Unz评论•另类媒体选择$
美国主流媒体大都排除了有趣,重要和有争议的观点
 博客浏览埃里克·马戈利斯(Eric Margolis)档案
美国支持中东最动荡的国家
通过电子邮件将此页面发送给其他人

 记住我的信息



=>

书签 全部切换总目录添加到图书馆从图书馆中删除 • B
显示评论下一个新评论下一个新回复了解更多
回复同意/不同意/等等 更多... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
同意不同意谢谢LOL轮唱
这些按钮可将您的公开协议,异议,感谢,LOL或巨魔与所选注释一起注册。 仅对最近使用“记住我的信息”复选框保存姓名和电子邮件的频繁评论者可用,并且在任何八个小时的时间内也只能使用三次。
忽略评论者 关注评论者
搜寻文字 区分大小写  确切的词  包括评论
列表 书签

Saudi Arabia has been shaken to its core by the gruesome murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi.

Turkish intelligence has leaked that the Saudi journalist, who wrote op-ed pieces for the Washington Post newspaper, was strangled in the Saudi consulate in Istanbul, then cut up into pieces for disposal or dissolved in acid. His remains have not yet been found.

Khashoggi’s brazen murder has caused a crisis in US-Saudi relations, an angry confrontation with Turkey, and serious questions about the Saudi war in wretched Yemen, which so far had caused 60,000 deaths and left this remote land facing starvation.

Trump and his allies initially supported the Saudi-Emirati war against Yemen, having fallen for the false claim that great Satan Iran was backing the Yemeni Houthi forces. Britain and Israel strongly supported the Saudi war.

In reality, Saudi Arabia’s headstrong Crown Prince Mohammed, got his nation embroiled in a no-win war against tough Yemeni tribes who refused to accept a Saudi-imposed figurehead ruler. The United Arab Emirates, a Saudi ally, also got involved to expand its little country-big ambitions around the Red Sea littoral.

But the Saudis lacked a real army to wage war in Yemen. They feared an army might mount a coup against the royal family as happened in Egypt, Iraq and Libya. In the past, the Saudis had rented crack Pakistani troops to protect their palaces and oil. But Pakistan refused Saudi requests to send troops to subdue Yemen.

As Libya’s late leader, Col. Muammar Khadaffi told me, ‘the Saudis are a small bunch of rich people living behind high walls in terror of their poorer neighbors.’ The Saudis hated Khadaffi because he kept calling them ‘traitors to the Arab cause, prostitutes, whore-mongers and crooks.’

Instead, the Saudis relied on their US and British-supplied air force to prosecute the war in Yemen by indiscriminate terror bombing and trying to starve the Yemenis into submission. Villages and schools were flattened, wedding parties rocketed, school buses attacked. US and British technicians and military experts kept the Saudi warplanes flying and provided bombs and targeting data from satellites. Western mercenaries fly and service the Saudi and Emirati air force.

No one in the West cared about this massacre until the unfortunate Khashoggi was murdered in Istanbul. This crime allowed disgust with Saudi Arabia over its Yemen war, beheadings and crucifixions to finally take precedence over arms sales and tawdry geopolitics.

The United States and Britain finally questioned their billions of arms sales to the Saudis who use these mammoth purchases to buy subservience from the western democracies. France and Germany recoiled from major arms sales. Self-righteous Canada prevaricated, trying to get the Saudi cash while ducking opprobrium for arming a cruel, murderous regime.

立即订购

Washington’s most ardent Israel supporters – Security chief Bolton, and Secretary Pompeo – rushed to support the Saudis. They repeated the ludicrous claim that Khashoggi was a Muslim Brotherhood member and thus worthy of execution. In truth, the Muslim Brotherhood is a venerable, moderate organization composed of Arab professionals that calls for democracy.

But the most interesting development may have been the flight from London to Riyadh by exiled Saudi Prince Ahmad bin Abdulaziz. This 70-something younger brother of King Salman was reportedly given security guarantees by the US and Britain that he would not be arrested by Crown Prince Mohammed when he returned to Riyadh from a golden exile in London.

You could almost hear them yelling ‘bad puppets, bad puppets’ at the Saudi royals. Only two weeks earlier an unusually frank President Trump had even observed that the Saudi 7,000-member royal family would not last ‘more than a week’ without US support.

He was quite right. Since the 1930’s, the Saudi dynasty has been defended and supported by first Britain, then the United States. Few questioned the support of the world’s leading democracy for a cruel medieval monarchy. There was too much oil money involved. The British government even quashed criminal charges when huge kickbacks to Saudi royals on aircraft orders were revealed. Washington covered up the Saudi role in the 9/11 attacks and financing of anti-US groups.

Back to Prince Ahmad. Has he been chosen by Washington and London to replace the rash, violent Crown Prince Mohammed? How worried is the US that the Khashoggi murder could set off a rebellion in Saudi Arabia? Or civil war in the royal family? The aged current king, Salman, is reported to have cognitive problems.

The clumsy, ham-handed meddling of President Trump in Saudi dynastic affairs propelled the bull in a china shop Crown Prince into power. The machinations of Trump’s son-in- law, Jared Kushner, and his Israeli allies have ignited the current crisis. Trump & Co have very much to learn about the Mideast. So far, their attempt to play colonial viceroys has been a fiasco.

(从重新发布 EricMargolis.com网站 经作者或代表的许可)
 
隐藏17条评论发表评论
忽略评论者...跟随Endorsed Only
修剪评论?
    []
  1. Alistair 说:

    There are too many cooks in the kitchen, yet the Near East needs a credible leadership.

    Saudis Arabia is a young state with no significant statehood background; since 16th century, the Near East has always been under “Custody or Protectora” of a major power, be it the Ottoman Empire, British, or American – like Israel, Saudis Arabia is an immature state that recklessly being enabled by the western powers for their own selfish interests, as such, today, the Saudi Government is a mirror image of its Young Prince (MBS) – i.e. a spoiled young brad, overly ambitious beyond his intellectual capacity who needs direct supervision in the running of the state’s affairs.

    Ironically, so do the United States; because there’s no competent leadership in the Oval Office either; a 72 years old “Playboy President” with his spoiled children, surrendered by a bunch of old advisors from 1970’s who believe in brute military force as opposed to intelligent diplomacy; these guys are leading the U.S into a New Cold War with Russia while crushing any middle eastern nation who dare to defy the U.S. policy in the region.

    There are simply too many incompetent cooks in the kitchen, yet, the Near East needs a regional leadership; too many new states and too many novice figures at the helms; Israel, Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Syria, Iraq, Kuwait – all these new states are the product of British and French colonial interference which had led to the broken Near East today and the U.S. follow suit. Perhaps regional powers should be left to assume their own responsibilities – perhaps an alliance between Turkey and Iran could bring some stability to the region, just as it did in Syria. Ironically, President Erdogan’s plan for the “New Ottoman Empire” doesn’t seem to be such bad idea after all.

    • 回复: @Fidelios Automata
  2. Isramerica will continue to support the blood-spattered Riyadh mob no matter what:

    because it sells oil for Jewbucks and Jewbucks only, and

    because it provides convenient bases for the upcoming ZOG war on Iran.

    • 同意: Moi
  3. @Alistair

    Except that Erdogan himself is a total douche.

  4. MEexpert 说:

    The article states the obvious but does not offer any solution. That MBS’ hands have blood on them is a fact. Trump should think what he would do if it were Iran accused of this shameful murder and act on it. He should demand, as a minimum, the removal of MBS. No War support unless that is done. War on Yemen will automatically scale down and eventually end. Saudis will always be under US control, no matter what. I know, I have been there. It is not Saudi Arabia that Trump is afraid of, it is Israel. Israel needs Saudi Arabia and MBS is doing Israel’s bidding. Hence Netanyahu bragging that he told Trump to give MBS pass on this murder. Time for talk is long over. It is time for US, President and the Congress to act. Where is Lindsay Graham? All of a sudden there is total silence.

  5. Renoman 说:

    Time for the US to bring democracy to Saudi Arabia. 80% of the Saudi population will be happy, the rest of the World will cheer and America will have all the oil. Everyone hates the Saudi’s why has no one figured that out? NO FRIENDS! They are complete douche bags, go get em.

    • 回复: @Moi
    , @Dan Hayes
  6. Yee 说:

    The MiddleEast would not be allowed to have a dominate and unifying power, just like Europe hasn’t been allowed to have one. The Brit has been a master in this game, and the Yankees are just their students.

    It doesn’t really matter which one to back, as long as you can get the MiddleEast fighting among themselves.

    The British has been playing this shit-stirring game for centuries.

  7. jimbim 说:

    To describe the House of Saud ” Reactionary” is to mild a description. It is a barbaric, medieval, gruesome, racist, brutal, radical islamist, dictatorship.

  8. Moi 说:
    @Renoman

    It’s not the business of the US to bring democracy/freedom anywhere. But it should end its support for this medieval, head-chopping “royal” family of former bandits and thugs.

  9. MEexpert 说:

    To describe the House of Saud ” Reactionary” is to mild a description. It is a barbaric, medieval, gruesome, racist, brutal, radical islamist, dictatorship.

    Calling House of Saud Islamic is an insult to Islam. They lie, cheat, kill, gamble, and drink alcohol. How could they be Islamic?

    • 回复: @anon
  10. Anon[425]• 免责声明 说: • 您的网站

    It’s more like the most reactionary nation in the Middle East backs the US that backs Israel, the most imperialist nation in the Middle East.

    PS. All this stuff about Kashoggi Murder was ridiculous. Israel targeted and assassinated Iranian scientists by using terror, but was there an outcry from NYT and Wapo? Who/Whom always. No, NYT reported on the assassinations with quotes around ‘terror’.

  11. anon[355]• 免责声明 说:

    So what is your solution to the dysfunctionality – at every aspect of life – of the Arab world Mr., Margolis?

  12. Pat Kittle 说:

    “The U.S. Backs the Mideast’s Most Reactionary Nation.”

    It also backs Saudi Arabia.

  13. Dan Hayes 说:
    @Renoman

    雷诺曼:

    Where have I heard that exclusionary tale before about democracy and oil? How about Iraq for one!

    • 回复: @Pat Kittle
  14. Pat Kittle 说:
    @Dan Hayes

    They called it “Operation Iraqi Liberation” — the acronym of which is obvious.

    What isn’t so obvious is the truth — the acronym more accurately denotes “Operation Israeli Land-grab.”

  15. anon[355]• 免责声明 说:
    @MEexpert

    How could they not? Sounds just like the “prophet”.

    • 回复: @MEexpert
  16. MEexpert 说:
    @anon

    How could they not? Sounds just like the “prophet”.

    I don’t know which prophet you mean. You are either totally ignorant or totally dumb. Read about the Prophet first.

  17. Anon[307]• 免责声明 说:

    “The Democrats have the more dynamic young White candidates. See O’Rourke, Conor Lamb, Abigail Spanberger.”

    They’ve also got guys like Andrew Gillum who beat all the democrat’s young White candidates despite being under multiple FBI investigations. Does this portend the future, perhaps? Let me know when a guy like O’Rourke beats a guy like Gillum in a one-on-one primary in a noncompetitive, heavily non-white blue area. But I think we’ve seen that already in the Alexandra Oscario Cortez race.

当前评论者
说:

发表评论-对超过两周的文章发表评论,将在质量和语气上进行更严格的判断


 记得 我的信息为什么?
 电子邮件回复我的评论
$
提交的评论已被许可给 Unz评论 并可以由后者自行决定在其他地方重新发布
在翻译模式下禁用评论
通过RSS订阅此评论主题 通过RSS订阅所有Eric Margolis评论
Personal 古典文学
“美国在中东和穆斯林世界的战略和经济利益正受到...
本·拉登已经死了,但他的策略仍然使美国流血。
埃及人反抗美国以及穆巴拉克的统治。
布什的朝鲜盲点开始产生威胁。
阿富汗远非成为“解放”伊拉克的典范,而是向人们展示了美国如何陷入苏联式的困境。