a millenium Austrian land has been wealthier than what is now Czech and Hungarian land.
     
    Not by much.

    In 1890, the per capita product, in 2010 dollars, in Austria was $3,005 and in Bohemia was $2,513.

    It wasn't twice richer. Only after Socialism did Austria become twice richer than Bohemia.


    Hungary and particularly Czechs had large removal of german population after WW2. To anybody with a brain, the german factor is critical
     
    It's funny that a Sovok untermench such as you considers Germans to be ubermenschen.

    Czechoslovakia lost Germans but also lost Carpathian Ruthenians, who were very poor (until recently their province was the poorest one in Ukraine).

    And anyways that loss of Germans would not explain how Czechoslovakia went from being richer than Austria in 1948 (the Germans were gone by then) to having only half the GDP of Austria in 1989.


    20th century socialism, CLEARLY is reponsible for Israeli tech sector you dipshit. 1990s economic growth and IT development in western economies is partially explained by ideas, human capital and other resources from Eastern Bloc after communist collapse
     
    Not in your case, of course.

    The socialist system could indeed train some smart people. It also kept them poor and short-lived. But they could use their skills to good effect in a non-socialist environment.


    Americans hate feudal societies. They sometimes like the British royal family but that’s ust celebrity worship. They only like the rich who talk like them and act like them. You are clueless as usual.

    Nonsense, Beckow is correct. Kennedy family , Bush family, ( if he wasn’t such another american sleazebag) then Clinton family.

     

    JFK was 60 years ago. Dubya Bush pretended to be a Texas redneck. "Bubba" Clinton acted like an Arkansas "good ole boy." Obama who went to elite schools and was raised by rich white family members puts on a fake African-American accent.

    Americans dislike elites so much, that the elites have to pretend not to be elites.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Gerard1234

  857. EPIPHANY FROSTS
    I was sceptical about reports of Russian infrastructure breakdown. A bit more than usual perhaps but exagerrated because of media attention. However, this list from Saratov, not reported as having a major breakdown, changes my mind. I have spend the Epiphany Frosts in Saratov. At Slonova 1, one of the listed buildings as it happens. Something bad really is happening to Russian heating utilities.

    https://www.vzsar.ru/news/2024/01/19/v-saratove-opyat-otkluchaut-otoplenie-i-gvs-nazvany-adresa.html

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Philip Owen

    Do you think the cause is lack of fuel, lack of maintenance men or something more subtle?

    Replies: @Philip Owen

    , @YetAnotherAnon
    @Philip Owen

    OTOH the Royal Navy seems incapable of wiring an electric motor correctly, AND incapable of testing that it's wired correctly.

    https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2024/jan/21/royal-navy-warships-crashed-into-each-other-due-to-faulty-rewiring-say-sources


    Two Royal Navy warships collided in Bahrain at the end of last week because one was incorrectly rewired, meaning that it unexpectedly went into reverse when it was set to go forward, military sources have said.

    The minehunter HMS Chiddingfold went backwards into HMS Bangor, which was lying at port, ripping a hole in a cabin above the waterline, in an embarrassing blunder that the defence secretary, Grant Shapps, insisted did not reflect incompetence.


    “HMS Chiddingfold’s motor was wired incorrectly and full ahead gave full astern,” a navy insider said. The vessel had been recently inspected by officers at the maritime capability, trials and assessment team, they added.

    Fresh video and pictures from inside HMS Bangor show sunlight clearly coming through a hole at the end of a kitchen cabin and damage to sleeping berths. Another picture of the outside of the warship shows the side ripped open and its pennant number, M109.

    Previous footage, which appeared on social media on Friday evening, showed HMS Chiddingfold heading inexorably towards HMS Bangor, a crash that its crew appeared unable to prevent.
     

    Replies: @Beyond the pale and fedup

  858. @Another Polish Perspective
    @A123

    The notion of false Jews, or "Jews who call themselves Jews but are not" in the words of Revelation of St John is essential for understanding of the current situation around JQ. It was already problem in the Old Testament, when Canaanites tried to infiltrate Jews. They finally did.
    It is also understandable that such false Jews would cooperate with Nazis to bring hate upon Jews. The modern, Talmudic concept of Jew (matrilineal), as someone obsessed with Oral Law (Talmud) and Moschiach is far away from that of the Old Testament: patrilineal, tribe-, Written Law-oriented.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Greasy William

    So wouldn’t that make the Samaritans the real Jews, in that case? I’m not sure what you are trying to say

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @Greasy William

    Samaritans are most likely not real Jews. They are really into cousin marriages, like Canaanites and Phoenicians, but not biblical Jews. They are probably remnant of pre-Jew population of Canaan. Interestingly, like British Israelites, they claim to come from half-Egyptian tribes: Ephraim and Manasseh. Therefore they are probably as fake as Jews as British Israelites are.

    Real Jews were most likely Karaites, some Askhenazi too.

    I am trying to say that people who are called Jews nowadays are mostly false Jews, not Biblical Jews and what is now Judaism is the result of hostile takeover of Judaism in the post-Temple period by Phoenicians and Canaanites. Interestingly, some Jews were said to have been as famously "red" as Phoenicians were. These people are not really betrothed to Jahwe, anyway they try not to pronounce his name as much as they can, and they are much more devoted to Talmud than Torah. And yet the antisemitism today is mostly directed against biblical Judaism, Jahwe despite them never condoning what modern Judaism had become. In other words, modern antisemitism is one big misdirection. It hates what once was for that what it allegedly has become.
    For some reason it is Askhenazi Jews who became its main target as fake Jews, whereas for some the same strange reason, Sephardi Jews are absolved from antisemitism, depicted as true Jews, whereas it is the Sephardi who are mostly fake, being former Phoenicians. Nevertheless, throughout history it was Sephardim who were mostly interested in supporting this or that Moschiach craze, which is in fact a strange doctrine, alien to the general spirit of teaching of Old Testament. Yet in antiquity the messianic expectation was based on the famous "son of star" verse from Numbers 24:17, but after failure of Bar Kochba, the new messianic verses were found: in itself the proof that messianic expectations, like matrilineality, came from outside Scripture and post hoc determined reading of Scripture.
    Just the knowledge that messianic expectations in antiquity were based on the Numbers verse, put a question mark behind Christianity.
    Anyway, the strange directions of anti-Semitic discourse suggests that it is generated in cooperation with false Jews.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  859. I went 3-3 on Wildcard weekend. Here are my divisional round picks:

    Bills
    Lions
    9ers
    Ravens

  860. • Replies: @John Johnson
    @songbird

    Who has a higher sociosexual number, Kamala or Haley?

    Definitely Kamala. Sounds like sexually unsatisfied mom vs an actual prostitute.

    Kamala started her political career by giving blowjobs to Willie Brown.

    This is prostitution:
    https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2020/08/13/18/31918142-0-image-a-77_1597340734012.jpg

    Even Willy the 100k lawyer would not have gotten a blowjob from her.

    She wanted a career in SF politics and went straight for the desk. Well under it anyways. She probably would have gone down on a woman if needed.

    Replies: @songbird

  861. @John Johnson
    @A123

    Your belief in large numbers of “anti-Semitic Jew Nazis” is particularly irrational. Do you believe they are hiding in your closet right now?

    Anti-Semitic Jew Nazis?

    Is that a Troma movie?
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fg5IsQKBE4g

    Replies: @QCIC

    Is that a Walther P38?

  862. @Greasy William
    @Another Polish Perspective

    So wouldn't that make the Samaritans the real Jews, in that case? I'm not sure what you are trying to say

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

    Samaritans are most likely not real Jews. They are really into cousin marriages, like Canaanites and Phoenicians, but not biblical Jews. They are probably remnant of pre-Jew population of Canaan. Interestingly, like British Israelites, they claim to come from half-Egyptian tribes: Ephraim and Manasseh. Therefore they are probably as fake as Jews as British Israelites are.

    Real Jews were most likely Karaites, some Askhenazi too.

    I am trying to say that people who are called Jews nowadays are mostly false Jews, not Biblical Jews and what is now Judaism is the result of hostile takeover of Judaism in the post-Temple period by Phoenicians and Canaanites. Interestingly, some Jews were said to have been as famously “red” as Phoenicians were. These people are not really betrothed to Jahwe, anyway they try not to pronounce his name as much as they can, and they are much more devoted to Talmud than Torah. And yet the antisemitism today is mostly directed against biblical Judaism, Jahwe despite them never condoning what modern Judaism had become. In other words, modern antisemitism is one big misdirection. It hates what once was for that what it allegedly has become.
    For some reason it is Askhenazi Jews who became its main target as fake Jews, whereas for some the same strange reason, Sephardi Jews are absolved from antisemitism, depicted as true Jews, whereas it is the Sephardi who are mostly fake, being former Phoenicians. Nevertheless, throughout history it was Sephardim who were mostly interested in supporting this or that Moschiach craze, which is in fact a strange doctrine, alien to the general spirit of teaching of Old Testament. Yet in antiquity the messianic expectation was based on the famous “son of star” verse from Numbers 24:17, but after failure of Bar Kochba, the new messianic verses were found: in itself the proof that messianic expectations, like matrilineality, came from outside Scripture and post hoc determined reading of Scripture.
    Just the knowledge that messianic expectations in antiquity were based on the Numbers verse, put a question mark behind Christianity.
    Anyway, the strange directions of anti-Semitic discourse suggests that it is generated in cooperation with false Jews.

    • Thanks: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Another Polish Perspective

    Being another expert on the topic, would you also confer whether or not self-identifying American Jewry that supports Ukraine today are not "real Jews" as kremlinstoogeA123 contends, and that those that support the kremlin are actually the real ones? This seems to be the litmus test that he uses, and I just wanted to see if anybody else out there buys into it?

    https://static01.nyt.com/images/2006/07/04/nyregion/04push.600.jpg
    I wonder whether kremlintoogeA123 still considers these folks to be Jews, or whether they've gone over the edge and have somehow biologically transformed themselves into some new sort of beings? Maybe they've become "born again" as he's professed his adherence to many times at this blogsite?

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Another Polish Perspective

  863. @Philip Owen
    EPIPHANY FROSTS
    I was sceptical about reports of Russian infrastructure breakdown. A bit more than usual perhaps but exagerrated because of media attention. However, this list from Saratov, not reported as having a major breakdown, changes my mind. I have spend the Epiphany Frosts in Saratov. At Slonova 1, one of the listed buildings as it happens. Something bad really is happening to Russian heating utilities.

    https://www.vzsar.ru/news/2024/01/19/v-saratove-opyat-otkluchaut-otoplenie-i-gvs-nazvany-adresa.html

    Replies: @QCIC, @YetAnotherAnon

    Do you think the cause is lack of fuel, lack of maintenance men or something more subtle?

    • Replies: @Philip Owen
    @QCIC

    I really don't know. I think it is subtle. Priorities have changed towards transport systems so less budget for building utilities. breakdowns are still happening more than usual.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s6cGyMAKYf8

  864. @songbird
    Who has a higher sociosexual number, Kamala or Haley?

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12970377/Nikki-Haley-cheated-affair-husband-affidavits-witnesses.html?ns_mchannel=rss&ns_campaign=1490&ito=social-twitter_mailonline

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Who has a higher sociosexual number, Kamala or Haley?

    Definitely Kamala. Sounds like sexually unsatisfied mom vs an actual prostitute.

    Kamala started her political career by giving blowjobs to Willie Brown.

    This is prostitution:
    Even Willy the 100k lawyer would not have gotten a blowjob from her.

    She wanted a career in SF politics and went straight for the desk. Well under it anyways. She probably would have gone down on a woman if needed.

    • Replies: @songbird
    @John Johnson

    Probably Kamala.

    Haley reportedly met her husband when she was 17, and then proceeded to change his name to "Michael."

    Sikhs have a similar custom to Mormons:
    https://www.sikhheros.com/blog/the-power-of-kachera-unraveling-the-symbolism-and-purpose-of-the-sikh-undergarment/

    Too bad Google image search doesn't have a neural net that can do paternity tests on family photos.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  865. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @AnonfromTN

    France is denying everything

    https://www.france24.com/en/europe/20240118-paris-dismisses-russian-claim-of-french-mercenaries-in-ukraine

    Which of course is one reason why mercenaries are useful. About once a week on r/military they have an obituary for another American merc.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @AnonfromTN

    France is denying everything

    As the saying goes, “it isn’t true unless the government denies it”.

  866. @Gerard1234
    @AP


    Of the three post-war economic systems in Europe (Euro-capitalist, Socialist, and semi-fascist), Socialist was the least successful.
     
    Of course this is a nonsense statement. The salary numbers are stupid and You're comparing countries that didn't suffer much or at all in WW2.........with the majority of countries that did you imbecile. Countries that had access to money from untouched or relatively untouched by WW2 American, British, French, Scandinavian money/loans and investments - with ones that mostly received from a massively damaged from WW2 USSR and didn't have the China as it is now to help, and didn't have the advantage from the 1970's of the very good benefits that a communist China and USSR relationship would have had for Eastern Bloc if the problem between the 2 countries didn't happen. Even with all that it was a miracle how much the Soviets were able to rebuild and enhance in these countries

    Then you look at the global trade issue - British, French, American, Belgian scum etc were able to immediately take private ownership of the natural resources of these countries in Africa and Asia that declared themselves "independent". Those new Independent countries that wanted control of their own resources and nationalised companies for them, were either Marxist or Soviet sympathetic........and western scum ensured they f**ked up these countries with extensive sabotage efforts EVERY time for several decades. They could have advantage of globalised economy from former empire while destroying every place on the planet outside of Europe that could have helped Soviets and Eastern Bloc.

    It's obvious that with those disadvantages, the communist system did a brilliant and very successful job - defeated those facist and euro-capitalist countries in many aspects. For 25 years ( at least) a clear winner.

    If you knew or had every spoke to anyone who grew up in communist Czechoslovakia or Hungary ( which you haven't and won't as human garbage as yourself has never visited this part of the world) .......then you would hear the vast majority say that to be a kid then would have incredibly fun, adventurous and enriched lives you deranged idiot.

    As for the idiotic comparison with Spain and Portugal - both countries untouched by WW2, access to western capital.....and tourism is at least 10% of each of those countries GDP you imbecile, making any difference non-existent if you exclude tourism.

    Austria now became not only the richest of the three former Hapsburg countries, but doubled the ones that got stuck under Communism. This is the most relevant comparison because these three countries are geographically close, and culturally and historically similar.
     
    LOL - you are doing this stupid misdirection because its self-evidently retarded to be making comparisons of why Bulgaria or Romania wasn't as rich as Austria. Austria was much richer than what is stated in that fake link. Whatever the BS is your fake link, Vienna was one of the richest cities in Europe for centuries, and was part of the richest part of that empire

    But you see, Portugal and Spain passed up Czechoslovakia and Hungary and were a lot richer per capita than those two Commie countries. Quasi-fascism beat Socialism.
     
    LMFAO -as if you can make serious estimates of GDP immediately after WW2 you ridiculous cretin. How the f**k can you have relevant statistics for countries still rebuilding in 1947, dumbass? Austria did not suffer under the Nazi's like the Czechs, didn't degermanify, had no sudden switch from one system to the other. Didn't suffer as much population loss as Hungary. As I said, for over half a millenium Austrian land has been wealthier than what is now Czech and Hungarian land.

    Obviously in Poland, if you eliminate the Germans and import more Poles you are going to get a dumber and poorer population you moron. Obviously in Poland if you eliminate the Galician khokhols and import more Poles than you are going to get a less dumb and more productive population you moron.

    Hungary and particularly Czechs had large removal of german population after WW2. To anybody with a brain, the german factor is critical - not socialist, fascist or capitalist system you dumb prick. Anybody can make any argument they want - degermanification, non-Protestant, Catholic,Orthodox, atheist - affected by population loss and physical damage from WW2 etc.

    That’s as stupid as giving Bolsheviks credit for antibiotics and electricity, as if it would not have occurred if not for them.
     
    20th century socialism, CLEARLY is reponsible for Israeli tech sector you dipshit. 1990s economic growth and IT development in western economies is partially explained by ideas, human capital and other resources from Eastern Bloc after communist collapse. It doesn't explain all but certainly some of it

    Anyway, 100 years before - industrialisation ( alot of it fueled by colonialism and the raw material from it) resulted in masses of people flooding into towns and cities to work in the factories. People having the same amount of children as they had in rural areas, but now in urban, living filthy lives and breathing unclean air, not able to grown their own produce and feed themselves like when they were poor but had their own land to grow produce in the countryside. Rich got even more wealthier and owned more land and properties.....while by comparison the rest were working longer , but limited social mobility...while having the intellectual ability and urge to group together and form political groups. Whatever rises in medical science and education ( at best nothing more than not being illiterate) did not compensate for the problems in this new social situation.Without communism this unfair position would not have been corrected. WW1 had nothing to do with it. Either countries became communist or several of these western states implemented very communist social and even economic and engineering/ architectural policies to appease large section of their populations

    Anyway - what does it say that socialist Cuba is FAR richer than Banderastan???!!! LOL

    Comparisons between European countries are very misleading........better comparison would be with the disaster that is American control of South and central America . Capitalist in Latin American with close relation with Pindostan - extremely chaotic and not rich. Communist/Socialist - f**ked up by the Americans every time. Dictatorship - see capitalist.

    America gives the world the produce of the cocaine barons from Colombia and creates most of the heroin trade from Afghanistan. With Soviets this sick filth would never have happened.

    Germany today still has significant difference ( though both still wealthy by most of Europe standards) in wealth of east german land compared to west germany, despite trillions invested and 35 years since end of communism

    19th century actually was a Golden Age for Europe, it ended in 1914. You doubt it? Compare cultural products, global power, etc.
     
    For the retard who was exposed as completely inept and not knowing at all the foreign blood in every single European monarchy.......its just sick fantasist nonsense that you would then come up with this new statement. Very bizarre.

    Americans hate feudal societies. They sometimes like the British royal family but that’s ust celebrity worship. They only like the rich who talk like them and act like them. You are clueless as usual.
     
    Nonsense, Beckow is correct. Kennedy family , Bush family, ( if he wasn't such another american sleazebag) then Clinton family. Cuomo's in New York. Even the way the mafia control appears to have been viewed. That the so-called anti-elite politician, Trump, is probably one of the most "elite" of them all and doesn't appear to have any entrepreneur ability or the ability to actually make money and generate jobs, like a Henry Ford, create anything and involved in New York real estate market......supports Beckow's position.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    Austria did not suffer under the Nazi’s like the Czechs, didn’t degermanify, had no sudden switch from one system to the other. Didn’t suffer as much population loss as Hungary.

    Austria lost a huge number of its young and middle-aged men during WWII since Austrian men were also drafted into the German Army en masse (or volunteered for this) since Austria was a part of the German Reich during WWII.

  867. @John Johnson
    @songbird

    Who has a higher sociosexual number, Kamala or Haley?

    Definitely Kamala. Sounds like sexually unsatisfied mom vs an actual prostitute.

    Kamala started her political career by giving blowjobs to Willie Brown.

    This is prostitution:
    https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2020/08/13/18/31918142-0-image-a-77_1597340734012.jpg

    Even Willy the 100k lawyer would not have gotten a blowjob from her.

    She wanted a career in SF politics and went straight for the desk. Well under it anyways. She probably would have gone down on a woman if needed.

    Replies: @songbird

    Probably Kamala.

    Haley reportedly met her husband when she was 17, and then proceeded to change his name to “Michael.”

    Sikhs have a similar custom to Mormons:
    https://www.sikhheros.com/blog/the-power-of-kachera-unraveling-the-symbolism-and-purpose-of-the-sikh-undergarment/

    Too bad Google image search doesn’t have a neural net that can do paternity tests on family photos.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @songbird

    Too bad Google image search doesn’t have a neural net that can do paternity tests on family photos.

    Son has the dad's mouth and teeth:
    https://media.ghgossip.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/20202657/Screenshot-2023-01-20-at-8.25.44-PM.png

    The brother and sister look similar in older photos. Probably his.

    I really don't see the problem though. The cuckold wing of the Republican party should be thrilled to have an honorary member in the White house.

    Replies: @songbird

  868. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Greasy William

    Samaritans are most likely not real Jews. They are really into cousin marriages, like Canaanites and Phoenicians, but not biblical Jews. They are probably remnant of pre-Jew population of Canaan. Interestingly, like British Israelites, they claim to come from half-Egyptian tribes: Ephraim and Manasseh. Therefore they are probably as fake as Jews as British Israelites are.

    Real Jews were most likely Karaites, some Askhenazi too.

    I am trying to say that people who are called Jews nowadays are mostly false Jews, not Biblical Jews and what is now Judaism is the result of hostile takeover of Judaism in the post-Temple period by Phoenicians and Canaanites. Interestingly, some Jews were said to have been as famously "red" as Phoenicians were. These people are not really betrothed to Jahwe, anyway they try not to pronounce his name as much as they can, and they are much more devoted to Talmud than Torah. And yet the antisemitism today is mostly directed against biblical Judaism, Jahwe despite them never condoning what modern Judaism had become. In other words, modern antisemitism is one big misdirection. It hates what once was for that what it allegedly has become.
    For some reason it is Askhenazi Jews who became its main target as fake Jews, whereas for some the same strange reason, Sephardi Jews are absolved from antisemitism, depicted as true Jews, whereas it is the Sephardi who are mostly fake, being former Phoenicians. Nevertheless, throughout history it was Sephardim who were mostly interested in supporting this or that Moschiach craze, which is in fact a strange doctrine, alien to the general spirit of teaching of Old Testament. Yet in antiquity the messianic expectation was based on the famous "son of star" verse from Numbers 24:17, but after failure of Bar Kochba, the new messianic verses were found: in itself the proof that messianic expectations, like matrilineality, came from outside Scripture and post hoc determined reading of Scripture.
    Just the knowledge that messianic expectations in antiquity were based on the Numbers verse, put a question mark behind Christianity.
    Anyway, the strange directions of anti-Semitic discourse suggests that it is generated in cooperation with false Jews.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    Being another expert on the topic, would you also confer whether or not self-identifying American Jewry that supports Ukraine today are not “real Jews” as kremlinstoogeA123 contends, and that those that support the kremlin are actually the real ones? This seems to be the litmus test that he uses, and I just wanted to see if anybody else out there buys into it?
    I wonder whether kremlintoogeA123 still considers these folks to be Jews, or whether they’ve gone over the edge and have somehow biologically transformed themselves into some new sort of beings? Maybe they’ve become “born again” as he’s professed his adherence to many times at this blogsite?

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. Hack

    No, it is not so easy.
    However, in CE Europe you must distinguish between the local Jewish communities and the Jewish organizations who are often run by transplants (chief rabbi of Poland is still American, after 30 years!) or by some rather narrow class of "political Jews" who are often unknown to normal Jews. In other words, there are Jewish organizations and there are Jews. I would bet that the former are ultimately run under the direction of false Jews. In Russia, Chabad build Jewish structures parallel to official ones, which certainly weren't anti-Putin. And Chabad is crypto-Sephardism (they follow Maimonides as Sephardim do and are obsessed with Moshiach) in Askhenazi world, thus I consider it false Judaism par excellence.

    But the most known American Jew living here in Poland, Anne Applebaum, who I see as 1-person Jewish organization, is staunchly pro-Ukrainian.

    It is conceivable that false Jews would support both sides of conflict in order to destroy ancient Jewish lands and force emigration to Israel. Well, USA, run partly by Jewish bankers, supported once build-up of both the Nazis and Bolsheviks (Sutton thesis etc.) in order to bring about the war of Gog (Germans) and Magog (Russsians)

    Hard to say for me how situation looks in USA. Israeli policy tried to be neutral, AFAIK.

    Historically speaking, neither Russia nor Ukraine were Jewish-friendly.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @LT1488, @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. Hack

    , @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. Hack

    If you like, there was recently a book written by a Jew which in jest hinted at truth: that behind Judaism, and not just it, other ancient religion hides.
    It is "Mother for Dinner: A Novel" by Shalom Auslander. Well, how far is from cannibalism to human sacrifice...?

  869. Come on Orest…you are kievstooge loser. What is your point?

    • Replies: @Derer
    @Derer

    It was a reply to #874, Orest Hackchuk.

  870. Musk credits his grandfather surviving WW2, by an IQ test that he took.

    Therefore, he believes he is alive because the fact that his grandfather took an IQ test.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    Sounds kind of "brainy" to me. :-)

    Replies: @songbird

  871. @German_reader
    @Greasy William


    who know people who are serving there and they tell me that the reporting they are getting back from the front is that the IDF is getting posititively waxed.
     
    I don't believe that. Urban combat is certainly difficult, but there's no possibility of Hamas actually winning in military terms. The real problem for Israel is political, since its actions in Gaza are extreme enough to potentially cause it a lot of trouble in its foreign relations, but as it stands now there's no prospect either of ending the issue once and for all by expelling or exterminating the Palestinians in Gaza.
    But I also think that's why a part of the Israeli right might actually welcome a big Mideast war involving Hezbollah and Iran, maybe even seek to bring it about. Presumably they think the US would enter such a war on Israel's side, and it might finally provide the conditions for effecting the expulsion of a large part of the Palestinians. imo that would be a crazy gamble and quite irresponsible. But on the other hand, it might also be entertaining to watch, and might speed on the end of this rotten system one has to live under in the West, so in that sense I'm beyond caring.

    Replies: @Greasy William, @Mr. XYZ

    If Israel was smart, they would say something along the lines of “We support an independent Palestinian state, but as an Israeli vassal state”. That would be unfair to the Palestinians, of course, but it would also ensure Israel’s security. What I mean by this is some kind of military alliance between Israel and this independent Palestinian state with a lot of military cooperation between the two of them, similar to what’s going on with NATO, while the Palestinians are allowed to run their own domestic affairs however they see fit just so long as they don’t engage in any Jew hatred. In other words, an arrangement with Israel similar to what Cuba had with the US with the Platt Amendment, before Fidel Castro came to power there.

    This is a good map for any peace settlement:

    https://www.shaularieli.com/en/maps/negotiations/

    Though I would prefer it if E-1 will also remain in Israeli hands. However, I won’t insist on it for the sake of peace.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. XYZ

    The left would be put in a tough position in such a scenario since it argues that the West should respect Russia's security concerns in Ukraine and elsewhere, but then by the same logic, shouldn't the Palestinians respect Israel's security concerns? It might be unfair to exclude Ukraine from NATO just like it might be unfair to fore a Platt Amendment-style deal upon an independent Palestinian state, but more powerful countries such as Russia and Israel need to be appeased, right?

    , @A123
    @Mr. XYZ


    If Israel was smart, they would say something along the lines of “We support an independent Palestinian state, but as an Israeli vassal state”.
    ...
    In other words, an arrangement with Israel similar to what Cuba had with the US with the Platt Amendment, before Fidel Castro came to power there.
     
    I think you just pointed out why the proposal is a non-starter. There is ample evidence that a "Platt Amendment State" failed. There is no reason to model an effort in Jewish Palestine that could create another figure like Castro.

    Palestinians are allowed to run their own domestic affairs however they see fit just so long as they don’t engage in any Jew hatred.
     
    This is one of those things that sounds good, but is devoid of adequate detail. I am dubious that the idea is practical. There are huge question that must be addressed up front.

    Hamas exercised control over domestic affairs in Gaza. They unilaterally destroyed the fresh water supply by stealing pipe & concrete for military use. How will a new domestic authority in Gaza fix this problem that they created for themselves?

    The Muslim colonies in Judea, Samaria, and Gaza have been systematically training Jew hatred for 50+ years. This includes every organization -- PLO, UNRWA, Fatah, Hamas, etc. How do you plan to change the hearts and minds of the Jihadists to be anything other than a threat?


    This is a good map for any peace settlement:
     
    Weakness emboldens the enemy. That map would guarantee future war. Here is a better map for understanding the situation.

     
    https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-i0S74GkjPuw/U8d5mEcbiiI/AAAAAAAAAec/0PeFvChmLb8/s1600/1922-mandate_for_palestine.jpg
     

    The Palestinian Mandate for a Jewish National Homeland was carved up incorrectly long ago. Jews received only 23% of the land. Then that sliver was further subdivided for Muslim colonies in Judea, Samaria, and Gaza. It is quite obvious that the current lines are inherently unfair to indigenous Palestinian Jews.

    Due to the "demographics are destiny" push by both sides, the population far exceeds what makes sense in the tiny area west of the Jordan River. This is particularly visible in Gaza. The vast numbers of people are dramatically mismatched to natural resources.
    ___

    Instead of repeating the failures of the past 50+ years, it is time for new thinking. The international community, in addition to the direct parties, have to consider solutions that reach outside the incredibly artificial 23% line.

    Realistically, the only hope for a long term fix to multiple injustices rests on bringing new land into the negotiations. To me, the most promising option is a New Muslim Palestine that does not have a physical border with Israel. However, feel free to offer other potential paths out of the 23% trap.

    PEACE 😇

  872. @Mr. XYZ
    @German_reader

    If Israel was smart, they would say something along the lines of "We support an independent Palestinian state, but as an Israeli vassal state". That would be unfair to the Palestinians, of course, but it would also ensure Israel's security. What I mean by this is some kind of military alliance between Israel and this independent Palestinian state with a lot of military cooperation between the two of them, similar to what's going on with NATO, while the Palestinians are allowed to run their own domestic affairs however they see fit just so long as they don't engage in any Jew hatred. In other words, an arrangement with Israel similar to what Cuba had with the US with the Platt Amendment, before Fidel Castro came to power there.

    This is a good map for any peace settlement:

    https://www.shaularieli.com/en/maps/negotiations/

    https://www.shaularieli.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/A-Stable-Border-Proposal-for-land-swaps-2020-scaled.jpg

    Though I would prefer it if E-1 will also remain in Israeli hands. However, I won't insist on it for the sake of peace.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @A123

    The left would be put in a tough position in such a scenario since it argues that the West should respect Russia’s security concerns in Ukraine and elsewhere, but then by the same logic, shouldn’t the Palestinians respect Israel’s security concerns? It might be unfair to exclude Ukraine from NATO just like it might be unfair to fore a Platt Amendment-style deal upon an independent Palestinian state, but more powerful countries such as Russia and Israel need to be appeased, right?

  873. @songbird
    Musk credits his grandfather surviving WW2, by an IQ test that he took.

    Therefore, he believes he is alive because the fact that his grandfather took an IQ test.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    Sounds kind of “brainy” to me. 🙂

    • Replies: @songbird
    @Mr. Hack

    What makes the anecdote particularly compelling, IMO, is the fact that his grandfather became a dropout to support his siblings, so he didn't have any sort of credentials.

    Have long been interested in what some of these tech billionaires say about IQ.

    Pretty sure that Bill Gates said something like, he wished he could give his prospective employees an IQ test, sometime in the '90s. Maybe, the lawyers got to him or something, but I never heard him talk about it later, even though Microsoft has or used to have these infamous tests for prospective employees, which involved very difficult puzzles. But politically, I think Gates comes from a left-wing family, so I imagine he can believe it, while saying nothing more about it, and even expressing strong contradictions.

    I've also been very interested in Musk's rhetoric over the years. I feel like he drops a lot of hints that he believes in politically incorrect ideas. But it is mostly very cagey and in a way that you have to ignore some things he says and read in-between the lines with others.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. Hack

  874. @Gerard1234
    @AP


    Of the three post-war economic systems in Europe (Euro-capitalist, Socialist, and semi-fascist), Socialist was the least successful.
     
    Of course this is a nonsense statement. The salary numbers are stupid and You're comparing countries that didn't suffer much or at all in WW2.........with the majority of countries that did you imbecile. Countries that had access to money from untouched or relatively untouched by WW2 American, British, French, Scandinavian money/loans and investments - with ones that mostly received from a massively damaged from WW2 USSR and didn't have the China as it is now to help, and didn't have the advantage from the 1970's of the very good benefits that a communist China and USSR relationship would have had for Eastern Bloc if the problem between the 2 countries didn't happen. Even with all that it was a miracle how much the Soviets were able to rebuild and enhance in these countries

    Then you look at the global trade issue - British, French, American, Belgian scum etc were able to immediately take private ownership of the natural resources of these countries in Africa and Asia that declared themselves "independent". Those new Independent countries that wanted control of their own resources and nationalised companies for them, were either Marxist or Soviet sympathetic........and western scum ensured they f**ked up these countries with extensive sabotage efforts EVERY time for several decades. They could have advantage of globalised economy from former empire while destroying every place on the planet outside of Europe that could have helped Soviets and Eastern Bloc.

    It's obvious that with those disadvantages, the communist system did a brilliant and very successful job - defeated those facist and euro-capitalist countries in many aspects. For 25 years ( at least) a clear winner.

    If you knew or had every spoke to anyone who grew up in communist Czechoslovakia or Hungary ( which you haven't and won't as human garbage as yourself has never visited this part of the world) .......then you would hear the vast majority say that to be a kid then would have incredibly fun, adventurous and enriched lives you deranged idiot.

    As for the idiotic comparison with Spain and Portugal - both countries untouched by WW2, access to western capital.....and tourism is at least 10% of each of those countries GDP you imbecile, making any difference non-existent if you exclude tourism.

    Austria now became not only the richest of the three former Hapsburg countries, but doubled the ones that got stuck under Communism. This is the most relevant comparison because these three countries are geographically close, and culturally and historically similar.
     
    LOL - you are doing this stupid misdirection because its self-evidently retarded to be making comparisons of why Bulgaria or Romania wasn't as rich as Austria. Austria was much richer than what is stated in that fake link. Whatever the BS is your fake link, Vienna was one of the richest cities in Europe for centuries, and was part of the richest part of that empire

    But you see, Portugal and Spain passed up Czechoslovakia and Hungary and were a lot richer per capita than those two Commie countries. Quasi-fascism beat Socialism.
     
    LMFAO -as if you can make serious estimates of GDP immediately after WW2 you ridiculous cretin. How the f**k can you have relevant statistics for countries still rebuilding in 1947, dumbass? Austria did not suffer under the Nazi's like the Czechs, didn't degermanify, had no sudden switch from one system to the other. Didn't suffer as much population loss as Hungary. As I said, for over half a millenium Austrian land has been wealthier than what is now Czech and Hungarian land.

    Obviously in Poland, if you eliminate the Germans and import more Poles you are going to get a dumber and poorer population you moron. Obviously in Poland if you eliminate the Galician khokhols and import more Poles than you are going to get a less dumb and more productive population you moron.

    Hungary and particularly Czechs had large removal of german population after WW2. To anybody with a brain, the german factor is critical - not socialist, fascist or capitalist system you dumb prick. Anybody can make any argument they want - degermanification, non-Protestant, Catholic,Orthodox, atheist - affected by population loss and physical damage from WW2 etc.

    That’s as stupid as giving Bolsheviks credit for antibiotics and electricity, as if it would not have occurred if not for them.
     
    20th century socialism, CLEARLY is reponsible for Israeli tech sector you dipshit. 1990s economic growth and IT development in western economies is partially explained by ideas, human capital and other resources from Eastern Bloc after communist collapse. It doesn't explain all but certainly some of it

    Anyway, 100 years before - industrialisation ( alot of it fueled by colonialism and the raw material from it) resulted in masses of people flooding into towns and cities to work in the factories. People having the same amount of children as they had in rural areas, but now in urban, living filthy lives and breathing unclean air, not able to grown their own produce and feed themselves like when they were poor but had their own land to grow produce in the countryside. Rich got even more wealthier and owned more land and properties.....while by comparison the rest were working longer , but limited social mobility...while having the intellectual ability and urge to group together and form political groups. Whatever rises in medical science and education ( at best nothing more than not being illiterate) did not compensate for the problems in this new social situation.Without communism this unfair position would not have been corrected. WW1 had nothing to do with it. Either countries became communist or several of these western states implemented very communist social and even economic and engineering/ architectural policies to appease large section of their populations

    Anyway - what does it say that socialist Cuba is FAR richer than Banderastan???!!! LOL

    Comparisons between European countries are very misleading........better comparison would be with the disaster that is American control of South and central America . Capitalist in Latin American with close relation with Pindostan - extremely chaotic and not rich. Communist/Socialist - f**ked up by the Americans every time. Dictatorship - see capitalist.

    America gives the world the produce of the cocaine barons from Colombia and creates most of the heroin trade from Afghanistan. With Soviets this sick filth would never have happened.

    Germany today still has significant difference ( though both still wealthy by most of Europe standards) in wealth of east german land compared to west germany, despite trillions invested and 35 years since end of communism

    19th century actually was a Golden Age for Europe, it ended in 1914. You doubt it? Compare cultural products, global power, etc.
     
    For the retard who was exposed as completely inept and not knowing at all the foreign blood in every single European monarchy.......its just sick fantasist nonsense that you would then come up with this new statement. Very bizarre.

    Americans hate feudal societies. They sometimes like the British royal family but that’s ust celebrity worship. They only like the rich who talk like them and act like them. You are clueless as usual.
     
    Nonsense, Beckow is correct. Kennedy family , Bush family, ( if he wasn't such another american sleazebag) then Clinton family. Cuomo's in New York. Even the way the mafia control appears to have been viewed. That the so-called anti-elite politician, Trump, is probably one of the most "elite" of them all and doesn't appear to have any entrepreneur ability or the ability to actually make money and generate jobs, like a Henry Ford, create anything and involved in New York real estate market......supports Beckow's position.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    Of the three post-war economic systems in Europe (Euro-capitalist, Socialist, and semi-fascist), Socialist was the least successful.

    Of course this is a nonsense statement. The salary numbers are stupid and You’re comparing countries that didn’t suffer much or at all in WW2………with the majority of countries that did you imbecile.

    Austria had more deaths than Czechoslovakia during World War II:

    https://www.nationalww2museum.org/students-teachers/student-resources/research-starters/research-starters-worldwide-deaths-world-war

    384,000 (Austria) vs. 345,000 (Czechoslovakia)

    Countries that had access to money from untouched or relatively untouched by WW2 American, British, French, Scandinavian money/loans and investments

    This wouldn’t explain the fact that the Socialist counties kept falling further and further behind, even decades after the war ended.

    Then you look at the global trade issue – British, French, American, Belgian scum etc were able to immediately take private ownership of the natural resources of these countries in Africa and Asia that declared themselves “independent”. Those new Independent countries that wanted control of their own resources and nationalised companies for them, were either Marxist or Soviet sympathetic……..and western scum ensured they f**ked up these countries

    All those countries got richer when they dropped Socialism.

    It’s obvious that with those disadvantages, the communist system did a brilliant and very successful job – defeated those facist and euro-capitalist countries in many aspects

    They won the competition for ugly and small housing.

    As for the idiotic comparison with Spain and Portugal – both countries untouched by WW2

    You are unaware of the fact that Spain had a bloody civil war.

    About 500,000 died in Spain during the Civil War.

    And it surpassed Commie central Europe long after Word War II anyways.

    .and tourism is at least 10% of each of those countries GDP

    Tourism doesn’t count as “capitalism” now?

    If you are going to play this game, exclude oil and coal from your calculations.

    Austria now became not only the richest of the three former Hapsburg countries, but doubled the ones that got stuck under Communism. This is the most relevant comparison because these three countries are geographically close, and culturally and historically similar.

    Austria was much richer than what is stated in that fake link

    Link for economic data was to Maddison project, hosted by University of Groningen:

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.
    Hungary: $2,200.
    Spain: $2,186
    Portugal: $2,046

    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Spain: $11,582.
    Portugal: $10,372

    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768
    Hungary: $6,903.

    Austria did not suffer under the Nazi’s like the Czechs, didn’t degermanify, had no sudden switch from one system to the other.

    Austria lost more people during World War II – lots of productive young men who were killed during the war.

    So in 1948 Austria was poorer than Czechoslovakia.

    In 1989 after Czechoslovakia languished under Socialism and Austria enjoyed capitalism for 40 years, Austria was about 2x richer.

    As I said, for over half a millenium Austrian land has been wealthier than what is now Czech and Hungarian land.

    Not by much.

    In 1890, the per capita product, in 2010 dollars, in Austria was $3,005 and in Bohemia was $2,513.

    It wasn’t twice richer. Only after Socialism did Austria become twice richer than Bohemia.

    Hungary and particularly Czechs had large removal of german population after WW2. To anybody with a brain, the german factor is critical

    It’s funny that a Sovok untermench such as you considers Germans to be ubermenschen.

    Czechoslovakia lost Germans but also lost Carpathian Ruthenians, who were very poor (until recently their province was the poorest one in Ukraine).

    And anyways that loss of Germans would not explain how Czechoslovakia went from being richer than Austria in 1948 (the Germans were gone by then) to having only half the GDP of Austria in 1989.

    20th century socialism, CLEARLY is reponsible for Israeli tech sector you dipshit. 1990s economic growth and IT development in western economies is partially explained by ideas, human capital and other resources from Eastern Bloc after communist collapse

    Not in your case, of course.

    The socialist system could indeed train some smart people. It also kept them poor and short-lived. But they could use their skills to good effect in a non-socialist environment.

    Americans hate feudal societies. They sometimes like the British royal family but that’s ust celebrity worship. They only like the rich who talk like them and act like them. You are clueless as usual.

    Nonsense, Beckow is correct. Kennedy family , Bush family, ( if he wasn’t such another american sleazebag) then Clinton family.

    JFK was 60 years ago. Dubya Bush pretended to be a Texas redneck. “Bubba” Clinton acted like an Arkansas “good ole boy.” Obama who went to elite schools and was raised by rich white family members puts on a fake African-American accent.

    Americans dislike elites so much, that the elites have to pretend not to be elites.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    Austria had more deaths than Czechoslovakia during World War II:

    https://www.nationalww2museum.org/students-teachers/student-resources/research-starters/research-starters-worldwide-deaths-world-war

    384,000 (Austria) vs. 345,000 (Czechoslovakia)
     
    Which makes it even more impressive since Austria had about two times less people than Czechoslovakia had and yet still had a higher death toll, again due to the mass Wehrmacht conscription of Austrians plus Austrian military volunteering that I mentioned in my previous post here.

    JFK was 60 years ago. Dubya Bush pretended to be a Texas redneck. “Bubba” Clinton acted like an Arkansas “good ole boy.” Obama who went to elite schools and was raised by rich white family members puts on a fake African-American accent.

    Americans dislike elites so much, that the elites have to pretend not to be elites.
     
    What about Al Gore? He didn't really hide his elite status and yet he almost won in 2000. And Hillary Clinton? She came close to winning in 2016 (and came very close to winning the 2008 Democratic presidential nomination before that) in spite of her being perceived as being very elite.

    All those countries got richer when they dropped Socialism.

     

    And began living longer too:

    https://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/2023/05/actual-communism-is-bad-for-your-health/

    https://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/wp-content/uploads/communism-life-expect.jpeg

    https://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/wp-content/uploads/life-expectancy-USSR-block-2048x1446.png

    https://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/wp-content/uploads/spline_fit_all.png

    Replies: @AP, @Beckow

    , @Gerard1234
    @AP


    Austria had more deaths than Czechoslovakia during World War II:
     
    I wrote "suffered under the Nazis", dickhead. The death issue is relevant, but the suffering refers to being taken over against their wishes.....(totally different to Austria),and all the reprisals, massacres, tortures, arrests, zero control that go with this. In addition I could add the seizure and total change and reorientation of the Czechs massive industrial capacity, essential to most of the Nazis military-industrial output......that Austrian economy would not have had to be faced with to the same level. But the main thing when I write about suffer is "taken over against their wishes". I have been to the museum in Prague about this - the Nazi section is about a million times worse than whatever they are claiming about the Soviets - I was surprised how mild it was towards the USSR, in view of all their post 1991 lies and BS.

    So in 1948 Austria was poorer than Czechoslovakia.
    In 1890, the per capita product, in 2010 dollars, in Austria was $3,005 and in Bohemia was $2,513.
     
    Nonsense and more nonsense. Austria always regarded by me and commonly perceived in USSR to be one of , if not the richest place in Europe. Historically and then.

    Not in your case, of course.
     
    A bizarre, idiotic and nonsensical statement from yourself, as usual.


    JFK was 60 years ago.
     
    And he followed his very rich and powerful father who was high profile Ambassador and politician - who helped bribe or cheat one of the states into helping his son win either the state Governor or Presidential election. His 2 other brothers very high profile politicians ( one of the idiot Bidens son's even Attorney-General for one of the states, LOL). JFK's son highly possible would have continued this trend ( and had masses of lazy, fat americans voting for him) if he did not die in plane crash.


    Bubba” Clinton acted like an Arkansas “good ole boy.
     
    He's the starting point, so doesn't classify. What does is his wife, and the suspicion that probably his daughter if he wasn't such a sleazebag so as to discredit her

    Dubya Bush pretended to be a Texas redneck.
     
    Americans too dumb to realise he wasn't the son of a President and head of CIA????!!!! Or that his brother was Florida governor and was strongly favourite to be his party's president nomination before Trump is a very amusing way humiliated him with jokes?

    Obama who went to elite schools and was raised by rich white family members puts on a fake African-American accent.

    Americans dislike elites so much, that the elites have to pretend not to be elites.
     
    Nonsense. All western politicians fake to some level. There are millions of middle-class Black-Americans, or many lower-class blacks who have become rich and or educated, or are even involved in American politics now who could have been promoted as candidate. That it was Obama is highly indicative of the feudal-type worship Beckow was talking of.

    Obama also had large amount of his childhood living in Indonesia and his father is Kenya, not African-American. African-Americans too dumb to realise he is not one of them?
    They did the same with Rodney King and this Floyd guy.......it doesn't necessarily indicate that they love the criminal scumbag violent rapists and drug-dealing drug-driving losers.... but corrupt circumstances and mass manipulations result in these creeps being the conduit for whatever thing they are advocating.

    The socialist system could indeed train some smart people. It also kept them poor and short-lived.
     
    LMAO - Cuba,life expectancy better than Americans. As for "short-lived" - not so much for women, not for the first 25-30 years of socialism. "Poor" is also nonsense. Drinking more spirits instead of wine or beer one thing to consider.


    It’s funny that a Sovok untermench such as you considers Germans to be ubermenschen.
     
    Thats just you projecting what ACTUAL galician inbred/iodine-deficient lowlife "nationalists" are projecting between themselves. Germans have to be respected for what they have done over the centuries, that wasn't evil, sadistic and mass murder. Czechoslovakia expelled 3 million of them.

    Tourism doesn’t count as “capitalism” now?
    If you are going to play this game, exclude oil and coal from your calculations.
     
    Russia sold plenty of this oil and coal and gas etc to the west, so now I won't exclude from these calculations. Forgetting about the Canary Islands and other places......is there a sane person who would choose holiday in Warsaw over Barcelona, LOL.

    Replies: @AP

  875. @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    Sounds kind of "brainy" to me. :-)

    Replies: @songbird

    What makes the anecdote particularly compelling, IMO, is the fact that his grandfather became a dropout to support his siblings, so he didn’t have any sort of credentials.

    Have long been interested in what some of these tech billionaires say about IQ.

    Pretty sure that Bill Gates said something like, he wished he could give his prospective employees an IQ test, sometime in the ’90s. Maybe, the lawyers got to him or something, but I never heard him talk about it later, even though Microsoft has or used to have these infamous tests for prospective employees, which involved very difficult puzzles. But politically, I think Gates comes from a left-wing family, so I imagine he can believe it, while saying nothing more about it, and even expressing strong contradictions.

    I’ve also been very interested in Musk’s rhetoric over the years. I feel like he drops a lot of hints that he believes in politically incorrect ideas. But it is mostly very cagey and in a way that you have to ignore some things he says and read in-between the lines with others.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @songbird

    But politically, I think Gates comes from a left-wing family, so I imagine he can believe it, while saying nothing more about it, and even expressing strong contradictions.

    He isn't from a left-wing family. His dad is a wealthy Democrat but not left-wing.

    Gates can never make up his mind on politics. He has funded both liberal and conservative causes. Both him and Ballmer have funded anti-gun groups.

    It was Gates that bought into a bunch of libertarian bullshit on charter schools. He went on some rant about "bad teachers" and how his organization was going to get rid of them with the implication that he would fix inner city schools. The after spending millions on charter schools he quietly went back to working on a cure for Malaria. Him and Betsy Devos combined spent like 200 million on charter schools and neither talk about the results.

    I'm in tuned to charter schools for undisclosed reasons so I know about his influence.

    Two other conservative billionaires did the same thing. Show up and throw money at charter schools, blame bad teachers or unions, then walk away. Fox News of course never investigates any of it and just goes back to blaming public schools.

    This is how Con Inc works. It's just a never-ending scam. They don't actually want to investigate why public schools in rural Montana don't seem to have the same problems with "bad teachers" or unions.

    , @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    I would think that today, in an age when it's hard to get young people to show up to work regularly, prospective employers have given up on entrance exams including very difficult puzzles. They're probably more interested in solving the puzzle as to how to motivate the young loafers to showup to work by 9:00 am and coddle them to do so for 5 days a week. :-)

    Replies: @songbird

  876. @Derer
    Come on Orest...you are kievstooge loser. What is your point?

    Replies: @Derer

    It was a reply to #874, Orest Hackchuk.

  877. Trump at 2AM gives an all cap post on why he should have total immunity:

    “EVEN EVENTS THAT ‘CROSS THE LINE’ MUST FALL UNDER TOTAL IMMUNITY, OR IT WILL BE YEARS OF TRAUMA TRYING TO DETERMINE GOOD FROM BAD,” Trump wrote. “THERE MUST BE CERTAINTY. EXAMPLE: YOU CAN’T STOP POLICE FROM DOING THE JOB OF STRONG & EFFECTIVE CRIME PREVENTION BECAUSE YOU WANT TO GUARD AGAINST THE OCCASIONAL ‘ROGUE COP’ OR ‘BAD APPLE.’ SOMETIMES YOU JUST HAVE TO LIVE WITH ‘GREAT BUT SLIGHTLY IMPERFECT.’ ALL PRESIDENTS MUST HAVE COMPLETE & TOTAL PRESIDENTIAL IMMUNITY, OR THE AUTHORITY & DECISIVENESS OF A PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES WILL BE STRIPPED & GONE FOREVER. HOPEFULLY THIS WILL BE AN EASY DECISION. GOD BLESS THE SUPREME COURT!”
    https://news.yahoo.com/experts-alarmed-trump-demands-immunity-145859079.html

    Yea nothing to worry about Trump fans. Nothing at all.

    He just decided to go on some unhinged rant in the middle of the night about how he should be able to commit crimes while in office.

    Totally innocent.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    What he wrote is basically correct. Leaders are given more leeway than people realize, if only because the context for their actions may be classified or simply barred from discussion. In those cases, defending their actions can be damaging to the office. This is not a failing of Trump, it is inherent with centralized authority. The situation is fuzzy in the US where the President is typically a mixture of figurehead and leader.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  878. @songbird
    @John Johnson

    Probably Kamala.

    Haley reportedly met her husband when she was 17, and then proceeded to change his name to "Michael."

    Sikhs have a similar custom to Mormons:
    https://www.sikhheros.com/blog/the-power-of-kachera-unraveling-the-symbolism-and-purpose-of-the-sikh-undergarment/

    Too bad Google image search doesn't have a neural net that can do paternity tests on family photos.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Too bad Google image search doesn’t have a neural net that can do paternity tests on family photos.

    Son has the dad’s mouth and teeth:
    The brother and sister look similar in older photos. Probably his.

    I really don’t see the problem though. The cuckold wing of the Republican party should be thrilled to have an honorary member in the White house.

    • Replies: @songbird
    @John Johnson

    Probably - I was joking a bit, though they do honestly seem a bit dark to me for half-Punjabis, in some photos. (Though, I guess the daughter has blue eyes). Possibly her husband is Sicilian or part Latino, and that might explain it.

    Suppose Gates is always warning about population growth in Africa, which some might see as a dog-whistle. But haven't Macron and others done that? There is a stability factor, where people who are very antinational will still do that. They don't seem to object fundamentally to the results of mass migration, but might be worried about big waves upsetting things.

    Perhaps, they are like AK and believe there is some modest max cap on the costs of diversity. Only 10%. To me, that sounds an awful lot like a tithe, and I don't see how it can self-limiting like that.

    I have had jury duty before, and it was kind of frightening to see the demographics of the courthouse. Basically, all the criminals were brown (and their families were there) and all the jurors (i.e. the people who showed up) were Euros.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  879. @songbird
    @Mr. Hack

    What makes the anecdote particularly compelling, IMO, is the fact that his grandfather became a dropout to support his siblings, so he didn't have any sort of credentials.

    Have long been interested in what some of these tech billionaires say about IQ.

    Pretty sure that Bill Gates said something like, he wished he could give his prospective employees an IQ test, sometime in the '90s. Maybe, the lawyers got to him or something, but I never heard him talk about it later, even though Microsoft has or used to have these infamous tests for prospective employees, which involved very difficult puzzles. But politically, I think Gates comes from a left-wing family, so I imagine he can believe it, while saying nothing more about it, and even expressing strong contradictions.

    I've also been very interested in Musk's rhetoric over the years. I feel like he drops a lot of hints that he believes in politically incorrect ideas. But it is mostly very cagey and in a way that you have to ignore some things he says and read in-between the lines with others.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. Hack

    But politically, I think Gates comes from a left-wing family, so I imagine he can believe it, while saying nothing more about it, and even expressing strong contradictions.

    He isn’t from a left-wing family. His dad is a wealthy Democrat but not left-wing.

    Gates can never make up his mind on politics. He has funded both liberal and conservative causes. Both him and Ballmer have funded anti-gun groups.

    It was Gates that bought into a bunch of libertarian bullshit on charter schools. He went on some rant about “bad teachers” and how his organization was going to get rid of them with the implication that he would fix inner city schools. The after spending millions on charter schools he quietly went back to working on a cure for Malaria. Him and Betsy Devos combined spent like 200 million on charter schools and neither talk about the results.

    I’m in tuned to charter schools for undisclosed reasons so I know about his influence.

    Two other conservative billionaires did the same thing. Show up and throw money at charter schools, blame bad teachers or unions, then walk away. Fox News of course never investigates any of it and just goes back to blaming public schools.

    This is how Con Inc works. It’s just a never-ending scam. They don’t actually want to investigate why public schools in rural Montana don’t seem to have the same problems with “bad teachers” or unions.

  880. @Mr. Hack
    @Another Polish Perspective

    Being another expert on the topic, would you also confer whether or not self-identifying American Jewry that supports Ukraine today are not "real Jews" as kremlinstoogeA123 contends, and that those that support the kremlin are actually the real ones? This seems to be the litmus test that he uses, and I just wanted to see if anybody else out there buys into it?

    https://static01.nyt.com/images/2006/07/04/nyregion/04push.600.jpg
    I wonder whether kremlintoogeA123 still considers these folks to be Jews, or whether they've gone over the edge and have somehow biologically transformed themselves into some new sort of beings? Maybe they've become "born again" as he's professed his adherence to many times at this blogsite?

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Another Polish Perspective

    No, it is not so easy.
    However, in CE Europe you must distinguish between the local Jewish communities and the Jewish organizations who are often run by transplants (chief rabbi of Poland is still American, after 30 years!) or by some rather narrow class of “political Jews” who are often unknown to normal Jews. In other words, there are Jewish organizations and there are Jews. I would bet that the former are ultimately run under the direction of false Jews. In Russia, Chabad build Jewish structures parallel to official ones, which certainly weren’t anti-Putin. And Chabad is crypto-Sephardism (they follow Maimonides as Sephardim do and are obsessed with Moshiach) in Askhenazi world, thus I consider it false Judaism par excellence.

    But the most known American Jew living here in Poland, Anne Applebaum, who I see as 1-person Jewish organization, is staunchly pro-Ukrainian.

    It is conceivable that false Jews would support both sides of conflict in order to destroy ancient Jewish lands and force emigration to Israel. Well, USA, run partly by Jewish bankers, supported once build-up of both the Nazis and Bolsheviks (Sutton thesis etc.) in order to bring about the war of Gog (Germans) and Magog (Russsians)

    Hard to say for me how situation looks in USA. Israeli policy tried to be neutral, AFAIK.

    Historically speaking, neither Russia nor Ukraine were Jewish-friendly.

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @Another Polish Perspective

    Just few days ago, Anne Applebaum said in Poland "Russia is never as strong as it looks". If this isn't war propaganda, I don't know what this is.

    I hope it won't end with "if you support Ukraine, you must support greater war with Russia'.

    Anyway, war drums in the West are slowly moving from beating "support Ukraine" to "prepare for general war with Russia".

    Ukraine is a pawn too. SUch a general war can happen only if Ukraine starts losing.

    Replies: @AP

    , @LT1488
    @Another Polish Perspective

    ''Historically speaking, neither Russia nor Ukraine were Jewish-friendly.''

    Jews were/are foreign to these lands, why would anyone be friendly to hostile alien foreigners?

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @Another Polish Perspective


    It is conceivable that false Jews would support both sides of conflict in order to destroy ancient Jewish lands and force emigration to Israel. Well, USA, run partly by Jewish bankers, supported once build-up of both the Nazis and Bolsheviks (Sutton thesis etc.) in order to bring about the war of Gog (Germans) and Magog (Russsians)
     
    FWIW, some right-wing Israelis are not comfortable with aliyah (immigration) to Israel in those cases where the immigrant (oleh) only has a Jewish grandfather (or even only two Jewish grandfathers). That's why they pushed to repeal the Grandchild Clause of Israel's Law of Return until Hamas's October 7 terrorist attack shut them up in regards to this issue, hopefully for a very long time.
    , @Mr. Hack
    @Another Polish Perspective

    The Jewish people for a very long time have been an amalgamation of different tribes, political views, philosophic views, geographic orientations (Sephardic, Ashkenazi, Khazar, African) even religious orientations: orthodox, conservative and reform. In other words, a very representative type of world ethnos, really only differentiating themselves in that they also have their own unique religion (although many are apostates and have embraced secularism). You clearly reference the Phoenicians, Samaritans and Canaanites as being "false jews" even though all three of these sub-groups were semitic peoples in very close proximity to the original Biblical Jews and inhabiting the lands of modern-day Israel, and no longer exist as independent peoples today.

    Even the original Biblical Jews were comprised of 10 tribes often warring amongst themselves. There was the long-developed cleavage between Israel and Judah. How can anybody today claim to have the authority to be able to pronounce who is a "real Jew" and who is a "fake Jew"? Preposterous!

    BTW, you never directly answered my question whether Jews who become part of the "Jews for Jesus" movement lose their authenticity?

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Another Polish Perspective, @Gerard1234

  881. @AP
    @Gerard1234


    Of the three post-war economic systems in Europe (Euro-capitalist, Socialist, and semi-fascist), Socialist was the least successful.

    Of course this is a nonsense statement. The salary numbers are stupid and You’re comparing countries that didn’t suffer much or at all in WW2………with the majority of countries that did you imbecile.
     
    Austria had more deaths than Czechoslovakia during World War II:

    https://www.nationalww2museum.org/students-teachers/student-resources/research-starters/research-starters-worldwide-deaths-world-war

    384,000 (Austria) vs. 345,000 (Czechoslovakia)


    Countries that had access to money from untouched or relatively untouched by WW2 American, British, French, Scandinavian money/loans and investments
     
    This wouldn't explain the fact that the Socialist counties kept falling further and further behind, even decades after the war ended.

    Then you look at the global trade issue – British, French, American, Belgian scum etc were able to immediately take private ownership of the natural resources of these countries in Africa and Asia that declared themselves “independent”. Those new Independent countries that wanted control of their own resources and nationalised companies for them, were either Marxist or Soviet sympathetic……..and western scum ensured they f**ked up these countries
     
    All those countries got richer when they dropped Socialism.

    It’s obvious that with those disadvantages, the communist system did a brilliant and very successful job – defeated those facist and euro-capitalist countries in many aspects
     
    They won the competition for ugly and small housing.

    As for the idiotic comparison with Spain and Portugal – both countries untouched by WW2
     
    You are unaware of the fact that Spain had a bloody civil war.

    About 500,000 died in Spain during the Civil War.

    And it surpassed Commie central Europe long after Word War II anyways.


    .and tourism is at least 10% of each of those countries GDP
     
    Tourism doesn't count as "capitalism" now?

    If you are going to play this game, exclude oil and coal from your calculations.


    Austria now became not only the richest of the three former Hapsburg countries, but doubled the ones that got stuck under Communism. This is the most relevant comparison because these three countries are geographically close, and culturally and historically similar.

    Austria was much richer than what is stated in that fake link
     

    Link for economic data was to Maddison project, hosted by University of Groningen:

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.
    Hungary: $2,200.
    Spain: $2,186
    Portugal: $2,046

    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Spain: $11,582.
    Portugal: $10,372

    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768
    Hungary: $6,903.


    Austria did not suffer under the Nazi’s like the Czechs, didn’t degermanify, had no sudden switch from one system to the other.
     
    Austria lost more people during World War II - lots of productive young men who were killed during the war.

    So in 1948 Austria was poorer than Czechoslovakia.

    In 1989 after Czechoslovakia languished under Socialism and Austria enjoyed capitalism for 40 years, Austria was about 2x richer.


    As I said, for over half a millenium Austrian land has been wealthier than what is now Czech and Hungarian land.
     
    Not by much.

    In 1890, the per capita product, in 2010 dollars, in Austria was $3,005 and in Bohemia was $2,513.

    It wasn't twice richer. Only after Socialism did Austria become twice richer than Bohemia.


    Hungary and particularly Czechs had large removal of german population after WW2. To anybody with a brain, the german factor is critical
     
    It's funny that a Sovok untermench such as you considers Germans to be ubermenschen.

    Czechoslovakia lost Germans but also lost Carpathian Ruthenians, who were very poor (until recently their province was the poorest one in Ukraine).

    And anyways that loss of Germans would not explain how Czechoslovakia went from being richer than Austria in 1948 (the Germans were gone by then) to having only half the GDP of Austria in 1989.


    20th century socialism, CLEARLY is reponsible for Israeli tech sector you dipshit. 1990s economic growth and IT development in western economies is partially explained by ideas, human capital and other resources from Eastern Bloc after communist collapse
     
    Not in your case, of course.

    The socialist system could indeed train some smart people. It also kept them poor and short-lived. But they could use their skills to good effect in a non-socialist environment.


    Americans hate feudal societies. They sometimes like the British royal family but that’s ust celebrity worship. They only like the rich who talk like them and act like them. You are clueless as usual.

    Nonsense, Beckow is correct. Kennedy family , Bush family, ( if he wasn’t such another american sleazebag) then Clinton family.

     

    JFK was 60 years ago. Dubya Bush pretended to be a Texas redneck. "Bubba" Clinton acted like an Arkansas "good ole boy." Obama who went to elite schools and was raised by rich white family members puts on a fake African-American accent.

    Americans dislike elites so much, that the elites have to pretend not to be elites.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Gerard1234

    Austria had more deaths than Czechoslovakia during World War II:

    https://www.nationalww2museum.org/students-teachers/student-resources/research-starters/research-starters-worldwide-deaths-world-war

    384,000 (Austria) vs. 345,000 (Czechoslovakia)

    Which makes it even more impressive since Austria had about two times less people than Czechoslovakia had and yet still had a higher death toll, again due to the mass Wehrmacht conscription of Austrians plus Austrian military volunteering that I mentioned in my previous post here.

    JFK was 60 years ago. Dubya Bush pretended to be a Texas redneck. “Bubba” Clinton acted like an Arkansas “good ole boy.” Obama who went to elite schools and was raised by rich white family members puts on a fake African-American accent.

    Americans dislike elites so much, that the elites have to pretend not to be elites.

    What about Al Gore? He didn’t really hide his elite status and yet he almost won in 2000. And Hillary Clinton? She came close to winning in 2016 (and came very close to winning the 2008 Democratic presidential nomination before that) in spite of her being perceived as being very elite.

    All those countries got richer when they dropped Socialism.

    And began living longer too:

    https://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/2023/05/actual-communism-is-bad-for-your-health/

    • Replies: @AP
    @Mr. XYZ


    What about Al Gore? He didn’t really hide his elite status and yet he almost won in 2000.
     
    He lost to Dubya, who played the role of Texas redneck.

    And Hillary Clinton? She came close to winning in 2016 (and came very close to winning the 2008 Democratic presidential nomination before that) in spite of her being perceived as being very elite.
     
    And this perception was a hindrance, not an advantage, in anti-elitist America.

    Agree with the rest that you posted.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    , @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ


    Austria had more deaths than Czechoslovakia during World War II:

    384,000 (Austria) vs. 345,000 (Czechoslovakia)

    Which makes it even more impressive since Austria had about two times less people than Czechoslovakia had and yet still had a higher death toll
     

    They were Nazis! Do you get that? Hitler and many leading Nazis were Austrian - they invaded countries like Russia and died in large numbers. That's what happens when you are a Nazi and lose...

    If you want to get "technical" there were 200k dead soldiers among 3 million Sudeten Germans from Czechoslovakia (plus an estimated 20k dead after the war) - add it up and it's almost even with Austria.

    But the point is that about 20% of Czechoslovakia where Sudeten Germans lived was totally depopulated with the Germans expelled (some of the main industrial areas) - that was a major drain on the economy. In spite of it GNP quadrupled in 40 years under the commies, population grew by half...(By the way, the expulsion was done by the democrat London based government with full Anglo support.)

    Austria was neutral and socialist (then and now), they did better. So? This is not about "what-if", it is about absolute results and at no point in Czechoslovakia history did the country do as well economically, demographically, culturally...

    (AP spouts cherrypicked nonsense and has no understanding of the context. He hides in minutia as all failed ideologues.)

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

  882. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. Hack

    No, it is not so easy.
    However, in CE Europe you must distinguish between the local Jewish communities and the Jewish organizations who are often run by transplants (chief rabbi of Poland is still American, after 30 years!) or by some rather narrow class of "political Jews" who are often unknown to normal Jews. In other words, there are Jewish organizations and there are Jews. I would bet that the former are ultimately run under the direction of false Jews. In Russia, Chabad build Jewish structures parallel to official ones, which certainly weren't anti-Putin. And Chabad is crypto-Sephardism (they follow Maimonides as Sephardim do and are obsessed with Moshiach) in Askhenazi world, thus I consider it false Judaism par excellence.

    But the most known American Jew living here in Poland, Anne Applebaum, who I see as 1-person Jewish organization, is staunchly pro-Ukrainian.

    It is conceivable that false Jews would support both sides of conflict in order to destroy ancient Jewish lands and force emigration to Israel. Well, USA, run partly by Jewish bankers, supported once build-up of both the Nazis and Bolsheviks (Sutton thesis etc.) in order to bring about the war of Gog (Germans) and Magog (Russsians)

    Hard to say for me how situation looks in USA. Israeli policy tried to be neutral, AFAIK.

    Historically speaking, neither Russia nor Ukraine were Jewish-friendly.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @LT1488, @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. Hack

    Just few days ago, Anne Applebaum said in Poland “Russia is never as strong as it looks”. If this isn’t war propaganda, I don’t know what this is.

    I hope it won’t end with “if you support Ukraine, you must support greater war with Russia’.

    Anyway, war drums in the West are slowly moving from beating “support Ukraine” to “prepare for general war with Russia”.

    Ukraine is a pawn too. SUch a general war can happen only if Ukraine starts losing.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Another Polish Perspective


    But the most known American Jew living here in Poland, Anne Applebaum
     
    Well, her ancestors were from Belarus.

    a general war can happen only if Ukraine starts losing
     
    Yes, the ones promoting policies for Ukraine to lose are the ones working to bring about a wider war.

    Bloodthirsty people.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

  883. @John Johnson
    @songbird

    Too bad Google image search doesn’t have a neural net that can do paternity tests on family photos.

    Son has the dad's mouth and teeth:
    https://media.ghgossip.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/20202657/Screenshot-2023-01-20-at-8.25.44-PM.png

    The brother and sister look similar in older photos. Probably his.

    I really don't see the problem though. The cuckold wing of the Republican party should be thrilled to have an honorary member in the White house.

    Replies: @songbird

    Probably – I was joking a bit, though they do honestly seem a bit dark to me for half-Punjabis, in some photos. (Though, I guess the daughter has blue eyes). Possibly her husband is Sicilian or part Latino, and that might explain it.

    Suppose Gates is always warning about population growth in Africa, which some might see as a dog-whistle. But haven’t Macron and others done that? There is a stability factor, where people who are very antinational will still do that. They don’t seem to object fundamentally to the results of mass migration, but might be worried about big waves upsetting things.

    Perhaps, they are like AK and believe there is some modest max cap on the costs of diversity. Only 10%. To me, that sounds an awful lot like a tithe, and I don’t see how it can self-limiting like that.

    I have had jury duty before, and it was kind of frightening to see the demographics of the courthouse. Basically, all the criminals were brown (and their families were there) and all the jurors (i.e. the people who showed up) were Euros.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @songbird

    Suppose Gates is always warning about population growth in Africa, which some might see as a dog-whistle.

    He is just a typical globalist. Won't commit to his own country but also doesn't fully buy into Wakanda theory. Wants it to be true but knows it isn't.

    I have had jury duty before, and it was kind of frightening to see the demographics of the courthouse. Basically, all the criminals were brown (and their families were there) and all the jurors (i.e. the people who showed up) were Euros.

    I assume a lot of non-Whites don't respond to the jury summons.

    Seems to be an honor system.

    I told them once that I can't go because I work and also watch my kids part of the time. They wrote back and said you'll have to go in at 6:00 AM and stand in line to ask the judge to be excused or you will be fined. In fact the letter had BOLD writing and made it clear that standing in line was my only chance and I probably wouldn't be excused. Meaning don't bother trying to get out of it.

    Well f-ck that. The day I was supposed to stand in line was when I had my kids. Was I supposed to bring them at 6 AM?

    I threw it in the trash.

    I never heard back from them.

  884. @songbird
    @John Johnson

    Probably - I was joking a bit, though they do honestly seem a bit dark to me for half-Punjabis, in some photos. (Though, I guess the daughter has blue eyes). Possibly her husband is Sicilian or part Latino, and that might explain it.

    Suppose Gates is always warning about population growth in Africa, which some might see as a dog-whistle. But haven't Macron and others done that? There is a stability factor, where people who are very antinational will still do that. They don't seem to object fundamentally to the results of mass migration, but might be worried about big waves upsetting things.

    Perhaps, they are like AK and believe there is some modest max cap on the costs of diversity. Only 10%. To me, that sounds an awful lot like a tithe, and I don't see how it can self-limiting like that.

    I have had jury duty before, and it was kind of frightening to see the demographics of the courthouse. Basically, all the criminals were brown (and their families were there) and all the jurors (i.e. the people who showed up) were Euros.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Suppose Gates is always warning about population growth in Africa, which some might see as a dog-whistle.

    He is just a typical globalist. Won’t commit to his own country but also doesn’t fully buy into Wakanda theory. Wants it to be true but knows it isn’t.

    I have had jury duty before, and it was kind of frightening to see the demographics of the courthouse. Basically, all the criminals were brown (and their families were there) and all the jurors (i.e. the people who showed up) were Euros.

    I assume a lot of non-Whites don’t respond to the jury summons.

    Seems to be an honor system.

    I told them once that I can’t go because I work and also watch my kids part of the time. They wrote back and said you’ll have to go in at 6:00 AM and stand in line to ask the judge to be excused or you will be fined. In fact the letter had BOLD writing and made it clear that standing in line was my only chance and I probably wouldn’t be excused. Meaning don’t bother trying to get out of it.

    Well f-ck that. The day I was supposed to stand in line was when I had my kids. Was I supposed to bring them at 6 AM?

    I threw it in the trash.

    I never heard back from them.

  885. Getting Blinkened

    From the below video, saying that Putin failed in eliminating Ukraine is like saying that Ray McGovern failed at becoming an African-American female. A well-deserved thrashing of the current US Secretary of State. Post-Soviet Russian policy including the Minsk Accords, the manner of Russia’s special military operation and the March 2022 Istanbul settlement proposal serve as rock solid proof debunking Blinken. To be expected from someone whose son dressed up as Zelensky and his daughter in the colors of the Ukrainian flag for Halloween. He’s a neocon/neolib geopolitical extremist.

    • Replies: @LondonBob
    @Mikhail

    Blinken settles the debate regarding whether it is IQ or nepotism.

    Replies: @QCIC

  886. @Mr. Hack
    @Another Polish Perspective

    Being another expert on the topic, would you also confer whether or not self-identifying American Jewry that supports Ukraine today are not "real Jews" as kremlinstoogeA123 contends, and that those that support the kremlin are actually the real ones? This seems to be the litmus test that he uses, and I just wanted to see if anybody else out there buys into it?

    https://static01.nyt.com/images/2006/07/04/nyregion/04push.600.jpg
    I wonder whether kremlintoogeA123 still considers these folks to be Jews, or whether they've gone over the edge and have somehow biologically transformed themselves into some new sort of beings? Maybe they've become "born again" as he's professed his adherence to many times at this blogsite?

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Another Polish Perspective

    If you like, there was recently a book written by a Jew which in jest hinted at truth: that behind Judaism, and not just it, other ancient religion hides.
    It is “Mother for Dinner: A Novel” by Shalom Auslander. Well, how far is from cannibalism to human sacrifice…?

  887. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    Austria had more deaths than Czechoslovakia during World War II:

    https://www.nationalww2museum.org/students-teachers/student-resources/research-starters/research-starters-worldwide-deaths-world-war

    384,000 (Austria) vs. 345,000 (Czechoslovakia)
     
    Which makes it even more impressive since Austria had about two times less people than Czechoslovakia had and yet still had a higher death toll, again due to the mass Wehrmacht conscription of Austrians plus Austrian military volunteering that I mentioned in my previous post here.

    JFK was 60 years ago. Dubya Bush pretended to be a Texas redneck. “Bubba” Clinton acted like an Arkansas “good ole boy.” Obama who went to elite schools and was raised by rich white family members puts on a fake African-American accent.

    Americans dislike elites so much, that the elites have to pretend not to be elites.
     
    What about Al Gore? He didn't really hide his elite status and yet he almost won in 2000. And Hillary Clinton? She came close to winning in 2016 (and came very close to winning the 2008 Democratic presidential nomination before that) in spite of her being perceived as being very elite.

    All those countries got richer when they dropped Socialism.

     

    And began living longer too:

    https://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/2023/05/actual-communism-is-bad-for-your-health/

    https://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/wp-content/uploads/communism-life-expect.jpeg

    https://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/wp-content/uploads/life-expectancy-USSR-block-2048x1446.png

    https://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/wp-content/uploads/spline_fit_all.png

    Replies: @AP, @Beckow

    What about Al Gore? He didn’t really hide his elite status and yet he almost won in 2000.

    He lost to Dubya, who played the role of Texas redneck.

    And Hillary Clinton? She came close to winning in 2016 (and came very close to winning the 2008 Democratic presidential nomination before that) in spite of her being perceived as being very elite.

    And this perception was a hindrance, not an advantage, in anti-elitist America.

    Agree with the rest that you posted.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    He lost to Dubya, who played the role of Texas redneck.

     

    He lost on a technicality. We don't know for sure who would have won had a full manual recount been conducted in Florida. (SCOTUS said that the existing one was unconstitutional because there was no uniform standard for recounting ballots and because this recount did not extend to all of Florida's ballots. SCOTUS also said that there was no time for a new, constitutional recount.) Even the 2001 post-election studies don't provide a conclusive answer to this because they only looked at overvotes and undervotes, not at the ballots that were classified by Florida's voting machines as legal votes. In its Bush v. Gore opinion, SCOTUS implied that the ballots classified by the voting machines as legal votes should also be manually recounted in order to find any ballots among them that were mistakenly counted by the voting machines:

    https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/531/98/

    "In addition, the recounts in these three counties were not limited to so-called undervotes but extended to all of the ballots. The distinction has real consequences. A manual recount of all ballots identifies not only those ballots which show no vote but also those which contain more than one,
    the so-called overvotes. Neither category will be counted by the machine. This is not a trivial concern. At oral argument, respondents estimated there are as many as 110,000 overvotes statewide. As a result, the citizen whose ballot was not read by a machine because he failed to vote for a candidate in a way readable by a machine may still have his vote counted in a manual recount; on the other hand, the citizen who marks two candidates in a way discernible by the machine will not have the same opportunity to have his vote count, even if a manual examination of the ballot would reveal the requisite indicia of intent. Furthermore, the citizen who marks two candidates, only one of which is discernible by the machine, will have his vote counted even though it should have been read as an invalid ballot. The State Supreme Court's inclusion of vote counts based on these variant standards exemplifies concerns with the remedial processes that were under way."

    (The relevant part is in bold.)


    And this perception was a hindrance, not an advantage, in anti-elitist America.
     
    In 2016, probably, but back in 2008, she was able to appeal to a lot of rednecks in the Democratic primaries:

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/b0/HillaryObamaPrimaries2008PopularVote.svg/2560px-HillaryObamaPrimaries2008PopularVote.svg.png

    She won the popular vote among redneck Southern whites like crazy! Of course, maybe it could be that they didn't like her so much as liked her husband and also thought that Obama was even more distant to them (because Hillary Clinton is at least a white woman, not a half-East African black man with a Muslim middle name and a Muslim father).

    (For reference, I supported Obama in the 2008 Democratic primaries but was too young to vote back then and also wasn't a US citizen yet. I became a US citizen in mid-2010, shortly before my 18th birthday.)


    Agree with the rest that you posted.

     

    Good.
  888. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Another Polish Perspective

    Just few days ago, Anne Applebaum said in Poland "Russia is never as strong as it looks". If this isn't war propaganda, I don't know what this is.

    I hope it won't end with "if you support Ukraine, you must support greater war with Russia'.

    Anyway, war drums in the West are slowly moving from beating "support Ukraine" to "prepare for general war with Russia".

    Ukraine is a pawn too. SUch a general war can happen only if Ukraine starts losing.

    Replies: @AP

    But the most known American Jew living here in Poland, Anne Applebaum

    Well, her ancestors were from Belarus.

    a general war can happen only if Ukraine starts losing

    Yes, the ones promoting policies for Ukraine to lose are the ones working to bring about a wider war.

    Bloodthirsty people.

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @AP


    Bloodthirsty people.
     
    Yes, they are indeed.

    I am sure they are also the people who promote vampires in popular culture. Anyone noticed that vampires are now for loving and not for fearing ?

    Replies: @songbird

  889. @AP
    @Another Polish Perspective


    But the most known American Jew living here in Poland, Anne Applebaum
     
    Well, her ancestors were from Belarus.

    a general war can happen only if Ukraine starts losing
     
    Yes, the ones promoting policies for Ukraine to lose are the ones working to bring about a wider war.

    Bloodthirsty people.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

    Bloodthirsty people.

    Yes, they are indeed.

    I am sure they are also the people who promote vampires in popular culture. Anyone noticed that vampires are now for loving and not for fearing ?

    • Replies: @songbird
    @Another Polish Perspective

    It is kind of interesting how vampires were aristocrats, when they were first popularized in the 19th century and in early film. Right when aristocrats were losing a lot of their power or seeing it decline in relative terms. Seems like there was definitely a class warfare aspect to it, though maybe, somewhat subtle.

    Have heard it claimed that the Vlad stuff started as German propaganda.

    I think the first written mention of a vampire comes from a Habsburg officer (winks at AP) observing Serb peasants in 1725.
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petar_Blagojevi%C4%87

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  890. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    Austria had more deaths than Czechoslovakia during World War II:

    https://www.nationalww2museum.org/students-teachers/student-resources/research-starters/research-starters-worldwide-deaths-world-war

    384,000 (Austria) vs. 345,000 (Czechoslovakia)
     
    Which makes it even more impressive since Austria had about two times less people than Czechoslovakia had and yet still had a higher death toll, again due to the mass Wehrmacht conscription of Austrians plus Austrian military volunteering that I mentioned in my previous post here.

    JFK was 60 years ago. Dubya Bush pretended to be a Texas redneck. “Bubba” Clinton acted like an Arkansas “good ole boy.” Obama who went to elite schools and was raised by rich white family members puts on a fake African-American accent.

    Americans dislike elites so much, that the elites have to pretend not to be elites.
     
    What about Al Gore? He didn't really hide his elite status and yet he almost won in 2000. And Hillary Clinton? She came close to winning in 2016 (and came very close to winning the 2008 Democratic presidential nomination before that) in spite of her being perceived as being very elite.

    All those countries got richer when they dropped Socialism.

     

    And began living longer too:

    https://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/2023/05/actual-communism-is-bad-for-your-health/

    https://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/wp-content/uploads/communism-life-expect.jpeg

    https://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/wp-content/uploads/life-expectancy-USSR-block-2048x1446.png

    https://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/wp-content/uploads/spline_fit_all.png

    Replies: @AP, @Beckow

    Austria had more deaths than Czechoslovakia during World War II:

    384,000 (Austria) vs. 345,000 (Czechoslovakia)

    Which makes it even more impressive since Austria had about two times less people than Czechoslovakia had and yet still had a higher death toll

    They were Nazis! Do you get that? Hitler and many leading Nazis were Austrian – they invaded countries like Russia and died in large numbers. That’s what happens when you are a Nazi and lose…

    If you want to get “technical” there were 200k dead soldiers among 3 million Sudeten Germans from Czechoslovakia (plus an estimated 20k dead after the war) – add it up and it’s almost even with Austria.

    But the point is that about 20% of Czechoslovakia where Sudeten Germans lived was totally depopulated with the Germans expelled (some of the main industrial areas) – that was a major drain on the economy. In spite of it GNP quadrupled in 40 years under the commies, population grew by half…(By the way, the expulsion was done by the democrat London based government with full Anglo support.)

    Austria was neutral and socialist (then and now), they did better. So? This is not about “what-if”, it is about absolute results and at no point in Czechoslovakia history did the country do as well economically, demographically, culturally…

    (AP spouts cherrypicked nonsense and has no understanding of the context. He hides in minutia as all failed ideologues.)

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Beckow

    I don't see why exactly the Sudeten Germans should be counted towards the Czechoslovak WWII death total since they didn't live in Czechoslovakia any longer by the start of WWII and since Czechoslovakia did not want them back after the end of the war (unlike their lands), unlike with the Hungarians in southern Slovakia.

    Replies: @Beckow

    , @AP
    @Beckow


    But the point is that about 20% of Czechoslovakia where Sudeten Germans lived was totally depopulated with the Germans expelled (some of the main industrial areas) – that was a major drain on the economy.
     
    It was irrelevant to the comparison which begins in 1948, after the expulsion of the Germans.

    So even after the Germans had been expelled from Czechoslovakia, Czechoslovakia's per capita GDP was slightly higher than Austria's.

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.


    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768

    In spite of it GNP quadrupled in 40 years under the commies, population grew by half…
     
    So under socialism, GDP in Czechoslovakia doubled per capita over 40 years.

    Under capitalism, during the same period of time, GDP in Austria quintupled per capita over 40 years.

    So Socialism resulted in Czechoslovakia having half the GDP of Austria, half of what it should have had. It became a much poorer country whereas before socialism it had been slightly richer. Even under the Hapsburgs, the Czechs were not nearly as poor relative to Austrians as they became after 40 years of socialism under Moscow.

    Austria was neutral and socialist
     
    You demonstrate that you spent too much time in the USA, where leftists earnestly believe that Western Europeans have socialist economic systems. Austria was not socialist, it was a capitalist country with higher taxes and more social spending than the USA. But it had a market-driven economy, the means of production were not controlled by the state/socialist party.

    This reminds me of when the American politician Bernie Sanders kept referring to Denmark as a socialist country - the Danish PM had to correct him.

    https://www.vox.com/2015/10/31/9650030/denmark-prime-minister-bernie-sanders



    Bernie Sanders has long referred to himself as a socialist rather than a member of the Democratic Party, which has naturally led to a lot of questions about what socialism means to him. He consistently references the social models of the Nordic states — especially Denmark — as his idea of what democratic socialism is all about. But in a speech Friday evening at Harvard's Kennedy School of Government, Danish Prime Minister Lars Løkke Rasmussen said that while he's flattered to see Denmark discussed in a widely watched US presidential debate he doesn't think the socialist shoe fits.

    "I know that some people in the US associate the Nordic model with some sort of socialism," he said. "Therefore, I would like to make one thing clear. Denmark is far from a socialist planned economy. Denmark is a market economy."

    In Rasmussen's view, "The Nordic model is an expanded welfare state which provides a high level of security to its citizens, but it is also a successful market economy with much freedom to pursue your dreams and live your life as you wish."

    Replies: @AP

  891. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ


    What about Al Gore? He didn’t really hide his elite status and yet he almost won in 2000.
     
    He lost to Dubya, who played the role of Texas redneck.

    And Hillary Clinton? She came close to winning in 2016 (and came very close to winning the 2008 Democratic presidential nomination before that) in spite of her being perceived as being very elite.
     
    And this perception was a hindrance, not an advantage, in anti-elitist America.

    Agree with the rest that you posted.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    He lost to Dubya, who played the role of Texas redneck.

    He lost on a technicality. We don’t know for sure who would have won had a full manual recount been conducted in Florida. (SCOTUS said that the existing one was unconstitutional because there was no uniform standard for recounting ballots and because this recount did not extend to all of Florida’s ballots. SCOTUS also said that there was no time for a new, constitutional recount.) Even the 2001 post-election studies don’t provide a conclusive answer to this because they only looked at overvotes and undervotes, not at the ballots that were classified by Florida’s voting machines as legal votes. In its Bush v. Gore opinion, SCOTUS implied that the ballots classified by the voting machines as legal votes should also be manually recounted in order to find any ballots among them that were mistakenly counted by the voting machines:

    https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/531/98/

    “In addition, the recounts in these three counties were not limited to so-called undervotes but extended to all of the ballots. The distinction has real consequences. A manual recount of all ballots identifies not only those ballots which show no vote but also those which contain more than one,
    the so-called overvotes. Neither category will be counted by the machine. This is not a trivial concern. At oral argument, respondents estimated there are as many as 110,000 overvotes statewide. As a result, the citizen whose ballot was not read by a machine because he failed to vote for a candidate in a way readable by a machine may still have his vote counted in a manual recount; on the other hand, the citizen who marks two candidates in a way discernible by the machine will not have the same opportunity to have his vote count, even if a manual examination of the ballot would reveal the requisite indicia of intent. Furthermore, the citizen who marks two candidates, only one of which is discernible by the machine, will have his vote counted even though it should have been read as an invalid ballot. The State Supreme Court’s inclusion of vote counts based on these variant standards exemplifies concerns with the remedial processes that were under way.”

    (The relevant part is in bold.)

    And this perception was a hindrance, not an advantage, in anti-elitist America.

    In 2016, probably, but back in 2008, she was able to appeal to a lot of rednecks in the Democratic primaries:

    She won the popular vote among redneck Southern whites like crazy! Of course, maybe it could be that they didn’t like her so much as liked her husband and also thought that Obama was even more distant to them (because Hillary Clinton is at least a white woman, not a half-East African black man with a Muslim middle name and a Muslim father).

    (For reference, I supported Obama in the 2008 Democratic primaries but was too young to vote back then and also wasn’t a US citizen yet. I became a US citizen in mid-2010, shortly before my 18th birthday.)

    Agree with the rest that you posted.

    Good.

  892. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. Hack

    No, it is not so easy.
    However, in CE Europe you must distinguish between the local Jewish communities and the Jewish organizations who are often run by transplants (chief rabbi of Poland is still American, after 30 years!) or by some rather narrow class of "political Jews" who are often unknown to normal Jews. In other words, there are Jewish organizations and there are Jews. I would bet that the former are ultimately run under the direction of false Jews. In Russia, Chabad build Jewish structures parallel to official ones, which certainly weren't anti-Putin. And Chabad is crypto-Sephardism (they follow Maimonides as Sephardim do and are obsessed with Moshiach) in Askhenazi world, thus I consider it false Judaism par excellence.

    But the most known American Jew living here in Poland, Anne Applebaum, who I see as 1-person Jewish organization, is staunchly pro-Ukrainian.

    It is conceivable that false Jews would support both sides of conflict in order to destroy ancient Jewish lands and force emigration to Israel. Well, USA, run partly by Jewish bankers, supported once build-up of both the Nazis and Bolsheviks (Sutton thesis etc.) in order to bring about the war of Gog (Germans) and Magog (Russsians)

    Hard to say for me how situation looks in USA. Israeli policy tried to be neutral, AFAIK.

    Historically speaking, neither Russia nor Ukraine were Jewish-friendly.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @LT1488, @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. Hack

    ”Historically speaking, neither Russia nor Ukraine were Jewish-friendly.”

    Jews were/are foreign to these lands, why would anyone be friendly to hostile alien foreigners?

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @LT1488

    At least Russia got its Jewish population mostly from annexing Polish lands. Since Jews weren't seen previously as hostile by Polish rulers, there was no automatic reason why they should be seen as such by Russian ones, unless Jews were some staunch Polish patriots, which they weren't.
    It was Russians who first limited Jewish rights and customs which Jews once enjoyed in Poland, not that Jews somehow attacked Russia.

  893. @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ


    Austria had more deaths than Czechoslovakia during World War II:

    384,000 (Austria) vs. 345,000 (Czechoslovakia)

    Which makes it even more impressive since Austria had about two times less people than Czechoslovakia had and yet still had a higher death toll
     

    They were Nazis! Do you get that? Hitler and many leading Nazis were Austrian - they invaded countries like Russia and died in large numbers. That's what happens when you are a Nazi and lose...

    If you want to get "technical" there were 200k dead soldiers among 3 million Sudeten Germans from Czechoslovakia (plus an estimated 20k dead after the war) - add it up and it's almost even with Austria.

    But the point is that about 20% of Czechoslovakia where Sudeten Germans lived was totally depopulated with the Germans expelled (some of the main industrial areas) - that was a major drain on the economy. In spite of it GNP quadrupled in 40 years under the commies, population grew by half...(By the way, the expulsion was done by the democrat London based government with full Anglo support.)

    Austria was neutral and socialist (then and now), they did better. So? This is not about "what-if", it is about absolute results and at no point in Czechoslovakia history did the country do as well economically, demographically, culturally...

    (AP spouts cherrypicked nonsense and has no understanding of the context. He hides in minutia as all failed ideologues.)

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    I don’t see why exactly the Sudeten Germans should be counted towards the Czechoslovak WWII death total since they didn’t live in Czechoslovakia any longer by the start of WWII and since Czechoslovakia did not want them back after the end of the war (unlike their lands), unlike with the Hungarians in southern Slovakia.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    If you count the dead Austrian Nazis (also an 'occupied' country), why not the dead Sudeten Germans? The point is that these losses had an impact on post-WW2 economy - loss is a loss. Czechoslovakia, if one includes the 3 million expelled Germans, lost much bigger share of its population than Austria. You need to be consistent.

    If UK would tomorrow lose 20% of its population, wouldn't you expect that to impact their GNP?

    Replies: @AP

  894. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. Hack

    No, it is not so easy.
    However, in CE Europe you must distinguish between the local Jewish communities and the Jewish organizations who are often run by transplants (chief rabbi of Poland is still American, after 30 years!) or by some rather narrow class of "political Jews" who are often unknown to normal Jews. In other words, there are Jewish organizations and there are Jews. I would bet that the former are ultimately run under the direction of false Jews. In Russia, Chabad build Jewish structures parallel to official ones, which certainly weren't anti-Putin. And Chabad is crypto-Sephardism (they follow Maimonides as Sephardim do and are obsessed with Moshiach) in Askhenazi world, thus I consider it false Judaism par excellence.

    But the most known American Jew living here in Poland, Anne Applebaum, who I see as 1-person Jewish organization, is staunchly pro-Ukrainian.

    It is conceivable that false Jews would support both sides of conflict in order to destroy ancient Jewish lands and force emigration to Israel. Well, USA, run partly by Jewish bankers, supported once build-up of both the Nazis and Bolsheviks (Sutton thesis etc.) in order to bring about the war of Gog (Germans) and Magog (Russsians)

    Hard to say for me how situation looks in USA. Israeli policy tried to be neutral, AFAIK.

    Historically speaking, neither Russia nor Ukraine were Jewish-friendly.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @LT1488, @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. Hack

    It is conceivable that false Jews would support both sides of conflict in order to destroy ancient Jewish lands and force emigration to Israel. Well, USA, run partly by Jewish bankers, supported once build-up of both the Nazis and Bolsheviks (Sutton thesis etc.) in order to bring about the war of Gog (Germans) and Magog (Russsians)

    FWIW, some right-wing Israelis are not comfortable with aliyah (immigration) to Israel in those cases where the immigrant (oleh) only has a Jewish grandfather (or even only two Jewish grandfathers). That’s why they pushed to repeal the Grandchild Clause of Israel’s Law of Return until Hamas’s October 7 terrorist attack shut them up in regards to this issue, hopefully for a very long time.

  895. @LT1488
    @Another Polish Perspective

    ''Historically speaking, neither Russia nor Ukraine were Jewish-friendly.''

    Jews were/are foreign to these lands, why would anyone be friendly to hostile alien foreigners?

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

    At least Russia got its Jewish population mostly from annexing Polish lands. Since Jews weren’t seen previously as hostile by Polish rulers, there was no automatic reason why they should be seen as such by Russian ones, unless Jews were some staunch Polish patriots, which they weren’t.
    It was Russians who first limited Jewish rights and customs which Jews once enjoyed in Poland, not that Jews somehow attacked Russia.

  896. @Mr. XYZ
    @Beckow

    I don't see why exactly the Sudeten Germans should be counted towards the Czechoslovak WWII death total since they didn't live in Czechoslovakia any longer by the start of WWII and since Czechoslovakia did not want them back after the end of the war (unlike their lands), unlike with the Hungarians in southern Slovakia.

    Replies: @Beckow

    If you count the dead Austrian Nazis (also an ‘occupied’ country), why not the dead Sudeten Germans? The point is that these losses had an impact on post-WW2 economy – loss is a loss. Czechoslovakia, if one includes the 3 million expelled Germans, lost much bigger share of its population than Austria. You need to be consistent.

    If UK would tomorrow lose 20% of its population, wouldn’t you expect that to impact their GNP?

    • Replies: @AP
    @Beckow


    The point is that these losses had an impact on post-WW2 economy – loss is a loss.
     
    This impact is irrelevant for he comparison, that begins in 1948, after the Germans were gone from Czechoslovakia.

    You were either too dumb and got caught in Gerard's misdirection, or went along with it out of your dishonesty.

    If UK would tomorrow lose 20% of its population, wouldn’t you expect that to impact their GNP?
     
    Not necessarily per capita. The comparison was per capita.

    Economic performance of capitalist Austria vs. Socialist Czechoslovakia (and fascist Spain), 1948-1989 (end of failed Socialist experiment)

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.
    Spain: $2,186

    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Spain: $11,582.
    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768

    Replies: @Beckow

  897. @Mikhail
    Getting Blinkened

    From the below video, saying that Putin failed in eliminating Ukraine is like saying that Ray McGovern failed at becoming an African-American female. A well-deserved thrashing of the current US Secretary of State. Post-Soviet Russian policy including the Minsk Accords, the manner of Russia's special military operation and the March 2022 Istanbul settlement proposal serve as rock solid proof debunking Blinken. To be expected from someone whose son dressed up as Zelensky and his daughter in the colors of the Ukrainian flag for Halloween. He's a neocon/neolib geopolitical extremist.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jRGkoBSFLRA

    Replies: @LondonBob

    Blinken settles the debate regarding whether it is IQ or nepotism.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @LondonBob

    I didn't know there was a question. Blinken is a creature from the muddiest parts of the swamp. His is mostly a lizard brain, though well trained in the rituals of the swamp.

    Replies: @Mikhail

  898. @Another Polish Perspective
    @AP


    Bloodthirsty people.
     
    Yes, they are indeed.

    I am sure they are also the people who promote vampires in popular culture. Anyone noticed that vampires are now for loving and not for fearing ?

    Replies: @songbird

    It is kind of interesting how vampires were aristocrats, when they were first popularized in the 19th century and in early film. Right when aristocrats were losing a lot of their power or seeing it decline in relative terms. Seems like there was definitely a class warfare aspect to it, though maybe, somewhat subtle.

    Have heard it claimed that the Vlad stuff started as German propaganda.

    I think the first written mention of a vampire comes from a Habsburg officer (winks at AP) observing Serb peasants in 1725.
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petar_Blagojevi%C4%87

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    I used to tease my Bukovinian/Ukrainian father about whether we had any vampires in our bloodline. Bukovina was very close to Transylvania after all. There were even some novels written back then about Dracula's time in Lviv. Lucky me that my father had a good sense of humor. :-)

    Replies: @Gerard1234

  899. @John Johnson
    Trump at 2AM gives an all cap post on why he should have total immunity:

    “EVEN EVENTS THAT ‘CROSS THE LINE’ MUST FALL UNDER TOTAL IMMUNITY, OR IT WILL BE YEARS OF TRAUMA TRYING TO DETERMINE GOOD FROM BAD,” Trump wrote. “THERE MUST BE CERTAINTY. EXAMPLE: YOU CAN’T STOP POLICE FROM DOING THE JOB OF STRONG & EFFECTIVE CRIME PREVENTION BECAUSE YOU WANT TO GUARD AGAINST THE OCCASIONAL ‘ROGUE COP’ OR ‘BAD APPLE.’ SOMETIMES YOU JUST HAVE TO LIVE WITH ‘GREAT BUT SLIGHTLY IMPERFECT.’ ALL PRESIDENTS MUST HAVE COMPLETE & TOTAL PRESIDENTIAL IMMUNITY, OR THE AUTHORITY & DECISIVENESS OF A PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES WILL BE STRIPPED & GONE FOREVER. HOPEFULLY THIS WILL BE AN EASY DECISION. GOD BLESS THE SUPREME COURT!”
    https://news.yahoo.com/experts-alarmed-trump-demands-immunity-145859079.html

    Yea nothing to worry about Trump fans. Nothing at all.

    He just decided to go on some unhinged rant in the middle of the night about how he should be able to commit crimes while in office.

    Totally innocent.

    Replies: @QCIC

    What he wrote is basically correct. Leaders are given more leeway than people realize, if only because the context for their actions may be classified or simply barred from discussion. In those cases, defending their actions can be damaging to the office. This is not a failing of Trump, it is inherent with centralized authority. The situation is fuzzy in the US where the President is typically a mixture of figurehead and leader.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @QCIC

    What he wrote is basically correct. Leaders are given more leeway than people realize, if only because the context for their actions may be classified or simply barred from discussion.

    No he is not basically correct. Presidential powers are defined by the constitution and there is no right to immunity while in office.

    You think it is a good idea to give presidents criminal immunity while in office? What would stop them from putting hits on the competition?

    Trump is cracking up because his lawyers don't have a plan for the documents case. He is trying a hail mary with presidential immunity.

    His lawyers keep quitting which is not a good sign. Lawyers quit when they think a case is not worth the money or if it will come with negative publicity from losing. Well Trump has plenty of money.

    Replies: @QCIC

  900. @LondonBob
    @Mikhail

    Blinken settles the debate regarding whether it is IQ or nepotism.

    Replies: @QCIC

    I didn’t know there was a question. Blinken is a creature from the muddiest parts of the swamp. His is mostly a lizard brain, though well trained in the rituals of the swamp.

    • Replies: @Mikhail
    @QCIC

    A most corrupt one at that:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ifnCakYJNVM

    Replies: @Derer

  901. @Mr. XYZ
    @German_reader

    If Israel was smart, they would say something along the lines of "We support an independent Palestinian state, but as an Israeli vassal state". That would be unfair to the Palestinians, of course, but it would also ensure Israel's security. What I mean by this is some kind of military alliance between Israel and this independent Palestinian state with a lot of military cooperation between the two of them, similar to what's going on with NATO, while the Palestinians are allowed to run their own domestic affairs however they see fit just so long as they don't engage in any Jew hatred. In other words, an arrangement with Israel similar to what Cuba had with the US with the Platt Amendment, before Fidel Castro came to power there.

    This is a good map for any peace settlement:

    https://www.shaularieli.com/en/maps/negotiations/

    https://www.shaularieli.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/A-Stable-Border-Proposal-for-land-swaps-2020-scaled.jpg

    Though I would prefer it if E-1 will also remain in Israeli hands. However, I won't insist on it for the sake of peace.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @A123

    If Israel was smart, they would say something along the lines of “We support an independent Palestinian state, but as an Israeli vassal state”.

    In other words, an arrangement with Israel similar to what Cuba had with the US with the Platt Amendment, before Fidel Castro came to power there.

    I think you just pointed out why the proposal is a non-starter. There is ample evidence that a “Platt Amendment State” failed. There is no reason to model an effort in Jewish Palestine that could create another figure like Castro.

    Palestinians are allowed to run their own domestic affairs however they see fit just so long as they don’t engage in any Jew hatred.

    This is one of those things that sounds good, but is devoid of adequate detail. I am dubious that the idea is practical. There are huge question that must be addressed up front.

    Hamas exercised control over domestic affairs in Gaza. They unilaterally destroyed the fresh water supply by stealing pipe & concrete for military use. How will a new domestic authority in Gaza fix this problem that they created for themselves?

    The Muslim colonies in Judea, Samaria, and Gaza have been systematically training Jew hatred for 50+ years. This includes every organization — PLO, UNRWA, Fatah, Hamas, etc. How do you plan to change the hearts and minds of the Jihadists to be anything other than a threat?

    This is a good map for any peace settlement:

    Weakness emboldens the enemy. That map would guarantee future war. Here is a better map for understanding the situation.

      

    The Palestinian Mandate for a Jewish National Homeland was carved up incorrectly long ago. Jews received only 23% of the land. Then that sliver was further subdivided for Muslim colonies in Judea, Samaria, and Gaza. It is quite obvious that the current lines are inherently unfair to indigenous Palestinian Jews.

    Due to the “demographics are destiny” push by both sides, the population far exceeds what makes sense in the tiny area west of the Jordan River. This is particularly visible in Gaza. The vast numbers of people are dramatically mismatched to natural resources.
    ___

    Instead of repeating the failures of the past 50+ years, it is time for new thinking. The international community, in addition to the direct parties, have to consider solutions that reach outside the incredibly artificial 23% line.

    Realistically, the only hope for a long term fix to multiple injustices rests on bringing new land into the negotiations. To me, the most promising option is a New Muslim Palestine that does not have a physical border with Israel. However, feel free to offer other potential paths out of the 23% trap.

    PEACE 😇

  902. [MORE]

    • Replies: @Gerard1234
    @sudden death

    LMAO !! So there is you..........a worthless Black Russian POS, reading the book of a worthless POS western "journalist", full of worthless POS, interviewing various psychotic worthless POS, talking worthless POS......all as a pathetic PR exercise of worthless POS........so that a worthless Black Russian POS can be pumped full or more worthless POS, so that you can remain to live as you are.........a worthless POS


    The military's commander in chief, Zaluzhny, ordered units to disperse around the country, ostensibly for training exercises, and moved air-defence batteries and military aircraft from their bases to new, hidden locations

     

    Yes......in the cities,around tall buildings you dipshit are these "hidden locations" for the A-A complex!

    WHAT successes of their aircraft in the opening months did the Ukronazis have you imbecile? Hiding small numbers of aircraft has not been especially difficult for the last 90 years, soviets made plenty of installations to do this.

    I would add that Russia has gone 2 different periods in the last 10 months of going several months without ANY plane or helicopter losses. Considering the numbers of sorties flown each day, that is fenomenal.

    I was afraid that we would lose the element of surprise
     
    So this retard admits the obvious that they "created element of surprise", i.e they got annihilated en masse......by deliberately not asking civilians to leave the cities or border regions, using them as civilian shields and or just killing them directly, embedding air-defence in the cities in or around high-rise buildings leaving huge numbers of people vulnerable, trying to claim that they were luring Russia into the cities etc. Incompetent, pussys, cowards and sadists!

    Anyway - an interview with the vatnik tramp Zaluzhny is irrelevant for what is a western operation.

    Replies: @sudden death

  903. Yet more detail from Nikki Haley’s own Twitter account (1)

    Nikki Haley
    @NikkiHaley

    We spent the last couple of days celebrating our son’s graduation. Tonight I turned on the news and am heartbroken. It’s important to understand that the death of George Floyd was personal and painful for many. In order to heal, it needs to be personal and painful for everyone.

    Why does the death of violent drug addict have to be “personal and painful for everyone”?

    If she wants to pump race division in the country, she really needs to change parties to run as a NeoConDemocrat. They would love her advocacy for foreign wars too.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://instapundit.com/627431/

     

    • Replies: @songbird
    @A123

    Brunette Liz Cheney?! What an ultra PC-characterization. To start with, it looks to me like Cheney dyes her hair. She has very dark roots.

    How about "Indian Killary", "Killary Kaur", or "Nimrata Rodham-Haley?"

    Replies: @A123

    , @Mikel
    @A123

    Nice to see you quoting Massie (a DeSantis supporter). Perhaps little by little you'll come around to the saner side with the more intelligent people.

    This image from your link is quite hilarious too:

    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/fc196082782ad3b33dacd50100f34958f595d90fcc86319df3cdf4a2bf98f174.jpg?w=800&h=367

    But it was to be expected that the John Johnson/John Bolton/Nikki Haley branch of the conservatives would fight tooth and nail against the MAGA turn in the GOP with the big resources they have. Nothing surprising there. What's remarkable is how unsuccessful they've been so far. Out of the 3 candidates remaining, the top two ones are MAGA and so was the fourth one. That doesn't represent the power they still have in Congress and the party in general. But they try to convince us to give up and let Nikki be the only contender against Biden LOL.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @John Johnson

    , @Derer
    @A123

    The hell will freeze before damaged Haley is elected president.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

  904. @QCIC
    @LondonBob

    I didn't know there was a question. Blinken is a creature from the muddiest parts of the swamp. His is mostly a lizard brain, though well trained in the rituals of the swamp.

    Replies: @Mikhail

    A most corrupt one at that:

    • Replies: @Derer
    @Mikhail

    To defeat the bragging has-been hegemon - for a peace on this planet.

  905. @A123
    Yet more detail from Nikki Haley's own Twitter account (1)

    Nikki Haley
    @NikkiHaley

    We spent the last couple of days celebrating our son’s graduation. Tonight I turned on the news and am heartbroken. It’s important to understand that the death of George Floyd was personal and painful for many. In order to heal, it needs to be personal and painful for everyone.
     
    Why does the death of violent drug addict have to be "personal and painful for everyone"?

    If she wants to pump race division in the country, she really needs to change parties to run as a NeoConDemocrat. They would love her advocacy for foreign wars too.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://instapundit.com/627431/


     
    https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgi3PFGKlSHiKExZW4Bo1k5MI3ASVz7_38Fc5-XUmxbZpHC5jyNEbNh9J7p6yOL2JIq7a0M9aQTlUyZfEUKdGUX3gACobkCBE1b6wuN9_poRSzmOInspzFxD5_u3dSIiQAZ86dG_U9LaCnjO_k11JikyvAHZ9BgiR-LuzG_hSaJhnnVhjG_dRXEWOQHtbM/s599/1%20dgsdfgsdgdsg.jpg

    Replies: @songbird, @Mikel, @Derer

    Brunette Liz Cheney?! What an ultra PC-characterization. To start with, it looks to me like Cheney dyes her hair. She has very dark roots.

    How about “Indian Killary”, “Killary Kaur”, or “Nimrata Rodham-Haley?”

    • Replies: @A123
    @songbird


    How about “Indian Killary”, “Killary Kaur”, or “Nimrata Rodham-Haley?”
     
    Trump grants your request. (1)

     
    https://static-assets-1.truthsocial.com/tmtg:prime-ts-assets/media_attachments/files/111/769/681/041/609/512/original/9c654b188c9b3815.jpg
     

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.dailydot.com/debug/donald-trump-nikki-haley-hillary-clinton/
  906. @A123
    Yet more detail from Nikki Haley's own Twitter account (1)

    Nikki Haley
    @NikkiHaley

    We spent the last couple of days celebrating our son’s graduation. Tonight I turned on the news and am heartbroken. It’s important to understand that the death of George Floyd was personal and painful for many. In order to heal, it needs to be personal and painful for everyone.
     
    Why does the death of violent drug addict have to be "personal and painful for everyone"?

    If she wants to pump race division in the country, she really needs to change parties to run as a NeoConDemocrat. They would love her advocacy for foreign wars too.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://instapundit.com/627431/


     
    https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgi3PFGKlSHiKExZW4Bo1k5MI3ASVz7_38Fc5-XUmxbZpHC5jyNEbNh9J7p6yOL2JIq7a0M9aQTlUyZfEUKdGUX3gACobkCBE1b6wuN9_poRSzmOInspzFxD5_u3dSIiQAZ86dG_U9LaCnjO_k11JikyvAHZ9BgiR-LuzG_hSaJhnnVhjG_dRXEWOQHtbM/s599/1%20dgsdfgsdgdsg.jpg

    Replies: @songbird, @Mikel, @Derer

    Nice to see you quoting Massie (a DeSantis supporter). Perhaps little by little you’ll come around to the saner side with the more intelligent people.

    This image from your link is quite hilarious too:

    But it was to be expected that the John Johnson/John Bolton/Nikki Haley branch of the conservatives would fight tooth and nail against the MAGA turn in the GOP with the big resources they have. Nothing surprising there. What’s remarkable is how unsuccessful they’ve been so far. Out of the 3 candidates remaining, the top two ones are MAGA and so was the fourth one. That doesn’t represent the power they still have in Congress and the party in general. But they try to convince us to give up and let Nikki be the only contender against Biden LOL.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Mikel

    The Daily Mail article on what a piece of work she is had 15 photos and every member of her family except her negro son-in-law. There are enough available that they probably did not have to photo-shop him out but I wonder how much of her publicity budget goes into editing photos that would be even more appealing without the big fellow.

    , @John Johnson
    @Mikel

    But it was to be expected that the John Johnson/John Bolton/Nikki Haley branch of the conservatives would fight tooth and nail against the MAGA turn in the GOP with the big resources they have.

    I'm not a conservative and posting my opinions is not fighting tooth and nail. I type around 80 wpm. If I really wanted to fight in politics I wouldn't bother with an alternative website that is backlisted by the major search engines. Which means they intentionally bury the results even if it matches.

    What’s remarkable is how unsuccessful they’ve been so far. Out of the 3 candidates remaining, the top two ones are MAGA and so was the fourth one.

    Why is it surprising that DeSantis is still in the race? Do you not follow US politics? Let me point out an ongoing pattern for you:
    1. Democrats/Republicans rally around someone they like but polls poorly with independents and moderates
    2. Democrats/Republicans lose to the other guy and say WHAT HAPPENED
    3. Pollsters point out again that you have to win independents. You can't just be popular with primary voters.
    4. Go to 1 in next election cause WE LIKE OUR GUY/GAL

    This happens all the time at both state and national level. Hillary Clinton is a good example. Feminists and liberals fawned over her but the polls said it was a bad idea to run her because of independents. Her fans didn't care. They would see cheering crowds of women and think WE ARE DESTINED TO WIN. Trump fans do the same thing at their rallies. They are certain he will win and yet they told us that in the last election.

    Independents outnumber both Republicans and Democrats. The two parties constantly walk into a false dichotomy where they think the opposition is merely their opposite.

    Replies: @A123, @Mikel, @Mr. XYZ

  907. @songbird
    @A123

    Brunette Liz Cheney?! What an ultra PC-characterization. To start with, it looks to me like Cheney dyes her hair. She has very dark roots.

    How about "Indian Killary", "Killary Kaur", or "Nimrata Rodham-Haley?"

    Replies: @A123

    How about “Indian Killary”, “Killary Kaur”, or “Nimrata Rodham-Haley?”

    Trump grants your request. (1)

     

     

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.dailydot.com/debug/donald-trump-nikki-haley-hillary-clinton/

    • LOL: songbird
  908. @Mikel
    @A123

    Nice to see you quoting Massie (a DeSantis supporter). Perhaps little by little you'll come around to the saner side with the more intelligent people.

    This image from your link is quite hilarious too:

    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/fc196082782ad3b33dacd50100f34958f595d90fcc86319df3cdf4a2bf98f174.jpg?w=800&h=367

    But it was to be expected that the John Johnson/John Bolton/Nikki Haley branch of the conservatives would fight tooth and nail against the MAGA turn in the GOP with the big resources they have. Nothing surprising there. What's remarkable is how unsuccessful they've been so far. Out of the 3 candidates remaining, the top two ones are MAGA and so was the fourth one. That doesn't represent the power they still have in Congress and the party in general. But they try to convince us to give up and let Nikki be the only contender against Biden LOL.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @John Johnson

    The Daily Mail article on what a piece of work she is had 15 photos and every member of her family except her negro son-in-law. There are enough available that they probably did not have to photo-shop him out but I wonder how much of her publicity budget goes into editing photos that would be even more appealing without the big fellow.

  909. @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    What he wrote is basically correct. Leaders are given more leeway than people realize, if only because the context for their actions may be classified or simply barred from discussion. In those cases, defending their actions can be damaging to the office. This is not a failing of Trump, it is inherent with centralized authority. The situation is fuzzy in the US where the President is typically a mixture of figurehead and leader.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    What he wrote is basically correct. Leaders are given more leeway than people realize, if only because the context for their actions may be classified or simply barred from discussion.

    No he is not basically correct. Presidential powers are defined by the constitution and there is no right to immunity while in office.

    You think it is a good idea to give presidents criminal immunity while in office? What would stop them from putting hits on the competition?

    Trump is cracking up because his lawyers don’t have a plan for the documents case. He is trying a hail mary with presidential immunity.

    His lawyers keep quitting which is not a good sign. Lawyers quit when they think a case is not worth the money or if it will come with negative publicity from losing. Well Trump has plenty of money.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @John Johnson

    Yes, I see you are an expert. What does the Constitution say about executive orders?

  910. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. Hack

    No, it is not so easy.
    However, in CE Europe you must distinguish between the local Jewish communities and the Jewish organizations who are often run by transplants (chief rabbi of Poland is still American, after 30 years!) or by some rather narrow class of "political Jews" who are often unknown to normal Jews. In other words, there are Jewish organizations and there are Jews. I would bet that the former are ultimately run under the direction of false Jews. In Russia, Chabad build Jewish structures parallel to official ones, which certainly weren't anti-Putin. And Chabad is crypto-Sephardism (they follow Maimonides as Sephardim do and are obsessed with Moshiach) in Askhenazi world, thus I consider it false Judaism par excellence.

    But the most known American Jew living here in Poland, Anne Applebaum, who I see as 1-person Jewish organization, is staunchly pro-Ukrainian.

    It is conceivable that false Jews would support both sides of conflict in order to destroy ancient Jewish lands and force emigration to Israel. Well, USA, run partly by Jewish bankers, supported once build-up of both the Nazis and Bolsheviks (Sutton thesis etc.) in order to bring about the war of Gog (Germans) and Magog (Russsians)

    Hard to say for me how situation looks in USA. Israeli policy tried to be neutral, AFAIK.

    Historically speaking, neither Russia nor Ukraine were Jewish-friendly.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @LT1488, @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. Hack

    The Jewish people for a very long time have been an amalgamation of different tribes, political views, philosophic views, geographic orientations (Sephardic, Ashkenazi, Khazar, African) even religious orientations: orthodox, conservative and reform. In other words, a very representative type of world ethnos, really only differentiating themselves in that they also have their own unique religion (although many are apostates and have embraced secularism). You clearly reference the Phoenicians, Samaritans and Canaanites as being “false jews” even though all three of these sub-groups were semitic peoples in very close proximity to the original Biblical Jews and inhabiting the lands of modern-day Israel, and no longer exist as independent peoples today.

    Even the original Biblical Jews were comprised of 10 tribes often warring amongst themselves. There was the long-developed cleavage between Israel and Judah. How can anybody today claim to have the authority to be able to pronounce who is a “real Jew” and who is a “fake Jew”? Preposterous!

    BTW, you never directly answered my question whether Jews who become part of the “Jews for Jesus” movement lose their authenticity?

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. Hack

    I see you read OT as something that once was and is no more. If religion is just a historical tale, it is just that - the story about past, not present, and not future. I suppose it is hard to believe in contingent historical ecclectism. But you can LARP;)

    The Old Testament has a notion of Jew which is only fully understandable if you see it also as a certain set of genes. It is only in this sense that Jew can be told nowadays - from the OT perspective. As a religion, Judaism in the sense of Jahwism does not exist anymore. There is Talmudism, which is not really closer to ancient Judaism than Christianity. And here lies an answer to your question. In the OT religious sense Jews for Jesus do not lose authenticity because they don't have any to lose in the first place. In the Talmudic sense they do not lose authenticity too, since it depends on their mothers being Jewish.
    That we cannot say who is who re Jewish tribes now, is irrelevant since God can know - if only some of these people fathered children through generations.

    BTW, there were 12 Israeli tribes, not 10. Actually 13 because the tribe of Joseph divided into Ephraim and Manasseh. And they weren't fighting among themselves really often.
    For your info, the tribes of Dan, Benjamin, Ephraim and Manasseh could be somehow false or inherently idolatrous (remember that Rachel hid an idol once, and who were her sons?) - Dan and Ephraim are removed from the list of tribes to be saved in Revelation of St John - they even write about such things in modern academic publications about Bible.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Mr. Hack

    , @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. Hack

    Maybe your reading of Jews as just an amalgam of historical people is influenced by Christianity; since Christianity is open to all people, you want to see in such a light its predecessor too.

    BTW, labelling all people around Jews as Semites is a bit misleading, since it comes from language systematic, which is not a final judgement on genetics. But in the Biblical genealogy, Canaanites are Hamites, not Semites.

    , @Gerard1234
    @Mr. Hack

    And Jews who become Chief of Staff to President, President and Prime Minister of a fake country at the same time, on two DIFFERENT times in the last 5 years?
    LMAO!

  911. @Mikel
    @A123

    Nice to see you quoting Massie (a DeSantis supporter). Perhaps little by little you'll come around to the saner side with the more intelligent people.

    This image from your link is quite hilarious too:

    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/fc196082782ad3b33dacd50100f34958f595d90fcc86319df3cdf4a2bf98f174.jpg?w=800&h=367

    But it was to be expected that the John Johnson/John Bolton/Nikki Haley branch of the conservatives would fight tooth and nail against the MAGA turn in the GOP with the big resources they have. Nothing surprising there. What's remarkable is how unsuccessful they've been so far. Out of the 3 candidates remaining, the top two ones are MAGA and so was the fourth one. That doesn't represent the power they still have in Congress and the party in general. But they try to convince us to give up and let Nikki be the only contender against Biden LOL.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @John Johnson

    But it was to be expected that the John Johnson/John Bolton/Nikki Haley branch of the conservatives would fight tooth and nail against the MAGA turn in the GOP with the big resources they have.

    I’m not a conservative and posting my opinions is not fighting tooth and nail. I type around 80 wpm. If I really wanted to fight in politics I wouldn’t bother with an alternative website that is backlisted by the major search engines. Which means they intentionally bury the results even if it matches.

    What’s remarkable is how unsuccessful they’ve been so far. Out of the 3 candidates remaining, the top two ones are MAGA and so was the fourth one.

    Why is it surprising that DeSantis is still in the race? Do you not follow US politics? Let me point out an ongoing pattern for you:
    1. Democrats/Republicans rally around someone they like but polls poorly with independents and moderates
    2. Democrats/Republicans lose to the other guy and say WHAT HAPPENED
    3. Pollsters point out again that you have to win independents. You can’t just be popular with primary voters.
    4. Go to 1 in next election cause WE LIKE OUR GUY/GAL

    This happens all the time at both state and national level. Hillary Clinton is a good example. Feminists and liberals fawned over her but the polls said it was a bad idea to run her because of independents. Her fans didn’t care. They would see cheering crowds of women and think WE ARE DESTINED TO WIN. Trump fans do the same thing at their rallies. They are certain he will win and yet they told us that in the last election.

    Independents outnumber both Republicans and Democrats. The two parties constantly walk into a false dichotomy where they think the opposition is merely their opposite.

    • Replies: @A123
    @John Johnson

    What is even more predictable is when parties go against their base in an attempt to woe swing and independent voters.

    Do you remember when the GOP went with a Blue State Governor that appealed to independents? What was his name? Oh yes... Romney. He lost because he could not pull the Main Street Republican base.

    Do you remember when the GOP went with a maverick Senator that appealed to independents? What was his name? John McCain. He lost because he could not pull the Main Street Republican base.

    There is every reason to believe that squishy establishment choices, Haley and DeSantis, would follow the same pattern. Not only would they lose by generating low turnout for themselves, the lack of base voting would impact down ballot on other races.
    ___

    Look at the polls without cherry picking the establishment ones (1) (2). Trump and Haley are doing similarly with independents and swing voters. There is no reason to accept anything other than genuine MAGA/Trump with his high probability of victory.

    We get it. As an emotional #NeverTrump cultist your thinking is 100% consumed by your fear of his personality. For those of use who want MAGA policy, we opt for the best choice. If there was a better option than Trump, I would take it. However, in the 2024 cycle everyone with rudimentary intelligence and observational skills realizes that Trump is the best choice for MAGA.

    When the only other MAGA candidate, Vivek Ramaswamy, dropped out, who did he endorse? Because he cares about MAGA policy, he went with Trump.

    PEACE 😇
    ___________

    (1) https://www.realclearpolling.com/polls/president/general/2024/trump-vs-biden

    (2) https://www.realclearpolling.com/polls/president/general/2024/haley-vs-biden

    Replies: @John Johnson

    , @Mikel
    @John Johnson


    Why is it surprising that DeSantis is still in the race?
     
    I didn't say that there's anything surprising at all about DeSantis being still in a race that has just begun (thought it's you who thinks he should quit in favor of a candidate doing worse than him LOL). I said that it's remarkable how bad the people you would favor are doing in the primaries, given the balance of forces in the GOP.

    I understand the problem with the independents and the MSM-brainwashed crowd. As I said the other day, I find it very difficult to believe that Trump can win in November. But what you are proposing is even more insane than sticking to the candidates you like at this stage of the race. You're asking the leaders in the race to quit and give way to the one in a distant 3rd position because some polls a year before the elections say that she does better with independents. That's crazy even from a strategic point of view. Let alone form an ideological one.

    We all here understand why you want Nikki to be the next president. It's a logical choice from your point of view (or from AP's and Mr Hack's POV too). But, at most, I'd be willing to tolerate Trump or DeSantis choosing her as VP for electoral purposes and then locking her up in some White House closet for the following 4 years.

    Replies: @Beckow

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson


    This happens all the time at both state and national level. Hillary Clinton is a good example. Feminists and liberals fawned over her but the polls said it was a bad idea to run her because of independents. Her fans didn’t care. They would see cheering crowds of women and think WE ARE DESTINED TO WIN. Trump fans do the same thing at their rallies. They are certain he will win and yet they told us that in the last election.

     

    TBF, I think that Hillary would have fared better back in 2008 had she been the Democratic nominee back then relative to 2016. But of course she was less Woke back in 2008 relative to 2016 as well. And the GOP had a more conventional candidate (John McCain) that year. Trump was unconventional.
  912. @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ

    If you count the dead Austrian Nazis (also an 'occupied' country), why not the dead Sudeten Germans? The point is that these losses had an impact on post-WW2 economy - loss is a loss. Czechoslovakia, if one includes the 3 million expelled Germans, lost much bigger share of its population than Austria. You need to be consistent.

    If UK would tomorrow lose 20% of its population, wouldn't you expect that to impact their GNP?

    Replies: @AP

    The point is that these losses had an impact on post-WW2 economy – loss is a loss.

    This impact is irrelevant for he comparison, that begins in 1948, after the Germans were gone from Czechoslovakia.

    You were either too dumb and got caught in Gerard’s misdirection, or went along with it out of your dishonesty.

    If UK would tomorrow lose 20% of its population, wouldn’t you expect that to impact their GNP?

    Not necessarily per capita. The comparison was per capita.

    Economic performance of capitalist Austria vs. Socialist Czechoslovakia (and fascist Spain), 1948-1989 (end of failed Socialist experiment)

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.
    Spain: $2,186

    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Spain: $11,582.
    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @AP

    What is irrelevant is your constant changing of the rules and cherrypicking. One more time: Czechoslovakia lost 20% of its population in WW2, Austria didn't. Austria is neutral and was occupied until 1955, it has no military expenses (smart).

    Austria did the socialist housing, health, education, labor policies without the stupid restrictions and military spending - it was only possible because of the socialist threat across the border. Vienna in 1988 had about the same living standard as Prague but with more fizz. I has started to blossom in mid-90's - in part as a neutral intermediary. Austria has been very smart and is among the best countries in the world (maybe the best).

    You are using fake numbers from biased sources - it depends on how you define GNP - very different in socialism where many things are not monetised. And on excahnge rate used that is quite random and changes dramatically over time. What matters is material wealth and how people live. But you will never understand that.

    Replies: @AP

  913. @sudden death
    https://i.postimg.cc/WztTW8Jt/oewv.jpg

    https://yarotrof.com/assets/downloads/main/content/books/Our_Enemies_Will_Vanish/our-enemies-will-vanish-poster.jpg


    https://i.postimg.cc/5yQDQRC5/oewv2.jpg

    https://i.postimg.cc/T3QG6Bqh/oewv3.jpg

    Replies: @Gerard1234

    LMAO !! So there is you……….a worthless Black Russian POS, reading the book of a worthless POS western “journalist”, full of worthless POS, interviewing various psychotic worthless POS, talking worthless POS……all as a pathetic PR exercise of worthless POS……..so that a worthless Black Russian POS can be pumped full or more worthless POS, so that you can remain to live as you are………a worthless POS

    The military’s commander in chief, Zaluzhny, ordered units to disperse around the country, ostensibly for training exercises, and moved air-defence batteries and military aircraft from their bases to new, hidden locations

    Yes……in the cities,around tall buildings you dipshit are these “hidden locations” for the A-A complex!

    WHAT successes of their aircraft in the opening months did the Ukronazis have you imbecile? Hiding small numbers of aircraft has not been especially difficult for the last 90 years, soviets made plenty of installations to do this.

    I would add that Russia has gone 2 different periods in the last 10 months of going several months without ANY plane or helicopter losses. Considering the numbers of sorties flown each day, that is fenomenal.

    I was afraid that we would lose the element of surprise

    So this retard admits the obvious that they “created element of surprise”, i.e they got annihilated en masse……by deliberately not asking civilians to leave the cities or border regions, using them as civilian shields and or just killing them directly, embedding air-defence in the cities in or around high-rise buildings leaving huge numbers of people vulnerable, trying to claim that they were luring Russia into the cities etc. Incompetent, pussys, cowards and sadists!

    Anyway – an interview with the vatnik tramp Zaluzhny is irrelevant for what is a western operation.

    • Replies: @sudden death
    @Gerard1234


    embedding air-defence in the cities in or around high-rise buildings
     
    haha, despite it allegedly being done before 02.24 when there were enough RF lovers existing in those cities and no any restrictions for info spreading had been enabled yet, still for some reason no any single video/photo of such things has surfaced at the time?

    Not only UA army outsmarted poor old Putler, but they managed to make those air defense installations in the cities outright invisible, truly great job achieved then;)

  914. @songbird
    @Another Polish Perspective

    It is kind of interesting how vampires were aristocrats, when they were first popularized in the 19th century and in early film. Right when aristocrats were losing a lot of their power or seeing it decline in relative terms. Seems like there was definitely a class warfare aspect to it, though maybe, somewhat subtle.

    Have heard it claimed that the Vlad stuff started as German propaganda.

    I think the first written mention of a vampire comes from a Habsburg officer (winks at AP) observing Serb peasants in 1725.
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petar_Blagojevi%C4%87

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    I used to tease my Bukovinian/Ukrainian father about whether we had any vampires in our bloodline. Bukovina was very close to Transylvania after all. There were even some novels written back then about Dracula’s time in Lviv. Lucky me that my father had a good sense of humor. 🙂

    • Replies: @Gerard1234
    @Mr. Hack

    That's good Hack, it confirms that your real name is Iosif.......your father must have named you after the great man for taking Bukovina and reuniting Russian lands!

    Did he have the iconic moustache also?

    It does remind me that the Galician prostitute cuckholds had zero role and ideological pursuit in reuniting Northern Bukovina for "Ukraine". Zero role or connection with the slavs living on that land even during 1941-43 (except for killing Jews). Zero writing about it in their toilet paper "journals" or newspapers of the time. It just confirms that there is no "Ukraine" project, zero thing as a "Ukrainian nationalist".... only some anti-Russia freakshow done for interests of their Austrian/Polish/German..... and now also Anglo-Saxon, masters.

    There was zero necessity for this action, which was completely independent of Molotov-Ribbentropp as it was only Moldovan lands the Soviets were legally entitled to take...... which does just that Stalin is the great father of 404.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  915. @songbird
    @Mr. Hack

    What makes the anecdote particularly compelling, IMO, is the fact that his grandfather became a dropout to support his siblings, so he didn't have any sort of credentials.

    Have long been interested in what some of these tech billionaires say about IQ.

    Pretty sure that Bill Gates said something like, he wished he could give his prospective employees an IQ test, sometime in the '90s. Maybe, the lawyers got to him or something, but I never heard him talk about it later, even though Microsoft has or used to have these infamous tests for prospective employees, which involved very difficult puzzles. But politically, I think Gates comes from a left-wing family, so I imagine he can believe it, while saying nothing more about it, and even expressing strong contradictions.

    I've also been very interested in Musk's rhetoric over the years. I feel like he drops a lot of hints that he believes in politically incorrect ideas. But it is mostly very cagey and in a way that you have to ignore some things he says and read in-between the lines with others.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. Hack

    I would think that today, in an age when it’s hard to get young people to show up to work regularly, prospective employers have given up on entrance exams including very difficult puzzles. They’re probably more interested in solving the puzzle as to how to motivate the young loafers to showup to work by 9:00 am and coddle them to do so for 5 days a week. 🙂

    • Replies: @songbird
    @Mr. Hack


    They’re probably more interested in solving the puzzle as to how to motivate the young loafers to showup to work by 9:00 am and coddle them to do so for 5 days a week
     
    Almost sounds like you have someone particular in mind and you are doing their job, when they don't show up.

    I used to tease my Bukovinian/Ukrainian father about whether we had any vampires in our bloodline
     
    My hunch is that we are all descended from revenants of one kind or another. Men who, after they died, had big stones put in their mouth, or who didn't die after they received seven wounds in battle.

    https://youtube.com/shorts/bmzN35tn51Q?si=JzRK06DN600Z-t4c
  916. @Beckow
    @Mr. XYZ


    Austria had more deaths than Czechoslovakia during World War II:

    384,000 (Austria) vs. 345,000 (Czechoslovakia)

    Which makes it even more impressive since Austria had about two times less people than Czechoslovakia had and yet still had a higher death toll
     

    They were Nazis! Do you get that? Hitler and many leading Nazis were Austrian - they invaded countries like Russia and died in large numbers. That's what happens when you are a Nazi and lose...

    If you want to get "technical" there were 200k dead soldiers among 3 million Sudeten Germans from Czechoslovakia (plus an estimated 20k dead after the war) - add it up and it's almost even with Austria.

    But the point is that about 20% of Czechoslovakia where Sudeten Germans lived was totally depopulated with the Germans expelled (some of the main industrial areas) - that was a major drain on the economy. In spite of it GNP quadrupled in 40 years under the commies, population grew by half...(By the way, the expulsion was done by the democrat London based government with full Anglo support.)

    Austria was neutral and socialist (then and now), they did better. So? This is not about "what-if", it is about absolute results and at no point in Czechoslovakia history did the country do as well economically, demographically, culturally...

    (AP spouts cherrypicked nonsense and has no understanding of the context. He hides in minutia as all failed ideologues.)

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    But the point is that about 20% of Czechoslovakia where Sudeten Germans lived was totally depopulated with the Germans expelled (some of the main industrial areas) – that was a major drain on the economy.

    It was irrelevant to the comparison which begins in 1948, after the expulsion of the Germans.

    So even after the Germans had been expelled from Czechoslovakia, Czechoslovakia’s per capita GDP was slightly higher than Austria’s.

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.

    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768

    In spite of it GNP quadrupled in 40 years under the commies, population grew by half…

    So under socialism, GDP in Czechoslovakia doubled per capita over 40 years.

    Under capitalism, during the same period of time, GDP in Austria quintupled per capita over 40 years.

    So Socialism resulted in Czechoslovakia having half the GDP of Austria, half of what it should have had. It became a much poorer country whereas before socialism it had been slightly richer. Even under the Hapsburgs, the Czechs were not nearly as poor relative to Austrians as they became after 40 years of socialism under Moscow.

    Austria was neutral and socialist

    You demonstrate that you spent too much time in the USA, where leftists earnestly believe that Western Europeans have socialist economic systems. Austria was not socialist, it was a capitalist country with higher taxes and more social spending than the USA. But it had a market-driven economy, the means of production were not controlled by the state/socialist party.

    This reminds me of when the American politician Bernie Sanders kept referring to Denmark as a socialist country – the Danish PM had to correct him.

    https://www.vox.com/2015/10/31/9650030/denmark-prime-minister-bernie-sanders

    [MORE]

    Bernie Sanders has long referred to himself as a socialist rather than a member of the Democratic Party, which has naturally led to a lot of questions about what socialism means to him. He consistently references the social models of the Nordic states — especially Denmark — as his idea of what democratic socialism is all about. But in a speech Friday evening at Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government, Danish Prime Minister Lars Løkke Rasmussen said that while he’s flattered to see Denmark discussed in a widely watched US presidential debate he doesn’t think the socialist shoe fits.

    “I know that some people in the US associate the Nordic model with some sort of socialism,” he said. “Therefore, I would like to make one thing clear. Denmark is far from a socialist planned economy. Denmark is a market economy.”

    In Rasmussen’s view, “The Nordic model is an expanded welfare state which provides a high level of security to its citizens, but it is also a successful market economy with much freedom to pursue your dreams and live your life as you wish.”

    • Agree: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @AP
    @AP


    So under socialism, GDP in Czechoslovakia doubled per capita over 40 years.
     
    I was going with Beckow's numbers but the reality is that from 1948 to 1989 Czechoslovakia's GDP per capita nearly (but not quite ) tripled. Whereas Austria's more than quintupled. So still a huge discrepancy.
  917. @John Johnson
    @Mikel

    But it was to be expected that the John Johnson/John Bolton/Nikki Haley branch of the conservatives would fight tooth and nail against the MAGA turn in the GOP with the big resources they have.

    I'm not a conservative and posting my opinions is not fighting tooth and nail. I type around 80 wpm. If I really wanted to fight in politics I wouldn't bother with an alternative website that is backlisted by the major search engines. Which means they intentionally bury the results even if it matches.

    What’s remarkable is how unsuccessful they’ve been so far. Out of the 3 candidates remaining, the top two ones are MAGA and so was the fourth one.

    Why is it surprising that DeSantis is still in the race? Do you not follow US politics? Let me point out an ongoing pattern for you:
    1. Democrats/Republicans rally around someone they like but polls poorly with independents and moderates
    2. Democrats/Republicans lose to the other guy and say WHAT HAPPENED
    3. Pollsters point out again that you have to win independents. You can't just be popular with primary voters.
    4. Go to 1 in next election cause WE LIKE OUR GUY/GAL

    This happens all the time at both state and national level. Hillary Clinton is a good example. Feminists and liberals fawned over her but the polls said it was a bad idea to run her because of independents. Her fans didn't care. They would see cheering crowds of women and think WE ARE DESTINED TO WIN. Trump fans do the same thing at their rallies. They are certain he will win and yet they told us that in the last election.

    Independents outnumber both Republicans and Democrats. The two parties constantly walk into a false dichotomy where they think the opposition is merely their opposite.

    Replies: @A123, @Mikel, @Mr. XYZ

    What is even more predictable is when parties go against their base in an attempt to woe swing and independent voters.

    Do you remember when the GOP went with a Blue State Governor that appealed to independents? What was his name? Oh yes… Romney. He lost because he could not pull the Main Street Republican base.

    Do you remember when the GOP went with a maverick Senator that appealed to independents? What was his name? John McCain. He lost because he could not pull the Main Street Republican base.

    There is every reason to believe that squishy establishment choices, Haley and DeSantis, would follow the same pattern. Not only would they lose by generating low turnout for themselves, the lack of base voting would impact down ballot on other races.
    ___

    Look at the polls without cherry picking the establishment ones (1) (2). Trump and Haley are doing similarly with independents and swing voters. There is no reason to accept anything other than genuine MAGA/Trump with his high probability of victory.

    We get it. As an emotional #NeverTrump cultist your thinking is 100% consumed by your fear of his personality. For those of use who want MAGA policy, we opt for the best choice. If there was a better option than Trump, I would take it. However, in the 2024 cycle everyone with rudimentary intelligence and observational skills realizes that Trump is the best choice for MAGA.

    When the only other MAGA candidate, Vivek Ramaswamy, dropped out, who did he endorse? Because he cares about MAGA policy, he went with Trump.

    PEACE 😇
    ___________

    (1) https://www.realclearpolling.com/polls/president/general/2024/trump-vs-biden

    (2) https://www.realclearpolling.com/polls/president/general/2024/haley-vs-biden

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @A123

    Do you remember when the GOP went with a Blue State Governor that appealed to independents? What was his name? Oh yes… Romney. He lost because he could not pull the Main Street Republican base.

    He didn't lose mainstream Republicans.

    Romney lost because he ran his mouth on tape. His numbers dropped after the bar recording. He lost too many swing voters.

    He was also never a good mainstream candidate. Mainstream Christians don't trust Mormons and the GOP is probably ran by secular Whites as the seemed completely clueless to this aspect.

    The Mormon religion is offensive to mainstream protestants. It's heresy.

    Do you remember when the GOP went with a maverick Senator that appealed to independents? What was his name? John McCain. He lost because he could not pull the Main Street Republican base.

    McCain/Obama was not a normal election. People on both sides were voting based on race. I can pull Con Inc articles where they actually argue voting for the Democrat to "heal the nation" (appease Blacks). McCain's numbers dropped after he selected Palin. One of the worst VP picks of all time.

    There is every reason to believe that squishy establishment choices, Haley and DeSantis, would follow the same pattern. Not only would they lose by generating low turnout for themselves, the lack of base voting would impact down ballot on other races.

    I don't understand what you are saying. Haley polls well with moderate Republicans and independents.

    Let me ask you this question: Would an innocent man rant at 2AM about how presidential immunity should exist?

  918. @Mr. Hack
    @Another Polish Perspective

    The Jewish people for a very long time have been an amalgamation of different tribes, political views, philosophic views, geographic orientations (Sephardic, Ashkenazi, Khazar, African) even religious orientations: orthodox, conservative and reform. In other words, a very representative type of world ethnos, really only differentiating themselves in that they also have their own unique religion (although many are apostates and have embraced secularism). You clearly reference the Phoenicians, Samaritans and Canaanites as being "false jews" even though all three of these sub-groups were semitic peoples in very close proximity to the original Biblical Jews and inhabiting the lands of modern-day Israel, and no longer exist as independent peoples today.

    Even the original Biblical Jews were comprised of 10 tribes often warring amongst themselves. There was the long-developed cleavage between Israel and Judah. How can anybody today claim to have the authority to be able to pronounce who is a "real Jew" and who is a "fake Jew"? Preposterous!

    BTW, you never directly answered my question whether Jews who become part of the "Jews for Jesus" movement lose their authenticity?

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Another Polish Perspective, @Gerard1234

    I see you read OT as something that once was and is no more. If religion is just a historical tale, it is just that – the story about past, not present, and not future. I suppose it is hard to believe in contingent historical ecclectism. But you can LARP;)

    The Old Testament has a notion of Jew which is only fully understandable if you see it also as a certain set of genes. It is only in this sense that Jew can be told nowadays – from the OT perspective. As a religion, Judaism in the sense of Jahwism does not exist anymore. There is Talmudism, which is not really closer to ancient Judaism than Christianity. And here lies an answer to your question. In the OT religious sense Jews for Jesus do not lose authenticity because they don’t have any to lose in the first place. In the Talmudic sense they do not lose authenticity too, since it depends on their mothers being Jewish.
    That we cannot say who is who re Jewish tribes now, is irrelevant since God can know – if only some of these people fathered children through generations.

    BTW, there were 12 Israeli tribes, not 10. Actually 13 because the tribe of Joseph divided into Ephraim and Manasseh. And they weren’t fighting among themselves really often.
    For your info, the tribes of Dan, Benjamin, Ephraim and Manasseh could be somehow false or inherently idolatrous (remember that Rachel hid an idol once, and who were her sons?) – Dan and Ephraim are removed from the list of tribes to be saved in Revelation of St John – they even write about such things in modern academic publications about Bible.

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Another Polish Perspective

    Good grief you know a lot about Jews. I was taught that Poland had exterminated all of theirs. Anyway I agree that virtually everybody I have ever known thought they had Jews figured out by age 15 or and they never had to bother learning one more thing.

    Have you ever read Michael Hoffman's 1000 pp summary of the Talmud? I gave up around p. 500 and I started skimming quick long before I got to there.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Mr. XYZ

    , @Mr. Hack
    @Another Polish Perspective


    I see you read OT as something that once was and is no more. If religion is just a historical tale, it is just that – the story about past, not present, and not future. I suppose it is hard to believe in contingent historical ecclectism. But you can LARP;)
     
    Who's larping here? You're reading things into my commentary that I never wrote, nor implied. I view the OT as being very important, not the least being the many allusions to the coming of the messiah Our Lord Jesus Christ within its written pages.

    The Old Testament has a notion of Jew which is only fully understandable if you see it also as a certain set of genes. It is only in this sense that Jew can be told nowadays – from the OT perspective.
     
    So apparently the "real Jews" share a unique genetic code? Has it been located and formulized yet? I think not, because you go on to state:

    hat we cannot say who is who re Jewish tribes now, is irrelevant since God can know – if only some of these people fathered children through generations.
     
    So if only God can know with any ceertainty (and perhaps kremlinstoogeA123), why are we even having this discussion anyway? Your guess is as good as mine, or anybody else's.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Another Polish Perspective, @Sher Singh

  919. @AP
    @Gerard1234


    Of the three post-war economic systems in Europe (Euro-capitalist, Socialist, and semi-fascist), Socialist was the least successful.

    Of course this is a nonsense statement. The salary numbers are stupid and You’re comparing countries that didn’t suffer much or at all in WW2………with the majority of countries that did you imbecile.
     
    Austria had more deaths than Czechoslovakia during World War II:

    https://www.nationalww2museum.org/students-teachers/student-resources/research-starters/research-starters-worldwide-deaths-world-war

    384,000 (Austria) vs. 345,000 (Czechoslovakia)


    Countries that had access to money from untouched or relatively untouched by WW2 American, British, French, Scandinavian money/loans and investments
     
    This wouldn't explain the fact that the Socialist counties kept falling further and further behind, even decades after the war ended.

    Then you look at the global trade issue – British, French, American, Belgian scum etc were able to immediately take private ownership of the natural resources of these countries in Africa and Asia that declared themselves “independent”. Those new Independent countries that wanted control of their own resources and nationalised companies for them, were either Marxist or Soviet sympathetic……..and western scum ensured they f**ked up these countries
     
    All those countries got richer when they dropped Socialism.

    It’s obvious that with those disadvantages, the communist system did a brilliant and very successful job – defeated those facist and euro-capitalist countries in many aspects
     
    They won the competition for ugly and small housing.

    As for the idiotic comparison with Spain and Portugal – both countries untouched by WW2
     
    You are unaware of the fact that Spain had a bloody civil war.

    About 500,000 died in Spain during the Civil War.

    And it surpassed Commie central Europe long after Word War II anyways.


    .and tourism is at least 10% of each of those countries GDP
     
    Tourism doesn't count as "capitalism" now?

    If you are going to play this game, exclude oil and coal from your calculations.


    Austria now became not only the richest of the three former Hapsburg countries, but doubled the ones that got stuck under Communism. This is the most relevant comparison because these three countries are geographically close, and culturally and historically similar.

    Austria was much richer than what is stated in that fake link
     

    Link for economic data was to Maddison project, hosted by University of Groningen:

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.
    Hungary: $2,200.
    Spain: $2,186
    Portugal: $2,046

    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Spain: $11,582.
    Portugal: $10,372

    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768
    Hungary: $6,903.


    Austria did not suffer under the Nazi’s like the Czechs, didn’t degermanify, had no sudden switch from one system to the other.
     
    Austria lost more people during World War II - lots of productive young men who were killed during the war.

    So in 1948 Austria was poorer than Czechoslovakia.

    In 1989 after Czechoslovakia languished under Socialism and Austria enjoyed capitalism for 40 years, Austria was about 2x richer.


    As I said, for over half a millenium Austrian land has been wealthier than what is now Czech and Hungarian land.
     
    Not by much.

    In 1890, the per capita product, in 2010 dollars, in Austria was $3,005 and in Bohemia was $2,513.

    It wasn't twice richer. Only after Socialism did Austria become twice richer than Bohemia.


    Hungary and particularly Czechs had large removal of german population after WW2. To anybody with a brain, the german factor is critical
     
    It's funny that a Sovok untermench such as you considers Germans to be ubermenschen.

    Czechoslovakia lost Germans but also lost Carpathian Ruthenians, who were very poor (until recently their province was the poorest one in Ukraine).

    And anyways that loss of Germans would not explain how Czechoslovakia went from being richer than Austria in 1948 (the Germans were gone by then) to having only half the GDP of Austria in 1989.


    20th century socialism, CLEARLY is reponsible for Israeli tech sector you dipshit. 1990s economic growth and IT development in western economies is partially explained by ideas, human capital and other resources from Eastern Bloc after communist collapse
     
    Not in your case, of course.

    The socialist system could indeed train some smart people. It also kept them poor and short-lived. But they could use their skills to good effect in a non-socialist environment.


    Americans hate feudal societies. They sometimes like the British royal family but that’s ust celebrity worship. They only like the rich who talk like them and act like them. You are clueless as usual.

    Nonsense, Beckow is correct. Kennedy family , Bush family, ( if he wasn’t such another american sleazebag) then Clinton family.

     

    JFK was 60 years ago. Dubya Bush pretended to be a Texas redneck. "Bubba" Clinton acted like an Arkansas "good ole boy." Obama who went to elite schools and was raised by rich white family members puts on a fake African-American accent.

    Americans dislike elites so much, that the elites have to pretend not to be elites.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Gerard1234

    Austria had more deaths than Czechoslovakia during World War II:

    I wrote “suffered under the Nazis”, dickhead. The death issue is relevant, but the suffering refers to being taken over against their wishes…..(totally different to Austria),and all the reprisals, massacres, tortures, arrests, zero control that go with this. In addition I could add the seizure and total change and reorientation of the Czechs massive industrial capacity, essential to most of the Nazis military-industrial output……that Austrian economy would not have had to be faced with to the same level. But the main thing when I write about suffer is “taken over against their wishes”. I have been to the museum in Prague about this – the Nazi section is about a million times worse than whatever they are claiming about the Soviets – I was surprised how mild it was towards the USSR, in view of all their post 1991 lies and BS.

    So in 1948 Austria was poorer than Czechoslovakia.
    In 1890, the per capita product, in 2010 dollars, in Austria was $3,005 and in Bohemia was $2,513.

    Nonsense and more nonsense. Austria always regarded by me and commonly perceived in USSR to be one of , if not the richest place in Europe. Historically and then.

    Not in your case, of course.

    A bizarre, idiotic and nonsensical statement from yourself, as usual.

    JFK was 60 years ago.

    And he followed his very rich and powerful father who was high profile Ambassador and politician – who helped bribe or cheat one of the states into helping his son win either the state Governor or Presidential election. His 2 other brothers very high profile politicians ( one of the idiot Bidens son’s even Attorney-General for one of the states, LOL). JFK’s son highly possible would have continued this trend ( and had masses of lazy, fat americans voting for him) if he did not die in plane crash.

    Bubba” Clinton acted like an Arkansas “good ole boy.

    He’s the starting point, so doesn’t classify. What does is his wife, and the suspicion that probably his daughter if he wasn’t such a sleazebag so as to discredit her

    Dubya Bush pretended to be a Texas redneck.

    Americans too dumb to realise he wasn’t the son of a President and head of CIA????!!!! Or that his brother was Florida governor and was strongly favourite to be his party’s president nomination before Trump is a very amusing way humiliated him with jokes?

    Obama who went to elite schools and was raised by rich white family members puts on a fake African-American accent.

    Americans dislike elites so much, that the elites have to pretend not to be elites.

    Nonsense. All western politicians fake to some level. There are millions of middle-class Black-Americans, or many lower-class blacks who have become rich and or educated, or are even involved in American politics now who could have been promoted as candidate. That it was Obama is highly indicative of the feudal-type worship Beckow was talking of.

    Obama also had large amount of his childhood living in Indonesia and his father is Kenya, not African-American. African-Americans too dumb to realise he is not one of them?
    They did the same with Rodney King and this Floyd guy…….it doesn’t necessarily indicate that they love the criminal scumbag violent rapists and drug-dealing drug-driving losers…. but corrupt circumstances and mass manipulations result in these creeps being the conduit for whatever thing they are advocating.

    The socialist system could indeed train some smart people. It also kept them poor and short-lived.

    LMAO – Cuba,life expectancy better than Americans. As for “short-lived” – not so much for women, not for the first 25-30 years of socialism. “Poor” is also nonsense. Drinking more spirits instead of wine or beer one thing to consider.

    It’s funny that a Sovok untermench such as you considers Germans to be ubermenschen.

    Thats just you projecting what ACTUAL galician inbred/iodine-deficient lowlife “nationalists” are projecting between themselves. Germans have to be respected for what they have done over the centuries, that wasn’t evil, sadistic and mass murder. Czechoslovakia expelled 3 million of them.

    Tourism doesn’t count as “capitalism” now?
    If you are going to play this game, exclude oil and coal from your calculations.

    Russia sold plenty of this oil and coal and gas etc to the west, so now I won’t exclude from these calculations. Forgetting about the Canary Islands and other places……is there a sane person who would choose holiday in Warsaw over Barcelona, LOL.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Gerard1234


    I wrote “suffered under the Nazis”, dickhead.
     
    You wrote:

    "You’re comparing countries that didn’t suffer much or at all in WW2"

    Sovok can't read. Sovok only writes. Remember the famous Chukchi joke?

    The death issue is relevant, but the suffering refers to being taken over against their wishes…..(totally different to Austria),and all the reprisals, massacres, tortures, arrests, zero control that go with this. In addition I could add the seizure and total change and reorientation of the Czechs massive industrial capacity, essential to most of the Nazis military-industrial output……that Austrian economy would not have had to be faced with to the same level
     
    This is all misdirection, this all happened before 1948.

    By 1948, Czechoslovakia had a higher per capita GDP than Austria.

    And then Socialism happened.

    After 40 years of the failed Socialist experiment, Austria had nearly twice the per capita GDP of Czechoslovakia.

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.

    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768

    In 1890, the per capita product, in 2010 dollars, in Austria was $3,005 and in Bohemia was $2,513.

    Nonsense and more nonsense. Austria always regarded by me and commonly perceived in USSR to be one of , if not the richest place in Europe.
     
    Sovoks don't know history, just as they don't know math.

    In 1890 UK's per capita GDP was $6,228 - twice Austria's.

    Dubya Bush pretended to be a Texas redneck.

    Americans too dumb to realise he wasn’t the son of a President and head of CIA?
     
    They didn't care about that, they cared about his acting like a Texas redneck, and they liked that. They like Trump's act too.

    The socialist system could indeed train some smart people. It also kept them poor and short-lived.

    LMAO – Cuba,life expectancy better than Americans.
     
    That's because Americans are overweight and many of them shoot one another.

    Better compare Czechia to Austria.

    https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.LE00.IN?locations=CZ-AT

    Czechoslovakia: 7o in 1960, 72 in 1989.

    Austria: 69 in 1960, 75 in 1989.

    “Poor” is also nonsense.
     
    Czechs had half the per capita GDP of Austrians in 1989.

    Replies: @Derer

  920. Vivek appeared on the Friday Night Tights stream yesterday. No one likes the M-SHE-U and its negative impact on popular culture.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @A123

    Who cares about the MCU and Jewish Hollywood in general anyway. It's all goyslop to distract the goyim from real issues such as mass immigration and neocon wars.

    Replies: @songbird

    , @LT1488
    @A123

    Who cares about MCU and Hollywood anyways? It's just goyslop to distract the goyim from real issues like mass immigration and neocon wars.

    , @LondonBob
    @A123

    Vivek reminds me of the Indian character in Mean Girls.

    Give him credit he knows what to say, and people seem to buy it, but he is the great replacement personified.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  921. @Mr. Hack
    @Another Polish Perspective

    The Jewish people for a very long time have been an amalgamation of different tribes, political views, philosophic views, geographic orientations (Sephardic, Ashkenazi, Khazar, African) even religious orientations: orthodox, conservative and reform. In other words, a very representative type of world ethnos, really only differentiating themselves in that they also have their own unique religion (although many are apostates and have embraced secularism). You clearly reference the Phoenicians, Samaritans and Canaanites as being "false jews" even though all three of these sub-groups were semitic peoples in very close proximity to the original Biblical Jews and inhabiting the lands of modern-day Israel, and no longer exist as independent peoples today.

    Even the original Biblical Jews were comprised of 10 tribes often warring amongst themselves. There was the long-developed cleavage between Israel and Judah. How can anybody today claim to have the authority to be able to pronounce who is a "real Jew" and who is a "fake Jew"? Preposterous!

    BTW, you never directly answered my question whether Jews who become part of the "Jews for Jesus" movement lose their authenticity?

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Another Polish Perspective, @Gerard1234

    Maybe your reading of Jews as just an amalgam of historical people is influenced by Christianity; since Christianity is open to all people, you want to see in such a light its predecessor too.

    BTW, labelling all people around Jews as Semites is a bit misleading, since it comes from language systematic, which is not a final judgement on genetics. But in the Biblical genealogy, Canaanites are Hamites, not Semites.

  922. @John Johnson
    @QCIC

    What he wrote is basically correct. Leaders are given more leeway than people realize, if only because the context for their actions may be classified or simply barred from discussion.

    No he is not basically correct. Presidential powers are defined by the constitution and there is no right to immunity while in office.

    You think it is a good idea to give presidents criminal immunity while in office? What would stop them from putting hits on the competition?

    Trump is cracking up because his lawyers don't have a plan for the documents case. He is trying a hail mary with presidential immunity.

    His lawyers keep quitting which is not a good sign. Lawyers quit when they think a case is not worth the money or if it will come with negative publicity from losing. Well Trump has plenty of money.

    Replies: @QCIC

    Yes, I see you are an expert. What does the Constitution say about executive orders?

  923. @AP
    @Beckow


    But the point is that about 20% of Czechoslovakia where Sudeten Germans lived was totally depopulated with the Germans expelled (some of the main industrial areas) – that was a major drain on the economy.
     
    It was irrelevant to the comparison which begins in 1948, after the expulsion of the Germans.

    So even after the Germans had been expelled from Czechoslovakia, Czechoslovakia's per capita GDP was slightly higher than Austria's.

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.


    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768

    In spite of it GNP quadrupled in 40 years under the commies, population grew by half…
     
    So under socialism, GDP in Czechoslovakia doubled per capita over 40 years.

    Under capitalism, during the same period of time, GDP in Austria quintupled per capita over 40 years.

    So Socialism resulted in Czechoslovakia having half the GDP of Austria, half of what it should have had. It became a much poorer country whereas before socialism it had been slightly richer. Even under the Hapsburgs, the Czechs were not nearly as poor relative to Austrians as they became after 40 years of socialism under Moscow.

    Austria was neutral and socialist
     
    You demonstrate that you spent too much time in the USA, where leftists earnestly believe that Western Europeans have socialist economic systems. Austria was not socialist, it was a capitalist country with higher taxes and more social spending than the USA. But it had a market-driven economy, the means of production were not controlled by the state/socialist party.

    This reminds me of when the American politician Bernie Sanders kept referring to Denmark as a socialist country - the Danish PM had to correct him.

    https://www.vox.com/2015/10/31/9650030/denmark-prime-minister-bernie-sanders



    Bernie Sanders has long referred to himself as a socialist rather than a member of the Democratic Party, which has naturally led to a lot of questions about what socialism means to him. He consistently references the social models of the Nordic states — especially Denmark — as his idea of what democratic socialism is all about. But in a speech Friday evening at Harvard's Kennedy School of Government, Danish Prime Minister Lars Løkke Rasmussen said that while he's flattered to see Denmark discussed in a widely watched US presidential debate he doesn't think the socialist shoe fits.

    "I know that some people in the US associate the Nordic model with some sort of socialism," he said. "Therefore, I would like to make one thing clear. Denmark is far from a socialist planned economy. Denmark is a market economy."

    In Rasmussen's view, "The Nordic model is an expanded welfare state which provides a high level of security to its citizens, but it is also a successful market economy with much freedom to pursue your dreams and live your life as you wish."

    Replies: @AP

    So under socialism, GDP in Czechoslovakia doubled per capita over 40 years.

    I was going with Beckow’s numbers but the reality is that from 1948 to 1989 Czechoslovakia’s GDP per capita nearly (but not quite ) tripled. Whereas Austria’s more than quintupled. So still a huge discrepancy.

  924. @Gerard1234
    @AP


    Austria had more deaths than Czechoslovakia during World War II:
     
    I wrote "suffered under the Nazis", dickhead. The death issue is relevant, but the suffering refers to being taken over against their wishes.....(totally different to Austria),and all the reprisals, massacres, tortures, arrests, zero control that go with this. In addition I could add the seizure and total change and reorientation of the Czechs massive industrial capacity, essential to most of the Nazis military-industrial output......that Austrian economy would not have had to be faced with to the same level. But the main thing when I write about suffer is "taken over against their wishes". I have been to the museum in Prague about this - the Nazi section is about a million times worse than whatever they are claiming about the Soviets - I was surprised how mild it was towards the USSR, in view of all their post 1991 lies and BS.

    So in 1948 Austria was poorer than Czechoslovakia.
    In 1890, the per capita product, in 2010 dollars, in Austria was $3,005 and in Bohemia was $2,513.
     
    Nonsense and more nonsense. Austria always regarded by me and commonly perceived in USSR to be one of , if not the richest place in Europe. Historically and then.

    Not in your case, of course.
     
    A bizarre, idiotic and nonsensical statement from yourself, as usual.


    JFK was 60 years ago.
     
    And he followed his very rich and powerful father who was high profile Ambassador and politician - who helped bribe or cheat one of the states into helping his son win either the state Governor or Presidential election. His 2 other brothers very high profile politicians ( one of the idiot Bidens son's even Attorney-General for one of the states, LOL). JFK's son highly possible would have continued this trend ( and had masses of lazy, fat americans voting for him) if he did not die in plane crash.


    Bubba” Clinton acted like an Arkansas “good ole boy.
     
    He's the starting point, so doesn't classify. What does is his wife, and the suspicion that probably his daughter if he wasn't such a sleazebag so as to discredit her

    Dubya Bush pretended to be a Texas redneck.
     
    Americans too dumb to realise he wasn't the son of a President and head of CIA????!!!! Or that his brother was Florida governor and was strongly favourite to be his party's president nomination before Trump is a very amusing way humiliated him with jokes?

    Obama who went to elite schools and was raised by rich white family members puts on a fake African-American accent.

    Americans dislike elites so much, that the elites have to pretend not to be elites.
     
    Nonsense. All western politicians fake to some level. There are millions of middle-class Black-Americans, or many lower-class blacks who have become rich and or educated, or are even involved in American politics now who could have been promoted as candidate. That it was Obama is highly indicative of the feudal-type worship Beckow was talking of.

    Obama also had large amount of his childhood living in Indonesia and his father is Kenya, not African-American. African-Americans too dumb to realise he is not one of them?
    They did the same with Rodney King and this Floyd guy.......it doesn't necessarily indicate that they love the criminal scumbag violent rapists and drug-dealing drug-driving losers.... but corrupt circumstances and mass manipulations result in these creeps being the conduit for whatever thing they are advocating.

    The socialist system could indeed train some smart people. It also kept them poor and short-lived.
     
    LMAO - Cuba,life expectancy better than Americans. As for "short-lived" - not so much for women, not for the first 25-30 years of socialism. "Poor" is also nonsense. Drinking more spirits instead of wine or beer one thing to consider.


    It’s funny that a Sovok untermench such as you considers Germans to be ubermenschen.
     
    Thats just you projecting what ACTUAL galician inbred/iodine-deficient lowlife "nationalists" are projecting between themselves. Germans have to be respected for what they have done over the centuries, that wasn't evil, sadistic and mass murder. Czechoslovakia expelled 3 million of them.

    Tourism doesn’t count as “capitalism” now?
    If you are going to play this game, exclude oil and coal from your calculations.
     
    Russia sold plenty of this oil and coal and gas etc to the west, so now I won't exclude from these calculations. Forgetting about the Canary Islands and other places......is there a sane person who would choose holiday in Warsaw over Barcelona, LOL.

    Replies: @AP

    I wrote “suffered under the Nazis”, dickhead.

    You wrote:

    “You’re comparing countries that didn’t suffer much or at all in WW2”

    Sovok can’t read. Sovok only writes. Remember the famous Chukchi joke?

    The death issue is relevant, but the suffering refers to being taken over against their wishes…..(totally different to Austria),and all the reprisals, massacres, tortures, arrests, zero control that go with this. In addition I could add the seizure and total change and reorientation of the Czechs massive industrial capacity, essential to most of the Nazis military-industrial output……that Austrian economy would not have had to be faced with to the same level

    This is all misdirection, this all happened before 1948.

    By 1948, Czechoslovakia had a higher per capita GDP than Austria.

    And then Socialism happened.

    After 40 years of the failed Socialist experiment, Austria had nearly twice the per capita GDP of Czechoslovakia.

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.

    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768

    In 1890, the per capita product, in 2010 dollars, in Austria was $3,005 and in Bohemia was $2,513.

    Nonsense and more nonsense. Austria always regarded by me and commonly perceived in USSR to be one of , if not the richest place in Europe.

    Sovoks don’t know history, just as they don’t know math.

    In 1890 UK’s per capita GDP was $6,228 – twice Austria’s.

    Dubya Bush pretended to be a Texas redneck.

    Americans too dumb to realise he wasn’t the son of a President and head of CIA?

    They didn’t care about that, they cared about his acting like a Texas redneck, and they liked that. They like Trump’s act too.

    The socialist system could indeed train some smart people. It also kept them poor and short-lived.

    LMAO – Cuba,life expectancy better than Americans.

    That’s because Americans are overweight and many of them shoot one another.

    Better compare Czechia to Austria.

    https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.LE00.IN?locations=CZ-AT

    Czechoslovakia: 7o in 1960, 72 in 1989.

    Austria: 69 in 1960, 75 in 1989.

    “Poor” is also nonsense.

    Czechs had half the per capita GDP of Austrians in 1989.

    • Replies: @Derer
    @AP


    After 40 years of the failed Socialist experiment, Austria had nearly twice the per capita GDP of Czechoslovakia.
     
    Caused by deliberate and artificially low exchange rate (not by trade) for the Iron curtain countries. What about Marshal Plan factor? Next time, used some more sophisticated analysis to improve your dismal high school term paper.

    Replies: @AP

  925. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. Hack

    I see you read OT as something that once was and is no more. If religion is just a historical tale, it is just that - the story about past, not present, and not future. I suppose it is hard to believe in contingent historical ecclectism. But you can LARP;)

    The Old Testament has a notion of Jew which is only fully understandable if you see it also as a certain set of genes. It is only in this sense that Jew can be told nowadays - from the OT perspective. As a religion, Judaism in the sense of Jahwism does not exist anymore. There is Talmudism, which is not really closer to ancient Judaism than Christianity. And here lies an answer to your question. In the OT religious sense Jews for Jesus do not lose authenticity because they don't have any to lose in the first place. In the Talmudic sense they do not lose authenticity too, since it depends on their mothers being Jewish.
    That we cannot say who is who re Jewish tribes now, is irrelevant since God can know - if only some of these people fathered children through generations.

    BTW, there were 12 Israeli tribes, not 10. Actually 13 because the tribe of Joseph divided into Ephraim and Manasseh. And they weren't fighting among themselves really often.
    For your info, the tribes of Dan, Benjamin, Ephraim and Manasseh could be somehow false or inherently idolatrous (remember that Rachel hid an idol once, and who were her sons?) - Dan and Ephraim are removed from the list of tribes to be saved in Revelation of St John - they even write about such things in modern academic publications about Bible.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Mr. Hack

    Good grief you know a lot about Jews. I was taught that Poland had exterminated all of theirs. Anyway I agree that virtually everybody I have ever known thought they had Jews figured out by age 15 or and they never had to bother learning one more thing.

    Have you ever read Michael Hoffman’s 1000 pp summary of the Talmud? I gave up around p. 500 and I started skimming quick long before I got to there.

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    Anyway I agree that virtually everybody I have ever known thought they had Jews figured out by age 15 or and they never had to bother learning one more thing.
     
    This is true and yet surprising if you know that Nazis themselves were really into Judenkunde. They even proposed to Majer Bałaban, a Polish-Jewish historian of Jews, exemption from sanctions on Jews (ban on public libraries, staying in ghetto etc) so he could end writing his history of Jews in Kraków.

    Have you ever read Michael Hoffman’s 1000 pp summary of the Talmud? I gave up around p. 500 and I started skimming quick long before I got to there.
     
    No, no really. But his "Occult Reneissance" is on the right track. Talmud is hard to read if you like to read books in one go... I wait when the translation will appear designed in the way Talmud is studied and some Jewish editions are printed: a fragment of Talmud in the middle of page, and most important rabbinic commentaries referring to this fragment around on the margins.

    BTW, Poles did not exterminate Jews. Germans did.

    Replies: @Greasy William

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    I was taught that Poland had exterminated all of theirs.
     
    Poland didn't. Rather, Nazi Germans did so (well, for 90% of Polish Jewry) on Polish soil.
  926. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Another Polish Perspective

    Good grief you know a lot about Jews. I was taught that Poland had exterminated all of theirs. Anyway I agree that virtually everybody I have ever known thought they had Jews figured out by age 15 or and they never had to bother learning one more thing.

    Have you ever read Michael Hoffman's 1000 pp summary of the Talmud? I gave up around p. 500 and I started skimming quick long before I got to there.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Mr. XYZ

    Anyway I agree that virtually everybody I have ever known thought they had Jews figured out by age 15 or and they never had to bother learning one more thing.

    This is true and yet surprising if you know that Nazis themselves were really into Judenkunde. They even proposed to Majer Bałaban, a Polish-Jewish historian of Jews, exemption from sanctions on Jews (ban on public libraries, staying in ghetto etc) so he could end writing his history of Jews in Kraków.

    Have you ever read Michael Hoffman’s 1000 pp summary of the Talmud? I gave up around p. 500 and I started skimming quick long before I got to there.

    No, no really. But his “Occult Reneissance” is on the right track. Talmud is hard to read if you like to read books in one go… I wait when the translation will appear designed in the way Talmud is studied and some Jewish editions are printed: a fragment of Talmud in the middle of page, and most important rabbinic commentaries referring to this fragment around on the margins.

    BTW, Poles did not exterminate Jews. Germans did.

    • Replies: @Greasy William
    @Another Polish Perspective


    BTW, Poles did not exterminate Jews. Germans did.
     
    The Polish people enthusiastically collaborated with the Holocaust every step of the way. The AK murdered more Jews during the Warsaw Uprising than the Nazis did. Poland was the only country in Europe to have a pogrom post war. Poland also expelled it's remaining Jews in the 1960's, something even the Hungarians and Romanians (nations who were certainly no lovers of the Jewish people) didn't do

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Another Polish Perspective

  927. @AP
    @Gerard1234


    I wrote “suffered under the Nazis”, dickhead.
     
    You wrote:

    "You’re comparing countries that didn’t suffer much or at all in WW2"

    Sovok can't read. Sovok only writes. Remember the famous Chukchi joke?

    The death issue is relevant, but the suffering refers to being taken over against their wishes…..(totally different to Austria),and all the reprisals, massacres, tortures, arrests, zero control that go with this. In addition I could add the seizure and total change and reorientation of the Czechs massive industrial capacity, essential to most of the Nazis military-industrial output……that Austrian economy would not have had to be faced with to the same level
     
    This is all misdirection, this all happened before 1948.

    By 1948, Czechoslovakia had a higher per capita GDP than Austria.

    And then Socialism happened.

    After 40 years of the failed Socialist experiment, Austria had nearly twice the per capita GDP of Czechoslovakia.

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.

    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768

    In 1890, the per capita product, in 2010 dollars, in Austria was $3,005 and in Bohemia was $2,513.

    Nonsense and more nonsense. Austria always regarded by me and commonly perceived in USSR to be one of , if not the richest place in Europe.
     
    Sovoks don't know history, just as they don't know math.

    In 1890 UK's per capita GDP was $6,228 - twice Austria's.

    Dubya Bush pretended to be a Texas redneck.

    Americans too dumb to realise he wasn’t the son of a President and head of CIA?
     
    They didn't care about that, they cared about his acting like a Texas redneck, and they liked that. They like Trump's act too.

    The socialist system could indeed train some smart people. It also kept them poor and short-lived.

    LMAO – Cuba,life expectancy better than Americans.
     
    That's because Americans are overweight and many of them shoot one another.

    Better compare Czechia to Austria.

    https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.LE00.IN?locations=CZ-AT

    Czechoslovakia: 7o in 1960, 72 in 1989.

    Austria: 69 in 1960, 75 in 1989.

    “Poor” is also nonsense.
     
    Czechs had half the per capita GDP of Austrians in 1989.

    Replies: @Derer

    After 40 years of the failed Socialist experiment, Austria had nearly twice the per capita GDP of Czechoslovakia.

    Caused by deliberate and artificially low exchange rate (not by trade) for the Iron curtain countries. What about Marshal Plan factor? Next time, used some more sophisticated analysis to improve your dismal high school term paper.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Derer


    After 40 years of the failed Socialist experiment, Austria had nearly twice the per capita GDP of Czechoslovakia.

    Caused by deliberate and artificially low exchange rate
     
    Did that also cause the dearth of consumer goods (Austrians had twice as many cars per capita than Czechs)?

    What about Marshal Plan factor?
     
    What about it? Czechoslovakia kept falling further and further behind long after the Marshall Plan ended.

    Replies: @Derer

  928. Battle of the Nations
    Czechia Poland

    [MORE]

    Unseeded and ranked #50 takes out number one. Swiatek played well to go by the highlights but it was Czechia’s day. She cries a lot at the end!

  929. @AP
    @Beckow


    The point is that these losses had an impact on post-WW2 economy – loss is a loss.
     
    This impact is irrelevant for he comparison, that begins in 1948, after the Germans were gone from Czechoslovakia.

    You were either too dumb and got caught in Gerard's misdirection, or went along with it out of your dishonesty.

    If UK would tomorrow lose 20% of its population, wouldn’t you expect that to impact their GNP?
     
    Not necessarily per capita. The comparison was per capita.

    Economic performance of capitalist Austria vs. Socialist Czechoslovakia (and fascist Spain), 1948-1989 (end of failed Socialist experiment)

    https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/original-maddison

    In 1990 dollars, per capita GDP

    1948:

    Czechoslovakia: $3,088
    Austria: $2,764.
    Spain: $2,186

    In 1990 dollars, 1989:

    Austria: $16,360
    Spain: $11,582.
    Czechoslovakia’s: $8,768

    Replies: @Beckow

    What is irrelevant is your constant changing of the rules and cherrypicking. One more time: Czechoslovakia lost 20% of its population in WW2, Austria didn’t. Austria is neutral and was occupied until 1955, it has no military expenses (smart).

    Austria did the socialist housing, health, education, labor policies without the stupid restrictions and military spending – it was only possible because of the socialist threat across the border. Vienna in 1988 had about the same living standard as Prague but with more fizz. I has started to blossom in mid-90’s – in part as a neutral intermediary. Austria has been very smart and is among the best countries in the world (maybe the best).

    You are using fake numbers from biased sources – it depends on how you define GNP – very different in socialism where many things are not monetised. And on excahnge rate used that is quite random and changes dramatically over time. What matters is material wealth and how people live. But you will never understand that.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Beckow


    What is irrelevant is your constant changing of the rules and cherrypicking.
     
    I don't do these things of course.

    It' very simple.

    In 1948, prior to Socialism, Czechoslovakia was richer per capita than Austria.

    in 1989, after 40 years of the failed Socialism experiment, Austria was about twice as rich as Czechoslovakia per capita.

    No amount of your cherry-picking can change this basic fact.


    Austria did the socialist housing, health, education, labor policies
     
    Austria had a market economy. Czechoslovakia didn't.

    Vienna in 1988 had about the same living standard as Prague but with more fizz.
     
    And here you go with trying to change rules, cherry-picking etc. In this case "fizz." You mean far more and better quality consumer goods? Yes, richer people have far more and higher quality consumer goods than poor people.

    Life expectancy in Austria was about 3 years longer too.


    You are using fake numbers
     
    Of course if the data don't support your silly claims they are "fake."

    I'm shocked you didn't start to shriek "autism."

    I suppose you think that the difference in life expectancy is also fake?


    What matters is material wealth and how people live.
     
    Well, they lived less in Czechoslovakia under the failed Socialism experiment. Their material goods were poorer and of worse quality. For example, in 1990 Austrians owned nearly twice as many automobiles per capita than did Czechs:

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/452092/austria-number-of-cars-per-1000-inhabitants/

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/452011/czech-republic-number-of-cars-per-1000-inhabitants/

    And Austrians owned nice western cars rather than shoddy Soviet bloc ones. I doubt it is different with other goods. You will claim that Socialist-era restaurants were better than Austrian ones? Lol.

    I guess you will claim that number of automobiles per capita, GDP, and life expectancy are all "fake." Or you will start to cry "autism." :-)

    Replies: @AP

  930. @John Johnson
    @Mikel

    But it was to be expected that the John Johnson/John Bolton/Nikki Haley branch of the conservatives would fight tooth and nail against the MAGA turn in the GOP with the big resources they have.

    I'm not a conservative and posting my opinions is not fighting tooth and nail. I type around 80 wpm. If I really wanted to fight in politics I wouldn't bother with an alternative website that is backlisted by the major search engines. Which means they intentionally bury the results even if it matches.

    What’s remarkable is how unsuccessful they’ve been so far. Out of the 3 candidates remaining, the top two ones are MAGA and so was the fourth one.

    Why is it surprising that DeSantis is still in the race? Do you not follow US politics? Let me point out an ongoing pattern for you:
    1. Democrats/Republicans rally around someone they like but polls poorly with independents and moderates
    2. Democrats/Republicans lose to the other guy and say WHAT HAPPENED
    3. Pollsters point out again that you have to win independents. You can't just be popular with primary voters.
    4. Go to 1 in next election cause WE LIKE OUR GUY/GAL

    This happens all the time at both state and national level. Hillary Clinton is a good example. Feminists and liberals fawned over her but the polls said it was a bad idea to run her because of independents. Her fans didn't care. They would see cheering crowds of women and think WE ARE DESTINED TO WIN. Trump fans do the same thing at their rallies. They are certain he will win and yet they told us that in the last election.

    Independents outnumber both Republicans and Democrats. The two parties constantly walk into a false dichotomy where they think the opposition is merely their opposite.

    Replies: @A123, @Mikel, @Mr. XYZ

    Why is it surprising that DeSantis is still in the race?

    I didn’t say that there’s anything surprising at all about DeSantis being still in a race that has just begun (thought it’s you who thinks he should quit in favor of a candidate doing worse than him LOL). I said that it’s remarkable how bad the people you would favor are doing in the primaries, given the balance of forces in the GOP.

    I understand the problem with the independents and the MSM-brainwashed crowd. As I said the other day, I find it very difficult to believe that Trump can win in November. But what you are proposing is even more insane than sticking to the candidates you like at this stage of the race. You’re asking the leaders in the race to quit and give way to the one in a distant 3rd position because some polls a year before the elections say that she does better with independents. That’s crazy even from a strategic point of view. Let alone form an ideological one.

    We all here understand why you want Nikki to be the next president. It’s a logical choice from your point of view (or from AP’s and Mr Hack’s POV too). But, at most, I’d be willing to tolerate Trump or DeSantis choosing her as VP for electoral purposes and then locking her up in some White House closet for the following 4 years.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @Mikel

    There is no difference between the Indian woman and Biden (or Kamala), they have identical views. Why even hold an election?

    These views don't have a majority support: militarism and interventions abroad, liberal economic globalism, open borders, social idiocies like LGBTQ and restricting speech...They also don't have majority support anywhere in Europe.

    The JJ's, Hacks, AP's....are obsessed with only allowing people in elections within the narrow band of views. It is not a democracy by any definition. I don't know what exactly it is, a weird mix of oligarchy-ethnocracy-mandarin state. But always pro-war - Joe McCain is their patron saint.

    Notice how they will never say a word about the last half-a-dozen failed Western wars. They want more. It is basically a pathological cult. If they care so much, why don't they go and fight themselves?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AP, @AnonfromTN, @Mikel

  931. @Mikel
    @John Johnson


    Why is it surprising that DeSantis is still in the race?
     
    I didn't say that there's anything surprising at all about DeSantis being still in a race that has just begun (thought it's you who thinks he should quit in favor of a candidate doing worse than him LOL). I said that it's remarkable how bad the people you would favor are doing in the primaries, given the balance of forces in the GOP.

    I understand the problem with the independents and the MSM-brainwashed crowd. As I said the other day, I find it very difficult to believe that Trump can win in November. But what you are proposing is even more insane than sticking to the candidates you like at this stage of the race. You're asking the leaders in the race to quit and give way to the one in a distant 3rd position because some polls a year before the elections say that she does better with independents. That's crazy even from a strategic point of view. Let alone form an ideological one.

    We all here understand why you want Nikki to be the next president. It's a logical choice from your point of view (or from AP's and Mr Hack's POV too). But, at most, I'd be willing to tolerate Trump or DeSantis choosing her as VP for electoral purposes and then locking her up in some White House closet for the following 4 years.

    Replies: @Beckow

    There is no difference between the Indian woman and Biden (or Kamala), they have identical views. Why even hold an election?

    These views don’t have a majority support: militarism and interventions abroad, liberal economic globalism, open borders, social idiocies like LGBTQ and restricting speech…They also don’t have majority support anywhere in Europe.

    The JJ’s, Hacks, AP’s….are obsessed with only allowing people in elections within the narrow band of views. It is not a democracy by any definition. I don’t know what exactly it is, a weird mix of oligarchy-ethnocracy-mandarin state. But always pro-war – Joe McCain is their patron saint.

    Notice how they will never say a word about the last half-a-dozen failed Western wars. They want more. It is basically a pathological cult. If they care so much, why don’t they go and fight themselves?

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Beckow


    I don’t know what exactly it is, a weird mix of oligarchy-ethnocracy-mandarin state.
     
    Fascism with American characteristics. What we really need is some deep fake Harris Haley lesbian porn.
    , @AP
    @Beckow


    The JJ’s, Hacks, AP’s...Notice how they will never say a word about the last half-a-dozen failed Western wars.
     
    I've always condemned the Iraq war. In addition to being morally wrong, it was a stupid distraction and trap that weakened the USA. Putin has gotten Russia into an even worse trap in Ukraine.

    Replies: @Sean, @Mr. XYZ

    , @AnonfromTN
    @Beckow


    McCain is their patron saint.
     
    Hey, with all due disrespect, McCain is a historic character: he is the only person in history who managed to damage US aircraft carrier so much as to get it out of commission for a long time. No Bin Laden in the world could even dream of such success.
    , @Mikel
    @Beckow


    There is no difference between the Indian woman and Biden (or Kamala), they have identical views.
     
    Well, I wouldn't say so. Left to her own devices, the Indian woman would start a war with Iran, directly involve the US in Israel's "war" against the Gazans and increase US involvement in the Ukraine war. She has clearly stated all of those (which is why JJ must find her so appealing) though, once in power, cooler heads may moderate her bellicose instincts, one hopes.

    But other than that, you're right, no difference worth mentioning. JJ hasn't even tried explaining how Nikki is different from Bush, Romney, McCain, Ryan, McConnell and all the rest of the pre-Trump era Republicans who entangled the US in pointless wars abroad while putting the legacy population of the US on an irreversible course of replacement with people from the 3rd World.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @John Johnson

  932. @Beckow
    @Mikel

    There is no difference between the Indian woman and Biden (or Kamala), they have identical views. Why even hold an election?

    These views don't have a majority support: militarism and interventions abroad, liberal economic globalism, open borders, social idiocies like LGBTQ and restricting speech...They also don't have majority support anywhere in Europe.

    The JJ's, Hacks, AP's....are obsessed with only allowing people in elections within the narrow band of views. It is not a democracy by any definition. I don't know what exactly it is, a weird mix of oligarchy-ethnocracy-mandarin state. But always pro-war - Joe McCain is their patron saint.

    Notice how they will never say a word about the last half-a-dozen failed Western wars. They want more. It is basically a pathological cult. If they care so much, why don't they go and fight themselves?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AP, @AnonfromTN, @Mikel

    I don’t know what exactly it is, a weird mix of oligarchy-ethnocracy-mandarin state.

    Fascism with American characteristics. What we really need is some deep fake Harris Haley lesbian porn.

  933. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. Hack

    I see you read OT as something that once was and is no more. If religion is just a historical tale, it is just that - the story about past, not present, and not future. I suppose it is hard to believe in contingent historical ecclectism. But you can LARP;)

    The Old Testament has a notion of Jew which is only fully understandable if you see it also as a certain set of genes. It is only in this sense that Jew can be told nowadays - from the OT perspective. As a religion, Judaism in the sense of Jahwism does not exist anymore. There is Talmudism, which is not really closer to ancient Judaism than Christianity. And here lies an answer to your question. In the OT religious sense Jews for Jesus do not lose authenticity because they don't have any to lose in the first place. In the Talmudic sense they do not lose authenticity too, since it depends on their mothers being Jewish.
    That we cannot say who is who re Jewish tribes now, is irrelevant since God can know - if only some of these people fathered children through generations.

    BTW, there were 12 Israeli tribes, not 10. Actually 13 because the tribe of Joseph divided into Ephraim and Manasseh. And they weren't fighting among themselves really often.
    For your info, the tribes of Dan, Benjamin, Ephraim and Manasseh could be somehow false or inherently idolatrous (remember that Rachel hid an idol once, and who were her sons?) - Dan and Ephraim are removed from the list of tribes to be saved in Revelation of St John - they even write about such things in modern academic publications about Bible.

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @Mr. Hack

    I see you read OT as something that once was and is no more. If religion is just a historical tale, it is just that – the story about past, not present, and not future. I suppose it is hard to believe in contingent historical ecclectism. But you can LARP;)

    Who’s larping here? You’re reading things into my commentary that I never wrote, nor implied. I view the OT as being very important, not the least being the many allusions to the coming of the messiah Our Lord Jesus Christ within its written pages.

    The Old Testament has a notion of Jew which is only fully understandable if you see it also as a certain set of genes. It is only in this sense that Jew can be told nowadays – from the OT perspective.

    So apparently the “real Jews” share a unique genetic code? Has it been located and formulized yet? I think not, because you go on to state:

    hat we cannot say who is who re Jewish tribes now, is irrelevant since God can know – if only some of these people fathered children through generations.

    So if only God can know with any ceertainty (and perhaps kremlinstoogeA123), why are we even having this discussion anyway? Your guess is as good as mine, or anybody else’s.

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. Hack


    So apparently the “real Jews” share a unique genetic code? Has it been located and formulized yet?
     
    Likely, but even if such a code was found, false Jews would never allow to make it public, as they would immediately be known as false. It would destroy Talmudic Judaism too.

    Your guess is as good as mine, or anybody else’s.
     
    Well, even guessing can be informed or not.
    , @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. Hack


    I view the OT as being very important, not the least being the many allusions to the coming of the messiah Our Lord Jesus Christ within its written pages.
     
    Yes, allusions, exactly. Very well said.

    Unfortunately, reading OT for allusions to one OT-external event is not a serious reading of OT. It is not even serious skimming of OT.
    Try reading OT without Christ in perspective. What this about if not about Christ...?

    Replies: @A123

    , @Sher Singh
    @Mr. Hack

    WHY DO SIKHS CARRY WEAPONS - WHY NOT JUST LANGAR (SOUP KITCHEN - ALMSHOUSE)!?!


    A hindu man was converted into Islam & kept as a slave for 9 years without any payment. Guruji ki Fauj (Nihanga Sikhs), went to rescue him. Yeah this is India only, not in Pakistan.
     

    https://twitter.com/Half_baaked/status/1746656996118626587

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. Hack, @Greasy William

  934. @Beckow
    @AP

    What is irrelevant is your constant changing of the rules and cherrypicking. One more time: Czechoslovakia lost 20% of its population in WW2, Austria didn't. Austria is neutral and was occupied until 1955, it has no military expenses (smart).

    Austria did the socialist housing, health, education, labor policies without the stupid restrictions and military spending - it was only possible because of the socialist threat across the border. Vienna in 1988 had about the same living standard as Prague but with more fizz. I has started to blossom in mid-90's - in part as a neutral intermediary. Austria has been very smart and is among the best countries in the world (maybe the best).

    You are using fake numbers from biased sources - it depends on how you define GNP - very different in socialism where many things are not monetised. And on excahnge rate used that is quite random and changes dramatically over time. What matters is material wealth and how people live. But you will never understand that.

    Replies: @AP

    What is irrelevant is your constant changing of the rules and cherrypicking.

    I don’t do these things of course.

    It’ very simple.

    In 1948, prior to Socialism, Czechoslovakia was richer per capita than Austria.

    in 1989, after 40 years of the failed Socialism experiment, Austria was about twice as rich as Czechoslovakia per capita.

    No amount of your cherry-picking can change this basic fact.

    Austria did the socialist housing, health, education, labor policies

    Austria had a market economy. Czechoslovakia didn’t.

    Vienna in 1988 had about the same living standard as Prague but with more fizz.

    And here you go with trying to change rules, cherry-picking etc. In this case “fizz.” You mean far more and better quality consumer goods? Yes, richer people have far more and higher quality consumer goods than poor people.

    Life expectancy in Austria was about 3 years longer too.

    You are using fake numbers

    Of course if the data don’t support your silly claims they are “fake.”

    I’m shocked you didn’t start to shriek “autism.”

    I suppose you think that the difference in life expectancy is also fake?

    What matters is material wealth and how people live.

    Well, they lived less in Czechoslovakia under the failed Socialism experiment. Their material goods were poorer and of worse quality. For example, in 1990 Austrians owned nearly twice as many automobiles per capita than did Czechs:

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/452092/austria-number-of-cars-per-1000-inhabitants/

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/452011/czech-republic-number-of-cars-per-1000-inhabitants/

    And Austrians owned nice western cars rather than shoddy Soviet bloc ones. I doubt it is different with other goods. You will claim that Socialist-era restaurants were better than Austrian ones? Lol.

    I guess you will claim that number of automobiles per capita, GDP, and life expectancy are all “fake.” Or you will start to cry “autism.” 🙂

    • Agree: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @AP
    @AP


    What matters is material wealth and how people live.

    Well, they lived less in Czechoslovakia under the failed Socialism experiment. Their material goods were poorer and of worse quality. For example, in 1990 Austrians owned nearly twice as many automobiles per capita than did Czechs:

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/452092/austria-number-of-cars-per-1000-inhabitants/

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/452011/czech-republic-number-of-cars-per-1000-inhabitants/

    And Austrians owned nice western cars rather than shoddy Soviet bloc ones. I doubt it is different with other goods. You will claim that Socialist-era restaurants were better than Austrian ones? Lol.
     
    Out of curiosity I decided to look up Prague vs. Vienna metro. Maybe Czechs had fewer cars but they had a better metro system? The one in Moscow is one of the best in the world , after all.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Prague_Metro_stations

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Vienna_U-Bahn_stations

    Well, Prague got a metro two years earlier than Vienna - 1974 vs. 1976. (Vienna only had 2 stations in 1976, several more opened in 1978).

    But by 1989, Prague's metro had 29 stations while that of Vienna had 46 stations.

    So not only were Czechs poorer, lived shorter lives, and had fewer automobiles (that were of poorer quality) than Austrians, but their capital had a much smaller metro system.

    Such was the nature of Socialism.

    (And in 1990 Prague had 1.2 million people while Vienna had 1.5 million people, not enough to compensate for the stark difference)
  935. @Derer
    @AP


    After 40 years of the failed Socialist experiment, Austria had nearly twice the per capita GDP of Czechoslovakia.
     
    Caused by deliberate and artificially low exchange rate (not by trade) for the Iron curtain countries. What about Marshal Plan factor? Next time, used some more sophisticated analysis to improve your dismal high school term paper.

    Replies: @AP

    After 40 years of the failed Socialist experiment, Austria had nearly twice the per capita GDP of Czechoslovakia.

    Caused by deliberate and artificially low exchange rate

    Did that also cause the dearth of consumer goods (Austrians had twice as many cars per capita than Czechs)?

    What about Marshal Plan factor?

    What about it? Czechoslovakia kept falling further and further behind long after the Marshall Plan ended.

    • Replies: @Derer
    @AP

    The GDP is expressed in monetary term and not in physical...subsequently exchange rate plays an important role, the PPP expression is somewhat better. Austria imported all the cars, you moron...how it is in Gross DOMESTIC Product (+X-M).

    Next time justified you reply by some sound reasoning and not by usual BS.

    Replies: @AP

  936. @Beckow
    @Mikel

    There is no difference between the Indian woman and Biden (or Kamala), they have identical views. Why even hold an election?

    These views don't have a majority support: militarism and interventions abroad, liberal economic globalism, open borders, social idiocies like LGBTQ and restricting speech...They also don't have majority support anywhere in Europe.

    The JJ's, Hacks, AP's....are obsessed with only allowing people in elections within the narrow band of views. It is not a democracy by any definition. I don't know what exactly it is, a weird mix of oligarchy-ethnocracy-mandarin state. But always pro-war - Joe McCain is their patron saint.

    Notice how they will never say a word about the last half-a-dozen failed Western wars. They want more. It is basically a pathological cult. If they care so much, why don't they go and fight themselves?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AP, @AnonfromTN, @Mikel

    The JJ’s, Hacks, AP’s…Notice how they will never say a word about the last half-a-dozen failed Western wars.

    I’ve always condemned the Iraq war. In addition to being morally wrong, it was a stupid distraction and trap that weakened the USA. Putin has gotten Russia into an even worse trap in Ukraine.

    • LOL: Mikhail
    • Replies: @Sean
    @AP

    Ever thought that the leaders of superpowers might not get up on the wrong side of the bed of a morning but have very good reasons for doing unpopular and difficult things like invasions?

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    I'm not sure that the Iraq War was morally wrong. More like morally ambiguous since Iraqis nowadays do likely have a better government than they had under Saddam Hussein, but at a very high cost. Iraqis themselves should decide whether this cost was actually worth it.

    This could have been achieved at a somewhat lower cost back in 1991 had the US actually supported the anti-Saddam Iraqi rebels back then after it encouraged them to rebel against Saddam. It didn't, and they got brutally crushed by Saddam afterwards.

    Replies: @AP

  937. @Mr. Hack
    @Another Polish Perspective


    I see you read OT as something that once was and is no more. If religion is just a historical tale, it is just that – the story about past, not present, and not future. I suppose it is hard to believe in contingent historical ecclectism. But you can LARP;)
     
    Who's larping here? You're reading things into my commentary that I never wrote, nor implied. I view the OT as being very important, not the least being the many allusions to the coming of the messiah Our Lord Jesus Christ within its written pages.

    The Old Testament has a notion of Jew which is only fully understandable if you see it also as a certain set of genes. It is only in this sense that Jew can be told nowadays – from the OT perspective.
     
    So apparently the "real Jews" share a unique genetic code? Has it been located and formulized yet? I think not, because you go on to state:

    hat we cannot say who is who re Jewish tribes now, is irrelevant since God can know – if only some of these people fathered children through generations.
     
    So if only God can know with any ceertainty (and perhaps kremlinstoogeA123), why are we even having this discussion anyway? Your guess is as good as mine, or anybody else's.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Another Polish Perspective, @Sher Singh

    So apparently the “real Jews” share a unique genetic code? Has it been located and formulized yet?

    Likely, but even if such a code was found, false Jews would never allow to make it public, as they would immediately be known as false. It would destroy Talmudic Judaism too.

    Your guess is as good as mine, or anybody else’s.

    Well, even guessing can be informed or not.

  938. @Beckow
    @Mikel

    There is no difference between the Indian woman and Biden (or Kamala), they have identical views. Why even hold an election?

    These views don't have a majority support: militarism and interventions abroad, liberal economic globalism, open borders, social idiocies like LGBTQ and restricting speech...They also don't have majority support anywhere in Europe.

    The JJ's, Hacks, AP's....are obsessed with only allowing people in elections within the narrow band of views. It is not a democracy by any definition. I don't know what exactly it is, a weird mix of oligarchy-ethnocracy-mandarin state. But always pro-war - Joe McCain is their patron saint.

    Notice how they will never say a word about the last half-a-dozen failed Western wars. They want more. It is basically a pathological cult. If they care so much, why don't they go and fight themselves?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AP, @AnonfromTN, @Mikel

    McCain is their patron saint.

    Hey, with all due disrespect, McCain is a historic character: he is the only person in history who managed to damage US aircraft carrier so much as to get it out of commission for a long time. No Bin Laden in the world could even dream of such success.

  939. @Mr. Hack
    @Another Polish Perspective


    I see you read OT as something that once was and is no more. If religion is just a historical tale, it is just that – the story about past, not present, and not future. I suppose it is hard to believe in contingent historical ecclectism. But you can LARP;)
     
    Who's larping here? You're reading things into my commentary that I never wrote, nor implied. I view the OT as being very important, not the least being the many allusions to the coming of the messiah Our Lord Jesus Christ within its written pages.

    The Old Testament has a notion of Jew which is only fully understandable if you see it also as a certain set of genes. It is only in this sense that Jew can be told nowadays – from the OT perspective.
     
    So apparently the "real Jews" share a unique genetic code? Has it been located and formulized yet? I think not, because you go on to state:

    hat we cannot say who is who re Jewish tribes now, is irrelevant since God can know – if only some of these people fathered children through generations.
     
    So if only God can know with any ceertainty (and perhaps kremlinstoogeA123), why are we even having this discussion anyway? Your guess is as good as mine, or anybody else's.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Another Polish Perspective, @Sher Singh

    I view the OT as being very important, not the least being the many allusions to the coming of the messiah Our Lord Jesus Christ within its written pages.

    Yes, allusions, exactly. Very well said.

    Unfortunately, reading OT for allusions to one OT-external event is not a serious reading of OT. It is not even serious skimming of OT.
    Try reading OT without Christ in perspective. What this about if not about Christ…?

    • Thanks: QCIC
    • Replies: @A123
    @Another Polish Perspective

    One can read a Bible. However, there are so many versions that calling it "The Bible" is more tradition than strict labeling as a singular work.

    The original chapters were products of fallible men writing in the context of the time in which they lived. Since then they have been edited, translated, re-edited, and re-translated many times. It is common knowledge that King James's version was crafted to be more compatible with the monarchy.

    Any serious read of the OT and the NT has to avoid over literalism and requires at least modest historical grounding.

    Are there parts of the NT that support slavery? An extremely literal reading would say, Yes. However, in context the author would have been executed and the words burned if he attempted to write a evocative anti slavery screed.

    Does the OT work by itself. Yes. The lessons of transgression followed by severe punishment makes points clearly. It did not go well for the Sodomites. However, the balance between NT and OT yields a more adaptable framework for the modern day. "Free Will" seems to be part of God's ineffable plan. This suggests that the best option for the literate is reading The Bible and making their own decisions in the grey areas.

    PEACE 😇

  940. @AP
    @Beckow


    The JJ’s, Hacks, AP’s...Notice how they will never say a word about the last half-a-dozen failed Western wars.
     
    I've always condemned the Iraq war. In addition to being morally wrong, it was a stupid distraction and trap that weakened the USA. Putin has gotten Russia into an even worse trap in Ukraine.

    Replies: @Sean, @Mr. XYZ

    Ever thought that the leaders of superpowers might not get up on the wrong side of the bed of a morning but have very good reasons for doing unpopular and difficult things like invasions?

  941. @AP
    @Beckow


    The JJ’s, Hacks, AP’s...Notice how they will never say a word about the last half-a-dozen failed Western wars.
     
    I've always condemned the Iraq war. In addition to being morally wrong, it was a stupid distraction and trap that weakened the USA. Putin has gotten Russia into an even worse trap in Ukraine.

    Replies: @Sean, @Mr. XYZ

    I’m not sure that the Iraq War was morally wrong. More like morally ambiguous since Iraqis nowadays do likely have a better government than they had under Saddam Hussein, but at a very high cost. Iraqis themselves should decide whether this cost was actually worth it.

    This could have been achieved at a somewhat lower cost back in 1991 had the US actually supported the anti-Saddam Iraqi rebels back then after it encouraged them to rebel against Saddam. It didn’t, and they got brutally crushed by Saddam afterwards.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Mr. XYZ


    I’m not sure that the Iraq War was morally wrong
     
    Invading other countries is generally wrong in principle, unless there are wildly extenuating circumstances (Hitler's genocide of Jews and Slavs even had it been contained within Germany's borders, Pol Pot, Stalin).

    In the case of the Iraq war, while the invasion itself was not terribly bloody or brutal (Americans killed fewer civilians while occupying all of Iraq than Russians did while occupying 8% of Ukraine in 2022-2024), it unleashed Iraqi forces who engaged in a horrific civil war with 100,000s dead and destruction of much of Iraq's ancient Christian population. This on balance wasn't "worth" deposing Saddam's secular dictatorship.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ, @Derer

  942. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Another Polish Perspective

    Good grief you know a lot about Jews. I was taught that Poland had exterminated all of theirs. Anyway I agree that virtually everybody I have ever known thought they had Jews figured out by age 15 or and they never had to bother learning one more thing.

    Have you ever read Michael Hoffman's 1000 pp summary of the Talmud? I gave up around p. 500 and I started skimming quick long before I got to there.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Mr. XYZ

    I was taught that Poland had exterminated all of theirs.

    Poland didn’t. Rather, Nazi Germans did so (well, for 90% of Polish Jewry) on Polish soil.

  943. @John Johnson
    @Mikel

    But it was to be expected that the John Johnson/John Bolton/Nikki Haley branch of the conservatives would fight tooth and nail against the MAGA turn in the GOP with the big resources they have.

    I'm not a conservative and posting my opinions is not fighting tooth and nail. I type around 80 wpm. If I really wanted to fight in politics I wouldn't bother with an alternative website that is backlisted by the major search engines. Which means they intentionally bury the results even if it matches.

    What’s remarkable is how unsuccessful they’ve been so far. Out of the 3 candidates remaining, the top two ones are MAGA and so was the fourth one.

    Why is it surprising that DeSantis is still in the race? Do you not follow US politics? Let me point out an ongoing pattern for you:
    1. Democrats/Republicans rally around someone they like but polls poorly with independents and moderates
    2. Democrats/Republicans lose to the other guy and say WHAT HAPPENED
    3. Pollsters point out again that you have to win independents. You can't just be popular with primary voters.
    4. Go to 1 in next election cause WE LIKE OUR GUY/GAL

    This happens all the time at both state and national level. Hillary Clinton is a good example. Feminists and liberals fawned over her but the polls said it was a bad idea to run her because of independents. Her fans didn't care. They would see cheering crowds of women and think WE ARE DESTINED TO WIN. Trump fans do the same thing at their rallies. They are certain he will win and yet they told us that in the last election.

    Independents outnumber both Republicans and Democrats. The two parties constantly walk into a false dichotomy where they think the opposition is merely their opposite.

    Replies: @A123, @Mikel, @Mr. XYZ

    This happens all the time at both state and national level. Hillary Clinton is a good example. Feminists and liberals fawned over her but the polls said it was a bad idea to run her because of independents. Her fans didn’t care. They would see cheering crowds of women and think WE ARE DESTINED TO WIN. Trump fans do the same thing at their rallies. They are certain he will win and yet they told us that in the last election.

    TBF, I think that Hillary would have fared better back in 2008 had she been the Democratic nominee back then relative to 2016. But of course she was less Woke back in 2008 relative to 2016 as well. And the GOP had a more conventional candidate (John McCain) that year. Trump was unconventional.

  944. @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    I would think that today, in an age when it's hard to get young people to show up to work regularly, prospective employers have given up on entrance exams including very difficult puzzles. They're probably more interested in solving the puzzle as to how to motivate the young loafers to showup to work by 9:00 am and coddle them to do so for 5 days a week. :-)

    Replies: @songbird

    They’re probably more interested in solving the puzzle as to how to motivate the young loafers to showup to work by 9:00 am and coddle them to do so for 5 days a week

    Almost sounds like you have someone particular in mind and you are doing their job, when they don’t show up.

    I used to tease my Bukovinian/Ukrainian father about whether we had any vampires in our bloodline

    My hunch is that we are all descended from revenants of one kind or another. Men who, after they died, had big stones put in their mouth, or who didn’t die after they received seven wounds in battle.

  945. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. Hack


    I view the OT as being very important, not the least being the many allusions to the coming of the messiah Our Lord Jesus Christ within its written pages.
     
    Yes, allusions, exactly. Very well said.

    Unfortunately, reading OT for allusions to one OT-external event is not a serious reading of OT. It is not even serious skimming of OT.
    Try reading OT without Christ in perspective. What this about if not about Christ...?

    Replies: @A123

    One can read a Bible. However, there are so many versions that calling it “The Bible” is more tradition than strict labeling as a singular work.

    The original chapters were products of fallible men writing in the context of the time in which they lived. Since then they have been edited, translated, re-edited, and re-translated many times. It is common knowledge that King James’s version was crafted to be more compatible with the monarchy.

    Any serious read of the OT and the NT has to avoid over literalism and requires at least modest historical grounding.

    Are there parts of the NT that support slavery? An extremely literal reading would say, Yes. However, in context the author would have been executed and the words burned if he attempted to write a evocative anti slavery screed.

    Does the OT work by itself. Yes. The lessons of transgression followed by severe punishment makes points clearly. It did not go well for the Sodomites. However, the balance between NT and OT yields a more adaptable framework for the modern day. “Free Will” seems to be part of God’s ineffable plan. This suggests that the best option for the literate is reading The Bible and making their own decisions in the grey areas.

    PEACE 😇

  946. Pretty amusing how Scholz is now demonizing anyone who remotely endorses deportations.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @songbird

    It's getting hotter...this is just funny:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cl8nRM_wWzs

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  947. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    Anyway I agree that virtually everybody I have ever known thought they had Jews figured out by age 15 or and they never had to bother learning one more thing.
     
    This is true and yet surprising if you know that Nazis themselves were really into Judenkunde. They even proposed to Majer Bałaban, a Polish-Jewish historian of Jews, exemption from sanctions on Jews (ban on public libraries, staying in ghetto etc) so he could end writing his history of Jews in Kraków.

    Have you ever read Michael Hoffman’s 1000 pp summary of the Talmud? I gave up around p. 500 and I started skimming quick long before I got to there.
     
    No, no really. But his "Occult Reneissance" is on the right track. Talmud is hard to read if you like to read books in one go... I wait when the translation will appear designed in the way Talmud is studied and some Jewish editions are printed: a fragment of Talmud in the middle of page, and most important rabbinic commentaries referring to this fragment around on the margins.

    BTW, Poles did not exterminate Jews. Germans did.

    Replies: @Greasy William

    BTW, Poles did not exterminate Jews. Germans did.

    The Polish people enthusiastically collaborated with the Holocaust every step of the way. The AK murdered more Jews during the Warsaw Uprising than the Nazis did. Poland was the only country in Europe to have a pogrom post war. Poland also expelled it’s remaining Jews in the 1960’s, something even the Hungarians and Romanians (nations who were certainly no lovers of the Jewish people) didn’t do

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Greasy William

    Poland also has more people belonging to this category than any other country in spite of the fact that attempting to save Jews' lives in Nazi-occupied Poland resulted in the death penalty if you were discovered doing this by the Nazis, which AFAIK was NOT true for other Nazi-occupied countries:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Righteous_Among_the_Nations

    Replies: @Greasy William

    , @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Greasy William

    The destruction of the Jews of Poland would have been far less had not the top Polish Jews fed the bottom Polish Jews into the machine doing all due diligence possible trying to save themselves.

    The Germans had a lot of help and those guys do not get the credit they deserve. Other countries did the same thing but in Poland they set the standard very high.

    , @Another Polish Perspective
    @Greasy William

    After 1945, it was Jewish communist themselves in Polish gov who were liquidating and closing Jewish organizations. They simply liked communism more than Judaism, and wanted everything to be under the control of Party. Also originally, communism disliked Judaism as much as Christianity. Jews who liked Judaism more, often emigrated, but as a result of their own choice.

    1968 was a result of intra-fight between Jewish communists and Polish communists. This immigration was small and concerned mainly big cities inhabitants. It wasn't a forced emigration too - you still could stay if you relinquished your previous job and accepted a low-profile life.

  948. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    I'm not sure that the Iraq War was morally wrong. More like morally ambiguous since Iraqis nowadays do likely have a better government than they had under Saddam Hussein, but at a very high cost. Iraqis themselves should decide whether this cost was actually worth it.

    This could have been achieved at a somewhat lower cost back in 1991 had the US actually supported the anti-Saddam Iraqi rebels back then after it encouraged them to rebel against Saddam. It didn't, and they got brutally crushed by Saddam afterwards.

    Replies: @AP

    I’m not sure that the Iraq War was morally wrong

    Invading other countries is generally wrong in principle, unless there are wildly extenuating circumstances (Hitler’s genocide of Jews and Slavs even had it been contained within Germany’s borders, Pol Pot, Stalin).

    In the case of the Iraq war, while the invasion itself was not terribly bloody or brutal (Americans killed fewer civilians while occupying all of Iraq than Russians did while occupying 8% of Ukraine in 2022-2024), it unleashed Iraqi forces who engaged in a horrific civil war with 100,000s dead and destruction of much of Iraq’s ancient Christian population. This on balance wasn’t “worth” deposing Saddam’s secular dictatorship.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    Invading other countries is generally wrong in principle, unless there are wildly extenuating circumstances (Hitler’s genocide of Jews and Slavs even had it been contained within Germany’s borders, Pol Pot, Stalin).

     

    Agreed about Pol Pot, Stalin, and Communists in general (I think that a Western-led/US-led regime change war against the Bolsheviks back during the Russian Civil War would have been not only justified but also very moral, for instance). (It's to the West's eternal shame that the West opposed the Vietnamese regime change in Cambodia back in 1979. The West should not have done that, for the sake of the Cambodian people themselves. Everything turned out OK in the end, thankfully.)

    In regards to Hitler specifically, it's very possible and perhaps even reasonably likely that he would have refrained from engaging in genocide (as opposed to mass deportations, which he would have been and remained a huge fan of) on anywhere near as large of a scale had the West allowed him to expand eastwards without any opposition. In such a scenario, Hitler probably wouldn't want to destroy his relations with the West by committing outright genocide.


    In the case of the Iraq war, while the invasion itself was not terribly bloody or brutal (Americans killed fewer civilians while occupying all of Iraq than Russians did while occupying 8% of Ukraine in 2022-2024), it unleashed Iraqi forces who engaged in a horrific civil war with 100,000s dead and destruction of much of Iraq’s ancient Christian population. This on balance wasn’t “worth” deposing Saddam’s secular dictatorship.

     

    Well, if one wants to be fair, Iraq's Christians have subsequently established new, perhaps sometimes better lives in the West, comparable to Mizrahi Jews resettling in Israel after they were expelled en masse from Arab and Muslim countries. But Yeah, this is why I'm suggesting that it's unclear if the cost of this was actually worth it. What is interesting, though, is that the Iraqi people themselves (at least excluding the Sunni Arabs, who were only 20% of Iraq's total population) wanted to overthrow Saddam Hussein back in 1991. Did they change their minds in regards to this by 2003?

    As a side note, I wonder if a better outcome for Iraq could have been established had we either helped the Iraqi people overthrow Saddam Hussein back in 1991 or had we allowed Iran to win the Iran-Iraq War and do regime change in Iraq back in the 1980s.

    But Yeah, I get your logic about the price of freedom of Iraqis possibly being too high. If open borders for Iraqis with some other, better off Muslim countries would have been available, then there wouldn't have been a need to overthrow Saddam. It's similar to how had there not been an Armenian Genocide and a Bolshevik coup in Russia, the final outcome of WWI, specifically the redrawing of Europe's borders more along ethnic lines, would have been highly desirable, but the cost of this would have still been way too high (millions of deaths and years of a devastating and destabilizing World War).

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Wokechoke

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    BTW, out of curiosity: Do you believe that, on balance, giving the Central Powers a temporary advantage during World War I (a war that they still ultimately ended up losing) was worth sending Lenin and the Bolsheviks over to Russia? You could claim that the Russians themselves succumbed to Bolshevism, but this still doesn't nullify the fact that the Germans facilitated the entry into Russia of a bunch of crazy and dangerous people who otherwise might not have been capable of ending up in Russia at a crucial moment. You argue that the US should still be to blame for Iraqis killing each other after 2003 because the US indirectly made it possible by removing Saddam's regime law and order presence and also disbanding the Iraqi Army, but by that logic, wouldn't the Germans have indirectly made possible the rise of Bolshevism in Russia? US and German behavior were not sufficient factors in and of themselves to make Iraq's 2003-2017 bloodshed and Russia's 1917-1991 Bolshevik tyranny happen, but they were nevertheless necessary factors for this. But of course Iraqis and Russians also had to "play ball" by doing stupid shit afterwards.

    It's not clear that anyone was actually better off as a result of the Central Powers' decision to send Lenin over to Russia, including the Bolsheviks themselves, who subsequently got purged and murdered en masse under Stalin, a fate that I consider to be quite appropriate for them for helping to create the Soviet monster state in the first place. It's just a huge shame that Stalin killed so many innocent people as well in addition to the guilty Bolshevik rats. Ukraine, Belarus, the Caucasus, Poland, the Baltics, et cetera certainly weren't better off long-term as a result of Germany sending Lenin over to Russia. The only positive benefit of Communism for Eastern Europe long-term is that they were able to prevent the large-scale immigration of culturally incompatible Muslims during the late 20th and early 21st centuries, unlike Western Europe.

    , @Derer
    @AP

    Why are you two replying to each other. You have the same IP and the same dual citizenship.

    Replies: @AP

  949. @Greasy William
    @Another Polish Perspective


    BTW, Poles did not exterminate Jews. Germans did.
     
    The Polish people enthusiastically collaborated with the Holocaust every step of the way. The AK murdered more Jews during the Warsaw Uprising than the Nazis did. Poland was the only country in Europe to have a pogrom post war. Poland also expelled it's remaining Jews in the 1960's, something even the Hungarians and Romanians (nations who were certainly no lovers of the Jewish people) didn't do

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Another Polish Perspective

    Poland also has more people belonging to this category than any other country in spite of the fact that attempting to save Jews’ lives in Nazi-occupied Poland resulted in the death penalty if you were discovered doing this by the Nazis, which AFAIK was NOT true for other Nazi-occupied countries:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Righteous_Among_the_Nations

    • Replies: @Greasy William
    @Mr. XYZ

    There were plenty of righteous Polish ~individuals~ but the Polish population as a whole behaved in a disgraceful fashion. The Poles probably weren't any worse than the Hungarians or Romanians but the difference is that those countries were German allies whereas the Poles were fighting the Germans but still murdered Jews en masse.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  950. @Greasy William
    @Another Polish Perspective


    BTW, Poles did not exterminate Jews. Germans did.
     
    The Polish people enthusiastically collaborated with the Holocaust every step of the way. The AK murdered more Jews during the Warsaw Uprising than the Nazis did. Poland was the only country in Europe to have a pogrom post war. Poland also expelled it's remaining Jews in the 1960's, something even the Hungarians and Romanians (nations who were certainly no lovers of the Jewish people) didn't do

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Another Polish Perspective

    The destruction of the Jews of Poland would have been far less had not the top Polish Jews fed the bottom Polish Jews into the machine doing all due diligence possible trying to save themselves.

    The Germans had a lot of help and those guys do not get the credit they deserve. Other countries did the same thing but in Poland they set the standard very high.

  951. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ


    I’m not sure that the Iraq War was morally wrong
     
    Invading other countries is generally wrong in principle, unless there are wildly extenuating circumstances (Hitler's genocide of Jews and Slavs even had it been contained within Germany's borders, Pol Pot, Stalin).

    In the case of the Iraq war, while the invasion itself was not terribly bloody or brutal (Americans killed fewer civilians while occupying all of Iraq than Russians did while occupying 8% of Ukraine in 2022-2024), it unleashed Iraqi forces who engaged in a horrific civil war with 100,000s dead and destruction of much of Iraq's ancient Christian population. This on balance wasn't "worth" deposing Saddam's secular dictatorship.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ, @Derer

    Invading other countries is generally wrong in principle, unless there are wildly extenuating circumstances (Hitler’s genocide of Jews and Slavs even had it been contained within Germany’s borders, Pol Pot, Stalin).

    Agreed about Pol Pot, Stalin, and Communists in general (I think that a Western-led/US-led regime change war against the Bolsheviks back during the Russian Civil War would have been not only justified but also very moral, for instance). (It’s to the West’s eternal shame that the West opposed the Vietnamese regime change in Cambodia back in 1979. The West should not have done that, for the sake of the Cambodian people themselves. Everything turned out OK in the end, thankfully.)

    In regards to Hitler specifically, it’s very possible and perhaps even reasonably likely that he would have refrained from engaging in genocide (as opposed to mass deportations, which he would have been and remained a huge fan of) on anywhere near as large of a scale had the West allowed him to expand eastwards without any opposition. In such a scenario, Hitler probably wouldn’t want to destroy his relations with the West by committing outright genocide.

    In the case of the Iraq war, while the invasion itself was not terribly bloody or brutal (Americans killed fewer civilians while occupying all of Iraq than Russians did while occupying 8% of Ukraine in 2022-2024), it unleashed Iraqi forces who engaged in a horrific civil war with 100,000s dead and destruction of much of Iraq’s ancient Christian population. This on balance wasn’t “worth” deposing Saddam’s secular dictatorship.

    Well, if one wants to be fair, Iraq’s Christians have subsequently established new, perhaps sometimes better lives in the West, comparable to Mizrahi Jews resettling in Israel after they were expelled en masse from Arab and Muslim countries. But Yeah, this is why I’m suggesting that it’s unclear if the cost of this was actually worth it. What is interesting, though, is that the Iraqi people themselves (at least excluding the Sunni Arabs, who were only 20% of Iraq’s total population) wanted to overthrow Saddam Hussein back in 1991. Did they change their minds in regards to this by 2003?

    As a side note, I wonder if a better outcome for Iraq could have been established had we either helped the Iraqi people overthrow Saddam Hussein back in 1991 or had we allowed Iran to win the Iran-Iraq War and do regime change in Iraq back in the 1980s.

    But Yeah, I get your logic about the price of freedom of Iraqis possibly being too high. If open borders for Iraqis with some other, better off Muslim countries would have been available, then there wouldn’t have been a need to overthrow Saddam. It’s similar to how had there not been an Armenian Genocide and a Bolshevik coup in Russia, the final outcome of WWI, specifically the redrawing of Europe’s borders more along ethnic lines, would have been highly desirable, but the cost of this would have still been way too high (millions of deaths and years of a devastating and destabilizing World War).

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. XYZ

    What I find interesting is that in a lot of cases where regime change occurs, even if the regime that is overthrown is bad, the replacement for it tends to be worse (albeit not necessarily always immediately). I can list several examples:

    -The replacement of the French monarchy with the Reign of Terror
    -The replacement of the Russian Tsar with the Bolsheviks after several months of freedom, liberty, and democracy
    -The replacement of the German Kaiser with the Nazis, albeit after an almost 15-year democratic republican interregnum
    -The replacement of Prince Sihanouk's and Lon Nol's regimes with the Khmer Rouge in Cambodia, thankfully overthrown by the Vietnamese after just four years in power
    -The replacement of the Afghan King by the Afghan Communists after several years, then by several brutal Afghan Wars and two stints of the Taliban coming to power in Afghanistan, with their second stint still going on right now
    -The replacement of the Iranian Shah by religious fundamentalist Ayatollahs and a subsequent brutal eight-year-long war with Iraq
    -The replacement of Saddam Hussein's regime in Iraq with two brutal civil wars, thankfully over now
    -The replacement of Muammar Gaddafi's regime in Libya with anarchy and civil war after a brief period of freedom, liberty, and democracy

    Are there any other similar examples of this that one can think of?

    BTW, examples of successful long-term transitions to democracy have been in Western Europe post-WWII as well as in Eastern Europe post-Communism, excluding both Russia and Belarus. Some Latin American countries after the 1980s and 1990s could also be examples of this.

    , @Wokechoke
    @Mr. XYZ

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xt-JCMXDS0U

    Mr Boris Johnson Says

  952. @AP
    @Beckow


    What is irrelevant is your constant changing of the rules and cherrypicking.
     
    I don't do these things of course.

    It' very simple.

    In 1948, prior to Socialism, Czechoslovakia was richer per capita than Austria.

    in 1989, after 40 years of the failed Socialism experiment, Austria was about twice as rich as Czechoslovakia per capita.

    No amount of your cherry-picking can change this basic fact.


    Austria did the socialist housing, health, education, labor policies
     
    Austria had a market economy. Czechoslovakia didn't.

    Vienna in 1988 had about the same living standard as Prague but with more fizz.
     
    And here you go with trying to change rules, cherry-picking etc. In this case "fizz." You mean far more and better quality consumer goods? Yes, richer people have far more and higher quality consumer goods than poor people.

    Life expectancy in Austria was about 3 years longer too.


    You are using fake numbers
     
    Of course if the data don't support your silly claims they are "fake."

    I'm shocked you didn't start to shriek "autism."

    I suppose you think that the difference in life expectancy is also fake?


    What matters is material wealth and how people live.
     
    Well, they lived less in Czechoslovakia under the failed Socialism experiment. Their material goods were poorer and of worse quality. For example, in 1990 Austrians owned nearly twice as many automobiles per capita than did Czechs:

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/452092/austria-number-of-cars-per-1000-inhabitants/

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/452011/czech-republic-number-of-cars-per-1000-inhabitants/

    And Austrians owned nice western cars rather than shoddy Soviet bloc ones. I doubt it is different with other goods. You will claim that Socialist-era restaurants were better than Austrian ones? Lol.

    I guess you will claim that number of automobiles per capita, GDP, and life expectancy are all "fake." Or you will start to cry "autism." :-)

    Replies: @AP

    What matters is material wealth and how people live.

    Well, they lived less in Czechoslovakia under the failed Socialism experiment. Their material goods were poorer and of worse quality. For example, in 1990 Austrians owned nearly twice as many automobiles per capita than did Czechs:

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/452092/austria-number-of-cars-per-1000-inhabitants/

    https://www.statista.com/statistics/452011/czech-republic-number-of-cars-per-1000-inhabitants/

    And Austrians owned nice western cars rather than shoddy Soviet bloc ones. I doubt it is different with other goods. You will claim that Socialist-era restaurants were better than Austrian ones? Lol.

    Out of curiosity I decided to look up Prague vs. Vienna metro. Maybe Czechs had fewer cars but they had a better metro system? The one in Moscow is one of the best in the world , after all.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Prague_Metro_stations

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Vienna_U-Bahn_stations

    Well, Prague got a metro two years earlier than Vienna – 1974 vs. 1976. (Vienna only had 2 stations in 1976, several more opened in 1978).

    But by 1989, Prague’s metro had 29 stations while that of Vienna had 46 stations.

    So not only were Czechs poorer, lived shorter lives, and had fewer automobiles (that were of poorer quality) than Austrians, but their capital had a much smaller metro system.

    Such was the nature of Socialism.

    (And in 1990 Prague had 1.2 million people while Vienna had 1.5 million people, not enough to compensate for the stark difference)

  953. @AP
    @Derer


    After 40 years of the failed Socialist experiment, Austria had nearly twice the per capita GDP of Czechoslovakia.

    Caused by deliberate and artificially low exchange rate
     
    Did that also cause the dearth of consumer goods (Austrians had twice as many cars per capita than Czechs)?

    What about Marshal Plan factor?
     
    What about it? Czechoslovakia kept falling further and further behind long after the Marshall Plan ended.

    Replies: @Derer

    The GDP is expressed in monetary term and not in physical…subsequently exchange rate plays an important role, the PPP expression is somewhat better. Austria imported all the cars, you moron…how it is in Gross DOMESTIC Product (+X-M).

    Next time justified you reply by some sound reasoning and not by usual BS.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Derer


    Austria imported all the cars, you moron…how it is in Gross DOMESTIC Product
     
    You are dumb as usual. Austria made automobiles and supplied parts for others’ automobiles.

    Although of course I was writing about rich Austrians buying cars.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steyr-Daimler-Puch



    After the war, Steyr-Daimler-Puch built diesel engined trucks and buses, small and heavy tractors and resumed passenger car production. First, Steyr assembled the FIAT 1100E, then put their own engine in a Fiat 1400, renaming the car the "Steyr 2000". From 1957 through to the early 1970s it produced the tiny Puch 500 under license from FIAT, again with an engine of Austrian design.

    Most prominent was its range of off-road cars, from the two-cylinder Haflinger and the 4 x 4 or 6 x 6 Pinzgauer, the Fiat Panda 4x4 (999 cc) to the Mercedes-Puch G. SDP was the initial designer and manufacturer of these utility vehicles. The Haflinger was produced from 1959–1974, the Pinzgauer from 1971–2000, and the Puch G (also known as Mercedes G-Class) from 1979.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Derer

  954. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    Invading other countries is generally wrong in principle, unless there are wildly extenuating circumstances (Hitler’s genocide of Jews and Slavs even had it been contained within Germany’s borders, Pol Pot, Stalin).

     

    Agreed about Pol Pot, Stalin, and Communists in general (I think that a Western-led/US-led regime change war against the Bolsheviks back during the Russian Civil War would have been not only justified but also very moral, for instance). (It's to the West's eternal shame that the West opposed the Vietnamese regime change in Cambodia back in 1979. The West should not have done that, for the sake of the Cambodian people themselves. Everything turned out OK in the end, thankfully.)

    In regards to Hitler specifically, it's very possible and perhaps even reasonably likely that he would have refrained from engaging in genocide (as opposed to mass deportations, which he would have been and remained a huge fan of) on anywhere near as large of a scale had the West allowed him to expand eastwards without any opposition. In such a scenario, Hitler probably wouldn't want to destroy his relations with the West by committing outright genocide.


    In the case of the Iraq war, while the invasion itself was not terribly bloody or brutal (Americans killed fewer civilians while occupying all of Iraq than Russians did while occupying 8% of Ukraine in 2022-2024), it unleashed Iraqi forces who engaged in a horrific civil war with 100,000s dead and destruction of much of Iraq’s ancient Christian population. This on balance wasn’t “worth” deposing Saddam’s secular dictatorship.

     

    Well, if one wants to be fair, Iraq's Christians have subsequently established new, perhaps sometimes better lives in the West, comparable to Mizrahi Jews resettling in Israel after they were expelled en masse from Arab and Muslim countries. But Yeah, this is why I'm suggesting that it's unclear if the cost of this was actually worth it. What is interesting, though, is that the Iraqi people themselves (at least excluding the Sunni Arabs, who were only 20% of Iraq's total population) wanted to overthrow Saddam Hussein back in 1991. Did they change their minds in regards to this by 2003?

    As a side note, I wonder if a better outcome for Iraq could have been established had we either helped the Iraqi people overthrow Saddam Hussein back in 1991 or had we allowed Iran to win the Iran-Iraq War and do regime change in Iraq back in the 1980s.

    But Yeah, I get your logic about the price of freedom of Iraqis possibly being too high. If open borders for Iraqis with some other, better off Muslim countries would have been available, then there wouldn't have been a need to overthrow Saddam. It's similar to how had there not been an Armenian Genocide and a Bolshevik coup in Russia, the final outcome of WWI, specifically the redrawing of Europe's borders more along ethnic lines, would have been highly desirable, but the cost of this would have still been way too high (millions of deaths and years of a devastating and destabilizing World War).

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Wokechoke

    What I find interesting is that in a lot of cases where regime change occurs, even if the regime that is overthrown is bad, the replacement for it tends to be worse (albeit not necessarily always immediately). I can list several examples:

    -The replacement of the French monarchy with the Reign of Terror
    -The replacement of the Russian Tsar with the Bolsheviks after several months of freedom, liberty, and democracy
    -The replacement of the German Kaiser with the Nazis, albeit after an almost 15-year democratic republican interregnum
    -The replacement of Prince Sihanouk’s and Lon Nol’s regimes with the Khmer Rouge in Cambodia, thankfully overthrown by the Vietnamese after just four years in power
    -The replacement of the Afghan King by the Afghan Communists after several years, then by several brutal Afghan Wars and two stints of the Taliban coming to power in Afghanistan, with their second stint still going on right now
    -The replacement of the Iranian Shah by religious fundamentalist Ayatollahs and a subsequent brutal eight-year-long war with Iraq
    -The replacement of Saddam Hussein’s regime in Iraq with two brutal civil wars, thankfully over now
    -The replacement of Muammar Gaddafi’s regime in Libya with anarchy and civil war after a brief period of freedom, liberty, and democracy

    Are there any other similar examples of this that one can think of?

    BTW, examples of successful long-term transitions to democracy have been in Western Europe post-WWII as well as in Eastern Europe post-Communism, excluding both Russia and Belarus. Some Latin American countries after the 1980s and 1990s could also be examples of this.

  955. Never imagined the woods held such nightmare visions, like something out of a zombie movie. The deer equivalent to a rat-king:

    [MORE]

  956. @songbird
    Pretty amusing how Scholz is now demonizing anyone who remotely endorses deportations.

    Replies: @Beckow

    It’s getting hotter…this is just funny:

    • Thanks: songbird
    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Beckow

    That is fake.

    This is authentic.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v2rS9d-r09M

    Replies: @Beckow

  957. @Mikhail
    @QCIC

    A most corrupt one at that:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ifnCakYJNVM

    Replies: @Derer

    To defeat the bragging has-been hegemon – for a peace on this planet.

  958. @A123
    Yet more detail from Nikki Haley's own Twitter account (1)

    Nikki Haley
    @NikkiHaley

    We spent the last couple of days celebrating our son’s graduation. Tonight I turned on the news and am heartbroken. It’s important to understand that the death of George Floyd was personal and painful for many. In order to heal, it needs to be personal and painful for everyone.
     
    Why does the death of violent drug addict have to be "personal and painful for everyone"?

    If she wants to pump race division in the country, she really needs to change parties to run as a NeoConDemocrat. They would love her advocacy for foreign wars too.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://instapundit.com/627431/


     
    https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgi3PFGKlSHiKExZW4Bo1k5MI3ASVz7_38Fc5-XUmxbZpHC5jyNEbNh9J7p6yOL2JIq7a0M9aQTlUyZfEUKdGUX3gACobkCBE1b6wuN9_poRSzmOInspzFxD5_u3dSIiQAZ86dG_U9LaCnjO_k11JikyvAHZ9BgiR-LuzG_hSaJhnnVhjG_dRXEWOQHtbM/s599/1%20dgsdfgsdgdsg.jpg

    Replies: @songbird, @Mikel, @Derer

    The hell will freeze before damaged Haley is elected president.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @Derer


    The hell will freeze before damaged Haley is elected president.
     
    That would be true if the elections were honest. With fraud on the scale like in 2020, any rat, even dead and smelly one, can be “elected”.

    Replies: @Derer

  959. @Beckow
    @songbird

    It's getting hotter...this is just funny:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cl8nRM_wWzs

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    That is fake.

    This is authentic.

    • Replies: @Beckow
    @Emil Nikola Richard


    That is fake.
     
    It is art, and all art is by definition fake...Is it a fake if most people are thinking it?
  960. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ


    I’m not sure that the Iraq War was morally wrong
     
    Invading other countries is generally wrong in principle, unless there are wildly extenuating circumstances (Hitler's genocide of Jews and Slavs even had it been contained within Germany's borders, Pol Pot, Stalin).

    In the case of the Iraq war, while the invasion itself was not terribly bloody or brutal (Americans killed fewer civilians while occupying all of Iraq than Russians did while occupying 8% of Ukraine in 2022-2024), it unleashed Iraqi forces who engaged in a horrific civil war with 100,000s dead and destruction of much of Iraq's ancient Christian population. This on balance wasn't "worth" deposing Saddam's secular dictatorship.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ, @Derer

    BTW, out of curiosity: Do you believe that, on balance, giving the Central Powers a temporary advantage during World War I (a war that they still ultimately ended up losing) was worth sending Lenin and the Bolsheviks over to Russia? You could claim that the Russians themselves succumbed to Bolshevism, but this still doesn’t nullify the fact that the Germans facilitated the entry into Russia of a bunch of crazy and dangerous people who otherwise might not have been capable of ending up in Russia at a crucial moment. You argue that the US should still be to blame for Iraqis killing each other after 2003 because the US indirectly made it possible by removing Saddam’s regime law and order presence and also disbanding the Iraqi Army, but by that logic, wouldn’t the Germans have indirectly made possible the rise of Bolshevism in Russia? US and German behavior were not sufficient factors in and of themselves to make Iraq’s 2003-2017 bloodshed and Russia’s 1917-1991 Bolshevik tyranny happen, but they were nevertheless necessary factors for this. But of course Iraqis and Russians also had to “play ball” by doing stupid shit afterwards.

    It’s not clear that anyone was actually better off as a result of the Central Powers’ decision to send Lenin over to Russia, including the Bolsheviks themselves, who subsequently got purged and murdered en masse under Stalin, a fate that I consider to be quite appropriate for them for helping to create the Soviet monster state in the first place. It’s just a huge shame that Stalin killed so many innocent people as well in addition to the guilty Bolshevik rats. Ukraine, Belarus, the Caucasus, Poland, the Baltics, et cetera certainly weren’t better off long-term as a result of Germany sending Lenin over to Russia. The only positive benefit of Communism for Eastern Europe long-term is that they were able to prevent the large-scale immigration of culturally incompatible Muslims during the late 20th and early 21st centuries, unlike Western Europe.

  961. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Beckow

    That is fake.

    This is authentic.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v2rS9d-r09M

    Replies: @Beckow

    That is fake.

    It is art, and all art is by definition fake…Is it a fake if most people are thinking it?

  962. Don’t see many commercials, but I did manage to see a very funny one recently.

    Know how they used to have those “save the children” type commercials about feeding or schooling kids in the Third World? A sort of subscription service where you sign up to pay so many dollars a month, sold as so many cents/day?

    Well, this was something similar – to fight trannies. But I didn’t like the way they sold it: female athletes losing out on scholarships. An aside: in my school, the only person I recall who got a big sports scholarship was a Negress bused in from Boston – and not one I would consider one of the pleasant types. And the ad was totally lacking in such.

    But anyway, I dislike this way of opposing trannies based on female victimhood in college sports. They should be fought on the basis that they are an abomination and an attack on the divisions ordained by God.

    Still, I don’t know if it was as funny as that “do the Christian thing and buy poor Jews in Israel kosher food for the Jewish holidays” commercial that I once saw.

  963. @Derer
    @A123

    The hell will freeze before damaged Haley is elected president.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN

    The hell will freeze before damaged Haley is elected president.

    That would be true if the elections were honest. With fraud on the scale like in 2020, any rat, even dead and smelly one, can be “elected”.

    • Replies: @Derer
    @AnonfromTN

    You are right, but Haley is not in that cheating gang. Democrats would vote even for monkey if that monkey will support Israel.

  964. @Beckow
    @Mikel

    There is no difference between the Indian woman and Biden (or Kamala), they have identical views. Why even hold an election?

    These views don't have a majority support: militarism and interventions abroad, liberal economic globalism, open borders, social idiocies like LGBTQ and restricting speech...They also don't have majority support anywhere in Europe.

    The JJ's, Hacks, AP's....are obsessed with only allowing people in elections within the narrow band of views. It is not a democracy by any definition. I don't know what exactly it is, a weird mix of oligarchy-ethnocracy-mandarin state. But always pro-war - Joe McCain is their patron saint.

    Notice how they will never say a word about the last half-a-dozen failed Western wars. They want more. It is basically a pathological cult. If they care so much, why don't they go and fight themselves?

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard, @AP, @AnonfromTN, @Mikel

    There is no difference between the Indian woman and Biden (or Kamala), they have identical views.

    Well, I wouldn’t say so. Left to her own devices, the Indian woman would start a war with Iran, directly involve the US in Israel’s “war” against the Gazans and increase US involvement in the Ukraine war. She has clearly stated all of those (which is why JJ must find her so appealing) though, once in power, cooler heads may moderate her bellicose instincts, one hopes.

    But other than that, you’re right, no difference worth mentioning. JJ hasn’t even tried explaining how Nikki is different from Bush, Romney, McCain, Ryan, McConnell and all the rest of the pre-Trump era Republicans who entangled the US in pointless wars abroad while putting the legacy population of the US on an irreversible course of replacement with people from the 3rd World.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Mikel


    and increase US involvement in the Ukraine war.
     
    This could be either good or bad. Bad because it could increase the risk of an accidental wider war (I doubt that Putin would purposely use nukes, though who knows, right? Putin might be paranoid and somewhat irrational but to that extent?), but good because it could allow Ukraine to get a decisive advantage in this war. But it's not guaranteed because trench-like warfare is very hard to break out of (it took until 1918 for the Western Front of WWI to begin seriously moving again, for instance, and even in Italy, the Central Powers' victory at Caporetto in late 1917 failed to even get them to Venice afterwards) and because Russia could in turn escalate its own commitment to this war in terms of money, troops, et cetera.
    , @Beckow
    @Mikel


    ...Left to her own devices, the Indian woman would start a war...
     
    You are right, she has the capacity to change, since the neo-cons are as..holes, they will just become bigger as..holes...

    I have been saying that we are in the early stages of this historical cycle, the sides are being formed, areas of conflict defined, emotions are only so-so, there is still some dissent - but it may go way further. These could be the good years. There is so much to fight over - and there are at least 5 billion 3rd worlders left who could take the track to the greener pastures...

    Freedom is unlimited, freedom is everything!...too bad perfect freedom has no existence.

    , @John Johnson
    @Mikel

    But other than that, you’re right, no difference worth mentioning. JJ hasn’t even tried explaining how Nikki is different from Bush, Romney, McCain, Ryan, McConnell and all the rest of the pre-Trump era Republicans who entangled the US in pointless wars

    You keep projecting your own fanboyism and assume I idealize political candidates in the way that you idealize Putin.

    Haley is merely a tool to me like a shovel or a rake. I think she is the better choice to remove Biden as I think it is likely that Trump will catch a felony. Meaning current Trump is not the Trump that would face Biden. It would be felony Trump and his 2AM rant about presidential immunity is not helping his case. After catching a felony his rating with independents will fall even further. We have not gotten to the documents case and he is already going on unhinged rants. Three of his lawyers have quit in the last month which is not a good sign. Lawyers don't normally quit cases that are funded by a billionaire.

    Let me reiterate my position even though I have stated it a dozen times:

    I want Biden out more than I want Trump as president.

    Yes we all know you would like a return of Trump and an end to Ukraine aid.

    But it was Trump that said Ukraine should be heavily funded if Putin doesn't agree to his plan.

    It was also Trump that sold Ukraine the nifty weapons that helped defeat Russian tanks. That was against the wishes of Putin.

    Trump is not pals with anyone. He is out for his own ego and if a war suits his ego then he will launch one.

    It was Trump that signed off on Golan as part of Israel and without any compromises. This idea of him as an isolationist is wishful thinking. Reminds me of anti-vaxxers that think of Trump as their guy and ignore how he funded Operation Warpspeed. I've had his deluded fans tell me that he didn't actually get the vaccine and that it was saline. His fans have a serious case of reality denial.

    It was Trump that left the border open and turned down a generous offer from the Democrats.

    Trump's fans have tribal brain. They don't want to look at how Trump mostly governed as a mainstream Republican.

  965. @Derer
    @AP

    The GDP is expressed in monetary term and not in physical...subsequently exchange rate plays an important role, the PPP expression is somewhat better. Austria imported all the cars, you moron...how it is in Gross DOMESTIC Product (+X-M).

    Next time justified you reply by some sound reasoning and not by usual BS.

    Replies: @AP

    Austria imported all the cars, you moron…how it is in Gross DOMESTIC Product

    You are dumb as usual. Austria made automobiles and supplied parts for others’ automobiles.

    Although of course I was writing about rich Austrians buying cars.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steyr-Daimler-Puch

    [MORE]

    After the war, Steyr-Daimler-Puch built diesel engined trucks and buses, small and heavy tractors and resumed passenger car production. First, Steyr assembled the FIAT 1100E, then put their own engine in a Fiat 1400, renaming the car the “Steyr 2000”. From 1957 through to the early 1970s it produced the tiny Puch 500 under license from FIAT, again with an engine of Austrian design.

    Most prominent was its range of off-road cars, from the two-cylinder Haflinger and the 4 x 4 or 6 x 6 Pinzgauer, the Fiat Panda 4×4 (999 cc) to the Mercedes-Puch G. SDP was the initial designer and manufacturer of these utility vehicles. The Haflinger was produced from 1959–1974, the Pinzgauer from 1971–2000, and the Puch G (also known as Mercedes G-Class) from 1979.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    You know, what I find interesting is that after World War I many people talked about how the rump Austria was non-viable as an independent state and thus needed to unify with Germany, but the post-WWII decades really put that viewpoint and mentality to rest once Austria experienced spectacular economic growth and progress in spite of it not being as thoroughly integrated into European structures as, say, West Germany was until the 1990s. In turn, this ensured that when the Cold War ended and Germany reunified in 1990, there was virtually no demand in Austria for a second Anschluss with Germany. Austrians just had it that good being by themselves, though they did subsequently join the EU in 1995.

    , @Derer
    @AP

    AP: "(Austrians had twice as many cars per capita than Czechs)?"

    As a justification for high GDP. The question is if those cars are home produced?
    No, 90% are produced outside Austria in lower cost countries.

    Now the AP hochstapler is bringing up that Austria actually produced heavy tractors and diesel engine trucks and buses instead of cars.

    AP:"Although of course I was writing about rich Austrians buying cars."

    No, you were writing about how number of foreign cars contributing to Austrian GDP.

    Replies: @AP

  966. @Mikel
    @Beckow


    There is no difference between the Indian woman and Biden (or Kamala), they have identical views.
     
    Well, I wouldn't say so. Left to her own devices, the Indian woman would start a war with Iran, directly involve the US in Israel's "war" against the Gazans and increase US involvement in the Ukraine war. She has clearly stated all of those (which is why JJ must find her so appealing) though, once in power, cooler heads may moderate her bellicose instincts, one hopes.

    But other than that, you're right, no difference worth mentioning. JJ hasn't even tried explaining how Nikki is different from Bush, Romney, McCain, Ryan, McConnell and all the rest of the pre-Trump era Republicans who entangled the US in pointless wars abroad while putting the legacy population of the US on an irreversible course of replacement with people from the 3rd World.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @John Johnson

    and increase US involvement in the Ukraine war.

    This could be either good or bad. Bad because it could increase the risk of an accidental wider war (I doubt that Putin would purposely use nukes, though who knows, right? Putin might be paranoid and somewhat irrational but to that extent?), but good because it could allow Ukraine to get a decisive advantage in this war. But it’s not guaranteed because trench-like warfare is very hard to break out of (it took until 1918 for the Western Front of WWI to begin seriously moving again, for instance, and even in Italy, the Central Powers’ victory at Caporetto in late 1917 failed to even get them to Venice afterwards) and because Russia could in turn escalate its own commitment to this war in terms of money, troops, et cetera.

  967. @AP
    @Derer


    Austria imported all the cars, you moron…how it is in Gross DOMESTIC Product
     
    You are dumb as usual. Austria made automobiles and supplied parts for others’ automobiles.

    Although of course I was writing about rich Austrians buying cars.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steyr-Daimler-Puch



    After the war, Steyr-Daimler-Puch built diesel engined trucks and buses, small and heavy tractors and resumed passenger car production. First, Steyr assembled the FIAT 1100E, then put their own engine in a Fiat 1400, renaming the car the "Steyr 2000". From 1957 through to the early 1970s it produced the tiny Puch 500 under license from FIAT, again with an engine of Austrian design.

    Most prominent was its range of off-road cars, from the two-cylinder Haflinger and the 4 x 4 or 6 x 6 Pinzgauer, the Fiat Panda 4x4 (999 cc) to the Mercedes-Puch G. SDP was the initial designer and manufacturer of these utility vehicles. The Haflinger was produced from 1959–1974, the Pinzgauer from 1971–2000, and the Puch G (also known as Mercedes G-Class) from 1979.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Derer

    You know, what I find interesting is that after World War I many people talked about how the rump Austria was non-viable as an independent state and thus needed to unify with Germany, but the post-WWII decades really put that viewpoint and mentality to rest once Austria experienced spectacular economic growth and progress in spite of it not being as thoroughly integrated into European structures as, say, West Germany was until the 1990s. In turn, this ensured that when the Cold War ended and Germany reunified in 1990, there was virtually no demand in Austria for a second Anschluss with Germany. Austrians just had it that good being by themselves, though they did subsequently join the EU in 1995.

  968. @Mikel
    @Beckow


    There is no difference between the Indian woman and Biden (or Kamala), they have identical views.
     
    Well, I wouldn't say so. Left to her own devices, the Indian woman would start a war with Iran, directly involve the US in Israel's "war" against the Gazans and increase US involvement in the Ukraine war. She has clearly stated all of those (which is why JJ must find her so appealing) though, once in power, cooler heads may moderate her bellicose instincts, one hopes.

    But other than that, you're right, no difference worth mentioning. JJ hasn't even tried explaining how Nikki is different from Bush, Romney, McCain, Ryan, McConnell and all the rest of the pre-Trump era Republicans who entangled the US in pointless wars abroad while putting the legacy population of the US on an irreversible course of replacement with people from the 3rd World.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @John Johnson

    …Left to her own devices, the Indian woman would start a war…

    You are right, she has the capacity to change, since the neo-cons are as..holes, they will just become bigger as..holes…

    I have been saying that we are in the early stages of this historical cycle, the sides are being formed, areas of conflict defined, emotions are only so-so, there is still some dissent – but it may go way further. These could be the good years. There is so much to fight over – and there are at least 5 billion 3rd worlders left who could take the track to the greener pastures…

    Freedom is unlimited, freedom is everything!…too bad perfect freedom has no existence.

  969. Is DeSantis going to bow out gracefully in the near future?

    In Florida the regular legislative session runs only 60 days per year. For 2024 this period started mid-January. Resuming full time presence in state would allow DeSantis to make gains as Governor.

    Endorsing Trump would be a primary ending blow to Nikki Haley. If DeSantis wants to chase MAGA 2028 after Trump’s 2nd term, this would be a sound strategic move.

    The DNC appears to be successfully manipulating crossover voting. Between temporary registration changes and New Hampshire’s “semi-open” primary, Haley could return an unrepresentative 30%+, with half of that being non-Republicans. Therefore, the best DeSantis can hope for in NH is a very weak 3rd. If he bails ASAP, there will be no official loss to Haley on his resume.

    There are some leading signs pointing at imminent departure (1).

      

    Bigly emotional commenters who exist only for personalities, not substantive policies, will continue their #NeverTrump cult behavior against MAGA. Those who yearn for Forever Wars are sadly incapable of improvement.

    However, when DeSantis folds, there is a huge opportunity for people without a candidate to come around to the saner side with the more intelligent people. Building bridges back to MAGA/Trump is the obvious move to oppose NeoConDemocrat Nikki and her ideological twin Not-The-President Biden.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://theconservativetreehouse.com/blog/2024/01/20/report-desantis-campaign-looking-for-a-fat-lady/

  970. @A123
    Vivek appeared on the Friday Night Tights stream yesterday. No one likes the M-SHE-U and its negative impact on popular culture.

    PEACE 😇

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=VdTiywjsfO0

    Replies: @LT1488, @LT1488, @LondonBob

    Who cares about the MCU and Jewish Hollywood in general anyway. It’s all goyslop to distract the goyim from real issues such as mass immigration and neocon wars.

    • Replies: @songbird
    @LT1488

    In the top forty action movies of the 2010s, the object of pursuit was a glowing rock a third of the time. Largely due to superhero movies.

    (Source: You Are What You Watch, Hickey)

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

  971. @A123
    Vivek appeared on the Friday Night Tights stream yesterday. No one likes the M-SHE-U and its negative impact on popular culture.

    PEACE 😇

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=VdTiywjsfO0

    Replies: @LT1488, @LT1488, @LondonBob

    Who cares about MCU and Hollywood anyways? It’s just goyslop to distract the goyim from real issues like mass immigration and neocon wars.

  972. Sher Singh says:
    @Mr. Hack
    @Another Polish Perspective


    I see you read OT as something that once was and is no more. If religion is just a historical tale, it is just that – the story about past, not present, and not future. I suppose it is hard to believe in contingent historical ecclectism. But you can LARP;)
     
    Who's larping here? You're reading things into my commentary that I never wrote, nor implied. I view the OT as being very important, not the least being the many allusions to the coming of the messiah Our Lord Jesus Christ within its written pages.

    The Old Testament has a notion of Jew which is only fully understandable if you see it also as a certain set of genes. It is only in this sense that Jew can be told nowadays – from the OT perspective.
     
    So apparently the "real Jews" share a unique genetic code? Has it been located and formulized yet? I think not, because you go on to state:

    hat we cannot say who is who re Jewish tribes now, is irrelevant since God can know – if only some of these people fathered children through generations.
     
    So if only God can know with any ceertainty (and perhaps kremlinstoogeA123), why are we even having this discussion anyway? Your guess is as good as mine, or anybody else's.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Another Polish Perspective, @Sher Singh

    WHY DO SIKHS CARRY WEAPONS – WHY NOT JUST LANGAR (SOUP KITCHEN – ALMSHOUSE)!?!

    A hindu man was converted into Islam & kept as a slave for 9 years without any payment. Guruji ki Fauj (Nihanga Sikhs), went to rescue him. Yeah this is India only, not in Pakistan.

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Sher Singh

    I wonder if Hindu nationalists have anything at all to say about what happened to him. It would allow them to reinforce their Hindu victim mentality, after all.

    , @Mr. Hack
    @Sher Singh

    Aren't guns more lethal than swords?

    Putler has decided to bypass swords, guns, tanks and planes in favor of the ultimate weapon in his religious quest for megalomaniacal immortality. His high priest, Patriarch Kirill (fully approved by kremlinstoogeA123) can be seen gleefully supporting his personal intercessor with the Almighty, egging him on and promising to bless this weaponry as he's been known to do with other such weapons earmarked for Ukraine:

    https://cartoonmovement.com/search?query=putin&field_editors_choice=0&page=5

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Sher Singh, @Sher Singh

    , @Greasy William
    @Sher Singh

    Can someone explain to me what the purpose of keeping someone as a slave is in 2024? Modern capitalism shows that slavery is inefficient, it's much more profitable to just have people voluntarily work for starvation wages than to enslave them. Haven't any of these human traffickers ever read The Jungle?

    Replies: @Sher Singh

  973. @Sher Singh
    @Mr. Hack

    WHY DO SIKHS CARRY WEAPONS - WHY NOT JUST LANGAR (SOUP KITCHEN - ALMSHOUSE)!?!


    A hindu man was converted into Islam & kept as a slave for 9 years without any payment. Guruji ki Fauj (Nihanga Sikhs), went to rescue him. Yeah this is India only, not in Pakistan.
     

    https://twitter.com/Half_baaked/status/1746656996118626587

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. Hack, @Greasy William

    I wonder if Hindu nationalists have anything at all to say about what happened to him. It would allow them to reinforce their Hindu victim mentality, after all.

  974. @Mr. XYZ
    @Greasy William

    Poland also has more people belonging to this category than any other country in spite of the fact that attempting to save Jews' lives in Nazi-occupied Poland resulted in the death penalty if you were discovered doing this by the Nazis, which AFAIK was NOT true for other Nazi-occupied countries:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Righteous_Among_the_Nations

    Replies: @Greasy William

    There were plenty of righteous Polish ~individuals~ but the Polish population as a whole behaved in a disgraceful fashion. The Poles probably weren’t any worse than the Hungarians or Romanians but the difference is that those countries were German allies whereas the Poles were fighting the Germans but still murdered Jews en masse.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Greasy William

    The impression that I got is that Poles were more passive relative to Hungarians and Romanians, no? In Hungary, for instance, IIRC, Nazi Germany had a lot of Hungarian collaborators on the ground who helped them mass murder Hungarian Jewry with extraordinarily ruthless speed and efficiency. I don't think that Polish collaborators were as crucial in Poland's Holocaust, were they? As for Romania, it had a notorious homegrown Nazi-like movement in the form of the Iron Guard before Antonescu crushed it but then sought to emulate some aspects of it, such as the vehemently violent anti-Semitism. But of course Antonescu did spare the overwhelming majority of the Jews of the Romanian Old Kingdom territories in a last-minute decision in an unsuccessful attempt to save his own skin after the end of the war. He was merciless towards Jews outside of these territories, though.

    Replies: @Greasy William

  975. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP


    Invading other countries is generally wrong in principle, unless there are wildly extenuating circumstances (Hitler’s genocide of Jews and Slavs even had it been contained within Germany’s borders, Pol Pot, Stalin).

     

    Agreed about Pol Pot, Stalin, and Communists in general (I think that a Western-led/US-led regime change war against the Bolsheviks back during the Russian Civil War would have been not only justified but also very moral, for instance). (It's to the West's eternal shame that the West opposed the Vietnamese regime change in Cambodia back in 1979. The West should not have done that, for the sake of the Cambodian people themselves. Everything turned out OK in the end, thankfully.)

    In regards to Hitler specifically, it's very possible and perhaps even reasonably likely that he would have refrained from engaging in genocide (as opposed to mass deportations, which he would have been and remained a huge fan of) on anywhere near as large of a scale had the West allowed him to expand eastwards without any opposition. In such a scenario, Hitler probably wouldn't want to destroy his relations with the West by committing outright genocide.


    In the case of the Iraq war, while the invasion itself was not terribly bloody or brutal (Americans killed fewer civilians while occupying all of Iraq than Russians did while occupying 8% of Ukraine in 2022-2024), it unleashed Iraqi forces who engaged in a horrific civil war with 100,000s dead and destruction of much of Iraq’s ancient Christian population. This on balance wasn’t “worth” deposing Saddam’s secular dictatorship.

     

    Well, if one wants to be fair, Iraq's Christians have subsequently established new, perhaps sometimes better lives in the West, comparable to Mizrahi Jews resettling in Israel after they were expelled en masse from Arab and Muslim countries. But Yeah, this is why I'm suggesting that it's unclear if the cost of this was actually worth it. What is interesting, though, is that the Iraqi people themselves (at least excluding the Sunni Arabs, who were only 20% of Iraq's total population) wanted to overthrow Saddam Hussein back in 1991. Did they change their minds in regards to this by 2003?

    As a side note, I wonder if a better outcome for Iraq could have been established had we either helped the Iraqi people overthrow Saddam Hussein back in 1991 or had we allowed Iran to win the Iran-Iraq War and do regime change in Iraq back in the 1980s.

    But Yeah, I get your logic about the price of freedom of Iraqis possibly being too high. If open borders for Iraqis with some other, better off Muslim countries would have been available, then there wouldn't have been a need to overthrow Saddam. It's similar to how had there not been an Armenian Genocide and a Bolshevik coup in Russia, the final outcome of WWI, specifically the redrawing of Europe's borders more along ethnic lines, would have been highly desirable, but the cost of this would have still been way too high (millions of deaths and years of a devastating and destabilizing World War).

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Wokechoke

    Mr Boris Johnson Says

  976. @A123
    Vivek appeared on the Friday Night Tights stream yesterday. No one likes the M-SHE-U and its negative impact on popular culture.

    PEACE 😇

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=VdTiywjsfO0

    Replies: @LT1488, @LT1488, @LondonBob

    Vivek reminds me of the Indian character in Mean Girls.

    Give him credit he knows what to say, and people seem to buy it, but he is the great replacement personified.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @LondonBob

    Who is the Indian character in Mean Girls? They weren't memorable enough for me to remember them, whoever they were.

  977. In how many Chinese comedies does the protagonist die at the end? (Have seen more than one)

    Can’t think of any famous Hollywood comedies where this happens.

    Thought the CCP had pretty much pulled Buddhism out by the roots, and one doesn’t think of China in a similar way to Japan, as being prone to natural disasters. (Though it is a big country and does have them.). Is it communism itself? Or a Buddhist resurgence?

  978. • Replies: @A123
    @Mikhail


    Ukraine & Netanyahu Face Significant Decline
     
    What an odd construct. One is a nation, the other is a person.

    Is Ukraine declining? Yes. Cash flows from America are cut off. And, Kiev still has no strategy for victory.

    Is Israel declining? No. This must be the reason for the odd headline. Israel, like Russia, is winning. They are beating the enemy 20:1 in the field. Every Israeli leader has similar national security policy, so removing Netanyahu would have limited impact.

    Is Netanyahu declining? TBD. His personal poll numbers are quite bad. This also applies to his predecessors Gantz and Bennett.

    Palestinian Jews are rightfully upset over officialdom allowing Oct. 7 to happen. This needs an investigation and explanation. Mossad was spending time organizing protests against Netanyahu instead of protecting the people from threats.

    Netanyahu is wisely rejecting the Veggie-In-Chief's efforts to make things worse: (1)

    Starting with the United Nations partition plan in 1948 and including several Israeli governments, there were repeated offers of a separate Arab state, and all were rejected by Palestinians.

    That hasn’t changed, with Hamas saying again last week it doesn’t want a two-state solution.

    Its leaders demand a one-state solution, with Israel eliminated.

    But undeterred by facts, Secretary of State Tony Blinken took the administration’s loopy fixation to Davos, where he declared that Israel can never achieve “genuine security” without a pathway to a Palestinian state.
    ...
    Netanyahu said Thursday that Israel must maintain security control “over all the territory west of the Jordan,” referring to Gaza and the West Bank.

    Asked about American pressure, Netanyahu told reporters: “The prime minister needs to be able to say no, even to our best friends.”
     
    The good news for Netanyahu is that he has time. The next budget ~12 months away, and the coalition is solid. If his administration delivers in Gaza, effectively shutting down Hamas, that will create significant good will with voters.

    PEACE 😇
    ___________

    (1) https://nypost.com/2024/01/20/opinion/a-two-state-solution-would-be-a-disaster-for-the-biden-administration/
  979. Battle of the Nations
    Russia Australia

    [MORE]

    Australia TV does not display the Russia flag to protest axis evil.

  980. It is interesting how Disney is considered or was considered a family-orientated entertainment company, but very few of its animated films feature a mother and father, where neither dies.

    I wonder if that same level would be considered a constant throughout the history of storytelling – if it is found in folklore too.

  981. @Sher Singh
    @Mr. Hack

    WHY DO SIKHS CARRY WEAPONS - WHY NOT JUST LANGAR (SOUP KITCHEN - ALMSHOUSE)!?!


    A hindu man was converted into Islam & kept as a slave for 9 years without any payment. Guruji ki Fauj (Nihanga Sikhs), went to rescue him. Yeah this is India only, not in Pakistan.
     

    https://twitter.com/Half_baaked/status/1746656996118626587

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. Hack, @Greasy William

    Aren’t guns more lethal than swords?

    Putler has decided to bypass swords, guns, tanks and planes in favor of the ultimate weapon in his religious quest for megalomaniacal immortality. His high priest, Patriarch Kirill (fully approved by kremlinstoogeA123) can be seen gleefully supporting his personal intercessor with the Almighty, egging him on and promising to bless this weaponry as he’s been known to do with other such weapons earmarked for Ukraine:

    https://cartoonmovement.com/search?query=putin&field_editors_choice=0&page=5

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Mr. Hack

    Follow the link to Nicocomix to the excellent cartoon "birthdayPutin".

    1 Comment


    Enrico Bertuccioli
    So good.

    , @Sher Singh
    @Mr. Hack

    An interesting type of polity in Ancient Punjab were the Ayudhajivi Sanghas, or republics/guilds who live by the means of arms :

    https://twitter com/sialmirzagoraya/status/1713289349788520735

    , @Sher Singh
    @Mr. Hack


    Aren’t guns more lethal than swords?
     
    Not if you're trying to be a lady killer.

    ਅਕਾਲ
  982. @Mr. Hack
    @Sher Singh

    Aren't guns more lethal than swords?

    Putler has decided to bypass swords, guns, tanks and planes in favor of the ultimate weapon in his religious quest for megalomaniacal immortality. His high priest, Patriarch Kirill (fully approved by kremlinstoogeA123) can be seen gleefully supporting his personal intercessor with the Almighty, egging him on and promising to bless this weaponry as he's been known to do with other such weapons earmarked for Ukraine:

    https://cartoonmovement.com/search?query=putin&field_editors_choice=0&page=5

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Sher Singh, @Sher Singh

    Follow the link to Nicocomix to the excellent cartoon “birthdayPutin”.

    1 Comment

    Enrico Bertuccioli
    So good.

  983. @Sher Singh
    @Mr. Hack

    WHY DO SIKHS CARRY WEAPONS - WHY NOT JUST LANGAR (SOUP KITCHEN - ALMSHOUSE)!?!


    A hindu man was converted into Islam & kept as a slave for 9 years without any payment. Guruji ki Fauj (Nihanga Sikhs), went to rescue him. Yeah this is India only, not in Pakistan.
     

    https://twitter.com/Half_baaked/status/1746656996118626587

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. Hack, @Greasy William

    Can someone explain to me what the purpose of keeping someone as a slave is in 2024? Modern capitalism shows that slavery is inefficient, it’s much more profitable to just have people voluntarily work for starvation wages than to enslave them. Haven’t any of these human traffickers ever read The Jungle?

    • Replies: @Sher Singh
    @Greasy William

    Power.

  984. @LT1488
    @A123

    Who cares about the MCU and Jewish Hollywood in general anyway. It's all goyslop to distract the goyim from real issues such as mass immigration and neocon wars.

    Replies: @songbird

    In the top forty action movies of the 2010s, the object of pursuit was a glowing rock a third of the time. Largely due to superhero movies.

    (Source: You Are What You Watch, Hickey)

    • Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    https://www.quora.com/What-was-in-the-briefcase-from-Pulp-Fiction-and-why-was-it-so-important

    Replies: @songbird

  985. @songbird
    @LT1488

    In the top forty action movies of the 2010s, the object of pursuit was a glowing rock a third of the time. Largely due to superhero movies.

    (Source: You Are What You Watch, Hickey)

    Replies: @Emil Nikola Richard

    • Replies: @songbird
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    TBH, Pulp Fiction has that one scene in it that triggers my strong disgust reflex too well for me to enjoy the movie. Think it is genetic.

    MacGuffins were really big in the '90s. I half-suspect that it wasn't so much a fashion as part of some broader cultural shift towards materialism. (Crazy theory, I know).

  986. @Gerard1234
    @sudden death

    LMAO !! So there is you..........a worthless Black Russian POS, reading the book of a worthless POS western "journalist", full of worthless POS, interviewing various psychotic worthless POS, talking worthless POS......all as a pathetic PR exercise of worthless POS........so that a worthless Black Russian POS can be pumped full or more worthless POS, so that you can remain to live as you are.........a worthless POS


    The military's commander in chief, Zaluzhny, ordered units to disperse around the country, ostensibly for training exercises, and moved air-defence batteries and military aircraft from their bases to new, hidden locations

     

    Yes......in the cities,around tall buildings you dipshit are these "hidden locations" for the A-A complex!

    WHAT successes of their aircraft in the opening months did the Ukronazis have you imbecile? Hiding small numbers of aircraft has not been especially difficult for the last 90 years, soviets made plenty of installations to do this.

    I would add that Russia has gone 2 different periods in the last 10 months of going several months without ANY plane or helicopter losses. Considering the numbers of sorties flown each day, that is fenomenal.

    I was afraid that we would lose the element of surprise
     
    So this retard admits the obvious that they "created element of surprise", i.e they got annihilated en masse......by deliberately not asking civilians to leave the cities or border regions, using them as civilian shields and or just killing them directly, embedding air-defence in the cities in or around high-rise buildings leaving huge numbers of people vulnerable, trying to claim that they were luring Russia into the cities etc. Incompetent, pussys, cowards and sadists!

    Anyway - an interview with the vatnik tramp Zaluzhny is irrelevant for what is a western operation.

    Replies: @sudden death

    embedding air-defence in the cities in or around high-rise buildings

    haha, despite it allegedly being done before 02.24 when there were enough RF lovers existing in those cities and no any restrictions for info spreading had been enabled yet, still for some reason no any single video/photo of such things has surfaced at the time?

    Not only UA army outsmarted poor old Putler, but they managed to make those air defense installations in the cities outright invisible, truly great job achieved then;)

  987. Did anybody ever verify the Gonzalo Lira report that a long distance missile at a NATO barracks that killed multiple NATO officers was the cause that squelched all the no-fly zone talk the first couple of weeks into the special military operation war? Ron Unz even wrote a long article about the reports’ reliability months after but there was no consensus back then.

    I thought that was close to Coach Red Pill’s best offering.

  988. @Greasy William
    @Another Polish Perspective


    BTW, Poles did not exterminate Jews. Germans did.
     
    The Polish people enthusiastically collaborated with the Holocaust every step of the way. The AK murdered more Jews during the Warsaw Uprising than the Nazis did. Poland was the only country in Europe to have a pogrom post war. Poland also expelled it's remaining Jews in the 1960's, something even the Hungarians and Romanians (nations who were certainly no lovers of the Jewish people) didn't do

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Another Polish Perspective

    After 1945, it was Jewish communist themselves in Polish gov who were liquidating and closing Jewish organizations. They simply liked communism more than Judaism, and wanted everything to be under the control of Party. Also originally, communism disliked Judaism as much as Christianity. Jews who liked Judaism more, often emigrated, but as a result of their own choice.

    1968 was a result of intra-fight between Jewish communists and Polish communists. This immigration was small and concerned mainly big cities inhabitants. It wasn’t a forced emigration too – you still could stay if you relinquished your previous job and accepted a low-profile life.

  989. @Mr. Hack
    @Another Polish Perspective

    The Jewish people for a very long time have been an amalgamation of different tribes, political views, philosophic views, geographic orientations (Sephardic, Ashkenazi, Khazar, African) even religious orientations: orthodox, conservative and reform. In other words, a very representative type of world ethnos, really only differentiating themselves in that they also have their own unique religion (although many are apostates and have embraced secularism). You clearly reference the Phoenicians, Samaritans and Canaanites as being "false jews" even though all three of these sub-groups were semitic peoples in very close proximity to the original Biblical Jews and inhabiting the lands of modern-day Israel, and no longer exist as independent peoples today.

    Even the original Biblical Jews were comprised of 10 tribes often warring amongst themselves. There was the long-developed cleavage between Israel and Judah. How can anybody today claim to have the authority to be able to pronounce who is a "real Jew" and who is a "fake Jew"? Preposterous!

    BTW, you never directly answered my question whether Jews who become part of the "Jews for Jesus" movement lose their authenticity?

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective, @Another Polish Perspective, @Gerard1234

    And Jews who become Chief of Staff to President, President and Prime Minister of a fake country at the same time, on two DIFFERENT times in the last 5 years?
    LMAO!

  990. @Mikhail
    French Fries (Stated as a rhetorical reverse JJ.)

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0rcay7IHH7I

    &

    https://strategic-culture.su/news/2024/01/20/macron-does-a-putin-ends-up-shooting-own-foot/

    Replies: @A123

    Ukraine & Netanyahu Face Significant Decline

    What an odd construct. One is a nation, the other is a person.

    Is Ukraine declining? Yes. Cash flows from America are cut off. And, Kiev still has no strategy for victory.

    Is Israel declining? No. This must be the reason for the odd headline. Israel, like Russia, is winning. They are beating the enemy 20:1 in the field. Every Israeli leader has similar national security policy, so removing Netanyahu would have limited impact.

    Is Netanyahu declining? TBD. His personal poll numbers are quite bad. This also applies to his predecessors Gantz and Bennett.

    Palestinian Jews are rightfully upset over officialdom allowing Oct. 7 to happen. This needs an investigation and explanation. Mossad was spending time organizing protests against Netanyahu instead of protecting the people from threats.

    Netanyahu is wisely rejecting the Veggie-In-Chief’s efforts to make things worse: (1)

    Starting with the United Nations partition plan in 1948 and including several Israeli governments, there were repeated offers of a separate Arab state, and all were rejected by Palestinians.

    That hasn’t changed, with Hamas saying again last week it doesn’t want a two-state solution.

    Its leaders demand a one-state solution, with Israel eliminated.

    But undeterred by facts, Secretary of State Tony Blinken took the administration’s loopy fixation to Davos, where he declared that Israel can never achieve “genuine security” without a pathway to a Palestinian state.

    Netanyahu said Thursday that Israel must maintain security control “over all the territory west of the Jordan,” referring to Gaza and the West Bank.

    Asked about American pressure, Netanyahu told reporters: “The prime minister needs to be able to say no, even to our best friends.”

    The good news for Netanyahu is that he has time. The next budget ~12 months away, and the coalition is solid. If his administration delivers in Gaza, effectively shutting down Hamas, that will create significant good will with voters.

    PEACE 😇
    ___________

    (1) https://nypost.com/2024/01/20/opinion/a-two-state-solution-would-be-a-disaster-for-the-biden-administration/

  991. Over at Godlikeproductions, the British forum moderator ‘Lagertha’ just outed themselves as govt or Tavistock asset, they broke the UKs online hate speech rules too.

    I commented on their hypocrisy and illegal online activity as per the UK govt, got banned LMAO.

    I suppose they are still butt hurt over their incompetent naval captains, same ship same capitan two collisions in two years.

  992. @Philip Owen
    EPIPHANY FROSTS
    I was sceptical about reports of Russian infrastructure breakdown. A bit more than usual perhaps but exagerrated because of media attention. However, this list from Saratov, not reported as having a major breakdown, changes my mind. I have spend the Epiphany Frosts in Saratov. At Slonova 1, one of the listed buildings as it happens. Something bad really is happening to Russian heating utilities.

    https://www.vzsar.ru/news/2024/01/19/v-saratove-opyat-otkluchaut-otoplenie-i-gvs-nazvany-adresa.html

    Replies: @QCIC, @YetAnotherAnon

    OTOH the Royal Navy seems incapable of wiring an electric motor correctly, AND incapable of testing that it’s wired correctly.

    https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2024/jan/21/royal-navy-warships-crashed-into-each-other-due-to-faulty-rewiring-say-sources

    Two Royal Navy warships collided in Bahrain at the end of last week because one was incorrectly rewired, meaning that it unexpectedly went into reverse when it was set to go forward, military sources have said.

    The minehunter HMS Chiddingfold went backwards into HMS Bangor, which was lying at port, ripping a hole in a cabin above the waterline, in an embarrassing blunder that the defence secretary, Grant Shapps, insisted did not reflect incompetence.

    “HMS Chiddingfold’s motor was wired incorrectly and full ahead gave full astern,” a navy insider said. The vessel had been recently inspected by officers at the maritime capability, trials and assessment team, they added.

    Fresh video and pictures from inside HMS Bangor show sunlight clearly coming through a hole at the end of a kitchen cabin and damage to sleeping berths. Another picture of the outside of the warship shows the side ripped open and its pennant number, M109.

    Previous footage, which appeared on social media on Friday evening, showed HMS Chiddingfold heading inexorably towards HMS Bangor, a crash that its crew appeared unable to prevent.

    • Replies: @Beyond the pale and fedup
    @YetAnotherAnon

    The same ship did the same to HMS Bangor in 2022, rammed it twice in fact.
    Methinks they are well jabbed and suffering brainfog. add in some DEI.

    They should change the ships name to HMS Idiocracy for 2024.

    Replies: @QCIC

  993. The recent ‘Ukrainian’ drone strikes on Russian infrastructure are alarming. My impression is that if these strikes keep up we are getting uncomfortably close to WW3. The strikes are fully supported by NATO and the USA and may not even be launched from Ukraine. If the strikes keep occurring I suppose Russia will institute some sort of civil defense measures to place alert and armed citizens at every possible drone target at all times. If these Western-sponsored attacks involve serious Russian civilian casualties I wonder if the government will go to a harsh martial law scenario? This may make people wish for the good old days of nice guy Putin.

    As the proxy war created by the West drags on it creates a challenge for the Russian military. If this were a Western campaign, Kharkov and Kiev would have been destroyed long ago and the surviving Ukrainian leadership would have capitulated. A big problem for Russia is that Kiev and Kharkov are some of the last places they want to destroy. A second problem is the mask of the West has mostly slipped and this is really no longer a proxy war. If Russia destroys the two cities to achieve capitulation, the West may fight harder and do more attacks from locations outside of Ukraine. They can always claim the attacks were committed by Ukrainian partisans to keep the proxy war mask from falling off entirely.

    The West is playing a very dangerous game of brinksmanship with Russia. The post-Cold War mandate for Western leaders was supposed to be do NOT pressure Russia into preemptively using nuclear weapons. The Western plan for the past two years seems to be designed specifically to push Russia dangerously in this regard. If the West does not back off the Ukraine project soon, China and Russia may decide it is better to collapse the dollar system and accept the risks and dire consequences which are hopefully less than an all-out nuclear war.

    Perhaps some Chechen will nuke Dnipro to see if that pressure point is sensitive enough to calm this situation down. Nukemap calculates a 50 kiloton Iskander detonation over Dnipro would lead to 60,000 deaths and 200,000 casualties. Call it 250,000 dead to be realistic. We know this would probably NOT stop the ‘Ukrainian leadership’ or the West since their shared goal seems to be to kill Slavs (Ukrainian or Russian, doesn’t seem to matter). But would it be enough to wake up the remaining sensible Ukrainians so they will starting shooting their comprador elites in the head?

    https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @QCIC


    Perhaps some Chechen will nuke Dnipro to see if that pressure point is sensitive enough to calm this situation down. Nukemap calculates a 50 kiloton Iskander detonation over Dnipro would lead to 60,000 deaths and 200,000 casualties. Call it 250,000 dead to be realistic. We know this would probably NOT stop the ‘Ukrainian leadership’ or the West since their shared goal seems to be to kill Slavs (Ukrainian or Russian, doesn’t seem to matter). But would it be enough to wake up the remaining sensible Ukrainians so they will starting shooting their comprador elites in the head?

     

    Do Chechens actually have access to Russia's nuclear weapons?

    Replies: @QCIC

    , @AnonfromTN
    @QCIC


    The recent ‘Ukrainian’ drone strikes on Russian infrastructure are alarming.
     
    This was to be expected. Ukie “counter-offensive” was a pathetic failure, Ukies keep losing militarily and retreating, so they are trying to take it out on civilians. Just yesterday they shelled Donetsk food market, which has zero military value, killing 25 civilians, including children. The head of Russian state investigating body ordered to identify everyone responsible on the Ukie side, from perpetrators to those who issued criminal orders. They will be punished.

    When the clown and other top criminals in his compradore administration run away from collapsed Ukraine to their puppet masters, if those masters don’t kill them promptly themselves, Russian operatives will deliver justice.

    The empire and its sidekicks encourage Ukie attacks on civilians in an attempt to provoke Russia into doing something similar. I don’t think Putin would bite this bait: Russia will likely keep avoiding civilan targets to minimize civilian deaths.

    As to nukes, let me assure you that Russian nukes won’t fly to Dnepropetrovsk, Kiev, or even Lvov. If Russian nukes start flying, they are going to target places where the decisions are made: Pentagon, US military bases, CIA headquarters, possibly MI6 and British bases.

    Replies: @QCIC

  994. @AP
    @Derer


    Austria imported all the cars, you moron…how it is in Gross DOMESTIC Product
     
    You are dumb as usual. Austria made automobiles and supplied parts for others’ automobiles.

    Although of course I was writing about rich Austrians buying cars.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steyr-Daimler-Puch



    After the war, Steyr-Daimler-Puch built diesel engined trucks and buses, small and heavy tractors and resumed passenger car production. First, Steyr assembled the FIAT 1100E, then put their own engine in a Fiat 1400, renaming the car the "Steyr 2000". From 1957 through to the early 1970s it produced the tiny Puch 500 under license from FIAT, again with an engine of Austrian design.

    Most prominent was its range of off-road cars, from the two-cylinder Haflinger and the 4 x 4 or 6 x 6 Pinzgauer, the Fiat Panda 4x4 (999 cc) to the Mercedes-Puch G. SDP was the initial designer and manufacturer of these utility vehicles. The Haflinger was produced from 1959–1974, the Pinzgauer from 1971–2000, and the Puch G (also known as Mercedes G-Class) from 1979.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Derer

    AP: “(Austrians had twice as many cars per capita than Czechs)?”

    As a justification for high GDP. The question is if those cars are home produced?
    No, 90% are produced outside Austria in lower cost countries.

    Now the AP hochstapler is bringing up that Austria actually produced heavy tractors and diesel engine trucks and buses instead of cars.

    AP:”Although of course I was writing about rich Austrians buying cars.”

    No, you were writing about how number of foreign cars contributing to Austrian GDP.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Derer


    AP: “(Austrians had twice as many cars per capita than Czechs)?”

    As a justification for high GDP.
     
    As evidence that Austrians were, indeed, a lot richer than Czechs. They had twice as many cars per capita.

    Now the AP hochstapler is bringing up that Austria actually produced heavy tractors and diesel engine trucks and buses instead of cars.
     
    The Puch cars were made there. Is reading hard for you:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puch_500

    Mercedes G-wagons were/are made in Austria also (it is of course an SUV but still a consumer product):

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercedes-Benz_G-Class

    Production 1979–present
    Assembly Austria: Graz (Magna Steyr)

    AP:”Although of course I was writing about rich Austrians buying cars.”

    No, you were writing about how number of foreign cars contributing to Austrian GDP.
     
    Nonsense. My words: "Did that also cause the dearth of consumer goods (Austrians had twice as many cars per capita than Czechs)?" It was a reflection of twice higher GDP, not a cause of it.

    Reading and thinking are hard for you, we know.
  995. @Mr. Hack
    @Sher Singh

    Aren't guns more lethal than swords?

    Putler has decided to bypass swords, guns, tanks and planes in favor of the ultimate weapon in his religious quest for megalomaniacal immortality. His high priest, Patriarch Kirill (fully approved by kremlinstoogeA123) can be seen gleefully supporting his personal intercessor with the Almighty, egging him on and promising to bless this weaponry as he's been known to do with other such weapons earmarked for Ukraine:

    https://cartoonmovement.com/search?query=putin&field_editors_choice=0&page=5

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Sher Singh, @Sher Singh

    An interesting type of polity in Ancient Punjab were the Ayudhajivi Sanghas, or republics/guilds who live by the means of arms :

    https://twitter com/sialmirzagoraya/status/1713289349788520735

  996. @Greasy William
    @Sher Singh

    Can someone explain to me what the purpose of keeping someone as a slave is in 2024? Modern capitalism shows that slavery is inefficient, it's much more profitable to just have people voluntarily work for starvation wages than to enslave them. Haven't any of these human traffickers ever read The Jungle?

    Replies: @Sher Singh

    Power.

  997. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ


    I’m not sure that the Iraq War was morally wrong
     
    Invading other countries is generally wrong in principle, unless there are wildly extenuating circumstances (Hitler's genocide of Jews and Slavs even had it been contained within Germany's borders, Pol Pot, Stalin).

    In the case of the Iraq war, while the invasion itself was not terribly bloody or brutal (Americans killed fewer civilians while occupying all of Iraq than Russians did while occupying 8% of Ukraine in 2022-2024), it unleashed Iraqi forces who engaged in a horrific civil war with 100,000s dead and destruction of much of Iraq's ancient Christian population. This on balance wasn't "worth" deposing Saddam's secular dictatorship.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Mr. XYZ, @Derer

    Why are you two replying to each other. You have the same IP and the same dual citizenship.

    • Replies: @AP
    @Derer

    Nice lies. I don't know his IP (neither do you) and I am not Israeli.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  998. Breaking news: (1)

    Ron DeSantis Drops Out of Presidential Race, Endorses Donald Trump

    Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, one of the two remaining challengers to former President Donald Trump, dropped out of the presidential race on Sunday, before the New Hampshire primary, and endorsed Trump.

    In a video DeSantis released from Florida on Sunday afternoon, he endorsed Trump over the last challenger—former South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley—saying that while he has disagreements with Trump he thinks Trump is better than Haley and certainly better than Democrat President Joe Biden.

    DeSantis’s exit from the race leaves one remaining serious challenger to Trump in the field: Haley. Things between Trump and Haley have been intensifying ahead of New Hampshire’s GOP primary on Tuesday, and a strong Trump performance there–as polls indicate is likely–could finish her off quickly and early, before the race turns next to Nevada and then to South Carolina. Haley is not even going to compete in the Nevada caucuses, which means DeSantis’s exit from the field essentially ensures a unanimous Trump victory there as only one other candidate–Ryan Binkley, who got slightly more votes than former Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson in Iowa’s caucuses–is competing in Nevada. What this all means is Tuesday’s New Hampshire primary essentially becomes do-or-die for Haley, in that she must defeat Trump and win the primary outright to have a path forward for her campaign.

    This was clearly the best move for DeSantis. Returning home to the active legislative session will generate positive results. And, he avoids an inevitable loss in New Hampshire.

    Endorsing Trump gives DeSantis’s supporters the opportunity to rejoin the saner & more intelligent MAGA policy side. Let us hope that they choose to build those bridges.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2024/01/21/ron-desantis-drops-out-presidential-race-endorses-donald-trump/

    • Replies: @Mikel
    @A123


    This was clearly the best move for DeSantis.
     
    Perhaps it was the best move for him personally but not for the chances of MAGA-like policies to ever be implemented at a national level (like he did in Florida).

    Not only are we now stuck with an inferior candidate that attracts the less intelligent and more divisive supporters (J6ers, conspiracy nutters and all sorts of fringe people) but also he leaves Nikki as the only contender. As I said the other day, he should have waited until the witch drops out too. If Trump doesn't make it to November for one reason or another, they may well try to shoehorn her as the Republican candidate.

    But, as Churchill said, the best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter. The average Republican voter wants to see a rematch with the con-man so we'll have to resign ourselves to a repeat of 2020, if we're lucky.

    Replies: @A123, @AnonfromTN

    , @Derer
    @A123

    Vindictive and snivelling Democrats start to concentrate on how to defeat Trump not by the will of the people by...now perfected 2020 criminal cheating scheme that gave this country 4 years of their mentally handicapped puppet.

    Beginning of the end of a great DNC "democracy" that keep defending borders of corrupt Ukraine and Israel instead of our nation.

  999. @Mr. Hack
    @songbird

    I used to tease my Bukovinian/Ukrainian father about whether we had any vampires in our bloodline. Bukovina was very close to Transylvania after all. There were even some novels written back then about Dracula's time in Lviv. Lucky me that my father had a good sense of humor. :-)

    Replies: @Gerard1234

    That’s good Hack, it confirms that your real name is Iosif…….your father must have named you after the great man for taking Bukovina and reuniting Russian lands!

    Did he have the iconic moustache also?

    It does remind me that the Galician prostitute cuckholds had zero role and ideological pursuit in reuniting Northern Bukovina for “Ukraine”. Zero role or connection with the slavs living on that land even during 1941-43 (except for killing Jews). Zero writing about it in their toilet paper “journals” or newspapers of the time. It just confirms that there is no “Ukraine” project, zero thing as a “Ukrainian nationalist”…. only some anti-Russia freakshow done for interests of their Austrian/Polish/German….. and now also Anglo-Saxon, masters.

    There was zero necessity for this action, which was completely independent of Molotov-Ribbentropp as it was only Moldovan lands the Soviets were legally entitled to take…… which does just that Stalin is the great father of 404.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Gerard1234

    I just don't understand you sometimes Gerald. It's obvious to anybody familiar with your communications here that you're a refined, scholarly sort always best informed by expressing your love for the arts, and yet you play cheerleader for the very uncouth Stalin and his progeny Putler? Do you really appreciate the music of Chick Corea or is it just a front of some sort?

    https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/bHMAAOSw9hJhwUBM/s-l1600.jpg

  1000. @Mr. Hack
    @Sher Singh

    Aren't guns more lethal than swords?

    Putler has decided to bypass swords, guns, tanks and planes in favor of the ultimate weapon in his religious quest for megalomaniacal immortality. His high priest, Patriarch Kirill (fully approved by kremlinstoogeA123) can be seen gleefully supporting his personal intercessor with the Almighty, egging him on and promising to bless this weaponry as he's been known to do with other such weapons earmarked for Ukraine:

    https://cartoonmovement.com/search?query=putin&field_editors_choice=0&page=5

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Sher Singh, @Sher Singh

    Aren’t guns more lethal than swords?

    Not if you’re trying to be a lady killer.

    ਅਕਾਲ

    • LOL: songbird
  1001. Made some pinnia

    Khoya – made from 35% cream, 10% half-half & some 3%
    Flour to make it stick
    Some sugar
    Almonds
    Protein powder

    Hits good – keeps you warm.

    Gonna try more protein heavy recipe + maybe some buffalo milk next week, then pics.

  1002. @Emil Nikola Richard
    @songbird

    https://www.quora.com/What-was-in-the-briefcase-from-Pulp-Fiction-and-why-was-it-so-important

    Replies: @songbird

    TBH, Pulp Fiction has that one scene in it that triggers my strong disgust reflex too well for me to enjoy the movie. Think it is genetic.

    MacGuffins were really big in the ’90s. I half-suspect that it wasn’t so much a fashion as part of some broader cultural shift towards materialism. (Crazy theory, I know).

  1003. @Gerard1234
    @Mr. Hack

    That's good Hack, it confirms that your real name is Iosif.......your father must have named you after the great man for taking Bukovina and reuniting Russian lands!

    Did he have the iconic moustache also?

    It does remind me that the Galician prostitute cuckholds had zero role and ideological pursuit in reuniting Northern Bukovina for "Ukraine". Zero role or connection with the slavs living on that land even during 1941-43 (except for killing Jews). Zero writing about it in their toilet paper "journals" or newspapers of the time. It just confirms that there is no "Ukraine" project, zero thing as a "Ukrainian nationalist".... only some anti-Russia freakshow done for interests of their Austrian/Polish/German..... and now also Anglo-Saxon, masters.

    There was zero necessity for this action, which was completely independent of Molotov-Ribbentropp as it was only Moldovan lands the Soviets were legally entitled to take...... which does just that Stalin is the great father of 404.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    I just don’t understand you sometimes Gerald. It’s obvious to anybody familiar with your communications here that you’re a refined, scholarly sort always best informed by expressing your love for the arts, and yet you play cheerleader for the very uncouth Stalin and his progeny Putler? Do you really appreciate the music of Chick Corea or is it just a front of some sort?

  1004. @Greasy William
    @Mr. XYZ

    There were plenty of righteous Polish ~individuals~ but the Polish population as a whole behaved in a disgraceful fashion. The Poles probably weren't any worse than the Hungarians or Romanians but the difference is that those countries were German allies whereas the Poles were fighting the Germans but still murdered Jews en masse.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    The impression that I got is that Poles were more passive relative to Hungarians and Romanians, no? In Hungary, for instance, IIRC, Nazi Germany had a lot of Hungarian collaborators on the ground who helped them mass murder Hungarian Jewry with extraordinarily ruthless speed and efficiency. I don’t think that Polish collaborators were as crucial in Poland’s Holocaust, were they? As for Romania, it had a notorious homegrown Nazi-like movement in the form of the Iron Guard before Antonescu crushed it but then sought to emulate some aspects of it, such as the vehemently violent anti-Semitism. But of course Antonescu did spare the overwhelming majority of the Jews of the Romanian Old Kingdom territories in a last-minute decision in an unsuccessful attempt to save his own skin after the end of the war. He was merciless towards Jews outside of these territories, though.

    • Replies: @Greasy William
    @Mr. XYZ

    As I said, Hungary was a Nazi ally, Poland was waging an insurgency against the Nazis. But those same insurgents fighting the Nazis also engaged in mass murder of Jews. And unlike the Hungarians, Ukrainians and Balts, these Poles did it purely on their own without German help or supervision.

    The fact is that the overwhelming majority of the Hungarian and Polish populations whole heartedly supported the Holocaust, although that support was generally passive. But the Hungarians at least had an excuse given that their own fate was tied to that of Germany.

    Seriously, fuck Poland. I have nothing against the current state of Poland or the Polish people who exist ~today~, but the Polish population as a whole behaved in a disgraceful fashion during the war years, regardless of the genuine heroism and sacrifice of many ~individual~ Poles.

    But it's all water under the bridge as far as I'm concerned. If the Poles don't want to own up to their history, they are only hurting themselves. What's done is done and neither the Poles, the Hungarians or anyone else for that matter has ever done something like Oct 7th. There is only one nation in history that has done something like that.

    Eyes on the prize.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  1005. @LondonBob
    @A123

    Vivek reminds me of the Indian character in Mean Girls.

    Give him credit he knows what to say, and people seem to buy it, but he is the great replacement personified.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Who is the Indian character in Mean Girls? They weren’t memorable enough for me to remember them, whoever they were.

  1006. @QCIC
    The recent 'Ukrainian' drone strikes on Russian infrastructure are alarming. My impression is that if these strikes keep up we are getting uncomfortably close to WW3. The strikes are fully supported by NATO and the USA and may not even be launched from Ukraine. If the strikes keep occurring I suppose Russia will institute some sort of civil defense measures to place alert and armed citizens at every possible drone target at all times. If these Western-sponsored attacks involve serious Russian civilian casualties I wonder if the government will go to a harsh martial law scenario? This may make people wish for the good old days of nice guy Putin.

    As the proxy war created by the West drags on it creates a challenge for the Russian military. If this were a Western campaign, Kharkov and Kiev would have been destroyed long ago and the surviving Ukrainian leadership would have capitulated. A big problem for Russia is that Kiev and Kharkov are some of the last places they want to destroy. A second problem is the mask of the West has mostly slipped and this is really no longer a proxy war. If Russia destroys the two cities to achieve capitulation, the West may fight harder and do more attacks from locations outside of Ukraine. They can always claim the attacks were committed by Ukrainian partisans to keep the proxy war mask from falling off entirely.

    The West is playing a very dangerous game of brinksmanship with Russia. The post-Cold War mandate for Western leaders was supposed to be do NOT pressure Russia into preemptively using nuclear weapons. The Western plan for the past two years seems to be designed specifically to push Russia dangerously in this regard. If the West does not back off the Ukraine project soon, China and Russia may decide it is better to collapse the dollar system and accept the risks and dire consequences which are hopefully less than an all-out nuclear war.

    Perhaps some Chechen will nuke Dnipro to see if that pressure point is sensitive enough to calm this situation down. Nukemap calculates a 50 kiloton Iskander detonation over Dnipro would lead to 60,000 deaths and 200,000 casualties. Call it 250,000 dead to be realistic. We know this would probably NOT stop the 'Ukrainian leadership' or the West since their shared goal seems to be to kill Slavs (Ukrainian or Russian, doesn't seem to matter). But would it be enough to wake up the remaining sensible Ukrainians so they will starting shooting their comprador elites in the head?

    https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AnonfromTN

    Perhaps some Chechen will nuke Dnipro to see if that pressure point is sensitive enough to calm this situation down. Nukemap calculates a 50 kiloton Iskander detonation over Dnipro would lead to 60,000 deaths and 200,000 casualties. Call it 250,000 dead to be realistic. We know this would probably NOT stop the ‘Ukrainian leadership’ or the West since their shared goal seems to be to kill Slavs (Ukrainian or Russian, doesn’t seem to matter). But would it be enough to wake up the remaining sensible Ukrainians so they will starting shooting their comprador elites in the head?

    Do Chechens actually have access to Russia’s nuclear weapons?

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Mr. XYZ

    Who knows, people tend to lie about that sort of thing ;)
    True Lies:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0vyQc2XUjn0
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GR3xaeE7oLc
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0HBj8OGw3ek (@ 0:30)

  1007. @QCIC
    The recent 'Ukrainian' drone strikes on Russian infrastructure are alarming. My impression is that if these strikes keep up we are getting uncomfortably close to WW3. The strikes are fully supported by NATO and the USA and may not even be launched from Ukraine. If the strikes keep occurring I suppose Russia will institute some sort of civil defense measures to place alert and armed citizens at every possible drone target at all times. If these Western-sponsored attacks involve serious Russian civilian casualties I wonder if the government will go to a harsh martial law scenario? This may make people wish for the good old days of nice guy Putin.

    As the proxy war created by the West drags on it creates a challenge for the Russian military. If this were a Western campaign, Kharkov and Kiev would have been destroyed long ago and the surviving Ukrainian leadership would have capitulated. A big problem for Russia is that Kiev and Kharkov are some of the last places they want to destroy. A second problem is the mask of the West has mostly slipped and this is really no longer a proxy war. If Russia destroys the two cities to achieve capitulation, the West may fight harder and do more attacks from locations outside of Ukraine. They can always claim the attacks were committed by Ukrainian partisans to keep the proxy war mask from falling off entirely.

    The West is playing a very dangerous game of brinksmanship with Russia. The post-Cold War mandate for Western leaders was supposed to be do NOT pressure Russia into preemptively using nuclear weapons. The Western plan for the past two years seems to be designed specifically to push Russia dangerously in this regard. If the West does not back off the Ukraine project soon, China and Russia may decide it is better to collapse the dollar system and accept the risks and dire consequences which are hopefully less than an all-out nuclear war.

    Perhaps some Chechen will nuke Dnipro to see if that pressure point is sensitive enough to calm this situation down. Nukemap calculates a 50 kiloton Iskander detonation over Dnipro would lead to 60,000 deaths and 200,000 casualties. Call it 250,000 dead to be realistic. We know this would probably NOT stop the 'Ukrainian leadership' or the West since their shared goal seems to be to kill Slavs (Ukrainian or Russian, doesn't seem to matter). But would it be enough to wake up the remaining sensible Ukrainians so they will starting shooting their comprador elites in the head?

    https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @AnonfromTN

    The recent ‘Ukrainian’ drone strikes on Russian infrastructure are alarming.

    This was to be expected. Ukie “counter-offensive” was a pathetic failure, Ukies keep losing militarily and retreating, so they are trying to take it out on civilians. Just yesterday they shelled Donetsk food market, which has zero military value, killing 25 civilians, including children. The head of Russian state investigating body ordered to identify everyone responsible on the Ukie side, from perpetrators to those who issued criminal orders. They will be punished.

    When the clown and other top criminals in his compradore administration run away from collapsed Ukraine to their puppet masters, if those masters don’t kill them promptly themselves, Russian operatives will deliver justice.

    The empire and its sidekicks encourage Ukie attacks on civilians in an attempt to provoke Russia into doing something similar. I don’t think Putin would bite this bait: Russia will likely keep avoiding civilan targets to minimize civilian deaths.

    As to nukes, let me assure you that Russian nukes won’t fly to Dnepropetrovsk, Kiev, or even Lvov. If Russian nukes start flying, they are going to target places where the decisions are made: Pentagon, US military bases, CIA headquarters, possibly MI6 and British bases.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @AnonfromTN

    I expected the drone strikes and agree that these will probably continue and possibly escalate. Previously I saw this mess as having an end point when Russia gains control of Kiev in whatever form that takes. Now I am not so sure. I don't think the frozen conflict will be Ukraine against Russia, it may be the West against Russia. I hope not. If so, I guess this is really just a continuation of the 1980's Cold War, except now most of the leaders in the West are both very stupid and crazy. Instead of gradual cooling and slowly improved relations we have a death spiral.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Mr. Hack

  1008. @A123
    Breaking news: (1)

    Ron DeSantis Drops Out of Presidential Race, Endorses Donald Trump

     

    Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, one of the two remaining challengers to former President Donald Trump, dropped out of the presidential race on Sunday, before the New Hampshire primary, and endorsed Trump.

    In a video DeSantis released from Florida on Sunday afternoon, he endorsed Trump over the last challenger—former South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley—saying that while he has disagreements with Trump he thinks Trump is better than Haley and certainly better than Democrat President Joe Biden.
    ...
    DeSantis’s exit from the race leaves one remaining serious challenger to Trump in the field: Haley. Things between Trump and Haley have been intensifying ahead of New Hampshire’s GOP primary on Tuesday, and a strong Trump performance there–as polls indicate is likely–could finish her off quickly and early, before the race turns next to Nevada and then to South Carolina. Haley is not even going to compete in the Nevada caucuses, which means DeSantis’s exit from the field essentially ensures a unanimous Trump victory there as only one other candidate–Ryan Binkley, who got slightly more votes than former Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson in Iowa’s caucuses–is competing in Nevada. What this all means is Tuesday’s New Hampshire primary essentially becomes do-or-die for Haley, in that she must defeat Trump and win the primary outright to have a path forward for her campaign.
     
    This was clearly the best move for DeSantis. Returning home to the active legislative session will generate positive results. And, he avoids an inevitable loss in New Hampshire.

    Endorsing Trump gives DeSantis's supporters the opportunity to rejoin the saner & more intelligent MAGA policy side. Let us hope that they choose to build those bridges.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2024/01/21/ron-desantis-drops-out-presidential-race-endorses-donald-trump/

    Replies: @Mikel, @Derer

    This was clearly the best move for DeSantis.

    Perhaps it was the best move for him personally but not for the chances of MAGA-like policies to ever be implemented at a national level (like he did in Florida).

    Not only are we now stuck with an inferior candidate that attracts the less intelligent and more divisive supporters (J6ers, conspiracy nutters and all sorts of fringe people) but also he leaves Nikki as the only contender. As I said the other day, he should have waited until the witch drops out too. If Trump doesn’t make it to November for one reason or another, they may well try to shoehorn her as the Republican candidate.

    But, as Churchill said, the best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter. The average Republican voter wants to see a rematch with the con-man so we’ll have to resign ourselves to a repeat of 2020, if we’re lucky.

    • Replies: @A123
    @Mikel



    Endorsing Trump gives DeSantis’s supporters the opportunity to rejoin the saner & more intelligent MAGA policy side. Let us hope that they choose to build those bridges.
     
    we [are] now stuck with an inferior candidate
     
    So no "bridge building" yet?

    You cannot accept the superior MAGA policy candidate who attracts saner and more intelligent supporters? For example, those who realize that the 2020 election was stolen. The evidence is undeniable and overwhelming.

     
    https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiv_eP2G0sljTc7R-d6ORVLWrav4ulUTwD5NAQ3WwQ2pk6EtJNWZO3HHDmY0AQwrcjGYPqQfHhzk0yJEZ2i8oQMsJxH4_0c-IoZXQLjSFkoOF8VvCKW-7D7R2sWkzllRXBCT3CpBsIvN82jYkfOrF14z_Y0-1i_RbQ5B4_3jJ9DX79kZl-NVWEXLKEp7qg/s1254/1%20dfsafsadfsadfasf.jpg
     

    The offer remains open. If you want to stop lying and return to MAGA, the Trump 2024 campaign will be here.

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇

    Replies: @Mikel

    , @AnonfromTN
    @Mikel


    he should have waited until the witch drops out too.
     
    She is not a witch, just a bitch.
  1009. @YetAnotherAnon
    @Philip Owen

    OTOH the Royal Navy seems incapable of wiring an electric motor correctly, AND incapable of testing that it's wired correctly.

    https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2024/jan/21/royal-navy-warships-crashed-into-each-other-due-to-faulty-rewiring-say-sources


    Two Royal Navy warships collided in Bahrain at the end of last week because one was incorrectly rewired, meaning that it unexpectedly went into reverse when it was set to go forward, military sources have said.

    The minehunter HMS Chiddingfold went backwards into HMS Bangor, which was lying at port, ripping a hole in a cabin above the waterline, in an embarrassing blunder that the defence secretary, Grant Shapps, insisted did not reflect incompetence.


    “HMS Chiddingfold’s motor was wired incorrectly and full ahead gave full astern,” a navy insider said. The vessel had been recently inspected by officers at the maritime capability, trials and assessment team, they added.

    Fresh video and pictures from inside HMS Bangor show sunlight clearly coming through a hole at the end of a kitchen cabin and damage to sleeping berths. Another picture of the outside of the warship shows the side ripped open and its pennant number, M109.

    Previous footage, which appeared on social media on Friday evening, showed HMS Chiddingfold heading inexorably towards HMS Bangor, a crash that its crew appeared unable to prevent.
     

    Replies: @Beyond the pale and fedup

    The same ship did the same to HMS Bangor in 2022, rammed it twice in fact.
    Methinks they are well jabbed and suffering brainfog. add in some DEI.

    They should change the ships name to HMS Idiocracy for 2024.

    • Replies: @QCIC
    @Beyond the pale and fedup

    PouponMarx, what do you have to say about these ship handling mistakes?

  1010. @AnonfromTN
    @QCIC


    The recent ‘Ukrainian’ drone strikes on Russian infrastructure are alarming.
     
    This was to be expected. Ukie “counter-offensive” was a pathetic failure, Ukies keep losing militarily and retreating, so they are trying to take it out on civilians. Just yesterday they shelled Donetsk food market, which has zero military value, killing 25 civilians, including children. The head of Russian state investigating body ordered to identify everyone responsible on the Ukie side, from perpetrators to those who issued criminal orders. They will be punished.

    When the clown and other top criminals in his compradore administration run away from collapsed Ukraine to their puppet masters, if those masters don’t kill them promptly themselves, Russian operatives will deliver justice.

    The empire and its sidekicks encourage Ukie attacks on civilians in an attempt to provoke Russia into doing something similar. I don’t think Putin would bite this bait: Russia will likely keep avoiding civilan targets to minimize civilian deaths.

    As to nukes, let me assure you that Russian nukes won’t fly to Dnepropetrovsk, Kiev, or even Lvov. If Russian nukes start flying, they are going to target places where the decisions are made: Pentagon, US military bases, CIA headquarters, possibly MI6 and British bases.

    Replies: @QCIC

    I expected the drone strikes and agree that these will probably continue and possibly escalate. Previously I saw this mess as having an end point when Russia gains control of Kiev in whatever form that takes. Now I am not so sure. I don’t think the frozen conflict will be Ukraine against Russia, it may be the West against Russia. I hope not. If so, I guess this is really just a continuation of the 1980’s Cold War, except now most of the leaders in the West are both very stupid and crazy. Instead of gradual cooling and slowly improved relations we have a death spiral.

    • Replies: @AnonfromTN
    @QCIC


    most of the leaders in the West are both very stupid and crazy
     
    Hard to argue, perfectly true regarding the real leaders, rich “elites”. So called “elected leaders” are no more than figureheads. That’s why they are all nonentities, including the puppet with Alzheimer’s.

    we have a death spiral.
     
    It’s a defeat of the empire and its cocksuckers, but not necessarily a death spiral. Our hope lies in the cowardice of fat cats that run the West. They never fail in three things: greed, hypocrisy, and cowardice. The funniest thing is, this assessment sounds optimistic.
    , @Mr. Hack
    @QCIC

    https://suindependent.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/Putin-back-to-Cold-War-by-Dave-Granlund.jpg

    Replies: @Derer

  1011. @Mikel
    @A123


    This was clearly the best move for DeSantis.
     
    Perhaps it was the best move for him personally but not for the chances of MAGA-like policies to ever be implemented at a national level (like he did in Florida).

    Not only are we now stuck with an inferior candidate that attracts the less intelligent and more divisive supporters (J6ers, conspiracy nutters and all sorts of fringe people) but also he leaves Nikki as the only contender. As I said the other day, he should have waited until the witch drops out too. If Trump doesn't make it to November for one reason or another, they may well try to shoehorn her as the Republican candidate.

    But, as Churchill said, the best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter. The average Republican voter wants to see a rematch with the con-man so we'll have to resign ourselves to a repeat of 2020, if we're lucky.

    Replies: @A123, @AnonfromTN

    Endorsing Trump gives DeSantis’s supporters the opportunity to rejoin the saner & more intelligent MAGA policy side. Let us hope that they choose to build those bridges.

    we [are] now stuck with an inferior candidate

    So no “bridge building” yet?

    You cannot accept the superior MAGA policy candidate who attracts saner and more intelligent supporters? For example, those who realize that the 2020 election was stolen. The evidence is undeniable and overwhelming.

      

    The offer remains open. If you want to stop lying and return to MAGA, the Trump 2024 campaign will be here.

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇

    • Replies: @Mikel
    @A123


    So no “bridge building ” then?
     
    Like I said, Trump supporters don't tend to be too bight so you don't seem to realize whose task it is now to do all the bridge building (unless you guys think that you don't even need the votes of the DeSantis and Vivek supporters to win in November).

    Let that bridge building take the form of acknowleging past mistakes and making specific commitments for the first months in office please. Empty words are not going to win you many votes in that camp.

    Replies: @A123

  1012. @A123
    Breaking news: (1)

    Ron DeSantis Drops Out of Presidential Race, Endorses Donald Trump

     

    Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, one of the two remaining challengers to former President Donald Trump, dropped out of the presidential race on Sunday, before the New Hampshire primary, and endorsed Trump.

    In a video DeSantis released from Florida on Sunday afternoon, he endorsed Trump over the last challenger—former South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley—saying that while he has disagreements with Trump he thinks Trump is better than Haley and certainly better than Democrat President Joe Biden.
    ...
    DeSantis’s exit from the race leaves one remaining serious challenger to Trump in the field: Haley. Things between Trump and Haley have been intensifying ahead of New Hampshire’s GOP primary on Tuesday, and a strong Trump performance there–as polls indicate is likely–could finish her off quickly and early, before the race turns next to Nevada and then to South Carolina. Haley is not even going to compete in the Nevada caucuses, which means DeSantis’s exit from the field essentially ensures a unanimous Trump victory there as only one other candidate–Ryan Binkley, who got slightly more votes than former Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson in Iowa’s caucuses–is competing in Nevada. What this all means is Tuesday’s New Hampshire primary essentially becomes do-or-die for Haley, in that she must defeat Trump and win the primary outright to have a path forward for her campaign.
     
    This was clearly the best move for DeSantis. Returning home to the active legislative session will generate positive results. And, he avoids an inevitable loss in New Hampshire.

    Endorsing Trump gives DeSantis's supporters the opportunity to rejoin the saner & more intelligent MAGA policy side. Let us hope that they choose to build those bridges.

    PEACE 😇
    __________

    (1) https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2024/01/21/ron-desantis-drops-out-presidential-race-endorses-donald-trump/

    Replies: @Mikel, @Derer

    Vindictive and snivelling Democrats start to concentrate on how to defeat Trump not by the will of the people by…now perfected 2020 criminal cheating scheme that gave this country 4 years of their mentally handicapped puppet.

    Beginning of the end of a great DNC “democracy” that keep defending borders of corrupt Ukraine and Israel instead of our nation.

  1013. @Mr. XYZ
    @QCIC


    Perhaps some Chechen will nuke Dnipro to see if that pressure point is sensitive enough to calm this situation down. Nukemap calculates a 50 kiloton Iskander detonation over Dnipro would lead to 60,000 deaths and 200,000 casualties. Call it 250,000 dead to be realistic. We know this would probably NOT stop the ‘Ukrainian leadership’ or the West since their shared goal seems to be to kill Slavs (Ukrainian or Russian, doesn’t seem to matter). But would it be enough to wake up the remaining sensible Ukrainians so they will starting shooting their comprador elites in the head?

     

    Do Chechens actually have access to Russia's nuclear weapons?

    Replies: @QCIC

    Who knows, people tend to lie about that sort of thing 😉
    True Lies:

    [MORE]

    (@ 0:30)

  1014. @AnonfromTN
    @Derer


    The hell will freeze before damaged Haley is elected president.
     
    That would be true if the elections were honest. With fraud on the scale like in 2020, any rat, even dead and smelly one, can be “elected”.

    Replies: @Derer

    You are right, but Haley is not in that cheating gang. Democrats would vote even for monkey if that monkey will support Israel.

  1015. @Beyond the pale and fedup
    @YetAnotherAnon

    The same ship did the same to HMS Bangor in 2022, rammed it twice in fact.
    Methinks they are well jabbed and suffering brainfog. add in some DEI.

    They should change the ships name to HMS Idiocracy for 2024.

    Replies: @QCIC

    PouponMarx, what do you have to say about these ship handling mistakes?

  1016. @A123
    @Mikel



    Endorsing Trump gives DeSantis’s supporters the opportunity to rejoin the saner & more intelligent MAGA policy side. Let us hope that they choose to build those bridges.
     
    we [are] now stuck with an inferior candidate
     
    So no "bridge building" yet?

    You cannot accept the superior MAGA policy candidate who attracts saner and more intelligent supporters? For example, those who realize that the 2020 election was stolen. The evidence is undeniable and overwhelming.

     
    https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiv_eP2G0sljTc7R-d6ORVLWrav4ulUTwD5NAQ3WwQ2pk6EtJNWZO3HHDmY0AQwrcjGYPqQfHhzk0yJEZ2i8oQMsJxH4_0c-IoZXQLjSFkoOF8VvCKW-7D7R2sWkzllRXBCT3CpBsIvN82jYkfOrF14z_Y0-1i_RbQ5B4_3jJ9DX79kZl-NVWEXLKEp7qg/s1254/1%20dfsafsadfsadfasf.jpg
     

    The offer remains open. If you want to stop lying and return to MAGA, the Trump 2024 campaign will be here.

    #LetsGoBrandon 😇

    Replies: @Mikel

    So no “bridge building ” then?

    Like I said, Trump supporters don’t tend to be too bight so you don’t seem to realize whose task it is now to do all the bridge building (unless you guys think that you don’t even need the votes of the DeSantis and Vivek supporters to win in November).

    Let that bridge building take the form of acknowleging past mistakes and making specific commitments for the first months in office please. Empty words are not going to win you many votes in that camp.

    • Replies: @A123
    @Mikel

    The smart DeSantis supporters accept that their candidate endorsed Trump and are already coming onboard. Sadly, a few fringe extremist slow ones refuse to support MAGA even though the train is leaving the station without them. Such, low-IQ yahoo, anti-MAGA mentality is self destructive.

    Bridge building should take the form of acknowledgement that lying about Trump's 1st term is a serious defect. Blaming Trump for those forced on his administration, such as Mrs. Mitch McConnell (Elaine Chao), is nonsensical. Continuing to lie only helps Not-The-President Biden. It takes extreme, inferior, dimwitted #NeverTrump anti-MAGA zealotry to want that.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Mikel

  1017. Oldie but goodie from 2007

    https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/9weLK2AJ9JEt2Tt8f/politics-is-the-mind-killer

    Pretty sure 95% of the sperg-lords are in the anybody but Trump camp today. Yudkowsky wants to drop bombs on AI computer centers now.

    • Agree: A123
  1018. @Mikel
    @A123


    So no “bridge building ” then?
     
    Like I said, Trump supporters don't tend to be too bight so you don't seem to realize whose task it is now to do all the bridge building (unless you guys think that you don't even need the votes of the DeSantis and Vivek supporters to win in November).

    Let that bridge building take the form of acknowleging past mistakes and making specific commitments for the first months in office please. Empty words are not going to win you many votes in that camp.

    Replies: @A123

    The smart DeSantis supporters accept that their candidate endorsed Trump and are already coming onboard. Sadly, a few fringe extremist slow ones refuse to support MAGA even though the train is leaving the station without them. Such, low-IQ yahoo, anti-MAGA mentality is self destructive.

    Bridge building should take the form of acknowledgement that lying about Trump’s 1st term is a serious defect. Blaming Trump for those forced on his administration, such as Mrs. Mitch McConnell (Elaine Chao), is nonsensical. Continuing to lie only helps Not-The-President Biden. It takes extreme, inferior, dimwitted #NeverTrump anti-MAGA zealotry to want that.

    PEACE 😇

    • Replies: @Mikel
    @A123

    Not so friendly reminder that RFK is still in the race. He's far from perfect but he has very solid positions on foreign wars and the border. And I'm 100% sure that he wouldn't hire Bolton (!!) or McMasters for his cabinet. Just like sudden death strongly motivated me to vote for an anti-NATO party in the next EU elections, you may make me go RFK if you're not nice going forward. Very nice.

    Replies: @A123

  1019. @Mikel
    @A123


    This was clearly the best move for DeSantis.
     
    Perhaps it was the best move for him personally but not for the chances of MAGA-like policies to ever be implemented at a national level (like he did in Florida).

    Not only are we now stuck with an inferior candidate that attracts the less intelligent and more divisive supporters (J6ers, conspiracy nutters and all sorts of fringe people) but also he leaves Nikki as the only contender. As I said the other day, he should have waited until the witch drops out too. If Trump doesn't make it to November for one reason or another, they may well try to shoehorn her as the Republican candidate.

    But, as Churchill said, the best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter. The average Republican voter wants to see a rematch with the con-man so we'll have to resign ourselves to a repeat of 2020, if we're lucky.

    Replies: @A123, @AnonfromTN

    he should have waited until the witch drops out too.

    She is not a witch, just a bitch.

  1020. The first highlights from the Roar Before the 24 are out.

    The GSX class is related to GT4, so it is all machinery we have seen before.

    The new Corvette and Ford entries are in GTD/GT3. Hopefully good video will be available Wednesday or Thursday. Clips of the new Z06 Corvette look stable and driver friendly. That should help them keep all 4 entries forward in their classes.

    PEACE 😇

  1021. Was thinking that Schweinburg must not be one of those ambiguous names, but I guess it is one:
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erich_Fritz_Schweinburg

  1022. @QCIC
    @AnonfromTN

    I expected the drone strikes and agree that these will probably continue and possibly escalate. Previously I saw this mess as having an end point when Russia gains control of Kiev in whatever form that takes. Now I am not so sure. I don't think the frozen conflict will be Ukraine against Russia, it may be the West against Russia. I hope not. If so, I guess this is really just a continuation of the 1980's Cold War, except now most of the leaders in the West are both very stupid and crazy. Instead of gradual cooling and slowly improved relations we have a death spiral.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Mr. Hack

    most of the leaders in the West are both very stupid and crazy

    Hard to argue, perfectly true regarding the real leaders, rich “elites”. So called “elected leaders” are no more than figureheads. That’s why they are all nonentities, including the puppet with Alzheimer’s.

    we have a death spiral.

    It’s a defeat of the empire and its cocksuckers, but not necessarily a death spiral. Our hope lies in the cowardice of fat cats that run the West. They never fail in three things: greed, hypocrisy, and cowardice. The funniest thing is, this assessment sounds optimistic.

  1023. Anybody knows what’s happening with the UN? First, it condemned Ukie attack on Belgorod that targeted civilians. Now UN secretary-general Guterres condemned Ukie strike on Donetsk food market, which also targeted civilians in a typical Ukie style. Did the puppet masters decide to throw away Ukies, like a used condom? What gives?

  1024. @A123
    @John Johnson

    What is even more predictable is when parties go against their base in an attempt to woe swing and independent voters.

    Do you remember when the GOP went with a Blue State Governor that appealed to independents? What was his name? Oh yes... Romney. He lost because he could not pull the Main Street Republican base.

    Do you remember when the GOP went with a maverick Senator that appealed to independents? What was his name? John McCain. He lost because he could not pull the Main Street Republican base.

    There is every reason to believe that squishy establishment choices, Haley and DeSantis, would follow the same pattern. Not only would they lose by generating low turnout for themselves, the lack of base voting would impact down ballot on other races.
    ___

    Look at the polls without cherry picking the establishment ones (1) (2). Trump and Haley are doing similarly with independents and swing voters. There is no reason to accept anything other than genuine MAGA/Trump with his high probability of victory.

    We get it. As an emotional #NeverTrump cultist your thinking is 100% consumed by your fear of his personality. For those of use who want MAGA policy, we opt for the best choice. If there was a better option than Trump, I would take it. However, in the 2024 cycle everyone with rudimentary intelligence and observational skills realizes that Trump is the best choice for MAGA.

    When the only other MAGA candidate, Vivek Ramaswamy, dropped out, who did he endorse? Because he cares about MAGA policy, he went with Trump.

    PEACE 😇
    ___________

    (1) https://www.realclearpolling.com/polls/president/general/2024/trump-vs-biden

    (2) https://www.realclearpolling.com/polls/president/general/2024/haley-vs-biden

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Do you remember when the GOP went with a Blue State Governor that appealed to independents? What was his name? Oh yes… Romney. He lost because he could not pull the Main Street Republican base.

    He didn’t lose mainstream Republicans.

    Romney lost because he ran his mouth on tape. His numbers dropped after the bar recording. He lost too many swing voters.

    He was also never a good mainstream candidate. Mainstream Christians don’t trust Mormons and the GOP is probably ran by secular Whites as the seemed completely clueless to this aspect.

    The Mormon religion is offensive to mainstream protestants. It’s heresy.

    Do you remember when the GOP went with a maverick Senator that appealed to independents? What was his name? John McCain. He lost because he could not pull the Main Street Republican base.

    McCain/Obama was not a normal election. People on both sides were voting based on race. I can pull Con Inc articles where they actually argue voting for the Democrat to “heal the nation” (appease Blacks). McCain’s numbers dropped after he selected Palin. One of the worst VP picks of all time.

    There is every reason to believe that squishy establishment choices, Haley and DeSantis, would follow the same pattern. Not only would they lose by generating low turnout for themselves, the lack of base voting would impact down ballot on other races.

    I don’t understand what you are saying. Haley polls well with moderate Republicans and independents.

    Let me ask you this question: Would an innocent man rant at 2AM about how presidential immunity should exist?

  1025. @Derer
    @AP

    AP: "(Austrians had twice as many cars per capita than Czechs)?"

    As a justification for high GDP. The question is if those cars are home produced?
    No, 90% are produced outside Austria in lower cost countries.

    Now the AP hochstapler is bringing up that Austria actually produced heavy tractors and diesel engine trucks and buses instead of cars.

    AP:"Although of course I was writing about rich Austrians buying cars."

    No, you were writing about how number of foreign cars contributing to Austrian GDP.

    Replies: @AP

    AP: “(Austrians had twice as many cars per capita than Czechs)?”

    As a justification for high GDP.

    As evidence that Austrians were, indeed, a lot richer than Czechs. They had twice as many cars per capita.

    Now the AP hochstapler is bringing up that Austria actually produced heavy tractors and diesel engine trucks and buses instead of cars.

    The Puch cars were made there. Is reading hard for you:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puch_500

    Mercedes G-wagons were/are made in Austria also (it is of course an SUV but still a consumer product):

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercedes-Benz_G-Class

    Production 1979–present
    Assembly Austria: Graz (Magna Steyr)

    AP:”Although of course I was writing about rich Austrians buying cars.”

    No, you were writing about how number of foreign cars contributing to Austrian GDP.

    Nonsense. My words: “Did that also cause the dearth of consumer goods (Austrians had twice as many cars per capita than Czechs)?” It was a reflection of twice higher GDP, not a cause of it.

    Reading and thinking are hard for you, we know.

  1026. @Derer
    @AP

    Why are you two replying to each other. You have the same IP and the same dual citizenship.

    Replies: @AP

    Nice lies. I don’t know his IP (neither do you) and I am not Israeli.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    What is your dual citizenship, AP, if you don't mind me asking? US citizenship and which other one? If it's Russian citizenship, then I'm going to be very surprised, even if your wife is Russian. If it's something else, what is it, if you don't mind me asking?

    You are correct that I myself am a dual Israeli-US citizen. So are the rest of my immediate family. We don't have Russian citizenship because my parents left the USSR as it was collapsing and thus their Soviet citizenship became worthless but they never actually ended up acquiring Russian citizenship afterwards. In the 1990s, they apparently contacted a Russian embassy about this but were told that they would have to pay money for this, which they did not want to do. A close relative of mine wanted to get Russian citizenship before the start of the current war so that Russia would pay them a pension, which they deserve since they worked there long enough back in the 1980s to qualify for this, but these plans were scrapped indefinitely when Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022. It doesn't sound or look very good to accept money from a country that's doing what Russia is currently doing, or to pledge loyalty to such a country. So, Yeah, none of us will ever even be considering Russian citizenship until and unless a pro-Western regime will actually come to power in Russia. Then, maybe. Could be useful if it will secure us a EU passport, assuming that such a new Russian regime will be democratic and will also seek to join the EU. But that's an extremely long way away and might not occur in any of our own lifetimes, unfortunately.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @AP

  1027. @A123
    @Mikel

    The smart DeSantis supporters accept that their candidate endorsed Trump and are already coming onboard. Sadly, a few fringe extremist slow ones refuse to support MAGA even though the train is leaving the station without them. Such, low-IQ yahoo, anti-MAGA mentality is self destructive.

    Bridge building should take the form of acknowledgement that lying about Trump's 1st term is a serious defect. Blaming Trump for those forced on his administration, such as Mrs. Mitch McConnell (Elaine Chao), is nonsensical. Continuing to lie only helps Not-The-President Biden. It takes extreme, inferior, dimwitted #NeverTrump anti-MAGA zealotry to want that.

    PEACE 😇

    Replies: @Mikel

    Not so friendly reminder that RFK is still in the race. He’s far from perfect but he has very solid positions on foreign wars and the border. And I’m 100% sure that he wouldn’t hire Bolton (!!) or McMasters for his cabinet. Just like sudden death strongly motivated me to vote for an anti-NATO party in the next EU elections, you may make me go RFK if you’re not nice going forward. Very nice.

    • LOL: sudden death, A123
    • Replies: @A123
    @Mikel

    Friendly reminder that Bolton(!!) was forced on Trump's administration by McConnell (!!!!). Trump's team ignored Bolton, excluded him from meetings, and generally abused him so badly that #NeverTrump Bolton quit. He even wrote a book against Trump.

    If RFKjr won, who would the Senate force into his administration?

    PEACE 😇

  1028. @AP
    @Derer

    Nice lies. I don't know his IP (neither do you) and I am not Israeli.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    What is your dual citizenship, AP, if you don’t mind me asking? US citizenship and which other one? If it’s Russian citizenship, then I’m going to be very surprised, even if your wife is Russian. If it’s something else, what is it, if you don’t mind me asking?

    You are correct that I myself am a dual Israeli-US citizen. So are the rest of my immediate family. We don’t have Russian citizenship because my parents left the USSR as it was collapsing and thus their Soviet citizenship became worthless but they never actually ended up acquiring Russian citizenship afterwards. In the 1990s, they apparently contacted a Russian embassy about this but were told that they would have to pay money for this, which they did not want to do. A close relative of mine wanted to get Russian citizenship before the start of the current war so that Russia would pay them a pension, which they deserve since they worked there long enough back in the 1980s to qualify for this, but these plans were scrapped indefinitely when Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022. It doesn’t sound or look very good to accept money from a country that’s doing what Russia is currently doing, or to pledge loyalty to such a country. So, Yeah, none of us will ever even be considering Russian citizenship until and unless a pro-Western regime will actually come to power in Russia. Then, maybe. Could be useful if it will secure us a EU passport, assuming that such a new Russian regime will be democratic and will also seek to join the EU. But that’s an extremely long way away and might not occur in any of our own lifetimes, unfortunately.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Mr. XYZ

    I had an older friend who left Ukraine when it was still a part of the Soviet Union. When it all fell apart, he was never able to obtain Ukrainian citizenship, although he would tangle with the Ukrainian embassy in San Francisco over this from time to time. I think that his chief concern was trying to obtain a Ukrainian pension, having worked most of his adult life in Ukraine. He ended up getting a small American benefit, and was a colorful figure within the emigre community in Phoenix. To his Jewish buddies he was a Jew, to the Ukrainian community a Ukrainian, to his Baptist community a Romanian. A true blue internationalist is ever there was one. RIP Vasyl.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    , @AP
    @Mr. XYZ


    What is your dual citizenship, AP, if you don’t mind me asking? US citizenship and which other one?
     


    When due to Covid restrictions Americans were barred from the EU (ruining vacation plans) I finally submitted the paperwork to get the citizenship of the EU country of which my paternal grandparents were citizens. It finally came through - sadly, a few weeks after the election. (you can guess which one, I won’t say)

    Hopefully it will make retirement plans easier. Due to my job I can’t leverage high income with lower cost of living abroad by working remotely, but I’ll be able to retire earlier than otherwise. Though I may stay if grandkids will be living nearby. Maybe. We used to send our kids to Moscow for the summer to be with their grandparents and cousins at the dacha in a beautiful pine forest, perhaps our kids will send theirs to be with us in some town on Lake Lugano or Lake Garda, exploring castles and being spoiled by gelato? Or in the Polish Tatras with the nice views, hearty food, and hot baths?

    My wife and kids have Russian and American citizenship. The kids have also gotten EU citizenship, with me. Our family have many escape options, if need be :-). Though the USA probably has a solid future.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  1029. @Mr. XYZ
    @Greasy William

    The impression that I got is that Poles were more passive relative to Hungarians and Romanians, no? In Hungary, for instance, IIRC, Nazi Germany had a lot of Hungarian collaborators on the ground who helped them mass murder Hungarian Jewry with extraordinarily ruthless speed and efficiency. I don't think that Polish collaborators were as crucial in Poland's Holocaust, were they? As for Romania, it had a notorious homegrown Nazi-like movement in the form of the Iron Guard before Antonescu crushed it but then sought to emulate some aspects of it, such as the vehemently violent anti-Semitism. But of course Antonescu did spare the overwhelming majority of the Jews of the Romanian Old Kingdom territories in a last-minute decision in an unsuccessful attempt to save his own skin after the end of the war. He was merciless towards Jews outside of these territories, though.

    Replies: @Greasy William

    As I said, Hungary was a Nazi ally, Poland was waging an insurgency against the Nazis. But those same insurgents fighting the Nazis also engaged in mass murder of Jews. And unlike the Hungarians, Ukrainians and Balts, these Poles did it purely on their own without German help or supervision.

    The fact is that the overwhelming majority of the Hungarian and Polish populations whole heartedly supported the Holocaust, although that support was generally passive. But the Hungarians at least had an excuse given that their own fate was tied to that of Germany.

    Seriously, fuck Poland. I have nothing against the current state of Poland or the Polish people who exist ~today~, but the Polish population as a whole behaved in a disgraceful fashion during the war years, regardless of the genuine heroism and sacrifice of many ~individual~ Poles.

    But it’s all water under the bridge as far as I’m concerned. If the Poles don’t want to own up to their history, they are only hurting themselves. What’s done is done and neither the Poles, the Hungarians or anyone else for that matter has ever done something like Oct 7th. There is only one nation in history that has done something like that.

    Eyes on the prize.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Greasy William

    The interesting thing is that Poland been an actual Nazi ally like Hungary and not tried backstabbing Hitler later on like Hungary did, Poland's Jews could have fared considerably better than they did in real life. Nazi Germany made the Holocaust optional for its allies in regards to their own Jews for so long as they remained loyal to Hitler. This is why Greater Hungary's Jews were spared until 1944, why Bulgaria's Jews were spared, why the Jews of the Romanian Old Kingdom territories were overwhelmingly spared (with an exception in Iasi), why Italian Jews were spared until 1943, why French citizen Jews (especially if they were naturalized a long time ago or were born French citizens) were mostly spared, et cetera.

    Poland put all of its eggs in the Anglo-French basket in 1939-1940 and then got let down when France fell in 1940 because it didn't properly defend the Ardennes sector.

    Replies: @LT1488, @Mr. XYZ

  1030. @QCIC
    @AnonfromTN

    I expected the drone strikes and agree that these will probably continue and possibly escalate. Previously I saw this mess as having an end point when Russia gains control of Kiev in whatever form that takes. Now I am not so sure. I don't think the frozen conflict will be Ukraine against Russia, it may be the West against Russia. I hope not. If so, I guess this is really just a continuation of the 1980's Cold War, except now most of the leaders in the West are both very stupid and crazy. Instead of gradual cooling and slowly improved relations we have a death spiral.

    Replies: @AnonfromTN, @Mr. Hack

    • Replies: @Derer
    @Mr. Hack

    Ironically, the one guy with the shoe, on your cartoon, insisted in 1954 that Crimea should be Ukraine's and the other insisted in 2014 the Crimea should be returned back to the right owners.

    BTW, you need some counselling on your preoccupation with Putin, he is doing just his job opposing silly people from Washington. Who cannot accept playing second fiddle on the world stage due to the humongous internal problems political, racial, social.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon

  1031. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    What is your dual citizenship, AP, if you don't mind me asking? US citizenship and which other one? If it's Russian citizenship, then I'm going to be very surprised, even if your wife is Russian. If it's something else, what is it, if you don't mind me asking?

    You are correct that I myself am a dual Israeli-US citizen. So are the rest of my immediate family. We don't have Russian citizenship because my parents left the USSR as it was collapsing and thus their Soviet citizenship became worthless but they never actually ended up acquiring Russian citizenship afterwards. In the 1990s, they apparently contacted a Russian embassy about this but were told that they would have to pay money for this, which they did not want to do. A close relative of mine wanted to get Russian citizenship before the start of the current war so that Russia would pay them a pension, which they deserve since they worked there long enough back in the 1980s to qualify for this, but these plans were scrapped indefinitely when Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022. It doesn't sound or look very good to accept money from a country that's doing what Russia is currently doing, or to pledge loyalty to such a country. So, Yeah, none of us will ever even be considering Russian citizenship until and unless a pro-Western regime will actually come to power in Russia. Then, maybe. Could be useful if it will secure us a EU passport, assuming that such a new Russian regime will be democratic and will also seek to join the EU. But that's an extremely long way away and might not occur in any of our own lifetimes, unfortunately.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @AP

    I had an older friend who left Ukraine when it was still a part of the Soviet Union. When it all fell apart, he was never able to obtain Ukrainian citizenship, although he would tangle with the Ukrainian embassy in San Francisco over this from time to time. I think that his chief concern was trying to obtain a Ukrainian pension, having worked most of his adult life in Ukraine. He ended up getting a small American benefit, and was a colorful figure within the emigre community in Phoenix. To his Jewish buddies he was a Jew, to the Ukrainian community a Ukrainian, to his Baptist community a Romanian. A true blue internationalist is ever there was one. RIP Vasyl.

    • Thanks: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. Hack

    He was a Ukrainian Jew of Romanian descent? From the Chernivtsi area? Makes sense since that area belonged to Romania in the 1918-1940 time period.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

  1032. @Mikel
    @A123

    Not so friendly reminder that RFK is still in the race. He's far from perfect but he has very solid positions on foreign wars and the border. And I'm 100% sure that he wouldn't hire Bolton (!!) or McMasters for his cabinet. Just like sudden death strongly motivated me to vote for an anti-NATO party in the next EU elections, you may make me go RFK if you're not nice going forward. Very nice.

    Replies: @A123

    Friendly reminder that Bolton(!!) was forced on Trump’s administration by McConnell (!!!!). Trump’s team ignored Bolton, excluded him from meetings, and generally abused him so badly that #NeverTrump Bolton quit. He even wrote a book against Trump.

    If RFKjr won, who would the Senate force into his administration?

    PEACE 😇

  1033. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    What is your dual citizenship, AP, if you don't mind me asking? US citizenship and which other one? If it's Russian citizenship, then I'm going to be very surprised, even if your wife is Russian. If it's something else, what is it, if you don't mind me asking?

    You are correct that I myself am a dual Israeli-US citizen. So are the rest of my immediate family. We don't have Russian citizenship because my parents left the USSR as it was collapsing and thus their Soviet citizenship became worthless but they never actually ended up acquiring Russian citizenship afterwards. In the 1990s, they apparently contacted a Russian embassy about this but were told that they would have to pay money for this, which they did not want to do. A close relative of mine wanted to get Russian citizenship before the start of the current war so that Russia would pay them a pension, which they deserve since they worked there long enough back in the 1980s to qualify for this, but these plans were scrapped indefinitely when Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022. It doesn't sound or look very good to accept money from a country that's doing what Russia is currently doing, or to pledge loyalty to such a country. So, Yeah, none of us will ever even be considering Russian citizenship until and unless a pro-Western regime will actually come to power in Russia. Then, maybe. Could be useful if it will secure us a EU passport, assuming that such a new Russian regime will be democratic and will also seek to join the EU. But that's an extremely long way away and might not occur in any of our own lifetimes, unfortunately.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @AP

    What is your dual citizenship, AP, if you don’t mind me asking? US citizenship and which other one?

    [MORE]

    When due to Covid restrictions Americans were barred from the EU (ruining vacation plans) I finally submitted the paperwork to get the citizenship of the EU country of which my paternal grandparents were citizens. It finally came through – sadly, a few weeks after the election. (you can guess which one, I won’t say)

    Hopefully it will make retirement plans easier. Due to my job I can’t leverage high income with lower cost of living abroad by working remotely, but I’ll be able to retire earlier than otherwise. Though I may stay if grandkids will be living nearby. Maybe. We used to send our kids to Moscow for the summer to be with their grandparents and cousins at the dacha in a beautiful pine forest, perhaps our kids will send theirs to be with us in some town on Lake Lugano or Lake Garda, exploring castles and being spoiled by gelato? Or in the Polish Tatras with the nice views, hearty food, and hot baths?

    My wife and kids have Russian and American citizenship. The kids have also gotten EU citizenship, with me. Our family have many escape options, if need be :-). Though the USA probably has a solid future.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    I got it! You're a Polish citizen and thus an EU citizen as well. Frankly, I wonder if I myself could get Polish citizenship through my Jewish paternal great-grandfather, who lived in Sarny (or somewhere very close to there, in that general area) until the Polish-Soviet War, when he got kidnapped by the Bolsheviks and taken to the Soviet Union as the Bolsheviks were retreating from Sarny because apparently the Bolsheviks wanted more literate people and he was literate. This move ironically ended up saving his life since it made it much easier for him to evacuate eastwards in 1941 during Operation Barbarossa, while his parents and most of his siblings, nephews, nieces, et cetera who stayed in Sarny were subsequently murdered in the Holocaust. But I don't know if my connection to Poland is actually close enough for me to acquire Polish citizenship. I think that Poland requires an ancestor who lived in Poland on or after January 10, 1920, but I don't know when specifically during the Polish-Soviet War the Bolsheviks kidnapped my Jewish great-grandfather or, even if he was kidnapped after January 10, 1920, whether there would actually be sufficient proof of him being in Sarny beforehand that would be sufficiently convincing for the Polish authorities. He was born in 1896, so he should appear in the 1897 Imperial Russian Census if the census lists themselves were not destroyed, but they might have been and 1897 is still more than two decades before 1920.

    So, ultimately, for me, I'll have to wait until there is regime change in Russia and Russia will seek and acquire EU citizenship in order for me to try acquiring Russian and EU citizenship. At least I speak fluent Russian. That's a plus!

    Did your wife and/or children ever seriously consider giving up their Russian citizenship after the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine?


    My wife and kids have Russian and American citizenship. The kids have also gotten EU citizenship, with me. Our family have many escape options, if need be :-). Though the USA probably has a solid future.

     

    Having both Russian and Polish citizenship, as your own kids apparently have, is very rare and unusual, I would think. But Yeah, I'm also pretty optimistic about the long-term future of the US.

    I think that the most valuable citizenships to acquire are these, in order:

    1. The U.S.
    2. The E.U.
    3. Other Anglosphere
    4. Israel/Japan/South Korea/Taiwan/Singapore/et cetera
    5. Russia/China/Vietnam/Thailand/et cetera
    6. India
    7. Latin American countries
    8. Everyone else

    Does that sound about plausible?

    Replies: @Derer

  1034. @Mr. Hack
    @QCIC

    https://suindependent.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/Putin-back-to-Cold-War-by-Dave-Granlund.jpg

    Replies: @Derer

    Ironically, the one guy with the shoe, on your cartoon, insisted in 1954 that Crimea should be Ukraine’s and the other insisted in 2014 the Crimea should be returned back to the right owners.

    BTW, you need some counselling on your preoccupation with Putin, he is doing just his job opposing silly people from Washington. Who cannot accept playing second fiddle on the world stage due to the humongous internal problems political, racial, social.

    • Agree: YetAnotherAnon
    • Replies: @YetAnotherAnon
    @Derer

    Plus that cartoon is crap. If there's one thing Putin isn't, it's a Krushchev-type.

    No shoe-banging, no "we will bury you", just cautious progress. If there's still a Russia in a hundred years, he'll get a very good press in their history books.


    Putin inherited a ransacked and bewildered country, with a poor and demoralized people,” Solzhenitsyn told the German magazine Der Spiegel in a 2007 interview, when Putin was still president. “And he started to do what was possible, a slow and gradual restoration. These efforts were not noticed, nor appreciated, immediately. In any case, one is hard-pressed to find examples in history when steps by one country to restore its strength were met favorably by other governments.”

     

    The history of Ukraine since it split from the Soviet Union is a little like what happened to Yugoslavia post-Tito, or India after the Raj departed.

    Some people (like Hacky) just want to MBGA - Make Bandera Great Again. Good luck with that.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ, @AP

  1035. @Derer
    @Mr. Hack

    Ironically, the one guy with the shoe, on your cartoon, insisted in 1954 that Crimea should be Ukraine's and the other insisted in 2014 the Crimea should be returned back to the right owners.

    BTW, you need some counselling on your preoccupation with Putin, he is doing just his job opposing silly people from Washington. Who cannot accept playing second fiddle on the world stage due to the humongous internal problems political, racial, social.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon

    Plus that cartoon is crap. If there’s one thing Putin isn’t, it’s a Krushchev-type.

    No shoe-banging, no “we will bury you”, just cautious progress. If there’s still a Russia in a hundred years, he’ll get a very good press in their history books.

    Putin inherited a ransacked and bewildered country, with a poor and demoralized people,” Solzhenitsyn told the German magazine Der Spiegel in a 2007 interview, when Putin was still president. “And he started to do what was possible, a slow and gradual restoration. These efforts were not noticed, nor appreciated, immediately. In any case, one is hard-pressed to find examples in history when steps by one country to restore its strength were met favorably by other governments.”

    The history of Ukraine since it split from the Soviet Union is a little like what happened to Yugoslavia post-Tito, or India after the Raj departed.

    Some people (like Hacky) just want to MBGA – Make Bandera Great Again. Good luck with that.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @YetAnotherAnon

    Russians need SILFEA hats

    Stand In Line For Eggs Again

    Head of Russian poultry farm shot at over egg prices
    https://www.newsweek.com/russia-eggs-crisis-prices-sanctions-1856439

    Russia is a bizarre country. They don't shoot their recruitment officers but they will shoot someone over the price of eggs.

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @YetAnotherAnon


    The history of Ukraine since it split from the Soviet Union is a little like what happened to Yugoslavia post-Tito, or India after the Raj departed.

     

    I have previously said that the 1990s position of ethnic Russians and ethnic Serbs was similar to the 1920s position of ethnic Germans and ethnic Magyars. When a giant multiethnic state collapsed, a lot of the relevant co-ethnics were left outside of their nation-states, which created a lot of problems and eventually revanchism.
    , @AP
    @YetAnotherAnon


    No shoe-banging, no “we will bury you”, just cautious progress. If there’s still a Russia in a hundred years, he’ll get a very good press in their history books.
     
    You are writing 2 years too late.

    Until 1914 Nicholas II was not so bad, either.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  1036. @YetAnotherAnon
    @Derer

    Plus that cartoon is crap. If there's one thing Putin isn't, it's a Krushchev-type.

    No shoe-banging, no "we will bury you", just cautious progress. If there's still a Russia in a hundred years, he'll get a very good press in their history books.


    Putin inherited a ransacked and bewildered country, with a poor and demoralized people,” Solzhenitsyn told the German magazine Der Spiegel in a 2007 interview, when Putin was still president. “And he started to do what was possible, a slow and gradual restoration. These efforts were not noticed, nor appreciated, immediately. In any case, one is hard-pressed to find examples in history when steps by one country to restore its strength were met favorably by other governments.”

     

    The history of Ukraine since it split from the Soviet Union is a little like what happened to Yugoslavia post-Tito, or India after the Raj departed.

    Some people (like Hacky) just want to MBGA - Make Bandera Great Again. Good luck with that.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    Russians need SILFEA hats

    Stand In Line For Eggs Again

    Head of Russian poultry farm shot at over egg prices
    https://www.newsweek.com/russia-eggs-crisis-prices-sanctions-1856439

    Russia is a bizarre country. They don’t shoot their recruitment officers but they will shoot someone over the price of eggs.

  1037. @Greasy William
    @Mr. XYZ

    As I said, Hungary was a Nazi ally, Poland was waging an insurgency against the Nazis. But those same insurgents fighting the Nazis also engaged in mass murder of Jews. And unlike the Hungarians, Ukrainians and Balts, these Poles did it purely on their own without German help or supervision.

    The fact is that the overwhelming majority of the Hungarian and Polish populations whole heartedly supported the Holocaust, although that support was generally passive. But the Hungarians at least had an excuse given that their own fate was tied to that of Germany.

    Seriously, fuck Poland. I have nothing against the current state of Poland or the Polish people who exist ~today~, but the Polish population as a whole behaved in a disgraceful fashion during the war years, regardless of the genuine heroism and sacrifice of many ~individual~ Poles.

    But it's all water under the bridge as far as I'm concerned. If the Poles don't want to own up to their history, they are only hurting themselves. What's done is done and neither the Poles, the Hungarians or anyone else for that matter has ever done something like Oct 7th. There is only one nation in history that has done something like that.

    Eyes on the prize.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    The interesting thing is that Poland been an actual Nazi ally like Hungary and not tried backstabbing Hitler later on like Hungary did, Poland’s Jews could have fared considerably better than they did in real life. Nazi Germany made the Holocaust optional for its allies in regards to their own Jews for so long as they remained loyal to Hitler. This is why Greater Hungary’s Jews were spared until 1944, why Bulgaria’s Jews were spared, why the Jews of the Romanian Old Kingdom territories were overwhelmingly spared (with an exception in Iasi), why Italian Jews were spared until 1943, why French citizen Jews (especially if they were naturalized a long time ago or were born French citizens) were mostly spared, et cetera.

    Poland put all of its eggs in the Anglo-French basket in 1939-1940 and then got let down when France fell in 1940 because it didn’t properly defend the Ardennes sector.

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    >Poland been an actual Nazi ally
    What a retarded thing to say, Nazis didn't even make a puppet state for Poles like they did in Croatia Slovakia and even Belarus and Russia (Lokot autonomy).

    Poles had no SS division or no volunteers for various nazi units
    even Russia had large collaborationism whilst Poland had almost none.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. XYZ

    "The interesting thing is that *had* Poland been an actual Nazi ally like Hungary and not tried backstabbing Hitler later on like Hungary did, Poland’s Jews could have fared considerably better than they did in real life. Nazi Germany made the Holocaust optional for its allies in regards to their own Jews for so long as they remained loyal to Hitler. This is why Greater Hungary’s Jews were spared until 1944, why Bulgaria’s Jews were spared, why the Jews of the Romanian Old Kingdom territories were overwhelmingly spared (with an exception in Iasi), why Italian Jews were spared until 1943, why French citizen Jews (especially if they were naturalized a long time ago or were born French citizens) were mostly spared, et cetera.

    Poland put all of its eggs in the Anglo-French basket in 1939-1940 and then got let down when France fell in 1940 because it didn’t properly defend the Ardennes sector."

    (Corrected typo. Forgot to insert a single word near the beginning.)

  1038. @YetAnotherAnon
    @Derer

    Plus that cartoon is crap. If there's one thing Putin isn't, it's a Krushchev-type.

    No shoe-banging, no "we will bury you", just cautious progress. If there's still a Russia in a hundred years, he'll get a very good press in their history books.


    Putin inherited a ransacked and bewildered country, with a poor and demoralized people,” Solzhenitsyn told the German magazine Der Spiegel in a 2007 interview, when Putin was still president. “And he started to do what was possible, a slow and gradual restoration. These efforts were not noticed, nor appreciated, immediately. In any case, one is hard-pressed to find examples in history when steps by one country to restore its strength were met favorably by other governments.”

     

    The history of Ukraine since it split from the Soviet Union is a little like what happened to Yugoslavia post-Tito, or India after the Raj departed.

    Some people (like Hacky) just want to MBGA - Make Bandera Great Again. Good luck with that.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    The history of Ukraine since it split from the Soviet Union is a little like what happened to Yugoslavia post-Tito, or India after the Raj departed.

    I have previously said that the 1990s position of ethnic Russians and ethnic Serbs was similar to the 1920s position of ethnic Germans and ethnic Magyars. When a giant multiethnic state collapsed, a lot of the relevant co-ethnics were left outside of their nation-states, which created a lot of problems and eventually revanchism.

  1039. @YetAnotherAnon
    @Derer

    Plus that cartoon is crap. If there's one thing Putin isn't, it's a Krushchev-type.

    No shoe-banging, no "we will bury you", just cautious progress. If there's still a Russia in a hundred years, he'll get a very good press in their history books.


    Putin inherited a ransacked and bewildered country, with a poor and demoralized people,” Solzhenitsyn told the German magazine Der Spiegel in a 2007 interview, when Putin was still president. “And he started to do what was possible, a slow and gradual restoration. These efforts were not noticed, nor appreciated, immediately. In any case, one is hard-pressed to find examples in history when steps by one country to restore its strength were met favorably by other governments.”

     

    The history of Ukraine since it split from the Soviet Union is a little like what happened to Yugoslavia post-Tito, or India after the Raj departed.

    Some people (like Hacky) just want to MBGA - Make Bandera Great Again. Good luck with that.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mr. XYZ, @AP

    No shoe-banging, no “we will bury you”, just cautious progress. If there’s still a Russia in a hundred years, he’ll get a very good press in their history books.

    You are writing 2 years too late.

    Until 1914 Nicholas II was not so bad, either.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Nicholas II already had a revolution back in 1905, a revolution that he appears not to have learned all that much from since afterwards he consistently tried to undermine the Duma and make it more pliable to him, such as by unilaterally changing the Duma election laws. Also, what's interesting is that AFAIK Tsarist Russia also had its own version of the propiska system, though unlike the Bolsheviks, it actually allowed people to emigrate in huge numbers.

    Nicholas II made a major blunder in entering WWI but nevertheless once Russia entered the war it would have been in a very, very good position after the end of the war had it managed to hold on until the point of victory. The US was essentially offering to finish the job of defeating Germany for Russia in 1917 and beyond while all Russia had to do was play defense in the meantime. But of course Russia couldn't even do that. The US was quite literally willing to bleed itself to ensure a Russian-dominated post-war Europe back then. The US was going to retreat back into isolationism after the end of the war, after all, and then Russia would be Europe's main security guarantor, especially in the long-run. But the Bolsheviks launched their coup and made Russia an international pariah! Dumbasses!

    Had Russia not been led by Bolsheviks, it could have helped maintain order in post-WWI Europe in places like Poland (protection against Germany) and Czechoslovakia/Romania/Yugoslavia (protection against Hungary and sometimes Germany, Poland, Bulgaria, and Italy as well). A peacekeeping role that Russian troops would have likely enjoyed and relished. Much more prestigious than merely doing this in the ex-USSR space like in real life over the last 32 years.

  1040. @AP
    @Mr. XYZ


    What is your dual citizenship, AP, if you don’t mind me asking? US citizenship and which other one?
     


    When due to Covid restrictions Americans were barred from the EU (ruining vacation plans) I finally submitted the paperwork to get the citizenship of the EU country of which my paternal grandparents were citizens. It finally came through - sadly, a few weeks after the election. (you can guess which one, I won’t say)

    Hopefully it will make retirement plans easier. Due to my job I can’t leverage high income with lower cost of living abroad by working remotely, but I’ll be able to retire earlier than otherwise. Though I may stay if grandkids will be living nearby. Maybe. We used to send our kids to Moscow for the summer to be with their grandparents and cousins at the dacha in a beautiful pine forest, perhaps our kids will send theirs to be with us in some town on Lake Lugano or Lake Garda, exploring castles and being spoiled by gelato? Or in the Polish Tatras with the nice views, hearty food, and hot baths?

    My wife and kids have Russian and American citizenship. The kids have also gotten EU citizenship, with me. Our family have many escape options, if need be :-). Though the USA probably has a solid future.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    I got it! You’re a Polish citizen and thus an EU citizen as well. Frankly, I wonder if I myself could get Polish citizenship through my Jewish paternal great-grandfather, who lived in Sarny (or somewhere very close to there, in that general area) until the Polish-Soviet War, when he got kidnapped by the Bolsheviks and taken to the Soviet Union as the Bolsheviks were retreating from Sarny because apparently the Bolsheviks wanted more literate people and he was literate. This move ironically ended up saving his life since it made it much easier for him to evacuate eastwards in 1941 during Operation Barbarossa, while his parents and most of his siblings, nephews, nieces, et cetera who stayed in Sarny were subsequently murdered in the Holocaust. But I don’t know if my connection to Poland is actually close enough for me to acquire Polish citizenship. I think that Poland requires an ancestor who lived in Poland on or after January 10, 1920, but I don’t know when specifically during the Polish-Soviet War the Bolsheviks kidnapped my Jewish great-grandfather or, even if he was kidnapped after January 10, 1920, whether there would actually be sufficient proof of him being in Sarny beforehand that would be sufficiently convincing for the Polish authorities. He was born in 1896, so he should appear in the 1897 Imperial Russian Census if the census lists themselves were not destroyed, but they might have been and 1897 is still more than two decades before 1920.

    So, ultimately, for me, I’ll have to wait until there is regime change in Russia and Russia will seek and acquire EU citizenship in order for me to try acquiring Russian and EU citizenship. At least I speak fluent Russian. That’s a plus!

    Did your wife and/or children ever seriously consider giving up their Russian citizenship after the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine?

    My wife and kids have Russian and American citizenship. The kids have also gotten EU citizenship, with me. Our family have many escape options, if need be :-). Though the USA probably has a solid future.

    Having both Russian and Polish citizenship, as your own kids apparently have, is very rare and unusual, I would think. But Yeah, I’m also pretty optimistic about the long-term future of the US.

    I think that the most valuable citizenships to acquire are these, in order:

    1. The U.S.
    2. The E.U.
    3. Other Anglosphere
    4. Israel/Japan/South Korea/Taiwan/Singapore/et cetera
    5. Russia/China/Vietnam/Thailand/et cetera
    6. India
    7. Latin American countries
    8. Everyone else

    Does that sound about plausible?

    • Replies: @Derer
    @Mr. XYZ

    I noticed your preference for citizenship ranking and actually agreeing with the AP statement: "But Yeah, I’m also pretty optimistic about the long-term future of the US."

    This view completely contrast with my two sons, born in the US to an iron curtain escapee. They are highly educated and successful, however decided to obtain EU citizenship and leave the US. This was reaffirmed after few visits to their and my fatherland in Europe.

    The US are in a turmoil with huge racial and political problems. Country is highly polarized and potentially in a path of unavoidable split into red and blue divide. The post WWII European brain is dying off and is being replaced by the generation of drugs and violence incapable of restoring former normalcy.

  1041. @AP
    @YetAnotherAnon


    No shoe-banging, no “we will bury you”, just cautious progress. If there’s still a Russia in a hundred years, he’ll get a very good press in their history books.
     
    You are writing 2 years too late.

    Until 1914 Nicholas II was not so bad, either.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Nicholas II already had a revolution back in 1905, a revolution that he appears not to have learned all that much from since afterwards he consistently tried to undermine the Duma and make it more pliable to him, such as by unilaterally changing the Duma election laws. Also, what’s interesting is that AFAIK Tsarist Russia also had its own version of the propiska system, though unlike the Bolsheviks, it actually allowed people to emigrate in huge numbers.

    Nicholas II made a major blunder in entering WWI but nevertheless once Russia entered the war it would have been in a very, very good position after the end of the war had it managed to hold on until the point of victory. The US was essentially offering to finish the job of defeating Germany for Russia in 1917 and beyond while all Russia had to do was play defense in the meantime. But of course Russia couldn’t even do that. The US was quite literally willing to bleed itself to ensure a Russian-dominated post-war Europe back then. The US was going to retreat back into isolationism after the end of the war, after all, and then Russia would be Europe’s main security guarantor, especially in the long-run. But the Bolsheviks launched their coup and made Russia an international pariah! Dumbasses!

    Had Russia not been led by Bolsheviks, it could have helped maintain order in post-WWI Europe in places like Poland (protection against Germany) and Czechoslovakia/Romania/Yugoslavia (protection against Hungary and sometimes Germany, Poland, Bulgaria, and Italy as well). A peacekeeping role that Russian troops would have likely enjoyed and relished. Much more prestigious than merely doing this in the ex-USSR space like in real life over the last 32 years.

  1042. @Philip Owen
    @Emil Nikola Richard

    Where I come from, dogs worked at herding sheep. They stayed outside in the barn or a kennel. Absolutely no one touched a dog's mouth or nose. Far less kissed it. It was a perfect way to catch liver fluke.

    Replies: @Sean

    A working line dog (bred for herding or hunting ETC) is a completely different creature.

  1043. @Mr. Hack
    @Mr. XYZ

    I had an older friend who left Ukraine when it was still a part of the Soviet Union. When it all fell apart, he was never able to obtain Ukrainian citizenship, although he would tangle with the Ukrainian embassy in San Francisco over this from time to time. I think that his chief concern was trying to obtain a Ukrainian pension, having worked most of his adult life in Ukraine. He ended up getting a small American benefit, and was a colorful figure within the emigre community in Phoenix. To his Jewish buddies he was a Jew, to the Ukrainian community a Ukrainian, to his Baptist community a Romanian. A true blue internationalist is ever there was one. RIP Vasyl.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    He was a Ukrainian Jew of Romanian descent? From the Chernivtsi area? Makes sense since that area belonged to Romania in the 1918-1940 time period.

    • Replies: @Mr. Hack
    @Mr. XYZ

    Who said anything about my father being Jewish? He lived near a large community of Jews, had Jewish friends in both the old world and the new, but him being a Jew?...

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  1044. @Mr. XYZ
    @Greasy William

    The interesting thing is that Poland been an actual Nazi ally like Hungary and not tried backstabbing Hitler later on like Hungary did, Poland's Jews could have fared considerably better than they did in real life. Nazi Germany made the Holocaust optional for its allies in regards to their own Jews for so long as they remained loyal to Hitler. This is why Greater Hungary's Jews were spared until 1944, why Bulgaria's Jews were spared, why the Jews of the Romanian Old Kingdom territories were overwhelmingly spared (with an exception in Iasi), why Italian Jews were spared until 1943, why French citizen Jews (especially if they were naturalized a long time ago or were born French citizens) were mostly spared, et cetera.

    Poland put all of its eggs in the Anglo-French basket in 1939-1940 and then got let down when France fell in 1940 because it didn't properly defend the Ardennes sector.

    Replies: @LT1488, @Mr. XYZ

    >Poland been an actual Nazi ally
    What a retarded thing to say, Nazis didn’t even make a puppet state for Poles like they did in Croatia Slovakia and even Belarus and Russia (Lokot autonomy).

    Poles had no SS division or no volunteers for various nazi units
    even Russia had large collaborationism whilst Poland had almost none.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    The context of that sentence makes it clear that I forgot to insert one word in there. I will fix it right now:

    "The interesting thing is that *had* Poland been an actual Nazi ally like Hungary and not tried backstabbing Hitler later on like Hungary did, Poland’s Jews could have fared considerably better than they did in real life."

    This correction (of a typo on my own part) makes it clear that I was speaking purely hypothetically here. And Yes, Poland would have been better off had it been a Nazi ally. The Nazis would have respected Polish sovereignty and Polish Jews at least a little bit more in such a scenario for as long as Poland would have remained loyal to the Nazi cause. Nuremberg-like laws for Polish Jews would have been expected, but mass murder of Polish Jews might have very well been optional for Poland (thus causing Poland to reject it) in such a scenario.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @LT1488

  1045. @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    >Poland been an actual Nazi ally
    What a retarded thing to say, Nazis didn't even make a puppet state for Poles like they did in Croatia Slovakia and even Belarus and Russia (Lokot autonomy).

    Poles had no SS division or no volunteers for various nazi units
    even Russia had large collaborationism whilst Poland had almost none.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    The context of that sentence makes it clear that I forgot to insert one word in there. I will fix it right now:

    “The interesting thing is that *had* Poland been an actual Nazi ally like Hungary and not tried backstabbing Hitler later on like Hungary did, Poland’s Jews could have fared considerably better than they did in real life.”

    This correction (of a typo on my own part) makes it clear that I was speaking purely hypothetically here. And Yes, Poland would have been better off had it been a Nazi ally. The Nazis would have respected Polish sovereignty and Polish Jews at least a little bit more in such a scenario for as long as Poland would have remained loyal to the Nazi cause. Nuremberg-like laws for Polish Jews would have been expected, but mass murder of Polish Jews might have very well been optional for Poland (thus causing Poland to reject it) in such a scenario.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    The Nazis would have respected Polish sovereignty and Polish Jews at least a little bit more in such a scenario for as long as Poland would have remained loyal to the Nazi cause.

    But how would we know that? Hungary became a Nazi ally and Hitler still wanted their Jews.

    What if Hitler planned on going after Europe's Jews from the beginning?

    In that scenario there is no way that Hitler would let Poland keep their Jews. Warsaw was the Jewish capital of Western Europe.

    In the case of Hungary it was Hitler that chose to expend limited military resources to acquire their Jews. That is why Hitler invaded Hungary in 1944. There was no strategic gain against the Soviets. It was all about getting the last Jewish population within his grasp.

    Which means he actually valued killing Jews over defending Germans. Once you reach that conclusion there is no reason to assume he would have given Poland a pass.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    , @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    You might already know this, but Poles themselves were quite anti-semitic and lots of Polish nationalists themselves mistrusted jews and advocated for their expulsion, Mr Roman Dmowski for example, still admired by right wing Polish nationalists, and who had bitter rivalry with Pilsudki, Dmowski advocated for expulsion/conversion of jews into Catholicism.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. XYZ

  1046. @Mr. XYZ
    @Greasy William

    The interesting thing is that Poland been an actual Nazi ally like Hungary and not tried backstabbing Hitler later on like Hungary did, Poland's Jews could have fared considerably better than they did in real life. Nazi Germany made the Holocaust optional for its allies in regards to their own Jews for so long as they remained loyal to Hitler. This is why Greater Hungary's Jews were spared until 1944, why Bulgaria's Jews were spared, why the Jews of the Romanian Old Kingdom territories were overwhelmingly spared (with an exception in Iasi), why Italian Jews were spared until 1943, why French citizen Jews (especially if they were naturalized a long time ago or were born French citizens) were mostly spared, et cetera.

    Poland put all of its eggs in the Anglo-French basket in 1939-1940 and then got let down when France fell in 1940 because it didn't properly defend the Ardennes sector.

    Replies: @LT1488, @Mr. XYZ

    “The interesting thing is that *had* Poland been an actual Nazi ally like Hungary and not tried backstabbing Hitler later on like Hungary did, Poland’s Jews could have fared considerably better than they did in real life. Nazi Germany made the Holocaust optional for its allies in regards to their own Jews for so long as they remained loyal to Hitler. This is why Greater Hungary’s Jews were spared until 1944, why Bulgaria’s Jews were spared, why the Jews of the Romanian Old Kingdom territories were overwhelmingly spared (with an exception in Iasi), why Italian Jews were spared until 1943, why French citizen Jews (especially if they were naturalized a long time ago or were born French citizens) were mostly spared, et cetera.

    Poland put all of its eggs in the Anglo-French basket in 1939-1940 and then got let down when France fell in 1940 because it didn’t properly defend the Ardennes sector.”

    (Corrected typo. Forgot to insert a single word near the beginning.)

  1047. @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. Hack

    He was a Ukrainian Jew of Romanian descent? From the Chernivtsi area? Makes sense since that area belonged to Romania in the 1918-1940 time period.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack

    Who said anything about my father being Jewish? He lived near a large community of Jews, had Jewish friends in both the old world and the new, but him being a Jew?…

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. Hack

    Oh, I got it! Vasyl, aka Basil, referred to your father, is that right?

  1048. @Mr. Hack
    @Mr. XYZ

    Who said anything about my father being Jewish? He lived near a large community of Jews, had Jewish friends in both the old world and the new, but him being a Jew?...

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Oh, I got it! Vasyl, aka Basil, referred to your father, is that right?

  1049. Here’s what I wrote about my friend Vasyl:

    I had an older friend who left Ukraine when it was still a part of the Soviet Union.

    Why would I try to camouflage my father for my friend? My father passed away a long time before I moved to Phoenix. The fact that they were both from Chernivtsy was only a coincidence.

    If it makes you think more highly of me if you think of me a being a Jew, then continue doing so, Vasyl would often state that Adam and Ever were both Jewish. 🙂

  1050. @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    The context of that sentence makes it clear that I forgot to insert one word in there. I will fix it right now:

    "The interesting thing is that *had* Poland been an actual Nazi ally like Hungary and not tried backstabbing Hitler later on like Hungary did, Poland’s Jews could have fared considerably better than they did in real life."

    This correction (of a typo on my own part) makes it clear that I was speaking purely hypothetically here. And Yes, Poland would have been better off had it been a Nazi ally. The Nazis would have respected Polish sovereignty and Polish Jews at least a little bit more in such a scenario for as long as Poland would have remained loyal to the Nazi cause. Nuremberg-like laws for Polish Jews would have been expected, but mass murder of Polish Jews might have very well been optional for Poland (thus causing Poland to reject it) in such a scenario.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @LT1488

    The Nazis would have respected Polish sovereignty and Polish Jews at least a little bit more in such a scenario for as long as Poland would have remained loyal to the Nazi cause.

    But how would we know that? Hungary became a Nazi ally and Hitler still wanted their Jews.

    What if Hitler planned on going after Europe’s Jews from the beginning?

    In that scenario there is no way that Hitler would let Poland keep their Jews. Warsaw was the Jewish capital of Western Europe.

    In the case of Hungary it was Hitler that chose to expend limited military resources to acquire their Jews. That is why Hitler invaded Hungary in 1944. There was no strategic gain against the Soviets. It was all about getting the last Jewish population within his grasp.

    Which means he actually valued killing Jews over defending Germans. Once you reach that conclusion there is no reason to assume he would have given Poland a pass.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson

    Hitler only went after Hungary's Jews after Hungary tried backstabbing him in 1944 by trying to pursue secret negotiations with the Allies about a separate peace, negotiations which Hitler found out about.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  1051. @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    The context of that sentence makes it clear that I forgot to insert one word in there. I will fix it right now:

    "The interesting thing is that *had* Poland been an actual Nazi ally like Hungary and not tried backstabbing Hitler later on like Hungary did, Poland’s Jews could have fared considerably better than they did in real life."

    This correction (of a typo on my own part) makes it clear that I was speaking purely hypothetically here. And Yes, Poland would have been better off had it been a Nazi ally. The Nazis would have respected Polish sovereignty and Polish Jews at least a little bit more in such a scenario for as long as Poland would have remained loyal to the Nazi cause. Nuremberg-like laws for Polish Jews would have been expected, but mass murder of Polish Jews might have very well been optional for Poland (thus causing Poland to reject it) in such a scenario.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @LT1488

    You might already know this, but Poles themselves were quite anti-semitic and lots of Polish nationalists themselves mistrusted jews and advocated for their expulsion, Mr Roman Dmowski for example, still admired by right wing Polish nationalists, and who had bitter rivalry with Pilsudki, Dmowski advocated for expulsion/conversion of jews into Catholicism.

    • Replies: @AP
    @LT1488

    The interwar anti-Semitic Polish far right also considered Nazism to be a subtype or a sect of Judaism.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    It wasn't only Polish nationalists who advocated encouraging Polish Jews to emigrate. Some Zionists likely did as well in part because they wanted to boost the Jews' numbers in Palestine and in part because they feared what eventually might happen to the remaining Jews in Europe in the future. Some external observers, such as Bernard Newman (a British author) in this book of his also wrote that Poland, unlike pre-Hitler Germany, actually does (in his opinion) have a Jewish problem because it has so many Jews who provide a lot of commercial and business competition to Poles that thus makes it harder for Poles to advance economically and to enter the Polish middle-class:

    https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.136797/page/n127/mode/2up?q=%22jewish+problem%22

    Probably the best long-term solution to Poland's Jewish problem in the absence of the Holocaust would have been mass intermarriage between Jews and Poles, similar to what happened in the USSR in its last decades, but with Eastern Slavs rather than Poles. Then there would be plenty of Polish-Jewish hybrids, similar to how there are many East Slavic-Jewish hybrids like myself in real life right now.

    Replies: @LT1488

  1052. @Mikel
    @Beckow


    There is no difference between the Indian woman and Biden (or Kamala), they have identical views.
     
    Well, I wouldn't say so. Left to her own devices, the Indian woman would start a war with Iran, directly involve the US in Israel's "war" against the Gazans and increase US involvement in the Ukraine war. She has clearly stated all of those (which is why JJ must find her so appealing) though, once in power, cooler heads may moderate her bellicose instincts, one hopes.

    But other than that, you're right, no difference worth mentioning. JJ hasn't even tried explaining how Nikki is different from Bush, Romney, McCain, Ryan, McConnell and all the rest of the pre-Trump era Republicans who entangled the US in pointless wars abroad while putting the legacy population of the US on an irreversible course of replacement with people from the 3rd World.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @Beckow, @John Johnson

    But other than that, you’re right, no difference worth mentioning. JJ hasn’t even tried explaining how Nikki is different from Bush, Romney, McCain, Ryan, McConnell and all the rest of the pre-Trump era Republicans who entangled the US in pointless wars

    You keep projecting your own fanboyism and assume I idealize political candidates in the way that you idealize Putin.

    Haley is merely a tool to me like a shovel or a rake. I think she is the better choice to remove Biden as I think it is likely that Trump will catch a felony. Meaning current Trump is not the Trump that would face Biden. It would be felony Trump and his 2AM rant about presidential immunity is not helping his case. After catching a felony his rating with independents will fall even further. We have not gotten to the documents case and he is already going on unhinged rants. Three of his lawyers have quit in the last month which is not a good sign. Lawyers don’t normally quit cases that are funded by a billionaire.

    Let me reiterate my position even though I have stated it a dozen times:

    I want Biden out more than I want Trump as president.

    Yes we all know you would like a return of Trump and an end to Ukraine aid.

    But it was Trump that said Ukraine should be heavily funded if Putin doesn’t agree to his plan.

    It was also Trump that sold Ukraine the nifty weapons that helped defeat Russian tanks. That was against the wishes of Putin.

    Trump is not pals with anyone. He is out for his own ego and if a war suits his ego then he will launch one.

    It was Trump that signed off on Golan as part of Israel and without any compromises. This idea of him as an isolationist is wishful thinking. Reminds me of anti-vaxxers that think of Trump as their guy and ignore how he funded Operation Warpspeed. I’ve had his deluded fans tell me that he didn’t actually get the vaccine and that it was saline. His fans have a serious case of reality denial.

    It was Trump that left the border open and turned down a generous offer from the Democrats.

    Trump’s fans have tribal brain. They don’t want to look at how Trump mostly governed as a mainstream Republican.

  1053. @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    You might already know this, but Poles themselves were quite anti-semitic and lots of Polish nationalists themselves mistrusted jews and advocated for their expulsion, Mr Roman Dmowski for example, still admired by right wing Polish nationalists, and who had bitter rivalry with Pilsudki, Dmowski advocated for expulsion/conversion of jews into Catholicism.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. XYZ

    The interwar anti-Semitic Polish far right also considered Nazism to be a subtype or a sect of Judaism.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    Yep, I seem to vaguely recall reading that somewhere. That said, though, it appears that even nowadays, among some extremely far-right Jews, there appears to be a soft spot for Nazi-like ideology:

    https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/rabbis-recorded-saying-hitler-was-right-pluralism-the-true-holocaust-588203

    , @LT1488
    @AP

    Yes I know, Dmowski accused a pro-German Polish activist of being a jew. They thought Yiddish speaking Jews were German agents.

  1054. @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    The Nazis would have respected Polish sovereignty and Polish Jews at least a little bit more in such a scenario for as long as Poland would have remained loyal to the Nazi cause.

    But how would we know that? Hungary became a Nazi ally and Hitler still wanted their Jews.

    What if Hitler planned on going after Europe's Jews from the beginning?

    In that scenario there is no way that Hitler would let Poland keep their Jews. Warsaw was the Jewish capital of Western Europe.

    In the case of Hungary it was Hitler that chose to expend limited military resources to acquire their Jews. That is why Hitler invaded Hungary in 1944. There was no strategic gain against the Soviets. It was all about getting the last Jewish population within his grasp.

    Which means he actually valued killing Jews over defending Germans. Once you reach that conclusion there is no reason to assume he would have given Poland a pass.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Hitler only went after Hungary’s Jews after Hungary tried backstabbing him in 1944 by trying to pursue secret negotiations with the Allies about a separate peace, negotiations which Hitler found out about.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    Hitler only went after Hungary’s Jews after Hungary tried backstabbing him in 1944 by trying to pursue secret negotiations with the Allies about a separate peace, negotiations which Hitler found out about.

    Hitler was forced to dedicate military resources to transport and gas 430,000 Jews because Hungary negotiated with the Allies as they and Hitler both knew the war was lost? What in the flying fuck do the Jews have to do with it? You do realize he could have used those same military resources to protect his own people? Or how about going after the Hungarian government instead of a bunch of Jews which included children?

    That's like saying you didn't return that weed trimmer you borrowed and that's why I killed your entire family. I guess you should have returned it.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  1055. @AP
    @LT1488

    The interwar anti-Semitic Polish far right also considered Nazism to be a subtype or a sect of Judaism.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

    Yep, I seem to vaguely recall reading that somewhere. That said, though, it appears that even nowadays, among some extremely far-right Jews, there appears to be a soft spot for Nazi-like ideology:

    https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/rabbis-recorded-saying-hitler-was-right-pluralism-the-true-holocaust-588203

  1056. @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    You might already know this, but Poles themselves were quite anti-semitic and lots of Polish nationalists themselves mistrusted jews and advocated for their expulsion, Mr Roman Dmowski for example, still admired by right wing Polish nationalists, and who had bitter rivalry with Pilsudki, Dmowski advocated for expulsion/conversion of jews into Catholicism.

    Replies: @AP, @Mr. XYZ

    It wasn’t only Polish nationalists who advocated encouraging Polish Jews to emigrate. Some Zionists likely did as well in part because they wanted to boost the Jews’ numbers in Palestine and in part because they feared what eventually might happen to the remaining Jews in Europe in the future. Some external observers, such as Bernard Newman (a British author) in this book of his also wrote that Poland, unlike pre-Hitler Germany, actually does (in his opinion) have a Jewish problem because it has so many Jews who provide a lot of commercial and business competition to Poles that thus makes it harder for Poles to advance economically and to enter the Polish middle-class:

    https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.136797/page/n127/mode/2up?q=%22jewish+problem%22

    Probably the best long-term solution to Poland’s Jewish problem in the absence of the Holocaust would have been mass intermarriage between Jews and Poles, similar to what happened in the USSR in its last decades, but with Eastern Slavs rather than Poles. Then there would be plenty of Polish-Jewish hybrids, similar to how there are many East Slavic-Jewish hybrids like myself in real life right now.

    • Replies: @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    Polish noviops would be an interesting phenomena.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  1057. @AP
    @LT1488

    The interwar anti-Semitic Polish far right also considered Nazism to be a subtype or a sect of Judaism.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @LT1488

    Yes I know, Dmowski accused a pro-German Polish activist of being a jew. They thought Yiddish speaking Jews were German agents.

  1058. @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    It wasn't only Polish nationalists who advocated encouraging Polish Jews to emigrate. Some Zionists likely did as well in part because they wanted to boost the Jews' numbers in Palestine and in part because they feared what eventually might happen to the remaining Jews in Europe in the future. Some external observers, such as Bernard Newman (a British author) in this book of his also wrote that Poland, unlike pre-Hitler Germany, actually does (in his opinion) have a Jewish problem because it has so many Jews who provide a lot of commercial and business competition to Poles that thus makes it harder for Poles to advance economically and to enter the Polish middle-class:

    https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.136797/page/n127/mode/2up?q=%22jewish+problem%22

    Probably the best long-term solution to Poland's Jewish problem in the absence of the Holocaust would have been mass intermarriage between Jews and Poles, similar to what happened in the USSR in its last decades, but with Eastern Slavs rather than Poles. Then there would be plenty of Polish-Jewish hybrids, similar to how there are many East Slavic-Jewish hybrids like myself in real life right now.

    Replies: @LT1488

    Polish noviops would be an interesting phenomena.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    Also Lithuanian, Latvian, Romanian, Hungarian, et cetera noviops. The last group actually does exist to some degree. Csanad Szegedi is one representative of them. Anna Julia Donath is another representative of them:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anna_Don%C3%A1th

    Hungary has a lot of noviops, actually:

    https://www.jpost.com/diaspora/dna-study-reveals-130000-hungarians-are-at-least-50-percent-jewish-598498

    Much more per capita than the US, Canada, et cetera. This is due to Budapest's Jews mostly surviving the Holocaust and many of them not emigrating afterwards as well as large-scale Hungarian-Jewish intermarriage pre-Holocaust.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  1059. @LT1488
    @Mr. XYZ

    Polish noviops would be an interesting phenomena.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Also Lithuanian, Latvian, Romanian, Hungarian, et cetera noviops. The last group actually does exist to some degree. Csanad Szegedi is one representative of them. Anna Julia Donath is another representative of them:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anna_Don%C3%A1th

    Hungary has a lot of noviops, actually:

    https://www.jpost.com/diaspora/dna-study-reveals-130000-hungarians-are-at-least-50-percent-jewish-598498

    Much more per capita than the US, Canada, et cetera. This is due to Budapest’s Jews mostly surviving the Holocaust and many of them not emigrating afterwards as well as large-scale Hungarian-Jewish intermarriage pre-Holocaust.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. XYZ

    Interestingly enough, Csanad Szegedi used to be anti-Semitic but has since become a religious Jew:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Csan%C3%A1d_Szegedi

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keep_Quiet_(film)

    Apparently he also made plans to immigrate to Israel several years ago:

    https://www.timesofisrael.com/former-far-right-hungarian-pol-who-discovered-jewish-roots-moving-to-israel/

    I'm not sure what exactly has become of these plans so far.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

  1060. @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson

    Hitler only went after Hungary's Jews after Hungary tried backstabbing him in 1944 by trying to pursue secret negotiations with the Allies about a separate peace, negotiations which Hitler found out about.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Hitler only went after Hungary’s Jews after Hungary tried backstabbing him in 1944 by trying to pursue secret negotiations with the Allies about a separate peace, negotiations which Hitler found out about.

    Hitler was forced to dedicate military resources to transport and gas 430,000 Jews because Hungary negotiated with the Allies as they and Hitler both knew the war was lost? What in the flying fuck do the Jews have to do with it? You do realize he could have used those same military resources to protect his own people? Or how about going after the Hungarian government instead of a bunch of Jews which included children?

    That’s like saying you didn’t return that weed trimmer you borrowed and that’s why I killed your entire family. I guess you should have returned it.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson

    Hitler wanted to kill Hungarian Jewry beforehand as well (ditto for Romanian, Bulgarian, French citizen, et cetera Jewry), but he was opportunistic and knew not to alienate allied countries so long as they remained loyal to him for fear of creating problems with them. But once Hungary was no longer loyal to him, he had no reason to care for Hungarian sensitives and could thus use this as a golden opportunity to achieve his long-desired goal of exterminating Hungarian Jewry. But had Hungary remained loyal to him, then this opportunity would not have come to pass. This is why Bulgarian, Romanian Old Kingdom, French citizen, et cetera Jewry overwhelmingly survived the Holocaust. Hitler wanted to kill them too, no doubt, but he didn't get an opportunity to do so like he did with Hungarian Jewry, because Romania, Bulgaria, and Vichy France remained loyal to the Nazi cause for a longer time period than Hungary did.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  1061. @Mr. XYZ
    @LT1488

    Also Lithuanian, Latvian, Romanian, Hungarian, et cetera noviops. The last group actually does exist to some degree. Csanad Szegedi is one representative of them. Anna Julia Donath is another representative of them:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anna_Don%C3%A1th

    Hungary has a lot of noviops, actually:

    https://www.jpost.com/diaspora/dna-study-reveals-130000-hungarians-are-at-least-50-percent-jewish-598498

    Much more per capita than the US, Canada, et cetera. This is due to Budapest's Jews mostly surviving the Holocaust and many of them not emigrating afterwards as well as large-scale Hungarian-Jewish intermarriage pre-Holocaust.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Interestingly enough, Csanad Szegedi used to be anti-Semitic but has since become a religious Jew:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Csan%C3%A1d_Szegedi

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keep_Quiet_(film)

    Apparently he also made plans to immigrate to Israel several years ago:

    https://www.timesofisrael.com/former-far-right-hungarian-pol-who-discovered-jewish-roots-moving-to-israel/

    I’m not sure what exactly has become of these plans so far.

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. XYZ

    Csanad Szegedi is Jewish only on maternal side, so according to the Old Testament, which is patrilineal, he is not Jewish.

    Interestingly, commercial DNA tests detect Jewishness only on paternal side, AFAIK, as it is easy due to the non-recombining nature of chromosome Y.

    BTW, do you know that Jemen is full of haplogroup J, which seems to be even named after "J" of Jews..?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  1062. @QCIC
    @Philip Owen

    Do you think the cause is lack of fuel, lack of maintenance men or something more subtle?

    Replies: @Philip Owen

    I really don’t know. I think it is subtle. Priorities have changed towards transport systems so less budget for building utilities. breakdowns are still happening more than usual.

  1063. @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    Hitler only went after Hungary’s Jews after Hungary tried backstabbing him in 1944 by trying to pursue secret negotiations with the Allies about a separate peace, negotiations which Hitler found out about.

    Hitler was forced to dedicate military resources to transport and gas 430,000 Jews because Hungary negotiated with the Allies as they and Hitler both knew the war was lost? What in the flying fuck do the Jews have to do with it? You do realize he could have used those same military resources to protect his own people? Or how about going after the Hungarian government instead of a bunch of Jews which included children?

    That's like saying you didn't return that weed trimmer you borrowed and that's why I killed your entire family. I guess you should have returned it.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Hitler wanted to kill Hungarian Jewry beforehand as well (ditto for Romanian, Bulgarian, French citizen, et cetera Jewry), but he was opportunistic and knew not to alienate allied countries so long as they remained loyal to him for fear of creating problems with them. But once Hungary was no longer loyal to him, he had no reason to care for Hungarian sensitives and could thus use this as a golden opportunity to achieve his long-desired goal of exterminating Hungarian Jewry. But had Hungary remained loyal to him, then this opportunity would not have come to pass. This is why Bulgarian, Romanian Old Kingdom, French citizen, et cetera Jewry overwhelmingly survived the Holocaust. Hitler wanted to kill them too, no doubt, but he didn’t get an opportunity to do so like he did with Hungarian Jewry, because Romania, Bulgaria, and Vichy France remained loyal to the Nazi cause for a longer time period than Hungary did.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    But had Hungary remained loyal to him, then this opportunity would not have come to pass.

    And how do we know that?

    We do know that Hitler prioritized fulfilling his own prophecy that Europe's Jews would suffer the greatest burden in the event of Germany losing.

    We also know that he prioritized killing Jews over protecting Germans from Red Army. Meaning he had no loyalty to his own people.

    Let's say that Hungary never reached out to the Allies. So what?

    Hitler made it clear that he had no loyalty to any alliance.

    He could have pulled another false flag as an excuse to invade.

    Hungary had the last remaining large population of Jews within Hitler's reach. That included Jews that had escaped other territories. We cannot say for certain that they would have survived if Hungary remained loyal. Hitler started the war by lying about a false flag event. And that was after breaking the Munich agreement.

    If Hitler had decided that he wanted to kill Hungary's Jews in 1944 then it would have happened. Hungary's government was weak and Hitler had long favored the opposition fascists. He could have made up an excuse to invade or simply demanded they be handed over or face invasion.

    Hitler had a strong belief that something like National Socialism would rise again but not if the Jews were around. He viewed Europe and Western Society as a biological struggle of Jews against Germans. In 1944 he knew the war was over and that Germany lost.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  1064. @Mr. XYZ
    @Mr. XYZ

    Interestingly enough, Csanad Szegedi used to be anti-Semitic but has since become a religious Jew:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Csan%C3%A1d_Szegedi

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keep_Quiet_(film)

    Apparently he also made plans to immigrate to Israel several years ago:

    https://www.timesofisrael.com/former-far-right-hungarian-pol-who-discovered-jewish-roots-moving-to-israel/

    I'm not sure what exactly has become of these plans so far.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

    Csanad Szegedi is Jewish only on maternal side, so according to the Old Testament, which is patrilineal, he is not Jewish.

    Interestingly, commercial DNA tests detect Jewishness only on paternal side, AFAIK, as it is easy due to the non-recombining nature of chromosome Y.

    BTW, do you know that Jemen is full of haplogroup J, which seems to be even named after “J” of Jews..?

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Another Polish Perspective

    Are you suggesting that the Mishnah is fake?

    Anyway, I define Jewishness in terms of any side of the family tree.

    "BTW, do you know that Jemen is full of haplogroup J, which seems to be even named after “J” of Jews..?"

    No, I don't. Thanks for sharing. Did a lot of Yemenite Jews historically leave Judaism and convert to Christianity and/or Islam, or what?

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

  1065. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. XYZ

    Csanad Szegedi is Jewish only on maternal side, so according to the Old Testament, which is patrilineal, he is not Jewish.

    Interestingly, commercial DNA tests detect Jewishness only on paternal side, AFAIK, as it is easy due to the non-recombining nature of chromosome Y.

    BTW, do you know that Jemen is full of haplogroup J, which seems to be even named after "J" of Jews..?

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Are you suggesting that the Mishnah is fake?

    Anyway, I define Jewishness in terms of any side of the family tree.

    “BTW, do you know that Jemen is full of haplogroup J, which seems to be even named after “J” of Jews..?”

    No, I don’t. Thanks for sharing. Did a lot of Yemenite Jews historically leave Judaism and convert to Christianity and/or Islam, or what?

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. XYZ


    Are you suggesting that the Mishnah is fake?
     
    Yes. Judaism was taken over by Phoenicians who created oral law as superstructure over written law in order to hollow it and to invert it. One very good example is the reversal from patrilineality to matrilineality. Another is turning Jews into a nation of craftsmen and traders. They start obsessing about never uttering the name of God, and other Kabbalistic nonsenses. I discussed the problem a lot here:


    https://www.unz.com/article/sir-richard-francis-burton-explorer-linguist-race-realist/


    Anyway, I define Jewishness in terms of any side of the family tree.

     

    It is wrong in terms of Mishnah. And genetically is irrelevant on mother side, since genetic component of Jewishness on maternal side has never been found.

    No, I don’t. Thanks for sharing. Did a lot of Yemenite Jews historically leave Judaism and convert to Christianity and/or Islam, or what?
     
    Partly, for sure. It seems it was Islam which originally was to replace the falsified Judaism. But I would look for solution to the Biblical Table of Nation too, investigating sons of Shem etc. In other words, genetic Jewishness trumps religious one.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  1066. @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson

    Hitler wanted to kill Hungarian Jewry beforehand as well (ditto for Romanian, Bulgarian, French citizen, et cetera Jewry), but he was opportunistic and knew not to alienate allied countries so long as they remained loyal to him for fear of creating problems with them. But once Hungary was no longer loyal to him, he had no reason to care for Hungarian sensitives and could thus use this as a golden opportunity to achieve his long-desired goal of exterminating Hungarian Jewry. But had Hungary remained loyal to him, then this opportunity would not have come to pass. This is why Bulgarian, Romanian Old Kingdom, French citizen, et cetera Jewry overwhelmingly survived the Holocaust. Hitler wanted to kill them too, no doubt, but he didn't get an opportunity to do so like he did with Hungarian Jewry, because Romania, Bulgaria, and Vichy France remained loyal to the Nazi cause for a longer time period than Hungary did.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    But had Hungary remained loyal to him, then this opportunity would not have come to pass.

    And how do we know that?

    We do know that Hitler prioritized fulfilling his own prophecy that Europe’s Jews would suffer the greatest burden in the event of Germany losing.

    We also know that he prioritized killing Jews over protecting Germans from Red Army. Meaning he had no loyalty to his own people.

    Let’s say that Hungary never reached out to the Allies. So what?

    Hitler made it clear that he had no loyalty to any alliance.

    He could have pulled another false flag as an excuse to invade.

    Hungary had the last remaining large population of Jews within Hitler’s reach. That included Jews that had escaped other territories. We cannot say for certain that they would have survived if Hungary remained loyal. Hitler started the war by lying about a false flag event. And that was after breaking the Munich agreement.

    If Hitler had decided that he wanted to kill Hungary’s Jews in 1944 then it would have happened. Hungary’s government was weak and Hitler had long favored the opposition fascists. He could have made up an excuse to invade or simply demanded they be handed over or face invasion.

    Hitler had a strong belief that something like National Socialism would rise again but not if the Jews were around. He viewed Europe and Western Society as a biological struggle of Jews against Germans. In 1944 he knew the war was over and that Germany lost.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson

    So, why didn't Hitler murder the Jews of Bulgaria, the Romanian Old Kingdom territories, and those Jews who were French citizens back when he had the chance? Bulgaria's Jews were spared the Holocaust, as were the Jews of the Romanian Old Kingdom territories (whom Antonescu decided to spare because he wanted to try saving his own skin after WWII, apparently), and only something like 9% of native French Jews were murdered in the Holocaust, as opposed to 45% of French Jews who were immigrants to France.

    Why didn't Hitler target these specific Jewish groups for mass extermination, thus increasing his Jewish death toll by hundreds of thousands of Jews?

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

  1067. @John Johnson
    @Mr. XYZ

    But had Hungary remained loyal to him, then this opportunity would not have come to pass.

    And how do we know that?

    We do know that Hitler prioritized fulfilling his own prophecy that Europe's Jews would suffer the greatest burden in the event of Germany losing.

    We also know that he prioritized killing Jews over protecting Germans from Red Army. Meaning he had no loyalty to his own people.

    Let's say that Hungary never reached out to the Allies. So what?

    Hitler made it clear that he had no loyalty to any alliance.

    He could have pulled another false flag as an excuse to invade.

    Hungary had the last remaining large population of Jews within Hitler's reach. That included Jews that had escaped other territories. We cannot say for certain that they would have survived if Hungary remained loyal. Hitler started the war by lying about a false flag event. And that was after breaking the Munich agreement.

    If Hitler had decided that he wanted to kill Hungary's Jews in 1944 then it would have happened. Hungary's government was weak and Hitler had long favored the opposition fascists. He could have made up an excuse to invade or simply demanded they be handed over or face invasion.

    Hitler had a strong belief that something like National Socialism would rise again but not if the Jews were around. He viewed Europe and Western Society as a biological struggle of Jews against Germans. In 1944 he knew the war was over and that Germany lost.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    So, why didn’t Hitler murder the Jews of Bulgaria, the Romanian Old Kingdom territories, and those Jews who were French citizens back when he had the chance? Bulgaria’s Jews were spared the Holocaust, as were the Jews of the Romanian Old Kingdom territories (whom Antonescu decided to spare because he wanted to try saving his own skin after WWII, apparently), and only something like 9% of native French Jews were murdered in the Holocaust, as opposed to 45% of French Jews who were immigrants to France.

    Why didn’t Hitler target these specific Jewish groups for mass extermination, thus increasing his Jewish death toll by hundreds of thousands of Jews?

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. XYZ


    So, why didn’t Hitler murder the Jews of Bulgaria, the Romanian Old Kingdom territories, and those Jews who were French citizens back when he had the chance? Bulgaria’s Jews were spared the Holocaust, as were the Jews of the Romanian Old Kingdom territories (whom Antonescu decided to spare because he wanted to try saving his own skin after WWII, apparently), and only something like 9% of native French Jews were murdered in the Holocaust, as opposed to 45% of French Jews who were immigrants to France.
     
    Because they were mainly Sephardic Jews (Romania, Bulgaria are former Ottoman territories), who are false Jews, aka Phoenicians. Somehow they have never become the target of anti-Semites, interestingly.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

  1068. So, why didn’t Hitler murder the Jews of Bulgaria, the Romanian Old Kingdom territories, and those Jews who were French citizens back when he had the chance?

    Jews were killed in those territories.

    and only something like 9% of native French Jews were murdered in the Holocaust, as opposed to 45% of French Jews who were immigrants to France.

    France never had that many Jews and Hitler had a complex relationship with France. From the beginning they experimented with French autonomy and separate policies for their smaller Jewish population.

    The Nazis sent 75k French Jews to the chambers so it isn’t as if they had a free pass.

    France also had Sephardic Jews from their territories and Hitler clearly viewed them differently from Eastern European Jews. At the time it was known by all sides that Communist Jews tended to be from Eastern Europe. The French Jews that were sent to the chambers were overly professional/educated. Hitler viewed Jews as a biological enemy of Germans that had higher intellect but ignored Christian/European morals. That explains why he targeted professionals but didn’t hunt down every Sephardic.

    The real question is why you think Hitler would have spared Hungary’s half million Jews when he made this statement:

    If international finance Jewry inside and outside Europe should succeed in plunging the nations once more into a world war, the result will be not the Bolshevization of the earth and thereby the victory of Jewry, but the annihilation of the Jewish race in Europe.

    Which he referenced later in 1941:
    Regarding the Jewish question, the Führer is determined to settle the matter once and for all. He prophesied that if the Jews once again brought about a world war, they would experience their extermination. This was not an empty phrase. The world war is here. The extermination of the Jews must be its necessary consequence. This question must be viewed without any sentimentality. We are here not to express sympathy for the Jews, but only to express sympathy for our own German people. As the German people again has sacrificed 160,000 dead in the eastern campaign, so the originators of this conflict must pay with their own lives.

    Which Goebbels referenced in 1943:
    None of the Führer’s prophetic words has come so inevitably true as his prediction that if Jewry succeeded in provoking a second world war, the result would be not the destruction of the Aryan race, rather the wiping out of the Jewish race.

    Hitler clearly valued killing the Jews over saving Germans by 1944. He knew that Hungary would fall to the Soviets and trying to hold it was futile. In fact he didn’t bother engaging most of Hungary’s troops. His focus was on removing the government and exporting the Jews. His actions suggest that he wanted the Jews and it was not a punishment against the Hungarian government. Hitler in fact let the Hungarian president live.

    To say the killing of Hungary’s Jews was the fault of the Hungarian government is absurd. Killing some 5 year old Jewish kid while letting government officials live is hardly some form of just revenge, even by twisted standards. The 5 year old was not involved in talks with the Allies.

  1069. @Mr. XYZ
    @John Johnson

    So, why didn't Hitler murder the Jews of Bulgaria, the Romanian Old Kingdom territories, and those Jews who were French citizens back when he had the chance? Bulgaria's Jews were spared the Holocaust, as were the Jews of the Romanian Old Kingdom territories (whom Antonescu decided to spare because he wanted to try saving his own skin after WWII, apparently), and only something like 9% of native French Jews were murdered in the Holocaust, as opposed to 45% of French Jews who were immigrants to France.

    Why didn't Hitler target these specific Jewish groups for mass extermination, thus increasing his Jewish death toll by hundreds of thousands of Jews?

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

    So, why didn’t Hitler murder the Jews of Bulgaria, the Romanian Old Kingdom territories, and those Jews who were French citizens back when he had the chance? Bulgaria’s Jews were spared the Holocaust, as were the Jews of the Romanian Old Kingdom territories (whom Antonescu decided to spare because he wanted to try saving his own skin after WWII, apparently), and only something like 9% of native French Jews were murdered in the Holocaust, as opposed to 45% of French Jews who were immigrants to France.

    Because they were mainly Sephardic Jews (Romania, Bulgaria are former Ottoman territories), who are false Jews, aka Phoenicians. Somehow they have never become the target of anti-Semites, interestingly.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Another Polish Perspective

    AFAIK, Romania had plenty of Ashkenazi Jews as well, especially in Moldavia:

    https://preview.redd.it/jews-and-armenians-in-central-europe-ca-1900-v0-gyrmf6utqew91.jpg?auto=webp&s=54a648281541b87912da462311b9b85e3818594f

    But they weren't exterminated either. (Romanian Moldavia, not Moldova, where there indeed was a large-scale Holocaust: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Moldavia )

    Also, your explanation here doesn't really work for another reason: Hitler was all too eager to mass murder Yugoslav, Greek, and Italian Jewry (after 1943), many of whom were Sephardic. By your logic, Hitler should have spared them, but he didn't. For that matter, Hitler also didn't spare the Krymchaks, who were likewise a non-Ashkenazi Jewish people.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

  1070. @Mr. XYZ
    @Another Polish Perspective

    Are you suggesting that the Mishnah is fake?

    Anyway, I define Jewishness in terms of any side of the family tree.

    "BTW, do you know that Jemen is full of haplogroup J, which seems to be even named after “J” of Jews..?"

    No, I don't. Thanks for sharing. Did a lot of Yemenite Jews historically leave Judaism and convert to Christianity and/or Islam, or what?

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

    Are you suggesting that the Mishnah is fake?

    Yes. Judaism was taken over by Phoenicians who created oral law as superstructure over written law in order to hollow it and to invert it. One very good example is the reversal from patrilineality to matrilineality. Another is turning Jews into a nation of craftsmen and traders. They start obsessing about never uttering the name of God, and other Kabbalistic nonsenses. I discussed the problem a lot here:

    https://www.unz.com/article/sir-richard-francis-burton-explorer-linguist-race-realist/

    Anyway, I define Jewishness in terms of any side of the family tree.

    It is wrong in terms of Mishnah. And genetically is irrelevant on mother side, since genetic component of Jewishness on maternal side has never been found.

    No, I don’t. Thanks for sharing. Did a lot of Yemenite Jews historically leave Judaism and convert to Christianity and/or Islam, or what?

    Partly, for sure. It seems it was Islam which originally was to replace the falsified Judaism. But I would look for solution to the Biblical Table of Nation too, investigating sons of Shem etc. In other words, genetic Jewishness trumps religious one.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Another Polish Perspective


    since genetic component of Jewishness on maternal side has never been found.
     
    https://www.timesofisrael.com/rabbinate-dna-tests-seek-jewishness-in-the-blood-become-a-bone-of-contention/

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

  1071. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. XYZ


    So, why didn’t Hitler murder the Jews of Bulgaria, the Romanian Old Kingdom territories, and those Jews who were French citizens back when he had the chance? Bulgaria’s Jews were spared the Holocaust, as were the Jews of the Romanian Old Kingdom territories (whom Antonescu decided to spare because he wanted to try saving his own skin after WWII, apparently), and only something like 9% of native French Jews were murdered in the Holocaust, as opposed to 45% of French Jews who were immigrants to France.
     
    Because they were mainly Sephardic Jews (Romania, Bulgaria are former Ottoman territories), who are false Jews, aka Phoenicians. Somehow they have never become the target of anti-Semites, interestingly.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    AFAIK, Romania had plenty of Ashkenazi Jews as well, especially in Moldavia:

    But they weren’t exterminated either. (Romanian Moldavia, not Moldova, where there indeed was a large-scale Holocaust: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Moldavia )

    Also, your explanation here doesn’t really work for another reason: Hitler was all too eager to mass murder Yugoslav, Greek, and Italian Jewry (after 1943), many of whom were Sephardic. By your logic, Hitler should have spared them, but he didn’t. For that matter, Hitler also didn’t spare the Krymchaks, who were likewise a non-Ashkenazi Jewish people.

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. XYZ

    Moldova was Polish-Ottoman condominium.
    Some Jews who are officially Askhenazi, genetically are Sephardic. The confusion is well documented in the character of false messiah Jacob Frank - he was Sephardi who lived like Askhenazi and yet his nick/surname "Frank" denoted Askehnazi Jews in Ottoman territories.
    But did you ever wondered why Sephardim and Askheanazm prefer not to marry each other?


    Hitler was all too eager to mass murder Yugoslav, Greek, and Italian Jewry (after 1943), many of whom were Sephardic. By your logic, Hitler should have spared them, but he didn’t.
     
    Hitler wasn't really concerned about any particular Jew. He basically tried to kill anyone under his direct jurisdiction, which Greeve, Yugoslavia and Italy became at some point.
    But False Judaism needs human sacrifice to Baal even from its genetic worshippers, aka Phoenicians, not only Ashkenazi converts. Analogically, Aztecs sacrificed mainly non Aztecs, often even their allies. But have you ever wondered why Holocaust has such a name - sacrifice...? Why not just the great murder etc. Frankly, is is in your face - sacrifice.

    The fact is, the core territories of Sephardim - Portugal, Spain, Turkey and former Ottoman territories, generally were spared from warfare.

    This Hungarian guy Szegedi who discovered his matrilineal Judaism looks like Canaanite, or Palestinian actually.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  1072. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. XYZ


    Are you suggesting that the Mishnah is fake?
     
    Yes. Judaism was taken over by Phoenicians who created oral law as superstructure over written law in order to hollow it and to invert it. One very good example is the reversal from patrilineality to matrilineality. Another is turning Jews into a nation of craftsmen and traders. They start obsessing about never uttering the name of God, and other Kabbalistic nonsenses. I discussed the problem a lot here:


    https://www.unz.com/article/sir-richard-francis-burton-explorer-linguist-race-realist/


    Anyway, I define Jewishness in terms of any side of the family tree.

     

    It is wrong in terms of Mishnah. And genetically is irrelevant on mother side, since genetic component of Jewishness on maternal side has never been found.

    No, I don’t. Thanks for sharing. Did a lot of Yemenite Jews historically leave Judaism and convert to Christianity and/or Islam, or what?
     
    Partly, for sure. It seems it was Islam which originally was to replace the falsified Judaism. But I would look for solution to the Biblical Table of Nation too, investigating sons of Shem etc. In other words, genetic Jewishness trumps religious one.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    since genetic component of Jewishness on maternal side has never been found.

    https://www.timesofisrael.com/rabbinate-dna-tests-seek-jewishness-in-the-blood-become-a-bone-of-contention/

    • Replies: @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. XYZ

    Hard to say. Later studies claimed that almost all females were indigenous ones, not from MENA.


    A 2013 study of Ashkenazi mitochondrial DNA by a team led by Martin B. Richards agreed with the older hypothesis of the origin. It tested all 16,600 DNA units of mtDNA, and found that the four main female Ashkenazi founders had descent lines that were established in Europe 10,000 to 20,000 years in the past[177] while most of the remaining minor founders also have a deep European ancestry.
     
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashkenazi_Jews

    Four genetic matriarchs nicely coincides with Judaism tradition of Sarah, Rebecca, Leah, Rachel as four matriarchs so obviously at least some rabbis would jump upon it.
    Nevertheless some sons of Jacob were born to slaves of Rachel and Leah so it can't be so important - none of biblical Jews was fathered by a slave.

  1073. @Mr. XYZ
    @Another Polish Perspective

    AFAIK, Romania had plenty of Ashkenazi Jews as well, especially in Moldavia:

    https://preview.redd.it/jews-and-armenians-in-central-europe-ca-1900-v0-gyrmf6utqew91.jpg?auto=webp&s=54a648281541b87912da462311b9b85e3818594f

    But they weren't exterminated either. (Romanian Moldavia, not Moldova, where there indeed was a large-scale Holocaust: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Moldavia )

    Also, your explanation here doesn't really work for another reason: Hitler was all too eager to mass murder Yugoslav, Greek, and Italian Jewry (after 1943), many of whom were Sephardic. By your logic, Hitler should have spared them, but he didn't. For that matter, Hitler also didn't spare the Krymchaks, who were likewise a non-Ashkenazi Jewish people.

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

    Moldova was Polish-Ottoman condominium.
    Some Jews who are officially Askhenazi, genetically are Sephardic. The confusion is well documented in the character of false messiah Jacob Frank – he was Sephardi who lived like Askhenazi and yet his nick/surname “Frank” denoted Askehnazi Jews in Ottoman territories.
    But did you ever wondered why Sephardim and Askheanazm prefer not to marry each other?

    Hitler was all too eager to mass murder Yugoslav, Greek, and Italian Jewry (after 1943), many of whom were Sephardic. By your logic, Hitler should have spared them, but he didn’t.

    Hitler wasn’t really concerned about any particular Jew. He basically tried to kill anyone under his direct jurisdiction, which Greeve, Yugoslavia and Italy became at some point.
    But False Judaism needs human sacrifice to Baal even from its genetic worshippers, aka Phoenicians, not only Ashkenazi converts. Analogically, Aztecs sacrificed mainly non Aztecs, often even their allies. But have you ever wondered why Holocaust has such a name – sacrifice…? Why not just the great murder etc. Frankly, is is in your face – sacrifice.

    The fact is, the core territories of Sephardim – Portugal, Spain, Turkey and former Ottoman territories, generally were spared from warfare.

    This Hungarian guy Szegedi who discovered his matrilineal Judaism looks like Canaanite, or Palestinian actually.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Another Polish Perspective

    Hitler wasn’t really concerned about any particular Jew. He basically tried to kill anyone under his direct jurisdiction, which Greeve, Yugoslavia and Italy became at some point.

    That's not true. He had different policies for each country. For example French Algerian Jews had a separate policy and many were deported. He did not view them in the same way as Polish or Russian Jews. He also demanded Hungarian Jews but was not as concerned with Italy. Mussolini in fact had an early pass.

    Hitler gave the order to kill Jews in the field during the Eastern Front but not the West.

    SS troops had free reign to kill any Jew as an assumed Commissar or partisan.

    They weren't allowed to take French Jews and just shoot them behind buildings.

    The Eastern Front had a "no questions asked" policy. We really don't know how many Jews they gunned down as they invaded. The SS attracted Nazi loyalists that wanted to kill Jews while the Germany military was opposed to the Commissar order. They correctly viewed it as discouraging surrender if the Commissar in the group knew he would be shot. I've read accounts from German regulars who didn't even know about the order or why it existed. The viewed it as SS business.

  1074. @Mr. XYZ
    @Another Polish Perspective


    since genetic component of Jewishness on maternal side has never been found.
     
    https://www.timesofisrael.com/rabbinate-dna-tests-seek-jewishness-in-the-blood-become-a-bone-of-contention/

    Replies: @Another Polish Perspective

    Hard to say. Later studies claimed that almost all females were indigenous ones, not from MENA.

    A 2013 study of Ashkenazi mitochondrial DNA by a team led by Martin B. Richards agreed with the older hypothesis of the origin. It tested all 16,600 DNA units of mtDNA, and found that the four main female Ashkenazi founders had descent lines that were established in Europe 10,000 to 20,000 years in the past[177] while most of the remaining minor founders also have a deep European ancestry.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashkenazi_Jews

    Four genetic matriarchs nicely coincides with Judaism tradition of Sarah, Rebecca, Leah, Rachel as four matriarchs so obviously at least some rabbis would jump upon it.
    Nevertheless some sons of Jacob were born to slaves of Rachel and Leah so it can’t be so important – none of biblical Jews was fathered by a slave.

  1075. @Mr. XYZ
    @AP

    I got it! You're a Polish citizen and thus an EU citizen as well. Frankly, I wonder if I myself could get Polish citizenship through my Jewish paternal great-grandfather, who lived in Sarny (or somewhere very close to there, in that general area) until the Polish-Soviet War, when he got kidnapped by the Bolsheviks and taken to the Soviet Union as the Bolsheviks were retreating from Sarny because apparently the Bolsheviks wanted more literate people and he was literate. This move ironically ended up saving his life since it made it much easier for him to evacuate eastwards in 1941 during Operation Barbarossa, while his parents and most of his siblings, nephews, nieces, et cetera who stayed in Sarny were subsequently murdered in the Holocaust. But I don't know if my connection to Poland is actually close enough for me to acquire Polish citizenship. I think that Poland requires an ancestor who lived in Poland on or after January 10, 1920, but I don't know when specifically during the Polish-Soviet War the Bolsheviks kidnapped my Jewish great-grandfather or, even if he was kidnapped after January 10, 1920, whether there would actually be sufficient proof of him being in Sarny beforehand that would be sufficiently convincing for the Polish authorities. He was born in 1896, so he should appear in the 1897 Imperial Russian Census if the census lists themselves were not destroyed, but they might have been and 1897 is still more than two decades before 1920.

    So, ultimately, for me, I'll have to wait until there is regime change in Russia and Russia will seek and acquire EU citizenship in order for me to try acquiring Russian and EU citizenship. At least I speak fluent Russian. That's a plus!

    Did your wife and/or children ever seriously consider giving up their Russian citizenship after the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine?


    My wife and kids have Russian and American citizenship. The kids have also gotten EU citizenship, with me. Our family have many escape options, if need be :-). Though the USA probably has a solid future.

     

    Having both Russian and Polish citizenship, as your own kids apparently have, is very rare and unusual, I would think. But Yeah, I'm also pretty optimistic about the long-term future of the US.

    I think that the most valuable citizenships to acquire are these, in order:

    1. The U.S.
    2. The E.U.
    3. Other Anglosphere
    4. Israel/Japan/South Korea/Taiwan/Singapore/et cetera
    5. Russia/China/Vietnam/Thailand/et cetera
    6. India
    7. Latin American countries
    8. Everyone else

    Does that sound about plausible?

    Replies: @Derer

    I noticed your preference for citizenship ranking and actually agreeing with the AP statement: “But Yeah, I’m also pretty optimistic about the long-term future of the US.”

    This view completely contrast with my two sons, born in the US to an iron curtain escapee. They are highly educated and successful, however decided to obtain EU citizenship and leave the US. This was reaffirmed after few visits to their and my fatherland in Europe.

    The US are in a turmoil with huge racial and political problems. Country is highly polarized and potentially in a path of unavoidable split into red and blue divide. The post WWII European brain is dying off and is being replaced by the generation of drugs and violence incapable of restoring former normalcy.

  1076. @Yahya
    @Mr. Hack


    Although its been a few years since I last viewed Mulholland Dr, I remember enjoying it and see that it nearly fell off of your list?…
     
    Mulholland Dr is an interesting and original film. Problem is, I’ve watched too many excellent films this year. As mentioned, I struggled mightily to winnow down this list; lots of otherwise good films like 2001: Space Odyssey, Fight Club, Charade, Pathar Panchali etc. had to be excluded from my list.

    In any case, welcome back!
     
    Thanks, but my stay here will be short-lived. I realized that passing time in an online forum with 50-60+ year olds is not ideal for someone my age. Although I’ve certainly enjoyed and benefited from interacting with many high-caliber individuals on this forum; I decided to focus more on cultivating my physical strength and social skills over the previous months, since I had neglected those in favor of intellectual activities from a young age. The aim is to attain comprehensiveness in character and balance out my overly-intellectual natural side.

    No need to despair though, Mr. Hack, because I will stop by here every once in a while. Best of luck.

    @Emil Nikola

    Great Expectations is indeed a great movie. I probably should’ve bumped it up the list a few spots. Haven’t read the novel yet.

    Replies: @Mr. Hack, @Sher Singh, @Talha

    Salaam Bro,

    Excellent idea – always good to be well rounded. I’m taking up Muay Thai myself and inshaAllah about to start a self-defense/grappling club (in my new basement – putting down enough pads/mats for two concurrent sparring sessions) for some of the older “uncle-brothers” in the community to get them out of skinny-fat and get used to getting punched and kicked in the face. It’s an excellent and humbling experience – I would recommend some self-defense training along with the weights. Know how to use the muscle properly – a trained jiu jitsu partner at 150 can repeatedly submit a guy 80 pounds larger. But the bigger guy who is also trained will win almost every time.

    Egypt generally brings some good competition to world wrestling and martial arts, though Morocco seems to produce very solid kickboxers.

    Anyway, may Allah swt grant you tawfiq in your endeavors!

    Wa salaam.

  1077. @Another Polish Perspective
    @Mr. XYZ

    Moldova was Polish-Ottoman condominium.
    Some Jews who are officially Askhenazi, genetically are Sephardic. The confusion is well documented in the character of false messiah Jacob Frank - he was Sephardi who lived like Askhenazi and yet his nick/surname "Frank" denoted Askehnazi Jews in Ottoman territories.
    But did you ever wondered why Sephardim and Askheanazm prefer not to marry each other?


    Hitler was all too eager to mass murder Yugoslav, Greek, and Italian Jewry (after 1943), many of whom were Sephardic. By your logic, Hitler should have spared them, but he didn’t.
     
    Hitler wasn't really concerned about any particular Jew. He basically tried to kill anyone under his direct jurisdiction, which Greeve, Yugoslavia and Italy became at some point.
    But False Judaism needs human sacrifice to Baal even from its genetic worshippers, aka Phoenicians, not only Ashkenazi converts. Analogically, Aztecs sacrificed mainly non Aztecs, often even their allies. But have you ever wondered why Holocaust has such a name - sacrifice...? Why not just the great murder etc. Frankly, is is in your face - sacrifice.

    The fact is, the core territories of Sephardim - Portugal, Spain, Turkey and former Ottoman territories, generally were spared from warfare.

    This Hungarian guy Szegedi who discovered his matrilineal Judaism looks like Canaanite, or Palestinian actually.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Hitler wasn’t really concerned about any particular Jew. He basically tried to kill anyone under his direct jurisdiction, which Greeve, Yugoslavia and Italy became at some point.

    That’s not true. He had different policies for each country. For example French Algerian Jews had a separate policy and many were deported. He did not view them in the same way as Polish or Russian Jews. He also demanded Hungarian Jews but was not as concerned with Italy. Mussolini in fact had an early pass.

    Hitler gave the order to kill Jews in the field during the Eastern Front but not the West.

    SS troops had free reign to kill any Jew as an assumed Commissar or partisan.

    They weren’t allowed to take French Jews and just shoot them behind buildings.

    The Eastern Front had a “no questions asked” policy. We really don’t know how many Jews they gunned down as they invaded. The SS attracted Nazi loyalists that wanted to kill Jews while the Germany military was opposed to the Commissar order. They correctly viewed it as discouraging surrender if the Commissar in the group knew he would be shot. I’ve read accounts from German regulars who didn’t even know about the order or why it existed. The viewed it as SS business.

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to All Karlin Community Comments via RSS
PastClassics
How America was neoconned into World War IV
The Shaping Event of Our Modern World
The Hidden Information in Our Government Archives