Unz评论•另类媒体选择$
美国主流媒体大都排除了有趣,重要和有争议的观点
 博客浏览特雷弗·林奇(Trevor Lynch)档案
看看谁回来了
通过电子邮件将此页面发送给其他人

 记住我的信息



=>

书签 全部切换总目录添加到图书馆从图书馆中删除 • B
显示评论下一个新评论下一个新回复了解更多
回复同意/不同意/等等 更多... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
同意不同意谢谢LOL轮唱
这些按钮可将您的公开协议,异议,感谢,LOL或巨魔与所选注释一起注册。 仅对最近使用“记住我的信息”复选框保存姓名和电子邮件的频繁评论者可用,并且在任何八个小时的时间内也只能使用三次。
忽略评论者 关注评论者
搜寻文字 区分大小写  确切的词  包括评论
列表 书签

“每当正义的衰落和正义的兴起,我都会回去教佛法。”

- 薄伽梵歌,第四章,第7节

“没有人可以永远对希特勒生气。”

- 看看谁回来了

大卫·温德特(David Wnendt)的2015电影 看看谁回来了 (他又回来了)是根据帖木儿(Timur Vermes)2012年同名小说改编的,该小说讲述了阿道夫·希特勒(Adolf Hitler)被神秘地运送到现代柏林,并引起了媒体的轰动。 看看谁回来了 是一部引人入胜且有趣的电影,但其意图传达的信息很难理解。 这部电影是否是现代社会的讽刺,现代媒体的讽刺,是否是对反法西斯主义的警告? 如果说这完全是讽刺的话,那么它太宽泛了,包罗万象,以至于人们都不知道电影制片人的立场和目的。 然而,正如我读到的那样,这部电影的最终效果是使希特勒看起来比我们习惯的咀嚼疯狂的疯子更具理性和吸引力。 反过来,这也破坏了电影试图通过将他们与希特勒联系起来,以抹黑Marine Le Pen和Geet Wilders等民族民粹主义者的企图。 但这当然不是Wnendt或Vermes意图的一部分。

看看谁回来了 令我震惊的是杰西·科辛斯基(Jerzy Kosinski)唯一的好故事, -其中一种神秘的密码将其他人的预测带入了权力的位置-并且 商业网络,这是帕迪·查耶夫斯基(Paddy Chayevsky)精采的电视讽刺作品,其中一位雄心勃勃且无良的女制片人利用霍华德·比尔(Howard Beale),后者是电视转播狂,是疯了的先知和民粹主义论坛。 仅在这种情况下,密码是不可见的,不是因为他不为人所知,而是因为他曝光过度,据说已经死了,人们拒绝相信他们说谎的眼睛。

立即订购

的基本故事 看看谁回来了 很简单从1945年2014月到XNUMX年,阿道夫·希特勒(奥利夫·马斯奇)经历了一些奇迹。他在老总理府所在地附近的柏林公寓大楼内醒来。 然后,他想到了那种像希特勒在当今柏林四处游荡时穿着打扮的家伙那样的喜剧性冒险。 自然,没有人认为 he 已经回来了。 相反,他们把他当作希特勒的模仿者,即疯子或小丑。 人们想和他合影并向希特勒敬礼。 电影的某些部分以与真实人物的未经脚本编写的互动形式呈现。 如果这是真的,那么他收到的负面反应很少。 坦白说,我认为这都是假的。

希特勒与报亭老板结为朋友,并开始追赶过去的70年。 得知波兰仍然存在,并且在德国领土上同样如此,他感到震惊。 希特勒鄙视安格拉·默克尔(Angela Merkel),并将她的政党视作对国家社会主义的苍白模仿。 但是他把大量股票投向了格林。

希特勒然后与一个有点输家的法比安·萨瓦斯基(Fabian Busch)合作,与他的母亲住在一起,梦想着当导演,而在MyTV网络的办公室里放邮件和煮咖啡。 Fabian坚信这位希特勒的模仿者将是巨大的成功,并希望与时俱进。 希特勒横穿德国,与普通的德国人谈论移民和种族混合的弊端以及自由民主的虚假。 他找到了很多听众。 再说一遍:这是真实的还是道德的游戏? 是否发出警告,甚至与自由民主共识之间的最小偏差也将直接导致您知道谁?

如果这是预期的信息,那么电影制片人为什么将希特勒描述为头脑冷静,理性甚至幽默? 为什么不只使用我们一千次见识的令人讨厌的电视希特勒呢? 韦尔梅斯(Vermes)和温纳特(Wnendt)知道,希特勒的形象是通过从充满事实和论点的长期讲座中提取出充满激情的高潮来构建的。 顺便说一句,Vermes非常擅长捕捉希特勒的声音和风格,因为 讨论得很好 by 逆流拥有詹姆斯·欧米拉(James O'Meara),即使希特勒遇到格兰诺拉麦片棒这样的现代怪诞事物,这也以搞笑的效果延续到电影中。

当Katja Bellini(Katja Riemann)接管MyTV时,希特勒迎来了重要的时刻。 她认为希特勒会引起轰动,但她的怨恨底气克里斯托夫·森森布林克(克里斯托夫·玛丽亚·赫尔伯斯特(Christoph Maria Herbst))认为他可以通过公开反对将希特勒参加电视讽刺节目而遭到强烈反对。 森森布林克(Sensenbrink)敦促作家提出尽可能多的令人反感的笑话。 (示例:问:犹太恋童癖说了什么?答:想买一些糖果吗?)

但是希特勒的独白并不是种族灭绝狂人的怨言。 尽管他们有点机智,但它们也不是喜剧的套路。 相反,他们对现代文化的平庸性,自由民主的失败以及对生活意义的需求进行了坦率和衷心的冥想。 希特勒成为病毒媒体的轰动。

但是,希特勒开枪攻击一只攻击他的小狗的镜头曝光了。 就像希特勒是爱狗人一样,整件事让我印象深刻。 但这是非常有用的。 观众打开他。 希特勒是卡普特。 贝里尼(Bellini)和萨瓦茨基(Sawatski)是澳大利亚人。 Sensenbrink接任Bellini的工作。

但是之后 。 。 。 希特勒回来了。 毕竟,希特勒是最畅销的作家。 因此,希特勒在萨瓦茨基(Sawatski)妈妈的公寓里打了个洞,写下了他的第二本畅销书, 看看谁回来了。 在对现代形象改造的讽刺讽刺中,希特勒向动物慈善机构捐款,出现在脱口秀节目中,甚至设法被光头党殴打。

同时,在没有希特勒的情况下,该网络的利润直线下降,这为Sensenbrink模仿希特勒的著名人物创造了一个场景。 倒台 长篇大论。 (值得注意的是,电影中唯一的抱怨不是希特勒的,而是森森布林克的。)网络中的一个白痴建议重新雇用希特勒,因为“没有人可以永远对希特勒保持生气。” 犹太人肯定会不同意。

这使我们想到了这部电影的另一个方面,使我感到非常伪造:不时提到犹太人,但总是以某种方式使他们看起来自己根本无能为力,需要保护,并且在开始走动时容易被解雇。关于复兴的希特勒主义的危险。 贝里尼希望希特勒保证不会嘲笑犹太人,但希特勒却认为希特勒是“没有笑的事”。 犹太组织的抗议被嘲笑了。 当一位年长的犹太妇女认识到希特勒确实是希特勒时,就被视为痴呆症。

这让我感到非常不诚实。 西方现代政治中大量的内容包括安抚“深切关注”的犹太人,即使他们显然是神经质的和操纵性的。 例如, 必须采取的步骤 当发现外星人被发现时,以免引发他们进入反犹太大屠杀 德国的树木美国的建筑物 从上面看起来像sw字。

电影以希特勒,萨瓦茨基和贝里尼为结尾制作了一部电影, 看看谁回来了。 最糟糕的情况是有人意识到希特勒实际上是, 希特勒,在电影中被表演出来并被诊断出患有精神疾病。 电影完成后,希特勒和贝里尼在一辆敞篷豪华轿车中穿过柏林的街道,而希特勒则独白了欧洲各地民族主义,民粹主义和仇外心理的兴起,以及蒙纳特·马林·勒庞和基尔特·怀尔德斯等示威者和政治人物的蒙太奇图像。 他声称,这是他回来的理想环境。

We are supposed to feel chills, but I felt rather angry at the attempt to stigmatize sensible European nationalism and populism by equating it with Hitler. Want borders? You’re no better than Hitler! Want standards? What is this, Nazi Germany? Of course, America was not Nazi Germany before 1965, when we opened our borders; or before the cultural revolutions of the 1960s which declared war against all reigning norms and values.

看看谁回来了 is a highly entertaining film, but it is deeply fake. The premise that Adolf Hitler could return to modern Germany, become a TV star, and then perhaps return to politics is meant as an insult to the German people. But surely there is no shortage of people in Germany who would scramble to engage in sadism and self-righteousness cloaked in the banner of anti-fascism if Hitler returned.

I suspect the truth would be closer to what we have been going through in America over the last few years when a real-life TV star became President. Donald Trump is no Hitler, but a large portion of the US population has gaslighted themselves into thinking Trump is Hitler’s second coming and reacted accordingly. And Trump Derangement Syndrome is the merest shadow of the oy veying that would rend the very fabric of the universe if Hitler actually did come back.

Nevertheless, I highly recommend 看看谁回来了. Oliver Masucci is a compelling Hitler, although they should have given him blue contact lenses. Katja Riemann is simply regal. Indeed, the entire cast is good.

Again, it is hard to determine the film’s actual message. But liberals find it deeply disturbing, and Right-leaning individuals who are supposed to be scared away from National Populism by an association with Hitler might have exactly the opposite reaction. I have never believed that the triumph of National Populism—which is based upon universal, objective reality, not mere historical contingencies—requires the rehabilitation of Hitler, but taking some of the sting out of the 减少希特勒 can’t hurt either. Try showing this film to normies and see how they react.

 
• 类别: 艺术/信件 •标签: 德国, 希特勒, 电影 
隐藏19条评论发表评论
忽略评论者...跟随Endorsed Only
修剪评论?
    []
  1. iffen 说:

    Have you written a review of 斯大林之死?

  2. mh505 说:

    This film cannot even remotely compare to the book, which is great.

  3. anon[171]• 免责声明 说:

    XNUMXD压花不锈钢板 国会大厦 movement in Germany (which already has hundreds of thousands of members and is steadily growing) actually believes that Hitler will return one day. According to them Hitler is merely sleeping under a mountain, but will return at some point in the future (maybe in January 2033), lead the 国会大厦 to victory over their enemies in a cleansing orgy of violence, restore the 帝国 as a perfect National Socialist community and rule it for a thousand years.
    It sounds pretty crazy, but so do many religions.

    • 回复: @SaneClownPosse
  4. Another “Springtime for Hitler.”

    Someone needs, and works hard, to keep the Hitler meme alive to justify their own crimes against humanity.

  5. @anon

    BS. Another fake group created by spooks. As are some established religions.

  6. Smith 说:

    I actually highly enjoy this film due to it’s portrayal of Hitler. Powerful, brave but also with a sense of humor.

    If the portrayal of this Hitler can be described as accurate, then he’s indeed the smart leader that the West has lost.

    It seems Germany still has a lot to fight for.

    • 回复: @Old Prude
  7. MEH 0910 说:

    HITLER TEA KETTLE : The Time JCPENNEY Got in Trouble for Selling a TEAPOT that looks like HITLER

    • 哈哈: Old Prude
  8. Q: What did the Jewish pedophile say? A: Want to buy some candy?)

    CLASSIC!!!

  9. Observator 说:

    American newsman William L. Shirer made the claim that Hitler was a “carpet chewer”. He reported that Hitler literally chewed the carpets in huge temper tantrums during the Czech crisis. He made this claim in “Berlin Diary”, “Rise and Fall of the Third Reich”, and even in his last book, “The Nightmare Years”, published in 1984. He learned nothing in all that time. The German term “Teppichfresser” means somebody who is climbing the walls or going around the bend, or is wearing out the carpets by pacing up and down while dictating. It’s slang, and anybody else would take it as slang. But Shirer repeated it literally for 44 years.

    Shirer also virtually single-handedly invented and popularized the idea that the Nazis claimed that the Germans or Teutons were a ‘Master Race’, a lie which is universally believed, although nobody can even tell you what it is supposed to mean, what the term is or means in German, or where it is to be found in National Socialist literature. “Master Race” was Shirer’s deliberate mistranslation of “Herrenvolk”, an extremely rare word used by German leaders a total of perhaps 8 or 9 times. As a stand-alone term, it means “Nation of Men”, a brave, independent people. Even at Nuremberg, they never claimed there was any “Master Race Principle” (except for Chapter 2 of Mein Kampf, which does not use the word Herrenvolk at all). It was used as a blanket accusation alleging racism, military aggressiveness, and so on, things that are not unique to Nazis or Germans at all but are the universal history of humanity.

  10. Even if the spontaneous public interactions are fake and are meant to shame Germans for acting like Hitler (Looks Who’s Back…in Spirit…), the reaction to the book and the movie have turned out to be Archie Bunkeresque. That’s the best part of all this.

  11. Dumbo 说:

    I thought of making a sequel, called “Look who’s black”. This would be about Hitler returning as a black man, and everybody including liberals fawning about him and supporting his plans for world domination, sending Jews to camps, invading Poland and getting blonde pussy.

    • 哈哈: Old Prude
    • 回复: @Milesglorious
    , @Old Prude
  12. The last of the Old Guard passes away.

    John Simon RIP

    • 回复: @Presocratic
  13. Old Prude 说:
    @Smith

    Agree. I enjoyed the thing. Well-produced and well-acted with a lot of dry wit. The anti-nationalist montage at the end was a sour note: A blatant and clumsy piece of propaganda out of joint with the rest of the work.

  14. @Priss Factor

    Simon’s death really does mark the end of an era in film criticism. The Cavett interview (starts at 1:22 of the video) is enjoyable; I had not seen it before. Simon is in his mid-40’s here and pulls no punches with fellow guest Erich Segal about the movie Love Story, which had just been released. You have to admire Simon’s absolute unwillingness to ever temporize his views. Cavett alludes to Simon having appeared on his program a couple of times before, and I will have to look for those videos.

    • 回复: @Presocratic
  15. @Presocratic

    I just noticed that there is a second Cavett interview of Simon on that link you provided (starting at 13:00). Includes some exchanges with Mort Stahl. Also worth watching. Simon speaks in a rather deliberate way (he’s not glib), but one gets the sense of a real mind at work in these two appearances on the Cavett program.

  16. conatus 说:

    I liked this movie a lot mainly because it is a Hitler you have never seen before.
    This is a very funny movie. The guy who portrays Hitler is great, he certainly lived up to my scant imaginings of Dolph Returns.
    The movie manages to give Dolph some human aspects, he is not this screeching end-of-Bolero guy we have seen ON TV EVERY NIGHT OF OUR LIVES.
    In the movie Dolph has a sense of humor(the n-word) and he can be taken aback by the audiences reaction to him. He cared, unlike Stalin and Stalin’s henchmen like (((Genrik Yagoda))) who just forced everyone by constant terror to be good Commies.
    Robert Gallately makes this point in his book ‘Backing Hitler’
    But anyway the movie is funny and it is a Hitler you have never seen before.
    And really….. could you expect anyone to make you take what a movie approving of Hitler’s return in this day and age?

  17. Trump is worse than Hitler! If he is not stopped, the dead will rise and eat our souls!

当前评论者
说:

发表评论-对超过两周的文章发表评论,将在质量和语气上进行更严格的判断


 记得 我的信息为什么?
 电子邮件回复我的评论
$
提交的评论已被许可给 Unz评论 并可以由后者自行决定在其他地方重新发布
在翻译模式下禁用评论
通过RSS订阅此评论主题 通过RSS订阅所有Trevor Lynch评论